Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / FBI PROFILER AND I DISCUSS THE COMPLEXITY OF REDUCING CRIME
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics Podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant doctor Carlos. Hey. Welcome back, everybody.
- 0:27Welcome back, Annie, Hey, Carlos How are you today. I'm doing
- 0:31great, doing well, doing well myself. Yeah, I know. Well,
- 0:36we're not on video, we're audio, right, audio only. You
- 0:39don't want to know what he's doing, folks. I have a I have
- 0:42a face for radio. This is what I've been doing well. Today we're
- 0:46going to be covering it may seem academic to some of you out there,
- 0:50where we talk about, uh, we're going to talk about criminal criminology theories.
- 0:54We're going to talk about four and how to reduce crime. I guess
- 0:57is one way to present this. The fourth we're going to be discussing as
- 1:00deterrence theory and capacitation theory, which kind of go hand in hand. Also
- 1:04talk about restore, restorative theory and rehabilitation a little bit of each theory and
- 1:11the complexities of reducing crime. And we see these cycles and I think Andy
- 1:17and I just talked about it. Before we get started on this though,
- 1:19folks, make sure to share, subscribe, and hit that like button.
- 1:22But before we get started, think Andy and I were talking before the show.
- 1:25This is cyclical. We go back and forth between the theories and people
- 1:30come back and say, you know what, the last twenty five years haven't
- 1:32worked. We're going to switch it back to this thing. And then we
- 1:34get into this three strikes. You're out hard stance on crime, and then
- 1:40you come back to the other one. No, no, no, we
- 1:41need to be softy into rebailability. We need to do this and do that,
- 1:44and because back and forth, so I thought it'd be a good time
- 1:46to kind of bring some clarity in defining terms into all these topics. So
- 1:53I guess, Andy, should we start on what these theories are? I
- 1:57think we can. Let's start with that. But you know, before we
- 1:59do is because you prefaced it so well. I just want to kind of
- 2:02see if I can't paint a picture for our audience because you talked about this
- 2:07pendulum swing, and you see this in almost everything. Everything organically has this
- 2:15sort of ying yang swing back and forth everything. Because here's what if you
- 2:23take the perspective that everything is seeking balance and everything in life, everything in
- 2:29the universe, all energy matters. It's constantly seeking its own base of theesis.
- 2:38You know. Homeostesis is the body trying to find balance. Right.
- 2:43Mental health is about finding balance between a psychosis and a neuroses. Right,
- 2:49We're looking for balance in everything we do. You and I do a separate
- 2:52podcast on the psychology of romance, and romance is about seeking balance, as
- 2:58we talked about in a previous podcast, between oneness, which is an extreme
- 3:02of two people becoming one unit, and separateness, which is critically necessary for
- 3:08passion and so erotically intelligent couples. They strike a balance between the two.
- 3:16Politics, both parties today are taken over by extremes in the parties. Right,
- 3:23the right wing of the Republican Party isn't the Republican Party. There is
- 3:28Rhino is the Dynos, the socialists that have taken over the Democrats. Most
- 3:31Americans want balance. I've and this is the point I'm making. Humans seem
- 3:38to be walking contradictions. We seem to be swinging from one side to the
- 3:43other in this kind of binary code. Even in relationships, we swing from
- 3:47trust to control, when in fact we're not We're not really extremists. Most
- 3:53of us are seeking balance. Most of us are somewhere in the middle.
- 3:57So we started our preface conversation, our pre podcast conversation by discussing what is
- 4:05the true measure of success in crime or crime prevention? Is it the absolute
- 4:14absence of crime in a society or is it something less than that, something
- 4:19more balanced. You don't want chaos, you don't want a brutal state of
- 4:24nature as Hobbes Thomas Hobbs would call it. But you also don't want a
- 4:29police state where your liberties are so controlled, like a North Korea, that
- 4:36you may have an absence of crime, but you also don't have liberties.
- 4:42And that's what we're striking when we talk about these theories, and when we
- 4:45talk about an open, democratic society, is where is that balance. I'll
- 4:49give you another quick example before I shut up the gun. You know the
- 4:54Second Amendment. You have those extremists to say there should be no gun laws.
- 4:58We should be able to have a bazook in my basement if I want
- 5:00to tank in my backyard. Well, of course, the founding fathers don't
- 5:04want that, and they always use that as the baseline. Right, What
- 5:08would the founding fathers say. But they also want us to be able to
- 5:12have some form of protectional arms. I mean, that's clearly stated in the
- 5:15Second Amendment. The reason we elect and we have a representative republic, the
- 5:19reason we elect officials is to come together collaboratively. So it's a win win
- 5:27or a compromise anyway. So it's fifty to fifty, and we have a
- 5:30balance. We have a balance in law that allows good law abiding citizens to
- 5:36own weapons right without the government impeding on it, but somehow restricting it or
- 5:42regulating it, because it says in the Second Amendment a well regulated militia.
- 5:46So we are seeking balance, and that's the preface of this conversation. How
- 5:50can we use these four theories to strike a balance in society where I feel
- 5:55safe to walk down the street at night, and I have my liberty to
- 5:59do that, but I also am being restricted so I don't beat the hell
- 6:02out of my neighbor as he comes home and steal his car. And with
- 6:06that, you know, I think, what do you think? I think
- 6:11it's a good point. It is a point about balance, and it kind
- 6:13of was a good segue into that issue. Is telling you about earlier,
- 6:15which I wanted to start the conversation with the As you mentioned before we started,
- 6:20each theory has its pluses and minuses. The question really becomes which which
- 6:26one has the more pluses and more minuses, And that's more complicated we're going
- 6:29to be talking about in a minute. The other thing that you segued me
- 6:31into was the definition. What's the definition of success in this metric because people
- 6:38like to argue, well, look there's still homicides happening even though you're using
- 6:42this technique or this theory. But the question never would be you never should
- 6:46be, at least in my mind, to eliminate crime one hundred percent.
- 6:48You just can't do it. That's that shouldn't be the metric. Well you
- 6:51could. I'm gonna interrupt you, because I think it's possible, Okay,
- 6:56really I do. I think it's possible to eliminate crime absolutely, and and
- 7:02societies like North Korea have nearly the absence of crime because if you're they have
- 7:08police, they're police there. Their standard of proof is is if we think,
- 7:14if if the and it's not even a reasonable person, if the government
- 7:16thinks you're going to commit a crime, will kill you proactively I mean there
- 7:20are people that think sideways. Relatives. Yeah, but relatives of the premium
- 7:29haveage you committed a crime that they kill you for interest for doing something.
- 7:31Anyway, if you go against the government, you've committed a crime in their
- 7:34eyes. If the government thinks so, I mean, you're right. Blasphemy
- 7:39used to be a crime. Right. Socrates was sentenced to death because he
- 7:43questioned the state. Just question the state, you know, so I would
- 7:48I would beg to differ on the standard. But to your point, I
- 7:54can change it into America, only you can't sit Can you stop crime and
- 7:59still be a democratic society? Here's another point I would make that you know,
- 8:05outside of the Guard of Eden. But in the in the Bible,
- 8:07in the Old Testament, we have a story of two brothers. Right,
- 8:11One brother, Kane, takes a stone or piece of wood or something,
- 8:18he thinks something, creates a weapon, beats his brother up, kills him.
- 8:22Right, So you would think that crime is as old as the Bible
- 8:28tells us, is as old as man itself. Cain and Abel, right,
- 8:33and aren't they Adam and Eve's children. Yeah, so we're talking like
- 8:39literally the second generation of human It was like a few I don't know how
- 8:41many pages into the Bible you had your first crime committed, right, Well,
- 8:46no, first crime was was stealing because Adam and Eves stole the fruit
- 8:48from the Tree of Knowledge. Right, so we talk about a baseline of
- 8:52expected pass Yeah, not a trespass, theft. It was theft. God
- 8:58said, don't steal my fruit, morons. Yeah, he said, well,
- 9:03actually it wasn't fruit. It was don't eat the fruit from the tree
- 9:07of knowledge. It's metaphorical. Well, cool, everything is in the Bible.
- 9:13I think could be argued this is metaphorical. But in any case,
- 9:16it's a good metaphor because humans, by their very nature will challenge boundaries.
- 9:24Let me give you how innate. This is a child, and you're a
- 9:28developmental psychologist, you know better than I. A child, we think is
- 9:33pretty much a blank, blank slate in terms of morality, right, and
- 9:37Kolberg and Paise and all those guys have studied childhood development of morality. But
- 9:43when a child, in practical terms, when a child is ambulatory, usually
- 9:48around the age of two, they start walking, they hear one word more
- 9:52frequently than any other word. One of the first words they hear starts with
- 9:56an N ends with a O. Right, and we tell that child no,
- 10:01no, no. Because the child, we set up boundaries. We
- 10:05tell them, don't touch the electrical outlet, don't go to the stairs,
- 10:09don't do this, don't do that. And what does the child do?
- 10:13He challenges us. The two year old is and we call it the terrible
- 10:18twos. I call it the terrorist twos because they want to provoke, defy,
- 10:24and resist the rules that we put in place from the earliest age.
- 10:28Our job and they even teach this in early pedagogial schooling is social emotional learning.
- 10:35Right. So the whole idea is that there's a line. Little Johnny,
- 10:39You're not always the number one person, the first person in line.
- 10:43Today, you're going to be the last person in line. And will Johnny
- 10:46has to understand that he is one cog in this giant system that we call
- 10:52society, and there are rules that they have to abide by. So when
- 10:56we talk about these theories and the context of rule making, we couldn't go
- 11:01back to Adam and Eve. There was only one friggin rule they had to
- 11:05follow, and because they were human, what did they do? They provoked,
- 11:09the fied and resisted that rule and broke the covenant with God, and
- 11:13that's the parable that tells us, hey, that's just natural human behavior.
- 11:20Provoke, defy, resist rules that we don't agree with or don't satisfy our
- 11:26self interest. It always goes back to Young Again's shadow, which she always
- 11:30talks about that dark side that we all have, and it is that the
- 11:33child has a dark side per se. But and I differ a little bit
- 11:39on the wording that was used. We tend to use more of the wording
- 11:43that the child's looking for boundaries, trying to figure out what's right or wrong
- 11:48in their mind. They're trying to establish That's why I always say it's really
- 11:50important you don't just tell them n O. You need to explain why that
- 11:54behavior isn't right. And this really should focus more also on behavior that is
- 12:00right. So if they're doing something they should be not doing, whatever it
- 12:05may be, I don't know, jumping on the sofa, you can always
- 12:07tell them, you know, we sit on sofas, we don't jump on
- 12:11sofas. It's a very different mentality than saying no, you can't jump on
- 12:16that sofa, because if there's no explanation, okay, they know it's not
- 12:20right. Mom and dad aren't happy, but I don't know why. Also,
- 12:24you raise itod point because one infers a negative intent and the other are
- 12:30positive. I'll give you an examples. So I like tangible examples. As
- 12:33you know. So space is a final frontier, right. So space,
- 12:39so we have these boundaries that are only limited by our imagination. Right,
- 12:45But humans have this innate curiosity, and I think that begins in childhood.
- 12:50So just like the astronomer who looks beyond our galaxy to the stars, beyond
- 12:56the boundaries for a positive intent, they want to explore, or because exploring
- 13:01gives them a sense of excitement, passion. Even that child isn't necessarily provoking
- 13:07the parent by putting a hairpin in the electrical outlet. They're trying to explore
- 13:15what's outside the boundaries that they've been given in a positive sense. Now,
- 13:18they might be doing breaking a rule we put in place, but their intent
- 13:22may not necessarily be negative. Our reaction to their behavior can set that up
- 13:28as a punishment and a negative when what you're saying is, hey, maybe
- 13:33we redirected in a positive manner. Right now, what we bring that over
- 13:37and channel it to crime somebody? Let's say, who's stealing to feed their
- 13:43family. Their intent is positive, right, their families starving and they steal
- 13:48a loaf for bread, and Locke and other philosophers talked about social contracts and
- 13:56social contract theory. So when somebody breaks the law, it may not necessarily
- 14:01be out of negative intent that they're selfishly trying to steal a bread for themselves
- 14:07order we sell it to somebody. They may be stealing that bread so that
- 14:11they could personally or their family could survive. And so you know, it's
- 14:16the way we treat the aggressor or the perpetrator. They could in fact define
- 14:22society as whole. In Korea, you steal bread, they kill you,
- 14:26boom. And maybe in the United States we put them in jail. Maybe
- 14:30in some other society they hire them as a baker and they have to make
- 14:35their own bread. That's what that's Okay, I'm sorry about interrupt That's the
- 14:41interesting part about the US. It's because you'd have different states responding to that
- 14:46stolen bread in different ways. Right. You'd have some who puts you okay,
- 14:50we're gonna put you on You're gonna have a court date, come back
- 14:52in three weeks. You never see them. Then you have another person who
- 14:56goes to jail for three weeks. Right, It's just kind of this weird.
- 15:01We have so much data to tell us which theory is working where and
- 15:05how it doesn't always work at Because I remember this one study that I used
- 15:09to like the highlight a lot of times. It was done in Dallas and
- 15:13it was a study measuring they had a lot of crime, a lot of
- 15:16violence with youth. Had to implement this curfew truancy law and put it into
- 15:22effect, and they did this for two months. It had a special group
- 15:26assigned to it, so they implementative. If children are teenagers were out of
- 15:31school at twelve o'clock hanging around, they brought them back to the parents,
- 15:35to the school wherever, or they detained them to three and then at the
- 15:37curfew law, I was a truancy long I'm sorry, the curfew law,
- 15:41if they were out of ten or nine o'clock, they sent them back home
- 15:43as well. Yeah, crime went down like forty or fifty percent, but
- 15:48that specific type of crime at least. And then they tried that over in
- 15:54La, so it wasn't generalizable because in La it didn't work. Which is
- 15:58kind of funny because you look at these theories and that's what that's what they
- 16:00are. You kind of alluded to this before the show. It's just a
- 16:03theory, it's not a fact. It's something that's trying to figure out how
- 16:07why this behavior is happening and can't we stop it in some capacity. So
- 16:11one of the things, you know, I'm trained as a criminologist, and
- 16:14I was instructor at the FBI Academy, and one of the things that we
- 16:17talked talked about in terms of crime prevention and criminology theories is that they're highly
- 16:22contextual. So it's it's not like you're creating it in a vacuum. So
- 16:29in a state like California, where you have perhaps a more liberal mindset and
- 16:34more more nuanced in a city like Berkeley, or in a city like Seattle
- 16:41where you have a very liberal population, then social justice theories might work better
- 16:48in terms of not just deterrence, but in punishment, where you have somebody
- 16:55stealing bread and you require them to take class is on, you know,
- 17:02I don't know, have them pick up garbage or some kind of remediation that
- 17:07that pays a remedy to the baker that lost the bread. Whereas in places
- 17:12like Alabama a little more strict, a little more conservative, or Georgia.
- 17:18You put them in jail for five days, you know, and and they
- 17:22sit in jail and they learn their lesson and as a deterrent, they're there
- 17:26for five days. Are not stealing bread? That's the compassion theory says that,
- 17:33Yeah, the terrance would be I get five days, were sitting there
- 17:36for stealing bread? I really wanted that? Or in New York they would
- 17:41just say, you know, here's ten loaves of bread. When New York
- 17:47they had that one guy, there was a one like she was a lady,
- 17:51she was shoplifting. You can look at this up folks, over one
- 17:53hundred and five times. Now. Yeah, she arrested for shoplifting and of
- 17:59course with a two years. Yeah, you know it's listen. Here's the
- 18:04other thing we need to start with this conversation, and we talk about,
- 18:07you know, crime prevention in criminology theories is it once once you are accused
- 18:12of a crime. And this is critically important and difference between the United States
- 18:17and North Korea, thank God, is that the system is defense centric.
- 18:22From the time you are accused of a crime, you are presumed innocent,
- 18:27until the time you are convicted of that crime. So when we talk about
- 18:32you know, these are these are theories about how to prevent crime or respond
- 18:36to crime. We have to keep in mind that you know, whether you
- 18:40stole a local bread in Seattle or New York or Alabama, that the accused
- 18:45is not guilty of the crime until they've either pled guilty or been proven to
- 18:51have committed the crime. And that's critically important in our system of governments,
- 18:56it really is. And I know there's a maxim if you could say it's
- 19:02a maxim, I can't show how you would frame it. But the only
- 19:04thing I've known, one of the things that does work well, and again
- 19:08well is the difficult how do you define well? It's going to have to
- 19:11be quantitatively? Is there a reduction in crime that existed? Is the concept
- 19:15of celerity, severity, and certainty. In other words, if somebody commits
- 19:21a crime, is a punishment certain is it going to be swift? And
- 19:26is it going to be severe? So you steal the bread? Am I
- 19:30going to get busted? For sure? And if I get busted, am
- 19:32I going to jail for sure? And am I going to go to jail
- 19:33for how long? And because if you don't have that, then you might
- 19:37end up with the one hundred and five shoplifting arrests because there's no certain teacher
- 19:42going to go anywhere. She wasn't going anywhere, she wasn't going to jail.
- 19:45It kept giving court dates that she never showed up for. And then
- 19:48the celerity. Yeah, I guess there was swift justice in the sense that
- 19:52she was arrested. That was the end of it. And severity there wasn't
- 19:56any There wasn't any severity. So there was a certain sources. And again,
- 20:00you know when we talk about restorative justice or you know, social justice
- 20:04in some states where they require the accused or the convicted at that point to
- 20:12repay their debt, whether it's time served or you know, some kind of
- 20:18social process. That's where I think the real debate comes in. If the
- 20:23person is incorrigible. Well, let's go back to the two year old for
- 20:27example. Because I raised four kids and they were four different personalities, and
- 20:33one of my children I won't out them on air, but one of my
- 20:38one of my children, all I had to do was put a rule in
- 20:42place. All right, I'll give you the gender. She was a rule
- 20:45follower, so I didn't have to worry. Once the rule was in place,
- 20:49she'll follow the rule. But like every family that has multiple children,
- 20:53you might find yourself with a rebel, a boundary pusher. So one of
- 20:59my children was a boundary pusher. And and so the process to make sure
- 21:06that that child knew that there were repercussions consequences to the choices that they made
- 21:11was to have a punishment that that was commensmate with crime. And and certain
- 21:21they knew if you did this, there was no second chance. I'm not
- 21:23there's no if ands or buts. You are going to your room time out.
- 21:27That's it. You're done right. Or you know your toy was was
- 21:32confiscated for a period of time, you would learn right. And the consistency
- 21:37of that is critically important. So if you have UH, you know,
- 21:41I don't care what state it is, be any state or any system of
- 21:45justice where there is a violation of law and UH, the process allows that
- 21:52individual no no kind of no, no no processes forget about you know,
- 21:59UH being the due process is stopped because they're given a court date, but
- 22:03there's no consequence for not showing up for the next court date. Then you
- 22:07have chaos in the court, in the system itself. Right, It's a
- 22:12maybe like, hey, let's play football. Here are the rules. You
- 22:15can't you know, uh, have pass interference. So then the next play
- 22:19there's pass inference and you tell the defender, hey, listen, you do
- 22:23that again, and we're going to call a penalty on you. And he
- 22:26does it again. You say, well, listen, seriously, now if
- 22:29you do that again, we're going to call a penalty on it. There's
- 22:32andy at some point realize, you know, I can get away with anything
- 22:34because I'm not going to be called on it. It's like parents, parents
- 22:37who threaten their children, don't do that again. But there was to do
- 22:40anything about it. Yeah, after a while, there's no punishment taking away
- 22:45something whatever it may be. That the punishment is if there is nothing there,
- 22:48the child just keeps doing it. And any way, we talk about
- 22:52deterrence theory, that's what we're talking about, you know, And it has
- 22:55to be it has to be consistent in terms of the punishments, so that
- 23:00you know, I was reading today on my phone. Is it Oklahoma is
- 23:04scheduled to have some kind of record number of executions? Did you see it?
- 23:11No? I haven't looked at that one yet. Uh okla, let
- 23:12me look it up real quick while you fill in. I'm going to find
- 23:15it for you. Well. The other thing too, I think for folks
- 23:18that understand is when you talk about criminals, you need to understand folks,
- 23:22there's different types of criminals and don't ever look at the media to try to
- 23:26describe a criminal for you. What I mean by that is if they say,
- 23:29oh, this person robbed two packs of gum at the liquor store.
- 23:33Now they're going to jail for two weeks, I promise you more than likely
- 23:38ninety five percent chance that if you read two or three paragraphs down, that
- 23:42person has probably committed a litany of crimes that have led to that sentencing.
- 23:48But though it doesn't catch the attention of anybody in the headline, but boy,
- 23:52you tell them he stole two packs of gum, he's going away for
- 23:53six months. That catches the headline. So they're not going to tell you
- 23:57the rest of the crime history. The other thing people don't realize you can
- 24:00back me up on this and if it's true or not when your experiences but
- 24:04a lot of times they can get charged with things, but when they go
- 24:08to the plea, deals with the das and all that, and those charges
- 24:12get dropped and they kept one charge. The other ones don't show up,
- 24:18and at least the media doesn't report it. Right, so you got ten
- 24:22charges, you got one did you get convicted on? And the other nine
- 24:26go away and the media says, oh, look, they've only had one
- 24:29crime that they've been convicted of. But yeah, yeah, yeah, but
- 24:33they were charged with about eight others. Right, But again, I will
- 24:37take I will play the devil's advocate if you will, I'll play the defense
- 24:41role. All that really counts are the convictions. I mean, you can
- 24:45be charged with anything, but behaviorally, well yeah, that's obviously true.
- 24:49But behaviorally you have to be careful because if they did commit multiple crimes and
- 24:52they only get in charge for one, right that It's also very true even
- 24:57at the lower levels of the court. Let's say you get you get stopped
- 25:00for speeding fifty five and a seventy five and your polite and I mentioned this
- 25:07in my classes, the law and the application of law are two different things.
- 25:11So you have the accused who maybe stop going, you know, doing
- 25:15seventy five and a fifty five mile hour zone. And the police officer says,
- 25:18you know, I've stopped you because you're doing seventy five miles an hour
- 25:22and it's only fifty five mile hours. Oone officer, I'm sorry, I
- 25:23have really bad um COVID and it's intestinal and but whatever whatever you excuse is,
- 25:30he says, you know what, I'm going to give you a lower
- 25:33or reduced ticket. So he might give you a ticket for having, you
- 25:42know, failure to obey traffic signs or whatever whatever it is. He gives
- 25:47you the ticket for inadequate muffler. That's when you see a lot or you
- 25:52go to the to the process, you go to the court date and you
- 25:55plead not guilty in your arraignment, and then you go to the a DA
- 25:57night and you talk to the ADA say listen, I was you know,
- 26:00I had bad COVID or whatever, and the ADA says, okay, you've
- 26:04got a clean record here tofore, so we're going to reduce the charge.
- 26:08So it's the reduce. My point is it's that it's what you're convicted of,
- 26:14not what you were accused of doing, that ultimately determines the crime rates
- 26:18that you see statistically. That's true, and keep in mind, a lot
- 26:22of those had been you know, reduced from you know, burglary one to
- 26:26trespassing or stuff like that. Right, would you still make my point it's
- 26:30really important to look at the plea deals and to see what happened there.
- 26:33Yes, I mean yeah, even though you're not convicted of certain crimes and
- 26:37you may not have been guilty of them anyway, even though they were charged
- 26:40with them, but some of them you may have been guilty. And that's
- 26:42why you have to kind of look at it. To my other point is
- 26:45there's different nationals too, right. It actually reminds me I grew up.
- 26:49You know, there were five of us, but four boys, and I
- 26:52remember my father, God loved them, probably had PTSD from Vietnam and Korea.
- 26:57But I remember several times where he would come home something would be broken.
- 27:00He wasn't sure who broke it, so he would line the four boys
- 27:04up, and he'd started knocking the crap out of all of us, right,
- 27:07and I'd be yelling down, I didn't do it. I didn't do
- 27:08it, he says. I don't care if you did this or not.
- 27:11I'm sure there's stuff that I didn't get you for in the past. He
- 27:15was he was making sure it was basically we were four stooges. But my
- 27:22point, my point is, you know he was getting he was punishing us
- 27:26regardless because the damn you know, peace furniture was broken. We were probably
- 27:32horse playing, somebody broke it, and by god, every one of us
- 27:36was going to be punished for it, right, and this sometimes that happens
- 27:38in justice where unfortunately, and we have the best system in the country in
- 27:44the world. We have the best system of justice in the world. And
- 27:47I'll include Louisiana, which is kind of backwards a little bit, but I'll
- 27:51include their system as well, right because based on the Nepollock was a Neopolitan
- 27:57court system, but any case, Neopolock, No, I'm mispronouncing. It
- 28:03isn't Napoleonic. No Poleonic, thank you in Europe. Yeah, yeah,
- 28:08But in any case, we have the best system of justice in the world,
- 28:11without doubt. But that doesn't mean that we're perfect, and it doesn't
- 28:17necessarily mean that it's pretty. So let me segue into what I just found.
- 28:19Oklahoma Ready's twenty five executions in the next two years. Critics and there's
- 28:25always critics are asking why the rush beginning Thursday, that would be today.
- 28:30Oklahoma is set to execute its first of more than two dozen death row inmates
- 28:36over the next twenty nine months. Wow, an average of one execution per
- 28:40month for the next two years. If carried out in full, the unprecedented
- 28:45number of twenty five executions will put to death fifty eight percent of Oklahoma state
- 28:49death row inmates. So you talk about deterrent, well, you know about
- 28:55sixty fifty eight percent, almost sixty percent of their death row inmates if this
- 29:00continues, will be be dead within the next twenty four month, twenty nine
- 29:06months. So that's in Oklahoma, right, we have the first one of
- 29:12those twenty twenty five. The first one is scheduled to be executed this evening.
- 29:21No, I'm sorry last night was scheduled to be executed last night.
- 29:26So let's see over the next two years. That includes John Hanson, Richard
- 29:32Fairchild, Richard Glossip, and James Coddington. Let's see what so And of
- 29:40course people are arguing and criticizing why the rush. Tracy Pearl, a professor
- 29:45of University Oklahoma College of Walk Parade, in an interview with Yahoo News,
- 29:49calling twenty five executions in two years, quote unquote horrifying. James Coddington was
- 29:56the first inmate to be executed. He died Thursday. More so that execution
- 30:00went forward, the Oklahoma governor did not give him a reprieve. He had
- 30:07been jailed since nineteen ninety seven for killing a friend who refused to loan him
- 30:11fifty dollars to buy cocaine. The Republican governor, Kevin Stitt, on Wednesday
- 30:18denied clemency, despite the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board recommending him for clemency earlier
- 30:23this month. Cottington repeatedly expressed remorse for the murder. His lawyer said he
- 30:30had worked to turn his life around for the better behind bars, all to
- 30:33no avail, Which begs the second question about deterrence. If you put somebody
- 30:41in jail for the rest of their life without parole, have you not deterred
- 30:45them from committeing further crime? If you don't put him joy you do put
- 30:51him no. If you do now, so you capacitate them from doing any
- 30:55further crime, and you deter everybody else from doing it. Hopefully. It's
- 31:00interesting because when you talk about they're not going to get into the death penalty
- 31:03issues here, but This again depends on the type of criminal you're talking about
- 31:07a lot for a lot of these different theories and how they apply. Some
- 31:11of the ones with rehabilitation work really well. Somebody has substance use issues,
- 31:15doesn't have a long history of crime, and that can help them. Others
- 31:18individuals who have a huge history of crime repetitive, maybe they're in their forties
- 31:22and to continue to do crime, that might be more challenging to try to
- 31:26get them. Studies have shown that. But even with the death penalty,
- 31:30if you have somebody who has a psychotic break, they don't give a rats
- 31:33for you, but that's the death penalty because they're not in that mindset.
- 31:38They're just going to do whatever they're going to do. And we see that
- 31:41a lot of times. Anyway. It may be true certain gang members or
- 31:45certain things like that nature say hey, we don't want to get involved in
- 31:48this because this state's going to put us away for like fifty years, or
- 31:51they're gonna shoot us and kill them. They're going to kill us. Then
- 31:52the problem is you know better than I with your background, that it's not
- 31:56those that have a psychotic break up. A person who has a psych cottic
- 32:00break like Hinckley isn't going to go to the electric chair because they're going to
- 32:05be deemed insane at the time of the crime and and be put, you
- 32:12know, given medical attention. What we're talking really about are these sociopaths,
- 32:16these these maladaptive personalities that you're right, these are just bad actors that they
- 32:23they were developed wrong, somehow, they went off course, and they don't
- 32:29believe in following rules. They don't believe in the laws. You know,
- 32:31if God told them don't eat the fruit from the tree of knowledge, they
- 32:35would take a chainsaw to that tree, you know. And psychopath Yeah,
- 32:39so that's what really you know, our our jails. I forget the statistic,
- 32:44but it's it's like eighty percent thereabouts in that percentile, eighty percent of
- 32:49anti social personalities, who are in twenty percent of psychopaths. Yeah, yeah,
- 32:52and they So that's the largest group of population in our jails and our
- 32:58prisons, in our federal penitentiaries. And you're dealing with people who are constantly
- 33:04challenging. They're the two year olds constantly challenging the boundaries, not out of
- 33:08curiosity in a positive sense, but purely out of a negative intent. You
- 33:14know, an evil that it just simply doesn't apply to them, and consequently
- 33:16they can only live in a in an environment that is highly structured. I'll
- 33:23give you an example. I was in Florence, Colorado at the eighty you
- 33:27know, the Max eighty X. It's built into the side of a mountain.
- 33:31It's where our worst of the worst are kept at the federal level.
- 33:36Simithy McVay was there. Ted Kazinski was there. The prisoners there are housed
- 33:43in a tiny little cell. It has about a four by twelve inch slit.
- 33:49I won't even call it a window, but it's this glass little rectangle
- 33:52that they can kind of see the mountains, like solitary confinement. Then it
- 34:00is twenty three hours these and yes they're in the boot. They're there twenty
- 34:06three hours. In their cell, there's a sally port system where there's two
- 34:10bars, you know, so that the jailer can pass through the food or
- 34:16if they get a haircut, they can come into this little sally port area
- 34:20without direct contact with the inmate and they cant get their haircut. They have
- 34:24a little I think it was like a five inch maybe seven inch black and
- 34:28white TV screen that they have a you know, a toilet that doesn't have
- 34:31a lid on it, an open toilet, a concrete bed with about a
- 34:36four inch mattress in this tiny little cell that's about i don't know, probably
- 34:40five feet wide by ten twelve feet long. And these worst of the worst
- 34:46criminals stay in this cell for twenty three hours. They are given one hour
- 34:52of outdoor time in a concrete area courtyard. The walls aren't a fifteen twenty
- 35:00feet tall up to the sky. They can see whatever God gives them over
- 35:04the head. They don't see the skyline. They don't see the mountains in
- 35:07Colorado, in Florence. They simply see whatever's above them in the sky.
- 35:13And that's their existence. And if you if you're Timothy well he was put
- 35:16to death McVeigh. But if you're Ted Kaczinski, even if you're you know,
- 35:21fifty years old, forty late forties, early fifties, when you're arrested
- 35:24and put in that environment, you could live for thirty years like that in
- 35:30hell, because you've shown you've proven to society you cannot obey the laws,
- 35:36the rules that govern us. That's the consequence. And there's there's listen,
- 35:42there's crime in jails. You know that, you know, the criminals commit
- 35:45crimes in jail, contraband, you know, it never stops in there.
- 35:50Yeah. Of course, people sometimes think they don't do drugs on there,
- 35:52they got clean in there. That's not the case at all. They make
- 35:58their own liquor there. Oh, there's so much. Every time I talk
- 36:00to a CEO, it's it's amazing how much you hear about the drugs,
- 36:04at the amount of drugs you can get in there. You can get more
- 36:06drugs in there sometimes in certain prisons than you can in the streets. Because
- 36:08they make weapons, they sell brug they sell other contraband too, I mean,
- 36:13they sell cigarettes, they sell they sell sex, I mean they sell
- 36:17you know, it's a it's a it's a whole society hits outside, but
- 36:22it's not like the society we live in outside the wall. It is a
- 36:25highly structured, strict environment, highly controlled. So the level of crime that
- 36:34you see in a prison is much smaller, much lower than you would see
- 36:38outside the prison. And you've got to figure that they're all criminals, they're
- 36:42all bad guys in the prison, they wouldn't be there, right, So
- 36:45it goes back to what you were talking about. We started our conversation with
- 36:49which is how do you measure the effectiveness of these theories? And I look
- 36:55at it, and we talked about this, that these theories really are part
- 37:00of the construct of a strategy. And in my class we talk about,
- 37:05you know, the Strategic Tactical and Operational Approach STO model, and every strategy
- 37:12that we looked at has one goal in mind, and that's to win.
- 37:16Tell me or show me an example of any strategic plan that the goal is
- 37:22to lose, and I'll point you right to a moron, right, because
- 37:28nobody, nobody creates a strategy to lose. Everybody's strategy is to win.
- 37:32So if that's the first point you're building a strategy to win, you have
- 37:37to define, well, what is winning in terms of crime reduction? Is
- 37:42it ten percent reduction crime, twenty percent, fifty seventy five, one hundred
- 37:47percent? And if we agree that one hundred percent is not rational, it's
- 37:52not obtainable. But if you strive for perfection and all you get to is
- 37:59excellence, that's pretty damn good. Better than good, it's excellent. So
- 38:06I think the goal should be in your strategy to eliminate all crime. But
- 38:10your your practical accomplishments should settle on what you define as excellent. What is
- 38:17that eighty percent reduction? A reduction I think is a positive step a reduction.
- 38:24And so when you look at these four that we talked about, and
- 38:28I think you want to repeat those four again. Sure, it's incapacitation where
- 38:31the person's obviously in prison, in jail so they can't commit crimes, to
- 38:35terrence where the punishment is severe enough if the person doesn't want to commit a
- 38:38crime because it doesn't worth the hass of the cost benefit of analysis, which
- 38:42is right up your alley and one of your main theories Andy, routine activity
- 38:47theory and your rational thinking theory of choice theory. Yeah. And then rehabilitation
- 38:52of course, which is you know, given rehabilitation, so it could be
- 38:57substance abuse, anger management, whatever the pending on the crime. Just so
- 39:00many variations of criminals, and they're all different. Rapists are going to have
- 39:04different motivations compared to somebody who's a killer, to a thief, a burglar,
- 39:08home invader. Everybody got different motivations and different types of crimes. And
- 39:12then the fourth one is restorative. Restorative is interesting because that's the one where
- 39:16you usually are confronting the victim and anybody else who's been affected by the crime
- 39:22that you've committed. And the funny thing about that one, it has had
- 39:25some impact, but not very much. And one of the interesting twists.
- 39:29I don't know if you know this, you might probably do. But the
- 39:31interesting twist is when in psychopaths were put in there, or people with anti
- 39:35social personality sort of, they actually enjoyed listening to the victims they're suffering.
- 39:40So then they backfired and they said, Okay, well that won't work over
- 39:43here. We have to pull that population out of there. But as we
- 39:45mentioned earlier, if there's a twenty percent of that population being a psychopath and
- 39:50eighty percent being anti social, doesn't leave you a whole lot of room for
- 39:54that particular theory. Doesn't the restorative justice theory also include the convicted providing some
- 40:06positive remedy to the victims. It can, Yeah, sometimes it's either working
- 40:10off something again, it depends on the degree of the crime, depends on
- 40:14the type of criminal you have. The idea is to make the victim whole
- 40:17again. I think you know there's you know, particularly in the northwestern part
- 40:21of the United States, the American Indian system of justice is to create some
- 40:27form of remedy that benefits the victim for a wrong. I think there's and
- 40:35I'm probably wrong on this, but I even think that's true in the Islamic
- 40:38system of justice as well, where there's some restorative elements to their to their
- 40:47system. I like to see what I don't know what Islamic countries. There's
- 40:52a com few that still follow the rule of cutting off the hand for robbery.
- 40:55Oh yeah, well, yeah, sure, I rackeded I erected that
- 40:59sort of Arabia does that. I don't think that an Asian still does or
- 41:01doesn't. It'll be interesting to see what their robbery rate is. I think
- 41:08it goes way down from the hand that was cut off. Yes, they
- 41:16tend to steal less from that hand. Yeah, you know, there's Those
- 41:21four theories are important. They and I think they go hand in hand with
- 41:24a couple of theories that you alluded to, which is, you know,
- 41:28I'm a big rational choice theorist. I believe humans make choices and life is
- 41:32a series of choices. Each one's a consequence from the time Adam and Eve
- 41:37made their choice to the time this morning when I you know, don't really
- 41:40need a chocolate croissant, but I made the choice to eat it anyway because
- 41:45I knew it was going to taste good. Humans will make choices, some
- 41:49rational, some irrational. That's why I call it the reason choice theory instead
- 41:52of the rational choice theory. But the thing is what we make these choices.
- 41:57They're not always consciously made, you know, sometimes they're not even based
- 42:01on all the information that we have. Bounded rationality or the bounded rationality theory
- 42:07says we only make choices based on the information we have at the time we
- 42:12make the choice, and so we regret some of the choices we make,
- 42:15from getting married to somebody that you end up getting divorced from, to buying
- 42:20a car that you wish you hadn't done, to stealing a loaf of bread
- 42:24because you're hungry and you realize maybe you should have asked for the bread instead
- 42:29of steal it, right, So that's important. And then the other part
- 42:31that's all in all four of these theories that we've talked about is routine activities
- 42:37theory, which is, you know, the bad guy realizes it's a cost
- 42:42benefit I can get away with this and not possibly get caught, there's a
- 42:45higher chance that that individual is going to conduct that criminal behavior. So in
- 42:51response to that proactively the end of the classic of criminology triad, you can
- 42:58put enough. You could put a handler over the offender, So somebody who
- 43:04has influence over a potential offender. If that person says, hey, you
- 43:07better not steal that loaf of bread, that could have a positive impact.
- 43:10Another is a manager over place. If you put CCTV cameras in a grocery
- 43:16store and put signage that says shoplifters will be prosecuted, perhaps that person thinks
- 43:22twice before that becomes a deterrent itself in terms of stealing that loaf of bread.
- 43:27And then, last, but not least, is the guardian over victim.
- 43:30So if you put a security guard in a bank, or put them
- 43:34in the grocery store next to the bread aisle, you might be able to
- 43:37reduce the amount of pilfridge and shoplifting that goes on. So I think it's
- 43:44important to remember those two pieces as we talk about these four contextually important theories
- 43:52in trying to reduce crime. I think we're both in agreement pretty much at
- 43:57the end of the day, and I guess we made the point that I
- 43:59was hoping we'd make, which was, it's not so simple, folks.
- 44:02It really isn't so when you see debates between politicians or media whatnot, it's
- 44:07just really there isn't the panasy. It's not a one but it's one out
- 44:10one pill. It's multifactorial, is going to be a lot of factors involved,
- 44:15and really you need to define it. So the next time, I
- 44:17ask, if you ever look at something in the newspaper about a certain theory,
- 44:22a certain da what kind of metrics are you looking for? You're looking
- 44:25for a reduction in crime we know in New York. Is fascinating to me
- 44:30because I remember in nineteen ninety, ninety one and eighty nine they had a
- 44:32what twenty seven hundred and three thousand homicides a year. Then it tanked and
- 44:38it's been low in the three to four hundreds for years, and then it
- 44:43was shooting up. Now I think they're aiming for six or seven hundred this
- 44:45year. It's going back up, and it's fascinating because it wasn't necessarily some
- 44:50attributed to the broken windows theory. But if you look at the chart,
- 44:52you'll see a declining before the broken windows theory went down. So was it
- 44:57we also know the eighty twenty Rowe Great Peretoes prints eighty twenty. We know
- 45:00it's about ten ninety I think in this in this realm, where ten percent
- 45:05of the criminals for me like ninety percent of the crime. So was it
- 45:07that they busted and incapacitated all these individuals that big, big swath of that
- 45:14ten percent, So you wiped out seventy percent, right, That's what my
- 45:16theory is in my head thinking. I don't know, but it definitely took
- 45:22a nose dive and it stayed very low for a very long period of time.
- 45:27But now I think I think that you know, you bring up some
- 45:30excellent points and certainly worth debate, but I think ultimately we have to be
- 45:34careful whether we are you know, uh, you know, consider ourselves more
- 45:37liberal in our mindset or more conservative in our mindset, to stay outside the
- 45:42box and to uh at least tolerate and entertain that there are elements of effectiveness
- 45:50contextually speaking from both sides, and you're striking that balance so that we live
- 45:54in a society that allows us to have our freedoms but also provide some form
- 46:00of security. I think, by the way, and I think this would
- 46:04be a good research project in the Latin American countries. So it's not just
- 46:09laws, it's also religion and politics. So in Latin American countries where Catholicism
- 46:14is predominantly the faith, and because of Catholicism, there against capital punishment,
- 46:20right, it's life in prison. In many South American Central American countries,
- 46:25there's a higher incidence of violence against police officers because the hulums, the bad
- 46:31guys know they're not going to be put to death if they go after a
- 46:35cop, and so you have a high level of disrespect and disregard for law
- 46:40enforcement officials in Central and South America. In the United States, you shoot
- 46:45a cop, it used to be you shoot a cop, you're in big
- 46:47damn trouble. If you even make it to court, right, they come
- 46:51at you. But that's kind of that's changed a lot because of attitudes towards
- 46:57authority and police officers specifically. So I think that you know, it's more
- 47:05than what's on the books in terms of laws. It's also culturally how society
- 47:08interprets the culture and the rules of engagement that determine whether or not you have
- 47:16increases or decreases. You talked about it in a macro sense, and I
- 47:20think you're right on point that the spike on murders in New York may have
- 47:29something to do with a lot of different things going on in the state.
- 47:31That's what it always is, always things. There's a lot more than we
- 47:34think it is. I know. Yeah, much more nuanced exactly. People
- 47:39like the little simple sound bites, but it does the work. You have
- 47:42a very false representation of a world that doesn't really exist. It's much more
- 47:46complicated. I know, folks, maybe you're frustrated. Do we didn't give
- 47:50you the answers you were looking for, But that's where it works. And
- 47:52if I can add one more thing, Andy, it's just if you can
- 47:55separate political ideologies folks from this kind of talk and really focus on thinking about
- 48:01as a scientific researcher looking at the data. Don't look at it through a
- 48:07Democrat report. That doesn't matter where it really looks at because some of these
- 48:09theories will work in certain contexts, as Andy mentioned, and it really is
- 48:13about understanding the theories and how they're being applied and looking at it as a
- 48:17scientific researcher. Yeah, you do that, just outside the box. Think
- 48:22critically and be as interested in the question as pursuing the particular absolute answer.
- 48:30You know. I think that's the critical piece is think of the question is
- 48:32as important and a objective as the answer itself. Great point. I think
- 48:39we'll wrap it up on there, folks. You know what to do.
- 48:42Share a subscribe hit that I like. But well, Andy, I think
- 48:45that wraps us up. I enjoyed this one. It's outside what we normally
- 48:47talked about. It was more theoretical, but it's always a pleasure speaking with
- 48:52you. Likewise, my friend, folks, have a good one. Start
- 48:57cracking on those books and start looking at these theories. Have a good week. I