Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the IKEA Effect Shapes Your Office Influence
Transcript
- Lucas: So let me ask you something. You know that colleague who always volunteers to present the team's findings, even though their slides are a mess? Luna: Oh, absolutely. And somehow they get really defensive if anyone suggests changing a single word. Lucas: Right. That's the IKEA effect in action. It's the tendency to overvalue things we had a hand in creating, even if the result is objectively worse than something we didn't touch. The name comes from a classic study where people who assembled flat-pack furniture were willing to pay more for their own wobbly shelf than for a professional carpenter's version. Luna: So it's not just about furniture. It's about our work, our ideas, our spreadsheets. Lucas: Exactly. And in an office, that bias is running under every collaborative project, every pitch, every annual review. It shapes who gets credit, which ideas get funded, and even which employees feel most invested in their jobs. Luna: I imagine it's why managers often get attached to their pet projects, even when the data says they're not working. Lucas: That's the dark side, for sure. But the flip side is that if you understand the IKEA effect, you can use it constructively. You can get people to buy into an idea by letting them shape it, even in a small way. And you can avoid falling for your own handiwork when you're making decisions. Luna: Let's dig into that. How did researchers actually prove this effect? Lucas: The seminal study was by Michael Norton and his colleagues at Harvard, along with Dan Ariely. They had people fold origami and then bid on their own creations against professional origami. The amateur folders consistently valued their own crumpled frogs and cranes almost as highly as the expert versions. In a second experiment, they compared people who could customize their IKEA boxes to those who just received standard ones. The customizers paid more for their own boxes. Luna: So it's not just effort, it's the illusion of choice and control that inflates value. Lucas: Exactly. The term 'IKEA effect' was coined by Norton and Ariely in 2011, but the underlying mechanism is effort justification. We rationalize that if we spent time on something, it must be worthwhile. That's why we see it in everything from DIY home improvement to, well, office presentations. Luna: I've definitely caught myself overvaluing a chart I spent an hour fiddling with, even though a colleague's version was cleaner. Lucas: We've all been there. But here's the thing: the effect is stronger when the task is completed successfully. If you fail, you're less attached. So there's a sweet spot where you want people to feel ownership without the pain of a failed effort. Luna: That's interesting. So how do you actually apply this in a team setting? Lucas: The classic move is to let people customize your proposal. Instead of presenting a finished plan, bring a draft and ask for their input on specific points. Even if you don't use their suggestions, they feel a sense of co-creation, and they're far more likely to support the final version. Luna: So it's a way to build buy-in without giving up control. Lucas: Right. And it works for individuals too. If you want your boss to feel committed to a project, don't just hand them the finished report. Give them a chance to tweak the methodology or the key takeaways. Their fingerprints will be on it, and they'll champion it more. Luna: But what about the downside? How do you avoid being blinded by your own effort when you're evaluating ideas? Lucas: That's the harder part. The bias is automatic, so you need deliberate strategies. One is to seek outside feedback early and often, before you've invested too much emotionally. Another is to focus on objective metrics rather than how something feels. Ask: 'Would I make the same decision if I hadn't been involved?' Luna: That, plus a healthy dose of humility, I guess. Lucas: Exactly. And here's a practical trick: when you're reviewing your own work, pretend you're seeing it for the first time. That's hard to do, but it can help you spot flaws you'd otherwise overlook. Luna: I've also heard that managers should be careful about the IKEA effect when they're deciding which projects to kill. Sunk costs are already dangerous, but adding the IKEA effect makes it even harder to cut losses. Lucas: Absolutely. If you've championed a project from day one, you're not just evaluating its future prospects; you're protecting your own effort. That's why it's so important to have a neutral party involved in go/no-go decisions. Luna: So, let's talk about a real-world example beyond the office. IKEA itself, obviously, but also LEGO. They've built a whole crowdsourcing platform where fans submit designs. The company produces the winning ones, and fans get a cut. That's using the IKEA effect to create a community of superfans. Lucas: Great example. LEGO Ideas doesn't just sell toys; it gives fans a sense of ownership over the product line. The IKEA effect is a core part of their business model. Similarly, in software, early beta programs get people invested in the product before it's even finished. Luna: It's funny, because we're talking about influence, but the IKEA effect is also about meaning. When we put effort into something, it becomes part of our identity. Lucas: That's a good point. And that's why it's so powerful in the workplace. If you can help people feel a sense of ownership over their work, they're more motivated, more engaged, and less likely to leave. It's a win-win if you use it ethically. Luna: But it's a double-edged sword. You could also use it to manipulate people into accepting a bad idea by making them feel they co-created it. Lucas: Right, and that's a real risk. The IKEA effect can blind a team to flaws. That's why the most effective leaders balance co-creation with honest evaluation. They invite input, but they also create a culture where it's safe to say, 'This isn't working.' Luna: So what's your takeaway for someone who wants to be more influential at work? Lucas: I think the biggest one is: stop trying to be the lone genius. The more you let others shape your ideas, the more support you'll get. It's counterintuitive, but sharing ownership actually increases your influence. Luna: And on the flip side, when you're evaluating your own work, be skeptical of your own enthusiasm. Lucas: Exactly. Ask for a devil's advocate, or set a 'pre-mortem' — imagine it's a year later and the project failed. What would be the reasons? That helps you see beyond your own effort. Luna: That's a great tool. I've used pre-mortems in my own team, and they really do surface issues you'd miss otherwise. Lucas: So the IKEA effect is one of those biases that can work for you or against you. The trick is to be aware of it, and to design your processes and your own thinking to account for it. Luna: Before we wrap up, I want to circle back to something you mentioned earlier about building buy-in. It feels relevant to how we run this podcast — the fact that we don't do ads, and we rely on listener support to keep it that way. Lucas: That's a good point. When people contribute, even a small amount, they feel more invested in the show. And for us, that support means we can keep making episodes without worrying about sponsors influencing what we talk about. Luna: If you've ever gotten value from a career insight on this show, and you want to keep it ad-free, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: Yeah, no pressure at all, but it genuinely helps us keep doing this. And now, back to the IKEA effect — one more practical example I want to share. Luna: Please go ahead. Lucas: Let's say you're a manager and you want your team to adopt a new process. Instead of rolling out a fully designed workflow, present the goals and ask for their input on the steps. They'll feel like they built it, and they'll actually follow it. That's the IKEA effect turning a mandate into a team-owned solution. Luna: That's a much better way to get engagement than just sending an email with instructions. Lucas: Exactly. And the same principle applies to giving feedback. If you want someone to improve, don't just tell them what to fix. Ask them how they'd approach it. They'll likely come up with the same solution, but because they thought of it, they'll be more committed to it. Luna: That's a nuanced takeaway. It's not about avoiding the IKEA effect, but about channeling it. Lucas: Right. And that's the real skill. Whether you're leading a team, pitching an idea, or just trying to get along with colleagues, understanding the IKEA effect gives you a lens on office politics that most people don't have. Luna: Well, I know I'll be more mindful of my own spreadsheet attachments from now on. Lucas: Ha, same here. But at least now we know why we're so attached.