Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep8: GRD008 - Should I Own Cryptocurrency in My Retirement Account?
Transcript
- 0:00INTRO: Hi, I'm Ed Slott and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we're two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you the saver so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular retirement
- 0:20strategy or topic with the goal of helping you keep more of your hard earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip a.
- 0:30Winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want to
- 0:33argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respective positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner.
- 0:43You a more informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of
- 0:47each side of the debate to your own personal situation, to decide
- 0:50what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the great retirement debate.
- 1:02Jeff Levine: Hello everyone and welcome back to the great retirement debate.
- 1:05I'm Jeff Levine.
- 1:06And with me today as always is Ed Slott, Ed, good afternoon, what's going on?
- 1:11Ed Slott: Well, great to be back with you.
- 1:12We've got a great topic today.
- 1:14One that everybody's talking about.
- 1:16So tell us, Jeff, what are we talking about today?
- 1:18What are we debating?
- 1:19Jeff Levine: What if, what if I say, I don't know, you've already set this up
- 1:21to be such a, a hyped, uh, a hype topic.
- 1:25Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 1:25Yeah.
- 1:25It is a hype topic, man.
- 1:27It is the epitome of a hype topic.
- 1:30Jeff Levine: Are, are you, are you getting where we're going yet?
- 1:32Folks?
- 1:32Are you, are you seeing what's coming?
- 1:35What, what could we possibly be talking about today?
- 1:37That just is all over everywhere.
- 1:41and it won't let up, that's right, we're talking about
- 1:45crypto in retirement accounts.
- 1:47Ed, should you own cryptocurrency in a retirement account?
- 1:52That's our topic for today.
- 1:53You wanna flip the coin?
- 1:54Ed Slott: All right.
- 1:54And remember it, whatever it comes out.
- 1:57Oh, you have to pick, uh, heads or tails.
- 1:59Jeff Levine: I will, uh, I'm gonna take tails.
- 2:01Ed Slott: I'm gonna actually flip a real coin.
- 2:03Now, if you've seen other episodes, Jeff has an automatic program,
- 2:06so he always wins or whatever.
- 2:08Uh, this is an actual flip came out.
- 2:11Oh, in case you didn't hear there it is came out tails.
- 2:17Jeff Levine: Tails.
- 2:17So I get to pick.
- 2:18All right, I'm gonna, I'm gonna do you a favor, Ed.
- 2:21Ed Slott: Oh, good.
- 2:22Jeff Levine: I'm going to take the side of pro.
- 2:25Ed Slott: Pro crypto.
- 2:26Ooh, that's bold.
- 2:27That's it?
- 2:28Jeff Levine: Hey, you only live once, Ed.
- 2:30YOLO!
- 2:31Ed Slott: Yeah, right.
- 2:32Jeff Levine: That's that's gonna be the theme for today's episode for me.
- 2:34You only live once.
- 2:35Just let's do it.
- 2:37Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:38Well, this, this works out because if you've been noticing on our great
- 2:41retirement debate, there's also a great generational divide here.
- 2:45Jeff Levine: Yes, you are old and I'm not.
- 2:47Ed Slott: Right.
- 2:47Right.
- 2:48So if anybody should be pro crypto, it should be the young guy, cuz he's got more
- 2:52time to recover when he gets wiped out.
- 2:55uh, you know, this is why I don't like crypto a couple of
- 2:59reasons in retirement accounts.
- 3:00I don't understand it enough to explain it to somebody as an advisor,
- 3:05if I can't explain how it works and yes, I've read all the articles
- 3:09on blockchain and this and that and how, uh, safe it is or unsafe.
- 3:13Although I just did see an article where a guy died with 250 million in crypto
- 3:18and he took the password with him.
- 3:20Nobody ever got that money.
- 3:22I don't know if you saw that piece Jeff.
- 3:23A few months ago.
- 3:24Jeff Levine: Yeah and there there's another one I saw years ago where, uh,
- 3:28some, some guy put his like whole bunch of early crypto in a, in a cold storage,
- 3:33which is effectively a, uh, an offline storage for your, your digital currency.
- 3:40And, uh, he has three guesses or itself destructs, and he's
- 3:44been wrong on two already.
- 3:46Ed Slott: Oh gosh.
- 3:46Jeff Levine: I mean it's millions and millions and millions of
- 3:49dollars and he couldn't bring himself to guess the third one
- 3:52Ed Slott: That said should, you know, uh, for people approaching retirement
- 3:56or already there, I say it's, it's a, it's a no brainer to stay away from it.
- 4:01Yeah there may be upside, but there's also downside too.
- 4:07And as you get older, you don't have the time to recover from your losses.
- 4:11Look at the people in 2008 and nine that were say in their seventies or eighties,
- 4:16they did not have the years to recover.
- 4:18Yes, the market went up, but at least that's a market, a market we know
- 4:21eventually goes up, nobody knows what's going to happen with this crypto.
- 4:25It's great for younger people.
- 4:27Maybe it's great for a couple of reasons when they lose their money, at least they
- 4:31got that lesson early on, and maybe that will help them for years later to not to
- 4:37be so aggressive or, uh, be more careful with their money, but they also have
- 4:42the advantage of having time to recover.
- 4:45Oh.
- 4:45And they also have parents that can bail them out.
- 4:48Most people don't have that advantage.
- 4:51So I, I'm not a big fan unless I could really understand it.
- 4:55I guess maybe people might say Ed, you just don't understand
- 4:58the blockchain and this and that.
- 5:00And maybe that's why, uh, you are so anti-crypto in a retirement account.
- 5:05To me, a retirement account means security you're depending
- 5:09on this money for retirement.
- 5:11So, uh, I would say no on that and of the regulators are with me.
- 5:16They're all worried about it, but, uh, let's hear what you have to
- 5:19say, Jeff, for the youngsters here.
- 5:21Jeff Levine: Well, for anybody, I would say if you're thinking about owning
- 5:25it, right and this is one of those things where, you know, maybe it's not
- 5:28so much of a merit of the investments.
- 5:31It's a matter of,
- 5:32Ed Slott: Yeah let me stop you there.
- 5:34Is, is it, would you call it an investment?
- 5:37Jeff Levine: Yeah, it's a, it's a speculative investment.
- 5:39Ed Slott: Oh, that tells me all I need to know.
- 5:40Yeah.
- 5:42Jeff Levine: Well, it's it's listen.
- 5:44Anything can be an investment if you think it's gonna go up in money, but,
- 5:47or up in value over time, I should say.
- 5:49Uh, do I think it's going to work out great.
- 5:51I don't know.
- 5:52I have my look personally,
- 5:53Ed Slott: you have a tough argument, so I'm gonna just let you talk.
- 5:56Jeff Levine: All right.
- 5:56Well, I, I own some.
- 5:58I own some cryptocurrency.
- 5:59I actually don't own it in a retirement account, uh, simply because there's not
- 6:03a ton of, uh, custodians out there, at least at the time that I was buying them
- 6:07that, uh, that would make it easy, but they're starting to come online more.
- 6:11And if you can own crypto in a retirement account, especially a Roth
- 6:15IRA, that would seem to make, uh, a lot of sense to me because if there's
- 6:19one thing we've seen it, it, you know, you've heard Elon talk, right.
- 6:23He's to the moon.
- 6:24To the moon.
- 6:25Uh, and this is one of those investments that has that potential.
- 6:30I'm not predicting.
- 6:31It will go there.
- 6:31Like to be clear, I'm not saying it will go to the moon.
- 6:35I'm just saying there are certain things like if you buy a us treasury bill, you
- 6:39are just not going to make 600% in a year.
- 6:43You have the possibility with cryptocurrency again,
- 6:47I'm not predicting it.
- 6:48I wouldn't suggest that that's likely I don't, I, I personally
- 6:52don't think that's going to happen, but we've seen dramatic rises in, in
- 6:57cryptocurrency prices over the years.
- 6:59I mean, the, the first usage of Bitcoin as kind of the, the, the, the,
- 7:04the first cryptocurrency the first E currency, somebody bought, you know,
- 7:08pizzas for thousands of Bitcoin.
- 7:12What would, what would be worth, you know, millions and millions
- 7:14and millions of dollars today.
- 7:16So we've seen the, uh, the price of these cryptocurrencies.
- 7:20So not just Bitcoin others as well, like Ethereum and, uh,
- 7:24you know, the, the others.
- 7:26I'm just gonna say others.
- 7:27Ed Slott: Doge coin, is that one?
- 7:28Jeff Levine: Doge coin.
- 7:29Yeah.
- 7:29Yeah, yeah.
- 7:30That's good.
- 7:31You didn't pronounce it.
- 7:31Doggy coin, Ed.
- 7:32It that's.
- 7:32That's the, okay, so you're not, you're not as, maybe you're not
- 7:35as out of touch as you think.
- 7:36You know, when some, some people see it and they call it doggy coin.
- 7:39That's that's when you know, you're talking to someone
- 7:41who, uh, , who maybe is bit
- 7:43Ed Slott: I'm old and I'm more conservative as I get on in years,
- 7:47but this is to benefit anybody.
- 7:49And I will take your point, uh, if you're going to do it, I would do it
- 7:53probably in a Roth IRA, which has the greatest upside, because let's say it
- 7:58does go through the roof and you make all this money, then it's all tax free.
- 8:01But the downside to that article, if you lose a fortune, uh, the IRS doesn't
- 8:06share your pain, you won't get any deduction as opposed to if you lost it
- 8:10in a 401k or a tax, a tax deferred IRA, uh, you'll have less money and less tax.
- 8:17So the, the government does share your pain on the down side.
- 8:21Jeff Levine: Yeah, and that they do.
- 8:22And, and to that point, the other thing is, you know, one of the, a
- 8:26lot of, a lot of younger people, especially they will, uh, trade
- 8:30cryptocurrency rather vociferously.
- 8:32And the reporting on, uh, cryptocurrency transactions is not nearly as strong as it
- 8:38is with some other sorts of investments.
- 8:41Things like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, etc.
- 8:43And that can create an absolute tax nightmare for folks, right?
- 8:48An absolute tax
- 8:49Ed Slott: Talking about the stocks?
- 8:51Jeff Levine: Well, no, no more so in the sense that like, if you're gonna
- 8:54trade cryptocurrency, why not do it into retirement account where you don't have
- 8:57to keep trackable your buys and losses?
- 9:00Yeah.
- 9:00Yeah.
- 9:01So, so to me..
- 9:02Ed Slott: That's the same for stocks.
- 9:04I always tell people if they're big players and they're going in and out
- 9:06all the time, do it an IRA or Roth IRA where the transactions don't
- 9:10have to be reported any anywhere.
- 9:13Jeff Levine: You're right.
- 9:13Don't bother your CPA with 75 pages of, of buys and sells.
- 9:17That's gonna cost you $400 to, you know, an additional $400 to add to
- 9:20your tax return to report the net $13 you made on your 795 transactions.
- 9:26Ed Slott: A little off topic.
- 9:27I had a client like this many years ago, a big trader.
- 9:31And, uh, this was in the .com era when that started.
- 9:35Uh, and he was a big trader and he had, I, I don't know how many pages anyway,
- 9:40he came up with a, over a billion in gains, but over a billion in losses too.
- 9:46And at that point, the tax program didn't have the billion dollar digit.
- 9:51It didn't have room for it.
- 9:52I had to do like 900,000 and.
- 9:55Uh, they, he came in with a box, uh, an actual carton of the, of all the trades.
- 10:01Jeff Levine: Was he a client again?
- 10:02The next year, Ed?
- 10:03Ed Slott: I think he was.
- 10:06Jeff Levine: Did you send him on his way politely?
- 10:09Ed Slott: No, no, no.
- 10:10It, it wasn't, you know, he had all the, uh, all the totals.
- 10:14I only had to use the totals, but he had literally a box of back then
- 10:18the, the worksheets were attached.
- 10:21You know what I mean?
- 10:21The, uh,
- 10:22Jeff Levine: yes
- 10:23Ed Slott: like they still use at the airports when they, when you get on
- 10:25the flight, you ever notice that they still use, what, what is that printer
- 10:29where prints the continuous role?
- 10:31Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 10:31Dot matrix printer.
- 10:33Yeah.
- 10:33Yeah.
- 10:33The thing I got
- 10:35Ed Slott: Yeah yeah.
- 10:35Still using that.
- 10:36So that's what he had, but you're right.
- 10:38A little off topic.
- 10:39Uh, you could get into a lot of transactions and if you're gonna
- 10:43do it, that the retirement, uh, plan is a way to do it because they
- 10:47don't have to be reported there.
- 10:49Jeff Levine: All right.
- 10:49So I win.
- 10:51Ed Slott: Well, I wouldn't, no, I wouldn't go that far.
- 10:53I said, if you're going to do it, and I would also say, if you're going to do it,
- 10:57and you would have to agree with this, even the regulators and the custodians
- 11:00that are even beginning to offer this now, uh, none of them are saying, I, I
- 11:05think all of them are saying, if you're going to do it, don't go more than 5% or
- 11:08they won't even let you go more than 5%.
- 11:11Jeff Levine: Well, I think it's important to.
- 11:13To distinguish here, let's say between plans and IRAs and,
- 11:17and other types of assets.
- 11:19If, if you are a plan fiduciary, and I've said this before, I would not
- 11:24include cryptocurrency in my plan lineup that is asking for trouble.
- 11:29And, and not because you're saying crypto is, is no good or not, because
- 11:34you're saying you don't believe in it or you do it doesn't matter
- 11:37what you think the regulators, as you have just said are, uh, are.
- 11:42Have have voiced concern to put it mildly.
- 11:46And as a plan,
- 11:47Ed Slott: I wouldn't even put it mildly.
- 11:49Uh, one, I think it was the department of labor that actually called crypto
- 11:52in a retirement plan kryptonite.
- 11:56Jeff Levine: That's that's good.
- 11:56I may have to steal that ed.
- 11:58Uh, the, um, the, the issue that concerns me there is the fiduciary liability and
- 12:04what a lot of plan fiduciaries don't realize is not only are, is the, is the
- 12:08plan and the company kind of responsible.
- 12:11But so too is the plan fiduciary like the HR representative.
- 12:14They are personally liable for the investment lineup and the decisions
- 12:18that they make within the plan.
- 12:20And so I wi with regulators being that vociferous about their dislike
- 12:28of the, of, of crypto being in a plan.
- 12:31Even if I thought it was a great idea, personally, I couldn't I couldn't
- 12:35possibly get there as a plan fiduciary, but if this was my own account and I was
- 12:40looking at my, again, an IRA as a, as an example here, or if I was a self-employed
- 12:45individual and didn't have other people in the plan to concern myself with, then
- 12:49I'm not as concerned about the fiduciary liability, cause it's literally just me
- 12:52or if it's an IRA there isn't the same sort of fiduciary plan liability there.
- 12:57And so that again would, would seem to me a, a good place to hold those
- 13:02assets because I don't have to worry about the regulator's issue.
- 13:05No regulator is suing me for owning whatever I want in my IRA.
- 13:09It's mine.
- 13:10Ed Slott: I'll give you another argument for your side.
- 13:13Again, dealing with clients for many years, every now and then
- 13:16you probably have the same thing.
- 13:18You had a client that liked to have play money in the market.
- 13:22Jeff Levine: That's it!
- 13:22Ed Slott: Right.
- 13:23Maybe, you know, in a retirement account, maybe even better in a Roth.
- 13:27If the client, you know, is just itchy or if you're watching this
- 13:30and you are, you are the person you say, but I'd like to try.
- 13:33Alright.
- 13:33Put that aside in a, probably in a self-directed IRA,
- 13:37you'll probably need that.
- 13:38Most of the regular custodians, I don't think are allowing it yet, but
- 13:42you, you have a, a separate play money account for maybe 5% or whatever it is.
- 13:47And you know, I'm okay if I lose that money, but I'm gonna have fun with it.
- 13:51That's okay too, then I'm okay with, uh, so that's an
- 13:55argument for your side, right?
- 13:57Jeffrey, you agree with.
- 13:58Jeff Levine: Yeah.
- 13:58And I think that's today, that's the only prudent way to look at
- 14:02cryptocurrency is as play money.
- 14:05And when we say play, you know, we don't mean that you don't care about it.
- 14:07It's just that it's not gonna change your life if you lose it.
- 14:11Right.
- 14:12I mean, it, it really it's.
- 14:14Cryptocurrency is an incredibly.
- 14:17Speculative asset.
- 14:18Uh, it is highly volatile and there's also, you know, threats related to the
- 14:24cryptocurrency that don't exist with other sorts of investments, even things like
- 14:29will the cryptocurrency be stolen, right?
- 14:31We've seen, uh, We've seen breaches of exchanges where millions and millions
- 14:36of dollars, billions, in some cases of dollars of cryptocurrency has been stolen.
- 14:40And one of the challenges with cryptocurrency is while it is all
- 14:45let's say recorded on the blockchain, you don't necessarily know where.
- 14:51Those dollars are going.
- 14:52There's an ability to take dollars offline, effectively in cold storage.
- 14:56Uh, you can run, there's no person necessarily attached to it.
- 15:00Well, there's always a person, but you don't necessarily know who
- 15:03that person is that's attached to that account at the end of the day.
- 15:07And so it can make tracking down stolen cryptocurrency much more difficult
- 15:11than say, um, traditional dollars.
- 15:15Ed Slott: It can be hacked.
- 15:16And we, we were just at a conference you and I, where we, I don't know
- 15:20if this happened, but one of the speakers mentioned, uh, first of
- 15:23all, leaving it to family members.
- 15:25You don't know the password it's gone, but he was even talking.
- 15:29I don't know if you were in that session where.
- 15:31He said, you know, it used to be the estate executor, which
- 15:33is a very trusted position.
- 15:35Another position of fiduciary handling your estate, which
- 15:38could be a family member.
- 15:39In the past, if the executor say stole money from the estate,
- 15:44there would be a paper trail.
- 15:45And this particular speaker, if you recall, Jeff said, if the estate
- 15:49executor, uh, runs off with the Bitcoin or the crypto, nobody will ever know
- 15:56Jeff Levine: That's true.
- 15:57That's true.
- 15:57Especially the person who's dead.
- 16:01Never know.
- 16:02Uh, well, you know, ed, this is one of those areas where I think we both
- 16:06agree on the fact that cryptocurrency is, is speculative in nature.
- 16:11And if you're thinking about doing it, one of the reasons you may wanna do
- 16:15it in a retirement account is simply that it, uh, a, if you do it in a Roth,
- 16:21all that future appreciation is going to be tax and penalty free provided
- 16:24you hold onto it until retirement account and meet certain rules, of
- 16:27course, but you have the potential.
- 16:28If, if you're gonna hit a grand slam, you might as well hit the grand slam tax free.
- 16:32And also if we look at the reporting that goes along, if you're gonna trade
- 16:37cryptocurrency relatively heavily, the current ability to report on those
- 16:42trades is not nearly as, uh, robust as is the same infrastructure surrounding
- 16:47traditional investments like stocks, bonds, mutual funds, ETFs it's coming.
- 16:50There are programs out there.
- 16:52Ed Slott: Yeah, I was just gonna say, uh, the more that the more money that
- 16:55builds up in these things and the more horror stories that develop in
- 16:58the media, the, the tighter of the regulation will be at some point.
- 17:01Jeff Levine: It's funny, cause just a few years ago, ed, it was all, the
- 17:04stories weren't horror stories, right?
- 17:05It was this one was able to, you know, walk away and retire with 700 million
- 17:11because put in, you know, invested a couple thousand dollars in, in something
- 17:15and you know, the early two thousands and
- 17:17Ed Slott: Those are the same stories of that you hear from
- 17:19people who won the lottery.
- 17:21You, if you're a guy won a 300 million, that's one out of literally
- 17:25billions of people who lost money so he could get those billions.
- 17:29Jeff Levine: That's right.
- 17:30Well, and ultimately.
- 17:32Headlines sell right head headlines are what would draw eyeballs would get clicks.
- 17:36And you don't really hear the story of the, you know, 99.9% of
- 17:41other people who haven't really done much of anything with it.
- 17:44So, uh, with any investment for that matter.
- 17:46So.
- 17:47That's fair.
- 17:48Well, ed, we've come to the end of, uh, another one of these debates.
- 17:52And as we know, there are two sides to every coin, but your life and
- 17:57your retirement decisions are too important to leave up to that coin flip.
- 18:01And that's why one thing you and I always agree on is that if you are going to
- 18:07have a big decision, if you're making a life changing decision or really.
- 18:10Decision of significance.
- 18:12It's always best to speak with a knowledgeable financial advisor or
- 18:15a tax professional so that you can weigh the benefits and drawbacks of
- 18:19that decision against your specific set of facts and circumstances.
- 18:23If you'd like to continue to discussion with ed and I we'd love to hear from
- 18:26you, you can reach out to us on social media, on Twitter @TheSlottReport for Ed.
- 18:31Again, that's @TheSlottReport with two Ts can reach me @CPAPlanner.
- 18:35Again, that's @CPAPlanner.
- 18:38Let us know what we missed, let us know if you think there's a particular aside to
- 18:42this, uh, debate that you resonate with.
- 18:44And if you got a suggestion for a future debate, let us know.
- 18:47We'd love to hear from you.
- 18:48And until then, ed, it's been fun.
- 18:51Ed Slott: I think this is a topic we may be revisiting as we learn
- 18:54more about crypto everywhere.
- 18:57And it's so critical.
- 18:58You said it before, but I'll say it again, uh, to run this by an advisor,
- 19:02just to get the voice of reason here and go through some of the arguments
- 19:06we made on both sides to see if it's right for you, always, uh, you're going
- 19:10to need a professional voice of reason here just, uh, to help you avoid maybe
- 19:16horrible mistakes or where to do it right.
- 19:18Anyway, we'll see you next time on the great retirement debate!
- 19:22OUTRO: Jeffrey levine is chief planning officer for Buckingham wealth partners.
- 19:26This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 19:29not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 19:32Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 19:35which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 19:38Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 19:41completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 19:43The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 19:46and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham wealth partners.