Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Valerie Fridland - Professor, Sociolinguist, and Author | Language and the Good in Bad English
Transcript
- 0:00What does this actually teach people? What are some examples of how drastic
- 0:04altering language could be on an individual? It's true. People generally have never heard of
- 0:09the socio-linguist. Today my guest is Valerie Friedland, an esteemed professor of linguistics at
- 0:16the University of Nevada and Reno. Her captivating language blog has been found on psychology today
- 0:20it's called Language in the Wild where she delves into slang, accents, and grammar myth. What is
- 0:26the psychological reasoning why people swear? I don't study profanity myself. There seems to be
- 0:31sort of an emotional response that it's helping us process when we use profanities. When we swear
- 0:37it seems to be something that helps us feel better it's helping us express an emotion an emotional
- 0:43reaction just in the same way like it's encoding an emotion in the same way that oh is encoding of
- 0:50surprise. I'm just super curious when you listen to me like what does that say about me
- 0:57and be ruthless like you can say whatever you want. One thing I didn't notice is you know men
- 1:02tend to think welcome to success story I'm your host Scott Clary. The success story podcast is part
- 1:07of the HubSpot podcast network. Now the HubSpot podcast network has incredible podcasts like my first
- 1:12million hosted by Sam Parr and Sean Perry. They interview some of the most incredible business leaders
- 1:18Alex Ramozi, Sophia Amaruso, Hassan Minhaj who shared their journey to success and how they made
- 1:24their first million. On a recent episode they featured the acquired podcast host Ben Gilbert and
- 1:29David Rosenthal to discuss how they scaled their multi-million dollar podcast. Don't sleep on my
- 1:34first million if you want to get inspired. If you want to learn from the best you got to tune into
- 1:39my first million wherever you listen to your podcast. Today my guest is Valerie Friedland,
- 1:43an esteemed professor of linguistics at the University of Nevada in Reno. She holds a PhD in
- 1:48linguistics from Michigan State University. She specializes in socio-linguistics American
- 1:54Dialectology and Regional Val variation. Her captivating language blog has been found on
- 1:59psychology today. It's called Language in the Wild where she delves into slaying accents and
- 2:04grammar myths. As a distinguished professor of the great courses series she shares her passion
- 2:09for language with students worldwide. She's taught at a multitude of prestigious institutions
- 2:15such as Georgetown, George Mason and others. She's recognized for her innovative teaching methods
- 2:20and dedication to mentoring graduate students. She's an active member of professional organizations
- 2:26like the linguistics Society of America, the American Dialect Society, and she also contributes
- 2:31as an editor or reviewer for renowned journals in her field.
- 2:44Well I had parents that are non-native speakers and I grew up in a small well it wasn't
- 2:48small town at the time either but it felt small town in the south and it really was very exotic
- 2:56to have parents that didn't speak with a southern accent and I remember when I'd have all
- 3:00these friends come over and my mom is French speaking and so she would say Valerie to call me
- 3:06and I every single friend it was like you know all of a sudden they call to attention and then they
- 3:12start imitating her you know with her accent and it really brought home to me how integral to our
- 3:18personalities voices how much having something that's different than somebody else from an accent
- 3:24perspective or whatever thing makes you different makes you stand out in some way and of course
- 3:29you know to a ten year old it wasn't a good thing I hated that I hated it when people you know
- 3:33I was like mom stop saying my name just don't talk but it really brought home to me the power of
- 3:39language in shaping social identity and the way that people perceive you so I really found languages
- 3:45fascinating just in general because I think you know partially it was my parents didn't just speak
- 3:49English and that wasn't the first language also from that experience of having people react to their
- 3:53accents and think things about us about us being kind of different or novel or not fitting in because
- 4:00of the way they talked so when I went to college at Georgetown University I went into the languages
- 4:05and linguistics program mainly just because I was curious about learning about more languages and
- 4:11more about how they worked I didn't really have any concept of linguistics at the time in fact I
- 4:16think if you told me at freshman year I would have been a linguist I probably would have cried
- 4:19because it sounds very boring to a 19 year old but I took a linguistics class that covered
- 4:27language and gender sort of all the different ways that our our speech reveals who we are from
- 4:32a sort of social and gender perspective and how that impacts how you perceive it impacts your
- 4:39opportunities in the office it impacts your relationships and it kind of blew my mind because
- 4:44it articulated all these things I had felt and noticed so we all have these feelings about
- 4:48language when someone says something in a certain tone or they sort of tell us dismiss us because
- 4:54of the way we talk we all have had that experience in some way a shape or form but we've never had
- 5:00the language to discuss it we always thought of it as a sort of a us problem and all of a sudden I
- 5:07thought oh my gosh this isn't just me people that remark on my slight southern accent it's not
- 5:13because I'm saying something wrong it's because of these larger sociolinguistic forces that make
- 5:18us notice the way people talk it makes us sort of predetermined who they are from a social perspective
- 5:24and it really impacts the opportunities that people have down the road because of the way people
- 5:29think you are because of the way you talk and it was that that was really the turning point for me
- 5:33where I decided oh you know screw chimis which was my major at the time I want to go study linguistics
- 5:39it was also that I was really bad at chimis that probably hits on him do with it too
- 5:44I'm you know this is so fascinating because like I think anybody listening understands how important
- 5:51language is and everybody who's listening has had these moments in their life when they've been
- 5:56judged or they've even judged someone else but it doesn't seem like be quite literally before
- 6:01I met you I've never heard of somebody studying this as a profession I mean I the only
- 6:06application that I can see this in day to day would be maybe actors and actresses and people that
- 6:11use this as part of their profession but this is so language is so powerful and it seems like
- 6:18the lack of understanding of language and how it impacts is something that could change people's
- 6:25careers change people's lives change their ability to negotiate the next job or present a certain
- 6:31way and there's all these other skills that are about are sort of adjacent to communication
- 6:38that people focus on but they never focus on language I've never heard somebody say like
- 6:43don't say this word or say this word as part don't you know they say don't say um or what not and try
- 6:49and cut out the filler words when you're doing a presentation maybe to be a bit more confident but
- 6:54I've never seen somebody and actually apparently according to your research that's not even
- 6:58the best way to present but the point is I've never seen somebody focus on this before so
- 7:02what does this impact what kind of impact does this study have what does this actually teach people
- 7:08what kind of influence could this have on somebody's life like what are some examples of how
- 7:14drastic altering language could be on an individual well you know it's interesting that you say
- 7:20that because it's true people generally have never heard of the socio-linguist or even a
- 7:24linguist that's a theoretical linguist like I am so we talk about linguists that study a lot of
- 7:29languages but the type of language that I am is someone who studies the underlying structure of
- 7:34language how we produce sounds why certain things happen a certain way how languages change over time
- 7:39what is the what are the social and linguistic forces that create the language we speak why did
- 7:46old English sounds so different than modern English all those kinds of things and we also try to
- 7:51trace back the evolution of where all languages come from did they were they from one language
- 7:57one proto-language or was it sort of multi multiple origin stories for language so those are all
- 8:02those big questions that we don't think about as speakers of a language we think about what's
- 8:06a noun what's a verb and you know where's my dangly modifier and those are really interesting
- 8:12because those are actually social preferences that we have learned when we study English language
- 8:17arts what we're studying is one person's version of what they like about language and what they
- 8:23have claimed language should be those are not the actual cognitive rules that create language and
- 8:29drive it forward so it's really kind of striking to me that we don't know this side of language because
- 8:35it's so pivotal in everything we do I mean do you have a voice assistant like a virtual assistant
- 8:41that you talked to Alexa or Siri linguist linguist linguist right if it wasn't for people like me
- 8:47wouldn't be able to talk to them so someone has to figure out how to program those computers to
- 8:52understand human speech what is the structure of a senate so that we make sure that when Siri spit
- 8:57something out she follows that structure right it's an analysis and she's using large data pool
- 9:02so she's doing analysis that is a syntactic analysis of those speech features so this predictive
- 9:08language model that is driving like chat GPT today what it does is it looks at huge quantities of
- 9:15language data and a lot of them have been pruned and approved by linguists like this is something the
- 9:21types of language data we want a lot of the language data comes from linguists in fact I have a
- 9:25friend that runs a large corpus that is a linguist and a lot of his lately a lot of his work is
- 9:32trying to field requests from these large language data runners to get his access to his
- 9:39corporate to help them build language models for these big chat GPT type things so that chat GPT
- 9:45is a predictive model meaning that based on its analysis it's sort of linguistic analysis of
- 9:50all these sets of data it predicts what comes next so if you have a sentence it's looking at
- 9:56massive quantities of data and saying what is the statistical probability that this type of word
- 10:02comes next and this is exactly what you do as a human language model right you are predicting when
- 10:08you hear someone talk you are predicting oh they said the nouns follow the that's probably going
- 10:13to be a noun and that's how I understand if you use a word that's not typically a noun
- 10:19and put it after a the all of a sudden it becomes a noun because my brain understands that the
- 10:24makes things a noun that that that slot in syntactic structure makes a noun so another great example
- 10:29is adulting right that we've made into her right people of course hate that but what they don't
- 10:35know is parent and parenting is actually the same relationship parent the noun came centuries
- 10:40before we started talking about parenting so you could be a parent in the 14th century but you
- 10:46didn't do parenting and really the first reference to parenting we find is in the 16th century and
- 10:51that it was hardly ever used until the 20th century but parent has been used for a long time well
- 10:56adult adulting has that exact same distribution or adult came first and it meant to be a grownup
- 11:02right a grownup person but adulting carries with it not just the idea of I'm being I'm grown up
- 11:08it carries all the things associated socio culturally with being an adult and it's by adding that
- 11:14ing that it signals to me okay I've shifted that noun to a verb so these are actually linguistic
- 11:21ways of looking at language that are super helpful in both you know data for language learning
- 11:26models in making sure Siri recognizes a southern accent versus a non-southern accent by giving
- 11:33it the understanding of the vowels for example that a southern uses versus a non-southerner it's
- 11:37also really important in educational context because a lot of times we have non-native or non-standard
- 11:44speakers I both of those go to schools along with native and standard speakers and we can have
- 11:50some problems in terms of how educational attainment is met for different pools of language learners
- 11:56or different pools of dialect speakers and it doesn't mean they're sending wrong with those
- 12:01dialects but we can use the models of standard English and the models of dialects are non-standard
- 12:07to try to compare them to help children achieve learning attainment by giving them really solid
- 12:13understandings of where their dialect differs from the one that is the socially preferred dialect
- 12:18now notice I said social prefer because there's nothing wrong with a standard dialect it's simply
- 12:24a different set of rules but how do you learn rules you learn it by having them articulated
- 12:29in English language arts we don't articulate here's the rule where English you know uses a noun
- 12:34after a the here we don't articulate those kinds of rules we give people ideas like nouns or
- 12:40person places or things which actually doesn't explain most nouns right especially abstract ones
- 12:45that's not really linguistics that's actually just sort of ideas about language that get floated
- 12:51around so there are lots of ways that linguists are relevant to our daily lives in professional
- 12:57circles linguists do a lot of things like studies on that as well as communication researcher studies
- 13:04on how different types of language use is perceived in different context so one place for example
- 13:10that I give talks on a lot is accent discrimination and how what kind of work research linguists do can
- 13:17show us where we're making some errors in the way that we approach accents in workplaces and
- 13:24sometimes it's really surprising so for example if you see if we do experiments where we see
- 13:29an Asian face a South Asian face and we play a standard English native speaker voice and then
- 13:37we compare that to a different control group that saw a white face with this the same exact voice
- 13:42what we find is ratings of intelligibility and ratings of non-native-ness go significantly up
- 13:49when you show them a picture of a non white person which means you're not actually listening
- 13:55to the actual signal because it's exactly the same voice but just your stereotypes about what
- 14:00that person should sound like influences strongly what you think they sound like and can affect
- 14:06intelligibility but what we find is people that are massive bias when it comes to hiring and
- 14:11right and then what's the solution that's the other thing so what we find in also doing the
- 14:16same studies is if we expose speakers to more talkers from diverse backgrounds they get better
- 14:22at not processing it in a negative way so it can decrease accent bias so there are a lot of
- 14:29different places where linguists are important and people just don't realize they are
- 14:34no I have no doubt they're very important I think that more people should be aware more people
- 14:41should be aware of their biases that they assume when they when they hear someone then when
- 14:47they receive a message but it's like without the education and the awareness like you said
- 14:54like just like a random study is going to show this is a very real thing in the workplace
- 14:59in a professional setting you're you're trying to get a job you're trying to raise money this is
- 15:03going to be is it going to be difficult if the person who's receiving it is not aware of these
- 15:07biases but the other question would be so outside of the person who's receiving the message
- 15:14being aware of these biases and being exposed to a different different individuals so these
- 15:19biases start to be reduced is that's sort of what I'm hearing that if the person speaks to a
- 15:24bunch of different types of individuals eventually over time these types of biases are reduced
- 15:29are there are there what was the word you used you said non like the preferred
- 15:36lane not the preferred language like the socially accepted language are the outside of that realm
- 15:43are there like language quirks or things that people say that they should not say it's not a
- 15:50bias it's just like a like a bad habit or a bad practice that that hurts you know I think that's
- 15:56a really loaded question because I'm a linguist so my aim is to study language descriptively so
- 16:02what do people actually do and then I can also look at the impact of what they do I particularly
- 16:08am interested in why they do it and where it came from so what what need in our speech did it
- 16:13develop to to serve and that's sort of a prescriptive question in the sense of is there anything we
- 16:19shouldn't do but again that all comes down to social preferences and I'm not saying that there
- 16:24shouldn't be things that we watch in our speech because we know how other other people perceive it
- 16:30and we obviously want to make a good impression for example a job interview you probably don't want
- 16:34to walk in there saying a lot of ums and us a lot of likes and use vocal fry if you want to be
- 16:40employed by someone who might have a bias against those kinds of features but in many ways I would say
- 16:46that actually says a lot more about that company and the kind of climate it has that you probably
- 16:51don't want to be a part of if they're going to have those kinds of biases against speakers that
- 16:55happen to typically be young and female because those are features that women young women tend to
- 17:00use at a higher rate so you know I think there's a difference between being aware of how you might
- 17:06be perceived based on using certain features versus the prohibition to not use them if you look at
- 17:12young speakers young speakers in general use those features so if you're aging up those features
- 17:17then any workplace would be you know sort of dumb to ignore them because that is the latest in
- 17:22the clients and the employees are going to have um so when we so when we look at language and like
- 17:30our language choices forget bias but just our personal language choices what does that say about
- 17:36our our identity and our personality and our social relationships I did enormous amount and I
- 17:42think that's the thing that people tend not to realize um you know we see language in two ways either
- 17:48good language or bad language and if you speak good language or a good person if you speak bad
- 17:52language or something wrong with you um but in reality language is about social identity just as
- 17:58much as it's about communication so think about you know things like hi how you doing that we say
- 18:04five million times a day uh they're they're really about making connection right it's there's
- 18:10nothing informational in that other than hey I like you I just want to check on you and let's
- 18:16have some connection here let's build a relationship so it's a relationship building so a lot of
- 18:21times language is about talking in such a way that it invites connection camaraderie solidarity
- 18:29and closeness or it tells someone the way that you're approaching them um so I you know we were
- 18:36talking before we went on about how you can change your speech over time that you become more
- 18:41informal more casual and that you've heard podcasters do that sort of over a couple of years well
- 18:46the idea with more casual informal speech is it's inviting when you when you go home and you used
- 18:52an overly formal way of approaching your family they're going look at you like what the hell is
- 18:57going on with you because who are you you know it because it's weird it's not it doesn't speak
- 19:02to your relationship so when you are in a conversation that was someone you just met for example
- 19:07and you sort of get that sense that you like them that you're making a connection do you stay
- 19:11stiff informal in your speech or do you switch and start using maybe more contractions like
- 19:15gonna want to have to do you start saying you know I always want to instead of will do you say
- 19:21things like walking instead of walking those are very subtle cues that we give each other
- 19:26about the relationship so if you've ever been in a conversation where someone does not shift
- 19:32it's very off-putting in fact you probably walk away with a bad impression about them and that's
- 19:37the same thing is using things like discourse markers well oh so like you know those are about
- 19:43connection and actually if you look at research on them we find that when people take personality
- 19:47tests more conscientious speakers tend to use more discourse markers so it's actually the linguistic
- 19:54version of kindness when you think about discourse markers so our dislike of them is really more
- 20:00about who has tended to use them historically more so women tend to use more discourse markers
- 20:06and it's probably a lot with women's speeches related to the position and the role that they've had
- 20:12compared to men for centuries and women's voices have always been sort of vilified and told to be
- 20:19silent for you know since Aristotle I think Aristotle had saying that said silence gives grace
- 20:27to women so you know it sort of tells you what he thought about women's voices in the public sphere
- 20:31and then you know we used to put them in scolds bridles in the middle ages if they talked too much
- 20:36and said things that we thought was blasphemy which was mainly saying you know he sucks we should
- 20:40get rid of this guy are you know talking around the gossip circles and the water well that you
- 20:46had these feelings about maybe those in governance or people that were doing things you didn't like
- 20:51well that was dangerous especially when women were saying it because women talked a lot of other
- 20:55women and they talked to their husbands and then it could spread like wildfire it was kind of the
- 20:59internet you know the gossip circles were the internet of the middle ages and so they actually
- 21:04would prosecute women for sins of the tongue and put them in things called scolds bridles which
- 21:10was like a metal handable lecture contraption that held their tongue down so that they couldn't
- 21:15speak so here's his history and so we have always been skeptical of women's voices so that
- 21:21leads us to believe a women talk more than men which they don't most research doesn't show that
- 21:26to be true women have less to say it's unimportant it's evacuous it's empty headed so that then
- 21:33gets assigned to the features they tend to use at a higher rate so things like like our vocal fry
- 21:38or using a lot of intensifiers like vary or so or pretty or really those tend to be used at a
- 21:44higher rate women's speech and the reason for that is that women actually lead in language change
- 21:48and have through time so almost everything that you say today as a man was something that was
- 21:53started with a woman centuries ago so it's very interesting that women are very powerful to
- 21:59generators of change can I ask something so if historically women's voices were suppressed
- 22:06how was it so that even though they were suppressed the the items in their speech were actually
- 22:14setting like the the precedent for how men speak in the future in the next you know couple
- 22:20years or the next the next the next the you know the next 10 years men will sort of adopt some of
- 22:30these speaking patterns how did that how did that happen well I mean of course the big answers
- 22:34women are just cooler so of course everybody goes after what they say but the real answer I'm
- 22:39we are cool but the real answer is what is what is a role of a woman historically so they are
- 22:46often the home makers they raise the children they are talking to their husbands when they get home
- 22:52so we have this really interesting thing called intimate diversification which is a big fancy word
- 22:57to say that unlike other subcultures that tend to be segregated so if you look in a lot of cities
- 23:03you'll find segregated ethnic enclaves so that you have these different sort of backgrounds and
- 23:08different language choices perhaps but they tend to be relegated to very distinct enclaves a
- 23:13lot of times because of historical power differences and socioeconomic differences but whatever
- 23:18the reasons there's catch separate so there's not as much borrowing across ethnic groups for
- 23:25features except of course now there's a huge amount of borrowing of African-American features from
- 23:30like black Twitter and hip hop into white male speech so that's a totally different thing but
- 23:36women raise the children so children tend to adopt initially at least until they go undergo
- 23:41vernacular reorganization in school they adopt the features of guess who their moms their mother
- 23:48their mom so you know unless that changes drastically and of course it has changed somewhat it's
- 23:52still the case that that happened so what we find is women are usually a generation ahead of men
- 23:57in picking up a speech feature now this is not all features there are this is when you ask that
- 24:02question about what is our language say about us it says a lot a lot so much it's hard to get to it all
- 24:08we could talk for hours but essentially in the majority of speech features that have become
- 24:13standard over time gone from being sort of less standard or just not notice to being standard
- 24:18it is women that have led in those changes they lead by usually at least one generation
- 24:22because when they have children those children inherit their speech so boys and girls inherit
- 24:29the system of the mother first and foremost and then they go to school and they start reorganizing
- 24:34their speech we call it vernacular reorganization to be more like their peers and then they pick up
- 24:39new forms and fashions in speech and that is what we dislike as adults right this difference in our
- 24:45speech and the children's speech because it says something like this is youth culture and this
- 24:49is adult culture it makes us feel old and we tend to label what they do as sort of novel and undesirable
- 24:57but in fact a lot of it does end up staying around and becoming the norms of the next generation
- 25:01but it's women more than men that in the teen years push language forward so then we have this
- 25:07relief frog where okay women were generation ahead they had children the kids inherited their
- 25:13generation they go to school are their speech they go to school with the same system but then girls
- 25:18forge ahead another generation if a change is going is going to continue the girls will push it
- 25:24and then they give it to their children so you have this kind of leap frog pattern that men stay
- 25:29a generation behind until that change has moved to completion meaning that it's sort of what
- 25:35everybody says and it's so so widespread that there's no more leapfrogging and that's only
- 25:39find that men catch up and that's when a new norm gets established over time and so a great example
- 25:46historically would be because sometimes it's easier if you have an example when you say you know he
- 25:51does instead of he dot that was actually a change led by women so we find in letters of course we
- 25:57don't have recordings back from back then but in the early modern period which was about 1500 to
- 26:021700 we find letters written by women and we also tend to find letters written by less educated
- 26:09people as well that sort of also gives us the sense that these weren't really standard features
- 26:15in fact it was a northern feature a northern British feature and it was finally adopted into
- 26:19London speech which is when it became the standard but we find does starting to appear instead of
- 26:24doth first in women's and less educated speakers letters and then about you know another generation
- 26:32skips forward and we start to see it in men's speech so that's sort of what incrementally pushes
- 26:38change forward now sometimes of course a feature gets very gendered so little boys go to school and
- 26:44then they hear girls say it and it takes on this very feminine tone they get a very gendered
- 26:50association with that sort of like totally as an intensifier and so they retreat and that's
- 26:56where you find that changes tend not to progress or they become very gendered changes over time
- 27:01where only women do them to a high degree and men don't and we find the opposite is true as well
- 27:06sometimes features become gendered towards men and women don't do it as much so you know what we
- 27:12just want to take a second and thank the sponsor of today's episode HubSpot now companies are under
- 27:16pressure right now pressure to get more leads closed deals faster get better insights to create
- 27:22the best experience for their customers see a CRM can help but not just any CRM one that is easy
- 27:29to set up intuitive to use and customizable to the way you do business now that's where HubSpot
- 27:34comes in HubSpot CRM is an easy for everyone to use on day one solution it helps teams be more
- 27:41productive you can drag and drop your way to attention grabbing emails and landing pages you can
- 27:45set up marketing automation to give every contact the white glove treatment plus AI power tools
- 27:51like content assistant mean less time spent on tedious manual tasks and more time for what matters
- 27:58your customers HubSpot CRM has all the tools you need to wow prospects lock in deals and
- 28:04improve customer service response times get started today for free at HubSpot.com and what would
- 28:10cause that what would cause the totally to to be a more gendered feature well a lot of times it's
- 28:14the different types of attract of sociocultural attractiveness that features carry so what makes a
- 28:20boy popular in school you know you you were a boy right traditionally sports yeah like
- 28:26links sports having friends you know being kind of tough in macho right yeah yeah basically
- 28:32yeah that kind of thing and does that is that the same kind of thing that happens for women
- 28:36when a girl I mean they can play sports but is sort of masculine bravado very
- 28:40traditionally no no it's really not femininity and more totally 180 yeah so think about the types
- 28:47of features that boys tend to use you know like man and bro and dude are good example of that
- 28:54that it sort of is a masculine solidarity tough kind of guy or just the appropriation of hip hop
- 29:01language you know that type of thing saying things like ain't generally women as young girls get
- 29:08vilified for their speech much more than boys do so if a girl comes home and says I ain't doing that
- 29:15that have parents that have an expectation about what that girl should sound like she's going to
- 29:19get ridiculed for it much more than a boy would because for a boy we kind of have this expectation
- 29:25of rough tough kind of behavior and so features that embody that kind of roughness that toughness
- 29:30that masculine kind of quality those are the types that boys tend to pick up which is why they
- 29:36tend to be very attracted to non-standard features because we have these stereotypes about what
- 29:42those speakers are like even though they're completely cultural artifacts like the idea that
- 29:48young black men are dangerous and rebellious and non-conformist well that's that's our
- 29:53interpretation of a speech feature that has nothing to do with the reality of why a young black
- 29:58man uses it right because what young black man might use a speech feature like thing or ain't or
- 30:04ain't or acts because he's trying for solidarity with a group of other speakers who have faced the
- 30:10same sort of social cultural prejudice as he has and and he has to have that that's part of what
- 30:16bonds them is having a shared language and it's it's actually acts is an older feature than
- 30:21ask and that's what ask came from which is so another thing that's why else that you're saying like
- 30:26people know I just wanted to understand so that means that one group of individuals have completely
- 30:32adopted a language I'm going to just very very simplify this so I understand it one group of
- 30:39individuals have have adopted certain things in their language because of a certain social
- 30:43cultural norm and then another group has misinterpreted that social cultural norm and then adopted
- 30:49things because of that misinterpretation and then that's been brought up that's exactly that's
- 30:53really what's happening exactly what happens that's exactly what happens and the reason that ethnic
- 30:57features tend to be so popular among young men so if you go to high school I have a teenage son
- 31:03and so I'm and he plays a lot of sports so I'm around a lot of boys a lot of times and sometimes
- 31:09it makes me laugh the way they talk because I want to say do you realize what you're doing you know
- 31:13but they would totally ignore me and my son would never invite me to another game so not gonna do it
- 31:18but what what they don't understand is the reason those features are attracted attractive to them
- 31:23is because they're completely misinterpreting why they're used in the first place they are used
- 31:30as sort of symbolic symbolic solidarity symbols for the groups that use them in the same way that
- 31:37we use certain features like like or vocal fry to like claim to other aspects of our identity and
- 31:44those tend to be very predominantly kind of white and middle class features and actually if you look
- 31:51at I'm an I use which we should talk about at one point because they will blow your mind if you
- 31:56look at the distribution of use of those features men use much more than women do and upper class
- 32:02speakers tend to use more field pauses than lower class speakers so they sort of it's funny how
- 32:08these different features take on these associations that are very subtle we don't realize it but
- 32:13they send messages to us about who those people are because of the very very detailed distribution
- 32:20of those features in speech that we can't articulate unless we're a linguist but influence us nonetheless
- 32:27so when we see higher rates of certain things like contractions or palitalization which is when
- 32:32you say things like watcha did ja that's called palitalization because it simply two sounds coming
- 32:39together because of how they're articulated in the mouth that get palitalized meaning the tongue
- 32:44moves more towards the palate we find higher rates of that speech feature everybody does them but
- 32:49we find higher rates in among non-standard English speakers probably because it is used as a
- 32:57language of of communication of intimacy of connection so when we shift to more informal
- 33:03features among our family members it's because we're showing them that were connected and we
- 33:08identify with them so in communities that tend to have that as a very very important facet of
- 33:14self-protection against a larger dominant culture that tends to despise them that's a way to show
- 33:21it is in your language is connection so but the problem is a lot of times young men misinterpret
- 33:27those sort of signs of solidarity as also representing what those people represent to them from
- 33:32cultural stereotype which is sort of dangerous and edgy and cool and then to get that in their own
- 33:39persona they adopt those features so that's sort of how that cycle works it's pretty fascinating
- 33:46and are there any other examples of because we've now we've sort of spoken how language impacts
- 33:53society and a little bit of how society impacts language but outside of North America what are
- 33:58some other interesting examples of how society impacts language because it seems to be this like
- 34:03Yin and Yang seesaw type relationship between language and society that goes back and forth and
- 34:09they almost impact each other constantly right and so that's a really good question and there are
- 34:13I mean language this is how language operates everywhere so there are linguists like me that study
- 34:18languages outside of English I'm an English linguist which means mainly what I study is in English but
- 34:24what's really fascinating is how these patterns that I've just discussed are not patterns that are
- 34:29somehow naturally driven so they're nothing biological they they have nothing to do with the fact
- 34:34that you're born female or you're born male they have everything to do with the way that society
- 34:40expects you to act because of those designation so and that access and to resources that you have
- 34:46as a member of that society so we find in American English that women tend overall to use more
- 34:52standard forms of speech and that's cuts across sort of ethnic and class lines if you look across
- 34:58those groups in every group and you study the same feature that's non-standard you typically find
- 35:04that man use non-standard features at a higher rate and so this is things like simple things like
- 35:11walking versus walking you know that alternation in the progressive participle we find in every
- 35:17group that studied that's an English speaker that man use a higher rate of in vending and women use
- 35:24typically a lower rate that doesn't mean that every single woman follows that pattern but the
- 35:28overall generalization that we find very very consistently and this is in world world English is
- 35:34not just American English is that men use more in and women use more in because in is considered
- 35:40the more correct version and in is the more casual sort of laid back version that we find that
- 35:47distribution but part of that is because women in this culture are valued for being standard speakers
- 35:53and a lot of times historically and ecologically they're given jobs in which language is very important
- 35:59so think about teachers historically teachers have been more women than men and that of course is
- 36:05a area where language is important so the way you speak to students is going to necessarily be
- 36:12more standard than the way you speak if you are say at a factory which have typically been male
- 36:16or into jobs and what kind of speech is valuable to factory well it doesn't matter what progressive
- 36:21participle you use it's that you have this sort of language that helps you kind of bond with
- 36:26the other people that are doing this boring job or a lot of cases that will help you communicate
- 36:32if there's any kind of danger so in in a lot of types of jobs that men historically have held
- 36:36there might be high rates of danger factory work it could be equipment in lumber it could be
- 36:42that a tree is falling right and firefighting it might be that there's a fire coming so there's
- 36:47all these different pressures on you but very few of them are speak standardly right it's like
- 36:52hey get out of the way that damn tree that kind of thing yeah so right these pressures are different
- 36:56it's just like because of how we treat men and women this culture in terms of jobs that we expect
- 37:00them to have another job that women have historically done more is being the front line of restaurants
- 37:06of banks of hotels of service industries and that again puts a pressure on women to have more
- 37:12standard speech versus being in a police force or something like that how many police men really
- 37:17worry about having standard speech not much because again it's a language of solidarity and brotherhood
- 37:23right but you go to a different country like perhaps in the Middle East where there's different
- 37:28norms for behavior for men and women were met or out in professions and women are not women have
- 37:35to rely on solidarity and friendship among other women primarily they don't need to have any kind
- 37:39of outward facing good speech we find the exact opposite pattern in those cultures men lead
- 37:46in the use of standard forums and women lead in the use of non-standard features so we find
- 37:51the same pattern but for the same reasons but sometimes it's reversed based on the social needs
- 37:56of that society now what so then what does this mean for an increasingly globalized world because
- 38:04now we're we're working remote working from home on zoom with people from every single country
- 38:10every single day and I would I would assume that most people don't understand the level of detail
- 38:16that one should understand to communicate with an individual in a different society or a different
- 38:20culture or a different part of the world right so what does this actually mean well you know I think
- 38:24and that's sort of what I'm trying to get my main message of the book in addition to being fun
- 38:28and learning about these fascinating facts because there's so many unbelievable facts about language
- 38:32we don't understand and we have these beliefs that they come from these weird places that they
- 38:35don't come from are they spontaneously come into existence and they're just bad almost everything we do
- 38:41has been around for centuries and there's a reason we do it and one thing that I think is my
- 38:46main message of the book is be compassionate right think about the fact that not everybody comes to
- 38:52language with the same perspective that you do and the reason they're doing the things they do is
- 38:57because that has been useful in their own background in their own language in their own
- 39:02existence and you are falling on the same exact pattern for the same exact reason so compassion is
- 39:08really key especially in this new connected world there are also a number of different things that
- 39:13if we understand the linguistics behind it it'll make it a little easier and things like the zoom
- 39:17I mean zoom is a weird context because first of all it has a delay there's a sort of an internet
- 39:23delay so that it kind of there's been a really fascinating study recently that looked at the way
- 39:28that we cognitive process we sort of process cognitively the interactions that we have when we
- 39:33talk to people and we do this in called like syncing so when we're having a conversation in real
- 39:38time with someone in a real place you know a one-on-one real real conversation in physical space
- 39:46there are brains sync up and they sort of are able to sort of attach to the pattern and the
- 39:52the stress pattern and the intonation pattern of that other person and kind of no one we're
- 39:57going to hop in and when we're not and our brain doesn't have to do that much work because it they're
- 40:01synced so it's not exhausting how many times have you had a zoom conversation and you're really
- 40:06tired at the end and you can't figure out why yeah because your brains can't sync to the same way
- 40:11because of that lag that slight lag throws off our automatic syncing and it makes us have to work
- 40:17harder to process what other people say and then to jump in and follow up with it so one thing
- 40:23to remember is that tiredness is actually real physical tiredness from doing heavy cognitive work
- 40:29and it's not only you it's everybody else on that phone call so one thing is to think about well
- 40:34what does that mean for me as a employer or as a manager as a participant in these things
- 40:39are there things we're doing on zoom that could be better done elsewhere through other forums
- 40:44either email something that's the asynchronous perhaps or through a phone call that we don't seem
- 40:51to have that same kind of exhaustion when we talk that maybe we should save the zoom for things that
- 40:57we can devote full energy to for a shorter period of time so one thing is to think about don't have
- 41:03these you know five hour zoom meetings or take breaks so that you let people's brains kind of
- 41:08have a chance to relax and get over it the other thing is who am I talking to in terms of
- 41:14what culture they're from and how do they deal with silence because different cultures have
- 41:19different norms for how long a lag to have between different conversational terms and American
- 41:24English speakers don't like having much time at all so we don't like to leave silence out there
- 41:30on the table but for example fins and Japanese speakers tend to have much longer silence that's
- 41:36acceptable and desirable so of course to them on a phone call on a zoom call or a phone call with
- 41:42an American English speaker the American English speaker is constantly talking jump interruptions
- 41:48jumping in all the time and basically hogging the conversational floor to an English speaker American
- 41:54English speaker a Japanese or Finn is never talking they're uninterested they're not holding up
- 41:59their end of the conversation so can you see how this one really simple difference in our cultural
- 42:04norms for talking can create some significant problems from a business perspective
- 42:11I love that that's fascinating okay I want to actually because we actually haven't spoken about
- 42:15like your book at all there's so much fun stuff to cover there's a lot this is made okay I will
- 42:22I will go into the book I'm just super curious um when you when you listen to me like what does
- 42:30that say about me which I want you to like I want you to give me like the rundown on on on how I
- 42:37speak and how I present it's it's so good and and be ruthless like you can say whatever you want
- 42:41well just to preface this by when a linguist study speech what we do is we actually record a bunch
- 42:46of speakers and then we analyze their speech usually using acoustic equipment and then so we can
- 42:52pull out statistical distribution so I don't usually just sort of take it on one person because speech
- 42:58it's usually a glomeration but that said um I actually now it's interesting because I had listened to
- 43:05you do a podcast before I came on I always like to listen and one thing I didn't notice is you
- 43:12know men tend to think they don't ever use like in their speech and one thing I didn't notice is
- 43:18you are a quoted of like per speaker you don't tend to use like in other contexts but I did hear
- 43:23you actually use quoted of like which is not surprising because it's the probably the fastest
- 43:28expanding use of like among Americans and Canadians the study actually that's showed at exponential
- 43:36use of quoted of like over 50% over 10 years of greater like use among young men and women in
- 43:42particular so I had noticed that you when you talk about what someone should say you'll say well
- 43:48so that if they were like this you know if they say if you don't you don't say if they said
- 43:52actually say if well if they were like this which tells me that you're under 40 most likely
- 43:59because it is a youthful marker especially quoted of like um a lot of people use discourse marker
- 44:05like especially older women you'll find middle-aged women that use it but for quoted of like for
- 44:11man to use it's usually a young male feature a younger male not not you know a teenager but teenagers
- 44:17do it too but I did notice that in your speech and then you have a really interesting uh valile
- 44:22raising in about that about yeah that's Canadian yes and so I was wondering if you were Canadian based
- 44:30on that I am I'm from yeah I'm born in Toronto okay so that's actually called Canadian raising
- 44:36um and that's sort of a stereotypical Canadian features Canadian raising now people usually
- 44:41have it wrong they think people say a boot which they don't right they say very subtly and you
- 44:46have a very subtle Canadian raising your speech um so that anyway that's my quick and dirty acoustic
- 44:53in our analysis now that's amazing um and it's it's quite funny because a lot of people when they
- 45:00find it on Canadian they don't they don't they don't hear any I guess uh Canadian air quotes in my
- 45:07in my accent but sometimes they have mentioned oh I hear it when you say about yes yes but it's
- 45:12only when I'm not thinking about it yeah just like right there and how do you say exactly yeah
- 45:17say this one word because this can also be Canadian but it's yeah yeah I think it's older Canadian
- 45:22feature so you may not have it how do you say the word S-O-R-R-Y sorry oh hey that's very Canadian
- 45:29you say sorry sorry yeah what how do you say how how would an American sorry sorry oh that sounds
- 45:38weird to me you say sorry it sounds so often it's a very Canadian feature it's it's some that if
- 45:42you're clout have a lot of contact with Americans we noticed that actually younger speakers can
- 45:46have it dissipating but it's a it's a very traditional Canadian feature to say sorry
- 45:53that's so funny um okay let's talk about your book so the book is like literally dude arguing
- 46:00for the good and bad English what what is the argument for the good and bad English what does that
- 46:05mean well so the idea here is sort of what we were talking about before that we have all these
- 46:09preconceived notions when we go into a speaking context about what good English is and if someone
- 46:14deviates from those norms that we expect them to use we think all sorts of things about them
- 46:20and so a lot of times that's things that are not in our own speech we judge other people or
- 46:24we feel very self-conscious about those things in our our speech because we know we do them and
- 46:28we know other people don't like them and we have these ideas based on this very prescriptivist
- 46:34view of language that we've been taught since we've been you know born basically our parents tell
- 46:38us oh don't say that it's not it's not him and I went to the store it's it's he and I right those
- 46:44kinds of things that are very prescriptivist notions that have developed over time what we don't
- 46:50realize is those are only moments right those are moments in our speech that we call attention to
- 46:56that over the long call of language have made no difference so these prescriptivist views first
- 47:01of all have only been around since about the 18th century before that we really didn't have a
- 47:05lot of prescription like you should do this you should do that you shouldn't do this talk like
- 47:09this don't talk like that that didn't mean we didn't notice differences in people's speech but we
- 47:14didn't tell them they were bad speakers because of it in the way that we do now but these are actually
- 47:19based on misunderstandings of where these features come from instead of realizing that they're
- 47:25actually part of the natural evolution of language and we have done the exact same thing throughout
- 47:29history with things that we think are totally right now but it's also that we don't recognize that
- 47:37speakers do that for very very good social reasons as well like people don't adopt our own
- 47:43our speech because they want something that they're getting from using those other speech features
- 47:48and it's that kind of social pressure that has moved language forward since the time of old
- 47:53English because if you've ever read Beowulf I think you'll probably agree with me that a
- 47:58Beowulf is unintelligible to anybody that speaks English today and be it wasn't really fun to read
- 48:05right so no one is brutal and I remember that too I was like why are we studying this like who's
- 48:11gonna ever need this in life and probably you don't tell you meet a linguist but reality is was
- 48:17that great English no but if we have if we follow this view that older features are better features
- 48:24than modern English speakers have a lot of explaining to do because clearly we have massively changed
- 48:29our language in the last thousand years and in fact the changes to English between the year 10,000
- 48:35I'll be sorry the year 1000 and the year 1700 basically were much more major in terms of
- 48:43radically reshaping the way that English sounded and looked like than any changes that have happened
- 48:48in the years since prescription started so we're actually really slowing the rate of change now
- 48:52not speeding it up but people act like we're decaying language constantly so this book was just
- 48:57like one of these features just before you keep going no sorry before you keep going what was the
- 49:01reason for that expedited change uh well wars invasions the French the Vikings right uh massive
- 49:09differences all of that so yeah you know in that eighth and ninth century we had a lot of old
- 49:14Norse inscriptions which basically was Viking incursions well what we don't tend to think of is
- 49:20Vikings were actually not that different than what Anglo-Saxons were Anglo-Saxons were essentially
- 49:25Vikings of an earlier era they all were from the great northern Germanic plains and so they all
- 49:31spoke a kind of related they also spoke dialects of essentially the same Germanic based language
- 49:38Anglo-Saxons came over several centuries before and then the language started to evolve in certain
- 49:43ways because those speakers were isolated especially back then when you didn't you know just pick up
- 49:47the phone or jump on zoom you didn't have a lot of contact so languages naturally evolved due to
- 49:52underlying linguistic pressures in different directions whenever speakers are separated and this
- 49:56can be separated by geography or separated by social distance whatever um so then when the Viking
- 50:02started to come over they spoke old Norse which was a similar dialect basically of the language
- 50:09the Anglo-Saxons spoke and people think of the Vikings as sort of these vicious people that came
- 50:14over and killed everybody but actually and they were I mean I'm not saying the Vikings were not
- 50:18fabulous and did only fabulous things they were mean and they killed a lot of people and you know
- 50:23they pillaged and all that but they also settled a lot in the Anglo-Saxon territory especially in
- 50:30the northern area of Britain and so they had a lot of assimilation with the Anglo-Saxons and so old
- 50:39Norse because it's a dialect whenever you have two dialects that are close together come in contact
- 50:43they influence each other quite a bit because those speakers can communicate so what happens is
- 50:48sort of a leveling where they kind of get rid of distinctive features and they move towards each
- 50:52other they become more similar so a lot of old Norse features came into the language through Viking
- 50:58contact um and so like that S that S I told you that does that's actually through old Norse contact
- 51:05it was a northern feature that came to us from old Norse contact um and then a lot of things we
- 51:10noticed in American English so southern features like Mike could saying things like Mike could
- 51:14those are actually come from contact with Scott's Irish back in the early days of colonial settlement
- 51:20um so those are all again very similar dialects to other ones that were sort of like the Virginia
- 51:26colonies spoke right they were from mainly South-Eastern British um areas then you have the
- 51:32Scott's Irish that also were in contact and so those those dialects blood together the history
- 51:38of our language in American English is very similar it's just all through contact and that of
- 51:42course you have the Norman invasion they brought the French over and I do talk about this history
- 51:47in the book and of course French was the language of government for and of the royal court for
- 51:51hundreds of years and what happens when you elevate a language it becomes the powerful language
- 51:56it's the one everybody wants to know if they want to work in that area if they want to have social
- 52:01status of a certain type those that don't speak it by default become colloquial vernacular speakers
- 52:08that we kind of you know those are scuzzy people you don't want to talk to them well that was what
- 52:12English was English was the scuzzy language right you didn't get educated in English you didn't
- 52:18make laws in English you didn't have religious ceremonies in English because English was considered
- 52:23as sort of gross vulgar language it was the language of common people I mean that is what English is
- 52:29right so the French though we borrowed a ton of vocabulary we got new sounds so for example
- 52:37f and v didn't exist in English as separate sounds until contact with the French which is why
- 52:42we have that weird spelling in words words like knife and knives and wife and wives that's actually
- 52:48from this contact with French that gave us these two different sounds that we actually now treat
- 52:53differently which we didn't in old English so massive changes to the language over time
- 52:58and then in the early modern period the drastic change was that English rose up as the language
- 53:03of power and then that massively changed English because it started to be used in government
- 53:09it started to be used in education it started to be used in law it started to be used in the court
- 53:14which then elevated forms of English to be the standard over the things that had been associated with
- 53:20French so all of those were pretty massive changes in according to you know modern times we
- 53:25really haven't had that much excitement so not much has happened in English in the last 200
- 53:30years compared to all those massive changes at that time let's speak about some of those
- 53:36filled pauses that you were speaking about previously the ums and the us so I even made a point
- 53:42at the beginning that that was the one thing that I I don't know anything about linguistics but I do
- 53:47know that I was not supposed to when presenting filled things with ums and us and I know that
- 53:51when you record a podcast and post production if you do the editing that's the parts that you're
- 53:56cutting out to make sure that it flows quicker so what are those where did they come from why do we
- 54:02do them what purpose did they have in our communication well and that what's so funny is so many
- 54:06people have told me I cut every uh and um out of my recordings because that is a widespread
- 54:12belief I mean no one has ever gone to a public speaking class and been told no stick your arms in
- 54:16they're awesome no one ever zero but that means no one has read the literature that suggests that
- 54:22um and uh are actually very very positive features in our speech now I'm not saying that they're
- 54:27positively perceived because that's clearly not true right we don't like them but this is a case
- 54:33a perfect example of where linguistic reality and social preferences do not meet so sometimes we
- 54:39have features that arise in our feet our speech to meet needs that we have as speakers of a language
- 54:44and those can be cognitive needs in terms of what's preferred in a structure linguistically it can
- 54:49be social needs in terms of how what how communication and connect connections can be made more
- 54:54effectively and then sometimes we have needs that arise because of social preferences that have
- 54:59developed in uh the world around us in businesses and schools that tell us to do something a certain
- 55:05way sometimes those are in tandem and we can get the same benefit from using the thing that's
- 55:11linguistically preferred and the thing that socially preferred sometimes they're in opposition and
- 55:15that's exactly what has happened with filled pauses filled pauses come up because we're doing
- 55:20heavy cognitive retrieval so it's basically a signal that our our brain is working over time
- 55:26and usually this happens when we're processing more difficult or new information so we have basically
- 55:32more neural firings that are needed when we have we're hearing something new for the first time
- 55:37then when we hear something many many times over and a great example of how integrating new
- 55:42information takes more cognitive effort and causes us to pause more a filled filler pauses more
- 55:48is a study that was done where they had people look at a picture and describe the picture
- 55:53and then they would have them describe the picture over and over again what you find is in their
- 55:57first description of the picture they use a much higher filled pause rate than in their third
- 56:02description of the picture because they're not doing as much cognitive processing because they've
- 56:06already explained it they've already gone through the stages in their head they know what they're
- 56:10going to say they've built the sentences they've come up with the vocabulary there's not much
- 56:14effort involved but when they're working harder they're coming up with new words they're using
- 56:18infrequent words they're constructing long sentences they're making in sort of embedded phrases
- 56:23in a different sentence all of those actually take additional cognitive effort and that is where
- 56:29we see ums and us come into play so the idea that ums and us are tied to anxiety is really not well
- 56:36established what it seems to be more tied to is hard cognitive effort um and that often comes up
- 56:42in cases where we might also be anxious which is why I think people conflate those two so when we're
- 56:47giving a presentation that usually involves bigger words than we usually use familiar less
- 56:52familiar words than we usually use because you don't talk at home like you do at the office
- 56:56and are in a business presentation and you're you're using bigger sentences right because you're
- 57:01probably not taking a lot of background information for granted like you would when you talk
- 57:05among friends and you're building out bigger syntactic structures well it also is a nerve-wracking
- 57:10experience to be giving a public presentation and therefore it seems like we're umming because we're
- 57:16nervous but actually we're umming and iying because we're doing really heavy cognitive work
- 57:21so now people do have rates of ums and us so some people do them a lot some people do them less
- 57:25and that does seem to be a kind of personal attribute I mean certainly this true that heavy
- 57:30ummers are generally less well received than light ummers but the reality is we um in us as speaker
- 57:36for a couple of reasons but one of them is basically we're doing heavy cognitive retrieval and so
- 57:41we're that's giving us a moment to get our thoughts together it's helping us retrieve the vocabulary
- 57:48out of a sea of other vocabulary words that would come to mind more quickly so if you're using a
- 57:53less familiar word what's going to come to mind more quickly are them more familiar words so you
- 57:57have to kind of wade through that cognitively to get to that word that's less familiar um and so
- 58:02that's like oftentimes have you ever been in a place where you're trying to come up with a word you're
- 58:05like uh uh uh it's because your brain is like marking marking marking i'm working i'm working i'm
- 58:11working but why we fill our pauses with a sound because we could just take a a silent pause seems
- 58:17to be because not only are we thinking harder but we want to signal to our listener that they need
- 58:22to give us a moment to come up with what we're going to say and don't take our turn from us so it's
- 58:26sort of a communicative aid that tells someone that's listening to you i have something more to say
- 58:33so you know don't go away and don't jump in my conversation you know don't don't still the floor
- 58:38for me which is why when you're talking either to Siri or Alexa or one of a computer or you're
- 58:43talking in a context where you're telling a story and you wouldn't expect to get interrupted we
- 58:48don't see filled pauses come up as often so the same speaker will decrease the rate of filled pauses
- 58:53in context where floor theft is not an option compared to when they're in a casual conversation
- 58:59hey everyone just want to take a second and thank the sponsor of today's episode masterclass now
- 59:03i wanted to share masterclass with everyone here i just discovered it it's an amazing streaming
- 59:08platform with over 180 classes taught by some of the world's best minds so i'm talking about
- 59:15learning how to cook from Gordon Ramsay or diving into writing with Neil gammon or even getting
- 59:22tips on tennis from serena Williams but what caught my attention was Alexis ohanian's class
- 59:28on building your startup now i'm a huge fan of the reddit story i'm an entrepreneur myself
- 59:33i could not resist checking it out and let me tell you i was blown away by the depth of knowledge
- 59:38and the quality of the experience see he shares valuable insights and advice from his own journey
- 59:44as a co-founder and venture capitalist and the best part is i didn't have to watch the entire class
- 59:48in one sitting so i can pace myself i could explore it when i had time even just learning something
- 59:53new in 10 minutes see masterclass is perfect for anyone looking to learn from top notch instructors
- 59:59across a wide range of topics it's super convenient too as you can access the classes on your phone
- 1:00:04your web literally anywhere plus each class comes with additional resources so downloadable guides
- 1:00:10class materials it all enhances the learning experience so i highly recommend you check it out
- 1:00:15you get unlimited access to every class and as a success story podcast listener you get up to 35
- 1:00:21percent off from mother's day so go to that is masterclass.com slash success story to get up to 35
- 1:00:29percent off from mother's day so really what are you waiting for they gave us a special code
- 1:00:34you gotta go to masterclass today take advantage of this special mother's day discount
- 1:00:38happy learning is that is that an exclusively north american or english feature and the reason
- 1:00:45why i ask because you mentioned that that other cultures were more comfortable with silent pauses
- 1:00:51so like like fins or or i think you mentioned a japanese before they're comfortable with silent pauses
- 1:00:58would they still have these arms and arms they do now that so what's interesting is what you're
- 1:01:01talking about are silent pauses between turns which we call turn transition cues and those are
- 1:01:06actually different so think about when you come to the end of a senate you don't usually go
- 1:01:11yeah so i had a great time at that party uh right that's not that's not what you say to tell someone
- 1:01:17it's their turn to talk right so what we're talking about actually when i say that is that that space
- 1:01:22that comes between conversational turns and it serves as a turn transition cue which tells someone
- 1:01:28else oh it's your turn to talk right um and that's what i was talking about in that context but
- 1:01:33yes that taking to your question we're directly every single language ever studied has filled pauses
- 1:01:39and not only do they have one filled pauses but every language studied so far has more than one
- 1:01:44filled pauses generally at least two like japanese for example has a and ono as well as several
- 1:01:51others and uh dutch has f and m right french has a and m so you have all these filled pauses now the
- 1:01:59reason the in though European languages sound very similar is that actually we hypothesize that they
- 1:02:05all or those those filled pauses probably all originated from a source language so for example
- 1:02:10all Germanic languages have essentially the same two pauses uh and um slightly different with the
- 1:02:15vowels based on whatever vowel context that language has but that's just to us that they're
- 1:02:21inherited from proto Germanic which probably got them from indo European which is like why french
- 1:02:27has very similar because it's a indo European language even though it's not a Germanic one so yes
- 1:02:32all languages do have them they seem to serve the same purpose and the reason they seem to have two
- 1:02:38is really fascinating because we don't tend to think there's a substantive difference between uh and um
- 1:02:43and if you think about it why would we need synonyms for a filled paus which is just sort of a
- 1:02:49thing that we insert in our speech it seems kind of odd but if you look at the length of the pause
- 1:02:55that people have after they are compared to the length of the pause that he people take after they
- 1:02:59um we find a statistical difference between them so that uh signals you just need a quick sec um
- 1:03:06signals you need to take longer so it actually seems to be listener directed so that listeners will
- 1:03:12know how long they have before you're going to finish your thought so a lot of times if I uh
- 1:03:17we find that people try to don't try to fill in what we're struggling with so have you ever been
- 1:03:22talking to someone that's I mean a lot and you're like wait do you mean this do you mean that
- 1:03:26well what's interesting is if you hear them uh because you know what means they're not having as
- 1:03:30much difficulty it's not going to take them as long you don't tend to do that to the same degree if
- 1:03:34you um someone is more likely to try to hop in and help you because that signals to them you're
- 1:03:39struggling more with whatever you're processing so there's a really interesting fascinating
- 1:03:44difference between the amount of times we uh the amount of time we need for an uh versus an um
- 1:03:49and that the final fascinating fact about your filled pauses because there are so many is that
- 1:03:54not only do they help you as a speaker when cognitive processing and communicating a lag or speech
- 1:03:59delay they really help you study show as a listener in both being quicker to process what someone says
- 1:04:09integrate new information faster and remember it better later so not only do your uh as an um
- 1:04:15help you signal to a listener like okay they're gonna take a minute but that listener upon hearing
- 1:04:20those seems to take it as a cognitive flag that whatever follows the filled pause is more is
- 1:04:26more difficult to process that seems to cue their in their interest and their cognitive effort
- 1:04:32towards it so they get kind of more neural firings directed towards that which makes them quicker
- 1:04:37to anticipate what you're gonna say and predict it quicker to integrate new information if it's
- 1:04:42something novel in that context and that it also seems to then cement it in their memory
- 1:04:47better so that if you give them for example pop quiz an hour later they'll remember words that
- 1:04:52had an hour or an um before them better than they remember words that didn't so if you think about
- 1:04:58that's pretty damn impressive for something we think of as bad habits right yeah no I mean it's
- 1:05:07exception I've never thought about it this much before this is amazing let's can we can we
- 1:05:15talk about profanity and and I want to understand its place in language and communication so what
- 1:05:22is the psychological impact or what is a psychological reasoning why people swear well you know there've
- 1:05:28been I know study profanity myself but I have read some of the literature on why people do it
- 1:05:35and there seems to be sort of an emotional response that it's helping us process when we use
- 1:05:40profanity so for the same reason that we express ourselves in different ways linguistically when
- 1:05:47we switch between saying something with a more formal context and saying something informal that's
- 1:05:52actually doing something for us from a sociocultural kind of perspective when we swear it seems to be
- 1:05:58something that helps us feel better it's helping us express an emotion an emotional reaction just
- 1:06:05in the same way like it's encoding an emotion in the same way that oh is encoding of surprise
- 1:06:11so if I say something like oh my god listen to this that oh is actually an exclamation that's
- 1:06:18encoding this is surprise here this is an emotion of surprise that I'm expressing I'm having and
- 1:06:25I want you to share it right and so we actually find that my understanding of what we find with
- 1:06:30swearing is it comes from a different side of the brain that processes emotion and response and so
- 1:06:36it is actually a way to help us process these emotions that we're feeling usually anger or frustration
- 1:06:42or something like that and what's really fascinating about swearing is of course you know it's
- 1:06:47really much more prevalent today than it was in you know something like the 1920s when it wasn't
- 1:06:52widely accepted we see an uptick in in bad words or bad language you know obscenities after a
- 1:06:58world war two and it seems like what happened is when soldiers went overseas and experienced probably
- 1:07:05the worst things they ever experienced in life profanity offered them a way to process those
- 1:07:10experiences to commiserate over those experiences to express exactly how deeply it affected them
- 1:07:18and they brought profanity home so they they had those experiences they brought it home and
- 1:07:22that's where we see actually women start to use it at a higher rate because their husbands came
- 1:07:26home they were using profanity they were describing experiences that were highly emotional and profanity
- 1:07:31helped emphasize the intensity of that emotion and so then it became more prevalent in people's
- 1:07:37speech every day when they also wanted to express an intensity of emotion so I know I know you don't
- 1:07:44study this so if you if you if you don't have the literature on it then that's fine but I'm
- 1:07:47I'm very curious if if swearing profanity you mentioned that it's mostly for the person who's
- 1:07:55actually speaking it's not for the recipient there's no correlation between profanity and
- 1:08:00level of trustworthiness or level of authenticity and delivery of message like I'm thinking of like
- 1:08:06the Gary V's of the world that swear casually right you know and he stands behind that
- 1:08:12I'd be interested I don't know the literature on that um sort of you're talking about sort
- 1:08:16perceptual response to swearing my my my suspicion would be it would depend on context right
- 1:08:22wouldn't be equivalently perceived well in or more trustworthy in different contexts um so you
- 1:08:30know if you swear in a professional place where more traditional norms are what are considered
- 1:08:36appropriate then I doubt that would make you feel more trustworthy because it would be a violation
- 1:08:40of corporate culture in that context right and the expectation would be you understand the
- 1:08:45corporate culture here and you understand that that's inappropriate versus maybe in Silicon Valley
- 1:08:49where it's much more laid back that would come across as a more authentic self um so I actually
- 1:08:55think that it would depend on the context you're studying it in but I just from what I know about
- 1:09:00other things about how informal speech tends to make you more sort of sociable and credible
- 1:09:06in many contexts because if you use overly stiff or more formal language it comes across as
- 1:09:12learned it in high status but also can be kind of arrogant pretentious and when we get into more
- 1:09:17informal speech it feels more trustworthy more like this is a person I know this is a friend
- 1:09:22that profanity could operate the same way but I don't know the literature on that um if I find
- 1:09:27any though I'd be happy to send you something I would do a whole show on that that's fascinating
- 1:09:32you know I just find it fascinating because even I I think to myself and you know when I swear
- 1:09:37and it's not always it's not always emotional so I'm trying to figure out what I would do it
- 1:09:41why I would why I would say it in a sentence that has you know consciously no emotion attached
- 1:09:47to that sentence maybe there is subconsciously I don't know well I think it seems like there's
- 1:09:51not so a lot of times what we do is we have something that is born in one circumstance so
- 1:09:56swearing came from an emotional core emotional response and it was in response that we did it
- 1:10:01first but a lot of times what we find with language is these these things that language has come to
- 1:10:07represent then get picked up and moved to a different context that is more metaphorical or
- 1:10:12figurative so uh oh for example is a metaphorical extension of surprise does that make sense that
- 1:10:19you've taken from an explanation to use it in a word in a as a sort of discourse marker that's
- 1:10:24telling your listener hey this is where we're going to shift to something that is new information
- 1:10:27that you didn't know and it should surprise you right you're giving them a heads up about it
- 1:10:31so it's already the figurative use of something that was once just an explanation of surprise when
- 1:10:36you know someone jumps out of a closet at you so that again is a good example of where swearing could
- 1:10:42have that same thing swearing mainly became something that was sort of an expression of intensity
- 1:10:48and surprise and chalk whatever and then now is sort of used for emphasis and intensity removed
- 1:10:56from its original use in more conversational speech so that would be something that would be very
- 1:11:01very normal and in fact intensification in general comes from that kind of space so when we say
- 1:11:07things like he's very good or terrifically awesome or totally great the reason we have those words
- 1:11:14is to express intensity or emphasis and in fact those words are called adverbial intensification
- 1:11:20that's what we call it but most words that serve as intensifiers started as something else that
- 1:11:26had a different meaning that got semantically bleached down to meaning just extremely so very for
- 1:11:33example is originally from a word that meant actual or true so in old English you would find people
- 1:11:41well actually it was be middle English because it came from French but in middle English early on
- 1:11:45around 1300 you would see references to Jesus as the very prophet which met the true prophet he
- 1:11:51was the true prophet but later on about a century later you start to see it as he was a very
- 1:11:58proper fool which is actually a quote from Chaucer and that means he was a true proper fool which
- 1:12:06means he had all the qualities of being a proper fool which is an intensification of being a
- 1:12:11proper fool so what over time happens is the meaning of true gets bleached out and all that's left
- 1:12:17a very is that it means a lot so I'm very happy means I'm extremely happy it doesn't mean I'm true
- 1:12:23it means I'm very happy but we can still see very retaining some aspects of that meaning when we
- 1:12:28say on this very spot he died which means on this true or exact spot so I do so what I'm sort of
- 1:12:37the example I'm using this for is that this one sense of very got extrapolated and became the
- 1:12:43prominent use of very today I feel like profanity could have worked the same way this emotional
- 1:12:49sense of what a word meant in one context this emphatic and sort of intensity that when you set a
- 1:12:55cuss word it brought into the context got extrapolated so now when I say damn I'm happy
- 1:13:02what I'm not saying like I'm having this emotional experience it's like I'm intensifying my happiness
- 1:13:07right so it's again extrapolated to the context from its original use but no longer carries that
- 1:13:13same original emotional intensity does that make sense it makes it makes a ton of sense and I have
- 1:13:18one more I have one more question and it's we're actually moving away from profanity and we're
- 1:13:24moving away from longer time periods I'm curious about accents I'm curious I don't know if this
- 1:13:28is your specialty at all I'm just throwing stuff on you now I'm just hoping you answer I'm so
- 1:13:35curious so when you look at someone and they're they came from one country to another country
- 1:13:43and say they move from anywhere anywhere in the world to the US and over their lifespan they've
- 1:13:48started to sound quote unquote American you know and but this another person will move to the US
- 1:13:55and their entire lifespan they'll have an accent from wherever they originally came from why is
- 1:14:00that and why is that even I'll give you a even better example even in you know so my girlfriend
- 1:14:05she has two sisters my girlfriend is a little bit of an accent or two sisters have no accent
- 1:14:11they're all very confused how the younger older than she is they're younger okay that's
- 1:14:16your trick so I actually this is my specialty I do a lot of work I'm a sociophonetician which means
- 1:14:22I do a lot of work on speech sounds and why they come to be in how they work cognitively and there
- 1:14:27are a number of things that enter into the question that you asked about why some people have
- 1:14:31stronger accents than others and what accents are we're basically an accent is related to speech
- 1:14:37sounds so when we talk about someone to accent the only thing that actually means is they have a
- 1:14:41sound to their speech that's uniquely identifying them as being from somewhere else or something different
- 1:14:46a fallacy is that we don't have an accent we do because if we go somewhere else they'll say oh you're
- 1:14:51an American it's because of your accent we just don't hear it because we're talking to other people
- 1:14:55that sound the same way so what happens is when you have a language that's not English mostly they
- 1:15:00have different systems of sounds typically in the vowels so English is an extremely vowel
- 1:15:07promiscuous language which means we just pot vowels out everywhere you know we have a ton of
- 1:15:11vowels in English it's not ideal which is why we have a lot of stuff going on with our vowels
- 1:15:16in American English they're changing a lot but if you look at the majority of other languages
- 1:15:21they have around five vowels so for example Spanish has five vowels so what happened when you go
- 1:15:28from a five vowel system to a 13 or 14 vowel system which is what English is and I say 13 or 14
- 1:15:33because it depends on the dialect of English you're speaking well you have to come up with something
- 1:15:38for those vowels so you then say the vowel in your system of those five vowels that's closest to
- 1:15:45one of those 13 vowels which then makes you sound different because you're not using the same
- 1:15:50vowel as someone that speaks that language so a lot of times accents are deeply tied to vowel
- 1:15:55pronunciation because that tends to be something that really differs among different cultures
- 1:16:00among different languages so the trick is the reason we have certain sounds is because we've
- 1:16:05learned those as babies as infants we find that children are able to recognize the sounds of
- 1:16:10their language by a year old so at six months they don't seem to notice they notice human speech
- 1:16:15sounds opposed to other sounds but they they will equally devote attention to every speech sound no
- 1:16:21matter whether it's in their language or not but so if th is a good example of the sound of the
- 1:16:26sound the English is unusual and having that sound many many languages don't so for example my
- 1:16:31mother's a French speaker she still says one too Tweet because French doesn't have a thus sound
- 1:16:37so a baby at an English baby will understand both the and ta at six months and so would a
- 1:16:43French speaking baby but by a year old a French speaking baby will filter out the thus sound
- 1:16:49because it's not relevant to their language whereas a American baby will still pay attention to it
- 1:16:53and suck harder that's how we measure baby attention they'll suck harder on a sort of
- 1:16:57electronic pacifier that transmits their sucking rate to a computer when they hear that sound
- 1:17:03meaning they're recognizing that that's part of their speech sound that they start babbling you
- 1:17:08know if you've had a baby or been around babies they do weird things with their mouths and they're
- 1:17:11like yeah ba ba ba ba pa ta ta and they make a lot of noises that is them actually practicing
- 1:17:18to make those sounds so they're exercising there are sort of physiological ability to make certain
- 1:17:24sounds and anything with practice the more you do it the better you get but if you don't do
- 1:17:29something learning a new skill no matter what it is is hard it takes time and we're often very
- 1:17:36good at the things we learned from being a very at a young age and bad at the things we learn
- 1:17:40at a later age well that's exactly what happens speech sounds you have been practicing and setting
- 1:17:46your articulatory mechanism to make these particular speech sounds since you were born but also
- 1:17:52you come into a language as an adult or a older adolescent and you have a whole bunch of new sounds
- 1:17:58that you haven't processed before cognitively you haven't practiced physiologically and you
- 1:18:04kind of use your own system to understand that language and that prohibits you in some ways from
- 1:18:11adopting that language as a native speaker so that's sort of the background the question you ask
- 1:18:18is why are some people better than others well some of us are better at doing the analysis as an
- 1:18:22older adult on sort of the new distribution of sounds and we just find certain people do that
- 1:18:27better and that's partially tied to motivation it depends on your motivation for doing it often
- 1:18:34depends on how close or distant your own system was from the one you're learning but it also seems
- 1:18:39to depend on whether how well you perceive sounds how well you sort of analyze the statistical
- 1:18:44distributions and that just seems to be blind luck like some people are good at it some people
- 1:18:49are less good the same way that people are good at hearing music or not like tonality of music
- 1:18:53so it does seem to be there some innate predisposition that makes you better or worse at it but the
- 1:18:58key is age of acquisition the older you are when you're exposed to a new system the worse you
- 1:19:03tend to be at acquiring it so I would suggest that with your girlfriend because her sisters are
- 1:19:09younger they had earlier exposure and longer to adjust to it at an earlier age and that really
- 1:19:16seems to make a big impact on how languages learned and how accents are gotten rid of
- 1:19:23I love this okay um so let's let's let's wrap this up uh I want to give the floor over to you so
- 1:19:28I guess two I always ask a question at the end but I'll say that for a second um two things
- 1:19:35anything else that you wanted to go into or teach over to uh the audience that we haven't
- 1:19:40come into feel free and then also uh more importantly um what can people get out of your new book
- 1:19:47where can they go get it and all of your social and and whatnot okay well so I think uh you know
- 1:19:52the big thing is everything we've talked about though a lot of it wasn't directly from the book
- 1:19:56although some of it was like the ums and us and the intensifiers and things but it's all about
- 1:20:01these questions that we have as speakers of human language I don't think there's anybody alive
- 1:20:06in any language that has never questioned their own speech or the speech of other people um you know
- 1:20:12it's it's not just because we're judgmental it's because we are indoctrinated into a really firm
- 1:20:18belief about what's good language and what's bad language and um the problem is it's it's an
- 1:20:24issue of equity for one because we tend to judge certain people's speeches better and there's
- 1:20:29reason socio historically for that but it's also of accuracy because a lot of the what we believe
- 1:20:35about language and the why people do it and what's bad is based on erroneous facts so it will blow
- 1:20:41your mind where a lot of these speech features come from so for example like where does it come from
- 1:20:47well valley girls right if I asked you you'd probably say it's Southern California's valley girls
- 1:20:53wrong it is actually centuries old if we look back in set the 1700s to British trial transcripts
- 1:21:00which because obviously we didn't have recordings we have to rely on transcripts there is something
- 1:21:04called the old Bailey proceedings which were criminal trial proceedings that were rigorously
- 1:21:09transcribed verbatim for about 200 years so if we look back in the 1700s in Britain we find
- 1:21:17like used as a discourse marker um we also find it in literature at that time but if you look in
- 1:21:22New Zealand at some recordings New Zealand did this wonderful project called I think it was called
- 1:21:26the arms project done in the middle of the 20th century where they recorded really old New Zealanders
- 1:21:31before they died um who had come over from British backgrounds in the late 1800s so these were
- 1:21:38people born in the late 1800s guess what they used like just like we use it today at the beginning
- 1:21:45of sentences for cohesion we also find an octogenarian rural speakers in Britain they used like the same
- 1:21:52way so this is actually a British feature and it wasn't until it got noticed with Southern California
- 1:21:58Valley girl speakers in the eight in the 1980s that we also were like oh my god like it's everywhere
- 1:22:03it's all it's a bad thing but actually it is centuries old and it has fascinating reasons for why
- 1:22:08it emerged so it's really about accuracy if you really want to know why people do this it's easy
- 1:22:14to dismiss them but then you miss the reality of why people change language and have through centuries
- 1:22:20and my book is really about getting to understand why we do the things we do in language um it's
- 1:22:24also really funny i i have fun with it i want people to enjoy reading it it will help you understand
- 1:22:30your kids if you have teenagers it will help you understand your employees if you have young
- 1:22:34employees and it will help you understand yourself if you use any type of non-standard speech marker
- 1:22:39in your speech so if you say like if you use vocal fry if you um in uh if you've ever said dude
- 1:22:44in your life if you're struggling with singular they any of those things you can find that in the book
- 1:22:50i love it okay where do they go what's the socials that you want to send people to in the website
- 1:22:54okay well my website will have information on other things i've written um and as well as the book
- 1:22:58so that's just Valerie Friedland dot com and i'm sure you'll have the link in your um show notes
- 1:23:04so that i don't have to spell that out because it's of course a little tricky to spell but that has
- 1:23:08a lot of information i also write a monthly blog for psychology today so it's called language in
- 1:23:12the wild you can just either go to my website to find it or if you search Valerie Friedland
- 1:23:18psychology today it'll come right up and and i pick fun things like swearing there's actually
- 1:23:22a one on swearing so i'll have to send you that link uh so that's where they can find me i don't do a
- 1:23:27lot on social but you can find me it on twitter uh Friedland Valorys my handle there and also on
- 1:23:33LinkedIn okay perfect all right so last question i ask everyone before we end this out um you've
- 1:23:41had an incredible career writing books you're i mean you've taught at multiple universities um
- 1:23:47very very impressive after everything that you've achieved in your life what a success mean to
- 1:23:52you you know that's a really great question because it's something i have thought about a lot
- 1:23:56in the last few years as i sort of evolved in terms of what i'm doing in my career and i think
- 1:24:01if you'd asked me 20 years ago when i was first starting out i would have said financial success
- 1:24:06you know that's what of course every 25 year old is thinking when they're going on the job right
- 1:24:11do something that's cool and i want to have money i want to be successful that success i think
- 1:24:17for a lot of young people maybe some people are better than me and don't think that but that's
- 1:24:20probably what i thought of in my 20s but as i've gotten older and wiser and also done work what i
- 1:24:28realized is freedom to me is really the ultimate success the freedom to pursue the things you like
- 1:24:34and not have to do the things that really you don't like because half of what you do no matter
- 1:24:38whether it's a job you love or a job you hate is something you don't enjoy about that right so for
- 1:24:43me it was administration i'm a professor and i really do enjoy teaching i'm still close friends
- 1:24:49with students i had 20 years ago because i try to be meaningful in their life in some way and i
- 1:24:55really try to support them because i think mentorship is really key so it's to me that's a really
- 1:25:00valuable part of my job i love to write i love to share what i learn it's passion for me because i
- 1:25:05find it so fascinating i think everybody else has to be also fascinated by this so those are the
- 1:25:10things i like but i also had to do a lot of administration like i hate forms i hate them if i
- 1:25:16had to fill out another form a writer report or oversee somebody or you know give lessons and
- 1:25:22lectures to students behaving badly or professors behaving badly both of which i've had to do
- 1:25:27because i was a director of the department for a while i don't like that i really i did it because
- 1:25:32it was my civic responsibility and it was what it meant to be in a career like i was in but i
- 1:25:37felt really awful in that phase of my life i did six years as a director and while
- 1:25:43i had cherished moments and experiences in that i will say it's not what i like to do at all
- 1:25:48now that i'm a full professor and i'm kind of at the ending stage of my career and sort of seniority
- 1:25:54i get to do what i love which is right and teach and i don't have to do nearly as much administration
- 1:26:00and so to me i think the freedom to pursue my interests rather than my obligations has really
- 1:26:04been success in the last few years