Latest / Journey to the Fringe / The epoch of its time: The Falun Gong part 3 of 3
Transcript
- 0:00From the unexplained to the mundane, come join us on a journey to the fringe.
- 0:12Hello and welcome to Journey to the Fringe, where sometimes we cover groups of swastikas
- 0:16in their logos, and a good chunk of them are probably not great.
- 0:20We are your podcast hosts, Taylor and Chelsea.
- 0:22And Chelsea, this may actually come as a surprise, seeing as how we've been talking about these
- 0:26people for several hours.
- 0:28This is one of those times, and maybe you should Google the Falun Gong and check out their logo.
- 0:34What? How did this surpass me? Huh.
- 0:37Yeah, it's not even a little bit of swastik.
- 0:40In all of the googling I've done about the Falun Gong, this has not come up yet.
- 0:46Yeah, there is no less than five swastikas in their logo.
- 0:49You should know it's not due to Nazis.
- 0:52It's actually a very prominent Buddhist symbol.
- 0:54When I was in Korea, if you look at a map of the city, you'll see swastikas on it,
- 0:58and that's where Buddhist temples are.
- 1:00Yeah, and it's all over Asia.
- 1:02But nonetheless, there are five swastikas in their logo.
- 1:05It's hard to believe we made it over two hours of talking about this group before it came up
- 1:09in the podcast, but it made it nonetheless.
- 1:11You find those groups usually use it to show that they're so enlightened,
- 1:15and that it's a good, nice symbol, and the cults and bad people don't usually use it for that reason.
- 1:23Yeah, oh, and it was used a lot before the Nazis came to power?
- 1:26Yeah.
- 1:26Robert Evans actually just did a behind the bastards episode on swastikas not that long ago.
- 1:31I listened to it, yeah.
- 1:32And there used to be a town in Ontario, Canada called Swastika.
- 1:36Chelsea, you can actually look it up.
- 1:37The Edmonton Swastikas was a hockey team.
- 1:40What?
- 1:40The more you know.
- 1:41Oh my god, look at this hockey team photo.
- 1:44That's not good.
- 1:45You really can't use that symbol anymore.
- 1:48Yeah, it's definitely a different time to be alive than then.
- 1:51A lot less dysentery, a little more negative views of swastikas.
- 1:55Yep, very negative views.
- 1:58But anyhow, let's get back on track.
- 2:00We've got a lot to cover still with the Falun Gong.
- 2:04What we've been covered for a while.
- 2:05Just give you a little reprieve there.
- 2:07Chelsea, we learned a lot of the bad side of Falun Gong in the last episode.
- 2:12Where we're going to pick that up now is how it's impacting the world that we live in today.
- 2:17Oh, I thought we're going to do the good side of the Falun Gong.
- 2:20I mean, that first episode was the best representation.
- 2:23That was it?
- 2:24I'm willing to do that.
- 2:25I'm willing to do.
- 2:28But they don't get sick.
- 2:29They don't get sick.
- 2:30That actually.
- 2:31They don't need hospitalization.
- 2:33Let's stop focus on that.
- 2:34Let's focus on how they're impacting the world today.
- 2:37So Chelsea, this group has a lot more sway in the modern world
- 2:43than I would really like to say a cult should.
- 2:46We're going to start off looking at some of their business endeavors.
- 2:49The first one being ultra surf.
- 2:51What is ultra surf?
- 2:51Well, in 2001, it was founded by Chinese dissidents in Silicon Valley.
- 2:56Basically what it is, it's a VPN for users in China to evade government censorship and monitoring.
- 3:02As of 2011, ultra surf reported over 11 million users worldwide.
- 3:07During the Arab Spring, it recorded a 700% spike in traffic from Tunisia.
- 3:12So it is actually like worldwide used.
- 3:15It's basically a way to avoid internet censorship.
- 3:18I mean, that's not a horrible thing, but it's also owned by the Falun Gong.
- 3:23And I should say too, similar traffic spikes occur frequently during times of unrest in other regions
- 3:27like Tibetan Burma.
- 3:29Some people have called it the most important free speech tool on the internet, but.
- 3:34I don't see it being a horrible thing.
- 3:35No, it seems like a good idea.
- 3:37This is the best thing they've ever done.
- 3:39It's anti-communist for sure, because it's meant to specifically get around the great firewall of China.
- 3:45There is some good parts to it, but let's talk about the rest.
- 3:50Some technologists have expressed reservations about ultra surf's model.
- 3:54However, in particular, its developers have been criticized by proponents of open source
- 3:59software for not allowing peer review of the tools designed, except at the discretion of its creators.
- 4:04Moreover, because ultra surf operates all its own servers, their developers have access to the user's logs.
- 4:12This architecture means that users are required to trust ultra surf not to reveal user data.
- 4:17Ultra surf maintains that it keeps logs for a short period of time and uses them only for the
- 4:22purpose of analyzing traffic for signs of interference or to monitor overall performance and efficacy.
- 4:28The company says it does not disclose user logs at third parties.
- 4:32However, we got to take their word on it.
- 4:35Yeah, because they don't let anybody else look at it.
- 4:37In an April 2012 report, Jacob Appelbaum with the Tor Project criticized ultra surf
- 4:43for its use of internal content filtering, including blocking pornographic websites,
- 4:49and for its willingness to comply with subpoenas from U.S. law enforcement officials.
- 4:54So it's anti-government, except in the case of the U.S.
- 4:58Is that weird?
- 4:59Appelbaum's report also noted that ultra surf pages employed Google Analytics,
- 5:03which had the potential to leak user data and that its systems were not all up to date with
- 5:08the latest security patches and did not make use of forward security mechanisms.
- 5:12It is a little weird, but this group and connection to the U.S. government is going to come up a
- 5:19lot in this episode.
- 5:20Oh, okay. I was like, why would they just choose the U.S. government? But okay.
- 5:25That made sense.
- 5:26Furthermore, Appelbaum claims that ultra surf client uses open and free software,
- 5:31but it's not disclosed. And this use and lack of disclosure is a violation of the licenses to
- 5:36use these products. In response, posted the same day, ultra surf wrote that it had already resolved
- 5:41these issues. Again, they don't actually let anybody else look at it, but they're saying that
- 5:46they do.
- 5:47If you were like, let me look at it to see and they're like, sure. I mean, that would immediately
- 5:53put doubt into your minds of who they're giving it to.
- 5:57Apparently a top secret NSA presentation revealed as part of a 2013 global surveillance
- 6:02disclosure. They dismiss ultra surf's response there as I'll talk in no show.
- 6:08Like they're just saying it.
- 6:10And then in a really weird coincidence, a Trump appointee named Michael Pack, who's the head of
- 6:16the U.S. agency for global media, made a real big push to get government funding for this project.
- 6:22The ultra surf?
- 6:23Yeah.
- 6:24Is that not Ray's red flakes?
- 6:26Michael Pack made a big push to stop federal funding for open technology fund, which develops tools
- 6:33that allow people to get around controls on internet access, which received 20 million in
- 6:38government funding as of 2022. So just cut it off. And then the last I could find on this is that
- 6:45this was from 2021, I believe in November. Mr. Pack provided ultra reach internet corp, which is the
- 6:51overarching company that does ultra surf nearly $1.8 million in federal contracts. Now as the
- 6:58time of the article I read, they'd only received 250,000, but still it was a push to move government
- 7:03funds from one project to a Falun Gong project in the tune of millions of dollars.
- 7:09That's weird. Is it because China hates them?
- 7:12No, not necessarily. And we're going to get to it in the next part, which is if you've had an
- 7:18interaction with Falun Gong, it's going to be through this group or the next one we talk after
- 7:23it. But the next one I want to talk after is the bigger surprise for Chelsea here. So we're going
- 7:27to start with this one.
- 7:28By after, do you mean part four?
- 7:31No, no, it will be in this episode.
- 7:33Falun Gong owns the Epoch Times. This is a newspaper.
- 7:39Yes.
- 7:40Did I sound shocked?
- 7:42Yes. And for those of you wondering why I titled the episode, so this is the payoff finally.
- 7:48Let's go into it a little bit. The Epoch Times was founded in 2000 by John Tong,
- 7:52spelled T-A-N-G, and other Chinese Americans affiliated with the Falun Gong new religious
- 7:57movement. Tong was a graduate student at Georgia at the time, and he began the newspaper in his
- 8:01basement. Founders said that they were responding to censorship inside China and a lack of international
- 8:06understanding about the Chinese government's repression of Falun Gong. In 2009, Lee Hongjur,
- 8:11the founder of Falun Gong, appeared in the newspaper's headquarters in Manhattan and called for the
- 8:15expansion of the Epoch Times to, quote, become regular media, end quote. Lee has called the Epoch
- 8:21Times our media, as in the Falun Gong's media, along with their other arm, the new Tong Dynasty
- 8:29Media Corporation. They're not going to come up as much, though. Two former employees said that
- 8:33the top editors traveled to meet with Lee at Falun Gong's compound, Dragon Springs, where he weighed
- 8:39in on editorial strategic decisions. However, the Epoch Times denies that these meetings take place.
- 8:44Of course they do. I believe I've used the Epoch Times for a year and a half.
- 8:50Yes. And I said, you know, that's owned by a cult, right?
- 8:56Yes, I remember that. That's in fact where I learned that they own this.
- 9:01Former Epoch Times employees have noted Falun Gong practitioner's involvement in management and
- 9:06editorial process, and three anonymous former employees said the Epoch Times workers were
- 9:11encouraged to attend weekly, quote, Faw Study, end quote, sessions. Outside work hours, study
- 9:18Lee's teachings. Former employees have said that criticizing the Epoch Times amounts to disobeying
- 9:24Lee. According to an NBC news article, the Epoch Times quotes generally stayed out of US politics,
- 9:30end quote, before 2016, unless they dovetailed with Chinese interests. Ben Hurley, a former Falun Gong
- 9:38practitioner and Epoch Times writer until 2013, said the paper was critical of abortion LGBT people
- 9:44and that Falun Gong practitioners saw communism everywhere, including in international figures
- 9:50like Hillary Clinton and Kofi Anand, who was the head of the UN at the time. But there was more
- 9:56room for disagreement in the early days. Since 2016, according to NBC News, the Epoch Times has
- 10:03promoted favorable coverage of Trump's campaign and presidency and emphasized topics like Islamic
- 10:09terrorism, illegal immigration to the US, anti-global warming conspiracies, great replacement theory.
- 10:17This is weird. I mean, it makes sense. It has also emphasized what the publication claims is a
- 10:24labyrinthian global conspiracy led by Hillary Clinton and former President Barack Obama to tear
- 10:29down Trump. A former Epoch Times reporter who covered the 2016 campaign, Steve Klatt said his
- 10:35editors had encouraged favorable coverage of Trump after he won the Republican nomination and that
- 10:41quote, they seem to have this almost messaonic way of viewing Trump as the anti-communist leader
- 10:47who would bring about the end of the Chinese Communist Party, end quote. After Trump was
- 10:53elected, the Epoch Times hired Brendan Steinhauser, a Tea Party strategist, to reach out to more
- 10:58conservatives and encourage the Trump administration to oppose the persecution of Falun Gong. So, yeah,
- 11:04they definitely linked to very pro Donald Trump conspiracies and QAnon. And if you go to their
- 11:11front page right now, there is literally on their front page a 2020 election fraud article.
- 11:19On my way. Oh, they cover Canada. Oh, yeah, it's in 80 countries.
- 11:23How am I supposed to look at this? One sec. Let me go to the front page.
- 11:26I went to Canada. So now it's showing. Oh, I went to the US one. But...
- 11:30Oh, it keeps redirecting me to Canada. Canada, factual and unbiased news provided in-depth
- 11:38coverage. There's a video playing right around Epoch Times. Oh, yeah. And if you read number three,
- 11:44trending videos, number three is thousands of 2020 votes misreported. Oh, great. Yeah.
- 11:50That's a Trump thing. That's a Trump thing. Yeah. Not even like past it. Like this happened
- 11:54four years ago and they're still pushing it hard. And it had a huge presence on Facebook
- 11:59right around the time of the 2016 election. I don't really get into it, but it's a scandal where
- 12:04they were running Facebook groups that didn't really talk about how they were the Epoch Times.
- 12:09And we're just like, they'd share pictures of puppies and things like that and then slowly
- 12:13leak it over into talking about conspiracy theories and QAnon and things like that. And like,
- 12:19they would have groups of five million people on Facebook that were there originally because they
- 12:23were talking about puppies sharing. Yeah. Misleading information. Anyhow, they've been banned from
- 12:28Facebook since then for being misleading ads and not saying where the actual money is coming from.
- 12:33And also there was a big controversy too because they were faking subscribers by making fake accounts
- 12:40and like they got caught because they had celebrity pictures. It's just like random people who were
- 12:44in the group. I just came here. Trump Flags terrorists, slams border deal, catastrophe waiting to happen.
- 12:52I actually came across that today. He said a terrorist attack was 100% going to happen under
- 12:58this administration. And Chelsea, like you can see at the very top, it's all the languages
- 13:03it's reported in. So you can go Chinese, Spanish, French, Portuguese, Hebrew, Japanese, Korean,
- 13:08Vietnamese, like this. This is crazy. I'm just scrolling through this. Some of the articles
- 13:13that they have on here. Don't read too much because there's a surprise on this page that leads us
- 13:17into the final part of the epoch time section. Okay, don't be a jerk at the gym. Not only did they
- 13:23push Donald Trump part in 2017, the German edition, epoch times, Deutschland, which became
- 13:28wet only in 2012 was ascribed by online magazine, the China file is aligned with the German far right
- 13:34and attractive to supporters of the alternative for Germany, AFD party and the anti immigrant group,
- 13:40Pajita, Stephanie Albright, a reporter for the German broadcaster RTL who spent several days
- 13:45inside the epoch times Berlin office while investigating the far right said that the staffer
- 13:49she met were all felon Gong practitioners who had no journalistic training and did not check facts
- 13:55trusting instead in the alternative sources they consulted during her times the epoch times office
- 14:00albright was exposed to debunked conspiracy theories such as pizza gate m trails weather
- 14:05changing machines and the great replacement theory. In France, the epoch times gives quote an
- 14:12unfettered platform to Jean-Marie Le Pen, the patriarch of the French far right and his daughter
- 14:18Marine Le Pen, who leads the nationalist party her father founded, who by a very narrow margin
- 14:24lost to Emmanuel Macron by a very narrow margin, the group that epoch times wants to lead the
- 14:30country just lost. The epoch times also publishes climate change denial content. It promotes
- 14:36doubt about modern science and medicine in line with Falon Gong's teachings. The epoch times has
- 14:41increased its revenue just over the last couple of years by 685 percent. What? It makes a hundred
- 14:49and twenty two million dollars as of 2021 annually. And since 2019, it has gone mostly digital
- 14:56spending millions on Facebook and YouTube advertisements. Although again, it was kicked
- 15:01off Facebook for that controversy I just told you about. Let me just find the name of it real
- 15:06quick. The beauty of life is the name of the facet group that caught all the controversy and got
- 15:10them kicked off. Are they on and they probably have another one? They probably do. But I honestly,
- 15:15I don't go near Facebook anymore. I don't really want to look as of 2023. It is the fourth most
- 15:22subscribed newspaper in the United States, which is just mind boggling. Yeah. None of this stuff
- 15:28makes sense to me. I read a few people who used to work for it who were Falon Gong practitioners.
- 15:34And they said at first they were not paid at all. It was all volunteers. And then eventually they
- 15:38got paid twenty thousand dollars a year to write for them. Their headquarters is in Manhattan.
- 15:43So like nobody can actually afford to live there if they're paying twenty thousand a year. Yeah.
- 15:47And they're expected to pump out five articles a day for that salary. That doesn't seem like
- 15:52something anybody would want to do. Doesn't give any time to actually reflect on what you're writing.
- 15:58No. During covid, absolutely a rat nest of anti covid conspiracies. And I believe pretty much
- 16:06everybody in Canada in the U.S. got a free copy mailed to them during covid with anti covid
- 16:12conspiracies in it. That's nice. Do you remember I got a copy of it in the mail once and it was
- 16:17right around that time during covid. Yeah. I've never seen it in print. I mean, I don't think.
- 16:21I found this website healthfeedback.org. It has a lot of the claims they've made in specific articles
- 16:27just to give you an idea of things that they've said in the article or in the headlines.
- 16:32Rat study alleged to link covid vaccine to autism. This is unsupported, but a statement they made.
- 16:37Natural immunity is better protection than covid 19 vaccine. Miss leading title. Study in Italy
- 16:43shows nearly one in three covid vaccine recipients have neurological side effects. Not correct.
- 16:48An accurate reporting by Pfizer would have shown equal numbers of clinical trial deaths
- 16:53in the vaccine and placebo groups and thus no benefit of vaccination. It is incorrect.
- 16:57Covid 19 vaccines are responsible for killing 17 people, 17 million people incorrect. Those are
- 17:04like very different numbers. 17 versus 17. Yeah, I'm just looking through their covid right now.
- 17:12Soaring childhood obesity after covid 19 lockdown poses lifelong health threat study. So yeah,
- 17:19very strange. Seeing as how do you remember from the first episode that Falun Gong practitioners
- 17:24are forbidden from being political in any way? Yeah, it seems pretty political like incredibly.
- 17:30Though they may not know because they don't have time to think about what they're writing.
- 17:34Yeah, and I do just want to give you guys, I did read one article on here and it is specifically
- 17:40titled because there are so many articles from other news groups saying like these guys are
- 17:45terrible because they don't actually do any journalism and just report Trump great all the
- 17:50time. Wave of hip pieces reveal why establishing this terrified of this defiant newspaper. This is
- 17:55from the epoch times and it basically says we didn't change. Everybody else just became anti-Trump
- 18:01for some reason and they're evil. We are unbiased and we only interpret everything from an anti-communist
- 18:06standpoint, which again isn't unbiased in itself, but let's not worry about that at this point.
- 18:11I love the spin they put on it. Do you think that they're funding Trump potentially? I don't know
- 18:17for sure, but I did find an article. Where is it? I need to find it really quick. GOP presidential
- 18:24candidate Larry Elders, who people may remember that name. He was running against Gavin Newsom to
- 18:30become the governor of California and he received from the epoch times between one million and five
- 18:37million dollars. Yeah, it wouldn't surprise me that they're heavily funding some of these things.
- 18:43Because when you're running for any government office, you have to do financial disclosure.
- 18:46He reported earning between one million and five million dollars from the epoch times.
- 18:51And I just want to say too that I am not slandering the epoch times by calling them extremely far
- 18:58right or conspiratorial. And in fact, they sued a journalist for calling one of their journalists
- 19:04extremely far right and spreading conspiracy theories such as Antifa is behind the January
- 19:106th riots. The court concluded that no, in fact, they were very correct. They may have made an
- 19:16overgeneralization, but they were incredibly correct for calling you guys far right conspiracy
- 19:20theorists. And it wasn't like they sued the New York Times either. It was like the main bugle
- 19:25or something like that. Like it was not somebody who has all the money behind them. But yeah,
- 19:33they had people at January 6th who were reporting and they said, oh yeah, Antifa's here doing all
- 19:38the violence. Why? This doesn't make sense to me. They believe that Trump was going to bring about
- 19:45the end of the Communist Party in China. Okay. So they went all in on him and they appeared to have
- 19:52a working relationship at this time. Remember, this is not the first cult that we have seen
- 19:59Donald Trump have a relationship with as he came up in the Mooney's episode two. Also,
- 20:03for those listening at home, which is not all of you, if you're in the car, this probably applies
- 20:07to you too. Out on the streets, do not listen. Washington Times and epoch times now are the
- 20:13two cult related new sources that we should be avoiding because they're both cults. But remember,
- 20:17Washington Times, not Washington Post. Washington Times. Yeah, we've brought them up. They were
- 20:22in the Mooney's episode, they're owned by the Mooney's. Right. Okay. So epoch times are Washington
- 20:28Times. Who has the bigger epoch times? It's the bigger breach. It says weird. You will still see
- 20:34epoch times coming up in conspiratorial circles and far right circles. And you should know absolute
- 20:40all their journalism is actually dog shit and has a slant towards bringing about the end of the
- 20:45Communist Party in China. And Chelsea, I've been looking for all the stuff they have here. They also
- 20:50have new Tong Dynasty news media, which has a lot of association with YouTubers. And I just have this
- 20:56one part from the rational wiki. I always like using the rational wiki because they use very
- 21:00colorful language when covering these types of things. This is what they say about the epoch
- 21:05times. Besides its usual anti PRC diet tribe that asked readers to resign from the Chinese Communist
- 21:11Party regardless of actual membership. The paper often publishes woo and conspiracy such as chemtrails,
- 21:16UFOs, an entire section titled beyond science. The beyond science section includes such things as
- 21:2212 million year old vehicle tracks, ancient Sumerian spaceships, and hype over meditation and near
- 21:27death experiences. Former employees noted the secrecy of the publication's ownership and funding
- 21:32and tendency to promote red baiting as well as anti abortion and homophobic views. Other former
- 21:37writers noted it's almost slave labor like work environment where they need to meet a quota of
- 21:42writing five articles per day and reaching 100,000 views and are paid in virtue, a white substance
- 21:48in another dimension that you gain when you do good things. Falun Gong associated editors then
- 21:53remove mentions of issues which conflict with traditional values as well as those unfavorable
- 21:59to Trump. This is not surprising since it was promoted by Chris Kitts of fake news website
- 22:05before it's news. They have an entire section called beyond science and that clicks something in my
- 22:11head. Chelsea do you ever remember it's like years ago there was a guy named Mikey Chen and he was
- 22:15doing a YouTube show called beyond science. No. And it was all like more paranormal or
- 22:22fringy news science stuff is what he was doing. Let me take a look. Yeah, take a look. I'm sure
- 22:27you've seen this guy and he also has a thing where he like goes and eats food and learning about this
- 22:33I learned that this guy is a Falun Gong practitioner. Really? Yes. And I learned that his subreddit
- 22:42is absolutely like the coast to coast subreddit and it is hilarious how much they hate the guy.
- 22:48I love that. I look at the history. Yeah, this guy's in his mid 40s. He married somebody who
- 22:55was 23 a couple of years ago. It was super sketchy. They went over all the controversy in there.
- 23:00They talk about how he's clearly balding now and just like he tries to cover it up in terrible ways.
- 23:06They just got divorced him and his 23 year old wife. Super sketchy. Anyhow, it turns out they
- 23:12have quite a few YouTube personalities who have millions of followers like Mikey Chen who push
- 23:19Falun Gong things and that's through their new Tong Media group. I didn't know that the epoch
- 23:25times was owned by the Falun Gong and even if I didn't know, I didn't know the history of the
- 23:30Falun Gong. And so you put things where they're putting so much money into Facebook ads and doing
- 23:39deceptive things like that. They're going to get a big following and if they're just sharing things
- 23:45especially during COVID, it probably amassed a huge following just with that and that's where
- 23:52there's a huge problem with it. We should know all their journalists are producing like five
- 23:57articles a day. Not all of them are just pro-Trump. They have things that are relatively normal
- 24:04that distort people down their pipeline. Yeah. And then I mean you just kind of push the narrative.
- 24:10So it seems like they're just distributing them into society to just see what sticks to see.
- 24:16And then just I mean then you're just going to be reading articles or not even reading
- 24:21articles just being like yeah I read it in the epoch time. Yeah. Yeah. And yeah there's an entire
- 24:27media group behind it. The epoch times is not the only one. They also through this own
- 24:34New Tong Dynasty television which was on the air. I think it still is in Canada. It's offered
- 24:40through Roger's Cable. They also own the where is it. I had one more I needed to talk sound of hope
- 24:48which is a radio channel that this all goes through as well. But Chelsea now I do want to draw your
- 24:54attention to that top part and one of the things that's always pinned at the top of epoch times
- 25:00is up there and I want you to say what it is. Okay. I feel like we're looking at different
- 25:06page. Are we really. Yeah. Is it not on the Canadian version. Mine too looks like yours.
- 25:12No it's not. Interesting. I'm trying to delete Canada but it keeps bringing redirecting me back
- 25:18to oh no it keeps redirecting me back. That's okay it actually does show up here still.
- 25:24It's still like not in the same way on the Canadian version but there's always an article
- 25:30that on the front page about Shen Yun and Chelsea have you ever heard of Shen Yun. No but I have
- 25:37actually I haven't heard of it but I've seen it. As in you've seen advertisement correct.
- 25:42Not you've been to a show. I don't know maybe that's what I did I see it in China. No you didn't
- 25:49because remember Falun Gong is banned in China. Well I don't know they love Shen Yun apparently.
- 25:54No Chelsea actually on the on the Canadian version where it says feature Canadian news just below it.
- 26:00There's a bunch of Shen Yun. Yeah it will always be there no matter where you're watching it it
- 26:06will always be there. Right above there's an ad for Shen Yun that says special coverage underneath
- 26:12there's an article and then you can if you go I just. Chelsea can you read the article title.
- 26:17There's a sense of the divine in Shen Yun says California theater goer. Actually just click
- 26:23on the Seymour and read a few top vertical headlines. What the hell is this Shen Yun China before
- 26:30communism Wikipedia came up when I googled Shen Yun and what it just said was this makes me question
- 26:37what this is China before communism Shen Yun's London performances leave CEO in awe of Chinese
- 26:46history Shen Yun's presentation of classical Chinese dance astounds Kamikura audience.
- 26:52Shen Yun is truly good and inspiring says Marine Corps Lieutenant Colonel Shen Yun is very uplifting
- 27:00very spiritual says Emmy award winning filmmaker is that James Cameron. I don't think it is.
- 27:08This is weird look at this is like a very nice age find a show near you. Yeah and I knew about
- 27:15Shen Yun up until like probably a year ago I didn't realize there was a relationship with
- 27:19Alan Gong and I always thought it was like a Chinese equivalent of Cirque du Soleil like I saw the
- 27:24advertisements that's what I got from it but I did see these like weird because they always get like
- 27:30viewer reviews of it and they're just so oddly worded like there's a spiritual. I have to give
- 27:37you another one. Okay Mastercard VIP says he felt connected to God during Shen Yun. Okay these are
- 27:44all the nice reviews and then directly to the right Shen Yun faces unrelenting interference from
- 27:51Beijing in South Korea. Sorry one more one more Shen Yun performing arts wraps up 2023 world tour
- 27:59amidst audience praise and acclaim. I really like this one it's right near the top Shen Yun is
- 28:07built on the values of goodness and commitment to traditions says physician and you'll notice
- 28:13when we're telling you who give this review it's not the New York Times it's not the New Yorker it's
- 28:18not like any reputable reviewing company it is people who they say saw it and have really weirdly
- 28:24spiritual connections to it. So you can narrow it down on the side it says global review USA Canada
- 28:31Europe Asia Oceana Latin America I thought you could just choose like a review from Canada like
- 28:37Canada but if you open it you can do Calgary Edmonton Hamilton Kitchener and it's all over yeah
- 28:43Bremen Burgess like you can click on specific cities and it's the same thing all of these reviews
- 28:50of how amazing it is and life changing it. Yeah from Vancouver business owner Shen Yun makes you
- 28:56want to be a better person says Vancouver business owner. This is so you can narrow it down by your
- 29:02specific location in case anybody is curious what they're talking about in your location about Shen
- 29:08Yun. This is so weird. Like I said these aren't reviews from like actual reviewing companies
- 29:14who go to plays like this or performances like this. Yeah I found the New Yorkers review or at
- 29:21least somebody from the New Yorker who saw it and did an article in the New Yorker about it
- 29:25I just need to take out some highlights. Okay. After we took our seats two hosts with animatronic
- 29:30smiles speaking both Chinese and English began introducing a series of dances which were called
- 29:35things like goodness in the face of evil and the world divinely restored. The female dancer moved
- 29:40in hypnotic swirls the male dancers jumped and flipped behind the stage was an enormous screen
- 29:45upon which digital backdrops ancient temples royal gardens the cosmos appeared along with
- 29:50digital dancers who would walk to the bottom of the screen and then pop out via the appearance of
- 29:55a living dancer on the stage. Living wow. The colors were near neon and unnatural they reminded me
- 30:01of the glowing hues of photo hunt the tabletop bar game. The host started talking about a spiritual
- 30:07discipline called Falendafa and they then introduced a dance in which a beautiful young
- 30:12follower of Falendafa was kidnapped and is imprisoned by communists who harvested her organs.
- 30:18Whoa I'm hallucinating. I whispered to my brother in the dark.
- 30:22It keeps going. Do you have something to say though? Is this Falengong's dance company?
- 30:28It's exclusively Falengong's yes. Okay this makes a lot. I guess I don't know what I was
- 30:35thinking there but yes that does make sense. Okay it seems incredible though. Look at all these
- 30:41good reviews. Yep from every city. And you will see if you go on YouTube and try to find it you
- 30:47cannot find anything from the actual performance. They keep that incredibly hidden and all you will
- 30:53see are these reviews. I mean the reviews look great. Would everyone like to learn a little
- 31:00Chinese? One of the hosts asked. He intoned a phrase and asked the audience to repeat it.
- 31:04That phrase means I love Shengyun he said. I felt my forehead the dances continued. Sleeves swirling,
- 31:11skirts rippling. A man came on stage to sing a song in Chinese which was translated on the screen
- 31:15behind him. We follow Dafa the great way he began. Yeah he singing about a creator who
- 31:21said mankind and made the world anew. This is a quote from the actual play. Atheism and evolution
- 31:26are a deadly ideas. Modern trends destroy what makes us human he's saying. At the end of the song the
- 31:32row of older white people sitting behind me clapped fervently. In the final dance number a group of
- 31:37Falendafa followers who wore blue and yellow and clutched books of religious teachings battle for a
- 31:42space in public square with corrupt youth. The corruption was evident because they were wearing
- 31:47black looking at their cell phones and in the case of two men holding hands. Chairman now appeared
- 31:52and the sky turned black. The city in the digital backdrop was obliterated by an earthquake. Then
- 31:58finished off by a communist tsunami. A red hammer and sickle glowed in the center of the wave.
- 32:03Days I rubbed my eyes and saw a huge bearded face disappearing in the water. Was that? I said to my
- 32:09brother wondering if I needed to go to the hospital. Carl Marx he said yeah I think that tsunami was the
- 32:14face of Carl Marx. Shen Yun according to Shen Yun means the beauty of divine things dancing. It can
- 32:21be translated as the rhythm of a divine spirit or more simply God's melody. The Shen Yun performing
- 32:27arts organization was founded in 2006 in New York's Hudson Valley and put on its first touring show in
- 32:332007. By 2009 there were three touring Shen Yun companies. Today there are six companies each
- 32:39consisting of 40 or so dancers. All of them trained at the Feitian Academy which is situated at Dragon
- 32:46Springs in upstate New York. The dancers are accompanied by an orchestra that incorporates
- 32:51Chinese instruments. Each troupe includes about 80 people in addition to this 96 American cities it
- 32:56is touring this year. Shen Yun would also visit Vancouver, Berlin, Auckland, Taipei, Daigou
- 33:01and a dozen other places. Shen Yun is a non-profit. In 2016 it reported more than $75 million in
- 33:08assets and more than $22 million in revenue. Given the amount of money the organization seems to
- 33:13spend on advertising it's hard to believe that it could be in the black but the Guardian has
- 33:17reported that each city's Shen Yun advertising campaign is sponsored by the local Falendafa
- 33:22association. The ad blitzes are carefully coordinated. Shen Yun ads is basically a season on the
- 33:27calendar now. In January I decided to double check my Woozie memory and buy a ticket to see Shen Yun
- 33:32again in Lincoln Center and after the purchase went through I received a survey that asked me
- 33:36which of the 36 different versions of Shen Yun ads that ran into a New York. Newsday spots,
- 33:42Metro North posters, brochures, and mail had convinced me to buy tickets. Shen Yun's saturation
- 33:47has reached such a ludicrous intensity that it has in recent months become a meme. Part of the
- 33:53seeming strangeness of Shen Yun could be attributed to a latent orientalism on the part of Western
- 33:58viewers including those of us who are Asian descent but the real root of Shen Yun's meme-friendly
- 34:03eeriness is that the ads brightly and aggressively broadcast nothing at all. That's why it's so
- 34:08easy to imagine them popping up in Ebbing, Missouri or in the extended Blade Runner universe or on
- 34:13Mars. The ads have to be both ubiquitous and devoid of content so that they can convince more than
- 34:17a million people to pay good money to watch what it is, essentially religious political propaganda
- 34:23or more generously an extremely elaborate commercial for Falendafa's spiritual teachings and his
- 34:28plight vis-a-vis the Chinese Communist regime. The Chinese embassy for its part warrants the
- 34:33American public to stay away from the so-called Shen Yun performances of the Falun Gong Organization
- 34:38so as to avoid being deceived and used by the cults. I think I can end it there with that quote from the
- 34:43Embassy. This is bizarre that they have a dance company and so I saw they have some performances
- 34:49here in Vancouver and it's very weird I put reviews and it's all five-star reviews but then
- 34:56you go to Reddit. I just like this one somebody says has anyone actually gone to Shen Yun and it
- 35:05says I've seen so many ads I'm genuinely curious who has actually seen the performance and some
- 35:10guy commented that they've seen it twice and they're like why have you gone twice and he said it was
- 35:19a decade apart one of my kids wanted to go it's just religious propaganda and symbolism it's
- 35:26expensive too like I don't think you can get in there for under a hundred I just looked no it's
- 35:31a hundred dollars for the back and it's just people being like reminder Shen Yun is a cult it's the
- 35:37Falun Gong and you will see posters for it everywhere I saw one where I live in Kelowna a poster
- 35:42when I've been in Vancouver I've actually seen like the performers have to go out and like advertise
- 35:46it in malls like they'll just stand in the middle of the mall and hang out wired no I have seen it in
- 35:52a mall that's where I know it from I have just the mall right here yeah all the reviews where you
- 35:57can review TripAdvisor are all five-star amazing this is so weird yeah but like straight up
- 36:05cult propaganda if you see an advertisement for Shen Yun it is cult propaganda and all of the
- 36:11dancers are part of the cult and the ABC investigation that I talked about in the last episode
- 36:16one of the people who left the cult she was mixed race and had sexual thoughts about women so she's
- 36:23oh no that's bad for her she ran into huge problems with them but she also and this is part of the
- 36:28article I just want to read at this time master Lee was establishing the professional dance troupe
- 36:32known as Shen Yun Anna's mother encouraged her to train to be a Shen Yun dancer quote she thought
- 36:37that it was the highest honor possible and that it would guarantee me getting into heaven essentially
- 36:42end quote but Anna felt that she was not as gifted as the other dancers and then there was the incident
- 36:47at the summer dance camp in New Jersey Anna's teacher placed her in front of a mirror and lifted
- 36:52up her shirt quote she grabbed my stomach shook it and then turned to the other kids in the class
- 36:57there were several of them and she said do you see this everyone this is an example of how a woman
- 37:01should not look at the age of 13 Anna ended up hospitalized with anorexia and that's part of
- 37:06the reason she ended up leaving the cult wow not that they were good to begin with yeah and you know
- 37:11what I found these on it was the st. Louis subreddit and they said Shen Yun was coming through and I
- 37:17seen it this comes from macaroni incident it was posted in 2022 people think they're an amazing act
- 37:23their marketing is everywhere who wouldn't in reality they got a lot of their ads and free
- 37:27stuff by bugging the shit out of their companies for in-kind donations in the form of ad space
- 37:32because they will relentlessly ask until you give in I used to work for a nonprofit arts company we
- 37:36ended up letting them use one of our dance floors for free for their performance in our city they
- 37:41also got tens of thousands of dollars in ad space in our playbills management just wanted them out
- 37:46of their hair and then this one coming from pjamas 41 two years ago as well in 2022 I've done
- 37:51advertising business with them before they will low ball the hell out of you and push until they
- 37:57get a firm answer a few years ago I gave up and just said no haven't worked with them since so
- 38:01not exactly a great group to work with Chelsea were you able to find any one star reviews this one
- 38:06just says very bad performance is very unprofessional because I feel like this is a good way to end it
- 38:12jeez this is all about the staff is this actually Shenyun no I know I just noticed that it's all
- 38:19not it at all it's all about the theater itself I know same that's what I found so fortunately
- 38:25we're just gonna have to revive rely on the new yorker for their one star review although I think
- 38:30it might have irony level of like a four out of five stars but those are the ways that we've all
- 38:35have interactions with Fallon Gong that we didn't know crazy no I had no idea I hope that this at
- 38:42least gives you some sort of ammo the next time that family member tries to share a news article
- 38:48with you and you can say you know that was published by a cult right yeah or when someone's
- 38:53like I just want Shenyun I am actually just like mildly actually curious to go see a Shenyun
- 38:57performance but I do not want my money to actually go to them I know that's my exact train of thought
- 39:02that I just had in thinking about it I hope this has been useful this is a huge group and is still
- 39:08very active today I feel like it was necessary to take this time to focus on these people and
- 39:13nobody knows anything about them I appreciated it spanning three episodes it was a fun one yeah
- 39:19and I have been Taylor here with Chelsea we are Journey to the Fringe thank you all for listening
- 39:23and we'll see you next week bye thank you for listening to Journey to the Fringe if you have
- 39:30liked what you have listened to please like share subscribe or follow depending on what
- 39:37venue you are listening to us through also please if possible leave a five star review as that really
- 39:43helps us in the algorithms should you wish to interact with us please check us out on your
- 39:48social media of choice I bet you we are there and if you really want to communicate with us and
- 39:54give us ideas for new episodes or tell us that we're wrong and terrible either way please send
- 39:59us an email at Journey to the Fringe at gmail.com for now I'll see you in the next episode