Latest / TFTC: A Bitcoin Podcast / #736: Bitcoin Treasury for Business with Scott Marmoll
Transcript
- 0:00Scott.
- 0:01Marty.
- 0:02We're here.
- 0:02We've been working together on something for the last, what, two months now?
- 0:07Measured in AI years, probably two years.
- 0:10Yes.
- 0:10But yes, at least a couple months.
- 0:11Yeah.
- 0:12And so I think we just jump right into it because we're launching the PDF that we've been working on,
- 0:16the Bitcoin Treasury and Exit Playbook,
- 0:19which we've been mulling around again for the better part of two months
- 0:24and basically what you're doing at Capital B Advisory,
- 0:26what I'm doing at TFTC and 1031,
- 0:31what the Bitcoin price is doing right now going up.
- 0:33I think it's important for business owners
- 0:36to understand, particularly private business owners,
- 0:40to understand the opportunity that Bitcoin presents them
- 0:43as a balance sheet asset.
- 0:45So we banged our heads and our clankers together
- 0:47for the better part of two months.
- 0:49We came up with this playbook, which you can go get now.
- 0:51The link to the playbook is in the show notes here,
- 0:54so you can go find those.
- 0:56But yeah, I think that's what we're going to do today is just walk through the playbook.
- 0:59But before we walk through it, maybe explain what the audience will get out of this if they listen to the end and why you're passionate about this particular part of the market.
- 1:10Yeah, I think hopefully useful tool.
- 1:14You know, Clanker aside, the content is ours with a lot of thought and detail into it.
- 1:21It's a playbook for, you know, the Bitcoin space has a lot of advice on what to do as an individual.
- 1:26and some individuals are business owners
- 1:29and those Bitcoiners need a guidebook
- 1:33for what that looks like for their business.
- 1:36Because at the end of the day,
- 1:37the goal on the individual side and the business side
- 1:39is to get as much Bitcoin as possible.
- 1:41I have sort of a decade of experience
- 1:45helping private business owners raise capital,
- 1:47whether that's selling the business,
- 1:49raising debt or equity,
- 1:51and recently brought that skill set
- 1:54specifically to the Bitcoiner
- 1:56business owner sector, which is not to say Bitcoin focused businesses and services exclusively,
- 2:03but rather just anyone with the mindset of a Bitcoiner should probably get advice when it
- 2:08comes to raising capital or selling their business from someone with the mindset of a Bitcoiner.
- 2:12So that's the idea. Playbook has lots of nuggets of wisdom from the dipping your toes to stacking
- 2:21a little bit of sats with the company cash flow to how do we augment that to should I own this
- 2:27thing at all when Bitcoin is your opportunity cost that question gets a lot harder to answer
- 2:32so that's the attempt and hopefully some good wisdom in there yeah I guess we start out it's
- 2:38broken up into four parts the four first part is the case for Bitcoin treasury in the first place
- 2:44like why if you're a business owner whether you're Bitcoin or not should you be thinking about this
- 2:50obviously Michael Saylor strategy been a big meme in public markets over the last almost five years.
- 2:57But this strategy applies to private businesses as well and probably is actually better for private businesses.
- 3:05It does and it is with the caveat that it's a little less financial engineering, right?
- 3:11Like Saylor's created a magical flywheel that I think people will study for ages.
- 3:17In the private markets, it's a little simpler.
- 3:20The opportunity is similar, though, which is accumulating Bitcoin on the balance sheet for businesses is augmenting the performance in the balance sheet,
- 3:30whereas the historical sort of fiat landscape for valuing businesses is all based on the P&L.
- 3:35And so you start to accumulate this hard asset.
- 3:38It gives you optionality to do other things.
- 3:40First section is kind of Bitcoin curiosity around the Bitcoin or business owner.
- 3:44Okay, what do I do?
- 3:46What should I do to start to explore that?
- 3:49Same as when you're first exploring Bitcoin as an individual, you start to get the advice of, hey, I should DCA.
- 3:55I should be careful not to be in a forced seller position over the short term.
- 3:59All these things apply, but in the business owner perspective, there's other factors.
- 4:04A big one being that if you own control, then the difference between doing this on your personal balance sheet and on your corporate balance sheet, there might be no difference.
- 4:13There might be major tax implications.
- 4:14And if you have sort of shared equity with family members or early investors or scaled investors, then suddenly the unilateral control to distribute capital is limited.
- 4:29But if you own control, then you still have the control to raise or to put Bitcoin on the balance sheet.
- 4:36So for some folks, it's like, hey, my father-in-law is a minority investor.
- 4:41And if I distribute cash to buy Bitcoin on my personal balance sheet, I've got to distribute cash to him too.
- 4:47And he's not going to buy Bitcoin with it.
- 4:49And I'm tired of arguing with him at Thanksgiving.
- 4:51I'm just going to buy Bitcoin and put it on the company balance sheet so that he now owns some Bitcoin through that minority equity position.
- 4:59So lots of little factors in there.
- 5:00I think at the solo entrepreneur and small, small business phase, it's really hard to distinguish between the personal balance sheet and the professional sort of corporate balance sheet.
- 5:08But as you get into that sort of two, five, $50 million of free cash flow, you're talking about businesses that have different tradeoffs between the tax and the shareholder dynamics for stacking sats in the corporate entity versus distributing to shareholders.
- 5:25Well, not only that, too, but once you get to those larger scales of cash flowing and then stacking cash on the balance sheet,
- 5:34the opportunity cost of keeping it in cash versus something like Bitcoin is extremely high.
- 5:38That's something we described in the first section as well, is trying to make the case, why should your business have Bitcoin on its balance sheet?
- 5:46Well, exactly. And I think, you know, do I expect the sort of non-Bitcoiner to crack this book and go, oh, my gosh, this is it?
- 5:52Maybe not, but I think it's going to help.
- 5:55And that first section is just explaining,
- 5:56look, if you have $10 million of working capital cash
- 6:00that you keep on hand to fund payroll and inventory
- 6:03and maintenance capex, that's a painful necessity
- 6:08because over a year's time,
- 6:11if you're, everyone's experience inflation is different.
- 6:15The CPI number is just one metric,
- 6:17but for most folks, especially in businesses,
- 6:20you're probably closer to PPI.
- 6:21that metric is still totally manipulated but the reality i think for most businesses especially if
- 6:27they have to accumulate any hard assets on the balance sheet is like 10 percent purchasing power
- 6:31loss every year so 10 million dollars of working capital cash gets you eight million dollars worth
- 6:35of stuff in a year that's a huge that's an important piece of the business um to to have
- 6:41optimized and you know there's a lot of different ways to skin that cat but certainly just sitting
- 6:46on a pile of cash is not the best way to do it.
- 6:48No.
- 6:49And then in terms of bringing this back to board members, family members,
- 6:55I think the way in which we describe the frame is really highlighting that problem
- 7:00that you just described with the erosion of the purchasing power,
- 7:03the cash sitting on your balance sheet,
- 7:04and basically having them recognize that first.
- 7:07So if you do have a board or a group of people you need to convince,
- 7:10I think framing and backing into a Bitcoin treasury strategy is very important here.
- 7:16Start with the problem.
- 7:17Exactly.
- 7:18Yeah.
- 7:18I think, and this is true for orange pilling your friends and family, your colleagues, or in the boardroom.
- 7:23Start with the problem.
- 7:25Who does a really good job of this?
- 7:27Jeff Booth, right?
- 7:28He was in nine chapters of the book, Price of Tomorrow, before he mentions the word Bitcoin.
- 7:32And he paints the problem pretty well.
- 7:34So I agree.
- 7:35It's the same approach there.
- 7:37because the odds that even if you are sort of fully orange-pilled Bitcoiner,
- 7:42it's not likely that your $20 million EBITDA business
- 7:45has a perfectly aligned board on this topic or shareholder group.
- 7:50It's common.
- 7:51I see a lot of like brothers-in-law that co-own businesses.
- 7:54That's a very common dynamic, right?
- 7:57Guys end up brothers-in-law through marrying
- 8:01and then they start a business sometime in their 30s.
- 8:04And by their 40s or 50s, they've got like a really nice asset.
- 8:08One of them is a Bitcoin or one's not.
- 8:10This is a super common dynamic.
- 8:11I'm actually working with some clients right now that have this dynamic.
- 8:13They're not brothers-in-law, but they are dear friends.
- 8:17One's totally down the rabbit hole.
- 8:19The other one's tiptoeing.
- 8:21So this would be a great tool for that conversation.
- 8:23And then moving into the tactical playbook and sort of frameworks for thinking about how to approach an allocation,
- 8:33depending on the scale of your business,
- 8:35the buy-in from board or brothers-in-laws
- 8:37that you may need?
- 8:38Right.
- 8:39Yeah, I mean, I think the last thing you want to do
- 8:42is rock the boat.
- 8:43So you want to be careful that you don't kind of say,
- 8:46all right, team, we're all in Bitcoin
- 8:48on October 6th of 2025, right?
- 8:50And then suddenly your working capital situation is dire.
- 8:55So, you know, the case is gonna be different
- 8:58for every single business and situation,
- 8:59but thoughtful approach to what's our runway, what's our burn, what is our sort of cash conversion cycle,
- 9:08and what can we do to safely move some of the value that's trapped in that situation into Bitcoin.
- 9:16And I think boards think about this anyway because they certainly don't want you sitting on cash,
- 9:21but usually it's, hey, reinvest in the business.
- 9:23But if the reinvestment in the business is like a 10%, 15% return on invested capital,
- 9:29So, you know, you probably want to evaluate other options a la Bitcoin.
- 9:34It's a lot less work to sit in Bitcoin and clip that success.
- 9:39It's also very hard to sell a board on that when we're at, you know, 70-some K and down 40-plus percent.
- 9:45But it's also the best time to do it.
- 9:47It is.
- 9:47And we touch on it in the playbook as well.
- 9:50But I think building on what you were just saying there with our experience at 1031,
- 9:55and we've seen this within our portfolio, Grant Gillum, co-founder,
- 9:59and a partner of mine at 1031, he wrote this piece, I think, two or three years ago,
- 10:04maybe even longer than that.
- 10:05At this point, Bitcoin is the fourth lever of equity value growth.
- 10:10And it's something we've highly encouraged portfolio companies to do,
- 10:16particularly if Bitcoin is significantly below the price of the previous all-time high,
- 10:22and they've raised around, let's put a chunk of that into Bitcoin,
- 10:25make sure you have enough runway to reinvest in the business and make payroll and all that.
- 10:29but put a chunk of Bitcoin, build out your company, your product suite as quickly and as efficiently as possible,
- 10:39run as lean as possible, get to revenue, profitability, and you'll find at the end of the day,
- 10:44Bitcoin has this forcing function to make you efficient, to make sure that you're not adding a ton of bloat to your organization.
- 10:51And then on top of that, once you get to profitability and you're looking pretty,
- 10:57when you go back to market and Bitcoin
- 10:59has appreciated, that takes two or three years.
- 11:02The value of the business is
- 11:03looking good and then you have incredible optionality
- 11:05as a founder. So a bit different scale.
- 11:08You're talking mid-market, established
- 11:09companies, spitting out cash flow.
- 11:11But it's true either way.
- 11:13I don't know where it was. Grant gave a presentation
- 11:15I watched on YouTube.
- 11:17Riga. Yes. And he's got
- 11:19great memes in there.
- 11:22Grant does a wonderful
- 11:23job of balancing Wall Street jargon
- 11:25and memes. I think there's a Michael Jackson
- 11:27thriller zombie image in there that gets to the heart of the problem, which is a lot of businesses,
- 11:33you know, if their sort of hurdle rate was Bitcoin, then they shouldn't exist. And yes,
- 11:40you guys at 1031 have lived it. The scale is different in venture, but honestly, you know,
- 11:46I think a lot of the way 1031 thinks about investment is more like a private equity fund.
- 11:50I mean, Bitcoin land doesn't have super copious numbers of 10, $20 million EBITDA businesses, but I think you guys are working hard to change that with the investments you make.
- 12:03And whether a business is negative cash flow like a venture opportunity or mid-market and cash flowing quite nicely, the math is the same, which is holding a bunch of cash for the long term is for sure not the best idea.
- 12:17Then the question is just, well, what is the right mix?
- 12:20Um, and, and I definitely think that from the investor perspective, from the 1031 perspective,
- 12:27you guys have probably seen it where having Bitcoin on balance sheet augments the equity
- 12:31value math in a way that's been helpful in otherwise, you know, down times in, in business
- 12:37cycles.
- 12:38Um, and you're right.
- 12:40I think it, it sounds too simple, but really just as long as you're not like right at all
- 12:45time highs, it's probably an okay time to stack aggressively into a Bitcoin treasury
- 12:49for the long term.
- 12:51And I think we talk about it in the book,
- 12:54in the PDF here,
- 12:55but you guys have seen that firsthand, right?
- 12:57I mean, some of the 1031 portcos
- 12:59have kind of weathered longer
- 13:02than they otherwise would have
- 13:04because they raised
- 13:05and allocated meaningfully that raise to Bitcoin.
- 13:09And now it gives them more runway
- 13:11because it's more than it was
- 13:12if they would have kept it in dollars.
- 13:14Yeah.
- 13:14And I think this gets into a good
- 13:16point of the playbook as well,
- 13:18which is running through the tactical decision tree of do I lump sum, do I DCA,
- 13:26in what situation should I do either or.
- 13:28And I think that's very important too because I think a lot of what we see in the 1031
- 13:32is the raise and most companies will do a DCA over a set period of time.
- 13:37Yep, yep.
- 13:38And that set period of time is less than a four-year, if cycles exist,
- 13:42it's less than a four-year cycle.
- 13:43There's not a right answer on this.
- 13:45That one, I mean, even, well, I'll tell you, on the personal side, whatever, if anybody could just look through all my trades, they should just do the exact opposite.
- 13:54Michael Saylor is competing for top tick king, but I'm pretty darn good at it.
- 14:00But the good news is if you just wait it out, that trade ends up being a good trade anyway.
- 14:04But that said, I like what Adam Back says about this.
- 14:08It's like if you take out, what is it, the 10 best days of a year in Bitcoin, you're just down hilariously.
- 14:13which means time in the market is more important than timing the market I think the DCA strategy just feels responsible when you doing it with large quantities When you get into seven eight or nine figures
- 14:26it's kind of nervy to be the guy that hit the button to do the spot buy.
- 14:32Because again, even if you're the control shareholder,
- 14:34whether that's at Thanksgiving or at board meetings,
- 14:37someone's going to be yelling at you if the timing was wrong.
- 14:39So I think there's a balance there.
- 14:42and at the end of the day, you know, the advice is just advice and the business owner has to decide.
- 14:49But I think that's right. It's like some version of we're going to like size into this over six
- 14:55months or 12 months, but also case dependent, right? How intense is your seasonality on cash
- 15:01conversion, right? It's like, oh, we buy a ton of equipment in the fall. Well, let's not run out of
- 15:06cash in the fall then. So, you know, that's always going to be a case by case situation. But
- 15:11the sooner you're off zero, the better.
- 15:13And I think for some businesses that'll be the case.
- 15:16But many it'll be, we want to move
- 15:18what is already a personal Bitcoin strategy
- 15:19into the corporate here.
- 15:21Well, I think it's important to elaborate on this too
- 15:24because we say it in the piece
- 15:26that if you pick a certain strategy,
- 15:30let's say you want to DCA a certain amount,
- 15:32either into perpetuity over a fixed period of time,
- 15:35and let's say the Bitcoin price dumps by 30%,
- 15:36you stop doing it because you're scared out of the market.
- 15:40You have to go into this with the mental framework that there is going to be volatility.
- 15:44Whatever plan you set, you have to stick to it.
- 15:48The easy part is buying the Bitcoin.
- 15:50Ask any long-term Bitcoin holder.
- 15:52The hard part is stomaching the volatility.
- 15:55So absolutely.
- 15:56Set a plan.
- 15:57Work with an advisor to set that plan.
- 16:00Be deliberate about establishing that plan outwardly with the key stakeholders,
- 16:08whether that's the management team or shareholders or brothers-in-law,
- 16:12so that you have something other than your own emotions
- 16:18to point to when decisions are being made on that strategy.
- 16:21Because for sure, if you're new to Bitcoin
- 16:23and you started sizing into it in October of this year,
- 16:26you probably have a little heartburn right now.
- 16:28But if you've set a playbook and you're sticking to it,
- 16:31then you can kind of rest easy that we need to see this all the way through
- 16:35before we get heartburn and change our strategy.
- 16:38All right, now let's walk into the spectrum of sort of different Bitcoin strategies depending on where the particular business owner is in their personal journey with their business.
- 16:49Some Bitcoiners that run businesses are like, hey, I'm going to keep running this for 10 years, so I'm just going to do a set and forget a DCA strategy over the next decade.
- 16:57Others are later in their careers and looking to make an exit and sort of framing what options exist to acquire Bitcoin using your business across that spectrum.
- 17:11And for those who are closer to selling their businesses, what does the landscape look like?
- 17:17why is now opportunistic?
- 17:19The Bitcoiner business owner hero's journey, I call it.
- 17:24It's similar to the individual Bitcoiner hero's journey.
- 17:26You start stacking some sats, you get excited,
- 17:29you sit in the red for two or three years,
- 17:32then you're kind of permanently in the green,
- 17:34you continue to stack sats,
- 17:35you start looking around at what else can I sell,
- 17:37you start liquidating IRAs and other positions,
- 17:41a decade in, you sell your chairs.
- 17:44The hero's journey on the business owner side looks similar.
- 17:47the scale is different, but the game is similar. Stacking Bitcoin to the balance sheet,
- 17:52some conservative portion of cash flow. Okay, get more aggressive. Okay, 100% of cash flow.
- 17:59Okay, can we borrow money against the business to accelerate that? Can we pull forward accumulation?
- 18:05And then Bitcoin or business owners, thinking about the end game for their business,
- 18:13have a different hurdle
- 18:17because Bitcoin, historical CAGR,
- 18:21pick your number, 30%, 40%, 50%
- 18:22makes you really want to own more of that thing.
- 18:25And if you're looking at your business saying,
- 18:27okay, next year, if we want to grow 10%,
- 18:29we need to put in,
- 18:31we need to reinvest into the business meaningfully
- 18:33and we run the math on that
- 18:35and the return on invested capital there is 15%, for example.
- 18:39In fiat land, that's great, right?
- 18:41Private equity will underwrite that all the time
- 18:43because they'll use leverage and they'll augment that and they'll make nice returns for their LPs.
- 18:48In Bitcoin land, you're like, okay, I can spend whatever, make 15% return on it with a bunch of
- 18:54risk, execution and otherwise, or I could have taken that same cash and just bought Bitcoin.
- 19:01Then it gets harder. So then you start thinking through, okay, the hurdle rate for a Bitcoin or
- 19:06business owner is that Bitcoin CAGR. And the hurdle rate for the potential acquirers of your business
- 19:14is the fiat treasury's CAGR or yield. And so what we're seeing, and this is in the materials,
- 19:22is that the fiat markets are overvaluing your business because they don't understand Bitcoin.
- 19:28I have a theory that the reason private equity hasn't yet come to understand Bitcoin is because
- 19:33if you take their playbook, which is five to seven years of illiquidity, and you apply it to just
- 19:39buying and holding Bitcoin for five to seven years, it kind of begs the question of like, well, why
- 19:44does this industry exist at all? Why are we allocating capital, paying two and 20 to these
- 19:50private equity professionals for them to underperform spot Bitcoin, which is liquid 24-7,
- 19:55tradable 365 around the globe? And if I just don't touch it for five to seven years, I probably
- 19:59they outperformed 99% of private equity funds.
- 20:03That is your advantage as a business owner
- 20:04because they're going to keep valuing businesses that way.
- 20:07It's their job to deploy that capital.
- 20:10That's private equity fund, LP capital,
- 20:14limited partners, think teachers pension funds
- 20:17and the firefighters union and university endowments
- 20:21chasing yield to pay their pension liabilities
- 20:25and other sort of long-term liabilities
- 20:28like from insurance funds.
- 20:29and they have to make a return.
- 20:32So there is this artificial bid for nice cash flowing businesses.
- 20:37And you can take those proceeds if you're at that stage in your business
- 20:41and sell all of it, part of it, raise some debt,
- 20:47or just stack a little bit of Bitcoin.
- 20:48But all across that menu of options,
- 20:50depending on where you are as a business owner,
- 20:52you can use sort of future performance,
- 20:55either equity value or cash flow,
- 20:57to accumulate Bitcoin at what I think everyone agrees is lower prices than it will be in the
- 21:01future. That's the exciting trade. And so you can see in the materials, you know, the overall equity
- 21:07valuations across public and private markets for these businesses, the enterprise values rather,
- 21:13is just going up and to the right. There are interruptions around COVID and whatever else,
- 21:17and I'm sure what's going on right now in macro isn't great for valuations, but overall,
- 21:21the trend is just up and to the right. So we see inflation everywhere, including in asset prices.
- 21:26that is coming to Bitcoin.
- 21:29But while it's still overstated in equities,
- 21:33you own equity as a business owner.
- 21:34So there's a monetization opportunity,
- 21:36but it is not near as simple as logging into Fidelity
- 21:40and selling shares of Apple Computer.
- 21:42The private markets are very illiquid, clunky.
- 21:45It takes months to negotiate.
- 21:46It's a lot of heartbreak.
- 21:48But deal-making is a ton of fun.
- 21:50And so that's CBA's pitch.
- 21:53Well, let's go into the three different scenarios
- 21:55you listed.
- 21:56sell the whole company, maybe sell part of it,
- 21:59roll it back in alongside the PE sponsor.
- 22:02And yeah, so, and then the other one is keep it, right?
- 22:04So the first one is,
- 22:07hey, return on invested capital in this business
- 22:09is now like objectively unexciting to me as the owner.
- 22:12I want to take all of my chips and go home
- 22:15and my chips are going into Bitcoin.
- 22:18That is the full sale strategy.
- 22:20I think the biggest thing for that plan is exit planning,
- 22:25which needs to happen way before you decide to go to market. I tell business owners,
- 22:30you should work hard for years in advance to make yourself useless to the business.
- 22:35That way, when the time comes to sell, the buyer isn't saying, okay, you need to be,
- 22:40I need you shackled to the desk here, right? I like to joke that private equity funds,
- 22:44they buy your company, they don't want you to go to the beach, they want you to drive a really nice
- 22:47car to the office every day. And so you've got to work really hard as an owner entrepreneur
- 22:52to do the one thing that you've always most times struggled to do, which is take your hands off
- 22:57and start empowering your team to run the business without you so that when you do go to exit,
- 23:02you really are a passive shareholder because passive shareholders get paid cash,
- 23:06active shareholders get paid in earnouts and other contingencies that tie you to the business.
- 23:11The next category is like, hey, I really like my business. It's got a great return on invested
- 23:16capital. The opportunity to grow here is huge, but I'm tired of betting the farm and I'm overweight
- 23:22my company and underweight Bitcoin. And so I don't want to miss the boat on Bitcoin, but I also not
- 23:28ready to like give, like sell my job away. I like running this business. You are in that case,
- 23:34private equity's favorite because you're saying, I want somebody to give me some money to take risk
- 23:38off the table. And then I want to go pursue the half a dozen aggressive growth strategies that
- 23:42I've always thought about, but always been scared to go after because I don't want to personally
- 23:45guarantee. I can't get the bank to give me that much money, whatever the risk. Private equity is
- 23:52going to eat that alive. They love that because they're saying, hey, there's a bunch of low-hanging
- 23:55fruit. The only reason this hasn't already happened in this business is because the owner
- 23:58is tired of doubling down with basically, and sometimes literally, signing the deed to his house
- 24:03to the downside case. So in that case, sell a portion of your business to a private equity fund
- 24:09or other acquirer. Roll some of your ownership into a minority position. Stay in an operator seat
- 24:15and go execute on that next phase of growth and know that you're partnered with people on the
- 24:21balance sheet in the investment that their job is to make three, five X on their money. And so
- 24:26you're riding along in your minority position with that, but you've also just taken some cash off the
- 24:31table. You've likely eliminated personal guarantees in the business and you're in a position to really
- 24:35chase the next phase of growth with the institutional sophistication that didn't exist before, right?
- 24:42They're going to help you set up a board. They're going to give you strategic planning, but you also
- 24:45are going to have, you know, in a, in a worst case description, you're going to have bosses. So there's
- 24:50a balance there. And then the far end of the spectrum would be, you know, don't partner with
- 24:55these folks at all. I think it would be like, this is definitely the case in a lot of Bitcoin
- 24:59companies is if we have, if a Bitcoiner has started a business, they have looked at the
- 25:05risk reward and said, I think I can outperform Bitcoin here. TFTC and CBA are both great examples.
- 25:10And like, can you picture a scenario where you would sell equity for anything beyond like a
- 25:16insane valuation? Probably not because you want to grow and be the beneficiary of all of that
- 25:22cashflow. And so I think in that scenario, if you've got lighting in a bottle, uh, then,
- 25:28then your goal should be to never give away any equity unless you're at that stage. So I think
- 25:33that's the early stage, right? Stack Bitcoin, grow the business on your own. That mid stage is really
- 25:38interesting because there's a lot of that happening. And then that final stage, you've
- 25:41really got to make sure that your transaction preparedness puts you in a position to
- 25:45not be a key man or mission critical to that transaction.
- 25:49Yeah. Let's go back to two parts.
- 25:53One being the second option.
- 25:55You're still part of the business, roll alongside the PE firm.
- 25:58I think another thing that we highlight in the playbook as well
- 26:02is that you take the proceeds, buy Bitcoin, your long Bitcoin,
- 26:06PE fund at the end of your relationship, they get their nuts,
- 26:10and then you have the potential if Bitcoin has a good run
- 26:14during your engagement with the PE firm to buy your company back.
- 26:18Yeah, so this would be so fun.
- 26:19I think we'll find this, you know, we're looking for this client at CBA,
- 26:23but I love the idea of using the private equity fund's money
- 26:28to buy Bitcoin on the personal side.
- 26:30Watching them, you know, make some smart decisions,
- 26:33but maybe some dumb ones too.
- 26:35And at the end of their sort of five, seven-year process,
- 26:38they're, you know, hiring an investment banker to go sell that business.
- 26:41You're a minority owner.
- 26:42and you're like, actually, I'll buy it.
- 26:46And you use your Bitcoin stack,
- 26:48which has probably grown much faster
- 26:50than their investment in your business,
- 26:52to reclaim ownership of your business.
- 26:56I think that would be really interesting.
- 26:57I've heard, I've had clients who've lived this experience
- 27:01where they sold to a big private equity fund.
- 27:04It didn't go great, whether growth slowed down
- 27:08or leverage was poorly managed or whatever it was.
- 27:10And they end up partnering with other groups
- 27:12to buy back the business and sort of write the course and grow it again.
- 27:17I think entrepreneurs are kind of serial.
- 27:22They're very competitive, and they like to win.
- 27:24And I think it would be a pretty cool win to unlock some liquidity from your business,
- 27:29use it to accumulate Bitcoin at what we all agree are lower prices today
- 27:32than they will be in the future, and then fast forward to that future date
- 27:37and say, hey, private equity guys, nice trade you did there.
- 27:39I'll actually take it back.
- 27:41And oh, by the way, it's going to take me half of the cash you gave me five, seven years ago because I stored it in Bitcoin.
- 27:48Yeah.
- 27:49And then second thing to bring it up on, you're a Bitcoiner ourselves, own a business.
- 27:54I alluded to it earlier with how 1031 portfolio company founders typically view their businesses.
- 27:59But Bitcoiners are good business operators, or they should be at least.
- 28:04That is the thesis for CBA.
- 28:06So I'm counting on the Bitcoin community to be, to make me look, to prove me right, which is, I think Bitcoiners are by nature contrarians.
- 28:16They have figured out something that requires a lot of humility.
- 28:18Now, I'm not saying we're all humble, but we had to start humble, right?
- 28:21Because you had to say, okay, what am I wrong about?
- 28:23Oh, literally everything when it comes to money.
- 28:26And then you sort of reeducated yourself on the Bitcoin standard.
- 28:30So if that is an archetype and I think somebody just did some research on like the emotional intelligence strategy or whatever Yeah Myers Yeah Myers I think Brandon Quintum did that years ago but he brings it up periodically It must have just hit like it just bubbled up to me recently
- 28:47And it's like, you know, Bitcoiners are one of two types.
- 28:50I think my thesis is that Bitcoiners are good business owners
- 28:53because they have figured out something that takes a lot of research and humility to understand.
- 28:58And if you apply that mentality to businesses,
- 29:00my thesis is that like being bitcoin first as an advisor to business owners i'm going to get to
- 29:07work with all the best business owners because all the best businesses will be run by bitcoiners
- 29:11um and and it's also a fun top of funnel because there's no such thing as someone who's like oh
- 29:18yeah i used to be into bitcoin and so my tam for people that want to work with cba because they want
- 29:25to work with the advice of an advisor that understands bitcoin is just however many bitcoiners
- 29:30there are their own businesses, and I'm betting on that number going up forever.
- 29:33Yeah, I think it will.
- 29:36And the thing I wanted to bring up after that is just highlighting that this is real.
- 29:44And not only is it real, it's more real than it's ever been because of the emergence of AI tools.
- 29:49Talking about running lean operations, I think that's one thing we've really bonded over over the last two months
- 29:57is banging our heads together,
- 29:59talking about our AI setups
- 30:00and what it's done for our individual businesses.
- 30:02Yeah, I owe you a big thank you.
- 30:04So anecdotes about AI and deflation
- 30:06that are useful for this
- 30:07is primary to my business and it's thanks to you.
- 30:12So I was playing around with OpenClaw,
- 30:13like everyone, in late February
- 30:15and was trying to hook it up to Maple.
- 30:21Ambitious, you know, privacy preserving,
- 30:24the right ethos.
- 30:25and you and I were chatting and I'm like, I just, this is, this thing is a net negative to my
- 30:30productivity right now. What am I doing wrong? And you encouraged me, you know, the trade-off
- 30:34is obviously privacy, but you're running a business. So it's not like you have super good
- 30:37privacy on that side anyway, lean into the frontier models and, and also lean into the spend,
- 30:43find a way to justify it. Right. So if that's, if you're pinching pennies on your AI subscription,
- 30:49that's not the right approach. Find a way to make it pay for itself. And that advice from you
- 30:54was probably in late February. And, you know, the anecdote for CBA is that prior to late February,
- 31:00the goal, so I launched this firm in October of last year. I was previously a vice president,
- 31:04Kenner Fitzgerald, not on their crypto stuff, but just a middle market investment banker.
- 31:10And so I launched this in October. The goal from October to sort of, I'll call it, you know,
- 31:15D-Day for OpenClaw and AI was to grow the business to a scale where I could justify a million dollars
- 31:21a GNA, a team of five, maybe three associates and two analysts or two associates and three
- 31:25analysts in investment banking to support deal execution for my top of funnel deal flow,
- 31:31enter OpenClaw and Frontier Models, agentic AI in general. And now I'm not sure that CBA ever
- 31:38needs a junior team member. And so like people say, well, where is the actual deflation in AI?
- 31:45Well, I mean, it's a million dollars of savings a year for CBA. And I know that you're seeing
- 31:50this on your side too but it's just that's happening really quick business owners especially
- 31:55in the middle market that that won't that aren't going to get disrupted by like oh we're a sass and
- 31:59we just don't exist anymore that you know live in the physical world molecules wise their opportunity
- 32:04to layer ai into their stack is is like they can probably shave multiple million dollars out of gna
- 32:09um and so you know let's go after that as a bitcoin community and and make even greater
- 32:15businesses and and then use those to accumulate bitcoin yeah and the anecdote from our side i
- 32:20this playbook is a perfect example of it like i said we banged our clankers together it's not
- 32:24really for the content itself but it's structuring it in a way like this pdf that we have i think
- 32:28it's very beautiful and the bigliest this has been an idea like partnering with somebody like you to
- 32:34do uh sort of like a collaboration on something specific in the space in this case the bitcoin
- 32:41treasury and exit playbook for private businesses but i wanted to do this for years but in my mind
- 32:45it's like i really i've got myself the team has grown we've added two team members so including
- 32:51myself there's six of us a couple of them are part-time over the last year we've added two
- 32:56and i've never had the confidence or the resources to be like okay if i wanted to do something like
- 33:01this i'd probably have to go hire a designer or somebody who can just run and lead this stuff and
- 33:07now that's not the case like we could sit there we went back and forth over multiple calls over the
- 33:13course of six weeks about how this is going to be structured and then we got our final sort of text
- 33:19and the graphics we wanted to put in and boom the clanker was able to actually format and design it's
- 33:24incredible pdf uh in minutes yeah i i think um i think that this it turns you i think i'm stealing
- 33:33this from you somebody i listen to a lot of podcasts uh you know it turns the ideas guy into
- 33:38a results guy. And you've got great ideas. And those can now basically come into existence with
- 33:44a voice message. I know the Bitcoin community is very pro-privacy and that there's massive
- 33:50trade-offs running these things on frontier models where they're for sure hoovering up your data.
- 33:55But look, if you're a business owner, who are you kidding yourself? All of your data is getting
- 34:00eaten alive. And I know that's not a good answer. That's a quitter's answer. But also, I think,
- 34:06if we look at where open source models are today, six to 12 months from now, I think it's not
- 34:10unrealistic to say we can self-host some of these things. Now that won't be cheap, but if you're a
- 34:15business owner getting a million dollars worth of GNA value out of running agents through OpenClaw,
- 34:22Hermes, whatever other agentic harness, and you need to spend 30 grand on GPUs, okay, it's pretty
- 34:29easy to do the math on that ROI. And so you can either sit around and wait for open source models
- 34:34to be ready for that so you don't ever have to violate the privacy.
- 34:37But you'll also be, you know, I mentioned at the beginning, it's like AI is like dog
- 34:40years.
- 34:40Like you'll be years behind if you don't play with these things now so that when you can,
- 34:45you know, take an open source model on your own hardware and run it, you're ready because
- 34:48you've already built the systems and processes around the business to be ready for that.
- 34:54Yeah.
- 34:54And I feel like we're very fortunate at TFTC because we run a media business.
- 34:58A lot of our output is public anyway.
- 35:00And so the input on the back end is just like a lot of source material.
- 35:03if our chats were to get leaked it's just us right like hey literally read everything we've ever
- 35:08written create our voice and here's the topics we're interested in here's the source material
- 35:14we want to report on help us format it the right way and people get people it is funny there are
- 35:20a lot of light lights out there who are they say oh this is all ai slop i i don't think they
- 35:26understand like yes ai is helping with the with the output the end output but there's a lot of
- 35:32curation and context provided before that and i showed you the sort of hockey stick growth we've
- 35:39seen on in terms of engagement and what's happening and i think despite what the luddites are saying
- 35:45like the proof is in the pudding like it's helping us be better at disseminating information absolutely
- 35:50if you're already a master of your craft which i'd like to think that you are i like to think that i
- 35:54am adding ai to your stack augments it uh augments you in the same way that tony stark's iron man
- 36:03suit augments him if you are not then you become a slop cannon and there is no in between and so i
- 36:10think what i've found actually great example i actually launched a side business focus on this
- 36:15i'm helping folks in the bitcoin community and now sort of just broader community get these
- 36:20harness setups running on their own machines. And I recommend the frontier models, even though
- 36:25there's a privacy trade-off. Every single one of my 30 plus customers now has started their own
- 36:31business. I think there might be one exception to that. And in every case, they're not saying,
- 36:38hey, AI, how do I make money? They're taking what they're already good at and working with their
- 36:44agent to build something that generates value for the world and bringing that to market.
- 36:50And so it's such a fun project to see folks kind of bear that out.
- 36:55What you, what you see online that is, you know,
- 36:58causing the Luddite behavior is people will just get a new agent and say,
- 37:01make me money. You know,
- 37:02I think you and Matt probably went through this experience trying to have them,
- 37:06having the agents trade, um, trade, whatever marketplace,
- 37:11you know,
- 37:13there are high frequency funds that have been working on that strategy for a
- 37:16long time. And so there's not a lot of alpha there, but if you're,
- 37:19if you have literally anything that you think you're halfway decent at,
- 37:22you can basically build a business around it with like a few voice messages. Um, so there's,
- 37:27there's never been a better time to start a business. Um, there's never been a better time
- 37:31to be in Bitcoin. Uh, I'm very bullish on, on all the, all the above and the intersection of AI and
- 37:36Bitcoin is pretty exciting. I didn't have in my base case for Bitcoin, uh, 50 plus percent
- 37:42deflationary event in AI sort of bringing value to the world. And my thesis is that the only
- 37:49strategy to solve for that. Like we can't have deflation in the economy. Like central planners
- 37:54could be laser eyed Bitcoiners. They don't have a choice. They can't have the value of the money go
- 37:59up. So they're going to have to print the difference. And so like when I first got into
- 38:03Bitcoin as a gold bug and I was like, wow, they're going to, they have, they have to print so much
- 38:06money. They have to print so much money. Um, I, I have, um, friends in the Bay area, Bitcoiners,
- 38:15San Francisco area that we keep in touch even though I've moved away.
- 38:18They are my original sort of Bitcoin meetup folks.
- 38:22And whenever we're texting about macro, I usually end our conversations with,
- 38:27they are going to print so much money.
- 38:29And for better or worse, AI accelerates that, I think.
- 38:33Yeah.
- 38:34We got a bit of an AI tangent.
- 38:37We glossed over it in the piece, but maybe we can do a whole other one on that.
- 38:41Yeah, I'd love to.
- 38:42how Bitcoin optimizes business or AI optimizes business.
- 38:45And then you can use the efficiencies and the productivity
- 38:47and hopefully the revenue and cash flow gains to funnel it into Bitcoin.
- 38:51But bringing it back to the playbook and just tying a knot in the exit decision
- 38:56or the three decisions that we talked about, why moving now as opposed to waiting?
- 39:02Yeah. So set aside Bitcoin for a second.
- 39:05The conversation I have with business owners for all of my career in fiat land,
- 39:10in private equity and in fiat land M&A, in private equity as a buyer in fiat land M&A,
- 39:16because I sort of went both sides of the deal table. It's always, you know, now's an okay time
- 39:21to sell, but I don't want to take the tax hit because I've got, you know, X value in the
- 39:27business. And when I sell it, you know, 80% of it's going to be ordinary income or no, sorry,
- 39:3220% of it's going to be ordinary income. And the other 80% is gonna be goodwill, which will be
- 39:36taxed at cap gains rates. Nobody wants to give away, like say you sell a business for a hundred
- 39:40million dollars and you give 30 of it to uncle sam like that's really painful and i don't like i
- 39:46don't think it's a an ethically good thing to do even so like there i understand people's a lot of
- 39:52business owners like well i want to delay that i want to deal with that later i want to get my
- 39:55house in order figure out a way to avoid more of that tax and i agree like there are legal and and
- 40:01trust and uh tax efficiency stuff that we kind of allude to we are neither of us professionals in
- 40:08those categories. I think you should get good advice in those categories. But if you're like
- 40:13waiting to sell or raise capital or take chips off the table because you think that you'll somehow
- 40:18save money on taxes later, if Bitcoin is your opportunity cost, good luck. Because American
- 40:25HODL says, this thing's a runaway freight train. Like every day you wait, the risk that you never
- 40:31see that price again is real. And so take the tax hit, see what that looks like and stack Bitcoin
- 40:38today at today's prices versus waiting five years, assume any reasonable CAGR for Bitcoin,
- 40:45and then run the math later, even at a more efficient tax rate, you're going to see that
- 40:50you'd have more Bitcoin by making that trade today. And this is a fun plug. There's a calculator
- 40:56on the CBA website that helps you look at this, which is just, okay, do I raise capital now? Do I
- 41:02sell equity now, whether it's control or the whole thing or most of it or a minority and use that to
- 41:09buy Bitcoin at today's prices? Or do I wait? Okay, well, what do I wait for how long? Okay, what's
- 41:14the Bitcoin kegger over that timeline? How much Bitcoin would I get if I waited? And it's, you
- 41:19know, that calculator, you know, I built it with my clanker. It's pretty hard to get that calculator
- 41:24to show you that the better trade is to wait.
- 41:26And now obviously as an advisor
- 41:28who makes transactions happen,
- 41:30that is self-promoting,
- 41:34but it is also just mostly true,
- 41:35which is if you look back
- 41:36on when you should have bought Bitcoin,
- 41:38yesterday was the best day,
- 41:40today is the next best day.
- 41:41Any form of waiting usually ends up being a mistake.
- 41:45Yeah.
- 41:45And then getting into the technical details.
- 41:48I think that's important.
- 41:49We can wrap up the four sections there,
- 41:52but then we'll get into some examples,
- 41:54which you provide at the end, some case studies.
- 41:57But in terms of what this looks like,
- 42:00not what this looks like in practice,
- 42:01but that's, I think, one of the underappreciated aspects
- 42:06of businesses getting into Bitcoin.
- 42:09You can convince them, like, all right, I'm in.
- 42:11I'm going to DCA.
- 42:12I'm going to lump sum.
- 42:12I'm going to do this, that.
- 42:13But what do you actually do?
- 42:14Who do you work with?
- 42:15Who are your counterparties?
- 42:16So I want to be careful not to, like, pick favorites.
- 42:19There's a lot of good services out there.
- 42:20a rule I would suggest folks adopt is look for businesses, services, and advisors that are
- 42:27focused on Bitcoin only. In optimizing for more than just Bitcoin in the crypto world,
- 42:34usually corners are cut and shortcuts are taken that are dangerous. And if someone doesn't
- 42:39understand that Bitcoin is the signal amidst the crypto noise, then you have to sort of doubt the
- 42:44rest of their advice. And so start with that as a filter. And then I think there's several
- 42:49categories. So there's, there's tax, right? You definitely want, well, you have to pay your taxes.
- 42:53You should do that every year You probably have advice for that already but I think tax efficiency for a transaction whether that raising capital to invest in the business acquire a competitor
- 43:04take chips off the table, sell outright, there are things you can do ahead of time with tax
- 43:08attorneys to be more efficient with that tax implication. Legal, from a structuring perspective,
- 43:15you know, when you transact, regardless of the type, you'll be making representations and
- 43:21warranties that create scenarios where if what you said or disclosed during the transaction was
- 43:27untrue, that can have real recourse. And so you want to make sure that the attorneys helping you
- 43:34document your transaction are top notch. Attorneys are painfully expensive, but sometimes it's money
- 43:41well spent. I'm curious to see how AI drives that cost down because a lot of what they do is just
- 43:46pattern recognition. So I'm excited for discounts in that category and I'll help businesses find
- 43:51them. So yeah, legal tax. If it's Bitcoin accumulation, then you got to think about
- 43:59custody for sure. And there's a there's no one size fits all. I think on one end of the spectrum,
- 44:04like a cold card in a desk at the CEO's office is a way to do it. But like, who are your
- 44:12shareholders? What is the risk profile? When do you need to move the Bitcoin? You could look at
- 44:17multi-sig setups where your board has a distributed set of keys, but then you run into this problem
- 44:23of like, okay, well, when we cycle out an employee, a C-level employee or a board member, we have to
- 44:28do a key rollover ceremony. That can get messy. There are businesses and service providers that
- 44:32cover that space. What else am I missing? Trading. So obviously, if you're going to
- 44:39deploy a Bitcoin accumulation strategy, you need to have an exchange acquire the Bitcoin for you,
- 44:44take your cash and give you sats for it um trying to think of what else did we cover in there
- 44:51there is a whole checklist that folks can go through and i think it it'll depend where you
- 44:56are um i mean being mna prepared like you just don't i think we touched on this earlier but it's
- 45:01like it's just not going to happen tomorrow that's right yeah you can't log into fidelity and sell
- 45:05shares in your in tftc and uh and and i can't in cba and so i think there's a lot of work to do
- 45:11there. It doesn't start when you decide you're ready. It starts well in advance. And so getting
- 45:17good advice on what that looks like, building a playbook and working towards it, whether that's a
- 45:2112 month, 18 month, three year plan, you know, just a regular way M&A process could take you six plus
- 45:29months. So and then and then what you need in that checklist will depend on where you're at.
- 45:36And so this will dovetail nicely into case studies. So CBA's client base spans anyone that's a Bitcoiner. And so in some cases, I'm helping seed round businesses, make introductions to potential investors. In other cases, I'm working with scaled entrepreneurs selling the whole business because they have looked at the return on invested capital in that business and said, I'd rather own Bitcoin and everything in between.
- 46:04And so in the sort of Bitcoiner seed round sort of stage, you're thinking about what portion of this raise do we allocate to Bitcoin?
- 46:15How do we manage against our burn?
- 46:17And you have these two trends of like, well, I want to raise as much cash as I can to buy Bitcoin today, but I don't want to sell any equity because the only reason I'm building this thing is because I think it's going to outperform Bitcoin.
- 46:27that's a very different mindset than fiat vc where you're saying just raise as much cash as
- 46:33possible because that's all that matters um and the other end of the spectrum before you come to
- 46:39the conclusion i'm going to sell the whole thing look at with an advisor what does a partial sale
- 46:46look like what does taking some chips off the table look like work with tax folks to look at
- 46:50what actually you know net proceeds is going to be um and then have a real sense of humor about
- 46:55it's not going to happen overnight because it's a lot of work yeah well getting i think to give
- 47:01tangible examples of companies that you've worked with i mean not to name them by name but you have
- 47:07a few in here that i think would be helpful for for people listening yeah maybe their business is
- 47:12similar and so the franchisee i think is a really good one the franchisee is my favorite and uh
- 47:18i called him before this to see if he would mind what level of uh of commentary i gave and so uh
- 47:25I'll keep it high level, but a multi-site franchisee,
- 47:30so I've done a lot of multi-site franchisee M&A
- 47:32in my Fiat days.
- 47:35This is a business in food, in restaurant,
- 47:40in a really nice scaled franchise brand,
- 47:43and the owner is a Bitcoiner.
- 47:46And so you're thinking, okay,
- 47:47well, that business has nothing to do with Bitcoin.
- 47:49The reason CBA is involved is because the owner is a Bitcoiner
- 47:53and he wants advice from another Bitcoiner.
- 47:54they are exploring the outright sale of that business because the return on invested capital
- 48:01of opening another store another of the multi-site brand is like 15 ish with leverage
- 48:10that's like not worth it when you think about the opportunity cost of just holding bitcoin
- 48:15and so for that situation we got involved early and started talking about hey maybe you should
- 48:22raise some debt to put Bitcoin on the balance sheet. So they started accumulating Bitcoin on
- 48:26their balance sheet a year ago. And the start of our conversation was, I think you should raise
- 48:31some debt. I think I, at the time, assumed he was pretty bullish on his business. I was like,
- 48:35I'm not telling you to sell equity. I think you should use debt to accumulate faster at lower
- 48:40Bitcoin prices last summer. And through that exercise and learning what the options were
- 48:47in the debt markets, he was like, man, I don't have that much conviction in the next five years
- 48:54of this trade to be long the equity with leverage just to get a little bit more Bitcoin exposure.
- 49:00And so through that exploration, we came to this conclusion of, I think there's a number where I'd
- 49:05like to sell this business. And so that's what we're working through right now. But that is a
- 49:10great example of one where he literally lived through the journey of just started stacking sats.
- 49:14we worked through that with him
- 49:17then we explored well could you
- 49:18use leverage to speed that up
- 49:20there feels like a runaway freight train
- 49:23in Bitcoin right now, last summer we sort of
- 49:25all thought we weren't going to be where we are right now
- 49:27but it still would have been a great trade
- 49:29if he ended up doing it, but through that
- 49:31exercise and looking at okay I have to do what
- 49:33I'm going to have to personal guarantee potentially
- 49:34I'm going to take on how much leverage, that's how much
- 49:37interest expense, whoa
- 49:38that's a lot of heartburn, I'm not that bullish
- 49:41on the brand here or the
- 49:42the underlying, um, investment opportunity. And so then I think the conclusion is going to be,
- 49:48let's sell this business. Now, part of the heartbreak in my business is the business owner
- 49:52retains up until the day of closing the right to change his mind and say, nevermind. Um,
- 49:58so I like to joke, you know, MNA advisory is like 364 days a year of heartbreak. And then one day a
- 50:04year, you're like crying tears of joy because you get a deal closed. Um, so I think I might be a
- 50:08little bit masochist for enjoying it so much but those closing days are very fun yeah all right
- 50:13next one uh multi-unit operator that that was the multi-unit operator so i jumped out of order the
- 50:18first one uh is is really transaction reparation is more of a an abstract of if you are in a sort
- 50:28of nice fiat business and you're thinking through what does that look like in 18 months don't wait
- 50:3318 months to call right we there's a lot you can do ahead of time the main thing we talked about
- 50:37earlier, which is make yourself replaceable, make yourself irrelevant to the business as the owner,
- 50:42as the control owner and entrepreneur. If everyone is paralyzed when you're on vacation,
- 50:47the investor, the buyer, whether it's a strategic or a private equity fund or a family office,
- 50:51is going to have a lot of trouble letting you go to the beach. And so then you get back to that
- 50:56analogy of they're going to want you to drive a really nice car to the office every day.
- 50:59So the work begins well in advance of a transaction to make yourself not needed.
- 51:05And so you explored this option with the multi-unit franchise owner, but he decided not to, wants to sell the business, but diving into who the leverage equity play or leverage treasury play may make sense for you.
- 51:18Yeah, so that's what we explored in the mid-stages with the multi-site operator, which was, I said,
- 51:23look, I think you're bullish your business, but you want to get more Bitcoin. You started stacking
- 51:27a year ago, and you're kind of feeling behind as the price runs. You have access to the private
- 51:34capital markets. Private credit, for all of its being in the news lately, is still $2 trillion
- 51:39of dry powder begging for anything good to lend to. And the anything good to lend to is cash flowing
- 51:45businesses. And so the idea there is, okay, let's go raise three or four times EBITDA,
- 51:53depending on the business and the situation, of debt capital, put that debt on the balance sheet,
- 51:59put the cash on the balance sheet on the other side, use that to acquire Bitcoin. Now, that's
- 52:04never really been done. Typically, these private credit funds, what they're underwriting is they
- 52:09give the owner a mountain of cash, the owner distributes that cash to himself, he buys a boat
- 52:14or an airplane or, you know, another vacation home. And in that case, the private credit funds
- 52:20recourse, what they're lending against is the business. It's not the boat, the airplane,
- 52:24the house that actually sits outside of the business. And so my argument to private credit,
- 52:28even though this sort of deal has never happened before, it's a better underwriting for them,
- 52:32because now there's the equity and cash flow that you're used to underwriting, but there's
- 52:36also this Bitcoin on the balance sheet. So your private credit fund guys aren't going to suddenly
- 52:41become Bitcoiners. But even if they valued the cash Bitcoin on balance sheet at 50%, it should
- 52:47give more recourse to the loan than a typical, what it's called when you distribute the cash for
- 52:53the airplane situation, is a dividend recap. So this should be net better than a dividend recap
- 52:59from the private credit side. And safe to say those folks are dying for a new form of deal with
- 53:04better collateral because we've seen what's happened to the public ones with redemptions.
- 53:09You've seen the software credit deals aren't panning out as many thought they would five years ago.
- 53:15I mean, I think you and I could both rattle through a half a dozen software, you know, B2B SaaS, like SMB SaaS products that we've replaced in our own businesses that otherwise I'd pay 50 to 100 bucks a month that now I just, I clank them together.
- 53:29Yeah.
- 53:31What would you say to people who say this is insane?
- 53:34We're not going to have businesses.
- 53:35What's the incentive for anybody to go start a business?
- 53:37I think that the Bitcoin hurdle rate does make it really hard to justify starting a business.
- 53:43But I mean, you and I are living proof that there's still businesses worth starting.
- 53:49But yeah, maybe that person is right when they say, if this continues, no one will ever open
- 53:55another Taco Bell. And I'd ask that person, well, does that sound like such a bad thing?
- 54:01So I do think that as the hurdle rate for investment capital rises, some businesses
- 54:06that currently look like good businesses
- 54:08will actually be exposed to be malinvestment.
- 54:11Because if I can make 30, 40, 50% CAGR holding Bitcoin,
- 54:16I'm not going to open another Taco Bell as an example.
- 54:21So yeah, I think there is this period of austerity
- 54:24where folks would rather save.
- 54:26And saving is investing in the future.
- 54:28So that's not a bad thing.
- 54:30No.
- 54:31All right, any final thoughts?
- 54:32Anything we didn't cover that we should get in here?
- 54:33I think this is very concise.
- 54:35I think we ran through the whole playbook.
- 54:37I think it was good.
- 54:38I would just say, I think,
- 54:41so I want to give a shout out to the Bay Area Bitcoiners.
- 54:46My Bitcoin origin story is mostly private.
- 54:50I didn't really sort of visit or talk with folks
- 54:52about Bitcoin and meet space for a few years.
- 54:55And when I finally did, it was during COVID in San Francisco.
- 54:57And so I was just like dying to talk to another human being.
- 55:00Those guys were the start of like kind of giving me
- 55:03the encouragement to, hey, like you should talk to people in person about Bitcoin because
- 55:07you do a good job of explaining it. And then I'm now in Charlotte, North Carolina. That's where
- 55:14we'll hope to stay for the long term. I'm very involved in that group. So I also want to give
- 55:17a shout out to them. I think I would encourage everyone. And the reason I thought of Bitcoin
- 55:23meetup groups is because I'm hearing exhaustion from like five-year Bitcoiners who are like, man,
- 55:32Like if we get to September of this year and we're not higher, then I'm really in it for the tech at that point.
- 55:39And, you know, I'm in it for the tech, too.
- 55:41But the tech is number go up.
- 55:43And I think one of two things is going to happen in September or by September.
- 55:47Because September of this year, the five year rolling comp is a 65K high of September 2021.
- 55:53So either Bitcoin's return is going to look really mediocre or we're going to laugh about how worried about the price of Bitcoin we were with the straight over muse stuff going on.
- 56:02when you fast forward to September of this year.
- 56:04Put me in that second camp,
- 56:06but otherwise I'll come back on
- 56:07and I'll help craft a new narrative
- 56:09that you just have to zoom out further.
- 56:11But I would just say,
- 56:12well, I would say what you say.
- 56:13We're going to win
- 56:14and I'm excited for the future for Bitcoin.
- 56:16We're going to win.
- 56:18Go check out the playbook.
- 56:19Let us know what you think.
- 56:21And yeah, if you're a business owner out there,
- 56:23I mean, I think what made me feel confident
- 56:26about writing this with you
- 56:27and now publishing it is that we're living it.
- 56:30like tftc runs on a bitcoin standard 1031 runs on a bitcoin standard cba as well and uh
- 56:38it as somebody's been doing it i've had bitcoin on the balance sheet since before sailor uh 2019
- 56:45it has i mean it has helped us reinvest in the business it has helped us me as a business owner
- 56:51grow grow the stack and it is a very pivotal tool to our capital stack that that has benefited us
- 56:59massively over the last seven years.
- 57:01Absolutely. And a huge thank you to you, Marty.
- 57:04Your
- 57:05openness to exploring this has
- 57:07been very well
- 57:09received, and I'm grateful for the
- 57:11partnership. Like I said, real recognize
- 57:13real Scott. So, that's all.
- 57:16Go read the playbook. Peace and love.
- 57:17Bicky!