Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric Cousins: Renault 5 and Micra EV Comparison
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome to the deep Dive. You know that feeling when you
- 0:12step out on a crisp morning, you unlock your car and for just a
- 0:16second it's the silence, the tech, the design?
- 0:21You feel like you're in a bit of a sci-fi film.
- 0:23Yeah, that little moment of the future.
- 0:24Exactly. And that's the feeling that's
- 0:26being promised by two Reborn legends, the 2026 Nissan Micra
- 0:31EV and the one everyone's talking about, the retro
- 0:34inspired Renault 5 EV. Huge anticipation for that one.
- 0:39Absolutely. So today we are pitching them
- 0:41head to The mission is simple, help you decide which electric
- 0:51future is the right fit for your garage.
- 0:53It's a really fascinating story, actually, because these two cars
- 0:57are, they're bound together, They're built on the exact same
- 1:01foundation, this advanced CMFBEV platform and the same factory in
- 1:05France, right? But what's so captivating is how
- 1:07they managed to achieve these completely different
- 1:09personalities, even though they share, you know, pretty much the
- 1:11same DNA. OK, let's talk about that DNA
- 1:14then. This Ampere CMFB platform, it's
- 1:18the core connection, but what does that actually mean for
- 1:20someone listening? Is it just, you know, generic
- 1:22cost saving stuff or does Ampere mean something a bit more
- 1:26sophisticated for how the car actually performs?
- 1:29Oh, it's definitely the latter, and this is a crucial point.
- 1:32Ampere is Renault's dedicated EV and software division, so this
- 1:36platform wasn't just adapted from an old petrol car, it was
- 1:40designed from the ground up for electric efficiency.
- 1:44That allows for better packaging, maximize the interior
- 1:47space, and critically, it helps with weight management, which
- 1:50keeps the whole driving experience feeling really
- 1:52nimble. It's a huge leap forward.
- 1:54OK, so let's unpack those shared technical bones, because
- 1:57underneath all the different styling, it's a family affair,
- 2:01especially when you look at the batteries.
- 2:02It is. You're basically looking at 2
- 2:04core battery sizes for both models.
- 2:06The entry point is a roughly 40 kWh pack, perfect for pure city
- 2:11driving, that kind of thing, daily commute.
- 2:12Exactly. And then they both offer a
- 2:14larger pack, which is somewhere between 52 and some reports say
- 2:1855 kilowatt hours. That's for people who might do
- 2:21the occasional longer trip or just want that extra buffer
- 2:24during the week and. What about power?
- 2:26Are we looking at identical clones here, or is there any
- 2:28subtle difference in how they put that power down?
- 2:31In terms of motor output, they are basically twins.
- 2:34The entry level motors start around 90 kilowatts, which is
- 2:38what, about 122 horsepower and they peak at a very respectable
- 2:42110 kilowatts, SO150 horsepower. That's plenty for a City car.
- 2:46It is, but what's more important, the city isn't the
- 2:48horsepower, it's the torque. And we're talking about that
- 2:51instant thrust, somewhere between 225 and 245 Newton
- 2:55meters. And that 245 figure, that's the
- 2:57key, isn't it? It's that instant pull that lets
- 2:59you merge into traffic or just, you know, squirt through an
- 3:01intersection. It just puts a smile on your
- 3:03face and away a little petrol car.
- 3:05It just can't. Absolutely.
- 3:07And they've kept them remarkably light from modern EVs.
- 3:09They're in that 1400 to 1500 kilo range and that combination,
- 3:13the lightweight and the instant torque gets them from zero to
- 3:16100 kilometers an hour in a really snappy 8 to 9 seconds.
- 3:20But. The real refinement, and I saw
- 3:22this in the sources, it's not just coming from the motor, it's
- 3:24actually from the rear axle, a detail that a lot of people
- 3:27might miss, but it really hints at a more premium intention.
- 3:31You're talking about the multi link rear suspension?
- 3:33Yeah, and that is a significant engineering choice.
- 3:37Most city cars built purely for cost will use a much simpler,
- 3:42cheaper torsion beam. The multi link system gives you
- 3:46superior control over each individual wheel, so it promises
- 3:50much better comfort over rough city streets, much more
- 3:52stability in corners, and it really transforms them from
- 3:55being just basic runabouts into genuinely sophisticated zippy
- 4:00little driver. So same heart, same bones, yes,
- 4:02but the second you look at them it's so clear.
- 4:04The design teams were in completely different buildings.
- 4:06Oh, completely. Let's get into that.
- 4:08That clash of identities. Yeah, retro icon versus modern
- 4:12minimalist. Where do you want to start?
- 4:13Well, the Renault 5 mean it is a master class in styling.
- 4:18It's leaned so hard into its 70s and 80s French heritage, it's
- 4:22designed to be a showstopper. It really is.
- 4:24You've got those punchy neon colors, the aggressive flared
- 4:27wheel arches, the iconic tail light stripes, and my favorite
- 4:31detail, that glowing 5 on the hood that acts as a charging
- 4:34indicator. It's just charismatic pop
- 4:36culture on wheels. It is, but I do wonder, with all
- 4:40that flash, all those very specific retro cues, does it
- 4:44risk alienating people who just want a reliable, understated,
- 4:48high tech EV for their daily life?
- 4:51And that is exactly the gap that the micro just steps right into.
- 4:54Micro EV takes the sleek, clean, almost minimalist approach.
- 4:58It's open, cool, but it keeps things sophisticated.
- 5:00Nissan themselves actually described the look as more
- 5:03feminine, with softer, rounder lines that are a deliberate
- 5:06contrast to the R5 sharp angles. And it has.
- 5:08Those little delightful details as Easter eggs.
- 5:10I love the sound of those rounded LED headlights that do a
- 5:13little dance or a wink when you unlock the car.
- 5:15Yeah, that's a nice touch. And the fact they molded A
- 5:17subtle Mount Fuji relief into a storage tray inside, it's a
- 5:22quiet little nod to its Japanese heritage without shouting about
- 5:25it. And that detail continues
- 5:27inside. I mean the technical layout is
- 5:28basically the same, same dashboard structure, the big
- 5:3110.1 inch Google based screen, right?
- 5:34But the sensory experience is totally different.
- 5:36The Micra is all about ergonomic premium materials.
- 5:39It feels refined, almost Scandinavian.
- 5:41Whereas the R5 is still having a party inside.
- 5:43Precisely, the R5 keeps that attitude going with tactile
- 5:47dials, pop art inspired fabrics on the seats, bright contrasting
- 5:50seatbelts. You're reminded of the cars
- 5:52history every single time you get in.
- 5:54The micro just gives you a clean contemporary EV cockpit.
- 5:57Same tech, completely different feel.
- 5:59OK, let's get into the realities of owning one of these charging
- 6:02range and some of the unexpected practical bits, because when
- 6:06you're relying on an EV, charging is vital.
- 6:09What's the split here? Because they're not identical.
- 6:11No, they're not. And this is where you can see
- 6:13that deliberate brand strategy. The Renault 5 pushes a bit
- 6:17harder on the DC rapid charging. It offers up to 130 kilowatts on
- 6:21the bigger battery versions. Which is a good number.
- 6:23It's a great number. It helps with that range anxiety
- 6:26on a long trip. It's a psychological win as much
- 6:28as a practical 1. Wait a second, if they're on the
- 6:31same platform, how did Renault squeeze out 130 kilowatts of
- 6:35peak charging while Nissan is only getting 100 on its big
- 6:39pack? Is that an engineering
- 6:40compromise or is it a strategic choice?
- 6:43The sources all suggest it's strategic, it's branding, it
- 6:46lets the run O5 claim that performance edge on charging
- 6:48speed. The Micra does 80 kilowatts on
- 6:52the small pack and 100 on the large one.
- 6:54OK, but, and this is important, the overall charging curve is
- 6:57very similar. Both cars can get from a low
- 7:00state of charge to 80% in about 30 minutes.
- 7:02That 130 kilowatt peak really only matters for the first few
- 7:05minutes before the system starts to throttle back the power
- 7:07anyway. And it seems like Nissan took
- 7:09its strategic advantage and put it into peer efficiency instead.
- 7:12Correct. The Micro just edges out the R5
- 7:15on range. It squeezes up to 253 to 260
- 7:20miles, so it's about 408 to 419 kilometers from its larger back.
- 7:26The Renault 5 is right there with it at up to 408 kilometers.
- 7:30There's a tiny difference. Tiny difference.
- 7:32It suggests maybe Nissan optimize the aerodynamics a
- 7:35little better, maybe the thermal management, but realistically
- 7:38both cars are going to cover several days of city commuting
- 7:40on a single charge easily. And the practicality doesn't
- 7:43stop there. Both of them have V2L vehicle to
- 7:46load. That's a huge feature that's
- 7:48usually reserved for much bigger, more expensive UV's.
- 7:50It's a game changer for a small car.
- 7:52V12 means your car isn't just transport, it's a mobile power
- 7:56source. You could run power tools from
- 7:57it, charge your E bike, even power some essentials at home
- 8:00during a blackout. It just elevates the utility of
- 8:02these cars massively. But if you're talking about
- 8:05pure, simple cargo space, the micro gives you a really clear
- 8:08reason to pick it over the R5. Yeah, this.
- 8:10Is a big one. The Micro has a noticeably
- 8:13larger boot, 326 liters, which is very competitive, and that
- 8:17expands to over 1100 liters with seats down.
- 8:21The Renault 5 is a bit tighter, you know, to preserve that retro
- 8:23shape. It's 277 liters, expanding to
- 8:27about 960. So if you're hauling gear, the
- 8:30micro has a definite advantage, no question.
- 8:32And the micro also throws in a couple of driver focused things
- 8:36that, you know, sealed and EV drivers really look for.
- 8:39It kind of speaks to Nissan's longer history with E VS like
- 8:42the Leaf. It does the micro has paddles
- 8:45behind the steering wheel for adjusting the regenerative
- 8:47braking so you can choose exactly how much the car slows
- 8:50down when you lift off the accelerator, and it also has a
- 8:54dedicated E pedal mode for true one pedal driving, which is just
- 8:57fantastic and stop start city traffic.
- 8:59That level of control is a big usability win for Nissan.
- 9:03OK, let's get to the price puzzle because this is where it
- 9:05gets really interesting. The sources show totally
- 9:08different pricing strategies depending on what country you're
- 9:10in. That's right, in the UK it's
- 9:12simple. The starting price is identical
- 9:14of 21,495 thousand after you factor in the government grant.
- 9:18So in the UK it's purely a choice based on style or
- 9:21features. Exactly.
- 9:23The price parity there positions them against petrol rivals like
- 9:26the VW Polo, but then you cross the channel and that all
- 9:29disappears. Yeah.
- 9:30Why is the micro consistently more expensive in mainland
- 9:33Europe? It's all about accessibility and
- 9:35market strategy. In a market like Belgium, for
- 9:38instance, the micro is consistently about 1300 to 1500
- 9:42more expensive on comparable trims.
- 9:44And the reason? The reason is that Renault is
- 9:46positioning the R5 as the ultimate budget entry EV.
- 9:50It offers a super accessible entry level version with a lower
- 9:5395 horsepower motor and the small battery starting around
- 9:5624,900 talent. So Renault's strategy is to get
- 10:00the entry price as low as humanly possible to grab all
- 10:02those first time EV buyers, and the micro is just avoiding that
- 10:05lowest tier. Exactly.
- 10:07The Micra doesn't offer that budget 95 horsepower model at
- 10:10launch. Its base model starts higher
- 10:12with 122 horsepower motor. It reflects Nissan positioning
- 10:16it as a slightly more premium tech forward offering right from
- 10:20the start. So if we pull all that together,
- 10:22who is the ideal micro buyer and who walks out with the keys to
- 10:26an R5? The Micra is for someone who
- 10:29wants that sleek, functional, modern design.
- 10:32They value the better practicality, the bigger boot,
- 10:35the E pedal, and they want a sophisticated, easy day-to-day
- 10:39experience. They also might value the longer
- 10:41warranty, which can go up to 10 years if you service it at
- 10:44Nissan. It's the pragmatic, refined
- 10:47choice. And the Renault 5 is for making
- 10:49a statement. The Renault 5 is for someone who
- 10:51wants their car to be a fashion statement.
- 10:53They crave personality, they love that nostalgic link to the
- 10:56past, and maybe most importantly, they prioritize
- 10:58getting the absolute lowest possible price to get into an
- 11:01EV. It's fun.
- 11:02It's accessible pop culture. This does raise a big question
- 11:05for our audience, especially if you're already an EV owner.
- 11:07Should you jump ship for one of these?
- 11:09It's a tricky one, but based on the deep dive, if you're a
- 11:12current EV owner, say two to four years into ownership, the
- 11:16strong suggestion is to hold on to your current car.
- 11:19You really need to maximize your total cost of ownership, the
- 11:22TCO. By aiming for six to eight years
- 11:24of total ownership, you spread out that initial depreciation.
- 11:28Upgrading now for style might feel good, but financially it's
- 11:32often not the wisest move. And.
- 11:33What's the big prize on the horizon if they do decide to
- 11:36wait? The big prize is solid-state
- 11:38battery technology. It's anticipated sometime around
- 11:412030 to 2033, and that tech promises a huge leap in energy
- 11:45density. We're talking reliable ranges of
- 11:47800 kilometers or more and much, much faster charging O.
- 11:51For first time buyers, the R5 and Micro are fantastic entry
- 11:54points today, but if you're an experienced owner looking for
- 11:57that next generation of leap, waiting might pay off.
- 12:00So we've covered the shared platform, the style clash of
- 12:03retro versus modern, the subtle but important differences in
- 12:06charging and practicality, and that crucial pricing puzzle that
- 12:10really defines who these cars are for.
- 12:12They really do prove that electric city driving doesn't
- 12:15mean you have to compromise on style or fun.
- 12:18Absolutely, they're both compelling, but you know,
- 12:20considering Grinnell was already showing off with the R5 Turbo
- 12:233E, this 540 horsepower 100 and 55,000 monster arriving in 2027,
- 12:28it does raise a question which is will Nissan ever fight back?
- 12:32Will we ever see a micronismal hot hash to truly settle this
- 12:36family feud? That's something for you to Mull
- 12:38over when you think about the future of electric pocket
- 12:40rockets. Thank you so much for joining us
- 12:42for this deep dive. If you found this deep dive
- 12:44useful, you can support this work here
- 12:46https.buymeacoffee.com/motors Electric Revolution.
- 12:50And don't forget to follow so you don't miss the next one.
- 12:53Stay charged. Stay curious.