Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Decoy Effect Shapes Office Decisions
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, you've been in the market for a new project management tool for your team. What did you end up picking? Luna: Honestly, I went with the middle-tier option, but it took me forever. There was this basic plan, a pro plan, and then an enterprise one that was way too expensive. Lucas: Right, and that's where the decoy effect kicks in. The enterprise plan wasn't really meant for you. It was there to make the pro plan look like the sensible choice. Luna: Wait, are you saying they deliberately put that expensive plan there just to push me toward the middle one? Lucas: Exactly. That's the decoy effect, or the asymmetric dominance effect. When you add a third option that's clearly worse on some dimension, it changes how you perceive the other two. The classic example is from a famous study with subscriptions to the Economist. They had a web-only subscription for fifty-nine dollars, a print subscription for one hundred twenty-five dollars, and a print plus web subscription for the same one hundred twenty-five dollars. Luna: That print-only option is the decoy. Nobody in their right mind would pick print-only when web plus print costs the same. Lucas: Exactly. And when they removed the decoy, people mostly picked the cheapest web-only option. But with the decoy, the majority went for the print plus web, which had the highest margin. The decoy didn't just influence the choice — it flipped it. Luna: So in my case, the enterprise plan was the decoy. But in the office, we're not always talking about pricing. How does this show up in everyday decisions? Lucas: Think about a meeting agenda where your boss wants to approve a new project. They might present three options: a low-cost, low-impact project; a high-cost, high-impact one; and a middle option that they actually want. The high-cost one is the decoy, making the middle option look reasonable by comparison. Luna: So I should start looking at every set of choices and asking which one is the decoy. Lucas: That's the first step. And once you spot it, you can either ignore it and focus on the real trade-offs, or you can use it yourself to steer a discussion. But let's be careful — using decoys can easily backfire if people see through it. Luna: When would using a decoy actually be a good move? Lucas: Say you're proposing a new initiative and you need buy-in from a skeptical stakeholder. You can present three approaches: a cheap and quick one that's not great, an expensive and slow one that's also not great, and your recommended one that balances cost and impact. The other two are decoys, but they're real alternatives, so it's not dishonest. It's just framing the choice to highlight the strengths of your proposal. Luna: That sounds a bit manipulative, though. Lucas: It can be, if you're hiding the ball. But in negotiation, it's standard practice. When you're comparing job offers, recruiters often include a lower-ball offer to make the standard one look better. That's a decoy. Luna: I've seen that happen. A friend of mine got two offers, and the lower one made the higher one seem amazing, but the higher one was still below market. Lucas: Exactly. So the key is to benchmark against external data, not just the options in front of you. If you know the market rate, the decoy loses its power. Luna: So what about performance reviews? I feel like there's always a decoy lurking there. Lucas: Absolutely. Managers sometimes include a 'needs improvement' rating that's actually fine, but it makes the 'meets expectations' rating look like a win. Or they'll compare you to a weak peer to make you look better. Luna: That's so common. It's like they're managing your perception without you even realizing it. Lucas: And that's why understanding the decoy effect is so valuable. It gives you a lens to see through the choices that are being framed for you. Luna: Speaking of seeing through things, I've been really grateful for the clarity this podcast brings to office dynamics. It's helped me navigate a lot of tricky situations at work. Lucas: That means a lot, Luna. And for those of you who find value in these conversations, if you've ever thought about supporting the show, we've got a way for you to do that. You can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Luna: It's a small gesture, but it helps keep this podcast ad-free and independent. We really appreciate it. Lucas: Okay, back to decoys. So we've talked about spotting them and using them. But there's a darker side — when decoys are used to push through bad decisions. Luna: Like what? Lucas: Imagine a vendor proposal where they add a super expensive version of their product to make the standard one look like a bargain. The standard might still be overpriced, but it looks good next to the decoy. Luna: So the decoy doesn't just influence the choice between two options, it can also anchor your perception of value. Lucas: Right. And that's why you need to anchor yourself with outside data before you walk into any decision. If you know what a fair price is, or what a reasonable timeline is, the decoy becomes almost invisible. Luna: And if you're the one setting up the options, how do you do it ethically? Lucas: The key is transparency. You can present multiple options, but you have to be open about the trade-offs. If you're honest and the decoy is a legitimate alternative, it's just good communication. It's when you hide the flaws that it becomes manipulative. Luna: So the decoy effect is really about framing and context. The same choice can feel completely different depending on what else is on the table. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the takeaway. Next time you're faced with a decision at work, ask yourself: is there a decoy here? And if there is, what is it trying to push me toward? Luna: That's a great question to keep in your back pocket. I know I'll be using it in my next budget meeting. Lucas: And if you're the one designing the options, remember that a well-placed decoy can be a powerful tool for steering a group toward a better outcome. Just make sure it's for the right reasons. Luna: So, Lucas, do you think the decoy effect is more common in the office than we realize? Lucas: Oh, definitely. It's everywhere. Look at how meetings are structured. The person who sets the agenda controls the options. If they want to kill a proposal, they'll include an obviously bad alternative. If they want to push one through, they'll add a decoy that makes it look like the only sensible choice. Luna: So the real skill is not just spotting the decoy, but also understanding the intent behind it. Lucas: Right. And once you see it, you can either call it out or play along, depending on what serves you. It's a subtle art, but it's a really practical one. Luna: I feel like I'm going to start seeing decoys everywhere now. It's like that film where once you learn a word, you hear it all the time. Lucas: That's the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon, but that's a whole other episode. For now, just remember: the decoy effect is about making the preferred choice seem like the obvious one. And that's a big part of office politics.