Latest / MBA Training Marketing / AI share of voice: what Comscore's data means
Transcript
- 0:00Host: Leaders' Insights Five minutes on ComScore says ChatGPT is
- 0:08Host: losing ground what AI share of voice actually means for CMOs.
- 0:13Host: ComScore dropped numbers last week showing ChatGPT's share of AI citations sliding while
- 0:17Host: Gemini and Claude climb.
- 0:19Host: Everyone read that as ChatGPT collapsing.
- 0:22Host: Is that the story?
- 0:23Expert: No.
- 0:24Expert: And that reading is lazy.
- 0:26Expert: ChatGPT isn't collapsing.
- 0:27Expert: It's being diluted.
- 0:29Expert: The pie got bigger and messier.
- 0:31Expert: In early 2025, you optimized for one machine.
- 0:35Expert: Now a customer asks Gemini, gets a different set of brands cited than Claude, and both
- 0:40Expert: differ from ChatGPT.
- 0:42Expert: Your visibility fractured across three answers, not one.
- 0:46Host: So the panic is misplaced?
- 0:47Expert: The panic is aimed at the wrong thing.
- 0:50Expert: CMOs are asking, how do I win ChatGPT?
- 0:53Expert: When the actual problem is they have no idea what any of these tools say about their brand
- 0:58Expert: on a given Tuesday.
- 0:59Expert: You're flying blind across three cockpits instead of one.
- 1:02Host: Let me throw three beliefs at you.
- 1:04Host: First one, AI share of voice.
- 1:07Host: The percentage of AI answers that mention your brand is the new SEO ranking, and you
- 1:11Host: optimize it the same way.
- 1:13Expert: Half true.
- 1:15Expert: The instinct is right.
- 1:16Expert: The mechanics are wrong.
- 1:18Expert: Old search rewarded whoever gamed keywords.
- 1:21Expert: These models cite sources they consider trustworthy.
- 1:24Expert: WordPress, Wikipedia, forums where humans actually discuss you.
- 1:29Expert: SEMrush pushes tools, claiming you can track and lift your AI mentions.
- 1:34Expert: And worth flagging, they sell exactly that software, so take the pitch with salt.
- 1:39Expert: Forester's independent read is blunter.
- 1:42Expert: There's no reliable lever yet.
- 1:43Expert: You can influence the inputs.
- 1:45Expert: You cannot rank on command.
- 1:47Host: Second belief, if ChatGPT is losing ground, CMOs should shift budget toward Gemini and
- 1:52Host: Claude.
- 1:53Expert: Wrong, and expensively so.
- 1:56Expert: Shift budget to what?
- 1:57Expert: There's no ad unit inside a Claude answer you can buy.
- 2:01Expert: You're not moving spend between channels.
- 2:03Expert: You're chasing three algorithms that decide who they trust based on your presence, everywhere
- 2:08Expert: else.
- 2:09Expert: HubSpot published a figure that something like 60% of marketers are already adjusting
- 2:15Expert: for AI search.
- 2:17Expert: And they sell the marketing software those people use, so that number is doing promotional
- 2:21Expert: work.
- 2:22Expert: The honest move isn't reallocating budget.
- 2:25Expert: It's building the credible footprint all three read from.
- 2:28Host: Third, attribution is broken now, so measurement is basically hopeless until the tools catch
- 2:33Host: up.
- 2:34Expert: Wrong, and it's a cop-out.
- 2:36Expert: Attribution, tracing which touchpoint drove the sale, was already broken before any of
- 2:41Expert: this.
- 2:43Expert: People pretended a clean click path existed when half of buying happens in conversations
- 2:47Expert: you never see.
- 2:49Expert: AI didn't break your measurement.
- 2:51Expert: It exposed that it was theater.
- 2:53Host: That's a strong claim.
- 2:55Host: What replaces the theater?
- 2:56Expert: Ask new customers where they first heard of you.
- 2:59Expert: Sounds primitive.
- 3:00Expert: It works.
- 3:02Expert: One direct-to-consumer skincare brand I advise added a single open text box at checkout.
- 3:08Expert: How'd you find us?
- 3:09Expert: And started seeing chat GPT told me, and Gemini recommended it, show up in real volume.
- 3:15Expert: No dashboard vendor sold them that insight.
- 3:18Expert: A text field and the nerve to read it did.
- 3:21Host: But that's self-reported.
- 3:22Host: Isn't that the softest data there is?
- 3:25Expert: Soft data you actually have beats precise data that's fiction.
- 3:29Expert: A tracking pixel that can't see inside an AI conversation gives you a confident number
- 3:34Expert: about the wrong thing.
- 3:36Expert: The survey is fuzzy and pointed at reality.
- 3:39Expert: I'll take fuzzy and real, over-sharp and imaginary every day.
- 3:42Host: So what's a CMO supposed to feel walking away from the comscore numbers, reassured
- 3:47Host: or worried?
- 3:48Expert: Neither.
- 3:49Expert: Curious.
- 3:50Expert: The splintering means whoever gets serious about measuring this now, while everyone else
- 3:54Expert: argues about chat GPT's obituary, builds a two-year head start.
- 3:59Expert: The last time visibility fragmented like this was mobile in 2011.
- 4:04Expert: The brands that mapped it early owned the decade.
- 4:07Host: One thing people can do Monday morning.
- 4:09Expert: Run the same prompt into Chagitai, Tabtii, Gemini and Claude.
- 4:13Expert: What are the best brands for whatever you sell?
- 4:16Expert: And screenshot all three.
- 4:18Expert: That's your baseline, done in 10 minutes for free.
- 4:21Expert: Do it monthly.
- 4:22Expert: When your competitor shows up in two answers and you show up in none, you'll know before
- 4:27Expert: your revenue does.
- 4:29Expert: And you'll have learned it without buying a single dashboard that promises to solve
- 4:32Expert: a problem nobody can define yet.
- 4:34Host: The cheapest research budget in marketing.
- 4:36Host: 10 minutes and the willingness to see something unflattering.
- 4:41Expert: Most CMOs will spend on the dashboard instead.
- 4:44Expert: That's the part I find genuinely funny.
- 4:46Host: What we read for this one, SEMrush vendor, SEO analytics tools, Forrester research, DigiDay,
- 4:53Host: HubSpot, vendor, CRM, marketing automation.
- 4:57Host: End of episode.
- 4:58Host: The CMO calculators are running at MBA-training.com.