Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / California's Expanded Pay to Play Rules: What the Levine Act Now Means for You and Your Clients
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone. Welcome to today's program,
- 0:07California's Expanded Pay -to -Play Rules, What
- 0:10the Levine Act Now Means for You and Your Clients.
- 0:13I'm Alapoli Castro, Director of Education and
- 0:16Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:18Association, and I'm delighted to introduce our
- 0:20speaker today, Amber Maltby. Amber is a partner
- 0:24at NoSim LLP where she leads the firm's California
- 0:29election law practice and spearheads its national
- 0:32nonprofit advocacy practice, advising clients
- 0:35on governmental ethics, campaign finance, and
- 0:39advocacy compliance. She represents a wide range
- 0:42of clients from statewide constitutional officers
- 0:45to nonprofits and political consulting firms
- 0:48before state and local regulators. Amber is recognized
- 0:53as a national thought leader who teaches election
- 0:56law at McGeorge School of Law and serves on the
- 0:59American Bar Association's Standing Committee
- 1:02on Election Law and is on the board of the California
- 1:04Political Attorney Association. We can't wait
- 1:07to hear what she has to share with us today,
- 1:09so I'm now going to turn it over to her. Great.
- 1:15Well, thank you. Thank you very much for having
- 1:17me and thank you very much for everybody who
- 1:20has taken the time to join the webinar today.
- 1:23Today we are going to be talking about what is
- 1:27colloquially. referred to as the Levine Act.
- 1:31And this is a provision within the Political
- 1:34Reform Act that creates a conflict of interest
- 1:39when campaign contributions are made in very
- 1:42particular circumstances. And so for the webinar
- 1:45today, we'll take you through a very brief history
- 1:49of where the Levine Act came from, what the current
- 1:53status of it is, and then walk through some of
- 1:56the mechanics as well as traps for the unwary,
- 2:00whether you yourself are navigating the Levine
- 2:03Act or if you're helping a client navigate the
- 2:05Levine Act. So how did we get here? In California,
- 2:10government ethics and campaign contributions
- 2:12are governed by the Political Reform Act. That's
- 2:16the main body of law, and it was adopted in 1974
- 2:20by voters. And shortly after that, in 1982, the
- 2:26legislature amended the Political Reform Act.
- 2:29to include government code section 8 for 308,
- 2:34what we call the Levine Act. And this was the
- 2:37first time that a conflict of interest was created
- 2:43when campaign contributions were being made.
- 2:46And it was. truly a very narrow application of
- 2:51those two ideas. A conflict of interest could
- 2:55be created when a campaign contribution was made
- 2:59in the context of a proceeding to an appointed
- 3:04official, when a campaign contribution was made
- 3:07in their capacity as a candidate to some other
- 3:10office. The genesis of that was a controversy
- 3:14around the California Coastal Commission. Commissioners
- 3:18who were making clearly very important decisions
- 3:21were accepting large campaign contributions from
- 3:26persons who had matters before the Coastal Commission.
- 3:31And so the Levine Act was a legislative means
- 3:35to remedy that perceived conflict. So the law
- 3:39went mostly unchanged for four decades. And in
- 3:442022, the legislature made an amendment that
- 3:48was really seismic in nature. And that was by
- 3:52extending its application to local elected bodies.
- 3:57So now not only would appointed officials Be
- 4:01subject to the live line act, but now, if you
- 4:04are serving on a local border commission elected,
- 4:09so a city council board of supervisors, board
- 4:12of education. Now you are tracking your campaign
- 4:16contributions as potential conflicts of interest
- 4:19for serving in those roles as well. The legislature
- 4:25did not add. the state legislature or state constitutional
- 4:29officers, so they remain exempt. After the Levine
- 4:35Act was amended in 2022, the legislature spent
- 4:39much of 2023 promulgating regulations to apply
- 4:44it. All of that was in effect in 2024. Because
- 4:49of some of the practical effects that were seen
- 4:53with the Levine Act being applied in 2024. Additional
- 4:58amendments were made through the legislature
- 5:00and then again through the FPPC's regulation
- 5:03process to clarify and refine how the Levine
- 5:09Act applies. Side please. So, the Levine Act
- 5:20has three buckets or three components in application.
- 5:26There's a recusal component, a limits component,
- 5:29and a disclosure component. An officer To a proceeding
- 5:35and we'll go through the definitions for each
- 5:37of these in the upcoming slides, but an officer
- 5:40to a proceeding is disqualified from voting.
- 5:43In a proceeding, if they have received a contribution
- 5:46of more than 500 dollars from a party participant
- 5:51or agent. To the proceeding in the 12 months.
- 5:55prior to their decision on the proceeding. So
- 6:00that's the recusal and disqualification component.
- 6:04There is also a limit component. So once there
- 6:08is a proceeding that is pending before the agency,
- 6:11and for 12 months after a final decision has
- 6:14been rendered, and officers prohibited from accepting,
- 6:20soliciting, or directing a contribution, of more
- 6:23than $500 from a party or a participant in the
- 6:27proceeding. And you'll note that there's a difference
- 6:31between the recusal and the limits in that the
- 6:35limit applies not only to accepting a contribution,
- 6:38but also to soliciting or directing a contribution.
- 6:42And that distinction is really important for
- 6:45the officer. It means that while the proceeding
- 6:47is pending before them and for that 12 months
- 6:50after a decision has been rendered, they cannot
- 6:54direct a contribution to any other entity. So
- 6:59it's not just about the officer receiving a contribution
- 7:02from a party or a participant or an agent. It
- 7:06is about directing as well. So if a officer has
- 7:11their own ballot measure committee, or they're
- 7:13supporting a local ballot measure, or they have
- 7:16an officeholder committee, or they're supporting
- 7:18another candidate, They can't solicit contributions
- 7:22from parties or participants or agents during
- 7:24this time period. And then there's a disclosure
- 7:28component. The officers required to disclose
- 7:32contributions of. More than 500 dollars that
- 7:37they received in the 12 months prior to a proceeding
- 7:40and similarly when a party to a proceeding submits
- 7:44their application or at the initiation of a proceeding,
- 7:47they're required to disclose on the record the
- 7:50contributions of 500 dollars or more that they
- 7:52have made. Next slide please. So, breaking down
- 8:02what all of this means. I thought it made sense
- 8:05to start with what exactly is a proceeding because
- 8:08all of these restrictions revolve around when
- 8:10there is a proceeding happening before an agency.
- 8:15So, the Levine Act applies when you have a proceeding
- 8:18before an agency involving a license, a permit,
- 8:22or an other entitlement for use. which is defined
- 8:26as all business, professional, trade, and land
- 8:29use licenses and permits, and all other entitlements
- 8:34for use. And this is a really important term,
- 8:37including land use entitlements, contracts, and
- 8:41franchises. And then through regulations, the
- 8:45FPPC has further defined this as a proceeding
- 8:48to grant, deny, revoke, restrict, or modify a
- 8:51license permit or other entitlement to use. solely
- 8:55involve purely ministerial decisions, and that
- 8:59is applied for by the party, formally or informally
- 9:02requested by the party, or if it's an action
- 9:04initiated by the state agency, or where there's
- 9:08a contract between the agency and the applicant.
- 9:12Next slide, please. So, when is there an entitlement
- 9:19for use? The FPPC throughout the course of the
- 9:25Levine Act has issued a number of advisory opinions
- 9:28looking at particular matters that are before
- 9:30an agency to determine whether or not that particular
- 9:34matter fits within the definition of a proceeding.
- 9:38And the characteristics to look for from FPPC
- 9:42guidance is that there are specific identifiable
- 9:47persons who are directly affected or in which
- 9:51there is a direct substantial financial impact
- 9:54upon the participants. Importantly, section 84308
- 9:59does not cover proceedings for general policy
- 10:02decisions or rules are made or where the interests
- 10:05affected are many and diverse. So the difference,
- 10:09the very, I think a simple way to think about
- 10:12it would be if you're submitting a permit, then
- 10:17you're in a proceeding. If the issue before the
- 10:21council is an ordinance of general application,
- 10:24then the Levine Act doesn't apply that smart
- 10:26of proceeding. Next slide, please. So the FPPC,
- 10:36again, through advice letters that have been
- 10:38issued over the decades of the Levine Act, has
- 10:42looked at a number of different scenarios and
- 10:45has identified where there is indeed a proceeding.
- 10:50So things like a professional license provocation,
- 10:53a conditional use permit, consulting contracts
- 10:57are on here, cable television franchises, building
- 11:01and development permits. private development
- 11:04plans, these are all the types of proceedings
- 11:08where you have the identifiable direct financial
- 11:14interest by one party and you don't have that
- 11:17general applicability where the matter would
- 11:21not be considered a proceeding. Next slide, please.
- 11:29So, 1 of the things that the legislature amended
- 11:33and its most recent amendments to the divine
- 11:36act was adding more things that are secluded.
- 11:39Excuse me, excluded from the definition of a
- 11:42proceeding. And among these were the types of
- 11:46contracts that don't count. And so again, this
- 11:51is based on the most recent amendments to the
- 11:55line act labor contracts. Personal employment
- 12:00contracts contracts that have a value of 50 ,000
- 12:03dollars or less contracts where there is no compensation
- 12:06involved. Contracts that are between 2 government
- 12:12agencies. All of those are excluded from the
- 12:16definition of contract. There are also. Other
- 12:20exclusions where you're looking at, let's say
- 12:22you have a development agreement, but it's coming
- 12:24up for review. If some significant or material
- 12:28modifications aren't being made to the development
- 12:31agreement, then it wouldn't necessarily be a
- 12:34proceeding and it would be considered excluded.
- 12:38As 1 of the types of contracts that don't count
- 12:401 of the recent advice letters under the new
- 12:45amendments found that. About to make an appointment
- 12:48to a board commission or a committee. So I have
- 12:51an individual to a board commission or a committee.
- 12:54That type of matter is not a proceeding that
- 12:56is treated like an employment contract. So it
- 12:59gets excluded. From being a proceeding next slide
- 13:05please. So. A ministerial decision is not a proceeding,
- 13:16but what is a ministerial decision? What the
- 13:20FPPC is looking for is clear objective criteria,
- 13:24and this is going to be criteria that is set
- 13:27forth either in a statute, a regulation, maybe
- 13:30an administrative rule. And all the officials
- 13:33are doing in that matter is they're figuring
- 13:36out, do the Do the facts before me fit within
- 13:42this criteria? So there's not discretion on the
- 13:45part of the officer. They are just following
- 13:49a ministerial set of actions. Next slide please.
- 13:59So now you have a sense of what is a proceeding?
- 14:01When are we thinking about the Levine Act? The
- 14:05next part is understanding where you or your
- 14:08client fit into the proceeding because whether
- 14:11you are, and I've mentioned these terms throughout,
- 14:14whether you're an officer, an agent, a party,
- 14:16or a participant, that will determine exactly
- 14:19what rules apply to you and also importantly
- 14:22the timing of when those rules attach. So we'll
- 14:26go through each of these and in the materials
- 14:29that were provided to you, the definitions are
- 14:33included. So, let's start with the officer. So,
- 14:37the officer is the elected or appointed official
- 14:40of the agency who's making the decision on your
- 14:43matter. It's the elected or appointed officer
- 14:47of an agency or their alternate. It also includes
- 14:50a candidate for elected office and an agency.
- 14:54It does not include the city attorney or county
- 14:58council who's providing legal advice to the agency
- 15:01and who does not have authority to make a final
- 15:04decision in the proceeding. And again, this applies
- 15:09to local agencies, the state legislature, the
- 15:13board of equalization and state constitutional
- 15:16offices have been excluded from the Levin Act.
- 15:21And then you have your party. So the party is
- 15:24the entity or the person who's actually the applicant,
- 15:28the permit seeker, or the subject of the proceeding.
- 15:37The participant can be a little bit tricky to
- 15:40identify. So a participant is a person who's
- 15:43not a party to the proceeding, but they're actively
- 15:48supporting or opposing the proceeding and they
- 15:51have a financial interest in the outcome of the
- 15:54matter. So who's actively supporting or opposing?
- 15:58That is defined as somebody who is lobbying the
- 16:02agency in person and that can either be the Elected
- 16:06or appointed officers, it can also be staff of
- 16:09the agency. Somebody who's appearing at a hearing
- 16:14or a meeting and testifying on the proceeding
- 16:17or somebody who otherwise is attempting to influence
- 16:21the outcome of the proceeding. And then the other
- 16:24part of that is that they have a financial interest
- 16:26in the proceeding. And so an example of somebody
- 16:31who would have a financial interest in a proceeding
- 16:33would be if you have a permit application to
- 16:40Or I guess an application to set up a. A big
- 16:44box retailer next door to a mom and pop shop
- 16:50that sells the same type of retail items and
- 16:54the owner of the mom and pop shop shows up. At
- 16:58the agency proceeding on that permit or application.
- 17:02to oppose it, it would be quite evident, well,
- 17:04they have a financial interest in the matter
- 17:07because a competitor is potentially moving in
- 17:11right next door to them. So again, that's who
- 17:14a participant is in the Levine Act framework.
- 17:18And then finally, you have an agent. So an agent
- 17:22is a person who is representing a party or a
- 17:27participant, oftentimes lawyers are going to
- 17:29be agents before proceeding. So an agent represents
- 17:34a party or a participant for compensation. And
- 17:38they are communicating with the agency to influence
- 17:42the proceeding. So this can be a contract lobbyist.
- 17:47It can be an in -house employee. The in -house
- 17:51employee, again, is an agent only if they're
- 17:53actually communicating with the agency for the
- 17:56purpose of influencing a proceeding, not if they're
- 18:00just providing technical assistance. And members
- 18:05of a law firm who qualify as, or if a member
- 18:11of a law firm, an architectural firm, an engineering
- 18:14firm, or a consulting firm, or something similar,
- 18:18if they qualify as an agent, then the firm that
- 18:23they work for will also be an agent. So. If you're
- 18:27an attorney, you're representing a client on
- 18:30a matter in front of a planning commission or
- 18:33in front of a city council and you qualify as
- 18:38an agent, that means that your law firm is an
- 18:40agent as well. Next slide please. So the next
- 18:50issue to work through is when is a proceeding
- 18:54pending? And this The answer to this question
- 18:58is actually different depending on who you are
- 19:01within that cast of characters that we just went
- 19:03through. So if you are a party or a participant
- 19:06or an agent to a proceeding, the matter is considered
- 19:10pending as soon as your application is filed.
- 19:15No matter where within the agency it is filed,
- 19:19so it doesn't mean when the matter is before
- 19:22or actually on the agenda for a vote by. the
- 19:27deciding body of the agency. It's as soon as
- 19:29you file your application, as soon as you are
- 19:31the subject of the proceeding, then the matter
- 19:35is pending as to you, the party participant or
- 19:40agent. On the flip side, if you're the officer,
- 19:44so you're the member of the elected body who's
- 19:48making a decision or will eventually make a decision,
- 19:52Then the proceeding is considered pending either
- 19:56when the matter is on the agenda. For you to
- 20:00vote on or when you have knowledge of the proceeding,
- 20:05and it is reasonably foreseeable that it will
- 20:08come before you. So, what is what is it that
- 20:12mean? that the officer has knowledge of the proceeding
- 20:16and it's reasonably foreseeable will come before
- 20:19then. Where I've seen this come to fruition would
- 20:23be, for example, if there's A matter that is
- 20:27heard before a planning commission and the applicant
- 20:31appeals the planning commission decision. There
- 20:35may be some time before it ends up before the
- 20:39city council. But the applicant wants to meet
- 20:42with. A city council member or several of them
- 20:46to talk about the matter, which will eventually
- 20:48come before them for a vote. The officer will
- 20:52know about the proceeding. and will know that
- 20:55it is reasonably foreseeable that it will come
- 20:58before them before it's agendized. So that's
- 21:01kind of the difference between the two ways that
- 21:05an officer will learn that a matter is pending
- 21:10before or proceeding is pending before them.
- 21:12So again, it's really important to know the difference
- 21:14between those two time periods because of the
- 21:17restrictions apply at different times based on
- 21:21those. Okay, next slide please. So, if you are
- 21:32an officer. You may not accept solicit or direct
- 21:38a contribution of more than 500 dollars from
- 21:41a party or a participant. while a proceeding
- 21:44is pending or during the 12 months following
- 21:47the final decision. So again, this is where the
- 21:51timing comes into play. It's pending as to the
- 21:54officer, so the officer may not solicit, accept
- 21:56or direct a contribution once the proceeding
- 21:59is either on the agenda for them to vote on or
- 22:03they. have actual knowledge of the proceeding
- 22:07and it's reasonably foreseeable that it will
- 22:09come to them. And I just want to re -emphasize
- 22:13here what I mentioned at one of the earlier slides.
- 22:16This prohibition extends to every committee controlled
- 22:21by the officer. So an elected official, they
- 22:24can have their own reelection committee. They
- 22:27can also have a ballot measure committee. They
- 22:30can have a legal defense fund, for example. Any
- 22:33of those would would count within this prohibition.
- 22:38It also applies if they're fundraising for other
- 22:42candidates, other ballot measures, and it also
- 22:44applies to contributions to federal committees.
- 22:48So if the officer is simultaneously running for
- 22:53Congress or wants to support somebody who is,
- 22:56even that type of contribution would be subject
- 22:59to this rule. Next slide please. So before the
- 23:12prohibition takes place, so again, that's once
- 23:14the proceeding is pending before the officer,
- 23:18there's also the recusal and disqualification.
- 23:22So if an officer receives a contribution of more
- 23:26than $500 in the 12 months prior to making a
- 23:31decision, They're not required to return the
- 23:34contribution, but they are required to recuse
- 23:37themselves from participating in the matter.
- 23:41And the officer is required to disclose the fact
- 23:44that they received the contribution either at
- 23:46the beginning of the meeting orally, or if there
- 23:49isn't a meeting, then doing so in writing. Next
- 23:56slide, please. Party participant or the agent,
- 24:05the contribution limit kicks in as soon as the
- 24:10proceeding is pending. So, again, this is where
- 24:13there's a little bit of tension or awkwardness
- 24:15in the timing of how the Levine Act actually
- 24:17plays out. So, as soon as you become a party
- 24:22or a participant, then the. Limit applies to
- 24:28you, even if the matter is pending as to the
- 24:32officer. So during this time, you're prohibited
- 24:35from making a contribution of more than $500.
- 24:39And for 12 months after a final decision is rendered.
- 24:43Now, there's another new change to the law. And
- 24:47this is with the 2025 amendments to the Levine
- 24:50Act. An agent is now prohibited from making a
- 24:55contribution in any amount during this period
- 24:59while the matter is pending and for 12 months
- 25:03after a final decision has been rendered. And
- 25:07importantly, agent contributions are no longer
- 25:10aggregated with contributions by the party or
- 25:13participant that they're working with. So this
- 25:16is a really important and pretty big change in
- 25:19the law. Previously, agents were allowed to make
- 25:23contributions during this period, but their contributions
- 25:26would be aggregated with the party or the participant
- 25:29for determining whether or not that $500 had
- 25:32been Reached now the agents are prohibited again.
- 25:37This is for the time when the proceeding is pending
- 25:39and for the 12 months after final decision agents
- 25:44may not make any contributions. However, if they
- 25:47do, they aren't aggregated with the party or
- 25:49the participant. For the lawyers who qualify
- 25:55as agents, this is a flag that again, if you
- 25:59qualify as an agent, your law firm qualifies
- 26:01as an agent and so your law firm will also be
- 26:04a prohibited donor during this time period. Next
- 26:09slide please. So, in terms of the disclosure
- 26:16for the parties, participants, and agents, it's
- 26:20actually only the party who has a disclosure
- 26:22requirement. And a party is required to disclose
- 26:26on the record of any proceeding any contributions
- 26:29of 500 dollars or more that were made within
- 26:32the proceeding 12 months. Participants and agents
- 26:37are not. do not have this disclosure requirement.
- 26:43And so we're going to talk a little bit about
- 26:45how this plays out on the enforcement side a
- 26:48little bit later in the presentation. Okay. Next
- 26:52slide, please. Okay. So what happens if a contribution
- 27:01is made? that is in violation of the Levine Act
- 27:06or should have required a disqualification. As
- 27:09you can see, these rules are very nuanced, they're
- 27:13very fact intensive, and it also requires understanding
- 27:18a lot of moving pieces and kind of aggregating
- 27:22a lot of different pieces of information in order
- 27:26to really make sure that you're staying ahead
- 27:28of and being compliant with the Levine Act. And
- 27:34another one of the amendments with the most recent
- 27:37updates to the Levine Act was actually expanding
- 27:41the possibility of a safe harbor. So there are
- 27:46two types of safe harbors in play now with the
- 27:48Levine Act. The first is if there's a situation
- 27:52where an officer should be disqualified from
- 27:57voting on a proceeding. they're allowed to return
- 28:01the contribution within 30 days. In order to
- 28:07meet the safe harbor, the officer would have
- 28:10to return the contribution within 30 days. And
- 28:14there's two timeframes. One would be 30 days
- 28:17from within the time that the officer makes a
- 28:19decision that they otherwise were disqualified
- 28:22from participating in, or. when the officer both
- 28:27knows about the proceeding and the contribution.
- 28:32And it's between the two of these, whichever
- 28:35one of these happens last will start the 30 -day
- 28:38safe harbor period to return the contribution.
- 28:42And also the officer is required to disclose
- 28:46that return of the contribution on the record.
- 28:51Now, some of you may be wondering what does it
- 28:53mean to say when an officer knows of a proceeding
- 28:57and a contribution. So it could be that the officer
- 29:04wasn't aware that the contribution happened because
- 29:07it came in, maybe a donor did it over Act Blue.
- 29:10The officer didn't knowingly solicit that contribution.
- 29:13So there could be a variety of ways that an officer
- 29:17receives a contribution. and becomes aware of
- 29:20it only after the fact. And like we talked about
- 29:23earlier, the officer may not know about the proceeding
- 29:27until it proactively comes to their attention.
- 29:31For example, when an applicant or a permit holder,
- 29:35somebody who's appealing an action comes and
- 29:37has a meeting with them and their staff and their
- 29:40office. So that's one type of safe harbor. During
- 29:46the time period when the proceeding is pending.
- 29:51I'm sorry, during the time period for the 12
- 29:53months after final decision has been rendered.
- 29:56So during that time period, the prohibition on
- 29:59receiving contributions over $500 from parties
- 30:02and participants is continuing. But what happens
- 30:07if an officer does solicit director accept a
- 30:10contribution over $500 during that period? There's
- 30:14also a safe harbor that provides that the officer
- 30:17may return the contribution within 30 days of
- 30:23receiving it. But here, this safe harbor can
- 30:27only be taken advantage of if the officer did
- 30:30not knowingly or willfully solicit, accept, or
- 30:34direct the contribution. And so I think this
- 30:37would really apply if, again, I think the win
- 30:40red or act blue processing of a contribution,
- 30:44meaning a donor made it through Um, you know,
- 30:47directly to a fundraiser or through an online
- 30:49forum, not with the elected, um, officer actively
- 30:54soliciting the contribution or appointed officer
- 30:56actively, um, soliciting the contribution, but
- 31:00they discover it during that 12 month period
- 31:03after the proceeding is concluded. Um, then they
- 31:06can return that contribution so long as it wasn't
- 31:09knowingly, um, solicited accepted. Or, um, directed.
- 31:16Next slide please. So I just want to go over
- 31:24again, spend a little more time on agents because,
- 31:27again, agents are given new treatment under the
- 31:30recent amendments to the Levine Act. So again,
- 31:35contributions from agents are no longer aggregated
- 31:38with the party or the participant. So on the
- 31:41one hand, that's great. That means if an agent
- 31:44has made a contribution before a proceeding is
- 31:47pending, it won't count against the party or
- 31:49the participant in terms of requiring the officer
- 31:53to be disqualified and recuse themselves. But
- 31:57a note on that is that regular aggregation rules
- 32:01do shall apply. What that means is that if you
- 32:08are a party or a participant and you're making
- 32:10a contribution, your contributions will potentially
- 32:15aggregate with other contributions. So that would
- 32:18be in scenarios where, for example, if you are
- 32:21the owner of a company and you're majority owner
- 32:26of a company, if you make a contribution and
- 32:29your company makes a contribution, then those
- 32:32two contributions aggregate under normal campaign
- 32:37finance contribution rules within the Political
- 32:39Reform Act. So, if you and your company both
- 32:43make contributions that exceed $500 in the 12
- 32:47months before a proceeding, then that would cause
- 32:50the officer to be disqualified from voting on
- 32:53your proceeding. Another way that aggregation
- 32:57comes up is if you're not a majority owner of
- 33:01a company, but you are the decision maker for
- 33:05that entity's contributions, then that entity's
- 33:09contributions would aggregate with your personal
- 33:12contributions, and it would have the same effect.
- 33:14And this applies both in terms of potentially
- 33:18triggering disqualification before... a proceeding,
- 33:22but also violating the $500 limit once the proceeding
- 33:26is pending and for that 12 months thereafter.
- 33:30So if you make a personal contribution, like
- 33:34let's say you're a party and you make a $500
- 33:37contribution while the proceeding is pending,
- 33:41that's fine. But then a couple months down the
- 33:45road, you direct a contribution on behalf of
- 33:50your company to the same officer for $500. You're
- 33:53now $500 over that Levine Act limit. And if the
- 33:59officer recognizes it, they would be able to
- 34:04return the contribution within 30 days so that
- 34:07they're not in violation of the Levine Act. And
- 34:10that would be remediation for the party as well.
- 34:16And again, I just wanted to reiterate a point
- 34:19that I made earlier, which is if you're a lawyer
- 34:22and you are a member of a law firm, and this
- 34:25also applies to other professions as well. If
- 34:28you're a member of an architectural engineering
- 34:31or consulting firm or a similar entity or corporation,
- 34:36if the individual acting on behalf of that entity
- 34:39or corporation qualifies as an agent, then their
- 34:43entity or corporation is an agent. as well. There
- 34:50are a couple of exceptions for who is not an
- 34:54agent. So again, an agent is somebody who's interfacing
- 34:57with the agency. For the purpose of influencing
- 35:03the agency with regard to a proceeding, but there
- 35:06are times when technical advice has to be provided
- 35:11architectural drawings or engineering designs
- 35:14have to be provided. And so there will be interfacing
- 35:18between technical experts or. materials being
- 35:24provided through the client to the agency. So
- 35:28if you're working in one of those capacities
- 35:30as a technical expert or working on the preparation
- 35:34of engineering or architectural designs, things
- 35:38of a similar nature, and you're not otherwise
- 35:41communicating with the agency for the purpose
- 35:44of influencing it, then those types of interactions
- 35:47will not the law will not treat that person as
- 35:52an agent for purposes of the Levinet. Okay, next
- 36:01slide, please. So in terms of enforcement, well,
- 36:10before getting into a few of the recent enforcement
- 36:13actions, I want to talk a little bit about how
- 36:18the Political Reform Act and the Fair Political
- 36:21Practices Commission treat violations of the
- 36:25of the Political Reform Act and the Levine Act
- 36:27generally. So the Fair Political Practices Commission,
- 36:31I think I've mentioned it a few times throughout
- 36:33the course of the presentation. That is a state
- 36:37agency that was created by the Political Reform
- 36:40Act to both interpret and apply the Political
- 36:45Reform Act, but also to enforce violations of
- 36:48it. So the FPPC both promulgates regulations.
- 36:53It also issues advisory letters, advice letters.
- 36:57These are not binding. They don't have treatment
- 37:02as a law, but they do give the regulated community
- 37:05an idea of how the FPPC is interpreting the act.
- 37:10And the FPPC also enforces the Political Reform
- 37:17Act through administrative proceedings. And under
- 37:23the PRA, a violation is, again, treated usually
- 37:29is an administrative violation subject to a $5
- 37:33,000 per count penalty. Although the FPPC often
- 37:39imposes penalties much lower than that if the
- 37:44harm to the public and other mitigating factors
- 37:47are present. I mentioned that after the Levine
- 37:53Act was amended by the legislature in 2022, the
- 37:56FPPC actually spent most of 2023 getting feedback
- 38:02from the regulated community as it worked through
- 38:05a number of very detailed regulations figuring
- 38:09out how to apply this. Conflict of interest framework
- 38:15to campaign contributions to members of elected
- 38:18bodies who are receiving sometimes hundreds upon
- 38:22hundreds of campaign contributions in any given
- 38:26election cycle. And so they really took their
- 38:30time with that and then. After 2024, the legislature
- 38:34made some clarifying amendments. into some of
- 38:40the FPPC advice that had been put out the year
- 38:43before and also just from seeing what really
- 38:46wasn't working on the ground with application
- 38:50of the Levine Act, what really wasn't reasonable
- 38:54in application. And I think that dynamic nature
- 39:00of the Levine Act in practice is part of why
- 39:05I have not seen a lot of enforcement, certainly
- 39:09not a lot of aggressive enforcement of Levine
- 39:13Act violations right yet. So we're still kind
- 39:18of in that phase where I think the regulated
- 39:20community and the FPPC and agencies are all getting
- 39:25up to speed and getting used to this new framework
- 39:30and new campaign finance conflict of interest
- 39:33world that we're living in. But this one case
- 39:37that I found I thought offered a really good
- 39:42representation of how the Levine Act applies
- 39:47differently depending on which of the characters
- 39:51you are in the cast of characters that we went
- 39:53over earlier in the presentation. So this was
- 39:58a recent enforcement action and it actually ended
- 40:01up with two individuals, a donor and a city council
- 40:08member. One of the matters ended with a warning
- 40:11letter. The other matter ended with a no action,
- 40:15meaning the FPPC did not even issue a warning
- 40:17letter. But it involved the same facts for both
- 40:22parties. And my caveat here is that the... Because
- 40:27of the nature of the disposition of these cases,
- 40:31we don't have, for example, a stipulated settlement.
- 40:33So I don't have all of the facts, but I can kind
- 40:36of read the tea leaves of the warning letters.
- 40:40So you had a city council member, and then you
- 40:44also had a donor. And the donor was a party to
- 40:49a proceeding before the council member's agency.
- 40:53And the party and his limited liability company
- 40:57made contributions to the officer. And so what
- 41:03the party did wrong was the party failed to disclose
- 41:06contributions at the hearing, both on his appeal
- 41:10at the preservation commission, which is where
- 41:12his proceeding was. And at the city council meeting,
- 41:17so he failed to disclose his contributions. But
- 41:25his contributions between him and his limited
- 41:29liability company exceeded that $500 threshold.
- 41:35The city council woman voted on the appeal, even
- 41:39though she should not have. Next slide please.
- 41:48So, there were violations in that case, because
- 41:51of the city council member was disqualified from
- 41:55voting on the matter because she she had received
- 41:57contributions in the aggregate over 500 dollars.
- 42:01And the conclusion from the though was that as
- 42:06to the council member, they said no action. We're
- 42:09not even issuing a warning letter and the concluded.
- 42:14We have insufficient evidence to support a finding
- 42:18that you had reason to know that the contributions
- 42:21were required to be aggregated. So reading between
- 42:25the tea leaves of this, what I read that to mean
- 42:27is that the party to the action, who is also
- 42:31the donor, did not disclose his own contributions
- 42:35or the contributions of his LLC. and probably
- 42:39did not identify that connection when making
- 42:42the contribution to the campaign committee's
- 42:45treasurer who would have been tracking that information
- 42:47on their side as well. So what the FPPC is saying
- 42:51here is you officer, you didn't have reason to
- 42:53know that these contributions were required to
- 42:56be aggregated and therefore we're not going to
- 42:59penalize you for not recusing yourself in that
- 43:03instance. You didn't have knowledge, you didn't
- 43:05have reason to know. donor side, so the party
- 43:09to the proceeding, they issued a warning letter
- 43:14and for the party they found that their actions
- 43:19violated the Political Reform Act because they
- 43:22failed to disclose their contributions at the
- 43:25proceeding. And so, interestingly, it's a warning
- 43:29letter that PPC could have issued a monetary
- 43:33penalty, but they did not. So, I think this shows
- 43:37that the is willing to look at all the facts
- 43:43of the case and. Look at things like was their
- 43:48intent to. Deceive the public was their intent
- 43:52to deceive the officer in question and then,
- 43:56and in this case, the determine that a warning
- 43:59letter would be appropriate. Presumably because
- 44:03of the minimal harm that was perceived to be
- 44:07done to the public. And with. that I would be
- 44:17very happy to take any questions that anybody
- 44:20in the audience has. Let's see what Q &A we have.
- 44:28Oh, what was, so one of the questions that we
- 44:32have is what was the reasoning or intent behind
- 44:35exempting city attorneys? So under the first
- 44:39round of regulations by the FPPC back in When
- 44:45they were working on the regulations in 2023,
- 44:49city attorneys and county council were included
- 44:52within the within the regulations definition
- 44:56of an officer. And there was a lot of pushback
- 45:01by the regulated community. Principally on the
- 45:05argument that the city council or that the city
- 45:09attorneys and county council, they're providing
- 45:10legal advice. They're not decision makers, but
- 45:14I think the view at the time was that, you know,
- 45:19they could ultimately sign contracts, for example,
- 45:22so you turn it like the city attorney's office,
- 45:24of course. Has authority to enter sign a lot
- 45:29of contracts on behalf of the city, but. That
- 45:33was, I think, through the course of 2024, as
- 45:37this is being applied, found to be unworkable.
- 45:41So it was the legislature that made that exclusion
- 45:45in the Political Reform Act in response to some
- 45:50of the regulatory interpretations of that PPC.
- 46:01So what are good best practices for firms to
- 46:05track employee contributions to avoid triggering
- 46:09the Levine Act? So I'm going to guess that you
- 46:14mean law firms, but I mean, this can apply to,
- 46:19this can apply to any firm. One, I think, so,
- 46:30I think that there's a sequential way to go about
- 46:34this, which is identifying when you have a proceeding.
- 46:41I think everything really revolves around when
- 46:44is there a proceeding? When do you think that
- 46:46there will be a proceeding? And once you've identified
- 46:48that. Then from there, you can identify who are
- 46:53your agents going to be so I think that this
- 46:55is a really good question. I've had this come
- 46:57up a lot. What a lot of firms will do is. Identify
- 47:04well, I think. And a lot a lot of companies who
- 47:08are parties will do this as well is they think
- 47:11that they have to put a prohibition on all employees
- 47:14or all members of the firm from making contributions.
- 47:17but it is a little bit more narrow than that.
- 47:22So it is just the individuals who qualify as
- 47:25agents and in the case of a law firm, the firm
- 47:30that qualifies as an agent, it wouldn't be other
- 47:35individuals within the firm who are not agents.
- 47:41To a particular proceeding, their contributions
- 47:44are not going to aggregate with the firm contribution
- 47:46so long as they're not getting reimbursement.
- 47:49From the firm, but I really think it all begins
- 47:53by identifying the proceeding. Identifying who
- 47:58the agents are going to be and really making
- 48:04sure that the individuals who are agents are
- 48:07aware that. Their contributions are going to
- 48:10be prohibited and that's not a company policy.
- 48:14That is that's the law as applied to them as
- 48:17individuals. Alrighty, so it looks like we do
- 48:26have some questions within our help desk here.
- 48:29Sometimes they're received through email. Let's
- 48:33see. What are the most common mistakes you see
- 48:37in determining which contributions must be aggregated
- 48:40towards the $500 threshold? So, definitely, I
- 48:46think the, the holdover, the fact that agent
- 48:52contributions. Are no longer aggregated with
- 48:56the party or participant contributions for whatever
- 48:59reason that information just doesn't seem to
- 49:01have percolated out into the community. That's
- 49:04why I wanted to emphasize it a few different
- 49:06times. So that that is 1 thing and that I think
- 49:13people still have the misconception that agent
- 49:17contributions are still. Aggregated, but I think.
- 49:25The role that you have with making contribution
- 49:30decisions for your firm or that your client has
- 49:34with their company and their personal contributions,
- 49:39I see that come up quite a bit, especially the
- 49:44disclosure issue that came up in the enforcement
- 49:47action that I highlighted is a really good case
- 49:49of that where The individual making the contributions,
- 49:54I think probably didn't realize that their contributions
- 49:58were required to be aggregated. One of the disclosure
- 50:03laws on the campaign finance side is that if
- 50:06you are making an LLC contribution, so a contribution
- 50:11from the funds of the LLC, you have to include
- 50:15the name of the person, authorizing that contribution
- 50:19for the LLC in the name of the donor. So if you
- 50:23look at the campaign finance reports, you would
- 50:27see ACME LLC, name of individual who authorized
- 50:33that contribution for the LLC. I think one of
- 50:36the reasons that the FPPC did that was for the
- 50:41individuals receiving the contributions to be
- 50:44able to identify that a contribution from an
- 50:48individual and an LLC would need to be aggregated.
- 50:52So I think it's just really understanding the
- 50:56nature and the relationships of the parties who
- 51:01are making contributions and understanding when.
- 51:07There's common direction and control or a common
- 51:11ownership to, um, to flag for potential aggregation
- 51:15of contributions. All right, it looks like we
- 51:22have another 1 here just 1 moment. All right,
- 51:28of course, I lose it for a moment. Here we go.
- 51:34For the 12 month post decision prohibition, what
- 51:37event starts the clock. So that would be when
- 51:43a final decision is is rendered in the proceeding.
- 51:47So. If a, if something is moving, for example,
- 51:53from a planning commission to to a city council,
- 51:56because it's being. The planning commission decision
- 51:58is being appealed to the city council. It's once
- 52:02the city council has rendered their decision
- 52:05in that matter, that would begin the 12 month.
- 52:08Period. What compliance procedures should cities
- 52:17and other agencies put in place to identify Levin
- 52:20act issues before an agenda item comes before
- 52:23the governing body. Yeah, so there I've seen
- 52:31different agencies to take a whole range of.
- 52:35Actions ranging from very proactive to no support
- 52:41at all to their officials or to their to their
- 52:45officers. Some agencies I've seen will they they
- 52:51will. What they will do is they will compare
- 52:53the agenda for the upcoming meeting and then
- 52:57identify who the parties are for that proceeding
- 53:02and share that information with the officers
- 53:06so that they in turn can have their staff do
- 53:09a cross reference for their donors and identify
- 53:13if any of the parties to the proceeding and if
- 53:17they can be identified, the participants. then
- 53:21the officer can cross reference that information
- 53:24against their own donor list and figure out if
- 53:28they're gonna have any Levine Act issues requiring
- 53:31them to disqualify. I've seen that work pretty
- 53:37well in some jurisdictions. All right, and let's
- 53:45see, we have another one. The Ontiveros coal
- 53:47matter turned in part. on whether the officer
- 53:50had quote -unquote reason to know that contributions
- 53:53were required to be aggregated. What facts does
- 53:56the FPPC consider sufficient to establish that
- 53:59knowledge? So there's the FPPC actually promulgated
- 54:05a regulation defining knowing and willful receipt
- 54:10of a contribution. And so that's a little slightly
- 54:16different from from what you're what you're asking.
- 54:18But, you know, I think I think it offers a, um,
- 54:22a fair parallel. So, um, and, and, and just for
- 54:26background, the reason why the FPC even like,
- 54:30open the door to make a distinction for knowing
- 54:32and willful is because they're. The FPC does
- 54:37not expect that. Officer is going to be intimately
- 54:42familiar with every single donor. To their campaign
- 54:47or on their most recent campaign finance report
- 54:50at any given moment in time, and that could be
- 54:53particular particularly true for very large jurisdictions
- 54:56like. city of Los Angeles where there's relatively
- 55:01low contribution limits, which means you're having
- 55:03a higher volume of donors. So they look to, did
- 55:08you personally solicit the contribution? Like,
- 55:12did you ask for it yourself? Or if you were at
- 55:15a fundraising event, was it actually like put
- 55:19into your hand by the donor? So there has to
- 55:21be actual knowledge. In terms of the the actual
- 55:27enforcement matter that I went over. I think
- 55:31they're what the FPPC was looking at. And again,
- 55:34we're just, we're looking at the bare bones of
- 55:37the warning letter and the no closure or no action
- 55:40closure letter. So I'm kind of speculating here,
- 55:44but my guess is that because the donor did not
- 55:51meet their statutory obligation of including
- 55:55the full LLC and their name on the donor information
- 56:00that they provided when they made their campaign
- 56:03contribution. The recipient, the officer, wouldn't
- 56:10have from the face of the campaign finance reports
- 56:15or from the information provided from the donor
- 56:17enough information to know that the LLC and that
- 56:22individual were in any way connected. So I don't
- 56:25know that there would have been a standard there
- 56:27that probably was established just on the facts
- 56:30that unfortunately we don't have our hands on.
- 56:36All right, it looks like we have one last question
- 56:38here. What lessons should practitioners take
- 56:41from the Alvey warning letter regarding a party's
- 56:43disclosure obligation at hearings and subsequent
- 56:46meetings? Well, I mean, I think I think certainly
- 56:53disclose 1 thing that I have seen is disclosure
- 56:58where it isn't legally required. But I think,
- 57:02you know, 1 in doubt disclose just so that everybody
- 57:05has the information in the hearing or in the
- 57:09matter. There's there will not be. That PPC isn't
- 57:16going to ding you for over disclosing in this
- 57:19context and providing the information. So. That
- 57:27would be my advice. Right, it looks like that's
- 57:30it for questions. Amber, do you have any other
- 57:32comments or closing remarks that you'd like to
- 57:35make to our audience? Yes, the VINE Act is a
- 57:41very fact -intensive inquiry. So anytime you
- 57:44have a campaign contribution and a proceeding,
- 57:49it's really critical that you're identifying
- 57:51exactly who's who within that proceeding. Understand
- 57:56the timeline of when the disqualification actually
- 58:00is required and when the prohibitions actually
- 58:03attach. It all can be navigated, but it does
- 58:09require a lot of special attention. What I went
- 58:12over in this presentation is fairly high level.
- 58:17There are a number of regulations, as I've mentioned,
- 58:21that the FPPC is promulgated. But since 2023,
- 58:25there have been about two dozen advice letters
- 58:30that have been issued. On the FPPC website, there
- 58:34is a dedicated page just to, it's called Pay
- 58:38to Play, but it's dedicated just to the Levine
- 58:42Act and it includes the FPPC's informational
- 58:46resource pages as well as just a compilation
- 58:50of all of those advice letters. So it's a really
- 58:53good place to go and look if you have specific
- 58:56questions. The FPC very well might have provided
- 58:59advice on that to somebody again. The FPC advice
- 59:03is not. doesn't give anybody immunity, but it
- 59:07does give the regulated community helpful information
- 59:09about how the FPPC is interpreting this information.
- 59:13And I guess the final thing that I will say is
- 59:15that people should not be intimidated from making
- 59:18contributions unless you're an agent during the
- 59:21prohibited time period. Just a matter of being
- 59:26aware. And that's it. I really appreciate everybody
- 59:29joining today. This concludes today's presentation.
- 59:33Thank you again, Amber, for an excellent presentation
- 59:36today and thank you so much to our audience for
- 59:38joining us. Have a great day, everybody.