Latest / Iconoclasting / EVOLVE Applied with Deb Keltner: Value Translation
Transcript
- Sarah Smith: Hello and welcome. We are going to deep dive into the Evolve framework today. We're going to take one single slice of it and you're looking at it right now. And today's size that we're looking at is value translation. Now before we get started and before I introduce my compatriot here, I want to tell you what is the Evolve framework? Well, it's actually something I came up with as part of my work in Iconoclast Innovations. And it's a way to think about how are you running your business? How are you getting things? Yeah, the cat's just going to be here. How are you working to improve what you have? It's just a way to guide you through your business decisions from an operations lens. And we'll talk with Deb here in a minute as our marketing bon vivant. She is somebody that's going to talk about it from a marketing lens too. So there's a multi-focus here that we can take. It's really, really cool. It's something I've developed over the 13 years that I've been doing this work. so like I said, we're going to talk about value translation, the second V and without further ado, Ted, Deb Keltner of Deb Keltner LLC, our marketing ball and we talked a lot about titles and what we should call you, but I would love it if you would. Deb Keltner: We're kidding, it's a shirt. Sarah Smith: Yes, I would love it if you would talk about what you do, who you are, why you're here. all of those things. Deb Keltner: Yes, thank you. I'm so excited to be here. I've loved talking to you and I'm really excited about the work you've done with the Evolve framework. so slicing out one of the V's and talking about it today is going to be really fun. For about me, I'm a growth brand and marketing consultant. I'm also working as an advisor with companies. Those companies are usually mid-sized. professional services companies, usually experiencing some kind of inflection point or growth wobble. I find it happens around like 20, 50, $80 million that they essentially find themselves in a spot where what was working kind of stops working. And so what got you where you are. Is it going to get you where you're going? And then that's the right time where I step in and I start working with clients a lot, which is part of what really attracted me to this framework that you've laid out because it echoes so much of what I see with these companies that get kind of stuck and the diagnostics you put together is a beautiful framework for figuring that out. So very excited to be here today. Sarah Smith: Thank you so much. I'm excited. Deb, we met recently, maybe in like the last six months or something, and we've just like vibed. And so this has been really exciting just to be able to go in depth into what this is with somebody who's got a different perspective. So I'm going to set it up and then we're just going to talk about what we see, some dysfunctions, and we'll go from there. This is going to be a little bit longer than like a podcast I do. because this is actually going to be how we experience this in our work, right? So Deb, when you think about value translation, what do you think about? And it can be before I introduce you to this framework or it can be like after, or how do you think about it? Deb Keltner: So when I think of value translation from a marketing lens, it's a fairly literal concept, right? Like how do you communicate the value that you bring to the market, to the market, right? So that they can make sense of who you are and understand what it is that they're interacting with when they come across your brand. they're as simple as that. Do you understand what it is that you're good at and how do you tell that story is that value translation? Peace. Sarah Smith: And I'm so glad you said it from like a marketing lens for me from an operations lens. When I first created this, was more of, do you know what your value is and how you perceive value within the organization? And do your coworkers know what it is? I've got a cat that won't leave me alone. So y'all are just going to deal. This is Lula. She has opinions. Yes. Deb Keltner: Co-host. Sarah Smith: She's employee of the month. Deb Keltner: Yes. Sarah Smith: so yeah, so what I, how I've experienced this is that like, when I'm working with say a publishing organization, their, CTO who was fairly new in the role at the time, he said, well, this is how I view value in my organization. Their CPO, a chief product officer, their head of sales, their rev ops person, they all had different opinions. because they saw things differently. Their marketing person that was there, said, see, that's not exactly like you said. That's a different way that I look at it. And so you have to make sure you're speaking the same language when you're thinking about value across the organization and how it filters out into the world. Deb Keltner: I was gonna say, I think that that's a different use case, but the Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: fundamental issue of do I know what I'm doing and what it means to other people, it persists, right? So whether you're talking Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: to that CTO and they're like, I think I know why people like having me around, or I think I know why the work that I'm doing is contributing to the greater organization, but I'm not actually certain about that. Or maybe everyone, you know, there's the metaphor of like, everyone's touching the elephant from a different angle. That is a microcosm of exactly what the issue is on a bigger scale at the org level, right? It persists as you sort Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Deb Keltner: of move out in rungs of influence from an individual out to the organization, that ability to translate why you're here and why it matters. is that same thing. Marketing is aligned with that in lot of ways. Sarah Smith: Yeah, and we were talking about when we were thinking about doing this type of material show, deep dive, whatever you want to call it. We were talking about, what are the dysfunctions that pop up when we're thinking through this? And you had some really good examples. And I want to hear from you. Deb Keltner: Yes, yes, it's funny when you work in professional services and you work with these mid-sized companies, it's really common for each one of them to say, you know, really need to understand us, we're so unique and we're so distinct that it's going to require a lot of institutional knowledge to figure out what's happening here. But as a consultant, I get to work with a lot of companies saying that same thing. And it's funny how patterns start to show up regardless. how distinct they are. So what I also like about this conversation we're having about dysfunctions is I think it's pretty agnostic as far as like industry or vertical that mid-sized services business has some what I would call like symptoms of dysfunction that are pretty easy to recognize. For a lot of companies, you know, I would love to say that companies clearly have value that they don't know how to articulate. What I think is actually a bigger risk is there's companies that have not really paused to figure out what their value ought to be or what it is and maybe haven't actually generated the value that they need to be in order to be resonating. So that's one of the... uncomfortable truths that a lot of times comes around to, especially founders who've been trying to build something, is it's not just that we need to tell our story better, but it might be that you need a better story. So I'm going to reference some notes that I have here because I've seen a few different things. So one of them is confusing value with activity. So this is a symptom of a dysfunction where if you are going to market or you're in a competitive situation and a potential customer says, why should I choose you? And your answers relate to our team has flexible time zones or the systems and tools that we use work really well with your systems and tools. We're very responsive. We have a 24 hour. Promise that you'll hear back from us if you have a question for or helped us or whatever the thing may be. As soon as you find yourself describing the way that you deliver your work as your value proposition, that is a sign that you've lost your way on what it is that the reason your company actually needs to exist. Set aside Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: the fact that those are easy to match and that any company on their first day can do that as well. Any company can. be nice and responsive and efficient. So it's not competitive. It's also not truly what your value story is. Another one that I see, I see this a lot, especially in technology companies, every company is a technology company now, is where the engineering team, for example, is designing your product or solution. And Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: I'll say I'm married to an engineer. I love engineers. They love features and they love building things to show that they can. And so if your technical delivery team is designing what your solution is, that's a symptom that you've lost your connection with the market and your purpose. And now you're building. So if you find that happening, that's like a little clue. that you've lost your way on value. The next one is how many companies that I've talked to and how many times have I found myself guilty of this. Like I can do anything for anyone. All they need to do is ask and I can get it done. My value is that I can solve any Yes, Sarah Smith: Yes, yeah, not niching down. Yeah. Deb Keltner: I can solve any problem. If they tell me their problem, I will solve it. Now you've completely handed your value proposition over to your customers. And especially if you're hungry for revenue, if you're in the saying, yes, business, your sort of rooted connection to your purpose and your reason for existing will get very distorted very quickly and Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: find yourself chasing pennies instead of chasing impact. So that's the core dysfunction. And we can go deeper in any of these. And then the last. Yeah. Sarah Smith: I wanna actually, you have one more? Okay. was, yeah, yeah, yeah. Deb Keltner: One more, one more, which is the last one, is value with price. If you think being cheaper is how you show your value, we all know that that's a fool's errand. Sarah Smith: Okay, so I have questions for you for all of these. And I love Deb Keltner: Yes. Sarah Smith: that you bring up like this being an agnostic framework because I've worked in, I work in a lot of tech. Traditionally, I've got a lot of experience working in tech. I've worked with marketing teams, HR teams as well as examples, but like when you're talking about value does not equal activity. I think we saw this in a big way during the pandemic. Right? Everything had to go online immediately. And so what happened? Everybody had to have a meeting on and it became Deb Keltner: Yeah. Sarah Smith: eight hours of meetings, no impact driven or delivered. So that's Deb Keltner: Yes. Yes. Sarah Smith: like the most, gut check of a, or gut punch of a way that I've thought about it of like, crap, there's that. And it doesn't stop. Deb Keltner: Well, I think, you we were talking about how this can work at an individual level or a company level. The advice that I would give, especially frankly to women who feel like their value is how busy they can be and their ability to Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: juggle, right? We have seen that that actually doesn't result in a promotion. parallel to a company. Like if you want to show how many projects that you can juggle at once or how many verticals you could go after, how diverse your expertise is, the hours we're on a 24 hour response, you know, we're global. And so Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: we respond 24 hours a day, all that kind of stuff. It speaks to your ability to be busy, but it doesn't speak to anyone's ability to have impact and, customers, managers, leaders don't reward. busy, it Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: would impact. Sarah Smith: Yeah. And goes back into that idea of like, and it's something I'm really big on is focusing on what your outcomes are versus what your output is. And so, Deb Keltner: Mm-hmm. Yes. Sarah Smith: yes, you can have a lot of output, but if it doesn't actually amount to anything, what are you doing? Deb Keltner: Yeah. And then the text is. Sarah Smith: And it goes back, of course, to value. What's your value? Where are you producing value? How do you align it? Deb Keltner: Well, in the tech space, I've worked a lot with companies that are in like, staff augmentation and often near shoring, right? Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: That's the space that I've spent a lot of time in. And that's an entire industry built around activity over value. And then they find themselves in very Sarah Smith: 100%. Deb Keltner: weird conversations about like why a web designer from Mexico is or is not Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: superior to a web designer from. the Czech Republic, like whatever the thing may be, because Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: they've kind of lost the plot by thinking that you could build a brand around your ability to deliver a high level of activity at a similar time zone at a lower price. All of that shifts Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: value. Sarah Smith: Well, and just goes back to that, you know, value does not equal price. And yeah, I think female founders do this a lot too, where they price themselves far lower than their actual value is when Deb Keltner: Yeah. Sarah Smith: they're talking about their services to get to that point where it's like, yes, I can do this. And like you said, Deb Keltner: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: chasing pennies instead of outcomes or impact rather. Deb Keltner: Well, and then when they lose an opportunity, when they know for a fact they were the least expensive and highest qualified option, Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: it's really, it's painful, it's expensive to lose deals, right? The time and effort that you put into it is now gone and it can be. really disorienting if you've rooted yourself like, can do the same activity for a lower price, therefore I am the Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: obvious choice. And when you're not the obvious choice, if that's something that's happening, you know, we go to these clues, these symptoms, that's a really powerful clue that your value proposition, the thing that you're saying your value is, is not necessarily what your customers are buying. It's not differentiated. It's not going to get you across the finish line. And that's one of the things that especially with these mid-sized companies where they've been in business five, 10, 20 years. I talked to somebody this week Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: in business 30 years, right? And they just can't break through some kind of lid. I knew one company they'd been in business for 20 years and couldn't break five million. Right. And Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: it just got really, really stuck there. It's It's difficult to grapple with the idea that the thing that you're offering is not actually that compelling. And then you're at this crossroads of, okay, is there a way to make these ingredients that we've got of a business compelling? Is Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: that we need to tell a different story or is it that we need to like really break down what we're doing and really innovate? a lot of, founders whose personal identity is attached to this business that they built this idea of really changing how they operate and going after that big V for value. it's got a lot of like frankly, emotional hurdles to it. And that's what bringing in a consultant is super important. If you're in house and I've been in house, if you're in house and you're observing these things, or if you're, a subordinate to a CTO, right? If you're in an Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: environment where you are dependent upon this person for your approval, for your paycheck, for your advancement, et cetera, it is a very difficult thing to do to ask that person to raise their hand and say, think that we have gone way off course here. This is where companies that have a hunch that their value proposition is off are really I really recommend bringing in a consultant who's not trying to please you and serve their own growth and advancement through their advice to you to be able to help you navigate these things because they're complicated. Sarah Smith: It is. And just like you said, it can be emotional, whether you realize it or not. And you pay people if, you know, if you're at that point, you pay people to come in and, you know, to some degree, they are relying on you. There's not that many people I know that are going to be able to call out their boss in certain things. Yeah. Deb Keltner: No, no, and not to be, you know, to be the person. And again, I'll go back to these midsize companies where sometimes there's one senior level marketer, you know, there's Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: one person who's there to really monitor how the brand is resonating and how the value proposition is resonating. And it's asking a lot for a person, a team of one or three or four, you know, they have these small marketing teams to raise their hand and try to disrupt the business. and Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: not risk being, you know, sort of alienated or, or disregarded whatever the case may be. So bringing in somebody who's, you know, like on the edge of inside your organization, who can really understand your landscape, understand how you got here, understand how you operate, and then have real, practical hard truth conversations about what needs to change. If again, we want to break past that lid. Right? You've been stuck at $5 million Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: for 10 years. How do we get to eight and sustain it? You've been stuck at 20. How do we get to 50? Those kinds of moments. Again, what got you here won't get you there. You usually need to bring somebody in to talk about it. Sarah Smith: Yeah. And I definitely want to go back to when you're talking about like niching down, right? So when Deb Keltner: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: you're talking about, okay, well, we've got to a point where we can do anything, pay us for anything. And you're right though. It's like what is that with that particular value that you want to bring into the market? This is something I just had a conversation with somebody who's thinking about getting into like being a founder, founding their Deb Keltner: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: own business, right? And they want to do like that. that those high stakes political conversations, they want to be able to get into that. Well, that involves a lot of trust, right? Deb Keltner: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: You have to have the trust of the people you're working with because it is easier to bring in somebody who is not tied to the organization, but they are still, you're bringing them in. And so you're getting, you you're giving them money. So at what point do you talk about like, what's the value you provide? And you really have to set that up for yourself. as a consultant and what's the value you want out of this person as you're evaluating this person as a consultant. Right. So do your, does your value translate across each other as you're evaluating from like an ideal client perspective and a vendor, right? There's a lot of V words happening. Deb Keltner: Vendors and value, viability, vision. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: We can do all of these. think, yeah, it's generally when you see whether it's a solopreneur or a very well established company, Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: when they claim that we can do anything for anyone, just tell us what you need. Not only is it clear that they've lost their own way, but it's not credible. Right? Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: One example is, I won't name names, we don't need to get into that, but there is a very popular podcast that's become a worldwide phenomenon, right? Like a really large podcast. And the people who run the podcast suddenly decided that they were going to start offering like mobile phone services. And it was clearly just like a cash grab where somebody like you can just Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: somebody pitched to them that they can make a bunch of money doing this. And they've got such a big audience that even if they get a little bit of it, they will make some money. Right. And and I thought it was such a great case study in alienating your audience by not knowing why they're here. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: and it exposed a greed that was completely unnecessary, right? It exposed sort of like a cash grab. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: That one comes to mind for me right away is like the opposite of that I shared with you. One of the brands that I think understands their value proposition really well, I will name names in that case, right, like Dyson understands that their Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: value proposition is that we move air. We get air from here to here, really, really efficiently. And so when Dyson, which started with a vacuum cleaner, when they launched a hairdryer, the reaction wasn't like curiosity or concern that they'd lost their way. was like, who's going to move air better than Dyson? I would love a Dyson hair. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: I'd love a Dyson hair wrap. They can charge a premium for it. They're an example of like, know exactly who we are and what we do well, and we're going to be creative with how we apply it. So we can cross Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: industries, but we're not warping your perception of what we're getting at by telling you that they're not making wild leaps. They're really logical conclusions. Sarah Smith: Yes, we had an air purifier slash fan by Dyson for years and it was my favorite thing because my for some reason my husband was really against ceiling fans. I don't know. You don't have to ask him. I don't get it. I Deb Keltner: My husband also does not trust my fans. Sarah Smith: don't get it and I need to have like I'm from the south. We needed like the noisiest fan you could have to sleep comfortably Deb Keltner: Yes. Sarah Smith: on at high speed and that thing never stops moving. And so he does not understand that. And so when we got the Dyson, just had it pointed directly at me while I was sleeping. And I was like, man, this thing is my favorite. Deb Keltner: Right, now your marriage is better, your husband is happy, you've got ventilation. Yeah. Sarah Smith: Yes, yeah, we did finally get a ceiling fan, but you know, that was, that's the compromise. Yes. Deb Keltner: But Dyson is a great example, like for those companies that are trying to figure out like, have some kind of adaptable solution, right? Like I've Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: got a framework that can apply to a lot of different scenarios. That still isn't saying I could Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: do anything for anyone, right? Like Dyson isn't saying, since we made vacuum cleaners, now we'll make carpet, right? Like not the flooring experts, they move air. Sarah Smith: Yeah, yeah. Deb Keltner: And so I think that that's where we're for those companies that are, they maybe have like a toehold of success into something and they're trying to figure out how to expand it so that they can grow. There's no time more critical than that to like genuinely understand who you are and why you matter and whether or not you should exist. Sarah Smith: Well, and that makes me think a lot of Simon Sinek and Apple, right? His very famous talk about start with Y, you know, in Deb Keltner: Hmm Sarah Smith: the golden circle. And it's that talk is so old, you know, it can probably drink at this point. And and so it Deb Keltner: But people needed to hear it. Sarah Smith: they did. And it still is true. And like when I talk about and I don't get any other computer that's not a MacBook, I love MacBooks. I'm an Android girl for my phone, but I love MacBooks. But when I talk to... Deb Keltner: I've got my my Lenovo ThinkPad over here and I will be buried with like King Tut and his tomb. I love it. So I hear you though. Sarah Smith: Yeah. And like, but my best friend just converted from an Android phone, which she's had for years and she's got a MacBook, but she was like, yeah, it just, it, it, everything integrates like my phone, my watch, my computer. And so I've never, without any of them, I know where they are. I can access them all. And I was like, that's, that's one of the things that's like the value that people really love. Deb Keltner: Right. Sarah Smith: is that integration like it is because it's so seamless. Yes. Deb Keltner: And it makes it addicting. Right. As soon as they remove that friction, you can't tolerate that friction coming back in. Yeah. Well, and I'll use a technology example. Sarah Smith: Yes. And yeah, it makes a lot of sense. Deb Keltner: There was, I'm sorry, I'm excited about, let's talk about the Windows phone. So, so Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: right. Apple and Android were going after each other in the smartphone market in 2009, 2010. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: And Steve Balmer, with all of his wisdom, had said that Microsoft shouldn't be in the smartphone business. And then he flinched and blinked and panicked because Apple was, what iPhone did for Apple is a story for the ages, right? Sarah Smith: yeah. Deb Keltner: And so he flinched and he created the Windows Phone, which was a very good device. It was like really, really good. But Microsoft Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: had... built its business around enterprise solutions, right? Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: And it was clearly chasing a trend. It happened Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: to chase it very, very well. Microsoft, the went talk to the randos who had Windows Phone and they will tell you how much they loved it. They really did. Microsoft created a beautiful product, but it was dissonant with who they say they are and what it is that they say that they're here to do. And it took all the way to Satya Nadella to bring it back to land that plane. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: to enterprise solutions. But that was a classic example. Like this isn't just a mid-sized business thing, right? That was a classic example of one of the biggest companies in the world chasing value and Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: chasing the story instead of really like growing it from within and going to market and testing it. And now Windows Phone doesn't exist. Sarah Smith: That's right. And you know, it's really interesting. Lula would like to say something, but I think about it as like, we're talking about how do you make it seamless and frictionless, right? Think about Deb Keltner: Mm-hmm. Sarah Smith: Teams, Microsoft Teams, when that launched, everybody was using Slack. I was using Slack. I was a huge devotee. I actually hate Teams because it never seems to work right for me. Deb Keltner: It's a heavy. Sarah Smith: It is, and I feel like I try and put it on anything. have clients that use it all the time. I'm using it in my MBA program and I hate it. I hate it so much, but when it was Slack and then they, Microsoft came out with Teams and it was included in your enterprise solution. So what happened? It was that inverse line. Teams goes up, Slack goes down because you're having to pay for a better tool, but this one's included. Deb Keltner: Right, right. Sarah Smith: So, and it shows where is your value at. Like people are doing okay in communicating, but we, this is also kind of a no brainer from a financial point. Deb Keltner: Well, I think, I mean, now we can talk ad nauseum, but I'll bring up another example of like where it backfires is Amazon was and continues to be at the forefront of, know, natural user interface around voice, right? So we always know in our house, we have to whisper when we say Alexa, cause she's always listening. There she goes. And, But that was not designed. One of the frustrations that Amazon experiences is that those devices are not designed to make your life easier. They're designed to get you to spend more. But unfortunately for Amazon, they just make our lives easier and don't make us spend more. And so that's an example of putting your customer first. Like if there's something that you have that makes our lives better, we're going to use it. Teams, it's funny, Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: people are really hostile towards Teams. I think it's just too heavy. think if it didn't... cause other things to crash, it would be more beloved. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: But it's, it's, Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: everyone's trying to get you to spend more money, honestly. And that's not value. That's not the thing. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Yeah. And it's not, that was one of the first conversations I remember having as I was doing like Scrum Master and Agile coaching work with technology companies is like, well, what is the value of this? And Deb Keltner: Mmm. Sarah Smith: having teams understand what is business value? What is the value for the teams? And how do you define that? And I remember being in, every time I do this training, like when I'm talking about what's your value, especially if we're talking about like how to create value in technology teams. And you talked about teams being basically feature factories, right? They're building Deb Keltner: Who's that? Sarah Smith: to show everything they can do. How does it tie back to what the business is trying to do? How do you create that value? And a lot of people were so confused that it was not tied always to the dollar amount when Deb Keltner: Right. Sarah Smith: they were making these discoveries. Deb Keltner: There's, you know, I am a big lover of missions, visions and values, but I also am a Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: big lover of accountability. And so, you know, one of the things that my mind goes to is like a truism is what you care about is what you talk about. And so Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: if you're in an organization and every meeting with the leadership team is fundamentally about say like revenue and P &L, which we have to talk Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: I'm not saying Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: don't talk about that, but if that's all you talk about, that's what you value. Like that's what you're trying to create is just more profit for the organization. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: And those are a lot of times with the companies that will chase deals and any dollar is as good as any other dollar, right? They, actually Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: have kind of lost the plot on what they're here to do. And that has like a whole diminishing Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: return. Customers start to notice that you're not actually committed to the thing you say you're committed to. But if you have rigor around. really building mission, vision, and values that are rooted and what the company is actually there to do. That does Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: very much have the ability to be at least a guidepost in your decision-making as you move forward. You can at least have this litmus test of does a decision move us closer to or further from the reason why we say we exist. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: Submission Vision values are a starting point. They don't just belong on the careers page. They don't just belong on the website. It's nice to have. They really do have the power to transform an organization if they're done well and authentically and with integrity and with intent. They offer a lot of guidance as far as where you should be going and what you should be doing with it, which is the last Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: engineers want to talk about. it's fine. Sarah Smith: Right, right. When I think about it, what you've got me thinking about is how do your mission, vision, and values, and I know we're not on vision and strategy, but it comes back to what do you value and how are you translating that across your organization? We've talked about it in a multitude of ways. How do you, what are your values across departments? What are your values to the organization? How do you talk about value in general? Is it always the dollar amount? But it's also, what is your value? to your customers and to your potential customers and your addressable market, those kinds of things. But how does that, Deb Keltner: What's the... Sarah Smith: sorry, this is a question. How does that go into innovation in what Deb Keltner: Mmm. Sarah Smith: we do? Dyson, we move air and so we have these different plug and plays because we move air, right? How does that play into the innovation space within your company if you've defined well what your value is? Deb Keltner: I think that's a fascinating question, especially when you couch it in this professional services universe Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: where we're not building platforms necessarily. Some professional services companies have some kind of proprietary system for managing the work or something like that that helps to differentiate them from others. what does innovation look like when you're selling human time and expertise, I think is actually a really fascinating conversation to go into. part of what there's a tension on innovation is a lot of times, say you have these established, like the 10 year old startup, that's another, by the way, symptom that something's gone wrong. is like, we're 10 years old, but we're still in startup mode. So for these 10 year old startups, a lot of times what they've gotten is some kind of framework, some kind of foundation that they started the business with. And they use that to build upon and to scale to whatever it is where they've gotten stuck. And Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: then the counter signal to innovation is trying to kind of force fit what was and what has worked. into that efficiency model for the next client and sort of wash, rinse, repeat with how we deliver work. So I think in the professional services space, if your value proposition has innovation as part of your value proposition, what I think that that shows up like is that you are current and ready and prepared to talk about what market factors are going to be affecting your ideal customers next. Right? So Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: even if the framework that you had still holds true, right? Like we talked about Simon Sinek and the golden circle being evergreen, right? Like it'll last forever. Even if that holds true, being able to contextualize it in what's next Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: and being able to adapt what's been working to what's happening. Obviously like AI is all over this conversation, but it's not just AI, AI just got Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: the most play. That's what Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: innovation looks like in professional services is there's the innovation delivery. That's not your value proposition, right? You can innovate so you can scale and you can use chat or process automation or whatever to make your business run more efficiently. That's operational Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: innovation. But for your value proposition where innovation comes in is helping your customers to adapt to what they haven't even seen around the Sarah Smith: And that's so I was, I remember working with a very talented, former CIO when I was doing consulting for this, one firm and she was very, very keen on how are we at the bleeding edge of what we're doing so that we can create a smoother vehicle for another V word for our clients. How are Deb Keltner: Yeah. Sarah Smith: we making sure we're doing that? And like you said, seeing around those corners, AI has been a huge disruption. And this is something I talked about on a, on a, a consulting circle earlier this week that I attended, which was really fun was how are we actually applying AI and where do we think it's going to go in the next five years and having those conversations, being able to think about it in depth. But that's also like creating time for yourselves to be, you know, have those. thinking sessions that blue time sky that you definitely need that that is valuable for what you're doing as a you know consultant as a firm whatever it is. Deb Keltner: Yeah. And there's going to be other technical disruptions as well. can't, the last, Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: the disruptions I've seen over the course of my career, I can't think of any other than the introduction of the World Wide Web, which was a little bit before my career started, but like Sarah Smith: Yeah. Yeah. Deb Keltner: the mass availability of the World Wide Web was the last time that I really saw everything turned on its side in the way that AI Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: is. But there were smaller moments. was, you know, the shift to like video used to be really like, look at us here, recording a podcast that you swore. Sarah Smith: Yes. Remember Skype? Deb Keltner: no, I remember giant 25 pound cameras and huge data tapes and editing bays. Right. And I was, you know, and then YouTube gets introduced. that turned an industry on its side and everyone benefited Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: from it. But AI is clearly another one of those epic shifts. But I Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: also, you know, going back to this value translation, if I had a nickel for every company that decided that the way that they were going to make more, get more market share was taking whatever they were doing before and slapping AI onto it. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: And there's a lot of You know, we talked about AI slop in one way, but like, there's a lot of companies out there who are like, we're now an AI enabled fill in the blank. That Sarah Smith: Yes, yeah. Deb Keltner: ain't it. That ain't it. Right. Sarah Smith: And I see a lot of like headlines out there and people saying AI powered. And it's like, I think we all are by now, not a differentiator Deb Keltner: we all right, right? Sarah Smith: at this point. Deb Keltner: No, no, it's and in fact, again, in professional services, there is an expectation and assumption that everyone is using Claude or GPT or whatever your tool of choice is to refine your emails and your communication, etc. So now Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: guess what, going back to that thing of activity not being value activity has lost more value perception than ever. Now in professional services spaces, people want to see your work. They want to see what you brought to what they're getting. Cause otherwise they're going to assume like what is 24 hour response time now and everything's done by a chatbot. That differentiator just out the window. What is multi-language, Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: you know, support mean now that you can have, you know, any language at any time. You could have ancient Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: languages spoken to you if you need to. That's out the window. What Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: do you want to see is what is your thinking? What is your depth of understanding? What can you Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: come up with that is the most human piece of this process that I can't replicate through chat GPT? And I know we've been talking a while about like symptoms and examples and things like that. I do want for anyone who's listening to be able to hear about like, okay, well then so what do I do? Like if they recognize themselves, Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: Like, shoot, you've just described my company in every like worst way. What do I do next? Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: And the solutions that I have, they're not easy button solutions, but Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Nope. Deb Keltner: they are really informative. And one of them is when you run your case studies, for example, are you talking to Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: your clients about why they chose you? and what it is that you did for them that no one else could have done. Or are you just talking about the results of the project? Right? Like there's, there's, I am not a big fan of surveys and for services, right? If you're selling, if you Sarah Smith: Right. Deb Keltner: sold 10 million mugs, sure do a survey about why people like your mugs. Um, but when it comes to services, I'm a real fan of high quality, deep and meaningful conversations with those Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: customers, um, sort of fearlessly talking about. Tell me why you chose us and being ready for the answer being like you were Chiefest or my cousin recommended you or whatever it is. It might not be the fascinating answer you're hoping for or you might get a beautiful nugget, which is like no one presented solutions the way that you do and your different perspective was refreshing and enlightening Right. We take granted the way we think about things and the way we process things but start by talking to customers is a really helpful way to do it. another way to do it. I was working with a consulting firm in the built environment and that company was, submitting responses to approximately 350 RFPs a year. So they had a huge data set of what they won, what they didn't win, often with details Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: who they lost to. And we were able to do kind of a diagnostic on where we're most competitive. Where you're most competitive is a really nice clue about where people see your value. And again, it wasn't price. Price was, it's Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: very rarely going to be the thing unless you're truly doing something commoditized, which in professional services we can talk about that. So doing some diagnostic on why you win and why you lose, doing Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: interviews with customers. The other piece is noticing when your own team talks about the work, when do they light up and when do they drift? Right? So Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: if you are a services oriented business and there's that point where you talk to one of your consultants or one of your project managers or account managers, and you just have them talk about their work in detail and you notice Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: this is the thing that's really cool that I get excited about. and then they can also fall back into like, here's like the rinse and repeat part of it that's not that interesting to me. That's a really Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: powerful clue about where you're operating today, what you're doing well and what you're not. Because those places that you're not interested, you're probably not very interesting either. Sarah Smith: That's amazing. What a great sound clip that is, by the way. Deb Keltner: Thanks. Sarah Smith: And the other question I have is, how are you thinking about, what are your feelings about how, about going back to a, I'm trying to think of the words to say this. What are your feelings about going back to like a lost prospect and saying, hey, what was this? that didn't stand out for you or what was something you were really looking for that became much more clear after the fact. Deb Keltner: think that you get really helpful information from that, but it's very difficult to do from within the organization. And so Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: there are professional services firms, consultants, independents, et cetera, that can do that kind of research for you. You can always ask, but there's some tension there around motivation or fear of hurting feelings. I think that... Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: It's very difficult to get a full honest response if you're the person who had been rejected or you're the firm that had been rejected unless you have really solid history there, right? If this is somebody Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: that, like we've all had the case where my old colleague brought me in to bid on a project, I thought it was a sure thing and then I lost it. Then you've got the capital to go into your old colleague and be like, hey, brass tacks, what happened? What went down? How can we do better? Outside of that situation, I think it's really helpful to bring someone in and have those conversations for you, and they are very revealing. Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: Be careful about letting them tell you who you're supposed to be, though. You Sarah Smith: Yes, that's a good point too. Deb Keltner: still fundamentally need to have some conviction around who you want to be. And this goes back to that hard truth. Some CEOs, some founders just want to be successful so that they're spouses are proud of them. there's some people where like their connection around Sarah Smith: Yes, yes, yeah. Deb Keltner: the offering is actually fairly flimsy and they're just trying to like be something and that's where they need maybe a co-founder or somebody who's got a different motivation to help them zero in on what's going to make things happen. Sarah Smith: Yeah, that's a good point. And was also thinking about how do you get them to disqualify themselves earlier if they're not your ideal client? And how do you think through that more? And just learning from that, like if you didn't win it, maybe they're not your ideal client. And how do you get them earlier in the process so Deb Keltner: Yeah. Sarah Smith: that you're not wasting so much time with clients that aren't actually your best fit? Deb Keltner: Right, well, so I'll use a client that I have experienced with as an example, where when you really talk to the founders, their passion story, their genuine reason for existing was that they wanted to transform the industry. And the industry Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: that they are in is a very cutthroat industry. It sort of is a meat grinder of an industry, chews Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: up and spits a lot of people out. And they wanted to create kind of an oasis. within that industry Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: where people are safe, healthy, happy, productive, and successful, right? Like it's not just Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: to be happy, it's also to make money. So they had a very clear idea of who they wanted to be and who they didn't want to be. And so for them, a lot of their decision-making comes down to actual like culture fit with a client. They Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: have a position of we will be dynamic in the type of work that we deliver, but they have a Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: zero-assholes policy, frankly. Sarah Smith: Yes. Yeah. Deb Keltner: And for them, that actually ties very much into, like I made a whole point, like our value can't be that we're nice people. That's not their value proposition. Their value proposition Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: is actually around making really incredible deliverables that can only be made by highly effective, satisfied, gratified people. Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: But for them, the mission and vision that they had was to transform the industry through the experience of doing the work. So in that case, Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: it was really easy to turn projects down. Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: Another example was in the technology space. And this one, it ended up, it had a wobbly finish. And it's because Sarah Smith: Hmm. Deb Keltner: the conviction wasn't quite as strong. So this was a technology company that wanted to be a small and mighty elite force. building highly cutting edge, deeply innovative technology solutions, right? Only Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yep. Deb Keltner: cool stuff that hasn't been done before. Well, it's Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: really difficult to find clients to do that who don't already know you. So building a business that only cool Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: stuff is very hard. And when times would get tough, they would fall back on staff augmentation or process automation or like really a base level integration work that were actually fully counter to the business they claim to want to be building. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: And in that case, when you have communicated to the team that will say yes to anything, even if it takes us further away from our vision, it all kind of collapses. Right. Sarah Smith: Yeah, because you're like, want to build good stuff and cool stuff, but we also got to make money. Deb Keltner: Right. Like the people who took a job there based on the promise of only elite high level innovation quickly be Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: disillusioned. They tell their friends that the promise isn't real. All that kind of stuff can happen. so, so that's an example of what happens when you take bad work. I'll use myself as an example. I, you might have, I bring it all back to B2B services. I've been, my first Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: job was when I was 16 as a marketing assistant at Marcus and Mila Chap. I have only. Sarah Smith: of that. Deb Keltner: I've only ever been in marketing and for 98 % of my career it's been in B2B professional services. I say no to consumer product stuff pretty regularly because I know I'm not going to be the best at it and I want everyone to invest in Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yes. Deb Keltner: my product because I'm just going to give them the best. I only want to do things where I will be the best at it. If I'm not going to be the best, I will refer you. Sarah Smith: And that's a hard lesson to learn, especially as you're building a business because it becomes very like, well, we got to make money. And I know I'm good at this, but it also doesn't light me up. Like you were talking about earlier. So. Deb Keltner: Yeah. Or I'm not going to be good at that thing. Right. Like, and Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Deb Keltner: to use that software company or that technology company as an example, they built their entire infrastructure around high aspiration projects. It is Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: very difficult to get your billing rate right on low aspiration Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: projects with a team of high aspiration engineers. It's a mess. It's mess. Right. Sarah Smith: Yes, yeah, it's it very much is. Yeah. Deb Keltner: So, so. You know, the value translation piece of it. I think what we've been talking about a lot here is before you could translate it, you need to understand what it even is. Right. And that's, Sarah Smith: 100%. Yeah. Deb Keltner: that's the gap that I think is really hard. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: Once you really understand it, then talking about it gets easy. Right. Yeah. Sarah Smith: much easier. So we have been talking about value translation in so many forms. What is the one thing you would have people walk away with from this conversation? Deb Keltner: I don't, okay, I can't say all of it in one run on sentence. Sarah Smith: No, unfortunately not. Deb Keltner: Yeah, the one thing I want people to understand about value translation is that it needs to be held up by an intense and clear conviction about why Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: your business needs to exist and what you can do that no one else can do. And until you've got that, your work can't really begin on communicating it outward. Sarah Smith: 100%. I love that. My number one thing would be value Deb Keltner: Yes. Sarah Smith: is not always what you think it is. And you need to be able to communicate to one another, to each other, to your audience, your market, whatever it is, you need to make sure you're landing on the same page together. Deb Keltner: I love that. I love that. It's not what you always think it is, is crucial. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. Deb Keltner: And get help. You don't have to solve this on your own. You don't have to figure this out Sarah Smith: Yes. Yeah. Deb Keltner: in the quiet dark of your bedroom by yourself. Bring in somebody who can help you navigate this, because this is hard stuff. Sarah Smith: Mm-hmm. It is. And having an outside perspective is so key sometimes to just get stuff moving. You don't have to stay stuck. Deb Keltner: It's an unlock, I'm sure. Sarah Smith: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Well, thank you so much. This was amazing. I will link all of your... Deb Keltner: my gosh, I could talk to you forever. Sarah Smith: I know. I will link all of your socials and how to get in touch with you in show notes. But this was great. And we will be doing this soon again. Deb Keltner: Awesome. Thank you. Thank you. I'll talk to you soon. Let's keep talking about EVOLVE Sarah Smith: Yes. Deb Keltner: Everybody, if you haven't looked into Sarah's framework, you should look into it. She has a diagnostic that is really well done, highly Sarah Smith: Yeah. Deb Keltner: recommend. Check it out. It's very good stuff. Sarah Smith: Well, thank you. All right. Well, I will talk to you soon. Thanks, Deb. Deb Keltner: All right, thank you.