Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / #CHannel-Is the BGG Top 100 fit for purpose?
Transcript
- 0:00So Steve, you're in Spain. I am Ben. This is a rare
- 0:06remote edition of what this is a hang on? Come on, you can
- 0:11do this? But actually it's in the link channel. Yeah, exactly,
- 0:15And do you know I'm in the States when we do this? Exactly?
- 0:17And do you know why it's perfect you're in Spain? Why's that? Because
- 0:21you always speak a loadable? This is hashtag channel, a podcast of a
- 0:29discord with Ben and Steve. Well, actually a hashtag means it's a channel,
- 0:42all right, Steve, here we are hashtag channel. Then I know,
- 0:47I know everyone thinks it's a bit, right like that. I don't
- 0:51ever know like what show it is or definitely yeah, can can you explain
- 0:56to the listeners that it's not a bit? I really don't know. No,
- 1:00I mean the thing is right, I'm the I'm the which is which
- 1:03is why five Games for Doomsday is the powerhouse that it is is. I'm
- 1:06the organizational brain behind it, and you're just simply the crazy improvisational talent.
- 1:12Imagine that. So this one is main feed, main feedure it's coming out
- 1:22this week. Do you have to be a patron to contribute? No?
- 1:26Just remember anyone can go to five G for d dot com. Yeah,
- 1:32and join the Discord and possibly contribute to one of our like dickhead discussions about
- 1:38hot board game topics. And I just want to say to people who are
- 1:41listening to this and suddenly think what Steve doing calling the listeners of the podcast
- 1:47terrible names with affection it is then if you join the Discord, you become
- 1:52a discored dickhead. And we're all Discord dickheads, so it's fine. I
- 1:56mean, some more dickheady than others. I'm mentioning no names, but you
- 2:00know, I mean if you're a board gamer, like, come on,
- 2:02look at yourself in the mirror. You know what you are. You know
- 2:06what you are, especially as if you join the Discord you can join a
- 2:09new list that has been put together by CD Hunter, in which not only
- 2:15do you have the ratings of games on BGG, you have the ratings that
- 2:20you've given games, but also the average rating of the members of the five
- 2:24G for D Discord, so you can see how we vary away from the
- 2:30bggs. This list has already broken my heart, though I have to be
- 2:34honest explain well, I looked at it and like the it shows you like
- 2:39the distance you are from other members. And I don't know if this is
- 2:43in the aggregate or on an individual basis, but I saw that the farthest
- 2:47person away from me is none other than Matt Green. He can't be the
- 2:53further CD Hunter lives in bloody New Zealand. No, no, not by
- 2:57distance. In rating ratings. Yeah, actually CD Hunter and I are quite
- 3:01close and rating sentiment. But I believe that Matt Green is actually putting like
- 3:07thought into his ratings and trying to create a more or less even distribution.
- 3:12He's taking advantage of the entire rating scale, which I suppose is what a
- 3:16scale lends itself to. But since no one else does that, and everybody
- 3:20rates things like seven and above, it makes him look like a bit of
- 3:23an outlier. But you know, Paul ar Abdolh song or song about that?
- 3:25Didn't she which one opposite its attract So you know it's not necessarily over
- 3:32for you and Matt Green, Steve. That's a good point, isn't it,
- 3:36And maybe we have we have a lot to learn from each other exactly.
- 3:38You can have a communal refertilization of each other's intellect. Beautiful sentiment all
- 3:47right, So we're going to open this talking about the thing that's been buzzing
- 3:53around the internet. At the moment, I'm going to get deeper into this.
- 3:57Sorry, the European election no no, no, no god no no,
- 4:01no, no no, no, British election, no no, no
- 4:04no. None of that politics is unimportant. I think did Nigeria have an
- 4:09election? I'm sure, I'm sure loads of places had elections of the American
- 4:14election. Obviously, no one cares about any other election besides that one.
- 4:16So we're talking about the thing that's buzzing on the internet. In the board
- 4:20game world that hands in glook. Not only have they have they copyrighted the
- 4:27word meepole, which they didn't invent, by the way. And not only
- 4:30have they done that, they have then stopped another game producer printing a game
- 4:39with the word meepole in the title. They get a cease and assist letter.
- 4:43So my question to you is, when a word is so intrinsic to
- 4:50this hobby, do you think it's justifiable that it can be copyrighted by another
- 4:56company? So did they copyright it in Germany or well, it's seeming what
- 5:00I've read they copyrighted a full stop so I'm not an expert in copyright law,
- 5:08but I am a middle aged man. Yes, more or less makes
- 5:11me You've got opinions for day, yes, everything. We do have an
- 5:15official five G for d lawyer. So I do hope hopefully CD Hunter will
- 5:19comment on this. I mean, do we need hope? Is hope necessary
- 5:24for this? What do you mean, like, do we have to hope
- 5:27that he chimes in? No, we don't have to hope. I mean
- 5:30there's no hope. I mean, definitely will he knows. We can just
- 5:32sit here, you know, with dead air until he does. I mean,
- 5:36you will eventually chime in. I could, I could actually discord him
- 5:40right now, probably, yeah, he would. Let's wait till this is
- 5:44released. That's more fun interacting with the show. Yeah. No. My
- 5:47my understanding or assumption I guess, is that you have to make some kind
- 5:54of a case for a copyright, and that case rests in part on what
- 6:00is happening in the public domain. I remember that Xerox used to run ads
- 6:05and the tenor of the ad was, don't use the word Xerox to refer
- 6:12to copying, because you know, we would casually use it as a verb,
- 6:14like to xerox something, because apparently if the word becomes so common in
- 6:19usage, you lose the copyright that there's something about the ubiquity of the language
- 6:26that makes it the public so something as soon as something becomes a generic word,
- 6:30you no longer have the right to copyright it is that? Is that
- 6:34what you're saying? Yeah, I believe so. And I think Google actually
- 6:38took the opposite tack in that they wanted to encourage people to refer to searching
- 6:43on the Internet as googling because it makes them feel like the default solution,
- 6:47which I think is more intelligent what Hans and Gluke gets out of copywriting people.
- 6:53I'm really not sure, Like, how is this a valuable piece of
- 6:56intellectual property? I think that you know, I don't know, like at
- 7:00what stage the like the copyright process is at. Maybe you're better informed than
- 7:05I am. I know nothing about this, but I would first of all,
- 7:10you can send anybody a seasoned desist order for anything. It doesn't mean
- 7:12it's going to stand up in court, right, I'd be surprised if this
- 7:15didn't get challenge. It doesn't make any They changed the name of the game.
- 7:19Well, they may have responded to the season desist because they were afraid
- 7:24of the awesome power of Hans and Gluck trist. What is it called?
- 7:29This is the the Tristerio Conspiracy from the City of Algsborg, isn't it.
- 7:32This is a Crying of Lot forty nine reference for anybody. You know,
- 7:36I've read the first two chapters and I couldn't get any further. So that's
- 7:40Gravity's rainbow. I don't think I could get through two sentences. Crying of
- 7:43Lot forty nine, though, is a bit more digestible. She'd give it
- 7:46another go anyway. I someone you know, this is a good point.
- 7:51You know, maybe maybe they're going to get away with it because nobody's want
- 7:55to take a risk knowing because you have to, like you would have to
- 7:57spend money on a legal team to challenge this. Right, you know,
- 8:00hands in Gluk are just being hands in Gluke. Right, hands in Gluk.
- 8:05Yeah, Well, the thing is, what's ironic? Is I am?
- 8:09What's ironic is hands in Gluke. Hands in Gluk is not something they
- 8:16no certain The ironic thing is hands in Gluke is an old fairy tale.
- 8:20So they've stolen their bloody name of their company to begin with. So the
- 8:26thing is, I've got two points. One, I don't see why you
- 8:30would seek to damage your reputation to such a great degree when for doing that,
- 8:37because the meeple is the central image of the board game world, right,
- 8:41it's when you when hobby gamers if they if you had a central image,
- 8:46it would be the mepal, and it would be the word maple.
- 8:48And secondly, they didn't invent the bloody word maple. It was an American
- 8:52journalist in the year two thousand and four referring to Carcassan, right, referring
- 8:56to the Meeples from Carcassan. But of course they originally hands in Glook called
- 9:01them followers, right, So their original their original publishers of Carcassone. Yeah,
- 9:09and they they called them followers, right. And so someone else came
- 9:13up with a name meeople, and they copyrighted it in twenty nineteen. And
- 9:16it's completely outrageous that it's like copyrighting the word carburetta or something. I mean,
- 9:22you just simply can't write. I just I just don't. I just
- 9:26don't see the point. I stand by my initial opinion that their dickheads,
- 9:30I mean a lot of these games are just like ripping off from public domain
- 9:33stuff. Okay, so I just realized Hans in Gluk is not what I
- 9:37was thinking. I was thinking of Torn and Toxis. But like every fucking
- 9:41German thing is a reference to a fairy tale or a legend or something historical
- 9:48like board games. I mean, this is a beautiful thing about the board
- 9:50games, right they they emerge from our collective consciousness and our collective culture,
- 9:54and every once in a while there's something something new emerges, like the term
- 10:00to describe, like I don't know, a common phenomena, a common aspect
- 10:05to the hobby. And and I think it's brilliant when it happens. We
- 10:07can all share it. And now Hans them Gluke wants to own it for
- 10:09themselves, which I can almost understand if it were worth anything, but worth
- 10:13point, if it was worth anything, I mean they haven't. The thing
- 10:18is, they haven't charged anyone else in the in the past. I mean,
- 10:22how many bloody the thing is. And if they if they demand that
- 10:24people stop using the term mepole, people are gonna get really pissed off the
- 10:30bout that. And I think with justification and it beggars belief that they would
- 10:37think to do it. Maybe you have to even like show I don't know
- 10:41what it's called. There's like harm is done by people using this term to
- 10:46their business. I think that would be very hard to show. And you
- 10:50know what this maybe we should just basically announce the first ever five G for
- 10:52D boycott of a board game company. Well, I think I'm changing the
- 10:58name of the podcast to fuck hands him glook. The Maple Hour is what
- 11:03I'm changing the podcast to now. Now the thing is this may have to
- 11:09like change it on every fucking change it on the discord, the website,
- 11:13the fucking It's fine, it's fine. I mean, you're right, it
- 11:16has to be done. Yans to have a yans to hammer folkman will do
- 11:18it. We're canceling the next print run of the more Stephen the f T
- 11:24shirt because it's got five G for D on it. Someone exactly you want
- 11:28to change? Yeah, if you want your more Stephen the feed t shirt,
- 11:31you got to go to sir meple dot com slash five G for D.
- 11:33I think how many are left? Like two? Maybe? Max?
- 11:37Yeah, last chance literally literally last chance. God, you're slick anyway,
- 11:43let's move on to after altogether too much consultation with the greatest minds in the
- 11:50world, topics we present this is all right. So I went out to
- 12:01the discord dicads and I asked them a question because I interviewed someone and they
- 12:07talked about how the BGG rating system wasn't really fit for purpose. And if
- 12:13you wanted to look at what is indicative of the people on BGG, you
- 12:18shouldn't look at where they stand where they stand in the ratings. You should
- 12:26look at how many ratings they have. Right. I don't think that's very
- 12:31good because they could have five thousand and one ratings, right. I don't
- 12:37think that's indicative of the quality of the game. It's indicative of the popularity
- 12:41of the game. But first of all, I want to ask you how
- 12:45central is BGG to your life as a board gamer of BGG itself or the
- 12:54rankings, No, BGG itself. First of all, just as a by
- 12:58way of introduction, I like to think of it as as very central,
- 13:03but I you know, I see the way some people engage with it,
- 13:05and I'm not even close. I mean, I don't really post to forums.
- 13:09All I do is I look stuff up on it, and I rate
- 13:13things, and the only reason I rate them is it's my way of keeping
- 13:16track of what I've played, because I certainly don't. Despite Big Kas demanding
- 13:20that I log all my plays, I never remember to do it. So
- 13:24in my imagination it's very central because it's sort of like the source of truth
- 13:28for all gaming lore, and like I'll refer to it if I want like
- 13:33a decision on a rule, because usually there's an FAQ or chat in the
- 13:39forum about you know, a corner case and a game, or if I
- 13:41want to download the PDF, like sometimes i'll buy a game in German,
- 13:46I want the rules in English, that kind of thing. So it's a
- 13:48tremendous resource. It's a you know, sina quanone I would say, right,
- 13:52yeah, So what I love about BGG is that it's all things to
- 13:56all people, right, So me as a content within the board game world,
- 14:01it's invaluable because I mean two which kind of I mean board games themselves
- 14:07being being like a bit of a jank analog hobby. I think it kind
- 14:11of makes sense kind of the website, but the thing is as well also
- 14:16with sort of people who were just well into the hobby it's really useful as
- 14:20a database, but also it's a social media platform and it's a it's a
- 14:26community. As much as you hate the word, and as you say,
- 14:30it's right. If you've got an issue and the game is older than six
- 14:33months, that will be on BGG. And what really surprises me with BGG
- 14:37is that it's managed to remain for twenty five years the central repository for this
- 14:45hobby and as you say, where they've basically not really done much to the
- 14:48interface. The UI is pretty bloody terrible can and you can go relive the
- 14:52early arts Internet exactly exactly. So yeah, I mean I once got not
- 15:00into a row with someone on Twitter, but I tweeted during the fun Drive
- 15:05because I fund them every year. I give them some money every year,
- 15:07I said you should go out and do this because Board game Geek is absolutely
- 15:09central, and this person sort of said Board Game Geek is terrible, screw
- 15:13them. I'm not giving them any money, And that really surprised me that
- 15:16someone would have a reaction. So moving on then the BGG rating system.
- 15:26So the reason I thought about asking this question not only because I had someone
- 15:30talk about it on the podcast, but because you are someone who likes to
- 15:37compile a canon. You've been on a sort of mission for the last five
- 15:41years, I think, to compile a sort of canon of board games.
- 15:45What are games that should be revered within this hobby? To what degree does
- 15:50BGG help you with that? And the top one hundred, specifically the top
- 15:56one hundred, I think not at all, but is a tremendous help.
- 16:02So I said a moment ago that kind of half jokingly that if you want
- 16:07to go relive the early days of the Internet or the early days of the
- 16:10web, that least, just go to BGG. And it actually is true.
- 16:12In this case. The whole point of the World Wide Web is not
- 16:15to go shopping or the original point, but to go to to serve content
- 16:22that links to other content that's relative relevant to what you're looking for. Right,
- 16:27So you you you end up following threads of conversations and various forms of
- 16:34content. And then this is what it's been great for for me in trying
- 16:38to put together this canonical list, because there are loads of games I just
- 16:41haven't heard of, and you you stumble on these conversations where you know there
- 16:48are people are talking about roads and boats, and then they mentioned maybe LaHave
- 16:52or they meant Laha is not a not a very good example because it's extremely
- 16:56well known. But now now I'm actually because I have I have this list
- 17:00of games that I wouldn't I wouldn't have known otherwise if it weren't for going
- 17:07through this process of just like stumbling on like conversations from ten years ago where
- 17:15just people mentioned like well if you if you've played that, then you've got
- 17:18to play this, and and then you know, and then I go to
- 17:22Essen or I go to Berlin Bretschpielkhan, and I can get stuff on the
- 17:26secondary market that's that's not that expensive, and just like fill out my collection
- 17:32and try for myself. I mean, it's it's fucking great. So I'm
- 17:37going to ask you some question. Here here we go. I found my
- 17:40I found my list, my never published geek list because I never I was
- 17:45never completely satisfied with it. But here are a few games that I didn't
- 17:48know about that I discovered just through poking around on board game geek. So
- 17:56that the Luve Inherits is definitely one, Cathedral is definitely one, Kless is
- 18:04definitely one. This is really exciting content. There are a few other ones
- 18:15that you and I have played together that like they're sort of okay. They
- 18:18basically they have an interesting idea and it's worth playing the game once to get
- 18:23a sense for that idea because they are like a lot of games contributed a
- 18:26lot of interesting ideas to like the evolution of mechanisms, and then they're just
- 18:32completely Why should we have a canon? Though? Why why do you have
- 18:37that sort of impulse in you to compile a canon? I mean, it's
- 18:41like slightly on the spectrum list making, isn't it. That's true? But
- 18:45but is it? Do you think that you want to confer a seriousness to
- 18:55games that you maybe feel that they're they're not getting that they that they are
- 19:00not getting the renown that they deserve in comparison to other art forms. Well,
- 19:07I mean I take it seriously, and I want to I want to
- 19:12know where like things come from. You know, I am kind of an
- 19:18amateur historian in that sense, like I want to understand the roots of the
- 19:22hobby. I don't want to have missed important games from gaming history, because
- 19:30like there is a bit of a gap for me where I was playing games
- 19:33and I wasn't and I was again and a lot of stuff came out that
- 19:37I just I just missed along the way, and some of the stuff I've
- 19:40rediscovered. I think like there's a lot of great stuff that didn't influence anything
- 19:45and stand up to games that are being published today. I think a lot
- 19:48of trends in gaming today are not Like a lot of games are being produced
- 19:52that are not really for me. I think they're just too heavy and complicated,
- 19:56and they're just like boxes of content right that publishers are trying to sell
- 20:00well, and twenty years ago you get a lot of solid games that were
- 20:04forgotten and deserve to be remembered. I don't know. I mean that's just
- 20:10me though. I think it's not something that everybody should go do. So
- 20:11another one Big City is another which which was great, Which was and we
- 20:15wouldn't have discovered without your sort of slightly obsessive researching. So I'm gonna ask
- 20:21slightly slightly la Chita, remember that one Lachita? Did we play Lachita?
- 20:27I played it? Yeah, I think you played it with me. I
- 20:30mean I definitely played it with people. Yeah, pretty sure. I'm gonna
- 20:33ask you some questions and you're going to answer it. About the BGG Top
- 20:37one hundred. So do you think it helps new games? Fine? Games?
- 20:41Yeah, I didn't really say anything about the Top one hundred. I
- 20:44think I just don't pay any attention to it. It doesn't seem to change
- 20:47that much, so I wouldn't say, like, it doesn't evolve a whole
- 20:51lot. So what am I supposed to do with it? Like what is
- 20:52it? What is it for? Like you suggest like a new player should
- 20:56consult the Top one hundred in order to like should they just go and buy
- 21:02Brass Birmingham. I mean, that's the number one game, right, And
- 21:04so I think the Top one hundred is Once since I've been into gaming,
- 21:10had a game that I think should be bgg's Top one hundred in the sense
- 21:15that if you're a new gamer and you go there, you buy it,
- 21:18and it tells you everything you need to know about how wonderful hobby gaming is.
- 21:23And that was that brief time when Pandemic Season one, Pandemic Legacy Season
- 21:27one was number one. That would be a moment when that was number one
- 21:33that I would not only say conceivably could be the best game ever made,
- 21:37but also for a new person coming into the hobby and thinking I want to
- 21:42play the best game ever made that they could take that and that would convert
- 21:48a new person into a gamer, because it's so bombastic and exciting and unlike
- 21:56what you expect ball games to be. Right, So I want to I
- 22:00want to take a little bit of a risk here by disagreeing with you that
- 22:03being in particular. I know, I know it's generally not permitted in the
- 22:07five G for D universe. That disagree with with with Ben Maddox. I
- 22:12think you're right about the quality of the game. I don't think it's the
- 22:15best entry game unless like not not not not by yourself. Like, I
- 22:22don't think a person who doesn't have a group should go out and buy this
- 22:25game and then try to figure out how to play it with their family or
- 22:29something like that, or their friends. I mean, maybe it could work.
- 22:33I'm a little bit skeptical. I mean, maybe do you think that
- 22:34that would work. I kind of think that you you need someone to like
- 22:37that you should be a player of that game with a group that's already I
- 22:41think the way Pandemic Legacy introduces Pandemic, which is not a difficult game for
- 22:47us but for non gamers might be, is great actually one of the first.
- 22:52It was the first game I ever bought when I wasn't a gamer,
- 22:55and me and a couple of people worked out how to play it. And
- 22:59because it's though not Pandemic Legacy, Yes, but the first game in Pandemic
- 23:03Legacy is a game of Pandemic, actually a slightly simple version of Pandemic.
- 23:07So actually I think it's great. Second question, does the BGG Top one
- 23:11hundred tell us which of the best games of all time? I mean,
- 23:17there's no objective way of knowing that, right, but you can give me
- 23:19an opinion. I mean, when was like, are you'll never you're never
- 23:23shy about giving an unsolicited, completely unresearched opinion. Well, to the extent
- 23:30that best best anything of all time is going to be crowdsourced to be worth
- 23:33anything, then I suppose it gets us the closest we possibly can get to
- 23:38the wisdom of the crowd, whether they actually are the best games of all
- 23:44time. I mean, this is gonna I mean, I mean answer is
- 23:48just no, isn't it? Because also this list is really it's really biased
- 23:53toward newer games for the moment. Well, that was my next question.
- 23:56Is it riddled with recency bias. Yeah, I mean, I don't think
- 24:00there's any way to avoid that. Because as the hobby expands, the newer
- 24:04games are going to get more attention, they're going to get more ratings.
- 24:07There's probably a bit of rating inflation going on. And I don't know.
- 24:11I mean, Marcus the Dog Shepherd, I believe, is a statistician right
- 24:15in the in the discord, Yeah he should, he should tell us.
- 24:18Yeah, he probably has some thoughts on this that I'd be interested in hearing.
- 24:22So, actually, Marcus, Marcus the Dog yea online isn't it can
- 24:27just interrupt each other all the time? Fucking finish your sentence. Yeah,
- 24:32I think I think at best the top one hundred list and and the ratings
- 24:34in general are a useful heuristic because there's so much information on Board Game Geek
- 24:41about games like how do you decide? I mean, it's very hard to
- 24:45do it starting with nothing. I mean, probably a game that has a
- 24:48very high rating on BGG isn't going to be terrible. But there are a
- 24:52lot of great games that don't have very high ratings, and those are going
- 24:56to be harder to find. And then you need, like people to share
- 24:59their opinions with you. So Mark is the dog shepherd, firstly, he
- 25:03says, and you know this has elevated him in my eyes. Are the
- 25:07top one hundred good recommendations for good gamers? No, of the recent number
- 25:11one games only Pandemic Legacy Season one is a pretty good entry for a generally
- 25:17interested person. Boom boom boom. But then he says, does it have
- 25:19recency bias? And he says strongly. Not only does the BGG user base
- 25:25increase constantly and a few new users go back, and few new users go
- 25:29back to rate their older games, but also the ranking is constructed to favor
- 25:33new games. Whilst the way the score is calculated a Baysian average does take
- 25:38into account the number of ratings. Oth Swann is currently number seventy three with
- 25:42four thousand, six hundred ratings. Even considering the small print runs in the
- 25:45hobby, that's a ridiculously small number to be counted amongst the greatest games of
- 25:51all time. Do you agree with him? I mean, I basically just
- 25:55said all that except for the last bit. So yeah, the thing is,
- 25:57I think you need to know how many what is an average rating for
- 26:03games in the top one hundred right. Well, I mean he's claiming that
- 26:07it's a small amount, but I don't know if that's true or not because
- 26:10I'm too lazy to check. Well, he has a whole have you read
- 26:11his blog. I think he's an actual research into this. I'm sure he
- 26:15has right, he's run the numbers. I mean, his blog's actually quite
- 26:18interesting. I commend it to the listeners. All right. I don't know
- 26:22what it's called though, so sorry, sorry, dog, go to the
- 26:27discord. Go to the discorder. He'll tell you. Yeah, so ceedee
- 26:30Hunter says, Yes, I think it's fit for purpose. The BGG ranking
- 26:34system is supposed to be similar to the IMDb. It does a reasonable job
- 26:38of doing that. Does it tell us the best games of all time?
- 26:41No? Does it help new gamers find games? No? Not really.
- 26:45It never really did this. But my anecdotal impression is that it might be
- 26:49worse at this than say, fifteen to twenty years ago. That said,
- 26:52it might be the move away from the middleweight euros more than anything. And
- 26:56I think it's interesting his comparison there with the IMDb Top one hundred. I
- 27:03think he's brilliant. Actually, it's a very apposite comparison because if you look
- 27:08at the the BGG, you look at the IMDb Top one hundreds, and
- 27:12Shore Shank Redemption is number one, and yeah it is, Yeah, And
- 27:18I don't think it as determined by what. It's the same as BGG user
- 27:22crowd voting, right, And so I have no idea. What's fascinating is
- 27:27the the first time I sure saw Shawshank Redemption might be the most enjoyable film
- 27:33watching experience I've ever had, But I wouldn't say it's the best film ever
- 27:37made. But what it does do is kind of tell you what the film
- 27:42viewing public considered to be the best, rather than a sort of critical eye.
- 27:48And I think BGG is exactly the same, right the top one hundred.
- 27:52Do you think Rotten Tomatoes is any better? I know that some people
- 27:56stand for that reading system more than IMDb or others. Well, I I
- 28:02don't know enough about it to be able to comment, But I mean,
- 28:03do you have an issue with BGG crowd sourcing the the opinions? Do you
- 28:11sure how else you would do it? Like? What what? What?
- 28:15What do they claim is the purpose of the ratings? And like these top
- 28:18ones? I don't know, but I assume it's I assume because it's it's
- 28:22gamers want to write stuff, right, It's there. They're an implicit desire
- 28:26to rate things and to compare things, right, And I guess, I
- 28:30mean, do you think it I guess do you think because it's crowdsource,
- 28:33it's devalued? No, not particularly, It's it's initially a question about the
- 28:41whole purpose of the thing. I mean, I think it is just scratching
- 28:42an itch, right, does it actually have value? I don't know how
- 28:45would you rate chess? I don't want to fucking play chess, But I'm
- 28:49not going to say that a game with that kind of like hoary legacy is
- 28:52a bad game. I'm just like, I'm not interested in participating in like
- 28:57chess world. I wouldn't even know how I would rate it on the BGG
- 29:03scale, Like how do you compare chess to fucking Haunted Tutanica? You know,
- 29:07Like it's like they occupy entirely different realms. Like at best, some
- 29:11of these rating systems are are basically like they're like like meta industrial, you
- 29:19know what I mean, Like they sort of they support the board game industry
- 29:22or they support board game publishing, but I don't know that they have any
- 29:27like merit on their own. Well, Chess is a fascinating example, right
- 29:33because gamers don't play chess by and large gamers, board gamers play all this
- 29:38other stuff, Chess is no longer to reger within the hobby board game worlds.
- 29:42And I guess, I guess Chess is. It's got to be.
- 29:47It's got like way more staying power than any other game, right, Like,
- 29:49yes, but that's not what the BGG hundred's for, is it.
- 29:53The BGG Top one hundred is to try and explain to us what we And
- 29:59I know you deny, but I mean you're like a flat earther at this
- 30:02point. What we as a community consider the games that not only are being
- 30:08played, but that should be played right, And I think, I think
- 30:11real classics remain. It could be that BGG is just a giant hype machine.
- 30:18It could be though, though I don't, I don't don't, I
- 30:22don't necessarily think so, Okay, Doribund So he says it was a really
- 30:26good source when I started, Similar to any top ten videos at the time.
- 30:30It's recently biased might work to its advantages. It helps new users find
- 30:34relevant games that they can buy. All lists would be subjective, So he's
- 30:41got no issue with how it works. After some time, you can tell
- 30:42what your taste is, and you just stopped bothering about rankings. Its main
- 30:48purpose now is more entertainment. Just sit and observe people arguing about some arbitrary
- 30:52numbers on a game. Now, that's interesting, right, because I think
- 30:56it's true that the longer you become a gamer, the less these kind of
- 31:03things are important to you. Right when I got into games, the reason
- 31:07I chose Pandemic is because I watched the top ten people's choice from the dice
- 31:11Tower and it was Pandemic was the one that stood out, and I thought
- 31:15that that sounded really interesting. But my attraction to a game is nothing to
- 31:22do with that sort of ranking anymore. Right. That's that's interesting though,
- 31:26that you so this is the first game that you bought. Yes, so
- 31:32you had played a lot of games before. It was not really unusual unusual
- 31:37to me that you would already be consuming like board game content before buying your
- 31:42first game. I think that that's got to be that's got to be an
- 31:47edge case, because I really don't think so, I don't know, I
- 31:49don't know, do we have any actual So I wasn't that people like a
- 31:53new gamer goes to Board game Geek to see what the top one hundred is
- 31:56as a way of guiding their purchasing decision. I wonder I think that actually
- 32:00happens. I feel like most like people who are on Board Game Geek are
- 32:04already like hardcore gamers, and they're unlikely to be people who go there to
- 32:08find a game to buy. But I you know, is do we have
- 32:12anecdotal evidence that anyone has actually done this, like they go look at the
- 32:15top one hundred lists. Well, never let it be said, never let
- 32:16it be said that you don't you don't listen. But I it was the
- 32:22Dice Tower was talking about. So but no, no, I know,
- 32:23I'm just saying, as far as like the top one hundred list being useful
- 32:27for this purpose, is this this has come up a few times. I
- 32:30guess it's kind of analogous to you watching the Dice Tower to you know,
- 32:35But I don't know if people actually go to bgg dot com and or Burgingbeak
- 32:39dot com and like use the top one hundred list the guid they're purchasing decisions.
- 32:43Well, I I wasn't into games and I moved to Berlin and I
- 32:46wanted to do something. I wanted to do something that wasn't drinking. I
- 32:49mean, it worked out, it worked out perfectly. In fact, do
- 32:52you still want to do something that isn't drinking? No, No, I've
- 32:54got I've got past a certain age, and I all I want to do
- 32:57anymore. But the point is right, I just went on YouTube and typed
- 33:00in best board games of all time and the Dice Tower was the only game
- 33:04in town at the time, and so I watched I watched them, and
- 33:07that's why I was watching board game content. But also the thing is,
- 33:12there is a habit. There is a habit I fall into that I'm sure
- 33:15loads of people do. Is when you want to buy something, you end
- 33:19up consuming a lot of content about that thing, and then you end up
- 33:23getting into certain YouTube channels that are really good. I'm watching a lot of
- 33:28guitar pedal stuff at the moment because I'm getting an electric guitar and I want
- 33:31to know what pedals to go with my guitar. But I'm also watching it
- 33:35for entertainment and so and so. There is that aspect of it. But
- 33:39your German neighbors are going to love that, love it anyway, oofaga,
- 33:45he says. When I was getting back into board games in the mid noughties,
- 33:46I looked out for SDJ winners and recommendations from friends. By the early
- 33:51teens, BGG and YouTube was where I was getting all my pointers. Then
- 33:53the Kickstarter Big Bang happened. I became a superbacker within two years. Then
- 33:59I discovered pod cat. This was perfect information. We don't talk about that.
- 34:02Then came the apocalypse and it is the five g F D discord that
- 34:06has superseded everything else. All the other stuff is useful, but it's the
- 34:09dickheads that reign supre What do you think of that, Steve, I mean,
- 34:14I think I know who the poster of the month is going to be.
- 34:17Never let it be said that blatant flattery won't work, because it certainly
- 34:23will. Yeah. Well, I mean I'm interested in You're like, so,
- 34:31do people do their research before they buy games? Is this the thing?
- 34:35I mean? I guess I have in the sense that I'm putting together
- 34:38this like canon of older games, I'm doing it in that sense. As
- 34:42far as new games, I think I'm very impulsive. I think there's a
- 34:45lot of impulse purchasing when it comes to board games. And I'm grateful for
- 34:51the curated opinions of the Discord dickheads because it has also influenced me, as
- 34:55have many guests on you on your show. I mean, I think the
- 35:00people that you have on like, there are people whose opinions are worth listening
- 35:02to by and large. And I've bought loads of games based on these recommendations,
- 35:07but like not without like going and reading reviews or watching videos just on
- 35:12their say so essentially. So so it's interesting. It's interesting that because it's
- 35:16cheap, cheap to try basically. Yeah, But the thing is, I
- 35:21think you go through a journey, right, I think once once, I
- 35:24think you sort of come round in a circle. At least I have.
- 35:29So when I when I was getting into games, I did a lot of
- 35:32research because I wanted to know what triggered what triggered you to do that,
- 35:37Like, because I wanted to I knew I knew nothing about it, and
- 35:40I wanted to know what was good. Then once I'd fallen into the hobby,
- 35:45I was just scattered on. I just bought anything that had a cool
- 35:49cover basically, And you know, I think you went through that phase too,
- 35:53and I think we're both out of that phase. And now when I
- 35:58buy a game, I want to know what people think about it. Now
- 36:02I might not use YouTube, I might use discord, like Ufaga said,
- 36:07but but I'm much more again looking at whether people think the game is good
- 36:15before I buy it, because I'm more discerning now, and it's only certain
- 36:21games that are made by certain designers that I'll buy Sight unseen right, whereas
- 36:24previously I would just buy anything if it had a cool cover. You know
- 36:28what I mean? Yeah, I mean this is one reason I'm grateful to
- 36:31have the five G for D community. So I often say there's no board
- 36:36game community, but we like this. This is a community, and these
- 36:42people are so critical of everything that like, I think the best games don't
- 36:49come from the top one hundred list. They deliquest out of the combined irascable
- 36:53opinions of this group of dickheads, and I can't go wrong. So Kathulhu
- 36:58dream says, egg Top one hundred jumped the shark when Brass was pushed a
- 37:02number one in response to gloom Haven being woke. Now, I don't want
- 37:07to use that particular example, but I think it's interesting that the culture wars
- 37:15have permeated everything that they permeate board game Geek right, and in a sense
- 37:22permeate the board game Geek Top one hundred. And when I got into games,
- 37:29I was so surprised that the sort of cultural bullshit seemed to not be
- 37:36a factor. And I think a large part of that was the fact that
- 37:39Tom Vassel just said no politics, zero politics, and you've seen it creep
- 37:45in. And I mean, do you see cultural bullshit in board games?
- 37:53M sure seems like almost a loaded question. It depends how we define culture
- 38:00war bullshit. I mean, occasionally there'll be a little note in a game
- 38:05that is a disclaimer about the like cultural appropriation or or or whatever of a
- 38:12particular theme. You know, like was it in Mombasa that I saw this?
- 38:16You know, just so you know, the cover art is in no
- 38:21way meant to denigrate the you know, rich and interesting culture of Central Africa.
- 38:29I don't remember what it said. It was something along these lines.
- 38:30And Okay, are these statements meant to get you off the hook? I
- 38:37mean they reprinted Mombasa as an entirely different game, right, Yeah, So
- 38:40I think it's I think it's interesting that for me was a dereliction of duty.
- 38:45They said, this isn't really thematically connected to the area. If you
- 38:51want to read about something, you can go off and read it. Why
- 38:53the hell then, would you, especially something that's so fractious. Why would
- 38:58you set a game beeple abound to get annoyed by it? But I think
- 39:01I think BGG it never really occurred to me. I didn't know that Brass
- 39:07was being pushed to number one because of gloom Haven being woke. I mean,
- 39:09I think Brass is a better game than gloom Haven. That not that
- 39:13I've got a lot of experience with it, but I but I have noticed
- 39:17that there is one and I'm not gonna mention names because I'm a classy bird,
- 39:23but there is one moderator on BGG who will ban people from BGG if
- 39:30they disagree with him politically, and he wields the ban hammer incredibly and I
- 39:37think it's and I think I am of the view that BGG should be a
- 39:44place for what I like with. I've seen comments on the five GVD discord,
- 39:49for instance, that I fundamentally disagree with, But I would never think
- 39:53to ban people unless they're uploading really heinous shit, right, And so and
- 40:00so. I'm and this guy is banning people literally for kind of saying moderate
- 40:07staff that doesn't agree with him politically, And I think BGG should I think
- 40:12this guy should be fired from being a moderator. I'm not saying his name,
- 40:15but for fear I get fired, I get kicked out of BGG.
- 40:19But but also I think BGG should should really aim to be politically neutral.
- 40:22Do you do you not think? I mean, I find very little in
- 40:27that to disagree with. I can't believe that the person is able to continue
- 40:32as a moderator behaving like that. I mean, there should at least be
- 40:35some kind of they go on they go on Twitter, They go on Twitter
- 40:38and brag about the people they've kicked off. This is some kind of virtue
- 40:44signaling, right I I I think that's pretty terrible. And this person's conduct
- 40:50as a moderator ought to be reviewed. As far as culture war bullshit content
- 40:55in games, Otherwise, most of it seems rather superficial. I mean,
- 41:00one might choose to be annoyed by it, but like, where does it
- 41:04affect the game? Are there such qualities that start to impact mechanisms? Like
- 41:08have games become in some sense two forgiving or too easy or too approachable.
- 41:16I mean, plenty of them still aren't so hard to say. I mean
- 41:21that would be like the one influence I could imagine they have on the actual
- 41:24artistic merit of a game. Everything else is like what like like the art,
- 41:30the graphics, the representation, the presentation of the packaging. And you
- 41:34might not like it, but it seems like mostly harmless to coin a phrase,
- 41:38so fbd, Isaac Shalev says, and we'll have this as the last
- 41:42comment. But I think it's interesting is he says, BGG has suffered the
- 41:45same in shitification that Twitter has, and he's mostly a post apocalyptic battleground of
- 41:51ratings paladins versus ratings trolls, all sponsored by late capitalist crowdfunding publishers seeking to
- 41:58be funded in under three point one one seconds. Do you see that?
- 42:07Famed board game designer Isaac shallb obviously spends way more time there than I do.
- 42:10So this is like, this is sort of like a summation in a
- 42:15much more pointed fashion of a few thoughts that I've had, but I just
- 42:21don't I can't say I'm not there that much. The thing is, I
- 42:24think this is basically is. I think clearly there are aspects of this that
- 42:29is true, but I think it's massively hyperbolic. I find a lot of
- 42:32good in BGG, and I don't think it's been completely enhitified. And I
- 42:37think the top one hundred I think, to wrap up my views on this,
- 42:40I think the top one hundred is massively useful. And also I aspire,
- 42:47as stupid as this may be, to play as many of those games
- 42:52as I can, because I see real value in the games there, and
- 42:57I think they reflect a very brawl palette of quality within this hobby. Do
- 43:02you agree with another agreed or disagree? Like I said, I don't really
- 43:07look at the top one hundred lists, So if you find it useful,
- 43:10then use it. I'm sure you're right about it's it's it's representation of the
- 43:16hobby, although I haven't looked. I mean, are smaller games like card
- 43:21games that you advocate for? Are these as well represented? I think that
- 43:23would be a point if it did have aspects that are as FPD Isaac Shalev
- 43:30describes, I wouldn't be surprised, like when I said before, that BGG
- 43:34could be just a giant hype machine. You know, you have to like
- 43:37follow the money or consider the boundaries in traditional newspapers between editorial and advertising.
- 43:42Right, Like BGG depends to a certain extent on board gaming being a giant
- 43:49hype machine because people pay for the content and board game publishers pay for advertising,
- 43:53and by by stimulating and hyping the hobby, BGG generates more attention for
- 44:00self and for I mean, it's like mutually reinforcing. I just haven't become
- 44:05quite as cynical about it as famed word game designer Isaac Shalev. But then
- 44:08again, he is a designer and a publisher, and I'm sure his feelings
- 44:13about the whole landscape are different than mine as a as a sort of you
- 44:15know, casual user. For me, there's only upside. I haven't experienced,
- 44:21like too much downside using BGG. I kind of don't want to,
- 44:25you know, I kind of want her to be some like what can I
- 44:29use the term safe space on the internet for me? Can I use that
- 44:34the loaded culture war? Yeah? But you know what I mean. So
- 44:38all right, let's move on to in an act of willful competition, we
- 44:44present our all right, Stevie, this is your this is the biggest decision
- 44:52you have to make every month. I'm talking about every aspect of your life.
- 44:55This is the most important decision you have to make. And this is
- 44:59who was not that I don't know. Is this month our poster of the
- 45:02month. I mean, through faga all the way. It's got to be
- 45:06who faga? Yeah, yeah, caveat, caveat. You're not gonna get
- 45:09Poster of the month every month simply by kissing our asses. It worked this
- 45:14time because it was an extremely cogent piece of ass kissery. But I don't
- 45:20want to start. I don't want to see like future hashtag channel threads polluted.
- 45:23Well I kind of do, actually, But I'm all for compliments.
- 45:28But you might not not you might not win the coveted Poster of the month
- 45:31award, but you better have the best one. That's all I'm trying to
- 45:34say. All Right, lovely, that was our all right, Stevie.
- 45:45Just to wrap up then, first of all, tell our listeners how'd you
- 45:47join the discord? As we so often announced to the listeners of the main
- 45:53Feed podcast episodes such as this one, if you'd like to join the conversation,
- 45:59And and I mean this sincerely, this has become for me, my
- 46:04home port on the internet. I know social media I have on my phone.
- 46:08Yeah, yeah, like you, I no longer. I mean I
- 46:10haven't paid attention to social media for a very long time. I think that
- 46:16social media was a fifteen years ago thing. And now we're all like re
- 46:21separating back into our little communities where we feel welcome and valued, and we
- 46:27don't think anyone is going to, like, you know, deliberately try and
- 46:31destroy our lives. And if you would like to where am I going with
- 46:36this, If you too would like to be a part of that community,
- 46:38please go to five G for d dot com, click the pins post at
- 46:42the top of the page, and that will take you to the discord,
- 46:45where, within within minutes you could have your most strongly held beliefs totally invalidated
- 46:52by your dreams. CD Hunter and FBD Isaac Shualas also go to iTunes give
- 46:58us five stars. I've stopped being modest about this now, just bloody do
- 47:01it? Give us five stars, write a review. You can also go
- 47:06where Steve like you to support the show. You can go to Patreon dot
- 47:09com slash five G for D, and I challenge you to support the show
- 47:15at the level I do. I think every dollar, every euro, every
- 47:19pound, every Swiss franc, every yen, every kangaroo pealth, I think
- 47:23that's what they use in Australia is worth contributing to this endeavor so that we
- 47:30can continue making these shows. I have a great time. I know Ben
- 47:35does, and you know, if we may humbly ask for your support,
- 47:39please please give Ben your support. This is not for me, This is
- 47:43for Ben. He does all the work. I just show up and you
- 47:46know, never really remember what I'm doing or why I am here. But
- 47:50I too, am a supporter, So please become a supporter like me.
- 47:53And if you want some swag to go along with your twenty five euro a
- 47:58month pledge that I know you're about to make dot com As we said,
- 48:01only two T shirts left? Do you want to have more? Steven the
- 48:04feed T shirt? Only two left. So finally, just to wrap up
- 48:07and say thank to everyone who contributed, everyone who backs the show, everyone
- 48:10who joined the discord, and all of you out there who were listening.
- 48:15And it just leaves me to say say goodbye Steve. Goodbye Steve. Without
- 48:28you, this show wouldn't exist, So really you're to blame, so thank
- 48:32you for listening. And oil up your ears for the next hashtag channel.