Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Three Smart Girls (1936)
Transcript
- 0:14And welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:16The show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:18nominee from 1927 to today. I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 0:21And we are joined by a very special guest today.
- 0:24That's right. Sitting upright like the best boy.
- 0:26The best boy. A man of few words, many would
- 0:29say, but also a man of the biggest of hearts.
- 0:33Say hello to the people, Murph. The fact that
- 0:37he is sitting so upright and so proudly is so
- 0:39funny to me. This is where I wish we were a visual
- 0:42podcast. Yeah, me too. To where Murph could just
- 0:44be sitting. You know what? I'm going to. With
- 0:46a thousand yard stare. With your permission.
- 0:48Yeah. I would love to take a photo. Oh, please.
- 0:50Hold on. On pod. Okay. Here we go. Murph. Murph.
- 0:52Smile. Hey, bud. He's kind of side eyeing me.
- 0:55That's perfect. I thought this was an audio only
- 0:58podcast. Yeah. I didn't sign up for this. I didn't
- 1:00have my makeup on today. I'll need you to strike
- 1:02that from the records. We are. And you know what?
- 1:05Who are we? If not three smart boys. This is
- 1:08true. This is true. In this room right now. Yeah.
- 1:11We're recording in my house, which is normally
- 1:13not something we do. But Murph has decided, my
- 1:16dog, I guess I should say that, has decided to
- 1:20join us here on the pod. Murph, your pet goldfish.
- 1:23Yeah. Sitting in your lap. It's worth noting
- 1:25that I'm sitting in a single seat couch cushion.
- 1:30And Murph has joined me on that single seat couch
- 1:32cushion. Yeah. And he is 90 pounds. He's very
- 1:36tall. He just yawned because he's very bored
- 1:38with our conversation so far. He's like, get
- 1:40to the movie. Yeah. He's like, stop burying the
- 1:43lead. You guys do that on every episode. It's
- 1:46called a lead -in, Murph. Yeah. And he's just,
- 1:49he's like, it's not a good one. So let me ask
- 1:53you this. Have you ever heard of Deanna Durbin?
- 1:57No, no, I had never heard of Deanna Durbin. And
- 2:00I'll be honest, doing my research here with all
- 2:03of the actors, he's licking your drink. I hope
- 2:07he enjoys banana bread latte. He definitely enjoyed
- 2:10the cream. Yeah, the whole cast here I was unfamiliar
- 2:16with, really, other than Alice Brady. Of course.
- 2:19We had talked about her before, but this is kind
- 2:22of all new territory for me. I also have not
- 2:25heard of Deanna Durbin, and the reason I ask
- 2:27that is pretty early on. When this movie starts
- 2:31and shows the credits, it kind of does that thing
- 2:33where it's like, yeah, there's this person and
- 2:35this person. But guess who? It's the what is
- 2:38a universal debut? Yeah, it's one of those new
- 2:41star and introducing blah, blah, blah. Yes, this
- 2:44person, which is something I don't think about
- 2:48a lot. But it's it's pretty common that you'll
- 2:51see that, you know, you have a whole cast of
- 2:53characters that you're probably familiar with.
- 2:55And then you get an introduction to what is supposed
- 2:58to be. the new star. And I, I kind of wanted
- 3:01to do some research to see like, what are some
- 3:04of the most notable moments of that? And I, I
- 3:08couldn't think of any that really showcase that.
- 3:10I mean, I think there's a couple that we've covered.
- 3:12I think, um, my God, Skippy Skippy. Yeah. Yeah.
- 3:17But I'm trying to remember his name. Little Jackie
- 3:20Cooper. That's it. Little Jackie Cooper. Little
- 3:23Jackie Cooper to a certain extent, but that kind
- 3:25of didn't last terribly long with the Academy.
- 3:29Shirley Temple certainly received a good bit
- 3:32of that. But those are kind of child stars who
- 3:35you expect that to be. But there are also moments.
- 3:38Is she 12, 14 in this? She might be. I would
- 3:42consider her a child star. But even that is like...
- 3:45Jackie Cooper to me is, hey, here's Jackie Cooper
- 3:48who was a kid. So it's his introduction. But
- 3:51I'm talking about like an adult actor that's
- 3:54introduced, you know, where it's like, OK, check
- 3:56this out. They've never really been in a movie
- 3:58before. Oh, very rare. They use it as a vehicle.
- 4:02Well, no, that's what I'm saying. I've seen it
- 4:04many times in the past. I want to say I've seen
- 4:08it with like somebody in Scream even where they're
- 4:12like an introducing or like some big horror movie.
- 4:15I don't know. I'm wondering who could be in Scream.
- 4:17It's probably not Scream. Drew Barrymore? It
- 4:18had to be Drew Barrymore. But she'd been in things
- 4:20since she was a kid, so it wasn't really an introduction.
- 4:23That's true, yeah. But yeah, hey, you know what,
- 4:25guys? If you are familiar with this concept where
- 4:28a movie is kind of utilized as a vehicle to introduce
- 4:31a new star, and not just a child actor, but anybody
- 4:35who's making their feature debut, let us know.
- 4:39Shoot us an email at outaopodcast at gmail .com.
- 4:42for your favorite example of that. That's right.
- 4:45And also, while you are emailing us, be sure
- 4:48to check out our Patreon, where you can go on
- 4:50and get a bunch of benefits, including early
- 4:52episodes, exclusive episodes like Horror of the
- 4:54Overlooked, and access to the Discord server.
- 4:56Yeah. But let's talk about Three Smart Girls.
- 5:01That is the movie we're talking about today.
- 5:03We are continuing the last three entries in our
- 5:071936, the ninth ceremony awards. Yes. I think
- 5:11I got that right. The final three movies of that
- 5:14time period, I'm very excited to go over them.
- 5:16Three Smart Girls is the first one we're covering.
- 5:19And you said something earlier, and I just want
- 5:21to reiterate it. This really is kind of like
- 5:24a debut across the board for me with a lot of
- 5:27people. Alice Brady, of course, I remember the
- 5:30name. I can't say I placed her, though. She is
- 5:34in one of the Fred and Ginger. Oh, that's right.
- 5:38She was in Top Hat. It might be the one prior
- 5:42to that. Oh, Gay Divorcee? I think it was Gay
- 5:45Divorcee. She was Edward Everett Horton's love
- 5:48interest. Oh, the aunt. Yes. That's it. Okay.
- 5:52Yeah. There you go. That makes more sense. So
- 5:54she is returning otherwise pretty new names to
- 5:58us across the board, including Universal's new
- 6:00star, Deanna Durbin. So Three Smart Girls has,
- 6:03fittingly, three nominations. One for each girl.
- 6:06Well, look at that. Sound was the first nomination
- 6:09for Homer G. Tasker. Original Story for Adele
- 6:13Comandini. An outstanding production on behalf
- 6:16of Universal Pictures. Yeah. So this was directed
- 6:18by Henry Koster and it did star, funny enough,
- 6:22these aren't like the top build, the three smart
- 6:24girls. No, they're further down. Yeah. But you
- 6:26have Nan Gray as Jean, Barbara Reed as Kay, and
- 6:30Deanna Durbin as Penny. And those are, in fact,
- 6:32the three smart girls. The Craig sisters. Yes.
- 6:35So the story follows these three young girls
- 6:39who live with their mother and her parents are
- 6:42divorced. And they find out that their father
- 6:45is about to remarry, and they do not want that
- 6:48to happen. So they pull a parent trap, and they
- 6:51do everything in their power to break off this
- 6:53new marriage and bring their parents back together.
- 6:57So the parents, Donna – no, not Donna. Where
- 7:01is it? Miss Lyons, the mother, is played by Alice
- 7:04Brady. And their father, Judson Craig, is played
- 7:07by Charles Winninger. And the new love interest
- 7:10is Donna Lyons, played by Benny Barnes. Yes.
- 7:14And you said something interesting here. You
- 7:17said that they pulled a parent trap. Worth noting,
- 7:20this predates the parent trap. Yes. The original
- 7:23parent trap. Correct. So this actually was the
- 7:25source material for Disney to create the parent
- 7:29trap later on. But otherwise, the reason... Okay.
- 7:35Good boy. The reason for that... is that so much
- 7:41of this is just what we know as the parent trap,
- 7:43right? Right. A couple differences. They're not
- 7:45twins, not triplets. Kind of a little women's
- 7:49situation in terms of the age gap of the three
- 7:51of these individuals. I think Penny being the
- 7:53youngest is about 12, or maybe 10, actually,
- 7:57now that I think about it. Because when I think
- 7:59back, it was... somewhere between either 10 to
- 8:0216 or 12 to 16 was the age range of these three
- 8:06sisters i believe so yeah with uh the oldest
- 8:08being uh was it joan i believe and k was the
- 8:12middle because k has a love interest and i was
- 8:14like that's a little dicey because she's 14 yeah
- 8:16yeah but um i believe joan's the oldest anyways
- 8:20this is one of the most odd things that we've
- 8:25covered for the pod And I don't mean that in
- 8:28the sense of like, this is the weirdest movie
- 8:30we've ever covered or we've seen. I just saw
- 8:33Buddy last night, so that's not true. But it's
- 8:36certainly the strangest best picture nominated.
- 8:41Yeah. Or strangest movie to be nominated best
- 8:43picture that we have covered so far. Right. Because
- 8:46we've talked about the movies that have only
- 8:49been nominated for one Oscar. Yes. And they always
- 8:51feel like, you know, what are you doing here?
- 8:54You're kind of just a fun movie. For example,
- 8:56Libeled Lady that we talked about recently. Definitely.
- 8:59Great comedy. Great star power in William Powell
- 9:02and Myrna Loy returning. Right. A lot of fun.
- 9:05But it's like. Spencer Tracy. How? How did this
- 9:09get nominated for the best picture? It almost
- 9:11feels more akin to like the modern version of
- 9:16what did they call it? Best most popular film
- 9:19or something at the Academy Awards. Cinematic
- 9:22achievement. Yes. And even then that. That's
- 9:25not what's going here. It seems almost like a
- 9:28retroactive decision because the term that they
- 9:32used in this is Universal's newest discovery
- 9:34for Deanna Durbin. Yeah. But Deanna Durbin and
- 9:38this becoming kind of a franchise for them, at
- 9:41least with three movies, actually. Was it three?
- 9:44It was three. It was like three smart girls.
- 9:49go grow up oh i wish it was returned strike back
- 9:53i believe is revenge of the three smart girls
- 9:55it's three smart girls grow up and then um hers
- 9:59to hold oh was the name of the third one which
- 10:02i gotta tell you i i don't understand that because
- 10:05i'm never gonna be like hers to hold is that
- 10:07the new three smart girls movie right you're
- 10:09gonna have to call it three smart girls comma
- 10:11or not comma colon hers to hold or three smart
- 10:15girls uh universe Or Three Smart Girls Story.
- 10:19Yeah, yeah. Colon. Hers to hold. Spiral. A book
- 10:21from the chapter of Three Smart Girls. From the
- 10:24book of Three Smart Girls. Yeah. From the book
- 10:26of Deanna Durbin. There you go. Yeah. That sounds
- 10:29terrifying. Yeah, this was a strange one because
- 10:32we've covered comedies, but this really is more
- 10:36of like a family comedy. Yes. Yeah. For sure.
- 10:39Except for like one minor thing of like a love
- 10:41plot. Again, she's 14. This is. Yeah. It's a
- 10:45weird one. How did you feel about Three Smart
- 10:48Girls? I am notorious for being, like, so hard
- 10:53to please with a comedy. And I'm always elated.
- 10:57I have an easier time with these early 1930s
- 10:59movies when they are comedies. This was not an
- 11:04example of that. The comedy really fell flat
- 11:07with me throughout a lot of it. The elements
- 11:11in the plot, like with the romance as well, are,
- 11:13like, really... bizarre through a modern lens
- 11:17um and we've also left out the fact that this
- 11:21is kind of a musical in a way like it has musical
- 11:25numbers i know that you have guess my reaction
- 11:28yeah you you have the opinion that a movie does
- 11:32not count as a musical if there aren't like musical
- 11:35numbers and like dance numbers and things like
- 11:38that right uh and this is like the most egregious
- 11:42example of the opposite of a standard musical.
- 11:46Deanna Durbin sings every once in a while, and
- 11:48that's it. So, okay, here's my thoughts. I agree
- 11:53with you on the comedy aspect and how these comedies,
- 11:56I mean, Live a Lady was one of my favorite things
- 11:57we talked about in a minute, and that was just
- 11:59a comedy. And the star power and the romance
- 12:02of it, like, makes you feel like it's an Oscar
- 12:04-nominated movie, fully understood. This is more
- 12:09egregious to me. uh then just like a broadway
- 12:11melody or like hey you're not really a musical
- 12:14because universal was so excited about having
- 12:18a star indiana durbin that they rewrote and refilmed
- 12:23not refilmed but like changed the story while
- 12:25it was going to fit her so the musical aspect
- 12:29that you're talking about is them rewriting it
- 12:31in real time of like oh she can sing put more
- 12:34of her in it So it's less a musical and more
- 12:38here's the part where Deanna Durbin just sings
- 12:40to people. Because, I mean, at one point when
- 12:43she sings, it's just kind of her singing in her
- 12:45living room. Another time it's when her father
- 12:47is like by her bedside and she's like, you know,
- 12:50father, I always say and just start singing.
- 12:52And it's fine. And she's good. She's really good.
- 12:58But it just feels like there is a plot of the
- 13:01movie. And then there's a Deanna Durbin movie.
- 13:04And this is just smushed into one. Right. And
- 13:07for me, it was very hard to get into. This movie
- 13:10is like 90 minutes, if even. And you're going
- 13:14to have to decide what you're doing here, bud.
- 13:16Nope. Okay, you're going back down? All right.
- 13:17Well, thank you. Stay there. It being two things
- 13:21smashed together of like, you know, sister comedy,
- 13:24which I actually enjoyed a good bit of, and then
- 13:27Deanna Durbin vehicle for her to like launch
- 13:29her career. It just, it felt so forced. It felt
- 13:34so forced and it made that 90 minute runtime
- 13:36I was talking about feel closer to two hours.
- 13:39It did feel a lot longer than it was. And I think
- 13:42it's almost comparable to like a Disney Channel
- 13:45original movie where they tried to take a pop
- 13:48star that they're looking to shape and mold into
- 13:50like the next biggest thing. Your Selena Gomez
- 13:53movies, your Miley Cyrus movies, Demi Lovato,
- 13:59right? That's a Disney star. Keep going. Name
- 14:02some more. Am I doing good? Yeah, you got them
- 14:04so far. Who else do we have? Sabrina Carpenter.
- 14:07Was she at Disney? She was. Yeah. Okay. She wasn't
- 14:11like the biggest Disney star, but she was on
- 14:13Girl Meets World and I think one DCOM they did.
- 14:16Gotcha. Bridget Mendler to a certain degree.
- 14:20AJ and Ali. Michalka. These are names I have
- 14:23never heard of. Well, that's because you haven't
- 14:26heard a potential breakup song and I have. we
- 14:29are not the same no we are not um all the girlies
- 14:32got me on that one um yeah it does feel that
- 14:36way but again here's the kicker this is not like
- 14:38the fifth shirley temple movie indiana durbin's
- 14:40like filmography this is it This is the debut.
- 14:44Exactly. So they are putting a lot of bets on
- 14:46Deanna Durbin being a huge star. This was not
- 14:49like we made two movies and found out she was
- 14:50big. So now we have to like counteract this.
- 14:53This is them saying like, we think she's going
- 14:55to be big. So we got to rewrite a lot of this.
- 14:57Right. And she was kind of. I mean, she was a
- 15:01big name and she went on to star in many Universal
- 15:03films. And when I say many, it's not a ton. When
- 15:07you look at a career of Shirley Temple or these
- 15:10other child stars, it doesn't go on forever.
- 15:13She inevitably, after a while, stopped being
- 15:16in the public eye and just stopped making movies
- 15:19altogether. Deanna Durbin debuted when she was
- 15:2114 years old. And she was very popular and successful
- 15:25for Universal, especially through the World War
- 15:27II years with film. very inspirational and taking
- 15:32a lot of the public eye away from the war coverage
- 15:35and everything. It was decided during filming
- 15:39to include Durban more in screen time. And that's
- 15:42my main concern here is you can feel it. This
- 15:45doesn't feel like it was written with the idea
- 15:46of like Durban being like the main character
- 15:48at times. Actually, it feels like she's kind
- 15:51of like, do you ever get that feeling when you're
- 15:53watching like an ensemble piece and you're like,
- 15:55are you a ghost? Like, is the twist here that
- 15:58you're a ghost and, like, no one else can see
- 16:00you but we do? That's interesting. Because there's
- 16:02a couple times where the sisters are just like,
- 16:03yeah, okay, let's do this. Yeah, Joan, you're
- 16:05right. And then Penny is like, me too. So I was
- 16:08like, I think she's not supposed to be here.
- 16:11It is strange. And obviously she was, but I think
- 16:13it's mostly the singing. And then kind of upping
- 16:16her screen time, like you said, was the element
- 16:20that feels very forced. And I think overall,
- 16:23similar to, like, a... Disney Channel original
- 16:26movie set to shoot somebody into stardom. It
- 16:29just feels very manufactured. It does. And I
- 16:33think that's an interesting feeling to get from
- 16:36a movie that was nominated not only for outstanding
- 16:38production, but also for best writing, original
- 16:41story. Because you can feel where the script
- 16:44was revised specifically to aid her. It was definitely
- 16:51aiding her. I do want to point out that she was,
- 16:55again, a big star by 21, so seven years after
- 17:00this film. She was the highest paid actress at
- 17:03the time. Wow. So she was a very big deal. Universal
- 17:07definitely put a lot of their stock in her and
- 17:09their pocket. But the thing that I thought was
- 17:10interesting is that she never really liked the
- 17:13adulation. Really? She just wanted to perform.
- 17:16She didn't really like the stardom of it all.
- 17:18So she stopped filming about 1948 is what I have
- 17:23here. So 1948 on, she never stars in another
- 17:27film. Wow. So they have her for about 12 years.
- 17:30Okay. Pretty much all at Universal, correct?
- 17:34Yes. Universal is where she was the highest paid.
- 17:37That's for sure. We're talking a lot about Deanna
- 17:41Durbin because it... That's really the most interesting
- 17:44thing about this movie, right, is the behind
- 17:46the scenes of this. Sure. It is interesting to
- 17:50know that like this story originated with this
- 17:53movie and then went on to be something that we
- 17:55know popularized in The Parent Trap. And outside
- 17:59of that, it's like a fun story. Yeah. And I don't
- 18:02mean to say it's a bad movie. It's not really.
- 18:05It's just more kind of like an odd duck in an
- 18:08otherwise like we've talked about some very big
- 18:11pictures. And then there's three smart girls.
- 18:16Yeah, this isn't breaking any new grounds. Really,
- 18:19the only thing is the introduction, like we've
- 18:21said a thousand times now of Deanna Durbin. But
- 18:24it's it's not bringing anything new to the table,
- 18:27really. It's not that impressive overall. I think,
- 18:33yeah, the behind the scenes really is what's
- 18:36most exciting to talk about. And we say like
- 18:39Universal really. put a lot of stock into Deanna
- 18:42Durbin, and it paid off for them. We've had Antonia
- 18:45Carlotta on the podcast to talk about Universal's
- 18:47history, specifically with the Lemleys, multiple
- 18:50times now. And we know that in 1936 or the beginning
- 18:56of 1937, the Lemleys did sell the company off.
- 19:00And, you know, they were done. They were through.
- 19:03And that's because a couple of movies, namely
- 19:07Showboat, did send... universal into bankruptcy
- 19:10and i feel like every time we talk about a universal
- 19:14movie on the podcast we're like and this movie
- 19:17pulled him out of bankruptcy which goes to show
- 19:19like how much they were struggling yeah throughout
- 19:22this this time period this is no exception this
- 19:26movie pulled them out of bankruptcy and it probably
- 19:28was the only reason universal continued on after
- 19:32the lemley sold the company which is wild because
- 19:35it doesn't seem like that type of movie to break
- 19:38the bank or anything no it doesn't and i think
- 19:40it's just more the child star of it um i think
- 19:44this is a little bit of blending uh realities
- 19:46of the academy and the reflection of what's being
- 19:49popular at the box office yeah so we've had like
- 19:53you know um little jackie coopers we've had freddie
- 19:56bartholomew we've had shirley temple like we
- 19:59are seeing that in the real world kind of mixed
- 20:02here but this is the first example of I mean,
- 20:05I would almost say maybe Skippy a little bit.
- 20:07But even then, Jackie Cooper's acting is just
- 20:10kind of like, yeah, we need to nominate this
- 20:11kid. And Deanna Durbin is good. I don't think
- 20:15she she definitely has the appearance and the
- 20:17way she talks. You're like, yeah, this is definitely
- 20:18the 1930s star at the time. But it's not like
- 20:22incredible acting. Right. Yeah. And I mean, Jackie
- 20:26Cooper was nominated. Deanna Durbin is not. And
- 20:28the other thing, too, we say like this is really
- 20:30worth noting just because of this rise of Deanna
- 20:33Durbin. From my research that I did, I didn't
- 20:38really see that we talk about Deanna Durbin much
- 20:40again. I don't think that would be the case.
- 20:44As heavily featured as she is here, I don't know
- 20:48that she really was in that level of spotlight.
- 20:52I mean, I looked at her IMDb and I went through
- 20:53the list and I was like, I don't recall any of
- 20:56these. Oh, you know when she shows up? Sorry,
- 20:57I didn't mean to cut off the end of that. 100
- 21:00men and a girl. Oh, next month. Yes. Yeah. Yeah,
- 21:03which is also a Henry Koster -directed movie.
- 21:06So that makes sense. They're going to stick with
- 21:07it. Well, I wonder if she's one of the 100 men
- 21:11or the girl. I'm going to go ahead and tell you.
- 21:14She is top billing on that movie. So she's the
- 21:17100 men. Yes, exactly. Spencer Tracy is the girl.
- 21:22Boy, I'd watch that. Yeah. Oh, Adolph Menjoo
- 21:26is in that movie. Can't wait. Welcome back. Oh,
- 21:28I'm excited for that. Yeah. Do you want to talk
- 21:33about the plot? I mean, we could talk about the
- 21:35plot in this sense. Essentially, Joan, Kay, and
- 21:37Penny, the Craig sisters, do make their way.
- 21:40This is what I thought was interesting. From
- 21:42the beginning, I was like, I wonder where they're
- 21:44traveling from. Because they're talking about
- 21:45going to New York City and how exciting that
- 21:48is. Are they in Ohio or Kentucky? And I looked
- 21:52it up. They're in Switzerland. That's a long
- 21:54journey. It's a long journey. The plot, essentially,
- 22:00it's exactly as you described it, but the only
- 22:02real details in between is that once they find
- 22:05their father and realize that the socialite that
- 22:08he's marrying into is not good for him, they
- 22:13decide to scheme a plot to get him away from
- 22:18her. And the main way they do that is to get
- 22:21her interested in another man who is also very
- 22:23wealthy. And they work with... Is it Bill Evans?
- 22:29So there's like three men in this movie. It is
- 22:31Bill Evans? Yeah. Okay, there's like three men
- 22:33that they recruit. That works out because there's
- 22:35three smart girls. They all look the same to
- 22:37me. They're all wearing suits. Yeah. At one point,
- 22:41we're introduced to Bill Evans, who is... Help
- 22:45me out here. Oh boy. Bill Evans is their father's
- 22:49advisor, financial advisor? That sounds right.
- 22:53Sure. He's their financial advisor, young guy,
- 22:56and he decides to help them because he doesn't
- 22:58really like her either and doesn't think that
- 23:00she's good for his employer. The new bride. Judson
- 23:04is the new bride. Yeah, Judson Craig. Judson
- 23:07Craig is the father. So he decides to help them
- 23:10hatch a plan, and this plan includes hiring a
- 23:13wealthy individual or a man who's claiming to
- 23:16be a wealthy individual to entice. the new bride
- 23:21to leave. And that's Lord Michael Stewart, correct?
- 23:24Well, the man that he hires is another stereotype
- 23:27that we, like a Bedini, if you will, from the
- 23:31Rogers and Astaire musical. And in this, they
- 23:37confuse a younger man for the person they're
- 23:41trying to be talking to. And that ends up being
- 23:43who you mentioned, Lord Michael Stewart. And
- 23:46he kind of assumes this position. and really
- 23:50likes Kay, the middle sister, and decides to
- 23:53move forward with his plan. This is where I have
- 23:57some complications. He does inevitably, we'll
- 24:01skip through the whole movie here, he does inevitably
- 24:03trick the new bride and her mother, who's kind
- 24:07of pushing for all this to happen, to leave Judson,
- 24:11the Craig father. And he then has the opportunity
- 24:16to fall in love with Kay. And then their father
- 24:20kind of has some, I guess, semblance of reconnection
- 24:25with their mother. Yeah. And happy ending. Here's
- 24:28the problem. These characters bleed into each
- 24:30other. You're absolutely right about that. You
- 24:32lose a lot of the plot of what's happening here.
- 24:35And all of that's kind of secondary. Because
- 24:36the movie just wants you to be in love with the
- 24:38Craig sisters, specifically Penny, played by
- 24:41Deanna Durbin. And they're charming. the three
- 24:45of them together. I do like them. I think Taylor
- 24:47would like it a good bit, especially when I told
- 24:49her like, Hey, this is what the parent tribe
- 24:51is based on. She's like, well, ham, if it's about
- 24:53three sisters and I have two sisters myself,
- 24:55I'm going to be interested. But again, that's
- 24:58not a bad thing. It's just, we talk about Charles
- 25:01Lawton on this podcast. Like this is a very different
- 25:04kind of thing. Yeah. And none of the acting here
- 25:06is like, Oh, well this is well worth like the
- 25:09Oscar nomination and this should be here for
- 25:11that. So. Because of that, rather than just going
- 25:14through the synopsis like beat by beat, which,
- 25:16you know, so sorry for anyone who is interested
- 25:18in three smart girls. I just gave you the whole
- 25:20rundown. Let's talk about it real quick. So of
- 25:23those three nominations, sound, original story,
- 25:26outstanding production, best picture. Yeah. So
- 25:29let's talk about sound. Was there any part of
- 25:32this movie that stood out to you as, oh, this
- 25:34sound recording is really, really ahead of the
- 25:37game? This nomination only exists because they
- 25:40added Deanna Durbin singing. That's right. That's
- 25:43all it is. And, you know, I don't know how many
- 25:47nominations there were in this category this
- 25:49year, but this feels like there's got to be something
- 25:53else out there more deserving of this. And this
- 25:56didn't win any Academy Awards. There's, you know,
- 26:00the evidence that, yeah, this wasn't the one
- 26:03to take home sound recording. I don't know. It
- 26:06feels odd to me. There's just not enough in it.
- 26:09I'll say of the movies that we've covered that
- 26:12there are at least one or two other movies that
- 26:14I think deserved a sound recording nomination
- 26:16over this one. But I will say there's a movie
- 26:19that we haven't talked about yet from this year
- 26:21that far and above. deserves that nomination
- 26:24more uh than three smart girls does yeah so it
- 26:28i agree it does feel kind of like a we can't
- 26:30really nominate deanna durbin for best actress
- 26:33because she's really not doing a ton in this
- 26:35um i also don't think that we're doing the best
- 26:38new actor uh award at this point so there's really
- 26:42no point to put deanna durbin in any of those
- 26:44acting nominations so this does feel kind of
- 26:46like a we can't really do score original song
- 26:49so let's just go ahead and do this I just looked.
- 26:51There were nine nominations in sound this year.
- 26:54That rocks. That's so many. I would argue it
- 26:58should have been eight. Four movies that we cover
- 27:01on the show and then five movies that are outside
- 27:04of Best Picture. But, yeah, it is bizarre. And
- 27:07I agree with you. We'll talk about the other
- 27:09movie that you're referencing that I think is
- 27:13a game changer. Yeah, for sure. Definitely. And
- 27:17I can't wait to talk about Tale of Two Cities.
- 27:21So the next one here is Original Story. Yeah.
- 27:25I'm trying to think of why this would be nominated
- 27:27for Original Story, because obviously it's very
- 27:31easy to look at this retroactively and say, well,
- 27:33Parent Trap is one of the most beloved movies
- 27:36of all time, especially of Disney's canon. So
- 27:38why wouldn't it be considered, you know? Why
- 27:41wouldn't we give it an award for its achievement?
- 27:43But that's retroactively looking, right? That's
- 27:45like looking back at this. At the time, was this
- 27:49story that well -written? I think even if you're
- 27:53looking at it retroactively, if you take that
- 27:56same viewpoint and say, well, this is the first
- 27:58time we're really seeing this type of story.
- 28:01And you look at this pulled Universal out of
- 28:04the gutter. Like, it must have been so exciting
- 28:07and so interesting for people sitting in a movie
- 28:09theater that. yeah that's got to be it it was
- 28:12just so popular see and here's what we're getting
- 28:15down to every answer that you've given on this
- 28:18is not only true but it is more in uh indicative
- 28:21of this being kind of like a victory lap than
- 28:25it is the merits of its own uh actions right
- 28:29Or merits of its own accomplishments on screen.
- 28:33Everything we're talking about is off screen.
- 28:34This is like how well it's done in theaters.
- 28:36It gave like a rising vehicle for Deanna Durbin.
- 28:39This helped them get out of bankruptcy for like
- 28:42the, I don't know, umpteenth time that we've
- 28:44seen Universal have this happen to. Right. And
- 28:47I'm sorry, just to confirm, Columbia Pictures
- 28:48was Poverty Row and not Universal? Correct. And
- 28:52yet Universal's always like, we need money. I
- 28:54think that all depends on how they started. Correct.
- 28:56If you start a company with... success not poverty
- 29:00row true so uh all these things are what i would
- 29:06consider like a cinematic achievement now granted
- 29:09that didn't exist back then but this it rubbed
- 29:12me the wrong way that's the main thing and i
- 29:14don't mean to say all that like this is like
- 29:16a star and a half like this movie sucks it's
- 29:19completely fine i think my mom would absolutely
- 29:21love it and i think taylor's gonna have a great
- 29:23time with it too but she's gonna really enjoy
- 29:25it walk away recommending it to her family and
- 29:28then turn to me and be like this was nominated
- 29:30for best picture right it's a weird one yeah
- 29:33i'm gonna say something controversial it's a
- 29:36good thing we're not recording you're right you're
- 29:38right um murph cover your ears he's asleep it
- 29:41doesn't count 50 years from now 60 years from
- 29:44now right from now or from now okay yeah into
- 29:47the future so we're looking at like 2086 right
- 29:51Say somebody is doing this podcast in the future
- 29:53and they're looking back at movies from like
- 29:55the 20 teens. Right. And they look at something
- 30:00like Get Out. Right. Good movie. Really good
- 30:04movie. A horror movie, which is usually overlooked
- 30:08by the Academy Awards. Right. We should make
- 30:10a show about that. We should. Horror of the Overlooked.
- 30:13Check it out. Patreon exclusive. But 60 years
- 30:17from now. I'm going to be very optimistic and
- 30:19say that we have progressed forward. You know,
- 30:22we have made huge strides towards kind of just
- 30:28being more accepting of people and cultures and,
- 30:32you know, just not being awful racist people.
- 30:35Most of us. Most of us. By 2086, right? Looking
- 30:40back at a movie like Get Out that feels really
- 30:42like in the times this is a big deal. The story
- 30:46that is being told is something that's not really
- 30:49been told to a mainstream audience with this
- 30:52like budget, you know? Right. Does somebody look
- 30:55at that movie 60 years from now and go, man,
- 30:58this is really good, but I don't really get why
- 31:00it was nominated for Best Picture. The cinematography,
- 31:04you know, the... The writing's good, but by then
- 31:07it's kind of part of the course. You know what
- 31:09I mean? They'll say, well, we've seen this before.
- 31:12Yeah, I mean, I see what you're saying. I think
- 31:15that I feel Get Out is more defensible in why
- 31:19it would be nominated for, you know, was it just
- 31:21nominated for screenplay? I don't even know.
- 31:23I should look up. I believe at least screenplay,
- 31:25because I know Jordan Peele won for that. But
- 31:27at the very least, screenplay alone. The screenplay
- 31:32on that makes sense because the story interweaves
- 31:35so much of the racial tension and societal placements
- 31:40of race or thoughts on race. Yeah. With this,
- 31:44it's... You know what? I just realized. This
- 31:46is the comp I want to make. This is essentially
- 31:49a Rogers and Astaire picture without the dancing
- 31:53and without as much of the singing. And when
- 31:56you do that... And you look at why that movie
- 31:58or those movies were nominated. The answer is
- 32:01Rogers and Astaire, which is why it was so popular.
- 32:04But they're dancing. And then the musical set
- 32:08pieces behind them, the choreography, all of
- 32:11that. The comedy was second to that, right? They
- 32:14were never nominated for the comedy. It was just
- 32:15that made it enjoyable. And that was a fun picture.
- 32:18Yeah. The music and the dancing is what made
- 32:22that stand out in this. It's just Durbin. And
- 32:26it's not like a Shirley Temple. She's like kind
- 32:29of like dancing around and people are like watching
- 32:31her again. This is more like, hey, I'm going
- 32:34to sing you a song right now. Is that OK? And
- 32:35everyone's like, I guess so. And she just sings
- 32:37in front of people and that's it. So there's
- 32:40no like grand scale of the music. There's nothing
- 32:42like soaring about it. She's a good singer. Yeah,
- 32:45no question about it. But that takes away everything
- 32:48that we've seen previously of why those kinds
- 32:50of movies have been nominated, which makes this
- 32:51feel just kind of flat. I would almost agree
- 32:54with you, but this was nominated for writing.
- 32:56Right. And that's what I'm saying. Why? Like,
- 32:59I don't really understand. But that's what I
- 33:01mean. When I brought up Get Out, it's like that
- 33:04was nominated for writing. And in this year,
- 33:072026, I totally get that. Because, again, that
- 33:11hadn't been done before. And it was so popular.
- 33:14It was so well received. Like you said, Jordan
- 33:16Peele took home the Oscar for writing. It was
- 33:19nominated for four as well. Oh, three other things.
- 33:22Outstanding. Best picture, whatever. Director
- 33:25and best actor. Oh, Kaluuya. Oh, nice. But in
- 33:3060 years from now, will that feel like we've
- 33:34had so many movies that have touched on this
- 33:36topic in a way that was inspired? You know, those
- 33:39movies will be inspired from Get Out, I'm sure,
- 33:43the way The Parent Trap was inspired from this.
- 33:46Do we just say, oh, well, we've seen this so
- 33:48many times. Going back to the source material
- 33:50feels like, yeah, it's good, but I don't really
- 33:54understand unless I really put myself in that
- 33:57time period and look at what was going on. And
- 34:01what do you think was going on at the time to
- 34:03where that made this story really stand out?
- 34:06It's not as important by any means as Get Out.
- 34:10Right. But I think people were. struggling through
- 34:13the depression and this was a movie that the
- 34:15whole family could go see and have a lot of fun
- 34:18with right i kind of think that's all it was
- 34:21this is the most popular film that universal
- 34:24put out and everybody enjoyed it yeah i think
- 34:28this is just gonna be one of those that i just
- 34:29don't fully like grasp why the original story
- 34:32nominated sure i get that and it again that feels
- 34:36like the cinematic achievement like hey everyone
- 34:38really enjoyed this picture um and that's about
- 34:41it but Let me ask you this of sound. I know the
- 34:44answer without staying in production, but of
- 34:46sound and original story, did it win any of those?
- 34:49This didn't win anything. No. Then it's a moot
- 34:52point. I'm okay. Yeah. I really do feel like
- 34:55this makes more sense to me to be nominated for
- 34:58original story and that's it. Not even for best
- 35:01picture. Yeah, I agree with that. I mean, the
- 35:05original story, I still obviously have some qualms
- 35:07as to like. why yeah but for the most part uh
- 35:10i would take that over the sound which i still
- 35:13think if anything maybe i would give it a sound
- 35:16because i understand why i don't think it's the
- 35:19best example of it but i understand but best
- 35:21picture just feels kind of like a we need a tenth
- 35:23same way that libel lady felt it's just We enjoyed
- 35:27that more, which is so funny because this has
- 35:29more nominations than Live Old Lady. I know.
- 35:31It's so bizarre. But this happens pretty frequently
- 35:34at the Academy Awards. If this movie, if Live
- 35:37Old Lady had come out the next year after this
- 35:40year, and we'll get there, I think that it would
- 35:43have gotten more nominations just for Spencer
- 35:44Tracy. But we'll get there. This is a weird one
- 35:48to talk about. Because there isn't anything really
- 35:52that consequential that happens in this outside
- 35:55of Deanna Durbin. Deanna Durbin is the largest
- 35:57part of the history of this movie. Yeah. And
- 36:00at the end of the day, it is a fun comedy that
- 36:04has some singing, not terribly much. And it's
- 36:08mostly just a Deanna Durbin vehicle that the
- 36:10story does not make her the vehicle. It's more
- 36:13just the way they filmed it did. Sure. So it
- 36:15feels very uneven. It's not really something
- 36:18I'm eager to revisit. And yet it's not terrible.
- 36:22Right. We talked about movies on here that we
- 36:24just didn't enjoy. Movies that outright annoyed
- 36:26us like Midsummer Night's Dream. Right. And sorry
- 36:30to do that to you. And this is just kind of there,
- 36:36which honestly, I don't know why almost makes
- 36:40me more aggravated, if that makes sense. Yeah.
- 36:43Like when a movie is that controversial. It's
- 36:47like, okay, well, I understand like some of the
- 36:48controversy here. Like now we're looking back
- 36:50and this isn't as interesting. And Midsummer
- 36:53Night's Dream is a great example because the
- 36:55visuals of that movie and the cinematography
- 36:57alone, you're like, look at what they're doing
- 36:59with this. That kind of complicates the problem
- 37:02a little bit when it comes to like how indecipherable
- 37:05the movie is for me. But still, you can't deny
- 37:08the cinematography of that. In this, you're really
- 37:11looking for like the thing that's going to defend
- 37:13it. Like you can say, oh, yeah, but look at that.
- 37:15And the only thing is Deanna Derman. And even
- 37:17then, we're going to talk about her one more
- 37:19time next month. And outside of that, I don't
- 37:21believe she pops back up. I don't think so. I
- 37:23think that through a modern lens, if there are
- 37:26people who enjoy this, which there definitely
- 37:28are. Oh, 100%. Letterboxd shows. Oh, I've got
- 37:33to pull it back up because I had get up. Get
- 37:35out. Get up. Get out. What is this called? Three
- 37:38Smart Girls? Get on up. You were looking at the
- 37:40James Brown movie. That's the one. So this has
- 37:453 .2 stars average on Letterboxd, which, you
- 37:47know, it's not crazy, but it's... It's above
- 37:50average. Yeah, it's above average. And I think
- 37:52that the people that do find enjoyment in this
- 37:55movie are going to find it in the comedy. Like,
- 37:57it's just going to work for them. And comedy
- 37:59is so subjective that... I mean, there are movies
- 38:03that you love, comedy movies, that I'm like,
- 38:06I... Here we go. Uh -oh. Ryan. Don't do this.
- 38:10Did I tell you that I watched Nirvana the Band,
- 38:12the show, the movie? Did I tell you that? You
- 38:14didn't tell me that, but I did see on Letterboxd.
- 38:17Yeah. And I was like, and we never spoke of Nirvana
- 38:20the Band, the show, the movie ever again. We
- 38:22never did. But that's an example, you know, where
- 38:24comedy is so subjective. Right. And that's a
- 38:27movie that you really like. I think you gave
- 38:29it five stars on Letterboxd. I gave it five stars,
- 38:30yeah. Yeah. And I sat down and I watched it at
- 38:33home and I... I always feel bad when somebody
- 38:37recommends a movie and then you're like, yeah,
- 38:39I wasn't really into it. But I genuinely struggled
- 38:41to get through that a little bit. You were two,
- 38:44two and a half stars? I think so, yeah. And your
- 38:47big sight there was you really liked the idea
- 38:52of how they did some of this stuff, which I'm
- 38:54excited to talk to you about. But the comedy,
- 38:56mostly Matt Johnson's edgelord comedy, if I can
- 38:59put words in your mouth, that didn't do it for
- 39:02you. There was a lot of like... And frantic yelling
- 39:06that I think was supposed to be the big selling
- 39:08point of the comedy. And it just got very tiresome
- 39:12very quickly. But that's what I'm saying. Like
- 39:15comedy is so subjective. And even in modern movies,
- 39:19you love that movie and I didn't personally care
- 39:22for it. So when you go back and you look at Three
- 39:24Smart Girls and I sit down and just almost immediately
- 39:27I was like, this isn't for me. The comedy is
- 39:30not working on me. It's doomed because that is.
- 39:33the core element of what the movie designs itself
- 39:37around, whether Deanna Durbin is fantastic or
- 39:40not, or, uh, Alice Brady, you're excited to see
- 39:43her again. If the comedy falls flat in your comedy
- 39:46movie, that's it. You're done. So that's right.
- 39:50I mean, and that's, that's really where it lies
- 39:53with me. Like it's the comedy fell somewhat flat
- 39:57again, like pretty good, but you're just kind
- 39:59of like, what am I, what are we doing here? Yeah.
- 40:02Um, you're right that people enjoy this movie
- 40:04and I'm nothing to take away from them at all.
- 40:08This is solely just me not being able to resonate
- 40:10with it as much, but it is the, the best way
- 40:13I can describe it is what I've said earlier.
- 40:14It's an odd duck. It is a strange movie to be
- 40:18nominated for best picture. And again, if it
- 40:22was bad, it'd be very easy to just be like, yep,
- 40:24this was a misfire. Let's move on. It's not bad.
- 40:27It's just kind of like, The best way I can put
- 40:30it is it's when you have a lasagna at a steakhouse.
- 40:34And you're like, hey, this lasagna is pretty
- 40:36good. Am I at a steakhouse? Right. It's like,
- 40:38well, why did we get this? Yeah. Why is this
- 40:40on the menu? Yeah. I mean, it's good. It just
- 40:43feels like this should be at an Italian spot
- 40:45or somewhere not at a steakhouse. So absolutely
- 40:49nothing wrong with the movie itself. Deanna Durbin
- 40:52I don't think worked for me as much as it did
- 40:54for the... general consensus of 1936 yeah but
- 40:59uh you can't deny the star power i mean again
- 41:03by seven years after this movie she was the highest
- 41:05paid actress in uh crazy in universal so maybe
- 41:10in general but i at least read in universal yeah
- 41:12so all credit where it's due uh fun uh exciting
- 41:17it spawned a lot of great things like the parent
- 41:20trap i mean it kind of continues the Not necessarily
- 41:23screwball comedy. A little bit it did. Yeah.
- 41:26But it definitely like made room for, you can't
- 41:29argue that this is a three women led movie. Like
- 41:34this is a movie that has revolved around three
- 41:35women in the comedy. And it was not like a punchline
- 41:39to like that they are women. It wasn't a punchline
- 41:41that they were little girls. If anything. There's
- 41:44kind of an inappropriate romance between... Let's
- 41:47talk about Bill Evans and Lord Michael... Byron?
- 41:50Scott? Michael... Not Michael Scott. Lord Michael
- 41:53Scott. Now, hold on. Michael Stewart, I think
- 41:55it was. Michael Stewart. That's it. Yeah. Because
- 41:57he mentions MS at one point, and I was like,
- 41:59what? Old MS. I was like, multiple school lessons?
- 42:03No, he was talking about MS. There's romances
- 42:06between Kay and Joan and their respective...
- 42:11It's not really ever fully outright said that
- 42:14Bill Evans and Joan are having a relationship.
- 42:16It's just you see the romance budding a little
- 42:18bit. Yeah. But 100 % you see the romance between
- 42:21Kay and Lord Michael Stewart. Now, big age gap.
- 42:25At what point? I mean, I guess you can be a child
- 42:27and be Lord. Yeah. But there's something about
- 42:30like a grown man and a, let's say at best, 16
- 42:34year old girl. Right. And she's calling a man
- 42:38Lord Michael Stewart. There's just something
- 42:41a little weird about that because the age of
- 42:43the girls is pretty cited often. It's cited pretty
- 42:47often. Sure. The age of the men isn't. And they're
- 42:51wearing suits and they're working in business.
- 42:54So it just kind of seems like at least 21, maybe
- 42:5820? Yeah, I mean, it's not great. Either way
- 43:01you look at it. No, it's not great either way.
- 43:03It's not like a deal breaker. It's just kind
- 43:05of like, oh, that's strange. I would say it's
- 43:08a deal breaker for me. Yeah, it was very uncomfortable,
- 43:11a lot of the flirting. There's also a strange
- 43:14scene in this movie between, which one? Barbara
- 43:18or Deanna is who? Penny? Penny. I think it's
- 43:21Penny. Penny goes upstairs to talk to her father
- 43:24at one point, and everybody is downstairs just
- 43:27listening. Is this after she broke the bed? Yeah.
- 43:31Penny breaks the bed trying to move it. And her
- 43:33father comes up and he's like yelling at her
- 43:35like, what did you do? And he starts to try to
- 43:38fix the bed. So he's like banging on a leg or
- 43:41something. Oh, yeah. And she's like, no, daddy,
- 43:45don't. You're going to break it. Or she doesn't
- 43:48say you're going to break it. But a lot of daddy,
- 43:50don't. Please stop. And it's kind of assumed
- 43:54by everybody downstairs that she's being. Punished
- 43:57by her father? Spanked is probably the best thing
- 44:01you can look at. And I think that can be kind
- 44:05of a, ha, that's kind of funny. I understand
- 44:08the comedic implications there. Yeah. But then
- 44:13it moves into laughter. They start laughing and
- 44:15everybody downstairs is like, what? Well, I think
- 44:18the line before it starts showing what's happening
- 44:21upstairs is, no, daddy, that's the wrong hand.
- 44:24And it's like, yeah, this is weird. Yeah. Yeah,
- 44:27it gets really awkward. I didn't like it. No,
- 44:31and it's very clear. It's not just like an incidental,
- 44:34we're looking too much into it. The camera work
- 44:36is like, you're supposed to see the reaction
- 44:38of the people downstairs who are hearing this
- 44:40before we cut up to see what's actually happening.
- 44:43And the people downstairs are like that monkey
- 44:45puppet meme where he's just like side -eyeing
- 44:49so hard. They're looking at Joan and Cain being
- 44:51like, is he good? Like, is she good? What's going
- 44:55on up there? It's very uncomfortable. Did not
- 44:58like it. I think I had mostly checked out up
- 45:02to that point. And then when that happened, I
- 45:03was like, if this is the comedy that we're leaning
- 45:05into. And then you also have these inappropriate
- 45:08relationships. Like, I'm good. I'm okay. I think
- 45:12the biggest offender for me is just how much
- 45:14of this movie feels like you can feel where they
- 45:17wrote in, this is where Deanna Durbin needs to
- 45:19sing a song. Yeah. Like, there was a scene where
- 45:21I think everyone's like, hey, we're going to
- 45:23continue the plot. Penny, you got to go down
- 45:26and tell the police officers what's happening
- 45:27here. Oh, boy. And she's like, cool, got it.
- 45:30Me, the 14 -year -old, again, at best, that's
- 45:33how old she was in real life. I think maybe she's
- 45:3510 in the movie. You need to go and tell the
- 45:37cops what's happening. She's like, heard, got
- 45:39it. And there's a whole scene where she's like,
- 45:41please, I'm paraphrasing immensely. Of course.
- 45:44Please, you got to help my dad. It's like he
- 45:47always said. And she goes into a song in front
- 45:49of the police officers. I'm like, what are we
- 45:51doing? Yeah. Why is this? And it's funny because
- 45:54she tells the police officers like, oh, I am.
- 45:56you know, studying opera or something like that,
- 45:59that explains why she sings. And all of the police
- 46:02officers sit there and they allow her to sing
- 46:04and they're listening intently. And then when
- 46:06she's done, the head cop or whatever goes, that
- 46:10was really nice. Fellas, take her away. Like,
- 46:13he didn't care at all. It's such a weird movie.
- 46:17I would have liked a scene where halfway through
- 46:20the song, it just cuts to a camera of a guy.
- 46:24booking someone or talking to a woman she's like
- 46:25please my husband's dead he just like right closes
- 46:28the door yeah they just leave some silence in
- 46:31here they don't care about anybody in this place
- 46:33um i actually want to get into ratings because
- 46:37there is an element historically that i like
- 46:40from this movie but it leads into my double feature
- 46:42heard okay which is funny because that's kind
- 46:45of the same thing for me so i'll tell you right
- 46:48off the bat i gave this movie two stars i didn't
- 46:51care for it I would probably give it less on
- 46:55a rewatch, honestly. It was completely mediocre
- 47:00and also kind of offensive at times. Yeah, I
- 47:04mean, there's no beating around the bush with
- 47:07that scene about the bed breaking. It's just,
- 47:10it feels very uncomfortable. I gave it two and
- 47:13a half stars. The half is mostly just kind of
- 47:16acknowledging what it goes on to be. Not that
- 47:21it factors into much of my rating, but I suppose
- 47:23we can also say the rising star of Deanna Durbin
- 47:26and this being her debut is a big part of that,
- 47:29too. And again, the movie is completely fine.
- 47:33And if this was like a not Disney Channel original
- 47:36movie, but Wonderful World of Disney that came
- 47:38on on ABC. If this was that movie, I would be
- 47:42like all day, every day. This movie is completely
- 47:43fine. It's exactly what you'd want from it. It's
- 47:46just not what you would want from a Oscar nominated.
- 47:50comedy it's very different than that so two and
- 47:53a half stars and i'm being a little generous
- 47:55with that yeah as far as double features go though
- 47:58yes uh i've kind of already um announced what
- 48:03i'm doing here but i did go with the original
- 48:06adaptation original adaptation the original uh
- 48:09parent trap film okay so this came out in 1961
- 48:13nailed it directed by uh david swift yeah i got
- 48:18that right Parent Trap 1961, directed by David
- 48:22Swift. This was the original Parent Trap. Would
- 48:26you say that the most, like when you think of
- 48:28Parent Trap, eyes closed, you think of the Lindsay
- 48:30Lohan? Absolutely. Same. Yeah. And I think that's
- 48:33the... quintessential version of the Parent Trap
- 48:36is the Lindsay Lohan vehicle. But with this one,
- 48:39I felt like it was important to highlight the
- 48:41original just because Parent Trap, Lindsay Lohan
- 48:45has a little bit more of a place in my heart.
- 48:47And I have a feeling if I see something that
- 48:48resembles it more in the future, I want to hold
- 48:50onto that card. But with this one, you can't
- 48:53deny what this did for Disney. Like this was
- 48:55their continuation of a success in live action
- 48:58films. And I think that they really took the
- 49:00story of Three Smart Girls and evolved it into
- 49:04its elite form would be this movie yes i agree
- 49:08i am grateful for this movie because it eventually
- 49:11led to the lindsey lohan parent trap and man
- 49:15i i love that movie growing up you really do
- 49:17give off uh tie -dye girl vibes do i yeah i appreciate
- 49:21that yeah you know i do my best it's a you never
- 49:24skip arm day that's definitely not true take
- 49:28the damn compliment So the other thing that I'm
- 49:32grateful that was birthed from this eventually,
- 49:37Henry Koster, the director here, goes on to do
- 49:41100 Men and a Girl. With Deanna Durbin, right?
- 49:43Henry Koster was a German -born director. He
- 49:47was Jewish as well. And he fled Germany in 1932
- 49:50due to everything going on with Germany. Right.
- 49:54Obviously. And there was a producer at Universal
- 49:57named Joe Pasternak, and he was kind of the European.
- 50:01He would go out and look for talent, basically,
- 50:03to sign people on for movies. And he stumbled
- 50:06upon Henry Koster, who was making movies out
- 50:08in Germany, and he offered him the opportunity
- 50:12to make three films for Universal Studios. They
- 50:15were all successful. Henry Koster begged to be
- 50:18able to make this movie. He really, really wanted
- 50:20to do it, and good for him because it pulled
- 50:23them out of bankruptcy. So this gave him a lot
- 50:25of freedom at Universal. One of the things that
- 50:29he ended up doing was he went to a nightclub,
- 50:31and he stumbled upon a comedy duo that he thought
- 50:35would be great for Hollywood Pictures. That comedy
- 50:39duo is Bud Abbott and Lou Costello. He directed
- 50:43One Night in the Tropics, which I personally
- 50:45have never seen, but I do have the... Abbott
- 50:48and Costello collection of everything they did
- 50:50with Universal. But my double feature is what
- 50:53eventually came to be Abbott and Costello meet
- 50:55Frankenstein. I love Abbott and Costello and
- 50:59I love specifically meet Frankenstein. I grew
- 51:04up mostly in Orlando, but I was born in New Jersey.
- 51:07And I remember sitting down when I was like five
- 51:10years old with my mom and watching these old
- 51:13black and white comedy movies that were just
- 51:16the perfect introduction to the universal monsters
- 51:19mixed with like a great level of comedy. And
- 51:22while that is not a Henry Koster film, the fact
- 51:26that Abbott and Costello even exist in the pictures.
- 51:30can be credited to director Henry Koster. The
- 51:32butterfly effect of Three Smart Girls. Yeah,
- 51:35so thank you so much, Three Smart Girls, for
- 51:39bringing me my two silly men. Yeah, that's right.
- 51:43That's really funny that that ends up being like,
- 51:46hey, this movie is great because it gave me Abbott
- 51:49and Costello. Yeah, I love Abbott and Costello.
- 51:52I didn't realize that with Henry Koster. Yeah.
- 51:55You said he directed, was it just the one Abbott
- 51:58and Costello film? I don't know if it was just
- 52:00the one. He may have done a couple. But he did
- 52:02not do Frankenstein. No, he didn't do the monster
- 52:05ones. Which are the best, I think. Yeah, absolutely.
- 52:10But One Night in the Tropics, I believe, is the
- 52:12Who's on First movie. Oh. So you could argue
- 52:16the most famous element of Abbott and Costello
- 52:19came from Henry Coster. Perfect. Plus them. Great
- 52:23pick. Thank you. Appreciate it. So is The Parent
- 52:25Trap, of course. Love The Parent Trap. But that
- 52:27is Three Smart Girls. Again, shoot us an email
- 52:30if you have thoughts and be sure to check out
- 52:32the Patreon. Next episode, we are covering another
- 52:35classic literature adaptation with A Tale of
- 52:39Two Cities. Looking forward to that one. But
- 52:41you have anything else you want to add? No, we
- 52:44go back to Charles Dickens. We've already talked
- 52:47about Shakespeare once this year. So we're going
- 52:49to be talking about Romeo and Juliet. Right.
- 52:52We've already done Romeo and Juliet. That's what
- 52:54I'm saying. We already talked about it. Oh, yeah,
- 52:56yeah, yeah. We already talked. I thought you
- 52:57were... I was like, I just said we're doing The
- 52:59Tale of Two Cities. No. And we have our Charles
- 53:02Dickens adaptation coming up. So excited for
- 53:04that. You know, I think that this is also the
- 53:07first time that we've covered movies since doing
- 53:11our 12 movie runs, the 12 nominated films. So
- 53:16do you feel... Do you feel that yet? Do you feel
- 53:20like we're covering less, or do you feel like
- 53:22it's about the same? No. I mean, it took us a
- 53:25month and a half to get through to the last ceremony.
- 53:28The last two. Even now, I'm just like, oh, wow,
- 53:31it's pretty much time for another ceremony episode.
- 53:34That is nuts. Yeah, that's true. We're just wrapping
- 53:38up here. I'm excited. I'm excited to keep it
- 53:40going, and I'm excited about the remaining two
- 53:41that we have left to talk about. Yeah, and just
- 53:43a reminder, if you want to get those thoughts
- 53:44in about the show. It is the Sunday before the
- 53:48ceremony drops. So we look forward to hearing
- 53:51those from you. But that's going to do it for
- 53:54this episode. As always, I'm Kyle. I'm Ryan.
- 53:57And we'll see you at the movies.