Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / The NCUA Appeal Process: A Complete Guide
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone, this is Mark with a special Archive episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I hope you enjoy.
- 0:07One of the first episodes I did back when the podcast started was on the
- 0:12appeal process within the region.
- 0:15And I had one of my team members, Todd Miller, on that podcast and Todd is
- 0:19very, was very experienced while he was at NCUA on appeals and then also serving
- 0:25on the supervisory review committee.
- 0:27And recently Todd and I had a conversation with the credit union
- 0:32relative to the formal appeal process and how that works at NCUA.
- 0:37And that's what this episode is about, the formal appeal process.
- 0:40So obviously when you get your exam report.
- 0:45The examination talks about how the appeal process works and that
- 0:48you should first work through your examiner and you should then work
- 0:52through your supervisory examiner.
- 0:55on up through the chain and that you can appeal to the regional director and
- 0:59beyond that you can appeal all the way to the NCUA board on certain things.
- 1:04So the exam cover letter walks through that and I wholeheartedly agree that the
- 1:09best place to start is with your examiner.
- 1:12The lowest level you can resolve something is the most time efficient.
- 1:16effective and with good communications on your side and good communications
- 1:21on their side in the perfect scenario, things can get fixed at the lowest level.
- 1:25Encourage that.
- 1:26However, you're going to find sometimes That might not be the case, and I've seen
- 1:31situations where credit unions pointed out factual errors to credit, to examiners
- 1:39were not fixed, where NCUA has made camel code conclusions, say a downgrade from a
- 1:45two to a three or a three to a four, or where a credit union is being asked to
- 1:51do things that is going to impact their positive ability to serve their members
- 1:56or build capital or build earnings.
- 1:59Or mitigate and control their liquidity.
- 2:01And so I've seen many different combinations of situations where
- 2:05credit unions have been faced with a fork in the road early on.
- 2:09One of my clients indicated that every time NCOA makes a recommendation or a
- 2:16comment, the credit union has to look at that comment and say, Does it make sense?
- 2:21Is it a great idea that I want to adopt?
- 2:24Is it a mediocre idea or is it a bad idea that's going to hurt me and my members?
- 2:29And when you get into the mediocre idea to bad idea, they have to weigh
- 2:34whether or not they want to push it.
- 2:36And I quite frankly, when I was at NCUA, I didn't realize the magnitude of how many
- 2:40things NCUA says falls into this category.
- 2:44And the client said, You have to weigh whether or not you
- 2:47want to go along to get along.
- 2:49Is it worth pushing or is it not worth pushing?
- 2:52And there's always the fear of retaliation that credit unions
- 2:55feel deep down in their hearts.
- 2:57Sometimes that might happen.
- 2:59And I think it's rare that the retaliation actually does happen quite
- 3:03rare, but that doesn't mean because NCUA is in the position of power.
- 3:08Theoretically that that credit unions don't feel like, Hey, maybe I shouldn't
- 3:13push on this because I just don't want to tick off the examiner or the
- 3:17supervisory examiner or above that level.
- 3:21So it's a constant ever present situation.
- 3:24A lot of credit unions have to deal with.
- 3:26When you get to the point where you have talked to the examiner, you've
- 3:31talked to the supervisory examiner.
- 3:34You've gotten a draft report.
- 3:35You've gotten a final report.
- 3:37And you don't like the camel code, or you don't like some of the things
- 3:41that NCUA is telling you, you need to do in a document resolution.
- 3:45And by the way, those document resolutions are negotiable, and
- 3:48sometimes it appears like they're not.
- 3:51So you have the ability to push back on those, push back on dates,
- 3:54push back on language, come up with, approaches to the document resolution
- 4:00that can create a win win for the credit union and a win win for NCUA.
- 4:05But sometimes you can't achieve that and sometimes you get to the
- 4:08point where you're at that fork in the road and you have to decide if
- 4:11you do want to consider appealing.
- 4:14The appeal process, it's detailed in regulation.
- 4:17By the way, and in regulation, I've said this before, when you're dealing with
- 4:21an NCUA regulation, it's always good to read the preamble of the proposed rule.
- 4:26The preamble of the final rule and the final rule, because you get,
- 4:30it's like a three chapter play.
- 4:31Here's what they propose.
- 4:32Here's why they're proposing it.
- 4:34Here's what staff thinks.
- 4:35Here's what the board thinks in the proposal.
- 4:38They get comment and then it's becomes final, but there's the preamble
- 4:42explains why they're doing what they're doing in the final rule or what
- 4:46they changed from the proposed rule.
- 4:49And it really is the arc of all three of those things that you need to look
- 4:53at to best understand why NCUA operates.
- 4:56What's a rule being replaced?
- 4:58I will have links to the preamble of the final rule and the final
- 5:02rule in, in the show notes.
- 5:04But when you want to appeal to NCUA, you can appeal certain things
- 5:10and the regulation defines it.
- 5:12But before I go into that definition, like I said, you can
- 5:16appeal to the regional director.
- 5:18Some things you can appeal just to the regional director.
- 5:20The regulation defines what you can appeal to the higher levels,
- 5:25but you can appeal or complain about anything to the NCOA regional
- 5:29director, and they can act on that.
- 5:32So.
- 5:33If, if you want a change in examiners, for example, that's not something that's
- 5:38a formal appeal, but you can do that by approaching the chain of command and then
- 5:43ultimately writing additional director.
- 5:46The example I'm talking about for this example would be someone being downgraded
- 5:51from either a 2 to a 3 or a 3 to a 4 and having document resolution items
- 5:58that you didn't agree to and that you don't agree to and want to get changed.
- 6:04So, the appeal process and the regulation states that credit unions
- 6:09may appeal material supervisory determinations as outlined in Part
- 6:13746, Subpart A of the NCUA regulations.
- 6:18Find which a material supervisory determination is defined as a
- 6:24written decision by a program office.
- 6:27So, program office would be the region or the Office of National
- 6:30Exam and Supervision, for example.
- 6:32that may significantly affect capital earnings operating flexibility or
- 6:38may otherwise affect the nature or level of supervisory oversight
- 6:43of an insured credit union.
- 6:45The nature or level, when you hear the word level, that means How frequently
- 6:49are they going to come see you, right?
- 6:51So if you're downgraded from a two to a three, they're
- 6:53going to come every 180 days.
- 6:54If you're downgraded from a two or a three to a four, they're going to come see you
- 6:59every 90 days, excuse me, every 90 days.
- 7:02So those codes impact the level of supervisory oversight that they have.
- 7:09And so because of that, you have the ability to appeal that.
- 7:13Now, there's some key language here in this next sentence, this includes,
- 7:17and I underline these next words, but is not limited to the following.
- 7:23You can appeal a composite examination rating of 3, 4, or 5.
- 7:28You can appeal a determination relating to the adequacy of loan loss reserves.
- 7:33And with CECL right now, you might have some situations where, uh, NCOA is pushing
- 7:39a little too hard on that, although, uh, I've seen that in a couple instances,
- 7:43but they were able to resolve it.
- 7:45The classification of loans and other assets that are significant to the
- 7:49credit union, a determination relating to compliance with federal consumer financial
- 7:54law, and a determination relating to a waiver request or application for
- 7:58additional authority where independent appeals procedures have not been
- 8:02specified in other and CUA regulations.
- 8:05So it would be an application for something, field of membership.
- 8:13So coordinated that something that doesn't have another way to appeal identified
- 8:17in that particular regulation, you can appeal under part seven, four, six, eight.
- 8:21So it seems like those examples are pretty tight, but this includes, but is
- 8:26not limited to let me go back and talk about the camel three, four, and five.
- 8:29So if you were downgraded from a two to a three.
- 8:33You notice that the language says composite examination
- 8:36ratings of three, four, or five.
- 8:38That means you can't appeal that you've got a three in capital
- 8:41or earnings or liquidity.
- 8:44However, of course.
- 8:46If you got a three overall, you got there because they downgraded some
- 8:50other things down to, from a, they downgraded capital, for example, or they
- 8:55downgraded liquidity, which is, by the way, something that's getting downgraded
- 8:59left and right by NCUA right now.
- 9:01Are you worried about an NCUA exam in process or looming on the horizon?
- 9:05Don't face it alone.
- 9:07We're ex NCUA insiders with decades of experience, ready to guide you to success.
- 9:12Our team understands the intricacies of NCUA examinations from the inside out.
- 9:17Hire us and gain peace of mind during your exam process, insider knowledge of NCUA
- 9:22procedures and expectations, strategies to address potential issues before they
- 9:26become problems, continuous access to our extensive subject matter expertise.
- 9:31With our Access Retainer, you'll have on demand support from former NCUA experts.
- 9:36We're here to ensure your credit union passes your exam with flying colors.
- 9:41Contact Credit Union Exam Solutions today to learn more about our services and how
- 9:46we can help your credit union succeed.
- 9:49So let's say it's capital and it's liquidity and sensitivity that
- 9:53got downgraded to a three and that drives your overall rating down.
- 9:59Oftentimes you'll, if you're a three overall, you'll get a three
- 10:01in a management that's not always required and sometimes there'll
- 10:04be a differentiating point there.
- 10:06My point is You cannot appeal by definition the components
- 10:12and you cannot appeal if you're a two and want to be a one.
- 10:16If you're going to be making an argument of the facts and persuading
- 10:21NCUA's regional director or NCUA's supervisory committee or NCUA's office
- 10:26of examination or ultimately NCUA's NCUA board to, to say why you're
- 10:32not a three, you have to explain how you're better than the components.
- 10:36So while it says you can't appeal it.
- 10:38You indirectly can because your argument is going to be made on that.
- 10:41Now, NCUA's regional director come back and say, well, I'm not
- 10:44changing the components because you can't, you can't appeal that.
- 10:48But then if they wanted to change the overall component, quite frankly, they
- 10:53would have to change the components.
- 10:54So you get into this little circular approach as it relates to CAMEL.
- 10:58Now, the other thing, but is not limited to, I want to go back to the
- 11:02definition of supervisory determination.
- 11:05So, let's say, and that is a written decision by a program office that
- 11:10may significantly affect the capital earnings and operating flexibility
- 11:14or may otherwise affect the nature of level of supervisory oversight.
- 11:18So if you have a document resolution and or examination findings that you
- 11:23don't agree with that have the ability to significantly affect the capital
- 11:27earnings and operating flexibility, that would be something that you could
- 11:31make an argument that you want to appeal, and it would be appealable.
- 11:35And again, an overzealous examiner puts in a document resolution, liquidity or
- 11:42sensitivity or earnings or asset quality or capital that restricts your ability
- 11:49and significantly affects your ability to achieve cap, to, to affect capital
- 11:53earnings and operating flexibility.
- 11:56Quite frankly, you can drive a truck through that definition.
- 11:58So while they frame it up, like it's only these things as examples, it's
- 12:02really very broad what you can appeal.
- 12:04Now, if you appeal.
- 12:06You still have to, that doesn't stay what you have to do.
- 12:11So you still have to comply with the examination.
- 12:14Now, another nuance to that is if you didn't agree to the document
- 12:18resolution, you can communicate that to them and you can say what
- 12:22you're willing to do in your letters versus what they've asked you to do.
- 12:25And you get into this no man, or again, no man's land where you're,
- 12:31you're kind of complying or you're complying with what you're agreeing to.
- 12:35Okay.
- 12:35And in so you, you write to the regional director, they're going to
- 12:39reply saying, yes, we agree, or we don't agree, but they're going to
- 12:43have to take in consideration what it is you write to them about, right?
- 12:47And so that creates an administrative record, by the way, NCWA's examination
- 12:51process is when they want to ratchet things up, and I'll have a separate video.
- 12:55Podcast on this, but you know, when they go from an examiner finding to
- 12:58a document resolution, to a letter of understanding, to a cease and
- 13:01desist order, to a preliminary warning letter, to the draconian actions
- 13:06of, of conservatorship, they have to build a record to get to that point.
- 13:10So they can't.
- 13:11Unless there's fraud involved, quite frankly, they can't go from zero to
- 13:1460 without taking those interim steps.
- 13:17And you need to look at your record, whether it's emails or whether it's
- 13:22a letter appealing, you have to look at what you're doing is building the
- 13:25administration straight of record from your side of it, because you can use
- 13:28that as you go on to the next level.
- 13:31All right.
- 13:31So what levels are they and how does that work?
- 13:34So I'm going to give you an example of how long an appeal can take.
- 13:39So the example I'm giving you.
- 13:41We'll, we'll be losing at every level until you ultimately
- 13:46go to the end to a board.
- 13:47So for sake of discussion, I'm recording this February 24th.
- 13:52Let's assume that on the last day of March, you get an examination.
- 13:57They meet with your board.
- 13:58It's a final examination.
- 14:00You're downgraded from a two to a three, and you've got.
- 14:03Three document resolutions, pick three categories, asset quality,
- 14:07liquidity, and sensitivity.
- 14:09And you disagree with one or all of those document resolutions
- 14:13and you want to appeal.
- 14:14Once you get that examination, you have 30 days to appeal it
- 14:20to the NCUA regional director.
- 14:22Now I've also, as an aside, I've also seen NCUA take the position that once you
- 14:28get the draft, the clock starts ticking.
- 14:31So.
- 14:31Once you know what your code is, the day you find that out, I would view
- 14:35that as the day your 30 days starts.
- 14:38And I think they need to fix their regulation relative to that because
- 14:42they're basing it on insue's internal legal guidance that once
- 14:45they know that the clock starts.
- 14:47But so I've framed this up as you didn't find out until March 31st.
- 14:52To keep this simple, that gives you 30 days to appeal.
- 14:57To the regional director or the office director.
- 15:01So that would be the three regions plus the office of national
- 15:04examination and supervision.
- 15:06And I often get this question, can you skip that step because the office.
- 15:12That office already has given you the examination.
- 15:15No, you must take it to that level.
- 15:17So you can't automatically pass, go collect 200.
- 15:20You got to go to the office, the regional director, the ones director.
- 15:25Now, NCUA by other law, I think it's the regal act is required to be.
- 15:31expeditious in responding to you.
- 15:33And so their regulation, the law says they have to be expeditious.
- 15:37And then when they put it in a regulation, that determines what expeditious is.
- 15:41And as you see, when I walk through these timelines, expeditious means
- 15:45different things, depending on what stage of the appeal you are.
- 15:49So.
- 15:50The office director, and in this instance, we'll say it's a regional
- 15:54director, has 30 days to reply.
- 15:57So March, you get the, the examination report.
- 16:02You have to appeal by the end of April.
- 16:05So that's 30 days.
- 16:07That gives the regional director until the end of May to heal,
- 16:12to reply to your appeal.
- 16:14So now we're 60 days in, we're at the end of May.
- 16:16Let's assume they say, nope.
- 16:18Okay.
- 16:18We agree with our examination staff and you'll get a letter from them and
- 16:22should you want to appeal it further, they'll explain how to do that.
- 16:25And the how to do that is that that gives you another 30 days.
- 16:30So expeditious to go to the regional director means 30 days.
- 16:34Every time the ball gets put back in your court, you have 30 days.
- 16:39So that gives you 30 days to go.
- 16:43One of two directions.
- 16:44You can go to the Office of Examination and Insurance, or you can go to
- 16:49the Supervisory Review Committee.
- 16:51Now, quite frankly, more often than not, it makes sense to just go to the
- 16:56Supervisory Review Committee, because this is a step you have an option.
- 17:00If your goal is to ultimately get to the NSUA Board, I would, I would go
- 17:05to the Supervisory Review Committee.
- 17:07Now, another caveat to that is the regions have their own quality control,
- 17:13which is their division of supervision.
- 17:16The ones credit unions, office of national examination and supervision.
- 17:20And as a reminder, that's over 15 billion in assets.
- 17:23Those credit unions have, have their own ones division, excuse me, their
- 17:28own division of supervision, but because they're significantly important
- 17:32to the insurance fund, they have to have their reports reviewed by the
- 17:37office of examination and insurance.
- 17:39So I would argue in no circumstances or very rarely would a ones Credit union,
- 17:46a credit union over 15 billion in assets will want to take it to E& I because
- 17:50they've already reviewed the report.
- 17:52This is a way to keep things moving.
- 17:53So let's assume by the, by on June 30th, excuse me, June 30th, you
- 18:00reply to the regional director.
- 18:04You reply to NCUA and you take it to the supervisory review committee.
- 18:08The supervisory review committee There's a lot of information relative to that
- 18:12in the preamble and the regulation, but it's a group, it's a committee
- 18:16of senior leaders and executives at NCUA and staff members at NCUA.
- 18:21I believe they have, now they have a rotating group of eight people that
- 18:26can serve on the supervisory review committee and they have to be independent.
- 18:30Of the chain of command in the region.
- 18:33So in this example, let's say your credit union in region one that has
- 18:38appealed the region one director did not side with you and then you went
- 18:44to the supervisory review committee.
- 18:45So they would pick from this pool of aid.
- 18:48And they would pick people that are not in any way connected to region one.
- 18:52So that could be someone from one, someone from the office of examination
- 18:55of insurance, someone from the two regions, the other regions, two or three.
- 19:00And that group of three, they would pick a chair and they would be able to,
- 19:05that would be the, the people who would decide your appeal now expeditious.
- 19:11What does expeditious mean in when it's either gone to the office
- 19:15of examination of insurance.
- 19:16For the supervisory review committee, those two steps in the appeal,
- 19:21they have 60 days to decide.
- 19:23But in my example here, I'm going to say, let's say they got it done in 30 days.
- 19:27And the other thing is you can ask for an oral hearing with the
- 19:32supervisory review committee.
- 19:33You cannot do that at the regional director level, and you
- 19:37cannot do that at the office of examination of insurance level.
- 19:40And if you ask the supervisory review committee for that, you,
- 19:44they must grant that opportunity.
- 19:47Now, that leads into an elongation of the process because when you're wanting
- 19:52to do something face to face, you have your schedules you have to work in, you
- 19:56have your legal counsel that you probably hired schedules, you have the NCUA staff
- 20:00member schedules and that can elongate it.
- 20:03Ultimately, in the end, if you have orals in the two steps that you
- 20:06can, that can add a quarter to it.
- 20:08But in this example, the Supervisory Review Committee responds to you and
- 20:13says, no, we still agree with the region.
- 20:17We still agree with the office director.
- 20:19And so now we're to the end of July.
- 20:22Okay.
- 20:23So you got the exam in March, four months have gone by.
- 20:27You were just told, no, we don't agree with you.
- 20:30That gives you another 30 days to appeal to the national credit
- 20:35union administration board.
- 20:37Okay.
- 20:38So that gets you to the end of August.
- 20:39You send in your appeal.
- 20:41Uh, at this time you can request an oral hearing, but the board
- 20:47does not have to grant that now.
- 20:50In, in examples of the past.
- 20:53I've seen situations where there were, the case brought before them was a similar
- 21:00thing that they'd already appealed.
- 21:01And in that instance, the board says, no, we're not going to
- 21:03grant oral face to face appeal.
- 21:07In that scenario, they said, no, we have enough information.
- 21:10We can make our decision.
- 21:11But they will and I have seen that they've allowed this and then that ends up being a
- 21:16closed item at the NCUA board meeting with the board they're listening and you have
- 21:20the opportunity to make your statement and the office that you're appealing has the
- 21:24opportunity and then the board has time to decide and that time to decide is 90
- 21:30days so the NCUA board gives themselves 90 days so the definition of In summary,
- 21:35the definition of expeditious as it relates to the board stage is 90 days.
- 21:40The definition of expeditious, if it's the SRC, Supervisory Review
- 21:45Committee, or E& I, the Office of Examination of Insurance, is 60 days.
- 21:49The office director has 30 days, and in every step of the
- 21:52way, you only have 30 days.
- 21:54But you know the facts, so I guess the argument for giving you a shorter time
- 21:57period is that you have the facts at hand.
- 22:00Although you could argue that Uh, maybe you should get a little bit more time if
- 22:03they're giving themselves the longer time, but in the same token, you want it done.
- 22:07So moving quickly probably isn't your best interest.
- 22:11So you get your feel into them by August 2024, that gives them 90 days.
- 22:17So now we're at the end of November.
- 22:19So you've had the report now six, eight months.
- 22:24And again, if you decide you want to do oral at either stage, that
- 22:28can add about 45 days either way.
- 22:30You can end up getting close to a year by the time that you have your appeal.
- 22:35And this has happened sometimes NCUA comes in and they do another
- 22:38exam and they upgrade you before the appeal process ever gets done.
- 22:42And if you do some research, you can see that that's happened on some of
- 22:46the decisions that have been made.
- 22:47And then you have to weigh ultimately, do you want to appeal
- 22:51or do you not want to appeal?
- 22:53What's the definition of victory, right?
- 22:55If you are looking to get your camel code upgraded, or you're looking to
- 22:59get a document resolution, totally eliminated or changed or tweaked.
- 23:04You can have partial victories along the way.
- 23:07You could have them say, we'll take this piece out.
- 23:09And let's say in this example, let's say the regional director said, you know what?
- 23:12You were given five document resolutions.
- 23:15I'm going to eliminate one of them, but I'm keeping the camel codes the same.
- 23:18You could go, Nope, that's not good enough.
- 23:20You could take it to the supervisory review committee and
- 23:22they could say, you know what?
- 23:23They moved it from, Five to four, we're not changing the camel code,
- 23:27but we're going to change the language of this document resolution.
- 23:29And you don't like that.
- 23:30And then you could appeal that on up to the NCUA board.
- 23:33So you can get partial victories.
- 23:35You can get full victories.
- 23:37But I've had credit unions say to me that they don't feel
- 23:41like they were free to prayer.
- 23:43Barely.
- 23:43They think that the powers that be need to know more information about
- 23:47how they were treated and or handled.
- 23:50And they want to bring things into the sunshine.
- 23:52And sometimes there are credit unions that will view victory as just having
- 23:57the opportunity to be heard, right?
- 23:58Because that can provide a sense of closure, but that can also.
- 24:02allow you to have your feelings heard on how the examination
- 24:06process in your view went awry.
- 24:09So that can be a victory, just having the opportunity to be heard.
- 24:13So that's it in a nutshell.
- 24:15Again, definition of success.
- 24:17And where you might succeed, I think the further along, when you get to the point
- 24:21where you're dealing with the board that's political, that may not like how you
- 24:25were treated, I've seen situations where the board has said, because staff said
- 24:29X, I can't support staff on this, right?
- 24:32So the higher up the hierarchy you get.
- 24:35The more political it gets and the different view that they have,
- 24:38maybe that's a better way to say than political, but there have been
- 24:41things overturned at the board level.
- 24:43I think your Kansas success is greatest there, second greatest at the supervisory
- 24:48review committee level, and then E& I and then the office director.
- 24:52And quite frankly, tie goes to the runners.
- 24:54So think of this when someone walks into your office complaining
- 24:58about your, a member complaining about your staff member.
- 25:02You look at the facts and you may see a situation where, again, it
- 25:07could be gray or black and white, you see a situation where the member
- 25:12clearly is wrong or that it's close, that the staff is right, here's the
- 25:18policy, you tend to want to support your staff because that has morale.
- 25:24ramifications, but you also want to treat your member fairly.
- 25:27The same thing works at NCUA.
- 25:29A regional director is just not going to willy nilly go changing things because
- 25:33they lose the, they can lose some of their staff if they start doing that too much.
- 25:37In the same token, and what I'm saying there is sometimes tie
- 25:41goes to the runner, so they're not going to just overturn to overturn.
- 25:44And so you have that burden of showing that it's not tied to go with the runner.
- 25:49You were clearly safe at first base.
- 25:50And here's why that's a good sports analogy relative to this.
- 25:55In any event, this podcast, I got a little bit more into details.
- 25:59I went down a couple of rabbit holes.
- 26:01Uh, that's a show that's out there that I want to start watching.
- 26:03Someone recommended I give that a watch with Kiefer Sutherland.
- 26:06And so went down some rabbit holes, but this is my take
- 26:10on the formal appeal process.
- 26:13If you or your credit union are considering that and would like
- 26:16to talk about it, give me a call you or track me down on LinkedIn.
- 26:19And as always listeners, I appreciate you listening.
- 26:22I hope you listen again soon.
- 26:25And this is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.