Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Fed Speak, Gold ATHs, DeepSeek, State-Level Adoption, & BTC Dominance
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop and we're
- 0:04going to be left holding the biggest bag of odorous excrement
- 0:08ever assembled in the history of darkness. 1974198792972000 and
- 0:18whatever we want to call this, it's all just the same thing
- 0:20over and over. We can't help ourselves.
- 0:23I say when we sell. Hey, OK.
- 0:27I say when we sell. All right, welcome back to the
- 0:34Last Trade. We are excited to kick off a new
- 0:38format for the show. We've been teasing it out the
- 0:40past couple weeks, but from here on out what you can expect is
- 0:44the four of us you see here on screen.
- 0:46For those listening, we have who have been my Co host for quite
- 0:50some time now, Brian Cabela's and Michael Tanguma of On Ramp.
- 0:54And then we have Tim Kotzman. We're honored to be joined by
- 0:58Big Tim, host of the Bitcoin Treasuries podcast, private
- 1:02equity fund manager, doing a lot of stuff in both traditional
- 1:06finance and Bitcoin. So for those who will be
- 1:10following along and have been following along, this is what
- 1:12you can expect. Now the four of us are just
- 1:13going to be riffing on a ton of topics, keeping you up to date
- 1:16on the markets, Bitcoin adoption, tech deals, what have
- 1:21you. And then we'll also be bringing
- 1:23in people, we'll be doing some, you know, some 55 way pods for
- 1:27those that are interested in that when the opportunity when
- 1:33the opportunity presents itself. So gentlemen, great to see you
- 1:36all excited for this new format. It's going to be a lot of fun
- 1:38and I think the listeners are going to get even more value out
- 1:40of the show. How is everyone doing?
- 1:43Very good. Jackson appreciates a good five
- 1:44way. So, you know, we had.
- 1:46Yeah, sometimes you got it, sometimes you got to throw 5
- 1:48heads at it. I mean, that's just the reality.
- 1:50But this is the core 4. Very excited for this this crew
- 1:53going forward. I fully not outnumber though,
- 1:55because you get this like NE contingent.
- 1:59It's true right there. And I'm just down here in Texas.
- 2:02Not enough Texas on the panel for.
- 2:03You holding it down, But I think I think it's good we got to
- 2:05have, you know, Tim specifically with that orange tie and sitting
- 2:10in Ground Zero of all that's happening in New York City to
- 2:14let us know what's what's happening on the ground floor of
- 2:16Bitcoin and Wall Street. Yeah, you've heard of the power
- 2:20of two. This is the power of four.
- 2:23I love it. Yeah.
- 2:25Well, Michael, it's kind of a shame to see you're the only
- 2:28person down in Texas. But it's clear, I guess, that we
- 2:32we've known that Philadelphia was the Bitcoin capital of the
- 2:35world. But it's also we, we know as
- 2:37well that New York is maybe second best to Philly.
- 2:41But let's start with the price. We got pulled up here on the on
- 2:44ramp terminal, which anyone could check out if they'd like.
- 2:48We got the price live action here.
- 2:50We got 105,663 per BTC. Gentlemen, what are the
- 2:57thoughts? I, I have some of mine, but
- 2:59Brian, let me toss it over to you.
- 3:01What's driving the price this week?
- 3:04Yeah. I mean, it could be a number of
- 3:05things. I think for me, there's been a
- 3:07few things that have happened this week that might be
- 3:10influencing Bitcoin price. Right now.
- 3:13You've got your typical sort of more Fed speak driven
- 3:17narratives. So FOMC met yesterday.
- 3:22Biggest takeaways from that were effectively they're keeping
- 3:26rates unchanged. And so that was expected by
- 3:30markets like 99 plus percent probability for that to be the
- 3:34case. But it was somewhat of a
- 3:37departure in that it was, it broke a streak of three
- 3:40consecutive rate cuts dating back to September.
- 3:44And so some of the, like I said, the Fed speak, the the reading
- 3:49of the tea leaves has has shifted somewhat from
- 3:52mentioning, you know, in the past that they were making
- 3:55progress towards their inflation targets to now sort of
- 3:59signaling, you know, inflation remains somewhat elevated.
- 4:04Taking a step back though, like I would say, you know, all of
- 4:08sort of Fed speak, Fed policies type stuff is, is very much just
- 4:11like short term noise in my mind and really does nothing to
- 4:15address the structural issues at hand.
- 4:17So, you know, massive public and private debt burdens that will
- 4:21inevitably lead to further monetary expansion and, and
- 4:24currency debasement. And so like this pause and rate
- 4:27cuts doesn't really alter the, the long term trajectory of, of
- 4:31Bitcoin or, or, you know, any other scarce assets that would
- 4:35benefit from, you know, continued to base debasement of
- 4:38the currency. And so you, you sort of compare
- 4:40and contrast that with at the same time, you have, you know,
- 4:44gold breaking out to all time highs somewhat quietly and, you
- 4:49know, Bitcoin starting to move up again.
- 4:50And so that's to me, the real signal is, is not, you know,
- 4:54what Jerome Powell has has decided to say this month, but
- 4:58more, you know, you know, what is what is happening in hard
- 5:01assets effectively. So gold and Bitcoin.
- 5:04And I think part of the gold story too.
- 5:06You guys can correct me if I'm wrong, but I think there was a
- 5:08report earlier this week that effectively some, some London
- 5:11gold markets allegedly don't have, you know, enough physical
- 5:15gold to satisfy the paper claims, which is just like so
- 5:18classic, like this is a flaw of gold.
- 5:21It's it's harder to verify than Bitcoin, obviously.
- 5:24And so you, you run into these instances where you know, the,
- 5:28there's too many paper claims effectively.
- 5:30And so you're seeing, you're seeing the, the price of, of
- 5:32Spot gold start to move as well. So that's that's what I think
- 5:35could be influencing just very short term price action and sort
- 5:38of how I've perceived what's happened throughout the week.
- 5:42I will say one thing I I listened to Fed speak is when
- 5:45they talk about, you know, banks being able to, to custody.
- 5:48Yeah, that was the other thing. Big, big Jerome Powell had a had
- 5:52a line in there around his confidence in that the the banks
- 5:57would be able to custody assets, custody digital assets and and
- 6:01Bitcoin, which I found interesting.
- 6:03It it's it's certainly just a massive pivot from, you know,
- 6:08prior government or Fed speak around Bitcoin and then and and
- 6:13other assets being, you know, they're just more legitimized
- 6:16now. So so it's into the conversation
- 6:18of yeah, banks are going to custody these yeah, they're
- 6:19prepared to do so. Like don't worry about it.
- 6:21Is is very different from the past several years of like I
- 6:25don't know if these banks can touch these high risk assets.
- 6:28So it's it's, it is distinct change in that respect.
- 6:33Yeah, No, I, I agree. I think the FOMC stuff did move
- 6:38the markets a little bit. One thing I think is worth
- 6:43pointing out is there's about $7 trillion of debt that needs to
- 6:47be refinanced by the US Treasury this year.
- 6:50And so Powell can hold out for now, I would say with higher
- 6:55rates. But the reality is that the
- 6:57fiscal situation is already extremely messy in the US, but
- 7:01also globally. And so rates will need to come
- 7:05down at some point to prevent, prevent more I'll, I guess,
- 7:12worse liquidity conditions, tighter financial conditions
- 7:15from impacting the US Treasury and their ability to refinance
- 7:19that debt. So that's something to pay
- 7:21attention to. And then I think Trump also in
- 7:23this first week in office, said something pretty strong, some
- 7:27strong language about how he's going to demand that rates come
- 7:30down in the US. And so I, I at least like that
- 7:34Trump is straightforward and will acknowledge the fact that
- 7:39there is really very limited independence between the US
- 7:43government and the Federal Reserve because central banks
- 7:45like to pretend that they are independent.
- 7:48They make their own decisions. But in reality, especially with
- 7:51debt levels the way they are, these two institutions are very
- 7:54intertwined. And so Trump wants rates to come
- 7:56down because he wants stimulation within the economy.
- 8:00And he also likes to look at the Bitcoin price now, importantly.
- 8:02So he wants the Bitcoin price to go up as part of his barometer
- 8:06for a healthy economy and markets, which that's not priced
- 8:09in yet. Is Donnie wanting to pump
- 8:11Bitcoin? He had a there was a hilarious
- 8:14clip I saw yesterday of some reporter, interviewer asking him
- 8:18like, you know, so you would just tell him that he needs to
- 8:22to cut rates. And he's like, yeah.
- 8:23And he's like, do you think he would listen to and listen to
- 8:27you? And Trump kind of like pauses
- 8:28for a second. He goes, yeah, I think, I think
- 8:30they listened to me. It's just like, you're right
- 8:33though, Jackson. He's just like very overt, like,
- 8:35yeah, this is this is what needs to happen realistically.
- 8:37And, and to be honest, like Powell knows that too.
- 8:40He knows rates can't stay here, but he knows it's unsustainable.
- 8:44So it's just that gets back to like the Fed speak kind of
- 8:48bullshit of like even the stuff he says he doesn't really
- 8:51believe long term makes any sense.
- 8:54Tim, how do you feel in regards to kind of the Fed conversation
- 8:58we talked about with banks custody the asset?
- 9:01Because I feel like that's a big component in the treasury
- 9:04narrative for businesses and corporations that you're going
- 9:06to have that asset sitting right next to, you know, your bonds
- 9:09and other cash equivalents as you're running an operation.
- 9:12Because I think that's something that as natives, we don't really
- 9:15think much about. But there's a lot of kind of
- 9:17friction when it comes to moving around capital to get exposure
- 9:20to Bitcoin versus being able to buy it in your existing, you
- 9:23know, capital stack when you're managing your corporate
- 9:25finances. Yeah.
- 9:28I think it'll be interesting to see how quickly banks roll out
- 9:33any sort of custody services and if that's akin to the ETF roll
- 9:39out where it's almost like family offices, ultra high net
- 9:43worth and then down to retail. And then, you know, but maybe
- 9:50your bank does it, maybe they don't do it, meaning, right,
- 9:55sometimes some U.S. citizens still can't buy the spot Bitcoin
- 10:00ETF in their brokerage account, which is nuts because we're over
- 10:03a year in. And then yesterday with J Pal,
- 10:12he, he just hit me with the question and answer that he was
- 10:18dancing around and really being pretty dovish in my view, where
- 10:24he's like, you know, we've had some readings that have been
- 10:27good, some that have not been so good, but we're just looking for
- 10:31serial readings to be heading in the right direction.
- 10:34And it appears that we have a path to get there.
- 10:37And it just seemed to always be threading this needle of being
- 10:41able to see this path to lower rates.
- 10:46So I don't know if I was just reading way too much into it,
- 10:50but I feel like my reaction to it and maybe the market took it
- 10:58the same way as, OK, there's no change in interest rates.
- 11:01That's a nothing. It's neutral, but everything's a
- 11:07forward-looking statement. What is he looking towards?
- 11:10And you know, outside of other events or industry specific
- 11:16events, everything kind of stayed the same, maybe pulled
- 11:20back just a tiny bit, but seems like everything's kind of
- 11:24heading higher. Well, except for gold, right?
- 11:26That's what we talked about. Brian referred to or Jackson on,
- 11:30you know, we talked about like bitcoins, a Canary in the coal
- 11:32mine. But it feels like gold is
- 11:33generally the leading indicator before Bitcoin.
- 11:35I think the breakout last year from that roughly 2000 range and
- 11:39you know, 2224 hundred proceeding by a few months
- 11:43before Bitcoin really took off. And so with its all time high,
- 11:46there's there's something there going on whether it has to do
- 11:48with illiquidity of delivery or also just to your point, you
- 11:52know dovish conditions where there's going to be some easing
- 11:56and and you naturally start to have hard assets start to run.
- 12:01Tim, you, you make a good point though about the Fed speak and
- 12:05sort of this, this dance that that Powell has been doing for
- 12:08what seems like over a year now. Frankly, I guess the question
- 12:14that comes to my mind and curious anyone's thoughts on
- 12:16this is like something that they have sort of dangled out there
- 12:20in the past. And some commentary is like
- 12:23basically revising the target rate to whether it's, you know,
- 12:27target CPI rate, I mean, you know, up from 2% to whether it's
- 12:312 1/2 or 3%. And to me that's like actually
- 12:35probably the most likely medium to long term outcome is they end
- 12:41up bringing interest rates down, not because they've reached the
- 12:452% target, but just because they've revised the, the target.
- 12:48And the new CPI target is 2 1/2 or 3%, which as we know is like,
- 12:54you know, meaningfully higher than 2%, right?
- 12:57On a compounded basis over 10/20/50 years, a 3% CPI is, is
- 13:02much, much, much different than a 2% CPI.
- 13:06Both sort of disastrous over the long term, but that, that would
- 13:09be a, a significant change. Like you guys have any thoughts
- 13:13on it? That's because in my mind that's
- 13:14kind of like the most likely path here is they don't actually
- 13:19get CPI to come down meaningfully to prior targets,
- 13:25you know, no matter how much massaging they do to to the the
- 13:28data itself. I totally agree.
- 13:32I mean they can change whatever they want.
- 13:34They change the basket of goods all the time, so why not?
- 13:38Yeah. I mean, what roads lead to
- 13:40inflation? There's no there's no way around
- 13:42this. Yeah, I more often than you
- 13:46would think, I have conversations with people where
- 13:48I say, do you know what the Federal Reserve's mandate, dual
- 13:50mandate is? And they're like, no, I have no
- 13:52idea. Like, well, it's full
- 13:53employment, 2% inflation and they're like exceeding their
- 13:57goal, like wildly exceeding their goal on inflation every
- 14:01year, 2% inflation. And do you know what 2%
- 14:03inflation is? No, I have no idea.
- 14:05Well, it's devaluing your money by 2% a year.
- 14:09What? So it's like getting back to
- 14:12basics. Yeah, but Tim, some some banker
- 14:14in New Zealand said that was that was good like 40.
- 14:18Years ago, yeah. It's.
- 14:19Actually, Brian, it is good actually, because they take your
- 14:23money and it becomes theirs. But yeah, I mean, I, I think
- 14:26that's kind of the natural conclusion, right?
- 14:28Because there's no, there's no way that all the liabilities and
- 14:33all the debt gets paid without creating more money.
- 14:36And so it's good to talk about what's going on with the price
- 14:40and what is J pal talking about? But it actually doesn't matter.
- 14:46And I get frustrated to even talk about it because it, it is
- 14:49really just bullshit. At the end of the day, we're
- 14:51talking about a made-up metric and we're also anchoring the
- 14:55entire economy and, and decisions around this metric
- 14:58that's made-up. So it's, it's actually
- 15:02incredibly frustrating when you think about that.
- 15:04And then you also think you could extrapolate this to the US
- 15:07Treasury markets that are heavily manipulated as well.
- 15:11That's the basis, that's the hurdle rate, right?
- 15:14In traditional finance we're talking about what do you, what
- 15:17equity risk premium do you need above the risk free rate of U.S.
- 15:21Treasuries? And that's just another, it's
- 15:24still somewhat of a free market, but it's based on flawed metrics
- 15:27and data that's manipulated. So that's like this entire
- 15:30system is just manipulated and favors whatever outcomes those
- 15:35who pull the strings. 1 And so that's going to be higher
- 15:38inflation over time because that's what's needed to actually
- 15:40get through this mess. I do, I want to hear some
- 15:45thoughts real quick before we pivot into more Bitcoin related
- 15:49news. Brian, can you share or anyone?
- 15:53But Brian, I'll give it over to you.
- 15:54First, just thoughts on Deepseek, It doesn't need to be
- 15:58long. I just want to touch on it
- 15:59quickly. But wiped out $600 billion of
- 16:02market cap of NVIDIA. The whole market was selling
- 16:06off. Bitcoin sold off, Yeah.
- 16:08Thoughts. Some thoughts and, and caveat
- 16:13all of this, I am not an AI expert by any means, the very
- 16:18cursory understanding of of all these things.
- 16:20But basically the, the story that occurred earlier this week
- 16:25that caused some, some turbulence in U.S. equity
- 16:28markets was effectively the release, the open source release
- 16:34of a large language model called deep seek from an entity in
- 16:37China. I think it was like a hedge fund
- 16:39in China. And the, the claim, the alleged
- 16:43claim is that they basically built this model, which is on
- 16:47par, if not better than sort of its, its Western AI
- 16:51counterparts. The, the claim is that they
- 16:54built it with a a, you know, a fraction of of the capital
- 16:57effectively. So I think the number that's
- 16:58being quoted is like 6,000,000 with an M to develop this.
- 17:03And so that's obviously just, you know, orders of magnitude
- 17:06less than the open AIS of the world are, are pouring into AI
- 17:10infrastructure and, and building and training their models.
- 17:13And so a few takeaways from this are effectively, I think what
- 17:18what we know around like deflationary technology, right?
- 17:21Like it allows you to do more with less and be more efficient
- 17:26by leveraging those deflationary tools.
- 17:28And so, you know, the Internet was an example of this, AI is an
- 17:31example of this, and even Bitcoin is an example of this.
- 17:35And so I think this is, you know, why it's particularly
- 17:39interesting in the context of U.S. equity markets is
- 17:42effectively, it was a wake up call to a lot of people that,
- 17:46you know, store long term value in U.S. equity markets, which is
- 17:49a a large swath of investors that use the S&P or the NASDAQ
- 17:55or the MAG 7 to to, you know, store value into the future.
- 17:59That was sort of a wake up call in that, you know, maybe you can
- 18:03be disrupted overnight by a more efficient player who's
- 18:05leveraging deflationary tech better than you are.
- 18:08And, you know, also just the notion that they open sourced.
- 18:11It was kind of interesting in the sense that, you know, I
- 18:14think there was a a notion that anything that, you know, China
- 18:17was going to be doing on the AI front would be closed source.
- 18:21They sort of, you know, obviously pivoted from that open
- 18:24sourced it, which is very different from some of the the
- 18:26companies in the West who are who are not open source.
- 18:29And so that was another interesting angle.
- 18:32But yeah, effectively it was, you know, I think it it calls
- 18:36into question effectively, are US equities a good store value?
- 18:42Probably not because there's competitive forces, there's
- 18:45execution risk, there's disruption risk.
- 18:48And as you know, these deflationary technologies
- 18:51accelerate, which that is what's going to happen, right.
- 18:53We've already seen this play out over the past several decades,
- 18:56but it's only going to accelerate from here with the
- 18:59likes of AI. And so it's just something to be
- 19:02cognizant of. And I think was sort of a wake
- 19:05up call to a lot of US investors and and why you saw some some
- 19:08sell off. Yeah, I think, I think this is
- 19:12super interesting and fascinating.
- 19:13It ties into the Bitcoin conversation, but like there's
- 19:17two factors and Jackson, we talked a little bit about this
- 19:20on final settlement, but to to call it back out is that there's
- 19:24like above our pay grade. I think all of ours on a
- 19:26geopolitical level, if there's any kind of like scurry going on
- 19:30around like why it happened after the inauguration, all
- 19:32that. But like independent of that,
- 19:34the theme that Brian said around deflation and the tailwinds,
- 19:39what that means for equities in businesses, I think he's really
- 19:42important, but also to distill it down to something that like
- 19:45makes cents less around an ephemeral equities like, you
- 19:49know, multi trillion dollar marketplace.
- 19:51It's like at the end of the day, there's been this misaligned
- 19:54incentives across capital formation to there's all this
- 20:00liquidity. So you have to throw it at all
- 20:01these firms and they raise these billion dollar rounds.
- 20:05They have to raise the the venture capital of the private
- 20:07equity firm has to raise the Billings because they get the
- 20:09management fees, they get the capital stack.
- 20:11All this excess capital has to go somewhere.
- 20:13And then you ultimately have to deploy it to others in like a
- 20:16good example, this was SoftBank with the Weworks and Ubers of
- 20:19the world. It was widely known that when
- 20:21they went and put the capital in front of them or had the
- 20:23conversations, it was almost like a it was a do or die in
- 20:27front of like Uber where they told him, if you don't take this
- 20:29money, well, we're going to give it to Lyft.
- 20:31And then when you take that money, you have to go and do
- 20:33something with it. And this happened across it.
- 20:34I think this probably happens across all, you know, large
- 20:38venture firms in some capacity. But what?
- 20:41But why this matters is so if you give a venture firm, whether
- 20:44it's 10 million or they have $10 billion, they have to deploy
- 20:46that capital and now they have raised $6 billion and they have
- 20:50to charge and they have this growth trajectory that open AI
- 20:52was on. Well, what happens when you open
- 20:55source and you build it at one 100th or one one thousandth of
- 20:59the cost and now it's free or it's one 100th of the cost to
- 21:03the open market. All that capital just gets
- 21:05destroyed effectively because why would you spend as an
- 21:09individual $10.00 or $100 per month when it costs, you know, a
- 21:13dollar, whatever the case is. And that's across all capital
- 21:17markets that all this money has just been.
- 21:20It's neutered. It's effectively drowned out all
- 21:23efficiencies in unit economics in businesses.
- 21:27And, and so anyway, that's just like a more overarching theme.
- 21:31We had a report that I want to pull up because it really like
- 21:34viscerally shows, yeah, shows us through from early writers is
- 21:40basically the amount of money supply and then the amount of
- 21:43seed raise, seed fundraises or seed company raises.
- 21:48But then the the cost of starting a business and
- 21:51developing economies, right? You have these natural resources
- 21:54where it costs less to start a business, AWS, all these things.
- 21:57But at the same time, venture capital firms raise more capital
- 22:01and businesses have to raise more money.
- 22:03It makes zero sense. And so I think this is just a
- 22:07product of what we're going to see more of independent of why
- 22:10they did it. It's just a forcing function.
- 22:12And when you think about capital allocation and who you're giving
- 22:14your money to? Yeah, that's why I like these
- 22:17charts, just because you don't need to pull them back up.
- 22:19But I like those charts because this problem actually only
- 22:22accelerates. There's only going to be more
- 22:23money and technology is only going to become more efficient.
- 22:27So it's like that, that alligator mouth just continues
- 22:29to widen where you have who knows what a trillion dollars is
- 22:3420 years from now, right? Like we're going to have to have
- 22:36new metrics if we're still using the US dollar and other
- 22:38currencies. We're just going to have to
- 22:40continue to make up larger and larger units of this currency.
- 22:43While in the flip side of it, everything should be getting
- 22:46more efficient. It should be getting cheaper.
- 22:49And yeah, I like this one, too. Michael, what are we looking at
- 22:51here? Yeah.
- 22:52So it's effectively showing from 1990 to 2020, the reduction in
- 22:55amount of employees it took to generate $1,000,000 at A S&P 500
- 22:59company. So it's just this notion that
- 23:02what seven or eight people could have done and 30 years later, it
- 23:06takes one to two to generate that same $1,000,000.
- 23:09And you can take that, you can extrapolate that to your point,
- 23:13because I think the, the, the kicker here is where you always
- 23:16hear there's going to be the first billion dollar business by
- 23:19one individual. And I think eventually that
- 23:21happens. But it's, it's ultimately going
- 23:23to be a Bitcoiner and it's going to be somebody that understands
- 23:25Bitcoin deeply because then they're ultimately always going
- 23:27to get to the most optimal outcome of how they can make
- 23:29more Bitcoin. And so we talked about it's like
- 23:33what Deep seek did it at 50 million with, I don't know, 100
- 23:35people. I can almost guarantee you they
- 23:38either understood Bitcoin and we're trying to make more.
- 23:40Or if somebody does understand what they know and understands
- 23:43Bitcoin, they're going to be able to do it at $25 million
- 23:46with 50 people, because you're just going to find optimal
- 23:49outcomes. Because if they raise that
- 23:50capital in Bitcoin and sit on it, then every decision is going
- 23:53to be like, how do I get more efficient?
- 23:54And that's effectively what they did independent if they were
- 23:56denominating their capital stack in Bitcoin or not, they just
- 23:59made their money go a lot further because the incentives
- 24:02or the constraints were there versus you'll raise a billion
- 24:05dollars, well, sure, you need a billion dollars worth of GP us
- 24:07and all the things associated with it.
- 24:10Yeah, the other, the other thread here worth pointing out
- 24:14is you know a lot of what Jeff Booth talks about in The Price
- 24:18of Tomorrow and just the this notion of deflation like things
- 24:22as technology advances, we get more efficient as a species,
- 24:27things should get cheaper, quality of living, standard of
- 24:30living should go up and things can get cheaper.
- 24:32The reason that doesn't happen is because we debase the
- 24:35currency in tandem with that deflation.
- 24:37And it's also a basically a necessity of a credit based Fiat
- 24:43system that you can't have severe prolonged deflation.
- 24:47Otherwise that mounting debt load basically is impossible to
- 24:51pay off and it gets harder and harder to pay off as as
- 24:54deflation occurs. So, so the other core take away
- 24:58of all of this is like, yes, this is all going to continue to
- 25:01accelerate and even more reason why you need basically a finite
- 25:06battery to store all that excess productivity and efficiency in
- 25:09which is Bitcoin. And so, you know, as this
- 25:12continues to play out, I think people will wake up to that
- 25:14reality that you need to be basically efficiently storing
- 25:21those productivity gains from these deflationary technologies
- 25:24in an asset that won't be diluted.
- 25:26It's actually super bullish on humanity when you really think
- 25:29about it, because for every person that's laid off,
- 25:31somebody's going and sitting around and figuring out how to
- 25:33actually produce value because all these companies were
- 25:36effectively, it's known that Google doesn't need these many
- 25:38of employees. We saw what happened with
- 25:40Twitter, those individuals when you get paid $250,000 a year to
- 25:43hang around, well, you're just like happy.
- 25:45But the second that you have to figure out how to like survive,
- 25:48that's when you naturally start to build products and services.
- 25:51And we haven't had that for 20 plus years.
- 25:53You've had all these very intelligent people to try to
- 25:55figure out how to optimize your brain.
- 25:57And we're just going to go to this world because of inflation
- 25:59and because of deflation that people are going to be out
- 26:03having to build better products. So it's going to be painful, but
- 26:06it's also going to bring a really, you know, interesting
- 26:09future when it comes to like, a renaissance of just innovation.
- 26:12We talking golden? Age Better Orange Orange age
- 26:17with orange man and the orange coin.
- 26:20But the golden age, isn't it interesting?
- 26:22I don't know the exact quote, but did you all see like he he
- 26:25referenced 1870s and 1912? Like there was something that he
- 26:29wasn't. Do you know what I'm talking
- 26:30about Tim? Like he didn't reference it as
- 26:32the golden age or what is it LaBelle the Pope And like, but
- 26:35he referenced that years he wants to go back from it was
- 26:39just funny because that's basically the Gilded Age.
- 26:42I thought maybe he was speaking to that around his comments on
- 26:48income tax. Yeah, Yeah, I think you're
- 26:52right. At least part of it, yeah.
- 26:55Bitcoin custody is evolving and as institutional allocators
- 26:58increasingly look to incorporate digital sound money into their
- 27:01portfolios, risk management and operational excellence are
- 27:04paramount. Both self custody and single
- 27:07third party custody expose institutions to significant
- 27:10vulnerabilities. That's why Onramp is pioneering
- 27:13a new standard multi institution custody which eliminates single
- 27:16points of failure, adding fault tolerance and redundancy to
- 27:19Bitcoin custody. With Onramp, Bitcoin is secured
- 27:22in a segregated cold storage multi stick vault guarded by
- 27:25three independent institutional grade custodians, none of which
- 27:29have unilateral control. Funds are fully auditable on
- 27:32chain, cannot be re hypothecated and can only move or be
- 27:35withdrawn at the explicit direction of the end client.
- 27:39Multi Institution Custody removes the operational and
- 27:41technical burdens of private key management, providing an
- 27:44institutional grade custody solution that meets the
- 27:47stringent demands of family offices, Rias, endowments and
- 27:50pension funds. We recently launched Onramp
- 27:53Institutional, a dedicated segment of the business designed
- 27:55to provide secure, innovative Bitcoin custody and advisory
- 27:59solutions for institutions worldwide, providing allocators
- 28:02with robust security without compromising on accessibility
- 28:06and allowing them to tap into a comprehensive suite of financial
- 28:09services, from trading to lending and more, all built to
- 28:12institutional standards. Discover how On Ramp
- 28:15Institutional can elevate your firm's Bitcoin strategy.
- 28:17Schedule a consultation with our team to learn more at on
- 28:20rampbitcoin.com. Oh, so I wanted to talk about
- 28:25Tesla because we're talking about capital allocation, we're
- 28:29talking about Bitcoin treasuries with big Tim Cotsman here.
- 28:32And so let's talk about fair value accounting, Tim.
- 28:36I think the number was $500 million of income that Tesla was
- 28:42able to mark up in this most recent quarter.
- 28:46You want to speak to that and how that how we'll continue to
- 28:49see this play out for other Bitcoin corporate treasuries?
- 28:54Yeah. So I don't have the numbers in
- 28:55front of me, but I believe that markup from indefinite and
- 28:59tangible accounting to the new FASPI accounting fair value
- 29:03accounted for I think 26% of their earnings.
- 29:08So it'll be interesting to see how everyone from mainstream
- 29:15media to the algorithms and traders and how everybody's
- 29:21accounting for the operating business versus the treasury
- 29:25business, whether it's Tesla or micro strategy.
- 29:30And I mean, I don't want to say the wrong number and I don't
- 29:34have it in front of me, but it's I think micro strategies Bitcoin
- 29:39hoard is like 47 times bigger than Tesla's.
- 29:43So what happens when micro strategy adopts the fast be
- 29:46accounting? Probably a positive development.
- 29:51Is, is there any notion though that like if you're a
- 29:54sophisticated analyst on Wall Street, like you've probably
- 29:58been pricing that in to your analysis for at least the past
- 30:0212 months? Like, so is it, is it this
- 30:04massive change that people are expecting it to be?
- 30:08I think that's the question. I don't know.
- 30:10I know that when they had whatever the numbers were 60, 6
- 30:18million or 60 million, it was like 100 X on their market cap
- 30:22when the market cap of Tesla went up by 5% yesterday.
- 30:26So it just the math alone is pretty staggering.
- 30:31I this unpopular take that like I don't think any of Wall
- 30:33Streeter people care about what micro strategy does or doesn't
- 30:36do. It's actually like they they
- 30:37care less what it looks like simply because it's become like
- 30:41a character caricature character of like of a business.
- 30:47So like, I don't think anybody's modeling outside of like
- 30:50hardcore either somebody that's, I don't want to say hardcore
- 30:53Bitcoin or I think it's somebody that on the edges is trying to
- 30:57maybe seize their business as kind of like similar to MSDR
- 31:01back in the day, like it was just stagnant.
- 31:03They weren't going anywhere. And so it's like, how can I have
- 31:05a new narrative and juice it in the capital markets?
- 31:07I think what like prudent traditional CF OS and analysts
- 31:11are looking for somebody that comes out and puts a very
- 31:14conservative, conservative placement like goes through the
- 31:20consensus from a governance perspective, explains why they
- 31:23did it, explains the tailwinds. I think that plays a lot of much
- 31:27larger factor and what we're talking about then anything
- 31:31really MicroStrategy does just because it just it's harder.
- 31:35It's hard to wrap your head around why if you're running
- 31:37your business and you're worried about all these other things,
- 31:39like how are you ever going to do anything that MSTR does?
- 31:42Or it just doesn't feel like it's, it's apples to apples.
- 31:46Yeah. I mean, basically there's micro
- 31:49strategy and then that's it. I mean, there's just so few
- 31:52companies that have more than even 1000 Bitcoin on their
- 31:55balance sheet that it's really an outlier that to your point,
- 31:58Michael, no one's really paying attention to.
- 32:02So it'll be interesting when we get to that moment where as the
- 32:08volatility continues until the lesson is learned that, you
- 32:13know, a lots of eyeballs continue on to this.
- 32:16And you know, my theory is you'll have some combination of
- 32:20executive order, congressional act and states adopting Bitcoin
- 32:25that at some point spurs more corporates to adopt at least a
- 32:29portion of their cash into Bitcoin.
- 32:32Probably the cheer, but this is. A great chart, Jackson, because
- 32:35like this is what I was getting at.
- 32:36So it's like MSTR, we're looking at the top, you know, Bitcoin
- 32:39treasuries. So it's MSTR 471,000 marathon
- 32:43with 40,000 you have riot Tesla Coinbase HUD 8 block.
- 32:48So blocks like the first one you get to that's not like pure oil
- 32:51and Tesla, but they both have insanely eccentric CE OS that
- 32:55you know, you're not looking at them for your, you know, capital
- 32:59to protect your capital sacks, specifically block and Jack
- 33:01Dorsey and cash app. But like you go through this
- 33:03list, there's not whatever it be either like a Facebook or just a
- 33:09company that is recognized for their underlying business
- 33:13structure and somebody coming out and saying, look, This is
- 33:14why we did a very small percentage.
- 33:18And I think more of that has to happen to really move the needle
- 33:20from like a Wall Street perspective, or at least like
- 33:23publicly traded companies. Yeah, like we had a conversation
- 33:27last night, Michael Bryan and I, or became apparent that most
- 33:31people just think that we're playing with this thing, right?
- 33:33Trump said that in his speech at Nashville, literally said have
- 33:37fun playing with your Bitcoin and crypto.
- 33:39Yeah. And so I think that is the
- 33:42perception where it's starting to become recognized as an asset
- 33:46class. I think that started in 2024.
- 33:50People were saying that it was happening for years prior to
- 33:53that, but it really didn't. The ETFs were the first
- 33:55successful financial product for Bitcoin that aligns incentives.
- 34:00It's always about incentives, right?
- 34:01So Wall Street wants to make money.
- 34:03So now they have product. They want Bitcoin to succeed And
- 34:06so 2024 was the first year for institutional adoption of the
- 34:10asset. And I would I kind of lean I'm
- 34:14somewhere in between Tim and Michael.
- 34:15I mean, I think that I guess where I would would say I'm at
- 34:20is Bitcoin treasuries is like it's still the first pitch of
- 34:24the first inning, right? Like to your point, this chart
- 34:27is almost all micro strategy. If you look at this chart, if
- 34:30you're on video, it's you're literally just looking at micro
- 34:32strategies, Bitcoin, treasury, and then you have a handful of
- 34:36other smaller boxes here, but they're all almost all Bitcoin
- 34:39or crypto companies, yeah. More than half of them are
- 34:41minors. And yeah.
- 34:43Yeah, I would say it is it is a startling contrast.
- 34:48And so I would say like the one that got me relatively excited
- 34:53was, was similar when they made their announcement.
- 34:56Now they haven't, you know, accumulated on par with a micro
- 35:00shed. Yeah, it's 2000 here.
- 35:02Yeah. But like that was, that was a
- 35:04company that I had known and followed from like my Triadfi
- 35:08days. So I I knew it as like a quality
- 35:11business that otherwise didn't need to do this.
- 35:15Like it was a cash flow positive business.
- 35:18And so that to me was like a really important one in terms of
- 35:22the adoption just because it was a, a credible business, like it
- 35:25wasn't, it was more credible business than like what micro
- 35:29strategy was prior to their Bitcoin strategy effectively.
- 35:34But to your point, Michael, like we haven't seen a ton since
- 35:36then. It's it's really been more on
- 35:38the margins, very smaller, smaller players.
- 35:40Yeah, And I guess that the essence, it's a gimmick to most
- 35:43people looking outside. And then even for Sembler, I was
- 35:46actually on your side. We're like very interested in a,
- 35:49you know, company adopting, thinking about macro tailwinds,
- 35:53inflation protection. But like I only listen to one
- 35:56pod with him and he basically came at it as the gimmick angle
- 35:58of like there was something that he like he didn't fully grok
- 36:01Bitcoin. It was like I can play this up
- 36:02as far. As like he knew he knew it was a
- 36:04contrarian bet and he likes contrarian bets was I think the
- 36:08bulk of his thesis. Yeah, which is to me is like a
- 36:12cousin of like I want to juice my stock price.
- 36:14And this is an interesting thing.
- 36:15It's like the the meta planets of the world, which are
- 36:17perfectly fine if that's what. But it's just like a different
- 36:19angle from serious people sitting in a boardroom trying to
- 36:23establish a position here. Like that's not how they're
- 36:26going to underwrite it is at a gimmick level or a contrarian
- 36:29bet. Like they it needs to be
- 36:30something sound and it's just not there.
- 36:32And I think that's what why we don't see a lot of it
- 36:35independent because this ties back to the fasby stuff you
- 36:38talked about and you were referencing like it hasn't an
- 36:40analyst looked at this is like they've all looked at it.
- 36:42But the problem is like, once you look at it and say it, you
- 36:44still have to generate the consensus at the corporate
- 36:46level, which is one of the probably hardest things to do.
- 36:48That's why we don't have that much adoption because there's
- 36:51people like us at all these companies.
- 36:52But then once you have to re, you know, run it up the ladder,
- 36:55you're either like kicked out or you just end up hitting your
- 36:57head against the wall because people just think people are
- 37:00crazy. Hey, Michael, do you think when
- 37:04Trump says stuff like have fun playing with your Bitcoin that
- 37:08it's just like an off the cuff, like he's not even really
- 37:13thinking about it in advance for a comment?
- 37:14Or is it like 4 or 5D chess where it's like, well, we need
- 37:19to create this stockpile and we don't want people to front run
- 37:23us. So if people think it's more of
- 37:24like a toy, then that's actually strategically good for the
- 37:28United States. Or am I just like way off on the
- 37:31edge somewhere? Definitely off on the edge.
- 37:33This is part. Of how this is how.
- 37:35This is how we stumbled on the talking about your bitcoins
- 37:37because we were talking about, you know, mission and things
- 37:40that we want to talk about in copy.
- 37:41And like as an individual, we all recognize what Bitcoin means
- 37:44and multi generational legacy and all that.
- 37:46But when you throw that on a website, like people look at it
- 37:48and they're like, wait, this is a toy you're going to play with
- 37:52your bitcoins. How is that going to protect
- 37:53your legacy? So it speaks to a subset of the
- 37:55market, but it doesn't speak to serious people that have
- 37:57legacies in the traditional world, right?
- 38:00And sort of bridge that gap. And so that's what I feel.
- 38:02And I think, I think Brian and Jackson.
- 38:04Are I'll take a, I'm going to take a, it's it's going to
- 38:06sound, it's going to sound like I'm going against what I just
- 38:12said. But I think it's both where
- 38:15there is this perception that Bitcoin is like this toy or it's
- 38:19this made-up technology and both people don't understand it yet.
- 38:22But there are enough people in Trump's cabinet and close to him
- 38:26that do understand Bitcoin and its strategic role.
- 38:29So who knows? I mean, Trump just says shit off
- 38:32the cuff, right? Like it's, it's entertaining and
- 38:34it's comedic relief. Who I'm not going to read too
- 38:38much into those comments, but I do think there's still a lot of
- 38:40people who probably like my family.
- 38:43They're like this guy's just playing with his Bitcoin.
- 38:46But there are. Think about the context of like
- 38:49what? What Tim had asked.
- 38:51Like so put yourself you're trunk, you know?
- 38:53And I was, I was going there. Who was?
- 38:55Just referring to in the context of theirs, like he's in a room,
- 38:58how many people were in that room for any other thing, any
- 39:03other asset or not that evangelical and all the things
- 39:06that are associated. You imagine his like mentions on
- 39:09Twitter, like, you know, he pays attention to the engagement.
- 39:13So it's like you guys are nuts. Like go have fun playing with
- 39:15your bitcoins. That's what like is embedded.
- 39:17I don't think there's anything more or less to that.
- 39:19It's like you guys go have fun. Like I'm going to give you what
- 39:21you want. You gave me a bunch of money.
- 39:22You guys are allowed like appreciate it.
- 39:24And then to your point, in his cabinet there is people that
- 39:27recognize this. Yeah, that's fair.
- 39:29And so that's an interesting point then.
- 39:32So we're talking about playing with your Bitcoins and the
- 39:36perceived lack of adoption of a Bitcoin within let's say non
- 39:40Bitcoin or crypto related businesses, right?
- 39:43So we haven't seen a ton of it yet.
- 39:44I think all four of us agree that it is coming.
- 39:46Some of the roadblocks and toxicity around managing the
- 39:49asset are now gone. So it's going to happen at a
- 39:53much more accelerated rate going forward.
- 39:56What I do think is interesting though is there's a lot more
- 39:58announcements around state legislation recently.
- 40:01So right where I think we're at now at 14 or 15 states.
- 40:06That have introduced legislation around something Bitcoin related
- 40:10it's not all strategic Bitcoin reserve bills.
- 40:13I think some of them are related to pensions being able to
- 40:15allocate potentially into ETFs. But I think that's particularly
- 40:20interesting because last week we talked a little bit about when
- 40:23we were recording, we were talking about the digital asset
- 40:26stockpile bill or part of the investigating that as part of
- 40:30the executive order. So that's still on the table.
- 40:32I think I forget if it's 180 days or something.
- 40:35But in the meantime, what we're seeing, our states are being
- 40:39really they're serious about Bitcoin, right?
- 40:41They're, they're looking into this in different ways.
- 40:44And So what do you guys think about that?
- 40:45I that's accelerating, states are thinking about it from a
- 40:48Treasury perspective more so maybe than corporates are right
- 40:50now. Yeah, I think it's insanely
- 40:52bullish and not being talked about enough.
- 40:54It's actually in my mind, like maybe not more important, but
- 41:01it's like a more logical path to government level adoption in the
- 41:06sense that, you know, Bitcoin is this emergent thing.
- 41:08It starts with the individual. And so it's, it's, it's logical
- 41:12that it would start with states as opposed to the federal level
- 41:14first in my mind. And it seems like there's a new
- 41:17one being announced every day or every other day.
- 41:20I think we're up to like 14, you know, pieces of legislation at
- 41:23the state level now. And to your point, like I think
- 41:27this if, if some of these get through, which I expect them to,
- 41:33it does start to give the court like the corporate the air cover
- 41:38to say, well, this is, this is clearly a reserve asset.
- 41:41Like it adds to the credibility of the argument when they go to
- 41:45their C-Suite or their investment committee to say,
- 41:48well, like, you know, these 14 states are accumulating Bitcoin
- 41:52for their treasury. Like, why aren't we as a, as a
- 41:54corporate entity? So I think I think this is super
- 41:57important and extremely bullish. Yeah, I think it's a cousin of
- 42:03the sovereign stuff we talked about at the base.
- 42:06You know, as you get closer and closer to the end individual,
- 42:10they are closer to the political framework and they all have I
- 42:15remember just 'cause I live here like the the studies that they
- 42:18did where for sound money like adoption.
- 42:22If you were like under the age of 50, I think you wanted
- 42:24Bitcoin some kind of, you know, policy in Texas.
- 42:27And if you're about 50, you wanted gold backed currency like
- 42:30people want a money that can't be debased.
- 42:33And so I think to Brian's point, you get closer to the signal as
- 42:36you get closer to the people. And, you know, we should
- 42:38probably get Lee on at some point because I know they're
- 42:40getting close, Lee Bratcher in Texas to get this in place.
- 42:46So, yeah, Michael, what do you think about that being the sole
- 42:49Texan here, the Lieutenant governor of Texas, Dan Patrick,
- 42:53I think it was yesterday or could have been this morning,
- 42:57something about Bitcoin Reserve being a top legislation priority
- 43:01for 2025. I think at the end of the day,
- 43:04like we talked about a lot, it's all about incentives.
- 43:06And in Texas, why the political framework has been so has moved
- 43:11so much or so fast is because of the amount of hash rate, which
- 43:15means amount of revenue, which means amount of lobbying.
- 43:19And so it's a it's a big deal. They understand that it
- 43:21generates revenue. I think there was a report that
- 43:24I won't pretend to fully understand, but I think that the
- 43:27mining industry helped the grid with like a save $18 billion
- 43:31last year that came out from I think it was a Texas Blockchain
- 43:35Council or one of the affiliates.
- 43:37So this is like not something that is just pandering in the
- 43:41sense of like, oh, there's some interesting parties.
- 43:43It's like they understand that there's real enterprise that's
- 43:45being formed. There's cities and Rockdale's
- 43:47one of them. There's there's a bunch of like
- 43:49articles and things that have come out where you've brought
- 43:51back jobs and capital to state. So it wouldn't make sense.
- 43:55Bill. Wyoming's also right there.
- 43:57They've been there for a while, as well as some others.
- 44:02Yeah. Well, I'm excited to see
- 44:03Pennsylvania there. That bill was introduced
- 44:07probably sometime in December. I want to say if I remember
- 44:10correctly, it's would allow for the state to put up to 10% of
- 44:16the treasury into Bitcoin, which is the total treasury I want to
- 44:19say is about 7 or $8 billion. So Max out allocation at 7
- 44:24hundred $800 million. And I think this is incredibly
- 44:28exciting. I, I think that this will happen
- 44:31likely before more accelerated corporate adoption.
- 44:35Maybe what will happen the fastest though, we are seeing
- 44:37this more and more just in conversation and tracking.
- 44:41Some of the data is within Wall Street, Wall Street adopt for
- 44:44think about 3. There's like the public sector
- 44:47with States and federal, there's corporations and then there's
- 44:51Wall Street. I think the Wall Street adoption
- 44:54is happening at the fastest clip. 2024, however many billion
- 44:59were in Ibid and other products. Now I don't know the number off
- 45:01the top of my head, most successful ETFs of all time.
- 45:04And I'm really excited to take a look into the 13 FS for the
- 45:10fourth quarter of 2024 because that'll show a lot of new
- 45:14allocations. We'll effectively be able to see
- 45:16what happened after Trump won in November.
- 45:20Did firm start to allocate in size?
- 45:22Were they adding to their positions?
- 45:24Do we see a lot of that new firm step in?
- 45:26Tim, I think there was one thing that you wanted to talk about
- 45:28too, just about some of these larger wire houses like Wells
- 45:31Fargo stifle others that are allowing for greater access to
- 45:36Bitcoin ETFs. I actually formerly worked at
- 45:38Stifel. I had an old account there.
- 45:40I wanted to buy the Bitcoin ETF in it like months ago before I
- 45:44rolled it over and I wasn't allowed to.
- 45:47So I put it into micro strategy and probably somewhere break
- 45:51even right now in the MSTR position.
- 45:53But point aside, Tim, what are your thoughts on just widening
- 45:58adoption access within Wall Street for the ETF products?
- 46:04Yeah, I mean, yesterday AP, Abacus, Andrew, you know, posted
- 46:10that they're expecting additional Bitcoin, spot Bitcoin
- 46:13ETF approvals, which again, seems kind of silly to say a
- 46:17year after they were approved by the Regulatory agency.
- 46:20But for multiple wealth management firms, to your point,
- 46:25by the end of Q1, names of note that will broaden availability.
- 46:28Wells Fargo, Steve Full, Raymond James, UBS and then, yeah,
- 46:38another account did a crypto presentation to 700 financial
- 46:43advisors, including from Wells Fargo, JP Morgan and similar
- 46:47firms. So I think it's all kind of
- 46:50brewing under the surface there. And then on the state's aspect
- 46:55of it, it reminds me of New Year's Eve.
- 46:58I'm standing there, sailors talking to us for a couple
- 47:00minutes. And one of his comments was, you
- 47:02know, people just tweet, right? You can just tweet all day long
- 47:05about whatever and but they won't read the first sentence of
- 47:09anything, let alone the entire 8K.
- 47:13So last night I listened to, you know, this took a lot of energy
- 47:17for me, like a whole 3 1/2 minute video.
- 47:20It was Thomas McCarthy giving testimony in New Hampshire for
- 47:24the House Bill 3O2 for state legislation for Bitcoin.
- 47:29And he said, you know, they're also expecting it, this similar
- 47:33legislation to be introduced in Oklahoma, Kansas, Iowa, Montana,
- 47:36Utah, Wyoming and others. And some of those states have
- 47:40been introduced over the last couple of days.
- 47:42But yeah, if you just kind of read the headline and make your
- 47:46assumption and either get super positive or super, you know,
- 47:51negative, it's not super helpful.
- 47:54So I think the the devil's in the details with all of these
- 47:57things. And there's so much going on
- 47:59that if you're not really spending hours a day, which most
- 48:04people are not, it, you can end up with the wrong impression
- 48:07pretty easily. Yeah.
- 48:09I think one thing that Brian had mentioned is like the friend,
- 48:13the friendly administration from a federal perspective, federal
- 48:16level is the air cover because there's probably states that
- 48:19wanted to do this. But because of that heavy
- 48:21reliance on Fed fund funding may have been just like banks, just
- 48:26like maybe we should do this. We don't rock the boat.
- 48:28And an easy example of this that we saw was El Salvador in the
- 48:31IMF, because it's different, but it's kind of the same in that
- 48:34they adopted the strategy. And then I think this week they
- 48:36had to come and roll back even more of what they put in place a
- 48:41couple of years ago. And so that's the difference
- 48:44between having the air cover from, you know, whoever is
- 48:47capitalizing Europe or helping and the IMF is probably the
- 48:52furthest from liking Bitcoin at this point.
- 48:57Yeah. What do you guys think?
- 48:58So there's a lot of stuff going on behind the scenes, states,
- 49:03corporates, Wall Street. I keep anchoring to those 3
- 49:06cohorts because when people talk about institutions like those,
- 49:09are the three cohorts worth paying attention to?
- 49:12I think the four of us generally are pretty busy working.
- 49:16So we don't tend to your point. We don't just get to sit on
- 49:20Twitter all day and read headlines.
- 49:21So trying to be discerning here on what actually the signal is
- 49:27from the noise. I'm curious guys, what did you
- 49:29see if you did see anything this week, like what, what was the
- 49:32noise? I think we already covered a lot
- 49:34of signal, but was there anything that caught your
- 49:37attention that was whether it was in Bitcoin or crypto or just
- 49:41in broader markets? I would argue that J pal is
- 49:44noise. The Federal Reserve, they're,
- 49:46they're always noisy, but I want to hear some better takes than
- 49:48that. I mean, DOGE ETF just comes to
- 49:51mind because I think they finally filed that, but we've
- 49:54already talked about that one. That was a bit wise.
- 49:59I think 11 narrative that I've seen the past few weeks is
- 50:07effectively like the the crypto. So like X Bitcoin space is even
- 50:17though bitcoins like at all time highs, like a lot of altcoin
- 50:21speculators are basically wrecked right now.
- 50:24And why that is is basically like you haven't seen like in in
- 50:29prior cycles, this like massive rotation from Bitcoin to
- 50:34altcoins. It just hasn't really happened.
- 50:37Like there's been a ton of liquidity pumped into meme coins
- 50:41and all these other things, but it hasn't like come from
- 50:43Bitcoin, which is what has happened in the past to some
- 50:46degree where Bitcoin sort of leads the rally and then sort of
- 50:50chills out for a little bit and that sort of then distributes to
- 50:53all coin market. Haven't really seen that.
- 50:55I think for a few reasons. 1 is just, there's a different market
- 51:01participant right now with ETFs and just institutional and sort
- 51:07of nation state level adoption occurring where for one, they
- 51:13have a long term view on the asset, right?
- 51:14So they're not looking to rotate into anything necessarily.
- 51:17They're just looking to accumulate the asset and hold
- 51:18it. And they're definitely not
- 51:20looking to rotate into meme coins or you know, XRP or
- 51:23something. And so I think that's, that's a
- 51:25component and just like the market participants are changing
- 51:29and this is reflective of Jackson.
- 51:32You want to pull up that chart that River put out is a great
- 51:35one, just showing the divergent and the decoupling of Bitcoin
- 51:41and, and broader crypto. And so you can see it in prior
- 51:43cycles, it's sort of maps where, you know, they're sort of rising
- 51:48and falling in tandem. And you've seen this departure
- 51:51over the past, you know, 6 to 9 months or so.
- 51:54And so this is a big sort of signal to me that despite what
- 52:00we often say, like, you know, there's a ton of education that
- 52:03still needs to occur in terms of, you know, distilling why
- 52:06Bitcoin is very different. I think this is a signal that it
- 52:09is happening on the margins. People are beginning to realize
- 52:12that these things are different. And now there's just a whole
- 52:16cohort of the market that's only interested in Bitcoin and not
- 52:20the rest of the stuff. And they're not looking to
- 52:22rotate, they're not trading. These are long term allocations.
- 52:25And so it's it's partly investment time horizon and also
- 52:30just the sophistication of the allocator that I think is is
- 52:34driving this slight departure from from previous cycles, which
- 52:38I think is pretty interesting. Yeah, I think I generally, I
- 52:43actually agree with pretty much everything you said there,
- 52:45Brian. The big pools of capital,
- 52:48they're going to stick to Bitcoin only.
- 52:50I think where crypto continues to get pumped on the market cap
- 52:53side is just by shit coin venture capital.
- 52:57That's not going to stop, especially as there's more
- 52:59dollars and more liquidity entering the market whenever
- 53:02that next liquidity cycle picks up.
- 53:04So that'll be a catalyst for more market cap in the rest of
- 53:09the crypto space. But I think that'll be more
- 53:10heavily outweighed. So it'll be significantly
- 53:14outweighed by all the other institutions that are stepping
- 53:17in from a more strategic asset allocation.
- 53:19And then you have the meme coins.
- 53:21I don't know where the tweet, when I saw a tweet last night
- 53:24about Maraud's top 10 meme coins from like 3 months ago, if you
- 53:28bought his basket, you're down like 80%.
- 53:32And so it's just, it's a shame because retail I think will
- 53:36continue to get distracted at the top of the funnel and
- 53:40there's infinitely more distractions now.
- 53:41I don't even know how many coins are created every day now.
- 53:44It's absolutely insane. But you can just download apps
- 53:46to your phone now. You can buy, you could buy
- 53:49whatever with Apple Pay. So like people are just like
- 53:52gambling rampantly in the meme coin space.
- 53:55And that's just going to get a lot of people wrecked.
- 53:57But I do think that chart that River put out, we're going to
- 53:59see a divergent there, an even greater scale.
- 54:02Bitcoin is still about 60% dominance in the market.
- 54:06And I think that previous market cycles, right, it's maybe gone
- 54:10down to about 40 or so as old, you know, old season picks up.
- 54:14I don't think that happens this time around.
- 54:16It may, it may be come down a little bit, but not much.
- 54:19I'll take the complete other side of that.
- 54:22I think we're giving. Trump's coin.
- 54:23Trump coin going to a trillion, Yeah.
- 54:26I mean, I think like. Because that's what it would
- 54:27take at this point though, no SO.
- 54:29Like I think there's two parts. There's the one that we talked
- 54:31about AI was there's all this liquidity.
- 54:33So AI naturally, like it ties into the discussion from the
- 54:36beginning about or near the beginning about open AI and all
- 54:41these firms raising billions of dollars and venture firms
- 54:44raising billions to deploy or needing to like shift their
- 54:47positions into AI companies because they had this capital
- 54:50and they had to justify it going somewhere.
- 54:52So that rotation will just naturally come into crypto.
- 54:56There's not enough places to put.
- 54:57And then ultimately what you guys are describing is everyone
- 55:00waking up and realizing it's Bitcoin, It's the same.
- 55:02It's a it's the same side of like corporate adoption where
- 55:05maybe there's less consensus, but there's still big consensus
- 55:08that has to go and leapfrog from this is speculative and a toy to
- 55:11now I'm going to deploy meaningful capital to to create
- 55:14that divergent. It's not to say it's not
- 55:15happening. It is happening because the
- 55:17markets getting more educated, but the way I look at it is for
- 55:20everyone individual that learns this, there's another 10 to 100
- 55:24that come in via the awareness of crypto and naturally have to
- 55:27go through that until we hit that like deep part, but we're
- 55:30still nowhere near that. And like the the indications of
- 55:33that were just this week with like, you know, you mentioned
- 55:36Trump coin. It's like not Trump coin.
- 55:37It's Trump media launches truth by fintech with crypto ambitions
- 55:41or also the accelerated narrative around, you know, fund
- 55:47managers. There's multiple that's come out
- 55:49this week that fund managers are ready to start deploying into
- 55:51crypto. It's just, it's just, it doesn't
- 55:55support like I know what we want to happen and what we think, but
- 55:57like at the end of the day, the incentives aren't aligned for
- 56:00them to go cuz then how do you get paid for going and
- 56:02allocating the Bitcoin, right? You got to go take a bet on the
- 56:05sector. And it doesn't have to just be
- 56:06like all coins, the security securitizing everything under
- 56:09the sun. It's been under the like
- 56:11happening that's rumbling and that's going to be a big thing.
- 56:14I know of like large firms, like multi trillion dollar banks that
- 56:17are coming in and going to securitize everything under the
- 56:19sun and call it whatever. So yeah, we're we got a long way
- 56:22to go before the market that divergent happens, but.
- 56:25This is how we get. It on tape so we can look back.
- 56:27You know, save some monster. So your so your call for the
- 56:30record is you think Bitcoin dominance decreases from here
- 56:33throughout this cycle? Or as long as we, yeah, I think,
- 56:37I think that's fair as long as the price of Bitcoin goes into
- 56:40the one 25150 to the 200 K range that it's going to reduce
- 56:46dominance over the course of next 12 to 24 months, not
- 56:49increase. So they actually said I said the
- 56:51same thing though I said that I thought.
- 56:53You said it's gonna go do the opposite.
- 56:54It's gonna go. Just I don't know.
- 56:56All right, let me put my position out there.
- 56:59I don't think it's gonna go down as far as it has in previous
- 57:01cycles, which is probably around 40% dominance.
- 57:05I could still see dominance going down a bit from here, but
- 57:08not much is is my point. I would also wouldn't be
- 57:11surprised if it went up. So maybe, maybe my maybe I have
- 57:14a lot of takes going on here, but.
- 57:16I just think like if we just think through the numbers a bit,
- 57:19let's say Bitcoin double S, it's a $4 trillion asset.
- 57:22So for dominance to stay where it is, then you'd basically need
- 57:29a little over 2 trillion in other assets.
- 57:33And for for just simplicity sake, like I'm not including
- 57:37like stable coins or like tokenized real world assets in
- 57:43this like other bucket because I just, I just don't think that
- 57:45really counts. You're just digitizing existing
- 57:47assets. And so, yeah, you'd have to
- 57:51assume that broader altcoin space, you know, adds a trillion
- 57:59if not more in market cap. And in my mind, it's just like,
- 58:02well, where is that coming from? Because I think the order, the
- 58:06the magnitude of capital flow is just different between what's
- 58:11going to flow towards Bitcoin with toward versus what's going
- 58:14to flow towards, you know, a given meme coin or XRPI think
- 58:17they're just orders of magnitudes difference.
- 58:20And so how do you move that broader altcoin market cap up
- 58:24that much? It would literally have to be
- 58:26like Trump coin going to like yeah, 3/4 of a trillion or
- 58:31something. So tell me if I'm missing
- 58:34something here, but if you're securitizing something on the
- 58:37blockchain or DOGE is going to use a public blockchain, they're
- 58:41going to attach some token or some, some unit and subscribe
- 58:44some value to it. We know it doesn't need, it's
- 58:47not needed. But like that it's they're not
- 58:49going to be, they're not going to securitize things in a
- 58:51vacuum. Right.
- 58:54So that would be they're, they're intertwined.
- 58:57That's fair. They're just not, they're not
- 59:02like alternate, like they're not alternate assets.
- 59:04They're existing assets on blockchain rails.
- 59:07So like I would include whatever the the native token of those
- 59:10rails is, is yes in that X Bitcoin category.
- 59:14And that's what will cause the pump, but that's what will cause
- 59:16the pump. So if you come in and you're
- 59:17going to like make an efficient doge or whatever, or you're
- 59:20going to securitize like the Bill Biddle or whatever that
- 59:23securitizes doing with BlackRock, like there's going to
- 59:25subscribe some token to that in multiple in whatever.
- 59:29You know, we got to get a resident expert altcoin, but
- 59:32like there's bridges and layer in multiple layers and roll ups
- 59:35and all this stuff that they're just going to like sell to Wall
- 59:39Street to say like this is how you use this.
- 59:41This is where the future is. And they understand
- 59:43diversification. And like, that sounds really
- 59:45sexy because you can get in early.
- 59:48I think a lot of times, though, the participation in these new
- 59:52memes and buzzwords and tokens isn't the venture space.
- 59:57And so I tried to pull up the venture fundraising numbers the
- 1:00:00past couple years. I don't know if they're
- 1:00:02accurate. It's just the first thing I saw
- 1:00:04is like about 60 to $70 billion. Which seems low, but if that's
- 1:00:10the case, even if it's a bit higher, that's such a small
- 1:00:13number compared to the larger pools of capital that would
- 1:00:16consider Bitcoin only in my opinion.
- 1:00:20So if it's like a 16Z and these other crypto funds that
- 1:00:24participate in new all coin issuance, that's just such a
- 1:00:28small market compared to traditional finance that may
- 1:00:32participate a little bit in that.
- 1:00:33But I just don't think it's scale like how how many assets
- 1:00:36are going to be in the DOGE ETF by the end of the year?
- 1:00:38The the example to go back to that is This is why the the take
- 1:00:44from safe was really good about they shouldn't have put Sam in
- 1:00:47jail for what he did because he gives you the air cover like
- 1:00:51Ontario pension or whatever. Like God bless up in Canada.
- 1:00:53They've gotten rugs so much like including in the crypto space.
- 1:00:56Then in 22, how many pensions were rugged by going into
- 1:01:00investing not only in hedge funds that invest in these
- 1:01:03tokens, but also like the infrastructure.
- 1:01:06So they love that story. You go to them because they're
- 1:01:08going to like, it's like, well, you can have a higher return
- 1:01:10profile on this. So there's capital pools that
- 1:01:12will come into those assets. They don't have to be like
- 1:01:15venture firms that buy up, you know, like the paradigm is a
- 1:01:18good example. Their seed funders was a was a
- 1:01:21Yale CC Swenson. So like the capital exists is
- 1:01:26really it's a pass through via these other entities, but
- 1:01:29they'll go and buy the tokens. I'm just saying like it's not
- 1:01:31over for everyone's going to wake up one day and realize
- 1:01:35bitcoins the thing and jump to their meaningful allocation.
- 1:01:37I think it's going to help, obviously, with the
- 1:01:39administration and reputation that's grown from it, but I'd be
- 1:01:42happy to be proven wrong. It's just everything we've seen.
- 1:01:45It's like nobody just wakes up. It's like, oh, bitcoins the
- 1:01:47thing. It's like, again, it's a
- 1:01:48gimmick. It's a toy for everyone, which
- 1:01:50ties into the Ledger stuff because like you give somebody a
- 1:01:52Ledger or a cold card and you tell them put $20 million on it,
- 1:01:55they're like, you guys are jokers.
- 1:01:56Like I'm just going to go back to, you know, my negative
- 1:01:58yielding bonds because at least they don't have that tomorrow.
- 1:02:04Yeah, that's a fairpoint. Yeah.
- 1:02:06What should we, Tim? Are there any things before we
- 1:02:11jump into something else, were there any other topics you
- 1:02:13wanted to cover? I feel like we went through a
- 1:02:16lot of news already, but I want to give you the floor as well if
- 1:02:20there's some things you've been paying attention to this week
- 1:02:22that we didn't get into and. And to pull on what I just said,
- 1:02:26because I feel like Tim, you're, I don't want to say newer to the
- 1:02:28space, but you're sitting in a somewhat different seat from
- 1:02:31your background coming in, who you're interacting.
- 1:02:34Like what do you think about just kind of Howard, as it ties
- 1:02:36into what Jackson asked, where you see that adoption And and do
- 1:02:39you think people kind of in the circles that you're running with
- 1:02:42or have adjacent from previous professional experiences, how
- 1:02:46they're going to come in? Because eventually a lot of
- 1:02:48people are going to come in because of the price
- 1:02:49appreciation in the sector. How do you see them adopting
- 1:02:52like different assets? Yeah, so the cover of Forbes
- 1:02:59this morning, having Michael Saylor on it actually really
- 1:03:02took me back because this morning you have Sailor on the
- 1:03:06cover. It says volatility virtuoso
- 1:03:10Michael Saylor, the Bitcoin alchemist.
- 1:03:13Why Michael Saylor's micro strategy is a brilliant
- 1:03:15blueprint for manipulating traditional finance to harness
- 1:03:20the Pixie dust of crypto mania now.
- 1:03:24There you go. Like damn it.
- 1:03:26They just distilled everything I was describing and one caption.
- 1:03:31What I. Didn't put the laser eyes on
- 1:03:34them there. I was a mess by them.
- 1:03:36Yeah. No orange tie either.
- 1:03:38No orange tie. So you got to represent.
- 1:03:40But it took me back because I had met many years ago, Aubrey
- 1:03:48McClendon, who was the CEO of the largest natural gas company
- 1:03:52in the United States at a certain point.
- 1:03:55And I was actually business partners with his nephew.
- 1:03:57And there's just some history there where I was literally at
- 1:04:01his funeral and he was on Forbes back in 2011.
- 1:04:05You can literally pull it up. Actually posted about it this
- 1:04:07morning. And the caption on Forbes was
- 1:04:10America's most reckless billionaire.
- 1:04:13And so there's two different threads here. 1 is there's a
- 1:04:20difference between being reckless and not being reckless
- 1:04:23when it comes to volatility. Like they don't have to be.
- 1:04:25You don't have to be reckless if you're dealing with volatility,
- 1:04:28but you could be. And then the aspect of you think
- 1:04:36about the story of natural gas and mineral rights, which is my
- 1:04:40background, and how when you lease up and you drill a lot of
- 1:04:44natural gas, you're creating more supply.
- 1:04:47It drives down the price. And sometimes that doesn't have
- 1:04:51a happy ending. I feel like now with Bitcoin,
- 1:04:54you literally have the exact opposite happening.
- 1:04:57You have a company that's levered long responsibly on
- 1:05:00Bitcoin, which is a finite asset.
- 1:05:02You can't just lease up more land and drill for more Bitcoin.
- 1:05:08And then just like the macro side of it of how early we are
- 1:05:12because like Early Riders is the first Bitcoin denominated
- 1:05:17venture firm. I don't know any other firm that
- 1:05:22offers Bitcoin treasury services like Acropolis.
- 1:05:25And so it took me back to like in 2015, I had zero competition,
- 1:05:31meaning like deal by deal, if I called up someone on my team,
- 1:05:34called up a mineral owner in West TX and said we'll pay you
- 1:05:36$5000 for these minerals. They're like, OK, I mean, some
- 1:05:40people said no, but some people said yes, we're buying for $5000
- 1:05:44an acre. And we really had no
- 1:05:45competition. The next year we had
- 1:05:48competition, but we were paying $50,000 an acre.
- 1:05:51So we were the highest price and we had some competition at lower
- 1:05:54prices. So that's 20/15/2016.
- 1:05:58No, you forward, you know, Fast forward 10 years to this
- 1:06:02morning, I get an invitation. NAPE is happening next week in
- 1:06:06Houston, which is the North American Petroleum Expo, which
- 1:06:10like I literally have a business partner flying into it from
- 1:06:12India, you know. Oh, are you going to be there,
- 1:06:14Tim? Are you going to be there?
- 1:06:15No, I'm not going to be there. The minerals and margaritas
- 1:06:20reception for the minerals and royalty space.
- 1:06:24Remember that I had no competition 10 years ago buying
- 1:06:29minerals in West TX. Literally not everyone has even
- 1:06:32RSVP D yet. Most people have.
- 1:06:35There's 274 companies that are going to be at this reception,
- 1:06:45and so you do the math on whether there's one or two or
- 1:06:48four people from each organization.
- 1:06:50There's 1000 people just in one little industry, but you're not
- 1:06:56at the beginning of it anymore. And so at the sake of rambling
- 1:07:01it just that all kind of kind of hit me this morning with that
- 1:07:06Sailor cover. And I think if you zoom like
- 1:07:09it's so with social media were like what's happening.
- 1:07:14Oh, which state introduced legislation today?
- 1:07:17But if you zoom out, it's like pretty incredible to think about
- 1:07:20how early we are in the adoption cycle.
- 1:07:24But I think in the example, there was a lot of froth and
- 1:07:26people that made bids that probably lost their shirts
- 1:07:29because people recognize that. And so I think the example here
- 1:07:32is where their signal similar to yours in the minerals is
- 1:07:35Bitcoin. But you have this hyper liquid
- 1:07:38other market where you can create these things and tell
- 1:07:40good stories to sell them. And so it's to the point there's
- 1:07:43a lot of before the market gets efficient, it's just insanely
- 1:07:47inefficient because what we talked about here, it's hard to
- 1:07:49like wrap your head around, it takes, you know, months if not
- 1:07:52years to understand why there's only 21 million in all the
- 1:07:54different properties that make Bitcoin valuable.
- 1:07:56And so that's kind of like the delta net gap of how long the
- 1:07:59froth exists. Yeah, even necessarily just like
- 1:08:03stock to flow or. But when the physical side, you
- 1:08:08do have a lot of guys in real estate or something that they
- 1:08:11think they can either touch, see or relate to.
- 1:08:16But like, I don't think anyone's ever actually seen natural gas.
- 1:08:22In fact, they actually put a chemical in it so you can smell
- 1:08:26it because it's odorless. Well, you can't smell Bitcoin
- 1:08:30either, but if you're looking at the chart, you might be able to.
- 1:08:35So yeah, it's just like a lot of similarities that, you know,
- 1:08:40kind of weave the story of, like why some people can appreciate
- 1:08:43it maybe before others. Yeah.
- 1:08:45The earliness thing to Tim that you mentioned, I think is
- 1:08:48fascinating as it relates to competition.
- 1:08:51We've been talking about it internally.
- 1:08:54I think Michael's pulled it up on a previous episode before,
- 1:08:56but the distribution of Bitcoin currently with 70% of the asset
- 1:09:03being held by individuals. So individuals have really not
- 1:09:05had to compete with anyone besides themselves to acquire
- 1:09:10Bitcoin. That is going to change though,
- 1:09:13and now there will be competition, right?
- 1:09:15And so there's no competition from zero to 100,000.
- 1:09:19Let's use those numbers just for ballpark and to be easy.
- 1:09:23But now there's going to be a crazy amount of competition from
- 1:09:25100,000 to $1,000,000 per Bitcoin.
- 1:09:28So that's Tim. Like what you're describing,
- 1:09:302015, $5000, 2016, 50,000. I think that's the same parallel
- 1:09:36where now we actually will have competition.
- 1:09:39It won't be me competing with Tim and who's going to stack
- 1:09:43more. It's going to be the four of us.
- 1:09:45If we're continuing to stack, which I am, I'm throwing in my
- 1:09:49little, you know, throwing my dollars here and there.
- 1:09:52But now we have nations coming in, corporations, we have Wall
- 1:09:58Street of all sorts of firms, family offices.
- 1:10:01And so this competition is going from virtually nothing to really
- 1:10:04intensifying. And so then I think that ties
- 1:10:08into just how early we are as an industry as well because the
- 1:10:11products that exist today, there's really not a lot of
- 1:10:13products that help these institutions allocate to Bitcoin
- 1:10:17securely. And then there's also not a lot
- 1:10:19of products and solutions that allow the people who were able
- 1:10:23to compete in this market of virtually 0 competition to
- 1:10:26compete in the market now where you have to compete.
- 1:10:29And all this competition is driving the price of Bitcoin
- 1:10:32from 100,000 to 200 to 500 to 1,000,000.
- 1:10:36And so that's how early we are, right?
- 1:10:38It's like 70% since of individuals, it's still only a
- 1:10:40$2 trillion asset class. The $900 trillion number is
- 1:10:44outdated now. We should run new numbers.
- 1:10:46It's quadrillions. I don't even know.
- 1:10:49And now we're going to actually have to start thinking about,
- 1:10:52and that's what we do here, of course, But thinking about
- 1:10:54solutions that will get people to securely from 100K to a
- 1:10:58trillion dollars, I think that's 100K to $1,000,000.
- 1:11:01That's not what people have Not appreciated that yet.
- 1:11:08Yeah, that's my spiel. We are indeed early.
- 1:11:13Yeah. I mean, come on, we have no.
- 1:11:15No, you're right. I mean, dude, it's.
- 1:11:17Insane. Like Joe Biden?
- 1:11:18Come on. Come on, guys.
- 1:11:21No, it's it's astounding the even just talking, talking
- 1:11:26specifically about the Ecfs, them being the most successful,
- 1:11:30fun product launches of all time and not even being like fully
- 1:11:34opened up yet. Like imagine, imagine what the
- 1:11:37flows would have been last year if like they were all all the
- 1:11:40wire houses, all the financial firms turn them on day one.
- 1:11:44Like they they were the most successful products without even
- 1:11:47really being turned on. Like that is astounding.
- 1:11:49And and I think probably still being slept on a bit.
- 1:11:54Yeah, Michael, what's the single point of failure of the week I.
- 1:11:59I think we we can go with Brian's.
- 1:12:01I think he pulled it up. He sent it in the the Slack
- 1:12:03channel if you. Want to?
- 1:12:04All right, let me pull it up for you, Brian.
- 1:12:06Yeah, I don't have a ton of context on this one.
- 1:12:08I just saw a tweet from a seems like a a crypto altcoin type
- 1:12:13person who's is referencing a friend of their theirs that got
- 1:12:18effectively extorted and robbed for seven plus figures.
- 1:12:26And you know, he he had some context here that he's not like
- 1:12:30an overly public person about his crypto holdings.
- 1:12:34So I think it this one was interesting to me just in the
- 1:12:36sense of like, you know, I think we talked a lot about the
- 1:12:39importance of this stuff for high profile folks in Bitcoin
- 1:12:42or, or crypto, but the reality is it could happen to anyone.
- 1:12:46And, you know, I think the, the person there references, you
- 1:12:51know, they think maybe it was like someone close to them that
- 1:12:54tipped off the the eventual attacker.
- 1:12:56So it's like, it's just like that.
- 1:12:59All of that is to say like, yes, it's it's, you know, probably
- 1:13:02most important for people that are known in the space who are,
- 1:13:05who are docks and have large balances, but it really, you
- 1:13:10know, attackers won't discriminate if they have some,
- 1:13:14some informational edge that they can try to exploit.
- 1:13:17They're going to do that whether you're known or flashy about it
- 1:13:20or not. Yeah, Jax and I had a very
- 1:13:23interesting conversation yesterday with a prospective
- 1:13:26client and we went through a lot of diligence and we're talking
- 1:13:30about it. And in a certain point, you
- 1:13:32know, you have to leverage what you know.
- 1:13:33I mean, this is where people come to a private Bitcoin
- 1:13:37institution, like not are they coming for, you know, custody
- 1:13:40and financial services, but they're coming for you.
- 1:13:44You, you guys talk about it a lot in the investment management
- 1:13:46space. You go to specialize, you go to
- 1:13:47the experts because they're going to tell you things that
- 1:13:50they, they know that the market doesn't or you as an individual
- 1:13:53don't because they've just been looking at the problem for a
- 1:13:54long time. And so we're walking through it.
- 1:13:57And then he referenced, well, like this seems complicated.
- 1:13:59Like I got to like, you know, ask to part like this partner
- 1:14:02and I got to go, you know, video verification.
- 1:14:05And it was rather than like a piece of injection plug, a kick
- 1:14:07out of it was like told was like you when the price is 250K,
- 1:14:12you're going to be begging to be asking for permission to move
- 1:14:15this thing. And the reason why is because
- 1:14:18you just referenced somebody getting kidnapped.
- 1:14:20I talked to another founder yesterday that sold or two days
- 1:14:23ago that sold his company somewhere.
- 1:14:24I won't disclose because it'll be easier to to get to back into
- 1:14:28where it happened. But sold his company to another
- 1:14:30crypto firm. Crypto firm CEO was kidnapped
- 1:14:33till ransom. So we were talking about
- 1:14:35something completely unrelated to custody, like, Hey, I want to
- 1:14:37talk to you guys. And where this all goes is 2
- 1:14:40parts. 1 is like all this metadata that we've talked that
- 1:14:42we've done, like whether it's like over socials, over emails,
- 1:14:46like all that data, you have to like assume somebody has peered
- 1:14:49into it at some point or will in the future.
- 1:14:52And you tie that to the blockchain and everything else
- 1:14:54that exists out there. It's not hard today and it
- 1:14:56definitely won't be hard in the future to discern what
- 1:14:59everyone's directional balances are.
- 1:15:01And what I'm starting to think about is I'm, I'm, I don't have
- 1:15:05no data on this, but I'm, I'm becoming more and more convinced
- 1:15:07that people have these large exchanges because they hold
- 1:15:09thousands of employees or just selling the data.
- 1:15:11Like we know on the dark web, it's the most expensive
- 1:15:14credentials you can get an information specifically like
- 1:15:16Coinbase. And so if somebody's willing to
- 1:15:18pay for it and all you have to do is click Excel, right?
- 1:15:21And like a couple things to get it out there.
- 1:15:25When the price is 200 K and bad actors know this sits around,
- 1:15:28it's just like it's part of the single point of failures.
- 1:15:31It's just this knowledge that you never have to speak about
- 1:15:34it. And there's no other asset that
- 1:15:37exists on our person or around us that is worth hundreds of
- 1:15:41thousands of millions of dollars.
- 1:15:42And all it takes is like 1 swoop to grab it.
- 1:15:45We see this with iPhones all day long.
- 1:15:47That's $1000, you know, asset. Imagine somebody finds out that
- 1:15:50on AUSB stick. So it's a, it's a good one to
- 1:15:53call out that just to be thinking through that.
- 1:15:58Yeah. And it's messed up because the
- 1:16:06awareness, like we were talking about it, right, the the
- 1:16:08positive, more awareness around Bitcoin means more adoption,
- 1:16:11means higher price. And so we all expect that to
- 1:16:14happen over time. But then of course, there's the
- 1:16:17counter to that, which is more awareness means much more
- 1:16:21malintent that comes into the space.
- 1:16:23There's more incentives for bad actors to target people.
- 1:16:26And then it's not only that too. It's not like it's not like
- 1:16:31everyone in the world needs to be concerned about this right
- 1:16:33now. I think it will become a bigger
- 1:16:35concern for more people. And I think people also
- 1:16:38underestimate the likeliness of this happening, especially if
- 1:16:41you have more material amounts of Bitcoin.
- 1:16:43But what I do think is a higher concern or or risk that people
- 1:16:47underweight is they actually are just playing with their Bitcoin
- 1:16:51at the end of the day. Like, I'm, I'm joking, but I'm
- 1:16:54not people who do self custody for the most part, like plug it
- 1:16:59in once every couple months. Yeah, they check on their seed
- 1:17:03phrase that's still here. Great.
- 1:17:05It's not like an actual serious thing.
- 1:17:07And there's nothing wrong with that.
- 1:17:08I personally don't want to be doing that because I don't
- 1:17:12really like doing it and I'm not good at it.
- 1:17:15And I know that there's more people that are like me than the
- 1:17:18opposite that have diligently done this and meticulously check
- 1:17:22on it and think about it. And so that's The thing is like
- 1:17:26people are actually playing with this and it's fine if it's $1000
- 1:17:29or $10,000 and it's 5% of your net worth, if you mess it up,
- 1:17:33it's not going to permanently destroy your legacy.
- 1:17:37And again, talking about legacy, right?
- 1:17:38We're talking about Bitcoin and legacy.
- 1:17:40But for us that that is the legacy.
- 1:17:41And for our clients, it is a legacy as well.
- 1:17:43And so you can't be playing with it anymore.
- 1:17:46It's like hard not to laugh, but you really can't be playing with
- 1:17:49it if it's $100,000 per Bitcoin and you're sitting on five or
- 1:17:5210/20/50 a hundred, what have you, right?
- 1:17:55Like this is something that needs to be seriously thought
- 1:17:58through and most people had just haven't done it yet.
- 1:18:01And so I think it ties into the competition.
- 1:18:03There's more competition for a scarce asset becoming more
- 1:18:06scarce over time, going to drive the price higher.
- 1:18:10And people are just not, you know, they're, they're not
- 1:18:13taking the serious considerations that they should
- 1:18:16be the. The thing that's honestly the
- 1:18:18most frustrating is that like this whole notion of every,
- 1:18:23like, time's a flat circle, Like we've already done this before,
- 1:18:25like Bitcoin is super transformative and we're
- 1:18:28watching an asset monetize in real time.
- 1:18:31But at the end of the day, like gold is money for a, because I
- 1:18:34think people get like caught with gold's 10 trillion bitcoins
- 1:18:37going to take, you know, 10X what gold is.
- 1:18:40But at the end of the day, gold was money for hundreds of
- 1:18:44thousands of years. And the reason why banks were
- 1:18:46formed was ultimately to safeguard the asset.
- 1:18:50And then you can build a civilization around capital
- 1:18:52formation and coordinating economic activity.
- 1:18:55And the reason why that happened was because people got hit over
- 1:18:58the head metaphorically in their cave for their gold.
- 1:19:01And then militias form and all these things happened.
- 1:19:03So it's just like pretend like a bare asset is digital.
- 1:19:07Yes, it can be secured easier. And it's just not to say you
- 1:19:10don't take some delivery of it because that's what makes it,
- 1:19:12you know, ultra valuable. You can move around.
- 1:19:14But to get to this point where it's $1,000,000 and the best
- 1:19:17that exists is holding it on a USB stick.
- 1:19:20And then anybody that's credible in Bitcoin will say, we'll just
- 1:19:23hire a security or guard an army.
- 1:19:25And it's just like, sure, you can do that.
- 1:19:27But then like you have family members and friends and if
- 1:19:29they're related to you, like do they all have to?
- 1:19:30And there's always plot holes like it's just it's a broken
- 1:19:33market structure. You can't kidnap them.
- 1:19:35They're like, if you think, I mean, you can kidnap them, but
- 1:19:37it'd be nonsensical because you're not going to get any of
- 1:19:39their capital. Because the amount of controls
- 1:19:41and plumbing that takes to liquidate a position in any, you
- 1:19:44know, large asset and then move it through the banking rails is
- 1:19:48similar to how you can think about what we do with multi
- 1:19:50institution custody and the different controls and in person
- 1:19:52verifications. So it's just frustrating because
- 1:19:55a lot of people put people in like these bad positions.
- 1:19:58When we'll look back and we all understand why Coinbase
- 1:20:01shouldn't hold all the Bitcoin and we'll look back 15 years
- 1:20:03from now, be like, I can't believe they had that much.
- 1:20:05But we'll also all look back and be like, I can't believe I
- 1:20:07secured that 10 Bitcoin or 100 Bitcoin on that little USB stick
- 1:20:11and then put the passphrase in my head or split it with my, you
- 1:20:13know, cousin when I passed that. We're going to put it all back
- 1:20:16together. It's, it's just going to be a, a
- 1:20:19wild thing. And this is still super
- 1:20:20contrarian, which is honestly very amazing because once we
- 1:20:23talk with somebody and walk them through this, it's very clear.
- 1:20:26We've thought very deeply about it.
- 1:20:31Yeah. Yeah, I think that inheritance.
- 1:20:34Piece is big. Too Because what people?
- 1:20:37What effectively exists for most?
- 1:20:39People is a treasure map. I actually spoke with someone
- 1:20:42yesterday who showed me a book that might have been called
- 1:20:45Crypto Asset Inheritance Planning or something that was
- 1:20:48published five years ago. And I was explaining we were
- 1:20:52talking about treasure maps, right?
- 1:20:53And this guy, Larry, goes to his bookshelf, pulls a book off the
- 1:20:57shelf and says, this book effectively recommends people to
- 1:21:02put together a treasure map for their asset.
- 1:21:04And so again, this is like published maybe five years ago.
- 1:21:07I didn't look at the book. I, I don't know anything beyond
- 1:21:09the title of it. But this is what people do.
- 1:21:12They set up treasure maps and they pray to God that their
- 1:21:17family figures it out. Maybe they show their wife, you
- 1:21:20know, this is what this does. It literally looks like a toy,
- 1:21:22though, right? Going back to you're, you're
- 1:21:24holding this thing in your hand. It doesn't feel real.
- 1:21:27And then if someone you show it, you show it to your wife like
- 1:21:30I've showed the C fray. Like I've we've done that with
- 1:21:34with my wife before. If I die, like anything I hold
- 1:21:36in self custody, which is becoming a smaller and smaller
- 1:21:39amount of time, I just don't feel confident that she'll get
- 1:21:42it because it's not like she's like, Oh yeah, like let's go try
- 1:21:46to plug in the, the signing device.
- 1:21:49Let's set, let's sign a transaction.
- 1:21:52And you know, like, let's take a look.
- 1:21:54Just like these things, you, you talk through it and you like
- 1:21:57hope to have a plan, but there's actually no plan.
- 1:22:00You talk about it one time or you talk about it a couple
- 1:22:03times, it's not a plan. And so that's another thing just
- 1:22:06to show how early we are. The thing that really frustrates
- 1:22:09me, if you can't tell is that everyone loves to talk about how
- 1:22:12early we are in Bitcoin, but there's actually very little
- 1:22:15serious discourse about what the implications of that are.
- 1:22:18So if you go on Twitter, that's why I barely go on Twitter, I
- 1:22:20barely post anymore is because it's just everyone bullying each
- 1:22:24other up about why the price will be this and that.
- 1:22:28But there's no actually like deeper level thinking beyond
- 1:22:32that. Just if we're serious people, I
- 1:22:34want to consider myself serious and in some regard I don't want
- 1:22:37to be too serious, but we actually need to have solutions
- 1:22:41that will help people to manage this.
- 1:22:44And it's just a shame that people just want to talk about
- 1:22:49the price and not actually. Build solutions.
- 1:22:51That will help people secure it or at least help themselves
- 1:22:54secure it. That's that's, you know,
- 1:22:55priority number one. Yeah.
- 1:22:58Or even just like you make a good point in that it's like.
- 1:23:01People want to bull post, they want to say we're early, but
- 1:23:04they don't want to think through the actual like ramifications of
- 1:23:07what that future state looks like.
- 1:23:10And that's, you know, a lot of what we're doing at on ramp and,
- 1:23:13and you know, with multi institution and, and all the
- 1:23:16financial services that we can provide, like we are planning
- 1:23:19for that future state where not only is the asset appreciated a
- 1:23:23ton. So you don't necessarily want
- 1:23:25that, that burden of private key management in your house or on
- 1:23:28your loved ones, but you also want to tap into financial
- 1:23:31services in a seamless way. Like Michael, I think you do a
- 1:23:34really good job of of highlighting this.
- 1:23:35It's like you can't tap into financial services if every time
- 1:23:41you need to access the coin, you've got to like go in your
- 1:23:43cave, follow the treasure map, like do all these things like
- 1:23:47one, it's extremely that's like a ton of friction.
- 1:23:50And two, you every time you do that, every time you go in to,
- 1:23:54you know, conduct whatever financial service you want to
- 1:23:56do, touch the Bitcoin like you're exposing the the attack
- 1:24:00vector in that moment, right? And so it's like, that doesn't
- 1:24:03make a lot of sense to do that in perpetuity, basically.
- 1:24:07Yeah. Yeah.
- 1:24:08Well, we've gone hard on this. But I mean confidently and this
- 1:24:12will play out over years that any financial product in Bitcoin
- 1:24:16will be built better backwards and forwards on multi
- 1:24:20institution custody, whether it's trade insurance, lending,
- 1:24:23inheritance and then companies as well.
- 1:24:26It's a different conversation. But if a company is ultimately
- 1:24:29just sending out their their clients, they have to figure it
- 1:24:32out or hopefully don't get their fingers sent back.
- 1:24:36If they get kidnapped is not going to win in the space long
- 1:24:39term because others are just going to out compete them with
- 1:24:41better solutions for their clients and they'll recognize
- 1:24:43it. But to take just like one other
- 1:24:46note is we don't even have to talk about individuals like this
- 1:24:49is where I always get concerned with the public traded companies
- 1:24:53and I got we got our friendly MSTR bull here, Tim.
- 1:24:56So got to tread lightly, but it's like if I was in MSTRI
- 1:25:00would always be underwriting with that position of like they
- 1:25:03have a single custodian or two that hold all those assets.
- 1:25:07So any value from a share is derived from the safeguarding of
- 1:25:10that asset. And nothing's bulletproof from a
- 1:25:15single custodial perspective. And for 15 years, all we've had
- 1:25:18is things that aren't bulletproof.
- 1:25:20I like to use analogy. If you put all the logos of the
- 1:25:22custodians or exchanges from the past 15 years and blindfolded
- 1:25:25yourself and through a dart, you've more than likely hit one
- 1:25:28that doesn't exist and lost all their clients funds.
- 1:25:31And we just somehow keep forgetting that.
- 1:25:33And so I think there's just like a lot of things that the market
- 1:25:36still has to get educated on. That's why it ties back to
- 1:25:38Brian, like the dominant stuff. It's just like, I wish, I hope
- 1:25:42you're right on there. It's just like everything we've
- 1:25:44seen, you know, these concepts are still so novel from a
- 1:25:46hardcore Bitcoin or like understanding it because they
- 1:25:49listen to the local influencer podcaster.
- 1:25:51And so now that is the derivative of like institutional
- 1:25:55level because those people work in institutions.
- 1:25:56It's just going to take a while because the opposite is like
- 1:26:00Coinbase or BNY Mellon, right? Which is great.
- 1:26:05It's a great. Opportunity for anybody this
- 1:26:07resonates with whether you're. Interested in our services or
- 1:26:10building a business around multi institution.
- 1:26:11Like we have a lot of plans to build the future infrastructure
- 1:26:13that actually, to Jackson's point, mitigates a lot of these
- 1:26:17concerns and builds better products.
- 1:26:18So it's an amazing set to where Tim is at.
- 1:26:21Like he saw 15 years from 11 to now of probably a lot of people
- 1:26:24that were very wealthy that understood what was happening
- 1:26:27and like had a vision and conviction on the direction
- 1:26:29where it was going to go. But along the way, a lot of
- 1:26:32people probably went bankrupt and ended up in different
- 1:26:34industries because the earlier you are, the the more tinkers
- 1:26:37and jokers you have in an industry.
- 1:26:39And I think that's what we've seen, you know, and that makes
- 1:26:41sense because 1st 15 years, the Internet, we're ripe with that
- 1:26:43as well. Yeah, I think.
- 1:26:48I actually have a notion. That you'll see.
- 1:26:52Corporates think ACFO. Think a.
- 1:26:55Controller that will innately have an appreciation for multi
- 1:27:02institutional custody because they have similar protocols in
- 1:27:06place. At the corporate level you have
- 1:27:08to have two separate people or at least two different user IDs
- 1:27:14where you log in and you go through the process before you
- 1:27:17initiate a wire for example, right.
- 1:27:20Even in my business, there's two different user IDs that need to
- 1:27:23be need to confirm a transaction before a.
- 1:27:27Batch of an ACH. Or a wire would go out on the
- 1:27:30corporate level. So maybe there'll there'll be an
- 1:27:33appreciation for that more on the corporate side.
- 1:27:36And then on the individual side, some people will understand and
- 1:27:41appreciate it, others will think of it as a novel thing.
- 1:27:44Other others will come in from the security safety standpoint.
- 1:27:50But I don't think it's a natural thing.
- 1:27:53If I was not in the financial industry, I might not have any
- 1:27:59appreciation for some of this because I would just think,
- 1:28:04well, JP Morgan Chase is too big to fail.
- 1:28:07So I'm I'm fine. And even if we say that that's
- 1:28:11true, if there's a better solution for the same cost, so
- 1:28:16to speak, why would you not consider that?
- 1:28:19So I think it'd be interesting to see the different buckets of
- 1:28:24adoption and, and how they play out.
- 1:28:26And that's where the Wall Street thing is going to get really
- 1:28:28messy because. We've seen institutions fail,
- 1:28:32we've seen the GFC. The problem is those all get
- 1:28:35kind of tapered or like plastered over because of you
- 1:28:40can print more money, you can bail out, you can't make any
- 1:28:44more Bitcoin. And so that's.
- 1:28:47Going to be the hard lesson we're going to learn.
- 1:28:49And a lot of these concepts we talked about because we
- 1:28:51experienced them like specifically around Block 5,
- 1:28:53because they were backed by Peter Thiel.
- 1:28:55And obviously they're nowhere at the level of a, you know, big
- 1:28:58bank. But it's still the same concept
- 1:29:00of the math. It's a math like when an
- 1:29:01institution loses their shirts, loses the bitcoiners off sides
- 1:29:05on leverage. At a certain point, the
- 1:29:08shareholders don't bail them out.
- 1:29:09There's no equity left. There's nothing left to do that.
- 1:29:11And that's the The Dirty secret of like Walsh, you're getting
- 1:29:14involved in Bitcoin or best, best, best case scenario, like
- 1:29:19you get the dollars back, right? Like they print dollars and they
- 1:29:21give you they give you dollars back at some point.
- 1:29:24But that's a test case scenario, yeah, which is?
- 1:29:29Yeah, which is a funny, not a funny thing, but that's.
- 1:29:31Something that comes up a lot of all this bankruptcy, the
- 1:29:35bankruptcies the past three years, just what's happened
- 1:29:37since 21 and 22, Folks, look at that page we pulled up.
- 1:29:41We have a part of our deck about the $655 billion in losses and
- 1:29:44there's all these logos and they just kind of point like, Yep, I
- 1:29:46was part of Block 5. Yep, I was there.
- 1:29:49Yeah. It's going to be an interesting
- 1:29:51next 24 months. Yes, I will.
- 1:29:57All right, guys, let's get back to.
- 1:29:59It good RIP this week higher right, Tim, are we going higher
- 1:30:05all right, higher all right. Thanks.
- 1:30:08Gentlemen, thanks boys. Good stuff, thanks for
- 1:30:12listening. To this week's.
- 1:30:13Episode of the show if you found.
- 1:30:14The information valuable. Please share the episode with a
- 1:30:17friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:30:19All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:30:22notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:30:24reminder that On Rat Media is for informational and
- 1:30:27entertainment purposes only and nothing should be construed as
- 1:30:30investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:30:33your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:30:35Visit onrampbitcoin.com Contact Schedule a consultation with one
- 1:30:40of our private client advisors.