Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How Trump's Global Tariff Reshapes the National Debt Math
Transcript
- Lucas: So the big story this week is the new global tariff the White House announced on Friday. A blanket ten percent tariff on imports from pretty much every country, with some exceptions, and it's supposedly justified by forced labor concerns. But the real question for this show isn't the politics—it's what this does to the national debt math. Luna: Right, because tariffs are a tax on imports, so they raise revenue for the government. But they also raise prices for consumers and businesses, which can slow the economy. So which effect dominates? Lucas: Exactly. Let's start with the revenue side. The US imported about $3.8 trillion in goods last year. A flat ten percent tariff, if it doesn't crush imports, could gross around $380 billion annually. But you have to subtract exemptions, retaliation, and the fact that some goods will stop being imported. Realistic estimates I've seen from the Tax Foundation and similar groups put it closer to $70 to $80 billion a year. That's not nothing—it's about four to five percent of the current $1.77 trillion deficit. Luna: But the deficit is still $1.77 trillion, and the debt just crossed $39 trillion. So $80 billion is a drop in the bucket. Lucas: It is. And the bigger concern is what happens to interest rates. The 30-year Treasury yield is already at 5.17 percent, the 10-year is at 4.71. If tariffs push inflation up even half a percentage point, the Fed might have to keep rates higher. The effective federal funds rate is at 3.63 right now, but the market is pricing in a possible hike. Higher rates mean higher borrowing costs for the Treasury—and we already spend more on interest than on Medicaid or defense. Luna: And import prices from China just hit their highest since 2008. That data came out July 17. So we're already seeing cost pressure before this tariff was even announced. Lucas: That's the key. The tariff compounds that. If import costs go up and stay up, it feeds into core inflation. The Fed has been trying to get inflation down to two percent—but if tariff-driven inflation ticks up, they might have to tighten, which pushes yields higher. And higher yields make the debt more expensive to service. Luna: So it's a Catch-22: the tariff brings in some revenue, but it might increase the cost of borrowing by more than that revenue. Have any models quantified that trade-off? Lucas: The Congressional Budget Office hasn't published a new estimate yet, but back during the 2018–2019 trade war, they found that the tariff revenue was roughly offset by higher interest payments and slower growth. And that was with a much smaller debt load. Now we're at a debt to gdp ratio of 122.6 percent, up from about 78 percent in 2018. Luna: That's a huge difference. Quick thought—and this is something I've been thinking about: if you find these numbers useful to understanding the economy, just know that this show is funded directly by listeners. A small group of people chip in a few dollars a month at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, and that's what keeps us going without corporate ads. It's a model that works for us, and we appreciate everyone who's part of it. Lucas: Absolutely. It keeps us independent, and we can dig into stuff like this without worrying about pleasing advertisers. So back to the tariff math—another angle is how foreign holders of Treasuries might react. If trade tensions escalate, countries like China, which still hold about $750 billion in US government bonds, could reduce their purchases. Luna: They've already been gradually reducing their holdings over the past decade. But if Trump's tariff is seen as targeting them specifically—I know it's supposed to be global, but China is the biggest source of imports—they might accelerate selling. Lucas: Right. And that would put upward pressure on yields. The Treasury has to roll over about $9 trillion in debt this year. If demand from key foreign buyers weakens, the Treasury has to offer higher yields to attract domestic buyers—pension funds, mutual funds, banks. That's a direct cost to taxpayers. Luna: So the tariff could backfire even before it collects a dime of revenue. Let's talk about the yield curve. The 10-year minus 2-year spread is now 0.36 percent, which is positive but pretty flat. What does that tell us about expectations? Lucas: It tells us the market expects moderate growth and maybe some inflation. A steep curve—like if the spread were over a percentage point—would signal strong growth expectations. A flat or inverted curve signals recession. Right now it's slightly positive, which is neutral to slightly bullish. But if tariff uncertainty rises, investors might flock to short-term safety, pushing the 2-year yield down and steepening the curve that way—which usually is a sign of economic uncertainty. Luna: And the 3-month yield is 3.95 percent, close to the 2-year at 4.37. So the front end of the curve is pricing in the current Fed stance, but the long end—like the 30-year at 5.17—is pricing in term premium for inflation and fiscal risk. Lucas: Exactly. The term premium on long-term bonds has been rising. A big reason is the growing national debt and the uncertainty about future fiscal policy. Tariffs add another layer of uncertainty. The CBO projects the deficit will remain around $1.5 to $2 trillion for the next decade even without new spending. If tariff revenue is temporary—because trade patterns adjust, or tariffs get negotiated down—then we're left with the same structural problem. Luna: And interest costs are already the fastest-growing part of the federal budget. This year they're projected to exceed $1.2 trillion. That's more than we spend on the entire military. Lucas: So let's tie it together. The tariff could generate $80 billion a year, but it could also add a quarter to a half percentage point to inflation. If the Fed raises rates by 50 basis points in response, the extra interest cost on the $39 trillion debt is about $195 billion per year—more than double the tariff revenue. Luna: That's a net negative. And that's without considering retaliation from trading partners. The EU and China have already threatened counter-tariffs. That could hurt US exports, slow GDP growth, and reduce tax revenue. So the deficit could actually widen. Lucas: There's a historical parallel. The Smoot-Hawley tariffs of 1930 were meant to protect American jobs but ended up deepening the Depression. Tariff revenue actually fell because trade collapsed. Now we're in a different economy, but the risk is similar: if global trade contracts, you lose the tariff revenue and the economic growth. Luna: And we're also in a period where the labor market is still relatively tight. The Fed's Beige Book last week noted some consumer weakness but overall moderate growth. Adding a tariff could tip some sectors into contraction. Lucas: Yeah, the World Cup gave bars and restaurants a boost, but that's a one-time event. The broader consumer picture is mixed. If tariff-driven price increases hit household budgets, spending could slow. And since consumer spending is about 70 percent of GDP, that would drag on growth. Luna: So the tariff is essentially a tax on consumers and businesses that may or may not reduce the deficit. And it could increase the debt burden by raising interest costs and slowing growth. Lucas: That's the bottom line. It's a fiscal policy that looks good on a bumper sticker—'make foreign countries pay'—but the actual numbers suggest it's more likely to worsen the debt trajectory. The 30-year yield at 5.17 is already reflecting a higher risk premium. If this tariff pushes that yield to 5.5 or 6 percent, the interest bill becomes enormous. Luna: What would that mean for the average taxpayer? More of their income going to service debt instead of funding things like infrastructure or healthcare. Lucas: Exactly. The Treasury Department is already paying the highest interest costs in history relative to GDP. In fiscal 2025, net interest was about 4.5 percent of GDP. If yields stay elevated, that could hit 5 or 6 percent within a few years. That's crowding out other spending. Luna: So the tariff, intended to reduce the trade deficit, might instead increase the fiscal deficit. Irony. Lucas: It is. And that's why we follow this closely. The national debt isn't just a number—it's a constraint on every policy decision. The tariff debate should include this fiscal math, but it rarely does. Luna: Well, we'll keep doing that math. Next week we're looking at the implications of the Fed's latest beige book and what it says about fiscal drag. Thanks for listening.