Latest / Yaron Brook Show / Ancient Philosophy -- Plato and Aristotle & More with Robert Mayhew _ Yaron Brook Interviews
Transcript
- 0:52Speaker 1: Yeah, oh what under little Briss's ouse, leader, rational self
- 1:03Speaker 1: interest and individual ones.
- 1:09Speaker 2: This is the Ran Brook Show, all right, everybody, welcome
- 1:17Speaker 2: to here on Brook Show on this Monday, Sober twenty second.
- 1:21Speaker 2: Pretty first, skipping ahead already second show today, and I'm
- 1:26Speaker 2: really delighted to have with me today. Robert Mayhew rob It,
- 1:33Speaker 2: for those of you who don't know who he is,
- 1:35Speaker 2: is a professor philosophy at Seaton Hall University. He's been
- 1:39Speaker 2: teaching there for over twenty years. Over thirty years. I've
- 1:44Speaker 2: got an old bio. Doctor Maye's primary research interest is
- 1:49Speaker 2: ancient philosophy, but he also has a serious scholarly interest
- 1:55Speaker 2: in Ironrand and has done a lot of work related
- 1:58Speaker 2: to iron Rand, from authoring books and editing, collection of
- 2:02Speaker 2: essays and writing and speaking and doing talks regular talks
- 2:08Speaker 2: at OCONN about irand Doctor Mehue also serves on the
- 2:15Speaker 2: board of the Ironman Institute and the Anti Foundation for
- 2:18Speaker 2: Objective Scholarship. Welcome, thanks for joining me.
- 2:23Speaker 3: Great to be here. This is my first time and
- 2:25Speaker 3: you had wondered about that on your earlier show. And
- 2:28Speaker 3: yeah it's we been on panels a lot and all
- 2:32Speaker 3: kinds of other stuff.
- 2:33Speaker 2: Yes, so let's let's start with your interest in ancient philosophy.
- 2:38Speaker 2: Maybe tell us a little bit how you got into
- 2:41Speaker 2: ancient philosophy. What was the kind of the path that
- 2:43Speaker 2: led you in that direction.
- 2:45Speaker 3: Sure, it actually connects, I think to interest, you know,
- 2:49Speaker 3: things that would interest your audience.
- 2:51Speaker 2: I was.
- 2:53Speaker 3: I thought philosophy was political philosophy when I was getting
- 2:58Speaker 3: interested in ideas and reading iin Rand and or at
- 3:03Speaker 3: least starting to. And so I was thinking, when it
- 3:07Speaker 3: came time for my PhD, I would work on Hobbes
- 3:11Speaker 3: and Locke and the Founding Fathers and try to show
- 3:14Speaker 3: that Locke is very different from Hobbes and things like that.
- 3:17Speaker 3: And then I was reading reading Atlas Shrugg for the
- 3:20Speaker 3: second time, and I mean I had noticed the references
- 3:24Speaker 3: to Aristotle before, but hadn't really done anything with the information. Okay, Aristotle,
- 3:30Speaker 3: and then but this time it really caught Why is
- 3:32Speaker 3: Aristotle the greatest of your philosophers? And why does she
- 3:36Speaker 3: have a character reading this obscure you that this stuff
- 3:40Speaker 3: from Aristotle's metaphysics in the Valley? And I thought, I
- 3:46Speaker 3: want to look into this. Why Aristotle? You know, I'm thinking,
- 3:48Speaker 3: you know what he's I don't think he's a champion
- 3:51Speaker 3: of capitalism. And so I went to the very beginning
- 3:54Speaker 3: of the complete works of Aristotle and it was the
- 3:59Speaker 3: category worries, and it's you know it it. I couldn't
- 4:03Speaker 3: see the value in it at all, but I but
- 4:07Speaker 3: I became fascinated with that. And while doing that, I
- 4:10Speaker 3: got really into not just Aristotle, but ancient Greek culture,
- 4:14Speaker 3: and I kind of made it a mission to find
- 4:16Speaker 3: out what was valuable in Aristotle. I started taking courses
- 4:21Speaker 3: in ancient Greek because I knew if I wanted to
- 4:23Speaker 3: make this my specialty, I needed, you know, to read
- 4:29Speaker 3: the text in the original. And so that's how I
- 4:31Speaker 3: got into it. And by the time I was, you know,
- 4:37Speaker 3: really serious about doing graduate work, I I that was
- 4:42Speaker 3: the field I wanted. And you know, I wrote my
- 4:44Speaker 3: dissertation on Aristotle's politics, his his uh criticisms of of
- 4:49Speaker 3: Plato's Republic, and that was that was that.
- 4:52Speaker 2: So I was hooked. So so what what made you
- 4:57Speaker 2: make that switch? That is what what took you from
- 5:01Speaker 2: you know, the irrelevance of categories and metaphysics to no,
- 5:06Speaker 2: I get it. This is amazing.
- 5:09Speaker 3: I wish I remembered it, but it wasn't. It was
- 5:13Speaker 3: just something about the breadth and the depth of his
- 5:16Speaker 3: thought and trying to connect it to what Ainran said
- 5:20Speaker 3: was valuable about him, because she it's very terse remarks,
- 5:24Speaker 3: you know, the objective reality and sorry, the efficacy of
- 5:30Speaker 3: the mind, and you don't really see that in those terms.
- 5:33Speaker 3: I mean, she saw it in Arisotoa. She knew the
- 5:36Speaker 3: history of his influence on Western culture. But I just
- 5:42Speaker 3: became very interested in him generally, and then his critique
- 5:48Speaker 3: of Plato, his criticisms of the forms of the communism
- 5:54Speaker 3: of the Republic and all of that. And then I
- 5:56Speaker 3: kind of I had this same interest in political philosophy
- 6:00Speaker 3: that that really grew out of kind of my interest
- 6:03Speaker 3: in reading dystopia novels and you know, anti communy, you know, Soviets,
- 6:10Speaker 3: you know, criticism of the Soviet Union, and that com
- 6:12Speaker 3: me into politics and and so it they kind of merged,
- 6:15Speaker 3: and I started doing work on Ariosotle's politics, and but
- 6:20Speaker 3: I wish there wasn't this aha moment. It was kind
- 6:22Speaker 3: of just trying to figure out why would I Ran,
- 6:25Speaker 3: you know, you know, recognize him. Then when I started
- 6:29Speaker 3: to read the non fiction and she refers to him
- 6:32Speaker 3: in for who, you know, for the new intellectual and
- 6:35Speaker 3: you know he is the founder of you know, everything.
- 6:37Speaker 3: And then she has that one line about everything we
- 6:40Speaker 3: you know, our language, you know, progress, industry, it all,
- 6:45Speaker 3: you know, the founding of America. She she laid on
- 6:48Speaker 3: his shoulder, put on his shoulders, and that I found,
- 6:53Speaker 3: it's kind of bizarre. It can't be right. And yet
- 6:55Speaker 3: you know, so I really dug into that, and uh, yeah,
- 7:00Speaker 3: that that kept me going for a long time, not
- 7:02Speaker 3: just through through the pH d. But if you remember
- 7:05Speaker 3: long ago when you when you organized conferences, you had one,
- 7:09Speaker 3: that wonderful one in Italy, and and uh that's where
- 7:13Speaker 3: I gave the lectures on I gave a pair of
- 7:16Speaker 3: lectures Aristotle and the and the Renaissance, because I you
- 7:20Speaker 3: know what she said that, you know, he made the
- 7:22Speaker 3: Renaissance possible, you know, was against everything that you read,
- 7:27Speaker 3: you know, you hear in in courses in medieval philosophy
- 7:31Speaker 3: and in into the modern era. And I wanted to
- 7:35Speaker 3: look into that. Yeah, I think they I think they
- 7:39Speaker 3: exist somewhere. Someone at the time said you should write
- 7:43Speaker 3: this into a popular you know, you should write a
- 7:44Speaker 3: bokular book. I said, no, no, you know, I'm a scholar,
- 7:47Speaker 3: and no one would would buy it anyway. And then
- 7:50Speaker 3: I think two years later, Aristotle's Children came out and
- 7:53Speaker 3: made millions. You know, it's all about timing.
- 7:56Speaker 2: So so so was gonna ask, to what extent is
- 8:03Speaker 2: it recognized in academia or among scholars that Aristota plays
- 8:10Speaker 2: this role in the West. I mean, we've got Aristotle's children,
- 8:12Speaker 2: We've got Caven the light right it was? I mean,
- 8:16Speaker 2: but to what extent is that view unique time vand
- 8:20Speaker 2: or is it becoming more acceptable within kind of uh philosophy,
- 8:25Speaker 2: the history of philosophy.
- 8:26Speaker 3: I think it's becoming more acceptable, But I think the
- 8:29Speaker 3: way people interpret it is that the story is messier
- 8:32Speaker 3: than you know, anyone you know statement can make. So
- 8:37Speaker 3: when I was in graduate school, the line, the standard
- 8:40Speaker 3: line was Aristotle was the philosopher of the Middle Ages
- 8:44Speaker 3: and Plato was the philosopher of the Renaissance. And what
- 8:48Speaker 3: they had in mind was that when Aristotle's works were
- 8:51Speaker 3: rediscovered and reintroduced into the Latin West, I mean, they
- 8:55Speaker 3: were immediately regarded as important, although they were also censored
- 9:01Speaker 3: and put on lists. And you know, the Church was
- 9:04Speaker 3: keeping an eye on that on it because they knew
- 9:08Speaker 3: this was it wasn't kosher to mix religions. So but
- 9:16Speaker 3: you know, and by the time you get to Aquinas
- 9:17Speaker 3: for example, I'm actually by the I think it was
- 9:21Speaker 3: twelve fifty four something like that, to teach philosophy in
- 9:25Speaker 3: the universities in the Latin West was to teach Aristotle.
- 9:30Speaker 3: And I mean he was so that's why they saw
- 9:33Speaker 3: him as this medieval figure. And then in the Renaissance
- 9:36Speaker 3: you get people like Galileo and others sort of pushing
- 9:40Speaker 3: back or objecting to, rejecting this sort of ossified Aristotle
- 9:45Speaker 3: that you know, Aristotle's view of the universe, his view
- 9:48Speaker 3: of the solar system, that was you know, part of
- 9:51Speaker 3: his philosophy. And at the same time, Plato's works, which
- 9:56Speaker 3: weren't much known in the Middle Ages, were rediscovered in
- 9:59Speaker 3: the Renaissance and people loved them. You know. You you
- 10:02Speaker 3: get these, you know, all a lot of these figures,
- 10:06Speaker 3: even some of the really good ones who saw themselves
- 10:08Speaker 3: as Platonists. So it gets very confusing. But what what
- 10:14Speaker 3: people are starting to just to spend more time I
- 10:18Speaker 3: think working on, is is that that story doesn't really
- 10:22Speaker 3: fit that that Aristotle. Yeah, there were these people who
- 10:26Speaker 3: were pushing back against Arisotole. But even Galileo, for example, says,
- 10:30Speaker 3: you know, while he's objecting to these these Catholic Aristotelians
- 10:37Speaker 3: who won't look through microscope through through telescopes, he's also saying,
- 10:42Speaker 3: I'm the real parapatetic. If you really understand Aristotle, I'm
- 10:46Speaker 3: you know, because he wants to look at the world
- 10:49Speaker 3: and use your reason to describe it. Yeah, and I
- 10:52Speaker 3: think you see that. I mean, Aristotle's works were really
- 10:56Speaker 3: influential at the University of Padua and where you had
- 10:59Speaker 3: Galilee and William Harvey and people like that. Jim Lennox
- 11:03Speaker 3: is doing work, I think on on the the Aristotelian influence, uh,
- 11:06Speaker 3: the unacknowledged influence of Aristotle on on science and things
- 11:12Speaker 3: of that sort. So this story that you have Aristotle
- 11:16Speaker 3: arrives in the Latin West, he's influential on a Quinas,
- 11:21Speaker 3: he becomes this dogma in effect, which in a way
- 11:23Speaker 3: is true. That's what what happens. And then uh, and
- 11:27Speaker 3: then you have these really good people who are you know,
- 11:31Speaker 3: empirically minded in a good sense if there is one,
- 11:34Speaker 3: and well, you know what I mean. And then you know,
- 11:36Speaker 3: based on century observation and reasoning based on that and
- 11:40Speaker 3: a good scientific method, and there's there's definitely an Aristotelian
- 11:45Speaker 3: influence there, but it just doesn't it's not as clean,
- 11:49Speaker 3: you know, clear cut as you would you would see.
- 11:52Speaker 2: So that kind of understanding of the both the complexity
- 11:56Speaker 2: of the story but the underlying the underlying value of
- 12:00Speaker 2: Aristotle that is becoming more prevalent among the Stabians and
- 12:05Speaker 2: Stabians philosophy it's not my.
- 12:07Speaker 3: Fields, so right, haven't kept up, but you do get
- 12:09Speaker 3: these popular books about you know, about Aristotle and his
- 12:13Speaker 3: influence of the books you mentioned, and I wouldn't be
- 12:18Speaker 3: surprised if there's more work of that kind. I mentioned
- 12:21Speaker 3: Jim Lennox, but you know he has a nine Ran
- 12:23Speaker 3: connection and not that that I mean, he could have
- 12:26Speaker 3: done it independently of that, I think, but but there
- 12:30Speaker 3: must be work on that. I mean, he's done work
- 12:32Speaker 3: on even you know, Aristotle's influence on Darwin, and you know,
- 12:35Speaker 3: there's there's these interesting connections that haven't been thoroughly explored.
- 12:42Speaker 2: I think, and of course philosophy. I mean, like Aristotle's
- 12:48Speaker 2: impact on you know, he impacts the culture and then
- 12:52Speaker 2: the culture can impact an individual. It doesn't always go
- 12:54Speaker 2: into direct line weed the person in order to So
- 12:58Speaker 2: before we I want to go back to I want
- 13:01Speaker 2: to go back to Aristotle and ancient philosophy. But tell
- 13:04Speaker 2: us how you discovered iron Rand and kind of the
- 13:06Speaker 2: influence she had on you in terms of kind of
- 13:09Speaker 2: your academic trajectory.
- 13:13Speaker 3: Well, I was reading in junior high, so I think
- 13:15Speaker 3: it was thirteen or fourteen. I started reading these dystopian novels,
- 13:22Speaker 3: and you know, I read Animal Farm, nineteen eighty four,
- 13:28Speaker 3: Brave New World, and then my And this is, you know,
- 13:32Speaker 3: if you were writing a novel, you wouldn't have your
- 13:34Speaker 3: mother influence you. I mean, that just doesn't work. And
- 13:38Speaker 3: so but there it is. I have to tell the truth.
- 13:39Speaker 3: And she said, oh, have you read Anthem? That's one
- 13:42Speaker 3: of those novels. And I said, no, I hadn't. So
- 13:44Speaker 3: I read Anthem and it was clearly the best I
- 13:49Speaker 3: know you could say that. I mean, nineteen eighty four
- 13:51Speaker 3: was a longer novel, you know, it was. It was
- 13:56Speaker 3: well longer, had a lot more events and stuff like that.
- 13:59Speaker 3: But there was some thing about Anthem that I couldn't
- 14:01Speaker 3: put my finger on at the time that was so
- 14:03Speaker 3: much better and more inspiring. And I wasn't a really good,
- 14:09Speaker 3: very confident reader. So I went looking for her other
- 14:12Speaker 3: novels and I saw Fountain had no that's too fat.
- 14:16Speaker 3: I don't read these fat novels, you know. But you know,
- 14:19Speaker 3: a couple of years later I did read it, of course,
- 14:21Speaker 3: and then that led to Atlas Shrugged. And at the
- 14:26Speaker 3: time I had no idea. I mean, neither of my
- 14:28Speaker 3: parents went to college. I didn't have I didn't know
- 14:30Speaker 3: what academia was or I was much more interested in
- 14:35Speaker 3: in high school and backpacking around Europe and in saving
- 14:38Speaker 3: up my money to do that. I didn't have any
- 14:41Speaker 3: I didn't know what I was going to do. So
- 14:44Speaker 3: you know, I went to college not knowing what I
- 14:46Speaker 3: was going to major in or anything like that. But
- 14:49Speaker 3: I was becoming interested in ideas, and especially politically ideas.
- 14:54Speaker 3: And also during this time, I'm starting to read anti
- 14:58Speaker 3: Soviet literature, a lot of it, and that tied in with,
- 15:02Speaker 3: you know, when I finally got around to we the
- 15:04Speaker 3: living that was there, So I'm becoming I thought of
- 15:09Speaker 3: myself as conservative, but that there were things I didn't
- 15:13Speaker 3: like about being a conservative, particularly because of iron Rand.
- 15:16Speaker 3: Like you know, I read Wreckage of the Consensus. Okay,
- 15:20Speaker 3: there goes the Draft. Because I didn't have a good
- 15:22Speaker 3: integrated view, I thought, well, if I have to choose,
- 15:25Speaker 3: I'm clearly a conservative, not a liberal. But then reading
- 15:29Speaker 3: iron Ran, the more you read at this, the little
- 15:31Speaker 3: parts of it get chipped away. No, there goes God,
- 15:34Speaker 3: there goes the Draft. And it became clear that there
- 15:37Speaker 3: was something very different about her. And then I did
- 15:43Speaker 3: one of the most important things to do, I think
- 15:44Speaker 3: when you're this point in your development. I went to
- 15:47Speaker 3: a libertarian meeting and it became clear it was odd
- 15:52Speaker 3: because someone had told me the Libertarians are the followers
- 15:55Speaker 3: of Iron Rand, and what did I know. I was
- 15:56Speaker 3: twenty or nineteen something like that. So I went there
- 15:59Speaker 3: and they were so it was so I felt, you know,
- 16:04Speaker 3: almost an esthetic negative reaction. And then there was a
- 16:09Speaker 3: speaker there. This was the Maryland Libertarian Partner or something
- 16:12Speaker 3: like that, and he was defending Palestine and the and
- 16:15Speaker 3: the American Indians. And I'm thinking, well, as the kids
- 16:20Speaker 3: say today, WTF, you know, what the hell is this?
- 16:25Speaker 3: And then someone made a critical remark about iin Ran
- 16:28Speaker 3: because I mentioned the influence and so in a way
- 16:31Speaker 3: it was that was it for the libertarians, you know,
- 16:35Speaker 3: that was that was enough? And then yeah, so she
- 16:40Speaker 3: was really I mean, you know, clearly was an important
- 16:45Speaker 3: influence in kind of getting me in the right direction,
- 16:47Speaker 3: even a very you know, this is before I read
- 16:50Speaker 3: anything about epistemology, and I believe I read Virtue of
- 16:53Speaker 3: Selfishness by around twenty or twenty one, and reading the novel,
- 16:57Speaker 3: but just reading it and so much of it, you know,
- 17:00Speaker 3: going past. But I was kind of figuring out what
- 17:03Speaker 3: I was. And you know, like I said, if they're
- 17:07Speaker 3: not really integrated, if you hold a set of beliefs,
- 17:09Speaker 3: because you know this is this must be I must
- 17:13Speaker 3: be a conservative. So I guess they're in favor of
- 17:15Speaker 3: the draft, I suppose, But those sort of things that
- 17:18Speaker 3: aren't held very well, very totally, they're easily you know, uh,
- 17:22Speaker 3: jettison and I mean reading Wreckage of the Consensus, Yeah,
- 17:26Speaker 3: that is a violation of the individual rights. And then
- 17:29Speaker 3: reading I think some of the brand and stuff. When
- 17:31Speaker 3: I found that the University of Maryland had the the
- 17:34Speaker 3: Objectivist New Newsletter and and those volumes, I kind of
- 17:37Speaker 3: read through those and yeah, so that's that really got
- 17:43Speaker 3: me in the in the right direction, and I even
- 17:45Speaker 3: I found that one of the things I was very
- 17:48Speaker 3: proud of. When when I was starting to write papers,
- 17:52Speaker 3: it looked like I was gonna I was majoring in
- 17:55Speaker 3: political science and minoring in philosophy. I started to look
- 18:00Speaker 3: at what did I like about Iinrand's writing. I mean,
- 18:05Speaker 3: this sounds presumptuous or whatever, but there was something very
- 18:07Speaker 3: clear and logical about it, and I started trying to
- 18:11Speaker 3: emulate that in the sense of at least having a
- 18:14Speaker 3: good structure and all that. And I was getting good grades,
- 18:17Speaker 3: and I got good feedback from my professors who liked
- 18:20Speaker 3: my writing, and so that made me think, well, maybe
- 18:24Speaker 3: I could, Maybe I could do what these guys are doing,
- 18:27Speaker 3: because I really, like I said, I didn't have a
- 18:29Speaker 3: clue of what academia was.
- 18:31Speaker 1: And so I.
- 18:35Speaker 3: Went to Georgetown originally to study political science or government
- 18:40Speaker 3: I think they called it, with which the idea that
- 18:42Speaker 3: I do political theory. And then after two years of that,
- 18:46Speaker 3: they allowed me to do something which I think would
- 18:48Speaker 3: be unheard of now. I jumped ship from the government
- 18:52Speaker 3: department to philosophy and started working on ancient philosophy. And
- 18:56Speaker 3: the first semester there it was just serendipity. Alan Gohel
- 19:00Speaker 3: was visiting professor, and that was wonderful. It was really
- 19:05Speaker 3: that was my first semester, you know, officially as a
- 19:07Speaker 3: philosophy student, and I met Allan and then you know it,
- 19:12Speaker 3: I was kind of set. So you know, by the
- 19:15Speaker 3: time I got my my PhD, it was really just
- 19:20Speaker 3: a question can I get a job or not? And
- 19:23Speaker 3: that was that. But well, I should mention going back.
- 19:28Speaker 3: I mean, the first conference was in eighty three and
- 19:30Speaker 3: I went to that and and that really you know,
- 19:34Speaker 3: the the not OCON, but it was the Thomas Jefferson Institute,
- 19:37Speaker 3: I think it was called.
- 19:38Speaker 2: And yes, there was the predecessor of OCON, so it
- 19:42Speaker 2: was right right right, So I went on similar format,
- 19:45Speaker 2: not exactly but some similar format.
- 19:47Speaker 3: But they were every other year for sixteen weeks.
- 19:51Speaker 2: What's that for two weeks?
- 19:53Speaker 3: Yeah, three weekends, I remember, and it was it was
- 19:56Speaker 3: amazing because you've got to meet people. And I met
- 19:58Speaker 3: the person I ended up marrying, And I mean we
- 20:01Speaker 3: met in eighty three, we hit it off in eighty five,
- 20:03Speaker 3: and then why do you need another conference? So we
- 20:06Speaker 3: didn't go in eighty sex. We got married in eighty
- 20:08Speaker 3: seven and eventually by the by the time I returned,
- 20:11Speaker 3: with one exception, I think I was teaching at the
- 20:14Speaker 3: conferences and then you know I did that with the
- 20:17Speaker 3: Lyceum conferences and all those and yep, well i've been
- 20:21Speaker 3: you know, I've been involved ever since.
- 20:23Speaker 2: But yeah, yeah, but.
- 20:26Speaker 3: Yeah, there was just something about the ancient Greek culture
- 20:29Speaker 3: that I really fell in love with, including you know,
- 20:34Speaker 3: the tragedies, Sophocles and Homer. I've been returning to work
- 20:38Speaker 3: on Homer. Yeah, that's all. It's all been.
- 20:42Speaker 2: So tell us a little bit about your work on
- 20:44Speaker 2: kind of the the I'm curious about Homer. About Homer,
- 20:48Speaker 2: what kind of work do you do? Are you doing
- 20:50Speaker 2: on him?
- 20:50Speaker 3: And well, it's connected, it's not directly on Homer, although
- 20:54Speaker 3: it kind of it sort of is. I became very
- 20:58Speaker 3: interested in the lost works of Aristotle. All we have
- 21:04Speaker 3: everything Plato ever wrote. Everything Plato wrote has survived Aristotle.
- 21:08Speaker 3: We have about a fifth of what he wrote and there,
- 21:12Speaker 3: but there's a lot of fragments. And fragments can mean
- 21:15Speaker 3: either works that survive from antiquity that quote Aristotle a
- 21:20Speaker 3: quota work that doesn't survive, or I mean more literal
- 21:23Speaker 3: the Pyrus fragments something like that and one of the
- 21:27Speaker 3: works he wrote. And there's kind of a big move
- 21:30Speaker 3: now there's there's one guy in particular I've been working
- 21:34Speaker 3: closely with at the University of Padua. The idea is
- 21:37Speaker 3: that we need to reassess all the evidence for Aristotle's
- 21:41Speaker 3: lost works, and the first work I have actually I
- 21:45Speaker 3: have my books here, some of them. Anyway, I don't
- 21:48Speaker 3: know if you can see that. Is it aristotle Lost
- 21:51Speaker 3: Homeric Problems? Yeah, that and you know it's Oxford University Press,
- 21:55Speaker 3: and I mentioned the Irate Institute.
- 21:57Speaker 2: That's great with.
- 22:00Speaker 3: Dollars of ancient philosophy, Lucus Caancer. But anyway, uh so
- 22:04Speaker 3: that was the first work of his lost work that
- 22:07Speaker 3: I've I published on and published a lot on. Namely,
- 22:11Speaker 3: he wrote a work called the Homeric Problems, which was
- 22:15Speaker 3: said to be in six books. That would have been
- 22:17Speaker 3: six papyrus roles scrolls, so you know it would be
- 22:21Speaker 3: a substantial work, and it was probably I mean, there
- 22:25Speaker 3: was emerging a kind of culture where the they weren't
- 22:30Speaker 3: sacred texts, but Homer's epics were very important to the
- 22:34Speaker 3: I mean, if you were an aristocratic young male, you know,
- 22:37Speaker 3: being educated, you would be reading and discussing Homer, I mean,
- 22:43Speaker 3: and and and there'd be questions that would arise, and
- 22:46Speaker 3: these became known as Homeric problems. And it was probably
- 22:49Speaker 3: Aristotle who got this started, but there may have been
- 22:53Speaker 3: and partly was it was to discuss you know, problematic
- 22:58Speaker 3: texts or parent contradictions and characterization. But also there was
- 23:04Speaker 3: there were critics of Homer, like Plato in the Republic
- 23:07Speaker 3: says Homer should be banned and uh. And one response
- 23:12Speaker 3: to that was to say, well, we'll, we'll, we'll interpret
- 23:15Speaker 3: him allegorically. And Aristota rejected both of those, you know, Uh,
- 23:20Speaker 3: he shouldn't be banned, you know, and for reasons deeper
- 23:23Speaker 3: than just one's appraisal of Homer his view of art
- 23:28Speaker 3: or literature anyway. But so I became really fascinated in that.
- 23:32Speaker 1: Uh.
- 23:32Speaker 3: And I've published well, this one book, uh and then uh,
- 23:37Speaker 3: several articles where most of the fragments survive in the
- 23:41Speaker 3: margins of the the manuscripts of Homer that have survived
- 23:46Speaker 3: to the Middle Ages, right, And so they're very you know,
- 23:49Speaker 3: they're difficult to read, and but I rely on mostly
- 23:53Speaker 3: I rely on other scholars for that. But some of
- 23:55Speaker 3: the some of the stuff I've looked at directly, and
- 23:58Speaker 3: I'm just find that really fascinating. Uh to dig up
- 24:01Speaker 3: this old Aristotle and and try to, uh, you know,
- 24:06Speaker 3: figure out what what's going on?
- 24:08Speaker 2: And uh so I'm curious now, So so what so
- 24:13Speaker 2: we're all familiar I think with uh, with with Homer.
- 24:18Speaker 2: So what what what value did Aristotle see in Homer
- 24:22Speaker 2: that that obviously Plato did not.
- 24:25Speaker 3: Well, Aristotle thought that Homer was the he was the
- 24:31Speaker 3: paradigm of epic poetry. I mean, because Aristotle wrote a
- 24:35Speaker 3: work in two books called the Poetics. The second book
- 24:38Speaker 3: is lost, which was probably it was almost It was
- 24:41Speaker 3: certainly on comedy, you know, ancient Greek comedy, the plays
- 24:45Speaker 3: like Aristophanes and stuff, and also similar kinds of like
- 24:49Speaker 3: there's a there was a genre called lampoons, and he
- 24:54Speaker 3: probably talked about that as well. But the first, the
- 24:58Speaker 3: first book of the Poetics, which is the one that survives,
- 25:01Speaker 3: is on tragedy and epic and especially tragedy, but which
- 25:05Speaker 3: I think Aristotle probably I think he regarded as a
- 25:09Speaker 3: superior form to Homer. But he did think Homer was
- 25:13Speaker 3: a genius and brilliant and the main difference, though because
- 25:21Speaker 3: he thought he created I mean, he went under the
- 25:24Speaker 3: assumption that there was one man named Homer who wrote
- 25:27Speaker 3: both of these who wrote both of these plays. I mean,
- 25:29Speaker 3: so modern Homeric scholars have very different views of those things.
- 25:34Speaker 3: But he and there is a I mean, there's a
- 25:36Speaker 3: reason why he keeps getting translated. He's continually discussed. I
- 25:41Speaker 3: find there's something really fascinating about these Homeric stories, and
- 25:45Speaker 3: they really they contain something of value for understanding, not
- 25:51Speaker 3: just the kind of the archaic period that it emerged
- 25:54Speaker 3: out of, or the Bronze Age culture that it talks about,
- 25:57Speaker 3: but the classical period, because they regarded it as so
- 26:00Speaker 3: such a value. Plato's problem was that he thought Plato
- 26:06Speaker 3: thought literature and art, generally representational art, was anti philosophical.
- 26:12Speaker 3: He thought that, you know, the forms. I don't know
- 26:15Speaker 3: how much into Plato's metaphysics you want to get, but
- 26:17Speaker 3: he was a metaphysical duellist. Plato thought there that this world,
- 26:21Speaker 3: the world of our bodies and physical reality, was a
- 26:24Speaker 3: quasi quasi real realm, a reflection of a greater you know, realm.
- 26:32Speaker 3: The world of the forms, or the ideas called forms,
- 26:35Speaker 3: I think is better. And this world is a kind
- 26:39Speaker 3: of imperfect reflection of the world of forms art. He
- 26:44Speaker 3: thought representational art was a copy of a copy. It
- 26:49Speaker 3: was a it was an imitation of this reality, this
- 26:53Speaker 3: material world, and so he thought it was the opposite
- 26:56Speaker 3: of philosophy. Philosophy is supposed to, for Plato, involves turning
- 27:01Speaker 3: your back on the evidence of the senses, trying to
- 27:04Speaker 3: think more abstractly, using pure reason reason alone. That's why
- 27:09Speaker 3: he thought mathematics was so important, because you know mathematics,
- 27:12Speaker 3: it seems, you know, it might seem that that's what
- 27:14Speaker 3: you're doing, turning your back on the sense is using
- 27:17Speaker 3: pure reason, and then in kind of you suddenly will
- 27:20Speaker 3: will grasp the forms or I'm being a little you know,
- 27:23Speaker 3: it's it's more complicated than that. That's kind of a story.
- 27:26Speaker 3: But the idea is that art does not contribute to
- 27:29Speaker 3: that at all. Art is it's a copy of a copy.
- 27:33Speaker 3: It's someone a painter uses his sense perception to look
- 27:37Speaker 3: at an artwork and he copies it. And it's often
- 27:42Speaker 3: driven by emotion. And Plato seems to think that when
- 27:47Speaker 3: their genius did happen, it was because the gods were
- 27:50Speaker 3: speaking through you. Was kind of divine inspiration. It couldn't
- 27:53Speaker 3: have been reason that was responsible for it. And that
- 27:56Speaker 3: explains why. Since it's twice removed from reality, right removed
- 28:00Speaker 3: from the truth, it's dangerous. I mean, after all you have,
- 28:05Speaker 3: you have Homer has these gods that do horrible things.
- 28:10Speaker 3: Let's face it, they're not Christian gods.
- 28:13Speaker 2: And Christian God does pretty horrible things.
- 28:17Speaker 3: Well yeah, well he does different horrible things. He becomes
- 28:21Speaker 3: a man and gives us a philosophy that that destroys us.
- 28:26Speaker 3: Whereas you know, Poseidon, you know, pretends to be a
- 28:29Speaker 3: human being and the next thing you know, he's abusing
- 28:31Speaker 3: women or something like that. So and also, I mean
- 28:35Speaker 3: what really, For example, Plato was in the Republic, he
- 28:41Speaker 3: particularly was found dangerous. That brilliant line of Achilles. When
- 28:47Speaker 3: Achilles is in Hades, he's in the afterlife, he's kind
- 28:50Speaker 3: of got the run of the place. And Odysseus, you
- 28:54Speaker 3: know Odysseus, this is in a book eleven of the Odyssey.
- 28:58Speaker 3: Odysseus sees him in says, you know, you don't have
- 29:01Speaker 3: much to complain about. I mean, yeah, you're dead and
- 29:03Speaker 3: you're here, but at least you know, you're a pretty
- 29:06Speaker 3: big man on campus around Hades and Odysseus sorry, and
- 29:11Speaker 3: Achilles says to that's did I mix that up? Yeah,
- 29:14Speaker 3: Achilles says to Odysseus, I don't want to hear that, Odysseus,
- 29:19Speaker 3: I would rather be the slave of a poor man
- 29:23Speaker 3: on earth than king of all of the afterlife. Because
- 29:27Speaker 3: for the Greeks, the afterlife it's just your memories, you know,
- 29:32Speaker 3: they go to some place and you have. But but
- 29:34Speaker 3: for the ancient Greeks, the earth is where it happens.
- 29:38Speaker 3: You want to be our hero, it has to happen
- 29:40Speaker 3: here on earth, and that's where all you have is.
- 29:43Speaker 3: It's like being a grandmother saying, ask me about my grandchildren.
- 29:46Speaker 3: You know, that's kind of what Hades is. And for
- 29:48Speaker 3: someone like Achilles, no, I don't want any of that.
- 29:51Speaker 3: He dies young. He knew he was going to die young.
- 29:54Speaker 3: He chose to go to Troy, having been told that
- 29:57Speaker 3: he could stay in Ithaca with no fame, but lived
- 30:00Speaker 3: to an old age. He didn't want that. So but
- 30:03Speaker 3: that that's a very brilliant expression of the Greek worldview,
- 30:07Speaker 3: and Plato says, no, we don't want that. In the republic.
- 30:11Speaker 3: That's going to teach soldiers that they shouldn't fear that
- 30:14Speaker 3: they don't want the afterlife. You know, we want warriors
- 30:18Speaker 3: going into battle thinking there's something better when they die,
- 30:22Speaker 3: and you know so so Aristotle's rejection of Homer, I
- 30:26Speaker 3: think is not just on literary ground. I mean Aristotle's rejection,
- 30:31Speaker 3: sorry of Plato on Homer. It's not just on literary
- 30:34Speaker 3: grounds that Plato didn't understand. Plato was pretty much he
- 30:40Speaker 3: had an idea of art as didactic. You know, it's
- 30:44Speaker 3: it's it's a moral it's a morality player or something like.
- 30:46Speaker 3: That's a little unsophisticated, but that's sort of pretty much
- 30:50Speaker 3: his view. And if you're gonna have art at all,
- 30:52Speaker 3: it's got to it's it's got to encourage proper morals.
- 30:59Speaker 3: And for Ariosot, I think he looked at Homer in
- 31:01Speaker 3: a very different way. I mean, I don't know, you know,
- 31:06Speaker 3: it's a story, it has a plot. In his view,
- 31:09Speaker 3: it has characterization. You see, you can talk about this.
- 31:13Speaker 3: That's kind of what these Homeric problems probably were raising
- 31:16Speaker 3: questions Odysseus would I mean one of the ones I
- 31:19Speaker 3: just have I have a paper coming out in well,
- 31:22Speaker 3: God knows when these things come out because I may
- 31:24Speaker 3: I send them in on the deadline. And then you know,
- 31:26Speaker 3: who knows what academics do. But it's a Calypso offered Odysseus,
- 31:33Speaker 3: you know, on the eye on Calypso's island, offered Odysseus immortality,
- 31:37Speaker 3: and he said no. And so that became one of
- 31:40Speaker 3: these problems. Why did Odysseus refuse immortality because Calypso and
- 31:45Speaker 3: it's not boring Christian heaven. Calypso says, stay with me.
- 31:50Speaker 3: You will be immortal, you will have pleasure in my
- 31:53Speaker 3: bed every night. You will not grow old. And he
- 31:56Speaker 3: says no. And you know, I'll take Penelope for all
- 32:00Speaker 3: her aging. And so the question is why, And you
- 32:04Speaker 3: know some people think, yeah, why and and I think
- 32:07Speaker 3: it relates to that point about Achilles. It sounds really
- 32:13Speaker 3: nice at first, right, you know, Eclipso is a nymph.
- 32:18Speaker 3: She doesn't grow old. You know, she's she's kind of
- 32:20Speaker 3: semi it's supposed to be really good looking, of course,
- 32:24Speaker 3: and she says that I'm you know, I'm not growing
- 32:27Speaker 3: old like Penelope. Right, And but again, for Odysseus, to
- 32:33Speaker 3: be a man means to achieve things. And now this
- 32:38Speaker 3: was probably, you know, part of the Greek culture that
- 32:40Speaker 3: that we might pause over but and to achieve things
- 32:45Speaker 3: that other people see as great accomplishments. That was really important.
- 32:51Speaker 3: And if if, if, if, staying on an island with
- 32:56Speaker 3: this really hot goddess for the rest of my life
- 32:59Speaker 3: means that I'm going to disappear, you know, I'll be
- 33:02Speaker 3: this obscure figure that no one's ever heard of. Again, No,
- 33:04Speaker 3: I'm not going to do it. And there are other
- 33:07Speaker 3: reasons as well, and and people talk about I mean, uh,
- 33:10Speaker 3: there was one view was that, well, Odysseus was really
- 33:15Speaker 3: smart and he knew that Calypso couldn't grant him immortality.
- 33:19Speaker 3: Only Zeus can do that. So that's that's not as
- 33:22Speaker 3: interesting an answer. And Arizontle's answered aren't really brilliant, you know,
- 33:26Speaker 3: they're not as interesting as some of the other ones
- 33:28Speaker 3: that might occur to us.
- 33:29Speaker 2: But so so all of these lust wooks, I mean,
- 33:35Speaker 2: you've you've got the one book on on on Homa.
- 33:40Speaker 2: What else are you guys expecting to find?
- 33:44Speaker 3: Well, a lot of it is not. Well, the work
- 33:47Speaker 3: I'm I'm devoting most of my time to now is
- 33:50Speaker 3: one called the zoka, which means animal matters, and one
- 33:54Speaker 3: of the last conversations I had with Alan Godhealth was
- 33:56Speaker 3: you know, we really someone needs to do more work
- 33:59Speaker 3: on that, and I thought, yeah, yeah, I went ought
- 34:01Speaker 3: to you know, I wonder who it's going to be.
- 34:03Speaker 3: I know, I wasn't this is you know, this was
- 34:06Speaker 3: I think the last year of Allan's life and he's
- 34:09Speaker 3: been gone what ten years something like that, I think
- 34:13Speaker 3: twenty thirteen so.
- 34:16Speaker 2: So.
- 34:16Speaker 3: But I then started to work on that. I thought,
- 34:20Speaker 3: this is I kind of stumbled across it somewhere and
- 34:23Speaker 3: I started looking at the evidence and wasn't satisfied with
- 34:28Speaker 3: what had been written on it in the past. So
- 34:32Speaker 3: I started working on it, and i've I have a
- 34:35Speaker 3: couple of publications. One publication has appeared already, I have
- 34:40Speaker 3: a couple in progress. But most of all I'm working.
- 34:43Speaker 3: What I want to do is as part of this
- 34:45Speaker 3: big project centered in Padua, in the University of Padua,
- 34:50Speaker 3: I want to have an edition of the the the
- 34:54Speaker 3: Greek and some Latin texts, translation and commentary. And that's
- 35:01Speaker 3: what I'm working on now, and I'm hoping that'll in
- 35:04Speaker 3: another year or so that'll be finished. Now I will
- 35:07Speaker 3: say this, I think it's a more boring work because
- 35:11Speaker 3: what I argue is that this was and one of
- 35:14Speaker 3: the things Alan talks about in his works on aerosol's
- 35:17Speaker 3: biology is that there was a collection of data stage,
- 35:20Speaker 3: an organization of data, and then the explanation of the data,
- 35:24Speaker 3: the causal explanation, and we have his works on the
- 35:28Speaker 3: collection of data that hasn't survived. Well, that's what I
- 35:32Speaker 3: argue that the zoeka is, the animal matters is and
- 35:35Speaker 3: I'm one of the things. I spent a week in Padua,
- 35:40Speaker 3: which is really lovely because it's thirty minute train ride
- 35:44Speaker 3: to Venice, which is pretty cool, and it's a beautiful
- 35:48Speaker 3: city in its own right. What I did is I
- 35:51Speaker 3: worked with some of the people there and I looked
- 35:54Speaker 3: at you know, I gave a two hour presentation of
- 35:58Speaker 3: you know, the evidence for Aristotle zoeka in Byzantine etymological works,
- 36:05Speaker 3: and you know, so I'm scraping the barrel right now.
- 36:07Speaker 3: I mean, there's not a lot of stuff left. I've
- 36:09Speaker 3: collected the material that exists. But I'm finding it a
- 36:13Speaker 3: fascinating activity. Although if I had to choose, which work
- 36:17Speaker 3: would you like to be discovered in the sands of
- 36:19Speaker 3: Egypt or in you know, Papyrus, or in Herculeannium. I
- 36:23Speaker 3: definitely want the work on Homer. I think it'd be
- 36:25Speaker 3: a much more fascinating work.
- 36:26Speaker 2: So do we know why Plato's survived and Aristotle didn't.
- 36:34Speaker 3: I think the main reason is Aristotle. I think he
- 36:41Speaker 3: appeared at the wrong time in a way, and it's
- 36:46Speaker 3: a complicated story. But when when Aristotle died, there's stories
- 36:53Speaker 3: about his library going to Theophrastus and Theophrastus giving it
- 36:58Speaker 3: to his heirs, and they were a neglect the work.
- 37:01Speaker 3: And this is why the archives is really important, and
- 37:05Speaker 3: neglecting the work, and then it showed it was lost
- 37:09Speaker 3: until fragments of it appeared in Rome centuries later. And
- 37:15Speaker 3: there's those are the stories we get from Plutarch and Athena,
- 37:20Speaker 3: these these ancient authors, and there's disputes about how much
- 37:24Speaker 3: we should we could rely on. I don't think. I
- 37:27Speaker 3: think his Lyceum which continued after he died, of course,
- 37:32Speaker 3: I think it had. It must have had a copy
- 37:34Speaker 3: of most of his works. I find that strange that
- 37:39Speaker 3: it wouldn't. But it just happened that the rival school,
- 37:43Speaker 3: Plato's Academy, which continued Plato's academy was in continuous operation
- 37:49Speaker 3: from when he found it until five five twenty nine
- 37:52Speaker 3: a d. When Justinian banned the teaching of any pagan philosophy.
- 37:58Speaker 3: Aristotle school didn't do so well. That is, his Lyceum
- 38:01Speaker 3: continued to work. And that's one of the things I'm
- 38:04Speaker 3: interested in now is I've become more involved in Project
- 38:08Speaker 3: Theophrastis that's recovering as much evidence as we can about
- 38:12Speaker 3: the the followers of Aristotle in the early Lyceum. But
- 38:17Speaker 3: I think his philosophy just wasn't as popular. It didn't
- 38:22Speaker 3: catch on as much during the Hellenistic period after, you know,
- 38:26Speaker 3: when when things changed very pretty radically from the Classical
- 38:31Speaker 3: period to the Hellenistic after the death of Alexander the Great,
- 38:36Speaker 3: and even before that with the the kind of the
- 38:39Speaker 3: Macedonian conquest of the whole you know, the whole world
- 38:43Speaker 3: in effect ultimately, and and and so what you get
- 38:47Speaker 3: is Plato's philosophy, I think had was more popular. And
- 38:52Speaker 3: then the new philosophies that emerged Stoicism, Epicureanism a bit later,
- 38:57Speaker 3: skepticism of various forms, these had I think they were
- 39:02Speaker 3: more influential, and I think, uh, and then a lot.
- 39:07Speaker 3: I think a lot of the works just may have
- 39:10Speaker 3: been not as interesting because Aristotol was you know, he
- 39:13Speaker 3: wrote works that were probably collections of data about animals
- 39:17Speaker 3: and collections of data about uh well, one of the
- 39:22Speaker 3: works I'm interested in his Aristotol wrote a work on
- 39:26Speaker 3: weather signs, and you know that is predicting, predicting the
- 39:31Speaker 3: weather based on the you know, what what the birds
- 39:34Speaker 3: are doing and what animal you know, if the setipedes
- 39:36Speaker 3: are running towards the wall, you know, maybe there's going
- 39:38Speaker 3: to rain. And I think he didn't believe all this stuff,
- 39:41Speaker 3: but he thought that if a lot of people believed that,
- 39:43Speaker 3: we should collect this data and see if there's anything
- 39:46Speaker 3: to it. So I imagine some of those works were
- 39:49Speaker 3: rather uninteresting to philosophers. In fact, it's it's not philosophy
- 39:53Speaker 3: at all at all as we know it. And since
- 39:56Speaker 3: it's very expensive to copy works, and I think they
- 40:00Speaker 3: weren't interesting to a lot of people, and and so
- 40:03Speaker 3: it's that's what I think happened. On the other hand,
- 40:08Speaker 3: it's not just boring stuff. I mean, he wrote dialogues
- 40:10Speaker 3: on justice, on on he wrote, you know, a treatise
- 40:15Speaker 3: on the River Nile, and you know, an explanation of it.
- 40:18Speaker 3: He has all these interesting works that are well. He
- 40:21Speaker 3: wrote works on medicine. I actually I published an article
- 40:25Speaker 3: on a possible fragments from that work as well. But
- 40:30Speaker 3: so I think it was a lack of interest in
- 40:34Speaker 3: some of his works, that his school was not as
- 40:37Speaker 3: influential as the other ones. Plus Plato wrote a set
- 40:42Speaker 3: number of you know, fairly however, thirty four or whatever
- 40:45Speaker 3: it is dialogues, and no, it's more going to be
- 40:49Speaker 3: more than that, but they kind of were carried on
- 40:52Speaker 3: by his school, and you know, they never really went
- 40:54Speaker 3: out of favor. And by the time you get to
- 40:56Speaker 3: the period, I mean, the crucial period is when they
- 40:59Speaker 3: start copy papyrus onto vellum or or different you know
- 41:04Speaker 3: kind of you know, into manuscript books that it's very
- 41:09Speaker 3: expensive process, and the ones that people weren't interested in
- 41:13Speaker 3: got lost.
- 41:15Speaker 2: Yep. Yeah, So is is the wook you've done on
- 41:19Speaker 2: ancient philosophy all Aristotle? Or is it included other other
- 41:24Speaker 2: Greek thinkers?
- 41:26Speaker 3: Oh? Yeah, I know, I've done a lot of others.
- 41:27Speaker 3: I didn't bring them all down here, but I brought
- 41:30Speaker 3: some of them I got here. I wrote this is
- 41:33Speaker 3: a translation of Plato's Laws Book ten. It's a translation
- 41:38Speaker 3: with commentary in the in the.
- 41:43Speaker 2: So you enjoy translating, what's that you enjoy translating?
- 41:48Speaker 3: I enjoy having translated. So that is when I've got
- 41:53Speaker 3: the finished product, I do like it, and I do
- 41:57Speaker 3: like it, particularly when I think there's not a very
- 42:00Speaker 3: good translation out there. And uh, yeah, so I like
- 42:04Speaker 3: it and I like like. Right now, I have two
- 42:07Speaker 3: contracts with Harvard University Press for translations, one of Aristotle's
- 42:11Speaker 3: Nikomacky and Ethics and one of where I'm general general
- 42:16Speaker 3: editor of a collection of it's called the Epuscula that
- 42:20Speaker 3: means Latin for little works in a way. And they're
- 42:24Speaker 3: not none of them are by Aristotle, likely even though
- 42:27Speaker 3: they come down what's in his name, But they're probably
- 42:29Speaker 3: by students of Aristotle. And they're kind of interesting works.
- 42:32Speaker 3: And I'm doing a couple of them. And then I
- 42:34Speaker 3: found other people who are experts in mathematics or music
- 42:38Speaker 3: theory or whatever to do the other ones. And that
- 42:42Speaker 3: one was supposed to be ready a year ago, but
- 42:45Speaker 3: one person is holding us up, not me. But yeah,
- 42:49Speaker 3: I enjoyed. I enjoyed the translation works I also did.
- 42:54Speaker 3: This is the producust the Sophist. It's a collection of
- 42:58Speaker 3: the fragments of his I dedicated that to to Leonard Peakoff, Uh,
- 43:05Speaker 3: not knowing that after right when the book came out,
- 43:09Speaker 3: I was asked if I would, And I actually have
- 43:11Speaker 3: this one here too. I'm bragging. I'm sorry, I shouldn't
- 43:13Speaker 3: do that. This is Theophrastus of on Winds. It's a
- 43:17Speaker 3: it's the Greek text with translation and commentary. Had I
- 43:22Speaker 3: known that I was going to be doing that, I
- 43:23Speaker 3: would have dedicated that one to Leonard because I referred
- 43:28Speaker 3: to him in one of my talks in Athens as
- 43:31Speaker 3: iron RAN's Theophrastus. And he he called me and and
- 43:35Speaker 3: said he he loved that description, and so I was
- 43:40Speaker 3: I would glad because I kind of looked at it
- 43:42Speaker 3: now in a way, I think he's much more than
- 43:46Speaker 3: than iron RAN's Theophrastus. Theophrastus was the person who followed
- 43:51Speaker 3: Aristotle on the school. He kind of did work because
- 43:54Speaker 3: Aristota was a scientist as well as a philosopher. He
- 43:57Speaker 3: you know, he kind of he did work in botany
- 44:00Speaker 3: that Arizonto only got a start on. And he did
- 44:03Speaker 3: work on you know, wins and and he wrote a
- 44:05Speaker 3: treatise on fire and stuff. So he's not whereas Leonard,
- 44:10Speaker 3: you know, wrote opar As as a favor to iron
- 44:14Speaker 3: Rand in effect, and he kind of and I think
- 44:20Speaker 3: he's in a different position. Theophrassis is among a group
- 44:24Speaker 3: of people working in various sciences. Where Aristotle was aware
- 44:32Speaker 3: that this is my theory given you know, the best
- 44:35Speaker 3: of the knowledge, you know, and so if someone comes
- 44:40Speaker 3: along and disagrees with him, that's no big thing. Whereas
- 44:43Speaker 3: iron Ran, it wasn't a science. She wasn't a physicist, uh,
- 44:47Speaker 3: and an expert in botany and things like that, where
- 44:51Speaker 3: it all just kind of come together. She was a philosopher,
- 44:54Speaker 3: pure and simple, and that is very different than than
- 44:57Speaker 3: the science. And my point is that one of doctor
- 45:02Speaker 3: Peakoff's roles, I think was to ensure the purity of
- 45:06Speaker 3: the philosophy beyond her death to the extent that he could.
- 45:10Speaker 3: And that's what and and unfortunately he was challenged to
- 45:13Speaker 3: do that very early on by people who want to
- 45:16Speaker 3: open objectivism up to anything. And uh, and I you know,
- 45:20Speaker 3: to do that without in a you know, in a
- 45:22Speaker 3: dogmatizing sort of way is really difficult. I think he uh,
- 45:28Speaker 3: what he did in the eighties was was just and
- 45:30Speaker 3: early ninees were really important from that perspective. So what
- 45:34Speaker 3: what I see happening in the eighties in a way
- 45:37Speaker 3: was in when when understanding objectivism came out. That was
- 45:43Speaker 3: dealing with this the the rationalism in the movement, and
- 45:47Speaker 3: then with fact and value and things of that. It
- 45:51Speaker 3: was dealing with the subjectivism in the movement. And and
- 45:53Speaker 3: so from that, you know, as in you know, Theophrastis
- 45:57Speaker 3: was Aristotle's intellectual air, and he did what he did,
- 46:01Speaker 3: but it wasn't the same and it wasn't as monumental
- 46:05Speaker 3: I would say, an achievements as well. I mean, they
- 46:11Speaker 3: both have hard acts to follow, Theophrastus.
- 46:14Speaker 2: And because of Leonard, we will get to keep you know,
- 46:18Speaker 2: we've got the full collection of Ironrand. We'll keep the
- 46:20Speaker 2: full collection of Ironran.
- 46:22Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, indeed disappear.
- 46:24Speaker 2: And he made sure of that, so, you know, and
- 46:27Speaker 2: they've all been published and do as good of a
- 46:32Speaker 2: job as preserving aristotle stuff.
- 46:35Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, I think so. And even well Leonard in
- 46:38Speaker 3: some of his more cynical moments where you know, even
- 46:43Speaker 3: having new acid free paper so it survives the apocalypse.
- 46:47Speaker 2: Put it into a nuclear roof bunker somewhere, bury it
- 46:52Speaker 2: All and yeah, in Utah, I remember that there was
- 46:55Speaker 2: a were supposed to get a mine, buy a mine
- 46:57Speaker 2: in Utah and bury All was there.
- 47:00Speaker 3: Yeah, that sounds familiar.
- 47:02Speaker 2: No, it was about two thousand, about two thousand, even
- 47:06Speaker 2: before nine to eleven. Yeah. So, so you've done a
- 47:13Speaker 2: lot of the Ancient Philosophy. You've also written a lot
- 47:16Speaker 2: about iron Rand, and so tell us a little bit
- 47:20Speaker 2: about the work you've done on nine Rand. I'm just
- 47:23Speaker 2: wondering where you get the time to do both. I mean,
- 47:26Speaker 2: you do all this and how you kind of mentally
- 47:28Speaker 2: divide the two or do you see it as more
- 47:32Speaker 2: integrated as maybe it appears. No? Not, I mean.
- 47:35Speaker 3: I've enjoyed myself. No, at at this moment, I've kind
- 47:40Speaker 3: of I've taken on too much. So I'm not really
- 47:43Speaker 3: enjoying it as much as I have in the past.
- 47:46Speaker 3: But in the past I really loved it when I
- 47:48Speaker 3: had an Ancient Philosophy project or two and an iron
- 47:52Speaker 3: Ran project. And so in the past that was working
- 47:57Speaker 3: for doctor Peacock to edit the the the nonfiction work,
- 48:02Speaker 3: the Marginalia, the non fiction work, the nonfiction writing course,
- 48:07Speaker 3: and the Q and a and I think that's that's
- 48:11Speaker 3: it as far as that goes, I think. And then
- 48:16Speaker 3: and then I did Song of Russia, which I read
- 48:18Speaker 3: the the Iron Ran and Song of Russia, which I
- 48:20Speaker 3: really enjoyed, was.
- 48:21Speaker 2: Kind of ARCHI that is, I don't think a lot
- 48:23Speaker 2: of people are familiar with that.
- 48:24Speaker 3: I don't have a copy of it here. That that's
- 48:27Speaker 3: It's when I kind of I went back to my
- 48:30Speaker 3: roots in a way, in the sense of when I
- 48:32Speaker 3: was really interested in anti Soviet literature and Iron there
- 48:37Speaker 3: it is. Uh, that's I think I Ran is the
- 48:41Speaker 3: first Soviet dissident, the first person. I mean, there were
- 48:45Speaker 3: some others who were more wishy while she but uh,
- 48:49Speaker 3: what she took on was this whole idea of the
- 48:57Speaker 3: in Hollywood the Communists were mistreated and isn't it horrible? Well, well,
- 49:03Speaker 3: she she was asked to. She worked in Hollywood. She
- 49:08Speaker 3: knew what was going on with the Hollywood Communists, how
- 49:11Speaker 3: they were influencing filmed in very subtle ways, even say
- 49:15Speaker 3: very clever ways.
- 49:16Speaker 2: And she was asked to.
- 49:19Speaker 3: At the HUAC hearings, the hearings for the what is it,
- 49:23Speaker 3: the House on American Activities Committee, they held hearings to
- 49:28Speaker 3: investigate communism in Hollywood, and she was called as a witness. Now,
- 49:34Speaker 3: she didn't particularly she didn't really think that this was
- 49:37Speaker 3: the proper function of Congress. I mean, she thought, if
- 49:41Speaker 3: they're if they're you know, they if they're worried that
- 49:43Speaker 3: there's actual foreign governments, uh, you know, influence, then then
- 49:47Speaker 3: that's a proper understand you know, but that should be
- 49:50Speaker 3: the FBI or someone like that having these congressional hearings.
- 49:53Speaker 3: But she she thought that there was no one really
- 49:56Speaker 3: speaking on getting really what was going on, and she
- 50:00Speaker 3: wanted to talk about that, and unfortunately all they talked,
- 50:04Speaker 3: all they asked her about was the film Song of Russia. Uh.
- 50:07Speaker 3: And so that's what we have the information where she
- 50:09Speaker 3: talks about, uh, what in what an obvious whitewashing of
- 50:17Speaker 3: Stalinists Russia it is uh And so it's very interesting
- 50:21Speaker 3: I thought to both get into the making of that film,
- 50:25Speaker 3: what that said about Hollywood. It was an interesting time
- 50:27Speaker 3: because I could interview one of this the one of
- 50:31Speaker 3: the screenwriters of the play who later turned Soviet He
- 50:38Speaker 3: turned evidence against the Hollywood communists. So he was treated
- 50:42Speaker 3: like dirt for the rust and the whole idea of
- 50:45Speaker 3: that the Hollywood Ten. You know that these people were
- 50:50Speaker 3: horrible victims of of American oppression when they were defending
- 50:56Speaker 3: Stalin and I mean were some of them, you know,
- 51:00Speaker 3: into the eighties were we're defending the Soviet Union and
- 51:04Speaker 3: and Scott and we're not apologetic at all. In fact,
- 51:06Speaker 3: they want, they demanded that you know, they be treated
- 51:10Speaker 3: as as heroes. And and I Ran, I think she
- 51:14Speaker 3: had some both her testimony and the things she wrote
- 51:17Speaker 3: about it, and I try to gather all that information
- 51:20Speaker 3: together and to tell the story of it. And uh,
- 51:23Speaker 3: and I enjoyed that project very much, but I also
- 51:27Speaker 3: came to the conclusion at the end, I never want
- 51:29Speaker 3: to read another Soviet dissident, you know, you know, any
- 51:32Speaker 3: more stories about how horrible it was in the Soviet Union,
- 51:36Speaker 3: although people ought to keep that alive, of course.
- 51:39Speaker 2: And so so in addition, you've done the collections of
- 51:46Speaker 2: essays on I Rang's novels.
- 51:48Speaker 3: Yeah, that was the next That was the thing to
- 51:49Speaker 3: keep me going to have these Iinram projects. And I
- 51:52Speaker 3: was very pleased about that because I kind of, with
- 51:54Speaker 3: my own initiative sort of just started writing to academic presses.
- 51:59Speaker 3: And that top tier ones weren't really interested, but I
- 52:03Speaker 3: got Lexington Books, which was at least at the time
- 52:06Speaker 3: was owned by Roman and Littlefield. They were very interested,
- 52:09Speaker 3: and I was. It was we'd also reached a point
- 52:12Speaker 3: where I thought, even if the the you know, the
- 52:15Speaker 3: really top objectivist intellectuals didn't agree to write essays for me,
- 52:19Speaker 3: we had all these other people who were coming up
- 52:22Speaker 3: and uh so, yeah, I think they're terrific. I think
- 52:27Speaker 3: they're really uh important essays. I also was very interested
- 52:31Speaker 3: in doing all four and doing them in order, even
- 52:34Speaker 3: though that that might not seem like a good idea.
- 52:37Speaker 3: And I liked the the the historical parts of it,
- 52:41Speaker 3: that is, the the information we have on on the
- 52:45Speaker 3: on the history of the works and how they were written,
- 52:48Speaker 3: and when, particularly with the earlier ones, we the Living
- 52:51Speaker 3: and and Anthem, when Iran was really struggling to get
- 52:56Speaker 3: things published, and whereas by the time you get the Atlas, shrug,
- 52:59Speaker 3: there's not my history there except for the drafts, which
- 53:02Speaker 3: are fascinating themselves, the drafts of of of these works,
- 53:07Speaker 3: because by then she could pick her own publisher after
- 53:11Speaker 3: the fountain Head. But yeah, so I'm very proud of
- 53:14Speaker 3: those and I wanted kind of historical stuff, literary analysis
- 53:19Speaker 3: and also philosophy, and and so there's really good, really
- 53:23Speaker 3: excellent pieces in there by on car On Cargate, Terra Smith,
- 53:30Speaker 3: Greg Sel, Mary Tora Buckman has some really good literary
- 53:34Speaker 3: analysis in there. And yeah, and I'm and I was
- 53:37Speaker 3: really pleased that aar I took the initiative to contact
- 53:41Speaker 3: the publisher and see about making an arrangement to release
- 53:46Speaker 3: them for free on I think it's new ideal, Right,
- 53:49Speaker 3: it's or yeah, I forget be.
- 53:52Speaker 2: Released as essays as independent essays.
- 53:55Speaker 3: Yeah, they're they're they've kind of released them slowly over
- 53:58Speaker 3: going back the past year or so, and so you
- 54:01Speaker 3: can find those online. And I think they're real. They're
- 54:05Speaker 3: real gems because when they came out, people were aware
- 54:07Speaker 3: of them and were reading them and thought, yeah, this
- 54:10Speaker 3: is great stuff. But you know, the next generation comes
- 54:13Speaker 3: along and and you want to keep those because of
- 54:16Speaker 3: it's it's it's there's not a lot like that out
- 54:19Speaker 3: there because a lot of the stuff that's being written
- 54:21Speaker 3: by iron Rand is really bad. But about iron Rand,
- 54:28Speaker 3: did I Yeah, about iron Rand is really bad and
- 54:31Speaker 3: from people who don't know what they're talking about. This
- 54:33Speaker 3: includes some of the biographies that are out there. But
- 54:36Speaker 3: there's also I think there's one Iron Rand as a
- 54:38Speaker 3: Jewish thing, you know, person.
- 54:42Speaker 2: I don't read these books, but I hear about them.
- 54:44Speaker 3: But yeah, and then I mean I I reviewed, I
- 54:51Speaker 3: wrote a review. I didn't want to do it, but
- 54:53Speaker 3: I figured if I didn't say yes, someone else would
- 54:56Speaker 3: and not as good. I was asked to review a
- 55:00Speaker 3: book by It was on in Rand and Chernichewsky. There's
- 55:05Speaker 3: this Russian, you know, nineteenth century Russian egoist, socialist, nihilist, anarchist,
- 55:12Speaker 3: you know, the whole bag, right, And I've heard this before,
- 55:17Speaker 3: the idea that he was an influence on iin Ran
- 55:20Speaker 3: and the book was so bad. It was so shocking.
- 55:24Speaker 3: But I think people don't have the same standards if
- 55:27Speaker 3: it's Iron Ran, because okay, any stuff that some historian
- 55:30Speaker 3: can come up with, they would never in a million years.
- 55:33Speaker 3: I think if someone in ancient philosophy tried to to
- 55:37Speaker 3: have such a shoddy job of making connections between between
- 55:42Speaker 3: two thinkers, at least I haven't seen works like that.
- 55:47Speaker 3: But yeah, I think for the time being, these these
- 55:52Speaker 3: are essay collections are really really valuable, and there's some
- 55:57Speaker 3: real gems in there, and I'm glad you can find them,
- 56:00Speaker 3: you know. You know, the New Ideal has been publishing
- 56:03Speaker 3: them fairly regularly, and I think they've gone through them.
- 56:06Speaker 3: I don't know if they've done all of them, but
- 56:09Speaker 3: a great many of them.
- 56:10Speaker 2: Well it's great because now there's such a ball. So
- 56:13Speaker 2: any of you who are interested in any of these
- 56:15Speaker 2: essays or I says about any of the novels, you
- 56:17Speaker 2: can find them online. They're easy to access. Any projects
- 56:23Speaker 2: you're working on right now in terms of oh, yeah,
- 56:26Speaker 2: there's a there's.
- 56:27Speaker 3: I guess the iron So that's what it looks like.
- 56:30Speaker 2: Yeah, I've got I've got them all here behind me.
- 56:32Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 56:34Speaker 2: Is are you working on any project right now? No?
- 56:40Speaker 3: And I'm really I want to find and an iron
- 56:43Speaker 3: Ran project. I've done a lot of talks recently on
- 56:48Speaker 3: iron Rand and atheism and her unique approach to to atheism,
- 56:53Speaker 3: I mean, the form it takes, the arguments against the
- 56:56Speaker 3: existence of God, things of that sort. I kind of
- 56:59Speaker 3: miss the bus on that one because the time to
- 57:02Speaker 3: write a book on that would have been when the
- 57:03Speaker 3: new atheists were out there and I was just doing
- 57:06Speaker 3: other things and I was working on and I talked
- 57:09Speaker 3: to Ankar about working.
- 57:11Speaker 2: On on the stuff.
- 57:11Speaker 3: But it's you know, it's finding the time. So that's
- 57:15Speaker 3: you know, it's in the back of my mind. It
- 57:17Speaker 3: might be better for me in retirement.
- 57:20Speaker 2: I mean, a lot of these atheists are finding God,
- 57:22Speaker 2: so maybe now's a good time. Yeah, that's a good
- 57:25Speaker 2: time to remind them of better arguments.
- 57:28Speaker 1: Yeah.
- 57:28Speaker 3: Or if they're not finding God there they're cultural Christians
- 57:31Speaker 3: or something like that, and that's a good that's a
- 57:34Speaker 3: good point that that. Yeah, these days are I.
- 57:37Speaker 2: Think it's a great time because they're all questioning, they'll
- 57:40Speaker 2: all have these doubts and now is a good time
- 57:43Speaker 2: to bolster the case. Yeah.
- 57:45Speaker 3: Yeah, so I'm so I've been working on you know,
- 57:48Speaker 3: I've given the number of talks even on the ontological
- 57:51Speaker 3: argument as esoteric is as that is. I'd also like
- 57:56Speaker 3: to find another archive product. I'd like to go look
- 58:02Speaker 3: at the drafts of of the or you know, with
- 58:05Speaker 3: the Living and Anthem and see if I can come
- 58:08Speaker 3: up with a project there. You know, I like the
- 58:11Speaker 3: idea of digging through the archives and I think it
- 58:15Speaker 3: will become easier to access the material and all that,
- 58:18Speaker 3: and so something like that. It's in the back of
- 58:21Speaker 3: my mind. It's just I've got so much ancient philosophy
- 58:23Speaker 3: stuff I've I've said yes to, so it'll be a while.
- 58:28Speaker 3: But yeah, I definitely I want to write more on
- 58:34Speaker 3: on Iran, that's for sure. But there's I should mention
- 58:38Speaker 3: one piece that I wrote a long time ago but
- 58:40Speaker 3: will be appearing. There's the Iran Society. Philosophical Studies is
- 58:46Speaker 3: a series published by University of Pittsburgh Press, really beautifully published.
- 58:53Speaker 3: They recently published Terry Smith's book Egoism Egoism Without Permission,
- 59:00Speaker 3: which really I recommend that book. But the series, the
- 59:05Speaker 3: collection of essays series that I referred to they have.
- 59:10Speaker 3: I think the next one that will be out is
- 59:13Speaker 3: on Aristotle and iron Rand or iron Rand and Aristotle,
- 59:16Speaker 3: I forget what title they arrived at, by Jim Lennox,
- 59:20Speaker 3: edited by Jim Lennox and Greg sel Mary and I have.
- 59:24Speaker 3: I have a piece in there on iron Rand and
- 59:27Speaker 3: Aris iron Rand as a as Aristotelian literary aesthetics. So
- 59:32Speaker 3: it's comparing Aristotle and iron Rand on literary aesthetics. So
- 59:39Speaker 3: you've probably heard a version of it in the two
- 59:41Speaker 3: thousands at some point, yes, yes, But finally it's you know,
- 59:46Speaker 3: it's ready to go, you know. So yeah, things are happening,
- 59:49Speaker 3: and I think you know, you go to a conference
- 59:53Speaker 3: and you're introduced to a young objectivist intellectual you've never
- 59:57Speaker 3: heard of, and that's, you know, a really good time
- 59:59Speaker 3: for someone who's been around for a while, I imagine
- 1:00:01Speaker 3: like you, that's always a good sign that you know,
- 1:00:04Speaker 3: whoa you know, there's more and more of them and
- 1:00:07Speaker 3: fresh blood fresh yeah yeah, yeah, so that's that's very encouraging.
- 1:00:12Speaker 3: And and and we have I mean, I've liked the
- 1:00:16Speaker 3: fact that you know, well Alan is Alan God health
- 1:00:19Speaker 3: has gone now, but but he was a big scholar
- 1:00:22Speaker 3: in ancient philosophy. It's terrific having you know, Greg who's
- 1:00:26Speaker 3: often been really good with feedback on the translation projects
- 1:00:30Speaker 3: of mine. And in fact, we just had a workshop
- 1:00:33Speaker 3: on Eudemian Ethics book eight in Austin that Greg kind
- 1:00:37Speaker 3: of hosted and we we kind of organized that together
- 1:00:40Speaker 3: where mostly just reading Greek and looking at my translation
- 1:00:45Speaker 3: with Greg and Jason Rhyans and good for a certain
- 1:00:50Speaker 3: kind of person that is a blast, you know, that's
- 1:00:53Speaker 3: and I'm one of them.
- 1:00:54Speaker 2: So it was it was terrific.
- 1:00:56Speaker 3: So it's nice that I have this this overlap, that
- 1:00:59Speaker 3: there's you know, the's always been a few people interested
- 1:01:02Speaker 3: in Greek philosophy among in the objectivist universe. And I
- 1:01:09Speaker 3: hope that some some younger ones on the horizon. I hope.
- 1:01:13Speaker 2: I don't know, but I hope so too, hope so too.
- 1:01:16Speaker 2: All Right, so we've got a bunch of questions. Uh,
- 1:01:20Speaker 2: this is good. So actually, this I think is so
- 1:01:25Speaker 2: this is some Adam. Let me just let me just wait.
- 1:01:29Speaker 2: I've got a few thank yous I need to do.
- 1:01:31Speaker 2: Let's say, Carolina, thank you, Jonathan, and these are stickers, Shelley, Mary,
- 1:01:38Speaker 2: Eleen Mary Lean again. All right, cool, Oh I didn't.
- 1:01:43Speaker 3: I didn't. I was worried I was going to brank,
- 1:01:45Speaker 3: bankrupt you tonight or something.
- 1:01:46Speaker 2: That we're doing great, We're doing great, Okay, Adam. Adam
- 1:01:50Speaker 2: has a fifty dollars question, and he says, I don't
- 1:01:53Speaker 2: know a lot about philosophy, but it is very interesting.
- 1:01:57Speaker 2: When do you think ran most voog just from Aristotle?
- 1:02:01Speaker 2: From what I think I know, he spoke of averages
- 1:02:05Speaker 2: when it comes to behavior, inherent purposes, and a lodge
- 1:02:10Speaker 2: l of government.
- 1:02:12Speaker 3: Well, that's a lot of different issues.
- 1:02:14Speaker 2: I mean, I think.
- 1:02:16Speaker 3: She always spoken very general terms that his metaphysics was
- 1:02:23Speaker 3: recognizing that, you know, existence exists, things are what they are,
- 1:02:28Speaker 3: which is the flip side of you know, A is
- 1:02:30Speaker 3: A is the you know, he talked very in very
- 1:02:32Speaker 3: serious terms about the law of non contradiction, and so,
- 1:02:37Speaker 3: you know, the basics of its metaphysics as she described them.
- 1:02:42Speaker 3: But you know, jettisating all the I think she calls
- 1:02:47Speaker 3: it the nonsense about the moving spheres and you know,
- 1:02:50Speaker 3: the prime mover and all that stuff, which is really
- 1:02:54Speaker 3: in a way it's kind of astronomy or or something
- 1:02:57Speaker 3: like that. Not exactly, but because he calls you know,
- 1:03:00Speaker 3: he refers to gods and things like that, So she
- 1:03:03Speaker 3: she doesn't accept that. I mean, she would accept, you know,
- 1:03:07Speaker 3: the importance of logic. Now he mentioned some things in ethics,
- 1:03:13Speaker 3: they're gonna be real differences. I don't know about the average.
- 1:03:15Speaker 3: I mean, she doesn't have a theory of the mean,
- 1:03:18Speaker 3: you know, virtue as a mean between extreme you know,
- 1:03:22Speaker 3: so so the details will be quite different in her
- 1:03:26Speaker 3: ethics and in Aristotle. You could say in very broad
- 1:03:33Speaker 3: brush terms that you know, they're both virtue ethicists. I
- 1:03:39Speaker 3: think I would call them. I know, in the case
- 1:03:42Speaker 3: of Aristotle, this is sort of a controversial issue. I
- 1:03:45Speaker 3: think they're both egoists in the sense that the purpose
- 1:03:52Speaker 3: of a person's life is to achieve one's own, you know,
- 1:03:56Speaker 3: happiness in those terms, but that how he formulates it
- 1:04:02Speaker 3: and and all of that. There's gonna be a lot
- 1:04:05Speaker 3: of divergences. But the person to ask there is Greg
- 1:04:08Speaker 3: So Mary. He's done some really excellent stuff on the
- 1:04:11Speaker 3: differences between Aristotle and iron Rand on ethics. He gave
- 1:04:15Speaker 3: a talk at Aristotle's Lyceum on an aspect of this topic.
- 1:04:22Speaker 3: I'm pretty certain I haven't seen the table of contents recently,
- 1:04:26Speaker 3: but the work I just referred to the Aristotle and
- 1:04:29Speaker 3: nine Ran volume. Greg will have something on that, and
- 1:04:34Speaker 3: there must be lectures of his available that where he
- 1:04:38Speaker 3: talks about these issues. So and then in politics, by
- 1:04:41Speaker 3: the time you get to politics, you're so far removed
- 1:04:43Speaker 3: from the basis that. Yeah, to say he has a
- 1:04:50Speaker 3: larger role of government, Yeah, that's true, but it's such
- 1:04:56Speaker 3: a strange context, the ancient Greek world. You could focus
- 1:05:01Speaker 3: on the positives he rejected Plato, he rejected explicitly, And
- 1:05:05Speaker 3: that was my doctoral dissertation in my first book was
- 1:05:09Speaker 3: Arizotl's criticism of Plato's Republic. And there are these kind
- 1:05:13Speaker 3: of themes running through his criticism. And it's not just
- 1:05:16Speaker 3: the he's not criticizing the forms and all that in
- 1:05:19Speaker 3: this in the part of the politics I'm talking about,
- 1:05:22Speaker 3: he's criticizing the communism of the republic aristotol Is. He
- 1:05:26Speaker 3: says Plato is focusing too much on He's trying to
- 1:05:30Speaker 3: create the unity of an individual human being out of
- 1:05:34Speaker 3: a city, and that destroys actual individuals. And so he
- 1:05:37Speaker 3: has a lot of good things to say about why
- 1:05:40Speaker 3: we don't need philosopher kings in fact, why we need
- 1:05:43Speaker 3: you know, there is the rule of law rather than
- 1:05:47Speaker 3: a rule of kings. You know, he has a kind
- 1:05:50Speaker 3: of a side where he sorts of defends kingship in
- 1:05:54Speaker 3: certain context. But I think that's a nod to his
- 1:05:56Speaker 3: Macedonian patrons.
- 1:05:58Speaker 2: Maybe I don't know.
- 1:06:00Speaker 3: And I remember when I was working on the Marginalia,
- 1:06:05Speaker 3: iin Ran gets to a point I think in uh,
- 1:06:07Speaker 3: in John Herman Randall's work Aristotle, which she would which
- 1:06:13Speaker 3: she praised, she gets to the point where he discusses slavery,
- 1:06:17Speaker 3: and she writes in the margin something like, oh, Aristotle,
- 1:06:21Speaker 3: you know, like you know, say it ain't so, but
- 1:06:26Speaker 3: you know, what do you expect? What can you expect
- 1:06:28Speaker 3: from you can't have I think a really an actual
- 1:06:34Speaker 3: advocate of individual rights when there has there is no
- 1:06:37Speaker 3: conception of rights yet, and you can have you know,
- 1:06:40Speaker 3: he talks about freedom, and he says positive things about freedom,
- 1:06:44Speaker 3: but his conceptualization of what freedom is is very dubious
- 1:06:47Speaker 3: in certain aspects. So by the time you get to
- 1:06:50Speaker 3: to by the time you get to politics, it's they're
- 1:06:55Speaker 3: they're no longer worth comparison comparing. However, they are worth
- 1:07:00Speaker 3: comparing when you get to their aesthetics. And that's what
- 1:07:02Speaker 3: I do in the article I mentioned earlier.
- 1:07:06Speaker 2: And where do you put them? In epistemology? What is
- 1:07:11Speaker 2: the theory of knowledge? How do they compare?
- 1:07:14Speaker 3: Again, just in broad bruck brush strokes, he believes in
- 1:07:19Speaker 3: you know, the efficacy of reason based on sense perception.
- 1:07:23Speaker 3: He believes that you know nothing, as Thomas aquinas, but
- 1:07:27Speaker 3: nothing reaches the intellect that doesn't come through sense perception.
- 1:07:31Speaker 3: So he's very good in those very general terms. He
- 1:07:34Speaker 3: regarded logic as really important and things of that sort.
- 1:07:39Speaker 3: But again, there's a very I found it a superb course,
- 1:07:44Speaker 3: but I don't know how easy it is. But Greg
- 1:07:50Speaker 3: saw Mary gave a course years ago on Aristotle's theory
- 1:07:55Speaker 3: of knowledge something like that where he goes into detail
- 1:07:58Speaker 3: about all the you know, the different kinds of intellectual
- 1:08:01Speaker 3: virtues and what's going on. And it can get very complicated.
- 1:08:05Speaker 3: And I guess the real point of comparison in epistemology
- 1:08:10Speaker 3: would be their theory of concepts. And iron Ran describes
- 1:08:16Speaker 3: Aristotle as I forget the expression she uses now, a
- 1:08:22Speaker 3: moderate realist, that's it. And there's I think real questions
- 1:08:28Speaker 3: as to whether that's whether Aristotle was actually even better
- 1:08:32Speaker 3: than that. I mean, he was certainly better than than Plato,
- 1:08:35Speaker 3: he was better than the Sophists. But how close he
- 1:08:40Speaker 3: is to object? I mean you can find passages that
- 1:08:43Speaker 3: sound like measurement omission, but you know, but what you
- 1:08:49Speaker 3: can make of that? I mean, we want we don't
- 1:08:50Speaker 3: want to massage Aristotle into into iron Ran, but I
- 1:08:55Speaker 3: think she would say the important thing is he's pro reason,
- 1:08:58Speaker 3: he's this worldly. He recognizes, you know, things are what
- 1:09:02Speaker 3: they are. I mean, the primary objects of reality, according
- 1:09:06Speaker 3: to Aristotle are the physical, the entities around us, and
- 1:09:09Speaker 3: he recognized entities, and he made the distinction between entities
- 1:09:14Speaker 3: and attributes and entities and actions, and all of that
- 1:09:17Speaker 3: is crucially important. And she's she recognized that.
- 1:09:22Speaker 2: Good Baker enjoyed, he says, enjoyed your reason in ancient
- 1:09:30Speaker 2: Greek drama lectures? Do you have any more work? And
- 1:09:34Speaker 2: ancient plays of poetry? Also? Are the other objectivists working
- 1:09:38Speaker 2: on these topics? And if so, what kind of things
- 1:09:41Speaker 2: are they working on?
- 1:09:43Speaker 3: I don't know of anyone working on ancient Greek literature
- 1:09:47Speaker 3: like that. Uh, that was one of my funnest I
- 1:09:51Speaker 3: enjoyed myself with that course very much. It was also,
- 1:09:55Speaker 3: if I could brag, it was the one lecture, the
- 1:09:59Speaker 3: one class where Leonard Peakoff sat in. When I did,
- 1:10:04Speaker 3: I applied his view, his theory of how to analyze plays.
- 1:10:09Speaker 3: I applied that to Escalus's Agamemnon, and he was thrilled.
- 1:10:12Speaker 3: And I was thrilled that he was thrilled. And I
- 1:10:15Speaker 3: really enjoyed that course generally. So thank you for you know,
- 1:10:19Speaker 3: you never know what happens these courses that we gave
- 1:10:23Speaker 3: decades ago. Now I think that's right. I think it's
- 1:10:26Speaker 3: decades plural that whether they just kind of float into
- 1:10:31Speaker 3: the ether or whether people are still listening to them.
- 1:10:34Speaker 3: I've not done in my own teaching. I've I've kind
- 1:10:39Speaker 3: of worked on some of these plays that that aren't
- 1:10:42Speaker 3: in that course that you know, the Youth, the Euripides, Medea,
- 1:10:49Speaker 3: and Sophocles. I think oedipis the King. No, I may know.
- 1:10:56Speaker 3: I did oedipis the King in that course, and Leonard
- 1:10:59Speaker 3: did antike it. But anyway, I've done some other things,
- 1:11:03Speaker 3: but I haven't given lectures on it or anything of
- 1:11:08Speaker 3: that sort. I did translate a play of Aristophanes called
- 1:11:13Speaker 3: The Assembly of Women, which is Aristophane's critique of egalitarianism
- 1:11:20Speaker 3: and communism. It's a fascinating play.
- 1:11:27Speaker 2: Richard asks what Plato's forms, a rejection of concepts and
- 1:11:33Speaker 2: inability to understand them, or something else.
- 1:11:37Speaker 3: I think you could say it was both of those
- 1:11:40Speaker 3: first two. Now it's difficult because you could say in
- 1:11:48Speaker 3: some respects his heart was in the right place, and
- 1:11:52Speaker 3: that is, he thought it was really important that the
- 1:11:56Speaker 3: concepts we work with this is our language, universals, that
- 1:12:02Speaker 3: they be objective, would be our language, that is, or
- 1:12:07Speaker 3: to put it that way, that they refer to something
- 1:12:09Speaker 3: that is absolutely true, that absolutely exists. So he was
- 1:12:13Speaker 3: resisting the sophists who claim that justice is just. It's
- 1:12:18Speaker 3: obeying the law and if you can get you know,
- 1:12:20Speaker 3: if no one's watching, you can get away with it.
- 1:12:22Speaker 3: There is no it has no harm to you. There
- 1:12:24Speaker 3: is no justice. It's a human construct, as you know,
- 1:12:27Speaker 3: the postmoderns might say. He was rejecting that, and for
- 1:12:31Speaker 3: good reasons. He thought it was very important that there
- 1:12:35Speaker 3: we could that we think there there must be something
- 1:12:38Speaker 3: that justice refers to that is what it is right,
- 1:12:42Speaker 3: and the same with the other virtues and other concepts
- 1:12:45Speaker 3: like the human human being, for example. It can't just
- 1:12:49Speaker 3: be a bunch of stuff that people make up. He
- 1:12:52Speaker 3: thought that was very dangerous and and we would collapse
- 1:12:56Speaker 3: into we might say nihilism or something like that. So
- 1:12:59Speaker 3: he was aware of that. He also thought it was
- 1:13:01Speaker 3: very important to answer people like Heraclitis who thought that
- 1:13:06Speaker 3: you know, you look at the world, there are no
- 1:13:07Speaker 3: real entities. It's just all this flux. And I think
- 1:13:12Speaker 3: Plato thought the only way to combat that into him,
- 1:13:18Speaker 3: to improve it is to say, yeah, yeah, that might
- 1:13:22Speaker 3: be true. Of this world. Things come into existence, go
- 1:13:25Speaker 3: out of existence were constantly changing, but it's not true
- 1:13:29Speaker 3: of the other the forms. So he wanted he didn't
- 1:13:33Speaker 3: know how to come up with an objective view of
- 1:13:37Speaker 3: concepts of universals, and so it's easy to criticize him
- 1:13:46Speaker 3: for doing it the way he did, and he deserves
- 1:13:49Speaker 3: some of that criticism, I think, but I also I'd
- 1:13:54Speaker 3: want to cut him a little slack because I think
- 1:13:56Speaker 3: his motives were to some extent, you might say or good,
- 1:14:01Speaker 3: let's say, that'd be a better way of putting it. However,
- 1:14:04Speaker 3: if you try to achieve in trying to defend that view,
- 1:14:09Speaker 3: you start to denigrate sense, perception, denigrate this world. Then
- 1:14:14Speaker 3: there's got to be something wrong with you. There's something
- 1:14:18Speaker 3: not healthy, not good, and it likely connected to a
- 1:14:24Speaker 3: sort of contempt for the world around him and a
- 1:14:30Speaker 3: kind of a lofty conception of what philosophers were that
- 1:14:34Speaker 3: was not at all admirable.
- 1:14:37Speaker 2: Yeah, Paul asks, Doctor Peacock says, quote, the arbitrary has
- 1:14:44Speaker 2: no epistemic status. Is that a statistically likely assertion that
- 1:14:50Speaker 2: is without evidence? An arbitrary assertion? Oh now, is a
- 1:14:55Speaker 2: statistically likely assertion that is without evidence and obituary you assessed,
- 1:15:01Speaker 2: I don't get that. How can this well, it could
- 1:15:04Speaker 2: be without evidence.
- 1:15:05Speaker 3: Yeah, that's okay, I think you would say. I mean,
- 1:15:08Speaker 3: it's you know, whatever, meteorologists assume that there's an eighty
- 1:15:12Speaker 3: percent chance of a thunderstorm tomorrow. I don't quite get it.
- 1:15:15Speaker 3: Or there's there's a fifty five percent chance that Trump
- 1:15:21Speaker 3: will win, which is not to say he's going to
- 1:15:23Speaker 3: get fifty five percent of the vote, right, Yeah, So
- 1:15:28Speaker 3: I mean I don't I don't get claims about likeliness. Now,
- 1:15:33Speaker 3: I could imagine a case where you know, you're reading
- 1:15:36Speaker 3: what is that Picketty, the guy who wrote Capital, you know,
- 1:15:39Speaker 3: who comes across some statistic and it's purely arbitrary or
- 1:15:44Speaker 3: the best example, in fact, I have my students read
- 1:15:47Speaker 3: this Alex Epstein's first book, What is it called The
- 1:15:51Speaker 3: Morality of Fossil Fuels?
- 1:15:52Speaker 2: Is that?
- 1:15:53Speaker 3: Yeah, a moral moral defensive. There's a chapter in there
- 1:15:57Speaker 3: about that claim that was going around that nine percent
- 1:16:01Speaker 3: of all climate scientists believe that, you know, global warming
- 1:16:06Speaker 3: is happening, it's caused by human beings, and it's dangerous.
- 1:16:10Speaker 3: He debunks that. I mean, he he analyzes that, and
- 1:16:13Speaker 3: it's if if you see what's behind that, then that
- 1:16:19Speaker 3: would be a statistic. That is, it is arbitrary, and
- 1:16:23Speaker 3: the people who malvet are just you know, accepting something
- 1:16:27Speaker 3: passively or are purely dishonest, and either one of those
- 1:16:30Speaker 3: is an unattractive thing to be. But I don't know
- 1:16:34Speaker 3: if that's really addressing your question. But and I really
- 1:16:36Speaker 3: don't know statistics.
- 1:16:37Speaker 2: But he's also he adds this Boltzmann brains seem arbitrary,
- 1:16:44Speaker 2: but not alien life. No hard evidence for either, though.
- 1:16:52Speaker 3: I don't know Boltzmann's I don't know what both Boltzman's
- 1:16:54Speaker 3: brains are. For alien life, you have to ask why,
- 1:17:00Speaker 3: why would you ask the question? So if that is,
- 1:17:04Speaker 3: there has to be a reason for raising it. Is
- 1:17:08Speaker 3: there any chance that there is our living beings somewhere
- 1:17:12Speaker 3: in the Andromeda Galaxy? Now, course, from last I read
- 1:17:16Speaker 3: the Andromeda Galaxy had a trillion stars now, but I
- 1:17:22Speaker 3: don't know, how do you assess the question? I would say,
- 1:17:25Speaker 3: in a kind of unsort of not philosophical at all. Way, Yeah,
- 1:17:30Speaker 3: I guess you know.
- 1:17:33Speaker 2: I mean it's arbitrary because you have no evidence.
- 1:17:36Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, but there's no evidence except for the fact
- 1:17:39Speaker 3: that we know that there's one planet where life has emerged.
- 1:17:43Speaker 3: We know that scientists have discovered what is it exo planets,
- 1:17:51Speaker 3: the ones that are outside of every solar system. They
- 1:17:53Speaker 3: have identified ones that seem to be earth like in
- 1:17:57Speaker 3: the range of temperatures that are you know, YadA, YadA, YadA.
- 1:18:02Speaker 3: So you could say that you know it. Whereas in
- 1:18:08Speaker 3: sixteen hundred, if someone speculated about life outside on a
- 1:18:13Speaker 3: planet other than Earth, that was purely arbitrary. It wasn't
- 1:18:17Speaker 3: really based on anything, whereas now it's quite different. But
- 1:18:21Speaker 3: I don't have you know, but if someone so, if
- 1:18:25Speaker 3: someone said there's no evidence of life on you know,
- 1:18:29Speaker 3: in other galaxies, I don't know what would the point
- 1:18:33Speaker 3: of a statement like that be except you know, okay,
- 1:18:35Speaker 3: they haven't landed here yet or we haven't communicated with them.
- 1:18:39Speaker 3: But so and there has to be a good reason.
- 1:18:41Speaker 2: Question what evidence means in this context. Yeah, yeah, there's
- 1:18:46Speaker 2: life on Earth. That's evidence, Yeah, indeed, And and then
- 1:18:50Speaker 2: there's evidence that the planets like this exist. As you said,
- 1:18:54Speaker 2: that constitutes evidence. So it really evidence doesn't mean this
- 1:18:59Speaker 2: specific concrete that you're looking for that life another planets.
- 1:19:04Speaker 2: Therefore I need evidence of literal life and another planets.
- 1:19:07Speaker 2: It means the evidence that the context, the whole you
- 1:19:12Speaker 2: know is possible, right, I think there's an equivocation of evidence.
- 1:19:17Speaker 2: Adam says, for Robert, who were the philosophers who influenced
- 1:19:22Speaker 2: a comedies?
- 1:19:25Speaker 3: Oh that's a good one. And I don't know the
- 1:19:27Speaker 3: answer to that. I just don't. That's Greek mathematics, and
- 1:19:32Speaker 3: that's one of those Greek mathematics and Greek music I'm
- 1:19:36Speaker 3: pretty bad on. Yeah, so I have to plead ignorance here.
- 1:19:43Speaker 2: I just don't know. But he says, doctor me Hugh
- 1:19:49Speaker 2: is incredible. It seems like he's already done the work
- 1:19:53Speaker 2: of three lifetimes. I love hearing him talk about his
- 1:19:56Speaker 2: passion and accomplishments.
- 1:19:58Speaker 3: Nice. Thank you? Who are that?
- 1:20:00Speaker 2: Oh that's I think I know who that is.
- 1:20:04Speaker 3: Yeah, thank you, Mary.
- 1:20:05Speaker 2: Elene Adam follow up to Rand Divergence from Aristotle. Question,
- 1:20:12Speaker 2: any issues will you you divute from Rand? Have you
- 1:20:16Speaker 2: found any contradictions in her philosophy of objectivism?
- 1:20:21Speaker 3: No, I mean it's a it's a system. I would say,
- 1:20:26Speaker 3: you know, there are some areas of her philosophy that
- 1:20:28Speaker 3: I just don't know, Like, for example, I could not
- 1:20:30Speaker 3: give a lecture on measurement omission, but I've read it
- 1:20:34Speaker 3: I've read doctor Peacock version of it. It all sounds like, yeah,
- 1:20:38Speaker 3: this is this is the answer, this is the solution
- 1:20:42Speaker 3: to the problem of universals. But I would never say that, well,
- 1:20:46Speaker 3: I don't know it really well. Therefore, I'm open to
- 1:20:49Speaker 3: the possibility that she's wrong on something. I don't look
- 1:20:52Speaker 3: at it that way. You know, there might be things
- 1:20:56Speaker 3: I disagree with, but none of them are important or fundamental.
- 1:21:06Speaker 3: I don't have strong views on dancing, but I don't
- 1:21:10Speaker 3: think tap dancing is my favorite. But you know, I'm
- 1:21:12Speaker 3: open to persuage. So it would be on the level
- 1:21:15Speaker 3: of that, or a kind of novel. You know, maybe
- 1:21:19Speaker 3: there's a novel she liked that didn't do much for me.
- 1:21:22Speaker 3: But I have a hard time.
- 1:21:24Speaker 2: You wouldn't consider objectivism, no.
- 1:21:27Speaker 3: No, no, no, no, that's not objective. Oh so, oh yeah,
- 1:21:29Speaker 3: he's specifically asked about objectivism.
- 1:21:31Speaker 2: No.
- 1:21:32Speaker 3: And I find one of the reasons, it's such an
- 1:21:36Speaker 3: integrated system. That's an area where I think she differed
- 1:21:39Speaker 3: from Aristotle, and why Aristotle's followers could could go in
- 1:21:43Speaker 3: different directions from Aristotle. Is it such an integrated system.
- 1:21:48Speaker 3: So I find that even when I encounter people who
- 1:21:51Speaker 3: you know, I agree with everything she says, except her
- 1:21:55Speaker 3: views on modern art or something. If you really dig,
- 1:21:59Speaker 3: you stark to see that No, no, you are getting
- 1:22:02Speaker 3: other things wrong besides her aesthetics. And it's it's a
- 1:22:05Speaker 3: it's fascinating how that that works in a way, but
- 1:22:09Speaker 3: it really is an integrated system. Uh, you know, and
- 1:22:12Speaker 3: I've not I've not encountered anything on the contrary that
- 1:22:16Speaker 3: I find the more I read, you know, and go
- 1:22:18Speaker 3: back to those essays you haven't read in a long time,
- 1:22:22Speaker 3: it's like, wow, that is clarifying that connection. And I've
- 1:22:26Speaker 3: done that recently with with going when I started taking
- 1:22:32Speaker 3: you know, becoming very interested in in her views on
- 1:22:35Speaker 3: the arguments against the existence of God and you know,
- 1:22:38Speaker 3: her particular view of of atheism. You find how brilliant
- 1:22:47Speaker 3: the philosophy is and how tight knit and how everything's connected.
- 1:22:51Speaker 3: And if you go wrong on plug in, if you
- 1:22:57Speaker 3: go wrong on on one little area, you start messing
- 1:23:01Speaker 3: up the kind of a cascade effect.
- 1:23:05Speaker 2: So Liam asks, why is Plato so dominant despite being
- 1:23:10Speaker 2: wrong about everything? Yeah?
- 1:23:14Speaker 3: Well, where is he dominant? I mean he where what?
- 1:23:17Speaker 3: Who has he influenced? And you know, he's he's kind
- 1:23:23Speaker 3: of the the philosopher of religion. I think, uh, and
- 1:23:28Speaker 3: I mean it's you know, I think it was W. T.
- 1:23:31Speaker 3: Jones who said that the biggest irony in Western philosophy
- 1:23:35Speaker 3: was that a Quinas merged Christianity and Aristotle. That was
- 1:23:40Speaker 3: just bizarre. The early Christians loved Plato. In fact, some
- 1:23:45Speaker 3: of them thought Plato was so good that he had
- 1:23:48Speaker 3: to have stolen it from Moses. That that is, you know,
- 1:23:51Speaker 3: from Jesus wasn't around yet, but it was. So you
- 1:23:55Speaker 3: see that in early philosopher Philo of Alexandria, and and
- 1:23:58Speaker 3: Justin Martyr and some of these early Christians, they love
- 1:24:01Speaker 3: Plato and they were right to do it. Augustine said
- 1:24:04Speaker 3: that it was it was the Platonists. He never read
- 1:24:07Speaker 3: Plato in the original, but he said it was the
- 1:24:09Speaker 3: Platonists that allowed him to see that it made sense
- 1:24:13Speaker 3: to believe in spiritual beings entities that had no physical embodiment.
- 1:24:18Speaker 3: The Plato, you know, Plato did that. So you know
- 1:24:24Speaker 3: he's wrong on those issues, But the people who are
- 1:24:26Speaker 3: influenced by him don't think he's wrong. They think he's brilliant.
- 1:24:29Speaker 3: And that's often how it goes. I mean it content
- 1:24:35Speaker 3: is even a worse example. How could he be so influential,
- 1:24:38Speaker 3: influential given what he's done and what he says and
- 1:24:47Speaker 3: how wrong he is?
- 1:24:48Speaker 2: And maybe maybe you'll understand this question because I don't.
- 1:24:51Speaker 2: This is from the synthetic, analytical synthetic that caught him.
- 1:24:55Speaker 2: How does objectivism account for the ontological difference between sin
- 1:25:01Speaker 2: and send s without reducing all complexities to MIAs send
- 1:25:06Speaker 2: s s C I E n d E S s
- 1:25:10Speaker 2: E I.
- 1:25:12Speaker 1: S C I N d E S.
- 1:25:16Speaker 2: Between don't. I don't understand I n n s E
- 1:25:19Speaker 2: I n d E S.
- 1:25:21Speaker 3: I don't understand it. I understand the the objectivist rejection
- 1:25:26Speaker 3: of the analytics synthetic dichotomy.
- 1:25:30Speaker 2: But that is uh.
- 1:25:31Speaker 3: And doctor Peacoff wrote a brilliant essay that was attacked
- 1:25:36Speaker 3: that was attached to the I T O E the.
- 1:25:42Speaker 2: Yeah, Yeah, I don't understand the question. You neither.
- 1:25:44Speaker 3: Yeah, I'm sorry about that.
- 1:25:46Speaker 2: So Joseph asked, have you written or done anything on
- 1:25:50Speaker 2: da Vinci, particularly his Aristatilianism, his integrations across multiple disciplines,
- 1:25:57Speaker 2: and the elements of Platonism that infected some of his thoughts. No,
- 1:26:01Speaker 2: I've not.
- 1:26:02Speaker 3: I've read on it, but I haven't. I haven't done it.
- 1:26:07Speaker 3: I went to the da Vinci Museum in Milan this
- 1:26:10Speaker 3: past summer where you can see his his inventions are,
- 1:26:14Speaker 3: are you know people created them? That's kind of an
- 1:26:18Speaker 3: interesting but I've not, and I've actually not read him
- 1:26:22Speaker 3: in years, so I can't. I can't.
- 1:26:27Speaker 2: Recently we had his biography what's his name? Quote? The
- 1:26:30Speaker 2: guy who did Steve Jobs. I forget to aufor name. Anyway,
- 1:26:36Speaker 2: da Vinci's life is pretty amazing, all right. So analytics
- 1:26:39Speaker 2: synthetic echoonomy says, what's meant is being and beings? So
- 1:26:46Speaker 2: how does objectivism account for the ontological difference between being
- 1:26:50Speaker 2: and beings without reducing all complexities to mia beings. I
- 1:26:56Speaker 2: still don't understand the question.
- 1:26:58Speaker 3: I don't. I don't understand that either. I mean, the
- 1:27:01Speaker 3: the analytic synthetic dichotomy is that there's two kinds of statements.
- 1:27:08Speaker 3: An analytic statement is like, you know all bachelors are
- 1:27:16Speaker 3: male because you know, bachelor by definition is an unmarried man, right,
- 1:27:24Speaker 3: And that's an analytic statement. You can you can see
- 1:27:27Speaker 3: it's true just by analyzing the words, whereas a synthetic
- 1:27:31Speaker 3: statement would be water boils at one hundred degrees celsius
- 1:27:36Speaker 3: at sea level or something like that. That's a synthetic statement,
- 1:27:40Speaker 3: according to this view, because you can't analyze it just
- 1:27:44Speaker 3: on the basis of the terms. Now, Einran rejects that entirely,
- 1:27:50Speaker 3: that all statements are analytic or synthetic, depending on how
- 1:27:53Speaker 3: you look at it. And her view is that if you,
- 1:27:57Speaker 3: I think she calls it the anti effort in one
- 1:28:00Speaker 3: of the marginalia, the anti effort mentality that if you
- 1:28:04Speaker 3: really understood everything there is to know about a concept
- 1:28:08Speaker 3: in a statement, you would see that it's quote unquote analytic. Now,
- 1:28:13Speaker 3: and she wouldn't put it that way. But so for example,
- 1:28:16Speaker 3: you say, you know, ah, you know, all bachelors are men,
- 1:28:22Speaker 3: you know, just by yeah, uh, And you compare that
- 1:28:25Speaker 3: to a synthetic statement like iron floats as iron sinks
- 1:28:31Speaker 3: in water. Now, her view was, if you know all
- 1:28:35Speaker 3: there is to know about water and all there is
- 1:28:38Speaker 3: to know about iron, and all there is to know
- 1:28:40Speaker 3: about you know, et cetera, that that that it's all there,
- 1:28:46Speaker 3: it's it's not somehow not quite as clear or or
- 1:28:51Speaker 3: not quite as crisp beneath.
- 1:28:53Speaker 2: Uh.
- 1:28:54Speaker 3: You know, a statement like like the the the analytic ones.
- 1:29:01Speaker 3: Now what about beings and being and beings?
- 1:29:04Speaker 2: I don't you know? The analytic synthetic dichotomy is his
- 1:29:10Speaker 2: that's his handle, that's his name. Oh, so the question
- 1:29:13Speaker 2: is not related to his name. Oh, the questions related
- 1:29:17Speaker 2: to something in Heidiger's philosophy. I don't know how well
- 1:29:22Speaker 2: you know Heidig. I don't know Heidige at all. Shendesk
- 1:29:26Speaker 2: refers to individual entities while sham.
- 1:29:29Speaker 3: That those are German words.
- 1:29:31Speaker 2: Fundamental concepts of existence.
- 1:29:33Speaker 3: No, I don't like Heidigger at all. If I quote him,
- 1:29:37Speaker 3: it's all at all. It's it's to make fun of him.
- 1:29:41Speaker 3: I have a paper coming out on Eudemus on infinity.
- 1:29:46Speaker 3: Whereas Eudemus was a follower of he was a colleague
- 1:29:48Speaker 3: of Aarsol. He was one of these people who was
- 1:29:50Speaker 3: around when Aristotle died. He went back to Rhodes and
- 1:29:54Speaker 3: started kind of in a Riscitilian school there, and he
- 1:29:58Speaker 3: he wrote, uh, you know, he defended Aristotle's views on infinity.
- 1:30:05Speaker 3: And at the end of the paper, I quote Heidegger
- 1:30:09Speaker 3: on on infinity. I wish I could remember, but he's
- 1:30:14Speaker 3: he's kind of you know, if you want to talk
- 1:30:16Speaker 3: about infinity. You can't use science. Science is can't handle
- 1:30:23Speaker 3: the concept of infinity. But that doesn't mean it's bad
- 1:30:26Speaker 3: to talk about infinity, because you know, all that means
- 1:30:30Speaker 3: is science can't handle it. And he goes on to
- 1:30:33Speaker 3: talk about it, and I think I Ran quotes it somewhere,
- 1:30:37Speaker 3: and I'm trying to think where she she quotes the passage,
- 1:30:41Speaker 3: but it might be an it oe where you know, uh,
- 1:30:45Speaker 3: you know, the attempt to analyze, you know, infinity, it
- 1:30:52Speaker 3: you know it it melts in the crude acid of
- 1:30:56Speaker 3: logic or something. In other words, you know, I discussed
- 1:30:59Speaker 3: the topics, but I don't use this mundane logic and
- 1:31:04Speaker 3: scientific reason that you people down there. I now, maybe
- 1:31:09Speaker 3: I'm interest in not interpreting Heidegger correctly, but I've always
- 1:31:12Speaker 3: found him impossible to read, and not because he would
- 1:31:21Speaker 3: weigh over my head. I mean, I find higher mathematics
- 1:31:24Speaker 3: impossible to read, and that's my problem because I'm ignorant.
- 1:31:28Speaker 3: But reading Heideger, I think, you know this is this
- 1:31:31Speaker 3: is Nietzsche's poets muddy their waters to make them appear deep. Well,
- 1:31:36Speaker 3: it happens to philosophers too, and Heideger, I think, is
- 1:31:39Speaker 3: one of them. My understanding is he's more difficult than
- 1:31:43Speaker 3: Kant in Germans.
- 1:31:44Speaker 2: Ok. Wow, so cold, writes. I'm reading Plato right now,
- 1:31:49Speaker 2: can't wait to move to Aristotle. Do you have any
- 1:31:52Speaker 2: advice on where to start with Aristotle? Any advice about
- 1:31:56Speaker 2: reading him or Plato?
- 1:31:59Speaker 3: I would say with both of the Plato's is a
- 1:32:01Speaker 3: little easier because you can start with the shorter what
- 1:32:04Speaker 3: are called Socratic dialogues, like the Youth of fro and
- 1:32:07Speaker 3: the Lockeyes, and you'll read the famous apology, which his
- 1:32:11Speaker 3: defense speech. Things of that story they can be lovely.
- 1:32:14Speaker 3: And I'm teaching a seminar on the republic right now.
- 1:32:18Speaker 3: That's the whole of the Platonism is all there. It
- 1:32:23Speaker 3: starts off with ethics, but it ends up being his metaphysics,
- 1:32:26Speaker 3: is epistemology, his ethics, his political philosophy, esthetics. It's all there,
- 1:32:32Speaker 3: and it's an interesting dialogue. I must say. With Aristotle,
- 1:32:37Speaker 3: my recommendation is to follow your values. What is of
- 1:32:43Speaker 3: interest to you. If you like ethics, start reading his
- 1:32:47Speaker 3: work on ethics. If you like his politics, start reading that.
- 1:32:51Speaker 3: If you're interested in literature, read the poetics. For the rest.
- 1:32:58Speaker 3: It gets difficult if you're interested in meta physics. If
- 1:33:01Speaker 3: you jump right into the metaphysics, that can be pretty difficult.
- 1:33:04Speaker 3: You know, maybe get a copy and flip through the
- 1:33:07Speaker 3: table of contents, find a topic. I mean, his discussion
- 1:33:11Speaker 3: of the law of non contradiction is fascinating.
- 1:33:14Speaker 2: You know.
- 1:33:14Speaker 3: He talks about God in some places, which is sort
- 1:33:17Speaker 3: of strange, but it can be very difficult.
- 1:33:22Speaker 2: To read.
- 1:33:22Speaker 3: And same with his logical works. I've stayed away from
- 1:33:25Speaker 3: them because they're really difficult. I mean, I've read them,
- 1:33:28Speaker 3: but I don't it's not something I write on. So
- 1:33:32Speaker 3: that would be my advice with with Aristotle.
- 1:33:37Speaker 2: Oh, here's a question you've been waiting for. Are you
- 1:33:39Speaker 2: voting for Trump or Harris?
- 1:33:42Speaker 3: I'm abstaining and I'm hoping Harris wins. I've and I
- 1:33:52Speaker 3: respect objectivists who take a different approach. I take very
- 1:34:00Speaker 3: seriously the idea and I did this very early on.
- 1:34:02Speaker 3: I really liked the principle that Iran says, there are
- 1:34:06Speaker 3: limits to the lesser of two evils. And if you
- 1:34:09Speaker 3: can't find more more positive than negative in you know,
- 1:34:14Speaker 3: the evil candidate, you know, the worst candidate, the non
- 1:34:17Speaker 3: ideal candidate, you know, abstained, and that's what Uh, that's
- 1:34:22Speaker 3: what I'm doing. I was hoping the Republican Party would
- 1:34:25Speaker 3: be shocked by Trump and and you know, his his claim,
- 1:34:31Speaker 3: you know, his his behavior. Uh, and would would come
- 1:34:35Speaker 3: up with someone halfway decent? I mean, you know, we're
- 1:34:39Speaker 3: we're pining for the days of Mitt Romney, right, yeah,
- 1:34:45Speaker 3: I would you know, Uh, yeah, that's just you know,
- 1:34:48Speaker 3: I don't know about George Bush, but so yeah, I
- 1:34:52Speaker 3: mean Trump is impossible. I think I think he's destroyed
- 1:34:56Speaker 3: the Republican Party and and the creatures who were coming
- 1:35:00Speaker 3: up in his place are in some respects more dangerous.
- 1:35:05Speaker 3: They're worse because they're articulate, they're intelligent, they read books,
- 1:35:10Speaker 3: and they're not sociopaths, and you know, but he's made
- 1:35:15Speaker 3: them possible in a way. And I would say in
- 1:35:18Speaker 3: this connection, I think it was in twenty twenty than
- 1:35:23Speaker 3: we did that podcast together, you on car and and me.
- 1:35:28Speaker 3: I thought that was really good and I thought it
- 1:35:30Speaker 3: was it's worth listening to again, where the three of
- 1:35:34Speaker 3: us talked about the president presidential elections, and we focused
- 1:35:41Speaker 3: on we spent a lot of time talking about Iron
- 1:35:44Speaker 3: Rand and the what she says about presidential elections. And
- 1:35:48Speaker 3: I think we did a really good job, and that's
- 1:35:51Speaker 3: that's worth you know, surprise, surprise, A lot of those
- 1:35:55Speaker 3: issues are still alive now. But I would there are
- 1:36:00Speaker 3: some things in the case of Trump that I regard
- 1:36:03Speaker 3: is unforgivable. I mean, we could make a long list,
- 1:36:07Speaker 3: but I mean saying he loved the dictator of Korea,
- 1:36:14Speaker 3: his his admiration for thugs, for Putin, it's abysmal. And
- 1:36:23Speaker 3: I made the point in this podcast that he's so
- 1:36:26Speaker 3: bad that even if he does something good, you can't say, well,
- 1:36:28Speaker 3: he's done this. The good things he does are an embarrassment.
- 1:36:32Speaker 3: And I think I mentioned the time, you know, moving
- 1:36:34Speaker 3: the capital to Jerusalem of Israel, and and pulling us
- 1:36:38Speaker 3: out of the Peace Accord, the the what is the
- 1:36:42Speaker 3: Paris Accords, the Environmental Accords. Those would be great from
- 1:36:45Speaker 3: anyone else, but when you come from him, it's just
- 1:36:49Speaker 3: this more nutty stuff from this guy who's now you know,
- 1:36:54Speaker 3: in is RFK really going to be.
- 1:37:00Speaker 2: Hell, he's gonna ban non organic food, I mean either
- 1:37:04Speaker 2: going to eat organic or not eat at all.
- 1:37:07Speaker 3: Yeah, So yeah, Trump is not Now. You know, there
- 1:37:10Speaker 3: was a day when I thought, you know what, I'm
- 1:37:13Speaker 3: going to bite the bullet and I'm going to vote Democrat.
- 1:37:15Speaker 3: I'm going to vote for Harris. And then I went
- 1:37:17Speaker 3: online and started reading her position, and I thought, no,
- 1:37:21Speaker 3: if she had come out with a really strong pro
- 1:37:26Speaker 3: Israel statement that made it clear that she repudiated that
- 1:37:32Speaker 3: she had nothing to do with that wing of the Democrats,
- 1:37:35Speaker 3: and she didn't do that.
- 1:37:36Speaker 2: As far as I'm concerned, and she never did. Yeah,
- 1:37:40Speaker 2: So that that episode is on New Idea. You can
- 1:37:44Speaker 2: find no YouTube. It's called Thinking about the US Presidential Elections.
- 1:37:49Speaker 2: It was taped in September of twenty twenty, I think
- 1:37:53Speaker 2: twenty eighth or twenty ninth of September, and you can
- 1:37:57Speaker 2: find an online. So it's it is available.
- 1:38:02Speaker 3: Yeah, you know, and two elections ago, I said, I,
- 1:38:06Speaker 3: you know, I don't support Trump. I think he's really dangerous,
- 1:38:09Speaker 3: but I could kind of understand YadA, YadA. I won't
- 1:38:13Speaker 3: say that now. I don't understand why any of us
- 1:38:19Speaker 3: would would vote for for Trump. Yep.
- 1:38:23Speaker 2: Yeah, all right, John asks, in editing Rand's Q and A,
- 1:38:30Speaker 2: did you act did you accurately transcribe Rand's answers to
- 1:38:35Speaker 2: questions such as the morality of smoking and using sacharine? Oh?
- 1:38:41Speaker 3: Well, this is an awkward kind of question because I
- 1:38:49Speaker 3: was asked by doctor Peacock if I would edit the
- 1:38:54Speaker 3: iron RAN's Q and A. I mean, I think I
- 1:38:56Speaker 3: broke the subject with him, and he talked about he
- 1:39:00Speaker 3: had to be edited or you know, Penguin wouldn't go
- 1:39:03Speaker 3: for it, and that he was going to oversee the editing.
- 1:39:06Speaker 3: And now that there was there was no there wasn't
- 1:39:16Speaker 3: any you know, I I would edit her and then
- 1:39:20Speaker 3: he would have suggestions and I would edit a bit
- 1:39:22Speaker 3: more and he would you know, I know, you need
- 1:39:24Speaker 3: more editing here. And I was aware at the time
- 1:39:29Speaker 3: that people are not gonna, you know, like this, but
- 1:39:31Speaker 3: I assumed people would could be good spirited for almost
- 1:39:35Speaker 3: because almost all of it is available, and you know,
- 1:39:38Speaker 3: any of the cuts that were made you could see,
- 1:39:40Speaker 3: and I mean, it's I think it's possible that I
- 1:39:41Speaker 3: made cuts that I shouldn't have, but I stand by
- 1:39:44Speaker 3: the work. But if it weren't for the fact that
- 1:39:48Speaker 3: the the a State of iron Ran was behind the
- 1:39:53Speaker 3: project and had control of it, I I probably would
- 1:39:57Speaker 3: have done some things differently, but then it wouldn't have
- 1:39:59Speaker 3: been published by pay when it would have been a
- 1:40:00Speaker 3: different kind of book. Now, I don't remember that particular one,
- 1:40:06Speaker 3: but there was some issue that that Leonard had issues about,
- 1:40:13Speaker 3: but I just don't remember it. So if if if
- 1:40:17Speaker 3: you have the original and you're comparing it to the
- 1:40:19Speaker 3: Q and A, and the Q and A is different
- 1:40:22Speaker 3: in a way that you don't like, then I you
- 1:40:25Speaker 3: should you should blame me. I mean, I I did it.
- 1:40:28Speaker 3: What can I said? I'm not gonna throw Leonard under
- 1:40:30Speaker 3: the under the bus because I could have you know,
- 1:40:33Speaker 3: if if I objected to something, I could have said so,
- 1:40:37Speaker 3: and sometimes I did and sometimes he said okay, and
- 1:40:41Speaker 3: other times he didn't.
- 1:40:42Speaker 1: And you know.
- 1:40:43Speaker 3: There it is.
- 1:40:47Speaker 2: Bakers as a donation for Robert's future translation of Nick
- 1:40:50Speaker 2: Nick Niki Machine Ethics. Ethics.
- 1:40:54Speaker 3: No, there's too many good ones, or at least okay
- 1:40:57Speaker 3: ones out there, so that one I'm not going to do.
- 1:41:00Speaker 3: I'm doing the Eudemian ethics now, which is the kind
- 1:41:03Speaker 3: of the the neglected step chot uh okay.
- 1:41:08Speaker 2: I didn't realize there were two ethics books.
- 1:41:10Speaker 3: Yeah, there are two. There actually there's four ethical works,
- 1:41:13Speaker 3: but two of them are by Aristotle. One of them
- 1:41:17Speaker 3: the Magnum Moorlia. People disagree, but but he probably wasn't
- 1:41:21Speaker 3: by him. And then there's one called Virtues and Vices,
- 1:41:24Speaker 3: which is likely not by him, almost certainly not by him.
- 1:41:28Speaker 2: But yeah, Andrew says, was there any ancient philosopher philosophy
- 1:41:36Speaker 2: that identified the principles of the initiation of forces evil?
- 1:41:40Speaker 2: What was Aristotle's position on force in social dealings?
- 1:41:48Speaker 3: I can't think of anyone who who puts it in
- 1:41:51Speaker 3: those terms, the initiation of force, I don't think so.
- 1:41:57Speaker 3: I mean, they have words like abuse and thing of
- 1:42:00Speaker 3: that sort, but what they talk about is there are crimes,
- 1:42:04Speaker 3: there are acts of injustice, and they would include you know,
- 1:42:08Speaker 3: murder and rate and things of that sort. But it's
- 1:42:11Speaker 3: treated as if these are wrong because they're unjust. That is,
- 1:42:18Speaker 3: an innocent person doesn't deserve to be treated this way.
- 1:42:22Speaker 3: And in creating a civil society, you're going to have
- 1:42:26Speaker 3: laws that that if if it's a just society, you know,
- 1:42:30Speaker 3: et cetera. So it's not it's gonna there won't be
- 1:42:33Speaker 3: a conception of rights. There a conception of of the
- 1:42:37Speaker 3: initiation of force. If if there is anything that comes
- 1:42:43Speaker 3: close to that, I'm not aware of it.
- 1:42:48Speaker 2: And to us asks can you put you on in
- 1:42:53Speaker 2: his place? And explain to him the romanticism applies to
- 1:42:58Speaker 2: not just literature but all the fineants.
- 1:43:02Speaker 3: No, you've asked the wrong person here, because I no.
- 1:43:08Speaker 3: I think I believe I've heard that exchange that you're
- 1:43:11Speaker 3: talking about. And if I remember correctly, I agreed with
- 1:43:17Speaker 3: your own what your own said. I think maybe at
- 1:43:19Speaker 3: the end of what your own said, you conceded a
- 1:43:21Speaker 3: little bit about maybe you'd call the David romantic or
- 1:43:23Speaker 3: something something like that. But I think there's a there's
- 1:43:26Speaker 3: a really good Q and A about that in the
- 1:43:28Speaker 3: Q and a book Ein Rand addresses that, and I
- 1:43:31Speaker 3: can still hear her voice. This is from the There
- 1:43:34Speaker 3: was a kind of extra Q and a session that
- 1:43:37Speaker 3: went off topic which was wonderful in the in the
- 1:43:40Speaker 3: nonfiction writing course, and someone asked her a question about
- 1:43:46Speaker 3: romanticism and painting. Would you call this one? And she
- 1:43:49Speaker 3: said something to the effect of, you know, sometimes, yeah,
- 1:43:53Speaker 3: there's something like that, but basically someone has to do
- 1:43:57Speaker 3: the work that she did in literature. Yeah, that is
- 1:44:01Speaker 3: she reconceptualized what we what romanticism was. Now, she didn't
- 1:44:07Speaker 3: rip it out of its historical context. Romanticism is something
- 1:44:10Speaker 3: that happened in history in the history of art. And
- 1:44:14Speaker 3: it's not something that you could, you know, say that, oh,
- 1:44:17Speaker 3: that's what Homer was doing. Now you might look at
- 1:44:21Speaker 3: you know, he's heroic and romantic art, but it was
- 1:44:24Speaker 3: something particular. And what she thought was that the people
- 1:44:29Speaker 3: who talked about Romanticism, they they conceptualized it improperly. They
- 1:44:37Speaker 3: said things like the Romanticists and in really really bad ways.
- 1:44:41Speaker 3: The Classicists were the ones who concerned with reason, and
- 1:44:44Speaker 3: the Romantics rejected that in favor of emotion and national
- 1:44:51Speaker 3: identity and things like that. She said, no, no, no,
- 1:44:54Speaker 3: that is that is such identification through non essentials. What
- 1:45:00Speaker 3: was really going on was with Romanticism was an emphasis
- 1:45:04Speaker 3: on values and on the independent choices and values of
- 1:45:09Speaker 3: the artist. And what you see is, you know, it's
- 1:45:13Speaker 3: not you know, some kind of music from the you know,
- 1:45:18Speaker 3: the medieval period where that all kind of sounds alike
- 1:45:21Speaker 3: or whatever, or certain kinds of sonnets or something. Well,
- 1:45:24Speaker 3: I don't want to get into poetry, I guess, but
- 1:45:26Speaker 3: romanticism you see that it's it's it's the recognition of values,
- 1:45:33Speaker 3: and that means that human beings have volition, they make
- 1:45:36Speaker 3: choices that are based on values and it's the interaction
- 1:45:40Speaker 3: of those choices that create a plot. That that's why
- 1:45:44Speaker 3: the plot is so important in romantic literature. So she's
- 1:45:48Speaker 3: reconceptualizing what and that's why she called it what is Romanticism?
- 1:45:52Speaker 3: Because it needed to be identified. And it's brilliant because
- 1:45:57Speaker 3: she doesn't, you know, she goes into a field and
- 1:46:00Speaker 3: even if you ask kind of experts in romantic literature
- 1:46:04Speaker 3: who are the major and they'll mention five people and
- 1:46:06Speaker 3: not mention Hugo and you know, so with her, you know,
- 1:46:11Speaker 3: you go as tops and Dostievskin and and they're very
- 1:46:14Speaker 3: different from from from Tolstoy. And so she did some
- 1:46:21Speaker 3: really heavy lifting intellectually to say the least to do that.
- 1:46:26Speaker 3: And what she said in this one little Q and
- 1:46:27Speaker 3: A is you have to do that. Someone has to
- 1:46:30Speaker 3: do that. In the field of the visual arts, for example,
- 1:46:33Speaker 3: and I imagine, I mean there's been some work that's
- 1:46:36Speaker 3: been done and that, you know, and not just by objectivists,
- 1:46:40Speaker 3: but I know Toro Buckman was starting to do some
- 1:46:42Speaker 3: in painting. He has a really excellent essay on cosper
- 1:46:47Speaker 3: David Friedrich, who regarded himself as a romantic and saw
- 1:46:52Speaker 3: himself as a romantic painter. But what it would mean
- 1:46:56Speaker 3: what were the painters who were calling themselves romantic, what
- 1:47:00Speaker 3: were they doing that was different from other schools, and
- 1:47:03Speaker 3: what were their motivations? And did it have anything to
- 1:47:06Speaker 3: do with the philosophers who were calling themselves romantic, who
- 1:47:09Speaker 3: seem you know, Schopenhower seems very different from Hugo. I mean,
- 1:47:15Speaker 3: I'm rand had to do that work, and you have
- 1:47:17Speaker 3: to do that work in all the visual fields. What
- 1:47:20Speaker 3: you can't do is or it can't because people do.
- 1:47:24Speaker 3: What you shouldn't do is claim that romanticism is anything
- 1:47:29Speaker 3: that I like, anything that especially that it glorifies human
- 1:47:33Speaker 3: beings or something like that. And you know, you can
- 1:47:36Speaker 3: make in a there could be an a static statue
- 1:47:41Speaker 3: of a of a human being, and what would make
- 1:47:44Speaker 3: it romantic? Maybe it is, but maybe it's it's not,
- 1:47:48Speaker 3: Maybe it's something different. Someone has to identify what exactly
- 1:47:52Speaker 3: romanticism is an apply because literature it's a conceptual, you know,
- 1:47:58Speaker 3: it deals with concepts, and so you know that's something
- 1:48:02Speaker 3: very different. And so if ein Ran identifies that what's
- 1:48:05Speaker 3: central to it is not only the artists own value
- 1:48:11Speaker 3: judgments and and values generally, but also that the the
- 1:48:16Speaker 3: the characters in the fiction, uh, have free will and
- 1:48:20Speaker 3: they're acting according to it, and it's all integrated by plot.
- 1:48:26Speaker 3: What would that mean for a painting, It's it's really
- 1:48:31Speaker 3: it's quite difficult, uh, I mean to to sort that out.
- 1:48:36Speaker 3: So I I tend not to use the term. And
- 1:48:39Speaker 3: if you're talking about I mean, there are some painters
- 1:48:41Speaker 3: in their historians who speak of a period that is,
- 1:48:44Speaker 3: you know, Romanticism in the visual arts, and certainly Romanticism
- 1:48:48Speaker 3: and music. And I mean, at a gut level, roch
- 1:48:52Speaker 3: Mononoff seems different to me than Bach. But how I
- 1:48:57Speaker 3: would identify that. Yeah, that's not my area at all.
- 1:49:01Speaker 3: But but yeah, so I would. I would not. I
- 1:49:05Speaker 3: would not put your own in this place.
- 1:49:07Speaker 2: I would this time anyway, Thank you, Eric, Sorry Andrew,
- 1:49:11Speaker 2: next time. All right, So they and a little synthetic
- 1:49:16Speaker 2: economy is going to try you one more time, see
- 1:49:20Speaker 2: says follow up, Being, which is sin is what comes
- 1:49:25Speaker 2: before existence? Sind this for Plato, for instance, being would
- 1:49:31Speaker 2: be thefones for Aristotle, it's nature.
- 1:49:38Speaker 3: I don't think anything comes before existence. And I don't
- 1:49:41Speaker 3: know that we would have a basis for conversation about this,
- 1:49:44Speaker 3: because existence exists. It's the very first thing. And even
- 1:49:49Speaker 3: being you know, I ran quotes Arizonal and metaphysics deals
- 1:49:54Speaker 3: with being qua being not just another way of talking
- 1:49:57Speaker 3: about existence as such as she puts it. So those
- 1:50:00Speaker 3: are those are synonyms in a way. Now, maybe if
- 1:50:05Speaker 3: I gave it some thought, which I haven't done, I
- 1:50:08Speaker 3: would think that there's existence emphasizes different, something different.
- 1:50:12Speaker 2: From because he says not existence existence existence.
- 1:50:20Speaker 3: Okay, I I don't think I have anything to say
- 1:50:23Speaker 3: about this existence. Yeah, I mean the Platonists talk about,
- 1:50:31Speaker 3: you know, something that's even beyond existence, but that well
- 1:50:37Speaker 3: non existence. Yeah, I don't.
- 1:50:39Speaker 2: I don't yep.
- 1:50:42Speaker 3: Yeah, I would have to read something in more detail
- 1:50:45Speaker 3: than this. I apologize if we're not connecting.
- 1:50:50Speaker 2: All right, I think that's it. Okay, we've run out
- 1:50:55Speaker 2: of questions. We've gone two hours. That's great.
- 1:50:58Speaker 3: Yeah I was. I would worry that you'll be hearing
- 1:51:01Speaker 3: crickets after forty five minutes with you know, a big guys.
- 1:51:04Speaker 2: So yeah, there's people are interested, people are interested.
- 1:51:08Speaker 3: Yeah, I've enjoyed it. Well, we can do it again sometimes.
- 1:51:11Speaker 2: Absolutely, this was fun. Yeah, absolutely we should do it
- 1:51:14Speaker 2: again and into some of these issues. Thanks Rob, yeah,
- 1:51:19Speaker 2: my pleasure to you too, but bye.