Latest / Systems and Power / Is College Still Worth It? The Truth About Higher Education | Jay Hershenson | Systems & Power #2
Transcript
- Moses: Hello everyone, welcome back to the Systems and Power Podcast. Today we have our very special guest. He was the former Vice Chancellor of CUNY for over thirty-two years and currently serves as the as the special advisor to the president of Queens College. Jay Hershinson, thank you for coming. Good to be here. I remember back when I first joined the student government and they I first heard the name Jay Jay Hershinson. They they they verbatim said. If you want to move mountains, Jay Hershinson is your man. Well, that's very kind. frankly, whatever mountains I've been able to move, I've always done it as part of a team. Hmm. Speaking of, I guess, you being so involved in in CUNY l CUNY life, you were also the the founder of USS and NYPERG. How do you looking back on when you first started those organizations and how they've been able to impact students here now to present day. How do you look back on it? I I very much appreciate the fact that I had the opportunity to again, with teamwork, be involved in the founding of the University Student Senate of CUNY, the New York Public Interest Research Group, NYPERG, and then later on when I became a vice chancellor, because I had been involved in those two first examples as a student leader. but the third example I was involved with as a vice chancellor and that is Citizenship Now, which is a program that has helped hundreds of thousands of immigrants. In the case of USS, there's no question that the opportunity to be involved in a student advocacy organization that spent a lot of time working on the rights and freedoms and responsibilities of students was an honor. It was a great privilege. I found out early on that there was no representation for the chair of USS to be on the Board of Trustees of CUNY and I tried very hard through the political process to reach representatives of the mayor. At that time it was Mayor Abraham Bean in order to try to get student representation on the board itself. And that was promised to myself and an ad hoc committee. That had been established of student leaders who were seeking student representation on the board. And I'll never forget that when the members of the board were selected, no student was appointed. And that was the moment in time when I realized that in order to gain student representation on the CUNY Board of Trustees, I needed to get the law changed. I needed to get some help from Albany, and that's when I Traveled 160 miles and made a coalition with the students of the State University of New York. A man named Ray Glass was the legislative director of the Student Association of the State University. And he and I were able to obtain legislation in both houses, in the Assembly and in the Senate, and begin the long journey to getting student representation on the board itself. And at the end of the day, We got it for every single public higher education governing board in the state of New York, which still exists as of today. Wow, that is a great story, especially when you're emphasizing coalition and building and how that's important in getting anything done in in today's even today's modern political climate nowadays. Now in the case of NYPERG was very different. The student association president, Mark Litwack, and I, we went to a national student association conference. This was in the Early nineteen seventies, and we met representatives of the Oregon Perg public interest research group and the Texas Perg public interest research group. They did a workshop and we listened to what they had to say. And Mark and I looked at each other and we said, Hmm, this sounds really interesting. Maybe this is something that would work for Queen's College and in general in New York State. But Mark and I, like many of the Student governments that you've been a part of over the years. Always start off skeptically. We have to get more information. And so we went to visit the New Jersey PERG, and we went to visit the Washington, D.C. PERG, which was at George Washington University. We checked it out ourselves, and we came to the conclusion that this was a model, this public interest research group model, which was detailed in a book called Action for a Change by Ralph Nader and Donald Ross. We could possibly do an organizing effort here in New York. And we went to Washington, we met with Donald Ross, who was the author of the original plan, and he said to us, New York is too big. There's no way you're going to be able to bring together upstate, downstate, the suburbs. New York is too big. Well, one of the things we've learned over the years is that when you challenge a person from Queen's College that something cannot be done. The opposite takes place. And so we took up the challenge, and I then wrote, I would say, two or three big articles for the student newspaper about creating a public interest research group. And lo and behold, what do you think happened? The Young Americans for Freedom, which was a very right wing conservative group, had a club on campus. And the leadership of that yeah, yeah, very right wing. They went ahead and they wrote an article saying that Herschenson and Nyperg are bad for Queen's College. god. And they presented all kinds of evidence, you know, saying that there was some report, you know, that showed that the Perg in Argonne, you know, had done all kinds of wrong things, and that there was examples after example. Of bad things about PERG. So of course I looked at the article and I said, What am I getting myself into? And I got in touch with Donald Ross, you know, who wrote the book. And Donald Ross showed me a manifesto that was produced by the Young Americans for Freedom. And I looked at the manifesto, and the same words that were in the manifesto were the same words that were in the student newspaper article. So the author had plagiarized this manifesto and presented it as evidence. And then it turned out that the criticism of Perg was from a utility and gas company that was angry because the public interest research group opposed rate increases on gas prices and on energy prices. And so I went ahead and I then wrote two big articles blowing apart the criticisms. which were of course stolen from the manifesto. And then I printed the rules of plagiarism. Ooh, that plagiarism is a crime in academic terms. And I showed the various violations, you know, side by side. Well, this four or five weeks of article after article generated a lot of interest on campus. And we pulled a whole team together, again teamwork being very critical. And collected fifteen thousand signatures in support of PERG. And I would say almost six thousand people voted in favor, you know, of having PERG established on campus and being part of a statewide organization. And together with students from other colleges, we got together. Dave Fields, he served as the parliamentarian to create the bylaws for for PERG. I chaired the search committee that hired the executive director, and lo and behold, PERG was created. And now PERG has been around since 1973 and has a fabulous record of accomplishments. Accomplishments in all kinds of civic and public interest issues that have been very helpful to consumers, protecting the environment, fighting for tenants' rights, government reform. I'm very proud of of NYPERG. And I'm very proud of USS, the University Student Senate, which recently achieved some additional support from the city to help students with free subway fares. They've gotten their foot in the door on that. So these are examples that I'm proud of and I do hope we'll talk about citizenship now at some point and the work that we've been able to do on immigrant rights. Hm, if you could go a little bit more into what citizenship now does, because me as a a a CUNY student and as someone who was involved in the student association, I was a lot more involved with the career development aspects of those things and I worked a lot with people from USS and some some of the NYPERG folks. But I personally I am not too familiar with citizens citizens now. And for anybody who is watching who is not as familiar as familiar with it, could you like Give an explanation of more of what it is, if you don't mind me asking. So for many years I've been active on voter registration. If you come to my office, you'll see right behind me is a giant photograph of Meg Urevers, the man who died registering black voters in Mississippi. And when I was a student leader, when I was an administrator at the central office, I got very involved in Voter registration drives, voter registration systems, voter registration campaigns, on a nonpartisan basis. And when we did these campaigns, I noticed that there were places in the CUNY system where we would try to register students to vote, but if they were not citizens, they were not able to register. And so it was a very discouraging situation. And many of the students who couldn't register to vote. They would get help from the international student advisors, but on most of the campuses there were never enough international student advisors to service the population. So I got together with Professor Alan Wernick, who was a professor at Hostos Community College. Later on I helped them transfer to Baruch College. He's one of the foremost immigration attorneys in the country. And Alan and I got together. He wrote a column for the Daily News about immigration issues. And I said to Alan, we have to find some ways to ramp up the idea of helping more students with respect to citizenship opportunities, naturalization opportunities, immigration concerns, not representing people in court, but helping them with counseling and putting them in touch with very low-cost, if not free, ways to get help. So we set about to do that. We look to create a Citizenship Now program for students. That was our intent. Well, lo and behold, when we did that, the students went home and they told their family members about this program. And we started to get inquiries from mothers and fathers and uncles and aunts and friends. Can you help us? Well, at that point, we realized that we needed to do something bigger. And I was very, very fortunate because a woman named Rita Di Martino, who was a trustee, she was on a plane flight to Washington and she met the deputy publisher of the Daily News, told him about me, and he and I ended up having lunch at Shun Li, a r a Chinese restaurant in Manhattan. And I said to him, Why don't we do a call in? Why don't we create a program where any New Yorker Who has a citizenship issue or an immigration issue could call up and for one week get free assistance over the phone, and of course some of them would have to make appointments and bring in papers as a follow-up and know that we're here to help them. And he said to me, That's way too big an idea for me. Would you be willing to meet with the editor? So, two weeks later, I'm back at Shun Lee and I'm with the editor. of the New York Daily News and who by the way had done some call ins in Europe so he knew how to do it physically. And we agreed that we would do a CUNY Daily News free citizenship call in called citizenship now. And we shook on it. You know, when you s when you said to me earlier in in our friendship that a person's word is their bond, we shook hands. that we were gonna get this done. So I knew it was gonna happen. So lo and behold, we put it together. We got the telephone company to donate free, you know, telephone systems to us. We got a few sponsors, and then we made the terrible mistake of putting the phone number in the Sunday before the Monday we were gonna get it started. So the phones blew out, right? 'Cause people immediately took advantage of the opportunity, you know, to call up Sunday. And of course we didn't start 'till Monday morning.' But we fixed the system. And we began to get thousands of calls. Now we had lined up attorneys from all over the city, labor organizations, churches, synagogues, mosques, you know, the That's one big coalition. It was a big coalition and we had this all set up and that is what launched Citizenship Now. and and it was the beginning of a major, major outreach to help immigrants in New York City. To this day, to this day There is no program anywhere at any university in the entire United States that has helped more immigrants than CUNY's Citizenship Now program. there's been lots of events that have occurred with elected officials. The city council has been magnificent. And when I returned to Queen's College after 32 years serving as a vice-chancellor and senior vice chancellor at the CUNY Central Office and Secretary of the Board, one of the first things I did was to work with now chancellor felix matos rodriguez to put a citizenship now office here at queens college so when you enter the student union building there is a citizenship now office and it's available to students here at Queens in CUNY and to the community. Nice. That was the vision. It was a vision of helping immigrants and today given everything that's been happening in our society with respect to how immigrants are being treated, having citizenship now is an extra blessing. I really like the that story, especially when you talk about how big of a coalition you put together to make this happen, and that even still to this day, coalitions do matter in making sure you work with people all all across. One and speaking of your egg experience as the CUNY Vice Chancellor for Over thirty years you have seen administrations come and go, new old ones come, new ones come in from all different types of mayors from Koch, Giuliani, Bloomberg, Deblasio. How was your experience like working with different administrations wh at the same time fighting for the rights of CUNY students and for the CUNY CUNY organization and de make and dealing with them? It was always an experience working with a new mayor. The the mayor gets five mayoral appointees to the CUNY board. The governor gets ten, and then of course the student that we had helped with the changing of the law, and then there's a faculty member who serves without a vote. So the mayor has input with respect to the governance of CUNY. And so yes, I I've I've had the opportunity to to work with many mayors and in many cases deputy mayors and commissioners over a long period of time. they're all different. They all have different priorities. They all have different styles. There's no question about that. And the mayors work of course with the city council. Yes. So they have a shared budget responsibility too, among other areas of authority that overlap and in some cases come into conflict. So My my memories back about mayors are really about city government in general, working with mayors and members of the city council. I will say that when when Mayor Dinkins became mayor, for example, we were able to get the CUNY Cadet Corps established, which was a great victory and a terrific opportunity for CUNY students to work in police precincts and get either stipends or their tuition paid for. And to get the opportunity to develop law enforcement careers. It was a terrific program. when Mayor Giuliani came in, he killed the program, eliminated it. And it's my hope that someday, someday the idea of a CUNY cadet program, you know, can be resurrected in some form. I think there should be cadet programs in general, whether it's in the NYPD or or the fire department or some of the other agencies, there should be more opportunities. that's something that might be considered in the future. The whole idea of internships, and that's where Queen's College is so important because a lot of time and effort is spent at Queen's College helping students to gain access to internships. And in reality cadet programs are sort of like that. So I've had good experiences and bad experiences with mayors when it comes to those kinds of things. most recently, of course, I had a great experience with Mayor Adams, who approved what's called CIG status, cultural institution group status for the Louis Armstrong House Museum, which I have the privilege of chairing the board. And that was a status that I had lobbied for for many, many, many, many years. And the mayor this past November, he approved CIG status, which provides a line in the city budget for the Louis Armstrong House Museum and helps give the museum access to a lot of support. And of course the Louis Armstrong House Museum is affiliated very closely with Queen's College. And I want to note that Mayor Mandami on February first visited the Louis Armstrong House Museum. So there's a lot of interest there on the part of the two most recent mayors to understand the importance of the Louis Armstrong House Museum. So that makes my heart sing. Speaking of the Louis Armstrong House Museum, I know you worked extremely hard to make sure you guys got funding funding for that. And recently in a new article, you it's it said it said that you got twenty six million dollars in in funding for it, but it took about ten years to get that done. Could you elaborate more on I guess the whole process of making sure that you worked through literally that for a decade? That is a very long time. How much did like I guess like tenacity and the will to make sure that get that done played into a factor throughout the whole process? I'm a kid from Jackson Heights, Queens. I was born in the Bronx and I was raised in Jackson Heights. Wow. And my mother was a community activist and she loved Louis Armstrong. And she did a petition drive in the district to get a local middle school named after Louis Armstrong. And to this day There was a Louis Armstrong middle school. Again, she did it as part of working with a lot of other people in the community to get that done. And she succeeded, and others succeeded too. So Louis Armstrong was always someone who was in our lives both in terms of his music and in terms of my mother's advocacy. And we grew up in Jackson Heights about a mile and a half from Louis Armstrong's house. So when I became a vice chancellor. at CUNY, the president of Queen's College called me up and he said, Jay, we have the Louis Armstrong House Museum in Corona, but we need a facility to be able to offer concerts and lectures and exhibitions and to host the archives of Louis Armstrong. But there's no space because the Louis Armstrong House Museum is the house that Louis Armstrong lived in. We have to preserve that. Can you help us? I said, Well, what do want me to do? And the first thing he did was tell me that he was having some difficulty getting an appointment with a local congressperson, who I happened to do some work for earlier on. So I said, I'll take care of that. So we went to see the congressperson and he said I could put in some support, but you're really gonna need state funding, you know, for in order to get things off the ground, in order to get the land and put in an appropriation Be able to build some type of facility that could do the kinds of things you're talking about exhibition space, concert space, archives, room for lectures. And so I went to the Chancellor. He gave me what I call a hunting license, which allowed me to then put a coalition together. And I give a lot of credit to former Assemblymember Jeff Aubrey. He was very helpful. at that time the Senate was run by the Democrat the the Assembly was run by the Democrats, the Senate was run by the Republicans. So I had to get support for both sides of the aisle, which I was able to successfully do with my team. And when the dust cleared, we got the first ten million from the state. And then we went after funding from the city, which was another ten million. We got some private money. We got support from the borough president, Helen Marshall at the time, the city council. Everything came together and we pulled out twenty six million That was the total amount that was necessary to do all the pieces. After we got that done, and yes, you're right, it took it took easily ten years. Some some people would say it took twenty years, because there were people in the community that wanted an Armstrong center across the street from the house, but they hadn't yet been able to obtain it. And what I'm about to say is a lesson that I often teach to student leaders. It's called once you get a yes. on a particular project like the one I'm describing, or anything that's important, then you have to get another yes. And another yes. And another yes. That it kind of dominoes its way. That's right. Because you have to get zoning approvals, you gotta get the community board, you have to get building permits, you have to get certificates of occupancy. You have to then go through the whole bureaucratic process. You have to get insurance done There are so many levels that you have to be willing to push for. And along the way, you will meet other adversaries. And sometimes the other adversaries, it's not that they are opposed to your project, but they have other projects that they would rather see funded. So sometimes things get held up because other priorities exist. So yes, it did require staying with it for A long, long time. It definitely took depending upon how you want to count it, it took certainly over a decade, but some would argue it took close to two decades. But at the end of the line, we got it. And just at that point in time, now that I think back, I returned to Queen's College to serve as Vice President for Communications and Marketing and Senior Advisor to the President. And when I returned, the president of Queen's College was Felix Matos Rodriguez, who was now the Chancellor of CUNY. And he said to me, Jay, you were so active getting the support for the twenty six million. Could you join the Board of Trustees of the Louis Armstrong House Museum? And I said yes. So when I went to join the board, the leadership of the board said to me, Well, can you help us get cultural institution group status? Now that took me about eight or nine years. And as I said earlier in your podcast, Moses, the the mayor, Eric Adams, d delivered on that back in last November. That took eight years. I had a good shot getting it from Mayor de Blasio to your question of, you know, how did you work with mayors? And he tried to get me to agree to a lesser amount of support. And I talked to our board and we decided to take a pass on that because we believe that the Louis Armstrong House Museum merits the same designation as the Metropolitan Museum of Art or Carnegie Hall or any of the major New York City cultural institutions. Because Louis Armstrong was the greatest jazz museum in the history of the world. And to have a museum in his honor was something that would be very special for New York City and deserves support. So there's no question that along the way I learned a few things. One is that the three elements of success Three most important elements are persistence, persistence, and persistence. I also learned that it's useful to remember what Confucius said, which is that if you sit by the river long enough, the body of your adversary will float by. So you do have to be willing to appreciate what the philosophers have said in the past. And then most importantly, most importantly, Jalen Brunson. Who without question is the greatest philosopher of our time. Because what Jalen Brunson reminds us is that, besides the fact that failure is not an option, but he does point out that don't worry about failure, because if you are prepared and you do everything you can to prepare, then if you do fail, you know that you have prepared to succeed. And then you get off the floor. and you simply try again. Which is why my philosophy, which I teach my kids, which I did not learn from the great Jalen Brunson, but I've taught my kids this for a long time, is that Fear Fear is a choice. A better choice is preparation. And that's been the lesson, the combination of persistence and preparation, and then victory. I might have to seal that from you. Why not? Fear is a choice, but preparation's the better one. Yes. I know you you made a poem and I know you sent it to me. Is it okay if I if I can read it out loud? Just bear with me for a second. Let me just go. It'll be an honor to to have you read it. Yes, I would love to share it with the with the people who are are are gonna be tuning into this. It's called Winning with Winton by yours truly, Jay Herschinson. Can you explain the context to it? of course. It was I would like to read it out out loud first if that's if that's fine. Of course. Okay. Okay. Winning with Winton by Jay Herschinson. What can one say about Winton Learson? Marcellus that has not already been said. It's a challenge indeed. But let's not get too far ahead. So we start your name w with your name, the proud f family of Marcellus, a constellation of musical stars shining more brightly than the Aurora Aurora Boralis. Now some say your brilliance is derived from family genes, but others credit that you grew up in New Orleans. A poem like this will have to be overt. So some will say it started with a trumpet your father gave to you from Al Hurt. Now it now it is a challenge to come up with a rhyme for Winton. That's so easy for a man. So often celebrated by President Bill Clinton. And Learson is simply a distinguished middle name. It fits perfectly with your well-earned fame. Nine Grammys, a Pulitzer, National Arts medals, recognition, and R resolutions filled with lengthy whereas you've defined music in so many ways and given the world the very best of jazz. Toward in million toward in seventy countries and nearly eight hundred fifty cities we can count millions of record albums that continue to mount. And tonight we celebrate your connectivity to pops because you always made sure Pops is tops. And we honor you tonight. His spirit is filling the room. His music is with us. His flowers will bloom. Winton, yours is a grand legacy to Lewis you proudly share. I can hear him right now saying two words yeah. I will I will admit I don't know the entire context behind all this as I did not grow up listening to jazz unfortunately. So I was hoping if if you could explain the thoughts of what was going through when you wrote this poem, if you don't mind me asking. What was in my mind was the fact that Wynton Marsalis, who many would say is the current world's greatest jazz musician, and certainly the awards that I made reference to in the poem Just one example of that. He agreed to permit us to honor him. Winton Marsalis was the founder of Jazz at Lincoln Center among many of his amazing accomplishments. And so he just announced his retirement over the last several months. So he was available as never before because he had announced his retirement to be recognized, to be honored, and he agreed to appear at a galaxy. That the Louis Armstrong House Museum was putting together to help raise support, you know, for programs and activities. And so when I was preparing for introducing him and recognizing him and being a part of the program, I said to myself, what can I say about a man who's been honored by President Bush, President Clinton, the United Nations, the Grammys, the the Pulitzer organization. Countries all over the world. What could I say differently? It was very beautifully written. Well, thank you. Definitely a lot better than a lot of the AI slob that is unfortunately being pushed out in the internet nowadays. But very well written. Thank you. I announced specifically that I did not do this through AI or GROC or any of those AI methodologies. although I'm not knocking the availability, but I didn't want them to be a substitute for my own creativity. And I wanted it to be from my heart. And Dan's paper and the Queen's Courier did publish my poem. And he wrote to me afterwards what a beautiful one it was. But it was a tribute. It was a tribute to someone who has brought joy to the world through his music. And my hope is that when people read the poem and when they expose themselves to the works of jazz musicians like Winton Marsalis. They'll make their own music too. Speaking of or g there's definitely one question I I definitely wanted to bring bring up and you just reminded me of this, speaking of ar artificial intelligence that's happening in education. A a lot of people have been using AI, whether it's like for studying or helping lear helping learn new topics. Do you think that it's come to the point where AI has been out been outsourced to do people's thinking for for their their schoolwork or anything like that that's going on in college and where how do you see that w where w artificial intelligence should be used in the day in the school system nowadays, especially for CUNY students? I certainly don't want to visualize AI as a substitute, but I do visualize AI as a supplement. It's a tool and it should be used as a tool, but not as a substitute for creativity. And for the opportunity for students to express themselves in their own words. And I think there is a a danger to AI, becoming real reliant upon AI. But at the same time, I think it can be extremely useful in terms of helping students get access to a much broader level of information than in in my day, which would be to consult the Encyclopedia Britannica or what was called funk and wagnails. You know, I'm really dating myself with that. But the point is there used to be encyclopedias, all of which are now pretty much you know, antiquated because there's Wikipedia and there's so many other types of ways in which you can get information. I I do think that there's a use for it. I worry about the ethics part of AI. because it can be very, very seductive when you are assigned a a term paper, you know, to utilize AI as a substitute for your work. But I also think that part of our job as educators is to help students develop a pride in their own thinking, in their own works, in their own creativity. And that's how knowledge gets generated, you know, because people take some risks in terms of how they develop information and what they believe it might lead to. The quest the quest for knowledge shouldn't be short circuited. Use your own critical thinking and don't outsource it. Yeah, exactly. I I I think sorry. I think that that's part of developing critical analytical skills and being able to challenge concepts. You know, I had a wonderful professor here at Queen's College. His name was Michael Harrington. he wrote a book called The Other America. And it was one of the first books that exposed poverty in America, including poverty in rural areas like Appalachia. And he was a professor here. He's a brilliant political scientist. And every class that he taught, he would first present a political scientist or philosopher that he was in sync with. And then at the same time, he would present another political scientist or philosopher that was opposed to the one that he was in sync with. And the third component involved the circumstances or the environment that both philosophers or political sciences lived in. And that was the model that he presented class after class. And it was brilliant. Because it gave you the student the opportunity to hear and learn about opposing views. Imagine watching a television show and seeing opposing views on a newscast analysis rather than one point of view or another point of view separately. I mean why is that such a sh right, shock? Is that a revolutionary concept? So I'm much more favorable. I'm much more favorable to approaches like that. It's one of the reasons why as I pull in information from different sources, why you know, I will watch CNN and Fox News and MSNBC, you know, and why, you know, I'll have you know access to some of the C C B S and ABC and you know channel channel four, the and I'll try to see some of the other stations, News Nation, or I'll listen to WBAI F I want to hear news from all across the spectrum. So I think one way to guard against the overuse of AI is to have a willingness, a willingness to accept information from multiple sources and then try to make your own judgments. And I think that becoming a more well rounded person educationally requires that level of openness. I 100% agree with you. Personally me, I'm I like to get my news from reading. I really like reading the New York Times and City Journal, so I like to at least see things from two different perspectives. And why? Especially like let's say for a a topic that's going on right now, like AI data centers. Usually City Journal, they're a lot more pro for having AI data data centers and N New York Times and the Brook Brooking Institutes, they would usually put on more ideas that are more like Hey, let's have some safeguards around this. I know New York State they put a a whole I guess pause on the putting the installation of data centers right now. But I think looking at things from certain even like looking at polarizing ideas such as putting in data centers in in the in a state should be always looked at through all di different different sour different types of angles. And I think that's one thing that I believe unfortunately now we have a very polarized society right now where everything is either to the extreme left, like w whether you're like a DSA or a socialist, or they're like MAGA Republicans. And most people I feel or I believe, I like to believe that are much more in the middle than what's portrayed online. what's portrayed online is much more different than reality and people often mistake that. Well many people are not on social media all the time. That's many people are trying to deal with high grocery prices or rent prices or gasoline prices or putting their kids to college or if you're a student, finding the money to pay for college. basic basic needs The job opportunities, people are worried about health insurance, what will happen to their families if there are medical issues, and are not spending their time, energy and effort being on one extreme or the other when it comes to the use of social media. th th they don't have the time, energy or interest in in focusing on that as a primary part of their lives. And so to me that is the center, right? That's the center. that needs attention. And so consequently, defining everything in terms of the far left or the far right, well, you know, that's kind of for the media, you know, to to do and become aware of because I guess that believes that extremes at attract attention. the but in reality, think of the people that have to deal with health issues and medical issues. You know, my wife was the chair of the Assembly Committee on on people with disabilities. You know, that's a whole part of our society, you know, that has to be concerned with very basic necessities. And those are the heroes and the champions of our society. The and as you start to look more carefully, you know, at various groups that have had to contend with challenges, you know, such as veterans, you know, that have sacrificed themselves in so many ways for our country. or as I said, people with disabilities, the or people who've been discriminated against, you b you begin to realize that defining our country in terms of left and right is tremendously insufficient, you know, and that what's really needed is to address where there is a sense of commonality. You know, what are the issues that people really can come together on that are not left or right, you know, but involve access, involve affordability, involve the ability for people to make their lives better. That's why a place like Queen's College is so important, because what this place does at unbelievably low cost, especially compared to other institutions. This exactly. This place Queen's College, it provides a a platform, you know, for the for the positive transformation of people's lives. And when I go to graduation and I sit on the stage and I look out to the audience and someone asks, usually it's the college president, how many people are the first here in their families to go to college? Invariably most of the audience raises their hand and says, We we're the first and I was the first in my family to go to college. So I have an appreciation for the fact that the the the first and foremost interests of my family were not where they were on the political spectrum. It was where they were in terms of their ability to have a have a decent and affordable life, you know, raising their kids. So we have to think as a society what's really important. And that's where more commonality I think can be established between people and groups and And the kind of coalitions that you made reference to earlier, you know, can be formed. We're definitely gonna need all of that especially if we're gonna keep tackle if we're gonna be successful in tackling on the affordable affordability crisis that we have ongoing in in the city. And one of the best things or at least tools for social mobility is college. If you grew up dirt broke, I grew up low income, college is the single best mobility for being able to get a child out of poverty. Over I believe that I you can correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe this statistic is over ninety percent of people who come from low income backgrounds and then end up in college, right when they right after graduation and they get their first job, that's usually what propels them out. And that's one of the best things about CUNY is that it's able to provide a source of college education To help these people in need so that way they can move up the social ladder. Well, there is a piece of data that is very similar within Queen's College and also the CUNY system, which is that after one year of graduation, over ninety percent of the graduates remain in New York State. And after ten years, over eighty percent. And that means that the vast majority, and I mean vast, of college graduates who come out of the CUNY system, they are returning to the state, to the city, to the borough. They're returning through taxes that are earned, through taxes that allow them to give back to their society through the spending power that they bring, they end up bringing many, many times the amount of economic investment to the state, to the city, to the borough And so consequently, we have to define the power of higher education as an investment. It's it's a short term investment, that's a prudent one, and it's a long term investment, because those are the those are the taxpayers of our state or the taxpayers of our country. So so so yes, public higher education in particular, which is low cost to start, the puts the society in a position where it's able to regenerate itself because of the investment that's been made. And that's why a place like Queen's College is so important. yes, especially ha being able to produce more graduates into the workforce and have them give back to our community. And that's one of the great things that Queen's College provides. Like even the the tech incubator here here for instance, it helps provide promote promote new businesses and startups. one of the alumni here. He now is a scout at A sixteen Z. So e even all the way back in s Sanf San Francisco. So even not just in in Queens, they are the alumni here are at going out into the world and doing great b big and great things here. Well I want to give a shout out to Professor Jimmy Vaca because we wouldn't have a Queens College incubator if it was not for him. Because he was an excellent city council member. And he is the one who was a pioneer in creating the opportunity for Queens College here in Queens and for Lehman College in the Bronx to establish incubators on their campuses. And it provides opportunities for students, for student interns, for faculty to work with an incubator, and of course for those people in the small business community to engage and startup business. opportunities and operations right on right on campus. And especially on a campus like Queens, which has a business school and has students interested in so many of these areas, it's just an enormous benefit and our thanks to Professor Vaca for being the visionary. Shout out to Queens College Business School. Speaking of Queens College, Frank Wu is retiring and As the senior advisor to the president of Queen's College, I wanted to ask you a question on how would you reflect on Frank Woo's term and especially since getting out of it happened right at around the start of COVID in twenty twenty, we were and then making that transition to getting the students back on campus, getting student life like active again and making sure that people were starting to come bend into the college and go and go back in person. And how do you expect and what do you expect from the new interim president that's going to be coming in on August first? Well, I think we certainly do owe a debt of gratitude to President Frank H. Wu because he began his presidency right at the beginning of the COVID crisis and he had the challenge, as many presidents did, to navigate us through that period, which was extremely difficult. For students, for faculty, for staff, alumni, for families. There were so many examples of families that were torn apart, you know, by the by the health impact, you know, of of COVID. and that was a a navigation, a steering operation that went on for a long, long time. as I reflect back, I certainly think about the fact that he was instrumental working with students, faculty, staff. and alumni in establishing the business school, which was a long sought after dream here at Queen's College. And speaking about dreams that take some time to be realized, and a and a school of arts to build upon many of the great programs that were here already. and by the way, similarly the School of Business builds on some wonderful programs in various departments. think he deserves enormous credit for the work that was done. and and I think about the the federal, state and city grants and programs that were funded during his tenure and the amazing amount of work that he did during that period as well as of course the leadership that he provided again working with faculty and staff and alumni and students to get the colleges to get the college reaccredited, which just took place last month, after a long period of many years of work with the Middle States Commission on Higher Education, and of course the development and preparation and implementation of the strategic plan from two thousand twenty one to two thousand twenty six. Those are just a few examples of of many. that he was able to accomplish, you know, during a very, very challenging period for Queen's College. I'm very excited about the interim president designate, Elizabeth Betsy Hendry Field. Field Hendry. she is a highly accomplished educator who has over a thirty year history here at Queen's College. wow including serving as provost She held many positions here at Queens, I think probably just about almost every senior administrative position at the college, some on an acting basis and some she did in concert with other positions. And she taught in economics. She's a significant scholar and someone who served as a department chair. So she brings to the interim presidency. enormous accomplishments, skills, great knowledge about Queen's College, and I think is is is in a wonderful position to help the college move forward. And so I'm looking forward to continuing to work closely with her and I know that she is raring to do great things for Queen's College. Awesome. Thank you again so much for appearing on the on the podcast and Before we do conclude this, is there any final words you would like to give to anybody who will be watching this? I guess the final words that I would have relate to what you pinpointed earlier on, which is that any time you're asked to do a presentation or accept a challenge or put yourself in a position, you know, where you may feel a little bit at risk, just say to yourself, fear is a choice. Preparation is a better choice. Whoever's watching this, make sure to steal that quote. Thank you so much, Jay. Thank you for coming. Thank for much.