Latest / The Vegan Report / The Case For Homeschooling. With Dr. Peter Gray | Reupload
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and welcome to The Vegan Report.
- 0:05In last week's episode, our guest Adam shared that he wanted to homeschool his son.
- 0:11A few years ago, I would have frowned at the idea of homeschooling.
- 0:16I would have thought of it as something very marginal, cultish, and even detrimental to
- 0:23the future prospects of any kids.
- 0:27But not anymore.
- 0:28Today, I think that the institution of school is what's detrimental to kids, to our mental
- 0:34health, to social cohesion, and even to democracy.
- 0:39And homeschooling, or any other alternative to schools, should be seriously considered
- 0:46by any responsible parent.
- 0:49Our guest today, Dr. Peter Gray, a research professor of psychology at Boston College,
- 0:56is the reason why my beliefs have so drastically shifted.
- 1:01His book, Free to Learn, has been hugely influential in shaping my views of school.
- 1:09In addition to getting the classic book Free to Learn, I invite you to subscribe to Dr.
- 1:14Gray's Substack.
- 1:16More details in the description of the episode.
- 1:19Peter, thank you so much for being here.
- 1:22Thank you for inviting me.
- 1:23I'm happy to be here.
- 1:25Of course.
- 1:26So let's dive right in.
- 1:29There is a crisis of mental health among younger people.
- 1:32I feel like everyone is aware of that at this point.
- 1:36We're talking about higher rates of anxiety, higher rates of depression, even sadly, higher
- 1:42rates of suicide.
- 1:44And every time someone mentions that issue, the great evil of social medias, and to a
- 1:50lesser extent, video games, will be blamed for that problem.
- 1:55And sure, let's be critical of social medias.
- 1:58I'm all about that.
- 1:59But I never heard someone mention schools as a probable cause.
- 2:05Yet if I think about my own experience, and I know it's anecdotal, but school was such
- 2:12a source of distress in my life.
- 2:14Because of school, I remember experiencing anxiety, episodes of depression, stress, shame,
- 2:21tiredness.
- 2:22So my first question for you, Peter, is what is the responsibility, if any, of schools
- 2:29in the current mental health crisis experienced by younger people?
- 2:35I like the way you introduced that question, because I think that one of the reasons that
- 2:42as a society, we want to blame computers, we want to blame social media, we want to
- 2:50blame anything else really other than school, because we think the school is just so absolutely
- 2:58essential.
- 3:00Everybody at school has a halo around it in so many people's minds.
- 3:06Anything else other than school lets blame for the huge crisis that we're finding among
- 3:12young people.
- 3:14But you know, if you ask young people, that's a new idea, right?
- 3:20Let's ask them what's bothering them, right?
- 3:23Instead of hypothesizing.
- 3:26So a few years ago, the American Psychological Association conducted a survey that they called
- 3:33Stress in America, and they surveyed people of all ages in the United States, asking them
- 3:40questions like, have you experienced severe stress?
- 3:46And they had some definition of severe stress over the past two weeks.
- 3:51And a number of other questions.
- 3:53The people who came out as the most stressed people in America were high school-aged students,
- 4:01more so than adults, more so than adults.
- 4:05Interestingly, when they asked this question during the summer, when school was not in
- 4:11session, the rate of saying that they had been highly stressed in the last two weeks
- 4:16was half what it was during the school year.
- 4:22When high school-aged students were asked the question, what is the primary source of
- 4:28your stress, 83% said school.
- 4:31Now isn't that interesting?
- 4:34This was done in 2014.
- 4:36It was published in a very small article by the American Psychological Association.
- 4:43As far as I know, no newspaper, no magazine ever picked that up.
- 4:49It simply was not relayed.
- 4:52You know, I've been publishing it on my site.
- 4:55I now have, I have actually a new article coming out in the Journal of Pediatrics that
- 5:01brings this to bear and other evidence.
- 5:04So not only that, but there are also several studies.
- 5:08We know that the suicide rate among school-aged children and teens is at record levels, way
- 5:15above, you know, it's like 10 times what it was 40 or 50 years ago.
- 5:20And this has been gradually increasing and it's at record levels.
- 5:26But again, suicides among school-aged children are the rate of them per month is twice as
- 5:32high when school is in session than when it's not in session.
- 5:37Twice.
- 5:38Twice as high according to some of the studies.
- 5:42And the suicide, you know, during COVID when people were isolated, everybody thought this
- 5:47was going to be a terrible time.
- 5:49The suicide rate among school-aged children went down.
- 5:53So the school, the suicide, suicides pretty much track schooling pretty well, you know,
- 6:00the evidence is glaring, absolutely glaring, but we don't want to admit it because we just,
- 6:08everybody thinks, everybody was predicting that during COVID the kids would be suffering
- 6:13because they're not in school.
- 6:16So that's the, that's the way we think about it.
- 6:19You know, it's got a halo around it.
- 6:22And school has, school is a much bigger source of distress in recent times than it was in
- 6:29the past.
- 6:31And the reason is because it truly is, first of all, it's taking much more of children's
- 6:37time than it did in the past.
- 6:38It's become, the school year is now five weeks longer than it was when I was a kid in the
- 6:451950s.
- 6:46The school day is longer in many, for many schools.
- 6:50But the biggest difference is homework for elementary school children.
- 6:54When I was in school many decades ago, there was no homework for elementary school children.
- 6:59Now even kindergartners have homework.
- 7:03So the school day doesn't end.
- 7:05When the school day ends, you're still doing school when you're back home again.
- 7:11The pressure of ever since No Child Left Behind in the United States, ever since the passage
- 7:18of that and the pushing for higher test scores, the pressure and the focus on drilling for
- 7:28tests, which is about the most boring, uninteresting thing you could possibly do is prepare for
- 7:34those multiple choice, you know, tests.
- 7:38I attest to that.
- 7:39It's horrible.
- 7:40And we now have the situation in the United States where teachers are being judged on
- 7:45the basis of those test scores.
- 7:47So of course they're spending lots of time on test scores.
- 7:50All kinds of other creative activity, which used to be kind of fun in school, writing
- 7:54essays and poems and putting on little plays and these kinds of things have largely been
- 8:01taken away for the sake of drilling for tests.
- 8:05Recesses have been in some schools completely eliminated and almost all schools greatly
- 8:11reduced from what they were before.
- 8:14So we have really changed the school environment in a way that's not that school was ever great.
- 8:23We've changed it in a way that it is worse, more stressful than it ever was before.
- 8:29One of the ways I sometimes put this to adults is that would you take, would you as an adult
- 8:39accept a job that's like school?
- 8:43Would you accept a job where you are being micromanaged throughout the day, where you
- 8:49are constantly being judged and evaluated and compared to your workmates?
- 8:55Who's better?
- 8:56Who is worse?
- 8:58Where you have to get permission to go to the bathroom?
- 9:02Where talking to your colleagues about the work you're doing would be called cheating?
- 9:08Would you accept a job like that?
- 9:11This is the worst kind of, this is a nightmare job for an adult and yet we require children
- 9:18to be in this kind of a setting.
- 9:24Well it resonates with me so much because I'm now a working adult and I understand that
- 9:33comparison to a deep level.
- 9:38What explains that halo you talked about around schools?
- 9:43Why is it this blind spot in people's conversation, minds, thoughts?
- 9:54For some reason, so first of all what we have to say is that school, along the lines that
- 10:04we know, although school has gotten worse, as I just described, we basically have school
- 10:10in a similar manner for several generations now.
- 10:15This has been going on so I went to school, my parents went to school, their parents went
- 10:23to school, I'm old enough so that the previous generation probably didn't go to school after
- 10:29that.
- 10:30So it would be younger people, it would be three or four generations of school.
- 10:35So you just think school is the key to growing up.
- 10:41The other thing is that this whole school system has adopted a language that's fundamentally
- 10:48deceiving and I don't think it's deliberately deceiving but it is deceiving.
- 10:53So for example, during COVID people were saying, because people were saying children need to
- 11:04get back to school for the sake of learning, right?
- 11:07So school becomes learning.
- 11:13People say should we have more recess or more learning?
- 11:20People say if we increase the summer vacation, as I've been arguing that we should, we would
- 11:26decrease learning.
- 11:27So learning, the word learning, which is a good word, we all need to learn.
- 11:33Learning has become equated with school.
- 11:36Learning quite properly has a halo around it, right?
- 11:40We all need to learn and we all need to be educated, we all need education.
- 11:46But we've confounded learning and education with school as if that's the only place it
- 11:51occurs.
- 11:52We've forgotten that children learn a huge amount of what they're ever going to know
- 12:00before they ever start school.
- 12:03They learn their entire native language, they learn a huge amount about the world around
- 12:08them.
- 12:11So learning is going on more rapidly than it does once they start school.
- 12:16And so we've got to get over this idea that school is learning.
- 12:22School is a certain kind of training in certain kinds of things and yeah, there's a little
- 12:28bit of learning that goes on.
- 12:30But most of what all of us learn, we learn outside of school.
- 12:36And so we've got to get away from that kind of language.
- 12:38We've got to get away from this idea that school is so essential.
- 12:42The other thing we kind of, you know, it's like we sort of, we almost turned teachers
- 12:49into saints.
- 12:50I like teachers.
- 12:51Most teachers are good people, but they're not in a good system.
- 12:55But we have this view that, you know, that if you're a teacher, you're just kind of a,
- 13:01you know, a saint.
- 13:03And if we're blaming schools, then we're blaming teachers.
- 13:06And so that's another part of it, I think.
- 13:10So I just, I think that the part of the problem is as a society, if we were to admit what
- 13:21we should know, if we were to admit the facts that school is driving a lot of kids crazy,
- 13:29that school is a huge part of the cause of the mental health crisis among young people,
- 13:37what would we do about it?
- 13:41Are we ready to really change in a serious way?
- 13:45Are we really ready to, you know, school has come to serve so many purposes.
- 13:51It's babysitting.
- 13:52It's, you know, it's keeping teenagers off the job market when there's not too many jobs
- 14:01available.
- 14:02It's serving, it's serving various social roles.
- 14:05And it's also serving a discriminatory function because wealthier people do well better in
- 14:12school than poor people.
- 14:13You can't discriminate against somebody because they're poor, but you can discriminate against
- 14:18somebody if they didn't do as well in school.
- 14:20So this is, school is serving a lot of societal purposes in addition to the purported purpose
- 14:32of education.
- 14:34So I think that it would just be a huge step.
- 14:38On the other hand, it wouldn't be such a huge step to say, well, let's at least try to turn
- 14:46back the tide of what's happened in school.
- 14:49Let's try to go back a little bit to where schools were 30 or 40 years ago where we,
- 14:54the school year wasn't as long, where the school day wasn't long.
- 14:58Let's reduce homework instead of increase it.
- 15:01Let's do away with standardized tests.
- 15:04Let's give teachers more authority in the classroom because most teachers are decent
- 15:09people and they will change the curriculum to fit what the kids need and what they're
- 15:13interested in to the degree that they can.
- 15:16Not that they can totally solve that problem if you've got 30 kids in your class, you can't
- 15:21please everybody, but you can at least move in that direction if you have authority to.
- 15:26But these days teachers are, I've heard teachers tell me I'm no more free than the kids.
- 15:33This is the curriculum I've got to teach.
- 15:36My response to them always is, well, that's not true because you're free to quit and the
- 15:40teachers are not and the kids are not.
- 15:43But as long as they're in that job, as long as they feel they have to be in that job,
- 15:49there's truth in what they're saying.
- 15:52Yes.
- 15:53And I think part of it is an American phenomenon because if we look at Europe, for instance
- 16:00France, the school year I think is shorter, you have more vacations and that is reflected
- 16:06with work too because in European countries workers have longer vacation time than American
- 16:17workers.
- 16:19Okay, so in your book Free to Learn, you attribute seven cents to school so you go into the consequences
- 16:30of having that system.
- 16:33And again, let's be clear, we're not blaming the teachers.
- 16:39I survived school because of a few teachers who were truly interested in my success in
- 16:48creating a relationship with me and I'm really grateful for them.
- 16:52We're talking about the institution, we're talking about that system.
- 16:57And the number one sin goes at the heart of the problem, school's pause, which is no freedom.
- 17:09We're attacking the freedom of kids.
- 17:12And you talk about how school is actually euphemism for prison.
- 17:17So could you please talk about this in more details?
- 17:23Yeah, I wouldn't exactly say that it's a euphemism for prison, but school is a kind of prison.
- 17:34Think about it.
- 17:35I mean, first of all, the children have no choice about being there.
- 17:40If they have very enlightened parents who have the capacity, whether it's the economic
- 17:47capacity or the time capacity to homeschool them or to find some kind of an alternative,
- 17:54a democratic school they could go to.
- 17:57But for most kids, there's really no choice.
- 18:00They don't, they're there.
- 18:02They're there for, they can say as much as they want, I don't want to go to school, but
- 18:10they have to go to school.
- 18:12They're being forced to go.
- 18:14So that's the first part.
- 18:15And then once they're there, they are, as I said, they are, they are, they are told
- 18:23exactly what to do, exactly where they have to have to be.
- 18:28What we think of in America as basic human rights are taken away.
- 18:34Free speech, freedom of assembly to get together with whoever you please, you know, pursue
- 18:40your own interests.
- 18:43These things, the right to trial by jury, if you're accused of due process, if you're
- 18:48accused of some wrongdoing, these are totally taken away from children when they're in school.
- 18:55You don't have a right to defend yourself.
- 18:58You don't have any way to defend yourself, any due process if you've been blamed for
- 19:04something.
- 19:05So you are, you are really in a prison like situation.
- 19:09There was a film done quite some years ago called The War on Kids in which what the filmmaker
- 19:17did is he went, he filmed, he went through a big city school, high school, and he filmed
- 19:26what was going on.
- 19:27He filmed what a typical day was like.
- 19:30He filmed, he filmed the, you know, the metal detectors in the school that the kids had
- 19:38to go through.
- 19:41And he, and the fact that they could, they were not free to leave their classroom and
- 19:47so on and so forth.
- 19:48And then he went through a maximum security prison, a real prison.
- 19:54And at the end of that film, you felt if you had to be in one or the other, you would rather
- 19:59be in the prison.
- 20:01They could go to the library whenever they wanted.
- 20:05They had more time out in the exercise yard for recess than kids had.
- 20:10Now granted, you know, kids do go home at a certain time.
- 20:16But while you're there, this is constraining even more than a prison is.
- 20:22You're not free to decide what you want to read.
- 20:25You're not free to decide what, who you want to talk with.
- 20:29You're not free to go out and play when you want to go out and play.
- 20:34You're, you are really being controlled.
- 20:38So that's what I mean when I say that school is a prison.
- 20:43And there is also the monitoring part.
- 20:45You have no privacy in school.
- 20:47You're always watched.
- 20:49You have no privacy in school.
- 20:51And while we're saying that it's worth pointing out that it's more and more true that children
- 20:57have no privacy anywhere.
- 21:00You know, I think this is a huge part of the mental health problem that we all need privacy.
- 21:06We all need time alone.
- 21:08We all need time just with our peers when there's no authority figures overseeing us.
- 21:14So children, not only are they increasingly imprisoned in school, but when they're out
- 21:22of school, they're more or less under sort of home lockup.
- 21:27You know, there is kind of a home in prison because at least in the United States, we
- 21:33have become so paranoid about the possibility that children could be kidnapped or something
- 21:40awful could happen if children are allowed to run free, even if teenagers are allowed
- 21:44to run free.
- 21:45This is another part of the change that's occurred.
- 21:49So not only are children's time being taken up more and more with schoolwork, but even
- 21:54when they do have free time, they're not allowed to just go out and play and explore as they
- 22:00used to.
- 22:01They're not allowed to just get together with their friends without some adult around.
- 22:06And more and more, they're put, you know, they go off to some kind of adult directed
- 22:13sports rather than just going out to play or some kind of adult directed activity, which
- 22:18are again is school like.
- 22:19And so they're constantly under surveillance by adults as opposed to and constantly being
- 22:28in a situation where somebody else would correct them if they're doing something wrong.
- 22:32You're not allowed to make mistakes.
- 22:34You know, I really believe that part of growing up is making mistakes and correcting them
- 22:43yourself, learning from your own mistakes, that misbehavior even is part of growing up.
- 22:52You need to misbehave a little bit.
- 22:55It's the perfect time.
- 22:57You need to be able to talk with your peers about this without your adult, your parents
- 23:02finding out about it or without some other authority figures, adult authority figures.
- 23:07But now young people are so constantly monitored, constantly that that is that they don't really
- 23:16have private time.
- 23:18And then we blame them for going on social media, which is the only place where they
- 23:22can get together with others without or some in some sense on the computer, whether they're
- 23:30texting one another or they're doing we think that we think is so shameful that they're
- 23:34spending so much time in the community.
- 23:36Well, why are they doing that?
- 23:37There was a there was a survey done a number of years ago in which the author of this book
- 23:46was originally done as a doctoral dissertation, interviewed hundreds of teenagers across the
- 23:52country on why they're why they're on on the computer so much interacting with other kids,
- 24:00other kids rather than interacting in person.
- 24:03And the basic response was we're not allowed to get together in person.
- 24:06This is the only way we can get together.
- 24:09And we need to get together in a way that that is private from adults.
- 24:15And so that's why they're doing it.
- 24:18And as soon as their adults, you know, they might have been on Facebook, but as soon as
- 24:23their parents are on Facebook, they're off of Facebook onto something else.
- 24:29It feels like a dictatorship.
- 24:31I feel like you're describing the dictatorship.
- 24:36Another component, another characteristic that you describe about school is sin number
- 24:44four, which is an unquote judging students in ways that foster shame, hubris, cynicism
- 24:52and cheating.
- 24:54You make the point that we teach children that their worth is determined based on others'
- 24:59judgments through class, rank or grades.
- 25:03And you mentioned that earlier.
- 25:05And when the value is placed on grading, rather than learning, cheating becomes a preferable
- 25:11option because it's more about scoring big than learning something new.
- 25:18What you are describing here is a violent system of competition.
- 25:22And I'm worried about what kind of adults will come out of this.
- 25:27I've seen students go as far as taking drugs like Adderall.
- 25:35And I mean, without a prescription to get a nudge in the classroom.
- 25:39I've also witnessed students displaying like an obsession with their success or lack of
- 25:46success and their self image and self esteem.
- 25:51And as I witnessed that, I wondered, is it how you create a narcissist, basically?
- 25:57I know that you wrote about this subject.
- 26:00So what exactly is the impact of school in adulthood?
- 26:07Because those children are going to grow up.
- 26:10And I know you don't like the word grow up.
- 26:18So I think that what school you're absolutely right.
- 26:22School is we have turned what we call education into a competition.
- 26:30And I think that I think that essentially all students, students are not stupid.
- 26:35They realize that what is important to the adults, what they have to do in order to beat
- 26:45this system is get high grades.
- 26:49It has even the best students.
- 26:51If you talk to them, they'll say this has really very little to do with learning.
- 26:56This has to do with knowing how to get high grades.
- 27:01And there are certain rules.
- 27:03This kind of and you know, the best students will say, you know, I've learned to play the
- 27:06game, right?
- 27:07The game.
- 27:08And I'm all for games, but this is a game that they didn't choose to play.
- 27:13This is a game they're being required to be in.
- 27:16And it's and it's a game that's taking an enormous amount of time, an enormous toll on
- 27:21their lives.
- 27:23But basically, it's a game of can you score higher than other people on the tests and
- 27:29that way get an A, you know, or if you're at the lower level, can you score high enough
- 27:35so you pass so you eventually get out of this system?
- 27:39Right.
- 27:40And I think every kid learns certainly by the time they're in fourth or fifth grade.
- 27:50What you need to do is you need to cram this information into your head long enough to
- 27:56take the test.
- 27:57Then you can forget it.
- 27:59Right.
- 28:00You learn it in a superficial way.
- 28:03You learn it.
- 28:05You learn just as much as you need to know to get whatever the grade is.
- 28:09You feel you need to get on the test and that's it.
- 28:13It would be a waste of time to really delve into something because you're not being tested
- 28:20on actual real deep knowledge.
- 28:23You're just being tested on this kind of shallow memorized information or ability to if it's
- 28:30arithmetic or math, the ability to carry out these calculations.
- 28:34You don't have to understand why they work.
- 28:35You don't have to really know it.
- 28:37You just have to remember the system for doing it.
- 28:43And whatever it is, you are learning in this shallow way and then you're forgetting about
- 28:49it.
- 28:50Now, every student knows that, all right, so if you write this information into your
- 28:58brain long enough for the test, that's legitimate.
- 29:01That's within the rules of the game.
- 29:03If you were to write this information on the cuff of your shirt or on a piece of paper
- 29:10that you stuck up your sleeve, that would be cheating.
- 29:14But I think every student knows that there's a fine difference between those two things.
- 29:20And is it really cheating to do that?
- 29:23Who are you cheating?
- 29:24Everybody wants a high grade.
- 29:26Your parents want you to get a high grade and so on and so forth.
- 29:29So the whole idea of cheating becomes, you know, this is not really cheating.
- 29:37This is just because this is just a hoop I'm going through.
- 29:40It's a meaningless hoop I'm going through.
- 29:42I'm just giving myself a little extra help to go through the hoop.
- 29:45Well, where does that stop?
- 29:49And where does this idea, the other thing that's, see, I believe that we human beings
- 29:57are naturally, if we allow ourselves to be naturally playful.
- 30:03And what playful means is that we do things, including learn things, because we want to,
- 30:10because we're motivated to, because it's fun to do it, because it's meaningful to do it,
- 30:14and so on and so forth.
- 30:16But school takes that all away.
- 30:19In school, we're not allowed to follow our own interests.
- 30:22We're not allowed to do the things that we want to do, to learn the things that we want
- 30:26to do, at the time that we want to learn them, in the way that we want to learn them.
- 30:31So we're forced to do it in this other way.
- 30:34And the motivation for doing it in this other way has nothing to do with any kind of intrinsic
- 30:40sense of I have accomplished what I personally want to accomplish.
- 30:47It has to do with rewards from the outside world.
- 30:50I have pleased my teacher.
- 30:52I have pleased my parents.
- 30:54I have gotten this material reward of a high grade, and that's going to be my ticket maybe
- 31:01to go on to college.
- 31:03And then if I get high grades there, maybe that'll be my ticket for the next event.
- 31:08So what school is doing is teaching us to work for extrinsic rewards, rather than because
- 31:18it's something that's really meaningful and interesting to us.
- 31:23And then I think that persists through life.
- 31:26So once you are finished with school, now what is the measure of your worth?
- 31:37In a sense, the grade becomes sort of the measure of your worth.
- 31:40I've proven to all these people that I can do this.
- 31:44I think once you leave school, the measure of your worth becomes are you in what society
- 31:52regards as a high prestigious job, and are you earning a lot of money?
- 32:00I remember one time, I'm no longer teaching, but back when I was teaching in college, I
- 32:06would sometimes meet with my advisees as a group, and I would ask them questions like,
- 32:15so what are you thinking of going on into once you finish college?
- 32:21And they would tell me things like, oh, I'm thinking I want to be a doctor, or I'm thinking
- 32:25I want to be a lawyer, or I want to be a business executive, or whatever it is, they would tell
- 32:31me.
- 32:32And then completely independently of that, at some other point, I would say, so I'm interested,
- 32:38when you have free time, what is it that you really like to do?
- 32:42And maybe the one who said, I really want to be a doctor, would say, well, I really
- 32:46love the woods.
- 32:47I like hiking out in the woods.
- 32:49And the one maybe who wanted to be a lawyer said, I like little kids.
- 32:53I like to be around little kids.
- 32:54I like to play with little kids, and so on and so forth.
- 32:57And then at some point, I would say, so to the one who wanted to be a doctor, I'd say,
- 33:01so you really like to be out in the woods.
- 33:04Why don't you want to be a forest ranger?
- 33:07You know, a doctor, you're not going to get out in the woods much.
- 33:11You're going to have very little time for me in the woods.
- 33:14And the one who wants to be a lawyer, I say, you know, why don't you, you know, we need
- 33:19really good, kind nursery school teachers.
- 33:22Why don't you want to do that?
- 33:24And they would feel like I had insulted them because I'm suggesting a lower level job to
- 33:29them that would be fun for them and interesting to them.
- 33:32But it would rank them in society's eyes as lower.
- 33:37And sometimes I would talk about, you know, people would say, well, I need to have a high
- 33:42income.
- 33:43And I'd talk about, well, why do you need to have a high income?
- 33:45How much you really need to make in order to fulfill the needs that you that are real
- 33:52needs for you to be happy.
- 33:55And I'd point out that, you know, once you have there's actually data on this.
- 33:59Once you once you have enough money to satisfy certain basic needs, after that, there's no
- 34:05relationship between income and happiness.
- 34:07So why have why why strive for why break your neck for higher income?
- 34:12Why struggle for that?
- 34:13Why is that even important?
- 34:14I think it's only important because it's a status symbol.
- 34:18So so we create people growing up who are working for status symbols, working for the
- 34:28the recognition of achievement from other people rather than their own internal sense
- 34:36of this would be great fun.
- 34:38This would be meaningful to me.
- 34:40This would be something that I feel I'm really doing something for the world.
- 34:45And there is also a financial incentive to that competition because there there are scholarships
- 34:52and that's scholarships are often seen as something great.
- 34:58And I've benefited from them.
- 35:00So I'm not here to complain.
- 35:02But I did notice that often scholarships are given to people who have the means, you know,
- 35:11to put time and efforts in their studies and not have like a part time job or something
- 35:17like that.
- 35:18So there is a social inequality component to to that.
- 35:22And then if you don't get good enough grades, you don't get the scholarship, which is unfair
- 35:30because you should get the scholarship in order to finance your efforts to get better
- 35:38grades.
- 35:39It's very twisted the way we think about this.
- 35:43Yeah, I think that that's true to the degree that's true.
- 35:47Some colleges, universities, the way they do this financial aid is if you get accepted
- 35:54and if you are financially needy, then they supplement, then they give you financial aid.
- 36:00That's the way I think it should be done, not scholarships based on the set.
- 36:04There should be a separate decision.
- 36:06Have you done well enough to be accepted or not?
- 36:08And then if you're accepted, do you need financial aid or not?
- 36:15And some schools do it that way.
- 36:19Yeah, so we talking about the violence of competition, there is also a more explicit
- 36:28form of violence I associated with school.
- 36:32I recently watched Real Time with Bill Maher and he was having a conversation with the
- 36:38famous David Sedaris and they were talking about how children were problematic.
- 36:45And Bill Maher said children are feral and they need adults to civilize them.
- 36:52They're different than they used to be.
- 36:54They're I mean, they're naturally feral.
- 36:57I mean, it's true.
- 37:01We all read Lord of the Flies, right?
- 37:03What did we get out of that book?
- 37:06Kids are feral.
- 37:07They have to be civilized by adults.
- 37:11And then David Sedaris responded, half joking that corporal punishment had some virtues
- 37:19and might we might benefit from a comeback from corporal punishment.
- 37:24I feel like a lot of people who say that they're wounded or offended by something don't when
- 37:30they were never hit by their parents.
- 37:32So I think it's true.
- 37:35I know people who have never ever hit their hit their children and so they don't know
- 37:41what pain is really.
- 37:42But I think that if you don't want to hit your kids, then that's fine.
- 37:47Of course, that's fine.
- 37:48But other people should be allowed to.
- 37:50And I was astonished by that discussion.
- 37:54I kept wondering where are those ideas coming from?
- 37:59Let's talk about the history of schools.
- 38:04Schools did not always exist.
- 38:06When and why did schools appear?
- 38:08How did people manage to get an education before schools?
- 38:12And how did this other contempt for children was born in our society?
- 38:21Yeah.
- 38:22So, well, first of all, the schools as we know them for the masses really began to appear
- 38:38as part of the Protestant Reformation.
- 38:43I mean, going as far back as the 17th century, there began to be some Protestant schools.
- 38:53They were developed especially in the German state of Prussia initially, but then they
- 38:58began to spread to other places.
- 39:01Even the colonies in the United States, what became the United States, the American colonies
- 39:08had Protestant schools.
- 39:11And in Massachusetts where I live, schools became more or less compulsory already back
- 39:18in the 1700s and even in the 1600s.
- 39:25And they were run by the Protestant churches of the local town.
- 39:32And the reason for compelling children to go to them is because the Protestant religions
- 39:41of that time believed that we were all going to hell unless we were saved.
- 39:51And the way you become saved is by learning the Bible.
- 39:56And unlike the Catholics, they believed that it's important for every person to read the
- 40:01Bible themselves.
- 40:03Hence learning how to read became part of school.
- 40:08And the other thing, of course, even more important than reading the Bible is believing
- 40:13it.
- 40:17And equally important to that is obedience, obedience to authority.
- 40:23So the whole system of theology is a hierarchical system.
- 40:34God is at the top.
- 40:39And we human beings, our job is to follow God's commands, follow God's orders.
- 40:46And within the Catholic church, the hierarchy spreads itself all the way down through the
- 40:50pope and the bishops and so on and so forth.
- 40:52But the Protestants said each person has to get the word directly from God and that they
- 40:58do that through the Bible.
- 41:01But the Protestants still held to the view that obedience to authority on earth is very,
- 41:06very important.
- 41:08So schools were developed really for three purposes.
- 41:13One, for those children who couldn't read or were growing up in families that couldn't
- 41:18read so that they would know how to read, so that they would be able to read the Bible.
- 41:24In the American colonies, the reader that children learned from was called the Little
- 41:29Bible of New England colloquially.
- 41:31It's basically Bible passages and little ditties about how if you lie to your parents, you'll
- 41:37go to hell and burn forever and so forth.
- 41:41This is what little children were learning to read on.
- 41:49But these were the first schools that looked like schools today in the sense that there
- 41:53was a school master, they were called a master at that time, standing in front, giving them
- 41:58lessons and then the children had to feed it back.
- 42:01One of the things we know about indoctrination is the way you indoctrinate people is making
- 42:06them repeat the same thing over and over.
- 42:09Make them memorize it, make them say it over and over and over again.
- 42:14And that was how biblical indoctrination was occurring through the schools.
- 42:20The way at that time that you enforced children to do these things was not so much by shame
- 42:28and embarrassment as we do today, it was by literally beating them.
- 42:32If you didn't get it right, if you made mistakes, you might be beaten with a stick.
- 42:37So that was the way schools began and the clear purpose of schools, it didn't have really
- 42:44anything to do with education in the sense of learning the things you really need to
- 42:48know.
- 42:49There was not even any pretense that this had anything to do with learning the things
- 42:53you need to know to live an adult life, to do your job, to be a good citizen in other
- 42:58senses other than the religious sense.
- 43:01It was all about saving souls, keeping people from being sinful.
- 43:08To many of the Protestants, play itself is sinful.
- 43:13Play is the devil's work.
- 43:17Children are born in sin.
- 43:19So this idea that children are naturally sinful, this was part of the Protestant beliefs at
- 43:24that time.
- 43:25Fortunately, most Protestants don't feel that way today, but that was the origin of a lot
- 43:30of the Protestant beliefs, so that was the origin of schools.
- 43:35So we've got to keep that in mind.
- 43:36Now, the other thing in terms of your question about, well, what about before there were
- 43:41schools?
- 43:43First of all, throughout most of human history, of course, there were no schools, and yet
- 43:48people have become educated throughout history.
- 43:55There is actually good evidence that before there were schools, both in Europe and in
- 44:02America, most people could read, most children could read, most children learned to read
- 44:09at home.
- 44:11It was well understood that if you were growing up in a literate family, if your parents could
- 44:17read, you would read.
- 44:19Every kid learned how to read from their parents.
- 44:21It's not hard to learn how to read.
- 44:23Today, homeschooling kids learn to read from their parents without any particular training
- 44:27even.
- 44:28They just pick it up.
- 44:29Go ahead.
- 44:30That's very surprising to hear because we have this impression that our ancestors without
- 44:38schools were just those ignorant peasants and they had no idea of what a book is.
- 44:47Right.
- 44:48Think about the time.
- 44:49First of all, almost everybody had a Bible and they could read the Bible.
- 44:57What schools I think were not so much interested in whether people could read or not, they
- 45:03were concerned.
- 45:05I think that the school personnel, people who started schools were more concerned that
- 45:09people were reading the wrong things.
- 45:12People were reading Thomas Paine's revolutionary writings.
- 45:20People were reading works that were going to stir up the masses because the masses really
- 45:28… There's even evidence in the United States that at the time of slavery, it was illegal
- 45:35to teach blacks reading, to teach black kids reading, but yet a very high percentage of
- 45:42slaves could read.
- 45:44They picked it up.
- 45:47Some of them who wrote by autobiographies later on talked about how they would bribe
- 45:51the white kid to teach them letters and then they learned to read.
- 46:00It's not that hard to learn to read.
- 46:02I studied children who were growing up outside of school in unschooling and in democratic
- 46:07schools where reading is not taught.
- 46:09They all learned to read, not all at the same age.
- 46:13They learned at various ages when they get interested in it, but reading is not hard.
- 46:20If you compare reading to learning your oral language, you're learning an enormous amount
- 46:26when you learn to speak a language.
- 46:28Reading is just taking a code and turning that into a code, a fairly simple code.
- 46:37Anybody can learn it unless they're blocked about it.
- 46:42We make reading hard in schools.
- 46:46We make it hard because we want everybody to learn at the same age, in the same way,
- 46:53at the same time, whether or not they have any interest in reading at that time.
- 46:59We give them readers that 90% of the kids have zero interest in.
- 47:07When you are interested in reading and when you're reading for meaning and you want to
- 47:12read, you learn how to read.
- 47:13The kids outside of school who learn how to read, they see how they learn how to read.
- 47:18They learn how to read.
- 47:19They don't start off learning how to read by learning the phonics.
- 47:23They start off by reading certain words that are important to them.
- 47:28A lot of kids these days are learning to read on the computer.
- 47:32They're playing video games.
- 47:33There's a word on the screen.
- 47:35They need to know that word in order to play the game.
- 47:39They pick up words and at some point they've picked up enough words that they kind of even
- 47:44unconsciously infer the grammar, infer the phonetics.
- 47:50This word cat and this word hat, they have a similar sound.
- 47:55They also look similar.
- 47:58This is the difference.
- 47:59A-T, that's the at part.
- 48:03The difference here is in this first letter.
- 48:05They make this assumption.
- 48:06They don't have to be taught that.
- 48:08They pick it up at some point after they've learned enough sight words.
- 48:16In school, that system doesn't work of picking up words because you have to be interested
- 48:21in what you're reading for that to happen.
- 48:23In school, you're forcing kids to read who aren't interested in reading and you're forcing
- 48:28them on material that they're not interested in.
- 48:31The only way you can teach them is the mechanical way of making them sound out the letters and
- 48:37sound out words and it becomes a mechanical thing.
- 48:42That really slows the process down.
- 48:44I also think that that becomes a source of what we call dyslexia because you're creating
- 48:51reading blocks in people by doing that.
- 48:55I never thought about this.
- 48:58There are also relatively high rates of illiteracy.
- 49:04School isn't, like you said, even doing a good job at teaching kids how to read and
- 49:09write.
- 49:12I think the worst thing you can do to a writer is make their book required in school.
- 49:21Children will hate it.
- 49:23I know that I picked up books that I had read in schools and I hated them, but now as an
- 49:29adult I find a new appreciation for those books.
- 49:38Still on reading, I did an informal study a few years ago where I invited people who
- 49:49are homeschooling or unschooling their children.
- 49:54I did a search for people who had a child who had been diagnosed with dyslexia while
- 50:01in school and who then took the child out of school for homeschooling or unschooling.
- 50:09I asked the question, did the child subsequently learn how to read and if so, how did that
- 50:16happen?
- 50:18I had about 60 responses to that, if I remember right.
- 50:26It wasn't really that many.
- 50:27It was something like 15 responses.
- 50:33Essentially what all of them said was, yes, my child learned how to read, but not right
- 50:39away.
- 50:41My child was terrified about reading when I took him out of school.
- 50:44He was terrified.
- 50:46Reading was scary.
- 50:47He didn't want to have anything to do with reading.
- 50:50The child had been diagnosed with dyslexia, but what the parents recognized was that this
- 50:55is not a cognitive problem.
- 50:57This is an emotional problem.
- 50:59This child has been terrorized in school about reading.
- 51:05Think about it.
- 51:07For whatever reason, maybe reading comes a little more difficult to you.
- 51:11I can identify with this.
- 51:12I was a late reader in school and I hated reading out loud in front of the other kids
- 51:17and the teacher.
- 51:18It was terrible.
- 51:21Because school wasn't as pressured, I didn't suffer as much as kids might today as a result
- 51:25of that.
- 51:29Then you begin to feel like I'm stupid, I can't read, I hate reading, I don't want to
- 51:34have anything to do with reading.
- 51:37At some point by third grade or so and you're still not reading, it's really interfering
- 51:42with your ability to do school and you get this diagnosis of dyslexia and then experts
- 51:48try to work with you who are supposed to be experts on dyslexia, at least if they've got
- 51:53such experts there, with various ranges of results.
- 51:59What essentially every one of these parents said is, at first I tried to teach reading
- 52:06but my kid would have nothing to do with it.
- 52:08So I finally gave up and I said, when and if you're ever ready to learn to read, that's
- 52:16up to you.
- 52:18What they all said is, at some point the child decided I'm ready to read.
- 52:23Some of the children basically taught themselves.
- 52:25They didn't need any help from the parents.
- 52:27Some of them asked for some help, but once they were ready to read, they learned to read.
- 52:33There was nothing wrong with their brains that made it cognitively impossible for them
- 52:37to read.
- 52:38This is a myth that we've developed that dyslexia is due to some kind of abnormality in the
- 52:45brain.
- 52:46There may be differences in the brain, in different ways that people learn to read,
- 52:49different ways people interact.
- 52:52The usual way to solve this problem of differences is let people choose their own way.
- 52:58People know better.
- 52:59The kid knows much better than any expert what works for him or her.
- 53:05You just have to let the kid do it.
- 53:08That's amazing to hear.
- 53:11It's a good segue for my next question.
- 53:14I'm thinking about the parents who are out listening and they're wondering, what can
- 53:19I do?
- 53:21What is the alternative?
- 53:23If school is that bad for my kid, what are my options exactly?
- 53:32It partly depends on where you live, but in the United States, homeschooling is easy to
- 53:38do and is completely legal.
- 53:41Large numbers, increasing numbers of families are homeschooling.
- 53:48The most recent poll, 11% of families with school-aged children in the United States
- 53:55are homeschooling at least one of their children.
- 53:59That's a huge number.
- 54:00A lot of that increase occurred as a result of COVID, but most of the people who started
- 54:05homeschooling then are staying with it.
- 54:07Before COVID, it was about 5% of families.
- 54:11More than double during COVID.
- 54:14As more and more people are doing it, it becomes more and more acceptable to do it.
- 54:19There are more and more resources for doing it.
- 54:22There's more and more opportunities for getting kids together who are homeschoolers so they
- 54:27have social groups.
- 54:28More and more opportunity for parents who are doing this to get reinforcement from other
- 54:33parents for doing it.
- 54:36The homeschoolers that I've been most interested in and have conducted research on are those
- 54:42who call themselves unschoolers.
- 54:44They are not trying to do school at home.
- 54:48They are rather allowing their child to direct his or her own education and they're facilitating
- 54:56it.
- 54:58You know how I said that children learn so much before they ever start school?
- 55:02They're just basically allowing the children to continue that.
- 55:07Children get interested in things.
- 55:08They read about things when they're interested.
- 55:10Once they know how to read, they get involved in building things.
- 55:14They get involved in exploring.
- 55:16Children are naturally curious.
- 55:18They're naturally playful.
- 55:20They're curious and their curiosity leads them to want to understand and know things.
- 55:25Their playfulness leads them to play at things where they're developing skills.
- 55:32So they're just allowing that to occur.
- 55:36My colleague Gina Riley and I did a study a few years ago of grown unschoolers.
- 55:43So these are people who didn't go to school growing up and they weren't homeschooled.
- 55:47They were legally homeschooled, but they were allowed to pursue their own interests.
- 55:54We identified 75 such people and we found they were doing very well in the world.
- 55:58If they wanted to go on to higher education, they were going on.
- 56:02They were in all kinds of careers.
- 56:04They were happy with their lives.
- 56:06So here's people in our world today who are not doing anything that looks like school
- 56:11during what we think of as their kindergarten through 12th grade years.
- 56:16And yet they're doing very well as adults.
- 56:18They're clearly educated by any meaningful definition of education.
- 56:23They believe they're more responsible, that they're happier, that they're in careers that
- 56:29they love because they were allowed to take charge of their own life as they were growing
- 56:36up.
- 56:37The other thing is that there are schools for self-directed education.
- 56:47In some cases these are certified schools, so they're legally schools.
- 56:54But at the extreme case, such as the Sudbury Valley School where my own son was a student
- 57:00many years ago, there are no courses being offered.
- 57:07Kids can get together and create a course if they want, but that doesn't happen very
- 57:10often.
- 57:11So you've got kids there from age four through what we think of as high school age, not segregated
- 57:19by age.
- 57:20They're interacting.
- 57:22All the rights that I said that children are deprived of in typical schools, they've still
- 57:27got here.
- 57:28They've got the right to free speech, right of free association, right to go wherever
- 57:33they want on campus, and the right to vote on any rules that affect them.
- 57:38So all the school rules are made by a school meeting.
- 57:41This is a democratic society for children.
- 57:47Staff members also have an adult, but the number of students greatly outweighs the staff
- 57:51members.
- 57:52It never is this case, but if it was ever the staff versus the students, the students
- 57:57would win on any vote.
- 58:01So this is a radically alternative school.
- 58:04The school that my son went to has been in existence now for 54 years.
- 58:08It has got hundreds and hundreds of graduates who are doing well in the world.
- 58:13I did a study of the graduates a long time ago and found that they're doing very well
- 58:17in the world.
- 58:19So it's basically been proven that you don't need school as we know it to do well in the
- 58:26world, to be well educated by any meaningful definition of education.
- 58:32My definition of education is that education is everything that a person learns that helps
- 58:38that person to live a satisfying, meaningful, and moral life, whatever it is.
- 58:46So education does have a whole halo around it in my view, but I don't equate education
- 58:51with school, as school as with compulsory schooling.
- 58:56Education comes from all the experiences that you have.
- 58:59And so this kind of a school, the Sudbury Valley School that my son went to, schools
- 59:04modeled after it, unschooling, these are all ways that people become educated.
- 59:12And this is very wise, and I'm happy that there are options out there for parents.
- 59:19You mentioned the right to vote.
- 59:22And for my final question, I would like to talk about the political side of this issue.
- 59:29Children are maybe the most vulnerable members of our society.
- 59:33And I wonder if it would be beneficial to give them more political power.
- 59:38I know that some politicians want to make it so that 16-year-olds get the right to vote.
- 59:44And this is just one way to give children more power, one, the power to defend their
- 59:50interests and have their voice heard about issues concerning them, two, give them power
- 59:56early so they can learn what it's like to be a citizen of democracy, and finally, three,
- 1:00:02if children had more power, I'm certain that schools would not stay open for very long.
- 1:00:09So is it going too far?
- 1:00:12I know that through your organization, you do a lot of advocacy work.
- 1:00:18What do you think about this suggestion?
- 1:00:21It's really an interesting question.
- 1:00:24John Holt, who was really the originator of the idea of unschooling and who wrote a book
- 1:00:31who played a big role in the idea of self-education and so on, he actually wrote a book that children
- 1:00:41should be liberated in the sense of having political power and having even the power
- 1:00:49to decide where they want to live, a lot of liberation.
- 1:00:52And that's a very controversial idea.
- 1:00:55And to be honest, I don't know where I stand on that.
- 1:01:00The truth of the matter is, of course, that children start off completely dependent on
- 1:01:06their parents.
- 1:01:07They can't live without their parents, right?
- 1:01:09And so where is the transition point between when you're no longer so dependent on your
- 1:01:16parents that you really feel comfortable expressing a political view, where you really feel comfortable
- 1:01:25and capable of presenting political opinions and so on that are independent of your parents?
- 1:01:36And if children are voting, but they're only kind of voting what their parents tell them
- 1:01:42to vote, then they don't, you know, what is the sense in that?
- 1:01:45What's the meaning of that?
- 1:01:46It basically doubles or triples or quadruples the parents' vote, right?
- 1:01:53So it's interesting.
- 1:01:55On the other hand, I do think it certainly made sense to bring it down to 18 from 21.
- 1:02:04I think it makes a lot of sense to bring it down to 16.
- 1:02:08You know, by 16, you're pretty independent thinker.
- 1:02:12You're pretty willing to disagree with your parents.
- 1:02:16You may be very willing to disagree with your parents.
- 1:02:20So I think it makes a lot of sense to do that.
- 1:02:23Maybe if we try 16 and that works, then down to 14, something like that.
- 1:02:30I wouldn't mind.
- 1:02:31But on the other hand, the idea that school should be a practice place for democracy and
- 1:02:39real democracy for the children at the school.
- 1:02:42You know, it's so ironic that we in America pride ourselves in being democratic.
- 1:02:53And yet we raise our children in schools that are the most autocratic institutions that
- 1:02:59we have.
- 1:03:01They are completely deprived of democratic rights when they're in school.
- 1:03:05They're completely they have no freedom.
- 1:03:07They have none of these things.
- 1:03:08It becomes a joke.
- 1:03:09I remember in school, kids would say, oh, yeah, free world.
- 1:03:12Ha ha ha.
- 1:03:15You know, you're studying that you're studying in your civics class about all these rights
- 1:03:21and you yourself are being deprived of these rights while you're in school.
- 1:03:26So the whole idea of the Sudbury Valley School when it was first started, there are now dozens
- 1:03:30of schools modeled after it was let's raise.
- 1:03:33If we want to raise children to be good democratic citizens, we need to raise them in a school
- 1:03:38where they are democratic citizens, at least of that school.
- 1:03:43So they're learning the principles of democracy.
- 1:03:46They're learning what voting means.
- 1:03:48They're really voting.
- 1:03:49They're making the decisions for their school.
- 1:03:51They've got due process.
- 1:03:54If somebody is accused of violating a rule in the school and the rules have to do with
- 1:03:58things like no bullying and no littering and if you place with something, you have to put
- 1:04:03it away afterwards and so on.
- 1:04:06If you're accused of it and you and you are claiming that you didn't do this, that you
- 1:04:12didn't violate a rule, then you have a right to a little trial of your peers.
- 1:04:17And that goes on at the school.
- 1:04:18So you're actually experiencing democratic citizenry growing up in the school.
- 1:04:25I think that is wonderful preparation.
- 1:04:28And I think one of the results is that graduates of schools like that are more likely to participate
- 1:04:34in the democratic processes of their city, of their state, of their nation when they
- 1:04:43do grow up and leave school.
- 1:04:47This is a wonderful answer and a great way to end the conversation.
- 1:04:51It was so pleasant to talk with you, Peter.
- 1:04:54Thank you very much.
- 1:04:55Did you have anything more to add?
- 1:04:58Well, I could go on forever, but I think we've covered enough ground for this time.
- 1:05:06Great.
- 1:05:07OK.
- 1:05:08Thank you again, Peter, for having been a guest on the podcast.
- 1:05:13Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:05:15I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 1:05:19Let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:05:22Again, thank you so much for caring.
- 1:05:25And I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.