Latest / A Hamster With a Blunt Penknife - a Doctor Who Commentary podcast / Hamster Book Club - Borrowed Time by Naomi Alderman (featuring Iain Martin)
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Hamster Book Club.
- 0:02My I forgot what it was called then.
- 0:04I could tell I could. Tell there's several arms for
- 0:07hamster now. My name is Joe Ford and I have
- 0:11been sitting here waiting for the delirious Ian Martin to
- 0:16appear on this podcast. I've been here ever since I
- 0:18started over a year now. Hello Ian, how are you today?
- 0:23Hello Joe, I'm really good. Thank you very much for having
- 0:26me on your book podcast. It's it's nice to do something
- 0:30different with your with your spare time, isn't it?
- 0:33I can. I can't, I can't really forget
- 0:36the last time you and I got together where, you know, we
- 0:40talked less about the book in question and more about a
- 0:43particular passage of that book, if you recall.
- 0:46I do remember that passage fondly and intimately.
- 0:49Scaly Richtus sax. Sax descending tubular shafts?
- 0:57No. That was in my Coldfield record.
- 1:00Yeah, no. What?
- 1:02I've got to tell you something as well, one of my book clubs
- 1:05said glamouring to do God engine because two of three of them
- 1:09love it. I mean, I know, right?
- 1:14Well, the the what we find with the books is that they speak to
- 1:18different kinds of readers and some people are very much there
- 1:22for the continuity and the real world aspect of it.
- 1:26And of course, in the real world, Ice Warriors would
- 1:29definitely shag. Indeed, I've got to really try
- 1:34not to just laugh every time you open your everything you say
- 1:36makes me laugh. You know, I'm going to try and
- 1:38compose myself on this recording.
- 1:40OK, Ian, we're here today to talk about oh, no it isn't.
- 1:45Oh, no, we're not. We were here to talk about Oh no
- 1:49it isn't. Yeah.
- 1:51Yeah. And then, and then you, you, you
- 1:54said you've given it to someone. Else, yeah, it's that Michael
- 1:57Mills, you know. Oh, him.
- 1:59Well, I'll, I'll, I'll be having him on on my show at some point.
- 2:02So I'll I'll take him to task. I shall listen to that episode.
- 2:08I'll take him firmly in hand. Extreme interest.
- 2:13Have we got here already? Instead of that, we are doing
- 2:17Borrowed time. By Naomi Alderman The renowned
- 2:21The renowned. Is it the only doctor?
- 2:24Who writer that has got on to become an international
- 2:27bestseller? I, I think it probably is.
- 2:33I mean she, so I mean, my relationship with Naomi Alderman
- 2:39is that I started she, she wrote for an app about 20 years ago
- 2:44called Zombies Run. Have you heard of that?
- 2:46No, so it's like an audio drama designed for people that that go
- 2:50running and at certain points in the IT basically it's the the
- 2:56end of the world has happened and there are zombies everywhere
- 2:58and you're a lone survivor. So you've got this voice in your
- 3:01ear saying you have to go to the storage unit in the woods and
- 3:07get some food. As you set off, you hear the
- 3:11sound of and then every time you hear the sound of a zombie, you
- 3:15have to kind of speed up, which is a really good way of doing
- 3:19interval running if you're. But the problem is I used to do
- 3:23it indoors on a treadmill and a treadmill does not accelerate
- 3:26fast enough. So I was always getting killed
- 3:29by this twat of a zombie about 3 minutes into my run.
- 3:34It was, it was, it was all awful.
- 3:36Does it know how fast you're running then so the zombie
- 3:38catches up with you? It does because it's linked to
- 3:40the and I forget the word, but the little movie thing in your
- 3:44phone that registers your movement it's.
- 3:48Such a clever idea to get it was.
- 3:51It was great. It's I think I assume it's still
- 3:53available. I'd be very disappointed if it
- 3:55wasn't and it's very good for making people do you know, speed
- 3:58up, speed down interval running and just and breaking it up a
- 4:01bit when. Those, those Pokemons were
- 4:04everywhere. You know when everyone had the
- 4:05maps out on their phone and everyone was it's, oh, was that
- 4:09you? No, it wasn't me, no.
- 4:11Well, everybody I knew seemed to be out, you know, down the pier,
- 4:14down the beach, down, you know, the toilets in the park looking
- 4:19for. Is that what they said they were
- 4:20doing? Looking for Pokémon?
- 4:22But it was the same sort of thing, right?
- 4:23So getting people moving. Yeah, getting people moving.
- 4:26And it's at this point in our civilization, it's anything you
- 4:30can do to get people moving and and get some exercising because
- 4:34we're all so busy. We are increasingly an indoors
- 4:38kind of species now. It's, it's kind of a familiar
- 4:43and probably completely wrong trope, but I get the feeling
- 4:46that like my nephews growing up just didn't play outside very
- 4:49much. And they're just, they're indoor
- 4:51people. They're sort of pallid, like
- 4:53Gollum. They look like sort of half
- 4:55fish, half. Fish, my nephew, right, sits in
- 4:57his bedroom playing computer games with his friends who are
- 5:01in their bedrooms. Yeah.
- 5:02That's what. Always has.
- 5:04They're basically fucking Cybermen, yeah.
- 5:06That's it and and and that's why Zombies run was a good thing to
- 5:11continue with Naomi all. Yeah, please.
- 5:14The next time I was aware of her was in about 2016, when her
- 5:19novel The Power got onto Obama's list of his favorite books of
- 5:25the year, and it became a sort of global literary novel.
- 5:29Now, in the in the kind of median point between zombies Run
- 5:32and The Power becoming a global literary sensation, she wrote
- 5:36Borrowed Time, which presumably, I'm very much assuming was her
- 5:41first book. I'm not quite sure how she
- 5:44managed to write it because I don't recall exactly when they
- 5:49advertised for, you know, writers to come to this series,
- 5:54but, you know, whatever do. You know what this was This was
- 5:57do you know when they used to bring out the new series
- 5:59Adventures in batches of free and this was a trilogy of Naomi
- 6:04Alderman, Jonathan Morris is Touched by an Angel and Euna
- 6:08Mccormack's The Way Through the Woods.
- 6:11And I think they may have peaked there, you know?
- 6:13I was, I was going to say, was that as good as it got?
- 6:16Pretty much, yeah. I've read some of the others.
- 6:19They held us great. If I want this, well, look,
- 6:22before, before we get on to the book itself, can I ask you a
- 6:26question, please, that I'd like to ask everybody who comes on
- 6:28this for the first time? I'm not.
- 6:30Wearing any. Are you not?
- 6:32No, never am I. Oh.
- 6:38What is your Doctor Who book journey?
- 6:39I sort of have pieced together bits and pieces from where all
- 6:44stories in the end where you talk about sort of the new
- 6:46adventure, things like that. But like, what was your first
- 6:48Doctor Who book and then where did you go from there?
- 6:51What a lovely question. Well, settle down everyone.
- 6:55I'm going to be talking for some time.
- 6:58My first Doctor Who book was Eric Pringle's The Awakening,
- 7:04which my dad gave me the the paperback target of probably,
- 7:10you know, very soon after it was published, 838485, something
- 7:15like that. And I think it was the first
- 7:18time I'd been aware that Doctor Who stories had been turned into
- 7:23books. And I was the sort of kid who
- 7:25read quite a lot. So I was delighted to learn that
- 7:28there was Doctor Who available in book form, and over the next
- 7:33sort of year or three, that one target book turned into about
- 7:38100 of them, and I would reread them over and over again.
- 7:42Money did you get? Well, not a lot, I mean I but a
- 7:45lot of them were from a second hand shop on like on the Hill
- 7:4840P ago and they were all, you know, really brown paper, quite
- 7:52smelly did. You say on the hill then.
- 7:55Yes, I was going to, I was going to specify exactly which Hill,
- 7:58it's East Hill in Colchester, but I figured that's slightly
- 8:01too much information and it's minutiae that your listeners
- 8:04really don't need. You know that a Hovis advert
- 8:07where the kid runs up the hill? I could just see you right
- 8:10enough to get. Your yeah, I'd, I'd save my
- 8:13lunch mate. I didn't have any food.
- 8:15So I had enough money to buy a Doctor Who book instead.
- 8:19And yeah, I used to, I used to go there and buy all the
- 8:22targets. I'd read them.
- 8:24I sometimes I'd read them in like I'd read exactly 1
- 8:27television episodes worth and I'd sort of hum the music to
- 8:30myself while I was, you know, putting the book away.
- 8:33Some, you know, I'd read the whole season over the summer.
- 8:36I'd read, you know, all of season 1 or all of season 24 or
- 8:39whatever. I used to love the Target books
- 8:42and then they finished the show finished in 1989 and being, I
- 8:49suppose, let's say, fairly immature, I still had this big
- 8:53hole in my life that Doctor Who, you know, should be filling So.
- 8:58So then the new adventures happened in the summer of 91 and
- 9:02I'm. Not sure you should be casting
- 9:04stones you know at your younger self.
- 9:06You're still reading Doctor Who books right now.
- 9:09I'm still intensely mature. In about 30 seconds I'm going to
- 9:13use the word shaft and we're both going to giggle.
- 9:16That's how immature I am now. So, so I've read the new
- 9:20Adventures religiously all the way from kind of secondary
- 9:24school through sixth form through uni.
- 9:27And then they finished and I was spat out into the grown up world
- 9:31of work and suddenly money was slightly more.
- 9:35Hideous, isn't it? It's oh, it's terrible, it's
- 9:38terrible. And at that point the BBC book
- 9:42started. So I hadn't, I had much less
- 9:43money and they weren't as good in, in and everyone says this,
- 9:49everyone says it on my show, everyone probably says it on
- 9:52yours. That first 5 or 6 BBC books, oh,
- 9:55they were shite. So I kind of let it go and read
- 9:59intermittently those books from the library.
- 10:04And when the show came back in 2005, I was quite happy to leave
- 10:08the books in the past because they'd done their job.
- 10:11They'd got me through. They'd kept the story going.
- 10:13But now the show was back on TV. So at that point I kind of
- 10:16stopped reading any of the the new fiction at all.
- 10:24Yeah. A lot of people on this podcast
- 10:29would say that that was a good move as well.
- 10:30Really, you know, sort of ducking out at that point
- 10:33because I don't even know. They're not really for ours.
- 10:35Are they like those books? They're not.
- 10:37They are tie in books for younger children.
- 10:41Yeah, which is exactly what they should be.
- 10:44Yeah, it's exactly what they should be.
- 10:45And that's exactly the job they do.
- 10:48And you would question if you were, if you were.
- 10:52Let me think. They were BBC books, weren't
- 10:54they? So it's technically part of PRH,
- 10:57Penguin Random House and any publisher worth their salt who
- 11:02wasn't publishing books aimed at children at that point would be,
- 11:06you know, quietly taken to the corner office and shot.
- 11:11Which is how in publishing we we change editors it.
- 11:14Was so interesting, right? I was, I was working for
- 11:17gardeners books at the time, OK, so I could see the sales figures
- 11:20of and that's like the that was the second biggest wholesaler of
- 11:24books. Now it's the first in Europe I
- 11:25think since they bought out Bertrams and the 8th Doctor book
- 11:32sort of past Octopus may be sold, you know, a couple of 1000
- 11:37if they were lucky, then the clockwise man and all that.
- 11:40The new series ones came out alongside the TV series,
- 11:44hundreds of that that, I mean, the sales went through the roof.
- 11:48So. So they were a success in that
- 11:50terms, you know? Yeah.
- 11:51Absolutely. And it's it's the same thing
- 11:53with Doctor Who magazine. At exactly the same time that
- 11:57magazine kind of jumped down to a younger readership and it was
- 12:01all about the TV show and it was much more kind of kid friendly.
- 12:05And again, it wasn't for me anymore.
- 12:08And I ducked out and I, I felt no bitterness about that.
- 12:11I didn't feel the need to complain about it on social
- 12:13media, Not that there were any social media at that point.
- 12:18But you know, I was just happy to let it go because it, it had
- 12:20got me through the, the 90s like the like the novels.
- 12:24And I was very grateful for that.
- 12:26But you know, believe it in the past.
- 12:28Here's something I'll have gleaned from We're All Stories
- 12:32in the End, and that is you quite enjoyed sort of diving
- 12:35into the mucky world of the new Adventures as they were coming
- 12:38out. You know, Poland, arts, semen in
- 12:42mouths and TARDIS is turning into cities and the Doctor
- 12:46turning human and all of this stuff.
- 12:48And now now the other thing I've sort of gleaned is coming back
- 12:53to that books for We're Stories in the End.
- 12:56You're going, oh, they are a peculiar sort of 90s phenomena
- 13:00now and that you know, and I know you Dicks ducked out sort
- 13:05of with the BBC ones, but you've quite enjoyed some of the BBC
- 13:08ones on Rediscovery. Yeah, I'm finding 2 very
- 13:13different things, which is the the new adventures were very
- 13:18much, obviously they were very much of their time.
- 13:22So all the kind of references are extremely dated now, because
- 13:26I don't that's a lie. I do remember exactly which
- 13:30songs they're using as chapter titles and who, who they're
- 13:33talking about and what they're riffing on.
- 13:35But it's all very gun. It's all very science fiction
- 13:41serious. There's a lot of a lot of angst,
- 13:44There's a lot of torture. There's it was.
- 13:46Not that as a kid though, right? It was, well it was, it was in
- 13:49the kind of era of The X-Files and everything was very gritty
- 13:52and very real and it was like Doctor Who, but it was Doctor
- 13:55Who but 15 certificate, which is what I wanted when I was 15.
- 13:59And occasionally you'd get, you know, the odd bit of sex
- 14:03creeping in as well. And it was, it was perfect for
- 14:05me. Then turns out as a grown up,
- 14:08that's not so much what I want to read all the time and it's
- 14:11certainly not what I want from my Doctor Who.
- 14:13Whereas the 8th Doctor novels, which I didn't get on with so
- 14:16much at the time, it turns out a lot of them have got quite a lot
- 14:22more going on than I appreciated originally.
- 14:25And there's a lot more experimentation and frankly
- 14:28there's a lot more frock. And the older I get, I find
- 14:31myself drifting ever more frockwards from a sort of gun
- 14:35based youth. My favorite quote ever from you
- 14:38for I've just howled and I was at work.
- 14:40Unfortunately, some people wondered why I was laughing out
- 14:42loud in the middle of the shot. But was when you said, yeah, you
- 14:46know, I've become to like frock a bit more.
- 14:48And you're talking about I think it was deaf and diplomacy, which
- 14:51is like a ROM com, right? You just went yes.
- 14:54As I get older, I find myself more.
- 14:56I find myself more and more attracted to romantic comedy.
- 15:00That's like, yeah, so do we all. At 15, we'd be like, I'd never
- 15:05watch those things. Yeah, exactly.
- 15:07But but because you kind of when you're 15, you think, oh, I
- 15:12don't, I don't care about romance.
- 15:13I don't care about comedy. I want a snog.
- 15:16And I use the word snog to cover a lot of activities.
- 15:19But but, but again, the older you get and the the less actual
- 15:24meat you have, sorry, the less actual skin you have in that
- 15:27game Then you. You love watching a bit of
- 15:29romance because it's just something that happens to other
- 15:31people. Is that what you told them?
- 15:33All that we did, Ian, just snog. Yeah, I, I, I did.
- 15:38I did, just euphemistically. Well done for rounding it out
- 15:42Good. Well, well OK, so I'm I'm
- 15:45getting a good idea of where your head is when we dive into
- 15:48Borrowed time. This is, I think, an atypical
- 15:55new series adventure in that I think it's a really good book
- 16:01like and I'm curious to see where you fall with this.
- 16:05I would. I would see that comment and
- 16:07raise it. I think this is a really good
- 16:09Doctor Who novel because it's really good.
- 16:14And yeah, I was completely expecting it to be like many of
- 16:21them, you know, six or seven out of 10.
- 16:23Perfectly serviceable. Yeah.
- 16:25Great. Does the job, tells you a story.
- 16:28Yeah, but my God. I did a Goodreads review after
- 16:33this, right? And I'll put I think this might
- 16:35be my favorite 11th Doctor story of all time.
- 16:39I was like that. That may sound like hyperbole,
- 16:41but I had a bit of an allergic reaction to this particular
- 16:45period of Doctor Who, which I think you're a bit kinder
- 16:47towards me. Massively so, massively so, and.
- 16:51Tell me. Tell me your love of Matt Smith
- 16:54and Karen Gillan. Well, and it's not so much Karen
- 16:58Gillan, but Matt Smith for me is the best doctor since Sylvester
- 17:02McCoy in terms of embodying the alien in a sort of
- 17:07inappropriately, really kind of human, dull, ordinary kind of
- 17:11body. He's he's got that that young
- 17:14old cliche that everybody says when they're trying to work out
- 17:19what it is about his doctor they like, but he's just awkward and
- 17:21knuckly and eccentric and weird and clearly an alien and.
- 17:26No wonder all the geeks fell for him.
- 17:28But that's just that is him. That is and that's and that's
- 17:32what's missing from a lot of other Doctors in certainly in
- 17:35terms of knew who he's. He's often or she portrayed more
- 17:42like a really cool bloke from down the pub than they are like
- 17:45an awkward, eccentric alien genius.
- 17:48But Matt Smith had that and the comedy was great in that era and
- 17:52I was there for it because I'd grown up as a Moffat fan loving
- 17:57coupling. So I knew what I was in for and
- 18:00that whole era just really worked for me.
- 18:03But I wasn't expecting it to necessarily translate to the
- 18:06page. I I hated coupling with a
- 18:10passion, but I just hate I hate American comedy, right?
- 18:14And that was that to me felt like auk sitcom doing American
- 18:18comedy. It was, it was very much sort of
- 18:21like, yeah, a British version of Friends, but again, a a kind of
- 18:2515 rated version. I didn't.
- 18:27David went Renwick sort of brilliantly structured episodes.
- 18:31It was very foot in the grave, wasn't it, How the episodes were
- 18:34all structured? It was, it was really, really
- 18:37clever. And that made it very because,
- 18:41you know, it started, I want to say one year after or maybe two
- 18:46years after the very last Men Behaving Badly went out, which
- 18:50was a very different kind of sitcom.
- 18:53And, you know, stripping out the kind of unspeakable lavish
- 18:57cancellable aspects of it. It was a, it kind of, it had
- 19:02followed the same kind of sitcom template going back to like
- 19:06Hancock's half hour. You know, it was largely real
- 19:10time. It was relationship based.
- 19:12It was it was just chatting and nonsense with the occasional
- 19:16silly situation. And Kaplan came along and kind
- 19:19of blew all of that out of the water.
- 19:21And it played with time and it played with, you know, there's
- 19:26that episode where Jeff's trying to chat up the, is she Israeli?
- 19:31And you get half the episode of him in English and her sitting
- 19:34there clearly not understanding a word he's saying.
- 19:36And then at the halfway point it flips and you hear the whole
- 19:38thing from her point of view. And there are so many examples
- 19:43of, of tricks like that throughout all four series that
- 19:47I thought it was the, the certainly the, the cleverest and
- 19:50most exciting thing to happen to the, the moribund world of
- 19:53British sitcom. So yeah, I was totally on board
- 19:57when my foot took over and I I totally loved it.
- 20:00And I appreciate that you and I will at some point in the future
- 20:03come to blows over this. But not today, because I think
- 20:09you're right. I think this not only it gets
- 20:13all three of the regulars absolutely perfect, they're so
- 20:16authentic on the page. I could see those actors saying
- 20:19every line in this book, but it added layers to their characters
- 20:22as well. I learnt something about each of
- 20:24them in this book. Yeah, it did.
- 20:27There was. There's a lovely sequence with
- 20:30not to sort of leap in and stop explaining the plot, but at some
- 20:36point Amy gets the opportunity to kind of steal a bit of time
- 20:40and do her own thing. So what does she do?
- 20:44She goes shopping and then she goes off to Leadworth to see mum
- 20:47and dad for a night and have and cook dinner for them.
- 20:51And that's so lovely. And that is a side of her that
- 20:53you didn't get on the TV. She was.
- 20:55She was always. Quite.
- 20:58A bit of a cow if I can, you know.
- 21:01But this phrase it to a come but yeah, I.
- 21:03Know well I you know she she was front adjacent on occasion, but
- 21:09some. Men love that though, you know.
- 21:10I know the people that love that in her.
- 21:12Yeah, no, I we've all, we've all known ladies like that, using
- 21:18these words carefully. But you know this, this fleshed
- 21:22out that family loving side of Amy.
- 21:29The Doctor got exactly the same kind of, you know, loaded
- 21:35dialogue that he would have got on the on the telly and Rory
- 21:39just radiated this kind of well meaning hopelessness, which
- 21:45which which is which is now kind of my my shtick.
- 21:49But you know, it was and it was so visual reading, you know,
- 21:56experiencing this book. It was so much like being back
- 21:59in front of like a a movie. But they would have made between
- 22:03series 10 and 11. I mean 5 and 6.
- 22:06I don't know why I said 10:00 and 11:00.
- 22:08It would have been a budget Buster, but I think they could
- 22:10have made this. I think it's all the bank, isn't
- 22:12it? And then the second-half,
- 22:14they're doing it, they're sort of out on the streets and
- 22:16there's a million times the same person.
- 22:19And it would have cost a bit of money, but they would have been.
- 22:22There, I think now they could absolutely do this as like a
- 22:25sort of two hour TV movie and they they absolutely that he
- 22:28should. I mean, one of the notes I came
- 22:30away from this book with is why hasn't Naomi Alderman been asked
- 22:35to write ATV episode? Because she has such a a visual
- 22:39imagination that not just in terms of the descriptions are
- 22:43very adroitly expressed, but the kind of set pieces you you can
- 22:49see them playing out. You can imagine what everything
- 22:51looks like. And yeah, there's a scene where
- 22:54they go to find someone who they think might be fiddling time and
- 22:59lo and behold, they go to his flat and he is there, about 10
- 23:02of him doing various jobs around the house.
- 23:06That's. The most muffy thing I could
- 23:07possibly imagine. Isn't it?
- 23:09And, you know, you can imagine that they're all kind of
- 23:12translucent. It's not beyond the realms of
- 23:14television, but one of one of, you know, strikingly visual
- 23:19idea. So clearly she can she, she can
- 23:23write the characters, she can write televisual or, or
- 23:27certainly visual sequences and set pieces.
- 23:31And you know, without, without coming to the end of the show
- 23:35too soon. But this is one of the most
- 23:37enjoyable Doctor Who books I've experienced.
- 23:40So surely she should be a showrunner by now.
- 23:45What is happening? Well, she's a best selling
- 23:47author. Well, she's too.
- 23:48She's too busy writing, you know, great friends with.
- 23:51Baraka Ballmer, you. Know, but I I I would imagine
- 23:54she'd she'd have got more money by producing Doctor Who than
- 23:58than by writing one you. Remember when Gareth Roberts
- 24:00wrote Only Human? I'm not sure if I will.
- 24:03I'd say his name anymore, but I'm covering one of his books
- 24:05soon so I better get used to it. And then Rusty Davis read Only
- 24:10Human and went Jesus Christ. He should be writing for the
- 24:12series. And then the Shakespeare Code
- 24:14came two seasons later. Oh, is that how it happened?
- 24:17They should be exactly the same, right?
- 24:18Moffitt should have read this and I don't even know if he had
- 24:21the time. He was juggling 22 fucking TV
- 24:23shows at the time, wasn't he? Well, you know what, there's
- 24:26this, there's this kind of sense that that the merchandise was
- 24:31like really strictly kind of controlled by Cardiff.
- 24:36So RTD would have, you know, he got sent a copy of all the
- 24:40action figures to check the faces were adequate or whatever.
- 24:44If, if they if, if RTD and Moffatt didn't read the books,
- 24:49there would probably have been someone whose job it was to read
- 24:52them and just let them know this happens and this happens.
- 24:56Is this going to impact anything you're planning to do in the
- 24:58show? Must have been somebody.
- 25:00So someone at some point could have said to Moffat, yeah, read
- 25:03this one. Stage please read this.
- 25:05It's fucking great. She's really good.
- 25:09You remember that slot in Series 6 you wanted to give to that
- 25:12prick Gareth Roberts? Well, Naomi Alderman's written a
- 25:15book here that would translate perfectly on the screen.
- 25:19See, the thing with Gareth Roberts is I've been, I'm not
- 25:25going to say I've been reading his book since the 90s.
- 25:27That makes me sound like I read them all constantly in a loop.
- 25:30I have been aware of the man for that long.
- 25:32I've read most of his Doctor Who fiction.
- 25:35I don't know what he's done wrong.
- 25:38I know he's a Tory, but I'm not aware of what it is that he's
- 25:42really done to make him so cancellable.
- 25:45I think I think the worst thing he's probably done in the eyes
- 25:49of a lot of people is very JK Rowling esque.
- 25:56Right. OK, well that seems.
- 25:59A book that sort of basically said that if gay people exist
- 26:04then trans people can't exist and so sort of cancelled out and
- 26:10cancelled out the the the T from the LGBTQ.
- 26:14Right now, did you do that in a Doctor Who novel or was it no?
- 26:18Alas, he did it outside of Doctor Who.
- 26:20He wasn't being used by Doctor Who publishers at.
- 26:23That as I was, I was going to say that's a hell of a a topic,
- 26:27a doctor book to to wander into. I mean, I'm pleased you said it,
- 26:31frankly, because now I've just got that out of the way and next
- 26:33time I talk about Gareth Roberts, I can just talk about
- 26:36the bloody book. Yeah, absolutely.
- 26:38But as you can imagine, there ain't a lot of people queuing up
- 26:40to do those books because that no one's willing to touch it
- 26:43with a barge pole going back to the regulars for a second.
- 26:47And I only want to do this because I've really come down
- 26:50hard on 11. I love Rory.
- 26:53I love her, but he's the underdog, right?
- 26:55And I always loved you. And he's treated appallingly in
- 26:58Series 5, where he's sort of tailing around after Amy and
- 27:01she's giving the Doctor moon eyes and shoving him on the bed
- 27:04and trying to suck his cock or whatever she's trying to do at
- 27:07the end of that episode. But there was a there was a
- 27:09description of Rory and this as somehow he wasn't the shortest
- 27:13of the three of them, but somehow he was always tailing
- 27:16behind, which I wish. I Yeah, that is.
- 27:18Do you remember the pit at the end where he finds out that
- 27:23she's borrowed all that time and she owes 10 years?
- 27:26And he goes, well, you're my wife, Your debts are my debts,
- 27:30so of course I will take them off you.
- 27:31And I was like, oh, that's just pure Rory.
- 27:34That's so Rory and that's so noble and kind of that's the
- 27:41kind of man or or person in a relationship that we should all
- 27:44aspire to be. I'd love to sit here now and say
- 27:47that if my wife came home and said, oh, I've lost 10 years to
- 27:50a dodgy time thing, I'd be like, don't worry darling.
- 27:53I have 10 of mine but I'm not sure I would.
- 27:56No, you go, you've lost 10 years.
- 27:58We still haven't been able to watch that bloody box set, what
- 28:01you've been doing. Yeah.
- 28:03But also as well, you know, you said about Amy going home, I, I
- 28:06think Naomi Alderman looks at Pandora Robes and The Big Bang
- 28:11and went that was absolutely amazing.
- 28:13But really we've had 0 explanation as to the two AMI
- 28:18timelines that are in existence because of that story.
- 28:21And so she just writes one paragraph in this, which if it
- 28:24had been on the TV I would have stopped whingeing completely.
- 28:27Where she goes, she sees her mum and dad there and she remembers
- 28:30them being there her whole life and having a really happy
- 28:34childhood. And she remembers them not being
- 28:37there and being a lonely little girl who was desperate for the
- 28:41raggedy doctors to come back. And I was like, that's all I
- 28:43needed. Well, this is what's so kind of
- 28:48impressive and graceful about about this book is that clearly
- 28:54one of two things happened. Either Naomi Alderman was a
- 28:57lifelong Doctor Who fan when she wrote this book, or, and I'm not
- 29:01saying this didn't happen because it might have done, or
- 29:04she watched all of Doctor Who and just dropped in enough
- 29:08continuity to say I know what I'm talking about.
- 29:12I know this show. I know inside out.
- 29:14I'm going to refer to this. I'm going to refer to that.
- 29:16I'm going to refer to an obscure reference to the 7th Doctor era,
- 29:21an obscure reference to the Tom Baker era.
- 29:24She just really lightly and delicately established her
- 29:27credentials and justified, you know, come on, boys, I'm allowed
- 29:31to write a Doctor Who book. I know what I'm talking about.
- 29:34I've seen the show without turning it into this kind of
- 29:38massive clunking. I'm going to reference every
- 29:41single. Story ever the new adventures
- 29:44under EDA. Which exactly, Exactly they'd
- 29:47have hammered it home. And Naomi just sort of lightly,
- 29:50lightly battered it and put it on a little plate and said
- 29:53voila. I mean, you haven't covered War
- 29:56of the Daleks yet, so that's why you you're keeping that shred of
- 29:58sanity still. But when you do, you'll learn
- 30:02that John Peel rewrites 4 entire TV stories just because he
- 30:06doesn't like the way that they go.
- 30:07You know, that's what the Edos were doing at the time.
- 30:09I can, I can remember I was, I think War of the Daleks.
- 30:15And I very unfairly say it was Castle's fault.
- 30:20I don't think it was, you know, how like, yeah, but that was,
- 30:26that was just one duffer too many.
- 30:28I feel like that's the dart board that everyone goes.
- 30:30For yeah, it's like, it's like in in Britain there was a very
- 30:33recent active kind of political referenda where a certain
- 30:38government were quietly got rid of.
- 30:41And it wasn't necessarily that people were sick of Rishi, but
- 30:45things have been building up for quite a while.
- 30:48And actually you can trace the moment that the Tories lost the
- 30:52election and it was, it was Johnson.
- 30:54In much the same way, I think War of the Daleks, although I
- 30:57carried on for a couple of books, War of the Daleks was the
- 31:01one that shat the bed. Understandably as well, yeah.
- 31:07Can I ask you a question? In your life, have you ever
- 31:11borrowed large sums of money? Borrowed large sums, Yes, I
- 31:17have. Well, I'm too sure then.
- 31:21I mean, I mean. Student.
- 31:24Student loans, that kind of thing.
- 31:26Did you have to pay back interest on that money?
- 31:29I I did. Yeah, I did.
- 31:31Were you educated about it in a Doctor Who book?
- 31:35Well. Not at the time.
- 31:38Could you have done with borrowed time in your teens?
- 31:41Would it, would it not have been absolutely amazing to get this
- 31:45lesson in how compound interest works?
- 31:48That's a point where, you know, I spent so, so coming out of
- 31:53university at the end of the 90s, we were the first
- 31:56generation that had to go and buy a mobile phone.
- 31:59And thank God they were expensive.
- 32:02And I was always kind of at the bottom.
- 32:05Yeah. Basic huge Motorola Mother
- 32:08Mother fucker 103. I think it was cool.
- 32:12And you know, I would always be overdrawn at the end of the
- 32:14month. I'd have credit cards.
- 32:16And at the time it felt like I was, you know, I was maybe I
- 32:22think as much as one or maybe 2000s in debt at any point now,
- 32:27as soon as I earned enough money, that stopped happening.
- 32:30And and you know, I'm, I'm, I'm quite sensible with money.
- 32:33I do know of people who are my age who are, you know, 10s of
- 32:38thousands in, in that kind of credit debt.
- 32:40If they'd had this book, the the way it explains how interest
- 32:45works. Oh God.
- 32:48So simply right. So it's a basically a cake.
- 32:52The Doctor starts cutting off layers of the cake to explain to
- 32:56Amy, because I suppose actually, sorry, we should really say it's
- 33:00not money that they're borrowing in this book.
- 33:01But the title sort of gives away what people are borrowing from
- 33:06the bank, and that is time. So they're borrowing time
- 33:09because they're busy high flying bankers and they want to zoom
- 33:12around in all the meetings and get the promotions and be the
- 33:14best people they could possibly be.
- 33:16Amy Pons, you know, in a moment of spectacular drama, realizes
- 33:20she's got a call from the Doctor and a call from Rory, and she
- 33:24needs to be in two places at once.
- 33:26Fuck, how am I going to do that? And then these two chaps come
- 33:28along and go, hello, I just so happened to have this watch,
- 33:31which means you can borrow some time.
- 33:33Don't read the terms and conditions.
- 33:34You don't need to read those. Just just sign there and you can
- 33:37borrow back as much as you like. 5 minutes you have to pay back
- 33:41for every hour. So she goes, that's not much, is
- 33:44it? You know, that's fine.
- 33:45And then she starts borrowing and borrowing and borrowing more
- 33:50things she thinks she needs doing.
- 33:52She's sort of doing her sums as she goes, thinking, well, you
- 33:55know, I borrowed 4 days, so that's only a couple of hours I
- 33:58owe back. Great.
- 33:59And then, yeah, comes the horrific moment where the doctor
- 34:02has to explain to her, no, this is how compound interest works,
- 34:07and this is how much you owe. Do you remember how much that
- 34:09was? I, I, I borrowed 1020 years, 10
- 34:13years, 10 years, 5 minutes per hour per hour.
- 34:19And because it was the two guys and one of them says, oh, it's 5
- 34:22minutes per hour and the other one goes per hour.
- 34:26And it's so cleverly done as well.
- 34:28It's so cleverly done though. That's why they were such good
- 34:30villains. Did you like how they explained
- 34:33as well that every time you use the the watch and you get given
- 34:38that time back again, it's, it's, it's a pleasurable
- 34:41feeling, like you've had all the sleep of that time put into you.
- 34:46And that's exactly the same feeling you get when you whip
- 34:49out your credit card and you buy something expensive.
- 34:52And I thought, she's so clever. That is exactly what it feels
- 34:56like when you spend money you haven't earned.
- 34:58It was a really sophisticated analogy, wasn't it?
- 35:01For again. Again, for a, for a, for a, a
- 35:04new series adventure book. My God, you know, we're getting
- 35:09great villains. We're getting a great premise.
- 35:11We're, you know, it's kind of like an episode of Red Dwarf,
- 35:13but we'll let that go. We're getting brilliant comedy
- 35:17and we're getting really entertaining books.
- 35:21So yeah, it's just yet another area in which this thing really
- 35:24excels. You know, when I was 20, Yeah, I
- 35:27I bought myself my first computer and I just saw it and
- 35:31it went by. Now pay two years later, I was
- 35:34like, oh, perfect, I'll just have it.
- 35:36Well, look, two years passed and that computer had broken by
- 35:39then. Yeah.
- 35:40And I no longer had it. I was on to my next one and it
- 35:43came to pay it back. I'll pay back that computer
- 35:45twice and I I wish I'd had this book back then, you know?
- 35:50Oh, you seem to be flicking right.
- 35:51Now I'm I'm just getting, I'm just finding my notes.
- 35:54Oh, what was? What was the computer?
- 35:56And it was really shitty. I mean the porn would only come
- 35:59up the screen one line at a time.
- 36:03So yeah, it was, yeah. I love that I.
- 36:06Remember that. You know, those sort of times.
- 36:09That's what she said. But like, as well as, as well as
- 36:15that very, very sophisticated metaphor for spending money,
- 36:22which, you know, like in terms of educating kids, I think
- 36:24that's probably the most the, the, the best use of education
- 36:28any Doctor Who has ever employed.
- 36:31There was like a wealth of like, just throw away great ideas.
- 36:35For example. Oh, excuse me, I'm just getting
- 36:37a call. Hang on.
- 36:38Yes. Hello.
- 36:40Galactic enquiries. Hello.
- 36:42Yes, I'd like to. What's that?
- 36:45Yes, I'm looking to podcast for someone called Ian Martin.
- 36:48Yes, Ian Martin. That's right.
- 36:51Oh, 565. Ian Martins on the Earth, you
- 36:55say? Well, what about in this
- 36:56particular area? Oh, OK. 30, How many are human?
- 37:00Oh, only three. OK, how many are hot?
- 37:0302? OK, how can we some this that is
- 37:07anyone got a load of new adventures behind him?
- 37:09Yes, that's the one. Put him on the call.
- 37:12I mean, that was a great idea, right?
- 37:14Galactic Enquiries. That was for me, that was kind
- 37:17of basically Douglas Adams level of throw away genius because
- 37:23that in itself, there's a there's a Doctor Who novel in
- 37:25that idea, but she's not worried about doing that.
- 37:28She doesn't, she doesn't need it.
- 37:30She's just throwing away brilliant ideas like that.
- 37:33It was so. Funny to get from A to B, isn't
- 37:35it as well? Yeah, yeah.
- 37:37I've got another question for you though, Ian.
- 37:39How much sort of Doctor Who merchandise do you own?
- 37:45Well. Now that was an almost psychotic
- 37:48giggle. Then it was.
- 37:49Not as much as as you might think.
- 37:51I've I've still got all the Nas and all the EDA, almost all the
- 37:55EDA's. I've got about 30 targets left
- 38:02and two Blu rays and assorted DVDs.
- 38:08When I say 2 Blu rays I mean two of the season box sets and a
- 38:12bunch of individual DVDs. Not a lot.
- 38:16I used to own a hell of a lot more.
- 38:18Do you imagine, though, that your missus, you know, if you
- 38:19sort of packed it away in a storage area, that she might be
- 38:23quite happy to use that space for other things?
- 38:25Absolutely yes I do, but she would use it poorly.
- 38:32Oh, OK. I mean, I was just using it as a
- 38:34way really to get a sort of Millennium Dome storage centre.
- 38:39Which which is another of those brilliant ideas that she's had.
- 38:44So you have the Millennium Dome and then beneath it.
- 38:49I'm going to do that. So.
- 38:50So it works visually. You have a much larger inverted
- 38:54hollow dip, which is yeah, for for off world travellers and
- 39:00people out of time. It's a special storage facility
- 39:04for for aliens. How amazing is this?
- 39:07It's like. You walk in, don't you?
- 39:09And you get shrunk down into a tiny size.
- 39:11That's how they can fit so much in there, because you're.
- 39:14Shrunk. And then there's these.
- 39:15Is it cockroaches? Yes.
- 39:18But they're normal cockroaches because you've been shrunk.
- 39:20They're now sort of guard cockroaches.
- 39:22So if you have bad things, they're going to come after you.
- 39:25And the whole place is governed by someone called Omelette
- 39:30something the omelette ram. Yeah, the space names, yeah.
- 39:36Yeah, there was, there was, there was a bit of a space name,
- 39:38but it even. Then right, they were just
- 39:40throwing open doors and she was throwing away ideas.
- 39:42Amy walks into one room and there's a load of mirrors and
- 39:45it's all these alternative versions of Amy in every mirror.
- 39:48And I was like, there's a book. And Rory opens a door and finds
- 39:53a room made of mucus. Well, of course, of course.
- 39:58And I laughed out loud and several people in the office
- 40:02looked at me like I was having a mental infarction.
- 40:04What's he reading? It must be so.
- 40:06Oh Doctor Who. Oh dear.
- 40:08Well, they couldn't. So, and and I'll come to this
- 40:12now because why not? But I didn't read it.
- 40:14I did the audio which was read by Mira Sayal.
- 40:18Now I've done her a great disservice over the years
- 40:21because I've I've been not the biggest fan of her or Sanjeev
- 40:27Bhaskar, both from Goodness Gracious Me I believe in the 90s
- 40:31and I've found them both to be fairly limited performers, which
- 40:35is, on hearing this audio book, really not the case.
- 40:38She is absolutely brilliant. Her Amy impression is fantastic.
- 40:43Her ability to cope with all the space names and silly words is
- 40:48brilliant. The only mistake she makes is
- 40:51the same mistake John Pertwee once made where she says
- 40:54chittiness. Oh no.
- 40:56Are you aware of the anecdote about the, the fan letter that
- 41:00John Pertwee got where someone said the reason I'm writing is
- 41:04how to say chitin and, and the same thing happened and I
- 41:08thought, well, do you know what the.
- 41:09Worst part of that is he asked Barry Letts, how do you say
- 41:12this? Is it chitonus or chitonus?
- 41:14And Barry Letts goes, I think it's chitonus.
- 41:17OK, well, we'll do that. I mean, I mean, it's fair
- 41:20enough. It's probably not a word in
- 41:22common usage at BBC Towers in the early 70s.
- 41:25I never do the readings, you know, I always read the books,
- 41:28especially the NSA's, because they're sort of brisk reads.
- 41:32Does it work as an audio? It absolutely works as an audio.
- 41:38And I think because it's so condensed, it was, it's six
- 41:40hours and you can measure that out in terms of, you know,
- 41:44that's, that's six commutes or it's, you know, 12 lunch breaks
- 41:50or or whatever. And it's each chapter's about 20
- 41:53minutes. And it really does work.
- 41:54Some books, let's for example, something like a Game of
- 41:58Thrones, there's no way you can actually listen to that without
- 42:01falling asleep at some point. And then you've lost your place
- 42:04in it and the whole thing's a disaster and you just go home
- 42:07crying because. But no, as a as a very it, it
- 42:12was like listening to some podcasts.
- 42:13It was that level of easiness of controlling the flow.
- 42:18Well, talking of the flow, perfect segue because.
- 42:21Do you need the toilet? I'm all right.
- 42:25I shall wait just for. OK.
- 42:26I'll borrow some time if I need to go.
- 42:27All right. I'll leave you here with another
- 42:29Joe. OK.
- 42:30OK. Yeah.
- 42:31Oh, the things I've done with my borrowed time.
- 42:33I'll tell you what, There was 10 of me in one place and there was
- 42:36no one else there. I'm telling you, what was I
- 42:41going to say? Again, I don't know.
- 42:42Is it? Is it something like a sort of
- 42:44Joe Ford based Human Centipede but with love?
- 42:49We have lots of love yes, and lots of mouthful What I was
- 42:54going to say was on the page. The prose flowed abusive.
- 42:59I'll read this in a day in a day and that is really fast for me.
- 43:03And just I just slipped across the pages like it was so fluid.
- 43:08But the way she paces a scene as well, because she has some very
- 43:12dialogue heavy scenes in this as she's explaining, you know, the
- 43:16people that are borrowed time and how you have to pay it back
- 43:18and all of that. And there's a ton of but it just
- 43:21sort of builds momentum and builds momentum.
- 43:23And then at the end of the chapter, it's like, how much do
- 43:25I owe 10 years? Boom, end of chapter.
- 43:28Like, it's like if this was her first book and then no wonder
- 43:33she went on to be an international bestseller.
- 43:35Well, that's or, or I would say the other way around.
- 43:38It's this good because she's that good of a writer.
- 43:41And there are there are other Doctor Who books I have read
- 43:45where the author is less. What's a nice way of saying it?
- 43:50The prose is is less kind of effortless and less subtly
- 43:55crafted, and you really have to work your way down the page
- 43:58because a lot of these paragraphs are quite hard work.
- 44:01And those are writers did not go on to be global literary authors
- 44:07in quite the same way. Barack Obama knows who Barry
- 44:10Letts is, you know. I That's probably true.
- 44:14I'm currently reading the Ghost event space, which is a typical
- 44:17example of what you're talking about there.
- 44:19Well, so I I do work in DC. So if I bump into Obama, do you
- 44:24want me to ask him if he's aware of who Barry let's.
- 44:27As he read the ghost event. That's that's your question.
- 44:29It's the list. If that's your question, you'd
- 44:32ask to Barack Obama if you had one question, it's Have you read
- 44:35The Ghost? Excuse me, do you know, like
- 44:38you're talking about politicians and Doctor Who spin off media?
- 44:40But I did in fact see a copy of Seal and the Devil Seat of
- 44:43Arador in Jeremy Corbyn's hands. Absolutely.
- 44:47So it's not without the realms of possibility.
- 44:51Which now that means and that that explains the problem with
- 44:55Corbyn. So he's clearly a a classic who
- 44:58fan so and classic Who fans. We were just weirdos.
- 45:02You know, it wasn't until the new series came along and
- 45:04everything got a bit cool and sexy and and kind of geekery
- 45:08became acceptable. Anyone from before times is just
- 45:14a weirdo. And that, I think, is probably
- 45:16what beset Corbyn. He should have borrowed some
- 45:18time and had another, you know, another go at.
- 45:21It the trouble is though, right? If this concept was real,
- 45:24everyone would be able to it, wouldn't they?
- 45:26Like, I think we all like to think we're a bit above this
- 45:28sort of thing, but oh, Jesus Christ, I would be borrowing and
- 45:32borrowing and borrowing. But you know what?
- 45:33I'll just be reading Doctor Who books is the trouble.
- 45:36Well I mean serious point, but everyone, everyone kind of has a
- 45:42a vice in their life and it might be a perfectly innocent
- 45:45voice. Like I need to spend 3 hours in
- 45:47the gym every day. Orgasms.
- 45:49Is that a voice? Orgasms.
- 45:51People who spend all day fiddling with themselves if they
- 45:53could. Well, I didn't say that excuse.
- 45:55Me people who or, or, or other people, people who who just
- 46:00would spend the time smoking or drinking or whatever.
- 46:05And if if, if this thing was actually offered to everyone on
- 46:09the planet, everyone on the planet would take it up.
- 46:12And if they'd indulge their kind of weak human voices at the same
- 46:19time as sending the other version now into the office to
- 46:21do the job all day. So.
- 46:23If there was an adult version of this book, it would be that,
- 46:25wouldn't it? Absolutely.
- 46:26It would be the sort of get it wouldn't be able to be going
- 46:29home and taking Rory out for lunch and things like that.
- 46:32It would be, yeah. And people doing.
- 46:37Terrible or, and you know what, I'm going to slip in a we're all
- 46:40stories in the end gag here just to prove how much I'll listen
- 46:44that if Fitz could borrow some time, maybe you can finally have
- 46:47a fucking fag, right yes, finally get me another one.
- 46:55Well, I. Remember, you know, reading,
- 46:58reading, reading some books with fits in in the, you know, late
- 47:0290s, early 2000s. Well, I did smoke and I'd be I'd
- 47:06be sort of quite merrily puffing away and Fitz needs a cigarette.
- 47:11I've I've got 11 in this packet and I was king.
- 47:16Of the world. You were offering them to the
- 47:18book, weren't you? Take it out.
- 47:21Mate, I felt bad for him because every time he really needed one
- 47:26it was like, oh I know what that's like.
- 47:27It's in the middle of a lesson. Where were we?
- 47:31I have no idea. I was actually going to ask you
- 47:34about the climax of the book, if I may.
- 47:36Oh. Get to the climax.
- 47:37Well, no, just sort of like, because I read a couple of
- 47:40reviews on Love Everyone Went. The first half of the book is
- 47:42just astonishingly good, you know, And you get that sort of
- 47:46sinking feeling in your gut as Amy is borrowing time, knowing
- 47:50even if she's doing nice things, horrible things are coming.
- 47:54And the way she shows how easy it is to spend time slash money.
- 48:04And we've all been there, right? Ah, yeah, absolutely.
- 48:06Just a bit more. Maybe just a bit more.
- 48:09Oh fuck. It's, it's the kind of human
- 48:13thought process of, oh God, I'm in trouble.
- 48:16I owe so much. So that being said, another
- 48:20another 1020 doesn't make a difference and that's the
- 48:23slippery slope everyone gets on. In the second-half of the book
- 48:27we joined forces with Andrew Brown and Samira Jenkins, who
- 48:31work at the bank, who basically started all this off borrowing
- 48:35time because they were rivals and they both were going for the
- 48:37same promotion. And the four of them are being
- 48:41pursued by relentless copies of I Can't Go Try and Say It.
- 48:47So it's Mr. Symington and Mr. Blankensop.
- 48:50Is that where you're going? Usefully done, yes, and I have
- 48:53seen loan sharks in inverted commas done on Buffy the.
- 48:57Van Buffy Yeah, in season 6, right, Just.
- 49:00Dreadful. Like the mask was awful.
- 49:02Whereas Naomi Alderman doesn't really describe big rubbery
- 49:05heads. She just goes for the teeth,
- 49:07didn't she? But did you think was it, did
- 49:10you bump on that moment? Did you think she's nicked that
- 49:12idea from Buffy or did it I? Wrote it in my nose.
- 49:15Yeah, me too. But I thought she made it
- 49:18scarier because all shit, there was one bit where someone got
- 49:20eaten and it was described as they could just hear the
- 49:24crunching of bones or something. I was like, yes, yeah, lovely.
- 49:28Nice bit of nice bit of grim. Bone crunching.
- 49:31Yeah, that's what you want. So, yeah.
- 49:34So you were saying how the first half was really exciting and
- 49:38then and then a lot of critics online.
- 49:41Well, not not saying that, not saying it was terrible, just
- 49:44that it couldn't quite keep up that momentum of absolute
- 49:47brilliance. But I found the second-half
- 49:49really satisfying. Yeah, I would disagree with
- 49:51that. I think if and and what I did
- 49:53because I listened to this once and I wrote down a little prey
- 49:57see of each chapter. So it's amazing and a so that
- 50:02I'd remember because I, I remember very little these days.
- 50:06In fact someone's weed in my trousers.
- 50:08It wasn't me, but I, you know, I have all the stuff written down
- 50:13so I'm able to go back and look at it and see how.
- 50:16She. Fills the time and tells the
- 50:19story and each chapter, certainly in the first half, but
- 50:23to a degree throughout the book is kind of, it works as a short
- 50:27story in that it's kind of 1 discreet event or or scene or or
- 50:34story being told and then it moves on and it's quite
- 50:37effortless. And I think because of the way
- 50:40she structures it, it does kind of maintain the rhythm and the
- 50:45pace and a lot of a lot of other books where it just jumps back
- 50:49and forth, back and forth, back and forth, spinning out certain
- 50:53kind of subplots in a really wearisome kind of way there.
- 51:00There's so many books that are a lot worse than this and a lot
- 51:03harder. And obviously with any story, as
- 51:06it gets towards the ending, you're the the kind of focus
- 51:10crunches right down to the the kind of point that's being made
- 51:14and the characters who are making it.
- 51:17And that was really good in this book.
- 51:21And I've seen it done really badly in other books, but here
- 51:23it was really effortless. I just, I just thought the way
- 51:27she was so focused on the bank in the first half meant that
- 51:31this was like a filmable book. But then in the second-half we
- 51:34go off to the, what is it, the galactic traders or something
- 51:37like that. Basically the doctor goes, look,
- 51:40everything they've borrowed, I will pay it back because I have
- 51:43a very long life. And she goes, well, if you're
- 51:45going to pay it all back, then you have to come with me and I'm
- 51:48going to sell you on the galactic trade market.
- 51:51Yeah. How much was he worth again?
- 51:53Hang on a minute. I did write it down.
- 51:55It was. It was made me laugh so much.
- 51:57He was worth. Hang on.
- 52:04Here we go. 5 inhabited Galaxy and 15 sextillion lives to have
- 52:09the for the last of the time laws.
- 52:11Because we're still the last of the time laws at this point,
- 52:13aren't we? So he's very valuable.
- 52:16Oh, and imagine, imagine if it was a post season 9 doctor who'd
- 52:22been alive for those extra 2 billion years, thumping his way
- 52:26through a diamond. I've got no time left, I've used
- 52:30it all. It's like I own everything.
- 52:32I've got all the money. I've there aren't enough
- 52:34galaxies to buy me. That is, I don't canny that
- 52:38impression. It's not one of my better
- 52:40doctors, but. Can you do Matt Smith?
- 52:43I'd love to. No, I can't.
- 52:47I saw his cock in the film Clone.
- 52:49You know, I wouldn't mind too much as well.
- 52:51And I'm not speaking as an 11th Doctor fan, but.
- 52:54I mean, I mean, I'm aware of the image because I have the
- 52:57Internet and I suspected he helped himself along just before
- 53:03that scene just to. Chapolis, when I'll do a quote
- 53:06of Matt Smith, I'll just use to say, oh, wibbly wobbly, totally
- 53:09why that you know, that's all. It's not bad.
- 53:11Thank you. That was good as your Capaldi
- 53:13Jesus. You should see my Jodie.
- 53:18I don't please do it. Please.
- 53:22I I've never even tried and I'm I'm certainly not going to start
- 53:25now. You'll be cancelled when this
- 53:28goes out. I know, well I will anyway.
- 53:30Things I've said, but he's he. I find him one of the less
- 53:35easily imitable doctors. But in print as well, because I
- 53:41read quite a few 11th Doctor books and they just overdo it.
- 53:45They make him like insane, like Willy Wonka, you know.
- 53:49And I know the TV series could go there, Doctor, The Widow and
- 53:51the Wardrobe every now and again.
- 53:54But for the most part that sort of humour was quite contained.
- 53:57It was all over the place. But he it wasn't madly over the
- 54:02top. And I think she got it perfect.
- 54:04Absolutely spot on. She, you know, this, for me,
- 54:08this is up there with the kind of the, the best Matt Smith
- 54:12episodes. I'm, I'm going to point to a
- 54:15couple from season 5, Christmas Carol.
- 54:18There was a kind of very finite but very, very distinct period
- 54:22where it was absolutely amazing and and she's writing at that
- 54:26level. She's not point, isn't it?
- 54:28This is exactly after Christmas Carol, before the impossible
- 54:31astronaut. Then then it's probably
- 54:33conscious and it probably just means she's an even better
- 54:35writer than I thought she was. But yeah, she's, she's not just
- 54:40doing a good job imitating the characters, she's she's doing
- 54:45them at their absolute best and doing them better than any other
- 54:49writer I've I've come across. I feel like how she makes him
- 54:52quirky, but then the in the way that Matt Smith did at his best,
- 54:56he just drops all the comedy and he's deadly serious at the end
- 55:00of that chapter when he just looks at Amy when she comes up
- 55:02to him with a watch and he goes, oh, Pond, what have you done?
- 55:04Have you done great? But I suppose, and then at the
- 55:10end, at the end, so they're selling the Doctor and we
- 55:15realise that oh, there's a great twist as well, wasn't there,
- 55:19about who was? I won't give away the twist,
- 55:21because maybe someone might want to learn something in the book,
- 55:23but who's actually behind all of this?
- 55:26Is A twist. It was a nice twist.
- 55:28Did you see it coming? Not at all.
- 55:30I was in I was in Starbucks with my over off He's working and I
- 55:34went what the fuck? He went what I went Oh my God,
- 55:38you wouldn't bullet because you are reading an NSA right.
- 55:41I was like, yeah, it's really good.
- 55:45But anyway, she we realized that she's obviously had to, This is
- 55:48how money works, right? You have, if you're going to
- 55:51lend money out, you have to borrow it from somewhere.
- 55:54And she's borrowed a shit ton of money.
- 55:57So you can then she can lend it out via the watches to all these
- 56:00other people. But because she's got the
- 56:02doctor's leverage now that she can actually borrow a whole lot
- 56:06more until the doctor throws a spanner in the works.
- 56:09And I think I don't know too much about the stock markets,
- 56:12Ian. You surprise me.
- 56:16Shut up. But once your sort of reputation
- 56:20is blown like hers is here, Yeah, I'm assuming that
- 56:23everything just sinks. Yeah.
- 56:25Like a stone. All your shades, all your worth.
- 56:29The the way it the way it's done here is, I don't know if you're
- 56:33old enough to remember that rather marvellous period in
- 56:35EastEnders where Ian Beale went bankrupt and he's running around
- 56:41the square and he's on his knees and frying and begging him and
- 56:44the snoss. That was lovely little runt.
- 56:48Yeah, it was like that. It just happens very quickly and
- 56:50it doesn't even take a concrete event or a specific loss.
- 56:55Once the momentum of failure is about you and the, and the, the
- 57:00smell of failure, then people call in their credit and you
- 57:04can't borrow anymore and you're finished.
- 57:07And it was described in about what, 2 paragraphs at the start
- 57:12of a chapter where the villains kind of reign of terror was over
- 57:16because just like that, the market decided bad investment,
- 57:20I'm off. And it was.
- 57:22So again, it was another another sequence where you actually
- 57:30learn stuff, you know, like the interest.
- 57:33This was this was aimed at kids to learn about money, but really
- 57:36it was me. Well, at the start she was told
- 57:39you knew all about banking and how that works.
- 57:41And she does like A2 page thing all about banking, but in a
- 57:44really fun way. Then you learn all about sort of
- 57:46borrowing, then you learn all about interest, then you learn
- 57:51all about liquidity, and then you learn all about your
- 57:55business just failing in the market.
- 57:57So, you know, this is if if every kid had to read 1 Doctor
- 58:04Who book when they were like 9 or 10, make it this one.
- 58:08And what a what a country of, you know, fiscally prudent
- 58:12people would grow up to be Rachel Reeves wouldn't have to
- 58:15raise anything, you know, because we'd all be fine.
- 58:18There'd be no there'd be no debt.
- 58:20There'd be no they'd. Be like, what's going on?
- 58:23No one's borrowing any money anymore.
- 58:26It's just so happens to have coincided with the reprint of
- 58:30Borrowed Time by Naomi Alder. Yeah.
- 58:32So it's like, well, this woman has destroyed banking, but she
- 58:37has captured Matt Smith really well, so.
- 58:39There's a load of sharks going around eating people.
- 58:42Yeah. So what are you going to do?
- 58:44What are you going to do? Did you like the idea of
- 58:46Torchwood and Unit both sniffing around the crime scene at the
- 58:49end? I did and again, how lovely was
- 58:52that little throwaway reference to because the the story is set
- 58:56in 2007, so that would be during season 3.
- 59:02So you had Torchwood and Unit capering round in the shadows of
- 59:07Mr. Saxon and it was, it was lovely to see.
- 59:10And, and in sort of two lines, she gets a bit of comedy out of
- 59:15the relationship of these two sort of quasi government bodies,
- 59:20which again shows her knowledge of the show and it's history.
- 59:25She knows how she can make jokes about it.
- 59:27She says UNIT will spend 18 fruitless months trying to
- 59:31reconstruct the pieces of the watch.
- 59:33Yeah, yeah. Poor Kate Stewart.
- 59:36She's getting very frustrated. Well, I, I imagine it's, it's
- 59:39Malcolm down there. I've.
- 59:44Really made it work. I'll have it done in a minute,
- 59:47Sir, OK? Oh fuck, I've broke it again.
- 59:52Bless. Him.
- 59:52Oh, it's borrowed my leg. And can I just say as well,
- 59:57because I didn't see this coming and I should have seen this
- 1:00:00coming. I really loved Samir and Andrew
- 1:00:03snogging at the end and going, do you know what?
- 1:00:06This bank ain't worth it. Let's go.
- 1:00:08I'm going to I'm going to own a bakery.
- 1:00:10You go paint. Let's have a happy life
- 1:00:12together. So I thought, actually it's
- 1:00:14quite a nice little, little romance there.
- 1:00:16It's lovely because from page one and, and maybe I'll go back
- 1:00:19and talk about chapter one in a in a second, but from, from page
- 1:00:23one, these two have been absolutely set up as being
- 1:00:27perfect for each other because they are exactly as ruthless,
- 1:00:30yet fallible, yet corrupt, yet inadequate as each other.
- 1:00:36So of course they belong to each other totally.
- 1:00:39And as the book goes on and you realise, maybe that's where
- 1:00:43we're heading, I'm sort of sitting there going go, go and
- 1:00:45have a snog. Well, you'd be great for each
- 1:00:48other. So if you say we're sort of
- 1:00:50sneering at each other in those first couple of scenes, I didn't
- 1:00:53see it coming a mile off. And then sort of halfway through
- 1:00:56the book when they started working together, I was like,
- 1:00:58well, of course they're made for each other, right?
- 1:01:00Yeah, yeah, everything they've, the reason they're both in so
- 1:01:04much debt is that from the from the word go, their story is that
- 1:01:08they're both vying for the same promotions.
- 1:01:11So they are absolutely at loggerheads and and getting
- 1:01:13themselves into more and more trouble to just seem better
- 1:01:18prepared and and better at their job than each other.
- 1:01:21So they're both, you know, awful people because I've never, you
- 1:01:26know, people, people. That take them up.
- 1:01:29Yeah, people that take their jobs that seriously, I've never
- 1:01:32really understood. And you know, that's that, you
- 1:01:35know. I thought there was an extra
- 1:01:37layer of education in this as well because the banks described
- 1:01:40towards the end as they don't care if you're borrowing time
- 1:01:44that you have to give back and that you will end up dead as a
- 1:01:47result. All they care about is the sheet
- 1:01:50at the end of the month. And I was like, yeah, say that
- 1:01:53to the kids. Don't end up in one of these
- 1:01:55dead end corporations that does not care.
- 1:01:58You know what the what they put you through and how how they
- 1:02:01basically kill you off. Yeah, HSBC would not give a shit
- 1:02:05if I were unable to make my repayments one month.
- 1:02:08They would not ask questions, they would not try to help.
- 1:02:11They would eat me up like a big metal machine.
- 1:02:14If they said to you though, OK, look, OK, clearly you can't pay
- 1:02:18this back. Like can we have a year of your
- 1:02:20life? Would you say yes?
- 1:02:26I might have done 30 years ago. Oh yeah, that's a good point.
- 1:02:31Yeah, I'm, I'm staring at the end of the tunnel now.
- 1:02:34Well, it's it's not so much that, but no one knows how long
- 1:02:37their personal tunnel is. Unless you'd like Adrian Mole,
- 1:02:41you've measured your personal tunnel.
- 1:02:45But yeah, I mean, it's one of those, it's one of those things
- 1:02:48you wouldn't necessarily do it in real, real life, but it is
- 1:02:52the sort of thing you do in a kind of fantasy world, I think.
- 1:02:59Voila. I mean, I think, look, we've had
- 1:03:01a good go at the concepts, the characterization, the guest
- 1:03:04characters that pays the pros. Have you got anything else on
- 1:03:08your nose that you would like to cover before we move on to the
- 1:03:11last segment of the episode? I there, there are two things I
- 1:03:14wanted to talk about. I wanted to talk about
- 1:03:16specifically chapter 1, because it's all about Andrew Brown and
- 1:03:20it's how you're introduced to the premise and he works at
- 1:03:23Lexington Bank. And Full disclosure, I listened
- 1:03:27to chapter 1 while I was on my way to work on Monday.
- 1:03:30So it was about 6:30. It's still dark outside.
- 1:03:35I'm at the bus stop at the end of the road, going to work in an
- 1:03:41office. And you've got this chapter
- 1:03:44that's telling you about Andrew Brown, who's getting up early
- 1:03:48and everything's going wrong. And he treads on his breakfast
- 1:03:51and he irons the carpet and the, you know, dog's sick on his
- 1:03:54shirt or something just so he can get into the office just
- 1:03:58because he's got a 9:00 AM presentation.
- 1:04:01And that goes wrong. And all the way through that
- 1:04:04chapter, everything is so leak and empty.
- 1:04:09And that's what adult life is like.
- 1:04:12And again, this would be a good book for for kids to read.
- 1:04:15It would also make a lot of them decide not to bother with
- 1:04:18growing up. But.
- 1:04:19What infant suicide through the roof while by a Time by Naomi
- 1:04:23Alderman's just been rewritten. So, so yeah, OK, there's there's
- 1:04:27good points and bad with the book, but what a brilliantly
- 1:04:31constructed and not, not sensationalist nothing out of
- 1:04:35the ordinary happened. Those are, you know, he the, the
- 1:04:39the train goes 3 minutes early before he can get on it.
- 1:04:42That's happened to all of us. We've all slept through the
- 1:04:45alarm. We've all had a unfortunate
- 1:04:47stain on our suit. You know, it's just this kind of
- 1:04:50succession that. Was a plot point though, wasn't
- 1:04:53it? Because that's when they
- 1:04:55realized that there were two versions of him because one had
- 1:04:58the stain and one didn't. Yeah, but it was.
- 1:05:01But I, I just thought Chapter 1 was such a skilful and brilliant
- 1:05:05and subtle evocation of the kind of awfulness of, of the life.
- 1:05:11You know, I've never worked in a bank.
- 1:05:13I don't assume it is actually that awful.
- 1:05:15If you're the sort of person who likes numbers, then you're
- 1:05:17probably quite happy working in a bank.
- 1:05:19I. Don't work in a bank.
- 1:05:20Get in touch with us. Let us.
- 1:05:21Know. Yeah.
- 1:05:21Let us know. Let us know.
- 1:05:22Are you living a soulless existence?
- 1:05:25Yeah. Are you able to?
- 1:05:26Time are you? Able to move a decimal point in
- 1:05:29my account so I've got some money that that would be good.
- 1:05:32Can you do them three points in my direction please?
- 1:05:35But the other thing that I, I did bump on in Chapter 1 is that
- 1:05:40Andrew Brown is permanently in competition with Samira Jenkins.
- 1:05:47And I bumped on that because obviously she's coded as a, an
- 1:05:51Indian lady because she's called Samira.
- 1:05:54And until I got to the point in the book where I realised that
- 1:05:58she was also borrowing time, I just thought this was about that
- 1:06:02kind of kind of truism about brown kids, that they are just
- 1:06:07pushed to be exceptional. And this is, and this is
- 1:06:11something I talked about with my wife, who is of Indian descent.
- 1:06:15And culturally, yes, those kids are pushed to work really hard
- 1:06:19throughout their childhood. They don't get to, they don't
- 1:06:22get to get AC for an essay. They get, you know, sent to
- 1:06:26their room without dinner if they don't get an A.
- 1:06:29That's why there are so many of them who become doctors when,
- 1:06:33you know, I, I fiddle about with a few spreadsheets for a couple
- 1:06:37of hours, you know, and I was, I was sort of momentarily
- 1:06:42wondering if we were going to get more detail about her or if
- 1:06:46she was just being kind of painted as well.
- 1:06:49She's Indian, so of course she's really good at her job.
- 1:06:53But no, we did get that fleshed out.
- 1:06:54So I was quite, I was very happy about that.
- 1:06:58Sort of the push away from that cliche is when she looks around
- 1:07:02and she goes, why the hell did I not notice that this bank is
- 1:07:06full of copies of people doing various things at the same time?
- 1:07:10Everyone in that bank's doing it.
- 1:07:11They're all boring time because they're all being pushed beyond
- 1:07:15the limits of human capacity. Now I've never been in a bank
- 1:07:19that's felt that kind of animated normally that everyone
- 1:07:22looks like they're half asleep. And you get some bloke comes out
- 1:07:25of his office in a suit and he yawns and he shuffles over to
- 1:07:29you and he's like, can I help? Or you want.
- 1:07:30A pen. Can I go back to sleep?
- 1:07:32Yeah. I've got a Metro Bank.
- 1:07:34They. Offer out lollipops.
- 1:07:35Metro Bank. Do they?
- 1:07:37Yeah, I love going in there. Oh we had a Metro Bank in
- 1:07:40Colchester before I before I left the UK.
- 1:07:43And a pen. I was sold.
- 1:07:46I opened the account that day. That's, yeah, that's, that's,
- 1:07:48that's better than what I got when I, when I joined the
- 1:07:51Midland Bank when I was at university.
- 1:07:53What did you think then of the comedy sequence, though, where
- 1:07:57the Doctor and Amy are sitting in on the presentation and the
- 1:08:02guys from America are making absurd demands that nobody could
- 1:08:06ever? Oh, I would have thought you
- 1:08:08would have had a report for this.
- 1:08:09And Andrew goes, oh, hang on a minute, walks out of the room
- 1:08:12and then walks back with that report that he's just spent the
- 1:08:14last, I know, half a day doing. And it goes.
- 1:08:17It gets sort of crazier and more faster as it.
- 1:08:21Goes yeah, but. You can see it on the screen,
- 1:08:23right? Absolutely.
- 1:08:24That again is is that's Moffat, that's coupling.
- 1:08:28That's exactly where that's coming from.
- 1:08:29That's the kind of energy that Alderman's pulling from.
- 1:08:33And it would have been so good on TV.
- 1:08:37And it still could be. I've only really got one thing I
- 1:08:41want to quote, which I think was sort of the moral of the story.
- 1:08:45But it it, it didn't come across as like, you know, looking at
- 1:08:48the screen and going, right, kids pay attention.
- 1:08:50It was just a lovely line where the doctor says that's the
- 1:08:54trouble with borrowing. It makes everything look good.
- 1:08:57No one wants to see what's going on underneath because the
- 1:09:00surface is just so shiny. There's no point making
- 1:09:03everything shiny if your whole species is going to die out the
- 1:09:06moment they call in those deaths.
- 1:09:09And I was like, yeah, that's true.
- 1:09:11Yeah, that is, that is very true.
- 1:09:13You know the only as a you know, in my in my 20's the only way to
- 1:09:18stop worrying about the amount of debt I had was to go and buy
- 1:09:21another DVD or another another 5 pints of beer or whatever.
- 1:09:28I would totally rationalize it, right?
- 1:09:30And then at the end of the month, the bank statement would
- 1:09:32come in and I'll be like, how did I rationalize any of these
- 1:09:35decisions? What was like?
- 1:09:37Do you know what I mean? Seriously, I was in By the time
- 1:09:40my marriage fell, I put I was at about 25 grands worth of debt,
- 1:09:44which was a lot for me because I'm.
- 1:09:45Absolutely a. Lawyer Unfortunately we had a
- 1:09:49flat to sell that managed to pay off that debt, otherwise I would
- 1:09:53have gone into single life a very unhappy man.
- 1:09:55Well, absolutely, this is, you know, the, the kind of unspoken
- 1:10:00point, I guess of, of the book is that, you know, a lot of
- 1:10:05people are in a very deep hole with, with credit cards.
- 1:10:11And it is because, well, I think a large part of it is that we're
- 1:10:16never really sat down and educated about this.
- 1:10:19It should be in the school curriculum.
- 1:10:20You know when you're doing your GCS ES, there should be a
- 1:10:24three-week module on how credit cards work and how mobile phone
- 1:10:28bills will destroy you. Just give them this book.
- 1:10:30Yeah, just do that. Just do that it it does so.
- 1:10:33We're going to make you even more famous.
- 1:10:35We're going to put you on the the prospectus you know you
- 1:10:37have. To read this book, Yeah,
- 1:10:39There'll be a GCSE in Aldermania.
- 1:10:42Aldermania. Oh.
- 1:10:44I love it. I mean, I said to you in a
- 1:10:46message and I read it back afterwards and thought, wow,
- 1:10:49Joe, you really are capable of hyperbole.
- 1:10:51When I said that this was potentially my favorite ever
- 1:10:5611th Doctor story because in terms of a story with packed
- 1:11:01full of brilliant ideas, great comedy, scary moments, great
- 1:11:07twists, great dialogue and just that furious pace, I was like, I
- 1:11:12was trying to pick up an 11th Doctor episode.
- 1:11:14And there are some I really like.
- 1:11:16Don't get me wrong, Doctor's Wife I absolutely adore with the
- 1:11:19GOB Complex, finish it and the Doctor, you know, there are some
- 1:11:21I absolutely love. This is up there though, in
- 1:11:25terms of the pure enjoyment I got.
- 1:11:26And forgive me, I'm going to say this don't hit me.
- 1:11:30It may have had something to do with the fact that the book was
- 1:11:33divorced from the excesses of Stephen Murphy's dialogue and
- 1:11:39the performances of Matt Smith and Karen Gillard.
- 1:11:41That may have because I was sort of, you know, conjuring this in
- 1:11:44my head. But just purely in terms of what
- 1:11:47it's doing with those characters, Yeah.
- 1:11:49Just just absolutely brilliant. Well, for me, it's exactly the
- 1:11:55same response, but from exactly the opposite direction.
- 1:11:57So I'm comparing it to a lot of episodes from the first two
- 1:12:04years of Matt Smith and his era, which for me was as good as
- 1:12:08Doctor, whoever got. And I was visualizing their
- 1:12:12performances as I was hearing the audio book, and it matched
- 1:12:16perfectly. So for me, this is one of the
- 1:12:20better 11th Doctor stories because it feels very much like
- 1:12:24all the other best 11th Doctor stories.
- 1:12:28And I think it's deliberate and I think it's an amazing work of,
- 1:12:32of art to to capture that. The fact that it pleased both of
- 1:12:37us and we come to this era from completely different directions,
- 1:12:42I mean, that's quite telling, isn't it?
- 1:12:44It really is. It's a great book.
- 1:12:46Yeah, go and get this one Go. I've been trying to convince
- 1:12:49people and they keep giving me a look like they've sort of
- 1:12:52swallowed a sour gummy going NSA.
- 1:12:55But actually, that's the last question I'm going to ask you
- 1:12:57before we go into the last little bit.
- 1:12:59It is, I read a review online and I sent it to you, and I
- 1:13:03really took exception with the last line of that review, which
- 1:13:06was something along the lines of they don't deserve something
- 1:13:10this good. And whether that was talking
- 1:13:13about the Nsas or whether that was talking about books for
- 1:13:17kids, I don't know. But I think that's a really
- 1:13:21shitty statement to make. It is, and I don't know either.
- 1:13:29There is a a kind of assumption that the Nsas are just for kids.
- 1:13:34There is also an assumption that the Nsas are therefore a bit
- 1:13:38shit. If you're not a kid, if you're a
- 1:13:42kid and you get a book, then you deserve that book to be as
- 1:13:46amazing and transporting and evocative and inspiring as it
- 1:13:51possibly can be. Because kids need to read and.
- 1:13:56Possibly more so, right? More.
- 1:13:58Can be amazing. More than adults, these books
- 1:14:01need to be really good. Keep kids reading.
- 1:14:05Exactly. There's a, you know, I'm not
- 1:14:08going to sit here and say that there's a problem with child
- 1:14:10literacy because everybody knows that people read less.
- 1:14:13And part of it is because we're just evolving away from the
- 1:14:17written word as a, as a, as, as a medium of narrative fiction,
- 1:14:24because everything's about TV now, prestige TV.
- 1:14:28But imagine if you as a kid had had a Doctor Who book this good.
- 1:14:32Now you know, Destiny of the Daleks is a fine novelization,
- 1:14:36but it's not this. But does the awakening still
- 1:14:40thrill you as much as it did when you were younger?
- 1:14:42Well, I mean, can you still feel the frisson?
- 1:14:45I can, I can, but that's because the waking happens to be
- 1:14:47probably my favorite Davison. So, you know, that's a
- 1:14:51coincidence. But yeah, this that review.
- 1:14:55I I interpret it as saying that the Nsas didn't deserve a book
- 1:15:00this good. Which is which is no all NSA
- 1:15:05should aspire to be this good. It's not like saying it's a it's
- 1:15:09a range of shit books and that's the way we like it.
- 1:15:11And how dare they put a good one in amongst the pile.
- 1:15:16It should be criticizing all the other Nsas that aren't this one.
- 1:15:20So why aren't they this good? Obviously on We're All Stories
- 1:15:23in the end, you cover the New Adventures and the Avve Dr.
- 1:15:26books, and you sort of said that you might be branching out into
- 1:15:28other areas. If you ever cover a new, just
- 1:15:31you wait, wait for the reaction you'll get from people if you
- 1:15:35suggest let's do one of these. Oh, you're just grabbing
- 1:15:39something off the shelf now. Oh, the Jodie ones.
- 1:15:45The good doctors are great read. Oh, we've got also Sophie
- 1:15:48Aldridge 10. Dear, I thought you had a
- 1:15:51psychotic look about you. Engines of war.
- 1:15:53Yes, Fabulous. Any anymore there?
- 1:15:57Yeah, but I can't reach them. But yeah, we've I've got quite a
- 1:16:03lot and I'm really looking forward to.
- 1:16:07Sorry. I should I should turn around
- 1:16:09and talk into the microphone. I think I'd be surprised.
- 1:16:12When I'd want to be there are. Average books there, I won't say
- 1:16:15there aren't, but there are average new adventures and there
- 1:16:19are below average adventures as well, you know?
- 1:16:23There are and I've I've just started re repurchasing all the
- 1:16:27Discworld novels because over here in America they're being
- 1:16:30reissued. And I was about to say that
- 1:16:33there's probably an average Pratchett novel, but I don't I
- 1:16:36don't think that's probably true.
- 1:16:37In fact, maybe Jingo. But yeah, every every author
- 1:16:42has, you know, off days in the office and not every book in any
- 1:16:47series is brilliant. Some of the Bonds novels weren't
- 1:16:50very good. All of the bombs weren't very
- 1:16:53good. But you know, every, every
- 1:16:57series is capable of having kind of unexpected treasures in it.
- 1:17:01And this you know, if the Nsas can contain something this good,
- 1:17:06then what possible reason is there not to read all of them?
- 1:17:09And this is a range that did it managed to bring in Johnny
- 1:17:13Morris, a great writer, Lance Parkin, Paul Mars, you know,
- 1:17:18brilliant, brilliant writers writing for kids.
- 1:17:21All credits are. I mean, I said to you in the
- 1:17:23message, didn't I? This shit's all over a bulk of
- 1:17:26the new Adventures and EDA's that I've read simply because
- 1:17:30it's just so enjoyable. It's quite happy being like a
- 1:17:35Doctor Who story. It's not trying to be big or
- 1:17:37clever or dramatic or angsty or or adult.
- 1:17:41It's just having fun. And at the same time it's doing
- 1:17:45what TV, or certainly the BBC used to aspire to do, which was
- 1:17:49educate and inform as well as entertain.
- 1:17:53So it's, yeah, it's, it's just one of the best Doctor Who books
- 1:17:58I've ever read are. You listening to this, Naomi?
- 1:18:02All right, OK, we want to we want to mention next time you're
- 1:18:05up against there with Barack Obama.
- 1:18:07All right. Yeah, when, when when I meet you
- 1:18:10at the launch of the Power 2 Electric Boogaloo.
- 1:18:14I want I want to share your crew details.
- 1:18:17Well, OK, Ian, let's slip on into the last section.
- 1:18:22And it's probably the smallest section, but I am really
- 1:18:24intrigued to hear what your answer to this is.
- 1:18:27For some reason people love her ranking right?
- 1:18:29People love to rank. Yeah.
- 1:18:32What has been your favorite? And I'm not saying your favorite
- 1:18:35episode to record, but what's been your favorite books to
- 1:18:39discover on where your story is in the end?
- 1:18:42Your top 3IN whatever order you like.
- 1:18:46Well, I very much enjoyed talking about Warhead with
- 1:18:55Andrew Cartmel a because it's not every day you get to
- 1:19:00interview someone who was responsible for for your era of
- 1:19:04Doctor Who. But but to get his perspective
- 1:19:08on it after all this time. And to finally get to the kind
- 1:19:12of peel the onion of how the Cats Cradle trilogy of new
- 1:19:16adventures came to be and how they were completely unconnected
- 1:19:19books written by authors who weren't in touch with each
- 1:19:22other, and how it was kind of crowbar into being a.
- 1:19:24Really, I could never have told. I mean, I mean, we could all
- 1:19:27tell at the time there was like, really, this is this is supposed
- 1:19:30to be a trilogy. I I could do better than this
- 1:19:33and I'm an idiot. What?
- 1:19:34Did it say when it came out it said cats cradle.
- 1:19:36What the fuck? That, well, I think he knew it
- 1:19:39was going to happen because he'd had to sort of go back and
- 1:19:41rewrite one paragraph to include a silver cat.
- 1:19:44But yeah, he was, he was not, not angry about it.
- 1:19:48Still, it was 30 years ago. But he was, you know, he was
- 1:19:51being paid. I never, I never wrote a book
- 1:19:53called Cat's Cradle Warhead. I wrote a book called Warhead.
- 1:19:57Thank you very much. So that was a really good book.
- 1:20:01Also, I have heard you say you know that, which is why I'm
- 1:20:06desperate to get you back on this to cover one of these
- 1:20:08Andrew Carmel books, because I think you and me will have
- 1:20:12different reactions, but that you said that is your peak.
- 1:20:15I think that's not trilogy specifically Warlock, but yeah,
- 1:20:20I, I, I that is a hill I will die on.
- 1:20:24So if you want to fight me on a hill, you may.
- 1:20:27Die on that hill. But well, bring it we.
- 1:20:29Get very dirty. Bring it, you tubby bitch.
- 1:20:36So wrestling, yeah. I another one would be End Game
- 1:20:42by Terence Dicks which. That was Dylan when it.
- 1:20:46That was now I thought at the time I read that book, firstly
- 1:20:50that it was it was kind of serviceable but underwhelming.
- 1:20:55Fast forward 20 years and talking about it with Dylan and
- 1:20:58obviously talking about anything with Dylan is one of life's joys
- 1:21:01because Dylan's great and. We try and be the best host of
- 1:21:06Doctor Who podcast, but we know we're already beat.
- 1:21:09He's yeah, damn him to hell, but he just finds these layers of of
- 1:21:15kind of unintentional comedy and ineptness.
- 1:21:19And he because he knows the the back story.
- 1:21:22I didn't know that this was like a sort of barely complete first
- 1:21:26draft that Terence Dix handed in and then effed off on holiday,
- 1:21:30leaving Justin Richards to kind of write an extra 40,000 words
- 1:21:33and turn it into a very short book.
- 1:21:36It was revenge for when Robert Holmes did that with the Thai
- 1:21:38warriors Terence Dix. Yeah, sure it was.
- 1:21:41But it's fascinating to find out things like that.
- 1:21:44And, and, and so this is a good example of where you find out
- 1:21:49why a book has turned out the way it has.
- 1:21:52Like if if we knew what the story was behind Belle Tempest,
- 1:21:56I think that would be that would be something a lot of people
- 1:22:00would like to know that in. Fact.
- 1:22:03Joyner Death cult. I don't know that he did, but
- 1:22:07you know, but it's so so. The Belle Tempest episode is the
- 1:22:12most popular episode of World Stories.
- 1:22:15In the end, it's had about twice as many downloads as any other
- 1:22:19episode, and I have no idea why. Maybe it's because my guest on
- 1:22:24that one's very popular, But yeah.
- 1:22:27And my third choice would be the Trevor Baxendale novel Cold
- 1:22:32Heart. That episode was hilarious, now
- 1:22:36hearing the two of you try and scramble around to find
- 1:22:38something positive to say about. That well, well, no.
- 1:22:41So, so I really enjoyed the book and what made it a really good
- 1:22:49episode was that Harry, obviously it it didn't work for
- 1:22:54him. So we had we had very different
- 1:22:58perspectives about the book and that led to a really good
- 1:23:02conversation, really good episode, I thought, because I
- 1:23:07could listen to Harry talk all day.
- 1:23:08Laughed. At it, didn't they?
- 1:23:10I was. He was not in the well-being
- 1:23:12room at work, howling with laughter.
- 1:23:14Someone ducked their head in the door and said, you're right.
- 1:23:16I went, Oh yeah, Doctor Who. Books, you know?
- 1:23:19Yeah, but, but, you know, as a, as a Doctor Who fan, I would
- 1:23:25have assumed that everyone would respond to that book the same
- 1:23:28way that I did, which is this feels like a six part John
- 1:23:32Pertwee story. We we know this, it's very
- 1:23:36familiar. There's a baddie, there's this
- 1:23:38sort of duplicitous son or whatever.
- 1:23:41There's a crap civilisation of poorly realised aliens.
- 1:23:45They're a ridiculous underground.
- 1:23:46I thought everyone would love this, so it was fascinating.
- 1:23:50Orifice on the cover. As well there there was a huge
- 1:23:52gaping orifice on the cover. More He.
- 1:23:56Likes a a big hole. Trevor Baxon Dale, isn't he?
- 1:24:00I think that's libelous, Joe. No, there's a hole on the front
- 1:24:03of Eaters of Wasps as well. That's a mouth.
- 1:24:06Oh. You're still a big.
- 1:24:07If you're going to, if you're going to say he holds a goal,
- 1:24:09I'm, I'm going, I'm not, I'm not being party to filth like that.
- 1:24:14He likes, yeah, he likes an unexpected aperture.
- 1:24:18If you shut your eyes it could be any sex, OK?
- 1:24:22Yes, it could. It could be any, any any lady
- 1:24:25with a prickly beard. Those are three great episodes
- 1:24:28as well. I've been, I mean, I chose 3 as
- 1:24:31well. I loved doing the Remembrance of
- 1:24:35the Daleks because another book that made me realize, man, oh
- 1:24:40man, sometimes when we're catering for kids, you get the
- 1:24:43best Doctor Who fiction you've ever had.
- 1:24:46And that sort of, that's the first new adventure, which is
- 1:24:49what it feels like. Absolutely.
- 1:24:51It's probably the best new adventure of all.
- 1:24:53Which kind of leaves the range in the dust after that well.
- 1:24:57Fortunately, you know, yes, it's got the Daleks in it.
- 1:24:59So of course it's going to be the best.
- 1:25:01But I, I and I was listening to your episode on Remembrance and
- 1:25:04I and I can't remember what it what I wanted to point out a
- 1:25:08couple of things that they got wrong.
- 1:25:11I think it came out in, I think it was April 1990.
- 1:25:16Oh yeah. And there seemed there seemed to
- 1:25:18be a lot of people who weren't sure when it came out.
- 1:25:20I'm supposed to edit that bit out.
- 1:25:21Everyone's just going through books going, oh, I'm not sure
- 1:25:24when. It happened.
- 1:25:25So I remember going into Ace Comics like every single Friday,
- 1:25:29because that was the day that they put that month's new Target
- 1:25:32on the shelf after school for a month.
- 1:25:35Because it was, it was delayed. Imagine that.
- 1:25:37A delayed book by Ben Ronovich. Good Lord.
- 1:25:42I remember all right. I remember exactly when it came
- 1:25:46out and yeah, it, you know, there were maybe what, 3 or 4
- 1:25:51books left after that and it absolutely blew me away.
- 1:25:56So it was great to hear your episode.
- 1:25:59Yeah, I I couldn't. Sing in its praises.
- 1:26:01Of course there are better new adventures, but not many, you
- 1:26:05know, I think that did start things high.
- 1:26:08My second one is what I've not long recorded, actually, which
- 1:26:10was Doctor Who in Wonderland by Paul Mars, because I fucking
- 1:26:14hate Alice in Wonderland with a passion.
- 1:26:16My other half's obsessed with it and I have to watch all these
- 1:26:19different versions. Have you seen the Alan Moore
- 1:26:21version of? Perfect.
- 1:26:24Novel Alice getting cunnilingus. I mean, it's absolutely
- 1:26:29terrifying. I know, right?
- 1:26:30I mean, now I will. It's called Lost Girls or
- 1:26:33something like that. Yeah, it's a big, big old tone
- 1:26:36full of pony images and pictures.
- 1:26:39Down lost girls. He's on Amazon as we speak.
- 1:26:45You, you keep talking. Don't mind what I'm doing.
- 1:26:47Did you say your your missus was away?
- 1:26:49Don't worry, they do 24 hour delivery all right.
- 1:26:53Anyway, I, so I went in with low expectations, but high
- 1:26:56expectations because I love poor Miles so.
- 1:26:59And finally I'm in on the party because he manages to fuse the
- 1:27:02two together so beautifully, so whistly.
- 1:27:08It was just an absolute joy. And everyone else there was a
- 1:27:10huge Paul Miles fan and a huge Alice in Wonderland fan.
- 1:27:13So it was just a big love in with me just shitting on Alice
- 1:27:15in Wonderland a bit. But you know, like you do.
- 1:27:17And then my number one is still The Eight Doctors, because I
- 1:27:22went into that expecting to really hate that book.
- 1:27:26I just found it an absolute tree.
- 1:27:29Like it was all the best and all the worst of Terence Dicks all
- 1:27:32in one book. All the indulgence, all the
- 1:27:36ambition, you know, all the humor.
- 1:27:38The pit where the trash in Ate the man.
- 1:27:40Maybe Howl for about 3 weeks. Yeah, and just put it apart.
- 1:27:45That absurd tone, how it is to be is baffling, right?
- 1:27:51It is. And again, speaking, speaking
- 1:27:54not just as a man, but as a, a publisher Now, anyone signed off
- 1:27:59on that as a commercial enterprise?
- 1:28:02It's like we've done a, we've done ATV movie.
- 1:28:05We're probably not going to go to series, but there is a, you
- 1:28:09know, we got 9 million viewers. There's a lot of interest.
- 1:28:12Let's start publishing some books that will sell to these
- 1:28:15new viewers who may not be interested delicately familiar
- 1:28:19with State of Decay and The Trial of the Time Lord.
- 1:28:24And how they ever signed off on on that book being put, I will
- 1:28:28never know. And I I won't get to cover that
- 1:28:31on my show for a number of years, and I may well be dead
- 1:28:35before those before that time. You'll have the best time, I
- 1:28:38promise you. No, I, I just, I don't know if I
- 1:28:42can. I think that might be the
- 1:28:43episode that breaks me. What you've got to do is it's
- 1:28:47literally, they should have asked Terence, like Terence, who
- 1:28:50is this book for once he'd finished it and handed it in and
- 1:28:52he just would have gone everyone.
- 1:28:54Because it's literally, it's the people that have never heard of
- 1:28:57Doctor Who. It's the people that know Doctor
- 1:28:59Who intimately. It's the people that like huge
- 1:29:03sprawling narratives. It's the people that like short
- 1:29:05stories because they're all kind of short stories.
- 1:29:08I mean, it is just eclectic, let's say that.
- 1:29:12So the way I look at it is, is I like what you've said, I like
- 1:29:17what you've done there, but I would add to it.
- 1:29:18So it's for simultaneously. It's a book for everyone and no
- 1:29:23one. It should be for no one.
- 1:29:26Yes, I'm saying about suicide rates going up.
- 1:29:30What? I don't know what the numbers
- 1:29:31were like in. They were quite heavy in May 97
- 1:29:35through the roof, a lot of sort of 20 something sad virgins were
- 1:29:39ending their lives. Oh my God, Ian, why do I always
- 1:29:43have the best time when I'll talk with you on a Zoom call?
- 1:29:46Jesus. Christ, I, I have no idea.
- 1:29:48I think, I imagine it's because you can see my cat and it's very
- 1:29:51therapeutic. I mean, it's like a, it's like
- 1:29:53the cat's cradle cat. It's a sort of silver cat in.
- 1:29:55The back, yeah, he's, he's, he's, he's Grey.
- 1:29:58When we when we rescued him, he was called Grey Wolf, but we
- 1:30:03changed his name to Harvey Cohen because he looked more like a
- 1:30:06lawyer. And he looked.
- 1:30:08His tail is just sort of gently caressing what looks like a load
- 1:30:12of past doctor adventures. I think he's his tail is on.
- 1:30:17What's he choosing out for? Yeah, it's a white one.
- 1:30:19He's he's picking out, he's pointing at Father Time, which
- 1:30:22is which at the time of recording is my most recent
- 1:30:25episode, Boys and girls. A cat of huge distinction.
- 1:30:30He's on brand. He's he's on brand.
- 1:30:34Although I'm scared now that Cat's here we might be.
- 1:30:36This episode may be the 4th instalment of the Cat's Cradle
- 1:30:39trilogy. What would we be called?
- 1:30:43Well, I would be. So I'd have one of those very
- 1:30:47long Gallifrean names like Violvarionsti, Cherarelle and
- 1:30:52Suits. You.
- 1:30:53You'd be like Joe the fucker and you'd get one line of dialogue
- 1:30:58which would be a foul mouthed rant about something and then
- 1:31:02you'd be eaten by a horse or a Centaur.
- 1:31:05Joe the fucker. I feel like that's a good, good
- 1:31:08way to end this episode. Ian, can I ask you please to
- 1:31:11tell people? Because I have a feeling they're
- 1:31:13going to want to after listening to this madness where people can
- 1:31:18find you elsewhere, not here. Not here.
- 1:31:21So I exist. You do.
- 1:31:24Much much like the man dragger. I've been spending the last two
- 1:31:29hours talking to myself otherwise.
- 1:31:32I am on numerous podcasts. We started out doing all of time
- 1:31:38and Space which you can listen to, which is me and my very dear
- 1:31:42friend Mark Cockrum working our way through all of Doctor Who
- 1:31:47televisually. Can I?
- 1:31:49Say something about all time and space.
- 1:31:50Yeah, please do. Please do.
- 1:31:52I think there are sort of tears of Doctor Who podcasts.
- 1:31:55Not to sort of denigrate anybody, but I would say in
- 1:31:58terms of the production and the quality of guests and the
- 1:32:02critique, there's two I'll put on the top tier and that is
- 1:32:07flight for entirety and all the time and space because you can
- 1:32:11see how much love goes into those two.
- 1:32:14Well, I mean, I'm, I'm flattered on Mark's behalf.
- 1:32:17He he produces that. So all of that quality is down
- 1:32:20to him. And to be to be mentioned in the
- 1:32:23same breath as flight for entirety is just I the stuff of
- 1:32:27a giddy fool's dream. So I thank you humbly.
- 1:32:31I'm also so. So that's my upmarket show.
- 1:32:34I also do rural Stories in the end, which as we've mentioned is
- 1:32:38me talking with a bunch of people about the New Adventures,
- 1:32:42the 8 Doctor books and who knows where we're going to go next
- 1:32:46year. Then I do a comedy podcast
- 1:32:50called The Electric Sod Cast and like a great many people, I am a
- 1:32:54stranger in space. So you can listen to me very
- 1:32:57infrequently these days because I'm spread ever so thin.
- 1:33:00And I'm toasting to strangers in space, you know?
- 1:33:03Well, I wouldn't play with anyone else.
- 1:33:05I said. I'll do it on my own or nothing.
- 1:33:08He went all right. Well, you've kind of
- 1:33:11revolutionized things. And I think J Rs desperately
- 1:33:15glad that someone's got a bit of drive and a bit of initiative
- 1:33:18because the rest of us are like cats and he has to spend all of
- 1:33:21his time corralling us to read this.
- 1:33:24Watch that. Now I'm on those group chats,
- 1:33:27I'll say just how much work he actually does.
- 1:33:29It's amazing on those goals. It's amazing, you know, but then
- 1:33:33again, it's because he puts out three episodes a week and that's
- 1:33:35a lot of content. And, and obviously we, we talk
- 1:33:39about films and books and and TV shows and we've, we've kind of
- 1:33:44run out of Doctor Who stuff donkeys years ago, but it's a
- 1:33:48really good pop culture show. Dip in and out of it.
- 1:33:50There's going to be an episode that will appeal to you.
- 1:33:53There's going to be 5 on the trot that maybe don't, but it's,
- 1:33:55you know, it's, it's like a like a.
- 1:33:58Person to your subject. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:34:00So yeah, I'm I'm. I want to say one thing about
- 1:34:03your book podcast now as well. Sorry, I'm so sorry about this,
- 1:34:06but I'm doing a bit of marketing for you here, OK, Because I
- 1:34:09mean, I will say that too hot for TV where that drops in my
- 1:34:12podcast catcher. It does make me sort of cream my
- 1:34:15knickers more than where were stories in the end, but that's
- 1:34:18only because it's more frequent. Otherwise you'd be on a par for
- 1:34:21excitement in my pants. But thinking what I'm trying to
- 1:34:26say badly is that the the MVP Doctor Who Book podcast is we're
- 1:34:33all stories in the end. And do you know why that is?
- 1:34:36Not clear. Because you're on it and you are
- 1:34:40so fucking funny. I see they're howling.
- 1:34:44You know, there's almost like a, yeah, I've committed to this
- 1:34:48task of reading all these fucking books.
- 1:34:51And now I'm, I'm wading my way through the dirt, you know, And
- 1:34:56every now and again there's a glimmer of light.
- 1:34:59You know, yeah. And this and this started off as
- 1:35:01a labour of love but after about 3 episodes I was like fucking
- 1:35:05hell was hundreds of these. What can I ask a favour?
- 1:35:10Yes, please. Please don't stop because it's
- 1:35:12just delightful. I love it.
- 1:35:15You're very kind, you're very generous, and just for you, I
- 1:35:18will keep soldiering on. Yeah, just.
- 1:35:21Just for you. I've seen the, I've seen the,
- 1:35:23I've seen the figures. It literally is just for you.
- 1:35:27Before we go, Ian, I've just, I've just acquired this watch
- 1:35:31that I would like to hand to you now, OK?
- 1:35:33Should you wish to get the last two hours of your life back,
- 1:35:36then just turn the don't read the terms and conditions, turn
- 1:35:39the dial. All right, Just see where you go
- 1:35:42from there. Is is there any interest or?
- 1:35:46Yeah, yeah, yeah. 5 minutes per hour.
- 1:35:49Oh, sorry, I'm sorry. I've got a cough.
- 1:35:51No, I'm quite happy to take that at face value and not think
- 1:35:54about the fact that you said that bit twice.
- 1:35:55That's fine, that's fine. Give me the watch.
- 1:35:57I'm off. I'm going to go and have a wee
- 1:35:59two hours ago. So I'm going to cut it right
- 1:36:02there.