Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Parenting Best-Practices to Raise Securely Attached Children
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:11That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. There we go.
- 0:21So welcome everybody. This is I love you.
- 0:24Keep going. It is Thursday, March 20. 6th
- 0:28Twenty 26th at 7:41 PM Pacific. Daylight Time and I thought that
- 0:35I would talk a little bit about Parenting secure.
- 0:40Parenting is always the question I remember when I was.
- 0:47Up at Berkeley. Doing the attack the Attachment
- 0:50Institute with Mary Mayne. And Eric Hesse, I was talking to
- 0:55her about the work that we do, which is.
- 0:59The the reparenting through ideal parent figure.
- 1:05Protocol the the development of mentalizing and emotional
- 1:08regulation strategies through the use of meditation practices.
- 1:12And the psycho education around. What what secure functioning
- 1:20relationships are supposed to look like if you grow up?
- 1:23Obviously. Or maybe not so obviously.
- 1:26In a family system where you're not receiving the instruction in
- 1:32how secure relationships function, we don't know and so.
- 1:36How are we going to find out? You're going to have to.
- 1:38Learn about the. The the notions of secure.
- 1:42Functioning relationships, and then you're.
- 1:43Going to have to develop the skills to be able to do it.
- 1:49But she was very pessimistic. About.
- 1:51The idea that you could take somebody who had no instruction
- 1:55in childhood around secure functioning relationships and
- 2:00retrain them later, and I think that.
- 2:02That that was largely because conventional psychotherapeutic
- 2:08strategies had up until that time, not worked very well in in
- 2:13changing people's attachment conditioning.
- 2:15And really, I I. Think that that's probably still
- 2:19true the. Addition of ideal parent figure.
- 2:24Protocol has changed that, but you still have to.
- 2:28Do the mentalization training. And the emotional regulation.
- 2:32Training and you still have to understand.
- 2:34The nature of secure, functioning relationships she
- 2:40thought that our. Efforts should be really focused
- 2:43on teaching secure parenting. Strategies to insecure and
- 2:50disorganized people. So that when they.
- 2:53Bring up their children. They bring them.
- 2:54Up in a way that's produces native security, which she
- 3:02thought, or at least she said that the the the the amount of
- 3:09resources that it takes to re. Parent somebody and to retrain
- 3:12them into security. Was beyond what we could
- 3:15recently do, but we. Might be able.
- 3:17To afford as a society. Teaching Parenting.
- 3:24Skills in a way that would produce security.
- 3:29It's an. Interesting thing about
- 3:33parenting. There's a it's almost an old
- 3:39idea of children as a chattel really, where the the parents
- 3:43have the absolute right to raise the child in.
- 3:46Any way that they want. To as if they were.
- 3:50Somehow independent. Of the rest of us and if
- 3:56something goes wrong and they're not resourced, of course the
- 4:00rest of the society has to come in and and and take care of it
- 4:04and to the extent that. We do of.
- 4:07Course, in our culture we don't really do that much as I like to
- 4:16harp on this the the yearly cost for.
- 4:21Medium security prison in California is 55,000 A.
- 4:26Year the average sentence in. California is 9 1/2.
- 4:31Years so. More than the tuition for
- 4:38undergraduate, masters and maybe even a doctorate degree.
- 4:45And we? Pay about 7 or 8000 a year to
- 4:51school. People, school children, so.
- 4:54Obviously if it wasn't so lucrative to.
- 4:58Run prisons. We would probably reorient.
- 5:00That in a way. All right, that's Mike Ripe.
- 5:05I'll I'll leave it there. But how?
- 5:13Would it? How would a childhood appear?
- 5:20What is it that that looks like? That astonishingly low bar of.
- 5:2430% of the time. The child.
- 5:27Needs our men. So or a.
- 5:35Shorthand would you would be when when your child needs to be
- 5:38picked up, you pick them up, and when your child needs to be put
- 5:41down, you put them down. Really the the that the first
- 5:48few months of life is a is that. Transition from the womb.
- 5:52Into the world itself and a lot of attention, a lot of care
- 5:58that's necessary really to produce in the.
- 6:01Child and expectation that their needs.
- 6:04Will be met. Doesn't sound so astonishing,
- 6:09except when. You are around infants and the
- 6:14demand is unrelenting. If you don't have enough care.
- 6:17If you don't have enough. Resources.
- 6:19There aren't enough people around to help you.
- 6:22It's easy to get overwhelmed by the experience of doing that if
- 6:29you don't have secure. Attachment instruction under
- 6:34your belt. Already.
- 6:35Then how are you going? To come up with the way to.
- 6:40Respond to your child. When they need something, the
- 6:47child expresses and the caregiver tunes to the.
- 6:54Child pays attention to the child.
- 6:56Empathetically connects to the child.
- 6:58Attempts to understand what the expression of the child means
- 7:03that they. Mirror back to the child, a
- 7:05sense that they. Understand what's happening, and
- 7:09then they respond. With the care that the child is
- 7:12requesting and the. Child has a sense that I can
- 7:17ask. The world.
- 7:18For my needs to be met and somebody.
- 7:20Will pay attention to me and somebody will meet my needs as
- 7:25the infant develops and they move.
- 7:29Into, you know, 3 to. Five months old?
- 7:32Something in that range to. Begin to understand that
- 7:35specific. People are coming and then they
- 7:37begin to develop a preference for some people over others.
- 7:43You. I think that we've talk about it
- 7:46as the child picking their caregiver, their primary
- 7:50caregiver, and then learning from the caregiver what the
- 7:55caregiver has to teach. If it's the first child, of
- 7:59course you don't. Have a database of.
- 8:02Understanding of how to respond and what the mind.
- 8:05Does is it looks? Into the the procedural database
- 8:09of how to do these things and if there isn't an entry where
- 8:12you're. The caregiver caring.
- 8:13For a child, but it can find an entry.
- 8:16Where you were the child cared for by somebody.
- 8:20That's close. Enough, then it will just flip
- 8:23it and. You will become your caregiver
- 8:26and your child will become you, and you'll transmit to the child
- 8:31the the the care that you. Got it's one of it's.
- 8:35The the the way that these attachment responses are just
- 8:40passed. Down generation by generation.
- 8:45You have an 85% chance of inheriting the attachment
- 8:49strategy of your primary caregiver, but you have a 70%
- 8:52chance of inheriting the attachment strategy of your
- 8:55great grandmother. That's 4 generations out.
- 8:59So it is very stable and it's. Passed down in these ways.
- 9:07So you pick your kid up. When they need to be.
- 9:08Picked up, that is to say the. Attachment system goes off.
- 9:11They rush to. They seek.
- 9:13Protection and comfort and you. Provide.
- 9:17That for them and then. As soon as that settles.
- 9:21And the attachment system turns off, the exploration system
- 9:25turns on, and you put them down. And then you encourage them to
- 9:29continue to, to play, to explore, paying.
- 9:34Attention to them and what it is that interests.
- 9:37Them and what it is. That matters to them, and as
- 9:40the. And the capacity of your of the
- 9:45child. Increases you make the range.
- 9:51For them the space, for them bigger.
- 9:57In some sense I like the way Winnicott.
- 10:02Talks about this is that. When the child feels a sense of.
- 10:05Safety in the caregiver. They don't need to be.
- 10:09Vigilant about the environment. And so in that protective space
- 10:13between the child and the caregiver, exploration happens.
- 10:19The child can absorb and exploring and discovering the
- 10:23things. That they want to know.
- 10:26Because they have a sense that the environment is protected for
- 10:30them. And if they don't have?
- 10:33That sense. In the the environment isn't.
- 10:36Protected then the child has to be vigilant about the.
- 10:41Environment they're in and that. Keeps the exploration system
- 10:46from activating depending on what happens in that
- 10:54relationship. An insecure attachment of.
- 10:58Course when the child is. Convinced that.
- 11:02There's no way to get response, a meaningful response from their
- 11:07caregivers. They become avoidant and when
- 11:13the care is unpredictable and some sense chaotic, they become
- 11:22ambivalent as children. And if the environment is.
- 11:27Frightening. They become disorganized.
- 11:31Who did? Hey George, the The Who was the
- 11:37the person he was mentioning was skeptical of the of the
- 11:43intervention. I think vessel in body keeps a
- 11:46score. The book also mentioned
- 11:48something similar, but it was related with something else that
- 11:54people, if you don't have that experience, it's hard for them
- 11:57to imagine or feel that experience.
- 12:00Right, so I. Can see why?
- 12:05Why their initial plot? Well, I would also think.
- 12:10That what is it we've? Had 150 years of Psychoanalysis
- 12:15right 100. And 50 years of therapy.
- 12:19Would you care? To posit how much?
- 12:24Less fucked up the world is. That's where I think that's
- 12:35coming from. The I I think we we still have
- 12:41to solve. It I don't, I don't get me
- 12:43wrong, I don't and. I I being basically hopeless all
- 12:50my life. Really endorsed Zizik's.
- 12:55Idea that hopelessness is the. Beginning of the change that we
- 12:59need not dog doggedly trying to maintain.
- 13:04Hopefulness, you know, and. Western psychology is very
- 13:16interested. In.
- 13:17Around the construction of the self.
- 13:19Experience if we. Reflect on this from the the
- 13:22Buddhist point of view, we think.
- 13:25That the self is a. Construction that we make up in
- 13:29every moment, which is different than, say, the Western
- 13:34psychological view. That the self is a is a thing,
- 13:39is a something that you can deconstruct and and affect and
- 13:49and the the the. Western versus the Eastern idea.
- 13:51Of how we perceive. And make reality in that
- 13:56Buddhist sense. We do a highly curated.
- 14:01Selection of mind moments around us based on our preferences, so
- 14:06we are drawn to the things that we prefer and we leave out.
- 14:09The things that we don't. Want and then we assign meaning
- 14:17to each of these mind moments. So the capacity to sense.
- 14:19Meets the object. That can sense consciousness of
- 14:21the sensing experience. Arises which is before the self
- 14:26experience, the body actually evaluates, I think mainly for
- 14:30urgency. Does it need immediate?
- 14:32Attention, does it not? Matter whether we ever get to
- 14:34it. Is there time for a pleasant
- 14:36experience? And that creates this cue.
- 14:40Urgent material always skips to the head of the line of these
- 14:45samples of the. Environment that we take.
- 14:48Through our. Senses that are then.
- 14:50Compared to the perceptual database, the.
- 14:54This is again unconscious and. Prior to the conscious self
- 14:58experience. And if there's an entry in the
- 15:02database, we define the present moment based on that meaning,
- 15:08which is the conundrum of the of the human condition in in the
- 15:13sense that time in each moment. Is only the present, right?
- 15:21There is only the. Present moment that we don't.
- 15:23Exist except in the present moment.
- 15:25But the present moment is defined by the past, and part of
- 15:29the past is our expectation of what will happen.
- 15:33So in that present moment experience, it's defined by the
- 15:37past. And we have an expectation.
- 15:38Of what will happen, which is the future, and they're all
- 15:41happening at the same time and then.
- 15:45We tell the self what's happening right then the mind
- 15:49informs the conscious. Self experience What's
- 15:52happening? It's like if, to use a computer
- 15:54metaphor, it's the printer. After everything has been done
- 15:59the the data is sent to the printer and then it it peels.
- 16:02Off and you look at the. Image of what reality you've
- 16:07just made and if you're in the present moment.
- 16:11You have. Almost enough time to avert a
- 16:15completely boneheaded move. But if you're not paying
- 16:19attention, of course the body mind just engages in it.
- 16:23It's not that the self. Makes a reflective decision
- 16:27about what to do and then carries it out.
- 16:29It's actually the fail safe system mostly.
- 16:33Is that making sense? One of the the things about.
- 16:44Taking care of a child. And attending to their needs.
- 16:52That core of that is that sense of safety, but.
- 16:58But it's beyond just the. Physical body of safety.
- 17:03Really what is important is that the child is free to express
- 17:11themselves authentically and that the the caregiver creates a
- 17:18space. Or a container that can.
- 17:19Hold the expressions of a child the authentic expressions of a
- 17:25child so that the child. Learns that.
- 17:27Their authentic expression is actually the thing that's of
- 17:30interest, that is of value and that the caregiver explores with
- 17:37the child what their authentic interests or their authentic.
- 17:41Meanings. Are so that that process of.
- 17:46Developing your native capacities is.
- 17:53What happens and so often? What happens instead is that.
- 17:59The caregivers have a preference for how their child should be
- 18:03and what their child should be interested in.
- 18:06And they direct the child toward the thing that they think the
- 18:09child should be doing rather than what is central to the the
- 18:15child. And, and often they demand a
- 18:23kind of responsiveness from the child.
- 18:28And if that contradicts the authentic desire of the child,
- 18:33the authentic interest of the child too much, then the child.
- 18:37Learns. To abandon their authentic self
- 18:42and develop the capacity for inauthenticity.
- 18:47The characteristics of or that. Division between secured
- 18:51insecure. Attachment.
- 18:52It's really that division between authentic expression and
- 18:59the value of that authentic expression and the the valuing
- 19:04of the inauthentic expression. Disorganized kids, of course,
- 19:10really what it is that happens there is the fearfulness of the
- 19:16caregiver. Typically the the caregiver
- 19:18behaves in a way frightening to the child and to the child is
- 19:27constantly vigilant in in relationship to the caregiver
- 19:31and they never really settle into a sense of safety and that
- 19:37space of exploration never really opens up.
- 19:52You know the the. As young as ten months you can
- 19:59take a child. Through the strange situation
- 20:01and evaluate what their. Detachment strategy.
- 20:04Is you have a 70. Percent chance of using this
- 20:12the. Attachment strategy you had at
- 20:1410 months all the way through your life.
- 20:18That leaves 30% of course, where it changes.
- 20:26And one of the arguments around this.
- 20:28Is that it's so simplistic? And.
- 20:31There's a lot of different effects that that in terms of
- 20:37the child's engagement of the world after they get out of that
- 20:41early childhood period to the mid childhood period.
- 20:44And depending on the the studies, there's more coherence
- 20:48over time or less. And so it's not written in
- 21:00stone. I guess part of it is also luck.
- 21:06You grew up in a. Family system and then.
- 21:09When you were what, four or five years old or maybe now 3-4 or
- 21:13five years old, off you went to preschool or to kindergarten
- 21:17and. How to do in kindergarten?
- 21:19Did they think you were? The bee's knees.
- 21:21And the cool kid. And the the peer group?
- 21:27Really. In your peer group enjoyed.
- 21:31You and you were included, or did that not happen?
- 21:37We all, of course, have the capacity for creating these
- 21:41social hierarchies, which we do. In every environment.
- 21:44We enter into. We create the social hierarchy.
- 21:48And then we peg ourselves. Somewhere in the hierarchy,
- 21:50depending on how well we think we can do.
- 21:53In the environment. What was valuable in the
- 22:00education systems after the Second World War of course the.
- 22:08Standardized test. Standardized testing.
- 22:11Came in and the skills that were valuable or for business came
- 22:17in. And kids were channelled toward
- 22:23activities and learning that was in line with the interests of
- 22:29the business community and less in line with what.
- 22:34The child might be interested in and what might might be good at
- 22:38and the resources were flowed. Into the kids that did well and
- 22:43that kind of learning, that kind of thinking away from the kids
- 22:48who didn't. Naturally fit into that and
- 22:50created a social hierarchy around a certain kind of
- 22:56thinking and devaluing of other kinds of thinking.
- 23:01Even though there there's a whole range of thinking
- 23:06capacities, a whole range of interests and capacities in in
- 23:11kids, we don't really support that much, would it?
- 23:20I had this question about the initial meaning.
- 23:23It's almost like a kid is born with inclination towards a
- 23:29particular thing. Yeah.
- 23:32Like I thought that even that thing if if that thing is
- 23:36considered conditional, then when I was born and if my
- 23:41caregiver put in front of me a guitar and a piano, like those
- 23:46are the only two that I would choose from.
- 23:50Which one did you choose? The guitar, but it's unlikely
- 23:58that I'll be playing the tuba because it was not introduced.
- 24:04Introduced to me by the caregiver.
- 24:06There's not an option. There's.
- 24:10A a wonderful book called Tuba City by Sam Quinones.
- 24:15Which you should really read even if you're not an avid
- 24:20tubist. Yeah, the I played the tube.
- 24:29But do you know, do you know that story?
- 24:31Right? That's why you're saying the
- 24:33tuba I. Know you do?
- 24:35Yeah, but not the not the book. Or you think you're born with
- 24:46that karma of the tuba. I don't know.
- 24:50I know that I I, I enjoyed being musical and.
- 24:55I I could play that OK I'm. I'm I still love music.
- 25:04Although I don't play anymore, I don't know whether.
- 25:10Circumstances had been more in line with what mattered to me
- 25:15that I might still, but the frustration of not.
- 25:18Being able to explore the stuff that I want to became
- 25:23overwhelming and so I stopped the.
- 25:28Frustration by stopping playing. Because that was really what I
- 25:36could figure out to do at the time, you know?
- 25:45The. There is a certain
- 25:47responsibilities for the caregivers to keep.
- 25:49Moving the. Goal posts for the kid so that
- 25:51the kid is. Striving and reaching.
- 25:53And extending and developing capacities as you grow, of
- 25:58course, the. Body is more and more capable
- 26:00and you want a. Caregiver that's attentive to
- 26:03that. And keeps moving the goal post
- 26:07keeps. Challenging.
- 26:09You want in some sense a caregiver who's paying attention
- 26:13to you and and wanting through attention.
- 26:18For. You to do your best, and they
- 26:24pay attention to whether you're doing your best or you're not or
- 26:27not doing your best, and they're supporting you to really come.
- 26:30Into that place where. In each thing you undertake in
- 26:34each. Moment you are doing.
- 26:36The best that you can in that moment doesn't.
- 26:39Mean that there's a a. Standard, because it's always a
- 26:44standard achievement level because each moment is
- 26:47different, obviously, and. Based on the.
- 26:49Conditions of each moment and, but that's very different.
- 26:57From setting the goals that matter to the caregiver and
- 27:01insisting that the child meet those goals right, it could be
- 27:06goals that the child could meet but have so little.
- 27:11Interest in that there's no. Reward for the child.
- 27:14And meeting the goals. Beyond satisfying a demand of
- 27:18the caregiver or the the caregiver.
- 27:21Moving the goal. Posts to the point that the
- 27:24child can't reach it. So that goal?
- 27:27Setting then becomes. A.
- 27:29A mechanism for discouragement or defeating the child's
- 27:35capacity, but that really takes that attention and interest and
- 27:45the resources that are available to the caregiver flowing.
- 27:49Into the things that really matter to the.
- 27:53Child, Do we think that we should be educating our children
- 28:02so that they're competitive in a late capitalist society?
- 28:11If you were to ask me, I think you probably know.
- 28:13I would say I don't. Think that that's actually.
- 28:15What we should be doing? I don't.
- 28:19Think that the consumption of. This period of civilization is
- 28:24actually. Sustainable at all?
- 28:28And that the the havoc that it's.
- 28:31Creating is going to be. Extremely that difficult to
- 28:36manage and actually what we should be preparing our children
- 28:42for is not the illusion that this is all going to be solved
- 28:46by technology, which I don't think it will to and to find a
- 28:51way of. Being in relationship to each.
- 28:56Other because really, we're still.
- 29:01Living in bodies. The singularity has not
- 29:05happened. We have not been uploaded and
- 29:10bodies need what bodies need. They just do.
- 29:14And if you don't have. That they're unhappy and the.
- 29:18Way that the the body. Lets you know.
- 29:20Is by being by filling itself with pain.
- 29:30Julie Hey George. So if my understanding right
- 29:38that if this happens so young that you know, the the parenting
- 29:47to where the child is not becoming doesn't have the the
- 29:54environment to become aware of their authentic interests, but
- 30:01rather is responding in the various ways to the parent.
- 30:06Then then by the time let's say I get to 4th grade and get to
- 30:11pick the band instrument that I'm, you know, interested in, I
- 30:17have no no connection with what my authentic.
- 30:25Yeah, it can be like that. You could have a.
- 30:28Hint. An inkling of it.
- 30:30That's that. You.
- 30:31Keep private. That might.
- 30:33Direct you, but if you've completely lost track of it
- 30:36then. You're going to be responding.
- 30:41To the person that you need to. To respond in in choosing.
- 30:47I was just wondering how like if you know, I guess it sounds like
- 30:52you could be relative degrees of in in touch with my my authentic
- 31:02interests. But how does one, I guess over
- 31:07the course of life, get back, you know, find some connection
- 31:15to their authentic interests? So depending on what your
- 31:22attachment conditioning is, is the place to begin looking.
- 31:25So for instance, if you grew up and you were dismissing, you
- 31:29would. Have a sense of what was.
- 31:32Authentically meaningful. To you, but it would be
- 31:35something that you kept the secret from everyone really the
- 31:39stuff that. You.
- 31:40You you're unwilling to tell anyone is really.
- 31:43The place to begin looking? If you are preoccupied, then
- 31:49what you've been doing is pretending, right?
- 31:52And that really is organized around the enmeshment into
- 31:58someone else. And the the the and the
- 32:05prediction, your prediction of what would.
- 32:08Get them to be responsive. To you.
- 32:11And So what you do is you. Pull your attention back into
- 32:14yourself. Come into your own mind.
- 32:17States your own. Feeling States and begin to
- 32:21examine what would be meaningful.
- 32:24For you. And if you've not explored so
- 32:28much, you're not going to have the knowledge.
- 32:32Already. You're going to have to do is.
- 32:35Try different things so. Then you're going to play 3 or 4
- 32:41instruments and see which one. Felt right.
- 32:45And then in in pursuing the instrument that.
- 32:48Felt more right you pursue. Instruments related.
- 32:51To that so that you. Begin to have.
- 32:54A sense of that, or you'll go hear a piece.
- 32:57Of music and decide whether it resonated.
- 33:01With you or not, and if it did then.
- 33:04That would open up an. Avenue of.
- 33:06Exploration that you would go into one of the things about
- 33:12exploration that is I guess one of the early important lessons
- 33:18to learn is that almost all things.
- 33:26Don't end up. With a lot of meaning and so in
- 33:32when you understand that that's the nature.
- 33:33Of exploration, you develop a resiliency and you also pivot
- 33:39fast. This didn't work.
- 33:42Pivoting into the next thing. One of the things about
- 33:45beginning to learn exploration. Is that you?
- 33:51It takes such. Effort and pressure to get.
- 33:55Yourself to do the first step that if there.
- 33:58Isn't immediate reward and meaning?
- 34:00That comes from taking the first step.
- 34:03You're immediately discouraged from taking the second.
- 34:07Step even though almost. All steps don't lead anywhere.
- 34:14That's the the dilemma, right? That's why I you have you heard
- 34:18my Apple story which I tell? I don't think so.
- 34:23I'll tell you when I in 1970. Eight I got as.
- 34:31Clean from, you know. The whole cocktail of things
- 34:37that I was. Managing life with and and I was
- 34:42really puzzled as what to do next.
- 34:44Right, so you know when. You when you have to get, when
- 34:46you have to acquire things to maintain sanity, you know you
- 34:50have an agenda. And when you don't have to do
- 34:53that anymore, there's no agenda. Really, what do I do?
- 34:56Now and so I. Said to the guy that.
- 34:58Was sponsoring me to me what do I do now and.
- 35:04He said well. Go out and live life.
- 35:09And I said, yeah, I know, but what do I do?
- 35:11He said, well, what? Kind of.
- 35:14Apples do. You like and I said.
- 35:16I don't like apples. They're.
- 35:17Green. They're hard.
- 35:18They're sour and he said. Yeah, Granny Smiths are green
- 35:23and hard and sour, but there's a lot of.
- 35:25Apples, but we really didn't. Have a lot of apples.
- 35:28When I was growing up until he. Said what you're gonna do is
- 35:32you're gonna go to the Korean deli, you're gonna buy a Granny
- 35:34Smith apple, and you're gonna buy any other apple and you're
- 35:36gonna eat them both and you're gonna decide which one you.
- 35:39Like better. And then the next day you're
- 35:41gonna buy the one you like better and another one you're
- 35:43gonna do that. Every day until you've tasted
- 35:46all of the apples. In the Korean deli in the 70s in
- 35:50New York, that was like 26 varieties of apples.
- 35:57So it took about a month. Every day I went and I.
- 35:59Bought the two apples. Then at the end of it I liked.
- 36:03Gala apples which I still. Like I like Pink ladies as the
- 36:07second and I really which are at the the the.
- 36:11Total sweet end of apples, whereas my mother liked sour
- 36:16apples. And they so.
- 36:17All the apples we had. Growing up were on the sour end.
- 36:21Of the scale but. In discovering the one apple
- 36:26that I really like, I. Also discovered.
- 36:28I didn't like 25. Apples.
- 36:31That much right and that's I think is a good.
- 36:35Metaphor for. Exploration most of the
- 36:38directions you had in Will. Not be fruitful.
- 36:42But they'll give you an inkling of what you need to know to pick
- 36:45the next. Direction.
- 36:48You do a survey. You take in the data, you make a
- 36:51decision, you take an action, and you make a.
- 36:53Survey of the data of what happened.
- 36:57Make a decision and take an action.
- 36:59That's the process of exploration.
- 37:01But in the beginning when? It's it's.
- 37:07There's so much energy and to figure out what to do and then
- 37:10you take the step and it doesn't immediately produce something it
- 37:14it can easily translate in in your mind to.
- 37:17The idea that I, I. I'm not doing this.
- 37:19Right. Or I can't do this.
- 37:21Or this is beyond all those things that come up.
- 37:26You know, and then don't forget the sophomore slump.
- 37:31Remember the you know what you're refreshed with.
- 37:37Everything is new, everything is wonderful.
- 37:39You do something two or three times and your skill jumps an
- 37:42amazing level and then you hit the Saltmore slump.
- 37:45Where? All of that.
- 37:47Easy stuff you've learned already, and now you have to
- 37:50learn the hard stuff, and then that takes repetition and takes
- 37:54doing it over and over again in order to.
- 37:57Develop the capacity to do that which is not so.
- 38:02Rewarding at it and because you made.
- 38:04Such fast project progress. In the beginning when you.
- 38:08Hit the sophomore slump you feel like you're not making.
- 38:13Progress. Even though you are right.
- 38:16And then when you get. Up to the to the level of an
- 38:20expert. Let's say I've been taking
- 38:23photographs for, I don't know, a long time, Maybe 40 or 50 years.
- 38:33I can make a good photograph. I can make a good photograph
- 38:37almost every time. I can make a pretty good.
- 38:41Photograph almost every time. But to make an exceptional
- 38:45photograph is really hard, right?
- 38:50And it's unusual when when that happens, right?
- 38:53Everything just has to come together at that moment and.
- 38:57Happen. So that means you make.
- 39:02A lot of good photographs. Very few really good ones, but
- 39:10you can't be. Discouraged by the.
- 39:12The abundance of good enough. You have to go for that that
- 39:21peak. I guess they used to call it a
- 39:23peak experience. There's also the the experience
- 39:35of what's culturally valuable. And how well, what interests you
- 39:42what? Matters to you what is.
- 39:45Meaningful and enjoyable to you. Lines up.
- 39:49With the cultural values and the cultural values is an extremely
- 40:00narrow band of interests that's rewarded and how do you and
- 40:07since we're also conditioned in in this.
- 40:10Sort of ordinary capitalist. The success and the the people
- 40:16that are rewarded, particularly at the the top of it.
- 40:19It's a it's an unbelievable. Amount of reward in comparison
- 40:25to what is available for. Most of the things.
- 40:29That you might do. How do you make peace with that?
- 40:36That you're actually engaged in the things.
- 40:39That are. Meaningful to you and satisfying
- 40:41for you, regardless of their position in the in the social or
- 40:51financial hierarchy. Can you do that, Julie?
- 40:59Yeah. That, that question of how do
- 41:02you know? Or well, maybe it's a different
- 41:06question, but I'm still a little bit stuck on how do you know by
- 41:12the time you get to, you know, adulthood and you're, you're
- 41:17wanting to explore authentically.
- 41:23How can you be sure that you're not just operating in, you know,
- 41:32with that early attachment conditioning of that?
- 41:38Like, let's say I try something and like the example you just
- 41:45gave a minute ago, it doesn't, it doesn't go great the first
- 41:49time. And so I tell myself, you know,
- 41:54that I can't do it or it's, I'm not not going to be able to do
- 42:00it or what? And and so like, like I'm, I'm
- 42:05stuck on how, how do you know you're not just operating in the
- 42:07same, same thing that you, you had, you got when you were a a
- 42:14child in the sense of I know you said like for dismissive look to
- 42:19what's. When you're keeping secret,
- 42:23yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 42:29But OK, well, I I I just I. How do you know is that you
- 42:36engage in the inquiry? Of what's meaningful to me.
- 42:41And you organize the exploration that you do with.
- 42:46That as one of the values that you're tracking what's
- 42:53meaningful to me. Yeah, to me, not to everyone
- 42:58else. And not in relationship to
- 42:59everyone else, just to me. What matters to me?
- 43:02What do I enjoy? Doing the activity of doing.
- 43:07And what do I derive? A sense of.
- 43:09Fulfillment and meaning from doing.
- 43:13Regardless of the the response from, you know the.
- 43:22Wider culture and the individual societies down to my.
- 43:26Peer group, obviously with a peer group.
- 43:30You're going to be engaging in an exploration and you're going
- 43:33to be relying on them to support.
- 43:34You to explore. And where that really is going
- 43:38to take off in relationship? Is because you're exploring
- 43:41something. That is and what you.
- 43:43Discover is actually useful to them and what they're exploring
- 43:47and discovering and what they're discovering is actually useful
- 43:51to you, so that. In the exchange which is.
- 43:54Part of the process of exploration, you go out and
- 43:57discover. What it is that matters to you
- 43:59and you come back and express it to the.
- 44:01People in your circle? And then they learn from that
- 44:07and. Use it in their exploration.
- 44:09And then they come back from what they're.
- 44:10Exploring and they express it. To you and you learn from that
- 44:14and that synergy. That develops between the
- 44:17exchanges that that's vital to. Each of you because it.
- 44:21It allows you to go further than you would have gone if you
- 44:25didn't have that information. Is a piece but.
- 44:32At the end of the day, it's the thing that.
- 44:35Provides that sense of fulfillment for you that
- 44:38matters. And most of us are going to be
- 44:42in a position where that isn't remunerative particularly.
- 44:46And so we're going to have to have.
- 44:47Some source of of support for our primary exploration and
- 44:53it's. Easy enough to get bogged down
- 44:55in the. Secondary exploration, the
- 44:57gathering of time, energy, and resources that there isn't much
- 45:02left for the primary exploration.
- 45:07And because it. It's often a cost rather than a
- 45:11a benefit. We can.
- 45:15Justify not doing it, but then and if.
- 45:19That were it, I think that's what people would do and they do
- 45:25it anyway. But but then the despair of.
- 45:29Life not being meaningful enough grabs you.
- 45:34And as you age of. Course and you have.
- 45:38Less capacity and less energy. If you don't really.
- 45:42Organize it so that you're. Still able to engage in the
- 45:46stuff that meaningful. The aging just becomes an.
- 45:49Unbearable burden. And you know, distraction only
- 45:57works while you're distracted. You know, our whole culture is
- 46:01based on the distraction, as I like to say.
- 46:06I I subscribe to like 9 streaming services and there's
- 46:10still nothing on. So anyway, why don't we do a
- 46:25little bit of practice? What would you like to do?
- 46:36What's 3 IIPF? Would you like to do some IPF?
- 46:46All right. So go ahead and settle in, OK?
- 46:50Let the scene fade, finding a way out of there.
- 46:52I'll count from 5:00 to 1:00 when I reach.
- 46:54One you'll be fully present. Fully Awake 543 21 Fully awake
- 47:05settling the experience how's. That.
- 47:20So. That a quick question.
- 47:28Sure. You know, within the scenes, the
- 47:30exploration saturates very quickly.
- 47:34I've done the you know, one play is over and I was wondering if
- 47:40and I feel like stuck at that point.
- 47:48Do you then begin another one? I mean, so there's a conscious
- 47:54change of scene, is it I just keep changing something else?
- 47:59Ideally it would flow one thing into the next.
- 48:04So you're doing something and then the mind just.
- 48:07Naturally, associates and carries you to something else,
- 48:11and so you move from thing to thing.
- 48:15I'm not sure what else to explore basically at that point
- 48:17with them, feel safe with them. As a child.
- 48:25Do you remember what you explored when you were a child?
- 48:32Maybe football, but. So then maybe go older each
- 48:39time, say. Three or four years older until
- 48:44you're at the age you are now. So it could be present moment
- 48:48exploration as well. Sure in, you know.
- 48:54In the development of that visualization, we start as a
- 48:57young child and then we. Add 3 or 4 years.
- 49:01And explore and then add 3 or 4. Years and explore until you
- 49:04reach the age you are now typically.
- 49:08It's amazing how language growing up in India, it was a
- 49:11different culture and language. Yeah.
- 49:15So I'm like, should I imagine like Indian parents?
- 49:18You know, that was always something that have intrigued
- 49:21me. Yes, why not?
- 49:25And imagine started in in the. Childhood experience that you
- 49:31actually had. I don't have a clear no memory
- 49:35of that. So then imagine the.
- 49:39Childhood that you had. Imagine the childhood that you
- 49:45would have liked to have had. Liked to have had.
- 49:51And remember, there's no practical limit.
- 49:53You could be flying around if you wanted.
- 50:02OK. Thank you.
- 50:06Be jumping off. Skyscrapers and having
- 50:08helicopters swoop. In and.
- 50:09Save you at the last second, you know.
- 50:11Whatever you want. I don't know how that would
- 50:14that. I've thought about that, but
- 50:20system visual but not a grounded feeling.
- 50:25Yeah, yeah, yeah. Where do you want to go and see
- 50:35if you can go? Hey George, if if you are using
- 50:41your present day age to imagine, do you then imagine the ideal
- 50:49parent figures older or the same age?
- 50:55Mine don't age. OK.
- 50:59But then mine aren't. So they're not lifelike.
- 51:03They're cartoon like. Oh, OK, so and I'm I'm my.
- 51:13Ideal parent figures are are more a felt.
- 51:16Sense or a tactical A tactile sense than a a.
- 51:21Visual image. So it's a feeling more than it
- 51:28is an appearance in that way. OK, interesting.
- 51:34So it their age doesn't doesn't matter.
- 51:38Yeah, they're. They're, I mean, they're
- 51:40essentially. Line.
- 51:43Drawings. Animated line drawings
- 51:46sometimes. With a little watercolor, OK.
- 51:52And then my. When I was a child, I always
- 51:58liked. The fabrics that my mother.
- 52:00Chose and. I always liked the fabrics.
- 52:03That my dad's. Suits were made out of and so a
- 52:05lot of it is the feeling, the sense memory of the texture of
- 52:12the fabric, if that makes sense. So what are the?
- 52:18What are the elements that? Have that comfort and soothing
- 52:24aspect to it, which I remember my mother subscribed to
- 52:32magazines, a lot of magazines when we were kids.
- 52:37And so I, I really enjoyed looking at the, the magazines.
- 52:41And so that there was a, a, a, an original structure of
- 52:47fondness of caregivers. I I had to reach for where that
- 52:52would be, but that was one of the things was there.
- 52:57So you are drawing some from your actual childhood?
- 53:02Yeah. What the?
- 53:04The definitions of, I mean, what we're trying to get at is.
- 53:08The longing for what? Care that you wanted as a child,
- 53:13right? That's the origin of it.
- 53:16So what? What is that care that you
- 53:19wanted? And how did?
- 53:20You imagine it. So I in some sense animated the
- 53:27the the illustrations from 40s home and garden magazines.
- 53:35That were around. The house, that's how I came up
- 53:39with an ideal parent. Cool.
- 53:44Thanks. Yeah.
- 53:49So tomorrow. Kaleidoscopist Meeting, which is
- 53:54our monthly gathering if you're. Available for that, it's at.
- 53:5711:00 AM Pacific and then on Saturday we're.
- 54:01Doing an exploration day long, so from 9 till one we've done
- 54:11quite a few of these and and so. What we're going to be doing
- 54:20going forward is focusing on. Particular topics and so the we
- 54:26have a a a topic for this day long which I wonder if I can
- 54:36remember or look up the the topic is reawakening authentic
- 54:44exploration and so it it. It probably the reason why the
- 54:50end of today's talk went the direction it is.
- 54:52Is I've been thinking about this for a few days.
- 54:55Since I'm gonna. Teach it on Saturday, but we
- 54:59will do some dyads as well, which I think will be helpful.
- 55:06And then the, I think that's mainly what's coming up.
- 55:15If you're in New York, I'm going to be teaching at New York
- 55:19Insight on Saturday. The 11th of April.
- 55:26I'm going to be done talking. About meditation and attachment
- 55:31there. And then?
- 55:32I will also be back there in September teaching meditation
- 55:36and addiction, and then in June I will be teaching in San
- 55:50Francisco. We'll do a level 1 in June as.
- 55:54Well, so that's the stuff that's coming up.
- 55:57It's on the website. Take a look.
- 55:58Ioffer the teaching. Freely, but I do.
- 56:01Hope if you're a resource. And can make a donation.
- 56:03You will, it helps support me and also the work that Medigroup
- 56:05is doing. Really appreciate your practice
- 56:11and I hope to see you soon. Bye now.