Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 80
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder true crime cases five four, three, two one one one one
- 0:22one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. Hot for teacher the case of Elizabeth Dyer. During their teenage years,
- 0:47students, both boys and girls, have been known to develop a crush
- 0:51on a teacher. In almost every instance, this innocent infatuation doesn't amount to
- 0:57anything, but not always. But one must always be careful what you wish
- 1:02for, because in some cases you might just get it. When it came
- 1:07to Eugene Chantrelle, Elizabeth Dyer was, for lack of a better word,
- 1:11obsessed. Despite being nineteen years her senior, her fifteen and him thirty four,
- 1:19she was convinced he was the man for her. The first two came
- 1:23in contact with one another because Chantrelle taught Greek, French and Latin in a
- 1:29school located in Edinburgh, Scotland during the eighteen sixties. Dyer just happened to
- 1:34be a student in his class. Elizabeth did everything she could to draw the
- 1:40attention of the tall and attractive man. Eventually, that attention led to more,
- 1:46and soon Elizabeth realized she'd missed her monthly period. Now pregnant with her
- 1:51teacher's child, she found herself in a difficult position. Not only was the
- 1:57baby unplanned, but her parents harbored a great deal of hatred towards Chantrell himself
- 2:02despite their personal feelings. However, when they learned of their daughter's condition,
- 2:07they insisted the two get married, which happened in August of that year.
- 2:13From the very beginning, Elizabeth was not happy in the marriage. Chantrell had
- 2:17a horrible temper, to the point where he would hit his wife. In
- 2:22one such case, she even went to the police and had Eugene thrown in
- 2:24jail. On top of this, he drank almost every day to excess,
- 2:30and he would constantly visit brothels around the city. Despite these shortcomings, the
- 2:36couple welcomed three children during their first eleven years of marriage. Things might have
- 2:42gone on like this for quite some time had the couple's financial situation not become
- 2:46problematic. All of the drinking and womanizing he engaged in caused a great deal
- 2:52of money. He'd attempted to earn extra cash by giving private tutoring lessons,
- 2:58but his reputation had his students leaving until there was no one left. He
- 3:02found a life raft in the form of a bank loan, but after a
- 3:06while even they were hounding them for payment. When Chantrelle became desperate, he
- 3:13took a part time job at an insurance company. He wasn't any more successful
- 3:16at this than as a tutor, only managing to sell a single policy to
- 3:22a personal friend of his, but during his time there he started making inquiries
- 3:27about what constituted an accidental death. He ended up buying three policies, one
- 3:32for Mary, one for himself, and a final one for Elizabeth. The
- 3:38terms were quite simple. If there was an accident and either he or his
- 3:42wife died, there would be a payment made in the amount of one thousand
- 3:46pounds, a tidy sum given their strapped financial situation. When Elizabeth learned of
- 3:53the purchase, she spoke to her mother, fearing that her husband was planning
- 3:57to kill her and make it look like an accident. Although frightened by her
- 4:00daughter's words, she tried to assure her that she had nothing to fear.
- 4:05On New Year's Eve, eighteen seventy seven, the entire family was sitting down
- 4:10together to have dinner, along with the five members of the family. Also
- 4:15present was a woman named Mary, who was employed to help around the house.
- 4:19They all listened to music through an open window as one year passed into
- 4:23the next, before going to bed shortly after midnight. The morning of New
- 4:28Year's Day was like many others. The family went about their normal business in
- 4:32the morning until around eleven a m. When Mary was given the rest of
- 4:35the day to herself. When she came back just before ten p m.
- 4:41Chantrelle told her that Elizabeth wasn't feeling well and had been confined to her bed.
- 4:46The maid was quickly at her side to see if she could do anything
- 4:49to make her feel more comfortable. Elizabeth told her she was feeling better than
- 4:54she had earlier in the day and asked for an orange before being allowed to
- 4:58go to bed for the rest of them. After Mary had retired, chantrell
- 5:03claimed he finished drinking a bottle of whiskey before paying his wife a visit in
- 5:08her room to make sure she was okay. He would later tell police that
- 5:13they had sex during this time, but given the state she was found the
- 5:16following morning, it is unlikely this ever occurred. He then stated he went
- 5:21to bed himself the following morning, Mary was preparing a kettle for some tea
- 5:28when she heard a dreadful moan coming from Elizabeth's bedroom. Running in, she
- 5:32found her missus very pale and in an almost catatonic state. There were also
- 5:39stains on the sheets and pillows that she assumed were from vomit. She woke
- 5:43Eugene, who ran to be at his wife's side. Upon entering the room,
- 5:46he asked the maid if she smelled something in the air. At first,
- 5:50she didn't detect anything, but soon the odor of gas seemed to be
- 5:55filling the entire room. Chantrou went in search of a doctor to help his
- 6:00wife. He founded in doctor James Carmichael, a man he knew personally.
- 6:05Upon entering the bedroom, the doctor detected the presence of gas and ordered Elizabeth
- 6:10to move to another room. He also called in another physician, who,
- 6:15upon examining Missus Chantrelle, determined the cause of her condition to be the gas
- 6:18as well. He also told Eugene that she was going to die and there
- 6:23wasn't anything they could do to save her life. Still, he ordered Elizabeth
- 6:28to be taken to the Royal Infirmary and the gas company to the residence When
- 6:32Elizabeth's mother learned of her daughter's condition, she came with their family's own doctor.
- 6:39He dismissed gas as the cause of the illness and instead put narcotic poisoning
- 6:44as the reason. The attending physician at the hospital also agreed with this reasoning,
- 6:48narrowing it even further to opium or morphia. Chantrell was furious at the
- 6:55hospital for making such a claim and stormed out of the building. He would
- 6:59later return to be at his wife's side, only to find out she'd expired
- 7:02during his absence. After her death, the doctors at the hospital found themselves
- 7:08with a problem. The issue with the two possible causes of death was they
- 7:13shared many of the same symptoms. It wasn't until an employee at the gas
- 7:16company found that one of the system's pipes had been deliberately loosened, an act
- 7:23that would have taken no more than a couple of seconds. The police investigating
- 7:28the death came to believe that Chantrelle had attempted to poison her with opium.
- 7:32They believed that Chantrelle, still drunk on whiskey from the night before, had
- 7:36decided that a poisoning death would not be considered accidental, and therefore he would
- 7:42not be able to collect the life insurance money. Some time, while Mary
- 7:46had been out of the room, they concluded Eugene had loosened the pipe in
- 7:49hopes the gas leak would be a more accidental death. When an autopsy was
- 7:55conducted on Elizabeth, it didn't make things any clearer. When inside the body,
- 8:00opium will dissipate quickly. It was in the stains on the bedclothes that
- 8:05police finally got their proof. Within the vomit, they located trace amounts of
- 8:09the narcotic. They connected this to Chantrelle by pointing out he kept a small
- 8:15apothecary in his home, inside which was a large amount of opium. Eugene
- 8:20Chantrelle was put on trial for the murder of his wife. He would be
- 8:24found guilty of murder and sentenced to be hung on May thirtieth, eighteen seventy
- 8:30eight. The night before the sentence was to be carried out, he was
- 8:33asked if he had any final wishes. To this he requested three bottles of
- 8:37champagne and a whore. None of these were provided, and he was put
- 8:43to death the following day.