Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Josh Powell (Chapter 2 - Childhood)
Transcript
- 0:00Heyzer listeners. This is chapter two in our deep dive on the Psychology of
- 0:04Josh Powell. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. I'm your host,
- 0:09doctor Kirkhana. I'm a therapist and I'm also a professor. My name is
- 0:12Umberto Casa, and I tend to Stone Garden. So in the last chapter,
- 0:18we mainly talked about Josh's father, Stephen, and his parenting and how
- 0:24that might have affected Josh. And in particular we went down a rabbit hole
- 0:29for the patrons anyway regarding early exposure to porn not only for Josh, because
- 0:36Stephen the father did expose Josh to pornography reportedly, but also I wanted to
- 0:43talk in general about this topic because I just wanted to know the research and
- 0:48I wanted to think about it some more. And it's a lot more nuanced
- 0:51and you can listen to that portion if you're a patron. But obviously in
- 0:57research shows this that to be exposed to pornography early in life can absolutely cause
- 1:03harm like hyper sexuality, low self esteem, risky sexual behaviors when you're older,
- 1:11sexual exploitation of others, and also just messaging around gender and sexuality and
- 1:17consent because it depends on the kind of porn that you're viewing. But anyway,
- 1:21we went into detail on that, and just to summarize what we've already
- 1:25talked about, it was reported that Stephen Powell, the father, his parenting
- 1:30vacillated between being extremely passive, particularly with his three boys, and at times
- 1:37suddenly very punitive, violent name calling and screaming and yelling at the kids and
- 1:46particularly at Josh. Apparently he was particularly violent and abusive and combative with Josh,
- 1:55which is interesting given how this story develops. Also, Stephen had a
- 2:00lot of bad boundaries. He would talk about things openly in front of the
- 2:05children, and he would share porn with the three boys. Also, in
- 2:10addition, Stephen was very anti authority. Teresa, Stephen's wife ex wife,
- 2:16would say Stephen is quote very anti church, anti country, anti authority,
- 2:25anti morality. All the while he's teaching the boys these things. He has
- 2:31taught the boys to mock and insult their mother at as he does, meaning
- 2:38the way that he mocks and insults me, he teaches the boys to do
- 2:43that to her and under some circumstances when I hear because most of these statements
- 2:49we have because they come from the divorce filings, and when people go through
- 2:53divorces, they'll exaggerate, maybe even invent things in their head because there's just
- 3:00so angry at their soon to be divorced partner. And hearing these stories,
- 3:06I'm always like, well, we'll see what they say about this in ten
- 3:08years, once the dust settles. But taking everything into account, these statements
- 3:15might be underplaying what Stephen was actually doing. You know, this notion of
- 3:23teaching the boys to actually go after the mom and mock her and insult her
- 3:29sounds fantastical, right, It's like, well, surely he was just modeling
- 3:34to the boys, or he was not stepping in and supporting the other.
- 3:39In all likelihood, no, Stephen was telling the boys, your mom is
- 3:45evil. Because we see this later on and we hear these statements and are
- 3:51recordings and other accounts of the way Stephen was in Josh would also become this
- 3:57way. So, BIRDO, when you were growing up you had a dad,
- 4:01You still have a dad who was very anti church, anti authority,
- 4:08anti establishment, And what was that like growing up with him? Yeah,
- 4:12that's a really interesting parallel there. Yeah, so my dad considered himself a
- 4:17very left leaning ideology ideologically and didn't trust institutions and had a good reason.
- 4:27You know, he grew up in a place in time where actually, yeah,
- 4:30that was totally legitimate, but you know it extended to the point where
- 4:32basically, and in Columbia, there was a lot of political streffs and a
- 4:36lot of economic strife and a lot of violence from the drug cartels. Right,
- 4:42So it was a very scary time, that's right. However, it
- 4:45basically consumed him because like his days would be after he stopped being able to
- 4:49have jobs, because essentially he would he would try to fight the system everywhere,
- 4:55right, and his days consisted of like crying out against the system,
- 5:00and you know, like watching the news and you know, being super upset
- 5:02at it and yelling at the TV and talking about how oh and I remember
- 5:08I can visualize this his anger and his frustration. He'd be like, oh,
- 5:13these people I hate like that. So what kind of effect might that
- 5:16have had on you? It was this interesting combination of one man, My
- 5:21dad is so affected, like he's not well. You know, I don't
- 5:26remember ever thinking oh he's not well, but I remember feeling like so much
- 5:30stress, so much intense emotion. Here was that concerning to you, because
- 5:35you know, when we're children, we depend on our parents to provide the
- 5:40foundation, a stable foundation, and if they're not stable, then we don't
- 5:44feel stable. I wasn't consciously aware of being concerned, but I was definitely
- 5:48concerned because essentially what happened is, if I think back, what I hated,
- 5:55I came to hate watching the news with him. In fact, I
- 5:58remember telling I do remember we're tellium like you're always complaining about when you added
- 6:04that to the actual situation happening, which everything was horrific, but not only
- 6:09things outside the house are horrific, but inside the house it doesn't feel any
- 6:14safer. And you know, and my dad wasn't like hitting me or yelling
- 6:19at me or anything, but it didn't matter because it was like, like,
- 6:23you're saying that the source of safety and security for me is unhinged.
- 6:27Yeah, and children can't process these things right. And this is becoming maybe
- 6:32worse anecdotally with how much news there is available to people and how especially how
- 6:41much, at least in my circle, how much people talk openly about politics
- 6:46and their concerns for the world. You know, maybe a little bit of
- 6:49education or exposure to children and teenagers can be helpful, but generally speaking,
- 6:57it's too much. They aren't ready to handle that kind of information the end
- 7:00of the world or climate change or war or death or political difficulties, Like
- 7:08it's hard enough for me to handle. I can't imagine, particularly when you're
- 7:13watching your parents suffer. There's age appropriateness, you know, like if you're
- 7:16sixteen, you might be able to handle your parents having a nuanced experience,
- 7:21but when you're five, ten years old, you really need to have the
- 7:27fantasy that your parents are omnipotent and all powerful and all knowing and they can
- 7:33fix anything, you know. I just remember when I was a kid,
- 7:35thinking that my mom could buy anything with her checkbook, right like I,
- 7:41this is this magical thing in her pocket that she could just write a check.
- 7:46And because I didn't understand how banking worked, they explained it to me
- 7:48when I was four, and I just didn't understand. And that notion of
- 7:54just like my mom, she's so powerful, you know, she can she
- 7:58can dry anywhere people talk to her. She's confident. Now was my mom
- 8:05internally and talking with my dad and behind closed doors and with was she scared
- 8:11or concerned about finances or the world. Yeah. Absolutely, she'd exposed me
- 8:16to that, so I grew up thinking she had it all figured out.
- 8:20And in a similar situation with your dad where you just kind of saw like
- 8:22steady worker at his company and he seems to be in control of his life.
- 8:28Yeah. And this notion that it's okay to expose children to this kind
- 8:33of thing, I think is a problem. And also there's a notion that
- 8:37you want to teach kids about certain global or societal topics early in life because
- 8:43you want to help them to become good citizens. Yeah, you know,
- 8:46there's age appropriateness around. I will say one of the positives when I moved
- 8:52here at fifteen is that my mom. You know, she had her own
- 8:56issues, but one area that she was good at was in helping me feel
- 9:01like okay, okay. Well, at least now the adults are in charge
- 9:03of because you know, I imagine that trade. Right, I'm sitting there
- 9:07in Bogota, daily horrific news and we're not talking about like, oh there's
- 9:11another protest, We're talking about car bomb the equivalent enough, the FBI building
- 9:16bombed to smithereens, kidnappings, like there was everything they overthrew the government.
- 9:24Yeah, nearly, Like yeah, like they invaded the Palace of Justice.
- 9:28This is the real Bullets went through my house everything, So that's thing.
- 9:35And then we have on the one hand, my grandpa's health deteriorating daily,
- 9:41my mom, my grandma and my dad at each other's throats, my dad
- 9:46railing at the world and powerless. Right, this is the And then I
- 9:50leave and I come here to what people at the time are like, oh,
- 9:54Tecma's so dangerous. It was like sleepy neighborhood in the middle of Koma
- 10:00where my mom pays the bills on time and she drives very carefully her Honda
- 10:05and you know, there's no one honking and everything. It's like which.
- 10:11So it was hilarious because I remember people are like, you go to Lakes
- 10:13High School. Oh god, that's so dangerous, and I'm like, what
- 10:16are you talking about it? But yeah, it was like this dramatic shift,
- 10:20right, so we could draw a parallel between what you're going through with
- 10:26your dad to how you reacted to nine to eleven totally and other kinds of
- 10:30things. Yeah, you became even today right fairly self destructively focused on the
- 10:37news cycle as a misdirected effort to soothe your anxiety but just makes it worse
- 10:43for you. Absolutely what used to happen to me? It started with the
- 10:46OJ thing. Actually, I couldn't rip myself away from the news. I
- 10:52remember missing some classes just to watch the not the news, like the trial.
- 10:56Right, And then when nine to eleven happened, Oh man, I
- 11:00would stay up nearly all night on the couch watching that television. It was
- 11:05really bad. Great and that old anxiety, I mean one just living in
- 11:11that environment would do a number on you. But your dad wasn't necessarily helping.
- 11:16Right, And imagine Josh with Steven railing, not just at the TV,
- 11:24but just twenty four to seven Because cutting to the chase, Stephen shows
- 11:31a lot of narcissistic traits, and the way that it manifests for Steven the
- 11:35father is that he talks and talks stocks, talk stocks. Josh also talked
- 11:39to talk talks, but Stephen really talks stalks and has no concern about other
- 11:45people's interest or experience with him talking and doesn't have any concern for the effect
- 11:50it'll have on children and Steven, as a lot of narcissistic people do,
- 11:54and a lot of internal anger and rage and felt like he knew better than
- 12:00other people. And since the Mormon Church was a large presence in this family,
- 12:05in the community, he Stephen hated just hated the church. It's unclear
- 12:11ast to how that developed over time. You know, I don't know.
- 12:13I could imagine that the church might have come down on him a couple of
- 12:18times, like hey, you can't do that or that's not okay, and
- 12:22he said, how dare you tell me what to do? He, according
- 12:28to Teresa, his wife, was anti authority. She says, anti morality.
- 12:35I don't know what that has to do with. I think that's a
- 12:39conflation probably where it's like she knows, she knows he was like doing all
- 12:43the pornography, all these other things, and so she throws that in.
- 12:46Yeah, but I seriously doubt that he was like people shouldn't have morals,
- 12:52right, like they yeah, right, So there's that, and she is
- 12:58talking about how he was like that very I mean, sorry, there is
- 13:01a possibility that he was like all these norms in society are bullshit. You
- 13:07know, people should be able to be free with their bodies. What possible.
- 13:11But yeah, I don't know. Yeah, if I remember, right,
- 13:13all the reporting and his own journals, which I've watched because he filmed
- 13:18himself just talking to the camera. Those are all available. He had notions
- 13:24of sexuality that a lot of people would you know, wonder about. And
- 13:28did you come across any indications at all of psychosis meaning delusions? Yeah,
- 13:35actually, Stephen, Yeah, no, Okay. The only reason I asked
- 13:39that is because there was this very interesting bit about the way he talked about
- 13:43the mother, where where I was like, you know, because sometimes there's
- 13:48the difference between oh, yeah, she's terrible, but and maybe I'm I'm
- 13:52misremembering. No, No, he was very exaggeratory. Yeah, and Josh
- 13:58would eventually become very exact story about his wife Susan, that Susan and Teresa
- 14:03were evil and were That's what what I'm leading to because I remember in high
- 14:07school there are there are a few of my I want to call them friends,
- 14:11just acquaintances that were in the very fundamentalist church and they were obsessed.
- 14:18I'm not saying they were psychotic, but they were obsessed with demons and angels
- 14:24fighting in the real world, and it's all they could talk about. Yeah,
- 14:28constantly. That's not psychotics. No, it's not, but I'm saying,
- 14:31like they were ascribing, I could imagine someone who, on top of
- 14:35that, has psychosis. The world becomes a really scary place all of a
- 14:39sudden. Yeah, the glimpses that I've seen into Steven's world regarding the Mormon
- 14:46Church and religion, it's really fascinating, and I wish we had more data.
- 14:52But he at one hand would adhere to the Mormon faith and was you
- 15:00know, for example, him and Teresa, they were married in the temple,
- 15:03which means that they had to play ball a lot. It's not just
- 15:05like getting a little bit of approval. You have to jump through a lot
- 15:09of hoops and prove yourself. And not only that, but then later he
- 15:11would just completely denounce the more mature or would occasionally do that. Also,
- 15:18he would claim during the divorce in nineteen ninety two that Teresa was the apostate.
- 15:26I think they call it where you're breaking from the church. He was
- 15:30saying that she was the sinner because she was into like crystals and New age
- 15:35stuff. But who knows if that's just him drumming up stuff to get people
- 15:41on his side. But I think he had a lot of pretty out there
- 15:46views So another thing that was reported by a lot of people, and there's
- 15:48a lot of data even from his own journals, that Stephen was very misogynistic.
- 15:54You know, a lot of people throw that word around. You know,
- 15:58back when I was learning these words of misogyny and sexism, sexism was
- 16:03more of a general, often a lighter accusation. Misogyny. Being a misogynist
- 16:10was an accusation that It's sort of like the difference between having inherent, culturally
- 16:17indoctrinated racist ideas and being a KKK member, right, Like you want to
- 16:23eradicate people of color, you want to kill them, as opposed to not
- 16:29hiring a person of color. Like that was my sense of what the difference
- 16:33was between sexism and misogyny. Well, Stephen legit was misogynistic. He often
- 16:38talked about how much he hated just women in general, particularly Teresa, because
- 16:44they fought a lot. So just imagine that for Josh. And it was
- 16:48very hard for Josh actually to go through this divorce. Josh turns to the
- 16:52dad and says, are you a mom getting a divorce? And they said,
- 16:56well probably, And Josh cried and it was very hard on him.
- 17:00Not only that, but just like the amount of fighting that was going on
- 17:03in the house. You know just how difficult that that would be for all
- 17:07the children. And Stephen often talked about just how much he hated women,
- 17:12and he just you know, women are this, women or that, and
- 17:17you know, not to bring up your dad again, but you got some
- 17:22dose of that. What was that like? Yeah? Absolutely. I don't
- 17:25know all the damage that happened to him. I know that he had a
- 17:27very a very tumultuous relationship with my grandma, and he definitely was scarred deeply
- 17:37by his relationship with my mom. But all I remember, honestly was he
- 17:42would like whenever there was a news anchor presenting that was female, he would
- 17:48call them the worst words and yell at the TV and be like this misogynistic
- 17:56words horrible. Yeah, I mean every time, no matter who they were.
- 18:00It's not like he found out all the scandals about this person's personal life.
- 18:03No, No, just because they're wearing makeup on TV? Oh really
- 18:07not. I thought it was if they were saying something he didn't like.
- 18:11Well, on top of that that he also didn't like what they were saying.
- 18:15But I guess sure he didn't like what they were saying and then he
- 18:19adds this whole thing. So do you remember processing that as a kid.
- 18:25Oh no, I don't know. How did you How did you internalize it?
- 18:30You know what what did it do to you? It was it turned
- 18:33me off, like as in I was repulsed, you know. I guess
- 18:40bye By there was this combination says something because it means that you saw it
- 18:45as not a great thing, right right? I never? Luckily, I
- 18:48never, And I think it's because I had such important women in my life
- 18:52that were there, my aunt, my grandma's, you know, multiple grandma's,
- 18:59multiple aunts, and my cousin. I was really close relationship with my
- 19:03cousins that were girls. And so anyways, I didn't see that and in
- 19:08any way identify anything with it. And it was lucky that I didn't,
- 19:12because he would tell me things like I remember in second grade, I had
- 19:15a little girl viciously scratched my cheek and she actually left for years. I
- 19:22had a red mark and eventually turned into a mole. Why why did she?
- 19:26I don't remember. It was second grade, so but it was it
- 19:30was like really bad. When I when my dad found out, He's like,
- 19:34you you punched them, punched them? If they do that, I'm
- 19:37like, well, but she's a girl, doesn't matter you, you know,
- 19:41I remember that, and I remember him give giving me a sense of
- 19:45like women are not trustworthy, they're all right. Well, so that's another
- 19:53angle to this. It's not just hatred of women, but what's the association?
- 19:57And often in a lot of it's their sluts, their manipulative, they're
- 20:03evil, they are always conniving, or they're stupid or whatever it is.
- 20:10And you imagine for Josh, he's absorbing all this and the difference, I
- 20:15think the kicker is like, Okay, you're internalizing these messages, but in
- 20:19the future, how do you process other experiences once you're on your own as
- 20:26an adult. And I think for a lot of people this didn't happen to
- 20:30you, but it could have that say, you fall in love and you
- 20:33get dumped, We're going to resort to a lot of different defenses to get
- 20:37ourselves out of that bind. Right? Was it me? Am I lovable?
- 20:44Am I ever going to find anybody again? Or I can just say
- 20:48that all women are bitches and sluts and manipulative. And you know, she
- 20:53tricked me, She gasled me into being in love with her and that's how
- 20:57I'm going to cope with this because I feel so bad as a person otherwise
- 21:02because I don't have a way. So if you're just absorbing misogyny, but
- 21:07you're also raised generally pretty well, then it will help in your development.
- 21:11Whereas if you're given all those messages and you struggle with attachments and go through
- 21:18some bad experiences, then it can lead to some rabbit holes. You know,
- 21:22the in cells and the migtows, right, you know, the red
- 21:23pill people that that's I think what happens. You know, they've already absorbed,
- 21:27you know, the in cells and the Migtaw Americans anyway, absorbed the
- 21:30same sexism that you and I did. If anything, they absorbed a lesser
- 21:37degree of it because they're probably younger than us, you know. And yet
- 21:41why did they go down that rebel was because once they ran into being dumped
- 21:47or frustration with dating or something, then they turned to the andrew Tates of
- 21:52the world and those people because they needed that, and then it just indoctrinates
- 21:57them and cultiviizes them. So you know that that is such an interesting thing
- 22:03because you would have me, I internalized so many other things from my dad
- 22:07that I struggled with and things. I do wonder if one of the things
- 22:12is that there was always this incongruity in my head because he spoke so badly
- 22:18about these people, but he took care to not speak badly about my mom
- 22:23to me, especially when I was young. And I wonder if that,
- 22:27like there was this weird, like little life preserver. Well, at the
- 22:32very least, it didn't add to the problem. It didn't add to the
- 22:34problem. But Josh got that. Steve mainly targeted, right, Josh's mom.
- 22:41So your Josh, and you're as your dad knew well enough that you
- 22:48still loved your mom, right, and he your dad probably had a typical
- 22:57desire to get you to realize how horrible she is, right, but he
- 23:03refrained because he knew better to do that. He knew that your love,
- 23:08your relationship with your mom was important, and to pull you onto his side
- 23:15and his world would ultimately harm you to please some weird fantasy for him.
- 23:22Stephen didn't have that line. And when you do that to children, it's
- 23:29important for me to emphasize that for children, and it changes as they get
- 23:33older. But you know, even well into our twenties, sometime maybe throughout
- 23:37our life, but particularly when we're children. Our entire world revolves around our
- 23:41parents, around our charagiters, whoever they are, whether it's grandparents you know,
- 23:45or our parents, our whole world revolves around them. We want their
- 23:52approval, we want their love, we want their stability, we want their
- 23:56attention, we want their approval. We want them to be proud of us.
- 23:59And if something goes wrong there, it just destroys us. We don't
- 24:03have like in today's world, if you even our spouses right, if something
- 24:10goes awry, it'll be devastating, it'll be hard, but we can transfer
- 24:15our love and attachment support system eventually to other people, maybe even during right.
- 24:22Children don't have that. They can't do that. They don't have that
- 24:25ability, they don't have that luxury. So when they're faced with a dilemma
- 24:29between mom or dad like that, it really screws them up because they have
- 24:33to wrestle. There's no good answer. There's only there's only bad answers.
- 24:37There's you know, a lesser of several evils. They either have to For
- 24:41Josh, just you know, imagining him developing in this cauldron of toxicity,
- 24:47he either has to go along with Dad and and believe Dad and hate because
- 24:52you need to believe in at least one of your parents. That's the dilemma
- 24:56is you don't have the ability as a child to say, like, well,
- 25:00dad's kind of unhinged, but he's good for what he's worth, you
- 25:04know, the way we might as an adult, particularly with adult relationships.
- 25:08But you know, when you're you know, forty five and your dad is
- 25:11a little iffy, sometimes you can be like, well, you know,
- 25:15you know, in a limited fashion, we have a bond, you know,
- 25:19but I know to not really go along with that thing when your child,
- 25:25you have we're black and white thinkers, and we don't have our independence
- 25:27of mind. So you have to go all in because you need to believe
- 25:33that one of your at least one of your parents is there to protect you
- 25:37because you're terrified of the world. And so you're Josh and you're looking at
- 25:41Dad, You're like, Okay, I can go along with Dad and hate
- 25:44all women, and hate my mom, and hate the Mormon Church and think
- 25:48it's okay to do whatever, and also think it's okay to be violent and
- 25:52abusive and harmful and exploitative and cruel, right, or I can go along
- 25:57with mom, And I'll get into more of this later, but I suspect
- 26:02the mom was a little standoffish. I don't have data on that, and
- 26:07I hate to throw her under the bus in this way, but I don't
- 26:11know. There's some indications which I'll get into later, so you know,
- 26:15he might struggle with that. But if I go with Mom, I'm going
- 26:18to incur more damage from my dad, who's going to harm me even more.
- 26:23So which one do I do? It's a terrible choice, right,
- 26:29and you end up being very conflicted, And I think for Josh throughout his
- 26:33childhood he would vacillate between that. I think there were times when he absolutely
- 26:37went along with Steven, as he would later in life, but I think
- 26:41there were the times when he absolutely hated Stephen. You just can't imagine otherwise,
- 26:45right if your dad is children feel like they're getting the short end of
- 26:49the stick anyway. All children are like, you know, my sister got
- 26:53this and I got like all children like that. But when you're particularly being
- 27:00targeted, then you know you're obviously gonna think, Wow, my dad really
- 27:03has it out for me. You know, I hate this man. But
- 27:06other times he was different, So anyway, Stephen was like that, and
- 27:11he also would rage against the Mormon Church and also Stephen himself, the father,
- 27:21was sexually attracted to minors. Oh, I don't know if I remember
- 27:25that. Oh, really, yeah I do. But right, so you
- 27:29know that Stephen eventually becomes obsessed with Stuart with Susan, right, yes,
- 27:33okay, Well Stephen not only had obsession, like a massive obsession with Susan,
- 27:37which we'll get into you later, but he also had been obsessed with
- 27:41a lot of women in their lives and in his own it's hard for me
- 27:45to get this out. In his own journal, he writes about a moment
- 27:52when his daughter is like a late teen, one of his daughters, and
- 27:56he talks about how she's, you know, just prancing around the house and
- 28:03in her in her pantyhose and a T shirt or a panty hose and a
- 28:07bra or something, and how hot she looked, and how mom wasn't home
- 28:15so he could really leer it her and that was his biological daughter. Yeah.
- 28:22Well either way, it's a child, I know, I know,
- 28:23but it's like he's not like he's not having that like instinctual mental separation that
- 28:32happens like you know, just I think it is an a certain amount of
- 28:36biology kicks in when like you have like the blood relations or at least you
- 28:41have a heavy duty wall that will you know, punish you internally if your
- 28:48mind just impulsively goes there. He didn't have that wall at all, and
- 28:52was attracted later, which we'll get into. He was attracted to young girls,
- 28:57like eight year old girls, which we'll get into later. And you
- 29:03would imagine, given the complete lack of boundaries that Stephen had with everyone,
- 29:10including his children, particularly his boys, what Josh was being exposed to regarding
- 29:15this hard to know because now you wonder that pornography, what kind of pornography
- 29:19that was, right, and just what sexual messages. I mean, the
- 29:22dad, which we'll get into. I mean, he is a piece of
- 29:26work. I mean it's just incredible. I'm actually gonna show clips from his
- 29:32journal, his video journal. Just it's like if you had a movie about
- 29:37this, I'd be like, come on, that's over the top. Yeah.
- 29:41So he wrote in his journal quote that his daughter's walking around quote just
- 29:45in T shirt and panties. That would drive me nuts, I mean ick.
- 29:52And was this a journal he was intending for people to read. No,
- 29:56well I don't think so. No, No, I'm well, he
- 30:00might have intended maybe someone to read it. He didn't intend on you and
- 30:04I reading it, which I'll get into you later because the police actually got
- 30:10their hands on it, so I want to. But that is a it's
- 30:14an interesting thing, and you tell me because I don't journal myself. So,
- 30:18but there's this additional layers. It's problematic enough if his brain is having
- 30:26these thoughts and he's not doing anything to regulate those thoughts, right, but
- 30:30then you actually remove the filter all together and start talking or writing quote out
- 30:37loud about it. Yeah, it's a good point one that he is not
- 30:42busted up. He's not like I'm terribly ashamed of myself. Oh, I
- 30:45can't believe I feel these things. If anything, his tone is she's doing
- 30:49this on purpose. To me, that that was his tone with all the
- 30:53women they're flaunting it, right, he's the victim of their well, not
- 30:57necessarily vic maybe, but that they're trying to provoke this feeling. It's that
- 31:03narcissistic notion that I'm having this feeling and there's no other explanation other than everything
- 31:10revolves around me and my fields and all my feelings are good, So she
- 31:15must be trying to do this to me because she's provoking it. She knows
- 31:19what she's doing. She's attracted to me. She wants me to feel this
- 31:22way. Of course, she wants me to be attracted to her. So
- 31:26he had that attitude with Susan and you know a lot, and I'm guessing
- 31:32also had it in these other circumstances. But but yeah, it's it's really
- 31:37just gross. But also I think to your point that it's not inconceivable that
- 31:41your journal might be happened upon, and to put it into black and white
- 31:48there says it says something about his personality that he doesn't think that the rules
- 31:56apply to him or that there possibly could be a problem here, and that
- 32:01is overwhelmingly demonstrated later on when we'll get to those data. But I want
- 32:07to show a little clip here, but first, let's take a break.
- 32:10What do you say? All right, we're back from the break. So
- 32:17this clip comes from the Cold podcast. It's available on your podcast app and
- 32:23also on YouTube, and it's just a fantastic podcast. It's like one of
- 32:30the best journalistic podcasts that's ever been created. I'm gonna show a little bit
- 32:37from it here. By the way, does the cold part of the name
- 32:40refer to anything specific like cold cases or yeah, exactly, Oh, okay,
- 32:44it's a cold case because the case of Susan cold. From the outside,
- 32:50the palace still looked like the typical Latter day Saint family. They went
- 32:53to church on Sundays and did stuff together. Steve, though, decided to
- 32:58feed his kids some decidedly different beliefs. He told the boys people were just
- 33:02animals and should be able to have sex with anyone at any time. He
- 33:07also kept porn magazines in the house. So thoughts on that, Yeah,
- 33:10that's interesting. Actually, I remember we were saying, what did she mean
- 33:14by his anti morality? Right? But so actually there might be something to
- 33:19that more literally meaning. I was theorizing that maybe she just kind of threw
- 33:22that in there because she's like, he's kind of immoral. But this makes
- 33:27it sound like he actually had these ideals like, oh, listen, we're
- 33:30all living these stupid constrained things. We should all be free and have sex
- 33:34with whoever. Right, So this fits within the more extreme end of the
- 33:38narcissistic spectrum. Also with the added psychopathic lack of empathy element. There because
- 33:45you can suffer from narcisstic personality and still have at least some empathy, although
- 33:51impaired and perhaps eclipsed by one's narcissistic supply desperation. But for some people with
- 33:59narcissism, they will also have a dose of psychopathy. They believe they're above
- 34:04the law, and it justifies their impulses. Right, they have an impulse.
- 34:08They one hundred percent, at least consciously, are convinced that everything they
- 34:14do is awesome. They couldn't possibly ever be wrong. And how do I
- 34:17reconcile that with all these messages of morality that I'm hearing or taboos that I'm
- 34:22hearing, Well, then they must all be wrong, and they're wrong about
- 34:28everything. And you might even get out ahead of these kinds of accusations by
- 34:32just dispen you know, making sure everyone around you is convinced that the whole
- 34:37system is wrong. Therefore, when I talk about my proclivities, then I'm
- 34:45something wrong with you. I'm off the hook because we've already established that the
- 34:47authority is wrong, or the church is wrong, or morality is wrong.
- 34:51Let's continue listening. Worse yet, he found himself attracted to his oldest daughter
- 34:57Jennifer. Many years later, Steve would write about the feelings in his journal.
- 35:00I remember many times sitting at the breakfast bar in our home when she
- 35:05would come into the kitchen in the morning dressed in a T shirt and panties.
- 35:09That would drive me nuts. We went on a trip one time,
- 35:13just the two of us, and she wandered around our hotel room in nothing
- 35:16more than a bron and panties. Steve wanted to tear Jennifer away from the
- 35:21Church of Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints when she became a teen. He
- 35:24told her the church's scripture, the Book of Mormon, was false. So
- 35:30you get a sense for what's going on here, right, Yeah, It's
- 35:34not just oh I had this attraction. There's a campaign he's trying to gmor
- 35:40Yeah, yeah, or it's it's unknown if he actually would have acted on
- 35:46it with his own daughters, it seems absolutely possible. But was he leading
- 35:53because with Susan when we'll get to you later, he it seems like he
- 35:58liked to lead himself up to the edge or something. So it's unclear,
- 36:01but at the very least the daughter's probably picked up on vibes, right,
- 36:07You know, looks or comments or attention or even just flat out touching or
- 36:13whatever. We don't know, but you get a sense for what's going on
- 36:17in his journal. It's not just like this one sentence. He's writing a
- 36:22lot about his daughter and this sort of thing, and then we hear that
- 36:25he's trying to tear Jennifer. Now, maybe that's just a coincidental that he
- 36:31just hates the Mormon Church and he's just trying to get his children to be
- 36:35on his side. Or was he trying to get Jennifer on her own?
- 36:38Let's continue listen. Terry found out about that conversation and was so upset she
- 36:43moved out of the house. When I was about fourteen, my mom pulled
- 36:46me aside and she had a conversation with me, and she said, look
- 36:52at this path that your father is going on. Look at the path that
- 36:57our Savior wants you to go on. So this is another element to it.
- 37:01It's that dichotomy. It's not the way we would see it, right.
- 37:06Right, we're not saying the alternative to this absolute depravity is the Mormon
- 37:14Church, right, We're just saying human goodness is on the other side,
- 37:20or just at the very least not harming other people is on the other side
- 37:23here, you know. So which, by the way, because there's there's
- 37:27also an implication of it's of culpability. What do you mean, listen,
- 37:34look at the path your father's on, But then what path do you want
- 37:38to be on? See? Because if I was just saying, like,
- 37:42listen, I'm worried because I don't I don't like the way your father has
- 37:45been behaving in things. I'm worried for you, so maybe we need to
- 37:50leave him or something, right whatever, that's not the conversation happening. It's
- 37:53kind of like you need to be aware of your responsibility in this whole thing.
- 37:58What path do you want to walk? I'm not hearing that. I
- 38:00mean, it could be there, and I want to be clear. I'm
- 38:02happy that the mom was there too. Whether it's the Mormon alternative to Stephen
- 38:09or whatever, I'm really glad the mom was there. Having said that in
- 38:14this family, it was clear to me and all of the data and all
- 38:17the journals and the statements from Jennifer and the mom and ever, that there
- 38:22were two worlds, the Mormon faith and church. I don't know how fundamentalist
- 38:29they were. I don't know how flexible they were. There's some evidence that
- 38:31there was some relatable flexibility in there somewhere, but at the very least that
- 38:37was that world, and then the other world is Stephen's world, which was
- 38:44something entirely different. And for Josh, just imagine zero to eighteen, you're
- 38:51observing this dichotomy Mom on one side, Dad on the other, and how
- 38:57screwed up that would make you, because there's oh whole other world out there
- 39:00of just like you know, if you're you definitely don't go your dad's direction,
- 39:06but you don't have to go your mom's direction if you don't want to.
- 39:07You know, there's a lot of directions right aside from your dad,
- 39:12you know what I mean, And so I wonder what that might have done
- 39:15to Josh Totally. It's just that I'm getting a little bit of a dugger
- 39:21feeling here right where, if you'll recall, and this might have been more
- 39:24extreme in their case, but even in cases where there was clearly something that
- 39:30the guys were doing wrong, the women were the ones responsible for the behavior.
- 39:35Again, I'm not hearing that, but she was specifically saying, like,
- 39:37you got to think about which path you want, Yeah, yeahs as
- 39:43if it's like or you could go down this path, this dark path,
- 39:46if you choose it's like, what that's not talk about paths here? Well,
- 39:50the thing that I was hearing and I hadn't really thought about it till
- 39:52you bring it up that the mom was maybe both, well, I don't
- 39:58know. It's the way I was here it initially before you infected my brain
- 40:02is the mom was trying to say, look, your dad is not okay,
- 40:06and this is not okay. But yeah, when you look at it
- 40:08in a certain way, well let's let's relisten to it. Actually, Terry
- 40:12found out about that conversation and was so upset she moved out of the house.
- 40:15When I was about fourteen, my mom pulled me aside and she had
- 40:20a conversation with me, and she said, look at this path that your
- 40:24father is going on. Look at the path that our Savior wants you to
- 40:30go on. The Gospel will lead you down. Compare them right. I
- 40:37was picking up and throughout my research on this case, I was picking up
- 40:42on that dichotomy, which I found to be interesting. But you're right,
- 40:45it is. It's like, look at the path right that your father's going
- 40:49Now he's it's an ant I don't know what how they would define that,
- 40:52but it's like not within the church, yeah, because it has that language.
- 40:57It's like this, the same language be used if someone just wasn't going
- 41:01to church on Sundays, you know what I mean. It's like, look
- 41:04at the path that they're going on. There's another path, which is the
- 41:07straight and narrow right again, now, I do not want to throw the
- 41:13mom on it. No, no, no. And the context matters a
- 41:15lot because, as an example, I could have imagined having the same conversation
- 41:17with my grandma. In fact, I kind of did where because my dad
- 41:22was an atheist and I remember my grandma talking to me and saying like,
- 41:25well, you know and and I And even if it didn't literally happen like
- 41:30this, I could have imagined a conversation like this one where it's like,
- 41:34look at the path your dad is on, and look at how he thinks
- 41:37of the world, and then there's this path if you actually believe in the
- 41:40Bible and all these other things, and there's that path. I could see
- 41:45that. The only part, and maybe it was the context that I don't
- 41:47know how related this is, is that when you add in the whole attraction
- 41:53to your daughter bit right, It's like that's not a path where I like,
- 41:58that's just we gotta we gotta like separate those ideas because there is that
- 42:02difference between if if all she was trying to say is hey, I'm concerned
- 42:07he might turn you away from the church, right right right, or I'm
- 42:10afraid you're gonna go down a Yeah. That's different from like I'm concerned about
- 42:20him treating your other sister this way, and or I would hope I'm and
- 42:27maybe this happened. I can't know that. Oh my god, I'm so
- 42:31sorry that your dad did this to you, Like, how are you feeling?
- 42:36What do you need? Oh my god? What have I done?
- 42:39Mary? You know, not that it's her fault, but you know these
- 42:42are common, you know, concern for the child, right, not like
- 42:46I already won is like just let's turn this into a religious lesson, right
- 42:52right? She literally, according to Jennifer, used the word lesson again.
- 42:54I'm not throwing the mom under the bus. I'm just saying there are very
- 43:00indirect indications that the mom might have had some compromised parenting and that could have
- 43:08you know, mildly like the thing that I in a better world. There's
- 43:14a version of the story where the mom had an extremely wonderful childhood herself,
- 43:21and although you know, also although but Mormon herself, but had a very
- 43:28effective way at helping the children recover from the abuse that was continually being dulled
- 43:34out by the father. It wouldn't mean that the children would be fine,
- 43:37but it would be a protective factor that could have made a difference in Josh's
- 43:43life. I'm not saying the mom is to blame. She's not. Stephen
- 43:46is clearly to blame, and Josh is to blame for his own behavior.
- 43:50But it just makes me wonder. And as I was listening to all the
- 43:53accounts, I didn't hear anyone even addressing this question. You know, And
- 44:00as a therapist that deals with real cases, and I'm not trying to make
- 44:05a point, as I'm trying to help people, I will, you know,
- 44:08I have the freedom to kind of ask these kind of questions, at
- 44:12least in my mind. All right, well, so let's take a break
- 44:14and let's continue getting into the story about the parents, because this is where
- 44:20Josh's personality was developed. But the rest is episode is going to be for
- 44:23patrons of the podcast, Burtos. So if I don't know why, I'm
- 44:27saying it to you man. Okay, So you people out there, if
- 44:34you want to hear this whole episode, and every episode is going to have
- 44:37a patron section. Sometimes that section is like, you know, thirty minutes,
- 44:43sometimes it's an hour long. It just kind of depends on what happens.
- 44:45But become a patron. Otherwise, take care of yourself because you deserve
- 44:50it. She Tt Sary