Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Promotion Without an Annual Review
Transcript
- Lucas: Alright, let's start with a listener question that came in last week. Sam writes: 'I've been at my company for two years, taken on major projects, but there's no formal review process. How do I even start the promotion conversation?' Luna: Oh, that's a good one. A lot of people are in that boat, especially at startups or smaller companies where performance reviews are more informal or nonexistent. Lucas: And honestly, if this kind of advice helps you navigate your career, and you feel like it's worth a coffee to you, we have that link. It's buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That's the only way we keep this show ad-free. Luna: It's a small ask, but it really helps us keep going. Appreciate everyone who's supported us so far. Lucas: So back to Sam. The first step is to create a document of your accomplishments, but not just a list of duties. You want to quantify impact wherever possible. Luna: Right, like 'increased sales by 15 percent' or 'reduced onboarding time by two weeks.' Something concrete. Lucas: Exactly. Even if you don't have hard numbers, you can estimate. I had a listener once who said she saved the company roughly $50,000 by automating a manual reporting process. That's a powerful data point. Luna: And it's not just about the numbers. You also want to note any new responsibilities you've taken on that go beyond your original job description. Lucas: Yes. Once you have that document, you need to schedule a dedicated meeting. Do not try to have this conversation in a one-on-one that's normally about project updates. Luna: How do you frame the meeting request without sounding pushy? Lucas: Simple: 'I'd like to schedule 30 minutes to discuss my career growth and contribution to the team.' That signals intent without demanding a promotion outright. Luna: Okay, so you have the document, you have the meeting. What next? Lucas: Prepare your talking points. Start with why you love the company and the team. Then walk through your accomplishments with data. Then state what you want: a promotion to X title, or a title change if the role itself has evolved. Luna: And practice it out loud. I always recommend running through with a friend or even recording yourself. It sounds obvious but it makes a huge difference. Lucas: Totally. Now, during the conversation, one common pushback is 'there's no budget right now.' How do you handle that? Luna: You can ask for a timeline. Like 'When would it be possible to revisit this?' Or propose a six-month check-in with specific milestones. Lucas: And you can also negotiate non-monetary things: a title change now with a raise later, more responsibility, or a stretch assignment that builds your case. Luna: A listener I know did exactly that. She asked for a senior title and got it without a raise immediately, but six months later she got a 10 percent bump when the budget freed up. Lucas: That's smart. The title is often easier to get than the money, and it positions you better for the next move, whether inside or outside the company. Luna: What if the manager says no to both? Like flat out, 'you're not ready'? Lucas: Then ask for specific, measurable criteria for what 'ready' looks like. Get it in writing. That gives you a roadmap and holds them accountable. Luna: And if they still won't commit, that's useful information. It might be a signal that it's time to look externally. Lucas: Exactly. But most managers do want to retain good people, so if you present a strong case, they'll at least consider it. The key is preparing well and framing it as a conversation about value, not entitlement. Luna: To circle back to Sam: the first step is building that document. Don't wait for a formal review that may never come. Lucas: Right. Take ownership of your own career narrative. You don't need an HR system to advocate for yourself. Luna: I think that's the big takeaway. Be proactive, be specific, and be patient but persistent. Lucas: Yeah, and if you want more detailed templates, we have a resource on the show notes at our website. Thanks for the question Sam, and good luck. Luna: And if you have a career question you'd like us to tackle, send it in. You can find us at fexingo dot com slash office hours. Lucas: Alright, that's it for today. We'll catch you next time.