Latest / The Vegan Report / Vegan Feminism in a Nutshell | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00This is Dr. Wren for The Vegan Report. Today's
- 0:04episode we'll be discussing the controversial
- 0:06perhaps topic of feminism and is it necessary
- 0:09for effective vegan outreach. I will be arguing
- 0:12that yes, it is not only essential but it has
- 0:15been fundamental to effective animal advocacy
- 0:17and vegan outreach from the very beginning of
- 0:20professional activism in the 19th century. If
- 0:23you'd like to learn more about me and the work
- 0:24that I do, before we get started, I'll direct
- 0:26you to coreyleen .com. And there you can find
- 0:34all of my research available to view and download
- 0:37free of charge. You can also find my YouTube
- 0:41channel at coreyleen. And I'm also on Instagram
- 0:44at coreyleen. And I have a newsletter and you
- 0:48can sign up for that if you go to my website.
- 0:50I am a senior lecturer of sociology at the University
- 0:53of Kent in Canterbury, England, and I'm the co
- 0:55-director of the Center for the Study of Social
- 0:57and Political Movements. And I received my PhD
- 1:00in sociology with Colorado State University in
- 1:032016. I'm past chair of the Animals and Society
- 1:07section of the American Sociological Association.
- 1:11And I was in the past a chair for that same section.
- 1:16I'm also the co -founder of the International
- 1:19Association. of vegan sociologists. I've published
- 1:23four books, five books, jeez, one's coming up.
- 1:27I've published four books so far on effective
- 1:29animal outreach and that is A Rational Approach
- 1:32to Animal Rights published by Palgrave in 2016,
- 1:36Peace Now protests, Animal Rights in the Age
- 1:38of Nonprofits that was published with the University
- 1:41of Michigan Press 2019, Animals in Irish Society
- 1:44published with SUNY Press 2021, Vegan Witchcraft,
- 1:48Contemporary Magical Practice, and Multi -Species
- 1:50Social Change, which is published by Rootledge
- 1:52this year, and forthcoming that should be released,
- 1:56gosh, if not in 2026 and definitely in 2027.
- 2:01I'm about to hand in the final draft for that,
- 2:03which is what, while we're talking about feminism
- 2:06today, the topic is vegan feminism. The book
- 2:08is called Vegan Feminism, History, Theory, Activism,
- 2:11and that will be coming with Bloomsbury Epidemic.
- 2:15So that's me in a nutshell. I'm really well published
- 2:17in these topics and I've been doing vegan feminism
- 2:20for 10 plus years and as part of my research
- 2:24for this forthcoming book I've really delved
- 2:26into what I would consider three major waves
- 2:29of vegan feminism since the 19th century. Now
- 2:33many people when they think of vegan advocacy,
- 2:37they think of it as something that is gender
- 2:39neutral, even race neutral or class neutral,
- 2:42ethnicity neutral. But actually, that's just
- 2:45not the way our society works. I can tell you
- 2:47as a sociologist that we're always viewing our
- 2:50social world through the lens of gender, race,
- 2:54and oftentimes class as well. So it really isn't
- 2:58doing us any favors if we try to pretend that
- 3:00gender doesn't matter. So I'm going to be talking
- 3:03today about my expertise as a sociologist and
- 3:08also someone who focuses on social movement theory.
- 3:11But I should also direct you to the wild and
- 3:13wonderful world of vegan social psychology. And
- 3:17they've been doing quite a lot of research that
- 3:19actually supports there is evidence that in people's
- 3:23minds, they do connect their attitudes about
- 3:27gender, race, and so on with their attitudes
- 3:29toward animals. So in the past 10 plus years,
- 3:32we now have evidence to support what vegan feminist
- 3:35theory has been arguing all along, that yes,
- 3:38gender does matter. So let me start by explaining
- 3:41what vegan feminism is and where it comes from,
- 3:44what its history is. So vegan feminism is basically
- 3:46making the argument that we can't fully understand
- 3:50veganism or advocate for other animals or promote
- 3:52veganism without having a critique of gender.
- 3:57So the idea with feminism, if we can even break
- 3:59it down further, feminism is not about hating
- 4:01men, bashing men, isolating from men. Feminism
- 4:06is all about the idea that gender should not
- 4:09matter when we are distributing resources, and
- 4:13gender should not matter as far as someone's
- 4:15quality of life and their life chances. However,
- 4:18we do live in a very gender unequal society.
- 4:20We do live in an andro -centric society, which
- 4:22means male -centered. And just as a quick example
- 4:26of that, if you look at most legislative seats
- 4:29in the world, globally, it's about 80 % of those
- 4:33go to men. In the United States, where I'm from,
- 4:36we still have not had a female president, and
- 4:37we probably won't for a very long time. Most
- 4:40of the people who are in important judicial seats,
- 4:44they are also men. Law historically has been
- 4:46designed around the male point of view and to
- 4:48protect male interests, et cetera, et cetera,
- 4:51et cetera. So we don't live in a post -feminist
- 4:54society where gender doesn't matter anymore because
- 4:56somehow feminism has solved all of our problems
- 4:58too. Contrary, we still have quite a lot of institutionalized
- 5:02sexism. And gender still is a key determinant
- 5:05in someone's life chances and their quality of
- 5:07life and resources they'll have access to. We
- 5:10have a lot of disparity over career aspects,
- 5:12for instance, what kind of jobs are open to you,
- 5:15kind of opportunities are open to you. And also,
- 5:18we have major disparities in pay. So we still
- 5:21have a big gender pay gap, which gets even worse,
- 5:23by the way, when you bring in race, class, et
- 5:26cetera. So the idea then with feminism is that
- 5:30we should not live in a society where that is
- 5:32the case. It should be a society where everyone
- 5:34is free to express their gender identity however
- 5:37they want and in some cases some feminists would
- 5:39also say maybe get rid of gender altogether and
- 5:41let people just be people. But it's not about
- 5:44putting men down or waging a war against men.
- 5:47That's not the case. So when we look at being
- 5:49in feminism, it's a similar situation. We should
- 5:53not have a case where masculinity and patriarchy
- 5:57is shaping our relationship with other animals
- 5:59or our diets, plant -based or not plant -based,
- 6:02but it's simply not the case. It is very much
- 6:05so true that gender does shape our relationship
- 6:08with animals and our diets. So for instance,
- 6:12we know that men are more likely to be consuming
- 6:16animal products and far more animal products
- 6:19than women. So part of men's Gender expression
- 6:23is through domination. So that's really about
- 6:26masculine and masculine T. Traditionally has
- 6:28been understood that it's about domination and
- 6:31so it's a very conflict -based gender Patriarchy
- 6:36is a very conflict -based social arrangement.
- 6:39So one way that you can express your masculinity
- 6:41is by putting down others and sort of making
- 6:43yourself king of the mountain, however you want
- 6:45to phrase that. And so putting down animals,
- 6:48consuming animals, dominating animals is one
- 6:50way to do that. So that's why we see men are
- 6:52more likely to eat meat and lots of meat. That's
- 6:54also why we're more likely to see men engaged
- 6:57in slaughterhouse work or vivisection laboratories,
- 7:01et cetera, et cetera. Whereas for women, because
- 7:05femininity has been defined as expressing submissiveness,
- 7:11Well, then you can understand then how women
- 7:14are more allowed to align with fellow animals
- 7:16because animals being one of the weakest social
- 7:19groups as far as access to power and resources
- 7:22and social status. It makes sense then for women
- 7:26to align with other animals because they too
- 7:28have very low social statuses in a patriarchal
- 7:31society. It's also okay for women to be vegetarian
- 7:35or vegan. for the most part because again that
- 7:38is aligning with social expectations of what
- 7:40femininity is and how it's supposed to be expressed.
- 7:43So it's no secret or it's no surprise rather
- 7:45that we see more women being vegan or vegetarian
- 7:49and more men who are not only eating a lot of
- 7:51animal products but resistant to veganism and
- 7:54vegetarianism because it undermines their very
- 7:56masculinity. So we have that. That's the basic
- 8:01element of vegan feminism. And also, if you look
- 8:04at the work of eco -feminists in the 1970s, 80s,
- 8:07and 90s, they will also say, well, let's take
- 8:09that a step further. And it's about our relationship
- 8:12with nature more broadly. So non -human animals
- 8:14oftentimes getting lumped into nature. Well,
- 8:17the idea that nature is feminized, something
- 8:19to conquer, something to exploit, resource to
- 8:23own, to be traded, bartered, to fight wars over.
- 8:27Nature itself then is part of that feminized
- 8:30space. And so Marty Keele, for instance, a leading
- 8:34vegan eco -feminist, and also Greta Gar is another
- 8:38good example. They've made the argument that
- 8:41as we in the West have started to objectify nature
- 8:44and feminize nature, then it's no surprise that
- 8:47the status of nature and the well -being of nature
- 8:52and non -human animals who are associated with
- 8:54that have plummeted. And then of course we can
- 8:57also take this to a global scale and see how
- 8:59this is also wrapped up with colonization and
- 9:02global inequality. So we really then from a vegan
- 9:06feminist perspective need to understand how theoretically
- 9:09we're using a gender lens to understand our material
- 9:13and our social world. And if we don't pay attention
- 9:16to that, we're not as activists really fully
- 9:19understanding the true mechanism of, in this
- 9:22case for this podcast, speciesism. So that's
- 9:27the gist, and this is something that is not necessarily
- 9:30new. This is something that has been around for
- 9:33several decades, maybe even centuries. So I would
- 9:39place this really into three ways. It sort of
- 9:41follows the animal rights movement, the waves
- 9:42of the animal rights movement, but also the waves
- 9:44of the feminist movement. In the 1800s, some
- 9:47of the very first activists for animals were
- 9:51women. We also had many men who were involved
- 9:53in that, but unfortunately, because patriarchy
- 9:56has really shaped the animal rights movement,
- 9:59a lot of that history has been lost to us. So
- 10:01we saw in the 1970s and 80s, for instance, an
- 10:04active discouraging of remembering women and
- 10:07their contributions and associating the public's
- 10:10mind with, or associating veganism and animal
- 10:14rights in the public's mind with women. So there's
- 10:17a reason why a lot of us don't know this history.
- 10:19It was sort of actively, if not outspokenly,
- 10:22but it was actively sort of pushed to the background.
- 10:25an effort for the hope was by these men was that
- 10:29animals would be taken animal rights movement
- 10:31would be taken more seriously if we kind of forget
- 10:33that women had anything to do with the movement.
- 10:36So just had to put that in there. But anyway
- 10:38in the 19th century there were a lot of women
- 10:40who were involved with this. So the anti vivisection
- 10:44campaign of the 1800s which really started in
- 10:47the 1860s and gained momentum in the 1880s 90s
- 10:51and 1900s. women were behind quite a lot of that.
- 10:56It wasn't just women, of course, men were also
- 10:57involved, but because so many women who were
- 11:00standing up against this new horror, this new
- 11:03institution of vivisection, very quickly became
- 11:06gendered in the public mind. So you have to remember
- 11:09at this time most women were not allowed to enter
- 11:12into medical facilities, they weren't allowed
- 11:13to become doctors, they weren't allowed to be
- 11:16professionally trained because for the past 200
- 11:18years women who had originally been the knowledge
- 11:21keepers, the community healers who understand
- 11:23herbs and folk medicines, that has been actively
- 11:27squashed out, midwives actively squashed out
- 11:30and then not long after in the 1800s outright
- 11:32banned. Then they were prevented from entering
- 11:35into medical official medical treatment as training
- 11:38rather. So this was an active effort to demean
- 11:42women and to rob women of their important community
- 11:45power and knowledge. So it wasn't a surprise
- 11:49then, you start to see men in vivisection who
- 11:52were using this, by the way. Some of it was out
- 11:55of interest, curiosity. A lot of it actually
- 11:58had to do with they just wanted to further their
- 12:01careers. Because going into the medical establishment
- 12:03was usually only available to the wealthy, but
- 12:06for those who could get in, it was a way to navigate
- 12:09the very rigid class system of the Victorian
- 12:11era. And so men really gravitated toward this.
- 12:15Women were not really allowed to participate.
- 12:17And a lot of feminists actually got involved
- 12:20in anti -bibisectionist work, and this is one
- 12:22of the reasons why it became sort of codified
- 12:25in the public mind that this was a women's movement.
- 12:29But actually, these feminists were not just,
- 12:32you know... doing women's suffrage and then trying
- 12:35to advocate for animals. They were doing a lot
- 12:37of other causes. They were very, very intersectional
- 12:40in their interests. They were fighting for Irish
- 12:42liberation, Indian liberation. They were fighting
- 12:44for the welfare of the poor. They were fighting
- 12:46for better conditions and working class slums
- 12:49and England and America and elsewhere. They were
- 12:52doing all kinds of... Abolitionists, quite a
- 12:54lot of them are also abolitionists. So it just
- 12:56kind of happened that there's a lot of reasons
- 12:59which I don't have time to get into. You can
- 13:00find out more in my book. But the idea is that
- 13:03they sort of got latched onto the animal rights
- 13:05movement even though feminists were doing a lot
- 13:08of work across the board. So then we moved into
- 13:12the world wars and during that time was a bit
- 13:14of an ambiance period where everyone was focusing
- 13:17on the war front. This doesn't mean that there
- 13:19was complete dearth of animal advocacy. There
- 13:22were women doing some work like advocating for
- 13:24war horses who were being wounded. And a lot
- 13:27of them were then being used for vivisection
- 13:29for war technology. So they were trying to advocate
- 13:31and help those animals. There was promotion of
- 13:35pacifism, being critical of a violent war society
- 13:39in of itself, et cetera, et cetera. But then
- 13:42by the time we move into the middle of the 20th
- 13:44century, the women are now regathering their
- 13:47strength. A lot of the organizations from the
- 13:50Victorian period are continuing on into this
- 13:5320th century. And new ones are being formed as
- 13:56needed because now we have a whole new landscape
- 13:58of speciesism. So they're doing a lot of amazing
- 14:01work. But unfortunately, as I said, this is also
- 14:03the rise of the male philosophers. But this is
- 14:06very important. I want to emphasize this is one
- 14:08of the things that vegan feminism aims to do
- 14:10is not just to say, well, we need to take a gendered
- 14:13perspective of the reality of the situation.
- 14:14We also vegan feminism is arguing. We need to
- 14:18deconstruct this patriarchal colonization of
- 14:21animal advocacy, because in fact some of the
- 14:23earliest philosophical works that were being
- 14:25produced in the 1960s were not by Peter Singer,
- 14:28but by the likes of Bridget Brophy or Ruth Harrison,
- 14:32and also the Godloviches. So, Roz Godlovich,
- 14:37who wrote one of the very first animal rights
- 14:40philosophical pieces, and then went on to co
- 14:43-author a book with several other philosophers,
- 14:45including Peter Singer. And now Peter Singer
- 14:47gets all the credit for it, but actually there
- 14:48were women doing this work at the same time as
- 14:51him and before him. So as we then move into the
- 14:56late 20th century, it's very, very clear that
- 14:58this is still a women's movement. And we have,
- 15:01by the turn of the new millennium, we have four
- 15:04out of five activists who are women. So regardless,
- 15:08we have all these efforts for women to be stamped
- 15:10out of the movement. Nonetheless, here we are,
- 15:12we remain. And we still have this sort of stubbornness
- 15:16about the role of women in the animal rights
- 15:18movement. It's as though this is somehow going
- 15:20to detract from animals. And vegan feminism would
- 15:23actually argue, at least I would argue, that
- 15:26by emphasizing that women are somehow selfish
- 15:29or egotistical by focusing on feminism, that's
- 15:32actually drawing on age -old stereotypes, sexist,
- 15:35misogynist in some cases, stereotypes, where
- 15:38women have historically been expected to put
- 15:40others first and to take take a step back and
- 15:44stay in the margins and that doesn't do anyone
- 15:47any favors because really it's invisibilizing
- 15:49one of the greatest strengths that the animal
- 15:51rights movement has and that's women's work women's
- 15:55efforts women's creativity so vegan feminism
- 15:58then is arguing what would happen what would
- 16:00we gain if we actually recognized women's contributions,
- 16:04validated them, celebrated them, and stopped
- 16:07filling up our animal rights hall of fame with
- 16:09men and stopped only reading books by men and
- 16:13only reading cookbooks by women, perhaps on the
- 16:15other side of that. What if we started to recognize
- 16:17and celebrate women's contributions? What could
- 16:19we achieve at that point? To that end, we also
- 16:22need to start thinking a bit more critically
- 16:24about the gender binary itself or about trans
- 16:27and non -binary folks. I'm so sorry to report
- 16:30that at the time of this recording, there's still
- 16:32quite a lot of division about the acceptance
- 16:34of the LGBTQ plus community. For instance, there
- 16:38was a belief they were a non -binary Taiwanese
- 16:41American person. They published a blog, The Vegan
- 16:44Society, near the end of 2025. And the vitriol
- 16:48that they received was so extreme the vegan society
- 16:50sadly had to shut down comments. And the nature
- 16:53of the comments who were in opposition was simply
- 16:56boils down to you're making it about yourself,
- 16:59you're taking away attention from the animals.
- 17:02But this is the deal, like animal rights and
- 17:05veganism has never been more popular. But one
- 17:07of the reasons that's becoming popular is because
- 17:09it's getting delodged from this archaic idea
- 17:12of who can be a vegan and who can be an animal
- 17:15activist. This idea that you have to be a middle
- 17:17-class white person in the West in order to be
- 17:21a legitimate, if you will, vegan activist, that
- 17:24needs to go. And now, recognizing not just the
- 17:28diversity in sexuality, but also in gender and
- 17:32nationality, all that's going to be very important.
- 17:34So that's where vegan feminism is asking us to
- 17:37push back, is to start challenging that which
- 17:40we take for granted. And this is me as a sociologist
- 17:44speaking as well, someone who specializes in
- 17:47social movement theory. One of the main problems
- 17:49with the animal rights movement is we have this
- 17:51idea, if it ain't broke, don't fix it. But what
- 17:54that really translates to is we have a fear of
- 17:57self -reflection. This idea of it's tradition,
- 18:00it's been that way, it's always been that way.
- 18:02We always read Animal Liberation by Peter Singer
- 18:04and we always promote men. We always put men
- 18:07at the front when we're speaking to media. And
- 18:09that's just the way it's always been. That's
- 18:11just the reality of it. Well, that's just simply
- 18:14bad science and bad advocacy. We need to be flexible.
- 18:18We need to be reflexive. And if we can't start
- 18:21to have that sort of movement around us, we are
- 18:24a movement dead in the water. So I'll leave it
- 18:28at that for today. That is me signing out. That
- 18:31is vegan feminism in a nutshell. It's illustrious
- 18:33history and why it is relevant for effective
- 18:36decision making and tactical inspiration and
- 18:41hopefully if the book comes out you'll be inspired
- 18:44to read a little bit further. So thank you for
- 18:48listening and I appreciate your interest and
- 18:50support.