Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Criminal Profiling & Police Psychology: Can You Really Get Inside a Criminal's Mind?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. Grab a coffee,
- 0:03pull up a chair, because you are sitting down
- 0:06with us today for a really intense study session.
- 0:09Yeah, we've got a massive deep dive ahead of
- 0:11us today. We are going straight into chapter
- 0:1410 of our textbook. Right, the police psychology
- 0:17chapter. And just to set the stage, we're looking
- 0:21at this from a Canadian perspective on forensic
- 0:23psychology and law. Exactly. Our mission for
- 0:26this session is to really define and discuss
- 0:29how psychology intersects with law enforcement.
- 0:32We want to pull out all the core concepts so
- 0:34you're totally prepped and well -informed. Without,
- 0:36you know, feeling like you're just listening
- 0:38to an audio textbook. We want to make this actually
- 0:40stick. Right. And to do that, we need to look
- 0:43at the thematic focus of today's Deep Dive. Because
- 0:46police psychology, it's not just about statistics
- 0:49or personality tests. No, it's way heavier than
- 0:51that. Yeah, it is heavily intertwined with morality.
- 0:53I mean, we're talking about who society grants
- 0:55the power to enforce its rules. It's almost this
- 0:58godlike responsibility, making literal life and
- 1:01death decisions. Exactly. And it's about how
- 1:04deeply flawed, imperfect human beings interact
- 1:09with these incredibly rigid systems. Before we
- 1:12can even get into the psychology of like a single
- 1:15individual police officer, we have to understand
- 1:18the systemic environment they're working in.
- 1:20Right, because that environment is built on some
- 1:23very old historical principles and strict territorial
- 1:26boundaries. Yeah, let's talk about that history.
- 1:28The textbook goes back to the 19th century. the
- 1:32peeling principles. Yeah, these were established
- 1:34in the 1800s to create this stable military style
- 1:38structure under central government control. And
- 1:40there was one principle in there that just totally
- 1:42jumped out at me. It says that a perfect command
- 1:44of temper is indispensable to a police officer.
- 1:47A perfect command of temper. Like that sounds
- 1:50like something you'd ask of a Zen monk, not a
- 1:52human being working a chaotic Friday night shift
- 1:54downtown. Yeah, it's an incredibly high historical
- 1:57ideal. And that ideal gets tested relentlessly
- 2:00by what the textbook calls the jurisdictional
- 2:03puzzle. Right, because Canada's policing system
- 2:05is complicated. Very. You have this complex web
- 2:10of federal forces like the RCMP, and then you
- 2:13have provincial forces and then municipal police
- 2:16departments. The problem is, crime doesn't care
- 2:19about the neat little borders on a map. Exactly.
- 2:22So investigations constantly become multi -jurisdictional.
- 2:26And when those bureaucratic systems clash over
- 2:28territory, the psychological and moral failures
- 2:31can be just catastrophic. Which brings us to
- 2:33the Robert Picton case. Yeah. The textbook points
- 2:37to Picton as the darkest example of this systemic
- 2:39failure. I mean, the details are just chilling.
- 2:42picked and killed dozens of sex trade workers
- 2:44over several years, preying on women from Vancouver's
- 2:47downtown Eastside. And he was taking them out
- 2:50to his farm property in Port Coquitlam. Right.
- 2:52And a massive reason he operated for so long
- 2:55was this psychological wall between the Vancouver
- 2:58Police Department, the VPD, and the RCMP in Port
- 3:01Coquitlam. Yeah, the VPD had jurisdiction where
- 3:04the women were going missing, but the RCMP had
- 3:07jurisdiction over the farm where the murders
- 3:09were actually happening. And they both had reports,
- 3:11right? They both had intelligence, but they fundamentally
- 3:14failed to cross -collaborate. They really did.
- 3:17The Missing Women Commission of Inquiry looked
- 3:19into this and officers cited an entrenched culture
- 3:22and climate. Which is wild. It is. They said
- 3:25stepping on another jurisdiction's authority
- 3:27was simply not done. The RCMP essentially treated
- 3:32the missing women as Vancouver's problem until
- 3:34they had undeniable proof it was happening on
- 3:36their turf. See, this is where I have such a
- 3:38moral issue with it. Like, I get bureaucracy,
- 3:41but we're talking about a serial killer here.
- 3:43Yeah. It feels like a really dark inversion of
- 3:45the parable of the Good Samaritan. I mean, in
- 3:48that religious story... The entire moral imperative
- 3:51is that you have to cross a social and physical
- 3:54boundary to save a dying person. Right. The boundary
- 3:56shouldn't matter when a life is at stake. Exactly.
- 3:59Isn't it a basic moral imperative for a cop to
- 4:02cross an imaginary line on a map to save a life?
- 4:05Why did bureaucratic pride supersede human morality
- 4:09here? Well, the textbook explains it impartially
- 4:12through the lens of institutional psychology.
- 4:14It's a massive diffusion of responsibility. So
- 4:16everyone just assumed the other guy would handle
- 4:18it. Yeah, or they felt the rules strictly forbade
- 4:20them from stepping in. The system's rigidity
- 4:23completely overpowered individual moral action.
- 4:26Wow. Okay, so if the systemic bureaucracy can
- 4:29fail that tragically, it puts like an insane
- 4:32amount of pressure on the actual individuals
- 4:34working inside that system. It really does. Which
- 4:37is why police psychology is heavily relied upon
- 4:39to ensure that the individuals they select are
- 4:41highly capable and morally sound. Right. How
- 4:45do you even find a flawless person for a flawed
- 4:47system? Well, that leads us to the four domains
- 4:49of police psychology. Oh, yes. I have a great
- 4:52memory trick for this. For everyone taking notes,
- 4:55use the acronym AIOC. Just think of it as always
- 4:59investigate our cops. That's perfect. AIOC stands
- 5:02for Assessment, Intervention, Operational, and
- 5:05Consulting. Always investigate our cops. Yeah.
- 5:07So let's start with the A, the assessment domain.
- 5:09So assessment is essentially the gatekeeping
- 5:11phase. The very first thing a police psychologist
- 5:14does is a job analysis. They're hunting for KSAOs.
- 5:17Yay, SAOs. Knowledge, skills, abilities, and
- 5:20other personal characteristics. Right. And while
- 5:23it's easy to test physical skills or cognitive
- 5:25abilities, it's that other category that's so
- 5:28crucial. Psychologists are explicitly testing
- 5:31for moral characteristics. Means like honesty,
- 5:34integrity. good judgment. Exactly. It's kind
- 5:37of like St. Peter's standing at the pearly gates.
- 5:40But instead of, you know, a divine ledger, police
- 5:44psychologists are using tools like the personality
- 5:46assessment inventory to judge if an applicant's
- 5:49soul is basically fit for the badge. That's a
- 5:52great way to look at it. The PAI hunts for underlying
- 5:55psychopathology or antisocial attitudes. But
- 5:58does it actually work? I mean, can a test predict
- 6:01if someone is morally sound? According to the
- 6:03data in our textbook, yes. There was this study
- 6:06by Loff and Ryan that looked at intensively screened
- 6:08candidates. And what did they find? Those candidates
- 6:10had significantly fewer motor vehicle accidents
- 6:13and way fewer sick days compared to officers
- 6:16who just went through standard screening. Oh,
- 6:18wow. So it actually changes real -world outcome.
- 6:20It does. And it gets even more advanced. There's
- 6:22a study by Diane and colleagues in Israel that
- 6:24showed you can't just rely on written tests.
- 6:26Right, because people can just fake written tests.
- 6:28They know what the right answer is. Exactly.
- 6:30So Danann combined cognitive tests, structured
- 6:32interviews, and situational assessment centers.
- 6:35Wait, what's a situational assessment center?
- 6:37It's where they throw applicants into high realistic,
- 6:40chaotic role -playing scenarios with actors.
- 6:43It provides unique, non -redundant data that
- 6:46a paper test just can't give you. Okay, so you
- 6:50screen an applicant perfectly at the pearly gates.
- 6:52They pass the actors, they pass the written test.
- 6:55But what happens when that officer faces an ultimate
- 6:59moral test in the actual chaotic real world?
- 7:03Well that takes us from assessment straight into
- 7:05the operational domain. Right. And this is where
- 7:07we have to talk about the use of force. Yeah.
- 7:09Use of force is critical. Canada has a national
- 7:12use of force model, and it's built on a continuum.
- 7:15Starting with just being there, right? Yes. Mere
- 7:17presence is the lowest level. Then it escalates
- 7:20to verbal communication, then physical control,
- 7:23then intermediate weapons like a taser. And then
- 7:25lethal force is the absolute last resort. Precisely.
- 7:28But as we know, that continuum can break down.
- 7:31And that brings us to the Robert Zekansky tragedy.
- 7:34For those who don't know, this was a 2007 incident
- 7:37at the Vancouver airport. Right. Sikansky was
- 7:39this immigrant. He didn't speak a word of English,
- 7:42and he was totally confused and agitated after
- 7:44being stuck in customs for hours. He was moving
- 7:47airport furniture around. He was frustrated,
- 7:49but he was unarmed. Exactly. Unarmed. And the
- 7:53RCMP arrived. Now, you'd think they would use
- 7:56mere presence and verbal de -escalation, right?
- 7:58The training. But within just 90 seconds of the
- 8:01officers arriving, Zekansky was tasered multiple
- 8:05times, and he died. Yeah. It's a horrific example
- 8:09of systemic and psychological failure. So here's
- 8:11my question. If cops are screened for that perfect
- 8:15command of temper we talked about, how does the
- 8:17situation escalate to lethal consequences in
- 8:20just 90 seconds? Like what happens to their brains
- 8:23in that moment? It all comes down to cognitive
- 8:25load theory. Okay, break that down for us. So
- 8:27in a chaotic environment, an officer's working
- 8:29memory only has so much processing power. Cognitive
- 8:32load theory divides this mental effort into three
- 8:35types of load. Right, I've got a great analogy
- 8:37for this so you guys can memorize it. Yeah. Think
- 8:39of the brain's working memory as a person carrying
- 8:42a really heavy backpack. Okay, I like that. So
- 8:45the first type is intrinsic load. Right, intrinsic
- 8:48load is the inherent weight of the books in the
- 8:50backpack. It's the complex, unavoidable nature
- 8:53of the threat in front of you. You can't change
- 8:55it. Exactly. Then you have extraneous load. Which
- 8:58is like someone shoving unnecessary rocks into
- 9:01your bag while you're trying to hike. Yeah, the
- 9:03screaming bystanders, the flashing lights, or
- 9:05even just really bad procedural training that
- 9:08confuses the officer. That's all the noise. Yeah.
- 9:10And then the third one is germain load. Right.
- 9:13And if the bag is heavy, the germain load is
- 9:15your muscles actually building a schema to carry
- 9:18it. It's your mental maps and your situational
- 9:20awareness kicking in so you don't panic. That
- 9:23is a perfect way to remember it. So operational
- 9:25psychologists aim to improve training by maximizing
- 9:28that germane load. How do you do that? The textbook
- 9:31details a study by Stafs and colleagues from
- 9:34Norway. They put police recruits in computer
- 9:37simulators and use something called the freeze
- 9:39technique. Oh, like pausing a video game? Basically,
- 9:43yeah. Midway through a chaotic simulation, the
- 9:46screen freezes and the instructor forces the
- 9:48recruit to explain what's happening around them.
- 9:51So they are forcing them to practice situational
- 9:54awareness. Exactly. They have to perceive the
- 9:56environment, appreciate what it means, and project
- 9:59what's going to happen next. And did it actually
- 10:01help? It really did. The trained recruits fired
- 10:04more accurate shots, but more importantly, they
- 10:06showed lower heart rate variability. Wait, really?
- 10:09Their physical biology changed. Yes. Good psychology
- 10:12training actually reduced the cognitive burden,
- 10:15keeping their bodies calmer in split -second
- 10:17decisions. That is wild. OK, so we've looked
- 10:19at how psychology builds the officer. But what
- 10:23happens when the officer faces an unknown monster?
- 10:25You mean when standard investigations hit a wall?
- 10:28Exactly. This is when police psychology brings
- 10:30out its most famous and probably most controversial
- 10:33tool. criminal profiling. Right. Profiling is
- 10:36essentially working backward. You take the crime
- 10:39scene and use it to figure out the who and the
- 10:41why. And there are two main approaches here.
- 10:45I have another memory trick for you guys listening.
- 10:46Let's hear it. Okay. Deductive profiling is like
- 10:50being a traditional detective. Deductive detective.
- 10:54You are zooming IN on the unique, specific facts
- 10:58of a single case. And the other approach is inductive
- 11:01profiling. Right. Inductive is inclusive. You
- 11:04are zooming OUT to include statistics and general
- 11:07patterns from known groups of past offenders.
- 11:10Exactly. So looking at the actual methods, the
- 11:13FBI's criminal investigative analysis is a classic
- 11:16approach. It relies on motivational typologies.
- 11:19Right. Looking at a scene and deciding if it's
- 11:20organized or disorganized to guess the motive.
- 11:22Yeah. But then you have David Cantor's investigative
- 11:25psychology, which is much more statistically
- 11:27derived. So less guessing, more data. Supposedly.
- 11:31And there's also behavioral evidence analysis,
- 11:33which is strictly deductive, and geographic profiling,
- 11:36which uses mathematical models like jeopardy
- 11:38surfaces. OK, I have to push back here. Go for
- 11:41it. Is this actually science? Yeah. The textbook
- 11:43literally mentions it's based on inferences,
- 11:46which is basically just academic slang for an
- 11:48educated guess. It is a guess. Right. So have
- 11:51profilers just become this sort of secular clergy
- 11:54offering these psychological prophecies to desperate
- 11:57cops. Well, the textbook actually highlights
- 11:59those exact dangers. It impartially notes that
- 12:02the academic community is very divided on this.
- 12:05Give me an example of when it goes wrong. The
- 12:072002 U .S. sniper case is a prime example. The
- 12:10profilers were incredibly confident that the
- 12:13shooter was a white male in his 30s working alone.
- 12:16And who was it actually? It was an older black
- 12:18man and a teenager. Oh my God. They were entirely
- 12:22wrong. Completely wrong. And this creates a massive
- 12:24moral risk of tunnel vision. Some researchers
- 12:27call profiling straight up smoke and mirrors.
- 12:30Because it leads to the harassment of innocent
- 12:31people who just happened to fit the prophecy.
- 12:34Exactly. Others argue it has limited statistical
- 12:36validity, but the danger of focusing on the wrong
- 12:39suspect is always there. Wow. OK. That is a lot
- 12:43to take in. So to wrap up our study session.
- 12:46Let's summarize the journey. Yeah. We started
- 12:48with the rigid and sometimes morally flawed jurisdictional
- 12:51boundaries of policing. Then we went through
- 12:53the psychological gates of assessment with our
- 12:55KSAOs. Right. Into the cognitive crucible of
- 12:59split -second use of force decisions. The heavy
- 13:01backpack. And finally into the murky, pseudo
- 13:04-prophetic world of criminal profiling. Seriously,
- 13:07what a deep dive. But before we go, I want to
- 13:09leave you with a final thought to mull over before
- 13:11your next exam. Ooh, okay. Land on us. Building
- 13:15on our source material, think about this. If
- 13:18police psychology continues to advance, if our
- 13:21KSAO assessments and our geographic targeting
- 13:24algorithms become incredibly precise, we edge
- 13:27closer to predicting human failure before it
- 13:30ever happens. Oh, wow. That's kind of terrifying.
- 13:33Right. Does the ultimate success of police psychology
- 13:35mean we eventually cross a moral line, punishing
- 13:38the statistical probability of a crime or a mental
- 13:41snap rather than the action itself? Think about
- 13:44that. That is deeply unsettling, but such a good
- 13:47point to end on. Well, thank you all so much
- 13:49for joining us for this session of the Psychology
- 13:51Undergrad. Keep studying, keep asking the big
- 13:54moral questions, and we'll catch you next time.