Latest / The Morning Rundown / Spain's Second Train Crash, Lagarde's Exit, and Lilly's Blowout Quarter
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, and the news is still heavier
- 0:17[Maya] than the coffee.
- 0:18[David] Dark roast or dark headlines?
- 0:21[Maya] Both, David.
- 0:22[Maya] Both.
- 0:23[David] Fair.
- 0:23[David] Morning, everybody.
- 0:24[David] This is the Morning Rundown.
- 0:26[David] I'm David.
- 0:27[Maya] And I'm Maya.
- 0:28[Maya] Three stories for you today.
- 0:29[David] A train crash in Spain, a central banker heading for the exit
- 0:33[David] early.
- 0:34[Maya] And a drug maker with a quarter that sounds almost too good.
- 0:38[Maya] Wait, almost too good?
- 0:40[Maya] Okay, hold that thought.
- 0:41[David] Holding it.
- 0:42[Maya] But the crash first because it's the one that's sitting on me.
- 0:45[Maya] People lost their lives, and the question everybody keeps asking is, how?
- 0:50[David] Right.
- 0:50[David] Specifically, how does a train that was allowed to restart end up
- 0:53[David] in a collision?
- 0:54[Maya] Mm.
- 0:55[Maya] That's the part nobody has a clean answer to yet.
- 0:57[David] And we're not going to pretend we do.
- 0:59[David] We'll tell you what's known and what isn't.
- 1:02[Maya] And the other two stories are a lot lighter, so hang in
- 1:04[Maya] there with us through the heavy start.
- 1:06[David] Yes, a little breathing room is coming, but facts first on all
- 1:09[David] three.
- 1:10[Maya] Totally.
- 1:11[Maya] So the story that's the heaviest this morning, Spain.
- 1:14[Maya] Two high-speed trains collided in Toledo Province, south of Madrid.
- 1:19[Maya] More than five hundred passengers were aboard between them.
- 1:22[David] Mm, and the toll is heavy.
- 1:24[Maya] NBC News reports at least sixty-eight killed and sixty-eight injured.
- 1:29[Maya] Those are early figures, and officials expect the death toll to rise.
- 1:33[David] So that number could move by the time people hear this.
- 1:36[Maya] Right.
- 1:36[Maya] And NBC also says several Americans were among the injured.
- 1:40[David] Which is a reminder of how far a story like this travels.
- 1:43[David] A crash in Toledo Province and somewhere else, a family is getting
- 1:47[David] a phone call.
- 1:48[Maya] Yeah.
- 1:49[Maya] With more than five hundred people on those trains, every number we
- 1:53[Maya] read out stands for a crowd of people whose day or whose
- 1:56[Maya] year just changed.
- 1:58[David] Okay.
- 1:59[David] Maya, the part that stopped me is the history here.
- 2:01[David] This is the second major crash on the same line under a
- 2:04[David] year.
- 2:05[Maya] Wait, really?
- 2:06[Maya] Same line?
- 2:07[David] Same line.
- 2:08[David] NBC says the January crash killed forty-six people, so you have two
- 2:12[David] disasters in a few months on one stretch of track.
- 2:15[Maya] That's a lot.
- 2:17[David] It is.
- 2:18[David] And politically, it lands badly for Prime Minister Snchez, who faces a
- 2:21[David] snap election next month.
- 2:23[David] NBC says he promised action if negligence is found.
- 2:27[Maya] If.
- 2:27[Maya] That's a big word there.
- 2:29[David] It is because nobody has established a cause yet.
- 2:32[David] I'd rather not guess past what officials have actually said.
- 2:35[Maya] Totally.
- 2:36[Maya] So what have they said?
- 2:38[David] CNBC reported what Transport Minister Oscar Puente said.
- 2:42[David] The control system near Urda failed, and six trains were stopped.
- 2:46[Maya] Six trains all held in place.
- 2:49[David] Yes.
- 2:49[David] Then one of them was allowed to restart.
- 2:52[Maya] Hold on.
- 2:53[Maya] Allowed by who?
- 2:54[David] The reporting doesn't say.
- 2:56[David] That's one of the open questions.
- 2:57[Maya] Okay.
- 2:58[David] That train traveled about twenty-five kilometers and hit a stopped train at
- 3:02[David] high speed.
- 3:03[Maya] Twenty-five kilometers?
- 3:05[Maya] That's not a few seconds of confusion.
- 3:07[Maya] That's a train moving for a while.
- 3:09[David] Which is probably why Puente called it inexplicable.
- 3:12[David] That was his word.
- 3:13[Maya] Mm.
- 3:14[Maya] When a transport minister says that, you know he doesn't have the
- 3:17[Maya] answer yet.
- 3:18[David] And Adif, the rail infrastructure manager, is investigating, so the same body
- 3:22[David] that runs the tracks is looking into what went wrong on them.
- 3:26[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 3:27[Maya] People are gonna have opinions about that setup.
- 3:30[David] They will.
- 3:30[David] But for now, it's the minister's account and an investigation that's just
- 3:34[David] starting.
- 3:35[David] The failure of the control system is one piece.
- 3:38[David] Why a train was released is the piece nobody has explained.
- 3:41[Maya] Let me ask the obvious thing.
- 3:43[Maya] When the minister says the control system failed, what does that mean
- 3:46[Maya] for someone sitting on the train?
- 3:48[David] I'll stay inside what's been said.
- 3:50[David] The system failed, and six trains were stopped.
- 3:53[David] A system like that is the safeguard, so the question is what
- 3:56[David] happened to the safeguard and to the decision that came after it.
- 3:59[David] Past that, and I'd be guessing.
- 4:01[Maya] And guessing on a day like this isn't fair to anybody who's
- 4:04[Maya] grieving.
- 4:05[David] Agreed.
- 4:06[David] Then there's the election.
- 4:07[David] Sanchez faces voters next month, and a second crash on the same
- 4:11[David] line is gonna hang over that campaign whether he likes it or
- 4:13[David] not.
- 4:14[Maya] Is that fair to say, though?
- 4:15[Maya] You just told me nobody knows the cause.
- 4:18[David] It's fair as a statement of stakes, not blame.
- 4:21[David] He promised action if negligence is found, and voters will remember whether
- 4:25[David] that promise gets kept.
- 4:26[David] What the investigation finds is a separate question, and that's the one
- 4:30[David] I'll wait on.
- 4:31[Maya] So two clocks running at once, the investigation and the campaign.
- 4:35[David] Right, and they won't necessarily move at the same speed.
- 4:38[David] Early cause details from a minister are a starting point, not a
- 4:41[David] verdict.
- 4:42[Maya] And the families are waiting on that answer while the toll is
- 4:45[Maya] still being counted.
- 4:46[David] Yeah.
- 4:47[David] That's the sober part of this.
- 4:48[Maya] Speaking of institutions in the spotlight, one of Europe's most powerful officials
- 4:53[Maya] just announced she's leaving early.
- 4:55[David] Christine Lagarde, and the timing is interesting.
- 4:58[Maya] Okay, so Christine Lagarde, she told the Governing Council and European Council
- 5:03[Maya] President António Costa that she will step down on February 7th, 2027.
- 5:09[David] Which is months before her eight-year term runs out.
- 5:12[Maya] Nearly nine months, CNBC says.
- 5:15[David] Right.
- 5:16[David] And that kicks off a selection process among European leaders.
- 5:19[David] So the first thing I ask is, who gains from the timing?
- 5:23[Maya] Wait, you've already got a theory?
- 5:25[David] I always have a theory.
- 5:27[David] Reuters, in a report carried by CNN, says her exit leaves time
- 5:31[David] to pick a successor before a French presidential election, and Marine Le
- 5:35[David] Pen is reportedly the polling favorite in that race.
- 5:39[Maya] Reportedly.
- 5:40[Maya] Not confirmed.
- 5:41[David] Right, and that matters.
- 5:43[David] Nobody in the reporting says that's why she's going.
- 5:45[David] The reporting just doesn't say why she's leaving now.
- 5:49[Maya] So it could be a coincidence?
- 5:51[David] Could be, but the calendar is awfully convenient.
- 5:54[David] If you're a European leader, you'd rather settle this job while the
- 5:57[David] politics are calm than argue over it in the middle of a
- 5:59[David] French campaign.
- 6:01[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 6:02[Maya] Does anyone want a central bank pick tangled up in an election?
- 6:06[David] That's my worry, honestly.
- 6:08[David] A central bank works best when people trust that it's independent.
- 6:12[David] Stable and boring is the goal.
- 6:14[David] The moment the top job looks like a political bargaining chip, markets
- 6:17[David] start asking whose interests the next president serves.
- 6:21[Maya] Totally.
- 6:21[Maya] And it's not like there's no turnover.
- 6:24[David] No, there's a lot.
- 6:25[David] CNBC says Chief Economist Philip Lane is also due to leave next
- 6:29[David] year.
- 6:30[Maya] Plus board member Isabel Schnabel.
- 6:33[David] Yep.
- 6:33[David] So you're not just replacing a president, you're potentially reshaping the top
- 6:38[David] of the bank.
- 6:39[Maya] Hmm.
- 6:40[Maya] That's a lot of fresh faces at once.
- 6:42[David] And these aren't small seats at the table.
- 6:44[David] Those voices are part of how the bank arrives at its decisions.
- 6:48[Maya] So a new president could walk into a room where some of
- 6:51[Maya] the other voices are changing too.
- 6:53[David] Which is why who picks them and how is the whole ballgame.
- 6:57[Maya] Okay, but explain the mechanics to me.
- 6:59[Maya] Who actually decides?
- 7:01[David] Here's what the reporting supports.
- 7:03[David] Her announcement sets in motion a selection process among European leaders.
- 7:07[David] Beyond that, I'm not gonna walk you through steps the reporting hasn't
- 7:11[David] laid out.
- 7:12[Maya] Okay, so who's in the running?
- 7:14[David] CNBC names two leading contenders, Klaas Knot and Pablo Hernández de Cos.
- 7:19[Maya] Tipped, not chosen.
- 7:21[David] Exactly.
- 7:22[David] As of today, those are names in the press, nothing more.
- 7:25[David] Leaders haven't decided, and the ECB did say it held rates at
- 7:28[David] its October meeting, so policy isn't changing hands overnight.
- 7:32[Maya] And naming names this early can backfire, can't it?
- 7:35[David] It can.
- 7:36[David] Names floated in the press sometimes go nowhere, so I'd hold them
- 7:39[David] loosely and wait for the leaders to actually decide.
- 7:42[Maya] Right.
- 7:42[Maya] So she's still steering until February.
- 7:45[David] She is.
- 7:45[David] And the next four months of horse trading will tell us a
- 7:48[David] lot about how much politics ends up in the room.
- 7:51[Maya] Horse trading is a polite word for it.
- 7:53[David] It is.
- 7:54[David] But the point is simple.
- 7:55[David] When a job like this opens up, people with different priorities want
- 7:58[David] a say.
- 7:59[David] The best outcome is a pick that markets and voters see as
- 8:02[David] qualified first and political second.
- 8:05[Maya] So what should a regular person actually watch for?
- 8:08[David] Whether the process looks orderly.
- 8:10[David] If the names come out cleanly and the timeline holds, that's reassuring.
- 8:14[David] If it turns into a public tug of war, that's a sign
- 8:17[David] politics is crowding in.
- 8:19[David] Either way, nothing's decided today.
- 8:21[Maya] I'll watch that with popcorn.
- 8:23[Maya] Okay, switching gears.
- 8:25[Maya] Now to a company with very different news.
- 8:27[Maya] Big numbers and a catch.
- 8:29[David] A catch?
- 8:30[David] Go on.
- 8:31[Maya] Okay, this one I can say with a smile.
- 8:34[Maya] Eli Lilly's third quarter revenue jumped thirty-nine percent to twenty-four point four
- 8:39[Maya] billion dollars.
- 8:41[David] Wait, really?
- 8:41[David] Thirty-nine percent on a number that size?
- 8:44[Maya] Really.
- 8:45[Maya] Lilly's own release from October twenty-ninth says Mounjaro and Zepbound led the
- 8:49[Maya] way.
- 8:50[Maya] That's the diabetes drug and the weight loss drug.
- 8:52[David] And CNBC's write-up says they surged again.
- 8:55[David] So this is not a one-quarter fluke.
- 8:57[Maya] Right.
- 8:58[Maya] And the company liked what it saw enough to raise the full
- 9:00[Maya] year outlook.
- 9:02[Maya] Revenue guidance now sits at ninety-one to ninety-two billion dollars.
- 9:06[David] Up from?
- 9:07[Maya] Eighty-five to eighty-seven.
- 9:09[David] So they walked in the room, looked at the old forecast, and
- 9:12[David] said, "Nah, bigger."
- 9:13[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 9:14[Maya] That's a pretty good problem to have.
- 9:16[David] Okay, but my instinct on a story like this is to ask
- 9:18[David] where the growth comes from, because price hikes would be a very
- 9:21[David] different story.
- 9:22[Maya] Totally.
- 9:23[Maya] And that's the part I like.
- 9:25[Maya] A companion release says volume rose fifty-three percent.
- 9:29[David] Fifty-three?
- 9:30[David] Okay.
- 9:31[Maya] And realized prices fell fifteen percent.
- 9:35[David] Hold on.
- 9:35[David] Prices went down and sales went up that much?
- 9:39[Maya] Yep.
- 9:39[Maya] More patients, lower price per prescription.
- 9:42[Maya] Think of a store that cuts its price and the line goes
- 9:45[Maya] out the door.
- 9:46[David] Mm.
- 9:46[David] From where I sit, that's the market-friendly version of the story.
- 9:49[David] They're growing by selling more to more people, not by squeezing the
- 9:52[David] same customers harder.
- 9:53[Maya] Right?
- 9:54[Maya] Nobody's writing an angry editorial about that one.
- 9:57[David] Fair.
- 9:59[Maya] Ha.
- 9:59[Maya] Fair.
- 10:00[Maya] Now, the earnings per share has a wrinkle.
- 10:02[Maya] Reported EPS came in at seven dollars and twenty-two cents.
- 10:06[David] And the adjusted number?
- 10:08[Maya] Non-GAAP was seven forty-eight.
- 10:10[Maya] The GAAP comes from acquired IP R&D charges, which were four dollars
- 10:15[Maya] and fifty-seven cents a share.
- 10:17[David] Okay, hang on.
- 10:17[David] Say what IP R&D means, because I know half the audience just
- 10:20[David] glazed over.
- 10:22[Maya] Fair.
- 10:22[Maya] It's in-process research and development.
- 10:25[Maya] Basically, money spent buying other companies' unfinished drug projects, and it gets
- 10:29[Maya] counted as a cost right away.
- 10:31[David] So they spent a pile on future medicines, and the profits still
- 10:35[David] landed above seven dollars a share.
- 10:37[Maya] Uh, yes.
- 10:38[Maya] That's the sunny read, anyway.
- 10:40[David] Let me make sure I have the price thing right.
- 10:42[David] Volume rose fifty-three percent and realized prices fell fifteen percent.
- 10:46[David] So the volume gain is much bigger than the price drop.
- 10:49[Maya] That's how I read it too, and it's why revenue still rose
- 10:52[Maya] thirty-nine percent.
- 10:54[Maya] Selling a lot more at a lower price per unit nets out
- 10:57[Maya] way ahead.
- 10:58[David] Which makes it a growth story built on demand.
- 11:01[David] For an investor, that's easier to like than a company leaning on
- 11:04[David] price increases.
- 11:05[Maya] And remember, these are the company's own numbers, so keep that framing
- 11:09[Maya] in mind.
- 11:10[Maya] But the figures themselves are specific, and that's what I'd hold on
- 11:14[Maya] to.
- 11:14[David] Fair.
- 11:15[David] And the raised guidance tells you the company is feeling good about
- 11:18[David] the rest of the year.
- 11:19[Maya] A forecast isn't a promise, though.
- 11:21[Maya] It's the company's best guess, which is a nice thing to be
- 11:24[Maya] able to raise.
- 11:26[David] And is there a pipeline hint in all this?
- 11:28[Maya] There is.
- 11:29[Maya] The release also notes a phase III head-to-head win for retatrutide over
- 11:34[Maya] Ozempic.
- 11:35[David] Wait, over Ozempic head-to-head?
- 11:37[Maya] That's what the company says.
- 11:38[Maya] It's their own release, so I'd read it as their framing, but
- 11:42[Maya] it's a notable line to tuck in there.
- 11:44[David] Sure.
- 11:45[David] Companies don't bury a win like that.
- 11:47[Maya] They really don't.
- 11:49[Maya] Okay, before we let you go, David's got three one-liners.
- 11:52[Maya] Brace yourselves.
- 11:53[David] Short ones, I promise.
- 11:55[David] Spain first.
- 11:56[David] A train that was cleared to move shouldn't have been able to
- 11:59[David] hit one that was standing still, so the control system is the
- 12:02[David] story now, not just the grief.
- 12:04[Maya] Mm.
- 12:04[Maya] And the investigation owes people an actual answer.
- 12:08[David] It does.
- 12:09[David] Lagarde next.
- 12:10[David] The date she picked leaves a window to choose her successor, and
- 12:13[David] why she picked it is still a blank.
- 12:16[Maya] Still a blank.
- 12:17[Maya] I keep wanting someone to fill it in.
- 12:19[David] Same.
- 12:19[David] And Lilly.
- 12:20[David] The company's selling to far more patients at lower prices, and so
- 12:24[David] far the market likes that trade.
- 12:27[Maya] Look at you.
- 12:28[Maya] Three stories, three sentences, no charts.
- 12:31[David] I'm growing.
- 12:32[David] Slowly.
- 12:34[Maya] Slowly is right.
- 12:35[Maya] Okay, that's all from us this morning.
- 12:37[Maya] Go drink some water, call somebody you've been meaning to call, and
- 12:40[Maya] be nice to whoever's driving near you today.
- 12:43[David] Good advice, especially the driving part.
- 12:45[Maya] Honestly, it's been a heavy start to the day, and I'm glad
- 12:49[Maya] we got to the lighter stuff before the end.
- 12:51[David] Same.
- 12:52[David] It's okay to sit with the Spain story for a minute.
- 12:54[David] People are still waiting on answers, and so are we.
- 12:57[Maya] And that's the thing about mornings like this.
- 12:59[Maya] You don't have to have a take on everything.
- 13:01[Maya] Sometimes the right move is to just know what's known and what
- 13:05[Maya] isn't.
- 13:06[David] Which is the whole job, really.
- 13:07[David] Say what's confirmed, say what isn't, and don't pretend otherwise.
- 13:12[David] All right, I think my coffee has finally kicked in, so that's
- 13:14[David] a good time to stop.
- 13:16[Maya] And that's the rundown.
- 13:17[Maya] We'll see you next time.