Latest / SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day! / Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 254:6-256:1

Transcript

Shulchan Aruch Orach Chaim 254:6-256:1 · SHULCHAN ARUCH YOMI: Own the Halacha in 25 minutes a day!

0:02
Okay, good morning. This year.
0:03
It's France for salima for you mean.
0:05
Marty Rock? Lester about clear, if gonna be
0:07
more innocent man IMA okay, just two quick questions out there
0:13
Desi ourselves. So there's a canal is that if a
0:17
person does an ester on Shabbos for Shabbos regarding health
0:22
oshawa's, there's a canal that you can't benefit until after
0:26
Shabbos until the time it takes him to do.
0:28
It does this, apply the Object. A shiatsu that you have to.
0:32
Wait, it could be half an hour or an hour or whatever it is.
0:36
Did you have to wait, is this apply for a Jew or non-jew any
0:41
takers? It's just a part of a Jew or
0:43
non-jew begin. This is there a cannot serve
0:47
because they, she has to that. You have to wait.
0:49
Or can you use it if it was done this or you can use it right
0:53
after Shabbos. so, the answer is By a mere Allah Aku, more a
1:01
mirror legit. When you tell someone to do it
1:03
for you, it makes a huge difference.
1:05
If you told the Jew or non-jew cause all were only goes there,
1:08
if you told a non-jew because who would tell her Judah doing
1:13
this on Shabbos, they didn't think to make such a zero.
1:15
But if you yourself, we learned recently.
1:18
If you yourself to the Ester, like you did an ester of hsieh
1:21
Hazara, one of these, you saw him.
1:23
So M. Abandon even if a Jew did it?
1:25
He has to wait in order to get benefit.
1:27
We say she asked him. Okay, makes difference on the
1:30
same exact scenario, but the concept of because a shiatsu
1:33
actually applies to a Jew, just as much as a non-jew, unless
1:37
it's a mirror, okay? And one last thing, we've been
1:41
reading a lot about myths. They can Vivace things look like
1:44
cooking. So we know shh leaving things
1:47
are Shabbos? That depends how you have to
1:50
leave it. The black no black, right?
1:51
Got of a cartoon. So that's an issue of we're
1:55
afraid. Maybe you're going to come to
1:56
stoke, the coals or turn up the flames.
1:59
There's no mikham of our show, but whenever you want to return
2:02
something Friday night, or put something on the on the oven or
2:08
stove on Shabbos morning, the issue is, it could be, maybe
2:12
you're going to increase the heat.
2:14
The other issue, is it could be what they call myths, they can
2:17
move a shell. It looks like you're cooking.
2:20
What's the problem with looking? Like?
2:22
It's cooking. So, the they don't most of the
2:25
postgame don't really explain it.
2:26
They just say, mix. They come of Oshawa and it's uh,
2:28
sir. So it's unclear exactly.
2:31
It's perhaps or likely some form of Maria sign.
2:37
It could be. It's a problem because we're
2:39
afraid it's going to leave for you to then continue and do some
2:43
kind of visual and Shabbos and it could perhaps be some kind of
2:48
a stir of Zozo. It doesn't looks like you're
2:51
cooking, it's just inappropriate.
2:53
But I don't have a complete Clarity if there is any Okay,
2:57
inside known dollar, okay, rationed, solid valve, see,
3:03
Bobby, maternal, Bishop? I feel amazing.
3:06
And if you what are we talking about?
3:10
We're talking about boy, metallic are talking about
3:14
putting on bread and you want to put it on shot.
3:18
You want to put it in the oven if you do it by mazeed.
3:21
We're talking about, let's say a person be amazed.
3:23
It's stuck bread dough, really, and you put it into Attached it.
3:27
You put it in the oven. That's a bit Sinister, derisive
3:30
of a fear Vishal. So what happens?
3:34
Muto, military lawyer, Dot card. Him.
3:36
She affect the person himself. Who put it up there.
3:40
Of course you should take it down right away.
3:43
Because even though it might be in this order abundant to take
3:46
it down, we want to make sure it doesn't turn into an ester.
3:50
The writer the Esther could be. If you're taking it down with
3:53
the fancy special kalium or perhaps it smokes.
3:58
So either way it's considered in this order, abundant to take it
4:02
down but for the person himself to avoid being an ester, dare I
4:05
say we say take it down. If there's a real because maybe
4:16
we'll start up again today. So yellow, your holy day is,
4:21
there's tequila to vent to prevent them from being over the
4:24
Esther Scylla, the perfect day. He himself should do this, but
4:28
other people should not do an ester, their abundance or
4:31
someone else to avoid the astir. Dare.
4:33
I say the one exception. Many say is if the person did it
4:37
bonus? Yes.
4:38
But they say, even if someone else did it to show gig, just
4:42
let it be okay. Zayn batana, ream shallow new.
4:47
She ain't let him Radia. And our ovens, we don't stick it
4:50
to the walls. We just put it on flat on the
4:52
grades, muhtar load. See you at are Mishler, stood up
4:54
mr. King of assumed of our Sheikh
4:56
ABO from your coma calmly at CB rocket mission to Mexico during
5:00
the hall. So he says nowadays, it's not
5:03
without sticking on the wall so you can take as much as you
5:05
want. Just do it with flashy Nuit.
5:08
Not don't use your regular utensil for taking down, taking
5:13
out bread, in the oven, just use some other utensil that's not
5:17
normally used because if you use this special plea, it's my new
5:22
card for baking. So then it's Mexico of doing the
5:25
hall, and it's inappropriate. So that's okay.
5:29
Head, where you marry, Adam coderre associate.
5:33
So, these are some kind of kidney has some kind of beans of
5:36
some sort. You can't make this kind of a
5:38
Dish. Which one was seen being taken
5:40
to talk at another Arab Shabbat some local Association.
5:42
Basically you can't start cooking it raw.
5:45
Right before Shabbos, why we've measured very mellow and I'm 35.
5:49
Mm, be shoe rub with. I truly am Aquaman the outer.
5:53
So if you put it on right before Shabbos, and again, it's like
5:56
any food that cooks easily, then we're afraid you might come to
6:00
play with the fire. I'll move in Aqaba.
6:02
Be Shillings. Bosh will call you car even if
6:05
you put it there completely wrong, right?
6:06
We learned by a big. Chunk of rock helmet.
6:10
That would be okay. But here, it's talking about
6:13
Simon the cooks quicker, all right?
6:14
Him Keisha are top shelf, so he clearly by shovel only special
6:17
codes are closed, Australia shelter.
6:19
This is already learned all this already by putting it on your
6:21
sharpest syrup shh who had in akhirah the kupaka and it
6:26
applies to a cure and Coop up and including our ovens.
6:29
Now how God what he said this earlier, but there are ma saved
6:33
it for the end that we're talking about because she ain't
6:35
on goofy mukha to me me the extra locked up.
6:38
Talking about it's not Garner from Khartoum.
6:40
So obviously if you have a proper blast or a hot plate, you
6:44
can put on your vegetables or whatever you want to cook.
6:46
Even if a cook, sir easily right before Shabbos, it's another
6:50
problem. Be my sock and a few of the
6:52
sugar. Again, if you did it'd even be
6:54
show, Greg suhr emotes, a Shabad Canisius.
7:00
So then if you did it but even if you did, it'd be showing you
7:02
can't eat benefits. This is if you put it on right
7:05
before Shabbos or shortly before Shabbos, it wasn't cooked.
7:08
Even commercial blender acai and there was no, the cases if there
7:12
is no block, right? So, usually we always have a
7:14
black or a hot plate so it's not an issue so then, right?
7:18
But otherwise you have to wait, but we mentioned today shiatsu.
7:23
Tet, kale table later Mi, a habitual mind, retain the toxin
7:28
or are of Shabbat in Kinshasa. We misaki, nacirema say Shabbat
7:32
big day. She asked you again picked a
7:34
chasseur. So what's the case?
7:37
We're talking about here in oven, or on top of an oven on
7:39
top of the stove? This is you can put water right
7:44
before Shabbos. The same problem.
7:46
This is an issue in the same issue of hsieh that we have for
7:49
other Foods. The applies to water, even
7:52
though water could be, you could drink it while it's raw, right?
7:55
And you can just same with like fruit same thing, but once you
7:59
decide to cook it, you have this gazzara you can put it on the an
8:03
open flame and open stove, right before.
8:08
Right before Shabbos. Unless it's cooked we say a
8:11
fully and the other depends, the Roma.
8:16
At least be at least chemical been draw sigh.
8:20
So, how does that play into into water?
8:24
So you can't see the water. Ideally to keep it simple.
8:27
You should heat up the water boil, the water before Shabbos,
8:31
and then there's no issues even if there's a right and there's
8:35
no issues, even if there's no blah.
8:38
What if you just remember right before Shabbos?
8:43
Again, if you have a black, these issues.
8:44
Don't apply a hot plates, a question.
8:47
Maybe we'll get to it at the end.
8:50
Maybe the hot plate needs to be covered.
8:51
Maybe not. So anyways so then it's but
8:55
let's say you want to just turn it put it on right before
8:57
Shabbos. So What's Ma call Brenda side
9:02
when it comes to water? So there are different opinions
9:05
out there. The egos Moshe says to be safe.
9:08
He wants you to wait, basically till it's got selected.
9:10
Both pretty much 45 degrees Celsius.
9:13
Can make sure that it's not because it's a very unclear.
9:16
What's ma called Bender aside when it comes to water many, I
9:21
did see one opinion that say 25 degrees, although I don't know
9:25
if I would rely on that that's most make of opinion because
9:29
he's basically Basically saying half of 50 degrees and he's
9:33
assuming 50 degrees is the absolute latest book.
9:37
I saw that I'm going to cut above but I saw a picture of us,
9:41
he says 35 degrees. So it's getting hot, but it's
9:44
still not yet selected. Well, I saw heard from of corn
9:48
felt ashamed, the mission Umbra. He said, it's how he interprets
9:52
the mission over that it's has to be that it's considered, and
9:57
it is rational, because my Uncle Ben's voice.
9:59
I To be words, edible, right? So, what's an order?
10:06
The minimum of the market vendor site for water would be the
10:09
amount that it's drinkable but and considered hot.
10:13
You want to ask for a hot cup of drink.
10:15
So again this is a bit subjective but if you want to
10:18
hike up with drink at a certain point, you it's you know, around
10:21
talking about you want scalding hot, you know, tea or coffee but
10:24
if whatever you would consider hot and drinkable, then now
10:28
would be concerned and you Don't spill it out into the sink.
10:31
So then that would you would consider ma called Bender side.
10:34
All right, just one thing, I don't think I mentioned before
10:38
on yet so let it go in general. I don't know if everyone would
10:41
agree but the venue's high rights and obviously some do
10:45
follow it. That's for sure.
10:46
That, you know, we don't walk around with a not a thermos,
10:52
what you call it thermometer, you know about, am I supposed to
10:56
know what it is? So he basically says, as long as
10:59
you can eat an entire I think it's, you know, it's not yet
11:01
selected book. Okay okay, did we finish?
11:07
Yeah. Race none.
11:08
Hey okay. Raishin and hey this lockers not
11:11
so not so common for us, except for maybe if you go camping or
11:15
you heat up your house or cook by a fireplace raishin.
11:19
And hey, I cannot how do you prepare the fire before Shabbos?
11:21
So Olive a nothing Madura. Maid seemed somehow cachaça, you
11:25
don't start making your fire your bonfire right away.
11:30
Right before Shabbos. I'd, she had seat behind at
11:32
work. You have to make sure that the,
11:33
the bonfire caught. It's, well, it's well lit.
11:37
It's well into its burning stage, the alien ship today.
11:40
I shall have it, hola malleable EC, U 8C McLaren.
11:45
So you're going to have your main cogs of what you want to
11:47
make sure it's fully but it's fully engulfed and it's going on
11:53
its own and it doesn't need any help anymore.
11:55
Doesn't need little Twigs all around it, to keep it going.
11:59
That's how you started. But It's got to be on that
12:01
stage. The Emu, eights your CD and if
12:04
it's one log of wood, so if she has her or barovia / / K, fo so
12:10
it has to be the majority of its of its of its width and
12:16
circumference And length the Imam low Hood lacock, but if
12:21
it's not full, it's not didn't catch well enough.
12:26
So then I sir, Leonard Barbara shibata, then you're not allowed
12:28
to use it. That job is to be 0 at
12:29
Chemeketa. Bob was were afraid you're going
12:31
to play with it, to make it better viene de 18 and to move
12:35
around. The the Twigs.
12:37
Are there? The the wood could, they should
12:40
to Aisha Levites in order to make it grow?
12:42
Okay, so, who would laka assure? And once it's lit enough, your
12:46
holy common connector, be Shabbat.
12:47
At least Amish Laura. Then you have no problem to be
12:50
next to it. Warm yourself up to use the
12:53
light to see things in the room because they have been in.
12:57
He a gobby karka or Gabrielle Menorah, okay, doesn't matter if
13:01
it's on the floor or higher up I feel he means writing Shana
13:04
cement patio Shabbat even if you don't use it for wax allowed to
13:08
use it. reading the separate topic coming up later,
13:37
we can't be, we can't tell you that there's no Say that is no
13:40
option and it's not as common. So I think so I mean you can
13:48
wear it to no end and say Okay no heat and no talent and
13:51
Chavez. And that's we're going to get to
13:54
shortly, which is completely a sir because you're following the
13:57
crime. So good question.
14:00
Yes. Own room.
14:01
Should we pack em in? I feel lower husband at work.
14:05
At a kosher Shari. Some say think that's how you
14:08
pass s generally. If he just says, he's shown with
14:11
Natalie Parsons just, not every not many of the rezoning salads,
14:15
but okay? So you show me.
14:17
If you have calls once they cut, it's good enough.
14:21
I'll just a little bit, it doesn't have to be so much
14:23
because we know you've been a shame though.
14:25
Kim, the Hokum once they catch their, they don't go out.
14:28
And I just get stronger and stronger.
14:31
Guillermo murder. Our show's official.
14:34
Go official cash. You gave us all these less
14:37
flammable or less strong. Fuel supplies.
14:44
Okay. Straw things like that.
14:46
I feel a little husband at work. Ella koshu, Shari once it just
14:50
catches a little bit that's enough.
14:52
Oh, can we do? I shall call him shoulder.
14:53
You need to marry him because she moves are him and so too.
14:56
When you have some other Twigs or these an economy, I don't
15:00
know. I'm kind of reads.
15:01
I'm not sure exactly and pits from Tomorrow dates when they're
15:06
spread out about am haqqani magadha's.
15:09
But the reason why it's okay is because once it catches your
15:13
we're not afraid, you're going to come to play with it because
15:16
the truth is even if you play with it you're actually going to
15:18
make it worse. Probably.
15:20
So these right? It's just in cases where we're
15:22
worried about it. That's when it's an issue.
15:24
When we're not worried about, it's not an issue about a
15:26
microrna magadha's regarding any imbecile, but if they're all
15:29
grouped together in a bundle, When a basket real close
15:32
together. So then it's a similar concept
15:34
because they're Compact and the air oxygen doesn't get through
15:38
them and it's the same concept. It becomes like a lot of what's
15:42
real came. She had see Panama, or actually,
15:43
I should have it all on me earlier.
15:44
I needs to be where it's, you know, it's completely.
15:48
It's the flame is on by itself. I mean, right?
15:50
There's no end, even with the wick of enter sometimes I
15:53
remember it's a cot. It's cam having by Shabbos and
15:55
more by Hanukkah, but you light it and then you turn around and
15:57
it's gone. Uh, only in behalf and some
16:00
There's the opposite. But okay, that's the challah.
16:04
So, British known valve. Change the Kyoto, Kyoto conveyor
16:09
Shabbos. Olive Keisha.
16:11
How you use their abusive on when the Jews lived in Israel.
16:15
Used to be how you took him, the air of Shabbat Shaista cute.
16:20
So they used to blow the shofar, six times in Israel, we have the
16:24
sirens in some of the city's, many of the city's neighborhoods
16:29
or music. That's right.
16:30
Kadai lat. G letter on minimal akka, in
16:33
order to tell people to stop working by God, I'll just point
16:38
out that originally that they did it.
16:42
The first time, I think it's the wrong.
16:44
One. Who explains the first time they
16:46
did. It was by mini hockey.
16:47
Dola that was for the people to stop working who lived outside.
16:51
We're working outside the city when a katana was the next time
16:54
for the people working inside the city.
16:56
Then the third time would be about some of the Chavez.
16:59
Maybe half an hour before. So just to finish preparing your
17:03
food, make sure you turn on the children to put on your black,
17:06
the water, whatever you doing. Good luck us know, it's true,
17:10
good. Okay.
17:12
And then, right before then a few minutes later, they would
17:16
blow three of them in a row to Kia.
17:18
True. It's a Kia and then you would
17:20
say Ms. More, surely, almost jobless.
17:22
How Garvin Abu Bakr was the closest shikoku, some of which I
17:25
was here talking about 30 minutes an hour before.
17:31
Many communities Schumacher is really active.
17:33
Or somebody in the Civil War would denounce.
17:37
The hockey nets on the showers to get ready for Shabbos.
17:39
Ruben, combat skills, premium not instead of the chaos that
17:43
they used to have read my idea notebook or Malcolm and this is
17:46
a great custom raishin own Zine Jeannie had some are not come
17:51
in. Okay, we're doing some Connor.
17:52
Okay, so now we're talking about her tamannaah know what.
17:55
Let's I just want to go over a few things that we learned
17:59
before. Just to clarify.
18:03
Okay? So this we just came up, let's
18:07
say you realize that Chavez is starting your Tech and alighting
18:12
right now or it's just about to be skier right now, and you
18:15
didn't heat up water. So we mentioned what you do.
18:18
If it's, if you're going to put the water on your black,
18:21
whatever, what about your hot water urn?
18:23
Can you turn it on right before Shabbos?
18:26
So I believe that you're allowed to because with the hot water
18:31
because arish August is an issue of shh.
18:34
And the only issue of she has, you might come to increase the
18:38
Heat play with the fire but the hot water earn.
18:41
I don't think there's any, I don't think there's any issue I
18:44
needed. Somebody might disagree.
18:45
I'm not sure but there's no. I don't think there's any fish.
18:50
Ah shit. Someone's going to push the
18:52
button on or boil so I don't think that there's any issue.
18:56
And everyone just going to wait for it.
18:59
You just put it on massage Shabbat or if there is such a
19:01
thing or there's just one setting and then it'll just go
19:04
up on its own. It could be that in peace.
19:07
Create True Value says it's a problem.
19:08
Not sure if I understand exactly his case but he could be the he
19:11
says it's a sir because by definition, the hot water earn
19:16
as no, it can't be guarded from cut down because it's all the
19:18
whole thing is like one element. So since there's no guard from
19:21
Khartoum, there's a problem. But I think the whole thing is
19:24
based on Sean Murray, Cotton, you might come to play with the
19:28
fire. So that's our opinion.
19:30
On that one. Okay.
19:33
What else just to clarify and kozara on Friday night, when we
19:40
said, you can return items to return it.
19:43
So, just to clarify the difference between Moran and
19:48
Hubbard. And the Roma is a moron.
19:51
He doesn't care about diet, Ola Hawks here and holding it.
19:56
Only thing he cares about is that you don't put it on the
19:59
floor on the car cut, and it's the Roma who Says, it's
20:03
important to have died to the Hawks here.
20:05
You have a mind to return it and it's in your hand and then, but,
20:08
but you have it is what to talk about.
20:10
But if you put it on a table or a chair for sure, it's okay.
20:14
That's not the karka and the postgame say, what do you do
20:18
with the shy ish? The countertop on your oven.
20:20
So that's that's amok. Locate.
20:22
I know summer Mako and I believe some are there going to be
20:25
Malcolm are too as far as if that's considered a car car.
20:29
Not Can you put the soup back onto this?
20:34
Onto a black? Let's say so.
20:37
That's so that's the issue of kozara.
20:39
What you learned? So look at Gila.
20:42
You have to hold it and have a mind to put it back.
20:47
Certainly according to the Roma and doctor, put it on the floor.
20:51
So that's that's the question if you put it on the shy ish.
20:54
So that that's amok. Look at it as long as and but
20:58
you should have but but the evidence they say it's much as
21:02
Leaving the Roadmaster just watching.
21:04
Okay. Directly on Directly on a black
21:12
for sure. That's Garfield cartoon.
21:14
What you call? Okay, so find it, let's talk
21:17
real quick about a black and a hot plate.
21:21
All right, I don't know if we discussed much.
21:27
Okay, black bears are, what is the blasphemy?
21:31
Yiddish for a ten, right? Sheet of Steel.
21:34
So they didn't didn't exist in the time with Gizelle.
21:38
All they had was these. These Ovens that you had an
21:42
opening from the side, so put everything in.
21:45
And on the top, it was completely open, maybe it had a
21:49
great or not, or just had a little bit of a lip that you can
21:51
rest your, your pot on top of it, or it would have stay on.
21:56
Top the open hole on the top by maybe the handles different
22:01
sketches I've seen. But basically the top was, the
22:04
slide was open to put things in and the top was open but there
22:07
was no concept of having this blessed in those days.
22:10
So, whenever you want it to put food on top of on the stove,
22:15
either talking about Gaara for cartoon, and to put it on on
22:19
Shabbos. Look at Iowa, let's say Shabbos
22:21
morning the only time the shows on our talks about the rishonim,
22:25
talk about I'm putting food on top of the stove is if you put
22:29
it on top of a cleat top, shell top of a cleat.
22:34
Okay no I'll just quickly say there's a locket.
22:38
What happened does it matter if there's food inside that?
22:40
Clear, not on that, pot does it matter if there's food inside?
22:48
This is the only case, right? So there's two opinions on the
22:53
matter some say fish as long as long as there's a pot and it's
22:58
going to separate there's air space in the pot and you're
23:00
going to put your food on top of it can take food from the
23:04
fridge, put it right on your talking about if it's fully
23:07
cooked and every other fish, it's dry.
23:10
You can put it directly on top of a a pot on Shabbos morning.
23:15
So does it have to have food in their You're not.
23:16
So that's a my cloak it. But I believe everybody says
23:20
it's okay. Even if it's empty, if that pot
23:23
is not over a flame, if that part is over a black over a hot
23:28
plate if it's sitting on a black or a hot plate.
23:31
So then everyone says, showing his Omen says, everyone says
23:35
again and argue if it's everyone or not, but even according to
23:38
the mission of Aura of Shlomo Zalman, says, you can definitely
23:41
put it straight on top of your pot.
23:45
It's the only issue the issue is, but if you have a pot that's
23:52
empty and that would be on an open flame.
23:55
Then the mission number says, based on the Prima Guardian, not
23:58
everybody agrees, then you can't put it directly on the pot.
24:01
But again nowadays we usually use a black and a hot plate so
24:06
you can take food. You have a cooked straight from
24:08
your fridge and put it right on top of a pot.
24:10
Let's do problem. Now, what about a blast on
24:14
Friday night. So everyone, everyone says a
24:21
black works as Gaara for Cuttin on Friday nights for the helices
24:26
of Shia and Hazara, not a problem you were left it, there
24:31
are Shabbos. So you're returning there.
24:32
It's already a hot and you're returning it on Friday night,
24:35
not a problem. Can you use a black to put food
24:40
on Shabbos morning? Take food piece of dry,
24:44
schnitzel or grilled chicken from your fridge.
24:48
Put it directly on a blessed, shall this morning?
24:51
So, of of audio Steve says you're allowed to and that's
24:56
what some of our team do some don't.
25:00
But as far as I know, certainly most, I'm not sure about all,
25:04
but certainly most say you're not allowed to Of the Ashkenazi
25:08
postgame certainly rubbish. If says you're not allowed to
25:13
have shown those almond says, in the later edition of shimmery
25:20
Shadow was guilt. Pasta is quoted as saying you
25:23
talking. Maybe it's mutter we Tove
25:25
lochner. So I'll let you interpret a film
25:28
with Salman for yourselves. If he says you're allowed to do
25:31
that or not, I'm talking about Right now, can you take food
25:39
from your fridge? If it's dry and fully cooked,
25:41
put it right onto the black Shabbos morning?
25:46
So that rather logical safe is the the famous one for being for
25:51
being Mako and okay. And now what about a hot plate?
26:00
All right, so I think we covered the black now.
26:02
What about a hot plate? So I'll have plate.
26:04
Certainly shown was almond says you're allowed to put food.
26:14
Is a hot plate without a black. What can you do with the hot
26:17
plate without a black? So, according to most part
26:20
opinions and their ovadia Yosef is, for sure a hot plate with no
26:24
covering. That's okay.
26:26
That's called Garo for costume and you can use it Friday night.
26:30
You are Shabbos and Shabbos morning.
26:34
No, so soup is a liquid. So only if it's still you have
26:38
selected will according to starting and for ashkenazim, it
26:41
has to be a still warm. Right, but it can reveal
26:46
afterwards so that's if it's liquid.
26:50
So, we're not right now, we're talking about Yeah, well it does
26:55
apply for Friday nights for soup.
26:58
As long as it's still the odd, select depends.
27:01
If you're talking about from the fridge or you talking about, if
27:03
it's, it's still hot from Friday night.
27:05
So good. Now, rawal yahshua is one who
27:08
says how plates are considered like a fire.
27:12
So he's a I don't know if he's a dossier awkward but he's
27:16
certainly. One of them are strict opinions.
27:18
He says a hot plate is considered so therefore, it's
27:21
never allowed. You can never use a hop.
27:23
Plate for Shia or Hazara, according to who, unless you put
27:28
a block on top of a hot plate or quite a few sheets of tin foil
27:35
might work aluminum foil what on top of a dish?
27:39
Well that for sure that everyone says the top of a dishes, okay?
27:42
Okay, I'm showing was Amin, says a hot plates.
27:49
For sure. Is ok for Friday nights for shh
27:53
and Hazara, but to use it, look how Kayla to take food from the
27:58
fridge. We said, I think he says, is not
28:01
okay, that's a, that might be. That's that might be a question.
28:06
I think he says, it's not, okay? And it's even worse than a
28:08
block. But okay, now, just to point
28:12
out, Out, interesting thing. Some people quote, egos Moshe
28:15
saying that for a hot plate, it's much or to use, no problem.
28:19
But if you read the words of the egress, Moshe, he says a hot
28:24
plate is not the directive to do Vishal and it doesn't really get
28:28
hot enough to cook. So if you have a hot plate,
28:31
that's not good enough to cook. So then our emotion would say,
28:34
yeah. You can take it from the fridge
28:35
and put it straight on on Shabbos.
28:37
But somehow plates, I know, there are different temperatures
28:41
of hot plates in America. I do You know about England but
28:44
I know in America some are not so hot in some are and Israel,
28:48
they're very hot. So it could be a difference
28:51
between what promotion was used to versus what there is
28:55
nowadays, or certainly in Israel.
28:58
Okay, we spoke about the Vishal, you know.
29:01
I think we'll stop a couple of little things and then we'll be
29:05
got had to manage tomorrow.