Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / 【Deep】Palantir Q3 Financial Analysis: Valuation, Growth, and Risks
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the deep dive. Today we're doing something a
- 0:04bit different, maybe even a bit tricky.
- 0:06We're taking Palantir Technologies, PLTR, you know,
- 0:10one of the darlings of high growth tech, right?
- 0:13And we're basically forcing it through the ringer of, well,
- 0:16really demanding debt value investing criteria.
- 0:18Yeah, it's like trying to fit a square peg in a round hole.
- 0:21Maybe or maybe not. That's what we're here to find
- 0:23out. Exactly.
- 0:24It's this conflict, isn't it? Exponential growth story versus
- 0:27the the cold hard path of traditional value.
- 0:31That is absolutely the mission today.
- 0:33You see a company like Palantir post these incredible Q32025
- 0:37numbers and it's easy to get swept up in the growth
- 0:39narrative. But you have to ask the
- 0:41fundamental question, does the current market price make any
- 0:44sense? So we'll synthesize those latest
- 0:46financials, apply that, you know, rigorous deep value lens
- 0:50and see what shakes out. Is it just a great business or
- 0:53is it also a sound investment right now?
- 0:55And you know, before we even jump into those numbers, which
- 0:58frankly are pretty eye popping, they are, we should probably set
- 1:01the stage a little because analyzing these metrics,
- 1:03especially these kinds of valuations, well, you need
- 1:06context, right? Keep the overall market
- 1:08temperature in mind. Valuations like Palantir's don't
- 1:11just pop up in a vacuum if you're trying to track, you
- 1:14know, the broader market health and you see if things are
- 1:16getting a bit frothy. Which is always a good idea.
- 1:18Yeah. We always recommend checking
- 1:20something like the Buffett indicator just for that bigger
- 1:22picture context. Agree.
- 1:23High valuations definitely tend to cluster when the market's
- 1:27running hot. OK, So Palantir is Q3.
- 1:30Why all the excitement? It took the.
- 1:31Headlines the revenue number $1.181 billion.
- 1:36That's up a massive 63% year over year.
- 1:40Huge. Jump 63%.
- 1:41Wow. And maybe even more striking,
- 1:44the GAP net income, it hit $476 million.
- 1:49That translates to, well, a very strong 40% margin.
- 1:53And just to clarify, gap means generally accepted accounting
- 1:56principle. So that's like real standardized
- 1:57profit. Exactly verified profit under
- 2:00the standard rules. Very solid numbers on the
- 2:02surface. OK.
- 2:03Let's focus on where that growth is coming from, because that 63%
- 2:07jump, it's not just their traditional government work
- 2:09chugging along, is it? No, not at.
- 2:11All the real story, the explosion, is on the commercial
- 2:14side. Right.
- 2:15US commercial revenue actually doubled.
- 2:16Doubled to $397 million. Just think about that kind of
- 2:21acceleration. It's incredible momentum and the
- 2:23customer count there. Also surged US commercial
- 2:26customers were up 121% compared to last year.
- 2:29Wow. So the overall customer count
- 2:31must be up significantly too. Yeah, Total customers hit 911.
- 2:34That's up 45% year over year overall.
- 2:37So this commercial boom really shows their core platforms,
- 2:40Gotham for government, Foundry for commercial, and now AIP for
- 2:44AI are getting serious traction outside that legacy defense
- 2:47space. What's the rough mix now,
- 2:49Government versus commercial? It's about 56% government, 44%
- 2:53commercial still, But given that commercial growth rate, you can
- 2:56see that ratio is likely shifting pretty fast.
- 2:58OK. So if that growth engine is
- 2:59firing like this, the next question has to be
- 3:02sustainability. What stops, I don't know, Amazon
- 3:05or Microsoft from just building something similar and crushing
- 3:09them? What's the Moat?
- 3:10Yeah, that's the crucial question.
- 3:12And their Moat is, I'd say, quite deep.
- 3:14It's not just about fancy software features.
- 3:17OK, first, it's the platforms themselves.
- 3:19Gotham, Foundry, AIP, they're almost like infrastructure for
- 3:24data analysis within large organizations, building that
- 3:28took decades and a lot of capital.
- 3:30Second, those established government relationships very,
- 3:33very sticky. Once you're embedded in a major
- 3:36agency, it's incredibly hard to get dislodged.
- 3:38So it's less like selling a software app and more like
- 3:41becoming the fundamental operating system for how these
- 3:44huge organizations run their critical operations.
- 3:46That's a great way to put it exactly.
- 3:48Once an agency or a big company is deeply integrated with
- 3:51Palantir's form, you get these powerful network effects and the
- 3:55cost of switching, training people, migrating all that data,
- 3:58it becomes almost prohibitively expensive.
- 4:01It's a classic high switching cost model that is a strong
- 4:04mode. And you can see that strength
- 4:06reflected pretty directly in the financials, can't you?
- 4:09Specifically, the gross profit. Absolutely.
- 4:12That's staggering. 80% gross margin, that number just screams
- 4:16scalability, 80%, it suggests that once they land a customer,
- 4:20the cost of delivering more software, more services to them
- 4:23is, well, marginal. Very efficient at that level.
- 4:27And how does their spending compare to get those customers
- 4:31like marketing? Interestingly, compared to a lot
- 4:33of other high growth tech firms, their sales and marketing spend
- 4:36is relatively modest. It seems they rely more on, you
- 4:39know, word of mouth embedded success within client
- 4:42organizations rather than just massive ad campaigns.
- 4:45Which helps keep that gross margin so high.
- 4:47Exactly. It reinforces that efficiency
- 4:49right at the top of the income statement.
- 4:51OK. So strong Moat, scalable model.
- 4:54But a great business also needs solid leadership, right?
- 4:58What about the executive team? Are they aligned?
- 5:00Well, you've got stability there.
- 5:01CEO Alex Carp, president Stephen Cohen, others in the top team.
- 5:05They've mostly been around since the early 2000s.
- 5:08Long tenure. And the board?
- 5:09Still, Peter Thiel is chair. Yep, Co founder Peter Thiel
- 5:12chairs the board. So experience is definitely
- 5:14there now. Alignment with shareholders
- 5:18insider ownership is around 7.49%.
- 5:22OK, 7.5% roughly. It fluctuates obviously, but
- 5:25maybe more telling are their recent actions.
- 5:28They started their first significant share buyback plan
- 5:31in 2025. Yeah, I saw that.
- 5:33That really stood out to me. They bought back what, 2.6
- 5:36million shares? Correct.
- 5:38And they still have $880 million authorized to buy more.
- 5:42That feels like a pretty strong signal for management, doesn't
- 5:45it? Using actual cash to say they
- 5:47think the stock's attractive, or at least that they're cash flow
- 5:49is strong enough to return capital this way.
- 5:51It's definitely a vote of confidence and they certainly
- 5:53have the financial firepower to do it.
- 5:55Their balance sheet is like a fortress.
- 5:56OK, let's check the safety boxes.
- 5:58Financially sound. Absolutely passes all the
- 6:00checks, high current ratio, tons of cash, and crucially 0 debt, 0
- 6:05debt. Which means their interest
- 6:07coverage ratio is, well, effectively infinite.
- 6:10Financially, they're incredibly secure.
- 6:12All right. So high quality business, stable
- 6:15and seemingly aligned management, rock solid balance
- 6:19sheet. This is starting to sound like,
- 6:21you know, an investor's dream. But here's where it gets
- 6:24complicated. We run into this sort of margin
- 6:28puzzle, OK, we just celebrated that fantastic 80% gross margin,
- 6:32right? Highly scalable.
- 6:33So you'd expect that to translate into really stellar
- 6:36net income, wouldn't you? Logically, yes.
- 6:39If it costs so little to deliver the service, more revenue should
- 6:42drop to the bottom line. But it doesn't, not entirely.
- 6:44This is where we have to look at the operating expenses.
- 6:46The OpEx that gross margin is 80%, which you know crushes the
- 6:50typical deep value benchmark of 40%, way above.
- 6:53But the net profit margin is only around 16%, still decent,
- 6:56but it falls short of the, say 20% benchmark we might look for.
- 7:00So. Where's the other 64% of revenue
- 7:02going between gross profit and net profit?
- 7:04That's the multibillion dollar question.
- 7:06It's a huge gap. It points directly to really
- 7:09significant spending below that gross margin line in OpEx.
- 7:13Now we can guess where a lot of that's going for a company like
- 7:15Palantir heavy research and development, almost certainly
- 7:19they have to stay on the cutting edge and the other likely big
- 7:21one. Stock based compensation.
- 7:23Very likely high stock based comp or SBC.
- 7:27It's common in tech. It keeps talent, but it dilutes
- 7:30existing shareholders and it eats into that gap
- 7:33profitability. OK.
- 7:34So the business itself delivers software cheaply.
- 7:37That's the 80% gross margin, but they're sending aggressively
- 7:41likely on people and innovation. Right, which results in returns
- 7:45like return on equity Roe around 9% and return on assets ROA
- 7:49around 7%. How do those stack up?
- 7:51Well, the ROA just barely squeaks past a 6% benchmark, but
- 7:55the Roe at 9% is quite a bit short of them more conservative
- 7:5815% standard you might want to see.
- 8:00So yeah, it's a high quality business, but maybe not yet
- 8:02super efficient at turning its assets into shareholder value
- 8:05growth. And before we pivot just a
- 8:06price, we should probably touch on the the external risks, the
- 8:10headwinds, because even the strongest moats can erode over
- 8:13time. Good point.
- 8:14What are the big ones for Palantir?
- 8:15Well, there are a few persistent ones.
- 8:17The ethical concerns around surveillance, AI usage, that's
- 8:22always there and could impact client adoption, especially
- 8:24commercially. Right, the Big Brother
- 8:26perception. Exactly.
- 8:27Then there's the constantly shifting landscape of data
- 8:30privacy regulations globally. They operate everywhere, so
- 8:33that's complex geopolitics to things like their vocal support
- 8:36for Israel recently that could alienate some international
- 8:39customers, both government and commercial.
- 8:41Potential customer friction there.
- 8:43And of course, you can't ignore the competition.
- 8:45The big cloud players, Amazon, Google, Microsoft, they have
- 8:48deep pockets and are always encroaching on the data analytic
- 8:51space. OK.
- 8:52Those are definitely serious long term risks to watch, but
- 8:55let's get to it. The real the real sticking point
- 8:58for any value investor looking at this the price tag.
- 9:01Valuation, yes. Now I know these traditional
- 9:03deep value criteria, they were developed like decades ago,
- 9:06right? Are benchmarks like PE under 15
- 9:09even relevant for a company like Palantir and AI infrastructure
- 9:13play growing revenue at 63%. That's the perfect question to
- 9:16ask. And we have to acknowledge the
- 9:18market often throws those old metrics out the window for
- 9:20companies promising disruptive growth.
- 9:23That seems like it. However, if our framework is
- 9:25deep value investing, which inherently demands a margin of
- 9:28safety, then these metrics become essential filters, non
- 9:32negotiable really. And when you apply them to
- 9:35pollunteer, well, the results are kind of spectacular
- 9:39failures. OK, lay it on us.
- 9:40Let's go through them. First, the classic price to
- 9:42earnings ratio PE. Palantir's PE is currently
- 9:46sitting at a a mind boggling 398 three. 198 So investors are
- 9:51paying $398 for every $1.00 of profit the company made in the
- 9:55last year. Correct.
- 9:56And our traditional deep value target is usually less than 15.
- 10:00OK, not even close. Next price to book.
- 10:03Price to Book Ratio PB Volunteer is trading at 34.7 times it's
- 10:06book value. 34.7 What's the target there?
- 10:09Typically under 1.5 S again, miles apart.
- 10:12That multiple basically says the market thinks almost none of the
- 10:15company's value is in its current assets.
- 10:16It's all future potential. All right.
- 10:18And the third one often used for growth companies, the PEG ratio
- 10:22price to earnings to growth. Right.
- 10:24The PEG ratio tries to justify a high PE by factoring in expected
- 10:28earnings growth. A PEG peg under 1 is often seen
- 10:31as potentially undervalued relative to growth.
- 10:34And volunteers. It's currently above 13. 13 So
- 10:37the PE is 13 times higher than it's expected growth.
- 10:40Rate, exactly. It signals extreme overvaluation
- 10:43even after you try to account for future growth using that
- 10:45metric. And, you know, tying this back
- 10:48to predictability, Palantir also fails a key historical test for
- 10:51value investors, which is consistent earnings growth.
- 10:55Value investors love to see ideally 10 years of steadily
- 10:58rising earnings per share EPS. It shows resilience through
- 11:02cycles. And Palantir's.
- 11:03Record Well, their EPS was actually negative before 2023,
- 11:07so they simply don't have that long track record of reliable
- 11:10profitability that a deep value approach demands.
- 11:13OK. So the traditional multiples are
- 11:14just completely blown out. Given that, we have to turn to
- 11:18discounted cash flow analysis, the DCF right to try and figure
- 11:22out what the business might actually be worth based on its
- 11:25future cash generation potential, ignoring the market
- 11:28noise. Exactly.
- 11:29DCF is crucial here. We need to estimate the
- 11:32intrinsic value. We used a base free cash flow
- 11:35figure of $1.14 billion. That's based on their recent
- 11:37performance and we applied a pretty standard 10% discount
- 11:41rate to account for risk and time value of money.
- 11:44All right, So what growth rate do we need to plug in to justify
- 11:47the current stock price, which is trading around what, $207.00
- 11:51per share? Roughly 207 dollars, Yeah.
- 11:53And the goal here is to see what kind of sustained perpetual
- 11:56growth rate is mathematically required by that price.
- 12:00The results they should probably make any value conscious
- 12:02investor pause. OK, walk us through the
- 12:04scenarios you ran. Start conservative all.
- 12:06Right. Most conservative the no growth
- 12:09case. Let's just assume Palin 2's free
- 12:11cash flow stays flat forever from today's level.
- 12:13OK value. Intrinsic value comes out around
- 12:15$4.89 per share. $4.89 sure versus 277, OK.
- 12:23Obviously no one expects 0 growth.
- 12:25What if we assume a little? Let's try a very conservative,
- 12:28but maybe slightly more plausible 5% perpetual growth
- 12:32rate forever. Value then.
- 12:34It bumps up a bit to about $7.74 per share still. 774 versus 207,
- 12:40that's a massive gap. But look, 5% growth feels way
- 12:44too low for a company whose revenue just grew 63%.
- 12:47Agreed. It's unrealistically low for
- 12:49Palantir right now. So let's jump up, Let's try the
- 12:51nominal case. We assumed a very aggressive 20%
- 12:54growth rate sustained indefinitely. 20% forever.
- 12:58That's already a huge ask for any company long term.
- 13:00It really is. Only the absolute best tech
- 13:02companies manage that for extended periods, but even with
- 13:0520% perpetual growth, the intrinsic value only gets to
- 13:07roughly 20, $5.33 per share. $25 still nowhere near 207.
- 13:12Growth. Not even close.
- 13:13This tells you the market isn't just pricing in strong growth,
- 13:15it's pricing in truly extreme, almost unprecedented long term
- 13:18growth. So what kind of growth rate does
- 13:20it take in the DCF model to even get into the same ballpark as a
- 13:23current price? We had to push the assumptions
- 13:26to what I'd call the optimistic extreme case.
- 13:29We modeled A frankly eye watering perpetual growth rate
- 13:32of 35% every single year, forever. 35% growth sustained
- 13:38forever from a multi billion dollar base?
- 13:41That seems extraordinarily difficult, maybe impossible.
- 13:45It's incredibly difficult to imagine, but even under that
- 13:48extremely optimistic scenario, the highest intrinsic value we
- 13:51calculated was approximately $73.63 per share.
- 13:55OK, let's just pause and absorb that $73.63.
- 14:00That's the result assuming 35% growth forever.
- 14:03So even if we grant Palantir this wildly optimistic, arguably
- 14:06unattainable 35% perpetual growth rate, the calculated
- 14:09intrinsic value is still less than half, dramatically less
- 14:13than half of the current market price, around 207 dollars.
- 14:15That's the stark finding. The DCF, even with heroic
- 14:18assumptions, cannot justify the current valuation according to
- 14:21this framework. It basically confirms that the
- 14:23current share price embeds expectations for future growth
- 14:27or maybe future margins that are just well, they seem
- 14:30disconnected from the underlying financial reality we can model
- 14:33today. The gap is severe hashtag tag
- 14:36outro. So let's try to synthesize this
- 14:38whole deep dive. Palantir, the business, it's
- 14:41demonstrably high quality in many ways, right?
- 14:44Phenomenal gross margins, check. Robust growth, especially
- 14:48commercially, check. Debt free balance sheet, check.
- 14:51Management seems aligned. Check.
- 14:53Lots of check the valuation multiples.
- 14:56They place it so far outside the bounds of traditional or even
- 15:00loosely interpreted deep value investing criteria that it's
- 15:03almost hard to comprehend just. Completely different universes.
- 15:06For a value investor demanding any kind of margin of safety,
- 15:09the data basically screams that it's just not there at this
- 15:12price, not even close. OK, so here's the final thought.
- 15:15Something for you, the listener, to really wrestle with when you
- 15:17see a market price like $207.00 so far removed from even the
- 15:21most aggressive, optimistic intrinsic value calculations
- 15:25like that 73 threader number. What exactly is it that you are
- 15:29assuming? What external factor, what
- 15:31future event, what level of dominance that isn't in the
- 15:34current numbers are you implicitly betting on?
- 15:36Yeah, what story are you telling yourself?
- 15:38Are you betting the market itself will just stay
- 15:39irrational, or that valuation metrics for tech have
- 15:42permanently changed? Or are you truly convinced
- 15:45Palantir can achieve a level of growth and profitability that
- 15:48frankly seems almost physically impossible based on the data we
- 15:52just went through? That underlying assumption,
- 15:54yeah, that's where the real risk and maybe for some the perceived
- 15:57opportunity truly lies. Something to think about.