Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP234: The Septuagenarian Serial Killers
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Talia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Welcome back, everyone to another episode of
- 0:37Crimes and Consequences. I'm Tanya and I'm Tealia, and this should be the
- 0:42first episode that we have put on our YouTube channel. Yes, so,
- 0:47if you found us on YouTube, thanks for watching. Please hit the like,
- 0:51subscribe whatever button. And if you're listening to us audio, then also
- 0:57you hit like and subscribe and thumbs up to yeah, thumbs whatever. That's
- 1:02like. So that's like I call it thumbs up, thumbs ups up.
- 1:07So today I have a story about Ray and Faye Copeland and I don't know
- 1:12it. She doesn't know it. Ray Copeland was born December thirtieth, nineteen
- 1:19fourteen. It's a little bit of an older story to parents, Jess and
- 1:23Laney Copeland. He was raised in Oklahoma in the Ozark Mountains. The Copelands
- 1:30were poor and they moved around quite a bit, so Ray didn't really complete
- 1:36school. He just worked a lot, like to help his family. He
- 1:40was known to be very stubborn and he never paid attention to anyone that was
- 1:44in charge. He was that kind of kid. Ray's mom, Laney,
- 1:49had given birth to two more children. So, like I said, he
- 1:52dropped out of school when he was in the fourth grade, and that's when
- 1:55he began working. Fourth grade. I know, Coplands ran a tiny farm.
- 2:01So he began his life a crime by stealing cattle when he was a
- 2:06kid in livestock and then he would steal them from his father's farm, sell
- 2:12them, and then give the money to his family without I guess his parents
- 2:16knowing what I know. Eventually he did move on to stealing other people's other
- 2:25people's cattle instead of stealing his dad's. Maybe his dad caught on, who
- 2:30knows, Like I got cattle missing and you're giving me money. Yeah,
- 2:35So I don't know, but that was the extent of most of his petty
- 2:38crimes. Is just you know, stealing cattle. Don't even know how to
- 2:42steal a cow, but I don't either. So when Ray was in his
- 2:46early twenties, he found other ways to make money and this these methods were
- 2:51a lot more serious. When he was twenty two, which was nineteen thirty
- 2:54six, so we are in the heart of the Great Depression. I think
- 2:58he was arrested for forging checks and he was sentenced to serve one year behind
- 3:02bars at the local jail in Harrison County. Soon after he was released in
- 3:07nineteen forty, he moved back in with his parents at their farm, and
- 3:13it would appear that he stayed out of trouble for at least a little while.
- 3:15But one day, when Ray was at a routine doctor's appointment, he
- 3:20met nineteen year old fay Della Wilson. Fay was born in nineteen twenty one
- 3:25to her parents, Rufus and Gladys Wilson. Wilson's were from Harrison, Arkansas,
- 3:31and they were known to be just really hard working people. Like the
- 3:36Copelands, the Wilsons were poor, but they somehow succeeded in raising seven children
- 3:43while living in a cabin that had dirt floors. Oh so Ray meets Faye
- 3:49and it is instant, right, and he's like, what twenty one,
- 3:53she's nineteen, Yeah, you know, he's about seven years older than she
- 3:57is. Oh, it is yeah, he was born nineteen fourteen and she
- 3:59was in nineteen twenty one, so he's a little bit older. But after
- 4:02meeting the connected like instantaneously, she just you know, still his heart.
- 4:10They were smitten. Ray made a promise to her during their relationship and he
- 4:15said that he was always going to protect her. Okay, So a few
- 4:18months later, Ray and Fay got married and within a year of marriage,
- 4:24they started a family. Their first child was a son named Everett, and
- 4:29within the next two years, Fay would give birth to another son that they
- 4:31named Billy Ray. Four years into their marriage, the Copeland family relocated to
- 4:39California in Fresno County, and within the next two years the family would get
- 4:45even bigger with the birth of their first and only daughter, named Betty Lou.
- 4:48She was born in nineteen forty five. Betty Lou, Billy Ray,
- 4:53Beutdy Lou and Billy Ray. Yep. They had a third son named Elvia
- 4:58A l v I A Elvia Alvia. He was born in nineteen forty seven,
- 5:02and so Ray and Fay have this blossoming family with all of these children.
- 5:10Right, they have four kids and in nineteen forty nine, Ray decided
- 5:15he needed to go back to his old ways to make extra money. Then
- 5:18to steal some cattle. Yeah, he was suspected of stealing a couple of
- 5:21horses, Yeah, from another farm who was close to where they lived.
- 5:29Although no charges were ever filed against Ray for horse theft, his entire reputation
- 5:33now around the county, it was just shattered. It's like a Yellowstone episode.
- 5:41Yeah, I'd never watched yellow Stone. You should, I should.
- 5:45A few months later, Fay gave birth to another child. Now it's their
- 5:48fifth, and this is William Wayne. And since Ray's reputation is garbage,
- 5:55he can't find a job and farming was really all he knew, but nobody
- 5:59try trusted him around their livestock. So no money's coming in to this household
- 6:04of seven, and the Copelands decide to leave California and go back to Arkansas
- 6:10for a fresh start. However, this fresh start didn't go as planned because
- 6:16Ray is a criminal, and he was arrested within the first month of being
- 6:20there for stealing cattle. With his arrest, he was charged with grand larceny
- 6:26and he had to serve a year behind bars. So what is she supposed
- 6:30to do? I know, rightis what do you do? I don't know?
- 6:34I mean, she had to do something right. I'm sure she got
- 6:39a job she had to of Hopefully there was family that could help to since
- 6:43they moved back to Arkansas. True. Once he was released from this now
- 6:46second year long stint that he's had in his life, the family moved from
- 6:51Arkansas to Missouri, you know, fresh start, And in nineteen fifty one,
- 6:57Ray was arrested again surprise, seiling cattle. Surprising, and instead of
- 7:02going to prison, he was sentenced to hard labor. But the hard labor
- 7:08was working on the Judges farm for a year. Isn't they crazy? You're
- 7:15not going to ja. Sorry, that's funny as how, Yeah, you
- 7:17need to do some physical labor to work for me. You're gonna work at
- 7:20my farm and for none of my cattle better. Yeah, I'm gonna count
- 7:26them every night stolen. After another release, Ray felt, okay, we
- 7:31need another fresh start. I gotta do it again. You gotta move again,
- 7:34gotta move again, and they went to Illinois. And in Illinois they
- 7:39would move from town to town over the next eight years. On three different
- 7:43occasions, Ray was arrested for forging checks. Even more of jail time he
- 7:47had to pay fines. I mean, nothing stopped him. He would continue
- 7:51forging checks, and in nineteen sixty one he wrote a check, a bad
- 7:56check for a little over twenty nine hundred dollars, which would be a lot
- 7:59of money. Yeah, and it was for a herd of twenty cows,
- 8:03so it was a lot of money. They think he's gonna get away with
- 8:07that. He's gonna bounce and he's gonna have He's gonna sell them, right,
- 8:11Yeah, he sold the cows. Well, his thing was he would
- 8:13sell them right away, like before, like the bank caught up with him
- 8:16and everything. So by the time, you know, yeah, the time,
- 8:20by the time they were come to him, he had already made the
- 8:22money. But obviously, yes, he's being a resident a restitution and oh
- 8:28yeah. He had to go back to prison for another nine months, and
- 8:33after he was released, Ray finally came to the conclusion that he needed to
- 8:37get his shit together, like, okay, we like this ain't working anymore.
- 8:43I need to do something different. So he was in jail more than
- 8:46he was out living free. So getting his shit together he had a different
- 8:52meaning that it would mean to you or me. Usually, you know,
- 8:58it means somebody, Okay, I'm gonna turn over a new leave I'm going
- 9:01to turn my life around. Straight path. Yeah, straightened my path out.
- 9:05But you know that didn't happen. Ray had a different plan. He
- 9:09was still going to commit crimes, but he was going to use a different
- 9:13method. Okay, So while he's ironing out these details of his new game
- 9:18plan, you know, he did remain on the straight and narrow until he
- 9:22got this plan together. It's now the summer of nineteen sixty six, and
- 9:26Ray decided, okay, we need to move one more time, one more
- 9:30time, I promise, Yeah, this is it. So they landed on
- 9:33a forty acre farm in a town called Moorsville in Livingston County, and I
- 9:39believe this is still in Missouri. The six thousand dollars farm consisted of a
- 9:45small farmhouse where his family lived. There's a few barns, and Faye decided
- 9:50to get a job working at Midwest Quality Glove Corporation. I'm not sure what
- 9:54she did, but forty acres and a farmhouse for six grand nineteen sixty six.
- 10:01So while finding their way to the farm, Ray and Fay got to
- 10:05know the owners of the neighboring farms and they these neighbors started to notice some
- 10:11things about the Copelands, and it became known years later that Fay and their
- 10:16five children were being abused physically by Ray. And Faye was raised in a
- 10:22good Christian home. She stayed with them. Yeah, she'd been raised to
- 10:28believe that divorce wasn't an option and that it was sin. She was raised
- 10:31by her parents to love and support her husband no matter what, and that
- 10:37the man was always the head of the household. And you know, the
- 10:41Bible says she needed to submit to her husband. So Fay said, even
- 10:45though Ray was mean and you know, beat her, she remained a good
- 10:52and loyal wife to him, even though he would end up at some point
- 10:56ruining her life. But that's spoiler alert. Since Ray knew he wasn't getting
- 11:03anywhere writing bad checks, he was still sorting out this new plan that this
- 11:07brainchild, I guess that he's going to hatch. In the early seventies,
- 11:11he had an eye for cattle, obviously, since that's really all he knew.
- 11:16But his issue was that he never had money to do anything with them.
- 11:22He had, you know, spent a lot of money bert purchasing this
- 11:24farm that they were living on, and they needed cattle for the farm.
- 11:30But he was adamant that he wasn't going to go back to jail. The
- 11:33potential of getting arrested again was not something that Ray was ready to risk because
- 11:39if he went back to jail, it would definitely have been longer than like
- 11:43nine months or a year long, because now he's got like this record,
- 11:46right, But if he got a job and saved his money, yeah,
- 11:50you know, to buy some cattle. A job is too boring to want.
- 11:54You need instant money when you have these problems, apparently, right,
- 12:00it's much easier to steal it. I guess, is it. I don't
- 12:03know. I don't steal. The consequences you've described seem easy to me.
- 12:07One fucking day jail. Look, I tell on every crime I ever knew
- 12:13anybody Tony went through a stop sign. Yes, thanks, Lea, sell
- 12:18me out. So eventually he comes up with this devious plan. Ray knew
- 12:22he needed to find someone else to write the bad checks for him, and
- 12:28this person needed to be someone that nobody had ever seen before and that nobody
- 12:31knew. This person also needed to be able to disappear immediately after the deed
- 12:37was done, and he knew exactly where to find such people on the side
- 12:39of the road hitchhiking. Oh yeah, you know, you're just blowing through
- 12:43town. He's got a job for you. And as crazy as this sounds,
- 12:48Ray was able to pull this scheme off several times. He'd get the
- 12:52various men to go to auctions for cattle and he would hire them, obviously
- 12:56to work for him. He would pay them fifty dollars a day, which
- 13:00I think was probably really good money. Yeah, And after all the details
- 13:03were ironed out, Ray and the mystery man, you know, they started
- 13:07showing up to these auctions once the cattles were brought. Once the cattle was
- 13:13brought out to be shown, Ray and you know, mister Mystery they would
- 13:18be on separate ends of the corral, they wouldn't stand together. And Ray
- 13:22would give him like a signal like these are the ones we want to buy,
- 13:26okay, So he would bid on them and win them in the auction,
- 13:33and the mystery man would then write out a check from Ray's checkbook and
- 13:39sign Ray's name to the check. So each check that was written when he
- 13:45pulled this off was between one thousand and fifteen hundred dollars. So he's still
- 13:48using Ray's checkbook though. Yeah, but it's not Ray writing the check.
- 13:52It's the guy now committing this crime. Right, Oh, Ray didn't do
- 13:56anything wrong, right, checkbook was probably still yeah, then put the guy
- 14:00up to it, right. The check would be handed over to the auctioneer.
- 14:03Ray would take the newly purchased cattle home. He would you know,
- 14:07sell the cattle by the time that the check bounced, and you know he
- 14:13didn't do it. I wasn't me, and the guy who wrote the check
- 14:16would be gone. So when this happened one time, law enforcement comes to
- 14:24Ray's house about another bad check. But Ray just played stupid and he acted
- 14:30like, you know, it's not my handwriting. I don't know what happened.
- 14:33And since the hitchhiker signed Ray's name, Ray just pointed out, you
- 14:37know, that's not my handwriting. I didn't do it, so I didn't
- 14:39do anything wrong, but that no charges could be filed against Ray since he
- 14:45wasn't the person who wrote it out. But everybody knows, I mean,
- 14:52yeah, it's pretty much his m out right steel cattle whatever. So after
- 14:56each of these and there was like a he did this dozens of times,
- 15:01you know, they would completely vanish as Ray had previously instructed them to do.
- 15:05They would just blow out of town and that would be that. After
- 15:09Ray pulled this off too many times to count, he thought he was in
- 15:13the clear. Like he thought he had now committed like the perfect crime he
- 15:18he had planned it. Never catch me, Yeah, they'll never catch me,
- 15:22Like this is this is gold This is a golden plan. He had
- 15:26planned out everything so perfectly, every little detail. It's always when you get
- 15:30too greedy and you'd just stop, Yeah, taking the cattle. Then had
- 15:33built a nice farm, Yeah, you'd think keep going. And I'm thinking,
- 15:39he's got to have a lot of money, Like, what are they
- 15:41blown? They've blown through all this money, thousands of dollars and they got
- 15:45cattled. Yeah, but they sell them right, but they keep some on
- 15:48their farm too, I think probably. Anyway, it doesn't matter. But
- 15:52Ray wasn't counting on was that a local police officer was catching up to one
- 15:58of the hitchhikers that had did the scheme with Roy Ray. The hitchhiker was
- 16:06named Gerald Perkins. So Gerald was asked about Ray, what Ray had asked
- 16:11of him, and he cooperated with law enforcement. He blabbed, he just
- 16:15told him the whole story. So Gerald led the police back to Ray's house
- 16:21and Ray was arrested yet again, and he was sentenced to serve two years
- 16:26in prison for forgery. So he's gone these two years, and once he
- 16:30was released, he still working on fine tuning the scheme because okay, it
- 16:37was almost perfect, and now what can I do? I already know what
- 16:41he can do? Yeah, Now what can I do to make it absolutely
- 16:45perfect? Yes? Right? Yeah? And he was banished from attending auctions,
- 16:49so he needed to find a new way. By nineteen eighty five,
- 16:56Ray had come to the conclusion that he completely fine tuned this scheme and he
- 17:00was excited to test it out. This has been like what forty years?
- 17:03Yeah, this has been like yeah, thirty years of stealing for sure,
- 17:07right. Yeah. By this time in his life, Ray was in his
- 17:11seventies. Jesus Us, yes, and Ray, Ray and Fay were empty
- 17:17nesters. Here he's still going at it to see him just get some so
- 17:23securedy and honestly it's the truth. What the hell his hearing was going.
- 17:32Both of them are growing older. They needed help around the farm, so
- 17:36they began to hire men as farm hands. Oh boy, Rai's new plan
- 17:41still had drifters writing bad checks, but the checks wouldn't have Ray's name on
- 17:47them. Ray would take the men to the local post office to get to
- 17:51get a PO box in their name. The next step Ray would then take
- 17:55him to the bank and they would open checking accounts in their own name.
- 18:00And the final step with Zen to make them write a check from their new
- 18:03account. You know that's going to bounce. And Ray lied to the men
- 18:07and told them, you know, they would be writing checks for him because
- 18:12he'd cover it. Yeah, he was going to cover it. Yeah,
- 18:15cover it because he's not allowed to go you know, the people at the
- 18:18auction hated him, so he's not allowed to go there anymore. So once
- 18:22this transaction was complete, Ray had a plan to make sure that the police
- 18:26would never catch up to another one again. He began murdering, as you
- 18:30probably have guessed, murdering these farm hands that he bought, that he brought
- 18:36to his farm. So once he got them to complete the scheme, he
- 18:41shot each man and he killed them so there'd be no possible way that they
- 18:45could blab to the police ever again in nineteen I still have these checks,
- 18:51m h. And you don't have those people, And so the police are
- 18:53going to investigate, maybe where those people are? You would think, right,
- 18:59That's what I would think. I would think in nineteen eighty nine,
- 19:02So about four years later, this has been going on about four years.
- 19:06The Copelands hired a farm hand and his name was Jack McCormick and he was
- 19:11fifty seven. Ray initially found him at the Victory Mission, which is a
- 19:15nonprofit organization whose mission is to help those who are struggling and in need of
- 19:22food and shelter. So it's like a shelter. Jack had been recovering from
- 19:25alcoholism and when Ray offered him a job, he jumped at it like this
- 19:30is his chance for his fresh start. Ray knew he could take advantage of
- 19:34the situation and you know, use these guys. So Jack had been hired
- 19:41to open a checking account. He was instructed to put a small deposit that
- 19:45Ray gave him into the account to start. Jack was told that Ray needed
- 19:49help at the auctions because Ray was hard of hearing. Oh, so Jack's
- 19:55job was to bid for him. Under Ray's instructions, Jack went to the
- 19:59post. You know, he got his po box and he began using Ray's
- 20:04money like for the starter tucks so then, you know, Jack went to
- 20:10the auction and he bought cattle for Ray. After the auction, Ray convinced
- 20:15Jack to come back to the house because he said, there is a raccoon
- 20:18in the barn and I need your help trapping it. So as they're walking
- 20:22to the barn, Ray had his rifle with him, and Jack noticed that
- 20:27one of the tractors from the farm was backed up close to the barn with
- 20:33a small trailer attached to it. And He's like, hmm, I'm a
- 20:36small trailer. There was a shovel along with a big sheet of plastics.
- 20:41Oh okay, all right, So Jack's like, oh, thank you.
- 20:45You know, Ray had every intention of killing Jack because this transaction is over,
- 20:49and digging his grave, wrapping his corpse up, you know, burying
- 20:53it. So after Jack set up the recoup the raccoon trap, he turned
- 21:02around and Ray was pointing a rifle directly at his head. Somehow, though
- 21:07I'm not sure how, Jack was able to convince Ray not to shoot him.
- 21:11Jack said, I'm going to leave Missouri. I'm gonna, you know,
- 21:15hi, tail it out of here. I'm out and I'm never going
- 21:18to talk about this to anyone, and if you're wondering where Fay is during
- 21:22this, she had left to go to work at her part time job.
- 21:26She worked at a holiday inn. And but she she's not I have a
- 21:32feeling she knows what's going on and she just doesn't want to be there when
- 21:37it all comes down. How could you not figure out? I know,
- 21:41right, obviously got a life of crime because this was an issue when they
- 21:45when when the law finally catches up with them, it was how much does
- 21:48Fae know? And I'll tell you a little bit later. So after Jack
- 21:52promised to leave Missouri. Oops, wait a minute, sorry, After Jack
- 21:56promised to leave Missouri, Ray agreed to shake Jack where you needed to go,
- 22:00like I'll drop you off wherever. But they were going to make a
- 22:03quick stop at the courthouse that was located in that county. When the two
- 22:08of them got to the courthouse, Fay was waiting there, so when she
- 22:11saw Jack, she seemed shocked because he should be dead and buried. At
- 22:15this point, Ray told Faye that he and Jack were headed to the bank,
- 22:22and so Faye followed them. Once Jack and Ray got to the bank,
- 22:27the checking account was closed, even though there was an outstanding check for
- 22:32a little over eleven hundred dollars. Jack told Ray that there was no need
- 22:37for him to head back to the farm. You know this is good.
- 22:40I've closed this account. Yeah, just let me go. Yeah, even
- 22:44though he still had clothes and other belongings there. He's just like, I
- 22:47don't care if I go back to that farm, he's going to kill me.
- 22:49Y I'm dead. Yeah, he wasn't. He wasn't really willing to
- 22:53risk his life. So Ray and Fay leave, They go home. Jack
- 22:59is now on his own and a little bit later that day, he meets
- 23:02a friend named Rose at a nearby bar. The two of them Jack Jack,
- 23:07two of them are chatting it up, and Jack told her everything he
- 23:11had just experienced at Ray's farm. Even though he promised not to tell anyone,
- 23:15I know, he told her, you know I would. I missed
- 23:19my deaf by this much. Right. He's like, if I go back
- 23:23there there, he's probably gonna kill me. But he's still in town.
- 23:26Yes, he's still in town. He's supposed to be leaving Missouri. So
- 23:30Rose told Jack, Okay, let's go back to the house together to get
- 23:33your belonging. No, yeah, no, part of what I've just told
- 23:37you, are you not understanding? And they go back I will be killed.
- 23:41Yeah, I'd be like, no, that's okay, I can leave
- 23:42it. What's wrong with Rose? I'm not going back to a house where
- 23:45I think someone could be murdered. But she maybe she thinks because she's there,
- 23:49they won't do it. No, no, down right, no no
- 23:55no no no no no no no no. So they when they right to
- 24:00the house, they were greeted by both Fay and Ray and they were just
- 24:07cursing Jack and Rose up and down, like what are you doing here?
- 24:11Jack introduced Rose to them. He told them that she was his sister,
- 24:17but Fay wasn't buying it. She kept trying to make Rose tell her her
- 24:21name for some reason, and she wrote it down along with the license plate
- 24:25from the car that they came in. They ended up leaving with their lives
- 24:30still, Jack and Rose. But the very important no, they didn't know
- 24:36any of Jack's belongings because I think they get there and they have this confrontation
- 24:41and they leave, and Jack did move. He left Missouri and he went
- 24:47to Nebraska good. And after Jack left, Ray tried to use the same
- 24:52scheme on two other men. One caught on and left as fast as he
- 24:56could, but the other did as he was instructed, but before Ray could
- 25:00kill him, he was arrested. So we have Jack in Nebraska and he
- 25:07gets there and he is thinking about what happened, and he's really feeling like
- 25:11he needs to expose Ray. So he makes a call to crime stappers in
- 25:15Nebraska, and while on the phone, he said, you know, I
- 25:19was working on this farm and while I was there, I accidentally uncovered some
- 25:25bones and I think they were human. Okay, okay, he said.
- 25:30On August sixth of that year, he took a little stroll behind one of
- 25:36the Copeland's barns, and while he was making his way, Jack looked down
- 25:40and thought he saw a human skull along with either an arm or a leg
- 25:47bone, and get the fuck out of there, amen, right, I
- 25:49don't know. He saw these bones coming out of the soil behind the barn,
- 25:55and Ray and Fay must have seen him walk back there, because when
- 26:00he went when he got back to the house, both of them were extremely
- 26:03upset at him and the fact that he walked behind the barn, and he
- 26:07was angrily told that he was not allowed to walk over there again. So
- 26:11he tells the hotline in this story, this Crime Stoppers hotline, and they're
- 26:15a little skeptical. They're like, hmm, I don't know, Like,
- 26:18Okay, you came across some human bones. But because you know, the
- 26:22Copelands are elderly, so they're thinking, hmm, he's got to be in
- 26:26his mid to late seventies, right, yeah, right, And but but
- 26:30I think what crime suppers does is they take the tip and they pass it
- 26:33along to law enforcement. And that's exactly what they did. They passed it
- 26:38along to Missouri's law enforcement for that area so that they could check it out.
- 26:45After the Missouri detectives heard about what Jack had seen on the farm,
- 26:49they took this information really serious because Ray had a criminal record, and so
- 26:56they they would then spend two much gathering all the information that they could find
- 27:03out about the Copelands. After taking this time to secretly investigate them, they
- 27:07were able to use everything they found, along with the Jack statement, to
- 27:11get a search warrant for the farm. Oh, I can't wait to hear
- 27:14what you tell me they find. The raid of the Copelands farm took place
- 27:18in October of nineteen eighty nine, and since this was such a large area
- 27:22to cover, like it's forty acres forty acres a lot. The sheriff,
- 27:26along with forty officers, units of bloodhounds, and a full bulldozers took Ray
- 27:32and Faye by surprise. They show up with a search warrant and they're like,
- 27:37oh shit, we're fucked. Yeah. The team of officers and bloodhounds
- 27:41scoured the farm for an entire week and they came up with nothing, not
- 27:47even by the barn, He said, what happened. They went as far
- 27:51as searching the property that surrounded the farm, but they still came up empty.
- 27:55Many of the officers then thought that tip was bullshit, right and this
- 27:59was how all just either wild goose chase, some kind of misunderstanding. But
- 28:03a few days later their luck would turn around because the bulldozers come out.
- 28:07So a few few bulldozers went into the nearby farm that Ray often used,
- 28:14and when police started digging, three bodies were unearthed. These bodies were of
- 28:19twenty seven year old Jimmy Dale Harvey, twenty one year old Paul Jason Cohort,
- 28:26and twenty seven year old John W. Freeman. Each of these men
- 28:30had died from a single gunshot to the back of their head. Two bodies.
- 28:37Two more bodies were found a little bit later. The body of Dennis
- 28:41K. Murphy had been found in a well located on the property and his
- 28:48body was badly decomposed and it was chained to a forty pound block of concrete.
- 28:53Oh man, so yeah, so somebody tossed that concrete into the well
- 28:59and down went Dennis. It's like a bad mood, scary moon well with
- 29:04my right. The other body was of Wayne Warner, and his body had
- 29:10also been found near the barn, but instead of being buried next to the
- 29:15other three, his body was placed in the barn under just bales of hay
- 29:19that had been stacked Florida ceiling. Now they're getting careless, yeah right,
- 29:23like not even burying the victims. And all the men had been shot with
- 29:29a twenty two caliber rifle. Is that six? Then six? According to
- 29:34court records, each of the victims were homeless men who were hired by Ray
- 29:40to participate in his illegal livestock dealings. At the auctions, because you know,
- 29:45Ray's not giving this up. Ray would put in some of his own
- 29:48money into their newly created checking counts, but before the checks bounced, the
- 29:52victims were murdered, so there'd be no trace of them, and he got
- 30:00away with this. I mean, yeah, he's already lived out a huge
- 30:04chunk of his life. Yeah, exactly. And I'll tell you a little
- 30:08bit about some of the evidence that was found. When police searched, they
- 30:15found two blank checks that were inside a phase purse when she was arrested.
- 30:19One of them was from Jack and the other one was the last man that
- 30:23Ray used con people. His name was James Page. All of these findings
- 30:29showed, you know, they knew she participated, They knew in these financial
- 30:34transactions. She knew every detail right, including the murders. Funny enough,
- 30:41Fay had gone to the bank on her own after a check after John Freeman's
- 30:47mail from the bank was sent to the Copeland address. John had had some
- 30:52remaining cash in that account and he's one of the victims that they found,
- 30:56but the amount was obviously not enough to cover that check that was written for
- 31:00the cattle. So after the check bounce, the bank took it upon themselves
- 31:03to close the account, and then they sent a check for the money that
- 31:08John had in the account and sent it to Ray and face House. So
- 31:14fake out her hands on this check and she actually sent it back to the
- 31:18post office. But then you know, she goes to the post office and
- 31:21she's like, I don't know who this John Freeman is. Where did he
- 31:25get my address? She just you know, trying to deny any kind of
- 31:30knowledge of that. Also, while searching the home, police found a handwritten
- 31:36list of names and they were the names of the victims. Why well,
- 31:41Ray couldn't read or write. The list was in phase handwriting. She wrote
- 31:47the name the point I have no idea because next to their names she would
- 31:52mark an ax next to their names, and like I said, they correlated
- 31:57with the men that were hired murdered. There were twelve names on the list,
- 32:04but only five of them had an axe. All other names listed are
- 32:07names of people who are still missing. They're missing and no remains of theirs
- 32:13have been ever been found. Wow, these are two right alleged cerial alleged
- 32:21serial killers. The murder weapon that twenty two caliberal caliber rifle that was found
- 32:25inside of Ray and Faye's farmhouse, and after ballistics tests were done it was
- 32:30determined that yes, it was the murder weapon. Okay, this is kind
- 32:35of weird. Another thing that they found. Okay, it was a quilt
- 32:38that Fay had sown. It wasn't just an ordinary quote though, it was
- 32:44made from clothing that didn't belong to either Ray or Faye. They had taken
- 32:50the clothes from the victims and sown them into a quilt. When police found
- 32:55this quilt, they felt like it proved she's involved. Yeah, she's totally
- 33:00involved, and that she acknowledge again because you know, when they get arrested,
- 33:05she denies. And that's weird shit, I know who to make a
- 33:08quilt out of victims clothes, out of victim's clothes, Like what you're snuggling
- 33:13up at night with that quilt? Fuck? Why would you do that?
- 33:15Why would you want to remember that? Right? You were against it and
- 33:21horrified you what your husband was doing. And let's say she didn't know,
- 33:24like, okay, you're coming up with clothing that doesn't belong to you,
- 33:30or you just show up with some clothes on, help me to make a
- 33:32quilt? Add all the little things up, I mean thing, Yeah,
- 33:37I don't know them. Checks are coming to her place, right, people's
- 33:40names, and you don't ask Ray about it? You don't she's not asking,
- 33:45I mean maybe not but come on now, I know that's a weird
- 33:49thing. So eventually, when they are arrested, they get charged with five
- 33:53counts of murder in the first degree. Bays trial began November one, nineteen
- 33:59ninety and during the trial, her attorneys did everything that they could to show
- 34:04that she was suffering from battered wife syndrome. That's right, she was,
- 34:07she had been been mm hm. They also made it a point to make
- 34:10sure that the court was fully aware that she was in her right mind and
- 34:15she didn't have any mental disease or defect. According to Fay, she had
- 34:20no knowledge of the murders and she was just an innocent bystander. However,
- 34:25the jury didn't believe that, and she ended up being found guilty on all
- 34:30five counts. She was sentenced to death whoa by lethal injection, I know,
- 34:36for four out of the five counts. For the fifth count, she
- 34:39was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. After Fay heard
- 34:45her sentence, she uncontrollably cried her eyes out, Oh hell yeah, and
- 34:50loud sobs were heard throughout the courtroom. That makes sense, mm hmm.
- 34:54On the morning after Fay had been sentenced, Ray was taken in for a
- 34:58mental evaluation at a Kansas City hospital. On the way to the hospital,
- 35:04the sheriff began to ask Ray if he'd heard about Fay's verdict, and Ray's
- 35:08like, no, I haven't heard a year. No, I'm surprised.
- 35:12He's like, well, what has happened. The sheriff told Ray about her
- 35:15being sentenced to death, and Ray responded, quote, well, those things
- 35:21happened to some you know, un quote, and he never asked about Fay
- 35:25ever. Again. Well, I thoughs he might be real worried, right.
- 35:31His trial started March seventh, nineteen ninety one, and the prosecution brought
- 35:36forth many witnesses along with the ballistics tasks on the rifle the bullets that were
- 35:40found. There was a bullet found lodged in one of the victim's skulls.
- 35:45The testimony went on for weeks, and after the jury heard everything, they
- 35:50also found Ray guilty on all five counts. He too, was sentenced to
- 35:54death by lethal injection for all five of them. When Ray heard a sentence,
- 36:00he muttered, I'm okay, No, you're not No, you're not
- 36:05no body. Yeah, you're not. No. Ray and fake Copeland are
- 36:09the oldest people to ever be sentenced to death in the history of the US.
- 36:15Oh Ray died on death row two years after he'd been sentenced. Yeah,
- 36:21see that's not there. No. In Faye's death sentence was overturned on
- 36:24August sixth, nineteen ninety nine, her lawyer came forward and said that ray
- 36:30Or Fay was barely guilty of anything. He continued, Yeah, she didn't
- 36:36at the standard, and she's barely She's just a little bit guilty. He
- 36:40continued to say that she was just there when the murders took place, and
- 36:45she never killed anyone, Like I just happened to be there. She's kind
- 36:47of confessing to what happened though, right, yeah, because she's saying,
- 36:52yeah, people were murdered. I mean yeah, I was just there.
- 36:54I didn't participate in it. Her appeal centered around the fact that the Duram
- 37:00were not given the opportunity to hear any evidence that could prove that she suffered
- 37:04from battered wife syndrome. Although the death penalty was taken off the table,
- 37:09she was still ordered to spend the rest of her natural life behind bars.
- 37:14In November the following year, the Missouri Attorney General tried to get phased death
- 37:19sentence reinstated, and at the proceedings, Fay was asked if she had anything
- 37:23to say, and she did. She said, quote, God will forgive
- 37:28me for everything I've said or done? End quote. Oh well, why
- 37:32don't you share with us? Yeah? Everything you yeah, please please do
- 37:36tell. The judge upheld the overturned death sentence, so the death penalty was
- 37:44not restored. She's old anyway, right, Yeah. On August tenth,
- 37:50two thousand and two, she suffered from a massive stroke and it paralyzed her.
- 37:54She was never able to speak again. So she was given parole,
- 38:00yes, and released to a nursing home. I don't know if it was
- 38:01Pearl, but they released her to a nursing home in her hometown, where
- 38:07she died December thirtieth two. Sometimes when you're gonna die, yeah, they
- 38:12let They let her die at the nursing home. And that is the story
- 38:15of Fan Ray Copeland, the oldest people sentenced to death Here, crazy stupid
- 38:22story. Cattle over Yeah, like the horses. I mean, I like
- 38:28that. He just worked years and years on the scheme, Like, well,
- 38:30you got I mean he got away with it a lot. I mean,
- 38:34he did time but as much as I mean he managed to survive and
- 38:38support a family. Yeah, I mean, I guess stealing and stealing and
- 38:43then eventually murdering murdering. Well yeah yeah, So anyway, that's horrible.
- 38:49It is horrible, And I wonder about the other where the body, the
- 38:52other missing people, Yeah, the missing people, Like it's just coincidental that
- 38:57their names happened to be on a list, and then again they were training.
- 39:00It sounds like they were transient, so yeah, I could anything could
- 39:04have happened to them. You're right, but it's awful coincidence, yeah,
- 39:08kind of h Anyway, Well, thank you all for listening or watching us
- 39:16on our own YouTube channel, which is what Crimes and Consequences on YouTube.
- 39:22Yeah, you'll find us, typick Crimes and Consequences on YouTube and you'll find
- 39:25us. Yeah, don't forget to hit the like or subscribe a button on
- 39:31whatever app you're listening to us, whether it's YouTube, whether it's Apple Podcasts,
- 39:37whatever, it doesn't matter. You can if you enjoyed this episode.
- 39:40I know, enjoy it is really a weird word, but you know what
- 39:44I mean. If you've hung in long enough to watch us and you want
- 39:46to see us again and you're interested in more. You're interested in more,
- 39:51yes, thank you. You can go to Patreon dot com slash t nt
- 39:55Crimes, where we release one episode a week that is not released to the
- 40:02public, and you can also go to Apple Podcasts. Additionally, part of
- 40:07the benefits that you get is this episode ad free in early release. You
- 40:15can go to our website, Cryingsoconsequences dot com. Yep, there's merch if
- 40:19you're interested in that. They check it out. Facebook and Instagram, but
- 40:23we haven't updated those in a long time anymore. I don't know yecause I
- 40:29got my account got hacked. That's oh, that's right, Yes, Lea's
- 40:32account got hacked, so can't link it anyway. Well, thank you for
- 40:37watching, and until our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye bye