Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / When a Child Needs a Voice: The Work of Minor's Counsel and Perspectives From the Bench
Transcript
- 0:03Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome. I'm Michael
- 0:07Hanasov. I'm the co -chair of the Beverly Hills
- 0:09Bar Family Law Section, and welcome to session
- 0:12one of the Family Law Symposium, The Custody
- 0:15Compass, Decoding Best Interests. First, we'd
- 0:18like to thank our sponsors. The Family Law Section
- 0:22is sponsored by White, Zuckerman, Versovsky,
- 0:25Luna, Hunt, LLP, Lawyer Mutual Insurance Company,
- 0:29Soberlink, and Our Family Wizard. White, Zuckerman,
- 0:32Mussofsky, Luna, and Hunt provide a wide variety
- 0:35of resources to complete almost any project,
- 0:38large or small. They also provide traditional
- 0:41accountant and tax practice services. We invite
- 0:44you to contact them to discuss your specific
- 0:46accountant needs and learn how they can be of
- 0:49service to you. Learn more at WZWLH .com. Soberwing
- 0:55provides objective real -time data that can be
- 0:58used to reduce disputes over alcohol consumption.
- 1:01leading to less conflict and custody cases. To
- 1:04help ensure smoother negotiations for a more
- 1:07efficient legal process, consider using SoberLink's
- 1:10trusted alcohol monitoring system to eliminate
- 1:13hearsay and protect your client's best interests.
- 1:16With an unprecedented combination of features
- 1:18including advanced reporting, facial recognition,
- 1:22tamper resistance, real -time results, and customized
- 1:25testing, the discrete system has been the leader
- 1:28in remote alcohol monitoring since 2011. Learn
- 1:31more at soberlink .com. For five decades, Lawyer
- 1:36Mutual Insurance Company has been the only California
- 1:39-based company to continuously provide lawyers
- 1:41throughout the state with professional liability
- 1:44insurance. Their experience and expertise are
- 1:47complemented by the fact that LMIC is directed
- 1:51by a group of dedicated lawyers. They offer special
- 1:54rates with competitive premiums for a wide range
- 1:57of areas of practice, including family law. Learn
- 2:00more at lawyermutual .com. Lastly, our family
- 2:03wizard is a co -parenting platform designed to
- 2:07help families communicate more effectively, reduce
- 2:09conflict, and create reliable court admissible
- 2:13records. Features like tone meter AI, shared
- 2:16calendar, expense tracking, and in -app audio,
- 2:20and video call, and help support compliance and
- 2:22better outcomes for families navigating custody
- 2:25disputes. Now. on to today's program and to introduce
- 2:29the speakers. When a child needs a voice, the
- 2:33work of minors council and perspectives from
- 2:35the bench, we have Callie Kramer, who's a partner
- 2:38at Summer Levine Lipstick and Hirsch LLP. With
- 2:41nearly 20 years of family law experience, including
- 2:45a focus on complex custody matters, where she
- 2:47often serves as a court appointed minors council.
- 2:50Before joining Summer's Levine, she spent over
- 2:53a decade practicing in New York City. including
- 2:56as a supervising court attorney in New York and
- 3:00as a staff attorney for the Children's Law Center
- 3:02in Brooklyn. With us today is also Commissioner
- 3:05Kendra Thomas, who serves as a family law commissioner
- 3:07in L .A. County, specifically in Chatsworth in
- 3:10Department F -58. Her role involves presiding
- 3:13over various family law matters. She assumed
- 3:16this position in February of 2024. Additionally,
- 3:20Commissioner Thomas is a certified family law
- 3:22specialist and previously practiced at Thomas
- 3:25Law Offices, a firm she founded in 2007. And
- 3:28lastly, our third speaker today is Judge Sonia
- 3:32Dijon, who is a judge at the Los Angeles Superior
- 3:34Court also in Chatsworth in Department F -48.
- 3:38Her judicial responsibilities primarily involve
- 3:40family law. Judge Dijon has a rich background
- 3:43in family law, having been admitted to the bar
- 3:45in 1999. Before her judicial appointment, she
- 3:49worked extensively in private practice, focusing
- 3:51on custody issues, and often served as minors
- 3:54counsel in family and probate and guardian cases.
- 3:57Now, on to the speakers. Let's get started. Thank
- 4:01you, Mike. I think I can say I speak for all
- 4:03of us in saying that we appreciate the invitation
- 4:05and we're delighted to be here to address this
- 4:08topic. Let's start from the top. Commissioner
- 4:12Thomas, can we first talk about when a bench
- 4:16officer may decide that minors counsel should
- 4:18be appointed to a case. Absolutely. So I don't
- 4:24think the starting point is simply whether a
- 4:26family or parents are experiencing high conflict,
- 4:29because I think I can speak for Judge Dujon when
- 4:31I say that we see high conflict cases every day.
- 4:35So the question for me is whether there's something
- 4:37about this particular child or this particular
- 4:39dispute that makes it difficult for the child's
- 4:44circumstances, needs or voice. and where I need
- 4:47that to be adequately presented. And where I'm
- 4:50not finding that that's adequately presented
- 4:52through the parents. So I'm looking at a child
- 4:55whose experience appears materially different
- 4:57from the narratives being presented by either
- 5:00parent, a mature child with significant views
- 5:02about custody or visitation, where maybe there's
- 5:05a refuse resist dynamic, where the reason for
- 5:08the child's resistance is potentially disputed
- 5:11between the parents, if there's serious allegations,
- 5:14DV, substance abuse, mental health, questions
- 5:17regarding medical school, therapeutic, developmental,
- 5:21or collateral information that's just not developed
- 5:23or the information's not being given to me, or
- 5:26were cases where the child risks becoming the
- 5:28battleground between the parents and I want to
- 5:31ensure that the litigation is just not weaponized.
- 5:36And what is the court hoping to the appointment
- 5:40of Miners' Council will accomplish for you? Well,
- 5:43I'm hoping to receive advocacy that's informed
- 5:46by meaningful investigation. And please understand
- 5:51that I'm not saying I need Miners' Council to
- 5:52go out and be a PI for me, but I want Council
- 5:56to know the child, know the record, identify
- 5:59the relevant issues, investigate red flags, tell
- 6:02me what supports the position Council is taking
- 6:05to bring me admissible evidence. I don't need
- 6:08Miners Council to decide the case for me. That's
- 6:11my job. But I'm looking for someone to legitimately
- 6:16bring the interest and the advocacy from all
- 6:20aspects regarding the minor child and be able
- 6:23to help articulate it on my record. And I think
- 6:27if I could just add to that also to take into
- 6:31account if there are any service providers for
- 6:35the minor child, what that what their experiences
- 6:42regarding the child's needs, and that may be
- 6:46information that should remain confidential,
- 6:50but Minors Council can take it into consideration
- 6:53when advocating for best interest. And that's
- 6:57what... also part of what I hope to accomplish
- 7:00when appointing minors council, if there are
- 7:03service providers, whether it be therapist, whether
- 7:07it be any type of occupational therapist or any
- 7:11other needs the child is receiving services for,
- 7:15and even teachers and education. So I think that
- 7:21sometimes minors council can take information
- 7:23into account. help determine best interest, that
- 7:28might be confidential information. Thank you.
- 7:32Sorry. And from the bench's perspective, does
- 7:35every difficult or high -conflict custody case
- 7:39require the appointment of Minor's Counsel? Absolutely
- 7:44not. In fact, I'll share a little anecdote. My
- 7:46first week in Chatsworth, I was on the... I was
- 7:50on the bench and trying to get the lay of the
- 7:51land. And in the majority of the custody cases,
- 7:55when I would rule, a hand would invariably shoot
- 7:58up and say, minor's counsel. And that's when
- 8:01I really had to realize that minor's counsel
- 8:05I look at is a tool for the court. Um, and so
- 8:08if I'm going to appoint minors council, I need
- 8:10to understand what I need that tool for. I am
- 8:14looking for information advocacy assistance that
- 8:18I otherwise could not receive. So, no. when it's
- 8:22clear what's going on, I don't necessarily need
- 8:25a minor's counsel to come in and tell me, your
- 8:27honor, these parents are in conflict. There's
- 8:30usually something, which is why we need to identify
- 8:33the scope of appointment and what we are looking
- 8:35for in why we're making said appointment. So
- 8:40let's look at that then. Judge Dujon, how does
- 8:43the court select a minor's counsel appointment
- 8:47for a case? So there's a lot that I take into
- 8:54account, I am not every attorney that serves
- 8:58as my nurse counsel is interchangeable or the
- 9:01same. And it's very case dependent. I take into
- 9:06account the age of the child, sometimes the gender
- 9:13of the child, the issues that are presented,
- 9:17if there are developmental needs, if there are
- 9:20domestic violence issues. if it's refuse and
- 9:23resist, if there are some specific cultural issues
- 9:28or language barrier issues. And then I try to
- 9:35put that together with minors council, perhaps
- 9:41temperaments, experience. If it's a gender issue,
- 9:47gender. And I and I try to find the best fit
- 9:53for that child so that the child has somebody
- 9:58that they can really turn to and open up to.
- 10:03And sometimes I also take into account the parties
- 10:06and what their temperament is like and, you know,
- 10:12perhaps how they would respond to different personalities
- 10:17of minors council. So The question is not whether
- 10:22minors council is qualified. That should already
- 10:25be taken care of and we can discuss it, but it's
- 10:28who is the right fit for this child in this family?
- 10:33I think that's an excellent point. Commissioner
- 10:35Thomas, anything else that you would want to
- 10:37add on that point as far as what you are looking
- 10:40for when you're trying to match up the appropriate
- 10:43minors council to a child in a case? I think
- 10:47Judge Dujan's points are all very, very valid.
- 10:50Sometimes I may also look at the experience of
- 10:53Minors Council. If I know I have a case that
- 10:56is dependency heavy, or there's certain records,
- 11:01or there's been, say, a forensic interview, or
- 11:04I need someone with the skill set, who knows
- 11:08how to maneuver that landscape. I may look for
- 11:11a Miners Council that I know has had to maneuver
- 11:14the DCFS framework to make sure that they know
- 11:18how to get the information or they have experience
- 11:21getting that information. especially if there
- 11:24are very sensitive concerns and time concerns.
- 11:29But I think that's the only thing that I would
- 11:31potentially look at relative to all the other
- 11:35brilliant points that Judge Dujan brought up.
- 11:38Okay, and so Judge Dujan, let's try and demystify
- 11:41the process for people watching the show today.
- 11:45How is the selection process made? Meaning, do
- 11:51the bench officers have a list of qualified minors
- 11:53council if you can speak a little bit about that?
- 11:56Sure. So the Los Angeles court does not have
- 12:03necessarily a list that the court puts together
- 12:07and keeps. But the Los Angeles county bar has
- 12:11a list. of anyone who takes its Minors Council
- 12:15Training Program. And then that list is given
- 12:20to Department 215 now, formerly known as Department
- 12:252. And then all judicial officers in LA County
- 12:30have access to that list. And what that list
- 12:34says is these people took the course through
- 12:39LA County Bar and Association, and LACPA can
- 12:45assure that it was a training that met the requirements.
- 12:50But there are requirements, and you don't necessarily
- 12:55have to go through just that one training to
- 12:59obtain the requirements. to be minors council.
- 13:03Could you speak a little bit then about the alternatives
- 13:06that may qualify someone to serve as minors council
- 13:09that may not have completed the LACPA training
- 13:13program? Sure. So when when you're appointed
- 13:18as minors council, every you have to file a form
- 13:24that's the FL322 and it's declaration regarding
- 13:29qualifications of counsel for child. And I want
- 13:32to say we have included that in the materials
- 13:34if anyone is interested in seeing that for today.
- 13:38And so part of what that says is that as an attorney,
- 13:44you have taken at the beginning 12 hours of training
- 13:50that is specific to representing children. It
- 13:54includes domestic violence training. It includes
- 13:58interviewing children. It includes cross -cultural
- 14:06subjects and issues that come up. And that once
- 14:12you've done your initial 12 hours, you are then
- 14:16continuing education of eight hours every year
- 14:22and that you have at least, I believe it's six
- 14:27or five custody hearings that you have conducted
- 14:31within the last five years. And so if you can
- 14:37show that you have that training and experience
- 14:40and you can fill out that form under penalty
- 14:44of perjury, you can serve as minors council.
- 14:48Excellent. As a bench officer, are you both open
- 14:52to attorneys letting you know or letting your
- 14:56judicial assistant know that you that an attorney
- 14:59is interested in being appointed as minors counsel?
- 15:03Well, I definitely am. That's actually how I
- 15:07got started doing minors counsel work. And I
- 15:12was waiting in. court one day at Stanley Mosque
- 15:16and the judicial officer, once all the morning
- 15:22calendar was done, called me over and asked if
- 15:25I would be willing to take a case as minors council
- 15:28and that's how I got started. So I am definitely
- 15:32open to that. I think that, you know, if, If
- 15:40you're interested in doing minors council work,
- 15:43we are always looking for good people who want
- 15:46to do the job, who care about doing a good job
- 15:50representing children. So I am open to having
- 15:56people notify my judicial assistant that they
- 16:00have the qualifications and they want to try
- 16:06it. Excellent. And Commissioner Thomas, anything
- 16:09you want to say on that point or things to be
- 16:12mindful of of practitioners when they're expressing
- 16:16their interest to a bench officer? Absolutely.
- 16:19I welcome you to let me know that you're interested
- 16:22or have taken the training. And if there's any
- 16:25special area that you think you bring expertise
- 16:27to or any other languages you speak, I welcome
- 16:30all of that. You can let my judicial assistant
- 16:34know, or to the extent I'm not on the bench,
- 16:37maybe see if I have a few moments to say hello.
- 16:40What I will caution you, though, is once you
- 16:43are on my radar, I welcome it, but I look for
- 16:47the right case for the right person. So please
- 16:51don't get offended if that appointment doesn't
- 16:53come immediately. It doesn't mean that I don't
- 16:55value you and I'm not thinking of you. And please,
- 16:58the little tip I give is never corner a bench
- 17:02officer at an event. to demand an understanding
- 17:06of why you haven't been appointed because it's
- 17:08very possible that appointment is just around
- 17:11the corner. But if you do have legitimate concerns
- 17:14or you want to speak to someone about an appointment
- 17:17or just randomly the process, please feel free
- 17:21to stop by or if you see me out, I'm happy to
- 17:23speak with you about it and happy to get to know
- 17:25more about you if you're not already on my radar.
- 17:28Great. And I think if I think it's a good thing
- 17:34to never corner a judicial officer for any reason.
- 17:38But if you are interested in being appointed
- 17:41and you drop off some business cards in your
- 17:44CV with the JA in a courtroom that you know accepts
- 17:51minors or appoints minors council. I think that's
- 17:54a good way to let judicial officers know that
- 17:57you're interested, and also you can include a
- 18:01little bit something about your background. Perhaps
- 18:04you were a teacher before you became an attorney,
- 18:08and you have a lot of experience with education
- 18:11issues. And that might be incredibly helpful
- 18:14for us to know. So if you're dropping off business
- 18:18cards, drop off something that also tells us
- 18:21a little bit about your background. Okay, great.
- 18:25And after minors council has been selected by
- 18:28a bench officer. the court will issue an order
- 18:32appointing counsel for a child, which is court
- 18:35form FL 323. And specifically, that form is included
- 18:41in the materials for today. Item four, reason
- 18:44for appointment. Do you want to speak to, is
- 18:48that a way for the court to tip off minors counsel,
- 18:51is to focus them on the issues that need to really
- 18:54be investigated and addressed, or how is the
- 18:57court handling that? Well, I definitely put in
- 19:04as much information as I can in that section.
- 19:09And I want Miners Council to know what concerns
- 19:15the court is looking for them to represent their
- 19:19client on. And I also want the parties to know
- 19:23and their parties attorneys to know that those
- 19:27are the issues that I have heard from them, that
- 19:33those are the issues I have heard and that's
- 19:35what I want Miners Council to investigate and
- 19:38represent their client on. But that also doesn't
- 19:42preclude Miners Council from investigating any
- 19:47other areas of concern that they find during
- 19:52their representation of their client. And the
- 19:55first thing that I put in the reason for the
- 19:58appointment is to represent the minor child's
- 20:01best interest and the minor child's wishes, if
- 20:05appropriate, which is really under Family Code
- 20:073151 anyway. But I really want Minors Council
- 20:14to not be completely restricted to the focus
- 20:19and scope of what I write in that order because
- 20:22perhaps there is something that has not been
- 20:25brought up that is really underlying the minor
- 20:30child's best interest. And I do not want anyone
- 20:33to think that they're limited in the representation
- 20:36of a child or the parties to believe that minors
- 20:40council is limited just to those issues. Mr.
- 20:45Thomas, anything you want to add on that point?
- 20:48No, I think that's absolutely accurate. I think
- 20:51that what we write in there, absolutely, not
- 20:54only tips off Minors Council, here's what we
- 20:58heard or here's what was said, because I try
- 21:00to frame the information that I received that
- 21:03led up to the appointment, but I also want the
- 21:06parties to understand from what lens I'm looking
- 21:09at this and why I find it necessary for someone
- 21:12to come in and represent the best interests or
- 21:14potentially the wishes of the child. I want it
- 21:19completely transparent. So not only am I tipping
- 21:21off Miners' Council, I'm absolutely, because
- 21:24that order gets sent not just to prospective
- 21:26Miners' Council, but also to the parents. I want
- 21:30them to be able to see exactly how the court
- 21:33heard what was put before me. I will also add
- 21:38that I have received appointment orders from
- 21:41bench officers that have had an attachment attached
- 21:45to the order in which it is clear to me that
- 21:48they have received input from both parents council
- 21:52as to specific either concerns or areas of inquiry
- 21:56to be made by minors council of the children.
- 21:59And I think that also helps both parents buy
- 22:02more into the process and make sure that their
- 22:05concerns are being heard by Minors Council. Thank
- 22:07you for those comments. I think we move on. We
- 22:11do have a question in the chat regarding if you
- 22:14take Judge Dujan, this may be a question for
- 22:17you. If you take the training in another county,
- 22:20does that mean that you can't serve as Minors
- 22:22Council in L .A.? No, it just means that you're
- 22:27not going to be on the L .A. County bar. Association
- 22:31list because they can only certify that their
- 22:35training meets the guidelines. They cannot certify
- 22:39that other trainings met the guidelines and so
- 22:44therefore you are qualified. But it does not
- 22:47mean that you cannot represent children in LA
- 22:53County. Okay, and I think as Judge Dujan, I believe,
- 22:59touched on earlier, once Minor's counsel receives
- 23:03the appointment order, they are charged with
- 23:06then filling out, serving, and filing the declaration
- 23:09of counsel for child regarding qualifications,
- 23:12which is court form FL322. Judge Dujan, let's
- 23:18move on to reminding our audience of what the
- 23:23actual role is that Miners' Council plays in
- 23:26the case. Can you discuss a little bit about
- 23:30that role that they have? Sure. So Miners' Council
- 23:35is an attorney. They are an attorney on the case.
- 23:40They are independent, but they're not necessarily
- 23:44neutral. They come in neutral. They should not
- 23:46have a relationship with either party or the
- 23:50child. But once they come in, they are on the
- 23:55child's side, so to speak, if we're going to
- 23:58take sides. They are representing the minor child's
- 24:03or children's best interest and perhaps wishes
- 24:08as well. They're an advocate for the child. They
- 24:13are not the court's expert. They are not an evaluator.
- 24:19They are not an expert witness. They are not
- 24:22a witness at all and they're not even a substitute
- 24:28judicial officer. They are another attorney on
- 24:33the case and they are charged with representing
- 24:37minors. It is not for them to have any of their
- 24:45requests just rubber stamped. They also need
- 24:48to present admissible evidence. There are times
- 24:53and there are judicial officers that will get
- 24:57a hearsay waiver, a Santa's waiver for minors
- 25:00council and so sometimes what they have found
- 25:06from collaterals might come in or from the children
- 25:09a little bit easier but it is still a position
- 25:14that they are taking on behalf of their clients
- 25:16and And that's really their role in the case.
- 25:24It's to represent the minor children as attorneys.
- 25:30So Commissioner Thomas, a question for you. If
- 25:33Miners' Council appears in your court and offers
- 25:37you their advocacy on behalf of their clients,
- 25:41is that evidence that you can consider in making
- 25:44your decision? No. I mean, no, it's advocacy.
- 25:50And sometimes it will be framed. If I hear factual
- 25:54information through argument of minors council,
- 25:59I'll probably look at that as an offer of proof.
- 26:03But I also know that the landscape of each case
- 26:06may be different. There may be an agreement between
- 26:09the parties that information from Miners Council
- 26:12as proffered has either been stipulated to or
- 26:15can come in through Miners Council, in which
- 26:18case that may be a little bit different. But
- 26:21absent some type of agreement, the fact that
- 26:24a Miners Council gives me a fact. does not make
- 26:28it evidence, I still need admissible evidence.
- 26:31So minors council coming in saying the child
- 26:33is doing terribly at school, I still need evidence
- 26:36if I'm being asked to make that as a factual
- 26:38finding. Thank you for that important clarification.
- 26:43The rights and duties of appointed minors council
- 26:47can be found both under family code section 3151
- 26:53and California rules of court rule 5 .242. And
- 26:59those really outline, I won't. go through all
- 27:01of them with everyone today, but they outline
- 27:04that minors council is to gather evidence that
- 27:08bears on the best interests of the child and
- 27:10to present that admissible evidence exactly what
- 27:14we were just speaking about to the court in any
- 27:17manner that is appropriate for the council of
- 27:20a party. And of course, if the child desires,
- 27:24minors counsel shall present the child's wishes
- 27:26to the court. We're going to circle back on that
- 27:29point for a minute. But what do those duties
- 27:33include? Those include the obvious things, such
- 27:36as interviewing the child, reviewing the court
- 27:40files, so you're familiar with the pleadings
- 27:42and the issues in the case, having access to
- 27:46all relevant records, making further investigation.
- 27:51Things such as looking at school records, counseling
- 27:54records, perhaps prior child protective proceeding
- 27:58records, medical records. It may also include
- 28:02talking to other people that are familiar with
- 28:04the child, such as teachers, counselors, doctors,
- 28:09a nanny or a caregiver, perhaps new partners
- 28:12of a mother or father. And it could also include
- 28:15things such as making a home visit to each of
- 28:18the parent's homes. Miners' Council also has
- 28:22the right to have access to the child, they have
- 28:25standing to seek affirmative relief, to receive
- 28:28notice of any proceedings, the right to take
- 28:31action, access to the child's records, advance
- 28:36notice of and right to refuse any physical or
- 28:39psychological examination or evaluation, which
- 28:42has not been court ordered, and the right to
- 28:45assert or waive any privilege on behalf of the
- 28:48child. So given all of the tools that Miners'
- 28:54Council has at its disposal, what would a good
- 28:59investigation look like to the court? Can I just
- 29:05add something before I jump to that? I think
- 29:09from the appointment order and from Family Code
- 29:133151 and CRC 5 .242, everyone should be very
- 29:19clear that once Miners' Council is appointed,
- 29:22they are an attorney on the case, they have a
- 29:24client. So it's extremely important that an attorney
- 29:31representing one of the parties, one of the adult
- 29:34parties, does not just talk to the child or interview
- 29:40the child after they have counsel. They have
- 29:44counsel and they are represented. And a lot of
- 29:47times I think people just think, well, minors
- 29:50council is not really an attorney. So, you know,
- 29:54my client came in, my client mom came in and
- 29:57I just happened to talk to the child because
- 30:00they were there. And so I really asked them what
- 30:03they thought. That is absolutely not acceptable
- 30:06for a lot of different reasons. But let's just
- 30:09since we're focusing on this, the fact that they're
- 30:12represented by council. So I think that's If
- 30:17you're not minors counsel, this is still incredibly
- 30:19important so that you understand the role and
- 30:22the limits. Minors counsel does have privilege
- 30:27with their client and with, as I said before,
- 30:35service providers, whether they're mental health,
- 30:37education, a lot of different people that are
- 30:43medical that have privilege with the child. And
- 30:47so Minor's Counsel is an attorney, and I think
- 30:50it's important for everybody to remember that.
- 30:54I would like to just jump on that as well. Not
- 30:58only is Minor's Counsel an attorney in the context
- 31:01of the courtroom, but to the extent you represent
- 31:04a parent and you know that that parent is going
- 31:07to expose the minor child to an interview with
- 31:10law enforcement, to an interview with DCFS, to
- 31:13some type of medical proceeding, I would say
- 31:17that it would be very, very difficult if you
- 31:19had that knowledge and that knowledge was not
- 31:21given to minors council. Because to the extent
- 31:24that a minor child is being subjected to an interview
- 31:29with law enforcement, they may have a right to
- 31:31be represented. Whether everyone agrees with
- 31:35minors council's position or not, there may be
- 31:37a right there and minors council is in a position
- 31:40to potentially be in that interview. and advocate
- 31:43for that child. And that applies to many other
- 31:48proceedings or situations where a parent may
- 31:53say, well, I want an independent individual to
- 31:56interview my child and start the ball rolling.
- 32:01I think it would be incumbent for everyone to
- 32:03be on the same page and at least Miners Council
- 32:05to have a chance to understand that that's going
- 32:07to happen in advance of whatever that situation
- 32:11is. Yeah, I agree. I think that's an excellent
- 32:16point. Coming back to what a good investigation
- 32:20by Miners Council would look like, what are some
- 32:23of the things that you're hoping to hear when
- 32:27Miners Council comes back after having been appointed
- 32:30to the case? And again, I know some of you cringe
- 32:34when we use that term investigation. I'm not
- 32:37envisioning any type of magnum PI situation here,
- 32:40okay? So minors counsel is not expected to go
- 32:43sit outside someone's house and start tailing
- 32:45them and all of that. And I laugh because I understand
- 32:49that that is a very divisive words in some respects.
- 32:53But when I'm talking about an investigation,
- 32:55I think I'm talking about the due diligence to
- 32:57prepare for the case. What I'm looking for, Do
- 33:01you know the case? Do you know your client? Have
- 33:04you met with your client? If appropriate, have
- 33:06you talked to your client? I don't necessarily
- 33:09need to know what you spoke about, but it does
- 33:12help me to receive enough information to understand
- 33:15that you've had contact. You've spoken to the
- 33:19school if there are school issues. Did you potentially
- 33:21speak with teachers? What about medical professionals
- 33:25or have you looked at medical records? Depending
- 33:28on what the level of controversy is about, I
- 33:33would expect everybody to have looked at the
- 33:38service providers involved in those issues and
- 33:41to know that there are service providers. Maybe
- 33:44it's not appropriate in every case for you to
- 33:46speak with the medical professionals, but it's
- 33:48helpful for me that you know the case well enough
- 33:51to know if your client has service providers
- 33:53and who they are. So that way, to the extent
- 33:57that I have a conflict in front of me, um little
- 34:00timmy is in therapy what do you mean i've never
- 34:03heard about therapy and my initial concern is
- 34:07well is there a therapist isn't there to understand
- 34:11your child's world well enough to know whether
- 34:14or not little timmy is even in therapy even if
- 34:18the name of the therapist hasn't been disclosed
- 34:20but that's what i'm looking for is someone who
- 34:22understands the child and the child's world in
- 34:26order to be able to take positions, or find the
- 34:30information that may be helpful to advocating
- 34:33for their child in their world as they perceive
- 34:35it. And Commissioner Thomas, there's a question.
- 34:40And it's, if the minor has health issues and
- 34:43the parent is taking the minor to a specialist
- 34:45who orders various tests, should the parent inform
- 34:49Minors Council? Oh, absolutely. I think that
- 34:54many experienced minors council probably have
- 34:56some type of intake process and in that intake
- 34:59process may ask who are the medical providers,
- 35:02but to the extent that minors council doesn't
- 35:05even start off asking that question, if the child
- 35:08has needs, especially needs where the child has.
- 35:13specialist or what have you, I think it's very
- 35:15helpful for Minors Council to have that information
- 35:18and maybe even authorizations from the parents
- 35:22to be able to speak to that specialist so Minors
- 35:25Council can understand why is there a specialist?
- 35:27What are we treating? How does this impact what's
- 35:31going on between the parents? Does it even impact?
- 35:34So absolutely. I think it can also be particularly
- 35:38helpful when the parents are disputing the findings
- 35:44or recommendation of the specialist or of the
- 35:47educational provider, having minors council be
- 35:50able to speak directly with that provider. can
- 35:54sort of kind of sometimes clear up some of the
- 35:57muddy waters and be able to then go back to the
- 35:59parents and say, well, this is the information
- 36:01I'm receiving. And let's see if we can work with
- 36:03this and resolve that issue. Right. OK. And Judge
- 36:10Duzon, just as a reminder, are there other tools
- 36:14that are available to the bench other than Miners
- 36:18Council in order to Learn more about the case
- 36:22or get some more information that's that's needed
- 36:24from the bench officer Sure, um there the The
- 36:32bench could order the judge could order a parenting
- 36:35plan assessment or a 730 evaluation. It's a little
- 36:40different The I could order some kind of therapeutic
- 36:45services and sometimes therapeutic services with
- 36:51reports to the court, sort of, you know, a lot
- 36:55of times you could have the therapist provide
- 37:00an update or provide a compliance letter that
- 37:05everyone is attending and compliant. I could
- 37:09order a child -only interview through Family
- 37:11Court Services, and that is just the evaluator
- 37:16interviewing the child and That is it. There's
- 37:21no recommendation with it. So there are other
- 37:25tools that I have at my disposal instead of minors
- 37:30council to hear from the child. Excellent. Well,
- 37:34let's circle back to that now. One of the rights
- 37:39and duties outlined for minors council is when
- 37:42appropriate to advocate the child's wishes and
- 37:45inform the court of the child's wishes. And so
- 37:48if we're looking at Family Code Section 3042C,
- 37:54which specifically states that if a child is
- 37:5614 years of age and wishes to address the court,
- 38:00the child shall be permitted to do so unless
- 38:03the court determines that doing so is not in
- 38:06the child's best interest, in which case the
- 38:09court must state its reasons for that finding
- 38:11on the record. So to you, judicial officers,
- 38:15what does that look like? Are there options available
- 38:18to you? as the officer when you determine that
- 38:22you are going to hear directly from a minor?
- 38:28Yes, there are options. There are a lot of different
- 38:33ways that this could be handled. Sometimes it
- 38:35could be, as we said, perhaps it's through a
- 38:40child -only interview, perhaps it's through minors
- 38:44council, perhaps it's through an evaluation,
- 38:48and perhaps it is through the child coming to
- 38:52court to testify. If they come to court, it is
- 38:57not to have a chat, it is to testify. And there
- 39:05are different ways to do it. And Family Code
- 39:103042 does state that the child's testimony will
- 39:17be done outside the presence of the parties.
- 39:21And we have different ways of being able to set
- 39:24that up, especially now with virtual appearances
- 39:28and LA Court Connect. But we also have to be
- 39:36careful because we can't just have testimony
- 39:42without any kind of transcript of it. or any
- 39:53summarization of it, or anyone else not being
- 39:57present or hearing it. And so that it is just
- 40:00the minor child and the judicial officer. And
- 40:04this was a case that came out a few years ago.
- 40:08It's the Soto versus Cardona case. And that was
- 40:14in a domestic violence. case. So it was a little
- 40:18bit different than preference. Actually, in my
- 40:22mind, it was worse because the minor child was
- 40:26a percipient witness to the domestic violence.
- 40:30And the judicial officer took the minor child
- 40:33into chambers. And the minor child testified
- 40:38about the domestic violence and the domestic
- 40:40violence towards her. And there was no court
- 40:45reporter. There was no electronic recording.
- 40:53It was just not reported in any way. There was
- 40:56nobody else present. And then when the judicial
- 40:59officer took the bench, they did not summarize
- 41:02even what the minor child testified to. And a
- 41:08restraining order was granted partially based
- 41:11on that testimony. So it deprived the respondent.
- 41:15of due process. So even though we're talking
- 41:20more in the context of preference and what a
- 41:24child's preference might be or what they're going
- 41:28through and not necessarily in a domestic violence
- 41:31case, I think that we still have to be very careful.
- 41:36I think attorneys need to be careful. I think
- 41:38judicial officers need to be careful. It is testimony
- 41:42It should be done with either a court reporter
- 41:47or electronic recording, or the parties could
- 41:51be listening as the child is testifying, but
- 41:56not in the same room. And I think one of the
- 42:02things that we have to be careful of is that
- 42:06when a child has to tell their story and has
- 42:11to speak about these things. It can be very suggestive.
- 42:19So a child could get cues from somebody who's
- 42:23not asking the questions correctly and give answers
- 42:28that perhaps are not completely authentic answers.
- 42:32I think the more they tell a story, the more
- 42:37it becomes ingrained in them. even if it's been
- 42:40something that's been suggested to them. And
- 42:44so if the child is going to come to court and
- 42:47testify or express their wishes, it should be
- 42:51a one time, we're done, one and done. And that
- 42:55means it should be recorded in some sort of way
- 43:00or the party should at least have a chance to
- 43:05see the testimony. so that they know what to
- 43:09respond to, so that their attorneys know how
- 43:13to respond to it, how to be prepared and represent
- 43:17the parties in their case. So that's my very
- 43:24strong opinion on it. Commissioner Thomas, anything
- 43:29that you want to add on that topic? And I will
- 43:32just say that that case is included in the materials
- 43:35prepared for today's presentation. Sure. I think
- 43:39all of those points are very, very valid. When
- 43:42I look at the Soto case, to me, that was more
- 43:44of an interview than really a child testifying.
- 43:48And here's the deal. We're not supposed to be
- 43:50interviewing children. We're supposed to be taking
- 43:53evidence. I get many requests like, hey, we're
- 43:59gonna bring the child. You can just have a chat
- 44:01with the child. I can't just have a chat with
- 44:04the child no matter how nice the child is. It's
- 44:08not proper and it's not okay. Judge Dujon listed
- 44:12the various ways we can hear from children. That
- 44:18can be, I mean, we have child interviews. We
- 44:21can hear from a child in the context of a PPA.
- 44:25To the extent you want us to hear from the minor
- 44:27child, that is not going to happen same day.
- 44:31It is not helpful to many judicial officers.
- 44:34I can only speak for myself. At a hearing to
- 44:38hear, we brought the minor child, the minor child
- 44:41is out in the hallway and will speak to you for
- 44:4310 minutes, Your Honor. There's not much I can
- 44:47do with that. So to the extent that I need to
- 44:50hear from a minor child, I'm happy to do so.
- 44:53But I'm going to rely on Miners Council. Know
- 44:57your client. Tell me how the best way I can hear
- 45:01from your client with minimal impact is. Is there
- 45:05a mental health provider? Is this me hearing
- 45:08from them going to be so challenging or have
- 45:13impact to where I need to make an order from
- 45:15the mental health provider to for the child to
- 45:18have access after they testify? I want to know
- 45:21the landscape so I can set up appropriately.
- 45:25I'm not saying I would never hear from a child
- 45:28in chambers. I have a very large chambers downstairs.
- 45:31I can fit a court reporter in my chambers, but
- 45:34the technology in Chatsworth as such, I also
- 45:38have the ability to have what the child is saying
- 45:43in my chambers be heard in my courtroom. We have
- 45:47microphones and speakers. We now have the technology
- 45:52that if I hear from a child in chambers, I have
- 45:56the ability for the parents to be in the courtroom
- 45:58and I also have the ability to bring the child
- 46:01in to where the child is not walking through
- 46:03the courtroom in front of the parents to make
- 46:05it to my chambers. But all of that requires planning.
- 46:10So what I look for is I look for minors council
- 46:13or even parents council. Please don't spring
- 46:16this on me and please don't spring on me. We
- 46:19need to do it now and we have 15 minutes because
- 46:21we don't want to take the child out of school
- 46:23again. meet and confer with the other side, ensure
- 46:26Miners' Council knows of the request, and let's
- 46:29put a plan together to make sure that we can
- 46:31use any of the tools available to us and to make
- 46:34sure that we can create a record and we don't
- 46:36run afoul of Soto v. Cordona. I also think that
- 46:41a lot of attorneys and parties believe that once
- 46:45the child is 14, and some people believe even
- 46:4812, but 3042 says 14, then the court has to hear
- 46:54from the child. Family Code Section 3042 does
- 46:59say if the minor child wishes to address the
- 47:03court, the child shall be permitted to do so
- 47:07unless the court determines that in doing so
- 47:12is not in the child's best interest. And that
- 47:15part of unless, most people tend to just avoid
- 47:19or forget or not read, And that means that it
- 47:23is up to the judicial officer to determine if
- 47:28this testimony, if this child coming to court
- 47:30is in that child's best interest. That is a huge
- 47:34responsibility that is put on judicial officers.
- 47:39And clearly, we have a lot of responsibility
- 47:42in all the orders. we make. But this could really
- 47:47harm a child's emotional state and emotional
- 47:50and mental well -being. And so this goes along
- 47:57with what Commissioner Thomas was saying, is
- 47:59do not bring a child to court. Do not think you're
- 48:02springing it on us. And just say, Your Honor,
- 48:05I have the child in the hall. They could tell
- 48:07you that. Because I first want to know Is it
- 48:12in the child's best interest? Is it in the child's
- 48:15best interest to somehow testify to me, whether
- 48:19it's just in chambers with a reporter, whether
- 48:23it's in court, however it is, is it in that child's
- 48:28best interest? I need to know more about this
- 48:31child. I need to know more about the issues and
- 48:35the circumstances before I'm going to tell you
- 48:39yes. It is in this child's best interest. Go
- 48:42ahead and bring them in and. I I support what
- 48:46Commissioner Thomas said. If I make that determination,
- 48:49we are going to especially set that case. I will
- 48:54not have other cases waiting to be heard. I will
- 48:58not rush through this. I will give that child
- 49:03the first of all the respect. That child deserves
- 49:09and I will have them come in once and be done
- 49:13that I do not want That child's testimony to
- 49:18have to take all day or have them have to be
- 49:21here all day They will come in once and be done
- 49:25I will not rush through it because I have three
- 49:28other cases to get to and finish They are going
- 49:32to be it for the day. So and we will make those
- 49:37arrangements and I will especially set it. So
- 49:40the worst thing you can do is come in and say
- 49:43the child's in the hall like Commissioner Thomas
- 49:45said because that's then you just took that child
- 49:48out of school and involved them in the process
- 49:52and wasted the day. So I would just also add
- 49:56I think it's important for council to manage
- 50:00expectations prior to a judicial officer holding
- 50:05a hearing the child's testimony in the sense
- 50:09that I never want a minor child to feel that
- 50:13what they will say is going to be responsible
- 50:16for deciding the case. Right. And I also think
- 50:19sometimes parents put pressure on the child while
- 50:22you're 14. What you say is going to carry the
- 50:24day. I think it's important to to have that conversation
- 50:29both as minors counsel with the child client
- 50:32and as parents counsel with with parents that
- 50:34they are representing. Yes. And I think it's
- 50:37also likely that perhaps I will appoint minors
- 50:41counsel if the child is going to testify because
- 50:44I want someone that comes in that is independent
- 50:48to prepare the child for that testimony and what
- 50:52the court process will be like. And so that they're
- 50:57coming from a neutral perspective and just explaining
- 51:02to them what to expect and what to say. And then
- 51:07perhaps Minors Council will come in and say,
- 51:10my client's really not in a space to be able
- 51:13to do this. It will be detrimental. And I also,
- 51:20I really agree with Callie where I think if people
- 51:24who have never represented children and who have
- 51:28never had those kinds of meetings with children
- 51:31do not understand the pressure and effect that
- 51:38some of these proceedings and choices that kids
- 51:43get have on them. And they're negative effects.
- 51:47And they feel that they're in this position where
- 51:51they can't win. No matter what they say, they
- 51:54can't win. They're going to disappoint one parent
- 51:56or the other. And coming into court sometimes
- 52:02makes them feel like they have the weight of
- 52:05the world on their shoulders because their parents'
- 52:09entire lives are dependent on this. And that
- 52:14is a huge burden for an adolescent to have, even
- 52:19for an adolescent who says they want to have
- 52:21that and they want to come in. So I think we
- 52:25have to really tread lightly with this and very,
- 52:29very carefully knowing how much it could harm
- 52:34and hopefully not harm, but how much it could
- 52:37affect the children in these cases. Thank you.
- 52:44Go ahead, I'm sorry. Final thought. I think it's
- 52:47also a lot for an adolescent to be able to understand
- 52:52the gravity or the long -term effects of providing
- 52:57testimony, providing an opinion to be able to
- 53:02come in and say, well, they want to, and they
- 53:04totally get all of it. I think it's a lot to
- 53:08place on a child's shoulders that they're going
- 53:11to be able to have such knowledge and maturity
- 53:15in this world to understand how that what for
- 53:19us is a moment in time is going to impact them
- 53:23or their relationship with their parent or their
- 53:25even their outlook on the world 10 years into
- 53:28the future. Excellent point. Okay, so moving
- 53:32along, since we're getting a little short on
- 53:35time, what do we do when the advocacy goes off
- 53:39track a little bit? I'm sure maybe you've had
- 53:42an experience in which a parent's counsel has
- 53:44said to you, minor's counsel is biased, I want
- 53:47them off the case. How do you handle those situations?
- 53:53Commissioner Thomas? But yeah, I don't just assume
- 53:58that because you tell me a minor's counsel is
- 54:01biased or that there's something off track. Minor's
- 54:06counsel is an attorney. I expect them to take
- 54:08a position. Sometimes that a position aligns
- 54:11with a parent. Sometimes it doesn't. And conflict
- 54:14in advocacy, I expect that. So don't just come
- 54:18in and tell me there's a problem with minor's
- 54:20counsel, remove them. I want to know what is
- 54:23legitimately happening. and then we're gonna
- 54:26pull back the layers on what is happening and
- 54:28really get into, is this truly bias or is this
- 54:34just they've taken a position and this position
- 54:37seems to align with the parent? And sometimes
- 54:41that's also looking at, okay, what is the advocacy?
- 54:47What is it based in? and to the extent that it's
- 54:51based on independent judgment of the Minors Council,
- 54:55then I'm not sure that we can automatically jump
- 54:57to bias, but we're absolutely going to have a
- 55:00discussion, and I'm going to expect that discussion
- 55:03to really articulate more than just Minors Councils
- 55:08aligned with mom or dad for their bias, because
- 55:11what I'm looking for is Minors Council continuing
- 55:13to exercise independent professional judgment.
- 55:16And that is where I'm starting my inquiry from.
- 55:21I also think that if as the party's attorney,
- 55:26if that's your position, you believe minors council
- 55:28is aligned with one party and they're biased,
- 55:31and you're going to come to court and argue that,
- 55:34you need to have a conversation, a real conversation.
- 55:39a meaningful meet and confer with Miners Council
- 55:43before you do that. I think if you have some
- 55:45serious concerns about their advocacy, where
- 55:49they're coming from, bring it up to them. Give
- 55:52them a chance to hear what your concerns are
- 55:55and address them. Perhaps there's something that
- 55:59you've missed that they know. Perhaps there's
- 56:04something that they missed, but once you bring
- 56:06it up to them, they'll follow up on it. I don't
- 56:10know, but I think coming to court and trying
- 56:14to sandbag Miners Council with this is really
- 56:17not the way to go. And it's not the way for you
- 56:21to have the court hear whatever your concerns
- 56:25are. And are there things that the court can
- 56:30do when there may be a concern about the advocacy
- 56:33that is short of removal? Are there other tools
- 56:37in the toolbox available? Oh, absolutely. We
- 56:42have the ability to understand what the concerns
- 56:45are and make orders accordingly. If the issue
- 56:48is there is a concern that there wasn't adequate
- 56:53meet and confer before the hearing, so parents
- 56:57council didn't understand why the advocacy was
- 57:00what it was, I can order a meet and confer. I
- 57:03can order any remedy for minors council that
- 57:07I can order for parents council. What I want
- 57:12to really draw the distinction on is the tools
- 57:15I'm going to use are likely going to be very
- 57:17similar tools to those that I use relative to
- 57:20parents' counsel. Why? Because there's still
- 57:23an attorney -client relationship there that I
- 57:26may be helped in forming, but I'm not going to
- 57:29interfere with. So although I will utilize tools
- 57:32to maneuver that relationship in a way that's
- 57:35helpful, what I'm not going to do is interfere.
- 57:39I'm probably not the right judicial officer if
- 57:41you are looking for orders saying We want after
- 57:46minors council speaks with their client. We want
- 57:49to make sure that minors council updates the
- 57:51parents on what was said attorney client privilege,
- 57:55I'm not going to Circumvent that and I'm not
- 57:59going to micromanage councils relationship with
- 58:02the child. I've also been asked for orders We
- 58:05want to make sure that minors council needs to
- 58:07respond to the child within 15 minutes of the
- 58:09child reaching out. Well, minors council is still
- 58:14a human and a professional human as that may
- 58:18not be an appropriate order for a parents council
- 58:22or even an appropriate expectation. I'm not sure
- 58:26that those are the types of orders or the type
- 58:29of micromanagement that's appropriate for me
- 58:31to involve myself in. But what I will do is look
- 58:34at where the breakdown seems to be and see if
- 58:37I can fashion some type of order that's short
- 58:41of either interfering in the entire attorney
- 58:44-client relationship or micromanaging a professional
- 58:48who should still maintain their independent professional
- 58:51judgment. And I also think that While we look
- 58:56to see if there's anything to substantiate what
- 59:02a party is complaining about regarding Miners
- 59:05Council, that also brings the spotlight on the
- 59:09party and the parties. And so we will know when
- 59:14a party is over -embroiling Miners Council in
- 59:18their conflict, when a party is interfering with
- 59:23the child's relationship with their attorney.
- 59:27All of that comes to light as they're pointing
- 59:30fingers at the attorney representing the child,
- 59:35their own behavior comes to light. And so I think
- 59:38that if you're an attorney representing a party,
- 59:41you need to be aware of that too. A lot of times
- 59:45when a party comes in like that, just going after
- 59:49minors council, they don't come in with clean
- 59:53hands and their behavior gets looked at also
- 59:57because that's what the spotlight does. And given
- 1:00:01that, there are some things that minors council
- 1:00:03can do. So if you're minors council, you can
- 1:00:07definitely make sure that you're staying neutral,
- 1:00:10that you're receiving information from both parents
- 1:00:13and not just one side, that you... At least when
- 1:00:18we see it when you come to court that you're
- 1:00:21not just sitting with one party I mean if you're
- 1:00:25sitting with mom For every when you're in the
- 1:00:30audience and then dad saying that you're aligning
- 1:00:32with mom Well, I mean, I don't know for sure
- 1:00:36but the appearance of it doesn't look good Same
- 1:00:40thing when you're at council table try to sit
- 1:00:42in the middle if you can, and just try to show
- 1:00:49that you're really there for the child and you're
- 1:00:53not aligned. And again, sometimes minors council's
- 1:00:57position just naturally aligns more with one
- 1:01:00parent than the other, but there are things that
- 1:01:04minors council can do to just show that they're
- 1:01:08not actually aligned, that it's just their client's
- 1:01:11position. Excellent. Well, I think we have reached
- 1:01:16our time limit. And so I just want to see if
- 1:01:18there's any other questions that we want to address.
- 1:01:22And also, Commissioner Thomas and Judge Dujan,
- 1:01:25maybe you have some final thoughts about my nurse
- 1:01:28counselor thing that we've talked about today
- 1:01:30that you want to share with the audience before
- 1:01:32we wrap up and conclude. Sure. Judge Dujan, I'll
- 1:01:38cede the floor to you first. OK. Thank you. Well,
- 1:01:42first, I just want to say thank you for having
- 1:01:44us and for tuning in and thank you to the Beverly
- 1:01:47Hills Bar for hosting this and asking Commissioner
- 1:01:51Thomas and I to come speak and for Callie Kramer
- 1:01:58for putting it together. And then I just want
- 1:02:02to say Miners Council work is not easy. It's
- 1:02:06not an easy position to be in. And it's an extremely
- 1:02:12important position to be in. The court does count
- 1:02:17on attorneys to represent their clients zealously,
- 1:02:23even when they're minors. And we also entrust
- 1:02:27you with maintaining the minor child's overall
- 1:02:35well -being and their emotional and mental well
- 1:02:38-being. given the fact that they're meeting with
- 1:02:42an attorney. So it's a very important job that
- 1:02:47we know has a lot of responsibilities. And we
- 1:02:53thank everyone who is willing to take on those
- 1:02:57cases. And we hope and expect at least for me,
- 1:03:03I can't speak for everybody that If you represent
- 1:03:07a party and you have minors council that you're
- 1:03:10working with, that you will work with them respectfully
- 1:03:16and understand their position. And if you need
- 1:03:22to do some research to completely understand
- 1:03:24their position, please do it. There are ways
- 1:03:28that the parties council and minors council can
- 1:03:32work together even if you don't completely agree
- 1:03:35on things, but you could really work together
- 1:03:38to help a family in need and get the best outcomes
- 1:03:43for the children. So that's it. Thank you. I
- 1:03:48absolutely echo the gratitude. Thank you to the
- 1:03:51Beverly Hills Bar. Thank you, Callie. This has
- 1:03:54been just a remarkable honor to be here. Thank
- 1:03:58you to everybody who undertakes the very, very
- 1:04:01difficult task. Minors council work is not for
- 1:04:05the faint of heart. It is difficult. It is challenging,
- 1:04:08but it's also very rewarding to give a meaningful
- 1:04:12voice to a child without making them responsible
- 1:04:15for the ultimate decision. But I applaud everybody
- 1:04:19out there for even if you're not doing minors
- 1:04:22council work, being an attorney in general and
- 1:04:25advocating in a courtroom also is not for the
- 1:04:29faint of heart. But the ability to understand
- 1:04:32this process and to embrace it and to make it
- 1:04:36easy enough for us to be able to hear from children,
- 1:04:39to be able for us to have this as a tool to understand
- 1:04:43best interests. I'm grateful to everyone out
- 1:04:46there. I wish everyone good health and great
- 1:04:50advocacy. And to the extent that you may be interested
- 1:04:53in dipping your toe into the world of minors
- 1:04:56council, feel free to reach out and say hello.
- 1:04:59I know myself and Judge Dujon would be very interested
- 1:05:02to continue to ensure that there's more phenomenal
- 1:05:09advocates to do this very meaningful work. Yes,
- 1:05:13I agree. Thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 1:05:16for having us and Commissioner Thomas and Judge
- 1:05:19Dujon for all of your time and helping me prepare
- 1:05:21the presentation for today. We appreciate all
- 1:05:24of you that have joined us today. Thank you.