Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E031: The Last Last Trade of the Year with Brian Cubellis
Transcript
- 0:00Before we get into the episode, a quick reminder that the last
- 0:03trade is for informational and entertainment purposes only and
- 0:06nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 0:10Now for a word from on RAMP on RAMP is a Bitcoin asset
- 0:14management platform built on multi institution custody.
- 0:17We serve high net worth individuals, institutional
- 0:20investors and financial intermediaries with the best in
- 0:23class suite of products which include multi institution
- 0:26custody, a spot Bitcoin fund on RAM, wealth for Rias and private
- 0:32wealth services for high net worth individuals.
- 0:35Leveraging our partnership with Bit Go and other industry
- 0:38leaders on Ramp's, Multi Institution Custody is a first
- 0:41of its kind institutional grade vault requiring two of three
- 0:46institutions at any point in time to sign once a client's
- 0:50unique permissions have been met.
- 0:52Our multi institution vaults utilize cold storage, key
- 0:55signing and authentication at the direction of the client to
- 0:59maximize security for client assets.
- 1:02This pioneering approach to custody is the foundation of On
- 1:05Ramp's financial products which reduce counterparty risk
- 1:09associated with trusting a single institution.
- 1:12To learn more about how On Ramp can help you secure a new or
- 1:16existing Bitcoin position, please visit our website at on
- 1:19rampbitcoin.com, where you can schedule a consultation and
- 1:23connect directly with our team. What you're telling me is that
- 1:28music is about to stop, and we're going to be left holding
- 1:31the biggest bag of odorous excrement ever assembled in the
- 1:36history of doctors 1974198792972000.
- 1:44And whatever we want to call this.
- 1:45It's all just the same thing over and over.
- 1:47We can't help ourselves. I say when we sell, hey, I say
- 1:53when we sell. There's freaks everywhere and
- 1:59you all need to speak up. Don't wait for the perfect
- 2:04allocation mandate. Just buy Bitcoin.
- 2:06Just ape in. Ask for forgiveness.
- 2:08Later the the returns will speak for themselves.
- 2:11This is not financial advice. This is the last trade.
- 2:14Last episode of the year full on ramp Rep We got Brian Cabela's
- 2:19with us gentlemen. How are we doing?
- 2:20We're. Doing well.
- 2:22Thanks for thanks for having me, boys.
- 2:25I don't think that the fact that we had to like assume that you
- 2:28will come on it many times. Soon.
- 2:31Last time, Brian, we got into some very spicy stuff, so we'll
- 2:34see if this goes anywhere near that stuff.
- 2:37No. If you recall that was on rabbit
- 2:38hole recap. We kept that for the freeze.
- 2:42It it was both the last time we talked about Binance and we some
- 2:46some individuals on this spot thought they were going belly
- 2:48up. I I was wrong on that one but.
- 2:52You know. The market rebounding the
- 2:56market. What's the BNB margin call
- 2:57looking like right now? Yeah, right, 'cause they really
- 3:00defended 200 and and that that was kind of the, the price point
- 3:04that I had penciled in as like they might be in trouble if the
- 3:07price goes under there, $200 per BNB and and then Bitcoin
- 3:12rallying kind of saved them, I think.
- 3:14I don't know. But like, see, it's like C ZS,
- 3:17like a Lannister. He just always pays his debts.
- 3:19He just continues to meet his obligations.
- 3:20Well, you know everybody. Matt says that the suits just
- 3:24wanted to to go under underwater and he just was standing all the
- 3:27arrows and he's going to sit in the background while his company
- 3:29just Rakes in dough next year. So one in the shadow the CFTC,
- 3:35the head of the CFTCI forget his name, it's escaping me right
- 3:38now. He did.
- 3:40I think it was a Bloomberg or CNBC interview last week and
- 3:44said that he'll likely do jail time.
- 3:47Looks like they're going after some federal prison time for CZ.
- 3:52Wow, that that would be quite something.
- 3:58I did see that there is criminal like prosecution that they're
- 4:02trying. I think that that's unfortunate
- 4:05in the sense of it's more of probably like a poster child for
- 4:08it versus like actual substance. But yeah, it's like, don't.
- 4:12Don't fight the Fed, don't fight the government.
- 4:18Or don't. I mean, if the laws are unjust.
- 4:24You you have it dude Dee Dee to disobey.
- 4:28Not saying that CZ does CZ. What's CZZZZ?
- 4:32Probably engaged in a lot of crime, particularly market
- 4:38spoofing. Wash trading bunch of.
- 4:41Other money laundering. Is that, is that what he is that
- 4:44what he got in trouble for? I thought it was just
- 4:46referencing, you know, the traditional like, I mean OFAC
- 4:50sanctions and KYC, which is obviously a crime, but I don't.
- 4:53Was he like, was he manipulating the market?
- 4:56And is it? If he's manipulating the market,
- 4:58what market? Yeah, I'm not aware of what the
- 5:04the government has accused him of versus what he has been.
- 5:07You know, finance has been rumored to have done.
- 5:10So I'm fuzzy on where the line is drawn, but I know that there
- 5:14is ample speculation and screenshots of internal chats
- 5:18you know, talking about, like how they effectively are money
- 5:22laundering operation for, you know, with regard to some
- 5:25clients in in sanctioned countries.
- 5:31Yeah. The interesting thing there is,
- 5:33I feel like they probably did very similar to what Arthur
- 5:36Hayes did, where like they didn't have the dollar rails,
- 5:39but they had, you know, money coming in and money coming out.
- 5:42FTX, they're all like in the same area of the market, this
- 5:47opaque version of like knowing your customer what's happening.
- 5:53But the one firm that we know for certain was running a Ponzi
- 5:56and taking everybody's money is the is SPF, everything else.
- 5:59Like, I don't know, like what's been proven.
- 6:02In Celsius, I think it's pretty clear it's Celsius running
- 6:05Ponzi. Yeah.
- 6:08Maybe a block fight too. Is isn't it scary that how like
- 6:14you just mentioned Celsius, I completely forgot about them And
- 6:17like in a year, just the craziness that can happen where
- 6:20you're just like it's kind of, it concerns me for next year
- 6:22because we're going to see crazy things happen again and we're
- 6:25just going to like Doom to repeat.
- 6:28Yeah, is is a great point though that like I mean a year ago was
- 6:33the bottom and it felt so awful, right.
- 6:37And that that just doom and gloom was was just a year ago
- 6:42and looking forward a year you know like the momentum of swung
- 6:48the pendulum is going in the other direction and we're
- 6:50probably right now at that like peak rate of change towards in
- 6:56terms of like sentiment from negative towards positive and
- 7:00we'll we'll we could be downright giddy a year from now.
- 7:03Do you? It's interesting.
- 7:04I, I, I kind of think we're in this weird spot where it's like
- 7:07eerily quiet like we're in this sort of Bitcoin echo bubble and
- 7:11chamber. And you know we know that all
- 7:14the things that have happened over the past year that really
- 7:16position us in a in a pretty good spot going forward.
- 7:20But when you you talk to people outside of that bubble and it's
- 7:23still, there's still so much unawareness about what's going
- 7:26on the fundamentals that's. So exciting because because all
- 7:30these things are like they're writing us on the wall for
- 7:32what's going to happen next year.
- 7:33And yet 99% of the world doesn't know just because they're not
- 7:37paying attention, because they don't want to consider Bitcoin a
- 7:40real asset. Like what?
- 7:42The incredible information asymmetry Just because people
- 7:45want to write it off as Monopoly money and not pay attention to
- 7:48the mechanics and and the ETF approval coming?
- 7:50Yeah. I mean, a year from now we could
- 7:55be doing the show with our shirts off because we were so
- 7:57ecstatic and. Well, before the shirts off
- 8:02episode we Jesse's getting us, just reminding you we have to do
- 8:06something special for the having.
- 8:08Like it just just has to be. I mean, it is Jesse's favorite
- 8:12event in all of human history that happens once every four
- 8:15years, so. 24 hour stream. Pretty much favorite event in
- 8:21human history. You can't say that.
- 8:23You can't say that, but but the the the most exciting future
- 8:28known event possible. There's no other known event in
- 8:32the future that's more exciting. I'll say that.
- 8:34I will claim that. What about your wedding?
- 8:38My wedding already happened. But that was but there was at
- 8:41that in the future planned it's I'm just messing around just to
- 8:45make sure. If that were a good time, the
- 8:47wedding, the wedding took precedent, yeah.
- 8:50Real quick question. We talk about a year from now,
- 8:53being autumn, being feeling so bad.
- 8:56I kind of feel, and I may be wrong, but like the summer was
- 8:58even worse because it was like the doldrums.
- 9:01But what? What would you guys say?
- 9:02Was it like this time last year when the markets collapsing?
- 9:05Or is it? Because we knew Bitcoin was
- 9:06fine, it was mainly the institution, right?
- 9:08There was, there was a weird element to a full year ago where
- 9:11it was like, we know that none of this has to do with Bitcoin.
- 9:14So it was like somewhat cathartic in a way, where it was
- 9:17like, all right, we're finally sort of wash washing out some of
- 9:19the bad actors here. Like, this is a a necessary
- 9:22means to an eventual end here. And then, yeah, to your point,
- 9:26like the summer was kind of like, OK, we got rid of those
- 9:28guys, but now we're still kind of just crabbing along here
- 9:30like. Yeah, talking.
- 9:32We're trying to talk to people about Bitcoin.
- 9:34People are raising capital, trying to drum up business, and
- 9:37they're like, yeah, we're good. Everybody just died.
- 9:39Like the thing's over. That's 'cause it was so fresh in
- 9:43people's mind. Like the FTX, the SPF trial
- 9:47haven't even hadn't even happened yet.
- 9:50Yeah, the summer. That's why.
- 9:51That's why summer doldrums are real.
- 9:53Just go to a beach. You enjoy your time.
- 9:55You lay low, try to be as productive as possible.
- 9:58Then you pop up in the fall. SBF goes to jail.
- 10:02The ETF approval seems imminent. You start beating the drum
- 10:05again. Having's four months away.
- 10:08The boys are back in town. Let's go.
- 10:10We'll see how that strategy works for this summer.
- 10:12You're gonna be like this. Oh, we kid.
- 10:19So we do have a lot of notes on our Slack channel for this
- 10:23episode. I think before we jump into
- 10:28either a year in review or a year ahead perspective, there's
- 10:34a lot going on in traditional markets.
- 10:35Michael, you drop, you dropped a long list of bullet points that
- 10:39I actually do want to read through because it is pretty
- 10:40insane just to highlight what's going on in the markets outside
- 10:45of Bitcoin right now. Then we can tie how Bitcoin is
- 10:48an alternative to this after we have a discussion on that, but
- 10:52it is pretty crazy. Last week obviously you had
- 10:55Jerome Powell come out post FOMC meeting and announced that they
- 11:00weren't gonna raise rates anymore, but more importantly
- 11:03began to signal more of a dovish tune.
- 11:07There are many theories on why he pivoted rather quickly.
- 11:10Earlier in the month, I believe December 3rd, he was adamant
- 11:14that rate cuts were not around the corner.
- 11:17That tune seemed to change last week.
- 11:20A lot of commentary around that and here are the headlines since
- 11:26that happened last week and somebody wrote.
- 11:29I've been working in finance for 15 years and this was one of the
- 11:32craziest weeks I have ever seen. The S&P rally is 2.7% now, only
- 11:361.6% away from a record high. The Dow and the NASDAQ 100 hit
- 11:41all time highs last week. the Fed held rates unchanged.
- 11:45Expects expects 3 rate cuts in 2024, which is amplified in
- 11:49their dot plot, which is one of the stupid graphs stupidest
- 11:53grass in the world. Fed member John Williams goes on
- 11:56CNBC and says premature to be thinking about March.
- 11:59Rate cut volatility hits a four year low.
- 12:02Retail investors are buying the most stocks since March of 2022.
- 12:05Jim Cramer says the recession is not coming.
- 12:08Apple hits a new record high. China's central bank injects
- 12:11record monthly amounts into the financial system.
- 12:14Germany, France and India stock markets hit all time highs.
- 12:18USCPI at 3.1% year on year in November in line with
- 12:21expectations. Goldman Sachs expects Fed to
- 12:25start cutting rates in March, Expects 2 back-to-back rate cuts
- 12:29of 25 bips. Alibaba hit a 52 week low.
- 12:34Pfizer hit a 10 year low. SEC holds a meeting with
- 12:37BlackRock to discuss its spot BIC weight ETF.
- 12:39JP Morgan says Ethereum will outperform Bitcoin in 2024.
- 12:44Jamie just ruining his reputation in real time.
- 12:48It must be nice to be the biggest bank in the United
- 12:50States. You can say stupid stuff like
- 12:51this with impunity. 30 year mortgage rates now below 7%.
- 12:56US retail sales increased by 30 bips in November.
- 13:01It was expected to be a -10 bip drop, an all time high of
- 13:05Americans spend spending more than 50% of their income on
- 13:09rent, which is insane. Restaurant prices are up 2024%
- 13:13since January 2020. Former President Trump says the
- 13:17US will have one of the greatest economic years the nation has
- 13:19ever recorded if he's elected in 2024.
- 13:22It's great. It's great campaign fodder.
- 13:26There was a bill introduced in the Senate that Wood Forest big
- 13:28investors to sell all the single family homes they own.
- 13:31Over 10 years and US consumers are spending at record lows and
- 13:35economists are mystified, struggling to forecast an
- 13:38endpoint. Crazy Americans.
- 13:40The economy's better. How come you're not spending?
- 13:42Where you guys thoughts on all these headlines?
- 13:44Chaotic mix. Yeah, I I have a lot of thoughts
- 13:48on all that. It is a chaotic mix and it's
- 13:51it's interesting that it, you know it paints this picture of
- 13:55recovery like you know and the Fed is even kind of taking a
- 13:59victory lap about how they successfully achieved their soft
- 14:02landing. Look at us, we solved it but I
- 14:05have seen some some headlines floating around from from like
- 14:092007 and and there were quite a few like similar narratives
- 14:15going around in mid two 2007. You know, which is to say like
- 14:23historically when when rates are cut, it is when shit starts to
- 14:28hit the fan the the the wheels start to fall off only when
- 14:34rates are cut. And and it's not to say that the
- 14:38rate cutting causes that, but more likely that the Fed and
- 14:43policy makers realize, oh shit things are not looking good
- 14:46under the surface time for us to start easing, to try to you know
- 14:52stimulate the economy. But you know as we've seen over
- 14:57the last few years, when they change rates, it takes 18 months
- 15:01for that impact to flow through the the economy.
- 15:05So they can cut rates now, but that won't really immediately
- 15:09change what's happening in the economy.
- 15:11We're we're what's happening in the economy is based on where
- 15:15you know what rates have been over the last 18 months which is
- 15:19very high relative to where they were for the prior few years.
- 15:23So the pain is still working its way through the system and
- 15:26that's why the consumer is hurting and yet stocks are up
- 15:31almost near an all time high. How and why?
- 15:34Well, a big part of that story is we've been printing a lot of
- 15:38new debt to service our interest expense.
- 15:42We're having to issue new debt and it plus our deficits are
- 15:46already massive. So you know that on on this show
- 15:49I've talked about how I had to have to revisit the numbers, but
- 15:53we were on pace for right now, but recently we were on pace for
- 15:57like $6 trillion in additional national debt for the 12 months
- 16:03following the debt ceiling being lifted back in in late spring.
- 16:09So where's where's the money coming from to bid up the stock
- 16:14market? Well it's it's all this new
- 16:16liquidity in the system that is, is coming in and and and the
- 16:22reverse repo facility is still being drawn down.
- 16:24It's not yet at 0, but it's close.
- 16:26So that's part of the part of the liquidity coming into the
- 16:29system is, is capital flowing out of reverse repo and having
- 16:34to bid something, having to go from reverse repo into into some
- 16:38kind of bond. And so there's there's actually
- 16:41liquidity at this moment and largely because of all the debt
- 16:44dynamics that are playing out. So that that's why the
- 16:47consumer's hurting because interest rates are high and and
- 16:51the economy is actually in pain and yet it looks like things are
- 16:55recovering because there's actually just a bunch of
- 16:57liquidity bidding up stocks and and bonds right now.
- 17:01Yeah. And I've got a couple of charts
- 17:04to really lean into this. Number one, the disconnection
- 17:08between stock markets, financial markets and the pain that
- 17:12individuals are feeling. And then #2, the premature
- 17:16celebrations that may be going on.
- 17:17So look and pull up the, the second chart I put in there in
- 17:20that one. I mean, this is a pretty scary
- 17:22stat. The percentage of Americans
- 17:29married by birth decade. So if you were born in the 90s,
- 17:33that's around 30% right now. And for comparison, in the
- 17:371940s, about 95 ninety, 95% of people were married by the age
- 17:43of 30 and the millennials, that that percentage is around 30%.
- 17:48So 1/3, at least of what it was in the 1940s, which signals that
- 17:53something is structurally broken in the economy.
- 17:56I say in this tweet, hint, it's the money.
- 17:58People are not forming families. There's a number of of factors
- 18:04that play into this. But I think economics, economic
- 18:08stress is probably #1. And then the other chart you can
- 18:14pull up Logan, which is the second one, just highlights that
- 18:18we may be repeating exactly what happened in the 1970s charts
- 18:22from EGA and Tony, which in that decade this.
- 18:26One's remarkable. Yeah.
- 18:28Brian, why don't you comment on this?
- 18:30I mean I just think it's, it's it's wild to think that you know
- 18:36the people of the Fed and and the government have to know this
- 18:39chart, right. Like they know what happened in
- 18:40the 70s and so they're they're sort of, you know, engineering
- 18:45this quote UN quote, soft landing, but with full knowledge
- 18:49that, you know, inflation could sort of get more aggressive
- 18:53again. And the reality is, you know, I
- 18:55think at at sort of at best CPI is a flawed metric and at worst
- 19:01it's highly manipulated. And so you know, the reality of
- 19:05the situation is that the pain being felt by the average
- 19:08consumer is real to to Jesse's earlier point.
- 19:12But they're they're sort of they've been able to massage the
- 19:17sort of perception of the economy through things like CPI
- 19:21employment data that's double counting people or even just you
- 19:24know going back to the stock market sort of seem to be
- 19:27floating suspended in in in air given you know interest rates
- 19:32have been high for the past year, year and a half.
- 19:34I think part of that is the concentration of the S&P and I
- 19:38think I, I posted a chart in the chat if you want to pull that
- 19:40one up, Logan. But this one is kind of wild to
- 19:43me. It's from ensemble capital and
- 19:45it's just shows basically the the, you know, the vast majority
- 19:49of contribution to the S&P 500 is is 7 stocks, right.
- 19:53And so the average company out there or you know not even the
- 19:56average, you know some of the top 500 companies in the world
- 19:59in the US are probably you know flat to down over this period.
- 20:04And this is this starts in 2019. And so the vast majority of sort
- 20:09of stock market performance has been. 7:00 or so companies and I
- 20:14think it's almost a convenient way for them to say, well, you
- 20:17know, the paint isn't really here because at the end of the
- 20:19day like the, the main barometer I think for the Fed, whether
- 20:23whether they'll ever admit it or not or not, is the stock market.
- 20:27And so if this can sort of continue to float, it helps
- 20:31their sort of soft landing narrative in a weird way,
- 20:34despite, you know, if you look under the surface, it's really
- 20:36not indicative of what's happening in the economy.
- 20:41Yeah, the stock market is not the economy.
- 20:44You think people would internalize this, especially
- 20:47after 2008 and years that have come and gone before.
- 20:53I mean 2020-2021 stock market roared and there was just this
- 20:58inflation demon lurking in the background and that.
- 21:02I mean, that's a big quip. Was that Michael?
- 21:06I wanna say, do we think something like structurally
- 21:08broke with this, like pivot, You know, we saw a gold rip about a
- 21:11week before and then they have. They weren't.
- 21:13They were hinting hawkish, and then they just completely
- 21:16pivoted on that. Yeah, well that's, I mean
- 21:20there's a number of theories out there.
- 21:22One is that something structurally broke and they're
- 21:26aware of it and the rest of the market isn't, which is hard to
- 21:29believe cause the market usually finds these things out first and
- 21:32then the second is simply we're heading into an election year.
- 21:35Janet Yellen in President Biden's administration, who have
- 21:38been publicly countersapling Jerome Powell for months, sort
- 21:43of had a discussion with him. We're like, yo, we're gonna need
- 21:45you to play ball here. He bent the knee.
- 21:50That's what I think is most likely.
- 21:53Yeah, I mean I find it fascinating.
- 21:56We talk about Bitcoin as being a, you know, the last free
- 21:58market and it kind of being the Canary in the coal mine, both
- 22:02upwards and downwards when liquidity is getting stripped or
- 22:05on the other side of it. It started running weeks before
- 22:08this happened, which is interesting.
- 22:11Maybe that's the market alarm bell.
- 22:14Jesse have thoughts on this? Yeah, it's the last functioning
- 22:18fire alarm in in global markets. So yeah it does tend to hint at
- 22:23what's really happening and the and the and yeah the the the
- 22:271970s inflation parallel. So something we we put out a
- 22:34piece on in the spring pointing out like this is exactly what
- 22:39happened in the 70s because they would they did a few rounds of
- 22:46trying to fight inflation by hiking interest rates and what
- 22:52you're really doing then is you're hurting consumption and
- 22:57and that helps bring down inflation because it's part of
- 23:02the story for inflation is, is how much demand there is.
- 23:05So you can destroy demand and and bring down inflation.
- 23:12But you know that that's one of the variables in the others is
- 23:16you know the the amount of money, the money supply.
- 23:20And so you know every every every good represents some tiny
- 23:26percentage of the existing money supply.
- 23:30And when you increase the money supply then the nominal number
- 23:33of of units that like a a car costs goes up, right.
- 23:38So the money supply matters but but also demand side matters for
- 23:43inflation. So you can kneecap the economy
- 23:47by hiking interest rates and and making people feel pain and
- 23:52they'll slow down their spending and bring down inflation.
- 23:55But then you create a crisis in doing so and then you end up
- 24:00having to ease up and stimulate your way out of the crisis.
- 24:05And that's kind of the pattern that happened a couple times in
- 24:08the 70s until they finally, you know, were able to commit to
- 24:15super high interest rates to to really break the back of
- 24:19inflation. And so we're kind of on the same
- 24:23trajectory here. And then kind of what I've been
- 24:25expecting for the last year or so of these, this interest rate
- 24:31hike that we've been living under is working to hurt the
- 24:36consumer and that brings down inflation, you know, the rate of
- 24:41inflation. But it creates a problem.
- 24:44It creates a, a brewing crisis that requires an injection of
- 24:49liquidity and then everything roars again to like you know,
- 24:52the COVID stimulus again and we'll have the next round of
- 24:57inflation if and when that occurs.
- 25:00And you know, I think it's just like AI think it's human nature
- 25:04is part of it. I think it's like it's no
- 25:05surprise that we're following the same trajectory of the 70s.
- 25:08It's it's that we all have a we're all dumbfounded at how we
- 25:16could possibly follow the same pattern of of, you know, group
- 25:19think and group psychology playing out the same as it as it
- 25:24has before. But it ends up playing out the
- 25:26same because that's how groups work and think together.
- 25:29And you end up taking the same short term measures like hurting
- 25:37the consumer to try to bring down inflation while sowing the
- 25:40seeds for a medium term crisis that results in a medium to long
- 25:44term, you know, inflationary stimulus.
- 25:47So we're just following the same pattern again.
- 25:50And yeah, brace yourselves. Yeah.
- 25:56Yeah, I think part, part of what I.
- 25:58Like to anchor too is is somewhat zooming out and and not
- 26:02ignoring the sort of near term realities of interest rate hikes
- 26:07and and cuts. But but Jesse you talk about
- 26:10this a lot and it's it's you know the long term reality of
- 26:13the situation is that they need to inflate away the debt like
- 26:16that. That is that is what we know and
- 26:19and sort of the the trajectory and how we end up there is much
- 26:23harder to predict with any sort of accuracy because again these
- 26:27are people in a room pulling levers at the end of the day.
- 26:30And so I think what I like to anchor to is, is the long term
- 26:35what we know in that in order for you know this sort of fiscal
- 26:43insanity to continue they need to, they need to inflate away
- 26:45that debt at some point. And so that means more printing
- 26:48and it means more continued debasement of the currency and
- 26:50that's that's what ties back to the Bitcoin thesis is this you
- 26:53know known absolutely scarce asset that you can store your
- 26:58wealth in. So for me it's it's not that I
- 27:01not that I ignore the the near term because I think it's
- 27:04important and certainly you know commentary that people care
- 27:08about in markets but I just try to anchor to what we actually
- 27:11know and what we know this sort of eventual reality situation is
- 27:17and and that means they they must print so own something
- 27:20scarce it. It it's such a good reminder
- 27:22that it's impossible to know what's going to happen near
- 27:26term, and that the further out you look, the more the math
- 27:29dictates what ends up happening. And the math is knowable.
- 27:33But who knows what happens in the next year?
- 27:36Yeah. Brian, going off of that, help
- 27:38us. You're the closest, most recent
- 27:42in the institutional space. Going back to your experience at
- 27:45BBH. What do you think like is going
- 27:48on in rooms right now when you think about the macro sentiment?
- 27:50Well, we just discussed all the things Marty went through then.
- 27:54Independent of any belief in Bitcoin, this ETF thing has to
- 27:57be being discussed, right? And what?
- 28:00What is it? What is that looking like
- 28:01heading into 2024? I mean, I think for the most
- 28:05part there's probably a good swath of the Trapfi industry
- 28:09that believes that the Fed can engineer a soft landing because
- 28:14generally speaking they don't think about CPI and inflation
- 28:18like we do and and the long term inevitability of of these
- 28:21things. They tend to be more short term
- 28:24oriented and and trading oriented and more so willing to
- 28:30ignore the long term and focus on the short term.
- 28:32So I think there's some element of that there.
- 28:36But to your point on the ETFSI think it'll be very interesting
- 28:38to see how this plays out. Because for a long time I've
- 28:41sort of thought, you know, there's there's sort of
- 28:44functional mechanics that are, you know, going to be positive
- 28:48for bitcoin's price that come out of these ETFs, right?
- 28:50Like these issuers are going to be forced to go buy spot
- 28:53Bitcoin. But to me, the the sort of
- 28:57almost more important point of these things getting proved is
- 29:00the shift in narrative and the shift in sentiment around this
- 29:03being a legitimate asset. And I think for better or worse
- 29:07like the approval stamp of the US federal government on and the
- 29:12SEC on a you know Bitcoin product will go a long way in
- 29:17terms of forcing people to open their eyes to this thing and and
- 29:21rethink their sort of pre consist pre you know
- 29:25preconceived notions and biases about it.
- 29:28So to me like yes it's it's clearly going to be a positive
- 29:32near term price catalyst when these things are approved.
- 29:36But the the more important point is sort of the narrative shift
- 29:39and you know being forced to think about it in the context of
- 29:44a portfolio or the context of you know other ETFs which may
- 29:48own may own Bitcoin. So that that to me is what I've
- 29:52sort of anchored to as as the more important outcome of of
- 29:56what we're about to see in the in the next month or so is that
- 29:59narrative shift is that sort of you know people being forced to
- 30:04wake up in a way to like this thing is real and there's now
- 30:08sort of a stamp of approval on it as a thing that you can own.
- 30:11But yeah, that's. Yeah, I love that.
- 30:15It's like, it's like FDA approval.
- 30:17It's like you're forced now to have.
- 30:18An opinion? You're you're forced like from a
- 30:21norming perspective and institutional perspective, you
- 30:24have to have. You're gonna be forced to have
- 30:26an opinion, whether it's rat poison or you might need to
- 30:28sprinkle a little bit on your 6040 to make sure you can, you
- 30:32know, hit your your benchmark the next year.
- 30:36Is this a whole new era for Bitcoin?
- 30:39Is this a demarcation line for what will be looked at?
- 30:44Look back on as like a a pivotal point in Bitcoin's history.
- 30:48If you're sitting on a throne this time next year, I think so.
- 30:51I think I was looking at you when you said that and it's like
- 30:53if the background's like paved in gold and we'll we'll know
- 30:56that the demarcation, if it's the same seat, I'm not sure.
- 30:59Hey, this is a pre 1971 antique chair I bought specifically
- 31:05because it was bought before it went off the gold standard.
- 31:07It wasn't cheap. It's very comfortable from an
- 31:13antique from an antique in Charleston, SC.
- 31:15Very great city, good good aesthetics.
- 31:19But yeah, I I think it I think it absolutely will be a
- 31:22demarcation point largely for lack of a better demarcation
- 31:27point. You can you can point to the
- 31:30halvings and I will continue to as you know the the real phase
- 31:35change from 1 arrow to the next. But from the from the mainstream
- 31:41perception of this asset, I think it will be like it will be
- 31:45before before the the powers that be blessed Bitcoin as being
- 31:53legitimate and after you know that that's how it's going to be
- 31:57perceived and viewed historically by by the people
- 32:02who aren't yet interested in Bitcoin in particular, which is
- 32:06the vast majority of people. And so I think that I, I, you
- 32:10know, it's it's almost the AOL moment for Bitcoin because, you
- 32:15know, with the Internet it started in in 1969, I think
- 32:22maybe it was 79, 79. That was like the first real
- 32:28instance instance of the Internet as we know it.
- 32:32And then it took from there 15 years for AOL to come along,
- 32:38roughly 15 years. And then AOL changed everything,
- 32:43right? It made it accessible.
- 32:44It made it made the Internet go mainstream because before then
- 32:49you had to deal with setting up your own server and all that and
- 32:54and you know connecting to the Internet the hard way.
- 32:58So you know this will be that this will be the AOL moment for
- 33:01Bitcoin and it will only be clear in retrospect and at the
- 33:05same time it will be underwhelming the the day, the
- 33:08month that it happens. I I think it's just going to be
- 33:12clear that you know the the 2024 bull market into 2025 that I
- 33:18think is catalyzed by the halving and not anything else
- 33:23catalyse without having but amplified by a switch from QT to
- 33:27QE and also amplified by the additional demand stream of ETFs
- 33:34trying to pile in pile capital into Bitcoin.
- 33:39All those things will be happening next year and that
- 33:44that'll matter a ton to amplifying the bull market.
- 33:48That ends up happening, I believe.
- 33:51But you know, it won't happen day one, it won't happen month
- 33:54one. It'll just be clear in
- 33:56retrospect. Thanks for tuning in to The Last
- 34:01Trade. If you're enjoying the show and
- 34:03want to dive deeper, check us out at on rampbitcoin.com where
- 34:08you'll find a full suite of institutional grade research and
- 34:11analytics, including our recently published white paper,
- 34:15Bitcoin's full potential valuation, and our new tool, the
- 34:19On Ramp Terminal. Now back to the show.
- 34:24Yeah I'm. I'm curious what you guys think
- 34:25about sort of the juxtaposition of this one on you know on one
- 34:30hand you have this regulatory stamp of approval that seems
- 34:33imminent but at the same time you have the Elizabeth Warrens
- 34:36of the world proposing bills that are pretty purely an attack
- 34:42on on Bitcoin and people's rights to use Bitcoin.
- 34:46And I think, you know, I've, I've been trying, I've been
- 34:48wrestling in my head with the past week of like OK, what are
- 34:50the Silver Linings of of something like this?
- 34:53And I think there are a few. I think one is, you know,
- 34:57Elizabeth Warren's position has been anti Bitcoin but also pro
- 35:02CBDC. And I think that's a pretty
- 35:05easy, easy argument to win in, in sort of the realm of public
- 35:08perception around CBDC as being the potential terrible path to
- 35:13go down in terms of sort of the encroaching surveillance state.
- 35:17So that that's one element that I think we have sort of in in
- 35:20our favor. The other one is like, you know,
- 35:22if something like her bill were ever to be passed and put into
- 35:26law, I think you know ultimately we still have courts in this
- 35:30country and people will have to fight these things.
- 35:33And I think ultimately it comes down to like you know, the
- 35:36Second Amendment is on our side or you know the 1st Amendment is
- 35:39on our side in terms of free speech and and code, you know is
- 35:42speech. And I think that's a fight that
- 35:45we'll eventually have to take on.
- 35:47So I would say like it, it's just an interesting time because
- 35:50you know on one hand we we have these approvals coming, but at
- 35:52the other time, you know, at the same time we have you know some
- 35:57real sort of proposed attacks. You know, people have talked
- 36:00about Elizabeth Warren's track record, poor track record of of
- 36:03getting bills passed, but just the just the existence of
- 36:07something like that. It tried to, you know, I've just
- 36:11been trying to think about the ways in which, you know, maybe
- 36:15this is actually a good thing in some sense.
- 36:17Like, you know, if the Elizabeth Warrens of the world weren't
- 36:20crafting these bills, I think you could make the argument like
- 36:23Bitcoin wasn't working as intended.
- 36:25Like the fact that that someone is coming out and trying to, you
- 36:30know, attack this open, open source, globally accessible
- 36:34network with a bill that, you know, at the end of the day
- 36:37would promote ACBDC. Like to me that's actually a
- 36:41strange indicator that like Bitcoin is doing something right
- 36:44and it's a fight that we're going to have to fight.
- 36:46So I, I mean I would say we're still firmly in the then they
- 36:48fight you stage of things here. So it's just an interesting
- 36:52juxtaposition given like the ETF excitement, but curious if you
- 36:56guys think about that. Yeah, that I, I, I do.
- 37:00I want to chip in with that. This makes me think about a
- 37:03quote from the cypherpunks. The the early cypherpunks of the
- 37:07The government is not a monolithic thing.
- 37:11That is your enemy is a multitudinous thing That is your
- 37:14enemy. And and I I think part of that
- 37:17is like Elizabeth Warren is, is trying to fight Bitcoin in her
- 37:21way. And there are other interests
- 37:25that are approaching Bitcoin in different ways, some fighting
- 37:27Bitcoin, some neutral. But I think there's also like a
- 37:30capitalist element that wants to make money off of Bitcoin.
- 37:34And that's the Trojan horse for, you know, how Bitcoin eventually
- 37:37wins is that there's this incentive for people to make
- 37:40money by adopting Bitcoin. And so people will do that.
- 37:46And Larry Fink is one of those people, in my opinion.
- 37:50And that, you know, makes Bitcoin available to a broader
- 37:55slice of the population. And yet it does come with some
- 37:58problems of, you know, is it actually Bitcoin?
- 38:02But, but it will open up a lot of people's eyes to Bitcoin
- 38:06being a valuable asset. And some people will take, you
- 38:08know, like take take their Bitcoin off of an ETF and and go
- 38:13buy real Bitcoin. And now we have more Bitcoin
- 38:15adopters. But all all that to say that I
- 38:18think we're kind of in a race between interests, people who
- 38:24want to to kill Bitcoin and people who want to make money by
- 38:31by harnessing Bitcoin for their own ends.
- 38:36But you know, as we all know, ultimately you you you don't.
- 38:40Yeah, Bitcoin doesn't serve you. You end up serving Bitcoin by by
- 38:45spreading the message of Bitcoin.
- 38:47I'll take this at a slightly different direction in which the
- 38:52timing of all this, where there's the imminent ETF
- 38:55approval and the posturing from the Treasury and Elizabeth
- 39:00Warren and her like, I can see it like being the attack where
- 39:07you have Elizabeth Warren pushing this bill And yes, she's
- 39:10had piss poor, a piss poor record of actually getting these
- 39:14bills passed. But it does seem like she's got
- 39:15a lot of cosigners on this particular bill and some
- 39:19narrative momentum using bug data, which we've talked about
- 39:22in the past. And I could easily see a
- 39:24situation where the ETF gets approved, this law gets passed
- 39:28and then Elizabeth Warren's like, yeah, you can have your
- 39:30Bitcoin where you can only access it via these avenues that
- 39:34that we deem appropriate. So that's what I worry about.
- 39:38And then they fight you and then stage materializing and I could
- 39:42easily see that happening in the next 12 to 18 months, which
- 39:49again we've been saying this on rabbit hole recap.
- 39:51That's the disconcerting. It's a disconcerting idea
- 39:57because black rocket come, get approved.
- 40:01All the other ETFs approved bags pump miraculously.
- 40:05Everybody's all fat and happy and rich.
- 40:08The law gets passed, Then people are like, maybe it's OK, maybe
- 40:12we can just get the ETF. I'm rich.
- 40:14Whatever. It's gonna sweat off my back.
- 40:16I've got all my money. And that's the ethical, mental,
- 40:20moral dilemma that BIC orders I think are going to face in the
- 40:24next two years is you're going to be extremely wealthy if you
- 40:27got in early enough. And the government here in the
- 40:30United States is going to attack it and create these avenues.
- 40:33The theory, It's my theory. I think it could happen.
- 40:36And then we're going to have that sort of decision to make.
- 40:41Are we going to bend the knee and say, all right, I'm rich,
- 40:44I'll just have my Bitcoin in the ETF and live off my gains?
- 40:48Or are people going to fight for the freedom to actually hold
- 40:53Bitcoin and possess it yourself outside the purview of the
- 40:57state? Yeah.
- 40:59I mean, I think the beauty of it is like Jesse reference, this
- 41:02whole thing's aligned based on incentives.
- 41:05And so everybody's going to do what they should do and they
- 41:07should do it. This reminds me of the same
- 41:08conversation, different scale, but ordinals and transaction
- 41:11fees. It's like at the end of the day,
- 41:15people are just going to use Bitcoin, what it was for.
- 41:18If it happens, it happens. People are going to give it up.
- 41:20They're not going to give it up. The reality is talk about like
- 41:23prohibition and they could never ban booze.
- 41:27And Bitcoin is infinitely more valuable than booze.
- 41:31So there's nothing's going to be banned.
- 41:33It's just going to be harder to use and everybody's going to
- 41:35have their decisions to make. But at the other side of it,
- 41:37it's like, in my mind, it feels like water just like flows down
- 41:40one way, like gravity goes. And so these are just periods we
- 41:43have to live through and everybody makes their own
- 41:45decision and they go through and you do what's best based on your
- 41:47incentive model. But it's part of like, the
- 41:49beauty of like Center Warren probably has like Bitcoin
- 41:51eventually, and then that's how we get her.
- 41:53And it's just it's just a natural progression, but it's
- 41:56very valid like on Margie's side what he's referencing because it
- 41:59very much could happen. But at the same time that's when
- 42:01you go back to states rights and they can be able to tell like in
- 42:04my mind it feels we're having discussions last week with
- 42:07people working with the politicians in Texas and they
- 42:09referenced over 50 the Republicans that are
- 42:12traditionally like against Bitcoin.
- 42:15But they're looking at the angle.
- 42:16What Brian said about, well, it's basically freedom money
- 42:19against like CBDC's and so these things will ultimately happen.
- 42:22And then it feels like Texas taking people's Bitcoin seems
- 42:25very similar to saying like we're taking your gold at this
- 42:27point. And so we are going to start to
- 42:29see those states rights go and that we're already seeing people
- 42:32move to these certain places. So I have, I've hoped that
- 42:35independent what happens, the market will kind of settle
- 42:37itself out and while it won't be you know seamless, we'll we'll
- 42:41be on the other side of it eventually and everybody's going
- 42:43to be better off because we're going to have a tool that they
- 42:44can use. Yeah, I agree.
- 42:46I agree with that. And to be clear, like, I think
- 42:48we're going to win this battle. But I do think it is willing to
- 42:53materialize. People can't control Bitcoin and
- 42:56they're going to try everything they can to stop it.
- 43:00I I have this fool's hope, I guess, that that Larry Fink and
- 43:05people like him become useful tools, useful allies of of
- 43:11Bitcoin. The the Trojan horse metaphor
- 43:14here. Uncle Larry's going to be like
- 43:16you're going to siphon all the AUM of people holding Bitcoin
- 43:19and into my funds. Yeah, write the law.
- 43:22Pass it a lobby for that. Well, yeah, yeah, there's
- 43:28there's that part too, I suppose.
- 43:30Yeah, I mean the the thing that we, we talked to this like 6
- 43:34months in the summer about Uncle Larry, you know like Uncle
- 43:38Larry, Uncle Brian over at Coinbase.
- 43:40Like these guys are de facto, like I don't even know if it's
- 43:44debatable like extensions of the government they've been blessed,
- 43:47apply them to operate. They hand over all the
- 43:49information when required. Specifically Coinbase, they're
- 43:52the last exchange standing. So I don't, I don't know, I
- 43:56don't, I don't. I wouldn't generally push back
- 43:59on like that. I I mean I just don't see how
- 44:03Larry Fink is pro Bitcoin at the end of the day.
- 44:07Yeah, I think he's pro his pocketbook.
- 44:09Yeah, I think that's right. But you know, I, I, I don't
- 44:12know. This is the fool's hope of, like
- 44:14there's so many capitalists out there that want to use the
- 44:20American rule of law to say this is a commodity and I want to
- 44:25sell it because I want to profit from it.
- 44:28And so that's my right and and how dare you try to take that
- 44:33away from me? I'm, I won't let you.
- 44:34And at the same time, there's a bunch of congressmen who start
- 44:40to allocate to Bitcoin. You know, we already have a
- 44:42handful of them. It won't be Senator Warren.
- 44:45I think Senator Warren will be the very last one.
- 44:48But it doesn't matter if we get her.
- 44:50It matters if we get 40 Congress people, you know, to have a
- 44:57Bitcoin allocation because they're excited about the
- 45:00halving or whatever, you know, or they want to have a hedge
- 45:04against the national debt because they've become concerned
- 45:06about the national debt. And.
- 45:08And so it's that that intransigent minority idea of
- 45:11like you don't, you don't win by winning over the the king of the
- 45:17enemy, you know, but you win by slowly winning over the people
- 45:23until it becomes, you know, impossible to go against that
- 45:28the people's will. And again that's the fool's hope
- 45:32of like I believe that ultimately you you can't go
- 45:36fully against you know the the strong passionate and and base
- 45:43that has numbers sufficient numbers on any topic.
- 45:46And you know like the kosher kosher foods is like the classic
- 45:50example of the intransigent minority where like we all, we
- 45:53all eat kosher foods because it matters to a tiny group of
- 45:56people like kosher salt. We you know we have kosher salt
- 46:02and and we all buy it whether or not you know it because it
- 46:06matters to a tiny group of people and it matters a lot to
- 46:09them. And so I hope that I hope that
- 46:12Bitcoin falls into that category and and it's possible that I'm
- 46:15you know just falling for the fool's hope here and and that
- 46:19Marty's idea of a a monolithic more sinister plot to end
- 46:26Bitcoin or or sub subvert it is possible too.
- 46:30Well, to be clear, they can't end Bitcoin or subvert Bitcoin.
- 46:33They'll just prevent Americans from participating fully and
- 46:37that's that's. A that's an that's an important
- 46:39distinction, right? Because like going back to to
- 46:42Michael's analogy of of prohibition, which I loved.
- 46:45Not only is Bitcoin like much harder to enforce a ban on than
- 46:49than alcohol, but it's also a global in in where he thinks
- 46:52where this this is an international asset.
- 46:55So it's going to be very difficult for them to do
- 46:58anything that actually, you know, impairs the network to any
- 47:00real extent. They're just going to you know
- 47:02make Americans lives much harder if they want to store their
- 47:07value in Bitcoin and and that's unfortunate but I'm I I tend to
- 47:10be somewhat optimistic like Jesse is like I think our
- 47:14numbers are growing in terms of you know Congress people who
- 47:17understand this thing and are you know hopefully going to be
- 47:19willing to fight for it because the the sort of facts and
- 47:23narratives are on our side at the end of the day.
- 47:25Like Elizabeth Warren is quoting literally false data to argue.
- 47:29Her point? Like, you know, it's just it's
- 47:33just a matter of time. It's a matter of continuing to
- 47:35shift that sentiment. You know, Bitcoin is is good for
- 47:38the world. It's freedom, money, and and you
- 47:40know, the reality is what Elizabeth Warren wants to usher
- 47:43in is a much scarier future. Yeah.
- 47:47And and to be clear, like what Jesse referenced, I believe like
- 47:49the intolerant minority, all of the, the, the margins accrue and
- 47:54it'll move over. What I was referring to is I
- 47:56think like when we get off this podcast, there's like a group
- 47:59chat with Jamie Dimon Warren, Brian Armstrong and Larry Fink,
- 48:04like all just joking around about like what's going to go
- 48:07down next week at the Christmas party or whatever.
- 48:09Like that's that's what I'm I'm referring to.
- 48:11It's like to think that they all aren't have a certain like
- 48:13agenda. Maybe it's not lockstep, but
- 48:16that's where that's kind of the angle.
- 48:18It's like, I don't think those are our friends.
- 48:20I think we have friends, but I don't think it's any of those
- 48:23four. No, I don't either.
- 48:28They have ulterior motives, if you will.
- 48:31But I I want to be clear. I'm very optimistic too.
- 48:33Again, I think we'll win this battle.
- 48:35I think the incentives are too strong.
- 48:38Our friends are the incentives, right?
- 48:40Our friends are the the incentives of Bitcoin plus the
- 48:441st Amendment. And so, so long as those two
- 48:47things are in place, like Bitcoin prevails, I think.
- 48:51I don't know if you've checked in on the federal government,
- 48:54but they don't really the Constitution that much anymore.
- 48:58Yeah, the 1st Amendment is being being encroached on in various
- 49:02ways. But but you know, I don't know
- 49:05if if that falls, if the heart of the 1st Amendment falls, then
- 49:10then the US has completely fallen.
- 49:12And and I have faith that people.
- 49:15I have faith that Americans care deeply about the 1st Amendment.
- 49:20And maybe that faith is misplaced because the government
- 49:23has rather effectively hoodwinked on a variety of
- 49:26topics in the last decade or so. But.
- 49:30I still have to have. That faith.
- 49:31I can't live in a world where I where I don't have that faith.
- 49:34Yeah, and to be clear, anybody listening to us is like, all
- 49:36right, these guys are like getting too deep into the weeds.
- 49:38This is one thing Bitcoiners love to do, is think
- 49:40adversarially. There's a spectrum of potential
- 49:43outcomes to all this, and in the Bitcoin world it is suggested to
- 49:51think as adversarially as possible.
- 49:53Worst case scenario at all times, that is what's going to
- 49:56make the network as robust as possible.
- 49:58If you're designing products, companies, protocol upgrades
- 50:03with that most extreme adversarial, adversarial outcome
- 50:08in mind, like that is what's going to make the network the
- 50:11strongest in the long run. Rationalist.
- 50:15Rationalists. Bitcoin rationalists.
- 50:18No, I think rational is somewhere like more in the
- 50:21middle of the spectrum where it's like, yes, this adversarial
- 50:24extreme outcome does have a potential to materialize, but
- 50:28it's likely that the incentives that Jesse and Brian mentioned
- 50:33really do play out and it doesn't get as extreme.
- 50:35But with that being said, you should always design and plan
- 50:38for the most extreme, which is part of what we're doing here.
- 50:42I was saying rationalist mainly from the topic calling ourselves
- 50:45bitcoiners, but to your point Marty, this is it's it's
- 50:49actually important in the sense of this comes up a lot with
- 50:52people that are very rational. I mean they just are curious,
- 50:55they understand the power of changing money means and what it
- 51:00means to power structures and they're concerned when they make
- 51:02an investment on like what does the landscape look and how does
- 51:04it change and what are the trade-offs and what are the risk
- 51:06factors. So it's relevant.
- 51:07We probably have to be a little bit better in referring to it as
- 51:10a battle in the enemy. But at the end of the day, it's
- 51:12still, it's relevant and it's important to talk about and just
- 51:17know what you're what, what's at stake.
- 51:19What's actually providing a good segue for what I wanted to talk
- 51:22to is like building a company with these regulatory landmines
- 51:26in mind, like you just mentioned, like we see this all
- 51:28the time at 10:31 with prospective investors like what,
- 51:32what happens if the regulators come and shut this down?
- 51:35Like how do you advise your portfolio companies to to act in
- 51:38that situation? And that's that's one thing like
- 51:41going back to the incentives like I think everybody on this
- 51:44show believes that the incentives are gonna win out at
- 51:47the end. And as somebody who's building a
- 51:49company or allocating money to companies building in the space
- 51:53like that's you have to have that long term vision like the
- 51:56incentives are gonna win out. Yes it's gonna be it could be a
- 51:59a very bumpy ride at times but that's why it's called risk.
- 52:04Like you take the risk with all this information in mind and had
- 52:08that long term vision of this is inevitable.
- 52:11In my mind, the world's gonna get better, better money, better
- 52:14money for the digital age that that cuts out.
- 52:18Central bankers like that. It is a step function
- 52:22improvement on the incumbent monetary system that will be
- 52:24recognized by the market in time.
- 52:26And yes, there will be ups and downs in price and ups and downs
- 52:28in the regulatory environment, but in the long run it will win
- 52:32out. And that's why you go and you
- 52:34build and you you weather the storm as it washes over you.
- 52:40Yeah, I mean the crazy part with that is like we can all pretty
- 52:44much stay here safely and you can look like Bitcoin's been
- 52:47deemed A commodity. Like you're pretty, you know, if
- 52:49they decide to be in or take draconian measures, like that's
- 52:51unprecedented. But you can live with that.
- 52:53You can live with that, right? It's like the effectively, if
- 52:55you're building a gold company, they just decided one day to say
- 52:57that. But what's scary is like the
- 52:59crypto stuff, but he's like, what's an unregistered security?
- 53:02Like you imagine building on that.
- 53:03And there's a lot of these ETF providers that are actually
- 53:05like, you know, having funds that have baskets of this stuff
- 53:08and who's your counterparty? Like, that's the thing that's
- 53:10actually more when you think on the risk curve and there's
- 53:12pensions that have allocated and all this stuff is, you know,
- 53:15we've seen it. It's not even vaporware is not
- 53:17even, I don't even think it's too far stretched to say, like a
- 53:20lot of this stuff doesn't even have.
- 53:22We've seen it go to 0. And that's the crazy part from
- 53:26like, you know, building. How do you imagine?
- 53:29I I wanted to ask you guys about this because it's something I've
- 53:31been thinking about like you know the there have been you
- 53:35know a few different Ethereum ETF proposals put out there.
- 53:39And and I was thinking about it in in my mind like those are
- 53:43actually, I mean who knows if they get passed, who knows if
- 53:46they get you know more scrutinized than the Bitcoin
- 53:50ETFs or less So would be interesting to see.
- 53:53But I think in some ways like it's almost, it's almost a
- 53:57Trojan horse of sorts for people to more deeply understand the
- 54:02difference between proof of work and proof of stake.
- 54:04Because in order for these things, you know, an Ethereum
- 54:07ETF to exist, you kind of need to dig into the details of how
- 54:11proof of stake works. And so whether that's
- 54:14regulators, these asset managers or just the general public, like
- 54:18I think how that plays out will be very interesting to watch.
- 54:21Because it could be sort of this interesting Trojan horse
- 54:26scenario where it actually forces people to more deeply
- 54:29understand the differences between proof of work and proof
- 54:31of stake, and why maybe there could be more reluctance to
- 54:35allow a proof of stake based ETF.
- 54:42I I hope that's true. I fear it it like you know if if
- 54:47you're, I don't know if you're setting up like a a corn futures
- 54:50product corn or soybeans or potatoes or whatever.
- 54:56It doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to like learn more
- 54:59about corn farming. You know what what's in a
- 55:03soybean you're just focused on packaging that up and and
- 55:09creating a a new market product. So I don't know but it would be
- 55:15great if that is how it plays out.
- 55:18I'm I'm I'm skeptical that people dig into these assets
- 55:22more than what they need to to you know create a a Wall Street
- 55:26product. Well, that's a very interesting
- 55:28point Jesse, cause the people who do dig into that, just
- 55:32thinking back to my days when I worked at the Manage Futures
- 55:35Fund, it's not the people providing the vehicle to get
- 55:38access to these financial products, it's the people
- 55:42trading those products. So like going back to like
- 55:44commodities like corn, wheat, like BlackRock has a commodity.
- 55:50They don't care about what's happening in the price, they
- 55:52just have this vehicle to get fees from.
- 55:54But the people trading it are going to look at weather
- 55:57patterns in Brazil and how much rain is falling in Kansas for
- 56:02Kansas red wheat. They're gonna look at coffee
- 56:06Funguses growing in Guatemala. Like they're gonna be doing
- 56:09those deep dive research to to actually trade that product,
- 56:15hopefully profitably. But the person providing that
- 56:18product is not doing that. Yeah.
- 56:20So in that sense, Brian might be right.
- 56:22And I just was was thinking about the wrong cohort there.
- 56:26Like, you're right, it's not about the people who sponsor
- 56:30these vehicles, it's about the traders who then do their
- 56:32diligence in order to make money in that market.
- 56:36I'll take the other side. I think I had this fascinating
- 56:39conversation with an investment banker that's far down the
- 56:42rabbit hole and it came in context.
- 56:45And there's a few tweets, Marty, you probably saw last week, one
- 56:48that I saw from Phil, Phil Geiger, diamond hands, he said
- 56:52you spend money when you're done using it.
- 56:54Spending money isn't using it. I don't make the rules.
- 56:56And I think he was referencing another tweet from Bitstein or
- 57:00Pierre which was referencing Mises.
- 57:04But effectively this idea that you, you hold a better form of
- 57:08money, that's the the form of using it and when you spend it,
- 57:10it's when you're done with it. And this idea of yield.
- 57:15And so these ETFs like I can see an Ethereum ETF, you know
- 57:20passing whatever the setup or mechanism is to pass on what I
- 57:26don't even know what it what it's like you stake it and then
- 57:28you get some form of yield based on it or other ETFs that offer
- 57:33some dividend. And it's this trick that that's
- 57:37been played on. You're looking for yield because
- 57:40you're a sucker if you're not using the money to generate more
- 57:43money because everything else is inflating away.
- 57:46And that the alpha or asymmetry, this is something we talk about
- 57:49a lot when we talk about like our products and and going to
- 57:51the market is like the alpha and the yield is the money.
- 57:54You just sit on it and you sit on your hands and you don't do
- 57:57anything. And so to to the point of these
- 58:01other ETFs, they'll come about, you know Ethereum and pass on
- 58:04dividends yield. I think that will actually play
- 58:07the opposite role. Similar to an ETF that will
- 58:09offer some other kind of like exotic mechanics that try to get
- 58:13you a return above the spot price of BTC.
- 58:16Because it's just the natural state of how messed up
- 58:18everything is that we've never had since our, you know,
- 58:20relative time being alive in the market.
- 58:23That you have a form of money that should appreciate in value
- 58:27based on its deflationary mechanics, similar to what gold
- 58:30did and what we see Bitcoin doing.
- 58:32So anyway, I think like other ETFs and cryptocurrencies ETFs,
- 58:35if they pass on additional kind of quote UN quote dividends,
- 58:38it'll play to the opposite effect of like going to Bitcoin.
- 58:42I I I love that mechanic because it's so frustrating how it how
- 58:46it works. And I have to admit that I fell
- 58:49for it when when I was in crypto land and still interested in
- 58:52altcoins was, you know the these altcoins generate their their
- 58:57new yield staking Proof of stake models and you're projecting
- 59:05based on the current market value of coins, what additional
- 59:12newly generated coins that are dividended to you are worth,
- 59:18right? So you're taking that snapshot
- 59:20and projecting forward in time based on how many units there
- 59:23are today and how much each unit is worth today and you're
- 59:27calculating how much income you're going to be generating
- 59:30just by the the staking yield. But it's a moving target because
- 59:35as those new units are actually produced, the total supply has
- 59:40shifted. And so, you know, all else
- 59:43equal, each unit becomes worth less and the total value of the
- 59:49system remains flat. But now you're you're yielding
- 59:53less than you were originally envisioning.
- 59:56And that that's such a subtle sleight of hand that I think all
- 59:59of this proof of stake bullshit rests on, that people will fall
- 1:00:04for and until the market bears out that it was a bad idea in
- 1:00:09the first place. Yeah, maybe I'm too optimistic
- 1:00:13on that point. But generally speaking, like it
- 1:00:17is, you know, it's been interesting to see the past
- 1:00:20couple months, like you start to see a little bit of that retail
- 1:00:24mania coming back to markets, particularly in like altcoin
- 1:00:28land. And it's been even more
- 1:00:32interesting to see that a lot of that activity in the past couple
- 1:00:34months has been like the Solana ecosystem.
- 1:00:36So it's like this weird dynamic where it's like, oh, Sam's in
- 1:00:39jail now, his his ecosystem, his beloved ecosystem can now
- 1:00:43flourish. And you're seeing people on
- 1:00:44Twitter, you know, praise, praise the tech.
- 1:00:47And in Marty's words, it's all a bit tiresome at the end of the
- 1:00:51day. But like do you guys think
- 1:00:53we're, you know we're going to get these altcoin cycles in
- 1:00:55perpetuity, Do they ever go away or is it does it end up just
- 1:00:59ultimately being a retail only phenomenon and institutions
- 1:01:04don't dip their hands in the latest dog token, but there will
- 1:01:08always be that segment of the market that is looking for
- 1:01:10essentially a a casino type environment.
- 1:01:15Yeah. My my take on it is that so long
- 1:01:19as we're moving through the adoption curve OK for the next
- 1:01:24several decades, the next incremental slice of adopters
- 1:01:28will fall for some some sort of affinity scam and it.
- 1:01:35So that's that I think will happen and simultaneously they
- 1:01:39will get more and more exotic as the you know the the first
- 1:01:44affinity scam was Litecoin, right?
- 1:01:46Silver to Bitcoin gold and that. Like, that's at the heart of
- 1:01:50money and it didn't work right and and now several generations
- 1:01:55later in the affinity scam, you're talking about Solana, you
- 1:01:59know sushi coin. Solana's got a phone.
- 1:02:02Yeah, Solana Phone, you got to, you got to spin up these weird
- 1:02:06little products in order to drive demand.
- 1:02:08And so I think that the the trend of increasing strangeness
- 1:02:14and like distance from the core value proposition of Bitcoin
- 1:02:18will also continue. Yeah, and this pull up the tweet
- 1:02:20from Alex Leishman, CEO of River Incredible Company.
- 1:02:27Just really respect what they're building.
- 1:02:29Their new product is fantastic. Riverlink it's you.
- 1:02:32Wanna read it? Marty for.
- 1:02:33Yeah, so this is Leishman's suite is east.
- 1:02:37Looks like it's on a trajectory to become a no man's land middle
- 1:02:41ground blockchain. It's subpar money compared to
- 1:02:44Bitcoin and subpar technology platform compared to Salada.
- 1:02:47So building on Jesse's point, like that's Solana's the new
- 1:02:51Etherium. Etherium had the robust
- 1:02:55scripting capability in the world computer, the virtual
- 1:02:58machine meme, then the eventual transition of proof of stake.
- 1:03:03And then they added sprinkled on ultrasound money at the end to
- 1:03:06compete with Bitcoin on that. And they just got completely
- 1:03:11just bulldozed by Solana and will be, I think this cycle,
- 1:03:16because Solana does everything that Ethereum wanted to do from
- 1:03:20the gate, they just rebuild it from scratch at a later year.
- 1:03:23It's faster. Proof of stake, it's got a phone
- 1:03:26and then Ethereum's gonna be sitting there trying to compete
- 1:03:29with Bitcoin and Solana. And Bitcoin does money way
- 1:03:33better than Ethereum. And then Solana does all the the
- 1:03:37Fugazi sort of mystical things that you don't need a blockchain
- 1:03:43for better than Ethereum does. Yeah, it's a good question on
- 1:03:47like in perpetuity, but definitely have a few more
- 1:03:50cycles. And what Jesse's said is
- 1:03:52probably one of the most valid is like institutions when they
- 1:03:54look at cash flow analysis or whatever.
- 1:03:56Like a new cryptocurrency spitting out is going to map to
- 1:03:59how they would evaluate another asset class versus Bitcoin where
- 1:04:03it's just you just sit on it like that's insane.
- 1:04:06That's a dumb you just buy it and lock it up and then it just
- 1:04:09appreciates forever. Like, what kind of black magic
- 1:04:13are you trying to sell me, you know?
- 1:04:15Yeah, yield is a pretty Evergreen allure and that'll
- 1:04:19that'll, that's a siren call that will get everyone who's new
- 1:04:24to blockchain, Bitcoin. You know, they'll fall for some,
- 1:04:28most, most people will fall for some sort of yield idea whether
- 1:04:32or not they put capital behind it or not.
- 1:04:34And yeah, but the wild. Part is the the money is the
- 1:04:37yield. The money is the yield.
- 1:04:40Yeah, I was going to say that the, you know, Bitcoin's accused
- 1:04:45of like, oh, is it Yahoo and and Google's right around the corner
- 1:04:50is this Alta Vista, you know that people try to to to say
- 1:04:55that about Bitcoin, but that's what's happening with these
- 1:04:58technology platforms and and luckily Bitcoin is kind of
- 1:05:01immune to that problem because it's not competing on
- 1:05:02technology. It's it's money.
- 1:05:04And so it it has set its flag in this different use case and it
- 1:05:09and it's damn good at it and it has the network effect that
- 1:05:12cannot be matched in proof of work.
- 1:05:15And so like that that battle's already won.
- 1:05:18But all these other coins are competing on technology and they
- 1:05:21are all subject to this Alta Vista, Yahoo, Google problem.
- 1:05:26And yeah, to to Michael's point, we'll see if if there's like a
- 1:05:28Google that emerges as a a dominant victor eventually like
- 1:05:32a, you know, a good enough technology platform for all the
- 1:05:34Fugazi has as as Marty said. But yeah, I wouldn't be
- 1:05:40surprised if we just see endless iterations of improved
- 1:05:46technology, improved technology that that allow these other, you
- 1:05:50know, new entrants to unseat the incumbent because they're
- 1:05:56flashier while competing on technology.
- 1:05:59Meanwhile, Bitcoin has money locked up.
- 1:06:04Yeah, I agree. Interesting 'cause like go.
- 1:06:06Ahead Mark I. Was gonna say I think the cycles
- 1:06:08continue, but as Bitcoin appreciates in value, the
- 1:06:11opportunity cost of messing around with the all coins just
- 1:06:14gets significantly higher. And so I think it'll continue,
- 1:06:17but it'll get more and more suppressed over cycles.
- 1:06:21Like, I don't think. I don't think we'll ever see.
- 1:06:23That right. You have to learn that like, oh,
- 1:06:26there's a there's a scam that happens every four years and
- 1:06:29there's some new thing and now there's a track record of like
- 1:06:32how many, how many scam cycles do we need to have before people
- 1:06:35are are like. That's what we did.
- 1:06:37You might not want to touch anything besides Bitcoin.
- 1:06:40I mean, you mentioned Litecoin and you had like feather coin,
- 1:06:42pure coin, steam it a dash and you had Ethereum and you had the
- 1:06:49ICO boom, then you had the D5 boom, then you have Solana doing
- 1:06:53their D5 boom. Like there's plenty of history.
- 1:06:56That's that's actually one thing.
- 1:06:57Parker, his next book that'll never write because he doesn't
- 1:07:01want to write it. But we need somebody to write
- 1:07:03like a like a historical book. Like we've talked about this
- 1:07:06with him before. Like, we need the history book
- 1:07:08that like stamps all these scams in history and the people
- 1:07:11associated with them and just hand it to people like, hey,
- 1:07:13this has all been done before. Yeah.
- 1:07:17Charles Hawkins? Yeah.
- 1:07:19Dan Larimer, Vitalik, all these guys.
- 1:07:23I can't help but feel like the what we're talking about is a is
- 1:07:26a symptom of like the money being broken.
- 1:07:28And I think it accelerates as the money breaks further but
- 1:07:31then it comes back harder once you have a like opportunity
- 1:07:35cost. Right.
- 1:07:36Because you need your your Bitcoin and and people start to
- 1:07:38understand and then better businesses are built less people
- 1:07:41are chasing these crazy tail ends of how to get returns and
- 1:07:44then you end up without all this.
- 1:07:46Right. Like people are playing with
- 1:07:48cryptocurrency the same way they're playing with the stock
- 1:07:50market and everything else on the end of the curve because
- 1:07:54they just have a bad form of money.
- 1:07:55And so they're just like fuck it like I hope I can.
- 1:07:58You know, whether it's a micro example of an individual that's
- 1:08:01trying to just like make ends meet and they're like I'd have
- 1:08:03no chance. That's the same person that buys
- 1:08:05a lottery ticket or an institutional investor that's
- 1:08:07trying to like just, you know, make it big because they either
- 1:08:10have to hit a benchmark or they they lost a bunch of fun.
- 1:08:13So it feels like we still have to accelerate and then we'll
- 1:08:15like kind of decelerate into less of it.
- 1:08:19Yeah and and that would be the adoption curve.
- 1:08:21That'd be the the the S curve of of adoption of Bitcoin of you
- 1:08:25know that incremental each incremental slice being new
- 1:08:29people coming in and making some some form of the same old
- 1:08:32mistake until you've you've onboarded most of the world and
- 1:08:37then they appreciate the opportunity cost of Bitcoin and
- 1:08:40then you've re established true true money and and like return
- 1:08:47to a a world of like sound finance and rational capital
- 1:08:53allocation. It could be several decades
- 1:08:56away, Marty. I have a question for you.
- 1:08:59How how does it feel for being around for so long and you've
- 1:09:01been public about, you know, family members calling you you
- 1:09:04nuts and, you know, just crazy like to be looking at this money
- 1:09:07but at the same time being like a Luddite and that you're just
- 1:09:10like care about this dumb, you know, boring rock while there's
- 1:09:14all this other innovation happening and why, like, you got
- 1:09:16to be more open minded? It's very frustrating, but
- 1:09:20you'll learn to live with it. It's hilarious.
- 1:09:22You're never right. It's like just a crazy contrast,
- 1:09:25like two sides and you're just sitting there like fuck.
- 1:09:27Because I forget. I mean, this goes back to like
- 1:09:30the Uppy Elite thing. It works in fractals, and it's
- 1:09:34not always the Uppy Elite. I saw like an interesting tweet
- 1:09:37thread the other week, but it was essentially like a start up
- 1:09:40founder who was like trying to tell his family that he, he had
- 1:09:44success and they were just like, yeah, whatever.
- 1:09:46Like I think and just like the ways humans are socially it's
- 1:09:51like especially like in familial situations for some reason or
- 1:09:55another a lot of people don't want to they they get a little
- 1:09:58jealous if somebody's succeeding and they have to find find like
- 1:10:04poke holes in it be like, no, you're wrong.
- 1:10:06It's this other thing the the uncle that I shield Bitcoin to
- 1:10:11in like 2014 his son was shielding me.
- 1:10:13Ripple 2017. And he was like yeah, he's he's
- 1:10:19like he's into crypto now. He knows what he's doing.
- 1:10:21I was like, all right, don't want to spill.
- 1:10:27I didn't. Know he was going to pull this
- 1:10:30out. Where did you put that in?
- 1:10:39Where did you find that? I didn't even see that pull that
- 1:10:41one. Out.
- 1:10:42Just tweeted it out. Somebody literally just tweeted
- 1:10:44out like 30 seconds ago. Time to start eating all the
- 1:10:47canned goods I bought two years ago when Marty Benz said they
- 1:10:50were attacking the food system. Collapses in it.
- 1:10:53They have attacked the food system.
- 1:10:55You're eating industrial sludge, putting crickets in your food.
- 1:10:57Now it. It is a great example.
- 1:11:02It's a great example, Marty, of like, and I think this is part
- 1:11:06of, this is part of what the yuppie elite are frustrated
- 1:11:08about when it comes to Bitcoin is that people who are
- 1:11:14predisposed to see everything as like you know, crisis is
- 1:11:21imminent or like you know the society's going to collapse.
- 1:11:25And people who who think in that way or are prone to that got to
- 1:11:30Bitcoin earlier and made and made a lot of money by, you
- 1:11:34know, some of the earliest bitcoiners were like, shit's
- 1:11:37going to hit the fan and I need to get out of the banking system
- 1:11:40and they bought Bitcoin, you know, at a dollar.
- 1:11:43And and that's like that was very much wrong in in 2010.
- 1:11:48It didn't, you know, that didn't pan out that way.
- 1:11:51But it worked in their favour and they made a fortune by being
- 1:11:56early to Bitcoin. And I think that is so pain that
- 1:11:59that hurts the yuppie elite so much to know that like, people
- 1:12:05are prone to like, conspiracy thinking, conspiracy theory
- 1:12:08thinking or. Like, are you trying to say
- 1:12:10Jessie, you're. Trying to know, Marty, I I think
- 1:12:13you're on that side of the curve, you know, got to Bitcoin
- 1:12:181st and that is so madding to an MBA or somebody who works in
- 1:12:23Wall Street. Yes, and I want to be clear.
- 1:12:26I love my uncle and my cousin. That's make that clear.
- 1:12:31But also, like, if you don't believe that men and women of
- 1:12:34power conspire to do things, I don't know what to I don't know
- 1:12:38what to tell you did. Everybody.
- 1:12:42This is a random, but it ties into this.
- 1:12:44Did you ever listen to the Tucker Carlson on All In
- 1:12:46Podcast? I did not.
- 1:12:48Really. Yeah.
- 1:12:49Like I haven't. I haven't seen it yet.
- 1:12:51It it was very good. But there was a there was a
- 1:12:54point there where they talk about people that make a lot of
- 1:12:57like wealth. They kind of destroy themselves
- 1:13:00and like Tucker's experience with people and working through
- 1:13:02it. And and there was a point I was
- 1:13:04like talking to my wife about And I was like, well, they're
- 1:13:06they're caveat in like people that are guilty that found
- 1:13:09fortunes very quickly in the same way somebody that bought a
- 1:13:12lottery ticket or maybe, you know, in a in a loose monster
- 1:13:16society where you can like hit it big easy, caught the right
- 1:13:19tailwind of like a startup or whatever it might be.
- 1:13:22And then you you know that it wasn't there.
- 1:13:24It wasn't all you. And everybody's looking at you
- 1:13:26like a genius. And there's just like natural
- 1:13:27thing versus kind of proof of work and slowly making your way
- 1:13:31through it. And and this like having this
- 1:13:33discussion, it kind of tied back to our discussion about like
- 1:13:37where we're headed. And it's not going to be
- 1:13:39seamless. And I think that there's a part
- 1:13:40of it and we've all probably experienced this.
- 1:13:42It's like it's not really like we we want to get to the other
- 1:13:44end of it and succeed in anything we do.
- 1:13:46But it's really like the journey is a big part of the fulfilling
- 1:13:50aspect of it and like having these discussions and being able
- 1:13:52to help people and see that light bulb when they when it
- 1:13:55clicks for them. So I think like, you know, at
- 1:13:57least personally a lot of this discussion or we talked about
- 1:13:59like it's not going to be easy, but it's like it wouldn't really
- 1:14:02not to be cliched with like or trite, but this is kind of like,
- 1:14:05you know, at least for me personally what I'm most excited
- 1:14:07for. I can't imagine a better time.
- 1:14:09And while it may be a little difficult at certain points it
- 1:14:12wouldn't be like really worth it to see all this like happen in
- 1:14:15real time if it's just like tomorrow it turned on
- 1:14:17everything's money. We kind of we may be like, it
- 1:14:20would be nice to seamlessly transition that I guess that
- 1:14:23that would take. But it's reality is when we look
- 1:14:26back at this, when we get on the other side, it's gonna all make
- 1:14:28sense and feel a lot. We're gonna feel fulfilled to
- 1:14:31like have gone through it. So yeah.
- 1:14:36That's the Solana people think, too.
- 1:14:40I doubt that, no. But it's true.
- 1:14:42It's been a long journey. It's been a long decade, which
- 1:14:45is crazy to think, but it's been fun, a lot of ups and downs and
- 1:14:49that's what I think having been in this for how many ever
- 1:14:54cycles. I think that's Michael, to your
- 1:14:57point, the one thing I'm most proud of this year is I've
- 1:15:00worked the hardest I have since being in this industry to
- 1:15:02prepare for whatever may come next.
- 1:15:06And I think we all agree it's up and to the right as has
- 1:15:10historically happened and it's been a lot of hard work, a lot
- 1:15:13of hard decisions and it will all be worth it, I think at the
- 1:15:17end of the day for all of us. Yeah, I think about 2021 and
- 1:15:21like the price ripping and if it all just took off for there and
- 1:15:23that was it. Like, I personally feel a lot,
- 1:15:26like a lot more unfulfilled based on what you just said.
- 1:15:28Like this past year, the things you've learned, the things built
- 1:15:30like, well, it's not easy. You get on the other side of it,
- 1:15:32you're like, oh, I wouldn't change it for the world.
- 1:15:34And so it's like that happens to a lot of people.
- 1:15:35And then they look back and they're like, oh, this was this
- 1:15:37is like the whole idea of you get what you want and then it's
- 1:15:39not really what you wanted. And that's the whole, like the
- 1:15:42concept of it. It's going to take time, but it
- 1:15:45makes sense that it takes time, because if it was easy, then
- 1:15:47it's just like not actually what you're trying to get to the
- 1:15:49other side of. I empathize at that point.
- 1:15:54I may never have left the triad fire world if things had just
- 1:15:57ripped in 21. Continuously gave gave me the
- 1:16:01opportunity to figure out what I actually wanted to do.
- 1:16:04And and you know, the dodge rooms can be nice to your point.
- 1:16:09Yeah, Brian would be still be writing about chain link at
- 1:16:11Coinbase would be. Hopefully not.
- 1:16:16Hopefully I would have, yeah. That would have been tough.
- 1:16:19Yeah. I mean, maybe this is like a
- 1:16:20point to reflect on this year. Obviously bitcoin's up a lot
- 1:16:25getting on the other side of the bear market, but it is that
- 1:16:28pressure, that stress does produce results if you're
- 1:16:32willing to put the work in. And I'm not trying to be some
- 1:16:37inspirational like I can like work hard guru right now but
- 1:16:46it's personally speaking. Yeah like it, it bear market has
- 1:16:49had a lot of stressful times for me personally, but it also
- 1:16:54forced me to be like all right how do we, how do we actually
- 1:16:56build a business here at TFTC at 10:31 and prepare for the next
- 1:17:03inflow. And that's what I'm most excited
- 1:17:05to see is but a lot of the companies on ramp obviously you
- 1:17:08guys been sprinting hard for the last year getting everything up
- 1:17:13like all the hard work you guys have been put in all the hard
- 1:17:15work of many other companies in the space.
- 1:17:18We mentioned Alex and River, you mentioned that that product they
- 1:17:21dropped last week, Jesse, that link product.
- 1:17:23I could see that being massive in the bull market, like just
- 1:17:27seeing everybody who's been in this for so long, building and
- 1:17:31knowing a lot of the people in the industry, talking to them
- 1:17:34behind the scenes and knowing they've been going through
- 1:17:36similar stresses. It's funny your your stress is
- 1:17:40tightly correlated to the price of Bitcoin and it's inverse.
- 1:17:43The the lower it goes, the higher your stress, the higher
- 1:17:45it goes, the the less high your stress is, but still a little
- 1:17:49high. Everybody, a lot of people have
- 1:17:51been working hard. I'm just extremely excited to
- 1:17:54see all that work pay off in the next cycle.
- 1:17:58Yeah, here's to a Here's to a stress bear market for the next
- 1:18:03year. You getting too gushy here,
- 1:18:07boys? No, I I I was thinking about you
- 1:18:12you made me think about Michael Saylor did it in one of his many
- 1:18:16interviews had a great little bit about I think he said 50%
- 1:18:23Kager annual growth rate is is about as fast as any asset can
- 1:18:27monetize and and and society can process that.
- 1:18:34And you know I think his point there the the kind of hidden
- 1:18:38point there is really profound of like this is a, this is a
- 1:18:41human process is playing out and all of the all of our individual
- 1:18:47psychology has to update to what Bitcoin is and is becoming and
- 1:18:53how it changes over time. And then all of the systems that
- 1:18:56we build as a as a group, as a society like the businesses, the
- 1:19:02institutions, the the legal code around a particular asset has
- 1:19:08have to be updated and built and that that process takes time.
- 1:19:15And so that that 50% mechanism you know which which manifests
- 1:19:20as these these bull markets that turn into mini bubbles and then
- 1:19:24crash to wash out that inflated optimism and and you know
- 1:19:32restore sentiment to like neutral that has to happen in
- 1:19:37order to stop a 50% kegger endlessly from becoming like
- 1:19:42overheated. Because if you if you got 50%
- 1:19:45kegger every year and and then that 50% was reliable every
- 1:19:49year, people would speculate too much and that's that's what
- 1:19:53happens. You know so the the reset the
- 1:19:55bear markets are just a reset of sentiment.
- 1:19:57You have to wash out the the speculators and and then you.
- 1:20:01At the same time, you have to allow for individual psychology
- 1:20:05and societal psychology and and systems and and institutions to
- 1:20:13incorporate the amount of change that has occurred over the last
- 1:20:16few years, process it and get ready for the next wave of
- 1:20:19change. So it's all like, it's all so
- 1:20:22beautiful how it it just has to happen this way.
- 1:20:25It can't. Bitcoin can't go through the
- 1:20:28adoption curve any other way. It has to go through these
- 1:20:30little mini Tulip Tulip bulb rallies every four years.
- 1:20:38There's just no other way. And it's it's beautiful.
- 1:20:41Yeah. And and that that's actually
- 1:20:43really topical because we talk about it like me and Cam often
- 1:20:46because we were you know the trenches onboarding individuals
- 1:20:49to multi sig. And when you think about like
- 1:20:51where we sit today couldn't existed without multi sig
- 1:20:54operators like a cost of unchanged like that market
- 1:20:57awareness that this thing exists, just the concept that
- 1:20:59you can split up the keys. But then you add to that the
- 1:21:02FTXS of the world that if you go two years ago it's probably too
- 1:21:06soon to talk about multi institution because it's like
- 1:21:08what you can trust institutions and obviously like Quadri you
- 1:21:11know Mount Cox and others had failed but not at the level that
- 1:21:16happened in 2022. When you know we look at the top
- 1:21:19five to 10 firms in the space or or like half of them are in jail
- 1:21:23and the other half are insolvent.
- 1:21:25So there's a lot of examples like that where you go across
- 1:21:28the spectrum. It's like it just had it had to
- 1:21:30happen. It was path dependent and you
- 1:21:32just have to make sure you don't die along the way and you're
- 1:21:34around long enough to like learn and then just like continue to
- 1:21:38when the bear happens rather than like you know there's no
- 1:21:41shortage of tradify folks that I talked to that we're looking to
- 1:21:43go back and like half did or a lot did and then others were
- 1:21:46like no, I'm going to tough it out.
- 1:21:47And because on the other side of that is you know, obviously we
- 1:21:51know what happens and then it just starts that next wave and
- 1:21:53opportunity base again, yeah. We're we're salty.
- 1:22:00We we've been through it. You know, I'm tired.
- 1:22:04I'm tired, Jesse. I don't know about Salty.
- 1:22:06Tired of it all? Yeah, I don't think the people,
- 1:22:09I don't think the people building altcoins have these
- 1:22:13scars or or perspective on like, you know, this is a marathon in
- 1:22:20Block Fi was built by people who were sprinting to a finish line
- 1:22:23that, you know, fell out, fell out before them.
- 1:22:29Yeah. So it's very funny to think
- 1:22:31about, like if you were to go on like an altcoin podcast and and
- 1:22:35ask about like the sentiment there, I think people would.
- 1:22:38The market's wrong would. Be like, yeah, the market's
- 1:22:41wrong and everything is about to change and we're about to enter
- 1:22:44a new paradigm where Solana takes over and and versus this
- 1:22:49kind of measured approach that we all have here of like, yeah,
- 1:22:53Bitcoin's gonna have another bear market and it's how it's
- 1:22:56gonna go. Do we see a bankless pivot
- 1:22:59during this bear, this bull market?
- 1:23:01They make too much money to ever update their reality.
- 1:23:09I don't know if if what Alex Leishman tweeted materializes,
- 1:23:14it's a lot of pumps. They could become a Solana
- 1:23:17podcast. At some point that that I could
- 1:23:19see, I could see that's what you're saying.
- 1:23:21Yeah, yeah, a bank. List has up upgraded from Yahoo
- 1:23:26to Google and Google is Solana. And now we all are a Solana
- 1:23:30podcast. I could totally see that.
- 1:23:33Yeah. It's it's The funny thing, like
- 1:23:36you mentioned, they're very successful.
- 1:23:40It's a there's something about the the altcoin narratives that
- 1:23:43really catches people. I I do think of everything we
- 1:23:46said maybe the old world, I think we we see the same stuff,
- 1:23:51but we see it around like securitization of assets and
- 1:23:54whatever they do in stable coins and like interesting exotic
- 1:23:57ways. Like, I think we'll see the new
- 1:23:59institutional flavors of what we just described.
- 1:24:03I don't think it looks exactly like the crypto I think we see
- 1:24:05in the institutional version of this stuff.
- 1:24:08I don't know if you. It has.
- 1:24:09To be that if it if it spreads to the institutional world, it
- 1:24:12has to be something like that because like they're not going
- 1:24:14to buy the new dog token. I mean I hope they don't, but
- 1:24:18like it has to be a different flavor for the institutions
- 1:24:21relative to like the retail focus mania.
- 1:24:23Because the the sort of continuing narrative there is
- 1:24:27just like meme coin, like no actual value just let's
- 1:24:30speculate on this thing going up.
- 1:24:34And so there's new dog coins, some old dog coins.
- 1:24:36But yeah, it's got to be. We did see a little match on.
- 1:24:40But we did see like jump in Terra Luna, which is effectively
- 1:24:43what what what you just described.
- 1:24:45That was the closest we've gotten to it from an
- 1:24:47institutional kind of level and Terra Luna.
- 1:24:51There's nothing stopping like JP Morgan from from spinning up
- 1:24:56Ripple 2.0. You know, like like what's the
- 1:25:00the value proposition of Ripple is like like that this is gonna
- 1:25:02be some interbank currency. But you could, you could have
- 1:25:06that done by a bank and they could, you know, claim that
- 1:25:10we're gonna do transactions this way and you create, but then
- 1:25:13they stake their whole reputation on it and that would
- 1:25:15be a a whole mess. I see.
- 1:25:19I was gonna mention I see the stable coins being the Trojan
- 1:25:22horse and then they get exotic. They'll try to like securitize
- 1:25:27mineral rights using a blockchain and track the the
- 1:25:30flow of natural gas from upstream to midstream to to end
- 1:25:33the market using a blockchain or something like that.
- 1:25:35But on that note, like did you guys see this week like tether
- 1:25:40coming out, freezing, addresses going full, we're gonna be OFAC
- 1:25:44compliant like. I did not see that.
- 1:25:47Maybe the pirate of the industry turns into the darling of of the
- 1:25:51tradfi world. Sort of.
- 1:25:54It seems like they're beginning to position themselves as a
- 1:25:59competitive circle in regards to being regulatory compliant.
- 1:26:02I don't know, it could be wrong, Brian.
- 1:26:04That's how your your eyes rise there.
- 1:26:06No, it was it was definitely an interesting twist.
- 1:26:08It's not something that I I necessarily expected to see.
- 1:26:12I wouldn't say necessarily that that means US regulators are
- 1:26:16gonna cozy up to tether in the boys like I I think their their
- 1:26:20preferred stable coin will probably still continue to be
- 1:26:23circle, but it is a it was somewhat of a surprising
- 1:26:27development. I mean what isn't Tether isn't
- 1:26:33kind of like a good chance tether is already cozied up like
- 1:26:36how do you manage that much treasuries and like those those
- 1:26:39go through, you know, coordinating banks.
- 1:26:42It's it's at Cantor Fitzgerald you.
- 1:26:46Know CEO was on CNBC pumping. I love tether.
- 1:26:50I love tether. Did you hear the clip where he
- 1:26:52referenced? I don't know if it's the same
- 1:26:54one, but re referenced like Bitcoin, love it.
- 1:26:56You know all the value props seems like, yeah, Ethereum, like
- 1:26:58Joe Joe Lubing can just turn that thing off whenever he
- 1:27:01wants. Yeah.
- 1:27:04I didn't hear that one. That's awesome.
- 1:27:06Yeah, I forgot his name. CEO of Cantor Fitzgerald.
- 1:27:10He seems to get it. Yeah.
- 1:27:12Or, you know, that's that's a perfect example though of like
- 1:27:15there's a guy who can make money this whole industry or at least
- 1:27:19like, you know, trying to put a little bit of weight behind
- 1:27:22like, yeah, we should allow this.
- 1:27:24And you know, CEO of Cantor Fitzgerald doesn't have no
- 1:27:28influence. So add up all those guys and
- 1:27:31that's, that's I think how you can overcome the Senator
- 1:27:35Warren's. Yeah, All right.
- 1:27:39We got to wrap up here. Soon 2024.
- 1:27:41Predictions Ho ho. What's the start?
- 1:27:46Let's get 3. 3 each. Or three together.
- 1:27:51All together. 3 each. OK, so all right, I I'm not.
- 1:28:02Saying that this is what I. Think will happen, but I'm
- 1:28:05saying that I wouldn't be surprised if we have a end of
- 1:28:09year peak which would be way faster.
- 1:28:14Than I think most. People are are thinking like
- 1:28:16it's possible in my mind that we have a end of 2024 peak and that
- 1:28:23would be kind of just an extrapolation of how cycles have
- 1:28:28been. The bull markets have been
- 1:28:29getting faster. In 2017 it was an 18 month bull
- 1:28:36market. The in 2021 the from having to
- 1:28:42enthusiasm peak which I'll say was was spring 2021 that was 11
- 1:28:49months. And so it's possible that we
- 1:28:52have like, you know, another rapid bull market which would
- 1:28:57only happen if like if the market is starting to learn, OK,
- 1:29:01having happens, bull market happens.
- 1:29:05And so I need to pile in and not waste any time.
- 1:29:09And so that could be a trend that's happening here.
- 1:29:11And so I'll say that, I'll say that that would be a possible
- 1:29:16prediction for 2024. Yeah, you got two more.
- 1:29:22Let's do it. Let's go around the.
- 1:29:24Horn. So I can.
- 1:29:24OK, we'll do one. We'll do one each.
- 1:29:26All right, I think. I would, I would say.
- 1:29:30We'll get at. Least.
- 1:29:33One to three more. Nation states.
- 1:29:36Come out in support of Bitcoin, whether that means they announce
- 1:29:40mining operations or just, you know it as you know, recognizing
- 1:29:46it as a currency in some way shape or format.
- 1:29:51So one to three new nation states added to that short list
- 1:29:55of countries that support Bitcoin.
- 1:29:57And then we're going to have Jesse do a 24 hour live stream
- 1:30:00of the halving and his shirt is off by hour 21.
- 1:30:06That sounds good. Just so long as that.
- 1:30:10That block reward gets cut in half, thank you very much. 2024
- 1:30:19we see at. Least one larger entity play in
- 1:30:23the space that ends up at the same fate of as in 2022, that
- 1:30:28it's caught offsides, whether it's with custody or some form
- 1:30:31of counterparty risk that brings back to the forefront.
- 1:30:35You know why custody matters? Yeah.
- 1:30:37OK, got a bold one. Here ETF.
- 1:30:40Does not get approved in January, OK, so just not January
- 1:30:46still. Approved.
- 1:30:47During the year but. Just not January.
- 1:30:49Yeah, I think it'll get approved in March.
- 1:30:52Could be wrong. That's possible.
- 1:30:54That and. We'll hit six figures in 2024.
- 1:31:00Yeah man, 6 figure Bitcoin's like different paradigm though.
- 1:31:06Like that's the real. Just heady, kind of everything
- 1:31:10changes. Like, Are you ready for a
- 1:31:12different paradigm, Michael? It's gonna happen in 2024.
- 1:31:15It has been predicted but that but that goes.
- 1:31:18Against like, the thing. With Jesse referencing if we hit
- 1:31:206. Figures in 2024.
- 1:31:21I don't think we peak in at the end of the year.
- 1:31:23Like, I think it just it's ripping for a while.
- 1:31:25No, we Bitcoin never peaks, OK? What I mean like this?
- 1:31:30What I mean this cycle like it? Doesn't it doesn't hit.
- 1:31:32Twenty 100K, whatever, 120. And then it's just like like we
- 1:31:37go into 2025 roaring we're gonna.
- 1:31:39It. RIPS 700 at least.
- 1:31:45No, no, I'm just kidding. No, I'm just getting bashful.
- 1:31:48ETS is not going to be on conference day.
- 1:31:51Yeah, 700 by conference. Day ETF is not get approved.
- 1:31:55I bet we'd touch six figures at some point next year.
- 1:32:01I. I think that we'll have one.
- 1:32:04Other At least one other Fortune 500 company add.
- 1:32:10Bitcoin to their balance that was going to.
- 1:32:11Be my other one, some more corporate adoption is likely.
- 1:32:15Yeah, specifically because of the FASB rule.
- 1:32:18Which Michael Saylor's very excited about and nobody else
- 1:32:21seems to like appreciate just how big of a deal it is.
- 1:32:25And and Michael Saylor's right it it makes it possible for
- 1:32:30makes it possible for everyone to see the Micro Strategy
- 1:32:33Playbook and be like Oh well I want to mark to market the value
- 1:32:37of my holdings in a Bitcoin bull market and and record those as
- 1:32:41profits. Like everyone's gonna want to do
- 1:32:45that or should want to do that. So hopefully that begins the
- 1:32:49real adoption of by corporates. You're gonna need a hash.
- 1:32:56My second. Wow, so doubling hash?
- 1:33:00Not quite double. It's at like 500 right now.
- 1:33:03Yeah, I'll, I'll piggyback on that in like more nation state.
- 1:33:07Vertical integration of mining, whether it's nuclear, whatever,
- 1:33:14whatever they're gonna. Go like I think.
- 1:33:17UAE, Latin America, we're gonna see a lot more tap in, a lot
- 1:33:23more firms tap into that or countries.
- 1:33:28OK, I'll say. I'll predict that we won't have
- 1:33:33an all time high for. Until Q4 next year.
- 1:33:43Which you know, I think is later than a lot of people would be
- 1:33:45thinking. I think it's just I think we're
- 1:33:49going to be surprised again by how much of A non event the
- 1:33:55having appears to be. You know when it happens, and
- 1:33:58then for several months following, I know you just
- 1:34:01contradicted yourself. Nope.
- 1:34:03Nope. Nope.
- 1:34:05No, I didn't. Yeah, I thought we were gonna
- 1:34:06get appears, appears. To be a non event.
- 1:34:08Appears to be a non event and and and.
- 1:34:10Then but. Beneath the surface, the
- 1:34:14available for sale supply of Bitcoin is being eaten up by the
- 1:34:20demand that is no longer fully satisfied by newly created
- 1:34:24Bitcoin, so that that would be reflected in price.
- 1:34:29What's that? Wouldn't that be reflected in
- 1:34:30price? Yeah, I think.
- 1:34:32There's a lag. Effect.
- 1:34:33I think there's there's not that far.
- 1:34:34From all time highs though, Jesse, Yeah, I'll, I'll take the
- 1:34:37other side. I think we hit all time high bot
- 1:34:39before. The halving and and so Brian,
- 1:34:42my, my. I guess I'm just scarred by you.
- 1:34:46Just try to hedge. You just try to hedge your
- 1:34:48predictions. I don't like your.
- 1:34:49Predictions have to be a lie. Spicy predictions Kind of.
- 1:34:52You know, they're both. Kind of, radical of.
- 1:34:56Q4 all time. High and also Q4 peak.
- 1:35:01So that would be that would be like a 2017 scenario where we
- 1:35:04went, we went parabolic in the last three months of the year.
- 1:35:09Yeah, we'll see. BlackRock ETF just got a Ticker
- 1:35:14I. Thought it already did.
- 1:35:19It's a ticker, Larry. Closely.
- 1:35:22Also, I bet I. Bet, I bet.
- 1:35:25Well, while I think that. While I think that we could see.
- 1:35:28A peak in 2024. It's not my base case.
- 1:35:30My base case is is, I don't know, Q2 2025, says Blackrock's
- 1:35:36proposed spot, Bitcoin ETF Christian with ticker.
- 1:35:38Ibit and updated filings include new language about cash
- 1:35:42redemption versus Incon. Breaking news on the last trade
- 1:35:48We're gonna need a. Special special two weeks
- 1:35:51starting the year. Just ETF madness.
- 1:35:54That's We got memes here already.
- 1:35:56I bet The corn and the. Corn one.
- 1:35:58I bet the corn and the corn one. Marty, do you wanna Who?
- 1:36:04Or maybe Jesse. Jesse.
- 1:36:06Has a connection with Uncle Larry if he wants to come on the
- 1:36:08pod, it's like the year. You mean Larry Fink?
- 1:36:13Yeah, Larry. Larry Fink.
- 1:36:14Your buddy, your buddy, your buddy the, the.
- 1:36:16The. The good act Savior.
- 1:36:19Savior to Larry I'll. Just shoot him a quick.
- 1:36:21Message and say, hey Larry, I've been saying that you actually.
- 1:36:24Like Bitcoin? And that you're good for
- 1:36:26Bitcoin. So won't you come on our
- 1:36:28podcast? I'm sure he'll answer that.
- 1:36:31Send him your article you wrote with the structurally broken
- 1:36:34vehicle. He he created with a with a
- 1:36:36block of a wheel. I'll love that, yeah.
- 1:36:41Larry and I are actually Pen. Pals on the next letter I.
- 1:36:44Write them. I'll throw out the invite.
- 1:36:48Nice. An open letter to Larry Fink
- 1:36:50makes you a pen. Pal, Yeah, he's he's so.
- 1:36:52Old school. He doesn't even use phones.
- 1:36:53He just he's he's big in the. Written word, pen to paper,
- 1:36:58flight to quality. Flight to quality, gentlemen.
- 1:37:05Let's be thankful for this. Year.
- 1:37:06I mean, we started the show. Going strong.
- 1:37:09Most podcasts will make it past three episodes.
- 1:37:12We are. We hit our 30th last last one.
- 1:37:15This is We hit 30th. I was guessing we're.
- 1:37:17In the high 20s, No. Yeah, we hit. 30 I was looking
- 1:37:20at something, Yeah, so 30. First episode we we beat we
- 1:37:24bucked to Trent it's. Been a great, been a great time.
- 1:37:27Week in week out talking with you 2 Brian a couple times,
- 1:37:32other guest. Still working on my my outro for
- 1:37:35this. I'm going to try it.
- 1:37:36We wrap up today, but it's been fun.
- 1:37:40I think people are getting value out of it.
- 1:37:42Yeah, the reception that's. My prediction for.
- 1:37:44For 2024, actually is. Marty will figure out his outro
- 1:37:48for this podcast. This is the last trade, but this
- 1:37:59is not the last. Episode of The Last Trade.
- 1:38:01We'll be back next week, next next year, next year, next year,
- 1:38:05next year 20. 23. I fucked it up already.
- 1:38:08Yeah, we'll try again next year. We're gonna respect everyone's
- 1:38:11family's time. Oh, we, We're out.