Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Guest Host Jamie Butters - Skip The Salesperson, Walmart Plugs In, Google Bids For Spirit
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is August 27th. That's a Thursday. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. Today I have with me the one and only Jamie Butters.
- 0:08But most important, the most important guest on the show might be Jamie Butters' new mustache. [laughs] That, sir, is a fantastic gentleman's mustache, I must say. Oh, thank you so much. Thank you. I appreciate that.
- 0:21I mean, distinguished. You've been a fan from the start. You know, here's what happened. Uh, you know, I had so much FOMO, mustache FOMO, when the third season of Ted Lasso ended. Oh.
- 0:31I, and so I started talking all this smack that if they ever brought the show back, I mean, it was such a perfect conclusion. I was like- [laughs]...
- 0:37"They're never bringing it," but if they brought it, ever brought it back, I would have to grow a mustache. As you did. [laughs] And so season four just started, and here I am, so- It works. It works- Man of my word...
- 0:46so, so well. Yeah. [laughs] And, uh, it's a great fit. I think it adds to... I mean, it's... I, I'm trying to think, like, legendary news mustaches and, and John Stossel just comes to mind.
- 0:57[laughs] Remember John Stossel had- Yeah, yeah... had a beast of a mustache and, and he was, you know- Yeah... obviously very well respected for a long, long time. Uh, thanks for joining me today.
- 1:04You're, uh, you were just telling me about the world's largest truck stop in Iowa? Please. Yeah, yeah. Uh, Walport. Tell me about this. Uh, the Iowa 80, the world's largest truck stop.
- 1:13They've got, you know, the, Wes Raynal, uh, legendary auto editor from Auto Week and worked with me at Automotive News, he goes on and on that he can't get enough of the Iowa 80 truck stop.
- 1:24But they've got, I mean, they've got barber services. They've got, I think you can buy insurance there. Oh my goodness. They've got medical care. So especially, I mean, I-80, right? Sure.
- 1:32It goes coast to coast through the middle of America. A lot of times truckers need to get stuff done. Absolutely. Long haul.
- 1:37And if they've taken their mandatory rest, it's a great chance to take care of some business and- Get a haircut... uh, there it is, right in the middle of the country. All the good stuff. Yeah. [laughs] That's amazing.
- 1:45Um, I wanna remind all our viewers, uh, we have a special episode coming up tomorrow. I'm gonna have a conversation with Rhett Reichert. I hadn't heard much from him in quite a while.
- 1:54I know he's, he's kind of chairman, so we're gonna get in a conversation with him. Uh, he k- kind of goes back to the, the OG, uh, SOTA community, too, so make sure you tune in for that.
- 2:02But, you know, for the rest of, for the rest of our time together, we have a few stories to talk about. Ready to talk about a little bit of news? Absolutely. All right, let's do it. My favorite thing to do. Yes.
- 2:11Mark Miller Subaru has essentially built its own Carvana competitor right on top of the franchise dealership model.
- 2:18Uh, GM Chris Hudson and his team have redesigned the digital journey around the same premise that made Carvana famous. Buy the car online, skip the salesperson, and have it show up at your door.
- 2:27Their new, uh, they're calling it the Promise Path. It's intentionally built around that experience. You choose a vehicle, you see upfront pricing.
- 2:34They value your trade, which they will guarantee whether or not you buy the car. They'll arrange financing, complete all your documents, and schedule delivery without interacting with a salesperson.
- 2:44The website leads with, quote, "Keep the dealership, skip the salesperson," and customers who want assistance can bring a human in the loop at any point using, uh, they have a 24/7 AI concierge appropriately named No Sell Nell.
- 2:56So that's the concierge. They can grab a human anytime they want. They, it currently requires 13 different integrations, including, uh, Roadster platform and internally developed tech.
- 3:07All 40 transactions that have run through so far, uh, well, ran through before the launch and everything went well they said. They say they're working toward becoming the Uber Eats of the franchised auto dealership.
- 3:19Yeah, [laughs] I see you- Interesting... trying to do some math there in your head. I can see this. I'm, I'm trying to figure out the Uber Eats part. But yeah, no, I mean, it makes a lot of sense.
- 3:25Sometimes you be, sometimes you're the innovator, sometimes you're the fast follower. Mm-hmm. And I think what people are seeing now is the success Carvana's been having.
- 3:35Is that just limited to Carvana, or can other people use the same recipe? And consumers aren't all the same, right? Some of them really want the engagement.
- 3:47Some of them appreciate the help that a salesperson can give them, understanding the product or whatever. Other people are really intimidated by it.
- 3:54If you can offer both or at least see what's works in your market, uh, you know, we always talk about it, the resiliency of auto dealers.
- 4:01And what it really is, is responding to messages in the market, reacting and- That's right... doing what it takes. That's right. You know, the fa- I love the fast follower phrase right there.
- 4:10You know, we've, we've always talked here, Kyle and I have always talked about how Carvana has done the industry such a huge favor by showing us and revealing what the customer wants.
- 4:19And then now that they bought the CDJR stores and they're moving into franchise dealerships, they showed that it's possible to innovate within that framework. And, uh, this is a real fast follower.
- 4:28The fact they were able to put this together and, uh, get it together, I don't know. On Carvana, can you get a human if you need one? Uh, I'm not sure. I don't know the answer to that. I, yeah.
- 4:38Uh, but I, from what I hear, they, I don't know, they're pretty fast, and they're pretty responsive. But if, yeah, if you had a particular question, I don't know that they're right there with it. Mm.
- 4:47But if you wanted more help- Oh, that'd be interesting... there's 17,000 dealers out there to help you.
- 4:51[laughs] That, that, that would be really interesting to see if they don't, if now they start to integrate that from a call center because if franchise auto dealers pick this up and start to share this- Mm-hmm...
- 5:00and integrate this tech, uh, they might have to move. That'd kind of be the first time we've seen it go in the other direction, but that's the beautiful part about innovation, right, and competition. Yep.
- 5:08Everybody forces the- Yep... innovate, forces the other person to get better. Speaking of getting better. Stop. Segue. Time. Little Segway music. There you go. That's some mustache music right there.
- 5:17Walmart is turning- [laughs]... its massive retail footprint into an EV charging network, opening its 100th company-owned fast charging site.
- 5:25It's another example that retailers, um, realizing charging can be a part of the experience.
- 5:31Walmart network now spans 20 states, with most locations offering 8 to 16 stalls and chargers capable of delivering up to 400 kilowatts. So super fast.
- 5:40Uh, retailer wants thousands of Walmart and Sam's Club locations to e- be equipped with these chargers just in the next few years. Leveraging their footprint puts the store within 10 miles of roughly 90% of Americans.
- 5:52So the charging right now is integrated right into the Walmart app, while Walmart Plus members receive discounted rates.
- 5:59Uh, Walmart's Adam Happel said, quote, "We're proud to reach 100 sites, but our focus remains on building a network customers can count on every time they charge with us." Uh, you want my reaction? I, of course.
- 6:11[laughs] I mean, I think it's brilliant. Uh, I mean, and it makes, just makes a lot of sense. It fits in a lot of trends we've, we're seeing.
- 6:18Uh, but it's such a, a, a bold move if they're really looking for 100% across the board. But I think, look, they know EVs are not having their greatest moment right now- Mm-hmm...
- 6:29but it is a growing part of the market, and it probably is the future, and they wanna be a part of it. We're seeing this trend a lot. EVgo just opened a big, uh, flagship store across from the GM Tech Center.
- 6:41A bunch of us automotive media were there. Automotive Press Association had an event. And they're, like, they're saying the average charge is 20 to 30 minutes. Mm-hmm.
- 6:49The average time somebody goes in a grocery store or even a big box discounter is about 20 to 30 minutes.
- 6:56It fits really nicely, and if you, whether you live in an apartment and wanna have an EV, and so you have to go shopping a couple times, and you have to charge a couple times a week- Mm-hmm... that can fit in well.
- 7:06Or just you're an EV owner and you're out and about, oh, hey, whether you're stopping at a Meijer because it has a Tesla- Right... or an EVgo or you're going to, uh, to Walmart.
- 7:16Obviously, the Iona stores are trying to have their own- Yep... you know, retail space in there. Mm-hmm.
- 7:21But combining those two, it kinda gives you that, you know, rest stop/, you know, gas station experience in a way that's sorta convenient, takes away some of the inconvenience- Without a doubt...
- 7:31of having to charge outside of your home. You know, I think that one- Walmart is such a, a known entity in any community.
- 7:38Everyone knows where the Walmart is, and if all of a sudden that becomes synonymous, like I know I can charge my EV at every Walmart, then, uh, I think it, I think the system really works.
- 7:46I think it's a great way to get people to download their app as well. And once you download- [laughs] Right?
- 7:50Once you get, download the app, you can already start your shopping and integrate your shopping, or at the very least, right, like, now they're getting some data benefit out of giving you a discounted rate.
- 7:59Um, I, you know- Mm... there was a, a pretty, uh, the, the EV rollout. I have an F-150 Lightning, so I've been living the EV life for about the last year, year and a half.
- 8:07And it's been a really interesting thing 'cause I'm in Syracuse, which is not, like, a major metro, but it's a decent sized city of, of Greater Syracuse.
- 8:14It's about a million people, so there's, there's some people around, but it's still kinda tough. I, I know where the chargers are because I know, but it's hard to- Mm... figure out where they are, where they're gonna be.
- 8:22And, uh, Wegmans is the big grocery train- chain around here, and they used to have two beautiful fast chargers out front of the Wegmans.
- 8:29And even though I charge at home and charge at work, there are times when you're out and about, and you're like, "Oh, you know what?
- 8:34It'd be nice to get, you know, a little bit of charge right now while I have to run in and grab something." And they just removed the chargers. They must have spent- Hmm.
- 8:42I mean, those chargers must have cost $300,000, $400,000 each, and they're gone. To put in. And they're gone now. Yeah. So I don't know what happened.
- 8:49I wonder if they were able to resell them and recoup most of the cost, but- Yeah... it seems like, I don't know. Used chargers. Yeah. Yikes. I, I mean, we have a level two right out front. I'm looking at it right now.
- 8:59A level three would be so, so dope, but the electrical- [laughs]... infrastructure alone would be cost prohibitive. [laughs] I mean, this one, so I o- I owe the one that's outside the building.
- 9:08Um, I, I put it in when we re- re- uh, you know, renovated this place, and, and honestly, every year, it pretty much costs money to have it there. And people charge- Mm...
- 9:17on it, and I don't know if I need to raise- Mm-hmm... my electricity prices or something, I don't know. But it, it's, it's not easy to keep it here, but granted, no one's coming here.
- 9:24There is a Starbucks right across the street, but- Yeah... the Starbucks isn't even a Starbucks where people can sit. They can only come in and come out, so I don't know. Hmm.
- 9:31But I think, I, I like the idea of me seeing a Walmart and being like, "I could charge there." I mean, you think about EV road trips, which used to be only for the super brave. Yeah.
- 9:42Uh, you know, now even if you had almost a 250-mile range vehicle, it wouldn't be that bad because there's always a Walmart [laughs] right along- Right... the highway. Right. There's always a Walmart off an exit.
- 9:52Let alone the Tesla Superchargers and all the- That's right... uh, all the others that are coming around. But yeah, if, if all the Walmarts had 'em, you'd just, range anxiety would pretty much be over. That's right.
- 10:02Yeah, that's the end of range anxiety. I think that's gonna be our headline that we put on our thumbnail for this. You're welcome. The end of range anxiety. My gift to you. [laughs] Thank you. Courtesy Jamie Butters.
- 10:11All right, and, uh, last, speaking of anxiety. Oh- Stop... I gotta get the right button. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] It's a good segue, I just, wrong button.
- 10:20Uh, Google is bidding $10 million for something you wouldn't typically see at a bankruptcy auction. They're bidding $10 million for 34 years' worth of Spirit Airlines corporate data.
- 10:32They want the information to train their AI systems, but thousands of former Spirit employees are pushing back over exactly what happens to their data once AI gets ahold of it.
- 10:40The purchase could include more than 175,000 employee records, contracts, tax records, crew scheduling, time card data, emails, and even Microsoft Teams records.
- 10:50The union representing the 5,500 former Spirit flight attendants obviously objected, arguing Google promises to remove personally identifiable information, but then they also argue that, like, AI can reverse that and just put it back.
- 11:02Uh, the union also argues, um, you know, re-identifying these employees is a violation of their privacy.
- 11:08A bankruptcy court, though, is expected to decide on the sale in early September, so usually at a bankruptcy, uh, auction, you know, you see, like, used aircraft and machines and office stuff, and Google stepped in.
- 11:20It's like, "Uh, we'll give you $10 million for all that little data right there." I mean, is this the day and age we're living in now, Jamie? Absolutely it is.
- 11:28You know, you said it's, uh, unexpected, but it is actually becoming this, uh, little blossoming market, uh, in the bankruptcy courts. When companies go under, they have all kinds of data.
- 11:38They're not even buying customer data. There are other people buying the customer data. Right.
- 11:41There's other people buying the customer communications, the interactions between, uh, the company and their, and their cu- and the customers.
- 11:48This is just internal to try to capture, right, how decision-making and gets communicated. How do you make a sausage? Yeah.
- 11:55And, yeah, and they, that's why ideally without identifying the people, but they do wanna track, you know, employee number fi- fi- 15,020- Sure...
- 12:05you know, had this problem, and they addressed it with these different people at these different levels. It really can be helpful. You can see the value in it, but a lot of concerns.
- 12:14You, you know, you sign away your privacy when you-- to your employer sometimes- Yeah... where you feel like you have that relationship. And if they fail, which I know in the end most of them do- Yeah...
- 12:24that's just up for grabs. I'll tell you what, it's, uh, [laughs] I have a couple thoughts immediately. Number one, if you're training AI on how to run an airline, Spirit's probably not the best- [laughs]...
- 12:34initial training. I, I don't think I'd start it there, [laughs] right? Like, okay, well, this is like... So- It could be learning how to not make decisions. I, I guess, yeah. You know, there's- [laughs]...
- 12:44there's an old story that, you know, Steve Jobs hired, uh, like, a top Microsoft executive and to be a part of their leadership team, and basically just wanted him in the room.
- 12:53So, like, whatever he thought about it, we're like, "Great, we're taking the opposite approach." So maybe S- Yeah... may- maybe they're being real savvy- [laughs]... and they're doing that.
- 13:00But I also think, like, con- customer, customer, like, service data is one thing, people leaving reviews and how do you handle disputes and claims.
- 13:07But this is how people work, this is how people interact and how that gets pushed through a work pipeline. And especially, I think, the most important data might be the Microsoft Teams data- Mm-hmm...
- 13:17because that's the data where people are having regular conversation about how, how to get things done. Uh, this, this is obviously gonna set a precedent, so, uh, we'll be watching this one very closely.
- 13:26It has me thinking, what, what is the actual value of an auto dealership's internal data? It's gotta be a lot. That would be amazing, yeah. And, and because it's- Yeah...
- 13:37well, right now everybody's fighting to aggregate. Like, the people on the front cutting edge- Mm-hmm...
- 13:41of deploying AI, they're fighting to aggregate all of their internal knowledge into an intelligence layer that then AI can start to use.
- 13:49And as more and more people get good at doing that and doing that, this aggregated data set is actually gonna be quite valuable.
- 13:55And I think future valuations of dealerships, Kyle and I talk about this, could be significantly affected by how clean their internal data is and what the value of that data is to running the store in the future for a potential buyer.
- 14:06So, I don't know. Brave new world, Jamie. Good thoughts, Paul. Oh, thank you so much for joining us today from Iowa City, Iowa. You and your mustache, the story about the truck, and some great color commentary.
- 14:18Have a good day whatever you're doing, and thanks for being here with us today on the show.
- 14:26[upbeat music]