Latest / Deep Dive / Why the Hiring System Is Broken: The Truth Behind the Skills Gap
Transcript
- 0:00Right now, across the country, countless employers are going on
- 0:04television, they're talking to journalists and they're just
- 0:07screening that they cannot find a single qualified worker.
- 0:10Oh yeah, constantly. You see it everywhere.
- 0:12Right. They're declaring like this
- 0:14massive talent emergency. And yet, if you're listening to
- 0:17this right now, you likely know someone, or maybe it's even you,
- 0:21who has sent out, I mean, 3 or 400 tailored resumes to those
- 0:26exact same companies. And heard absolutely nothing
- 0:29back. Exactly.
- 0:30Not a single phone call. So the question is, how is it
- 0:33mathematically possible for both of these realities to just, you
- 0:37know, exist in the same universe?
- 0:39Well, I mean, it creates this cognitive dissonance that just
- 0:42drives people completely crazy. You have two sides of a market
- 0:46that are totally failing to connect.
- 0:48And the fascinating part to me is how much energy is spent
- 0:51pointing fingers, you know, rather than actually diagnosing
- 0:55the mechanics of why it's failing.
- 0:57Which is exactly what I want to spend our time today doing.
- 0:59We're going to figure out the mechanics of that failure.
- 1:01It's a much needed deep dive. It really is because to find out
- 1:05why good, capable people are being shut out of the labor
- 1:08market, we need to take a deep dive into two sources that,
- 1:12frankly, fundamentally changed how I view this entire system.
- 1:15They are fantastic sources. They really are.
- 1:18First, we're looking at a foundational economic paper from
- 1:21the Center for the Economics of Education and Training, right?
- 1:24And this paper rigorously unpacks the actual mechanics of
- 1:28what gets labeled as a quote UN quote skill shortage.
- 1:31And 2nd, we are pulling extensive insights from a really
- 1:34eye opening book by Wharton professor Peter Capelli.
- 1:37Yes, why good people can't get jobs.
- 1:40Exactly. And our mission today, you know,
- 1:42for this deep dive, isn't just to casually chat about the job
- 1:44market. We are here to entirely
- 1:47dismantle the myth of the skills gap.
- 1:48Which is a huge undertaking, but so necessary.
- 1:51Definitely. We're going to explore how a
- 1:53combination of unrealistic managerial expectations and
- 1:57deeply flawed automated hiring algorithms and the near total
- 2:01abandonment of corporate training programs have basically
- 2:03created this massive systemic barrier between employers and
- 2:07you, the workforce. Yeah, it's a perfect storm.
- 2:10And these two sources complement each other so beautifully.
- 2:13How so? Well, the economic paper
- 2:15provides the strict macroeconomic framework, right?
- 2:19It gives us the definitions, the math.
- 2:21Right, the zoomed out view. Exactly.
- 2:23And then Capelli's work takes us down into the trenches.
- 2:26It shows us what HR departments and hiring managers are actually
- 2:29doing on a random Tuesday afternoon when they sit down to
- 2:32review your application. Which is usually just tossing it
- 2:35in the trash apparently. Unfortunately, yeah.
- 2:37But I feel like before we start pointing the finger at the
- 2:41algorithms or the applicants, we really need to define our terms
- 2:45here. Oh, for sure.
- 2:46Because the language being thrown around in the media by
- 2:50these executives feels very sloppy.
- 2:53I'd go further and say the language is more than sloppy,
- 2:56it's actively deceptive. Oh wow, really?
- 2:59Yeah, when you read the framework laid out by the Center
- 3:02for the Economics of Education and Training, you realize pretty
- 3:05quickly that the terminology actually dictates the policy.
- 3:08OK, break that down for me. So the authors of the paper
- 3:11breakdown all these generalized complaints we hear from
- 3:14executives into three very distinct, highly specific
- 3:18economic terms. OK, the problem is that these
- 3:21three terms are just constantly conflated in public discourse.
- 3:24They just mush them all together, right?
- 3:26Those terms are a true skills shortage, a skills gap and
- 3:31recruitment difficulties. OK, let's pull those apart one
- 3:33by one. What is the baseline definition
- 3:35of a true skills shortage, according to the economists?
- 3:38Right. So a Trueskill shortage occurs
- 3:41only when the demand for workers for a particular occupation is
- 3:45genuinely greater than the supply of workers who are
- 3:48qualified, available and willing to work under existing market
- 3:51conditions. Let me stop you right there.
- 3:52Under existing market conditions, feels like the
- 3:55operative phrase. It absolutely.
- 3:56Is meaning at the wage that is currently being offered by the
- 4:00market. That is the crucial caveat.
- 4:02Like if there are literally no human beings capable of
- 4:05performing a highly specific surgical procedure at the
- 4:08current market rate for surgeons, that is a shortage.
- 4:11Because you can't just pull a guy off the street to do brain
- 4:13surgery. Exactly.
- 4:15The capacity simply does not exist.
- 4:18However, that scenario is remarkably raw in the broader
- 4:21economy. Right, most jobs aren't brain
- 4:23surgery. No, they aren't.
- 4:25What is far more common is the second term, which is a skills
- 4:28gap. And how does the paper
- 4:30distinguish a gap from a shortage?
- 4:32So a skills gap refers to a situation where an employer
- 4:36feels that their current workforce or, you know, the pool
- 4:40of people they are actively interviewing is underskilled
- 4:43compared to an idealized standard.
- 4:45Idealized standard. Yeah, the paper actually refers
- 4:47to this as a normative skills gap.
- 4:50It's basically the distance between the workers you have and
- 4:53the utopian workers you wish you had.
- 4:55Could you give me an example of how that plays out in like a
- 4:58normal business? Sure, think of a regional
- 5:00manager at a chain of auto repair shops, right?
- 5:02OK, The mechanics they employ are perfectly proficient.
- 5:06They diagnose engine trouble. They rotate tires.
- 5:08They fix brakes. They do the job they were hired
- 5:11to do. They fix the cars.
- 5:12Exactly. But then the regional manager
- 5:15goes to some corporate seminar and decides, hey, every mechanic
- 5:19should also possess elite interpersonal communication
- 5:22skills. Oh boy.
- 5:24Right, so they can upsell customers on premium maintenance
- 5:28packages while they're walking them out to the car.
- 5:30Right, like a salesperson. Yes, and when the the mechanics
- 5:33fail to do this because they are mechanics, not salesman, the
- 5:36manager complaints to corporate that they're suffering from a
- 5:39massive skills gap. But they don't have a shortage
- 5:42of mechanics. The cars are getting fixed.
- 5:44The business is running. Precisely, the core function of
- 5:48the business is operating smoothly.
- 5:50The manager just wishes their mechanics were also highly
- 5:53trained, charismatic sales professionals.
- 5:56Either judging the workforce against the norm they just
- 5:58completely invented in their head.
- 6:00Yeah, exactly. Rather than the actual
- 6:02functional requirements of the trade, which.
- 6:04Naturally leads us to the third category, which, looking at the
- 6:07job boards right now, seems to be the most common culprit.
- 6:11Oh, absolutely. The paper calls it recruitment
- 6:13difficulties. What triggers this specific
- 6:15diagnosis? Well, recruitment difficulties
- 6:17happen when an adequate supply of fully capable workers exists
- 6:21in the geographic area, but the employer simply cannot convince
- 6:24them to take the job OK, and the reasons are usually painfully
- 6:29obvious to everyone except the employer.
- 6:32Like what? Like the pay is significantly
- 6:34below average, the shifts are grueling, maybe the commute is
- 6:37miserable, or the management is notoriously toxic.
- 6:41Or their internal recruiting process is so like, convoluted
- 6:45that applicants just give up halfway through.
- 6:47Yes, that happens all the time. I see the trap now.
- 6:50So when ACEO takes a survey or goes on a financial network for
- 6:53an interview, they experience a recruitment difficulty.
- 6:56Say nobody wants to work in their non air conditioned
- 6:59warehouse for minimum wage with no breaks and they label it a
- 7:02skills shortage. Exactly.
- 7:04They lump all of their varied frustrations under that single
- 7:08panic inducing umbrella term. They tell journalists the nation
- 7:12is facing a massive skills shortage, which creates this
- 7:15false narrative that the educational system has
- 7:17completely collapsed and the country has literally run out of
- 7:20capable human beings. You know, it's like me walking
- 7:23into a luxury auto dealership and complaining to the local
- 7:26news anchor that there is a severe Ferrari shortage in our
- 7:30city. I love this analogy.
- 7:32Right, like I go on TV and say I cannot find a single person
- 7:36willing to sell me a brand new Ferrari for $10,000.
- 7:40Right, which is absurd. The cars are sitting right there
- 7:43on the lot. There is no supply chain crisis,
- 7:46I am just stubbornly refusing to pay the sticker price.
- 7:49And then I have the audacity to blame the manufacturer for my
- 7:53lack of a sports car. The Ferrari analogy captures the
- 7:56dynamic perfectly. It's so frustrating to watch.
- 7:59It really is. The employer is experiencing a
- 8:02totally self-inflicted recruitment difficulty based on
- 8:05a delusional pricing model, but they diagnose it as a structural
- 8:09supply shortage. Which just changes how you view
- 8:12every single headline you read about the labor market.
- 8:14Exactly when executives complain about a lack of talent, you
- 8:17really have to ask, are they lacking human capacity or simply
- 8:21lacking human beings willing to accept a stagnant, unappealing
- 8:24offer? So if we accept that a huge
- 8:26portion of this quote UN quote, talent crisis is actually just a
- 8:30recruitment difficulty, it begs a massive question.
- 8:34Which is. Why are employers doing this to
- 8:37themselves? I mean, if you need a worker to
- 8:39keep your business running and capable workers are submitting
- 8:43resumes, why not just hire them and get back to work?
- 8:46It's a great question. To answer that we have to look
- 8:48at a structural shift in corporate psychology that
- 8:50Capelli outlines in his book. OK, he introduces A framework he
- 8:54calls the Home Depot view of hiring.
- 8:57The Home Depot view. Walk me through that.
- 8:59So historically, hiring a new employee was viewed as a process
- 9:03of bringing a person into an organization, assessing their
- 9:06foundational capabilities, and then molding them to fit the
- 9:08specific needs of the company over time.
- 9:11It was an investment. Exactly an investment in a human
- 9:13being. Today, Capelli argues, employers
- 9:16view filling an open desk exactly the same way you view
- 9:19buying a replacement part for a broken washing machine.
- 9:21Oh wow. So you go to the hardware store,
- 9:24you find the exact PDC pipe with the exact threading and the
- 9:27exact diameter. Yeah, you take it home, you
- 9:29screw it in, and the machine works immediately.
- 9:32That is the modern corporate expectation.
- 9:34They want a human being who fixed the job description to the
- 9:37millimeter. Which is impossible.
- 9:39Right, but they want someone who can execute the exact
- 9:42specifications perfectly immediately on day one with 0
- 9:47modification, 0 training and zero ramp up time.
- 9:51The examples Capelli provides in the book to illustrate this are
- 9:54honestly staggering. They're almost unbelievable.
- 9:57There was one that stuck with me about a cotton candy machine
- 10:00operator. Oh, I remember that one.
- 10:02I mean, making cotton candy is essentially pouring sugar into a
- 10:06heated spinner and twirling a paper cone.
- 10:09It is a job you can learn at a County Fair in about four
- 10:12minutes. Right, it's not rocket science.
- 10:14But the job advertisement for this role mandated that the
- 10:17applicant must demonstrate prior success operating similar cotton
- 10:21candy machines. Not just any food service
- 10:23experience, and not even just any cotton candy machine.
- 10:27A similar one. It is laugh out loud funny until
- 10:30you realize some poor person lost out on a paycheck because
- 10:34they had spun sugar on a brand X machine instead of a brand Y
- 10:38machine it. Illustrates the core pathology
- 10:40perfectly, though hiring managers are no longer looking
- 10:44for general capability or intelligence or potential.
- 10:47They don't care if you're a fast learner.
- 10:48Not at all. They are looking for absolute,
- 10:51documented replication of the exact tasks they need done.
- 10:55The term Capelli uses is looking for a Unicorn.
- 10:58And because the hunt for unicorns has basically become
- 11:01standard operating procedure, job descriptions have mutated
- 11:04into these bloated, contradictory wish lists.
- 11:07You see it constantly on LinkedIn and indeed, entry level
- 11:11position requires five years of experience, a master's degree,
- 11:14proficiency in graphic design, a background in corporate
- 11:17accounting, and fluency in Mandarin.
- 11:18It's totally detached from reality.
- 11:20The hiring manager is piling on all those requirements to
- 11:23eliminate any perceived risks. They want a sure thing.
- 11:26Yes, they want to ensure that the candidate has zero learning
- 11:30curve, regardless of how absurd the combination of requested
- 11:33skills might actually be in a real human being.
- 11:37I'm trying to understand the motivation behind this extreme
- 11:39risk aversion though, like what happened in the corporate
- 11:43ecosystem that made managers so terrified of a normal learning
- 11:46curve. Well, the root of this behavior
- 11:48traces back to the macroeconomic math following the 2008 Great
- 11:52Recession. OK, great.
- 11:54When the economy crashed, companies panicked and laid off
- 11:57millions of workers. However, the sheer volume of
- 12:00work required to keep those businesses afloat did not
- 12:03decrease proportionally. The work still had to get done.
- 12:06Exactly so. The employees who survived the
- 12:09layoffs were quietly forced to absorb the duties of the
- 12:12colleagues who were let go. Right, Everyone was doing the
- 12:14job of three people just to avoid being the next one out the
- 12:16door. And the data reflects that
- 12:19brutal reality perfectly. Following the recession, worker
- 12:22productivity, which measures the output per worker, surged by a
- 12:26massive 6 point 7%. Wow 6.6.
- 12:29Yeah, yet the overall economy, the GDP, only grew by 1.2%
- 12:35during that same period. So companies realized they could
- 12:38squeeze significantly more output from a much smaller,
- 12:42terrified workforce. Exactly.
- 12:44The companies learned to operate leaner than ever before.
- 12:47Because they had to. Right.
- 12:49And because they were getting so much extra labor out of their
- 12:52skeleton crews, the immediate financial pressure to fill an
- 12:55open vacancy plummeted. Oh, that makes sense.
- 12:58Yeah, if someone quits today, the manager knows the rest of
- 13:01the team will just work unpaid overtime to cover the gap.
- 13:04Exactly. The company does not feel the
- 13:06pain of the vacancy immediately. Therefore, they feel they can
- 13:10afford to leave a desk empty for six or eight months while they
- 13:13hunt for the perfect Unicorn. And because of the lingering
- 13:16high unemployment from the recession, they also had a
- 13:19influx of applicants for every open role.
- 13:22It creates what Capelli describes as the prom date
- 13:25scenario. Prom date scenario.
- 13:27Yeah, and employers are acting like teenagers who have suddenly
- 13:29been asked to the dance by 50 different people.
- 13:32I see. They are so overwhelmed and
- 13:34dazzled by the sheer volume of choices that they develop a sort
- 13:39of paralysis. They can't pick just one.
- 13:41Exactly. Yeah, they delay making any
- 13:43decision at all, constantly wondering if an even more
- 13:46flawless candidate might submit a resume tomorrow.
- 13:49Right, like maybe someone with a PhD will apply for this entry
- 13:52level job tomorrow. Exactly.
- 13:54They have the luxury of time subsidized by the burnout of
- 13:57their current staff, so they hold out for the washing machine
- 14:00part that fits perfectly. I have to play devil's advocate
- 14:03here, though. Sure, go for it.
- 14:04If I'm running a business and I have a stack of 400 resumes on
- 14:09my desk for one open position, isn't it entirely rational for
- 14:13me to be incredibly picky? It seems that way.
- 14:15Yeah, right. If the market is offering me
- 14:17someone who is wildly overqualified for the exact same
- 14:20salary I was going to pay an entry level worker, why wouldn't
- 14:24I take the overqualified person? It seems like a smart business
- 14:28move. It does seem rational in the
- 14:30micro sense for that single hiring manager in that single
- 14:33moment. But Capelli points out that when
- 14:35this behavior scales across the entire economy, it creates A
- 14:39deeply toxic environment that actually harms productivity.
- 14:44How so? Well, when employers
- 14:47systematically hire the overqualified, it means
- 14:50perfectly capable, adequately qualified people are continually
- 14:54boxed out of jobs they could easily perform.
- 14:56OK, I follow you. The candidate with the master's
- 14:59degree takes the job that requires a bachelor's degree.
- 15:03The candidate with the bachelor's degree is forced to
- 15:05take the job that requires a high school diploma.
- 15:08Everyone gets bumped down and rung on the ladder.
- 15:09Exactly, and this triggers A vicious arms race for
- 15:12credentials. Oh wow, people realize they are
- 15:15being bumped down so they go back to school.
- 15:17They take on massive amounts of student debt to get a graduate
- 15:20degree. Just to compete.
- 15:21Yes, not because the daily tasks of their target job actually
- 15:24require the knowledge contained in a graduate degree, but simply
- 15:28because they need the credential to beat out the other 300
- 15:31applicants in the queue. So the credential loses its
- 15:33actual educational value and just becomes a very expensive
- 15:37sorting mechanism for HR. Yes, and from the employer's
- 15:40perspective, hiring the overqualified candidate rarely
- 15:44results in better performance anyway.
- 15:46Really. Yeah, Capelli sites research
- 15:48showing that overqualified workers often become bored,
- 15:51frustrated and disengaged much faster than adequately qualified
- 15:55workers. I guess that makes sense.
- 15:57If you're doing a job way below your skill level, you'd tune
- 15:59out. Right, and they are more likely
- 16:02to quit. The moment of better opportunity
- 16:03arises which forces the company to restart the expensive drawn
- 16:08out hiring process all over again.
- 16:10Which brings up a fascinating dynamic.
- 16:13If employers are demanding these highly specific over
- 16:16credentialed unicorns who can execute 10 different roles on
- 16:19day one, the fundamental laws of a free market economy suggest
- 16:23they should be paying a massive premium for that rare talent.
- 16:26You would think so, yes. Does the data show that
- 16:28companies are opening their wallets to secure these perfect
- 16:31candidates? The data from both the CET paper
- 16:34and Capelli's research provides A resounding negative on that
- 16:37front. Let's get into the mechanics of
- 16:39wages then. The CE paper introduces a
- 16:42concept called dynamic shortages.
- 16:44How does that make explain what we are seeing?
- 16:48Well, in a healthy functioning market, if the demand for a
- 16:51specific rare skill rises faster than the supply of workers who
- 16:55possess it, the price of that skill, meaning the wage, must
- 16:59increase. Right supply and demand one O 1.
- 17:01Exactly. That is the mechanism the market
- 17:03uses to clear itself. If a company suddenly needs
- 17:06experts in a brand new programming language, they offer
- 17:09a massive salary. And that high salary sends a
- 17:12signal. Yes, it sends a clear signal to
- 17:14the rest of the workforce. Go learn this language.
- 17:16There's a lot of money to be made, right?
- 17:18Eventually, workers get trained, the supply increases and the
- 17:21shortage is resolved. That is a dynamic shortage in
- 17:24action. But the CEE paper notes that we
- 17:27are currently seeing massive wage stickiness.
- 17:30The wages are simply not moving in response to these supposedly
- 17:33desperate cries for talent. It's totally disconnected.
- 17:36Capelli highlights a brilliant case study involving a company
- 17:39called Mechanical Devices. Tell me about this one.
- 17:41So the executives of this company went to the press
- 17:44complaining bitterly that they had 40 open machinist positions
- 17:49they could not fill. 40 open jobs.
- 17:51That's a lot. Right, and they claimed this
- 17:53shortage of talent was actively holding back their sales and
- 17:56stunting their growth. It was presented in the media as
- 18:00a classic textbook example of the American skills gap.
- 18:03But when you dig into the actual job listing, what was the catch?
- 18:07The catch was that they were offering to pay their machinists
- 18:10$13 an hour. $13 an hour for a highly skilled technical
- 18:15manufacturing role. Exactly.
- 18:16And this was at a time when the national average wage for a
- 18:19machinist was over $19.00 an hour.
- 18:21Wow. So this company was offering
- 18:24compensation nearly 50% below the established market rate and
- 18:28then acting entirely bewildered that skilled professionals were
- 18:32not flocking to their factory floor.
- 18:34That is just wild. There's an even more extreme
- 18:37example in the book actually involving Emirates Airline.
- 18:39Oh yes, that 1 is incredible. They were trying to staff their
- 18:43cabin crews. So they organized these massive
- 18:45job fairs in the United States, expecting thousands of
- 18:49applicants to show up, right? But only a handful of people
- 18:52actually went. The airline executives were
- 18:55baffled. They genuinely thought Americans
- 18:57had just lost their work ethic. But then you look at the offer.
- 19:01Exactly. When you look at the offer, they
- 19:03were paying roughly $2500 a month.
- 19:05Which is barely $30,000 a year. Right.
- 19:08For $30,000 a year, they expected applicants to
- 19:11completely uproot their entire lives, leave their families,
- 19:15navigate international visa requirements and relocate
- 19:19permanently across the globe to Dubai.
- 19:22It's completely delusional. The problem wasn't a lack of
- 19:25people who knew how to serve drinks or demonstrate seat belt
- 19:28safety. The problem was a profound lack
- 19:31of people willing to move to the Middle East for poverty wages.
- 19:34Capelli contrasts these failures with an industry that actually
- 19:37understands how supply and demand works, which is the
- 19:40mining industry. Oh, that's a good comparison.
- 19:43Yeah, because mining is physically demanding, dangerous,
- 19:46highly specialized work, and it's often located in really
- 19:50remote areas. Not an easy pitch for a job.
- 19:52Not at all. But when the mining sector
- 19:55experienced a genuine need for more labor, they did not just
- 19:59run to the newspapers to complain about a skills gap.
- 20:02What do they do? They accepted the reality of a
- 20:04true shortage and they responded by raising salaries.
- 20:08They offered six figure incomes to heavy equipment operators.
- 20:11And I'm guessing it worked. It worked, Florida State.
- 20:14They met their staffing needs. Because people will gladly drive
- 20:17a massive dump truck in a remote quarry if you compensate them
- 20:21fairly for the hardship and the skill.
- 20:22Exactly. The CE paper argues that a true
- 20:26structural labor shortage can only be verified if an employer
- 20:29raises wages significantly above the market average, maintains
- 20:33those high wages for an extended period, and still cannot attract
- 20:37qualified applicants. And the vast majority of
- 20:39companies crying shortage have never even attempted to raise
- 20:42their starting offers. Not even close.
- 20:44The Manpower survey Capelli sites mentions that around 11%
- 20:49of employers globally admitted that candidates rejected their
- 20:53job offers specifically because the wages were too low.
- 20:57And I have to imagine that 11% figure is likely a massive under
- 21:01representation of reality. Oh, without a doubt, employers
- 21:04suffer from significant blind spots, right?
- 21:06A hiring manager often and genuinely believes that their
- 21:09offer is fair and competitive, even when it's totally stagnant.
- 21:13When a candidate ghosts them or turns down the offer, the
- 21:16manager rarely attributes it to the low salary.
- 21:19They just assumed the candidate was flaky or uncommitted.
- 21:21Exactly. They blame the applicant's
- 21:24character, not their own checkbook.
- 21:26I am really struggling with the logic of the corporate
- 21:28executives here though. How so?
- 21:30Well, if keeping a desk empty for six months is hurting
- 21:33productivity and stifling sales, as those mechanical devices
- 21:36executives claimed, why is keeping the starting wage
- 21:39stagnant worth more to them than getting a warm body in the chair
- 21:43to generate revenue? Why are they so stubborn?
- 21:45The Sea Eat paper provides A fascinating economic explanation
- 21:49for this stubbornness, actually, and it centers on the concept of
- 21:53internal equity. Internal equity, meaning how the
- 21:56pay is distributed among the people already working there.
- 21:59Precisely. Let's say a company has three IT
- 22:02specialists on staff, and they each make $70,000 a year.
- 22:06OK, one of them quits, leaving a vacancy.
- 22:08The company goes out to the market to hire a replacement.
- 22:11But they quickly discovered that the market rate for an IT
- 22:14specialist has risen to $90,000 a year.
- 22:18So they have a choice to make. Exactly.
- 22:20And the executives are terrified of paying the new hire $90,000.
- 22:25Because of the other two guys. Right, because they know that
- 22:27the moment the new hire walks through the door, the other two
- 22:31IT specialists who have been loyal to the company and know
- 22:33the systems inside and out will discover they are being
- 22:36underpaid by 20, $1000. Yeah, I'd be furious if I were
- 22:40them. Anyone would be those existing
- 22:42employees will immediately demand a raise, or they will
- 22:45quit and go to a competitor. So hiring one person at the new
- 22:49market rate actually triggers a massive company wide wage
- 22:54inflation event for the employer.
- 22:56Yes. To prevent that internal revolt,
- 22:59the company simply refuses to raise the starting offer.
- 23:02They keep offering $70,000 knowing full well it is below
- 23:06market value. The position remains vacant for
- 23:09months. The remaining IT staff gets
- 23:11burned out covering the extra work.
- 23:13And the executives go to a conference and complain about
- 23:17the massive quote UN quote shortage of tech workers.
- 23:20You've got it. That's the playbook.
- 23:21The hypocrisy is staggering. Companies are the biggest
- 23:25cheerleaders for free market capitalism when they're the ones
- 23:27selling a product. Oh, absolutely.
- 23:29If demand for their software or their cars spikes, they will
- 23:32raise the price of their goods by the end of the business day.
- 23:35In a heartbeat. But the moment they step into
- 23:37the labor market as a buyer, they completely ignore to the
- 23:40fundamental laws of supply and demand.
- 23:43They expect the laws of economics to apply to everyone
- 23:45except their own human resources department.
- 23:48It is a profound structural disconnect.
- 23:51But because these executives cannot publicly admit that they
- 23:54are deliberately paying below market wages to protect their
- 23:57internal equity right, or that they are demanding absurd
- 24:00Unicorn level qualifications for entry level pay, they have to
- 24:04find a scapegoat to explain the empty desks.
- 24:08Which brings us to the next massive piece of this puzzle.
- 24:11Yeah, blaming the supply. Yes, if the companies hiring
- 24:15practices and compensation models are supposedly flawless,
- 24:19then the problem must lie with the workforce itself.
- 24:22That's the narrative. The narrative becomes that the
- 24:25schools, the universities, and ultimately you, the applicants,
- 24:29are fundamentally broken. It is the most pervasive
- 24:31narrative in business journalism today.
- 24:33You hear it at every single corporate retreat.
- 24:35The schools are failing. Recent graduates lack basic
- 24:38cognitive skills. The new generation just doesn't
- 24:40have what it takes. Exactly.
- 24:42But Capelli takes a sledgehammer to that narrative using hard
- 24:45data. Let's dig into that data.
- 24:47Let's look at the failing schools argument.
- 24:49If you track. The National Assessment of
- 24:51Educational Progress. The NAEP test scores, which are
- 24:56considered the gold standard for measuring student achievement
- 24:59over time in the US. The scores for reading and math
- 25:02have not plummeted. They've actually improved
- 25:05steadily since the 1970's. The measurable.
- 25:07Academic proficiency of the average student literally higher
- 25:11now than it was when the executives complaining about
- 25:14them were in school. That's amazing.
- 25:16And the dropout rates for low income students, the demographic
- 25:20historically most at risk of falling behind.
- 25:23What happened to them? Those rates.
- 25:24Literally halved between 1972 and 2009.
- 25:28The workforce entering the market today is, statistically
- 25:32speaking, more formally educated and academically tested than any
- 25:35generation before it. So if the data.
- 25:37Proves that academic skills are not actually in decline.
- 25:40It forces us to ask a really important question.
- 25:43What are employers? Actually complaining about when
- 25:45they claim an applicant lacks skills, right?
- 25:48Capelli references a comprehensive Business
- 25:51Roundtable survey where employers were asked directly
- 25:54what recent graduates were missing and the answers were.
- 25:57Incredibly revealing, weren't they?
- 25:59Oh, totally. When asked to rank their
- 26:00frustrations, the top complaints were not about a lack of
- 26:04proficiency in calculus or physics or advanced engineering.
- 26:08The highest ranked deficiencies were attitude, punctuality and
- 26:12work ethic they are complaining about.
- 26:14Character issues. They are essentially frustrated
- 26:17that 22 year olds behave like 22 year olds in that same.
- 26:20Survey A lack of oral communication skills ranked 8th
- 26:23on the list of concerns and a lack of basic reading skills
- 26:27ranked 14th, 14th. The employers are.
- 26:29Not encountering a workforce that cannot read or do math.
- 26:33They are encountering a young workforce that requires active
- 26:36management, mentorship, and socialization into the norms of
- 26:40a professional corporate environment.
- 26:42They just don't want to teach. Someone how to send a
- 26:44professional e-mail or how to navigate office politics.
- 26:47So they label that lack of Polish as a skills gap.
- 26:51Exactly. It's a.
- 26:52Cop out. But what about the college?
- 26:54Degree myth. The other argument you hear
- 26:56constantly is that students are simply studying the wrong
- 26:59subjects. Right?
- 27:00The classic. Too many philosophy majors
- 27:02argument exactly. Yeah.
- 27:03They say kids are getting degrees in art history when the
- 27:06economy needs engineers and data scientists.
- 27:08Well, Capelli dismantles. That myth as well.
- 27:11The United States currently sends roughly 70% of its high
- 27:15school graduates to four year colleges, which is a huge.
- 27:18Number it is. And the data shows that those
- 27:20students are desperately trying to chase the jobs.
- 27:23Over the past few decades, the number of undergraduate business
- 27:27degrees awarded has tripled. The crippled The number of
- 27:30information technology degrees has skyrocketed 15 fold.
- 27:34Wow. The students are highly attuned
- 27:36to the market signals, and they are rushing toward the perceived
- 27:39opportunities. So if they're.
- 27:41Getting the right degrees in massive numbers.
- 27:45Where is the friction coming from?
- 27:46Why aren't they getting hired? The friction.
- 27:48Occurs because the modern technological market changes far
- 27:52too rapidly for the traditional education system to keep pace.
- 27:56Oh, I see. Capelli uses the.
- 27:58Information technology sector as the prime example of this
- 28:01failure. the IT employment market is incredibly volatile,
- 28:05right? I agree.
- 28:06And it takes a. Student four years to complete a
- 28:09traditional bachelor's degree in computer science, right?
- 28:12They enroll. As a freshman, pick a track and
- 28:14spend 4 years learning the foundational architecture.
- 28:18But silicon? Valley, by its very nature, is
- 28:20designed to disrupt itself constantly.
- 28:22Yeah, they invent a new software framework, a new coding
- 28:26language, or a new cloud architecture.
- 28:28Almost overnight. An entire sub industry can
- 28:31spring up in a matter of months. They release a new.
- 28:34Mobile Development framework on a Tuesday, and by Wednesday
- 28:37afternoon the tech CEO's are furious that they cannot find
- 28:41thousands of graduates with five years of senior level experience
- 28:44in it. That's exactly what.
- 28:45Happens they act shocked and complained to Congress about a
- 28:48severe quote UN quote skills shortage when the public
- 28:51university system has not instantly produced a graduating
- 28:55class of absolute experts for a proprietary technology that
- 28:59literally did not exist when those students enrolled in their
- 29:02freshman year. It seems like a complete.
- 29:03Failure of the IT industry to manage its own developmental
- 29:07risk. It really is.
- 29:08They are treating. The public university system
- 29:11like an on demand just in time vendor, right?
- 29:15But they never bothered to tell the vendor what product they
- 29:18will actually need in four years.
- 29:20They expect the. Public taxpayer to shoulder the
- 29:22cost and the time required to develop highly specialized
- 29:26skills while they maintain the flexibility to change their
- 29:29requirements on a whim. I want to push back.
- 29:31On this a little bit, though, let's think about the transition
- 29:34to the future knowledge economy. Regardless of whether a specific
- 29:38coding language changes, aren't jobs across the board just
- 29:42getting inherently more complex? It's a fair question.
- 29:44Like, don't we? Legitimately need a smarter,
- 29:47more highly trained, more cognitively advanced workforce
- 29:50just to survive in a modern digitized world.
- 29:53It is a very common. Assumption.
- 29:55And intuitively, you know, it feels correct.
- 29:57We look at our smartphones and assume that operating in a world
- 30:00with smartphones requires more intelligence, right?
- 30:03It feels more. Complicated, but Capelli
- 30:05counters. This assumption beautifully.
- 30:07He points out that while a very small percentage of high end
- 30:10specialized jobs certainly require more advanced degrees,
- 30:14the broad introduction of technology into the workplace
- 30:17very often reduces the cognitive and skill requirements for the
- 30:21average worker. OK, walk.
- 30:23Me through how technology lowers the skill floor because that
- 30:26sounds counterintuitive think about the.
- 30:28Role of a professional typist or a copy editor. 30 or 40 years
- 30:32ago, that job required immense, specialized skill.
- 30:36You had to have flawless spelling and innate
- 30:39understanding of complex grammar rules and the physical dexterity
- 30:43to format a document manually using tabs and carriage returns.
- 30:46On a typewriter, that sounds stressful.
- 30:48It was. If you made a structural mistake
- 30:51halfway down the page on a typewriter, it was a disaster.
- 30:53You had to start over. The human being held all the
- 30:55skill and today. Today.
- 30:57Any high school student with a laptop can open a word
- 31:00processing program that automatically highlights their
- 31:03typos in red, corrects their grammatical tense in real time,
- 31:06and formats their margins perfectly with the click of a
- 31:09button. I see.
- 31:10The technology. Absorbed the skill.
- 31:12It removed the high barrier of entry previously required to
- 31:16produce a clean, professional document.
- 31:18So the technology. Acts as a crutch or a substitute
- 31:21for human mastery, making the daily tasks easier to execute.
- 31:26Not harder exactly you. See it in retail as well.
- 31:29A cashier 50 years ago had to mentally calculate, change and
- 31:32memorize the prices of hundreds of items.
- 31:35Yeah, they had to be good at math.
- 31:36Today. A barcode scanner and a point of
- 31:39sale computer do all the cognitive heavy lifting.
- 31:43The human just waves the item over the red light.
- 31:45It's idiot proof. The argument.
- 31:47That there is a massive economy wide deficit of cognitive
- 31:51ability simply does not hold water when you analyze how work
- 31:54is actually performed today. The applicants are there, they
- 31:58are educated, and they are fully capable of utilizing the tools
- 32:01provided to them. OK, let's tie these.
- 32:02Threads together. If we know the workforce is
- 32:05statistically more educated than ever, right, and we know they
- 32:08are applying for these jobs in massive numbers, and we know
- 32:10that technology has largely made the basic task easier to learn,
- 32:14where are all these applicants physically going into the void?
- 32:18Why are the hiring? Managers looking at empty desks.
- 32:21This brings us to the most dystopian part of our deep dive
- 32:25the tyranny of the algorithm. Oh man.
- 32:28This is where the macroeconomic theories hit the very
- 32:31frustrating reality of the modern job hunt.
- 32:33It's brutal. It really is.
- 32:35Over the last two decades, corporate human resources
- 32:38departments have had their budgets systematically slashed
- 32:42right. Concurrently, the Internet made
- 32:44it possible for a job seeker to apply to 50 different companies
- 32:47in an hour with just a few clicks.
- 32:49So the HR departments. Are smaller, but the volume of
- 32:52incoming applications has exploded exponentially to handle
- 32:55this. Unprecedented tsunami of resumes
- 32:58companies is turned entirely to automation.
- 33:01They implemented Applicant Tracking Systems, commonly known
- 33:04as ATS. ATS.
- 33:05Today, software. Rules the hiring process.
- 33:07The resume does not go to a human being, it goes into a
- 33:10digital parser. The horror.
- 33:12Stories Capelli highlights regarding these ATS systems are
- 33:15just incredible. We touched on one earlier, but
- 33:17we really need to examine it closer.
- 33:19Yeah, let's hear it. There was a company that posted
- 33:21a perfectly standard engineering position and because the ease of
- 33:25on the applications they received 25,000 resumes for that
- 33:31single opening 25,000. Human beings raised their hands
- 33:34and said, I want to do this work.
- 33:36Yes. And the ATS software, after
- 33:39scanning all 25,000 documents, deemed that exactly zero of
- 33:44those applicants were qualified for an interview, not one.
- 33:47Single person, not one. Out of a small city's worth of
- 33:50applicants met the machines criteria the software.
- 33:53Acts as an absolute unyielding gatekeeper.
- 33:56Capelli shares another case study about a highly experienced
- 33:59mechanical engineer that just blows my mind.
- 34:02What happened to him? So this candidate.
- 34:03Had a master's degree in his field, he held an active
- 34:06professional engineering license, and he had three
- 34:09decades of relevant successful experience on paper, the.
- 34:12Definition of a highly qualified candidate?
- 34:14Absolutely. He applied for a standard role
- 34:16and was immediately rejected by the algorithm.
- 34:19Well, when they dug into the logs to find out why, it turned
- 34:22out the software rejected him because he had indicated on a
- 34:25questionnaire that he could not type 65 words per minute for a
- 34:30mechanical. Engineering job.
- 34:32He's not transcribing court documents.
- 34:34He's designing HVAC systems. I know.
- 34:38The software does not possess common sense.
- 34:40It treated a trivial tertiary requirement as a hard pass fail
- 34:44hurdle. That's so messed.
- 34:46Up if you did not. Meet the arbitrary typing speed.
- 34:49Your master's degree and 30 years of experience were
- 34:52completely irrelevant to the machine.
- 34:54The one that really frustrated. Me was the proprietary title
- 34:57trap. Explain how the keyword matching
- 34:59creates these invisible walls for applicants.
- 35:01Yeah, this happens all the time. ATS software relies heavily on
- 35:04strict keyword matching. It looks for the exact words
- 35:07listed in the job description to appear on the applicant's
- 35:09resume. Word for word for word, Capelli
- 35:12details a scenario where a highly capable candidate was
- 35:15rejected simply because his past job title did not precisely
- 35:19match the totally unique made-up job title used by the company he
- 35:23was applying to. Right, so.
- 35:24The applicant had spent five years successfully managing
- 35:27client relationships, but his previous employer called the
- 35:31role an account manager. But the new.
- 35:33Company trying to be trendy had titled their open position
- 35:37client Success Ninja. I hate those.
- 35:40Titles. They're the worst.
- 35:42But because the algorithm was specifically instructed to look
- 35:45for the phrase client success, it could not comprehend that an
- 35:49account manager was the exact same thing, so the candidate was
- 35:52tossed. In the digital trash because of
- 35:54a synonym. Exactly.
- 35:55A synonym. Let's breakdown the.
- 35:57Actual mathematics behind this algorithmic filtering because I
- 36:00think it explains why the talent pool appears so empty to the
- 36:04executives at the top. The math is.
- 36:06Brutal. And it perfectly illustrates the
- 36:08compounding nature of risk aversion.
- 36:11Imagine a standard job description that lists 10
- 36:14specific requirements or hurdles that a candidate must clear.
- 36:17OK, these could be years of experience, specific software
- 36:21proficiencies, a particular degree, or a keyword. 10 hurdles
- 36:25seems. Pretty standard, maybe even a
- 36:26little light for some of the descriptions I've seen lately.
- 36:29Now let's. Say a generally capable, decent
- 36:32applicant has a 50% chance of meeting any single one of those
- 36:36given requirements. OK, a coin flip.
- 36:38For each hurdle right to. Pass the ATS software and get
- 36:42your resume onto a human being's desk.
- 36:44The machine usually dictates that you must clear all 10
- 36:47hurdles. The machine doesn't.
- 36:49Grade on a curve it does not. The mathematical probability of
- 36:53an applicant clearing all 10 hurdles is 50% * 50% ten times
- 36:58over, which is not good. When you run that.
- 37:00Calculation. It means that only one in 1000
- 37:03applicants will possess the exact specific combination of
- 37:07traits required to pass the filter one out of 1000.
- 37:10So if a company gets 5 500 resumes, the machine tells the
- 37:13hiring manager that nobody is qualified and remember our.
- 37:16Earlier discussion about the Home Depot syndrome in the hunt
- 37:19for unicorns. Yeah, because hiring managers
- 37:21are terrified of taking on any risk.
- 37:23They do not stop at 10 requirements.
- 37:25They pile on 15 requirements, 20 requirements.
- 37:28They want the applicant. To have ACPA plus graphic design
- 37:31skills, plus five years of sales force experience.
- 37:35Exactly. And the probability of finding a
- 37:38match drops from one in 1000 to one in a million.
- 37:41Wow. They are essentially building a
- 37:44digital filter so incredibly tight, so absurdly specific,
- 37:48that absolutely nothing can pass through it.
- 37:51And then they sit in their empty offices, look at the blank
- 37:54interview schedule, and complain to the media that the American
- 37:57workforce has lost its edge. You know, I keep picturing.
- 38:01This ATS software as a bizarre digital bouncer at a very
- 38:06exclusive nightclub. That's a great way to think.
- 38:09Of it, it doesn't matter if. You are the best dancer in the
- 38:11world. Or if you have VIP tickets in
- 38:13your pocket. Or if you literally know the
- 38:15owner. If the bouncers programming says
- 38:18that every guest must be wearing Navy blue shoelaces and you
- 38:21happen to be wearing royal blue shoelaces, the velvet rope is
- 38:23not opening for you. Nope, you're out.
- 38:25And the wildest part? Of the analogy is that the
- 38:27bouncer isn't even looking at your feet or assessing your
- 38:29overall outfit, he is just scanning a barcode on your
- 38:32forehead that says royal blue. It is a system completely blind
- 38:36to actual human capability, which is why Capelli.
- 38:39Devotes a significant portion of his advice to helping the
- 38:42applicant survive this dystopian process.
- 38:45If you want a job in the modern economy, you have to learn how
- 38:48to beat the software. What does that?
- 38:50Entail for the person listening right now who is updating their
- 38:53resume. Well, first you have.
- 38:54To accept that your first audience is a machine, not a
- 38:58human right. The algorithm does not care
- 39:01about your beautifully designed resume with the elegant fonts
- 39:04and the creative layout. In fact, those things confuse it
- 39:08really. Yes, it wants plain text.
- 39:11You must remove all headers and footers from your document
- 39:13because the parser cannot read the accurately.
- 39:16And what about the keywords? You must use.
- 39:18Exact verbatim keyword matching. No Synonyms, No.
- 39:21Synonyms. If the job description asks for
- 39:24ACPA, your resume must explicitly say CPA, not
- 39:29Certified Public Accountant. If they ask for customer
- 39:31service, do not write client relations.
- 39:34You must echo their language back to them perfectly.
- 39:36What about the file? Format.
- 39:38Does that matter? It does.
- 39:40Capelli also advises using a Microsoft Word format over a
- 39:44PDF, because some older ATS parsers actually turn PDFs into
- 39:48unreadable blocks of code. 0 graphics, 0 pictures, 0 complex
- 39:53formatting. You're feeding data to a
- 39:55machine. It is.
- 39:57Incredibly depressing that the pinnacle of modern hiring
- 40:00technology requires us to strip away all nuance and humanity
- 40:04just to pass a keyword test. It's bleak, but.
- 40:07This leads to the. Biggest, most fundamental
- 40:09question of our entire deep dive Why is the algorithm programmed
- 40:13to look for an exact 100% keyword match in the 1st place?
- 40:16Why can't a company hire someone who meets 8 out of the 10
- 40:19requirements and just teach them the last two?
- 40:21The algorithm is. Programmed for an exact match
- 40:24because companies expect the worker to hit the ground running
- 40:26at maximum capacity on the very first day.
- 40:29OK, and they expect that because they have entirely on hand in
- 40:31their historical responsibility to train their workforce.
- 40:34The death of corporate. Training.
- 40:35This is the final piece of the puzzle, the data.
- 40:38Illustrating the decline of corporate training over the last
- 40:41few decades is staggering, and it explains almost everything
- 40:44we've discussed today. Let's hear it.
- 40:45Let's look back to 1979. In that era, when a young worker
- 40:49entered the workforce, they received on average 2 1/2 weeks
- 40:54of intensive formal training per year directly from their
- 40:57employer, the company. Acknowledged that the worker was
- 41:00green and they actively invested the time and resources to teach
- 41:04them how to perform the specific duties of the job.
- 41:06Exactly. Fast forward to the modern era.
- 41:09Capelli cites a comprehensive survey conducted by Accenture in
- 41:132011. What did it find?
- 41:15That survey? Found that nearly 80% of the
- 41:17entire United States workforce had not received any formal
- 41:21employer provided training whatsoever in the previous five
- 41:24years. Wait 80%?
- 41:2680% when half a decade without a single day of formal skilled
- 41:29development from the people who signed their paychecks, it is
- 41:32completely vanished from the corporate budget it really has.
- 41:35You see it most starkly in the manufacturing sector.
- 41:38Formal apprenticeships used to be the bedrock of the American
- 41:41middle class. Yeah, you join a.
- 41:42Trade and learn on the job a company would.
- 41:45Bring on a novice, pair them with a master Craftsman and
- 41:48train them over several years. Today, those programs have
- 41:52practically disappeared. Go on.
- 41:54Capelli notes that the number of registered apprenticeships
- 41:57dropped to just 18,000 nationwide.
- 42:00In a manufacturing industry that employs millions, are employers
- 42:04trying to? Hide this fact.
- 42:05Do they pretend they are still training people?
- 42:07Not at all. When surveyed anonymously,
- 42:09executives openly admit they will not train employees.
- 42:12Why? They cite 2 primary reasons.
- 42:15The first, predictably, is cost. Training takes time.
- 42:19It requires dedicated instructors and it slows down
- 42:22production in the short term. And the second reason the.
- 42:24Second reason is. A profound fear of poaching,
- 42:27meaning they train. Someone and that person
- 42:29immediately leaves for a better offer.
- 42:31Exactly. The employers logic is why
- 42:34should I spend $10,000 in six months teaching a junior
- 42:38developer how to code in this new language when the moment
- 42:40they become proficient my competitor across the street
- 42:43will offer them $5000 more a year and steal them away?
- 42:46So because. They are terrified that someone
- 42:49else might benefit from their investment.
- 42:51They collectively decide that nobody will invest in anyone.
- 42:55It is a classic. Tragedy of the Commons and this
- 42:57abandonment of training represents a massive fundamental
- 43:01economic shift in how capitalism approaches human How so?
- 43:05For decades, major companies operated on what economists call
- 43:10an internal labor market. How did the internal?
- 43:13Labor market function a company like.
- 43:15IBM or General Electric would hire a large cohort of people at
- 43:19the entry level. They would train them
- 43:20extensively, evaluate their potential, and then develop them
- 43:24over the course of decades. So you'd start in the mail.
- 43:26Room and end up AVP. Exactly.
- 43:28When a mid level management position opened up, they didn't
- 43:31post it on a job board. They promoted someone from
- 43:33within the organization who had been groomed for the role the
- 43:36company functioned. Like its own closed ecosystem
- 43:39today. Companies have shifted almost
- 43:41entirely to an external labor. Market meaning they look
- 43:45outside, right? They do not build talent
- 43:48internally, they simply try to buy pre trained talent off the
- 43:51shelf. Whenever a position opens up,
- 43:53they look outside the company. They try to poach a worker from
- 43:57a competitor who has already paid the cost of training them,
- 44:00which creates the. Ultimate, inescapable Catch 22
- 44:03For the person listening to this who is trying to build a career,
- 44:06it is a devastating. Closed loop.
- 44:09You need exact, highly specific experience to get the job,
- 44:12because the ATS algorithm will reject your resume without those
- 44:16exact keywords, and the company refuses to offer any training to
- 44:20bridge the gap. But you can.
- 44:21Only acquire that highly specific experience by already
- 44:24having the job exactly. You cannot get the job without
- 44:27the experience, and you cannot get the experience without the
- 44:29job. It locks out new.
- 44:31College graduates. It locks out people trying to
- 44:33transition into a new industry, and it locks out older workers
- 44:37whose previous roles were rendered by technology.
- 44:40The practical. Result of this structural shift
- 44:43is that corporations have successfully pushed the immense
- 44:46financial burden of training entirely off their own balance
- 44:49sheets and onto the shoulders of the individual worker and the
- 44:52public education system. And we see the.
- 44:54Manifestation of this in the explosion of unpaid internships.
- 44:58Precisely. Young people are being forced to
- 45:01work for free, sometimes for months or years, or they are
- 45:04paying out of pocket for expensive boot camps and
- 45:07certification programs simply to acquire the specific bullet
- 45:11points required to bypass the algorithmic bouncer.
- 45:14Let's take a step. Back and look at the absolute
- 45:16absurdity of the macroeconomic situation we have uncovered
- 45:20through these two sources today, the full picture.
- 45:22Is quite damning when you assemble all the pieces
- 45:25employers have essentially. Decided to outsource their
- 45:27entire supply chain of human talent.
- 45:30They expect the public, universities and the individuals
- 45:33themselves to shoulder the massive financial and temporal
- 45:36cost of training, yet they refuse to communicate with the
- 45:39schools to tell them what specific skills they will
- 45:42actually need in the future. Then, when a candidate who is
- 45:45paid for their own training finally emerges, the employer
- 45:48refuses to pay the fair market wage for that talent.
- 45:51Terrified of upsetting their internal equity, they use
- 45:54broken, hyper rigid software to filter out thousands of
- 45:58perfectly capable people who apply anyway.
- 46:00They refuse to offer even a week of internal training to bridge
- 46:04minor gaps in experience. And then after actively
- 46:07sabotaging every single step of the hiring process, they go on
- 46:10television, point their fingers at the workforce, and complain
- 46:14that a skills gap is ruining their business.
- 46:16It is a self-inflicted. Wound on a massive societal
- 46:19scale, the skills gap as it is popularly understood by the
- 46:23public and portrayed by the media is largely A myth.
- 46:26It's totally fake. It is a convenient.
- 46:27Narrative designed to deflect blame away from broken corporate
- 46:31compensation models, risk avert hiring practices and the total
- 46:35abandonment of employee development we have covered a
- 46:37tremendous. Amount of ground today,
- 46:39unpacking the invisible forces that are making the modern job
- 46:42hunt so miserable. Well, you really have.
- 46:44We started by. Defining the language realizing
- 46:47that true structural labor shortages are incredibly rare,
- 46:50and most corporate complaints are simply recruitment
- 46:53difficulties caused by wage stickiness and a refusal to meet
- 46:56the market price, we examine the.
- 46:58Home Depot Syndrome, where employers hunt for impossible
- 47:01plug and play unicorns because the aftermath of the 2008
- 47:04recession taught them to fear the short term cost of an empty
- 47:07desk less than the perceived risk of training a human being
- 47:12we dismantled. The pervasive myth that the
- 47:13modern workforce is uneducated or lazy, showing that the real
- 47:17barrier isn't a lack of academic proficiency, but rather a lazy,
- 47:21keyword obsessed algorithmic bouncer that throws away 25,000
- 47:26resumes because it doesn't understand synonyms.
- 47:27Yeah, that still blows my. Mind.
- 47:29And finally, we saw how. The death of corporate training
- 47:31has created a punishing Catch 22 that forces workers to finance
- 47:35their own professional development just to get a foot
- 47:38in the door. The reality?
- 47:39Of the modern job market is not a lack of talent, and it is not
- 47:42a lack of ambition. It is a complex combination of
- 47:47wage stagnation, unrealistic managerial expectations, deeply
- 47:52flawed technological filtering, and the complete collapse of the
- 47:56internal labor market. And that leaves us with.
- 47:58A final provocative thought to Mull over something that bills
- 48:01directly out of the implications of Capelli's text.
- 48:04We've talked a lot about the damage this system does to the
- 48:06applicant, but what about the long term damage to the
- 48:09companies themselves? It is a critical.
- 48:11Question if companies continue? Down this rigid path, if they
- 48:14absolutely refuse to train new talent, and they rely entirely
- 48:18on keyword algorithms to find candidates who have already
- 48:20performed the exact same job in the exact same way for a
- 48:23competitor, are they inadvertently killing their own
- 48:26ability to innovate by demanding?
- 48:28Perfect replication. They are actively filtering out
- 48:31cognitive diversity. Think about it.
- 48:33Innovation requires bringing disparate ideas together to
- 48:36create something new. But if you only ever hire people
- 48:39to do exactly what they have done before, you are hardwiring
- 48:43stagnation into your company's DNA.
- 48:45You really are. You are guaranteeing.
- 48:48That no new perspectives, no unconventional problem solving
- 48:51methods, and no fresh ideas ever.
- 48:53Enter the building. You are building a company of
- 48:56clones in a rapidly changing economy.
- 48:59Adaptability and the capacity to learn, not a perfectly matched
- 49:03keyword resume might be the only real skills that actually matter
- 49:07for long term survival. It is a profound.
- 49:09Existential risk In their desperate, short sighted quest
- 49:13to eliminate the minor risk of training a new employee, these
- 49:16corporations are taking on the massive long term risk of
- 49:20becoming entirely obsolete. We started this.
- 49:22Deep Dive talking about how the X-ray machine of the labor
- 49:25market is broken, and how we've been looking at this murky,
- 49:27confusing picture where employers scream about shortages
- 49:30while qualified resumes disappear into the void.
- 49:33Right? But I think the CE paper and
- 49:35Peter Capelli's work have finally brought the image into
- 49:38sharp, undeniable focus. It is not that society has run
- 49:42out of Ferraris. It is that the buyers are
- 49:44demanding a custom built pre race Ferrari for the price of a
- 49:47used sedan, and they're using a broken barcode scanner to decide
- 49:50who gets the privilege of selling it to them.
- 49:52The talent is out. There waiting to be utilized.
- 49:55It is the corporate hiring system itself that is
- 49:57fundamentally broken and in desperate need of repair.
- 50:01Thank you SO. Much for joining us on this deep
- 50:03dive into the true mechanics of the job market.
- 50:06Take these insights, use them to strip the formatting off your
- 50:09resume to beat the algorithmic bouncer, and never forget your
- 50:12actual worth out there in the market, regardless of what the
- 50:15machine tells you. We'll see you next time.