Latest / Following Leads / 'This is a crime story': Putting polarizing politics aside to cover the killing of Charlie Kirk
Transcript
- 00:00:00 Speaker: It is interesting covering a story, especially when it's a political figure, which she was, because half of your viewers aren't are not going to like the person. I mean, that's just the reality of politics. And so in this story and covering this story, we really had to try to put the politics aside and remember that this is, at its core, a crime story. This is a dad. This is a son. This is a friend from our community who was murdered. One year ago, Americans were stunned by the assassination of Charlie Kirk. The thirty one year old was shot and killed on Wednesday, September tenth, twenty twenty five, while speaking at a public event at Utah Valley University. As the news spread across social media. So many people started seeing the disturbing pictures and videos from what played out on that campus. Political violence, though, is unfortunately nothing new in our country. Presidents, political leaders and other activists have all been targeted in our nation's history. But Kirk's very public assassination impacted people differently. And perhaps it was because whether you strongly agreed with him or strongly disagreed with him, you felt like you knew him. That was thanks in large part to the nonprofit that he founded, Turning Point USA. It's an organization that is headquartered in the Phoenix area, where Kirk and his wife, Erika, lived and were raising their two very young children. So as the nation followed the manhunt for Kirk's killer, journalists there in the Phoenix area began examining the broader impact of his death on his family, his organization and the conservative movement. Morgan Low is the chief investigative reporter for Arizona's family that is Gray Television Station in Phoenix. And Morgan, we appreciate you joining us today. Sure, Laura, thank you for having me. Morgan, please take us back to Wednesday, September tenth, twenty twenty five. What do you remember about that day? Yeah, it was just a, you know, a regular news day. And we were figuring out what we were covering for the day. We had crews all over the valley. And, um, and then this news alert goes on that there was a shooting, uh, potentially involving Charlie Kirk. And as you know by now, that shooting was caught on camera. And, uh, so we're seeing a live feed of, of the area. And then we're seeing these replays that are coming across the feeds to us. So they're not going out on the air, um, live. But as soon as we saw the actual shooting, which was horrific, we knew this was not going to be good. It, it was a pretty, it was pretty obvious quickly that that was going to probably be a kill shot and that he was not going to survive. So we immediately had to regroup and say, all right, how are we going to cover this, this big story? Charlie Kirk was not somebody who was on our local air all the time. He was a national figure, but he was a resident of our community, a lot of supporters in our community, a lot of employees in our community. And so we had to mobilize to cover every angle that we could on this story, because the people in this area wanted to know A what happened and B, what does this mean? What is it going to mean for this really important organization that's based here? And as the manhunt unfolded and details started coming in, what were you starting to notice about the impact on the Phoenix area? Yeah, I mean, this is a story that as soon as we saw that and knew that that he was likely not going to survive this, this was the only story. So we put all of our resources into covering every angle. Um, and, and probably the most notable immediately was at Turning Point, which is, as you said, located in the Phoenix area. People just started showing up at the headquarters and bringing candles and flowers. And I mean, we've seen this over and over again in this business covering crime, covering true crime, um, the sort of makeshift memorial, as they call it. And, um, and that's what we saw there, but it was on a, a really large scale. We're talking about hundreds of people showing up. Um, and at that point, you know, right away they didn't know that he didn't, didn't survive, but they announced it pretty quickly. And that mood changed a real sorrow. Mhm. People wanted to know why. They wanted to know who it was that did this. What was the motivation? How is this going to affect their movement? And, and, you know, Charlie Kirk wasn't just, you know, the head of this organization. He was really the charismatic leader of Turning Point. Turning point is what it is and became what it was because Charlie Kirk made it that way himself with his personality, with his intelligence. And whether you agreed with what he said or disagreed with what he said, he was a very good orator. He was very good at debating, and he would just go around to these college campuses and basically debate anybody who came up and talked to him. And and it was that charisma and that ability to speak that made him so popular. And you really could see that right from the get go with the people showing up. And then what ended up unfolding over the next few days, which was this giant memorial service at State Farm Stadium where the Arizona Cardinals play. And that place was packed. People showing up early. I mean, that was a few days later. But but we knew right away that this was going to be a big, big story, an important story, a very sad story, and one that we needed to cover, uh, with, you know, all the resources that we have. And still, I would imagine there had to be such an element of fear. Is there going to be some type of copycat situation that plays out. Is the memorial service going to be some type of target where you have the most notable leaders in our country all descending at the same time? What was it like in Phoenix with with that level of anxiety going on? Yeah, that whole week, um, between the shooting and the memorial service was something else beefed up security at turning point at their headquarters. Um, you know, he was also a divisive figure. So there were, you know, people who showed up and said things that they were, you know, like they were happy that he was gone. Um, and that did not go over well with his supporters. Um, so it was beefed up security. Absolutely. We had, you know, all of the leaders of, of the country on the Republican side, at least, including the president coming for the memorial service that took place, um, at the football stadium. The security there was over the top, as you would imagine it would be, because it's a divisive figure. All these people from the Maga movement showing up there. The turning point figures there. Yeah. That was a big that was a a big deal. And it is you know, it is interesting covering a story, especially when it's a political figure, which she was, um, because half of your viewers aren't, are not going to like the person. I mean, that's just the reality of politics. And so in this story and covering this story, we really had to try to put the politics aside and remember that this is, at its core, a crime story. This is a dad. This is a son. This is a friend from our community who was murdered. And and we had to, you know, at the base sort of bottom line, the way we covered it, covered it like we cover any crime story like that. And that is you try to get the people that knew the person try to explain what they were like, you know, peel the onion back a little bit and show what they were like, you know, personally, not necessarily what everybody saw on camera. And, and that's, that can be a challenge when you have somebody who's popular like that and sort of an insular figure in a very close circle of friends here and then nationally, a larger circle of friends, but a lot of those friends were public figures there. Um, and so, you know, it wasn't like you're covering a crime story where you, you can get the friends or the relatives to sit down and do the interview. This one was a little more challenging. He was also a husband and without a doubt the person who knew him best is his wife, Erica, who is now leading Turning Point USA. And I remember watching the memorial service and you remember the moment to of forgiveness. Do you think her forgiving the alleged killer impacted Phoenix in a unique way and bringing people together in forgiveness? I mean, I that's really hard to say. What I can tell you is Erica Kirk is, is a religious person. She is she grew up here. She is. Charlie moved here. Erica grew up here. She went to grade school, high school here. She's always been known as somebody who was was spiritual. Um, and so that probably isn't as much of a surprise. And turning point does have a sort of a spiritual, religious aspect to it. I don't know that that the religious, um, I don't know that that, that the, the view of Christianity they subscribe to is one hundred percent based on forgiveness to some extent. Absolutely. So I guess the long and the short of that answer to that question is, I don't think people were surprised by that. But at the same time, I don't think that Charlie Kirk supporters are willing to forgive. She might have been able to. And that's not a surprise to any of us who've followed them because of the way they lived. But their supporters are angry. They are angry to this day that he was taken in a violent way. There's really has not been an incredible explanation for it because of the way that the Utah justice system works. And they're going through this preliminary hearing that goes over a long period of time. The defendant, Tyler Robinson, hasn't even pleaded yet. Guilty or not guilty. So? So there really isn't an explanation. I think that is added to the frustration of the people who knew him, people who loved him, the people who supported him. What makes this so unique, as you mentioned, it being a crime story and you covering it from the local aspect is, as you just also mentioned, it's all playing out in Utah. So from a coverage angle, how is that within your Phoenix station taking what's happening in Utah and knowing with so many supporters, so many viewers in Phoenix wanting to know every detail? How do you handle that? Yeah, that's, um, I mean, I'm the managing editor here as well. And we view this as a local story. We view this as a Phoenix area story and Arizona story. Even though the crime occurred in the state north of us. So we're covering it, um, you know, every way that we can. And luckily in this day and age with cameras in the courtroom, we are getting a firsthand view through the feeds. Uh, anytime that there is a court hearing. Um, so we're able to see that I would imagine that if this, um, if this makes it to trial, if there's not a plea that we will probably be covering it firsthand in person, um, for the trial. So yeah, we're, we're covering it just like we would any big event that happened here because it does affect us and our, our viewers. A lot of people have learned a lot about the judicial system in this preparing to potentially go to trial if there's not a plea deal reached, but with it now being one year since that shot rang out on September tenth of twenty twenty five. What do you see as the lasting impact of Charlie Kirk's assassination? Well, I think there's there are a few ways to look at this. Um, he is definitely missed in the conservative movement. Um, because that turning point was, was his baby. And as I said, he was the charismatic leader of Turning Point. So things have been different within that organization. Um, and there is really an, a, an emptiness in the conservative movement. There's nobody who has stepped forward who's been able to talk to young people the way Charlie Kirk did to rally young people the way they have. Um, I can tell you just by watching and sort of studying some of the dynamics around turning point. The organization is is struggling. They, um, you know, it is obvious that they weren't going to be able to just replace him. Erica Kirk is running the organization, but she is not Charlie, just like he was not her. She has different a different style. She has different attributes, um, that help her in leading that organization. But there's no, you know, number one figurehead right now, like, like he was. And just to give you an example, um, and it may sound callous because, um, this is just the way one of the metrics that we look at, but I was looking at turning point videos on YouTube and that was a big thing. Charlie Kirk, he had a podcast, he spoke to young people and older conservatives around the country, around the world through social media. So we looked at the YouTube views and the views that Turning Point puts out generally get between, I don't know, anywhere from nine thousand to about forty thousand views. And that's that's a good number. I went back last year when Charlie was posting videos, and you would have five hundred thousand to a million and a half views. And so what that tells us is that this organization that relies so much on, you know, popularity among young conservatives is not getting the eyes that it was before. And so what that tells us also is that it's not easy to replace somebody like Charlie Kirk. And, and he is being missed not only by his friends and his family here, but by the broader conservative movement that nobody in that organization has come forward to replace him with the type of magnetism that he had. And so that really is a legitimate sort of consequence that's outside of the, you know, human loss. That turning point is, is feeling right now. You've already spoken with such sensitivity to this conversation, and you've been an investigative reporter for a very, very, very long time. But you're a human being. So looking back over the last year, is there a conversation, an interview, a moment that has impacted and changed you in covering all of this? I mean, I think any time we cover a crime story and we, we cover them all the time, unfortunately, we have an epidemic of crime in this country. Always have. Um, uh, every one of the stories will change you, uh, and in, in different ways, uh, you have to cover these stories with empathy, um, and with understanding. And, and the Charlie Kirk story is interesting because if you're a reporter here, if you're an aggressive reporter here, you no doubt have had an exchange with him. And they aren't always pleasant. And I remember the last time I was covering a news conference where he was and, and we had a fierce exchange, um, one that outside of the news business, you probably think was kind of funny because of the, the back and forth, but it was a serious topic. And so I, you know, and I, I think about that and then I think about the loss and what's happened. It is, it is really, really sad that you have somebody that had such a big presence, whether you agreed with that presence or not. I understand a lot of people disagreed with it. Um, and then it's just a void and they're gone. And, and every time you cover a story, you know, a murder story, a true crime story, the thing that stands out is this sense of loss. And it's just I still can't wrap my mind around it that, you know, the reality is, is some people are there one second and then they're gone when they're murdered or they die. And it's just such a strange phenomenon for human to think about that they're just gone. And, and we when we interview, you know, the husband or the wife or the, the children, uh, on a, on a murder story, a true crime story. You see that, you know, that sense of loss and you feel that from talking to them. But in this story, it is so much larger because we're seeing all these consequences of that loss. From talking to people in the conservative movement. Nobody is filling that void. I don't think that's a void that's possible to fill the way he filled it. And you have to think, even though we don't, you know, we don't really call Erica Kirk and get her to do a sit down interview here locally. But we do as residents of the Phoenix area and longtime people here, we know friends of theirs. And and so we also see the loss of, uh, you know, through their eyes. And so this has been a big true crime story here that has played out probably exponentially, um, larger than, than most of our stories and even big stories that we cover, you know, on a weekly or monthly basis. Morgan Low, the chief investigative reporter at Arizona's Family, thank you for the gift of your time.