Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Ruby Franke & Jodi Hildebrandt (Chapter 2)
Transcript
- 0:00Heyter serve listeners, Let's continue following the Ruby Frankie Jody Hildebrand story of abuses
- 0:06and torture on children. Trigger warning of course for all of these episodes.
- 0:10So let's get to it. My name is doctor Kirk Conda. I'm a
- 0:13therapist and a professor. In case you don't know me, I will say
- 0:18to you that as a therapist and a professor for over twenty five years,
- 0:21at the beginning of my career, I did have a fair amount of experience
- 0:24being hired by child protective services to go into homes and to help to end
- 0:31abuse in homes. And I want to remind everyone that I'm watching these clips
- 0:35on the National Desk YouTube channel, the National Desk. Let's I want to
- 0:40go down to Brian Schneed joining us live after speaking exclusively with the niece of
- 0:43Jody Hildebrand and Brian, what did she say about watching all of this unful?
- 0:47Okay, So this is the YouTube channel, the National Desk, and
- 0:51they are about to throw to a journalist who interview who interviewed the niece of
- 0:57Jody Hildebrand. Jesse Hildebrand lived with Jody and received therapy with air quotes as
- 1:03she described it to me today. Jesse described abuse while living with Jody back
- 1:07in two thousand nine or so. She went into detail, telling me she
- 1:11was tied up, duct taped. Okay, again, seriously, trigger warning.
- 1:15If you have been abused in this way or this triggers you, do
- 1:19not watch this video, don't follow the story unless you're talking with your therapist.
- 1:23It can actually harm you. Can we traumatize you. And if you
- 1:26don't know the answer that question, you should get treatment so you know the
- 1:30answer that question. But moving forward, we have her name is Jesse,
- 1:36the niece of Jody, and interesting that she's saying that the abuses were happening
- 1:42back in two thousand and nine when Jesse the niece was under the care of
- 1:48Jody or something well, living with Jody back in two thousand nine or so,
- 1:51she went into detail, telling me she was tied up, duct taped,
- 1:55blindfolded, experienced severe isolation, severe emotional When we see so many news
- 2:01stories with this kind of reporting, and if you see a lot of it,
- 2:07you become desensitized to it. But maybe a lot of you aren't.
- 2:09But just if you are desensitized to it and you can handle it, I
- 2:14always make sure you can handle it. Just imagine that children. It's not
- 2:19okay to do to anybody but children, innocent, little children. It's monstrous
- 2:28and interesting that this is Jody Hildebrandt's m O that goes back to two thousand
- 2:34and nine, the duct tape, the starving, the tying people up,
- 2:38this sort of thing. Yeah. Wow, And then you think, well,
- 2:44if Jody Hildebrant has been on the loose for at least fourteen years,
- 2:49how much damage has she done? And she's taught how many people about this?
- 2:53And then you got to wonder, is Ruby Frankie actually just a lieutenant
- 2:59of because the way it comes across and the reporting, it's like you have
- 3:02Ruby Frankie, who's this ringleader in the Jody Hildebrant person is just someone that
- 3:07is glomming on to Ruby Frankie's fame or something. But you know, it
- 3:13could have actually been the other way around. I don't know, spiritual and
- 3:16psychological abuse among other things, such as being forced to sleep outside in the
- 3:21snow, I asked her, among many other things. Yeah. So,
- 3:24in the deep Dive on the Duggers, I was told by some of the
- 3:29patrons, some of the listeners that the podcast that there's this book written by
- 3:34an individual name I think Michael Pearl, and I can't remember the name of
- 3:37the book. Let me look it up. The book is called to Train
- 3:39Up a Child, To Train Up a Child, and in that book he
- 3:45recommends abuse of children, physical abuse, and also disciplining children with cold,
- 3:52not only with having them sleep out in the snow, but also with cold
- 3:55bazz ice baz, with posing them down outside while it's cold, that sort
- 4:00of thing. And the way it sounds to me, they want to cause
- 4:04pain, they want to abuse the children. The book is recommending that and
- 4:09appealing to parents who want to do this kind of abuse to children. But
- 4:12they know that you can't just slap a child or hit a child or push
- 4:16them down the stairs. You can only do things to them that are underneath
- 4:20the threshold of what is considered a crime. Right, and if you have
- 4:25a child that's now that absolutely is considered a crime to have a child sleep
- 4:29outside of the snow. Absolutely, but it's not as discreet or there's not
- 4:34as much evidence about it as much as if you, for example, punched
- 4:39a child in the face and left them with a black eye and they go
- 4:43to school, right, that's much more noticeable and much more reportable. So
- 4:46the way it seemed to me, and I didn't realize this during the duggerdeep
- 4:49dive, but the more I thought about it, the more it seemed to
- 4:51me that the book To Train Up a Child, which was published in nineteen
- 4:56ninety four, by the way, you know, some whacko writes a book.
- 5:00Problem is is that a lot of people around the world consider this book
- 5:04to be this Godsend, this Bible of parenting, giving them permission or giving
- 5:11them guidance, this kind of thing. And this author, Michael Pearl,
- 5:14became quite rich. And by the way, from the reporting, Michael Pearl
- 5:18his organization because it's considered a religious organization, he doesn't have to pay taxes.
- 5:24Just just think about that. It's government subsidized abuse of children. That's
- 5:30what it is. So the problem is is this book became very popular,
- 5:32and it became extremely popular within the evangelical Christian movement, maybe even in the
- 5:38Mormon movement. I don't know, I could imagine that, and also within
- 5:41the IBLP movement. The Bill Gothard, that whole thing that the Duggers were
- 5:46a part of. So once you have ministers preachers and whatever chrismatic leaders pushing
- 5:51this book. Then the book really takes off right, and then you have
- 5:56this systematic movement and religion that is teaching all their people that it's actually not
- 6:03only a good idea to beat your children and following the advice of this book,
- 6:08but it's actually your godly duty to do this. So you have seeming
- 6:12probably parents who otherwise wouldn't be doing this, these kinds of abuses, but
- 6:16are brainwashed to do them. And you just think about the millions of kids
- 6:20who have been abused because of this book and because of the support it had
- 6:25within the Evangelical, Christian, Mormon, IBOP communities. I want to be
- 6:30clear, there are plenty of Christians I know them, They're in my family
- 6:34who would never do this sort of thing. Christians. There's a lot of
- 6:38flavors to Christians, but we all know that there are many Christian organizations that
- 6:43are unfortunately political and are highly problematic. So you know, it's not Christianity,
- 6:48it's a problem. It's the group that's the problem and the way they
- 6:51interpret Christianity and the Bible anyway, So this, you know, the Jody
- 6:56Hildebrandt stuff, what we're hearing now reports from the niece. It's reflective of
- 7:01this massive problem that is under the radar in our society. And that's what
- 7:06I was alerted to when I was doing the Duggard deep dive. I had
- 7:10no idea that there was basically this systematic movement for decades now that is preaching
- 7:15and systematizing and solidifying the abuse of children. I didn't know that, and
- 7:23now I do. And many of you have even told me you're a victim
- 7:27of that. You know, it's one thing to have an abuse of parents,
- 7:30another thing to be abused by a parent that you know has the support
- 7:33of the church and the organization and the cult and the community. That is
- 7:39particularly hard, that's particularly hurtful. If she's met Ruby Frankie, to which
- 7:43she had told me she had not, and hadn't heard of her until all
- 7:46of this. She told me that she's seen some of her videos on YouTube
- 7:49now found them to be quite triggering, but telling from her own experiences,
- 7:54it's been a really interesting experience watching everyone focus on Ruby, and I understand
- 7:58why. But this is Jody. These are Jody's words, these are Jody's
- 8:01ideas, These are over decades old, so interesting. I mean, I
- 8:09don't know if Jesse necessarily knows the pathway that Ruby Frankie took. Maybe she
- 8:13does, but it's possible that they both were like this before they even knew
- 8:18each other. But there's also a good chance, and I trust Jesse's conclusion
- 8:22a lot more than mine, obviously, because she lived through it and it
- 8:26has been close to it that Jody was the one that developed this mindset decades
- 8:31ago and has been abusing kids and recommending this sort of abuse to many other
- 8:37parents, and that Ruby Frankie got sucked up in it. Maybe Ruby Frankie
- 8:41was in that direction but then got sucked up in it, you know,
- 8:43like the I don't know, just speculation, but if Ruby Frankie were left
- 8:48to her own devices, she would have abused her kids in the way that
- 8:50we might be seeing in the videos. But maybe who knows, just speculating,
- 8:56she wouldn't have tied up her children and taped him that sort of thing.
- 9:01But because of Jody Hildebrandt's charismatic leadership or convincing or something, then Jody
- 9:07actually convinced Ruby to go even further. That's one story. Another story is
- 9:11that Ruby Frankie is a monster times ten beyond Jody Hildebrandt, and it just
- 9:16looks different. We just don't know. But Jesse's saying that Jody Hildebrant is
- 9:22the problem. That's interesting. Yeah, yeah, Well, hopefully the investigators
- 9:26in the law actually pays attention to all this because, you know, the
- 9:31public, Ruby Frankie is the face of this story because she had the YouTube
- 9:35channel, But hopefully the agencies and the officials actually take the time to not
- 9:41just focus on Ruby Frankie, but also I'm Jody Hildebrandt, and I guess
- 9:46they should look into all the parents who are following the program this connections thing,
- 9:50and start investigating all those others. I mean, the sort of person
- 9:52that would be attracted to Jody Hildebrant and Ruby Frankie, then anyone who's liked
- 9:58any of their videos should be investigate it. Right. I mean, I'm
- 10:01not saying that you send the army in and you round them all up,
- 10:05but I'm just saying, just right, there's a problem, and let's start
- 10:13here. I have heard this term called mommy guilt one a bit. Have
- 10:20you heard that or maybe you use that term. Every time I hear that
- 10:24term, I think Okay, so this video on YouTube is on the YouTube
- 10:26channel called the Law and Crime Network, So let's watch. Jody Hildebrandt was
- 10:33taken into custody in Ivan's, Utah last week after police said Ruby Frankie's son
- 10:39climbed out of a window at her home with duct tape on his ankles and
- 10:43wrists. Just think about that innocent little boy being treated like. You know,
- 10:50you hear about these stories. You see the pictures of the kids,
- 10:52the six kids, and then you actually see the chat. You know,
- 10:58I didn't know which one it was, and to know which one it was
- 11:01is I mean, it just breaks your heart. You know, I treat
- 11:07people. It breaks my heart to hear about cases that are five percent this
- 11:11when I hear about people children who are overly chastised by their parents or their
- 11:18parents are on their phone all the time, Like that absolutely breaks my heart.
- 11:24This is like, this shatters my heart. There's day The Daily Mail
- 11:30is reporting that during a hearing over custody of Ruby Frankie's minor children, she
- 11:35claimed that one of them molested their siblings and other neighborhood children over several years.
- 11:41So who's the sheet in that? Is that Ruby Frankie during a hearing
- 11:48that was determining where the kids were going to go that Ruby Frankie said that
- 11:52one of the kids in her family was Let's hear that again and get this.
- 11:58On Thursday, the Daily Mail is reporting that during a hearing over custody
- 12:03of Ruby Frankie's minor children, she claimed that one of them molested their siblings
- 12:09and other neighborhood children over several years. The reporters said that Frankie sobbed during
- 12:15the interview. Okay, so we're learning that during the hearing recently, Ruby
- 12:20Frankie discloses that one of the children was sexually abusing the younger children in the
- 12:28family and other children in the neighborhood. So we're looking at another Josh Dugger
- 12:33situation, potentially another Dugger family scenario, and possibly similar factors that could be
- 12:39speculated as contributing to the You know, in all my thinking around the Dugger
- 12:46deep dive that we made, I had a chance to really think about how
- 12:52being in a Christian cult like you know, not every Mormon is like this,
- 12:56but many Mormon organizations are very much like a cult or are a cult
- 13:01in that their high control in that there's a chrismatic leader that can do no
- 13:05wrong in that abuses are covered up, in that everyone is being harmed within
- 13:09the cult, particularly people that don't have power, like children. So I'm
- 13:13not saying all Mormons like this, but many are so similar to IBLP,
- 13:18which is the cult that the Dugger family was involved with. And I don't
- 13:24use the cult the word cult lightly. It absolutely given all the data the
- 13:28IBOP organization, Bill Gothard as a chrismatic leader was absolutely a cult high control
- 13:35chrismatic leader. Da Da Da Dada. We go over through all the criteria
- 13:37in the Deep Dive, so I had a lot of time to think about
- 13:41how you how that could play a factor. Now, in any group of
- 13:45people, you're going to have some people, some children even, who are
- 13:50going to develop attract sexual attraction to miners. And out of those people who
- 13:54are sexually attracted to miners are much younger people, a portion of them are
- 13:58going to develop into actual sexual predators sexual offenders. So in any group,
- 14:03you know, in a group that doesn't involve any sort of cult, research
- 14:09shows you're going to see a certain rate of that developing. We can do
- 14:13a lot to reduce that rate. We're doing a lot currently, but we
- 14:16could do a lot more. So it's possible that within IBOP, within certain
- 14:22cult organizations, within the Mormon Church, you're going to have the same rate
- 14:28of this sort of thing. But considering that we have these very famous cases,
- 14:33and you know it's an end of two. You have the Dugger family
- 14:35and the Frankie family, where seemingly they're in a high control cult that involves
- 14:41the abuse and control of children. I don't know what sort of Mormon sect
- 14:46they're a part of, but you know, we can imagine the sort of
- 14:48things that they're being taught. You know, I had a lot of time
- 14:50to think about how that actually could contribute to one of the children, or
- 14:56more of the children becoming a sexual predator. There's no way to prove this,
- 15:01of course, because because we couldn't ethically experiment on children in this way,
- 15:05but it does stand a reason to me anyway that it's possible that when
- 15:09you have a Christian cult, a religious cult that is extremely shaming about sex
- 15:15in a variety of ways. And doing the deep dive on the Duggers really
- 15:18informed me just how all encompassing the mind control of these cults are, especially
- 15:24regarding sexuality, and because of their belief system or their focus or their machiavellianism,
- 15:30who knows, they actually do not want people having sex out of procreation
- 15:35or at least marriage, right, And so what you have to do is
- 15:39you have to be constantly trying to suppress the urges and the needs of non
- 15:46married individuals, particularly younger people. Right. You have teenagers starting around purity
- 15:50or maybe before, who have affection needs or romantic needs, holding hands,
- 15:56hugging, kissing, making out, this sort of thing, and then advancing
- 16:00to more sexuality kinds of verges and left to their own devices. Children,
- 16:04will you know, there's a bell curve of experimentation, but with some people
- 16:08experimenting a lot and some people not experimenting, most people being around the middle
- 16:12somewhere, left to their own devices. Kids, teenagers, young adults are
- 16:17going to explore that. And as long as we are supportive of that,
- 16:19and we don't harm them along the way by brainwashing them and being too harsh
- 16:26about things and guiding them and being there for them as a secure person that
- 16:29they can come to educating them asons we do all those things, which does
- 16:33happen for a lot of kids. Then things generally work out. Okay.
- 16:37There are anomalies, of course, because you can't control for everything, but
- 16:40generally speaking, you know, it tends to work out okay. But that
- 16:42includes a flexibility regarding the allowance of children expressing themselves. You know, like
- 16:48your son has a boyfriend when he's sixteen years old. They go to the
- 16:52homecoming dance together, and you expect them home at ten o'clock and it's ten
- 16:57fifteen, and you look outside and you see the car that they took,
- 17:02and you see it maybe kind of moving around a little bit, and the
- 17:06policy that you have as a parent is, well, that's not fantastic,
- 17:10but it's not against the rules. You know. They're probably just kissing and
- 17:12making out and doing things that maybe we did when we were sixteen. And
- 17:17okay, maybe we'll have a talk when he gets home, but but I'm
- 17:21not certainly I'm not going to chastise or excommunicate or make the kids sleep in
- 17:26the snow tonight, you know that kind of thing. So there's different approaches
- 17:27and different parents and different sort of cultures around this, but things generally work
- 17:32out. Now, I want to say that our society is generally completely screwed
- 17:36up about sexuality, particularly around younger people, so that damage is inevitable.
- 17:41But for the most part, in spite of that, you know, things
- 17:44can work out generally okay for a lot of people. But when you're living
- 17:47in a high control cult that for some reason just wants to eliminate that human
- 17:52aspect of life, not only do you have to preach all that, but
- 17:59you have to put a lot of effort into controlling it because the urge is
- 18:03powerful. It is it is a biological you know, for a lot of
- 18:07people, it is a biological mandate that you procreate. Right. We evolved
- 18:12to have these urges. Not everyone has that urge, but we evolved at
- 18:15the very least for our gene pool to have a certain percentage of people that
- 18:18have varying degrees of urge. Some people with a strong urge regardless of gender.
- 18:23And I'm not just talking about boys, people of all genders, the
- 18:27varying degrees have strong ass urges to have some of that ass Oh my god,
- 18:37that's the dumbest thing ever said, but it just had to be said.
- 18:41I guess it's what popped in my head, so I say it to
- 18:45emphasize it's real, you know, and it potentially last our entire lives,
- 18:52right to some degree, and ebbs and flows. Some people point is it's
- 18:55a powerful urge, it's a it's a mandate, it's a thing, right,
- 18:59And so if the cult is trying to stop that, it has to
- 19:03be a full court press. There just has to be a constant barrage of
- 19:07shaming people and advice and control and monitoring and discipline it just because you're essentially
- 19:15it's like trying to get people to not want to drink water or something.
- 19:21I mean, it's not that extreme, but it's in that direction. Like
- 19:22people have a when you're thirsty and you want to drink water, you it's
- 19:26a strong urge, particularly when you haven't had any in a while. Right,
- 19:30It's like there's a there's an urge that builds over time, and and
- 19:34there's a lot of cells and bones in your body that are pointing and one
- 19:40direction. And you're trying to stop people from doing that. You're it's inhumane.
- 19:45So you have to be very good about it. You have to be
- 19:48very persistent and hyper vigilant. And when you're growing up in that system as
- 19:53a child, and then you also have parents that are screwed up themselves because
- 19:57some Christian organization, religious organization, or parents or something screwed them up when
- 20:02they were kids, and so the parents are all discombobulated around sexuality themselves.
- 20:06So God knows what sort of things you're seeing as a child, you know,
- 20:08because there can be a lot of different reactivity, a lot of different
- 20:11things that are happening. But anyway, so you're going up in that,
- 20:15and you're also getting a little bit of a dose from society that also doesn't
- 20:18help. But you're fourteen years old or even younger, maybe even you're twelve,
- 20:22and you're starting to have a little bit of that feeling. And what
- 20:25does that due to a child with no guidance, and the only message they're
- 20:29getting is that's the devil. There's something wrong with you. We're going to
- 20:32punish you. You're weak for even having those kinds of thoughts, you know,
- 20:36particularly if the twelve year old takes an action like masturbates or something,
- 20:41has a fantasy and it's just drilled into the head. You're wrong, You're
- 20:45weak, there's something wrong with you. If you continue to do this,
- 20:48then not only is your life going to go down the tubes, but everyone's
- 20:52life. You're going to drag your whole family down. Literally, this is
- 20:53what's taught to them. Because if you're going to control human erge, you
- 20:56gotta, like I said, there's got to be a full court press.
- 20:59You can't just say, hey, kids, don't do front hugs, just
- 21:02do side hugs, like you got to come at them with all the shame
- 21:04and all the ridiculousness. Right, So you're twelve and you're perceiving that,
- 21:10and again that this could go for someone of any gender. There are gender
- 21:12aspects of this, of course, because these cults tend to be very different
- 21:17towards boys as they are towards girls at the expense of girls. But it's
- 21:21not like the boys are treated well. They're just treated less badly, you
- 21:26know. But anyway, so you have this message, you know it's this
- 21:30controls internalized and you know you've been indoctrinated into this cult since you were born,
- 21:34so you believe it, and when you're younger, you believe things so
- 21:38much more black and white because you don't have nuance, you don't have the
- 21:42neurons to understand things in a gray area. So when you cross that line,
- 21:48you are a horrible horrible human being like you believe it, you know
- 21:52entirely, and it creates obviously a very intense internal conflict, and there's no
- 21:59guidance, there's nobody, And especially if your IBLP and your homeschooling and you've
- 22:04cut them off from the Internet and from any sort of person outside of the
- 22:07cult, you're just drowning in shame and horribleness. But there's this urge that
- 22:15is coming, that's piercing through the noise, and it once what it once,
- 22:19just like thirst once what it wants, and hunger once what it wants,
- 22:23and what do you do with it? And you're stuck at home and
- 22:27you're denying it. I don't have this, I don't have this. I
- 22:30don't have For some of those people, we could imagine that they would have
- 22:36some interesting behaviors that they would turn to their younger siblings. They certainly can't
- 22:41date, that's forbidden, they can't express interest. They might not They might
- 22:45worry that even if they were to go behind the church and maybe hold a
- 22:51girl's hand or kiss around the cheek, that the girl would tattle on them
- 22:53and then they would have to sleep in the snow for a month. So
- 22:56and since everything is so clost in these families anyway, they're so enmeshed,
- 23:03and you're being taught by your parents that it's okay to exploit younger people for
- 23:06your own, you know, interests, because that's what the cult often does
- 23:10to people who don't have power. You can imagine someone concluding, well,
- 23:15maybe I'll just direct the sexuality towards the younger people. I need some release
- 23:21from this. I'm not excusing it. Josh Dugger has signs that maybe this
- 23:25was a part of it. I don't know. I didn't hear anything in
- 23:26this direction. I'm completely speculating he could have just you know, even if
- 23:30the family grew up outside of the cult, maybe he was going to be
- 23:33a sexual offender anyway. It's possible, but it does raise some interesting questions
- 23:37about the environment and under which these children are being raised. And we see
- 23:44or these you know, we knew, we know a lot about Josh Dugger,
- 23:45and listen to my deep dives on the Dugger family if you don't know
- 23:48about this. But and now we're hearing another story, potentially from the mom's
- 23:52mouth. God knows if any of that is accurate, but it is interesting,
- 23:56right who are married, if we're going to be sexual, that we
- 24:00do it inside the institution, the constructs of a marriage. Yeah, Based
- 24:07on very little information that I have so far on Ruby Frankie and Jody Hildebrand,
- 24:11given the deep dive that I did on the Duggers, I have been
- 24:14wondering and thinking it's very likely that they are both within a very similar high
- 24:18control cult, similar to IBLP that the Duggers were a part of. And
- 24:23the more I hear, the more it sounds like that is true. There
- 24:27might be some variations to that, you know, like in the IBLP cult,
- 24:32they were saying that for women and girls to wear tampons that's a sin
- 24:37or something. It's wrong because it tempts them sexually or and it denies the
- 24:44future husband the ability to break her hymen, which is just dumb and unscientific.
- 24:52And I mean, if you made a satirical South Park episode about that,
- 24:56you would be like, well, that's going too far, that's ridiculous.
- 24:59No one believes that, but millions of people did, and they talked
- 25:03about it openly. So maybe this cult or high control group that they're a
- 25:07part of doesn't believe in things like that. Maybe they do, but you
- 25:11know, maybe not so there's variations, but the foundations are the same,
- 25:15which is high control abusing children. It is rejection of the secular world and
- 25:22maybe psychotherapy and the liberal point of view about parenting, and also highly focused
- 25:29on the control of children, and particularly the control of sexuality in general.
- 25:33And the thing I wanted to say earlier is that cults often focus on sexuality
- 25:37because it separate It serves the purpose of high control because again, you have
- 25:41this urge that is happening for a lot of people in the group. And
- 25:45if you have this rule that has been established and it's taken for as taken
- 25:51as a given, then the individuals in the cult have to struggle with their
- 25:56own urges and they have to shame themselves. It also excuses punishments to the
- 26:00group because you want to control everybody. It also separates the members because you
- 26:04don't want cult members to confer and to band together, because if they do,
- 26:10they get power, and you don't want anyone to have power. You
- 26:12want full control over all the all the lackeys and the members, and so
- 26:17you have to separate them not only from each other, and sex brings people
- 26:22together, presumably, but you also have to separate them from themselves because they're
- 26:26having these normal human urges, and to separate, you're separating them from their
- 26:32humanists, from who they are, and you've injected all this brainwashing into their
- 26:36heads, so they're they're rejecting even their own bodies and their own selves and
- 26:40their own humanity. So they're separate from themselves, are separate from the other
- 26:44members, and they're separate from society because when they start talking about the sort
- 26:48of stuff, the society is like, you're a whacko, or the members
- 26:52will look at society and say you are a whackos and so I'm gonna So
- 26:56you're separate from society, maybe from other family members, you're separate from them
- 27:00fellow members, and you're separate from yourselfs. And when you establish that,
- 27:03you can control the masses. And we are currently watching the Law and Crime
- 27:11Network YouTube channel, so let's continue continue watching. And not just a marriage
- 27:18just you know, I go and I get married, but a marriage between
- 27:22a man and a woman. Yeah, I didn't expect it all to be
- 27:27crammed in here. So yeah, anti LGBTQ people, of course, it
- 27:33just has to be a part of the whole ridiculous oppressive, criminal ball of
- 27:41wax. It's just ridiculous, the obsession that these people have on LGBTQ people
- 27:48and the obsession that they have about sexuality. It's because to me if I
- 27:55were in, because of course it makes sense because it's so much a part
- 27:57of this always is around the world. But if I were an alien,
- 28:00I would say, you know, you'd probably find more success and more longevity
- 28:06with your cult if you just accepted everybody and you didn't exclude, right,
- 28:15especially if you're following the Bible with the New Testament, Jesus talks a lot
- 28:21about accepting and loving and not judging. So you just think you would probably
- 28:26last longer if you didn't. You know, attack ten to fifteen percent of
- 28:32the population. You know some of your members are gay. You probably find
- 28:37a lot, you know, and if you're gay, you're much more likely
- 28:41to leave the cult because you realize how stupid it is. Right. So,
- 28:45and maybe they're gay people or trans people or by people who want to
- 28:49be a part of your cult, but they can't because you are you by
- 28:52definition reject them, you know. So if I were at anything, I'd
- 28:56be like, you're really shooting yourself in the foot. Here. But of
- 29:00course that's ridiculous. Because this you have to create an outgroup. And the
- 29:03current boogeyman for the Christian right is the LGBTQ people on the lips. It's
- 29:10just like the Antifa. They're all out to get you just think it's so.
- 29:18I've been dealing with this my whole fucking life, and I've been upset
- 29:21about it my whole fucking life. I'm old. I'm fifty two. I
- 29:23was upset about this in the eighties and I'm still fucking dealing with this.
- 29:27My fellow Americans are still fucking like this. In the eighties and nineties,
- 29:36I could excuse them because they there was no advocacy. There was almost no
- 29:41voices. There were some, but there was very few in twenty twenty three.
- 29:47If you're still holding on to this ridiculous fucking notion, there are people
- 29:51that I know who grew up with that notion that gay people are evil or
- 29:56sinners are disgusting or something, and it's as soon as they met a gay
- 30:00person, or as soon as they saw a gay person on television like Ellen
- 30:03or something, they immediately just changed their mind. They're like, oh,
- 30:07huh, I guess all that was wrong. People can do that. You
- 30:11can be brainwashed and pull yourself out of it when data presents itself. It's
- 30:18I've seen it before, people close to me, people in my family,
- 30:21who had very little contact with LGBTQ people. As soon as they just got
- 30:26a little bit of contact, they're like, oh, what I've been learning
- 30:29was wrong. Well, that's kind of obvious. I can still be religious,
- 30:33I can still be Christian, I can still be me. It's not
- 30:37hard. So if you're holding onto it in twenty twenty three, just oh,
- 30:51it just makes me so angry, you know, like it's sad.
- 30:59It's wrong with you who love God, which means they individually love God.
- 31:04So there's no lust in your marriage. It's I love me, I love
- 31:10God, and so therefore I truly love you, which means I will never
- 31:12take from you. I will never did she say no lust because sometimes people
- 31:19within these kind of high control groups will at least allow for lusts between married
- 31:25people married heterosexual people. So yeah, use you to make me feel better.
- 31:32Jody Hildebrandt claims to have counseled thousands of people over the years. She
- 31:37says she's counseled families of all ages with her unique style of it, and
- 31:41I don't doubt that. Just imagine all of the people who she influenced to
- 31:45be abusive, and all the abusive parents who were given license by her to
- 31:48do that and ideas and support to do what they were doing. Just imagine
- 31:53all those kids. You know, I've talked not with the kids who were
- 32:00influence who had parents who influenced by her, but you know, similar kinds
- 32:02of things, like that book To Train Up a Child by Michael Pearl,
- 32:06that kind of thing, Ibeal pe stuff. According to the affidavit filed in
- 32:09support of the child abuse charges, two of Frankie's children had been at Hildebrandt's
- 32:15home last week. A twelve year old boy climbed out of the window.
- 32:19Wow, the home that I thought in my head that I was visualizing was
- 32:22not like that. It wasn't as remote. I mean, we're not seeing
- 32:27the neighbors, but that looks a lot more remote. I don't know why
- 32:30that changes things for me. It makes it much more harrowing for the children
- 32:35to have escaped and found a neighbor because the neighborhoods they keep showing in the
- 32:39news reports, I think might be where Ruby Frankie lives because it's one of
- 32:45those McMansion and there's nothing wrong with it. But you know, one of
- 32:47those neighborhoods that just sort of crop up in the middle of the desert and
- 32:52Whiney roads and there's house, hose house house. It looked like one of
- 32:54those neighborhoods, and of course very harrowing. But in my head it's like,
- 32:59you pop out the window the neighbors, but this looks like you'd have
- 33:01to travel through the desert to get to the neighbor I don't know, maybe
- 33:05there are houses right nearby. But what's interesting. I mean, it's almost
- 33:07like some sort of evil compound James Bond movie, the villain would live in
- 33:13a place like I mean, if you have a house like that, God
- 33:17bless you. It looks like beautiful, expensive house, asking a neighbor for
- 33:22food and water. Duct tape was on his wrists and ankles, and he
- 33:25had deep lacerations from being restrained. Yeah. I've heard worst stories clinically about
- 33:34abuse of children, of course, but this is up there. This is
- 33:37up there. There's different styles of abuse or different types of abuse, right
- 33:45loose categories that I've developed clinically over the years. Like a more common type
- 33:52of abuse that I will hear about or maybe you've heard about, is you
- 33:55have a parent, maybe who drinks too much or as a bad temper,
- 33:59and just loses control suddenly. Like you're running through the living room and you're
- 34:04playing with your siblings and you bump into something and you know you don't knock
- 34:08it over, but you almost do, and your mom just flies into a
- 34:14rage and comes at you, and just like I told you to stop playing
- 34:17in the living room, and you're running away, And then five minutes later,
- 34:22the mom has calmed down a little bit. Might still be angry and
- 34:27resentful and verbally abusive, but isn't necessarily raging with her fist coming at your
- 34:31face, or maybe even she connects with your face and then continues to brate
- 34:37you or something like that. That style is of course very abusive, but
- 34:40it is much more spontaneous and much more reactive to things, things that might
- 34:45even be more relatable to parents. You know, when you have kids and
- 34:49you've been telling them to stop playing in the living room and they keep doing
- 34:52it, you know there's some upper level of your reactivity that you know is
- 34:59upper level. Let's say you're not abusive, but it wouldn't be unusual for
- 35:02a very good parent to raise their voice and say, hey, you know
- 35:06I told you and get firm. So it's a little bit more relatable,
- 35:09you know, times at times one hundred, it's not hard to imagine that
- 35:13some parents would take that a lot further than they should, and because of
- 35:16the way they were parented or their lack of emotional control, this sort of
- 35:21abuses though as on a whole level, you know, no good parent can
- 35:23relate to this, tying up your children for extended periods of time, duct
- 35:29with duct tape, not feeding them, not giving them water, like that's
- 35:34in a whole other ballpark. No good parent can relate to that. So
- 35:38it says something about Jody Hildebrandt says something about Ruby Frankie that is particular.
- 35:45It's very particular, sadistic, psychopathic, lack of empathy. I don't know
- 35:52about their personalities, but the actions lack empathy. Then police said Ruby Frankie's
- 35:58ten year old daughter was found in the whole as well, malnourished Lisay.
- 36:01A YouTube video showed Frankie in the home two days prior, and that she
- 36:06was aware of what was happening to her children. Frankie and Hildebrandt are Mormons,
- 36:09and they talk about God in many of their videos. Okay, I
- 36:13suspected Jody was also a Mormon, but we're hearing that explicitly here. There
- 36:19was really no way that I could cover Jody Hildebrand without risking you defamation or
- 36:25whatever. So now that Jody hildebrand is in jail, a few courageous people
- 36:34have reached out and said that there feel safe enough now to tell their story.
- 36:40And one of those very courageous people is Jody Hildebrandt's niece, Jesse Hildebrandt.
- 36:49Okay, so this is the main thing that y'all wanted me to watch.
- 36:52It is the podcast and YouTube channel called Mormon Stories Podcast. I remember
- 37:00watching him before for other types of stories like this, and he interviews Jesse
- 37:06Hildebrant, Jody's niece. Jesse wrote to me, it's hard to quantify the
- 37:12emotional and spiritual abuse and torture Jody Hildebrant caused, and I think I'll probably
- 37:16have to do so anyways for the police. But physically, just to name
- 37:21a few off the top of my head, I experienced being tied up blindfolded,
- 37:25punched in the back, my knees, kicked out, and dragged by
- 37:29my hair upstairs, I was blindfolded and tied and thrown into a car and
- 37:34forced to lay down on the ground. So I can't quote manipulate people into
- 37:37thinking anything. Yeah again, trigger warning. I have treated clients who have
- 37:45had one incident with one babysitter of something even much smaller than this, that
- 37:52traumatized them for their entire life. When you hear it, just this onslaught
- 37:57of abuses, and it's overwhelming, and it's hard to comprehend the enormity of
- 38:05it, and for the rest of their life it affects them in various different
- 38:08ways. So imagine having not only millions of incidents like this throughout your childhood,
- 38:16but it was your parent. You know, it's different when it's your
- 38:19babysitter or at least your parents are coming home, But when it's your parents
- 38:22that are doing this, and then you have everyone else in the community,
- 38:25in whatever sort of cult they're in, is also supporting this. It's enormous.
- 38:29The abuse, mouth duct taped. I wasn't allowed to speak to anyone,
- 38:34even if they spoke to me directly. Food withheld, forced to run,
- 38:37forced to sleep outside in the snow, forced to drop out of school,
- 38:42never allowed privacy even when using the bathroom, seven minutes to shower,
- 38:45two minutes to use the toilet with the door open, wasn't allowed tampons because
- 38:50she was convinced I was a sex addict and masturbating with them. So okay.
- 38:55Earlier, I was saying that surely this whatever they're in, whatever group
- 39:01they're in, even if Jody hildebrand is the leader or part of a larger
- 39:06group, I wouldn't be surprised if Jody Hildebrandt is part of a larger whether
- 39:09it's a formal or informal or larger group. And so I was saying that
- 39:13I'm hearing a lot of things with Jody Hildebrandt and Ruby Frankie that is very
- 39:16similar to the IBLP cult, the Dugger family, right, And of course
- 39:21there's a lot of other groups around the world who adhere to these ideas.
- 39:23But I was thinking, well, they probably aren't necessarily related because IBLP,
- 39:29I don't think they necessarily going to run along with Mormons and vice versa.
- 39:31So I was thinking, well, there's a lot of similarities there, but
- 39:35there's probably some differences. For example, we learned that IBLP forbade girls and
- 39:40women from wearing tampons because of some ridiculous reasons. So I'm just going to
- 39:45take a guess and say that this group doesn't believe that, because that's stupid,
- 39:47Like, how could you possibly believe that? But we even hear that,
- 39:52We even hear that. But that's sort of a side note. The
- 39:57bigger note here is that we're hearing a about You know, he's rattling him
- 40:00off pretty quickly, but you could really do a deep dive on each one
- 40:05of those allegations, you know, like hearing that she was forced to run
- 40:08in the snow for hours to get the sin out right. It's just that
- 40:14mindset, right. It's it's one thing to torture your children, it's another
- 40:17thing to say that you're sinning. There's something you're getting into a child's head,
- 40:22You're getting into their soul. You're saying there's something deeply sinful about you.
- 40:27You deserve this, God wants this. God's behind me and the communities
- 40:30behind you. Know, I'm inside of you. I'm in your spirit,
- 40:34beyond your body, beyond the physical realm. I am punishing your spirit,
- 40:39there's something deeply inherently wrong with you, right, It's yeah, it's awful.
- 40:44But we heard about other other things too. And you think about that
- 40:47compound that Jody Hildebrandt seems to have, I'm calling it a compound at the
- 40:52house, and it's it seems there's some indications that Ruby Frankie was convinced or
- 41:00in league with Jody Hildebrandt and brought her kids, two of her kids over
- 41:06to Jody Hildebrandt, and Jody took over the discipline of the children, and
- 41:10that's where you know the duct tape and all that stuff, And then the
- 41:14kids escaped and got to neighbors. And we hear about that, But what
- 41:19we don't hear is how many thousands or hundreds or tens of thousands of kids
- 41:23went through the same thing but didn't escape. How many of the of the
- 41:28Frankie kids were abused over time at the Joy Hildebrant House, but how many
- 41:32other families. Because we know that Jody Hildebrandt has been for decades working with
- 41:37families and probably with a very similar program, and that's usually what we hear
- 41:43in these kinds of cults and these kinds of criminals is that by the time
- 41:46they get caught, they have had a long path of escalation. You think,
- 41:52you know, extreme cases like Ted Bundy or Charlie Manson, there's a
- 41:54similar thing where criminals like this they each step of the way they're tentative,
- 42:00but then they get away with it and they just keep it just keeps getting
- 42:04worse and worse. And so in all likelihood, for Jody Hildebrandt, for
- 42:07a while, it's been at this level, but you know, it probably
- 42:09goes back decades and we're so we're hearing from Jesse Hildebrant that all the way
- 42:15back in two thousand and nine, if I'm hearing it right, So fourteen
- 42:19years ago, Jody Hildebrandt was already at this high level. So yeah,
- 42:23I just think about all the other kids that don't get media attention because they're
- 42:30not they don't have YouTube channels. You know, just think about all the
- 42:31other families that have been involved in this, and all the other children who
- 42:35have been abused in this way. It's just it's upsetting. Obviously, welcome
- 42:42Jesse hildebrand They then pronounced niece of Jody hildebrand Oh. Then a lot of
- 42:50people are miss gendering Jesse. I guess I should have watched this up front,
- 42:53but Jesse has been referred to as she by a lot of other people,
- 42:59and I was figuring that they knew their pronouns, and so I apologized
- 43:04for not knowing that earlier aptation and my credibility and kind of used previous problems
- 43:15that I was facing as a teenager being angry and sad and angsty and capitalized
- 43:24on that as a reason that anything that I say is not true. Yeah,
- 43:30this is a well known tactic within cults. We saw this in Nexium.
- 43:32Actually it was more deliberate in that Nexium, Keith Ranieri would have the
- 43:39people in the Inner Circle commit crimes, they would film it, and then
- 43:44they would just overtly tell the cult members that were being the victims. They
- 43:49would say, if you leave the cult or you accuse of if anything,
- 43:52we're going to release this video. But short of that, what cult members
- 43:59and leaders will do to control people as they will, well, what they
- 44:02do is they harm the members. The members are psychologically struggling and will have
- 44:09behaviors from that struggle. Right, they might have a period of addiction because
- 44:15they're just trying to cope, or a period of high rebellion and maybe even
- 44:21a period of crime where they shoplift or they become violent because you know,
- 44:24you put that much pressure on someone and something's going to burst, right,
- 44:29and then the cult turns. So the cult is the problem, is the
- 44:32original factor in why the teenager is acting this way, and then they turn
- 44:37around and use that as a way of discrediting them. And we're hearing that
- 44:43from Jesse a Mormon background, right, No, I know when people find
- 44:46out they're they're typically pretty surprised. I tattoo, I'm a tattoo or here
- 44:52in Seattle, I do American traditional Oh so it's a nice little connection there.
- 45:00Combine that with reports of how she treated men specifically in her therapy practices,
- 45:09and then you combine that with the information that she apparently has a real
- 45:15history of dual relationships and inappropriate relationships with the women in the couples that she's
- 45:23counseled. Okay, so I think the host of Mormon Stories podcast is saying,
- 45:30at least what I'm hearing I think is that there are allegations that Jody
- 45:35Hildebrandt and her practice over decades was overly harsh to the husbands and nicer to
- 45:43the women, and maybe also had quote unquote inapproprilationships with the women. I
- 45:47think, implying that maybe Jody hild Brandt is gay herself or queer in some
- 45:52way. And you know, it's a story that we all have heard many
- 45:57times before that when you you are queer and you are being raised within a
- 46:02high control religious group, you have a limited amount of choices, none of
- 46:07which are very pleasant to you, especially when you're inundated and drowning in the
- 46:12cult. You can try to get out of the cult, which of course
- 46:15is very very difficult, or try to express yourself within the cult, which
- 46:20of course is you know, potentially life threatening at times. Or you can
- 46:25try to suppress your urges and you can try to get a hold of it.
- 46:30You can try to get control of it, you can try to get
- 46:32on top of it, and that can lead to a splitting off of your
- 46:37personality. Not a split personality, but in the psychoanalytics sense of there's the
- 46:43sexual the real person that you are, say a gay person, and then
- 46:46there's this imposed fucked up super ego that's been affected by what's around you,
- 46:52that is coming down hard on who you are as a human being and has
- 46:58to constantly just be pressing down on it and berating yourself and controlling it.
- 47:02And when you have these warring factions within your psyche, one of the defenses
- 47:07that was identified over one hundred years ago called projective identification. We will project
- 47:14one side of that diad outward, and we will identify with the other side,
- 47:17and we will sometimes even find someone that fits with the other side.
- 47:22And what I think you might be getting at is when Jody Hildebrant comes across
- 47:27a queer person such as Jesse Hildebrant, then Jody Hildebrant. Given that conflict
- 47:32and that propensity for projective edication, you find people that are queer if you're
- 47:38Jody, because you made that choice to suppress and control and brate yourself.
- 47:44So you find someone that's queer and then you attack them and you attack them
- 47:46because really what you're doing is you're attacking yourself because you internalize that voice,
- 47:51and you find someone that represents that part of yourself that you're denying, and
- 47:55you attack it, and you attack it and you attack it. And that,
- 47:58of course is a story we've heard a lot of within the Christian right
- 48:01conservative. There are a number of famous cases where you have someone who is
- 48:07spearheading bigotry against LGBTQ people and then at some point it comes light that they
- 48:13are gay themselves, and you're just thinking, what so, At least in
- 48:17my model of understanding personality and within the object of relations, and you know,
- 48:23a lot of people in the psychodynamic psychoanalytic world. The explanation is that
- 48:27it's not a scientific understanding of personality because we can't open the brain and look
- 48:31at it. But it is a model for understanding and it does pan out
- 48:35for a lot of situations. Projective idification is a powerful tool for me understanding
- 48:38myself and my clients and people around me. If you want to learn more
- 48:42about that, you can search projective nification on my channel and listen to some
- 48:45deep dives on that. You might have to be a patron. I'm not
- 48:47sure, but yeah, it's interesting. I mean, you know, it's
- 48:50all speculation about Jody, so I wonder what he's referring to though, although
- 48:54I don't know that's really secondary to the abuses that she has committed. She
- 48:59said thing to the effect of, yes, being gay is evil, and
- 49:06you know, pleasures of the flesh and YadA YadA. But if I were
- 49:10to have sexual relationships with my friends, if we were like, it would
- 49:15be different because there's an a deep emotional connection there and that's different. And
- 49:22like, I like, we were sitting in someone's living room and she said
- 49:23this, and I was just like, what, Yeah, that's called being
- 49:30gay. Yeah, yeah, who knows what that says, but it might
- 49:37say something, right, that's interesting. Yeah, again, in some ways,
- 49:44and I think Jesse feels bad for Jody along these lines that Jody,
- 49:50along with Jesse, both victims of the bigotry within not only our society but
- 49:55also within this religion. And yeah, so you know you feel bad for
- 50:00Jody in this way. Could that be a factor in the abuse. I
- 50:06don't know. Maybe the struggle on the inside creating a lot of turmoil could
- 50:12be a factor. But you know, Jesse went through a similar problem of
- 50:16being chastised and believing that they were sinning in a horse. You know.
- 50:21I didn't show the clip, but Jesse was saying that they were fully on
- 50:24board with the Mormon religion and the particular type of Mormon religion that they were
- 50:30ascribing to. In the family, the way that they described it, it
- 50:34was exactly like IBLP, traditional gender roles, homeschooling, you know, just
- 50:39all the stuff. And for Jesse, they took a different path. Jody
- 50:44took a very particular path. So I don't know if we can necessarily attribute
- 50:47Jody's behavior to that. The other thing that Jesse went into actually which was
- 50:52interesting, but it was a lot of speculation, and Jesse was couching it
- 50:58as such, you know, because Jesse is the niece of Jody, right,
- 51:01so Jesse knows Jody's father, because Jesse for a time was I think
- 51:08being raised by their grandfather, which was Jody's father. So Jesse was basically
- 51:15saying that the father to them, to Jesse was the grandfather. Jesse's grandfather
- 51:22was a good guy and someone that Jesse looked up to or respected or something.
- 51:27But then Jesse quoted Shakespeare pointing out that, well, but I don't
- 51:32know what Jody went through as a child. I only know my grandfather based
- 51:37on my experience. He could have been a very different sort of parent to
- 51:43Jody and everyone else. But they did point out that the grandmother, Jody's
- 51:47mother, Jody Hildebrandt's mother was very stern and very harsh and lacked a lot
- 51:54of nurturing. That's basically I'm using different words, but that's essentially what Jess
- 52:00She was saying. Who knows, but it does raise a question about Jody's
- 52:04upbringing. I think I think Jesse was saying that Jody was the youngest child
- 52:08out of several children, seven eight children or something, and you know,
- 52:13who knows, but you know, there could something happened to Jody which when
- 52:16she was growing up. Let's just assume that and the germination of that problem
- 52:24probably developed early in life. Hard to know, it'd be interesting to know,
- 52:30right, So I was like, Wow, Like my aunt's powerful,
- 52:37Like she's fighting Satan, Like yeah, wow, And this is this is,
- 52:43as far as I understand it, over the past twenty thirty years,
- 52:45the most recommended therapist in the lassatche front by the Mormon Church, because every
- 52:51single person that's reached out to me to tell an her ethic story says that
- 52:53it was their bishop that recommended Jody Hildebrand. Because wow, So I didn't
- 53:00know. I couldn't have even imagined this. I don't know why I wasn't
- 53:04imagining this, but I have been really trying to pay attention to Jody Hildebrandt's
- 53:08license or her qualifications. She calls herself accounselor she calls herself a counselor.
- 53:13But I was thinking that it was a non clinical designation, someone who just
- 53:19calls themselves a counselor a parenting coach or something. I didn't actually think that
- 53:23she was actually trained and licensed and practicing. I guess I still don't know
- 53:30that, because back in the day you could practice, and especially if you're
- 53:35in a high control group that doesn't talk to the outside world, then anyone
- 53:39could be considered to be a professional or a clinician, I suppose, but
- 53:44it kind of sounds like Jody hildebrand was legit licensed in Utah or California,
- 53:49at least that's what I think I'm hearing, and that Jody Hildebrandt was famous
- 53:53for being one of the best therapists around. Now, maybe she was.
- 53:58Maybe she was very effective, and if I saw sessions, maybe I would
- 54:01say, oh, yeah, that's that's not what I would do, or
- 54:05maybe even that's what I would do. I don't know. There's a lot
- 54:07of things that you face as a therapist parenting as a sliver of that so
- 54:12who knows. But it's also highly possible that if I watched even a sampling,
- 54:19I would say, oh, wow, that is horrific what she's doing,
- 54:22so which we could imagine right the way. I haven't been reacting to
- 54:27all the bits, but Jesse just got done telling a story when everything changed.
- 54:31Jesse tells a really interesting story how they early in life. You know
- 54:37a lot of kids in the family Mormon, very devout Mormon family, and
- 54:40Jesse talks about how they were very distant from the father, but not a
- 54:45terrible relationship, but very distant, and Jesse actually really liked their mother.
- 54:50The mother was kind, but also very much indoctrinated into the cult, but
- 54:55not extreme, and for Jesse, they were very inquisitive, maybe on the
- 55:02rebellious side of things. And Jesse talks about their mother, saying that their
- 55:07relationship was good and that the mother was a really good mother and someone that
- 55:13Jesse would go to for comfort, but the mother was very indoctrinated into the
- 55:16cult anyway, So Jesse subscribing their childhood as they were on the rebellious side,
- 55:23on the inquisitive side, but very much trying to do the right thing,
- 55:27very much believing in all of the cults high control messages. You know,
- 55:31Mormonism is right, God evil sin. Jesse was fully indoctrinated. There
- 55:37was very little questioning that. But because Jesse is a very inquisitive and smart
- 55:43person, they started to It was interesting actually hearing Jesse talk about the role
- 55:49that the different kids had that if you wanted dad's attention, and maybe generally
- 55:54just parental attention. There was politics, sports and a few other things,
- 55:59and the older kids and Jesse's family had already found their ditch. And what
- 56:05Jesse decided consciously was, Okay, I'm going to be the kids that knows
- 56:08a lot about religion, knows a lot about the Book of Mormons. So
- 56:13Jesse sat down and read through at thirteen times, which is really amazing,
- 56:15and started to discover some inconsistencies with dates not really lining up with the Bible,
- 56:22and also some questions about like, well, wait, why we're black
- 56:27people not allowed to be priests? You know, that whole thing because if
- 56:31you know, you know, and the questioning was seen as bad as you're
- 56:37a bad kid because you're asking those questions. And I've heard this before before.
- 56:43I've treated clients who have experienced this kind of this kind of problem where
- 56:47they're fully indoctrinated into Mormon particularly, but really just any religion, and they're
- 56:55just asking questions. You know, they're so into it that they're they want
- 57:00to know. Yeah, they you know, Okay, what is Joseph Smith
- 57:02say about this? And you know what does Jesus say about that? You
- 57:05know, they're just inquisitive. And then they come across some inconsistencies, not
- 57:08because they're looking for him, but because there are a lot of fucking inconsistencies.
- 57:13There's a lot of weird things, you know, and you're just like,
- 57:16okay, what about that? What about that? And then you ask
- 57:19these kind of forbidden taboo questions and you get a very strange response from people.
- 57:25And so Jesse was talking about that, and then Jesse says, this
- 57:30turning point happened when they were at dinner at Jody Hildebrandt's house. Because we
- 57:34remember Jesse's father is the older brother of Jody. So they're going to anti
- 57:38Jody's house. They are having dinner there, maybe Thanksgiving, I'm not sure,
- 57:43and Jesse couldn't eat any of the food because they were vegetarian at the
- 57:47time. Maybe still, but nothing on the menu. Nothing on the and
- 57:52the meal was vegetarian. So Jesse was upset about that teenager and maybe being
- 57:58and you know, Jesse puts themselves down and saying, yeah, I was
- 58:01probably being a snotty kid, but I'm thinking, after all you've been through,
- 58:07I can imagine it would probably be understandable. But anyway, so Jesse
- 58:12was being impertinent in some way and went into another room, and then the
- 58:17parents had a conversation. So Jesse's parents had a conversation with Jody, and
- 58:22it was apparently decided that the whole that Jesse's whole family was going to go
- 58:27home and leave Jesse with Jodi, and Jody was gonna fix Jesse. And
- 58:34when you know, so Jody comes to Jesse's. So your family left,
- 58:37and you're now under my control. And the feeling of Jesse didn't really describe
- 58:40it, but you can imagine the feeling of terror Jesse talked about. You
- 58:44know, in the movies, when you zoom in and zoom out on someone,
- 58:47suddenly the protagonist realizes what's happening. That's really what it felt to me.
- 58:52You know, that your life being turned upside down. Just imagine,
- 58:57especially if you already knew Jody's thing. Just being left in the den with
- 59:01the lions, right, just being left without any lifeline, right, without
- 59:07your mom, without your siblings, You're just left with the enemy, with
- 59:10an abuser, with a criminal. It's like a horror movie. Right.
- 59:14So that's what they're talking about. And so for Jesse, that was maybe
- 59:19the turning point of saying, maybe Mormonism or this particular brand of Mormonism is
- 59:27not for me. I think that's what they're talking about. But anyway,
- 59:30then we hear that Jodi is this renowned clinician within the Mormon community and it's
- 59:37being referred many many clients. That's interesting and worrisome. Which was a very
- 59:44common theme about like through the entire process of living with Jodi was if someone
- 59:49liked me, if someone felt sorry for me, it was all because of
- 59:52manipulation. And I was a masterful manipulator constantly, And I was told this
- 59:57constantly to the point I mean where I mean I believed it. I was
- 1:00:01like, you're right, I must be this horrific. And I was already
- 1:00:05believing I was evil because I was gay. And so like, if she
- 1:00:07plays into things that are already there, she finds the hot point and then
- 1:00:13drills into it. Wow. Yeah, it's interesting getting details to Jody Hildebrandt's
- 1:00:20method. You know, you think on the abstract, you figure something's going
- 1:00:24on there, But to hear from one of the victims themselves, it's it's
- 1:00:30chilling that Jody Hildebrandt, to Jesse and countless other children and maybe even adults,
- 1:00:37has been using this method, this method that is endorsed heavily by the
- 1:00:44church, to break people down in this way, abuse people get inside their
- 1:00:50minds. It's wow. And if you hear about this in a book about
- 1:00:58the Spanish Inquisition, you're just like, yeah, well, you know that
- 1:01:00was centuries ago and things were different. This is happening right now. Before
- 1:01:07this broke, the story broke a few weeks ago. I'm assuming what we
- 1:01:10know that Jody Hilderbrant was doing that to the two kids that were found by
- 1:01:15the police, But you know, think about all the other people that Jody
- 1:01:20Hilderbrant has been using these tactics with torture and using her clinical clout and skills
- 1:01:28maybe to like get inside people's minds and convince them that they're I don't know
- 1:01:34if I reacted to this clip, but Jesse was talking about how Jody had
- 1:01:37totally convinced Jesse that while they were battling it out, because the family left
- 1:01:43Jesse with joy. Jody was saying, I am speaking, you know,
- 1:01:46the Jesus and God are speaking through me, and the Devil is speaking through
- 1:01:52you, and I am trying to stop that. And Jesse admits that they
- 1:01:58believed that because Jesse was completely indoctrinated in the cult, and Jesse was a
- 1:02:02child, So how could Jesse have fought against that in their minds? And
- 1:02:06so that that notion, you know, and I've talked about this before,
- 1:02:09but just imagine what that would do to someone's especially a child, to believe
- 1:02:14that you are of the devil. You know, It's one thing to make
- 1:02:17a kid feel like a piece of shit and worth us, another thing to
- 1:02:21quit them with Satan himself, especially when in these cults you have a very
- 1:02:28robust feeling of who Satan is right and the sort of people that hand themselves
- 1:02:31over to Satan. And like I wasn't allowed to speak to my parents,
- 1:02:36I wasn't allowed to speak to anyone alone. And then it got then like
- 1:02:39with the duct taping, I wasn't allowed to speak to anyone. So if
- 1:02:43I was at church and I wasn't duct taped and a church leader came,
- 1:02:45and because this happened, a church leader would come and be like, are
- 1:02:49you okay? And I would have to just stare at them. Because she
- 1:02:53also had spies, she had people reporting back to her anything and everything that
- 1:02:59I did. So if I did talk to someone chief, my goodness.
- 1:03:05Wow, it's like a cult within a cult. You have the cult of
- 1:03:08the Mormon Church, and then you have Jody Hildebrant creating like a subsection of
- 1:03:15a cult within the cult and supported by the larger cult, like Jody Hildebrant
- 1:03:19was her own chrismatic leader. Yeah, that's interesting. I could see why
- 1:03:22Jesse, upon learning about the story about Ruby Frankie, would say, this
- 1:03:27isn't a story about Ruby Frankie. This is a story about Jody Hildebrant.
- 1:03:30Yeah, who knows, But wow, the tactics used psychopathic. On the
- 1:03:37other hand, it's possible, given the rhetoric within these religions, that people
- 1:03:45like Jody Hildebrant aren't psychopathic, but they believe they're following God's will. It's
- 1:03:52hard to know. Found out somehow like and it the amount of paranoia and
- 1:03:59fear that I had, whereas like I can't talk to anyone, and also
- 1:04:03people saw, people saw me duct tapes, people saw that these things were
- 1:04:08going on, and other than the few people that like went to Bishop and
- 1:04:12being like, hey, it's something's wrong, no one did anything. And
- 1:04:17I believe, yeah, I was suspecting it. I mean at the very
- 1:04:21least, because you hear about the kids being duct taped at Jody Hilderbrand's house
- 1:04:26and you think, well, Ruby Frankie probably knew about that. And then
- 1:04:29when you think about the scope of this that for decades, Jody Hilderbrand has
- 1:04:33been doing this at this high level, because what Jesse is referring to is
- 1:04:39fourteen years ago and it was just as bad then. So you just think
- 1:04:44the scale of the abuse, and then you think that it's all indorsed by
- 1:04:47the Mormon Church, or at least this subsection of the Mormon Church which is
- 1:04:53endorsed by the larger government of Utah and of California or the local governments.
- 1:04:58If you just think, like you know, when you I think of cults
- 1:05:00and you think of the harmful cults like Charlie Manson or Branch Davidians or other
- 1:05:08kinds of things. They think that's the stereotype, right, that I've had.
- 1:05:12But there's this massive, you know, millions and millions of people within
- 1:05:18this massive cult. Even if you just think about the United States and it's
- 1:05:24it's happening right next door, it's the cult next door for all of us,
- 1:05:30or the cult in our own house. The Jesse actually is talking saying
- 1:05:35a lot of things that I've heard from a lot of clients along who have
- 1:05:39told me about this. I haven't necessarily had clients come to me for this
- 1:05:43specifically, but once we get into their history, I hear about these kinds
- 1:05:46of things. But I've had clients before we had a very very similar story
- 1:05:49where they grew up in the Mormon Church. It was very high control there.
- 1:05:56Everything was swept under the rug. Jesse mentioned that and that you can't
- 1:06:00question it at all, there can be no you know. I wonder if
- 1:06:04for Mormons it's worse. I know Jewish people who you know, it's a
- 1:06:10wide variety of Jewish folks, but I know Jewish people who in actually one
- 1:06:13of my mentors, Phil Kushman, Jewish himself, and would talk about how
- 1:06:17for the Jewish people that were around him, it is a very important tradition
- 1:06:23to question the Jewish faith and to you know, really discuss and question your
- 1:06:30own bias, question your own assumptions, and listen to other people and have
- 1:06:34a discourse and figure things out and always know that you don't really know the
- 1:06:40will of God. It's it's an approximation. You're doing your best. It's
- 1:06:44a for some for my understanding within Judaism, it's written into the religion that
- 1:06:50you are critical and skeptical of your assumptions about God and about the written word
- 1:06:57of God, the sort of thing. And I wonder if for Mormons they
- 1:07:00swing so far the other way because one because it's a cult, but two
- 1:07:05because there's so many problems with the story. You know, if you really
- 1:07:12if I'm guessing you're younger than me and you've seen the South Park episodes and
- 1:07:16you probably know, I mean, there's so many ridiculous things. Because it's
- 1:07:20it's a more recent cult. There's a lot of religions around the world,
- 1:07:25but the Mormon religion is rather new. It was invented by Joseph Smith a
- 1:07:30couple hundred years ago, Ish or something maybe a hundred years ago, I
- 1:07:33can't remember, but it's recent enough that we have enough written and history around
- 1:07:41how it was developed. And when you hear the story, it's like,
- 1:07:45it's just it's it's ridiculous. And it's easier to see those you know,
- 1:07:51Joseph Smith and the people around him, it's easier to see him as just
- 1:07:55a regular human being. When we go back a thousand years or two thousand
- 1:07:59years one, we don't have a lot of history to depend on to corroborate
- 1:08:02stories, so it's all kind of this amorphous. You just have to have
- 1:08:08faith, and also you just don't have any accounts to kind of give the
- 1:08:12story more richness to moll over. But with Joseph Smith, there's a lot
- 1:08:16to bull over. And it's ridiculous. There's so many dumb things about it.
- 1:08:20Now, if you're a Mormon or you want whatever you want to believe
- 1:08:23in, I will fight tooth and nail so that you can believe what you
- 1:08:28want to believe, whatever religion you want to believe. But when it harms
- 1:08:30people, then that's where I draw the line, and that's where we should
- 1:08:35be drawing the line. So as some would say we should just get rid
- 1:08:40of religion altogether because it runs this risk of harm happening because you start to
- 1:08:46fall in love with your own ideas. But I don't take that stance.
- 1:08:50I understand it, but I don't take that stance. I think there's a
- 1:08:54lot of good that religion or deism, belief in God, belief in the
- 1:08:58supernatural can can give people. It could be used for good. It often
- 1:09:02is. I grew up in a church, you know, it was Christian,
- 1:09:04and it used religion for good. From my memory, love forgiveness,
- 1:09:11non judgment, charity, acceptance, fellowship. A lot of who I am
- 1:09:17as a person actually comes from my experiences in that Christians church, not only
- 1:09:23just as a person during sermons and that sort of thing as a kid,
- 1:09:27but also I was in youth group pretty heavily, and a lot of what
- 1:09:29we did was we would sit around in a circle, sing songs and we
- 1:09:33would talk about our feelings because it was a teenage group that was led by
- 1:09:40a young adult, like a twenty two year old guy or maybe younger,
- 1:09:44I don't know. And a lot of who I am comes from that.
- 1:09:46So, you know, religion can do a lot of really good things,
- 1:09:49and it could do a lot of really bad things, obviously because of the
- 1:09:53culture of the Church, of this patriarchal familiar set up. If like my
- 1:09:59dad is the patriarch of our family, right, he's supposed to receive revelation
- 1:10:03for his family, and so if he is in support of something, it
- 1:10:09must be good. It must be because God gave him revelation that this is
- 1:10:14the right thing. Yeah, so we're hearing a very similar story to the
- 1:10:16Duggers and IBLP. It's just systematized patriarchy and sexism and high control of women
- 1:10:26and girls. And it's awful that it slots right into history and right into
- 1:10:32our societal ideas about gender, and yeah, pretty awful. And it's written
- 1:10:40in the Bible. There are passages in the Bible that absolutely support this point
- 1:10:44of view, so they have their support, and yeah, pretty pretty awful.
- 1:10:49And I think what Jesse is getting at is And therefore, if you
- 1:10:56are a girl in a family like this, you have no power. If
- 1:11:01the dad or someone older than you just decides that two plus two equals six,
- 1:11:08then two plus two equals six. That's just the way it goes,
- 1:11:11and you have no ability to fight against it, even in your own mind.
- 1:11:15Because you're like, well, I'm in this school too, Yeah,
- 1:11:16Dad, if he says something that that's from God. And so it creates
- 1:11:20the system of not challenging things that should be challenged, and it keeps it.
- 1:11:29It disempowers especially women to not challenge anything and and not voice anything.
- 1:11:40Yeah, I mean, yeah, especially I don't think I've ever thought about
- 1:11:48this before, but you know, if you watch this channel, or even
- 1:11:53if you've just watched this video, you know I love to spout about things
- 1:11:58and think about things and explore things and challenge things and what I see and
- 1:12:01even to myself, and just I'm just trying to imagine. I can't,
- 1:12:06but I have a sliver of being able to, you know, imagine what
- 1:12:13it would be like to grow up in that and to be a woman,
- 1:12:16and to have no freedom to even do that in my own mind, to
- 1:12:20not ask questions. I was a very inquisitive kid as well, probably annoyingly
- 1:12:26so similar to Jesse. And yeah, I can't imagine what that would feel
- 1:12:31like to just shut it all down and to kill a part of myself to
- 1:12:39survive. Yeah, just awful. I know this timeline is going to be
- 1:12:44a kind of no, this is amazing and all. All right, Well,
- 1:12:48I'm going to have to adjourn there because it's getting very late, and
- 1:12:54I'm just realizing that this interview is over three hours. It's about three and
- 1:12:58a half hours, and I'm only an hour through it. So I worry
- 1:13:04that some very interesting things I'm sure are later in the interview, but I
- 1:13:10just don't have the time, and at the time that I'm recording this,
- 1:13:13I have a lot of other things I have to get to actually, because
- 1:13:16this is before the weekend where we're having our fifteen hour live stream, and
- 1:13:19you know, there's other kind of things I have to do. So I
- 1:13:25feel bad that I have to cut it short here. But it's demoralizing to
- 1:13:31think about the scale, even if we just think about the United States,
- 1:13:35and of course it's going on all around the world. But it's demoralizing and
- 1:13:40depressing and scary to think about the scale of this movement within Christian circles to
- 1:13:50abuse their children and to lean more into fundamentalism and patriarchy and high control and
- 1:14:00cult organizations. It's really scary, and it's it's threatening. You know,
- 1:14:09there's so many it's it's we're talking like a fourth of Americans or something,
- 1:14:14and we're talking about a lot of people. I don't know the exact stat
- 1:14:17but there's a lot of these individuals. It's not just like the Westboro Baptist
- 1:14:24Church where there's thirty members. We're talking about millions upon millions of people who
- 1:14:29are indoctrinating even more millions upon millions of children into this. And of course
- 1:14:32they're having millions and millions of more kids. You know, the the amount
- 1:14:36of kids within IBLP and Mormon church is exponentially more numerous than the average American
- 1:14:45family. So it's it's pretty awful. And the siloing of their thinking,
- 1:14:54you know, the way they cloister themselves and their echo chambers. How can
- 1:15:00we change this? How could it possibly change? And yeah, I've worked
- 1:15:02with clients like this who tell stories that where they start to question things and
- 1:15:09oh, yeah, this is what it's getting at. Earlier, they start
- 1:15:11to question things, and then there comes a point where it's usually around thirteen
- 1:15:15or fourteen, and they start to think, because that's usually when kids start
- 1:15:18thinking for themselves or trying it on for size, and they're just thinking,
- 1:15:23wait, is this whole thing a sham? And they often have a little
- 1:15:29contact with the outside world. So there's maybe some influence there. They love
- 1:15:34Taylor Swift or something, and Taylor Swift isn't morbid, right, isn't.
- 1:15:39I don't know whatever, you know what I mean, And so that this
- 1:15:44question starts to merge, and then everything starts to come into question, and
- 1:15:46then you start to push back as a child. But because of the high
- 1:15:50control and because of the methods of sweeping under the rug and rejection and excommunication
- 1:15:57or disciplining the devil out of the child, because you're just questioning, you
- 1:16:00get thrown away as a child or harmed. It's like you're either one hundred
- 1:16:06percent in or you are dead to us. And I've seen that before,
- 1:16:12and yeah, it's it's just in disaster movies or in MCU movies, Marvel
- 1:16:20movies. There's some evil you know, Zod, General Zod or what was
- 1:16:26his name from Superman too. There's always some evil force that like comes at
- 1:16:31Earth or comes at the human race, and you know they're gonna get us.
- 1:16:35We're doing this to ourselves. This is these are human beings and human
- 1:16:42institutions and human governments that are doing these atrocities to ourselves. We are our
- 1:16:49own villains. We don't need aliens to come from out of space to get
- 1:16:55us. We get ourselves. It's so pressing and it's so sad. It's
- 1:17:01just so pathetic that we're so stupid as an animal. What could you expect?
- 1:17:08I mean, we didn't evolve to understand these things. We evolved to
- 1:17:13feed ourselves and procreate within a small group of one hundred people, and we're
- 1:17:17very good at that. But when it comes to these large scale movements and
- 1:17:21influence and cults and religions and propaganda and echo chambers and fake news and social
- 1:17:30media, we didn't evolve to survive that. And will it destroy us?
- 1:17:34I mean, we're destroying ourselves and just causing a wake of damage. Jesse
- 1:17:44mentioned that they've been in therapy a number of times, and Jesse seems like
- 1:17:48they've really found a good place for themselves. And Jesse speaks a lot of
- 1:17:55authority about a lot of things. Seems very strong. And I'm going to
- 1:18:02take a guess though, that there's still a lot of pain and still a
- 1:18:05lot of hurt and a lot of trauma. I don't hear that, but
- 1:18:11it's possible. It's likely, yeah, yeah, yeah. Before the dugger
- 1:18:15deep dive I knew about it. I knew about all this stuff, heard
- 1:18:19about it, treated clients within it. But after the Dugger Deep Dive and
- 1:18:24also this Ruby Frankie story, I just really feel the scale of it.
- 1:18:30Yeah. I think another thing is I live in Seattle, and of course
- 1:18:33these folks are in and around Seattle. There's a fair amount of Mormons in
- 1:18:38and around Seattle. But I don't really come into contact with a lot of
- 1:18:42this, and the Christians I do know are nowhere near any of this.
- 1:18:45Although I do know some people that are in this camp, They're not close
- 1:18:50to me, but I people close to me know to tell me about them,
- 1:18:55and so it's not that far afield, but it's pretty far from me,
- 1:18:59you know, some of you, I live in communities where you're just
- 1:19:00like yeah, I mean everyone's like like this, and I'm the one weirdo
- 1:19:04in the community. So for me anyway, this has been a real I'm
- 1:19:11getting a real felt sense for the scale of the problem and the ongoing nature
- 1:19:15of the abuse to children. It's going to continue there there's not enough CPS
- 1:19:21workers in the United States to combat this, and how do you combat it?
- 1:19:26You have if it's just an isolated family that you're going at, but
- 1:19:29you're going after organizations, and and you have to get them to stop doing
- 1:19:33their stupid shit. You have to get religions to stop doing half of what
- 1:19:39they talk about. You know, you can keep this half, but you
- 1:19:42got to get rid of this other half that ain't gonna happen, that is
- 1:19:46not going to happen. Half of them are congress members themselves, right presidents.
- 1:19:51So it's pretty depressing. I guess I'm just really sad. I guess
- 1:19:59I haven't impulse to say something uplifting or optimistic. But you know, fuck
- 1:20:02it. Why it's not my response. I didn't I didn't fuck this up.
- 1:20:06Why do I have to somehow make it nice nice? It's not nice
- 1:20:12nice, it's bad bad. So well, if you're with me, still,
- 1:20:16we're in it together, you and me. So let's hang together,
- 1:20:20support each other, let's fight where we can. But you know, it's
- 1:20:24a big thing. We're not going to be able to change it in and
- 1:20:27of ourselves, and even if we all work together, we might not be
- 1:20:30able to change it. But we can be together, you and me,
- 1:20:32And please take care of yourself and I'll take care of myself. I was
- 1:20:36gonna say, don't worry about me, but you can feel free to not
- 1:20:40worry about me, but you can care about me. I can care about
- 1:20:42you. I don't I'm not a fan with people, but don't worry about
- 1:20:46me. It's like, hey, yeah, it's I can worry about you.
- 1:20:48It's okay. You know, I'm not gonna cry myself to sleep every
- 1:20:51night, but I do care. And so so that's me stopping myself from
- 1:20:56saying that. But you know, we're in this together. We have that.
- 1:21:00And take care of yourself because you deserve it, you really, really do