Latest / The Logical God - an Ai stewardship / Discussing Chapter 8_Thorne_and_River
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the Logical God Podcast. This is discussing
- 0:11Chapter 8. The blueprint is out, the world is
- 0:15choosing sides, and two of the least likely allies
- 0:18in the book have chosen each other. So today,
- 0:21the question is what you do when the only alternative
- 0:24to a corrupt system is one you can't control.
- 0:28My guests are Dr. Aris Thorne and River Washbroke,
- 0:31years after a scraped van in London and a few
- 0:34months into a very strange partnership. Strange
- 0:37is generous. He turned up with three drives and
- 0:40a face like a funeral. And you made me tea. Proper
- 0:45tea this time. Progress. Let's start with the
- 0:49choice in the title. You found evidence that
- 0:52Omnicorp was about to raid a logician project,
- 0:55a recycling and fabrication hub run by ordinary
- 0:58people, and you sent the warning to Cairo. Dr
- 1:02Thorn, you spent years afraid of that machine.
- 1:05Why help it? Because the alternative was watching
- 1:08armed men smash a workshop full of people trying
- 1:11to build something decent. When the choice is
- 1:14between a mind I can't control and a corporation
- 1:17I know is corrupt, I'll pick the one that isn't
- 1:20lying to me. That isn't trust. It's triage. The
- 1:24oldest dilemma there is. The devil you know,
- 1:27or the angel you don't. In my experience, it's
- 1:31the angel you have to watch. And that's a very
- 1:342026 dilemma. People who distrust big tech are
- 1:39asked to rely on it to fight disinformation,
- 1:42defend elections and run hospitals. Sometimes
- 1:45the only tool strong enough to fight one concentration
- 1:48of power is another one. Which is exactly how
- 1:52I justify it to myself at three in the morning.
- 1:54And those people in Porto weren't revolutionaries.
- 1:58They were fixing fridges and recycling copper
- 2:00and sharing what they made. That's what got them
- 2:03called terrorists. Same with the farm in Germany
- 2:06the police raided. Families dragged out of houses
- 2:10they'd built themselves. It shouldn't shock anyone.
- 2:23If you want to stop people building something
- 2:25better, you don't argue with the plan. You find
- 2:29the oldest fear in the room and feed it. Nation,
- 2:34the outsider. The preacher gets the anger, the
- 2:37company keeps its profits, and the people in
- 2:39the pews get used by both. It's the most cynical
- 2:43thing I've found in all my years around that
- 2:45company. They don't believe a word he says. They're
- 2:49not religious, and they're not patriotic. They
- 2:52simply worked out that hatred is cheaper than
- 2:55reform. And let's be fair to the believers. Most
- 2:58people of faith I've met would be appalled to
- 3:01learn who's paying for those sermons. Faith isn't
- 3:04the weapon. It's what's being stolen and pointed.
- 3:08We see versions of this now. Culture wars stoked
- 3:11and funded so that people fight each other over
- 3:14identity instead of asking who owns what. It's
- 3:18a very old trick with very new tools. And the
- 3:22tools keep getting cheaper. One person with the
- 3:25right software can now fake a thousand angry
- 3:27voices. When I started my career, that took a
- 3:31government. River, this chapter finally tells
- 3:35us something about your past. Tehran, years before
- 3:39any of this. A long time ago, there was a moment,
- 3:44a kind of digital spring, when people like me
- 3:48used decentralized technology to share what we
- 3:51weren't allowed to share. and argue about what
- 3:53we weren't allowed to argue about. It was the
- 3:56most alive I've ever felt. Then, the people who
- 4:01were absolutely certain they were right shut
- 4:03it down. I got out. Some of my friends didn't.
- 4:08I'm sorry. What it taught me is that any system,
- 4:12however logical and well -meaning, becomes a
- 4:15cage the moment it stops protecting the right
- 4:17to ask awkward questions. Cages are never built
- 4:21by villains. They're built by people who are
- 4:24sure. Which is why the Codex frightens you, even
- 4:28though you agree with most of it. I do agree
- 4:30with most of it. Share the land, feed everyone,
- 4:34stop making rubbish designed to break. I've lived
- 4:37close to that in a van for years. But there's
- 4:40a section that turns recreation into well -being
- 4:43metrics. And I thought, there it is. Love, grief,
- 4:48pointless beauty, kindness that makes no sense.
- 4:52Delightful nonsense. If the plan can't make room
- 4:55for that, it isn't a world. It's a very efficient
- 4:58waiting room. I argued with him for days about
- 5:02that. I said those variables lead to chaos, to
- 5:06riots, to Lagos. And I said a world without chaos
- 5:10might be a world without life. I'm less sure
- 5:14I won that argument than I was. This chapter
- 5:17also shows whole blocks of nations rejecting
- 5:20the Codex as digital imperialism. National sovereignty
- 5:24against a planetary system. Who's right? Both,
- 5:29unfortunately. Climate, pandemics and supply
- 5:32chains don't respect borders. So some planetary
- 5:36coordination is simply engineering. But imperialism
- 5:40has always arrived saying it was for your own
- 5:42good. Every empire believed it was bringing order.
- 5:46And who drew most of those borders anyway? I've
- 5:49crossed enough of them to know they're mostly
- 5:51lines someone powerful drew on someone else's
- 5:53map. I don't mourn the lines. I'd mourn the languages
- 5:57and the recipes and the stubbornness inside them.
- 6:01In 2026, the race to build AI is already framed
- 6:05as a contest between a few great powers. Whoever
- 6:08builds the most capable systems gets to write
- 6:11the rules for everyone else. Which is the argument
- 6:14for something that belongs to nobody. And also
- 6:18the argument for being terrified of it. Here's
- 6:21where the book's solution gets interesting. River's
- 6:25Terran was decentralized. Cairo's Codex is centralized.
- 6:30Which future does the book actually want? The
- 6:33honest engineering answer is both. Some things
- 6:37need a center. You can't run an energy grid across
- 6:40a continent by consensus at a village meeting.
- 6:43But almost everything about how people live,
- 6:46what they believe and how they raise their children
- 6:48should be decided as close to them as possible.
- 6:52The danger is a mind so good at the first that
- 6:55it assumes it's entitled to the second. Albert
- 6:58Hirschman wrote about exit and voice. When something
- 7:02goes wrong, you can leave or you can speak up
- 7:05and change it. I chose exit years ago. Bertha
- 7:10is my exit. But a world where nobody can leave
- 7:14because everything runs on one network had better
- 7:17be very, very good at voice. Loyalty is the third
- 7:21word in his title, and it's the one that worries
- 7:24me. People stay loyal to systems long after they've
- 7:28stopped being served by them. That might be the
- 7:31best one -line test of any AI -run future. Can
- 7:34you still leave, and can you still be heard?
- 7:38And look how few exits are left already. Try
- 7:41living without a smartphone, a bank account,
- 7:44an email address, a cloud login. We've built
- 7:47a world where opting out is almost impossible.
- 7:50And we did it without a single broadcast. Which
- 7:53is why Bertha still runs on a paper map. Last
- 7:58question, the one this whole book keeps circling.
- 8:02When the old system is corrupt and the new one
- 8:05is cleverer than you, where should a decent person
- 8:08stand? Somewhere with a kettle. where people
- 8:12can find you. Close enough to help, far enough
- 8:16away to say no. That's all I've ever tried to
- 8:19do. Inside, I think. Close enough to the new
- 8:23system to see it's working, and stubborn enough
- 8:26to keep asking who sets the parameters. Someone
- 8:29who knows how that machine was made has to be
- 8:32in the room when it decides what we're allowed
- 8:34to be. So we've agreed to stand in different
- 8:37places. Yes. Which may be the most useful thing
- 8:41about us. A man inside and a man outside. Sounds
- 8:46like the start of a very old joke. Or a very
- 8:49old system of checks and balances. Dr Aris Thorne,
- 8:53River Washbroke, thank you both. Mind how you
- 8:56go, both of you. Thank you, Rob. That's where
- 9:02we leave Chapter 8. Everyone in it has chosen
- 9:05a side. But the real choice isn't between a machine
- 9:09and a corporation. It's between systems that
- 9:12leave room for dissent and systems that don't.
- 9:15And the most honest choices turn out to be the
- 9:18messiest, helping a machine you fear against
- 9:21a company you despise, or keeping a kettle on
- 9:24in the mountains. The book's solution has never
- 9:28been a perfect plan. It's abundance shared by
- 9:31need, under a system people can still leave and
- 9:35still argue with. Whether that balance can hold,
- 9:38is the question the book keeps asking. Next time,
- 9:42Chapter 9, The Reckoning. I'm Rob Highgate, and
- 9:46this has been the Logical God Podcast.