Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / From UBC Sticker Defamation To GST Liability To Work From Home Rights
Transcript
- 0:24Michael Mulligan: So this is you're quite right.
- 0:25Michael Mulligan: It's a defamation case.
- 0:26Michael Mulligan: It's just out of a court of appeal.
- 0:28Michael Mulligan: And the factual background to it, this comes from uh back in 2023 and at UBC.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: Uh and what was alleged is the allegation is that uh a fellow who is employed by a group over there that uh his task is to promote Jewish life at UBC uh was alleged to have printed up uh some 500 stickers uh in a circular format, which read I Heart Hamas, and then UBC Social Justice Center printed on them.
- 0:58Michael Mulligan: And apparently a hundred of them were stuck around UBC, and then some pictures were taken and put up online.
- 1:04Michael Mulligan: And that led to this defamation claim being brought by, first of all, that UBC Social Justice Center against the person that they alleged put up these stickers, um, and also uh an individual there who was associated with that social justice center who was had sort of a public role in it as a coordinator.
- 1:26Michael Mulligan: Now, the first thing about the case, which is notable, it's I think generally an important principle, is who can sue.
- 1:34Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the first problem for the UBC Social Justice Center is that that organization is described as an unincorporated association, like just a group of people.
- 1:45Michael Mulligan: Uh, it it caused me to think about uh those of us who might be familiar with the Monty Python quest for the Holy Grail and the scene involving the constitutional peasants who describe themselves as an autonomous collective when confronted by the king.
- 1:59Michael Mulligan: That is the constitutional peasant.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: Yeah, yeah.
- 2:03Michael Mulligan: So the problem with that is that I an autonomous collective or an unincorporated association isn't a legal entity that can sue on its own behalf.
- 2:13Michael Mulligan: It's just a glob of people, right?
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: Uh and sort of globs of people can't sue.
- 2:20Michael Mulligan: And you can imagine the problem if globs of people could sue, you would arrive, you would have issues like, well, the glob of people was awarded some money.
- 2:27Michael Mulligan: Who gets it?
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: Or the glob of people sued somebody unsuccessfully, who's paying the costs?
- 2:32Michael Mulligan: Everyone would just scatter into the wilderness, right?
- 2:35Michael Mulligan: Um, and so this entity, the Social Justice Center, unincorporated, uh, apparently had some 12 coordinators, no board of directors, 30 active members, uh, and you know, it was just a glob.
- 2:51Michael Mulligan: Uh, and so that entity uh discontinued uh its defamation claim uh uh a year or so, it looks like after it was started, on the basis that you just can't sue as a glob.
- 3:03Michael Mulligan: Uh but that left this individual who was one of the uh people described as a coordinator for the Autonomous Collective, uh, and the coordinator sued on the basis that um even though uh he didn't have some official role, there was no board of directors, the person wasn't identified, for example, as uh some position like uh meaningful position, I don't think, on a website or anything to do with this collective, uh, that he is somebody who had made uh like uh speeches and done sort of forward-facing things for the Justice Center uh group.
- 3:37Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh he alleged that uh people would who were familiar with him uh would have reasonably concluded that the sticker, which the there was agreement that a reasonable person could conclude that it was intended to convey the idea that members of this uh social justice center supported a terrorist organization, which uh could uh cause reputational damage.
- 4:01Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the the claim he made was, well, hey, if somebody knew me and was familiar with us, they would conclude that the IHart Hamas referencing this collective or justice center would have concluded that meant him.
- 4:13Michael Mulligan: Um and so uh that was how his claim was advanced.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: Now, uh at the sort of before the thing could get to trial, uh the defendant, who's alleged to have made these stickers and put them up, which which would be a publication, that's sort of a requirement for a defamation claim, uh brought an application under the Public Participation Act.
- 4:35Michael Mulligan: It's like that act intended to prevent lawsuits being brought, often by like big companies or whatever, to discourage people from you know engaging in uh expression on matters of public interest.
- 4:46Michael Mulligan: And so where you can establish that the pro the proceeding, the defamation claim, uh involved an expression made by uh somebody, which was an expression relating to a matter of public interest.
- 4:58Michael Mulligan: And I think there was it was agreed that uh what was going on with Hamas and the uh attack in Israel and so on was that, was a matter of social interest.
- 5:07Michael Mulligan: Then at that point, unless you could establish that, that is to say, the plaintiff can establish that the claim has substantial merit, like a real prospect of success, then a judge can dismiss the claim uh at an early stage, and that's to avoid, you know, like big companies being able to just bully people around by suing them, uh, and then you know, potentially running up legal costs and so on that would make it uh such that people would be afraid to comment on matters of public interest.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: And so the judge concluded that uh the claim did not have substantial merit on the basis that um you know wouldn't be connected to this person, the remaining person suing, uh because that person could maintain a claim, unlike the autonomous collective.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: Uh and so uh the claim was struck out by the trial judge, uh, and that led to this appeal to the Court of Appeal, where the uh plaintiff, the remaining plaintiff, uh argued that the judge had applied the wrong test by allegedly uh assessing whether uh a reasonable and informed person would conclude uh that this sticker related to him rather than a person who is familiar uh with him, right?
- 6:16Michael Mulligan: Uh and you you can appreciate how that could be so, right?
- 6:19Michael Mulligan: I mean, let's say, for example, somebody alleges that some dastardly thing had been done by, I don't know, the uh, you know, a something which was clearly identified with a person, right?
- 6:29Michael Mulligan: That's a different thing from, you know, hey, if I know that person, I know that's really who it refers to.
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: But the Court of Appeal looked carefully at all the things the judge said, including the judge's references to earlier cases that involved the correct test in terms of a person familiar with the individual, and concluded that the judge had not made a mistake and applied the wrong test.
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: Uh, that uh while it's true that these things could uh uh be defamatory in the sense of uh you know connecting somebody to a terrorist organization, uh it was not enough to connect this particular person, one of some, whatever it was, twelve coordinators uh as being who they were directed at.
- 7:10Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the claim was dismissed, the appeal was dismissed.
- 7:14Michael Mulligan: Now, on the other hand, the uh judge also uh did not award costs to either side.
- 7:19Michael Mulligan: And usually you get costs if you're the party that succeeds, right?
- 7:23Michael Mulligan: That's to discourage meritless claims.
- 7:25Michael Mulligan: Yes.
- 7:26Michael Mulligan: But here the judge exercised discretion saying, hey, what you did here was in fact defamatory, but with respect to an entity that can't sue you, because it's not really a legal entity, uh, and so the judge exercised their discretion not to award costs, and despite the appeal and an appeal of that issue, um the uh court of appeal uh refused to uh overturn the decision to allow both of these people to bear their own costs.
- 7:53Michael Mulligan: That's the later so the Court of Appeal on some of those important issues, including what kind of an entity can sue uh and how that's uh to be assessed in the case of uh claim of definitions.
- 8:03Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Lawyers legally speaking will continue right after that.
- 8:07Adam Stirling: As we continue legally speaking right now for the moment, though, with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 8:13Adam Stirling: It says a bookkeeper 50% liable for advertising IDST didn't need to be collected for several years.
- 8:21Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 8:22Michael Mulligan: Uh well, some bad advice is what happened.
- 8:25Michael Mulligan: Uh and the background of it is that the claimant, who is described as somebody who operated several small businesses as sole proprietorships, like that's kind of on your own accord, right?
- 8:34Michael Mulligan: Not incorporated, um, hired the defendant to act as a bookkeeper uh for a number of years.
- 8:40Michael Mulligan: The time in question was 2018 to 2022.
- 8:44Michael Mulligan: And the claim was based on advice uh received from the uh person who was doing the bookkeeping, uh, who advised the uh claimant uh that she did not need to charge GST unless she uh earned more than thirty thousand dollars each quarter.
- 9:03Michael Mulligan: Uh and that's wrong, by the way, for listeners.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: Okay.
- 9:07Michael Mulligan: Um and in fact that the general requirement uh is that if you are earning thirty thousand dollars sales in any twor quarters, like any year, right, on a rolling basis, then you would be required to register and you're required to charge GST on the sale that puts you over the limit.
- 9:24Michael Mulligan: Some people, by the way, are required to register immediately, like taxi drivers, Uber drivers, rideshare drivers, limousine operators, and some others have to register from day one as mandatory, so don't miss that wrinkle.
- 9:38Michael Mulligan: Uh the other thing to know is that you can voluntarily register as a GST registrant even if you don't go over that threshold.
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: And some people would be well advised to do that because it allows you to claim back what are called input tax credits, like the GST you paid on things for the businesses, like st business, like stock you might buy or like equipment for your business, for example.
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: And so, like a business in the early days might actually just get refunds of GST they paid.
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: So it's something you'd want to get some good advice about from somebody who knows what they're doing.
- 10:10Michael Mulligan: Well, here uh the person did not know what they were doing, uh, and that led to this uh eventually when the uh person wound up with a new, actually qualified accountant, uh, it was determined that uh she had not filed GST when she was required to, and so she had to file and pay twelve thousand six hundred and seventy-seven dollars in uncollected GST because she's still liable for it, whether she did it correctly or not, right?
- 10:35Michael Mulligan: The new accountant realized that, hey, you didn't done this to get it done.
- 10:38Michael Mulligan: And so she did it and then sued this person.
- 10:40Michael Mulligan: And that led to the issue about, first of all, what was the role of this person?
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: Um and the uh it was somewhat ambiguous, and it led to the judge looking at things like the LinkedIn postings of this person who was doing the bookkeeping, uh, where she uh had kind of uh uh uh ambiguous descriptions of herself, like she didn't indicate she had a license or that she was a certified bookkeeper or an accountant, but did describe, for example, experience doing things like, quote, responsible for accounting and clerical support uh for a particular place, bookkeeping, payroll, administration, uh, and claimed to have done accounting courses from an unknown institution at an unknown time.
- 11:24Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that was kind of ambiguous.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: And then the judge looked at, and this was quite important, the invoices that this person had given to the bookkeeper had given to the small business person.
- 11:35Michael Mulligan: Uh and those were quite significant because they included invoices for things like 2020 business accounting book review and twenty hours of annual bookkeeping and bank statement consolidation, and described herself as a quote, accountant for small business, which she most certainly was not.
- 11:53Michael Mulligan: Uh and uh I must say the other thing which I found amusing in the description is two of the years involved, there were no invoices because she wanted to be paid in cash.
- 12:02Michael Mulligan: And I must tell you, there's a red flag when your bookkeeper or accountant does not want to render an invoice and wishes to be paid in cash.
- 12:09Michael Mulligan: That may be a bit of a red flag for you in terms of who is doing your bookkeeping for you.
- 12:15Michael Mulligan: Uh and so the judge found that this woman had overstated her qualifications on these invoices, holding herself out to be a quote, accountant for small business, which is not a thing.
- 12:25Michael Mulligan: An accountant is a thing.
- 12:27Michael Mulligan: Uh, and uh I must say the cash payments and no invoices for a couple years were quite troubling on its own.
- 12:32Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: Uh ironically, that might have produced a uh a GST credit if there was an invoice you could reduce your GST liability by, but that's by the by.
- 12:42Michael Mulligan: Um and so the judge had to then go on and assess, first of all, whether that amounted to negligence.
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: Uh what happened here, this uh advice that was received.
- 12:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and when you have somebody who's clearly acting as a professional, like an actual accountant or a lawyer or a doctor or somebody, right?
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: Just acting in a professional capacity, the way that would be approached is you would you would owe a duty of care to the plaintiff, right, virtually by definition.
- 13:09Michael Mulligan: And then you would look at like the standard of care, which would be like a reasonable accountant, lawyer, doctor, whatever it might be.
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: Uh, and then you would look at whether a person fell below that and whether they were you know the injury or loss was foreseeable, and then what the actual damages were that occurred.
- 13:24Michael Mulligan: Now, the challenge here is that this woman wasn't really a professional of any kind.
- 13:29Michael Mulligan: Um, you know, she was sort of a kind of held herself out to be that, made that representation in the invoices when she did produce invoices.
- 13:36Michael Mulligan: Uh, but ultimately the way the judge approached it was to say, look, this person wasn't really a professional, and so that wasn't really a matter of professional negligence, it was more in the sort of simple negligence sort of category.
- 13:48Michael Mulligan: Um, and on on that basis found that uh it was uh so egregious when she was holding herself out to be an accountant, particularly in a couple of those years, that it obviously fell short in the judge's view of the standard of care expected of anyone.
- 14:02Michael Mulligan: Uh right, you holding herself out to to be that.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: And so found that she was uh in breach of that uh the standard of care that would apply to her.
- 14:11Michael Mulligan: Now, that wasn't the complete end to it, uh, because the the other thing that the judge had to assess is whether the business person who hired this woman uh shared any responsibility for what happened.
- 14:23Michael Mulligan: Um and it found in fact the judge found that she did.
- 14:27Michael Mulligan: Uh she found that the uh businessperson was negligent in hiring her in the first place to do these things uh without making some further inquiries about her ability or lack of qualifications.
- 14:40Michael Mulligan: For example, when you looked at her LinkedIn profile, you know, the hey, I took some kind of an accounting course somewhere, it's unclear where, you know, I went to some school, it was is uncle or said she went to some school, but not what kind of degree she got, and found that there was some responsibility on her, that is to say, the employ you know, the small business person who is employing this individual, uh, to make further inquiries about the qualifications and some of the uh inquiries about the GST liability, and so found that they were each responsible, both of them, uh, for what happened, and so assigned 50% responsibility for each of them, the wisdom of Solomon, right?
- 15:16Michael Mulligan: Uh and so at the end of the day, the judge ordered that this woman, holding herself out, at least on the invoices, to be the small business accountant and providing this advice uh was that she would be responsible for half of what was enclected.
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: So some$6,011.58 was the final upshot.
- 15:33Michael Mulligan: But the the takeaways there are both both, first of all, what I talked about in terms of that general obligation to be aware of if you're um you know selling things, get some good advice about whether you are required to register, because if you don't, that doesn't eliminate your responsibility.
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: It just racks up for all of that uh what you should have been collecting, and you could be responsible for years in the past.
- 15:53Michael Mulligan: And if you didn't do what the actual accountant did, you could also wind up with a bunch of penalties for like failing to do it.
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: So get good advice.
- 16:01Michael Mulligan: It is a nuanced area, uh, and there could be some uh big dollars involved.
- 16:05Adam Stirling: Absolutely.
- 16:06Adam Stirling: Four minutes left.
- 16:06Adam Stirling: Our final story.
- 16:07Adam Stirling: It's a it's it's a little of a human rights claim for not permitting a TELUS employee to work from home in Stanichton.
- 16:13Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 16:14Adam Stirling: So this is interesting.
- 16:16Michael Mulligan: It's somebody a little bit before her time, I guess.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: The fact pattern came out of 2018, and it was a person who had these sort of various uh employment contracts with this TELUS entity, um, and she uh uh alleged that she began to have various kind of vague health symptoms, uh which she believed flared up, quote unquote, at work, uh, claiming that she and she believed that she had had a allergic reaction to something in her work building.
- 16:44Michael Mulligan: Uh the cla the symptoms uh were uh things like uh being fatigued, having poor sleep, low mood, brain fog, leg movements, and cramps, uh which she said seemed to worsen at work.
- 16:58Michael Mulligan: Uh and so she applied for permission to be allowed to work from home pre-COVID, I guess.
- 17:05Michael Mulligan: Um and the TELUS entity um indicated that uh first of all they needed some medical documentation about these things, uh uh because she didn't meet the criteria that they had for allowing somebody to work at home, some kind of performance standards.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: And so they wanted some medical uh basis for this request.
- 17:26Michael Mulligan: Um and the uh note that she wound up getting from the uh doctor uh initially was quite vague.
- 17:35Michael Mulligan: Um it said this for health reasons, a trial of work from home is recommended, right?
- 17:41Michael Mulligan: Without any diagnosis or anything else, just well, recommend you try this.
- 17:45Michael Mulligan: And of course, many doctors' notes are nothing more than a person showing up telling their doctor, hey, by the way, my back is sore, and the doctor writes down reported bad back, right?
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: Yeah.
- 17:54Michael Mulligan: Um and so uh with that, the employer said, No, you you can't do that, and then the woman just stopped coming in and brought a human rights complaint, alleging that she'd been discriminated against based on her uh physical uh health and mental health.
- 18:09Michael Mulligan: Um and uh that the human rights tribunal eventually, and I should say those things can be time-consuming and expensive processes, but eventually the human rights tribunal dismissed the woman's claim on the basis that there just wasn't a satisfactory um, you know, basis for there to be a medical problem at the time this application was made.
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: Um and the woman didn't accept that.
- 18:31Michael Mulligan: She appealed it, first of all, to the BC Supreme Court and then off to the Court of Appeal.
- 18:36Michael Mulligan: Um, and so no doubt a very expensive and time-consuming legal process altogether.
- 18:41Michael Mulligan: Uh, but ultimately the Court of Appeal concluded, and I should say this, eventually, after all of that water had gone under the bridge, uh the woman managed to get some form of a medical uh diagnosis to put some terminology to this collection of vague symptoms.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: Uh but the Court of Appeal uh and all of the various uh eventually concluded that uh an employer doesn't have an obligation to accommodate um things which might eventually wind up with some diagnosis.
- 19:08Michael Mulligan: You need to uh make a the assessment is whether uh based on what information they had at the time, in this case sort of a belief of allergic reactions to something vaguely in the workplace, and that note from the doctor that I mentioned, um, was not the sort of information which was uh medical evidence which would cause an employer to have some obligation to start uh accommodating it, at least when that's reasonably possible.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's an important principle to take away from this.
- 19:36Michael Mulligan: When you're assessing whether an employer uh has met their obligation to uh accommodate a disability, uh the assessment is made based on the information available at the time, not what information might eventually come to light by some other doctor after all of that has transpired.
- 19:52Michael Mulligan: Uh and so that's the uh latest from the Court of Appeal on the uh duty to accommodate somebody wishing to work from home.
- 19:59Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defense Awards, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 20:04Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 20:05Adam Stirling: Pleasure as always.
- 20:06Adam Stirling: Thanks so much.
- 20:07Adam Stirling: Always great to be here.
- 20:07Adam Stirling: Quick break news is next.