Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Mediating Against Public Entities
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Mediating Against Public Entities.
- 0:07I'm Ala Policastro, Director of Education and
- 0:09Professional Development at Beverly Hills Bar
- 0:11Association. And today I am delighted to introduce
- 0:14our speaker, Rhonda Mallory. Rhonda is a mediator
- 0:18at Signature Resolution with over 35 years of
- 0:21legal experience spanning both public and private
- 0:24sectors. Her extensive background includes leadership
- 0:27roles at Caltrans and the California Department
- 0:29of Justice, where she oversaw litigation involving
- 0:32public entities, civil rights, and imminent domain,
- 0:36giving her deep insight into the complex dynamics
- 0:39of government -related disputes. Known for her
- 0:42resolution -focused approach and commitment to
- 0:44civility in the legal profession, Rhonda brings
- 0:47a nuanced understanding of the approval structures
- 0:49and procedural challenges that often accompany
- 0:52mediating against public entities. We can't wait
- 0:55to hear what she has to share with us today.
- 0:57Rhonda? Thank you, Ala. So this presentation
- 1:01is not just for the plaintiff's bar or plaintiff's
- 1:05attorneys. It's for anyone basically who has
- 1:08any type of case with a public entity. whether
- 1:13it be Code of Defense counsel or whatever, and
- 1:15even for public entity attorneys. But it certainly
- 1:18is focused more on hopefully trying to educate
- 1:22the plaintiff's bar with the challenges and the
- 1:26obstacles that go on behind the scenes for the
- 1:28public entity attorneys in trying to get authority
- 1:33to mediate or settle the case. And so hopefully
- 1:38the takeaway here at the end of the program will
- 1:41be time. We need time to get the case prepared
- 1:46and the information to the powers that be and
- 1:49also information. So we don't want to do those
- 1:53at the last minute. So those are kind of the
- 1:55two takeaways that I want to start off with is
- 1:57time and information. I do want to apologize.
- 2:01I had to cancel this a couple of weeks ago because
- 2:04I had a got COVID, and so I apologize for any
- 2:08scheduling issues that it may have presented
- 2:10to you. All right, so, and I'm still getting
- 2:14healthy, so hold on one second, please. All right,
- 2:18thank you. All right, meeting with public entities.
- 2:23So I had prepared a article that was kind of
- 2:27the genesis or the basis for this presentation.
- 2:30And in looking back at the about the article
- 2:33and then also the subject matter title is mediating
- 2:37against public entities. And so, oh, that's okay.
- 2:41The first thing is mediating with public entities.
- 2:44I decided to change it to mediating with public
- 2:46entities because number one, it really should
- 2:49be or try to be a collaborative process. uh the
- 2:53more information and the more time and the more
- 2:56you can understand what goes on you know in order
- 2:59for the public entity attorney to get the information
- 3:02and the authority that they need for uh settlement
- 3:05for mediation hopefully settlement uh hopefully
- 3:08the more that you can appreciate that what goes
- 3:11on um and what this presentation is not is it's
- 3:16not giving the secret keys to the kingdom it
- 3:19is not uh putting the roboways to see what's
- 3:24going on with the wizard in the background, because
- 3:27the reality of it is there is no such thing.
- 3:30What I'm going to talk about here today is pretty
- 3:33basic understanding, makes sense type of an approach,
- 3:38but it's one that everybody involved needs to
- 3:41remember and to hopefully embrace in order to
- 3:46make the mediation or ADR process at least beneficial
- 3:53to both sides. All right. Let me, again, next
- 4:00slide, please. Okay, this is kind of a tongue
- 4:03in cheek, or maybe perhaps a tongue in a baby's
- 4:07mouth, if the case may be. About some frustration
- 4:12that you may feel when you're dealing with a
- 4:15public entity. Um, it is it is it is felt by
- 4:18by all. It's unfortunately, we're fortunately
- 4:21the process that we have. And so, you know, yes,
- 4:24you may want to cry. Um, next slide. But just
- 4:35so you know, we're all in this together because
- 4:36we all might want to cry. Now I'm hoping that
- 4:39the majority of your mediations and even just
- 4:42your litigation in general public is as seamless
- 4:45as possible. But what this presentation hopefully
- 4:49highlights is just to educate you on those situations
- 4:53that might be out of the ordinary, out of the
- 4:56norm. you know, what to do as far as trying to
- 5:02address those issues to make sure that everyone
- 5:05can be on the same page and have a successful
- 5:09mediation or ADR. All right, next slide, please.
- 5:15All right. So the state, counties, and cities
- 5:20all have different processes for obtaining settlement
- 5:22authority for mediation. and even within one
- 5:25entity, they may have different processes depending
- 5:27on what type of case it is. Employment, for instance,
- 5:32might have one process where they get their mediation
- 5:35authority or settlement authority, let's say
- 5:37settlement authority. Tort might have theirs
- 5:40and eminent domain or any type of land use or
- 5:43property might have theirs. I come from the state
- 5:47and so my 20 years of state practice essentially
- 5:50is with Caltrans and with the AG's office. I
- 5:54don't pretend to know the processes of the 58
- 5:57other counties or the 482 cities and municipalities
- 6:01in California. So the majority of what I'm going
- 6:05to be talking about is state related. However,
- 6:09having spoken to other city attorneys and deputy
- 6:13county council, I know that they also have their
- 6:16processes and their timeframes that they need
- 6:19to adhere to. And so although it may not be specific,
- 6:22or as specific or as protracted as the state,
- 6:26they still have similar challenges. All right.
- 6:36Generally, the bigger the entity, the more processes
- 6:38involved. And as stated, since I was with the
- 6:43state, which was the biggest entity in California,
- 6:47I can speak to some of the protracted processes
- 6:50that, yes, may not make sense, but it's just,
- 6:54you know, it's the world that we live in. And
- 6:58let's say a slip and fall at a small city, a
- 7:04public entity, a slip and fall on a park might
- 7:07be able to get authority for mediation much faster
- 7:11than, let's say, you know, something having to
- 7:14do with the state and depending on what level
- 7:17of authority that you're looking for. Smaller
- 7:20entities may use retained council rather than
- 7:22the deputy attorneys general, which are counsel
- 7:26that work at the AG's office, represent those
- 7:29public entities, deputy attorneys such as Caltrans,
- 7:32deputy county council, or just a deputy city
- 7:35attorneys as well. So many of the smaller entities,
- 7:39just to kind of know who the players are and
- 7:41who you're dealing with, many of the smaller
- 7:43entities may not have their own litigation or
- 7:47trial counsel. And so they use retained counsel
- 7:50in order to represent them in those types of
- 7:53cases. And again, I'm not talking about, I'm
- 7:56mainly focused on litigation because there's
- 7:58a lot of other transactional and other components
- 8:00to government as well. But right now we're focusing
- 8:02on litigation. Civil litigation. I will say that
- 8:08the routine counsel that some of the smaller
- 8:13entities may use are typically very, very good
- 8:16attorneys. They know they're a client. They know
- 8:20the processes that their client demands. And
- 8:23so although they may not be an employee or in
- 8:26the legal division of that particular entity,
- 8:29they, for the most part, are darn good and they
- 8:31know what they're doing. All right. So the more
- 8:35authority requested, the longer it takes in the
- 8:38multiple processes. And sometimes the legislature,
- 8:42governor's office, board of supervisors for a
- 8:46county, city council for a city, or other governing
- 8:49board involvement in approval. So it really depends
- 8:54on, again, the entity and the amount of authority
- 8:58requested. So I'm going to... describe a real
- 9:03-life situation that I had on a case that I supervised
- 9:06when I was at the AG's office. I bring this one
- 9:10up because it was probably the most protracted
- 9:14process of any case I can think of in the last
- 9:1820 years. But it was for a lot of multiple reasons.
- 9:24It was a very, very tragic, sad case where three
- 9:28women were on the beach. And a bluff above the
- 9:34beach area failed and fell on these three women
- 9:37who were all from the same family. And to make
- 9:40matters worse, it was in front of many other
- 9:44family members. And they were there to celebrate
- 9:49one of the ladies being cancer -free. I can't
- 9:52remember what type of cancer it was. Anyway,
- 9:55tragic, just horrible, gut -wrenching, pulled
- 9:58your heartstrings type of a case. But it was
- 10:04a very complex case because we had private defendants,
- 10:09we had another public entity defendant, we had
- 10:12the State of California through one of its departments
- 10:15as the other defendant, which is the one that
- 10:19I was supervising. We had a trial date, don't
- 10:24ask me when it was, but we had a trial date and
- 10:26we had, we, and I say we, both public entities
- 10:30had filed a motion for summary judgment on multiple
- 10:34legal issues. And I believe it was going to be,
- 10:39the MSJ was going to be heard, let's say in May
- 10:42of that year. I think the trial date was September,
- 10:45if I recall. Anyway. because time was of the
- 10:49essence and because time it was a case that you
- 10:51know should should be settled for a lot of reasons
- 10:54it should be settled. So we went to mediation
- 10:58in January all the defendants and the plaintiffs
- 11:02and I remember it was really long to like 11
- 11:04o 'clock at night we were all tired but we actually
- 11:09did come to an agreement. Now what's important
- 11:12to know about this is that it's important to
- 11:15educate yourself and your clients as to some
- 11:18of these processes. So all council were very
- 11:23very experienced council they've dealt with public
- 11:25entities or they represented public entities
- 11:27and they knew going into it the state of California
- 11:31we could not actually say that the case was resolved
- 11:34for whatever amount because it had to go all
- 11:37the way up for legislature approval because the
- 11:39amount an issue so we finally you know through
- 11:43this long long long mediation late at night finally
- 11:47came to a number and so um pursuant to the agreement
- 11:54that we did that night um we indicated to everybody
- 11:58that yes this is what the ag's office is going
- 12:03to recommend for settlement but we can't say
- 12:06that it's settled because there's the governing
- 12:09body the legislature and governor's office and
- 12:11everybody going up to that has to sign off on
- 12:14it. So we knew it was going to be a long process.
- 12:17The plaintiffs knew it because their attorney
- 12:19had told them about that because you know we
- 12:22had communicated with that with with all other
- 12:24counsel and so we were essentially settling this
- 12:28case in principle but you know anyway along the
- 12:31line it could have been it could have been the
- 12:35settlement could have failed. At the same time,
- 12:39we all agreed to postpone the hearing of the
- 12:41motion for summary judgment in order to try to
- 12:43see if this case could be resolved. That happened
- 12:46in January and then for multitude of reasons
- 12:50and all the parties involved and all the people
- 12:53had to sign off on it, it finally went to the
- 12:57legislation. Then they were at a session and
- 12:59then I think they went back in October. I think
- 13:01it was January, it settled in principle, and
- 13:04then it finally was approved in November of that
- 13:06year. So I think about 10 months, that was the
- 13:08longest case that I'd personally ever worked
- 13:11on that took from settlement through payment.
- 13:15So 11 months. Anyway, just to use that as a highlight,
- 13:19that's certainly exception, not the rule, but
- 13:22it can happen. And the more that you as council
- 13:24can appreciate, these possibilities and can advise
- 13:28your client, you know, the better off and the
- 13:30less frustration, hopefully, um, others will
- 13:33have. Okay. Next slide, please. Okay. Differences
- 13:44from other parties. I was in private practice
- 13:47for 15 years. I did medical malpractice defense
- 13:50work for about four years, and then I was house
- 13:52counsel for all state from The point in time
- 13:56that I had left private practice, House counsel
- 14:00at Allstate and gone to the state of California,
- 14:02I'd been practicing attorney for 15 years. I
- 14:05had mediated hundreds and hundreds of cases.
- 14:10When I got to the state, I thought, how different
- 14:12could it be? Totally completely wrong, but how
- 14:15different it could be. First, and these are kind
- 14:18of the four takeaways as far as me as a practice
- 14:21and attorney back in the day that I highlighted
- 14:24as differences right off the bat from private
- 14:28practice to public entity practice, at least
- 14:31public entity, again, at the state. Okay, number
- 14:34one, the process for obtaining authority is more
- 14:37complex and time consuming, 100%. So in private
- 14:41practice, let's say I had a mediation scheduled
- 14:44for June 1st. I would have been in contact with
- 14:49my client, turns defense is usually claims adjuster,
- 14:52maybe claims management, perhaps my senior partner
- 14:56or manager, et cetera, from my side of the aisle.
- 15:02And we would have been updating each other as
- 15:06to what we thought that the value would be and
- 15:09they knew what was said in deposition and hopefully
- 15:11I was doing my job and sending those status reports.
- 15:17Theoretically, a case is, let's say, June 1st
- 15:20mediation date. I could take two weeks. Sometimes
- 15:24it only took days. Sometimes it took a few weeks,
- 15:26depending on the complexity of the case and the
- 15:29level of authority. So that's a reoccurring theme,
- 15:32no matter private practice or public entity practice.
- 15:36But I can usually get some authority within a
- 15:39few days to a week or two. So I. Foolishly. Assume
- 15:45that was what it was also when I went to the
- 15:47state. So I think it was the very first case
- 15:50I mediated. It was a tort case. And I remember
- 15:54speaking to my supervisor at the time. We were
- 15:57just kind of going over cases. And I said, OK,
- 16:01well, this case is set for such and such date.
- 16:05um you know this is what's going on he goes okay
- 16:08you know let's talk about this blah blah blah
- 16:10so we talked about the analysis and the liability
- 16:12and the damages and and everything you need to
- 16:14to properly evaluate a case for potential settlement
- 16:17and then when i told him what i was you know
- 16:21what i valued it at he said wait a minute um
- 16:25that has to go you know i have to sign off on
- 16:28it and then the deputy chief counsel has to sign
- 16:30off on it and because of what you expect to to
- 16:33the value to being what you want for settlement
- 16:35authority, chief counsel has to also sign off
- 16:39on that. So I thought, okay, well, yeah, I'm
- 16:42used to that. I'm used to people having to sign
- 16:44off and review and approve. So how long did that
- 16:47possibly take? Because I was used to, you know,
- 16:50maybe a few weeks, three weeks on the outset.
- 16:54So not so when I was at the state, he said. informed
- 16:56me he said no it usually is about two weeks turnaround
- 16:59for each level and it just depends on you know
- 17:01what's going on this obviously isn't the only
- 17:04case people are looking at and so I foolishly
- 17:07totally underestimated the time that it took
- 17:10to get to the level that I wanted because there
- 17:13was in addition to myself analysis there was
- 17:16one two three levels that had to look to look
- 17:20at it. So that was the first thing that I noticed
- 17:23coming from private practice to public, is that
- 17:25just the timing is much more protracted in the
- 17:31public entity arena. The second thing that I
- 17:37noticed, differences from other type of parties
- 17:39once you're in the public entity realm. is you're
- 17:43not able to pivot as easily once the mediation
- 17:45should new information arise. So again, having
- 17:48come from private practice, I mean, hopefully
- 17:50we all know the information that we should know
- 17:55about the case before the mediation occurs. That's
- 17:58not always the case. And sometimes it's no one's
- 18:01fault that something just happens at the last
- 18:03minute. And certainly we all know that that can
- 18:05happen. But the second. It wasn't the second
- 18:09mediation I handled at Caltrans, but it was one
- 18:11of the first ones that I handled, was in the
- 18:15mediation. And I believe, if I remember right,
- 18:19it was liability dispute. I thought that liability
- 18:22was kind of thin as far as the plant was concerned.
- 18:26But it was a big damages case. I think I had
- 18:29a motion for summary judgment on design immunity
- 18:32pending at the time. And so even though I was
- 18:36pretty confident that the motion for summary
- 18:38judgment would get granted, obviously there's
- 18:41no guarantees and that's kind of where your head's
- 18:44in your bed when you have pending motions and
- 18:46you try to take a case to mediation and get it
- 18:49resolved. So I thought that I would. eventually
- 18:53prevail on liability. However, because of the
- 18:55big damages, it needed to have some offer on
- 19:01the table for the plaintiff. So while we were
- 19:04in the mediation, the plaintiff attorney said,
- 19:09oh, by the way, Mrs. So -and -so went to another
- 19:15doctor, a training doctor through her HMO. And
- 19:19he is now saying that it was a laminectia. And
- 19:22the surgery has to be performed. Whereas beforehand,
- 19:26both sides were under the impression that the
- 19:28surgery, she said she didn't want it. She was
- 19:30not going to have it. It was iffy whether or
- 19:32not it was actually going to be performed. And
- 19:36even the plaintiff acknowledged that as well.
- 19:40But somehow now this new information, it changes
- 19:43it. I mean, you're talking back in the day it
- 19:45wasn't. whatever it is, 100 ,000 plus general
- 19:48damages plus time off because I know she was
- 19:51a physical laborer and so she was going to have
- 19:54to take some time off. This new information changed
- 20:00the value of the case. We needed to put more
- 20:03money on it. Again, coming from private practice,
- 20:06I was used to calling. claims management or calling
- 20:10home office and saying, hey, this is new information.
- 20:14Can we offer more than we've evaluated the case
- 20:16ad and blah. Well, not so easy with a public
- 20:21entity. Not that you can't, it's just a lot more
- 20:24difficult to pivot once you've known certain
- 20:29facts or what you believe certain facts are about
- 20:31the case and it's been evaluated by multiple
- 20:34levels and that's kind of kind of what it is.
- 20:38So we ended up, you know, continuing the mediation
- 20:40and it eventually resolved. But that was one
- 20:44of the other things I noticed that was not as
- 20:46easy to pivot once you were in the mediation
- 20:48process. Number three, the post -mediation process
- 20:51can also be more time -consuming and complex.
- 20:54Again, private practice, you settle a case, you
- 20:57know, I think maybe even claims handles it's
- 20:59been a long time since I've been in private practice.
- 21:02But the paperwork is somewhat minimal and you
- 21:06can get a check at least back in the day within
- 21:0830 days, sometimes two weeks. Then that's your
- 21:12dismissal, request for dismissal. Everything's
- 21:14done really quickly. But that is not so with
- 21:19some public entities. It's even to the point,
- 21:22it depends on where the funding source comes
- 21:24from and that's where it gets convoluted and
- 21:27I could do a whole other presentation just on
- 21:29funding sources. It does depend on if it's state
- 21:34controller's office that's issuing the settlement
- 21:37check or a functional unit or another department.
- 21:46The public entity attorney cannot say out of
- 21:50mediation that yes, it's settled on such and
- 21:54such date. Payment to be done within 2 weeks,
- 21:573 weeks, whatever it is. So those are usually
- 21:59more open ended and more time consuming and complex
- 22:04procedures as far as the type of paperwork that's
- 22:07involved. And then the last kind of. highlighted
- 22:12difference from coming from private practice
- 22:14to public was that most of the time, not most,
- 22:19but oftentimes the client representative is more
- 22:21likely to be an attorney rather than a claims
- 22:23adjuster or a reading one like that. If you are,
- 22:31for instance, Caltrans in the tort case, dangerous
- 22:35condition of public property, I'll use that one
- 22:37because it's That's one that gets addressed a
- 22:40lot with Caltrans, gets sued for that quite often.
- 22:43So there's no client per se, but the legal division
- 22:49hierarchy or management chain of command is the
- 22:52one that has different levels of authority. And
- 22:55so oftentimes, they'll be the one going to the
- 22:59mediation with you. So it would be me as the
- 23:02handling attorney and then another. somebody
- 23:06within the legal division who has the proper
- 23:08authority. Likewise, at the attorney general's
- 23:12office, which I don't know if you guys, it's
- 23:14confusing, I know. So I'll use the two state
- 23:17entities that I'm familiar with. Caltrans is
- 23:20the Department of Transportation, Caltrans, and
- 23:23they have the legal division, which is the second
- 23:26largest litigation firm in California. for California.
- 23:31The Attorney General's office is a little different.
- 23:34It works more like a private law firm, but for
- 23:38public entity departments and agencies. So one's
- 23:42a legal division of that actual entity, and the
- 23:45other one is more like a more traditional attorney
- 23:49-client situation, but in the public realm. And
- 23:56so, and this can be a good thing, and it can
- 23:58be a bad thing, depending on which. You have
- 24:01another attorney there, you know, in the mediation
- 24:04with you, and it's so they have their own experience
- 24:09and their opinions and, you know, again, not
- 24:12to make a judgment. It could be good or bad,
- 24:13but it's just different. I was used to having
- 24:15a claims adjuster being the representative or,
- 24:17you know, someone else from a business be the
- 24:20representative, but with the public, sometimes
- 24:23it's an attorney. Okay. Let's see. Let's go to
- 24:31the next slide, please. All right. Welcome to
- 24:37bureaucracy. And anyone that's dealt with the
- 24:41government knows that this is a, it can sometimes
- 24:45be very frustrating. It doesn't make sense. Why
- 24:49is this process, you know, needed or done and
- 24:54we get it and it's a true thing. But to try to
- 24:58have maybe a more positive spin on the bureaucracy,
- 25:04the good thing is the reason that the checks
- 25:06and balances are there is because these are public
- 25:10funds. This is taxpayer money that's going to
- 25:14fund and to pay these settlements in mediation
- 25:16or post verdict, whatever it might be. And so
- 25:21it's a good thing. It's not just one person saying,
- 25:25oh, I think it's this much and it's not, or I
- 25:28value it this much. You've got lots of different
- 25:30areas, lots of different people that are vetting
- 25:33it, multiple eyes on it for their own analysis.
- 25:37And so again, try to think of it in a positive
- 25:39spin, if you will, that it's protecting. public
- 25:43funds and taxpayer money. That's how I try to
- 25:47look at it when the frustration sometimes gets
- 25:50to us as well, because it does to the public
- 25:52and the attorneys as well. To understand this
- 25:56chain of command that I have discussed before
- 26:00earlier. So generally, it's the handling attorney
- 26:04who has primary responsibility of the case. So
- 26:07this slide is to kind of hopefully explain why
- 26:10things are so slow when, you know, in a perfect
- 26:13world, some of this may not make sense. But generally,
- 26:17it's the handling attorney who has primary responsibility
- 26:19of the case. You deal with that person on a day
- 26:22-to -day basis. The person works the case up,
- 26:25analyzes it, and is the starting point to evaluate
- 26:28liability and damages and to request settlement
- 26:31authority from the client. So this is the person
- 26:34that you're going to depots with, you're in a
- 26:37case management conference with, it's the one
- 26:39that's primary responsibility for the case. But
- 26:44in the public entity realm world, there's then
- 26:48also a chain of command, which is a little bit
- 26:51more, rather than private sector, it's a little
- 26:53bit more, I would say militant, but it's a little
- 26:55bit more. military, how about that, in nature
- 26:58as far as decisions and authority that need to
- 27:03be vetted up the chain of command. So the public
- 27:06entities and their chain of command, which is
- 27:08usually multiple levels of authority that review
- 27:11the settlement authority evaluation. So let's
- 27:14say I'm the handling attorney. I have a wrongful
- 27:17death case in a state park. I am the one that
- 27:24has worked it up. I know what's been said in
- 27:27the depositions. I know what discovery and discovery
- 27:29is revealed. I know, hopefully, most of the case,
- 27:34or all the case to the extent that you can. And
- 27:36so I'm going to then prepare my analysis for
- 27:41the chain of command so that people can, those
- 27:44up the chain of command can sign off on it. And
- 27:48it's far more, let's say it's far more, most
- 27:52of the times it's, A lot of information is required.
- 27:58These settlement memos can take a long time for
- 28:01the attorney. And again, it's not like you have
- 28:03one case, so you have other things going on.
- 28:06It can be dozens of pages depending on what type
- 28:09of case it is. On the bluff failure case that
- 28:12I mentioned earlier, it was a highly, highly
- 28:16technical case with erosion and engineers and
- 28:19things of the like. So the settlement memo for
- 28:22that was, I don't remember how many. 33 pages
- 28:25or something. It was a lot because there was
- 28:26a lot of information and because we were going
- 28:29to be asking for a lot of money and we knew the
- 28:31legislature was going to be involved, you know,
- 28:34every I had to be dotted and every T crossed.
- 28:38So the settlement memo is prepared depending
- 28:41on how long it is, you know, much more simpler
- 28:43for a simpler case, more complex for a higher
- 28:47authority or more complex legal issues case.
- 28:50And so that's prepared by the attorney handling
- 28:52the case. And then at least from the state's
- 28:58perspective, the AG's perspective, it goes up
- 29:01to the next level of authority, which is the
- 29:03supervisor or the SDAAG, who then will look at
- 29:06the settlement memo, may have some questions,
- 29:10usually will edit it. For content or other other
- 29:13reasons, or they may have say, why wasn't this
- 29:16person's deposition taken and isn't this important?
- 29:19So you then have another pair of eyes that are
- 29:22vetting that evaluation that the primary attorneys
- 29:24handled. And then depending on the amount in
- 29:28the type of case, it can go a couple, four steps
- 29:32above that, three steps above the handling attorney.
- 29:39Everyone within the legal division then representing
- 29:43the public has reviewed it. They feel comfortable
- 29:47after the process. They feel comfortable with
- 29:50the amount requested. They feel comfortable that
- 29:52all the information is needed in order to request
- 29:55that amount. And then the next step. The chain
- 30:06of command will review the evaluation, may ask
- 30:07for more information. Okay, whatever that, or
- 30:09may disagree with the requested amount. If that
- 30:11occurs, the process takes a step backward for
- 30:13further evaluation, which I think I just explained,
- 30:16but it can put a cog in that process, if you
- 30:18will, if there's additional information that's
- 30:20needed, or there's someone that disagrees with
- 30:23the value, either it being too low or too high.
- 30:26The next one is there could be four levels of
- 30:28authority or more. I just stated that. It's kind
- 30:30of the public and diversion of the tower as far
- 30:33as additional authority. And then once everything's
- 30:38signed off on the legal counsel division, then
- 30:42it goes to the client for internal review. So
- 30:45for instance, I'll use the CHP as an example.
- 30:49Let's say it's an excessive force case and they're
- 30:53asking, you know, $4 million in settlement authority
- 30:56using that number. The AG's office and the handling
- 31:00DAG and the SDAG and the SAG and the CAG, and
- 31:04the state loves acronyms by the way. They all
- 31:08sign off on it. Then it goes to CHP using them
- 31:12as an example, an excessive force case. Then
- 31:15it goes up their chain of command who are all
- 31:17attorneys. The staff counts. staff attorney who's
- 31:20basically the one dealing with the primary handling
- 31:23attorney from the AG's office again using AG
- 31:25as an example and then assistant chief counsel
- 31:28and then general counsel depending on what type
- 31:33of case and how much 4 million definitely general
- 31:35counsel would be involved. So that's just one
- 31:41example of how that would happen. And then retain
- 31:43council on those cases where they may not be
- 31:48an actual public entity attorney and it might
- 31:51be outside retain council. My understanding is
- 31:55that they have to follow similar paths for their
- 31:57public entity clients within the process of that
- 32:00public entity. And then you may have additional
- 32:04issues if in fact they have like an SIR itself.
- 32:08insured retention limit. And if it's a case that's
- 32:12going to be in excess of that SIR limit, then
- 32:16they have to get there. So the people that are
- 32:21involved, whoever the prism or whoever it is,
- 32:24after the SIR limits, they have their processes
- 32:27that they have to also get involved with and
- 32:31do whatever it is for those processes, which
- 32:33I'm not savvy to those, but I do know that they
- 32:36exist. OK. Next slide, please. And I forgot to
- 32:43mention this earlier. I apologize, because I
- 32:45was going to actually do questions. And I know
- 32:48that there's some in the chat. So I was going
- 32:51to do them as I went. But let's see. OK, now
- 32:58we're all good there. All right, we'll take them
- 33:06afterwards. Okay, pre -mediation. So now that
- 33:12you've seen a little bit, heard a little bit
- 33:16about all the process and all the time and all
- 33:19the people that have to look to get authority
- 33:22before we can go to mediation, for the public
- 33:25and they can go to mediation, you know, the next
- 33:28question is, okay, so what can I do? I'm stuck
- 33:33with those processes, I understand. But what
- 33:35can I do in order to represent my client the
- 33:38best that I can and to try to ensure that the
- 33:42mediation, we'll just say mediation rather than
- 33:45ADR, that the mediation is successful or at least
- 33:51beneficial to my client. Here's what I would
- 33:56suggest the takeaways especially is to the plaintiff's
- 33:59bar, but this goes to the defense as well. Because
- 34:03you need to have your case prepped. Number one,
- 34:08know your case. I can be wrong about this, but
- 34:12it seems in recent time years, some cases go
- 34:16to mediation before they're ready to go to mediation.
- 34:21key depositions haven't been taken, or there's
- 34:24some other issues that neither party knows the
- 34:27answer to, or maybe there's a potential, let's
- 34:30just say, surgery that no one really knows, you
- 34:33know, if it's going to happen, or if it's going
- 34:35to be recommended, etc. Anyway, so number one,
- 34:39know your case. This helps you. Even if the case
- 34:44doesn't resolve the mediation, it helps you.
- 34:46It helps both sides. It helps both sides. in
- 34:50filing or opposing any type of dispositive motion.
- 34:54It helps you have confidence in order to advise.
- 34:58you know, either of your clients as to the risks
- 35:02and potential value of the case. And so it's
- 35:07not for naught. Even if the case isn't resolved,
- 35:09please know your case. And in order to do this,
- 35:12you have to take key depositions well in advance
- 35:14of mediation so the public entity can have all
- 35:17the information needed to evaluate it. PMQs are
- 35:21important to take because no matter how much
- 35:25you prepare your witnesses or your employees,
- 35:29stuff happens in depot that you just don't have
- 35:32any idea that that was going to be testified
- 35:34like that. So it's best if everyone knows. what's
- 35:39going to eventually be evidence. So take PMQs,
- 35:43take important experts. I'm not saying you have
- 35:45to take every expert, but take those that are
- 35:47going to be the big ticket items or the big issues
- 35:50in dispute. Take the parties, take whatever percipient
- 35:55witnesses, especially if it's maybe treaters,
- 35:58doctors, medical providers. Again, this helps
- 36:01both sides know the actual evidence rather than
- 36:03thinking. what's going to happen. I mean, there
- 36:06may be a report where, you know, witness Mr.
- 36:10X says X, Y, and Z, but then in deposition, that
- 36:14changes a little bit. So, and I know there's
- 36:18two schools of thought. Sometimes people like
- 36:19to go to mediation before they, you know, expend
- 36:22a lot of time and money and energy and effort
- 36:25on the case, if it's going to resolve. But bottom
- 36:29line, the more that you know and the more prepared
- 36:31you are, the better. Okay, number two I would
- 36:36say communicate. Let council know you're interested
- 36:40in mediation if you are early on. The signal
- 36:44said the other side they need to get their ducks
- 36:46in a row, the other side meaning public entity
- 36:49council, and they know what they have to do and
- 36:51how long it takes. So I don't know if this is
- 36:54a trend or maybe just a trend that I've seen
- 36:57more but you know back in the day we would have
- 37:03demand letters, or we would have 998s, or we'd
- 37:06kind of have a we. I mean, the defense bar would
- 37:08have a little, you know, some idea of what the
- 37:11plaintiff thought the value of this case would
- 37:12be. Or people would start talking about mediation,
- 37:16you know, soon after red discovery was completed.
- 37:19And it seems, again, I could be wrong about this,
- 37:21but it seems that now no one wants to blink.
- 37:24No one wants to say, hey, do you want to go to
- 37:26mediation on this case? Or, you know, they may
- 37:28take it as a sign of weakness, whether it be
- 37:30on either side of the fence, plaintiff or defense.
- 37:33And I think that's wrong. I think you should
- 37:35communicate with the other side that, hey, I
- 37:41know we have a lot of discovery yet to do, but
- 37:43is this something that we think that we should
- 37:46mediate? And if you communicate with your opposing
- 37:53council and you can even just ask them, I think
- 37:57this is a $5 million case. What's that gonna
- 38:00take on your side? And they may not agree with
- 38:02it obviously, but what's it gonna take time wise
- 38:04on your side? How many levels do you have? How
- 38:07many levels have to see it? I mean, they're not
- 38:09gonna probably give you all that specifics, but
- 38:12they can say, yeah, it's gonna take me about
- 38:1490 days, 60 days to get any type. of authority,
- 38:17so let's set the mediation and buckle down and
- 38:20make sure we can get all the information that
- 38:22we need to try to resolve this case. I just think
- 38:27that there's no reason not to discuss an interest
- 38:29in mediation early on so that everyone has that
- 38:34same objective or same goal to do what they can
- 38:37to get everything done that needs to be done
- 38:39in order to go to mediation. And I will say here,
- 38:46I know sometimes pre -mediation, or excuse me,
- 38:51pre -mediation, pre -filing can be done. In the
- 38:57government world, it's a little more difficult
- 38:59because of the six -month statute. So unless
- 39:05there's... Unless you have all the evidence right
- 39:08from the beginning, everybody does, it might
- 39:10be a little bit more difficult. Not that it can't
- 39:12be done, but because of the claim statute and
- 39:15the six months filing deadline, it's a little
- 39:19harder to get some public entity cases into pre
- 39:23-filing mediation. But for the right case, it
- 39:26might be something you want to consider. The
- 39:29timing of mediation is important. Dispositive
- 39:32motions, governmental immunities. So the government
- 39:35has a lot of immunities, a lot of qualified immunities
- 39:40on certain areas, design immunity for dangerous
- 39:43condition, and a whole host of other immunities
- 39:45that dispositive motions may be successful for
- 39:49the public entity. When I was a defense attorney,
- 39:53and I don't even know if this is not a right
- 39:56or wrong thing to do it a certain way, but it's
- 40:00something that should be considered by both sides.
- 40:05Oftentimes, I would want to get my motion for
- 40:08summary judgment or motion for summary adjudication
- 40:10on file as soon as possible, because they're
- 40:14immunities, they're legal issues motions, and
- 40:17not a lot of discovery needs to go on with that,
- 40:21because it is what it is in their legal motions.
- 40:24So to the extent you can get one on calendar
- 40:27as soon as possible, it might... behoove both
- 40:30sides because then you see what you're up against
- 40:34if you're on the plaintiff side and you can see
- 40:36how strong your arguments may be if you're on
- 40:37the defensive side. So again, it's just something
- 40:41to be considered. I usually would like to have
- 40:44a pending motion for summary judgment before
- 40:48I went to mediation so that it's pending. I think
- 40:51that possibly can give some leverage. But you
- 40:57never know. Even if the motion gets denied, doesn't
- 40:59mean that the other side's going to prevail or
- 41:02the plaintiff's going to prevail in trial. But
- 41:05it's just something to consider is the timing
- 41:09of your mediation, especially in conjunction
- 41:11with this positive motions, motions to dismiss,
- 41:14MSJs, et cetera. I think that's it on that one.
- 41:35One last thing on the motion or the timing of
- 41:40the mediation. Some people may have different
- 41:45thoughts about that, wait until after the motion
- 41:49is heard and then go to mediation. But I know
- 41:53as an attorney, if I can resolve a case, And
- 41:59before I have to do a motion for summary judgment,
- 42:01if it's going to be resolvable, I'd rather do
- 42:05that than have it until the MSJs are in motion
- 42:09to dismiss much less. But MSJs can take a lot
- 42:11of time, energy, effort. And it's just something
- 42:15to be considered because they are a lot of work.
- 42:18And it costs the clients money to do them. So
- 42:21I mean, arguably, do they put that towards settlement
- 42:24rather than paying you know if it's AG's office
- 42:27Caltrans a little different uh and other entities
- 42:30city county may be a little different but um
- 42:34but it is still time you know and money out of
- 42:36that entity's pocket if you will uh having to
- 42:39to oppose or um file motions dispositive motions
- 42:45okay let's go to the next slide please all right
- 42:51so you've you know your case you've got it all
- 42:55teed up. You have, you know, with the, you know,
- 42:57the key people, the key witnesses are going to
- 42:59say, um, you've picked a mediator that you both
- 43:03like and trust. Um, so here's kind of some of
- 43:08the little nuances at mediation that's a little
- 43:12different for public entities. Um, the first
- 43:14one, I kind of wouldn't touch upon this earlier,
- 43:17but Don't throw new important information into
- 43:19the mix at the mediation. Unlike some private
- 43:22parties defendants, there's less of a chance
- 43:24of using this new information to reevaluate the
- 43:27case while at the mediation. I gave you the example
- 43:29of what happened to me on that. And it's true.
- 43:34You know, we all recognize things happen to the
- 43:36last minute. Sometimes you have no control over
- 43:38personally. If something happened like that to
- 43:41me, I'd probably call my opposing counsel before
- 43:43the mediation and just say, hey, look at this
- 43:44is what's going on. If you know, you may not
- 43:46know this is what's going on. Do we try to continue
- 43:51this mediation or how do you want to handle this?
- 43:54But again, I really do think communication with
- 43:56opposing counsel is. really key in addition to
- 44:00the civility aspect of it. I think it's also
- 44:03very productive for both sides. All right. Public
- 44:08entities cannot have confidential settlements,
- 44:10and there's not really any specific statute that
- 44:14I'm aware of. But it comes from the whole policy
- 44:19of transparency in government and the Public
- 44:23Records Act. which I assume most of you know
- 44:27what that is, essentially means a member of the
- 44:29public can request most documents, except some
- 44:35employment and confidential records and things
- 44:38of that nature. If you look at the CPRA Act,
- 44:41it'll tell you all the exceptions. But someone
- 44:45can request a settlement memo of a particular...
- 44:49individual if they know how to find it. And so
- 44:52the whole transparency in government predicated
- 44:56on the Public Records Act that really frowns
- 44:59upon any type of confidential settlements. And
- 45:02then I know on the employment realm, things have
- 45:05really even expanded to privities in that regard.
- 45:09So it's more and more disclosure rather than
- 45:12the other way around. Public entities cannot
- 45:19make a gift to public funds. And this is the
- 45:21California constitution. This is kind of a broad
- 45:25area. It's like, what does it really mean? Essentially,
- 45:30if you want to read it, it's there. But essentially,
- 45:32it just means that kind of what I was going to
- 45:35before, these are public funds. These are taxpayer
- 45:38monies. And public entities cannot just make
- 45:41a gift, you know, something that's not valued
- 45:44just to make something go away. I remember one
- 45:47case that I had, a lot of sad cases, sad case
- 45:52where a teenage boy had hit an electrical cabinet
- 45:56on the side of a freeway and his liability would
- 46:03have, I had motion for sentry judgment pending,
- 46:06but again, very sad case. And so we did have
- 46:09some money evaluated. to for the for the mother
- 46:13that was the only plaint only plaintiff um and
- 46:17so about halfway into the mediation we settled
- 46:21on on the amount which was not which was great
- 46:23however then the mediator came back and said
- 46:27wait a minute there's kind of a fly in the ointment
- 46:30um in addition to this you know x amount that
- 46:32she's willing after we went back and forth some
- 46:35time willing to settle for she wants to have
- 46:37a little memorial i think it was bench, a memorial
- 46:41with their son's name on the side of the roadway.
- 46:46And I assume that that's not going to be an issue.
- 46:51Well, it is an issue, not just for the public
- 46:54funds aspect of it, but you can't have memorials
- 46:58on the side of public roadways. And it could
- 47:02be a safety issue. There's lots of other non
- 47:04-monetary reasons why you can't have that. But
- 47:06also, on a case it was evaluated to being favorable
- 47:10liability -wise, and yet a decision was made
- 47:13to pay some out for it, $5 ,000 bench may not
- 47:19seem like a lot of money. But it wasn't contemplated
- 47:24within that settlement. And so that was one example.
- 47:29And actually, the settlement fell apart because
- 47:32that's really what she wanted. She didn't want
- 47:33the money. She didn't care. It was her son. Eventually,
- 47:37it did resolve. But if the plaintiff attorney,
- 47:41her attorney would have known that that's not
- 47:43a possibility, presumably he would have squelched
- 47:46that right away, and that wouldn't have been
- 47:49on the table or been an issue. So just educate
- 47:52yourself on what public entities can and cannot
- 47:55do. Also, while at mediation, and this goes,
- 48:00well, while at mediation, there may be a mix
- 48:02of public and private funds, and ask who is in
- 48:06attendance. I always thought either public or
- 48:09private sector, I always thought it was very
- 48:11interesting to know who was in the other room.
- 48:14The mediator may not get permission from the
- 48:18other side to tell you who's in there, but it's
- 48:23interesting to see who's in there. Sometimes,
- 48:26like I remember a case, this is private practice,
- 48:28there was an excess carrier who said they absolutely
- 48:31were not going to even attend the mediation.
- 48:33Nothing was going to get into their level, you
- 48:35know, blah, blah, blah. And then lo and behold,
- 48:39they were there at the mediation and they ended
- 48:42up actually putting up some money for the settlement.
- 48:46Anyway, it's just something that I think is interesting
- 48:49and helpful. And maybe you want to do it, maybe
- 48:52you don't want to do it, but I would suggest
- 48:54that. Oftentimes there has to be language that
- 48:57gives a broad time frame for payment of settlement.
- 49:01I kind of touched upon this before as well because
- 49:04of the time frame, it can take state controller's
- 49:06office or whatever the funding source is rather
- 49:09than those two weeks to four weeks that a lot
- 49:12of them have. You can't say, yes, we agree to
- 49:16X amount of money to be paid within on or before
- 49:21two weeks, three weeks, whatever it is. a lot
- 49:25of public entity attorneys are very kind of cagey,
- 49:28cagey is not the right word, they're kind of
- 49:31concerned, that's the word, about putting that
- 49:34time frame down because they have no control
- 49:37over when it's going to be issued, when the when
- 49:40the warrant is going to be issued, when the payment
- 49:41is going to be issued, and sometimes if they
- 49:44get backed up it can take a long time. Usually
- 49:47it's eight to ten weeks but it can be, you know,
- 49:50six months or whatever. Just something again
- 49:53to let your client know and be aware of. Also,
- 50:01we know some cases need to be tried. They just
- 50:04do for whatever reason. The liability assessment
- 50:09is too great or the damages assessment or evaluation
- 50:14on either side is too vast and some cases need
- 50:19to be tried. But we all would agree, I assume,
- 50:23that resolution is best for all involved. It
- 50:26gives closure to everybody. It's a bird in the
- 50:31hand. You know what it's going to be. Even with
- 50:35a public entity, if it's going to take some time
- 50:39longer than you may even think, it is a for sure
- 50:41thing. Not that the state of California doesn't
- 50:44implode, but we won't go into that. But it is
- 50:46a for sure thing. You don't have to do post trial
- 50:52motions. There's, you know, all that guarantee.
- 50:55So it is, it is best resolution is best for all
- 50:58involved with the caveat that understands some
- 51:00cases need to be tried. Another thing that Plaintiff's
- 51:04Bar should be aware of, and maybe, maybe all
- 51:06are already, but it's not anything I ever even
- 51:08use that often when I work for the state is after,
- 51:12assume the case doesn't resolve and it goes to
- 51:14verdict. You should look under government code
- 51:17984 and government code 985. Those are tools
- 51:21that the government can use to basically extract
- 51:26out a payment of a verdict for 10 years. That's
- 51:29government code 984. The court allows it. It
- 51:31has to have court approval, obviously. I know
- 51:34my team up in San Diego, down in San Diego, where
- 51:36am I? No, in San Diego, dealt with this a couple
- 51:40years ago. It's, again, I think I've only used
- 51:42it twice ever in 20 years. That's a possibility.
- 51:46It could be extracted over a 10 -year time period.
- 51:50And then government 985 is for collateral source.
- 51:53So the government does have some tools that it
- 51:56can use that private entities can't. And that's
- 51:59done on the back end of a verdict. So let's say
- 52:04the Howell number is $20 ,000 paid by the HMO
- 52:08of the plaintiff. On the back end, the government
- 52:10can then make a motion. for that amount not to
- 52:15be included in the verdict. So I won't go into
- 52:19all the details because I need to sum it up here
- 52:21pretty soon, but I would look under government
- 52:23code 984 and 985 just for your own edification.
- 52:29Okay, oh, you know, one thing I was gonna say,
- 52:31and I did employment for 17 years at CalTrans.
- 52:35On the public, on the cannot make a gift of public
- 52:38funds, sometimes this comes into play in the
- 52:40employment context where the plaintiff or plaintiff's
- 52:46counsel wants someone reinstated or promoted
- 52:49or they want some monetary increase for pension.
- 52:55They can't be done for the most part. I mean,
- 52:57can't say it can never be done, but for the most
- 52:59part, it can't because it would fly in the face
- 53:02of CalPERS regulations, which is a whole other
- 53:07state entity with all their own rules and regulations.
- 53:11And it could be conceived as making a gift of
- 53:14public funds, something that someone's not entitled
- 53:17to just to resolve the case. So I did forget
- 53:20to say that because sometimes in the employment
- 53:22context, it does come up. All right. Next slide,
- 53:28please. All right. So post -mediation. Congratulations.
- 53:31You've resolved your case. Now what? Time for
- 53:35payment. I told you. I told you. Explain that
- 53:37one. Just please let your clients know that it
- 53:41is not a short. timeframe, typically, at least,
- 53:46you know, not for the state. I know some of the
- 53:48smaller ones are shorter. I had a case once where
- 53:52it was like end of November and this, I know
- 53:56the case settled because the woman wanted money
- 54:01for her granddaughter for Christmas and she thought
- 54:04it was going to be, you know, done within. that
- 54:07timeframe because presumably her attorney said,
- 54:10oh yeah, it usually takes two weeks, 30 days
- 54:12on these types of things. And then once we talked
- 54:17about that, as we were finalizing the settlement
- 54:21of mediation, he was totally shocked by it and
- 54:23didn't know about it and had no clue and nothing
- 54:27of disparagement on him. He just didn't know.
- 54:29He hadn't done a lot of public entity cases.
- 54:31So time for payment, get your client's expectations
- 54:34in check because it could take some time. Post
- 54:37-mediation paperwork, this also can slow down
- 54:41the process. Once a case is mediated, sometimes
- 54:44depending on the entity, additional paperwork
- 54:48and analysis has to go for approval, somewhat
- 54:51release. or agreement, sometimes they're releases,
- 54:54sometimes they're agreements. And then the payment
- 54:57form, whatever it is, it has to be exactly correct.
- 55:00You have to dot your I's, cross your T's. The
- 55:03names have to be exactly the same. I had a plaintiff
- 55:06attorney a few years back invert the name of
- 55:09his client, which, you know, not a big, not a
- 55:12big deal, perhaps, and certainly understandable.
- 55:15But, you know, five weeks later, I get a rejection
- 55:18back saying, well, this is not consistent with
- 55:20what the settlement, you know, the settlement
- 55:23release says. So that can start you over the
- 55:26clock running as far as processing the payment.
- 55:29So just make sure everything is perfect. It has
- 55:31to be really, really by the book. Otherwise,
- 55:35it can be a further aspect of delay. Budget issues.
- 55:39Oh, wow. Okay, I'm going fast. Budget issues
- 55:41that may require multiple payments over more
- 55:43than one fiscal year. So yes, there's a pot of
- 55:46money. But every agency, department, even district
- 55:52and functional unit may have their own operating
- 55:57budgets. So sometimes you're going to come into
- 56:01a situation where, and this has happened in the
- 56:05employment context more because At least at Caltrans,
- 56:10it comes out of the operating budget for that
- 56:12particular district. Sometimes if the settles
- 56:16in May, they don't have enough money to pay for
- 56:18the full settlement, whatever it might be. There's
- 56:23a request that once the new fiscal year begins,
- 56:25which is July 1st of every year, then it'll get
- 56:28paid out of that. I had at the AG's office also
- 56:32in a bigger $5 or $6 million case where We were
- 56:37out of funds for payment of a particular settlement,
- 56:40and we had to go to the next year. Actually,
- 56:43we didn't, because they ended up having enough.
- 56:45So he actually got it or she got it within that
- 56:48same fiscal year. But again, communicate with
- 56:50plaintiff. any of you public entity attorneys,
- 56:55let them know that this may happen. Communication,
- 56:58communication, communication. It diffuses any
- 57:02frustration and lets everyone be on the same
- 57:04page. That is something. I don't know if cities
- 57:06and counties do that. I know the state has done
- 57:08that because I've handled it many times myself
- 57:10as far as payments over more than one fiscal
- 57:13year. Next slide. Here's just some basic random
- 57:21tips. This may be, this actually happens public
- 57:25practice, excuse me, private practice too, but
- 57:28public entity counsel may not even know the authorized
- 57:30settlement amount. Some clients do not share
- 57:32that information. You may have done the settlement
- 57:34memo and you know what your chain of command
- 57:36recommends, then it goes over to the client and
- 57:39they don't let you know what they decided they're
- 57:41gonna give. So just a little caveat, some clients
- 57:45don't share that information even with their
- 57:46attorneys. Number two, public entity counsel
- 57:49is accurate when they convey the timeframe challenges
- 57:52and agreeing on a mediation date. I had one attorney
- 57:55scream at me saying I was lying that I couldn't
- 57:58do a mediation for 90 days because I had to get
- 58:01my ducks in a row and get the authority. It takes
- 58:06a long time. It does take a long time. Hopefully,
- 58:08I've conveyed that how long it takes. It just
- 58:11takes longer than you think it should or would
- 58:13and maybe that's the case. They're not yanking
- 58:17your chain or dragging their heels. It is a reality.
- 58:23Public entity is not the enemy, although there
- 58:25may be some exceptions. That was a just kidding.
- 58:30Public entity counsel wants to resolve the case
- 58:32as well. There's nothing better than having a
- 58:35case 30 days before trial and having all the
- 58:39binders in your office, or in my case, loose
- 58:42on my desk. And then it resolves the mediation.
- 58:45It's just like this breath of fresh air. And
- 58:51so they're not the enemy. Give them what they
- 58:53need so they can request the amount of authority
- 58:55that will hopefully resolve the case. Doesn't
- 58:58always happen, as we know. But most of the time
- 59:02it does, as we know. I think what, 96 % to 97
- 59:05% of all cases, I don't remember what the latest
- 59:07stats are, of all filed cases do resolve short
- 59:09of trial. All right. Getting your case worked
- 59:12up early on before the entity files its dispositive
- 59:15motion may be helpful to both sides. I kind of
- 59:17alluded to that before. I think it's just smart
- 59:21to do because then you know on both sides what
- 59:25you can oppose that motion with and the case.
- 59:29So getting your case that worked early on is
- 59:31beneficial in all areas. And then probably the
- 59:34most important is be patient. It takes a long
- 59:37time and hopefully they've conveyed. the reasons
- 59:41why in this presentation um let's see okay last
- 59:49one all right Second to last. Okay, how to have
- 59:54a successful mediation. More of the same preparation,
- 59:56develop your case early, taking depots and whatever
- 59:59you need to know your case and work it up. Perseverance,
- 1:00:02understand the long but necessary authority process
- 1:00:05before mediation can occur so that it gets teed
- 1:00:08up early on and you and your opposing counselor
- 1:00:10are both on the same page. And then patience,
- 1:00:14educate your client and yourself so you don't
- 1:00:16have the mishaps of getting people's expectations
- 1:00:19inflated or just unrealistic because you're dealing
- 1:00:22with a public entity. And it also keeps frustration
- 1:00:26hopefully to a minimum for all counsel and for
- 1:00:30clients. All right, last. All right, so this
- 1:00:39is kind of a little Zen thing. Take a deep breath
- 1:00:42because even with all your preparation, everything
- 1:00:45you've done, a great mediation brief, a great
- 1:00:48presentation, some cases don't resolve. Vast
- 1:00:53majority we do, we just discuss, but some cases
- 1:00:55just don't resolve. So just realize that all
- 1:00:59that work that you've done, it's not for naught,
- 1:01:01it will... It will do you well if the case has
- 1:01:04to get tried or if there's a second mediation
- 1:01:06or whatever it may be. But you only have control
- 1:01:10over what you have control over. And that implies
- 1:01:12the public entity attorneys too. I mean, we get
- 1:01:14frustrated with our clients just as much if we've
- 1:01:18recommended something and they go a different
- 1:01:20route or whatever it may be. So anyway, just
- 1:01:22take a deep breath and recognize that you've
- 1:01:24done the best you can to repair your case for
- 1:01:26the best resolution. And you can only control
- 1:01:29what you can control. All right. Thank you very
- 1:01:31much. If anyone has any questions, I know I went
- 1:01:34over a minute. If anyone has any questions, I
- 1:01:36don't see any in the chat. Unless I'm not...
- 1:01:40We actually have two questions. Oh, I'm sorry.
- 1:01:42I didn't see that. Yes. Okay. Oh, PMQs. I'm sorry.
- 1:01:45Person most qualified. What are PMQs is the question.
- 1:01:49So a lot of people call them PMKs, which is a
- 1:01:52pet peeve of mine because that's a federal term.
- 1:01:54Although I work federal courts as well. But in
- 1:01:57California, they're called... person's most qualified
- 1:02:00so that's a category let's say you want to let's
- 1:02:04say you want to take a pmq of of we'll use the
- 1:02:09state park Again, someone who authorized the
- 1:02:13design plans for a sidewalk or a stairwell. So
- 1:02:18you don't know who that person is. So you would
- 1:02:20do a deposition notice for the person most qualified
- 1:02:23and then whatever that category may be. It's
- 1:02:26the public entity that gets to choose who the
- 1:02:28PMQ is, not you. You can individually notice
- 1:02:31someone in their individual capacity, but it's
- 1:02:34the public entity that decides who the PMQ is.
- 1:02:38All right, a question for Lady. Later, are 998s
- 1:02:41enforceable against public entities? Yes, but
- 1:02:45I've seen the argument that prejudgment, okay,
- 1:02:47let me read this, I'm sorry. A question for later,
- 1:02:49are 998s enforceable against public entities?
- 1:02:51I have seen argument that prejudgment interest
- 1:02:54is punitive and therefore not recoverable against
- 1:02:56a public entity. You are correct. Prejudgment
- 1:02:58interest you cannot have against a public entity.
- 1:03:00You also cannot have punitive damages against
- 1:03:03a public entity. All right. There's government
- 1:03:10code sections that are right on point to that.
- 1:03:13Anyway, if anyone has any specifics they want
- 1:03:15to run by me, feel free to email me at my email
- 1:03:18address, which is on the front page, I believe,
- 1:03:21of the presentation. I'm also a texter. If you
- 1:03:24want to text me on my cell, it's 858 -883 -1100.
- 1:03:33858. And I apologize I went over. I'd be happy
- 1:03:39to answer any questions for anyone else. Thank
- 1:03:41you. Thank you, Rhonda. This concludes today's
- 1:03:44presentation. Thank you so much and thank you
- 1:03:47to our audience as well. Have a great afternoon,
- 1:03:49everybody.