Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #4: Previewing the 2026 American Season
Transcript
- 0:14Hello, and welcome to episode number four of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:18We're currently in the middle of going through each conference's outlook for the twenty twenty-six college football season, and today we'll be discussing the American Conference.
- 0:26Prior to the twenty twenty-five season, the American Conference went through a rebrand.
- 0:29They dropped the"Athletic" from the middle of their name and the AAC abbreviation.
- 0:35The American will feature fourteen teams in twenty twenty-six, the third season they'll be at that number, having most recently added six teams in twenty twenty-three, while simultaneously losing three to the Big Twelve, and then adding their fourteenth team, Army, in twenty twenty-four.
- 0:50Last year's American season was highlighted by how it performed against the Power Four conferences head-to-head, specifically the Big Ten and the Big Twelve.
- 0:57The CSR does take into account conference strength and is measured on conference head-to-head results, so the fact that the Americans split their two matchups with the Big Ten and their four matchups with the Big Twelve had a huge impact on what teams were ranked in the CSR at the end of twenty twenty-five.
- 1:13The American Conference had winning records head-to-head against three different conferences.
- 1:17That slotted them in just behind the ACC as far as conference strength, just behind the Mountain West, and just ahead of the Sun Belt.
- 1:25Last year's American championship game featured a Tulane victory over North Texas, a matchup that would inevitably send, uh, the winner to the college football playoff.
- 1:33Tulane, via their win, secured the number eleven seed in the college football playoff and then promptly got stomped by Ole Miss in the first round.
- 1:42At the end of the twenty twenty-five season, the American had four teams ranked in the top twenty-five of the Common Sense ranking.
- 1:47They had Tulane appropriately at number eleven, North Texas at number nineteen, Navy at number twenty-three, and South Florida at number twenty-four.
- 1:55The bottom of the conference was held by Charlotte by a mile, and then Tulsa, Florida Atlantic, and UAB moving up the rankings.
- 2:03In twenty twenty-six, the American will continue to play eight conference games, a number shared by most of the non-Power Four conferences.
- 2:09But a reminder that Army-Navy will continue to be the second Saturday in December, which is a week after conference championship games, and that will not count toward the American standings.
- 2:20The American does play every other conference in twenty twenty-six, a reminder that that is crucial in the Common Sense rankings, and they will play most conferences at least three times.
- 2:28They will, however, play the ACC only once, and they will play the Big Twelve twice.
- 2:33Now, let's dive into each of the fourteen teams that will be in the American in twenty twenty-six First up in the American alphabetically is Army.
- 2:42Jeff Monken is the head coach.
- 2:44He's led the St- West Point Service Academy for the last 12 years.
- 2:47He's won over 125 games in his tenure as head coach.
- 2:51Cody Woehrle, his offensive coordinator, will return, which means we'll continue to see the triple option from the Black Knights, while the new defensive coordinator, Darryl Dixon, will oversee the defense.
- 3:00Army did manage six wins last year, making them bowl eligible, but they did lose by a single point in their matchup against Navy at the end of the season.
- 3:09As always, Army ranked among the top teams in the country as far as rush yards per game, totaling over 250 yards on the ground per contest.
- 3:16This led to Army also having the largest time of possession in the FBS in 2025.
- 3:21Now because they are a service academy, Army cannot accept transfers, so all talent will be carried over from last season.
- 3:27Superstar quarterback Kale Hellams will return as QB one where he will lead the threat in that triple option.
- 3:33Defensively, Army has lost several of its top tacklers from 2025, meaning they will need new players to step up on that side of the ball.
- 3:40Army will continue to play 11 regular season games that can contribute to its effort to make the college football playoff courtesy of their date with Navy after the completion of championship week.
- 3:49And as a result, they'll face a slightly easier schedule than most of their American colleagues.
- 3:54They'll start with an FCS school in week one, then face additional non-conference opponents in Louisiana Tech and Air Force throughout the season.
- 4:00And then in conference, they'll face two of the ranked American teams from the end of last year, South Florida and Tulane, but they'll also get games against Tulsa and Florida Atlantic, teams toward the bottom of the 2025 American standings.
- 4:12Arm- Army is always in a tough position given its requirements as a service academy, so another five and six or six and five season is the likely finish for the Black Knights in 2026.
- 4:23Next up is the Charlotte 49ers, who finished one and 11 in 2025 and near the bottom of the CSR, finishing 134th out of 136 teams.
- 4:33Considering their only win was over an FCS school, that is not surprising.
- 4:37Their head coach, Tim Albin, will start his second season.
- 4:40Uh, both his offensive and defensive coordinators are also going into year number two, with Nate Fones having coached with Albin at Ohio as defensive coordinator before their Charlotte hires.
- 4:51Charlotte managed to score very few points in 2025, just 14 a game, last in the American and fourth fewest in college football.
- 4:59Their defense was not much better.
- 5:00They had the worst pass defense in the American and the third worst run defense in the conference as well.
- 5:06Their top incoming transfers are all on the offensive side of the ball, where the top five incoming players are either pass catchers or offensive linemen.
- 5:13Bodes well for improving on that 14 points per game last season.
- 5:16Overall too, Charlotte did a great job retaining talent, so with most of the defense especially holding over from 2025.
- 5:23They do unfortunately have a very tough schedule, second hardest in the American according to the 2025 CSR rankings.
- 5:30They'll start with four consecutive non-conference games, FCS opponent, Ole Miss, App State, and Louisiana, so they'll have two Sun Belt opponents.
- 5:38In conference however, they will face five of the top six American teams from the CSR last season, meaning if they're going to improve upon their one and 11 finish last year, they will need to pull off an upset somewhere.
- 5:52Let's talk a little bit about the East Carolina Pirates.
- 5:54They were the fifth among American teams in the twenty twenty-five end of the season CSR, completing the season with an eight and four record, six and two in the American.
- 6:04Blake Harrell will return for year number three, but he will have new coordinators in Jordan Davis, who joins the Pirates from North Texas, and Jordan Hankins, who joins East Carolina after serving in the same role for the Memphis Tigers.
- 6:16Jordan Davis' add as offensive coordinator is particularly interesting as the North Texas Mean Green last year, where he coached, had the most prolific offense in college football.
- 6:25So Davis hopes to bring that fast-paced score at all costs mentality to Greenville, North Carolina.
- 6:31ECU prided themselves on stopping the run.
- 6:33In twenty twenty-five, they ranked first in the American in opponent rush yards per game, while also allowing the fewest points per game in the conference.
- 6:40They were able to bring in one of the top transfer classes in the American Conference, including running back Ashton Gray, who followed his offensive coordinator in from North Texas.
- 6:49They will also benefit from an easier twenty twenty-six schedule.
- 6:52They'll likely be demolished by Alabama in week one, but then they get three winnable games, two against Sun Belt opponents in App State and Old Dominion, and then their non-conference slate ends with an FCS school before they launch into American Conference play.
- 7:04Even in the American Conference, they'll be fortunate to play Charlotte and Florida Atlantic, two of the bottom three teams from the twenty twenty-five CSR in the American, and they won't have to face any of the top three American teams from last year.
- 7:16So based on an easy schedule, OC was a clutch hire and a good inflow of talent, signs point to East Carolina being in the hunt for a conference championship berth in twenty twenty-six.
- 7:27The Florida Atlantic Owls will be the first of three Owls mascots we talk about in the American Conference preview.
- 7:33The FAU Owls finished 12th of the 14 American teams in last year's Common Sense rankings, sputtering to a four and eight record.
- 7:41They will have the benefit of carryover coaches, with head coach Zach Kittley also calling offensive plays, while Brett Dewhirst will be in charge of the defense.
- 7:49Florida Atlantic could definitely hang with teams on offense in 2025, on display through their number one rank at passing yards per game.
- 7:56They just couldn't stop the other teams on defense, allowing 36 points per game on the defensive side of the ball.
- 8:02FAU had a purpose going into their transfer portal signings.
- 8:06They continued to bolster their receiving corps, again backing up their number one passing, uh, offense last year, and then they also focused on the secondary on defense, trying to put a lid on the pass game.
- 8:17Fortunately for the Owls, their QB one is back for his final collegiate season.
- 8:20That'll be Kaden Veltkamp.
- 8:22He will continue to be under center in 2026.
- 8:25Florida Atlantic has a respectable but not overly hard 2026 schedule.
- 8:29Out of conference, they have two in-state rivals in Florida and FIU, and then another co- out of conference date with UL Monroe.
- 8:37In conference, they'll need to go through four of the top five in the American and last year's CSR, but they'll also get Tulsa, UTSA, and Rice from the bottom end of the conference, evening out their American slate.
- 8:49My assumption would be Florida Atlantic will be favorites in maybe four or five of their games, so if they were able to scrape a bowl appearance, that would be a successful season for the Florida Atlantic Owls.
- 9:00The Memphis Tigers started out twenty twenty-five on fire.
- 9:04They won their first six games, and they rose up to the CSR number five at one point.
- 9:07But ensuing losses saw them finish with an eight and four record and sixth among American teams at the final CSR last season.
- 9:15Last year's head coach, Ryan Silverfield, found new pastures at Arkansas, taking his offensive coordinator with him.
- 9:20So Memphis will have brand-new leaders starting at the top with new head coach Charles Huff, who most recently coached at Southern Miss.
- 9:27While Memphis was middle of the road in the American in most statistical on-field categories, well, they did pride themselves in twenty twenty-five on stopping the ground game on defense.
- 9:36If you bought a Memphis jersey with a specific player's name on the back last year, you will be disappointed at the start of the twenty twenty-six season.
- 9:43Of the twenty-two offensive and defensive starters, it's likely twenty will be new to the Memphis sideline after Memphis signed no fewer than, get this, fifty-three players out of the portal, with several of those following their coach over from Southern Miss.
- 9:56Memphis also has the third hardest schedule of all American teams in twenty twenty-six, starting before most with a week zero clash with UNLV, followed by clashes against Arkansas State and Boise State, now a part of the Pac-12.
- 10:09Following an FCS game and a bye, Memphis will play four of the top five American teams from twenty twenty-five in Tulane, East Carolina, South Florida, and Navy, while also getting the benefit of playing teams toward the bottom of the twenty twenty-five American standings in Charlotte, UAB, and Temple.
- 10:26Based strictly on incoming talent, I'd say Memphis has a chance to improve on their eight and four record in twenty twenty-five, but a tougher conference schedule may make it hard to qualify for the American championship game.
- 10:38The Navy Midshipmen won their first seven games in 2025.
- 10:42However, none of those wins were over a team that finished very well in the common sense ranking, so their finishing nine and two record was a little inflated based on low opponent quality.
- 10:51Navy, similar to Army, will return to the triple option offense as Coach Brian Newberry returns and brings back his offensive and defensive coordinators as well.
- 10:59Due to their scheme, it's no surprise that Navy finished atop college football with nearly three hundred rush yards per game, running the ball on nearly eighty percent of offensive plays, which was third behind Army and Air Force.
- 11:11Since service academies do not allow transfers, all of Navy's production will have to be homegrown, and with guys stepping into starting roles as each of their top four rushers have graduated.
- 11:20On defense, however, they return their top three tacklers, so look for Mark Anthony Parker, Giuseppe Sesi, and Coleman Collie to be all over the field on defense.
- 11:28Navy, by virtue of playing just 11 games during the regular season, will have the second easiest schedule in the American, with just two games against team that finish in the top half of the league in the twenty twenty-five CSR.
- 11:39That'll be North Texas and Memphis.
- 11:40And their only challenge out of conference likely being Notre Dame, Navy could see themselves right back near the top of the American in twenty twenty-six.
- 11:49The North Texas Mean Green went 11 and one in the regular season last year, earning a spot in the American championship game before losing to Tulane to miss out on a college football playoff spot, which if you were following the Mean Green at all last year, that would have made for a fun watch as their offense was historically prolific.
- 12:07They did lose their head coach, Eric Morris.
- 12:09This is what happens when Group of Six teams are successful.
- 12:12Coaches leave for Power Four conferences, as Morris did moving up to Oklahoma State.
- 12:16He also took North Texas' star QB with him.
- 12:19The coach will be replaced by Neil Brown, who will also call the offensive plays, but he did retain the services of last year's defensive coordinator.
- 12:27North Texas would need to replace that generational QB talent to match their 2025 season.
- 12:32He finished first in the country with both points per game at over 44 and second in pass yards per game at 318.
- 12:39North Texas sucked the transfer portal dry, drawing in 49 new players for 2026, including the majority of their likely starters.
- 12:47The QB one heir apparent, his name is Tayvan Jackson.
- 12:50He transferred over from UCF in the off-season.
- 12:53North Texas does have the unenviable task of taking on Indiana in week one, but their schedule is manageable throughout 2026.
- 13:00After Indiana, they'll face UNLV and Texas State, and then their American schedule is highlighted by the conference championship rematch with Tulane in week 12.
- 13:08But games against most of the bottom half of the 2025 American standings allow for a potential return to the American title game for North Texas in 2026.
- 13:19Moving on to the second Owls of the American, the Rice Owls finished 2025 just short of bowl eligibility at five and seven with a two and six finishing record in the American Conference.
- 13:29They will return their head coach and both coordinators.
- 13:32Scott Abel will lead the Owls in his second season at the Houston, Texas school.
- 13:36Rice played more than capable defense throughout most of 2025, but they just couldn't score any points.
- 13:42Second worst in the conference in points per game at less than 20, with the passing game taking the majority of the blame, ranking just above Army down at the bottom of the American.
- 13:51Rice was among the bottom of the conference in incoming talent, with the transfer portal being particularly unkind to the Owls.
- 13:57They did manage to secure the services of Koa Akui at safety, and they likely found their 2026 QB in Jacuri Brown through the portal as well.
- 14:05Fortunately, their 2026 schedule is the easiest in the conference.
- 14:09Their first FBS game is against Notre Dame, which is sub-ideal, but then they face Western Michigan and Fresno State in weeks three and four.
- 14:16Within the American, their games against Tulane and North Texas will likely be catastrophic, but winning games against FAU and Tulsa will hopefully be a bright spot on their schedule.
- 14:25Unfortunately, I don't see a path to bowl eligibility for the Rice Owls, even with their slightly easier slate, so I'd expect another four or five-win season for Rice.
- 14:37The South Florida Bulls made early splashes in 2025, ranking second in the CSR following their week two win over Florida.
- 14:44A loss to Miami in week three stalled momentum, but then they topped out at CSR number 13 after week eight before finishing the season at number 24.
- 14:53Similar to most successful Group of Six teams, they'll need to replace most of their coaching staff in 2026, and they'll be giving the reins to Brian Hartline at head coach, who comes to the Sunshine State via the Ohio State Buckeyes.
- 15:04USF scored over 40 points a game in 2025, driven by a balanced yet excellent offense.
- 15:10They just couldn't stop the pass on defense, ranking near the bottom of the conference in that regard.
- 15:15In the transfer portal, we saw a lot of the Bulls' top talent leave with their former head coach for Auburn, Alabama.
- 15:19But a huge crop of incoming talent actually put South Florida at the top of the recruiting rankings in the American Conference.
- 15:26Some of their top incoming recruits are edge rushers and quarterbacks, including CJ Hicks from Ohio State, so the coaching staff also recognized the need for a better pass defense in 2026.
- 15:35South Florida has the third easiest schedule in the American in 2026 with non-conference games against a couple of MAC teams in Kent State and Bowling Green, as well as FIU and an FCS school.
- 15:46In-conference will be a little tougher, as they have Tulane in the final week of the season, as well as Memphis and East Carolina in that second half of the year.
- 15:53They do get games against UTSA, UAB, and Florida Atlantic, though, so there is a good chance South Florida improves off an already superb 2025.
- 16:04Now our third and final owl mascot in the American, the Temple Owls finished twenty twenty-five at five and seven, losing their last four games to miss out on bowl eligibility by one win.
- 16:14Their coaching staff is sticking around for another year, providing some stability and leadership on the sideline.
- 16:20Temple's pass defense is what kept them in games in twenty twenty-five as that was the only offensive or defensive stat that was in the top half of the conference last season.
- 16:29Their transfer portal commitments were fewer than other teams in the conference.
- 16:32They did also retain, though, more talent and will be leaning on returners more than many other American teams.
- 16:38Their top recruits are mostly on the offensive side of the ball as they picked up a couple of likely starting receivers, a tight end and an offensive tackle, while developing more depth through the portal on defense.
- 16:48Temple will face an average schedule for an American team in twenty twenty-six.
- 16:52Their biggest non-conference foe will be Penn State.
- 16:54They will also play Toledo and UConn out of conference.
- 16:58In conference, though they might be favored in about half of their games, looking to games against Rice, UAB, Charlotte, and Army as winnable games for the Owls.
- 17:06While retaining talent is less important than it used to be, but with a handful of games where the Owls can expect to win, I'd bet Temple will be bowling come season's end.
- 17:16And now we've come to the defending American Conference champions.
- 17:19The Tulane Green Wave, who beat North Texas last year in the American Championship, secured the eleventh seed in the college football playoff before bowing out to the Ole Miss Rebels.
- 17:28To nobody's surprise, given Tulane's successful twenty twenty-five season, their head coach, John Summerill, got snatched by a Power Four school, in this case the Florida Gators, and he took his offensive coordinator with him, which means both roles needed to be filled at Tulane.
- 17:41They hired their head coach from within, promoting Will Hall from the pass game coordinator.
- 17:46The Green Wave dominated in twenty twenty-five on defense, especially the pass rush.
- 17:50They led the American in both passes deflected and sacks last season.
- 17:55Tulane lost a ton of talent to the transfer portal following the season last year and were unable to replenish with talent of similar quality.
- 18:02Tulane will be needing new faces to step up in twenty twenty-six.
- 18:06Their strength of schedule is fourth in the American this coming year.
- 18:10They'll play an important role in the American's place in the college football ecosystem though, playing American's only game against the ACC, which is against Duke in week one, and then one of only two games against the Big Twelve, which is Kansas State in week three.
- 18:23And Tulane is one of the few FBS teams who will not play a team from the FCS in twenty twenty-six.
- 18:28In conference, they'll need to play North Texas, South Florida, and Memphis, but they'll get the benefit of playing Charlotte, Tulsa, and Rice.
- 18:35Tulane will almost certainly regress in twenty twenty-six, likely due to the outflow of talent, where they will probably stabilize around seven or eight wins.
- 18:45The Tulsa Golden Hurricanes finished last season second to last in the American, finishing four and eight with just one of those wins occurring in conference.
- 18:53Given their mediocre season, there was not a lot of interest in hiring away the Tulsa coaching staff, so Trey Lamb will return as head coach, and he will also return both his coordinators for twenty twenty-six.
- 19:03If there was a bright spot for Tulsa statistically in twenty twenty-five, it was their pass defense, where they allowed just two hundred and fourteen yards per game, good for fourth in the American Conference.
- 19:13While we know twenty twenty-five didn't finish how they wanted, they did perform well in the off-season, snatching twenty-four commitments out of the portal.
- 19:20Offensive skill positions as well as the defensive front will see the most new faces based on those additions.
- 19:27Another benefit for Tulsa, they'll face the easiest schedule of all American teams in twenty twenty-six.
- 19:31That's based off the value of teams finishing CSR in twenty twenty-five.
- 19:36They'll have the other American Big Twelve matchup with a revamped Oklahoma State.
- 19:40Then they'll face Sam Houston and Arkansas before turning their attention to their in-conference games.
- 19:45Those in-conference games include easier wins against Charlotte, FAU, and Rice, each among the bottom five in the conference last year, according to the CSR, while their hardest games will be against North Texas, Navy, and Tulane.
- 19:57There's definitely an opportunity for Tulsa to improve in twenty twenty-six.
- 20:01An easier schedule as well as a good transfer portal this past off-season could easily see the Golden Hurricanes getting bowl eligible in twenty twenty-six.
- 20:10The UAB Blazers finished the 2025 season four and eight with a two and six record in conference.
- 20:16Their season last year was punctuated by a surprise win over Memphis in week eight.
- 20:21Alex Mortensen took over the reins from Trent Dilfer halfway through 2025 and was hired on a full-time basis following the season.
- 20:28He has taken it upon himself to call the offensive plays while he will rely on newcomer Todd Grantham on defense.
- 20:34You'll know that name from stints at various Power Four schools in the SEC and Big 12.
- 20:40UAB's crux in 2025 was keeping opponents out of the end zone.
- 20:44They did manage a respectable 26 points per game on offense, but they allowed a very weighty 38 points per game on defense, which was second worst in the country, ahead of only 0-12 UMass.
- 20:55Fortunately for the Blazers, they had a solid time recruiting in the portal, finishing as the sixth-best incoming class in the conference.
- 21:01Their top four incoming transfers are all in the defensive secondary, so they recognize the need to keep the lid on opposing offenses.
- 21:08Their 2026 schedule falls right in the middle of the American Conference.
- 21:12They'll follow several American teams' scheduling strategy by picking up two non-conference games against the Sun Belt in UL Monroe in Louisiana, while also facing Big Ten team Illinois in week one.
- 21:23In conference, they'll start hard with games against Navy, Memphis, and East Carolina to begin conference play before getting to play Charlotte, Temple, and UTSA later in the season.
- 21:32After finishing four and eight in 2025, the Blazers' definition of a successful season is likely six wins and bowl eligibility.
- 21:39I just don't know if they have quite enough to get there in 2026.
- 21:43Last up alphabetically in the American Conference are the Roadrunners out of UTSA.
- 21:49They were right in the middle in twenty twenty-five, finishing five hundred both overall and in the American.
- 21:54They will, however, return both head coach Jeff Traylor and defensive coordinator Jess Lopp, while they replaced their offensive coordinator in the offseason, hiring Rick Bowie away from Western Kentucky.
- 22:04The Roadrunners did a good job putting points on the board last season, finishing third in the conference at thirty-five points per game.
- 22:09They also did a good job on defense on key downs, ranking near the top of the conference in both third and fourth down defense.
- 22:16UTSA had a hard time keeping its players in the offseason and an even harder time recruiting replacements.
- 22:21They ranked eleventh of the fourteen teams in the American as far as transfer portal success.
- 22:25But considering two of the teams, Army and Navy, can't accept transfers, they're really eleventh out of twelve.
- 22:31They did manage to procure several solid defensive line recruits.
- 22:34They should improve in that area of their defense.
- 22:36UTSA will face a twenty twenty-six schedule that ranked in the top half of the conference.
- 22:40They'll have to deal with Texas out of conference, as well as Texas State and Colorado State.
- 22:45And in conference, their hardest games will be Tulane and North Texas, numbers one and two in last year's final common sense ranking for the American.
- 22:52On the easier end of their schedule, they get to play UAB, Tulsa, and FAU in conference.
- 22:56So they will likely see a decrease in success in twenty twenty-six, while the Roadrunners likely failing to match the six wins they had in twenty twenty-five.
- 23:06As the 2026 American season progresses, I envision seeing South Florida consistently toward the top of the standings.
- 23:12I also pick North Texas as a likely conference championship game participant, as I think they've replenished their talent well.
- 23:19And then I'm also looking at East Carolina, who's looking to take the next step in 2026.
- 23:24The biggest games for the American in the Common Sense rankings are going to be the lone ACC versus American matchup.
- 23:30That'll be Tulane and Duke in week one.
- 23:33And then Tulsa's week one matchup with Oklahoma State will be the first of two between the American and the Big 12, with the other featuring Tulane and Kansas State in week three.
- 23:42A reminder that those matchups are important because the value of a win, and on the opposite side, a loss, is judged by conference head-to-head records against each individual conference.
- 23:51So if the American can scrape a winning record against both the ACC and the Big 12, that could loom large in the Common Sense rankings.
- 23:59And with that, I want to say a big thank you for joining us for the fourth episode of the CSR podcast.
- 24:04You can follow the Common Sense rankings on the socials at comsenseranking.
- 24:08You can also check out commonsenserankings.com throughout the season for the most statistically accurate rankings for both college football and eventually college basketball.
- 24:17We'll be back next time for another conferences preview for the 2026 college football season.
- 24:22Until then, as you go about your day-to-day, please use some common sense.