Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Ego, Emotion, and Excel: Using Forensic Accountants in Mediation
Transcript
- 0:03Jeff Kravitz and Bob Cohen from the Beverly Hills
- 0:07Bar Association's ADR committee. We are very
- 0:12pleased to have with us here today two accomplished
- 0:16forensic accountants, Michael Kaplan and David
- 0:20Goldahar. Their kudos are in the materials that
- 0:24have been provided to you. And we're going to
- 0:27be exploring with them today how best and worst
- 0:31to use forensic accountants in mediation. And
- 0:36I thought it was always good to start out with
- 0:38a happy story. So, Michael, maybe you can briefly
- 0:41talk with us about one instance where you were
- 0:45retained and how nicely it went. The one instance.
- 0:52that I was retained in, that is one that's generally
- 0:57at the top of my mind when I address the issue
- 1:00of mediation. It was a mediation of a family
- 1:05dispute. Their brother and sister, they were
- 1:08in business together, a business that their father
- 1:11started. And at some point, sister became very
- 1:16unhappy with the way her brother was running
- 1:18the business. Brother was the manager. So she
- 1:22brought a suit against the corporation, filed
- 1:25for a dissolution of the corporation. And Brother
- 1:31and his family responded, and it was their intention
- 1:36to buy Sister out at the fair value of her interest.
- 1:43The court appointed Three appraisers. I was one
- 1:46of the three. Each side selected one appraiser,
- 1:50and then the two of us agreed on a neutral. So
- 1:53one selected by the plaintiff, one selected by
- 1:56the defendant, and a neutral. We went through
- 1:59the process, and it was a very, very difficult
- 2:02process because these people were at each other's
- 2:05throats. But the neutral and I came up with the
- 2:09same number for the value of the business, which
- 2:11was about $3 .7 million. The plaintiff's appraiser,
- 2:17the appraiser selected by the plaintiff came
- 2:20up with a number of $6 .6 million. There's a
- 2:24little difference there. The court affirmed the
- 2:28number that I came up with and the neutral came
- 2:30up with the plaintiff. took the case up on appeal
- 2:34and the appellate court in its infinite wisdom
- 2:38referred it out for mediation, referred it out
- 2:42to mediation. The mediation was in San Francisco.
- 2:46I got up to the mediation venue. I was invited
- 2:50to be there, you know, all of the appraisers
- 2:53were invited. The neutral was not there. The
- 2:56one, I as the one selected by the defendant was
- 2:59there, the appraiser selected by the plaintiff
- 3:03was there, it became very apparent to me that
- 3:08the attitude, that everyone came there with the
- 3:11attitude that the other side is not going to
- 3:13come around and see it our way. And if they don't
- 3:18come around to our line of thinking by 10, 1030
- 3:23in the morning, we're out of here. And I know
- 3:26that there's so many parties who will go into
- 3:30mediation with that mindset. This is a waste
- 3:33of time. We're here because the court ordered
- 3:34it. Well, 10 .30 came and went. My people were
- 3:39still sitting there. The plaintiffs' group, they
- 3:41were in their caucus room. About noon, the defendants
- 3:48said, look, let's all go out to lunch. We'll
- 3:50have a nice lunch. When we come back, if the
- 3:53plaintiffs haven't come around to the way we
- 3:56see it, we're out of here. And we came back and
- 3:59time went anyway that we were there for a little
- 4:03while in the afternoon. Now it's three o 'clock
- 4:05and I'm realizing that my people are getting
- 4:08ready to go. They mean it this time. They're
- 4:11not going to stick around longer unless someone
- 4:14keeps them there. And I'm thinking to myself,
- 4:18each side has spent $1 .5 million on this litigation,
- 4:23and it's a family. Christmas dinner is not the
- 4:26same as it had been in years past because brother
- 4:29and sister are at each other's throats. So at
- 4:33about three o 'clock, I'm sitting in the room
- 4:35with all of the defendants and their attorneys,
- 4:39and I looked up and I said, I have an idea. And
- 4:41they all kind of jumped up. And I said, let's
- 4:45look at each of the four issues that's before
- 4:47the appellate court, and let's put a probability
- 4:51on whether the court will rule in our favor or
- 4:53rule against us. And they provided me with those
- 4:57probabilities. They got working on it. And then
- 5:00once we had that, I said, OK, now if the case
- 5:03is remanded back to the trial court, what do
- 5:06you think is the high, the low, and the most
- 5:09probable number the trial court's going to come
- 5:11up with? And they gave me a high, a low, and
- 5:14a most probable. And we put probabilities on
- 5:17that. And I multiplied it out. That 3 .7 million
- 5:21turned into 4 .1 million. The next time the mediator
- 5:27walked into the room, I said, go back to the
- 5:29plaintiff's room. Get them started in this type
- 5:31of process. Maybe we can make some headway. To
- 5:35make a long story short, And I can go on with
- 5:38this story for the whole day, but to make the
- 5:40long story short, we started this process at
- 5:433 p .m. These people were at each other's throats
- 5:46in litigation for six years. By 530, the ink
- 5:49was dry on the settlement conference, on the
- 5:52settlement agreement, I should say. Ink was dry
- 5:55in the settlement agreement. And what happened,
- 5:58what I realized that I had done is I got the
- 6:01people off of being... just ensconced in their
- 6:06particular positions and focused their attention
- 6:09on what number would settle it. How do we get
- 6:14it settled? And they did. And it was a happy
- 6:21ending for the parties because they would have
- 6:23each spent another million and a half and wouldn't
- 6:26have gotten any farther along and would not have
- 6:30had a better outcome. That's a great story. So
- 6:33in a sense, you kind of assisted the mediator
- 6:35in the process of settlement. That's right. The
- 6:40mediator was running back from room to room with
- 6:42his frying pan, you know, banging everyone over
- 6:45the head. We've all been in mediations like that.
- 6:49But what we needed, we needed to get the parties
- 6:54focused on the process. I knew what numbers were.
- 6:59And, you know, explaining the numbers to the
- 7:01people in that type of setting isn't going to
- 7:04get us any further along. It was a matter of
- 7:06getting the parties invested in the process of
- 7:09looking for a resolution. That's very interesting.
- 7:13Now, I've got a question for you, Michael. You've
- 7:17been doing this for decades. I'm sure you've
- 7:19been in numerous scores, if not more than that,
- 7:23of mediations as an expert. And of course, you've
- 7:26testified at trial. What types of mediations
- 7:30are you involved with? Family law, business dissolution,
- 7:36personal injury, economic loss, and also are
- 7:41your analyses and reports different for a mediation
- 7:45versus trial? Are they more simplified or is
- 7:49it the same type of work product you would have
- 7:51for a trial? Great question. First of all, the
- 7:56work that I do, the mediations that I've been
- 7:58involved in are pretty much parallel of the type
- 8:01of practice that I have. They're primarily business
- 8:05litigation. And there's some employment litigation
- 8:08in there. Occasionally, I'll take on a family
- 8:11law case. Those become even more challenging
- 8:15in the mediations. But they're typically business
- 8:19-related cases and different kinds of economic
- 8:22damages, lost profits, whatever the case may
- 8:25be, business interference. When I go to a mediation,
- 8:32I'm fully prepared to walk into the courtroom
- 8:35and give testimony as if I was being put on the
- 8:40witness stand. Typically, the mediations that
- 8:46I've been involved in have been scheduled at
- 8:48a date after I have finished my work. Usually,
- 8:54it's after my deposition. And then there's a
- 8:57mediation where the parties are attempting to
- 9:01get a resolution to the case. I was just speaking
- 9:05last week, I was speaking with a retired judge
- 9:09who's in the ADR practice in Maryland. And he
- 9:16was telling me, when you have a mediation, everyone's
- 9:21got to be sufficiently prepared in order for
- 9:25that mediation to be productive. You don't know
- 9:28where to go if you don't know where the numbers
- 9:30are. So my belief, and it's a strong belief,
- 9:36is when I walk into mediation, I want to be prepared
- 9:39to take that case into trial, even though my
- 9:45objective is different in mediation from what
- 9:47it is in trial. what, when I walk into that mediation,
- 9:53I want to be well versed in the facts and the
- 9:57evidence and the approaches and in the work that
- 10:00the other expert did. And I want to be in a position
- 10:04where if the other expert, if there is something
- 10:10about the other expert's analysis that I believe
- 10:13that he and I or she and I can sit down and gain
- 10:16more clarity as to what the other one did, we
- 10:21can together guide the numbers to a point that
- 10:26makes sense for settlement purposes. Does that
- 10:32happen frequently or infrequently when the two
- 10:35competing experts come to a consensus when there's
- 10:40a dispute? The process of the two experts coming
- 10:46together, whether it's before the mediation,
- 10:49or during the mediation. I mean, there have been
- 10:51times that I've turned to my retaining counsel
- 10:53and asked, can I take the other expert into another
- 10:57room? And I've got a few things to talk about,
- 10:59and I think we can move it along. But those happen
- 11:03quite often, where I can have an audience with
- 11:07the other expert. Those situations, They happen
- 11:15when they happen. I mean, I can't say they happen
- 11:17a high percentage of the time or a low percentage
- 11:20of the time. It just depends upon the particulars
- 11:22of the case. Jeff. David, tell us a little bit
- 11:27about your practice, how it varies by category,
- 11:32if it varies, how you get used differently maybe
- 11:35in a family law dispute as opposed to a piece
- 11:38of business litigation. Sure. I think in the
- 11:42context of mediations, those have happened more
- 11:45along the lines of personal injury cases and
- 11:48employment cases. Similar to Michael's experience,
- 11:55I'm also focused on business litigation. Those
- 11:59cases, I think, because it's more, we're talking
- 12:03about methodologies or different assumptions
- 12:07when we come together. those seem to be resolved
- 12:11across financial experts, I think more easily
- 12:14than when it's emotional like family law. So
- 12:18I've also participated in family law mediations
- 12:21as well. And similar to, although it was a business
- 12:25dispute in Michael's case, when it comes to family,
- 12:30I think emotions take over and it prevents at
- 12:36least what I've seen, the parties really coming
- 12:39together and reconcile. And so that's really,
- 12:44I've seen it at least in not as many mediations,
- 12:49but in the cases I've been in, the parties, and
- 12:53it's also up to council really to bring the parties
- 12:56together. I have a question. Well, and I wanna
- 13:01ask the two of you, kind of the secret sauce
- 13:05for what we're doing today. And let's start,
- 13:10David, we'll start with you and then to Michael,
- 13:13what do you think is the best way for lawyers
- 13:15and accountants to best prepare for mediation
- 13:18together? So similar to what Michael said, we
- 13:24come in and we're prepared as if we're going
- 13:27into trial. So my schedules, the analysis is
- 13:33set up for essentially completion. I've been
- 13:37in matters where they're like, well, we have
- 13:39a limited budget. Please just do a limited set
- 13:42or a limited analysis. And those are the ones
- 13:45that really hurt because if it's not done all
- 13:51the way to a T, you're setting yourself up for
- 13:55what could be a disaster or at least not a strong
- 13:58mediation. And that's where I think experts and
- 14:03counsel need to work together to say, look, our
- 14:06goal for mediation is really to come together
- 14:08and settle this. I think that's really, and the
- 14:13secret sauce is having counsel and experts that
- 14:18work in tandem together, knowing, having all
- 14:22the facts. I've seen the other side come in and
- 14:26have blinders on. without having all the facts
- 14:30together. And that hurts the mediation itself.
- 14:34Because when you, and I think Michael has a great
- 14:37story about this, when the other side does not
- 14:41have everything and then you come together and
- 14:43like, well, if you had this piece of information,
- 14:46would it change your answer? And that sometimes
- 14:49becomes yes. Michael. Okay, go ahead. I have
- 14:57a couple things to add to that, and that was
- 15:00great, David. Thank you. If you have a mediation
- 15:07too early in the process, you don't have all
- 15:11the facts. You don't have all the evidence. The
- 15:14expert has not had a chance to evaluate it, to
- 15:18interpret what does it mean. And I know that
- 15:23there are situations where, in certain jurisdictions,
- 15:28they schedule mediations very early in the case
- 15:31when the parties aren't ready. Well, you can't
- 15:34settle it then. You need to have experts who
- 15:39know what they're talking about, who have the
- 15:42facts, who have the understanding. And I prefer
- 15:49that the mediation is farther along. I prefer
- 15:54that it's farther along in the process when earlier
- 15:57we're not going to have what we need. But at
- 16:01that point where the experts have what they need
- 16:03and they've done what they need to do, then you
- 16:05have the mediation as soon as possible, assuming,
- 16:08of course, that the issues that the experts are
- 16:12there for are the issues at the heart of the
- 16:14case. And But if the experts are prepared, if
- 16:19the experts are prepared, I know whatever the
- 16:22case may be, if David and I are on opposite sides
- 16:25of the case and we've done our work, you could
- 16:28put the two of us in a room and we're going to
- 16:31come up with a proposal that will work for everyone.
- 16:36Certainly some variation of it will work for
- 16:39everyone. But if we don't have all of the facts,
- 16:43we don't have all the evidence, haven't had the
- 16:45chance to evaluate it through our research, it
- 16:49really erodes the value and impact of that mediation.
- 16:56Michael, I want to actually build on an assumption.
- 17:02I've prepared for mediations where we are not
- 17:05in the room or not are not a part of that process,
- 17:10outside of providing schedules and a report.
- 17:13So Jeff and Bob, when we are involved, and I'm
- 17:18happy to participate in those conversations,
- 17:24because when we're not there, if a mediator has
- 17:28questions, I've been on call, but the impact
- 17:31of having both experts there to have to be translators,
- 17:38financial translators, or to at least reconcile
- 17:42certain differences. I think that's what really
- 17:45is the key because both sets of council want
- 17:50to advocate for their client's position. We as
- 17:54independent financial experts will have the objectivity
- 17:59to bring in and say, look, you know, on these
- 18:02areas we can come closer together. but there
- 18:05really is a legal question or a fact question
- 18:09on these areas where we cannot reconcile. And
- 18:12so I think having us in the room is the secret
- 18:16sauce and being able to help the mediator shuttle
- 18:20between the rooms. Sounds really right on, because
- 18:26information and mediation really and communication
- 18:29is everything. I've got a question for both of
- 18:31you. have either of you been in a situation where
- 18:35there's a dispute between the accountants and
- 18:38the mediator sides with the other accountant
- 18:41expert? And if so, what do you do in that situation?
- 18:46How do you handle being told either directly
- 18:50or indirectly that you're wrong? I have an answer
- 19:00to that one. That's a mediation. The mediator
- 19:04is not the judge. The mediator is not there as
- 19:08a judge. I will pull my retaining counsel aside
- 19:11and tell her or tell him the mediator is wrong
- 19:17on that. And this is why. This is not like being
- 19:27in a courtroom and giving testimony before a
- 19:30judge or testimony before a jury and what comes
- 19:33back from the trial or a fact is just wronged
- 19:36or out into left field. This is a process where
- 19:40everyone participates in the process and I would,
- 19:44you know, if I knew that, I don't want to, I
- 19:52don't want to. put myself up on a pedestal. But
- 19:54if I knew that I was right and what the mediator
- 19:57came up with was just wrong, I'm going to tell
- 20:00my retaining council. I'm not doing my job unless
- 20:04I tell a retaining council, look, there's a problem
- 20:06with what the mediator is proposing. It's a problem
- 20:10with it. Similar to Michael, I don't think I've
- 20:14been in a situation where a mediator has come
- 20:17out and said, you know, David is wrong or the
- 20:19numbers are wrong and so forth. But It's also
- 20:23part of the process to help communicate clearly
- 20:27to the mediator at that position. So I think,
- 20:31I've seen mediators do a great job of, I don't
- 20:33understand, please help me see what you're seeing
- 20:37and then let me kind of bring that to the other
- 20:40side. So I think it's not necessarily, I guess
- 20:45the wrong is the word that I didn't like in that
- 20:48question because From what I've seen, everyone
- 20:52tries to come together. And I guess the experts
- 20:57I've been opposed to, it's not like something
- 21:02is necessarily wrong. It's either there's missing
- 21:05information, a difference of opinion and methodology.
- 21:10So those are the ones where I can speak to. Now,
- 21:17kind of transitioning it to, special situations
- 21:20where we couldn't bring the other side together,
- 21:25when one side has a retained expert and the other
- 21:28side doesn't, those I've seen more likely fail
- 21:33because opposing party that doesn't have an expert
- 21:37doesn't have the acumen or an objective person
- 21:42to help them come together. And that's where
- 21:46I've been involved. I guess one of my war stories
- 21:49is on a healthcare M &A where we represented,
- 21:54I was retained by the buyer and the seller disputed
- 22:01the earn out and the accounting methodology the
- 22:05owner used was not something that was generally
- 22:07accepted, was not something that was within the
- 22:10contract and the numbers just did not make sense.
- 22:14The mediator was able to see that the mediator
- 22:18brought that and explained it I was actually
- 22:21luckily to be part of I was one of them on call
- 22:23for and unfortunately, so this is where Ego and
- 22:29emotion really affects Excel is that the other
- 22:33side was unable to at least see and understand
- 22:37and say okay We hear you but we disagree because
- 22:40we'd like this number. It was just a flat -out
- 22:43rejection and that one failed. And I felt terrible
- 22:47about it. Yeah. Well, have you ever gone in the
- 22:52other room with opposing counsel and the other
- 22:57side's client to mano a mano, mano a mano chat
- 23:04with them and explain what you've done in your
- 23:07methodology? I've offered it and I am an open
- 23:14book because I do see myself as someone who has
- 23:17to communicate the methodology, the facts and
- 23:21the figures that we're seeing to both sides equally.
- 23:24So it's the same explanation that I would give
- 23:27my own client is what I would need to explain
- 23:30to the opposing counsel. And that's what we do
- 23:32at the end of the day in a deposition or in a
- 23:35trial. So in the mediation, it's the same. explanation
- 23:40that we're giving. I guess it just has, we're
- 23:44trying to make everyone to come together at the
- 23:46end of the day. I agree that we're trying to
- 23:51make everyone come together. And that's the objective
- 23:56of a mediation. We're trying to get the case
- 23:59resolved. And with that as a premise. I will
- 24:04go into a room with opposing counsel, with opposing
- 24:09counsel's client, with the other expert, whoever
- 24:13it is who needs clarification, if it will assist
- 24:17in the process of bringing the parties together.
- 24:20That's why we're in mediation. Mediation, it's
- 24:26not like going into a courtroom and trial. You've
- 24:30got a trial, there's a judge there, there's a
- 24:32jury there. The experts get up and they give
- 24:35testimony that's built around the home run number.
- 24:44The home run being supported by evidence and
- 24:48the expert's judgment. But you go into mediation
- 24:54and the parties, certainly the attorneys know.
- 24:58you're not going to get your home run number
- 25:00in a mediation. There is going to be some give
- 25:04and take. And as experts, we need to be able
- 25:07to explain the realities of the variables and
- 25:11the pieces that go into whether the number should
- 25:13be a little bit this way or a little bit that
- 25:15way, or this should be out or that should be
- 25:17added in. Well, that's a good segue. And I'll
- 25:22ask each of you, how much do you work with the
- 25:25clients themselves? you know, which may have
- 25:27in -house accounting capability as opposed to
- 25:31working through the attorneys. And maybe a war
- 25:33story or two would be good here. Sure. I think
- 25:38it all depends on the case. More on the business
- 25:42litigation side, the fact finding happens with
- 25:46in -house accountant CFOs to pull the data that
- 25:50we need. And I think You know for some of the
- 25:56employment or PI so employment you're pulling
- 25:59the information Based if it's an individual their
- 26:04numbers and then on PI it's also I guess what
- 26:08we've been given and the situation there So there
- 26:12is more in -house I think within commercial litigation
- 26:15on the business side, but family law Employment
- 26:19and PI it's it's more with the with counsel I
- 26:23have a question. Well, go ahead, Michael, and
- 26:26then I'll pose my question. I usually look to
- 26:30the attorney to get his or her preference as
- 26:35to whether I should be dealing directly with
- 26:41his or her client or employees of the client
- 26:44company or should I be going through counsel
- 26:48for everything that I need. And there are issues
- 26:54of discoverability. But I will look to counsel
- 27:01for direction on that. At the beginning of the
- 27:04case, I'll be very, very clear. I'll have clarity
- 27:07with counsel. Are you ever retained, either of
- 27:11you, as the single expert CPA for purposes of
- 27:17mediation only, realizing that you're Bindings
- 27:21are not binding, but they're looking to you for
- 27:24advice and to save some expert costs. I've been
- 27:32retained jointly by the parties, but not specifically
- 27:37for mediation. I've been brought in as a joint
- 27:41expert or even as a court appointed expert. But
- 27:46again, the end game in terms of the thought process
- 27:52of the attorneys and the objective that I had
- 27:57was to prepare and take the case through trial.
- 28:01If there's a mediation along the way, that's
- 28:05so much better. That just adds an opportunity
- 28:08to get the case resolved. Yeah, I think similar
- 28:12to Michael. I've been retained solely for the
- 28:15purpose of mediation. Mediation has been a product
- 28:19of the litigation process. So we'll step into
- 28:23it as the case moves forward. If an expert is
- 28:31brought in just for the mediation, you're looking
- 28:34at something that could have a very, very significant
- 28:37cost to get you to the mediation. If the expert
- 28:43is brought in to be an expert in the matter,
- 28:47in the lawsuit, with a likelihood of going to
- 28:52trial and mediation is a step along the way,
- 28:56the marginal cost of having the expert involved
- 29:01in the mediation is not that big. And it's likely
- 29:10to be less costly than not having the expert
- 29:14in mediation. Have you ever dealt with situations
- 29:17where you basically were in a conflict with your
- 29:22retaining attorney over your evaluation or analysis
- 29:25and yet still were able to participate in the
- 29:29mediation? How did you work through situations
- 29:32like that? Are you suggesting that council's
- 29:42opinion was different from my opinion? Yes, yes,
- 29:46yes. Basically, council once says to you, look,
- 29:51put your thumb on the scale. I don't like what
- 29:54you've done. Where do you go then? I give council
- 30:00a list of other experts that he or she should.
- 30:04Yeah, Bob, we definitely see that, look, council's
- 30:10advocating a position. But it's, I think very
- 30:15often we see the, we come in as objective and
- 30:22ethical experts and we can't become advocates
- 30:26for council's position or the client's position.
- 30:31So I always appreciate those debates. But like
- 30:35Michael, if they don't like what we have that
- 30:41we're presenting, we're not the right fit. And
- 30:45so I will happily excuse myself and Michael's
- 30:49on my list. Have you been in situations where
- 30:53you've had to withdraw on ethical grounds? Can
- 30:57you share some examples? Yeah. I just tell counsel,
- 31:03I can't do it. What you're asking me to do is
- 31:07not my opinion. My opinion is different from
- 31:10the number that you want, and it's different
- 31:14from the number that you want me to testify to.
- 31:18And when I swear to tell the truth, the whole
- 31:20truth and nothing but the truth, I'm going to
- 31:23tell the truth. I'm going to give my opinion.
- 31:27Well, I'll jump in with a quick story, which
- 31:29is I had a piece of business litigation and it
- 31:34was a seven and maybe an eight figure case on
- 31:37the plaintiff's side. I hired reputable accountancy
- 31:42firm to do the analysis and back before Zoom,
- 31:48my expert demanded or requested a face -to -face
- 31:53meeting. And I came in and I said, what's up?
- 31:57And he said, I don't want to say this guy's books
- 32:01are cooked, but they may be microwaved. And for
- 32:07one example, he said he's deducting his wife's
- 32:11lingerie as a business expense. Well, this was
- 32:16a medium sized business where the guy's role
- 32:18was law within his company. So I went to my client
- 32:24and I said, you know, we got a couple of issues
- 32:25here. Not the least of which is your wife's underwear
- 32:28on the books. And his attitude was that if she
- 32:33was going to grandiose company functions, he
- 32:37was entitled to deduct those. Well, and I said,
- 32:41you know, and maybe with the IRS, you can win
- 32:43that battle, but we're either going to have to
- 32:47amend the books or we're going to have to find
- 32:50another expert. And I don't think we can find
- 32:52another expert who's going to hold up in court.
- 32:54So, reluctantly, he agreed that that would come
- 32:57off the books, but it was a real fight. It should
- 33:00not have been, but it was a real fight. And I've
- 33:05seen similar situations where there is a disagreement.
- 33:12For me, it's uncomfortable, but I guess it has
- 33:14been necessary, where we have to educate. Look,
- 33:17if we advocate a certain position, like as Michael
- 33:19said, we swear an oath. And if we have inconsistent
- 33:26testimony, that's where I first go like, if I
- 33:30have to go on the stand and talk about this,
- 33:33my prior case that I had a different opinion,
- 33:35different methodology, opposing counsel is gonna
- 33:38rip me apart. Is that something you'd want me
- 33:42to face? And usually that realization and that
- 33:46discussion helps us reconcile more towards our
- 33:52objective point and kind of what we are set out
- 33:55to do to help at least present the financials
- 33:59in these complex situations. Do you ever go into
- 34:02joint sessions to present your position with
- 34:07the other expert present as well or is it always
- 34:09done separately shuttle diplomacy style? I would
- 34:16prefer to have the other expert there. And I've
- 34:20been in situations where we have presented together
- 34:24and presented in the presence of the other expert.
- 34:32I mean, I had a situation, and this was a number
- 34:36of years back, where there was a huge difference
- 34:41between my number and the other expert's number.
- 34:45and there was mediation and I attended the mediation
- 34:48and so did the other expert. What I realized
- 34:52at the mediation is the other expert did not
- 34:56have all of the evidence. He did a good job,
- 35:00did an excellent job with what he had, but he
- 35:02was missing a big chunk of the evidence. I turned
- 35:06to my retaining counsel, I said, Is it okay if
- 35:10I take the other expert into a conference room
- 35:14and sit down and talk to him? I think I can get
- 35:16through all of this. We can resolve our differences.
- 35:21I took the other expert into the room and I showed
- 35:25him the additional evidence that he didn't have.
- 35:28There was a lot more evidence in the deck and
- 35:31he looked at it and I could see, his eyes really
- 35:33got big and he said, he was very, very surprised.
- 35:39And I looked at him, I said, if you had had this
- 35:41evidence when you did your work, would it have
- 35:44changed your opinion? He said, yes, it would
- 35:48have. Well, let's see what it would do. And right
- 35:51there, I had him go through and update his numbers,
- 35:57factoring in all of this other evidence that
- 36:00we had. And it was in a format that it was easy
- 36:03to grab the relevant numbers. And somehow miraculously,
- 36:08His number was so close to mine. I mean they
- 36:12were within pennies apart And when I realize
- 36:16we both approached the case the same way We both
- 36:20I mean we were we both had the same objective.
- 36:23What was missing is he didn't have all the evidence
- 36:26So the more opportunity that I have to work with
- 36:31the other expert The better off everyone's gonna
- 36:35be Do you know why the other expert didn't have
- 36:39all the information? Was the attorney working
- 36:42with that expert stacking the deck and intentionally
- 36:45withholding information? You just hit one of
- 36:48my hot buttons because I've seen that time and
- 36:50time again where the attorney has withheld evidence
- 36:55that he or she knows will harm their client's
- 37:01position if that evidence comes to light. Yeah.
- 37:06What do you do? What do you do? What do I do?
- 37:11Well, I never take another case from that attorney
- 37:13again. It's someone I know that I can't trust.
- 37:18I had a case in trial. I was in trial. It was
- 37:22a small case. My number was $93 ,000. I was a
- 37:27defense expert. The plaintiff's expert was $158
- 37:30,000. The court appointed expert was was came
- 37:35in at one hundred and twenty five thousand. That
- 37:37case should have never gone to trial, but the
- 37:40jury came back with a verdict of seven hundred
- 37:42thousand. Oh, my God. And the case settled the
- 37:45next day for nine hundred thousand. Wow. OK.
- 37:49And it all revolved around it all revolved around
- 37:54some evidence that neither I nor nor the plaintiff's
- 37:59expert had. It was this evidence that that was
- 38:04being hidden. But opposing counsel had that evidence
- 38:08and introduced it in court and it was just a
- 38:12disaster for a lot of people. Wow. That's a very
- 38:16big lesson that I've seen throughout the tenure
- 38:19of my career is when counsel either cherry picks
- 38:24information or withholds information, it leads
- 38:29to issues down the line. ultimately doesn't serve
- 38:35the client. So if we know what we have in front
- 38:40of us, and that's why a few key points that I
- 38:43drill with all the attorneys I work with is hire
- 38:47us early on. Hire us during pre -litigation where
- 38:51we can help you with discovery because that helps
- 38:53with that information. If we are working in tandem,
- 38:57the ultimate result is better. when it comes
- 39:01to, I think on the valuation side, and Michael,
- 39:05it seems like you've done a few appraisals, when
- 39:08we don't have the evidence, if we're cherry picking,
- 39:11and it's more of an art than a science, then
- 39:16there could be big differences. And so that's
- 39:21where having everything in terms of all the information,
- 39:26all the facts, upfront and early. will help you
- 39:31in mediation and in trial. What do you do and
- 39:39I'm sure this happens occasionally, hopefully
- 39:42not too often because I know you both handle
- 39:44bigger cases. What do you do when your attorney
- 39:48client tells you we're running out of money and
- 39:50you've done a lot of work and they're trying
- 39:53to salvage the situation? Maybe the client's
- 39:57not going to go into bankruptcy, but for whatever
- 39:59reason, they're running out of money. What do
- 40:00you do in that situation? I hate to say it. I'll
- 40:06take the case to finish because I believe in
- 40:10getting it done. More often than not, we'll figure
- 40:14it out in a way that's a win -win for everyone
- 40:17involved. Michael, what do you see? I agree with
- 40:22you. It all depends upon the circumstances leading
- 40:28to their running out of money. It becomes more
- 40:33problematic when the attorney or the client owe
- 40:37you a lot of money. You've got a big outstanding
- 40:40receivable and then they come back and now you're
- 40:42thinking, now you're realizing that you're on
- 40:45a contingency fee arrangement. Even though that
- 40:50is a departure from professional standards, by
- 40:54having contingency arraignment, but you know,
- 40:57sometimes things - Yeah, de facto. Yeah, it's
- 40:59a de facto contingency arraignment. Of course.
- 41:01And by the way, an expert, you know, when I explain
- 41:06to my retaining counsel, you don't want me on
- 41:10the witness stand if I'm in a contingency arrangement,
- 41:14because if I'm on the stand and you or your client
- 41:19owe me money, the message that that puts into
- 41:25the jurors' minds is that my compensation is
- 41:29dependent upon my testimony. Notwithstanding
- 41:33that it's a departure from professional standards,
- 41:35but you don't want me on the stand under those
- 41:38circumstances. So my answer to the question would
- 41:42be different if the receivable had been managed
- 41:45properly and they just got to the point where
- 41:49they'd paid everything up to the current bill,
- 41:53and they say, okay, you know, we're at the point
- 41:55we're running out of money, we've got to do this
- 41:57on a limited budget. I mean, I had one where
- 42:00I was court -appointed, and I got involved in
- 42:05the case, and I discovered that the subject company's
- 42:09books were a mess. on a good day under the nicest
- 42:13thing I could say is they were a mess and I came
- 42:16back to them and I said to clean up the books
- 42:18and records to get them to the point where I
- 42:20could even approach valuing the business this
- 42:24is how much money it would cost in terms of accounting
- 42:27fees and one of the parties ran to the judge
- 42:31or they both ran to the judge and the judge said
- 42:33you know what I I can't authorize that kind of
- 42:39fee, this is the amount of money that I'm going
- 42:43to direct you to pay Mr. Kaplan, and he's got
- 42:45to come up with an opinion within that scope.
- 42:49And then what I did was I brought counsel together.
- 42:53I had a meeting with both counsel, without their
- 42:58respective clients, and they said, look, this
- 43:00is what I could do within the scope of that budget.
- 43:04And I laid out what I could do. I said there's
- 43:08certain assumptions that I would have to make.
- 43:12Certain assumptions that I would have to make
- 43:14without going through the process of really cleaning
- 43:16up their books and records. I'd have to assume
- 43:19the tax returns signed under penalty of perjury
- 43:22were accurate, a reasonable reflection of their
- 43:25income and expenses and all the financial information
- 43:29was reasonable. And there were certain other
- 43:31things I said, if If each of you agrees, and
- 43:37your clients agree, and I want that in writing,
- 43:40that you will agree with these following assumptions,
- 43:43then I will come back with a number that will
- 43:46put you in a position where you can get this
- 43:47case resolved. And that's what we did. But when
- 43:53those things happen, they have to be addressed
- 43:56proactively. When money is an issue, we have
- 43:59to step back and say, You know, what can we do?
- 44:03What can't we do? And it also depends, and I
- 44:09think David would agree with me, that it depends
- 44:12how far along in the case are you. You know,
- 44:15are we just talking about that last segment or
- 44:17are we just getting involved in an enormous amount
- 44:21of work? I mean, it's a different case. It's
- 44:26a different matter. It's a different decision.
- 44:28Right, I think I've seen that more often than
- 44:31not happen towards the end, because, you know,
- 44:35Bob and Jeff, I think when we are being retained,
- 44:40there is a discussion around the economics. More
- 44:44often than not, if I see that the numbers don't
- 44:47make sense on the face, or, you know, like that
- 44:50case you're talking about, Michael, where you're,
- 44:52it's less than $100 ,000, well, you know, whether,
- 44:56We're doing an analysis that will result in $1
- 45:00million or $100 million of damages. The process
- 45:05is the same. It still takes time to go through
- 45:09the data to analyze it and produce a report.
- 45:14And unfortunately, if it's a smaller amount,
- 45:18risk management will, in my head, the game theory
- 45:22and risk management dictates maybe an alternative
- 45:25path. So I'm happy to put myself out of a job
- 45:29if we know that the economics won't make sense.
- 45:33On the flip side, where it might be a smaller
- 45:37dollar amount, but the work still matters, happens
- 45:40in, I think, white collar. So criminal defense
- 45:42cases where you don't want that charge and restitution
- 45:46is not a big deal, that's where we'll work and
- 45:51the budget will exceed what restitution could
- 45:54be. Interesting. You know the whole thing about
- 46:02mediation is interesting today because it's so
- 46:05popular compared to the way it was five or ten
- 46:08years ago and of course even 20 years ago. Do
- 46:12you find that there's a higher percentage of
- 46:15settlements in the mediations that you're involved
- 46:17in now versus what it was maybe five or ten years
- 46:20ago? Is there any change in that? I'm looking
- 46:26up because I'm processing. I think more often
- 46:29than not, the mediations I've been a part of
- 46:31have not settled and have gone to the next step.
- 46:37And I think that's more of parties and what they're
- 46:41trying to do. And like what Michael said, sometimes
- 46:44I think mediation is happening a little too early.
- 46:48And so if it's too early without willing parties
- 46:53to really want to reconcile and it's just like
- 46:56something we have to do to build the case, then
- 47:00more often than not doesn't work out. You've
- 47:03never gone back to the judge through the attorney
- 47:05saying it's too early and that they need to extend
- 47:08the time to complete the mediation. Have you
- 47:09ever done that? Because that is a problem now,
- 47:13early mediation. I haven't counseled the attorneys
- 47:20on timing just yet. I'm trusting that they know
- 47:26what they're doing at this point. But I think
- 47:29now I have a takeaway from this call, from this
- 47:33webinar that maybe recognizing that and having
- 47:37some alertness falls onto the shoulders of the
- 47:41experts as well. We've got about 10 minutes to
- 47:47us. I thought I would throw out for each of you.
- 47:52The question is, what has been your most challenging
- 47:54assignment in a mediation and how did you handle
- 47:57it? I think it's the largest challenge I faced
- 48:06was that one case where I'm the only expert and
- 48:10there isn't an expert on the other side. And
- 48:13that becomes difficult because of the other side,
- 48:19A, may not have the acumen or the willingness,
- 48:23but when experts come together, we more often
- 48:27than not can, you know, essentially we speak
- 48:31the same language. So I'm able to say, here's
- 48:34where I'm coming from. I see where you're coming
- 48:36from. To Michael's point, is there any evidence
- 48:41that's missing that will drastically change the
- 48:44same methodology that we're using? Or do we say,
- 48:51I see what they're talking about and to retain
- 48:53counsel and here's a way we could come together.
- 49:00So I think that's my biggest challenge is not
- 49:03even being able to communicate with someone else
- 49:06that understands what we're doing in the other
- 49:09room. The most challenging situation that I've
- 49:14had in mediation. is when counsel tells me that
- 49:20I should not participate in the mediation because
- 49:23his or her client doesn't want to spend the money.
- 49:29And first of all, in most cases, that's being
- 49:34penny wise and pound foolish, especially when
- 49:37they're earlier mediations. Just think about
- 49:44what the cost is if the mediation is not successful.
- 49:52If the difference between the mediation being
- 49:55productive, successful, and the parties come
- 49:57to an agreement, take the cost of having the
- 50:03expert there and compare that to the cost of
- 50:07the mediation falling apart. and then having
- 50:12to continue the case all the way through trial
- 50:14with all of the risks that go along with it or
- 50:17continue it to another follow -up mediation.
- 50:23And my philosophy is I will never let the cost
- 50:31of having me there get in the way of my being
- 50:35invited to the mediation. If it's a mediation
- 50:42that I should be attending and participating
- 50:44in, I'm going to attend and participate. Unless
- 50:49I'm directed, no, we're not going to let you
- 50:51in the room. But for the most part, if there's
- 50:55a mediation, the expert should be there. Jeff
- 50:59and Bob, actually, I want to pose that question
- 51:01to you. Have you been in a mediation where the
- 51:05experts were not in the room and you wish they
- 51:07were? Yes Yeah, and you know, I think Michael
- 51:19pinpointed it that it was a A question of money
- 51:26on the part of my Client and you know, we've
- 51:32kind of alluded to this which is The ethical
- 51:38dilemma my expert was willing to come And that
- 51:46does present an ethical dilemma that you guys
- 51:49have pointed out where it looks at that point
- 51:52like a one -way contingency. And I ended up in
- 51:57my particular case having the expert there because
- 52:02I thought that the benefits of this person being
- 52:07there, let's just say they outweighed my ethical
- 52:14concerns. And I felt that I had an obligation
- 52:17in the first ethical dilemma to serve my client
- 52:21and that my client was better served having that
- 52:24person there with what minute risk there could
- 52:27be down the road of an accusation that he only
- 52:31would be paid if we won the case. Interesting.
- 52:37I don't disagree. I have found in the last 10,
- 52:4015 years, experts are more often involved in
- 52:44mediations, both outside of the session and in
- 52:49the session. I've always felt that experts brought
- 52:52a wonderful added informational element to the
- 52:57process, whether it was an accountant or somebody
- 52:59else, an economist, or even an expert physician.
- 53:02In the past, I think mediators have been you
- 53:07know, reticent to spend much time with experts,
- 53:11but I do think that's changing, and I think that
- 53:13that's for everyone's benefit. That's my take
- 53:15on it. Yeah, I think that at the end of the day,
- 53:19having us in the room prepared and working in
- 53:26tandem with counsel and the client really pays
- 53:29off, and I think that's kind of a great ending
- 53:32note. We work as teams and so being able to take
- 53:38our work and explain it and communicate it so
- 53:42that the parties can reconcile is really the
- 53:46most important thing. David, can you think of
- 53:50a situation where there is no upside to having
- 53:56the expert there or there was only downside?
- 53:59I don't see it. It can only be good. For the
- 54:04party. I agree. I think maybe one council may
- 54:07have said well if you're there then You know
- 54:10our weaknesses may show up Well, I think if you
- 54:13may if you own to those and then that's really
- 54:15where you know That's where you can make it You
- 54:18don't have to roll the dice and so if you I'm
- 54:21a big believer if you know what you're you're
- 54:23gonna have and you don't have to show up to trial
- 54:26And it removes the guesswork. Yeah, so long way
- 54:30of saying I think there's only benefit in having
- 54:35experts, and to your point, Bob, whether it is
- 54:39the accounting economist or physician expert
- 54:43or other experts in the room, if that's what
- 54:46the case is based on. So I agree. Well, go ahead,
- 54:56Bob. Well, I was going to say when you don't
- 54:58settle and then you proceed to trial, Does your
- 55:04mindset change? I can see you being more collegial
- 55:09and collaborative in a mediation, which is what
- 55:12mediation is all about. But then you go to trial,
- 55:16now you're in an adversary situation. Do you
- 55:19think differently in that context? Do you act
- 55:22differently? Let me jump in on that one. When
- 55:29I'm in mediation, My objective is to assist in
- 55:35the facilitation of a resolution of the case.
- 55:39When I'm on the witness stand in the courtroom,
- 55:42I'm there to persuade, to assist the trier of
- 55:46fact and help the trier of fact understand the
- 55:48evidence. And at the same time, persuade the
- 55:52trier of fact, be it judge or jurors. that my
- 55:57opinion is the one that should be embraced rather
- 55:59than the other guy's opinion. So there's a different
- 56:04objective in the process, and I don't think mediation
- 56:08harms or changes the expert's approach in the
- 56:15courtroom. Yeah, I was gonna say if there are
- 56:23mediation privileges, privilege issues, I think
- 56:27that could be a topic for another time. But that
- 56:30I think also comes into play. I've seen things
- 56:34change. Let's say mediation is too early and
- 56:36there is still discovery, then things do change
- 56:40before trial. But we are there, I think, to provide
- 56:47the analysis. in an objective way, in an ethical
- 56:51way. And I think to Michael's point, if all parties
- 56:59buy in into what mediation is, yes, that we're
- 57:02there with a halo or an umbrella of reconciliation
- 57:08and let's walk out of there to resolve this.
- 57:11So we don't have to have trial. But in trial,
- 57:15it is a different process. And we are there to
- 57:21provide our opinion and to, I think, explain
- 57:25it and to, yeah, I think, persuade. But we do
- 57:30that through what we've done and how we've done
- 57:32it, and usually it just comes through as experts.
- 57:45Do we have any Q &A before we end? I don't think
- 57:50we do. I don't see. Now, in mediation, obviously
- 58:02it's collaborative, but do you ever turn on your
- 58:06persuasion hat, light bulb as well, and start
- 58:10trying to persuade the other expert or the mediator?
- 58:14How does that happen? Go ahead. Mediation, in
- 58:29my experience, is not a form, it's not a venue
- 58:32in which I'm testifying and I'm giving testimony
- 58:35with the intention of persuading the trier of
- 58:39fact to embrace my opinion. Mediation, it's a
- 58:46process of bringing people together and working
- 58:50with those factors, taking the numbers that I've
- 58:55developed, the opinions that I've developed,
- 58:57the basis for the opinions, and working with
- 59:00whomever I have to work with in a mediation in
- 59:04the interest of bringing the people together
- 59:06to come up with a resolution. So it's a different
- 59:13enough form that I don't think in terms of persuasion,
- 59:17except when I took that other expert out into
- 59:20the other room and showed him the other evidence
- 59:22he didn't consider. And I, you know, he persuaded
- 59:26himself that it was something that he needed
- 59:28to consider. So then it would be accurate to
- 59:32say that the mindset and remediation is more
- 59:34of a give and take on the part of the accountant,
- 59:39CPA experts. And of course, once you're done
- 59:42with that, you go into an adversarial mode where
- 59:45you're just 100 % behind your position. Would
- 59:48that be correct? We're trying to resolve the
- 59:51case in mediation. There is give and take in
- 59:55the process of resolving a case. Every case,
- 59:59every expert will typically have certain pieces
- 1:00:03of the ingredients that go into his or her opinion.
- 1:00:12Some of them are may be a little bit softer,
- 1:00:16may involve more judgment, and some of them are
- 1:00:19matter of fact. In mediation, the expert knows
- 1:00:24which of those are judgmental and is in a position
- 1:00:28to evaluate alternative looks at those pieces,
- 1:00:34at those agreed. at those ingredients and those
- 1:00:39numbers that go into the equation. So it's just
- 1:00:42a very different mindset. And I want to add that
- 1:00:47the numbers that we put forth in the mediation
- 1:00:51are generally the numbers. So it's not that it's
- 1:00:56going to change at trial, but I think it's an
- 1:01:00analysis on risk management to Michael's point.
- 1:01:05which one of those soft areas that's more judgment
- 1:01:09will come to pass at trial and what's the weight
- 1:01:14of those things. So if you're able to do weighted
- 1:01:17probabilities of what you think will happen,
- 1:01:20that's where the mediation comes to play, I think.
- 1:01:25And you're able to resolve something without
- 1:01:27incurring additional costs and living through
- 1:01:32the risk of whatever may happen at the end of
- 1:01:37a trial, which you can't control when it's a
- 1:01:40jury. It can go many different ways, from the
- 1:01:44highest to the lowest, or a number that you did
- 1:01:48not think of. So that's where I think we are
- 1:01:53there to inform, I mean, more so than anything
- 1:01:57else, I'm educating the mediator on my position.
- 1:02:01it's up to the opposing expert to do the same.
- 1:02:05And if we can reconcile that and say, look, odds
- 1:02:08of something happening or not happening is X,
- 1:02:13what do the parties think about that? And how
- 1:02:16do they wanna act based on what they're seeing?
- 1:02:20And we can't end on a better note than that.
- 1:02:24I wanna thank everybody who's participating both
- 1:02:28live and in the Beverly Hills. Bar Association
- 1:02:32Library, and particularly thank Michael, David,
- 1:02:38and my co -host Bob for what has been an informative
- 1:02:42and entertaining hour. Much appreciated, folks.
- 1:02:45Thank you. Thank you, everyone. Appreciate it.
- 1:02:49Thank you.