Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 6 Episode 1: "Just Leave": Examining Displacement-Based Responses to Domestic Violence
Transcript
- 0:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And we're back, and we're back, hello there.
- 0:19David Mandel: Hi there, how are you?
- 0:20David Mandel: I'm good.
- 0:21David Mandel: Welcome to our first episode of 2025 of Partner with a Survivor, and I'm David Mandel.
- 0:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I'm Ruth Ramunda Mandel.
- 0:29David Mandel: And we are joining you from where.
- 0:31Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We are joining you from the island of San Miguel in the Azores and I'm going to do a little land acknowledgement.
- 0:40David Mandel: Great.
- 0:41Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I would like to acknowledge the traditional owners of the land, who we do not know who they are, because when the Portuguese came they said there was nobody here.
- 0:49Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But my family has lived on these islands for as long as the records were kept.
- 0:57David Mandel: Like 500 years Over.
- 0:59David Mandel: Okay, over 500 years, yeah.
- 1:01Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And we are on volcanic island soil out in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean.
- 1:10David Mandel: Sitting between the European and the North American geological regions.
- 1:17David Mandel: So we're like in liminal space.
- 1:19David Mandel: Yes, in liminal space.
- 1:20Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Truly liminal space.
- 1:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And it is a gorgeous day.
- 1:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is sunny, it is almost neon green outside because of the nutrients and the seawater that the island provides all of us, and you may be able to hear the wind, which has a true presence on this island, and the birds.
- 1:46Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So we are joining you from my father's family's volcanic island lands and it's so good to be here.
- 1:55David Mandel: It is Okay.
- 1:56David Mandel: So, in that vein, felice Anonovo, happy New Year, yes, okay to everyone wherever you are, nice, portuguese.
- 2:06David Mandel: Good for Felice Anonovo, do you like that?
- 2:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I hope all of our Portuguese listeners appreciate that David and I are stumbling through learning Portuguese, which I did not learn as a child growing up in an institution in California because I was not connected to my Azorean family, but I did learn how to speak Spanish, which breaks your brain for Portuguese is my opinion.
- 2:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, it's hard to move between one and the other it really does.
- 2:36David Mandel: So we've been talking behind the scenes, you and I, about this.
- 2:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We talk behind the scenes all the time we do.
- 2:42David Mandel: We do.
- 2:44David Mandel: We do talk all the time.
- 2:45David Mandel: We live together, work together, raise children together.
- 2:48David Mandel: But we've been talking behind the scenes about partnering and ideas about responsive systems and the big thing, that kind of rose to the top that you've been talking to me a lot about, is sort of talking to you or at you a lot about with me with me.
- 3:08David Mandel: It's been mostly a conversation.
- 3:10David Mandel: I don't know you, you know sometimes I just vent, but yes, that's okay too.
- 3:15David Mandel: Um, and you've been you've been talking about displacement based responses.
- 3:22David Mandel: Yeah, and use that word displacement, I think I want to center that word and sort of the kind of inherent unfairness.
- 3:31David Mandel: Gender, double standards and the gender double standards embedded in this idea that well, why don't you explain it?
- 3:38David Mandel: Why don't you talk?
- 3:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: about it.
- 3:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I fully recognize and I want to acknowledge the need for displacement-based responses for physical safety, and there is a real need to have places for victims of domestic abuse, particularly women and children, where they can be safe from a perpetrator.
- 3:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But the reason that that necessity arises is fundamentally out of our system of gender double standards, in a context where women did not have the ability to own access and have access to financial and housing and property resources.
- 4:33Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And so, once women started to gain ownership and not be viewed simply as wards of men or property of men or under the care of men, that we then were operating in a system that was demanding us to abandon access to our housing, to our education, to our financial assets, to our safety networks, to our resources, in order for us to find physical safety from a person who is choosing or using criminal violence.
- 5:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's the only crime where we focus on the victim and we force them to be displaced.
- 5:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And now, in a context where, in certain cultures, women have more ownership of property, of financial assets they're equal co-owners, they're co-responsible for those assets.
- 5:37Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We know that displacement-based responses cause a tremendous amount of vulnerability.
- 5:42Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Their primary drivers domestic violence and the assumption that victims must leave their own homes is a primary driver of unhousedness, and unhousedness is a crisis in every single country that we are operating in and, in fact, many victims cannot get refuge spaces because there is a lack of housing.
- 6:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So continuing to operate under a gender double standard assumption, where women are not co-owners of property, do not have access to financial bank resources, and forcing them to abandon their homes and assets in order to find physical safety from a person who is using criminal violence, who should be addressed by the law and by every single system, is not okay.
- 6:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's dangerous, it causes tremendous vulnerability.
- 6:44Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It does not guard or safeguard against post-separation coercive control.
- 6:48Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is extremely time limited.
- 6:51Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is displacement based victims to delay trying to find interventions because the only way that they see forward is leaving their homes that they worked hard for, leaving their financial and bank assets, and we know that once a victim leaves, that, that pressure actually increases with coercive control and oftentimes that perpetrator then takes those assets those assets which are co-owned and leverages them, uses them, wastes them, robs their children of those resources in order to continue their post-separation control and abuse in financial ways, in legal ways, in housed ways, by controlling housing or getting them kicked out of housing or having people evicted.
- 7:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So this is not a system that would have arose had men been the primary victims of domestic abuse, with their male privilege.
- 8:07Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We would have said what, what crazy, crazy to ask a man to lose his rights, to lose access to his financial assets, to leave their hard-earned home.
- 8:22David Mandel: Well, man's a man's home is his castle.
- 8:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Ah, there we go.
- 8:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's exactly it.
- 8:27David Mandel: A man's home is his castle kind of summarizes a lot of that for me.
- 8:30Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And women just live in it.
- 8:31David Mandel: Well, I think you really I mean to me I've got so many thoughts.
- 8:35David Mandel: I love the way your brain works.
- 8:36David Mandel: I always want people to.
- 8:38David Mandel: You can't see us, but just you know, the way you put things together and the way you think about things is always exciting for me and challenging sometimes, which is okay, you know.
- 8:50David Mandel: But I love the way you're connecting the dots here, you know.
- 8:53David Mandel: One of the things I'm thinking about is, you know, the refuge movement, which is really the seeds of this idea that leaving is the answer.
- 9:01David Mandel: You know.
- 9:03Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well, you know, I want to give a real nod to the refuge yeah, yeah you know I don't talk a lot about it, but some of on my mother's side, some of my people, are very well-known abolitionists and they ran the underground railroad and it's not similar to this, because this is not chattel slavery like.
- 9:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I just want to say that up front.
- 9:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I understand that in extreme conditions the need for displacement can be very real, but by making that a primary quote, unquote intervention strategy, we're actually destabilizing people further.
- 9:36David Mandel: Well, the thing you know, the connection I make is one is that that refuge movement, that crisis response movement arose and that's all you're talking about.
- 9:46David Mandel: Women didn't have credit cards.
- 9:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It was a context, it was contextual, and there's some places that are still like that.
- 9:52Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's right.
- 9:53Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's right.
- 9:55David Mandel: And what's happened is and my take on this has been that we often look at a survivor who goes to refuge or leaves a relationship.
- 10:04David Mandel: We see her as taking the necessary steps to protect herself and her kids, and then often criticize her if she doesn't right.
- 10:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Worse than that.
- 10:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Worse than that, we take her children.
- 10:15Ruth Reymundo Mandel: If she doesn't, that's right.
- 10:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: If somebody gets hurt by the perpetrator, we charge her double the crime.
- 10:20David Mandel: Or she ends up in a house, she goes to jail two times longer, or she ends up in.
- 10:24David Mandel: She goes to jail two times longer, or she ends up in an unhoused situation, she may lose her kids.
- 10:27David Mandel: But I think we forget and this is what, and even for me I've had to really question myself and kind of land in saying wait a second.
- 10:35David Mandel: We can see refuges as necessary evils.
- 10:37David Mandel: We can see refuges as important steps to somebody getting away from violence, if that's what they need and that's important.
- 10:43David Mandel: And there is somebody who is forcing that and then a system that is in many cases actually enabling that or expecting that of her.
- 10:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Okay, so I'm going to give you an example, and not holding him accountable for that, I'm going to give you an example anonymized.
- 11:00David Mandel: Okay.
- 11:00Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Somebody recently contacted me who is a frontline practitioner who works with domestic violence victims and child protection and had talked about how frustrated they were Because, as a victim survivor they knew that what the organization they were working for was asking was wrong, Right.
- 11:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And they were frustrated because they had these cases that they needed to work through and there was their supervisor and manager saying pressure her to leave and if she doesn't leave, do domestic abuse training where she understands how bad domestic abuse is for her and her kids.
- 11:41Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That was their solution and this person that was the magic.
- 11:44David Mandel: I write about that in my book.
- 11:45David Mandel: I write about the magic of insight.
- 11:47David Mandel: The magic of insight.
- 11:47David Mandel: If we could just make her aware, she'll do the right thing.
- 11:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I never knew.
- 11:51Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So she was very frustrated as a worker, as a lived experience person.
- 11:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: She was feeling that she was doing destructive things Because it is destructive, and so she started to engage in the training, particularly around working with men as parents, and she wrote and she said thank you so much.
- 12:14Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I felt like I had no direction, no skills, no actual concrete training from my organization beyond.
- 12:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Go tell the survivor how bad domestic abuse is for her and I was doing things that was pressurizing her and she was starting to not you know whatever, just it's not effective.
- 12:35David Mandel: Well, and you told me about this, which is, this was a survivor who wanted, wanted and this, to me, is really important, I know it's important to you too wanted to stay, wanted to stay, yes, wants to do this, and wanted and I think even wanted to be in the relationship that wanted to stay, wanted to stay and wanted and I think even wanted to be in the relationship, but wanted to be better, and I think this is for me.
- 12:52David Mandel: It's the autonomy thing, the the autonomy part, which is, um, that survivors have the right to make a decision, to say you know, this is my partner, I deserve to be safe, I want to, I want to see if this can continue, and the message that I remember that was being told was we don't work with perpetrators.
- 13:12David Mandel: You've got to get her to leave and this is the message I've been hearing for you know for different systems.
- 13:19David Mandel: And again, remember, this is layered because that's coming from a domestic abuse service.
- 13:24David Mandel: But that message is often picked up by a child protection service or a family court service, where in the child protection system that survivor who won't leave a seat into failure to protect, or in the family court system, where they take it as well.
- 13:40David Mandel: Once you're out, the issue's over.
- 13:42David Mandel: It's historic, irrelevant to the family matter.
- 13:44Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well, it's even worse than that.
- 13:45Ruth Reymundo Mandel: In the family court, people who have fled to refuge have been charged with parental alienation by their perpetrators.
- 13:51Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Okay Right, let's just be super clear Right, that's right.
- 13:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Fleeing is not necessarily safe.
- 13:57David Mandel: That's right.
- 13:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Now, in a system which defines safety as mere immediate lethality.
- 14:05Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right maybe we've contrived a very temporary type of safety, but to me, safety is not just about if I'm dead or not and if that's the way that most professionals view safety.
- 14:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We have a bigger conversation that we need to have Right, Because it is unsafe for children and victim survivors to be unhoused.
- 14:33Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We know this.
- 14:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is unsafe for children and victim survivors to lack financial resources to feed themselves to feed themselves.
- 14:52Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Our definition of safety as being merely whether or not a perpetrator is immediately going to murder somebody is a poor definition of safety, which comes about in a system that's incident-based right and that doesn't have any other strategies for assisting people or focusing on the person who's choosing harm so there's power in my mind to this idea of referring to this as displacement-based strategies or policies, because it helps label it, I think, in some ways as the disruptive nature of it.
- 15:37David Mandel: I guess is thinking about the disruptive nature of it.
- 15:39David Mandel: It's disrupting Right we made it very friendly, just leave.
- 15:44David Mandel: Oh just leave.
- 15:46Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It sounds like you're going on vacation, just leave.
- 15:48Ruth Reymundo Mandel: What refugees, refugees?
- 15:50David Mandel: refugees right, we look at refugees as being victims of a circumstance or situation war.
- 15:55David Mandel: Right, you know natural disasters, you know um uh, famine, whatever.
- 16:01David Mandel: People become refugees from their own homes yes and they, they.
- 16:07David Mandel: In my limited understanding, I really haven't thought about this before, but as refugees they hold a right of return that you know in theory.
- 16:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: In theory.
- 16:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: In theory okay.
- 16:19David Mandel: But I think in some sense again, we are talking about the framework.
- 16:22David Mandel: I know you and I had this discussion behind the scenes about what is practice and what's the theory Right.
- 16:26David Mandel: But I think the theory is important because the theory is the language and the language is is kind of helps shape out what is legitimate and what's not.
- 16:33David Mandel: And I think the language of refugees really brings with it as failed as the response globally is to refugees, let's kind of just say that is this idea that these people have the right to that homeland, to that place they came from, from where they started.
- 16:49David Mandel: That is, even as failure is kind of at the center of some international tensions right.
- 16:55David Mandel: So I think it's this idea that using displacement language builds in this sort of tension, which is saying wait a second, I've been displaced.
- 17:04Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah.
- 17:04David Mandel: When we make it sound like, oh, we've created safety for you.
- 17:07Ruth Reymundo Mandel: No, I'm so sorry.
- 17:09Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We've created safety for you.
- 17:10Ruth Reymundo Mandel: No, by giving you this refuge, right, but I think that's where thank you for creating a space where I wasn't immediately going to die, but that is not actually creating safety and we know with and we know with refugees.
- 17:19David Mandel: I guess kind of to kind of go with this, this kind of analogy or this kind of which is refugees lose connection to land, right to the, the places that hold their traditions and their customs.
- 17:30David Mandel: They may bring some of that with them, obviously, food and spirituality, but they may to sacred places.
- 17:37Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Access to their financial resources, their financial resources.
- 17:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Their homes are off and their land is off, and that's right.
- 17:42David Mandel: All these things and we know this, and I think the same things can be said about many survivors, which is that in them moving and it's not just say First Nation people who have a strong connection to land, but anybody who's embedded in community homes, kids who like their rooms, who are familiar or comforted by a room or a neighborhood, or friends down the street or a teacher they love, or are known by the doctors I mean, all these things are the cost of displacement-based practices which, again, might be necessary in some circumstances but shouldn't be held up as, oh look, we've created safety for you.
- 18:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: They should not be held up as the measure of best practice.
- 18:20Ruth Reymundo Mandel: This is the worst case scenario.
- 18:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: This should be the worst case scenario.
- 18:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: This should not be.
- 18:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: The bar that we are shooting for Is removal of people from their homes because we won't, we refuse to deal with the person who's causing the problem.
- 18:38David Mandel: Right, so this is the gender bias piece you're talking about, which is it covers up and makes it harder, and this is part of what the model talks about To deal with the perpetrator, the perpetrator.
- 18:48David Mandel: It makes their responsibility harder to pin down, because their behavior is creating the disruption in combination with our failure to find ways to address them.
- 19:00Ruth Reymundo Mandel: If, in my opinion as a lived experience expert, if a perpetrator causes children and their partner to be unhoused, they should be charged with failure to protect their children.
- 19:14Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right, they should be charged, as parents, with endangering their children.
- 19:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: If a parent is so violent and dysfunctional that they cause instability in the family, that they unhouse their own family, that they cause poverty to the point where children are starving, they should be charged with failure to protect.
- 19:39David Mandel: That's right.
- 19:40David Mandel: So this is what we try to do with the multiple pathways to harm framework in the model.
- 19:44David Mandel: So one of the things to pivot, know to pivot.
- 19:47David Mandel: So we kind of naming this um displacement idea right.
- 19:54David Mandel: I I think one of the ways that I and I'm actually working on a um, uh linkedin article about this right now, which is about about sort of what does it mean to really shift the conversation.
- 20:07David Mandel: You were having a you and I were having a discussion about the word safety and how do you change the meaning, and I think we're on the same page.
- 20:12David Mandel: Well, I think safety means different things to different systems.
- 20:15Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I mean in child protection safety means one thing, in law enforcement safety means another.
- 20:20Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I don't even think law enforcement is more concerned about just the minutia of the legality of the law rather than safety.
- 20:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I think people who operate under the assumption more concerned about just the minutiae of the legality of the law rather than safety Right.
- 20:31Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I think people who operate under the assumption that law enforcement officers are trying to keep people safe don't understand how the law works.
- 20:38David Mandel: No, and I think a lot of people would agree with you, because you have to have something have happened to you already in many cases that's correct.
- 20:44David Mandel: So I was talking about and thinking about this child protection expert who said something that stuck with me for 25 years and he said child protection is getting it wrong when they're talking about abuse and neglect of children by centering physical safety as the driver of their policies and their services and their tools and everything else they said.
- 21:10David Mandel: This person said we should be centering well-being.
- 21:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I don't, I don't.
- 21:14Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Actually, I think that when you say child protection is focused as centering physical safety, yes you're, that definition of physical safety is an extremely narrow definition that really truly doesn't include what most people would consider physical safety.
- 21:34Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It really truly is about immediate lethality period.
- 21:39David Mandel: Yeah, an absence of physical violence right now.
- 21:41David Mandel: And I mean, and really you know, look at Maslow's hierarchy of needs, safety is like the second thing after breathing, but really breathing.
- 21:50David Mandel: When you talk about physical safety, strangulation, other stuff, they're actually right there together.
- 21:54David Mandel: What he was saying that I really hold on to I think that may offer some of the way forward with this is that if you center well-being, physical safety is a given in the sense of you have to address it but, you actually prioritize people thriving, not just surviving.
- 22:14David Mandel: You prioritize stability, safety, emotional connection, and you can't have emotional connection if you're in danger, if you're busy figuring out how to stay safe physically in the moment right If you're in crisis mode.
- 22:28David Mandel: And his thought was if you center your policy and your response system around well-being and saying children deserve to thrive, and then you're going to kind of line up everything the right way and I think with the shift to kind of focus on coercive control, the time is ripe, because coercive control tells time is ripe yeah, because course control tells us we we shouldn't just be focused about physical injury or danger of lethality, but entrapment and control over social.
- 22:56Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I gotta I gotta tell you that when you talk about this, though I agree with you what I see in my head is like a train conductor who has a system and a track that they need to go down, saying, yeah, that's great man, but how do we do it?
- 23:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Because the whole system has been set up in a really specific way to very much focus only on lethality.
- 23:30Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And when you say well-being and quality of life and all that stuff, a lot of us agree with you.
- 23:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But ultimately, at the end of the day, when you get into some of these huge systems, these huge health social care systems, and they're very much focused on efficiency, that's where we start to have a divergence of practice.
- 23:54David Mandel: So this is a big conversation, and we discussed keeping our episodes a little bit shorter.
- 24:02Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We're going to try, we're going to try.
- 24:04David Mandel: We'll see how we do.
- 24:04David Mandel: So let me see if I can land this concept and land this, because I'd really like for people who are in, for example.
- 24:09David Mandel: We're going to try, we're going to try.
- 24:09Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We'll see how we do.
- 24:10Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So let me see if I can land this concept and land this.
- 24:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Maybe this Because I would, no, because I'd really like for people who are in, for example, child protection systems, which are really specific law enforcement, family law, to really understand.
- 24:20Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I don't believe that debating whether or not safety means just immediate physical lethality or demise is a good way for us to concretize this type of practice.
- 24:35David Mandel: I agree with you, but I think I think one of the ways to concretize it in my mind is that we really approach safety, these situations, with a really deep listening and partnering mentality.
- 24:54David Mandel: I think systems often come at these situations with how do we triage risk of severe violence and lethality and that's what's built into tools.
- 25:05Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Add one more thing to that.
- 25:06David Mandel: Okay.
- 25:07Ruth Reymundo Mandel: How do we mitigate risk and lethality so that we reduce our liability if we're engaged with this family and potentially somebody might die?
- 25:20David Mandel: Yes, I mean, I love cranky survivors who are being like.
- 25:24David Mandel: Let's name this driving force of reducing liability, and I agree with you about that.
- 25:29David Mandel: I think that's many decisions are made with a CYA mentality, both at the individual level but also at the system level, policy level as well.
- 25:36David Mandel: Yeah, but what I want to say is, what would it look like to concretize this the way you're saying it, if we really valued what survivors say is important to them?
- 25:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: To their safety and well-being.
- 25:49David Mandel: To their safety and well-being and the well-being and safety of their kids.
- 25:52David Mandel: Which could be about?
- 25:54David Mandel: I just want my kids to finish this year up in high school.
- 25:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: At their school.
- 26:00David Mandel: At their school and go to university.
- 26:02David Mandel: Yeah, that's what's important to me right now.
- 26:05David Mandel: I've been living with this for 15 years.
- 26:07David Mandel: You know you've got involved as a professional.
- 26:10David Mandel: This is your crisis, not mine.
- 26:11David Mandel: You know you've got involved as a professional.
- 26:13David Mandel: This is your crisis, not mine.
- 26:15David Mandel: My crisis quote unquote is my objective is to get my kid launched into the world.
- 26:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Safely.
- 26:22David Mandel: Safely, with a chance that they'll have a successful life.
- 26:24David Mandel: What can you do for me to help me and, yeah, help me be as physically safe as possible, help me make my situation better and better to me looks like maybe my physical safety and my kid getting to university.
- 26:36David Mandel: What can you do for me that gives me both those things?
- 26:39David Mandel: Don't make me choose between the two.
- 26:40David Mandel: And I think that's a concretization of that in my mind.
- 26:48David Mandel: At least one possible way is are we really listening and valuing survivors choice making autonomy prior to their prioritization, their way of understanding well-being and safety, and are we listening to that and this goes to children survivors as well, but but anyway, I I think it's just sort of an it's, it's one concrete way keep going back to that word to kind of respond to well, what do we do instead of displacement-based practice?
- 27:18Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right.
- 27:18David Mandel: Okay, so that's my thought about what we can do differently, right?
- 27:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: well, one of my thoughts about what we can do differently and I'm going to use child protection as an example because they're the largest in my mind conflict with real, true well-being and safety for adult and child victim survivors.
- 27:35Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Once we're in that system and the system is focused on us as parents rather than focusing on the perpetrator, we are actually in greater danger in multiple ways from multiple pathways.
- 27:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We're in danger from the system itself removing our children.
- 27:54Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We're also in danger greatly from the perpetrator who leverages the fact that we're in child protection involved.
- 28:01Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You know contact against us.
- 28:05Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So one of the ways that we can really shift this is to change the way that we think about safety.
- 28:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: To just continue to say things like if you unhous your children, you are creating unsafety.
- 28:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I understand that we have to operate as practitioners with very specific mandates.
- 28:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right, that say, you know if a child dies, that we have to review our practices and understand what went wrong from the system's standpoint.
- 28:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right, what did we not do?
- 28:42Ruth Reymundo Mandel: What could we have done?
- 28:45Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But at the same time, if you're setting such a low bar for safety, you are missing so much information about the patterns that are causing that unsafety.
- 28:57Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You are not engaging in conversation, assessment, assessment, assessment, basic assessment of what it is that may be causing unsafety.
- 29:10Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And we know that child protection will take our children if our perpetrator unhouses us.
- 29:18Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We know this.
- 29:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So many many survivors are forced to stay in their homes with a perpetrator and then, if something happens, be charged with a crime.
- 29:31Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So if we know that the way that we are operating in this space is pressurizing people into behaviors and actions which lead to unsafety, which lead to those things, we have a responsibility as practitioners, as professionals and as systems to say how can we do this better?
- 29:56David Mandel: So I think, to move us to wrapping up, one of the things that you're hearing you say is let's widen and deepen our definition of safety and who we hold responsible for disrupting safety If a perpetrator creates a scenario where a kid is more vulnerable to drugs or loses housing, that kind of thing.
- 30:15Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Or loses contact with their school.
- 30:18David Mandel: That's right and I'm saying, you know, let's add in and prioritize and this is additive, these are not in opposition, you know really deepen our commitment to listening to survivors and autonomy and their choice making, and also talk more about well-being, talk more about those things.
- 30:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And create a range of options for survivors and victims of domestic abuse, from the most critical, the most urgent, where we have to offer somebody displacement-based responses, just for them to be safe.
- 30:51David Mandel: Offer somebody displacement-based responses just for them to be safe, and don't judge them when they resist or they don't want to take those steps, or don't make them the problem.
- 31:00David Mandel: And I think that's where I think you and I are very much on the same page, which is, these systems make survivors the problem.
- 31:06David Mandel: When they won't leave, they'll judge them as failing to protect, they'll judge them as being in denial, and that's what we're really speaking about.
- 31:15David Mandel: So I think we did it.
- 31:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Did we do it?
- 31:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, I think so.
- 31:19David Mandel: I think it's close to just oh, it's just over.
- 31:21David Mandel: It's 31 minutes.
- 31:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's just over.
- 31:23David Mandel: We were so close.
- 31:24David Mandel: This is my challenge to myself, and we did well, I think.
- 31:28David Mandel: So you have been listening to Partner with a Survivor, and if you want to learn more about the Safer Together Institute, go to safertogetherinstitutecom.
- 31:37David Mandel: If you want to take any of our e-courses, go to academysafertogetherinstitutecom.
- 31:42David Mandel: If you want to, I reference my book.
- 31:45Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Go to amazoncom, amazoncom.
- 31:48David Mandel: And the book is called Stop Blaming Mothers and Ignore Fathers how to Transform the Way we Keep Children Safe from Domestic Violence and we are out.
- 32:00Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Feliz Ano Novo, thank you.