Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / Dr. Layne Norton - Founder of BioLayne | The Science Behind Health & Nutrition
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to success story. I'm your host, Scott Clary. The success story podcast is part of the HubSpot podcast network
- 0:07They supported the show for over two years now, and I've used HubSpot for the majority of my professional career
- 0:13One of the most useful tools that is included in the HubSpot suite of products is sales hub
- 0:18Sales hub is an all-in-one platform built with the tools and
- 0:23Insights that you need to communicate on a personal level with every lead every prospect every customer
- 0:30It doesn't matter what kind of business you're building sales hub makes it easier to close more deals and drive more
- 0:39Revenue if you're looking for a better way to acquire customers and we all are because that is the lifeblood of our business
- 0:45If you're looking to make smart data-driven decisions increase visibility productivity
- 0:50Predictability of your revenue you've got to look at sales hub
- 0:54It can organize and sort deals in your pipeline
- 0:57It creates reminder tasks for your most important deadlines and manages leads it automates outreach
- 1:03It tracks and closes deals all in one place and on top of that
- 1:07It's free to get started and it grows with your business as it scales
- 1:11There's 1300 integrations and a ton of valuable add-ons
- 1:14Customize it exactly to your needs with sales hub closing deals is no longer a big deal
- 1:20Go to HubSpot.com slash sales and try it for free
- 1:34Doctor Lane Norton. I'm super happy that you're here. I'm very excited. I've I've watched a ton of your
- 1:40Content going into this and I've read some of your work as well followed some of the things you put it on Twitter
- 1:45And I love how much you speak your mind in this space and it's important now
- 1:49Let's kick this off with an interesting question. Why is there so much pseudoscience in health wellness nutrition?
- 1:55Why does it feel like everybody even before we kick the software speaking about people adhere to their
- 2:01Ideologies of health and wellness, but it seems like there's so much
- 2:05Fake and so much misrepresented in this space. Why is that?
- 2:10So it's a great question and I actually do feel like I have a pretty good answer for that. So I used to have this kind of
- 2:18Epiphany when I would go out. I hated telling people I had like if I was just meeting people
- 2:23I kind of didn't like telling why I did like having a PhD in nutrition
- 2:28Like if I could if I go out to a party or or meet new people or whatever and I say
- 2:33Yeah, I'm a theoretical physicist and I study string theory
- 2:37You know, I might get questions about the universe and stars and some fun stuff
- 2:42But I think you know, most people are probably not gonna try and have a debate with me
- 2:48About string theory, right?
- 2:52Or if I was a professor of mathematics, you know, most people aren't gonna like question my theorems
- 2:58But be a PhD in nutritional sciences
- 3:02Everyone eats so everyone has formed some opinion of nutrition
- 3:07Because whether it's right or wrong, they have associated something they beat me with some outcome and
- 3:14It is really interesting to
- 3:17people
- 3:19They'll get different ailments. They'll have something happen
- 3:23They'll get a headache whatever and it seems invariably they associate it
- 3:28They try to associate back to something they ate. I don't know where this obsession comes from. I wish
- 3:34Nutrition had that much power
- 3:37Because I'd probably make more money to be quite frank if nutrition really had that much power
- 3:42But I think a lot of it boils down to everyone has a personal experience with nutrition and so
- 3:50That personal experience I was talking about to friend about this today that personal experience is by far
- 3:57More powerful than any study I can show them
- 4:01They're they're even and the problem is
- 4:05People don't understand the concept of bias and confounding variables. So for example, I'll hear this all the time
- 4:11Why cut out carbs and I I lost weight all my blood markers improved
- 4:16You know, so it was the carbs that were were causing me problems
- 4:20well
- 4:21You one you probably didn't do that in isolation people don't typically do behaviors in isolation
- 4:27They cut out carbs they tend to eat less processed food. They're eating less calories overall
- 4:33They probably start exercising because they're getting serious about their health
- 4:38And they get all these but they tie it to the fact that well, I was eating too many carbs
- 4:41So it was insulin sugar that made me made me fat and unhealthy
- 4:46But
- 4:47That's why we have human randomized control trials because
- 4:51The important thing and I think this is so important for people to understand why
- 4:55Randomized control trials are so are the gold standard of research
- 5:00because
- 5:01If we like take let's say we take a hundred people I was okay some of you were going to do the high-carb
- 5:07Low-fat diet some of you go to the low-carb high-fat diet
- 5:11You you could choose which group you want to go into
- 5:15Well problem is
- 5:17There could be certain characteristics about people that select each diet that predispose them to better adherence
- 5:24Or
- 5:24More activity or all kinds of confounding variables, right?
- 5:29But if we take a group of a hundred people and we randomly assign them
- 5:33What you can
- 5:35What it gives you confidence in is that any of those kind of confounding variables are going to be randomly
- 5:41Distributed across the groups and so if you see differences or don't see differences
- 5:47You can be relatively confident that what you're looking at is a treatment effect. Hopefully that makes sense
- 5:53So it does so this is why human randomized control trials are considered the gold standard of research
- 5:59So again going back to somebody's a lot of carbs and I lost weight. I feel amazing
- 6:04Okay, well here's 20 randomized control trials where they control people's food intake
- 6:11Equated calories, equated protein and did the gamut of carbs and fats in terms of all the way from very low-carb
- 6:18to very high-carb low-fat
- 6:20And we see that there's really no difference in fat loss if you equate and control for those variables
- 6:27But the problem is because that person had that experience
- 6:32It almost doesn't matter how much research you show them and
- 6:36This is what we call confirmation bias where people have an experience
- 6:42And then they will retroactively look for reasons why whatever they did is the best thing to do
- 6:48Because people like feeling righteous
- 6:50They like to feed and honestly, I think I do think it's like oh, I want to help other people with this thing
- 6:55And I'll give an example where I fell into that
- 6:58So I do my kind of approach things when I call flexible dieting
- 7:01So I have a certain amount of calories protein carbs and fats that I'm trying to hit you know every day
- 7:08And you know for the most part I eat foods that I enjoy eating to fill those out
- 7:12I eat plenty of fruits and vegetables, but I still you know I'm ice cream every day
- 7:16Um, I love like popcorn. So I have popcorn like I have foods that you would not consider
- 7:21You know normal diet diet foods
- 7:24Uh, but I'm extremely consistent. I'm brutally consistent and it works and in fact
- 7:29When I was getting into bodybuilding 20 years ago, I kept trying to eat clean
- 7:33You know, which was basically like your traditional diet foods
- 7:37And I found that
- 7:39I would eat clean for a period of time and then I would invariably break and I would you know
- 7:44Go off the deep end and binge eat and you know have a bunch of crap
- 7:50You know, it's having trouble making progress
- 7:52And so I was like I said you know
- 7:54I wonder if I just allowed myself to have this moderation
- 7:59But you know didn't over calories and whatnot
- 8:02You know how it and once I started doing that
- 8:04I mean I became brutally adherent it felt relatively easy
- 8:07You know, and I've just been able to be consistent that way and I thought oh this is it
- 8:11This is the solution for everyone
- 8:14And then as I got into coaching and coach more people
- 8:16I found it. Yeah, it was a great option for a lot of people
- 8:20But some people the idea of tracking or hitting certain numbers
- 8:23It's just very stressful for them and they'd rather just not eat carbs or they'd rather
- 8:27Timer stricter eating whatever it is
- 8:30But fortunately having that scientific background
- 8:33I was able to identify oh, I'm being
- 8:35Confirmation biased right now. The data doesn't really support what I'm actually saying
- 8:39It's just a tool and a tool belt
- 8:41But I think people just become very dogmatic about whatever approach they felt feel like they got results with
- 8:47You know, I you know when it comes to I use financial examples a lot
- 8:51It would be like
- 8:53You know somebody who got rich in tech stock during the tech boom be like you got to invest in tech stock
- 8:59That's the stock that always works you know, and it's like
- 9:02Well, we know what tends to work for finances overall
- 9:06Like you want to for the most part be really consistent with your investing
- 9:10start early
- 9:12Consistently put away like at least 15% of what you're taking home and you spread of the cross
- 9:17Of various different types of mutual funds so that you're diversified and risk and hey if you become wealthy enough
- 9:23Then you can kind of mess around with single stocks
- 9:26What you have what you have some money that you can afford to lose essentially or not touch
- 9:32But that's not that sexy and so you know you get kind of similar types of messaging
- 9:38So I think that that's where you know people just can become dogmatic about anything based on their own personal experience
- 9:44Well, it seems like when you look at all the different types of diets
- 9:48So you look at the the high carb low fat you look at the low carb
- 9:52Higher fat and like more traditional keto if you look at intermittent fasting these are almost just
- 9:58psychological tricks
- 10:00To to promote a certain diet that you can adhere to for a long term is that is that more or less
- 10:05Yeah, I mean, so there was actually a really a really telling study
- 10:09Um, it was it was called um
- 10:12Was a meta analysis so a meta analysis just so people understand is
- 10:16Not a study in and of itself you're not recruiting subjects or anything like that what you're doing is
- 10:23you are
- 10:24scouring the entire database of research and you're looking for studies that fit your what you call inclusion criteria, right?
- 10:34So
- 10:35Basically these this particular meta analysis. I forget the exact inclusion criteria
- 10:40But I think they were looking for
- 10:42You know studies looking at weight loss diets in humans
- 10:46That tracked I think weight loss over
- 10:49three months six months and two years
- 10:52Um, and there was some other inclusion criteria as well and basically they're including any studies that fall into this
- 10:57And then and they have certain exclusion criteria like I you know again
- 11:01I'm not certain I'm not saying that these were the exact exclusion criteria
- 11:05But like for example some studies will say you know, we didn't take people with heart disease
- 11:09We didn't take people with type 2 diabetes, you know like that sort of thing, right?
- 11:13I'm not saying that was the case for this study
- 11:14I'm just saying you can set whatever criteria you want
- 11:17So you include all the studies that fit that criteria and what you try to do then is basically combine all those data points
- 11:25To try to come up with a consensus of what the research says for your particular research question
- 11:30So it's a very powerful tool because a lot of times you can take you know individual nutrition studies and randomized control trials
- 11:37It is very very difficult to get randomized control trials
- 11:42That last longer than a few months with any kind of reasonable amount of control
- 11:47So for example, um, if you want to really highly controlled study you have to pay people
- 11:53Like you like you can't
- 11:55Just have that much control over people's lifestyle people would be like, okay, sure now I'll do that
- 11:59You know, I'll go sit in food jail for for six months
- 12:03You know, so I mean there was a study recently where um
- 12:07Uh, I can't remember the exact study, but basically they paid people like seven hundred dollars seven eight hundred dollars
- 12:13Uh, for like over a hundred thousand participants are sorry sorry sorry
- 12:18seven eight hundred dollars per participant and the total end up being like several hundred thousand dollars
- 12:23They had to pay out and all they were doing was monitoring people over like a six month period
- 12:28Like they weren't even like forcing them to eat the meals that they wanted
- 12:31They just told them what to do and like had them come in and take measurements and stuff
- 12:36So the point being it's really really hard to get long multi-year randomized control trials with a high degree
- 12:43Of control
- 12:44And so the ones that are do have a high degree of control end up being very few subjects, right?
- 12:50So the power of a meta analysis is you've combined all these you can take
- 12:55You know a study may only have 20 or 30 people
- 12:58But once you do a meta analysis, you may have thousands of data points
- 13:02So it really could be a powerful tool
- 13:04Oh, I was gonna say you have to be careful for uh searching for studies
- 13:07It also support what you're looking for because I know that you can find studies on any kind of support
- 13:11Any conclusion right right and again
- 13:13That's why meta analyses are so powerful because I always tell people I don't care about single studies
- 13:19I mean, I may get like excited about how well a study was done or how tightly it was controlled or whatever
- 13:25But I will very very rarely make
- 13:28Uh strong statements about one study. I'll usually say this study suggests this
- 13:33Here's how it fits with the rest of the evidence
- 13:36Well, we probably need more research and I will say that I was every time right
- 13:40So that's why meta analyses are so powerful because it's not one study. It's multiple studies now
- 13:45It's important to read because you can do a bad meta analysis as well because there are meta analyses with like two studies
- 13:51You know are three studies
- 13:53You know, especially if research is emerging that's not necessarily a knock on the meta analysis if the studies don't fit the
- 13:58Inclusion criteria there may only be that many studies
- 14:01um
- 14:02But again in this one they were looking at 14 different like popular diets and how they
- 14:09You know their effects on weight loss over like six months a year two years
- 14:14And what they found basically is in the long term over two years
- 14:18All of them were equally forable at promoting a facilitating long-term weight loss
- 14:23There really wasn't much difference
- 14:25But when they took people and stratified them from least adherent to most adherent
- 14:32Regardless of diet used there was a linear effect on their results
- 14:37So basically the most adherent people got the best results regardless of diet used
- 14:43So what that says to me especially based on another a meta analysis I kind of was talking about
- 14:50This one from 2017 by Kevin Hall where they looked at um
- 14:56Low carb versus low fat diets
- 14:59When protein was equated and when calories were equated and when meals were provided to the participants
- 15:05So actually a high degree of control and they found that there was no difference between fat loss between these groups really
- 15:11Um, so taking all those things together. I look at that and say well
- 15:17The best diet is probably the one that you can stick to as an individual and we look at adherence
- 15:24adherence appears to be very individual because they even looked at hey did any of these diets tend to have better adherence than others
- 15:31And the answers though um
- 15:33There doesn't really seem to be one diet that pops up as as being better for adherence
- 15:38But for individuals
- 15:41You'll hear individuals say man. I did time restricted eating. It felt like I wasn't even dieting
- 15:47You know, it was so easy for me or I did low carb. It felt easy. I did plant-based. It felt easy
- 15:54I did flexible dieting. It felt easy
- 15:57So
- 15:58If you want to lose fat
- 16:01You have to you have to restrict in some way
- 16:04But you should probably pick the form of restriction that feels the least restrictive for you
- 16:10Because most people think about a diet just as a diet and they don't think about it as a lifestyle
- 16:15And that's why the weight loss recidivism rates which is basically relapsing to previous weights after weight loss
- 16:21Are like 80 90 even a percent even higher if you look out past five years
- 16:27So what it really says is whatever diet that you're
- 16:31Choosing to use to lose weight
- 16:33Those habits and behaviors you build you better be able to maintain them
- 16:37Because weight maintenance is actually more difficult than weight loss
- 16:42So on that point when you're talking about all these different types of diets. Is there any
- 16:47Uh, type of diet that is not just for fat loss
- 16:50But for muscle preservation and or cognitive performance that could be optimal or does it still follow those
- 16:56That exact same trend I can't really speak to the cognitive because it's not really my area
- 17:01What I will say is if you see people lose body fat
- 17:05um
- 17:06Following healthier diet practices you do say tend to see better cognition. I will say
- 17:12um
- 17:14There appears to be a link between the gut and the brain. Don't fully understand it yet
- 17:18So I will say eating sufficient amounts of fruits and vegetables uh and enough dietary fiber
- 17:24Is pretty much the best way to have a healthy gut microbiome
- 17:29And that may be important if it ties into cognition
- 17:32But I wouldn't say that there's strong
- 17:34Direct links between the two yet. Although I haven't looked really hard at it either so it could it could be there and I just not aware of it
- 17:41um
- 17:43When it comes to muscle retention really what you're looking at is getting enough protein in um and then resistance training
- 17:51If you do those two things you're you're you're doing 90% of the the work
- 17:55There is some data that suggests that a ketogenic diet specifically
- 18:02may not be optimal for lean mass retention
- 18:05Compared to a diet that has sufficient carbohydrate that is
- 18:10mechanistically
- 18:11That's probably because carbohydrate release insulin
- 18:15insulin has a inhibitory effect on what we call proteolysis which is basically
- 18:20Muscle protein breakdown, right?
- 18:22so
- 18:23That is probably why
- 18:26Uh, and then we do see that in the randomized control trials too
- 18:29Especially a randomized control trial by Kevin Hall
- 18:32Where they took people and put the monochetogenic diet compared it to
- 18:37Eating like a sufficient amount of car or not a sufficient because there's no requirement for carbohydrates
- 18:42But like a high carb low fat diet
- 18:44And they found that their urinary nitrogen
- 18:47excretion was higher and they had they lost more lean mass over the course of the rct
- 18:54So
- 18:55urinary nitrogen basically uh, why that's important is because
- 19:00Protein is the only nitrogen containing macronutri if there is the nitrogen component of what makes it unique
- 19:07and so um
- 19:09We can look at
- 19:10How much nitrogen appears in your urine we can also look at how much you're taking in
- 19:15And we can come up with like a pretty good idea of like whether or not you're in a positive or negative nitrogen balance
- 19:21And if you're in a negative nitrogen balance, that's a pretty good indicator that you're probably losing lean tissue
- 19:27So
- 19:28I'm not saying that you can't gain muscle on a ketogenic diet because I know people will
- 19:32Misinterpret what I'm saying and and bake it black and white and go to extremes. You could absolutely gain muscle on a ketogenic diet
- 19:39um
- 19:40But when they compare them straight up to diets equal in protein that are non ketogenic
- 19:46The non ketogenic diets tend to do a little bit better
- 19:50Again, it's not a massive difference in lean mass retention
- 19:53So I wouldn't tell anybody hey like if you have success in a ketogenic diet
- 19:57It's easy for you to adhere to i'm not saying don't do it because you're just gonna strip off a bunch of muscle
- 20:03But is it the best thing for muscle retention?
- 20:05Not based on the the data we have i also think it's it's important to note that when you look at the
- 20:12Individuals that are sort of preaching about one diet versus the other i mean you see this all the time
- 20:17So you live in this world a lot of them are not natural online
- 20:21And obviously that changes the whole game right yeah
- 20:24You can take any diet to a point and have some success with it
- 20:27And I know that some of the guys that you debate with
- 20:30And you and some of the guys that post a lot of bullshit online about this that that that diet they totally
- 20:36Negate to disclose or they just don't discuss that their whole body
- 20:40Physiology changes to a degree once you're on this that or the other
- 20:44Yeah, I mean obviously performance and answering drugs can make up for a lot of you know
- 20:47Inadequacies and in diet and training and whatnot
- 20:50Um, and it's always like you know, so people people will ask me things like oh um
- 20:56It reminds me of a meme somebody uh simply this meme and it was like um
- 21:01I took
- 21:03You know, I took statistics this year
- 21:05Um, and then they go into like p-values and stuff um and then the person goes oh it seems like it really it must have really helped you
- 21:12And the person goes um maybe
- 21:14Because if you understand statistics you understand that everything is just risk and probabilities that there are no
- 21:20There are no absolutes
- 21:22Uh, and so you know these people will say well, I did this and look I got this
- 21:27And like somebody yesterday asked me oh do you think um something they asked me something about my training
- 21:33Do you think that that was the reason that you set this world record in a squat?
- 21:36And for those are familiar 2015. I set um
- 21:40And then world's spot record 668 pounds at 205 pound body weight class
- 21:44Been broken a bunch of times since then
- 21:46But they were asking something about my training and whether or not that particularly was one of the reasons I was able to do that and my response was
- 21:53Maybe because
- 21:55I can't go back and clone myself and have myself do it a different way and then compare it right
- 22:01I'm basically my own case study
- 22:04And it's very possible that I could have gotten the same outcome
- 22:08Maybe I could have gotten a better outcome doing it some way differently
- 22:11But I there's no way for me to know that because I can't go back and copy that in time and again
- 22:15That's why we have randomized control trials because that's where we try to pick out some of those differences
- 22:21And people who say well, I did this and I got this
- 22:24Here's the problem with anecdote
- 22:26And I'll use carnivore diet for example, there's people say lane
- 22:30There's all these people that say you know they they did the carnivore diet and they resolved all these health problems
- 22:35They're autoimmune issues
- 22:37blah blah blah blah blah blah
- 22:39I'll say cool
- 22:40I can go find the same amount of vegans or more who say the same thing
- 22:45What makes your anecdote more valuable than theirs
- 22:50Now I'm not saying that your experience is incorrect
- 22:52I'm not saying that you didn't get some benefit
- 22:56What I'm saying is you cannot apply that broadly to other people
- 23:01You cannot do that because you started following the carnivore diet
- 23:05Okay, cool
- 23:06You also basically stop eating processed foods
- 23:09And it's also very hard to overeat calories on the carnivore diet
- 23:13So guess what fixes a lot of stuff
- 23:16Calorie restriction and weight loss
- 23:18If you're 50, 60, 100 pounds overweight
- 23:21I mean do I think a carnivore diet is the best diet out there?
- 23:24No, do I think it's optimal for human health?
- 23:27No
- 23:28But if somebody loses 50 pounds on it
- 23:31Compared to what they were before if they were overweight or obese
- 23:34Are they probably better off now than they were previous?
- 23:39Probably
- 23:40So
- 23:41But are they as good as it?
- 23:42Are they good if they could have been if they included fruits and vegetables
- 23:45And a more balanced diet and lost the 50 pounds through that?
- 23:48Probably not
- 23:49And so I think those are the nuances that people are missing when it comes to this discussion
- 23:54And again, anecdote is so powerful
- 23:56I mean, just to think about it for like in finance, right?
- 23:59Like how many times do you do a rigorous analysis of like
- 24:06Hey, who's the best in financial advice in my area?
- 24:09No, you go to your body who made a lot of money in investing
- 24:11Oh, hey, who did you use?
- 24:12Right?
- 24:13Like that's what we do
- 24:14And if you see somebody you like to paint job on their house
- 24:17You're like, hey, who painted your house?
- 24:19Right?
- 24:20You don't go like
- 24:21Look up who's in the better business bureau or any of this kind
- 24:25Because anecdote for us in word of mouth is really powerful
- 24:28And people's personal experiences are very powerful
- 24:32And I think a lot of that too is
- 24:34People feel very disconnected from scientific research
- 24:39Which is one of the things I really try to do is I really try to
- 24:42Make it not an ivory tower
- 24:45That's why I started my research review
- 24:48Every month we like basically review like five different popular studies
- 24:51And break them down in a way that's like easy for people to understand
- 24:54Because I think that's so important for people to have that connection
- 24:57To what's actually going on
- 24:58Because otherwise they're just going to consume stuff over social media or what's in the news
- 25:02And I can tell you
- 25:04In my experience I've been doing this 20 years
- 25:0899 times out of 100
- 25:10The headline in the news does not reflect the actual results of the study
- 25:17This goes down this this this is about everything from seed oils
- 25:21We're going to talk about some of that
- 25:23I think meat being carcinogenic
- 25:26Sugar all these artificial sweeteners
- 25:29All these different things that you've seen in the news all the time
- 25:31So let's talk about some of these sort of more popular topical items
- 25:36Because I think this is sort of top of mind for everybody
- 25:38I think it's an interesting you know
- 25:39It's an interesting comment that these studies don't translate into headlines
- 25:43So what happens what happens when you see in the news
- 25:47Meat is carcinogenic or seed oils are bad for you
- 25:50Or artificial sweeteners are bad for you
- 25:52That's a you know super super basic headline
- 25:55Then all of a sudden everyone's parents are stressed out or
- 25:58But he's trying to throw at the splendor from their house or everything like that, right?
- 26:01What what happened here?
- 26:02What happened in the study?
- 26:04How did it get miss the misinterpreted misrepresented?
- 26:06So keep in mind first thing is that negative news sells way better than positive news
- 26:11So for example, there's a company I worked with they're called consensus. They're a
- 26:17There are an AI powered
- 26:19Research
- 26:22Crawling tool basically so you can go to consensus and you can type in
- 26:27Does create and build muscle and it will not only like pull up
- 26:32All the relevant research studies it will actually basically answer your question based on the consensus of the data
- 26:39In terms of yes, possibly no right
- 26:42So and it will show hey 80% of studies show this
- 26:4710% show this 10% show this right?
- 26:50So they break down like what the actual distribution of the answers are
- 26:54And then you can further like refine it based on like okay. I just want the human trials or I just want
- 27:00randomized control trials
- 27:03And when you go and you look at like for example
- 27:08Do does aspartame cause cancer
- 27:12Um actually, I think I had this just pulled up
- 27:14Let me just see if I can find or fire it. Uh, let me just pull up
- 27:22Because these are these are the things that you know, I
- 27:26I hear all of these I hear all of these you know, and these these sort of these tropes and
- 27:31I try and do my own research as well because I'm I am somebody who would try and go into a PubMed study and see where this came from
- 27:38But even even for somebody that does the effort and does the cognitive work and goes in and tries to understand
- 27:44You can still even find these PubMed studies to support one way or the other and it gets very difficult
- 27:49To understand what's what's correct and what because you don't you're not I'm not a research. I'm not a scientist
- 27:54You know, there's how many how many pages in this study and you're just looking at the abstract and you're hoping that the study was done right
- 28:00You're looking at the end results
- 28:03But it gets very confusing so I can only imagine if somebody does not go to the even that level
- 28:07How confusing some of these things could be oh yeah
- 28:10so
- 28:11Basically if I pull it up so it's like okay
- 28:15Hey, so here's the result if I if I use the um the phrasing
- 28:21Does consuming aspartame increase the risk of cancer?
- 28:24um
- 28:2614% say yes
- 28:2814% say possibly
- 28:3072% say no
- 28:33Now if you are the news what's going to get you more clicks
- 28:40Aspartame not found to be associated with cancer in this cohort or
- 28:48Aspartame increases risk of
- 28:51Whatever tumor by 15% right well of course it's the the negative headline and that gets down to a more um
- 28:59Important aspect of cherry picking
- 29:01So you can always it doesn't matter what what your belief is
- 29:07You can always find a study to support whatever your belief is okay?
- 29:12Now a lot of them are like people will use like in vitro studies, which is basically the petri dish or animal studies
- 29:17It's so but just to show how powerful cherry picking can be
- 29:22I pulled up a um
- 29:24I actually did this because I I did a big long debunk of Paul Soledino's appearance on the Joe Rogan podcast a few years ago
- 29:31So Paul is a carnivore diet advocate
- 29:34um
- 29:35and
- 29:37Basically says that fiber is useless fruits or vegetables are bad for you and all kinds of crazy stuff and
- 29:45Just to give you an idea of how much it how much effort it takes to debunk nonsense versus saying it
- 29:49His podcast is like just over three hours long probably took me 50 hours to do this breakdown
- 29:55It was 48 pages in the google doc and it had two hundred and three citations
- 30:00Um, it took me 10 hours just to listen to it because every time there was a claim I had to write it down
- 30:04And they'd go back and address it right and I had to cite the whole thing
- 30:08But there were several times where he would cite a study and I would like scream
- 30:13I'm like that's one study and all the other studies showed something else right like you're picking one study
- 30:20So just to make the point in that breakdown I pulled up a research men analysis
- 30:27Uh the risk of smoking on a dental carcinoma right
- 30:32So if you look at the overall effect
- 30:35I believe the effect of
- 30:37Smoky on a dental carcinoma when you could pile all these studies
- 30:40It's like a seven times risk increase like a seven hundred percent increase in the relative risk of cancer
- 30:45That's massive right
- 30:47And when you look at what they call a forest plot and a forest plot is basically there's a center line
- 30:52Which basically means no effect and then to one side there's either a positive or to the other side
- 30:57There's either a negative effect and depending on how far it is to one side for each individual study
- 31:02It shows you how powerful the effect was. Hopefully that makes sense
- 31:06Well then if you look at this center line
- 31:09Virtually every study is like far to the right showing increased risk of cancer
- 31:14But there were two studies that were just a little bit left of that line
- 31:18So if I wanted to make the argument that smoking did not increase the risk of a dental carcinoma
- 31:24And oh by the way might actually be protective
- 31:27I could just highlight these two studies and completely omit the other 48 studies
- 31:32And so that's why it's so important to
- 31:35I mean frankly this is so hard for the the average person because they don't have a research background
- 31:40They don't know like what to give more weight to which is why I again
- 31:45I love that tool consensus dot app because
- 31:48They you could ask the question and it will kind of show you pretty quickly and then their search filters as well
- 31:54Um because it's so hard for the average person to like hear this stuff in and
- 31:58You know and really feel like oh, and then if it fits their bias, that's another thing
- 32:02So let's say somebody doesn't really like any vegetables and here comes this expert with a medical degree
- 32:10Um, by the way, he's a paul's a psychiatrist
- 32:13um
- 32:14But here comes this expert with a medical degree
- 32:18Who says oh no, you know vegetables actually not good for you
- 32:22Because vegetables contain fatates
- 32:25Which uh can and oxalates which increase your risk of ox oxalates stones
- 32:30And can also bind to nutrients and reduce your nutrient absorption
- 32:34Also, there's sulforofane and broccoli and look at this study showing when they gave sulforofane
- 32:40It increased the risk of cancer
- 32:42You know
- 32:43And it's like so you can
- 32:45And then when you look at the sulforofane study it was a crazy high dose and it was in rats
- 32:49And you could find more studies showing that sulforofane may actually have an inhibitory effect on cancer
- 32:54But you can always find a specific compound in any food
- 32:59Man made or natural
- 33:01That if you fed it in a high enough dose would cause problems. I mean you give people enough water. It'll kill them. Okay
- 33:08So
- 33:09Unfortunately, people don't know how to unpack this stuff
- 33:12And again, you know all all kind of go to yeah, but
- 33:16What actually happens with people who eat lots of fruits and vegetables
- 33:20Because based on what you're saying they should die earlier. Oh
- 33:24Oh, it studies when they look at people eat lots of fruits and vegetables
- 33:27They live significantly longer
- 33:29So how does that like this is the direct question we're concerned about so how do you reconcile your claim
- 33:36With the actual human outcome data
- 33:39And so this is what's so hard for people to unpack
- 33:42I just want to take a second and thank the sponsor of today's episode HubSpot
- 33:45Now the success story podcast is part of the HubSpot podcast network
- 33:50So if you like this show you'll love some of the other shows in their network
- 33:54One of my personal favorites is the hustle daily show
- 33:57It brings you a healthy dose of a reverent offbeat and informative takes on business and tech news
- 34:03And you guessed it every single day
- 34:05Some of their recent episodes that were my personal favorites how AI is making fake IDs
- 34:11How to meet your favorite CEO for a few thousand dollars and also how tick-tock is turning into an online mall
- 34:18And starting to replace QVC if you love business if you want to get it daily
- 34:23Let's into the hustle daily show wherever you get your podcast
- 34:26Well, it seems like it so it's sort of unfortunate that people are
- 34:31They're not fair with their representation of facts
- 34:33Like an individual that goes that deep and does a three-hour podcast on a particular subject
- 34:38You would think that they would look at all the data, right?
- 34:40But that's I mean this is probably why you're so fun at parties because
- 34:44You're bringing you're bringing up you're bringing up all the shit that they don't want to address and and you know that some of these people found
- 34:49These studies as well, but it doesn't fit the narrative and then like let's say you're somebody who doesn't like eating vegetables
- 34:54And you hear this guy say oh vegetables are bad for you
- 34:57It's not gonna take that much evidence to convince you that oh yeah
- 35:01Vegetables are not good for me. I'm not gonna eat vegetables. You're not looking at it. Right exactly
- 35:05I mean same thing with like, you know
- 35:08It's funny like I um every once in a while smoke a cigar and I you know, I'll be like
- 35:13I've been on social media and like had a cigar in a picture or whatever and people will be like
- 35:17So that being smoking is it bad for you? And I'm like no, it's bad for you
- 35:22I I just understand it's bad for me and I am valuing the experience over the fact that you know this may this one cigar
- 35:31I doubt will will increase my risk that much if I did it very regularly it might
- 35:37Um, but I acknowledge it is definitely not the best thing I can do for myself
- 35:42But I'm also not over here trying to convince myself that
- 35:46You know smokey actually isn't that bad and you know actually it's good for you, you know because
- 35:51Uh, it lowers my stress it lowers my stress and lower stress is associated with longer long
- 35:57I can bake any argument I want you know based on whatever it is I want
- 36:01Uh, and so it's really important to just look at the human
- 36:05direct
- 36:06Data with regards to that stuff. I mean another great example is um
- 36:10uh
- 36:12The the artificial sweeters
- 36:14You know like people are so scared of artificial sweeters
- 36:19And the resource like I said 71% of the studies show that it doesn't cause cancer
- 36:23But what gets focused on is the 14% that say it does
- 36:27Um, when you're looking at so if you look at all the different types of diets just sort of one last question on this
- 36:31Because you didn't mention longevity
- 36:33Are there any is it just a balanced diet that has the best possible outcome for human longevity across all the different studies
- 36:41Okay, so I kind of um
- 36:45I have
- 36:46six pillars for longevity, okay
- 36:50um
- 36:54Don't eat too much
- 36:56Meaning control your calories. Don't become obese. Okay. Now there are people who say you got a fast because a Tophagy
- 37:03um
- 37:03There's there's no evidence that fasting is superior for producing the desirable effects compared to just normal calorie restriction
- 37:11Now there are monkey there's actually more studies showing that uh
- 37:14Caloric restriction is better for longevity now we can't really do
- 37:19That study in humans because you have to track them their entire lives and control their calories
- 37:24But we do have in primates. So a recess monkeys
- 37:28Uh, they showed that a 30% reduction
- 37:31Uh, in calories a 30% walled. Okay, so here's where it's going to get tricky
- 37:35They showed that a 30% calorie restriction
- 37:39Was sufficient to prolong lifespan significantly. I can't remember what it was. I think it was like something like a like a year or two
- 37:45What's the baseline when you say calorie restriction? So is it like you say
- 37:492000 calorie diet are you supposed to be hitting?
- 37:51So, so this is the this is the question Scott
- 37:55So this is why it's important. So I did a lot of the animal research and I know how these studies are done
- 38:00They didn't find out
- 38:02What the maintenance calorie level of these animals were
- 38:06And then feed them 30% less
- 38:08What they do in caloric restriction studies is though they just have animals eating ad libitum
- 38:14So however much they want
- 38:16They track how much they eat and then they restricted by by a certain percentage and they call that calorie restriction
- 38:23um
- 38:24So
- 38:27Interestingly animals overeating captivity
- 38:30Right? So when you look at the research data when they cut these animals calories
- 38:37Yes, they lost weight initially, but it plateaued very quickly and then they just maintained it. Okay
- 38:44So if it was true calorie restriction, they would lose it lose weight for a really long period of time
- 38:49And they'd actually have to adjust it
- 38:51What did what what you really see? I think
- 38:55Is there simply stopping these animals from becoming obese from gaining excess body fat?
- 38:59I think that's really what that data says. I don't think you have to eat low calories your entire life
- 39:06I think
- 39:07You just need to stop yourself from becoming obese like have a normal
- 39:11A level of body fat and I will say too lean also has increased risk of mortality. So you don't want to go too lean either
- 39:19Um, but a normal level of body fat, you know from in 10 to 15% for women 20 25% all those are totally fine
- 39:26Um, so that's number one. Don't eat too much
- 39:30exercise
- 39:31vigorously and frequently move your body that's you if you look at any study at activity
- 39:37Like even with steps
- 39:39There is a huge drop off in mortality going from 2000 steps today to 8,000 steps today. I mean, it's a massive difference
- 39:46Um, and then it's the benefits slows down, but it never caps out
- 39:51Like even up to like 24,000 steps today. You're still getting incrementally
- 39:55Like smaller and smaller benefits, but they're still a benefit now. I think steps are magic
- 39:59No, they should the same thing with push ups men who could do like over a certain amount of push ups
- 40:04Had lower risk of mortality. These are just more active people. This is this is what this data is showing
- 40:10So number two is exercise. Number three
- 40:13Don't smoke or limit smoking, right?
- 40:15Um, you know, there's no benefit to smokey
- 40:18Other than like I said for my cigar like helps me relax every once in a while
- 40:21But this is something I do once a month, you know, do like for the most part
- 40:26Smoke as little as possible
- 40:28And even like with the vaping
- 40:31Uh, the vaping isn't as bad as regular smoking, but it's still not good
- 40:35Um, it still increases risk of lung cancer and cardiovascular disease because it's the smoke itself
- 40:41That appears to be negative. It's not the nicotine
- 40:44Brim may not even be the tobacco. It may just be the the the smoke you inhale itself
- 40:49um
- 40:50Number four
- 40:52Would be uh, get enough sleep
- 40:54Okay, so most people again, this isn't something sexy. They don't do this, right?
- 41:01Um
- 41:03Number five
- 41:04Actually, I'm gonna make this seven pillars now that I'm thinking of it. Uh, number five limit alcohol
- 41:09I say limit people get mad at me
- 41:11That I think small amounts of alcohol are not harmful your body has a system in place to metabolize it
- 41:17Um, there are cohort studies that show a dose response of alcohol on mortality
- 41:22But again, people who tend to drink also tend to have other unhealthy lifestyle behaviors
- 41:27Um, if you look at the human randomized control trials looking at like small amounts of drinks
- 41:31You can't really find them of negatively affecting health markers. So in my opinion
- 41:37I think you know a few drinks per week is probably fine, but if you can abstain fantastic um
- 41:43And then the next one number six is what I think is really underrated
- 41:47Mental health and stress management if you look at psychological stress
- 41:54And the risk of mortality and autoimmune disease
- 41:59Very very strong association with autoimmune disease and most people who have autoimmune diseases
- 42:05There's actually a very strong cross correlation between autoimmune diseases and um
- 42:11psychiatric disorders
- 42:13So people who have psychiatric disorders or an increased risk of autoimmune diseases and vice versa
- 42:19So I think when you're putting your body into fight or flight mode all the time um
- 42:26Your body can begin to attack itself. I mean, I'm not an autoimmune expert
- 42:30Um, this is just some stuff I've seen in the research literature
- 42:34But honestly overall call that we do see it in mortality there there is there does be an effect of mortality in psychological stress
- 42:42so
- 42:43Getting cognitive behavioral therapy and learning how to manage stress
- 42:47Because um, I think most people uh, I include myself in this for a long period of time
- 42:55Had this idea that we could just get stress out of our lives
- 42:59That is never going to happen
- 43:02Especially if you're a driven person who wants to do something you will have stress
- 43:06It is part of life every single one of us is going to go through trauma
- 43:11Tragedy horrible things are going to happen
- 43:14What matters is how do you handle it? How can you perceive it? Can you
- 43:23Feel your feelings and move on from them or do you get stuck in a leak? So I think
- 43:29Like mental health is a huge component of longevity
- 43:33Edges quality of life obviously
- 43:36Then finally I eat enough fiber fruits and vegetables. That's there's very for every 10 ram
- 43:41There was a meta analysis and met what they call men of regression where they basically like
- 43:46try to project based on the research day they have um
- 43:51And using uh milit or using statistical modeling
- 43:55Like what is the the effect of this is it like a u-shaped curve is it linear
- 44:00So in most of these models when they look at fiber and take it is a linear effect on the risk of cardiovascular disease
- 44:07Cancer at all calls mortality and they find that for every 10 ram increase in fiber
- 44:14There is a relative 10 percent reduction in the risk of all calls mortality cancer and cardiovascular disease
- 44:20So fiber is like literally a longevity hack
- 44:23So so that actually is an interesting point because normally I'd look at the traditional
- 44:30You know, government-sponsored food pyramid and say that they got most of that wrong
- 44:34But I would say that that fiber component is actually something that aligns with sort of more mainstream health narratives
- 44:41I think um, right, you know
- 44:44So people love to slam the food guide pyramid. They love it when they're going after me too. They say I'm like a government or big food shell
- 44:53And um, yeah, that's funny too some people will sound like do you what do you think I did for my PhD?
- 44:57Because they'll say well, you didn't do your degree in a hard science. I'm like, uh
- 45:02My BS is in biochemistry. I took calculus one two and three. I took differential equations. I took
- 45:08I took physical chemistry
- 45:10instrumental chemistry and a little chemistry
- 45:12Organic chemistry one and two I took advanced nutrition and metabolism. I took nutritional biochemistry
- 45:18So please explain to me which one of these aren't hard sciences
- 45:21Do you think I just like sat and looked at the picture of the food guide pyramid for six years?
- 45:26So the food guide pyramid
- 45:29Do I agree with it not really
- 45:32Mostly from the perspective that I think um lean sources of protein were unfairly demonized um
- 45:40But do I agree with most and I think they they
- 45:46People don't do well with nuance unfortunately, and so what you see was at the bottom was emphasizing whole grains
- 45:53Starches, you know those sorts of things if you look at the research
- 45:57So the research that supports the consumption of whole grains for reducing the risk of metabolic disease cardiovascular disease
- 46:03But unfortunately people look at that and they go oh, well
- 46:08Yeah, I just have a lot of spaghetti and meatballs or or have a lot of you know
- 46:13um refined carbohydrate
- 46:15um
- 46:16Which again, there's there's actually like very little research to suggest refined carbohydrates and isolation are bad
- 46:22It's more about the fact that people eat a lot of refined carbohydrates. Don't eat much fiber
- 46:26um
- 46:27Because if you look at studies where they equate carbohydrates and calories it either eat
- 46:32Have people eat refined sugar or like very little refined sugar
- 46:37People lose the same amount of weight on weight loss diets and have similar improvements in their health markers
- 46:42But the real problem is it's hard to eat a lot of refined people
- 46:47Don't add they replace when they eat so if they're eating one thing they stop eating another
- 46:52so
- 46:53A great example of this is like if sugar is so bad
- 46:56Why is fruit associated with so many positive health outcomes because fruit has a lot of sugar in it
- 47:01Well, because fruit has a lot of fiber in it and it's difficult to overeat right because of the fiber content
- 47:06So again, uh, I think the food guide pyramid wasn't really that bad and the end of the day people didn't really follow it
- 47:12That's the issue
- 47:13Like sure people ate a lot of carbohydrates
- 47:18But they also ate a lot of fats in fact the biggest source of added calories in the last few decades is oils
- 47:23Uh, not carbohydrates
- 47:25In fact, if you look at the last 20 years sugar consumption has actually dropped quite a bit
- 47:29I and we're still getting fatter and I'm more unhealthy
- 47:32So again people took out sugar, but they replaced it with oils, you know
- 47:37And so um, I you know, I don't like demonizing the food guide pyramid
- 47:41Just because I think if people actually followed it which which would also said exercise and limit your calories
- 47:48Limit your sugar limit your added oils if people actually followed it it would have worked
- 47:52But people didn't follow it
- 47:53You know, unfortunately the messaging that they took from it was eat a lot of carbs
- 47:58But then they also added fats with it so
- 48:02Okay, last thing on nutrition than I want to speak about resistance trainings physical activity
- 48:07Um on Twitter right now
- 48:09You are going into it with
- 48:12Your good writ on see I think it's about seed oils. What where did that come from because I've heard
- 48:17Oh my goodness. I've heard the most ridiculous things about seed oils the last thing that I heard about seed oils
- 48:22And I'm not I'm not an expert, but I'm just telling you anecdotally what I heard was some guy told me
- 48:27That if you don't eat oil you won't sunburn anymore and I was like listen, I can't
- 48:32I can't get this anymore one
- 48:35Yeah, so this is what we call mental gymnastics um, so
- 48:39What they're doing so seed oils essentially are like canola oil
- 48:43Um, but you know mostly polyunsaturated fats, which is what's been emphasized uh in the food guide pyramid and government recommendations
- 48:51So
- 48:53Here's my doubles advocate argument
- 48:55Seed oils are not innocuous in so far as they are the largest source of added calories in the last two decades
- 49:04And have contributed to obesity crisis because of that
- 49:08But and if you look at cohort studies where people consume more oil
- 49:14Uh, by default more calories. There are negative health outcomes
- 49:19And they're also looking at research studies looking like omega-6 to omega-3 ratios and showing that you know
- 49:25There's higher incidence of disease and people need more omega-6 for omega-3s
- 49:29But what do the human randomized control trials say where they don't just add it they replace it
- 49:37Meaning if we substitute in
- 49:40polyunsaturated fats in place of saturated fat
- 49:44Based on these folks
- 49:46Claves we should see worsening health outcomes for cardiovascular disease
- 49:53For cancer for inflammation for metabolic health
- 49:59Nobody yet
- 50:01Nobody I've challenged them challenged Tucker no one has been able to for
- 50:05Show me one randomized control trial
- 50:08Were these markers got worse when saturated fat was replaced with polyunsaturated fats
- 50:14So and so it's either neutral and in many studies it has a positive effect
- 50:20So
- 50:21If you look at say like liver fat there was a study where they replaced um
- 50:26Uh, they other had people consume polyunsaturated fats or saturated fats saturated fat they or sorry
- 50:32They overfed them so this is actually an overfeeding study
- 50:35Saturated fat increased liver facts 78% more than polyunsaturated fats
- 50:42Um, if you look at the the effects on insulin sensitivity
- 50:48There's either a neutral positive effect if you look at the effects on blood lipids
- 50:53There's a neutral or positive effect. There's actually a pretty big positive effect when it comes to LDL cholesterol
- 50:58Um, if you look at the risk of cardiovascular disease of cancer the same things
- 51:03So where are all these negative effects come inflammation?
- 51:07These guys there are one of their big central core themes is these things because they're unsaturated because the
- 51:13So in polynomial saturated fat you have multiple double bonds these double bonds can become oxidized
- 51:19And that oxidation they claim is going to cause inflammation
- 51:22Okay, cool
- 51:23So we have these things called human randomized control trials where we can feed people this stuff and see if it increases inflammation
- 51:30So what do we see when we feed polyunsaturated fats in place of saturated fat and look at inflammatory markers
- 51:38We have to see a neutral or positive effect most studies are mostly neutral but there are a few that you'll pause this
- 51:44Now Paul Soledino came back on Twitter and said something like um
- 51:48We'll look at the study where they fed alpha linolytic acid and saw
- 51:53um, an increase in lipid peroxidation
- 51:56Great
- 51:58So what what so let's okay, so that's a mechanism all right, so that is one thing I hold open
- 52:05I hold open the idea that nutrients can have both positive and negative effects in multiple different pathways
- 52:13And so the question becomes is the overall effect positive or negative that is the question we should ask
- 52:20Because what Paul is doing by pointing out a mechanism whereas I'm pointing out the actual human outcome data
- 52:26Hey, look cardiovascular disease cancer metabolic health
- 52:31That's like saying hey look at this mutual fund and let's say the mutual fund has 150 funds in it
- 52:37Hey, you don't want to invest in this mutual fund
- 52:39It's got these two funds in it and they went down by 50% this year
- 52:44Without with omitting the fact that the overall fund is up by 30%
- 52:49What do I care more about that the overall mutual fund is up 30% or that there's two stocks in it that are down by
- 52:56I don't even data on those two stocks
- 52:58I care about the performance of the overall mutual fund and that is the difference between looking at human outcome measurements versus these
- 53:05um, these mechanisms these guys love to focus on
- 53:08and
- 53:10Fortunately again, people don't know the difference between the two they just go oh well this guy started the study and this guy
- 53:16Side of the study and I'm like yeah, but that study doesn't actually answer the question that we're asking
- 53:20So at the end of the day, they're doing just a more educated version of what the news is doing already pretty much
- 53:26it's it's it's cherry picking it's
- 53:29um, and then it's like so there's always all these guys whether it's plant-based zealots, intermittent fasting zealots
- 53:36Seed oil zealots they all follow the same arc
- 53:38Which is look at these studies and then I say okay?
- 53:42Well, here's these studies that actually measure what we're wanting to measure and they show no difference
- 53:46And then they go well look at these anecdotes and I'm going well
- 53:49Here's these anecdotes over here from people who did the opposite thing. So what makes sure is more valuable
- 53:54And then invariably their last gas effort is to completely dismiss all scientific research
- 54:01So I say look at this
- 54:04Thing that shows that there was this article published in the Lancet where the Lancet claimed that like 40% of scientific research was
- 54:12Either doctor or fabricated, right?
- 54:14And so they'll say we'll see
- 54:17We can't trust any scientific research. I'm like no, you can't trust any one research study
- 54:22But what you can trust is the consensus of scientific
- 54:26Data because
- 54:28Replication is the mother of all science
- 54:32Because when somebody produces an outcome in a lab
- 54:37Other labs look at that and go hmm, I'll believe that and so they try to replicate it
- 54:43Because one if they can replicate it they want to know if they're wrong
- 54:48And sure maybe there's even multiple labs and did stuff but it doesn't you it's not going to survive
- 54:55The rigor of scientific experimentation over time and when people say this stuff you'll have people say well
- 55:02You know they've had a cure for cancer. They've been hiding it
- 55:06My response is always so basically what we're saying is all scientists are pieces of shit
- 55:11Is what you're saying they go what do you mean? I'm like
- 55:15You don't think
- 55:17That there's a scientist involved in this cover up who has a family member that died of cancer
- 55:24You think you can just pay off everybody like one of uh, well Joseph Zundell great great follow on instagram is a cancer biologist
- 55:32He got into cancer because one of his family members died of cancer
- 55:35You think there's a amount of money that you're gonna give that got like like scientists work for very little to begin with
- 55:42You know am I saying that there's no bad eggs out there? No, of course there's bad eggs out there
- 55:48But that's why replication is the mother of all science and that's why we don't just look at one research study
- 55:53We look at the consensus of the data
- 55:58I love that okay, let's talk a little bit about resistance training
- 56:01um in your opinion resistance training is the best thing you can do for your health
- 56:06And I say obviously in your opinion you have some data to back that up
- 56:09And personal bias I am biased in this and personal bias of course
- 56:14So let's talk about resistance training versus aerobic training
- 56:18Sprinting jogging whatever it is pick anything else wise resistance resistance training king
- 56:25Great question. So there's actually just a study published
- 56:27I believe where they looked at the risk of cardiovascular disease
- 56:30And actually found it was lower in people who resistance trained versus people who just did aerobic exercise
- 56:34I can't remember the exact citation so I should go hunt that down um
- 56:40The the reason I like resistance training is if you're doing it hard enough
- 56:45If you're going hard enough you're going to get the benefit some of the benefits of cardiovascular work
- 56:51Like um, you know, I have a apple watch that tracks my heart rate and whatnot
- 56:55So if I do a two-hour resistance training session
- 56:57I'm doing like heavy squats and dead lifts my average heart rate will be 130 to 140
- 57:02I mean, that's right zone to you know what I mean
- 57:05Um, and I max heart rate will sometimes hit like 190
- 57:09So
- 57:10Like you're getting some of those cardiovascular benefits from doing this
- 57:15But you're also getting the benefit of more muscle mass and muscle mass is tied to longevity lean mass is tied to longevity as well as strength
- 57:23And muscle is your uh metabolic health organ
- 57:27It is the largest organ in your body by weight and it is a metabolic sink if you have a lot of muscle mass
- 57:34Quite frankly you got a lot of places to put stuff as as like
- 57:39Reductionist is that sounds
- 57:40So if you have people who don't change anything, but they just are resistance training you'll see improvements in their blood markers
- 57:47Because you just have more throughput
- 57:50To get glucose and fatty acids in all the study of more places to put it muscle cells are energetically greedy
- 57:57So that's what then also you get the huge benefits on bone density like for bone health there is nothing better than resistance training
- 58:06Period like if you think calcium and vital and deer good for bone health
- 58:10Resistance training absolutely slaughters them in the research data
- 58:15I mean, and just as a personal anecdote
- 58:17I've been resistant training for 25 years
- 58:20The last time I had a bone mineral density scan done I was basically
- 58:24Almost off the chart of what they usually do
- 58:28And I've never broken a bone in my life. I'm not saying it'll never happen again. That's my own personal experience
- 58:32But it just has so many benefits for the stuff we care about for not just longevity but quality of life
- 58:39And bone density and muscle mass are not just huge for longevity. They're huge for quality of life as we get close to end of life
- 58:46Is there is there a correlation between uh strength training resistance training in your VO2 max?
- 58:51I'm not sure about that. I would imagine it's better than just doing nothing
- 58:55It's probably not better than aerobic exercise and I'm not trying to poo poo aerobic exercise
- 59:00If you like doing aerobic exercise ball beans do it any form of activity is better than nothing
- 59:04No question about it. In fact, there was even a research study that showed that just four minutes of intense exercise a day
- 59:11I'm not kidding
- 59:12Four minutes of intense exercise per day and it didn't have to even be consecutive. It could be broken out
- 59:17Four minutes
- 59:18reduced the risk of
- 59:20Cancer by 20% four minutes. That's what four minutes. That's insane. That's the that's wild
- 59:27That's absolutely wild
- 59:30When you look at when you go sort of a level deeper into the types of resistance training
- 59:34You're you're actually interestingly enough a powerlifter and a body builder
- 59:39Is there a certain kind of training that is more focused on powerlifting versus bodybuilding that
- 59:46Is maybe better for general health and longevity does one camp help better than the other
- 59:51Yeah, I don't think there's enough research to kind of pick that out in terms of what's better for overall health
- 59:57I think if you're just doing
- 59:58Some resistance training and be intense enough with it in terms of like, you know, getting close enough to to muscular failure
- 1:00:07Um, then then you're gonna get a lot of benefits from it
- 1:00:10But I don't think there's enough research out there to really pick out like which one might be better for overall whole
- 1:00:16Are they are they are they both more or less progressive overload?
- 1:00:19I've like I've never I've more in my life trained as a body builder versus a powerlifter
- 1:00:23But it's more it's all it's all very much the same
- 1:00:26Yeah, I mean, it's progressive overload, but just in different
- 1:00:28Fashions right like with progressive overload in bodybuilding. There's a lot of different ways to progressively overload
- 1:00:35Um, you could add, you know, weight you can add reps. You can add more sets more hard sets
- 1:00:40Um in powerlifting. I mean, you can aggressively overload the same way really what you're trying to get is just get stronger
- 1:00:46Uh, but both progressive overload is important for both
- 1:00:50And it's just the way in which you progressive overload like a little bit different for bodybuilding
- 1:00:54There really seems to be key to do enough hard sets very close to failure
- 1:00:59for powerlifting
- 1:01:01Proximities of failure are based on the latest meta analysis doesn't actually seem to matter much
- 1:01:06What seems to matter is doing enough sets and a high intensity like close to your one rep max so that you build that skill and then um
- 1:01:15At any given load
- 1:01:17Moving it as quickly as possible
- 1:01:20So for example, and you can apply the same force to 300 pounds that you apply to 600 pounds
- 1:01:25300 pounds just going to move faster
- 1:01:27So with powerlifting it just basically becomes very important to at any given load move it as quickly as possible
- 1:01:34And I mean is there is there a four four the types of training that you do for powerlifting versus bodybuilding
- 1:01:42um in terms of
- 1:01:44Physique look is there one that you prefer more than the other or is that just a a cause of the right diet
- 1:01:52I mean
- 1:01:54You'll probably gain more muscle with a bodybuilding type trading
- 1:01:58Uh, you can do both as well. I don't necessarily think it was a downside to doing extra accessory work
- 1:02:04You know for bodybuilding with a powerlifting base
- 1:02:08Uh, it's kind of what I do
- 1:02:10Uh, but as far as like your body composition the amount of body fat you have
- 1:02:14Um, that is determined by you know your your energy balance and your your most of that is to diet so
- 1:02:21Yeah, I mean, I you know, I
- 1:02:23Look, I mean, I could probably diet for 16 weeks and be ready for stage and I would look like a wide
- 1:02:29And there's a lot of powerlifters who would fit that that
- 1:02:32That realm. I mean the super heavy weights might need more like a year diet
- 1:02:36Uh, but they could do it because they would have a lot of lean mass as well
- 1:02:41But would it be optimal for bodybuilding probably not um
- 1:02:45Because there's more time efficient and set efficient ways
- 1:02:49Uh, to build muscle computer how you do it
- 1:02:52Understood and then just one last one last point on this
- 1:02:56Um, people that are listening to this that are are either working out or getting into working out
- 1:03:02You know, they see so many
- 1:03:04Supplements they see all these different things that they could take
- 1:03:07I mean, I'm sure you've tried the gamut of things that you're able to take and and try as a natural athlete
- 1:03:13What would you recommend without going through each each thing? Yeah, you know specifically the types of way different as a protein creatine anything off the shelf at a G&C or a vitamin shop
- 1:03:23What actually moves the needle? So that's why self the line behind me
- 1:03:26Ha ha ha ha ha ha
- 1:03:28So I kind of I move I put supplements into like three tiers right now
- 1:03:32First tier is very very clearly defined uh, creatine little hydrate weight protein and caffeine those are
- 1:03:41Ca those are supplements with hundreds and thousands of research
- 1:03:47Studies to support their efficacy
- 1:03:49Um, there there is no question about the benefits of those supplements for performance
- 1:03:54For building need tissue for getting stronger
- 1:03:58Then you can move into kind of tier two stuff
- 1:04:01Things I would consider in tier two are things like um ashwaganda
- 1:04:06rodeola roséia
- 1:04:08Those are adaptogens which appear to reduce stress
- 1:04:12Uh, in the case of ashwaganda they actually even build some lean mass
- 1:04:16We've also got things like citrally on there. You've got things like um
- 1:04:20Betaine which has been shown to increase power
- 1:04:23Uh beta alanine would probably make the second tier
- 1:04:26And you've got stuff like melatonin uh, in fact like melatonin in a research study was actually shown to add lean mass to participants
- 1:04:34Now that might be secondary to just them, you know getting better sleep and recovering better
- 1:04:39um
- 1:04:40But that's and so that's why like my supplements are very basic. I have way protein powder
- 1:04:45I have a free workout with you know caffeine rodeola some other
- 1:04:50cognitive enhancers
- 1:04:51A recovery product that has creatin
- 1:04:54Uh ashwaganda some other things in it
- 1:04:57And then uh sleep supplement that the base is melatonin. There's some other
- 1:05:01Positive supplements in there as well
- 1:05:03But everything like I saw and could say at least tier two which tier two is basically like
- 1:05:09There's
- 1:05:10Not the same body of research. You could be the same length of time done on these and I want to see more research
- 1:05:18To kind of fully flush it out um, but it appears to be trending in a very very positive direction
- 1:05:24There's very few studies showing it does nothing
- 1:05:27tier three is like very new to market
- 1:05:30very little research data
- 1:05:33Basically, I'm unsure you can dump almost all of them into that bucket
- 1:05:37And then anything that don't fit those three tiers is you know, obviously not worth wasting your time on um
- 1:05:44You know, but but tier three I wouldn't even waste my time on I you know
- 1:05:47Most people are wearing it
- 1:05:48But most most people and even most people don't eat tier two stuff. I mean most people
- 1:05:53You know
- 1:05:54Creatin in the weight protein are very very cheap if you tolerate caffeine while it's a great cognitive enhancer
- 1:05:59forced an answer
- 1:06:01But those three you know, unfortunately, you don't hear a lot about them
- 1:06:06In terms of because they're not sexy because everybody knows that they were all the companies know that they were so all the companies sell them
- 1:06:12so they're cheap um
- 1:06:15And that's why they also tried to reinvent the wheel with like we have this uh, this is way made from goats
- 1:06:21Like a dead series. They have a goat way
- 1:06:23It's more anabolic than talway
- 1:06:26No research to support it or they're like creates an effulester more anabolic than regular creature
- 1:06:32No evidence to support that actually research science actually suggests the opposite um
- 1:06:37You know, so they're just people they just try and reinvent the wheel so they can charge you more money because
- 1:06:43It's like uh think about uh think about
- 1:06:46Flatt's green TVs, you know, when I bought my first flatt's green tv in 2009. It was an LCD tv
- 1:06:52I paid a thousand dollars for a 42-inch now. I can go down and try to stick a bubble gum for a 42-inch tv
- 1:06:57You know what I mean like because everyone sells them
- 1:07:01So they're cheap because the market is competitive
- 1:07:04So people try to reinvent the wheel on this stuff with this the stuff that works is the stuff that's on the floor
- 1:07:09All right, I love this. Thank you. Um one one last
- 1:07:13Piece of wisdom from you um think about perhaps one of the most dangerous
- 1:07:18nutrition health wellness exercise myths that you've ever heard
- 1:07:23What was that myth and what would be something that people just have to be very aware of that major red flag
- 1:07:28Is a sort of delve into bettering themselves being healthier whatever it is
- 1:07:32And you know, I don't know that there's one specific thing, but I guess it's more of like a a category of stuff which is
- 1:07:39X thing is toxic
- 1:07:41um
- 1:07:42I think this messaging is toxic
- 1:07:45um
- 1:07:46If you've done any research into toxicity the dosage makes the poison
- 1:07:51You know, I guess it you could find the components of any different feet. I look and read me
- 1:07:55heterocyclic amines if I look in um
- 1:07:59You know
- 1:08:00Plants uh if I look at apives cyanide
- 1:08:04Uh if I look in you know, like I said any food you could find something
- 1:08:10cyanolcobalamin has cyanide which is vitamin B
- 1:08:13like
- 1:08:14You could find something that sounds scary
- 1:08:17But they're like there was a there was actually a video of carry broccoli who's got really famous recently talking about cyanolcobalamin
- 1:08:24And how you got to be careful do you know how much vitamin B12 capsule it capsule for you would have to take
- 1:08:33To take enough
- 1:08:35cyanide to harm you
- 1:08:37Uh, it's about 43,000 servings of vitamin B12
- 1:08:42So good luck with that
- 1:08:44You probably die from your stomach exploding and going septic from eating so many pills
- 1:08:50Before you would ever get hot and cyanide toxicity
- 1:08:54So again, when people say stuff's toxic, you know
- 1:08:58ensued
- 1:09:00Hey
- 1:09:01Very very rarely is it actually something you'd be concerned about
- 1:09:06But it gets people scared to eat hardly anything and increases
- 1:09:09I mean people have so much food anxiety now. I know so many people don't do they don't attempt to do anything
- 1:09:13They don't try to make any healthy lifestyle changes because they're like well
- 1:09:18You know the chain to the car award diet because meat math for me
- 1:09:20I can't do vegan diet because plants are bad for me. I can't do you know
- 1:09:25She'd do the diet because of this I can't eat list of foods and they go oh, oh, I'm just not gonna do anything
- 1:09:29I'll just keep doing what I'm doing because everything's gonna kill me. Sometimes what you whatever I want
- 1:09:32Uh, that is way more damaging than like any
- 1:09:38toxic
- 1:09:40Componing with food
- 1:09:42And then the last day I just want to ask you at you know at this point in your career
- 1:09:47Both for the industry and for yourself
- 1:09:50You've had an incredible career as a as a bodybuilder powerlifter now
- 1:09:53You know sort of an advocate for the truth and nutrition and health and wellness
- 1:09:57Um, what is what is success in your career mean to you right now and for yourself
- 1:10:03We're gonna ask me more questions
- 1:10:05Uh, the head
- 1:10:07You know, I think I I don't think I ever set out to be really well know
- 1:10:13Um, I kind of just set out to
- 1:10:16What out stuff that was helping
- 1:10:18I just I just wanted to like simplify things for people
- 1:10:21I think I was speaking to the 18-year-old version meat was so confused about everything
- 1:10:26It had that duped all along still um
- 1:10:30So I guess success but but as as I went through it
- 1:10:34I realized well if my content becomes popular I become popular by the fault
- 1:10:41So now I mean success to me is you know
- 1:10:44Getting on some of these like you know more major podcasts, which I've been lucky enough to do
- 1:10:49Um, you know, I do want to write a book and get that all messed up as you know, I do want to be
- 1:10:55You know
- 1:10:56Maybe even like get involved with government policy in some way shape or foreign
- 1:11:01um
- 1:11:03You know just to just to try to help in any way I can
- 1:11:06Um, because I wouldn't have the largest beneficial or you know positive impact I can
- 1:11:12Well, I think for me um
- 1:11:16I want to simplify nutrition and take the
- 1:11:20Take the scare factor out of it like just let's focus on the good stuff that you can do rather than like scaring everyone
- 1:11:26All the time because it's just not helpful messaging, you know, it's like that doesn't really help anybody
- 1:11:31So I think you know success for me
- 1:11:35would be
- 1:11:37I'm already seeing it in that like I
- 1:11:39I'll go to these videos of these guys making crazy claims and sure enough and and almost ever in one of them
- 1:11:45Which comments say where's your citations?
- 1:11:48Where's your sources? You know like people are starting to ask those questions
- 1:11:53Um
- 1:11:54Because you can't just take people's work for
- 1:11:57You know you can't just take the key
- 1:12:01So I think that one thing that I I really respect about you is you're such a logic driven data driven individual
- 1:12:08I think that this industry needs it. I think that even like having a you know
- 1:12:13An hour long conversation with you it really says a lot of light on things that you see in the news
- 1:12:17And I consider myself somebody that would go a level deeper and try to do the research and it's still so confusing
- 1:12:23So I really appreciate like how you bring this message to the world. I think it's very very important
- 1:12:27Um, I want people to go follow you
- 1:12:29I think it's at biolane on twitter and I think on all other most socials at biolane. I think your website
- 1:12:36biolane.com
- 1:12:38Um, and I just want to thank you. I appreciate your time. I appreciate what you're doing and let you know
- 1:12:43I think this is a very very
- 1:12:45Much needed perspective on this entire industry that impacts people's lives in such a major way
- 1:12:51But it's so confusing and scary to your point. So I appreciate it. Thank you, Matt
- 1:12:59You