Latest / Ops Cast / Why Most AI Initiatives Fail with Paul Shirer
Transcript
- 0:24Michael Hartmann: Hello, everyone.
- 0:25Michael Hartmann: Welcome to another episode of OpsCast, brought to you by marketingops.com, powered by all the MoPros out there.
- 0:31Michael Hartmann: I am your host, Michael Hartman, joined by no one again.
- 0:34Michael Hartmann: We'll get Mike and Naomi back at some point here, I'm sure.
- 0:37Michael Hartmann: But today I am talking with Paul Shirer, founder and CEO of Infinite Ideas AI and director of AI and go-to-market technology at Bridge Partners.
- 0:46Michael Hartmann: Paul spends his time helping organizations evaluate, implement, and scale AI initiatives.
- 0:51Michael Hartmann: And in earlier conversations with him, we found ourselves coming back to a theme that many ops professionals are wrestling with right now.
- 0:58Michael Hartmann: That is, despite massive investment in AI, many organizations are struggling to generate meaningful business impact.
- 1:05Michael Hartmann: That is measurement.
- 1:06Michael Hartmann: We'll explore why that is, where companies are getting AI adoption wrong, how leaders should be thinking, think about workflow design and decision making, and what practical steps organizations can take to move beyond experimentation and toward measurable value.
- 1:20Michael Hartmann: So, Paul, welcome to the show.
- 1:22Michael Hartmann: Thanks for joining.
- 1:24Paul Shirer: Hi, Michael.
- 1:25Paul Shirer: Yeah, thanks so much for having me.
- 1:26Paul Shirer: Yeah, excited to talk today.
- 1:28Michael Hartmann: Yeah, it's it's an all-Texas affair today, since you and I are uh what, about 50 miles apart?
- 1:35Michael Hartmann: Is that about right?
- 1:36Michael Hartmann: Yeah, that's about right.
- 1:38Paul Shirer: You got the north side covered, I got the south side.
- 1:40Paul Shirer: We got our we got our territories we stay in.
- 1:42Michael Hartmann: So there you go.
- 1:43Michael Hartmann: There we go.
- 1:43Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 1:44Michael Hartmann: Um, well, again, I appreciate it.
- 1:47Michael Hartmann: Uh so let's just j dive right in.
- 1:50Michael Hartmann: So when we when when you've talked and what we took sort of trade message about, you've you've said that many organizations are treating AI as a tooling problem when in reality it's a workflow and adoption problem.
- 2:02Michael Hartmann: So break that down.
- 2:04Michael Hartmann: What do you like what does that mean in your words?
- 2:07Michael Hartmann: Um, and and how did you get to that that sort of point of view?
- 2:13Paul Shirer: Yeah.
- 2:13Paul Shirer: Well, I got to that point of view by failing, uh, number one.
- 2:17Paul Shirer: Uh so that that helped or a little bit of a lot of people.
- 2:19Michael Hartmann: That's yeah, pain pain is a good teacher, right?
- 2:21Paul Shirer: That's right.
- 2:22Paul Shirer: Um, yeah, so I I remember, I recall, you know, back whatever a couple years ago, when maybe it was two and a half years ago now when the Chat G GP uh moment hit.
- 2:31Paul Shirer: And uh the first thing was like we need to get Chat GPT, right?
- 2:34Paul Shirer: And so we got it, everyone got everyone got a license, you know, and it was like, and then you'd go look at the usage of that tool, and it would be like, you know, very few people using it at the time.
- 2:44Paul Shirer: Now I'm sure that would be different if we did it today, but at the time it was very little.
- 2:48Paul Shirer: Yeah.
- 2:48Paul Shirer: And so you started looking at uh, you know, uh how are we gonna start transforming uh the way we work?
- 2:55Paul Shirer: And really that was the theme from the beginning.
- 2:57Paul Shirer: If you were getting ahead of it from a strategic standpoint, you'd be thinking this is going to change, but how long is it gonna take?
- 3:04Paul Shirer: What's it gonna take to do that?
- 3:05Paul Shirer: And what are the baby steps along the way, right?
- 3:07Paul Shirer: And so a tool is just a tool, it's sort of like a hammer is just a hammer, like we hear that all the time.
- 3:13Paul Shirer: That's right, what it is, but unless you have something to use it on and and kind of what you're trying to build, then it doesn't, it's not really all that useful.
- 3:20Paul Shirer: Um so I think that the key to this whole thing is for most organizations is you know, start where people are.
- 3:29Paul Shirer: Don't don't get way, way ahead of yourself.
- 3:31Paul Shirer: You know, like the idea that you're going to change away all of your workflows and processes and get people to follow along and do that all at the same time, it's a very difficult thing to do.
- 3:42Paul Shirer: And I think a lot of people, a lot of folks have done that in terms of how they piloted AI.
- 3:47Paul Shirer: Um, they're trying to rewire everything.
- 3:48Paul Shirer: And so I I kind of advocate for meet people where they are, how they're currently working, um, give them to buy in, get them to actually start to use these things and see the value and let them be your research, you know.
- 4:01Paul Shirer: And I one of the metaphors I use, and not that's a metaphor, but uh a sort of strategic uh framing I use is we're working inside organizations, but it's not much different than uh if you were going to market with a new tool.
- 4:16Paul Shirer: And so think about your organization as the marketplace, if you will.
- 4:20Paul Shirer: Yep.
- 4:20Paul Shirer: And what are the pain points?
- 4:22Paul Shirer: What are the problems they're they're they're the challenges that they have?
- 4:25Paul Shirer: And how can we have this new technology come in and help solve some of those problems?
- 4:30Paul Shirer: So meeting them where they're at, you know, getting their sort of buy-in in the early early stages of it, how can you help them create better content, make better decisions, um, you know, look at analytics in a different way, all the things that we know AI can do, but talk to them about it and start to begin to understand how you can support them with the tool itself.
- 4:50Paul Shirer: And uh that means, you know, obviously skilling, obviously means um, you know, onboarding and creating communities of practice, make it be their idea, so to speak.
- 4:59Paul Shirer: Right, how people share those ideas.
- 5:01Paul Shirer: Um, anyway, point being that I think a lot of folks have been trying to solve the whole thing all at once.
- 5:08Paul Shirer: I don't think that that's reasonable in terms of transformation within an organization, and you have to have a strategic approach to looking at the workflows, uh looking at the the adoption first, and then kind of slowly moving towards how you can kind of uh impact and operationalize uh AI with uh the specific workflows.
- 5:28Michael Hartmann: Yeah, I mean, I like that idea.
- 5:29Michael Hartmann: Uh so for the audience who's listening only, I'm sitting here nodding my head all the way along through Paul's description there, because I think uh that I like that idea of thinking about this as a little bit of an internal sales and marketing initiative, right?
- 5:42Michael Hartmann: Or go-to-market initiative.
- 5:44Michael Hartmann: That's an interesting one.
- 5:45Michael Hartmann: But your point about meeting people where they are, I think is a is an often missed one with kind of all change management.
- 5:51Michael Hartmann: Um, I can't remember if we talked about this when we last spoke, but I I did some research on change management as I was working with a client um a couple of years ago, and I came across a Harvard Business Review article from like I want to say it was the late 60s, it may have been the 70s.
- 6:06Michael Hartmann: I don't remember exactly when it had been revised.
- 6:08Michael Hartmann: But what struck me about it was even though it was that old, right, the principles were still there.
- 6:15Michael Hartmann: And I think, you know, the this idea that one size fits all is not realistic.
- 6:21Michael Hartmann: I think, and I don't know if this is true or not, I would imagine there's sort of a bell curve, right?
- 6:25Michael Hartmann: Of people who are like on the one end, you've got people who are gonna be like jumping right in, they're hot to do this, they want to change this.
- 6:33Michael Hartmann: On the other end, of the people who are like totally reticent, why break something that's already working?
- 6:38Michael Hartmann: And then like over time, like you've got this whole big chunk of people who are sort of somewhere in between.
- 6:43Michael Hartmann: Yeah, and and so thinking that they're all on the one end, right, is probably not gonna be successful if you treat everything that way.
- 6:52Michael Hartmann: Now you could take advantage of those people.
- 6:53Michael Hartmann: I think that you were hinting at that, right?
- 6:55Michael Hartmann: You were talking about pockets of community.
- 6:57Michael Hartmann: I mean, if I think about like that pocket of community is the ones that are gonna really test the boundaries and then they can help advocate and teach others.
- 7:07Paul Shirer: Yeah, exactly.
- 7:08Paul Shirer: I mean, I think a good uh skilling program.
- 7:11Paul Shirer: There's different levels we actually put together kind of a different levels of skilling program uh with one of our um, as we were initially rolling out, this is about a year and a half ago or so, um, that we really spent a lot of cycles on this.
- 7:24Paul Shirer: And um the skilling is yeah, giving them some free courses that are on YouTube or LinkedIn learning.
- 7:29Paul Shirer: That was obviously obvious or low-hanging route.
- 7:32Paul Shirer: Yeah, and then some certificate programs, maybe pay paying for a few things.
- 7:36Paul Shirer: But one of the best things you could do is identify those champions and and those those folks that are the super users that and and really they can train the train, you know, they can train the folks.
- 7:47Paul Shirer: They're they're happy to share all the practice.
- 7:49Paul Shirer: In fact, they're they're very vocal about it.
- 7:51Michael Hartmann: It's an ego, it's an ego-based thing for them, right?
- 7:53Paul Shirer: So yeah, and it's a career path for them in some ways, too.
- 7:56Paul Shirer: They're seeing it as an in a an opportunity to build not only their skills and in their position, but also maybe even leap within the comp company or who knows, go somewhere else.
- 8:06Paul Shirer: But they they will be the leaders of a community of practice.
- 8:09Paul Shirer: So we've uh I've stood up probably about um, I guess three or four uh communities of practice now within companies.
- 8:16Paul Shirer: And um, you know, you just get them started in Slack or Teams and have those folks that really want to be the champions come in and they're very vibrant internal communities.
- 8:27Paul Shirer: I was actually surprised at how vibrant they would be.
- 8:30Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 8:30Michael Hartmann: I mean, I've I've seen the same thing internally.
- 8:32Michael Hartmann: I mean I'm a big fan of like the internal communities for things like that.
- 8:38Michael Hartmann: I think I think um the only thing I've seen that has hampered them is when there's um there's too much concern about what might be said inside those, right?
- 8:48Michael Hartmann: Um it's kind of the same with it as when you have a say customer community, but like I'm always I tend to go like let it go.
- 8:56Michael Hartmann: Like, and if it happens, right?
- 8:58Michael Hartmann: First off, you're I think it's like the like teaching kids, right?
- 9:02Michael Hartmann: They they fear doing something new, and it's usually the fear is way greater than the reality, right?
- 9:08Michael Hartmann: That's right.
- 9:08Michael Hartmann: And and I and um I think I'm all for like let it flow, right?
- 9:15Michael Hartmann: Don't I mean set guidelines about the way that you can communicate that's acceptable?
- 9:20Michael Hartmann: So that's a little bit different, but if like in terms of the content itself, okay, if they say this tool sucks, right?
- 9:25Michael Hartmann: Let them say it.
- 9:26Michael Hartmann: Ask why, right?
- 9:28Michael Hartmann: Yeah, um, and let what I found is that then the rest of the community who doesn't agree will counter it.
- 9:35Paul Shirer: And it's kind of like social media.
- 9:37Michael Hartmann: Yeah, I mean, well, yeah, I mean uh with with with hopefully with some more guardrails than what you see.
- 9:43Michael Hartmann: So um all right, well, so another thing you and I talked about is that you and I see this too, right?
- 9:51Michael Hartmann: I've seen companies, I've seen comments about people sort of accumulating tools, agents, um spending sort of unexpected large amounts of money on um tokens, things like that with some of these tools.
- 10:07Michael Hartmann: So when you you you use the word agent sprawl, right?
- 10:12Michael Hartmann: How do you how do you think about that versus maybe a more um appropriate adoption of AI and that it might be more useful for organization?
- 10:25Paul Shirer: Yeah, it's a great question.
- 10:26Paul Shirer: And you know, not having a perfect answer by by any means, but just uh observing what I've seen in kind of the evolution.
- 10:32Paul Shirer: Um, you know, we first saw, we just talked about the idea of having tools was the first thing, and then prompt techniques were everywhere, right?
- 10:39Paul Shirer: And everybody was sharing those prompt techniques, and that was kind of a nice, fun little age where people were just playing with these things.
- 10:45Paul Shirer: Um and uh then, of course, agents come around.
- 10:49Paul Shirer: And uh what just to kind of define what agents are for this point here, I'm making is we sure co-pilot agents within Microsoft uh 365 or the ChatGPTs within OpenAI or Gemini Gems and and things like that.
- 11:03Paul Shirer: Um now there are some other a little more robust agents that folks were building, but by and large, the citizen developed agents that are in play uh that are out there.
- 11:12Paul Shirer: And I don't want to I'll take it a little further.
- 11:15Paul Shirer: There were folks paying for you know more production level and for development companies to build some agents too.
- 11:22Paul Shirer: Um, but the the problem with it all was it was all done kind of in a vacuum and uh all done in terms of um we need this now, let's build it and let's we're not gonna think about how everything connects together.
- 11:36Paul Shirer: Um, you know, what my uh co my uh colleague is doing, or what this other department over here is doing, not gonna think about um you know all the governance or any of these things, and we're just gonna do it.
- 11:47Paul Shirer: In part, that was also because leaders were saying use AIRLs.
- 11:51Paul Shirer: They were freeing up budgets to invest in AI and they just said go.
- 11:55Paul Shirer: And so what we ended up having was all these agents.
- 11:59Paul Shirer: Um, some of them were duplicate efforts, a lot of them were lower quality citizen development agents, um, things that were you know helping like product marketing or sales outreach or content development or analysis, and they've been doing some things.
- 12:11Paul Shirer: Um, and uh and but they by and large um weren't being used in the most efficient ways, the most productive ways, and there was just a lot of waste.
- 12:21Paul Shirer: Um, so that's what I call that agent sprawl factor.
- 12:24Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 12:24Paul Shirer: We we saw this a lot at enterprise, but I I I think it was happening pretty much everywhere, even in mid-size, um, etc.
- 12:32Paul Shirer: But um that that's the agent sprawl.
- 12:34Paul Shirer: But I'm happy to go further and talk about, you know, you know what why that happened and what we can do about it and what's the next evolution, if you like, as well.
- 12:43Michael Hartmann: Yeah, I mean, I think um I I definitely see it.
- 12:46Michael Hartmann: I don't think it's isolated to, in fact, there's part of me that thinks that it's probably less of an issue in enterprise organizations because they're so hard to move.
- 12:57Michael Hartmann: Um there's a part of me that thinks it's like in like early stage small companies where people sort of they just figure shit out and how to get things done, right?
- 14:18Michael Hartmann: They're gonna be adopted with less of that four-letter word governance, right?
- 14:24Michael Hartmann: Um yeah, so I'm curious to me, I are you seeing some of that more in enterprise organizations?
- 14:30Michael Hartmann: Are you seeing more of it in mid to smaller companies?
- 14:36Paul Shirer: It's definitely both.
- 14:37Paul Shirer: I agree with your point on um the you know, mid-size is the kind of the one where it's the least it's the most propensity for enough people to do some things, but less governance.
- 14:47Paul Shirer: So that's where it's happening, probably probably the biggest problem area.
- 14:51Paul Shirer: Smaller is just not enough people to mess it up anyway.
- 14:54Paul Shirer: So you're kind of yeah, yeah.
- 14:56Michael Hartmann: And uh the implications are the Yeah, the risk, the risk is lower in terms of like the scope.
- 15:00Michael Hartmann: Yeah, I get it.
- 15:02Paul Shirer: Yeah, yeah.
- 15:02Paul Shirer: And then but enterprise, yeah, definitely saw it now.
- 15:05Paul Shirer: It they have, and I work with Microsoft, Google, um, SAP, AWS, and we're talking about big cloud enterprise.
- 15:12Paul Shirer: Sure.
- 15:12Paul Shirer: There's a couple other hyperscalers we work with and that kind of thing, and they're partners.
- 15:16Paul Shirer: But now what I saw there, what I've we're in the midst of is there was a whole fix my agent phase.
- 15:24Paul Shirer: So the citizen developed, and then we came in and fixed their agent, so to speak.
- 15:28Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 15:29Paul Shirer: Now um, so they were seeing, and then RI responsible AI started really coming down the pipe, right?
- 15:35Paul Shirer: And so, in particular on at the Microsoft area, uh, responsible AI is a huge part of now of the overall, just getting an agent into their system now is becoming a big thing.
- 15:45Paul Shirer: But um, the fix my agent was the thing uh for a little while.
- 15:50Paul Shirer: The biggest thing that's happening now is um that's this stakeholder and this one business unit over here is talking to this stakeholder because they have teams of matrixes uh you know across all these.
- 16:01Paul Shirer: They're very similar in a lot of ways.
- 16:04Paul Shirer: My my Microsoft's maybe a little more matrix-oriented.
- 16:07Paul Shirer: But um, they're now going, wait, you're doing this, I'm doing this, you're doing this.
- 16:12Paul Shirer: Maybe we can bring these things together.
- 16:14Paul Shirer: So they're getting pretty proactive about being bringing things together and not just working in their silos.
- 16:21Michael Hartmann: Yeah, that makes sense.
- 16:22Michael Hartmann: I mean, that's the one that it's the benefit of having a larger organization.
- 16:25Michael Hartmann: You probably if thinking about Belker, I mentioned, right, there's gonna be just more volume of people at any one particular place in terms of their propensity to use the tools.
- 16:34Michael Hartmann: So um so a curious, you know, um, and I think you you and I when we talked about like you're thinking about evolving, you're thinking about AI and how to incorporate it and implementing it, all that has evolved over time.
- 16:50Michael Hartmann: So if I remember right, you you felt pretty strongly that you need to wire together end-to-end kind of automated workflows, call it magents, whatever.
- 17:00Michael Hartmann: Um, but it sounds like you're I think in our conversation, it sounds like your perspective has shifted shifted.
- 17:04Michael Hartmann: So maybe talk about like, yeah, what was your belief at kind of early and then how has it evolved and what like what is it that's changed in in that process?
- 17:13Paul Shirer: Yeah, yeah.
- 17:14Paul Shirer: Thanks for that question.
- 17:15Paul Shirer: And then that is really probably at the center of my the thinking that I'm really really focusing on now with the teams uh that I work with as well, is um the reality of the concept of an end-to-end workflow where you can, first of all, just agree on the key steps of that workflow.
- 17:35Paul Shirer: Say it's a sales prospecting all the way down to nurture, down to some level of conversion.
- 17:40Michael Hartmann: Sure.
- 17:41Paul Shirer: Um, or a content pipeline or whatever it may be, especially in the market.
- 17:44Paul Shirer: Um the idea that there are quote unquote key steps and micro tasks that happen that are rinse and repeatable all along that cycle is a is a little more illusion than reality.
- 18:00Paul Shirer: You know, like it's it's you want it to be true.
- 18:02Paul Shirer: Theoretically, it sounds like it can be true, but then you get in to do the work and you find out everyone's different.
- 18:08Paul Shirer: You find out uh there's nuance to it, and there's like customization all the time that's necessary.
- 18:12Michael Hartmann: Shadow, shadow processes, shadow systems, right?
- 18:15Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 18:16Paul Shirer: Yeah, exactly.
- 18:16Paul Shirer: You got it, yeah, all these different things that you weren't aware of, and you you you always and this goes back to all the days that we we tried to be to engineer workflows, right?
- 18:25Paul Shirer: We've been trying to be agile for years, or not just that not scratch that word agile.
- 18:29Michael Hartmann: I don't really mean I meant it in the kind of the not the general certain not the methodology.
- 18:33Michael Hartmann: I get it.
- 18:34Michael Hartmann: Okay.
- 18:34Paul Shirer: Yeah.
- 18:34Paul Shirer: When we first started talking about workflows, this is our old land.
- 18:38Paul Shirer: But the the point is uh that we um we've been trying to do this for a long time.
- 18:43Paul Shirer: And so we thought AI would be the forcing function in a way to get our stuff together so that we could have the right AI doing things and human in the loop or human on the loop and we can construct anything.
- 18:53Paul Shirer: But the the trial struggle was not only just that can we get something that is rinse and repeatable, but then getting human beings to be in the loop.
- 19:01Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 19:02Paul Shirer: It's like rallying cats, right, to come in and do this thing and to believe and to buy buy into it and all that stuff.
- 19:07Paul Shirer: Now, I'm not saying I gave up on that.
- 19:09Paul Shirer: I I do think there's uh certain uh pieces of the of the puzzle, the pipeline where you can come in and and and get some pretty nice uh wired uh workflows.
- 19:19Paul Shirer: Um and you know, having AI autonomously do some pieces of the puzzle that would be called agentic workflows.
- 19:25Paul Shirer: I think that's real.
- 19:27Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 19:27Paul Shirer: Um, but yeah, I just I just decided that, you know, the bigger opportunity and the thing that we kind of just rushed right past is just getting people to be better at using the tools that they have and expanding out the workspaces, which I won't go into that right now.
- 19:44Paul Shirer: I think we're gonna probably talk about that a little bit more.
- 19:46Paul Shirer: But um, that is what I've seen.
- 19:48Paul Shirer: I know it's contrary to everything you're seeing on LinkedIn.
- 19:51Paul Shirer: I get it.
- 19:52Paul Shirer: They're all workflow first.
- 19:53Paul Shirer: And I was writing about workflow first a year ago.
- 19:55Paul Shirer: I was uh I was talking to my uh my leaders and companies, and but uh as we've tried to do it, I just it just hasn't always played out the way we expected it to.
- 20:05Michael Hartmann: It's I just want to make sure I'm clear.
- 20:07Michael Hartmann: So when I hear you talk about that, I'm thinking like a workflow, like say it's let's say you can even agree on like your point about agreeing on what the steps are, right?
- 20:16Michael Hartmann: But let's say you've got general agreement, you've got 10 steps, and you try to automate the entire process.
- 20:21Michael Hartmann: Um, is that what you're talking about?
- 20:24Michael Hartmann: Like okay.
- 20:25Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 20:27Paul Shirer: Yeah, I think it's um when I look at workflows, it's always going to be some mix of what AI can do, what automation can be done, and then humans take a piece of the puzzle and then they're in the loop.
- 20:38Paul Shirer: But it requires this official formal design of a workflow.
- 20:41Paul Shirer: And and that's you know, this conflict.
- 20:45Paul Shirer: So I've seen a lot of uh another, it's again, I was talking about this over a year ago, and I'm taking back just a little bit, is that um a lot of folks have said you have to invert, and that's what I was saying, you know, back then too.
- 20:56Paul Shirer: It's like invert from um people first to workflow first.
- 21:02Paul Shirer: And so instead of hiring people, and this has implications for how you change your workforce and who you hire and all that kind of stuff, you're hiring for the workflow versus having people do it and then have them use tools.
- 21:14Paul Shirer: So it's just and and again, I haven't given up on it, Michael.
- 21:17Paul Shirer: I I do think that there are some spots where this is useful, but I think that this sort of blanket statement around workflow-first mentality is is it's not as practical as it may sounds.
- 21:29Michael Hartmann: Yeah, and the reason I ask you that, I I I remember seeing LinkedIn posts when I was still sort of, I feel like I was late to dipping my toes into using tools like ChatGPT or Cloud or whatever on an individual basis and kind of thinking about it as I was working on a problem or some sort of deliverable, right?
- 21:48Michael Hartmann: I it wasn't at my normal, it took a while for that to become a part of how I thought about getting things done.
- 21:54Michael Hartmann: But what I remember seeing is some people who had tried to do whether it was you call it agentic workflows or whatever, that had um like lots of sort of AI components and an overall automated workflow, right?
- 22:08Michael Hartmann: Maybe there was some human in the loop component to it.
- 22:11Michael Hartmann: Um, and it feels like people were sharing, like, this is what I'm doing, and here's what it looks like.
- 22:14Michael Hartmann: And then it felt like it wasn't that long after where I started to like actually what we find is if a step something goes off the rails in one step, right, it it has this cascading effect.
- 22:25Michael Hartmann: Um yeah, it's to me, it's like I think about like okay, if I'm this is gonna maybe offend some people, like if you're shooting a gun at a target, right?
- 22:34Michael Hartmann: And it the tar the farther the target is away, right, any little variance is gonna be at the end when you get to that target, it's gonna be way off.
- 22:42Michael Hartmann: And it feels like that's kind of what it was happening, is like people are like, oh, I'm gonna automate this whole thing, but then something would break here.
- 22:51Michael Hartmann: And actually, what I think I remember is like not only did it break somewhere, it was harder to figure out where something went off the rails.
- 22:59Paul Shirer: Yeah, yeah, it's I don't again, we would we probably need 15 different use cases to really search this.
- 23:07Paul Shirer: And you'll you know, if you're doing data consumption and you're extracting data and turning it into some organized form, and then that's then manifesting an email that gets pushed to your business leader.
- 23:17Paul Shirer: Maybe that's the uh a useful automation that probably would work most of the time.
- 23:21Paul Shirer: If you're having AI make decisions for you based on some level of criteria, I think your your example comes into play more.
- 23:27Paul Shirer: It's like, yeah, that could go off the rails.
- 23:29Paul Shirer: That's not right.
- 23:30Paul Shirer: And um and then you have the AI.
- 23:34Paul Shirer: For all its promise, and I I love it.
- 23:36Paul Shirer: Look, I use AI every day.
- 23:37Paul Shirer: I'm a this is what I do for a living.
- 23:39Paul Shirer: Sure.
- 23:40Paul Shirer: You know, the the generative AI portions are always they're just not quite right yet all the time.
- 23:46Paul Shirer: And so we can't just have it do things for us, um uh, you know, and do it in these automated ways.
- 23:53Paul Shirer: But um the as you add as you add human in the loop uh components to it, um the biggest problem we have there is then, so let's say that you have an end-to-end, uh, I'll just do a content engine real quickly.
- 24:08Paul Shirer: We'll just do a little campaign in a box concept real quick.
- 24:10Paul Shirer: Got it.
- 24:11Paul Shirer: So a campaign in a box, you would have a creative brief of what the campaign is.
- 24:15Paul Shirer: Um, you'd probably marketing a specific product or service.
- 24:18Paul Shirer: You have target personas, you have probably a message you can position you framework that governs that brand guidelines, all these things that can help you kind of put together a content campaign.
- 24:26Paul Shirer: And maybe your content campaign has a uh an ebook and then maybe has a one-pager and then has nurture it has reach out emails, nurture streams, ads, all these things that are kind of in that campaign that help that.
- 24:38Michael Hartmann: Sure.
- 24:39Paul Shirer: Well, if you put together an end-to-end workflow that says we're gonna pipeline this thing, we're gonna say AI is gonna do this part, humans are gonna do this part, AI is gonna come next, and blah, blah, blah.
- 24:49Paul Shirer: You put this whole thing together and you say, got it, we got this really streamlined thing.
- 24:54Paul Shirer: Our efficiencies are gonna go down, we still have quality gates, all these things are great.
- 24:58Paul Shirer: And then you um then you go put that into practice.
- 25:01Paul Shirer: Well, you've got writer X over here that has to pick it up after this.
- 25:07Paul Shirer: Where did it go?
- 25:09Paul Shirer: Where's the project management tool we're gonna use?
- 25:11Paul Shirer: What's the status of this thing?
- 25:12Paul Shirer: Well, now do we have to put a project management tool in this thing?
- 25:15Paul Shirer: Okay, and and people have done that.
- 25:17Paul Shirer: And then it's like, what's next after that?
- 25:19Paul Shirer: What's next after that?
- 25:20Paul Shirer: And so what you thought was this theoretically easy end-to-end thing, it started got it started to get really complicated when there was new writers coming in.
- 25:28Paul Shirer: Oh, that person was fired.
- 25:28Paul Shirer: No, they're not here anymore.
- 25:29Paul Shirer: Oh, that it's like it's like, you know, there's just the idea that it's just gonna somehow work, you know, um, you know, that's the problem.
- 25:39Paul Shirer: But yeah, you try.
- 25:41Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 25:41Michael Hartmann: So and you so you hinted at this uh a few minutes ago about the idea or con concept of um I think you call it connected workspaces.
- 25:52Michael Hartmann: So rather in in that as an alternative.
- 25:55Michael Hartmann: So first off, maybe like that you did earlier, like what's the what's the definition of a connected workspace?
- 26:01Michael Hartmann: How is it different than some of these other scenarios we talked about where things seem to be uh appear to be, you know, connected but aren't really right?
- 26:10Michael Hartmann: They're disconnected.
- 26:11Michael Hartmann: Um, and then what does that look like?
- 26:13Michael Hartmann: You know, do you have an example or something where you can talk about in the practice?
- 26:16Michael Hartmann: Maybe maybe what you just went through as a variance.
- 26:20Paul Shirer: Yeah, we I think we've been evolving to this in general with different solutions of late.
- 26:24Paul Shirer: And I'll try to lay this out.
- 26:25Paul Shirer: And without having like visuals and you know, kind of get looking at these examples, I think it might be a little hard to follow, but I'll do the best I can to kind of lay this out.
- 26:34Paul Shirer: Um, we've talked about some of the um underlying problems, the the agent sprawl, for example, right?
- 26:40Paul Shirer: You think of a marketing team or a sales team and or any go-to-market team, right?
- 26:46Paul Shirer: And they are uh working, they they started off, they got these tools, they're starting to work in silos, they're building all these, and we got the agent sprawl issue.
- 26:56Paul Shirer: Um you then go, okay, well, why don't we create workflows that will, again, we just talked about the workflows, these are all part and parcel, where let's end to end, we're gonna have agent X come in here, and the loop do Y and things like that.
- 27:10Paul Shirer: So that was another sort of address way to address the kind of the work to be done in that area.
- 27:15Paul Shirer: And we've already talked about some of those problems.
- 27:17Paul Shirer: So now what we have is like co-workspaces that are are growing up.
- 27:22Paul Shirer: So popularity of Cloud and co-work and Microsoft has its own word, um, um, its own co-workspace, and we'll see more and more of these.
- 27:30Paul Shirer: But these are really personal workspaces still, where people are doing work and they're doing in all their one-off ways in their own idiosyncratic personal ways, which is what they should do.
- 27:39Paul Shirer: But what I think is uh emerging is you still have marketing teams, you still have sales teams, and you even have teams within those teams that do work together.
- 27:48Paul Shirer: And so I'm what I'm seeing is this concept of a connected workspace where it's built around a specific team's needs, and um, it's anchored in all the the data that they work together with, the documentation they work with, the processes too.
- 28:04Paul Shirer: But shared context.
- 28:06Paul Shirer: It's a shared context.
- 28:07Paul Shirer: And so one example we've been building out recently has been around um product marketing teams um that also, of course, do activation campaigns.
- 28:18Paul Shirer: They also do sales enablement and things like that.
- 28:20Paul Shirer: So you get it, you get it acrossroads and you go, well, aren't there some tools out there that we can just buy?
- 28:26Paul Shirer: And then you go down the buy world and you go, like, well, no, not quite right.
- 28:30Paul Shirer: Doesn't quite fit me.
- 28:32Paul Shirer: It's not exactly what it was.
- 28:33Paul Shirer: And then then what do we do with all of our data?
- 28:36Paul Shirer: Like, is that just all over there?
- 28:38Paul Shirer: Like, what are we doing with it?
- 28:39Paul Shirer: So what I'm seeing is, and we're building out a couple of these recently, they've been really resonating with clients, and so we're happy that that's happening.
- 28:47Paul Shirer: That's always good.
- 28:48Michael Hartmann: Market validation is always good.
- 28:50Paul Shirer: Yeah, yeah.
- 28:50Paul Shirer: So, and so this is kind of an exciting area where we're building all those agents that work on are disconnected or they were just plugged into M360 Microsec 365, or they were GPTs or whatever those.
- 29:01Paul Shirer: Instead, we're building one space where all the product marketing needs are there, where you can build the vision and mission statement for the product, the um the overviews, the features and benefits, the ICPs, all there, but it gets stored in a data layer.
- 29:15Paul Shirer: So it's not just knowledge sources that are unstructured, like all these documents that are you're putting in there.
- 29:21Paul Shirer: Okay.
- 29:21Paul Shirer: We're storing it in a day layer.
- 29:23Paul Shirer: And then they go to create um blogs or they create uh ebooks and things like that, and that's all getting stored in the day layer.
- 29:29Paul Shirer: And so are all the chat sessions.
- 29:31Paul Shirer: So what we're creating is the really this completely connected space, a round of business function where all the rich data is being built up over time.
- 29:40Paul Shirer: And so when you go to each agent that builds something, whether you're building the blog or you're building the draft of a of an email sequence and all that kind of stuff, instead I have to reground every one of those agents in the documents, it's pulling from the same data layer across everything.
- 29:54Paul Shirer: And uh it's creating a much more powerful way to do work and do it at scale.
- 30:00Paul Shirer: And I think that I don't know where this all will go.
- 30:02Paul Shirer: I'm just saying what I see, Michael, and what we're building.
- 30:05Michael Hartmann: I swear, like I've given up trying to predict because it's like it feels like every time I turn around, there's some new thing out there.
- 30:11Michael Hartmann: And if I go back to like we talked about like the adoption of different types of companies, I mean, I know of at least one organization that I've heard where developed their own sort of um tool for people to use, you know, uh um LLM kind of based on some of the other um models.
- 30:30Michael Hartmann: Um, and then using IP restrictions like blocked all the other ones.
- 30:35Michael Hartmann: Well, new ones are popping up all the time for specific use cases and people are getting around it, or they turn off a VPN or whatever, right?
- 30:41Michael Hartmann: It's like, I mean, that's the stuff that's really happening out there.
- 30:46Paul Shirer: Yeah, the shadow AI, I was I'm I've actually got a post that's gonna go out in the next few days.
- 30:50Paul Shirer: Um, I've been doing some a research piece around it first, and I'm gonna post around it uh on shadow AI and what to do about that.
- 30:58Paul Shirer: And I think that we're seeing a first, it's like, don't ask, don't tell.
- 31:04Paul Shirer: And then it's like, then it's like, let's be punitive.
- 31:07Paul Shirer: Let's like, uh well, you know, do all that.
- 31:09Paul Shirer: But then I think the next phase, which I believe we need to look at very closely, is let's let's let that be a tell on the market.
- 31:17Paul Shirer: What do people want?
- 31:18Paul Shirer: Because these are the people that want to use things, and so ask them.
- 31:22Paul Shirer: You know, embrace it, intake what they're doing, and then maybe you could put together a plan about which tools you're going to buy to support them, even though Shadow AI is still going to be there, at least you're embracing what's happening and know that that's not nefarious.
- 31:36Paul Shirer: It's like, I just want to do my work better, I want to move faster and to embrace it, in other words, yeah.
- 31:41Michael Hartmann: Yeah, no, I mean I'm again kind of going back to this.
- 31:43Michael Hartmann: Like, I I would rather be have that be in the open and know about it than to think it's not happening because you know, and then people feel like they can't talk about it.
- 31:52Michael Hartmann: I think that's a a worse kind of outcome.
- 31:56Michael Hartmann: You you you talked about a data layer, and and I don't I want to maybe dive into that a little bit because I'm not sure this is exactly what you were talking about.
- 32:02Michael Hartmann: So if not, that's fine.
- 32:04Michael Hartmann: We can we can kind of connect the dots here.
- 32:07Michael Hartmann: But yeah, one of the challenges I think everyone in ops would tell you is like our data sucks and go to market, right?
- 32:12Michael Hartmann: But there's marketing sales, whatever, especially in B complex B2B sales stuff.
- 32:17Michael Hartmann: Um how two-part question, because I I have a strip.
- 32:22Michael Hartmann: So, how important do you think that data quality is to enabling these kinds of tools?
- 32:29Michael Hartmann: Um, and then one thing that I'm would like to see, I haven't heard a lot of people talking about this.
- 32:33Michael Hartmann: I'd like to see AI being used to help improve the data quality and completeness.
- 32:38Michael Hartmann: Like just think is is it like so in other words, don't wait for the data to be whatever.
- 32:45Michael Hartmann: We pick the level you want, right?
- 32:46Michael Hartmann: Um before you start using AI tools for other things, but like how can the AI tools help expose and correct the data?
- 32:54Michael Hartmann: Like, what's your take on all that?
- 32:56Paul Shirer: Yeah, that's a great question, Michael.
- 32:57Paul Shirer: And I think um to to just say it um and state that data's a problem is one thing, but to then unravel like what's inside all of that as you work through it.
- 33:06Paul Shirer: And I think um, you know, it it's a problem in so many ways, and it's always been a problem.
- 33:13Paul Shirer: It's just that AI is now exposing it because as you try to really leverage the power of AI, which essentially it's like it just needs data, it just loves data, it can't do anything without data, um, really to really be effective or to be differentiating or useful.
- 33:30Paul Shirer: So you just could go across any area of the go-to-market um space, you know, all the way to up and down the customer journey, if you will, and you're gonna find, well, you can't personalize uh outreach if you don't have data, right?
- 33:45Paul Shirer: You can't um follow, you can't um have on-point battle cards and sales enablement if you don't have data.
- 33:52Paul Shirer: I mean, you can wing it as much as you want, um, but you're gonna need that intake.
- 33:57Paul Shirer: And so um the the struggle we have is that data uh in an unstructured form is not all that useful.
- 34:06Paul Shirer: It has to be structured, and we know that.
- 34:07Paul Shirer: But um, so how do you go about doing that is the question.
- 34:11Paul Shirer: Um, and how do you pull from all these sources?
- 34:13Paul Shirer: Well, um, sometimes um it's just a matter of like you can't even get access to a lot of data.
- 34:19Paul Shirer: Like, you know, yeah, sometimes it's not collecting the right data.
- 34:22Paul Shirer: Think of all the just the entire trail, we're not collecting all the data properly.
- 34:27Paul Shirer: There's that.
- 34:28Paul Shirer: But sometimes even within organizations, it's just so many systems, whether it's within Salesforce or you know, different CRMs, um, or maybe it's all your ad data over here and your customer intelligence or feedback loops, the market research that you do that's over here.
- 34:44Paul Shirer: And um, so we're like just recently I've been working on um competitive intelligence a lot for whatever reason.
- 34:51Paul Shirer: I have uh two competitive intelligence solutions.
- 34:54Paul Shirer: Um, and it's really rearing its ugly head around like, well, we have external data sources we can grab with AI, which that's available on a lot of levels.
- 35:05Paul Shirer: Sure.
- 35:05Paul Shirer: Where are all your internal sources?
- 35:07Paul Shirer: Like, well, there's documents just gathered everywhere.
- 35:10Paul Shirer: There's there's CRM data, there's sales force casting data, there's our customer feedback data, and it's everywhere.
- 35:18Paul Shirer: Um, but the challenge is then um how do you get access to it, pull it together, normalize it so it can actually be used, and then you can actually have AI do all kinds of levels of rag responses and in you know ingestion of it and do things with it.
- 35:35Michael Hartmann: Right.
- 35:36Paul Shirer: Um, but it's just it's a long process.
- 35:38Paul Shirer: And it's the thing that then the the biggest thing I would say is this, and like if you go macro, sometimes we can dissect these things, but if you want to just put it as a big equation, um data is super important.
- 35:51Paul Shirer: Leadership doesn't want to invest in it because it's not they don't understand, it's not sexy, it doesn't make sense, right?
- 35:57Michael Hartmann: Right.
- 35:58Michael Hartmann: The the immediate immediate, there's not a there's just not an immediate, obvious value to putting in the effort and cost yet.
- 36:04Michael Hartmann: Totally.
- 36:05Paul Shirer: They don't want to invest in it, but it's super important, so crappy output.
- 36:08Paul Shirer: It's it's the simplest equation in the world.
- 36:10Paul Shirer: But um it, you know, I think that um the good thing is that AI has exposed a lot of things, and we talk about this a lot, exposed our workflow process issues, we've exposed um you know, talent and skilling issues, is exposed um data issues, and I think that's one of the best sort of value benefits we've gotten out of AI.
- 36:32Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 36:32Michael Hartmann: I I I think so.
- 36:34Michael Hartmann: Like I still I think I still feel like there's a play here to use AI to help with that data quality.
- 36:40Michael Hartmann: I just don't I don't know what it would look like.
- 36:44Michael Hartmann: You know what I mean?
- 36:47Paul Shirer: Yeah, um well if I agree.
- 36:50Paul Shirer: No, no, AI, it's one of its beautiful things it can do is it can organize, right?
- 36:54Paul Shirer: It's taxonomy, uh I it's it's so much better than us, and it's so much faster.
- 36:59Paul Shirer: And so I agree with you on that.
- 37:00Paul Shirer: Um in fact, we were doing a project, there's another project we're working on where it's a um first thing we're doing is we're just doing some data auditing.
- 37:09Paul Shirer: And uh we want to build some dashboards for um OKR.
- 37:12Paul Shirer: So you know, the um objective is in key results for a quarter.
- 37:16Paul Shirer: And so the first thing we're doing is we're going through like 15 different dashboards that have already been created.
- 37:24Paul Shirer: Just like nuts.
- 37:26Michael Hartmann: And uh dashboard is a four-letter word to me.
- 37:29Paul Shirer: Yeah, it's it is at this point, you know.
- 37:31Paul Shirer: If you do it right to some degree, but the problem is people never go, there's a lot of problems with dashboards.
- 37:36Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 37:36Michael Hartmann: Anyway.
- 37:37Paul Shirer: Nonetheless, the we can use AI to go into these data systems, which you know, some the inconsistencies of data across all those systems, those dashboards.
- 37:46Paul Shirer: We are using AI to go in and extract all that and create a master taxonomy, like a sensible master taxonomy that can come all of that in order to then build the the next dashboard.
- 37:57Paul Shirer: Um, but then we'll also have push, you know, notification, you know, push information and things like that will come off of it.
- 38:03Paul Shirer: Um, but that's one way AI can just intelligently sift through it and suggest a better taxonomy.
- 38:08Paul Shirer: That's a simple sort of thing.
- 38:09Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 38:10Michael Hartmann: Well, I mean, I'm sure somebody's got to be doing this right.
- 38:13Michael Hartmann: A very common thing for uh in the ops world, both marketing and sales ops probably is get an external list, you gotta normalize country or state or whatever, right?
- 38:23Michael Hartmann: And I'm like, that's a or or normalize uh job levels, right, based on titles.
- 38:31Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 38:32Michael Hartmann: Um, I mean, I think that's a powerful way of using it, right?
- 38:35Michael Hartmann: Doing that that organization for you and doing it dynamically, right?
- 38:38Michael Hartmann: So over time, like you it adjusts based on what the real data is.
- 38:42Michael Hartmann: Um flat as it may be.
- 38:44Paul Shirer: Yeah, absolutely.
- 38:45Paul Shirer: I think that's that's a great point.
- 38:47Paul Shirer: And um the well, I'll just say that my uh the basis of the business I'm building, Infinite Ideas AI, is all based on the idea that AI can create new and unique data in the market.
- 39:00Paul Shirer: Um and so that's yeah, my not only agreeing with you, like it's like um to me, I I was looking at the way we um all the signals that are out there in the world, you know, not just around conversations on Twitter or Reddit and things like that, and sort of that typical sentiment analysis and things like that, but just taking the everyday sort of things that are happening out there and turning it into real signals, um, you know, what's the velocity of investment in a specific space?
- 39:29Paul Shirer: Um what's the what's the um if you knew what your current product was and you and you saw um something happening, some news item hacking happening in the market, um, how related is this news item to my product line and should I do something about it?
- 39:46Paul Shirer: And you could score that, right?
- 39:47Paul Shirer: Right.
- 39:48Michael Hartmann: So like a like a risk assessment or an opportunity assessment.
- 39:51Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 39:51Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 39:52Michael Hartmann: Yeah, I like that.
- 39:53Michael Hartmann: It's interesting your point, like the this is the other thing that really it wasn't until I was talking to someone who was a writer at one point, and I we were talking about something else, and I asked through in the question, like, oh, what do you like?
- 40:04Michael Hartmann: Because I'm assuming most writers detest right these LLMs for what they do.
- 40:09Michael Hartmann: And and this person was like, Well, we do breaking news, so they can help us make our writing better, but like they can't break new news because there's nothing to go on.
- 40:18Paul Shirer: That's right.
- 40:18Paul Shirer: That's right.
- 40:19Paul Shirer: I do love that part.
- 40:20Paul Shirer: And and uh when people were talking about content creation first, that was kind of an area that I was like, well, you can always do new reporting, you can always do new things.
- 40:30Paul Shirer: You can there's things happening everywhere and um that are unique that um yeah, that LMs are not trained on, not yet.
- 40:39Michael Hartmann: Yeah, well, I mean, there's this whole thing I saw that like if you're a top performer and whatever you think you're gonna use AI for, uh, the likelihood that you're gonna stay a top performer is actually pretty low.
- 40:49Michael Hartmann: Like it's gonna bring you down to the median, right?
- 40:51Michael Hartmann: And if you're a poor performer, poor it's gonna help you up.
- 40:54Michael Hartmann: Like, so is it in a lifetime?
- 40:57Michael Hartmann: I mean, I mean, I was like, oh yeah, that's like, oh yeah.
- 40:59Michael Hartmann: Like, so if you're like if you're a top performer, should you be using AI?
- 41:04Michael Hartmann: Well, maybe you should be using AI differently.
- 41:05Michael Hartmann: This like Ed like it begs a lot of interesting sort of questions that go beyond that.
- 41:10Paul Shirer: Great point on that one.
- 41:11Paul Shirer: It's an equalizer.
- 41:12Paul Shirer: We used to say that when we were playing, I played a lot of basketball in my life.
- 41:15Paul Shirer: I still play a lot of basketball.
- 41:17Paul Shirer: Um, and when we played basketball in the rain, it's like, well, they want your speed advantage, that's gone.
- 41:24Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 41:25Paul Shirer: There's no first step in the rain.
- 41:27Paul Shirer: So uh, you know, everybody was equally the same speed in their yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure.
- 41:33Michael Hartmann: Outdoor basketball, or if there's a wet lot of wind, right?
- 41:36Paul Shirer: Sparkman, yeah.
- 41:36Paul Shirer: Football is the same, right?
- 41:38Paul Shirer: If it's raining or snowing, like it doesn't really matter who was better anymore.
- 41:42Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 41:43Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 41:44Michael Hartmann: I uh yeah, like all kinds of good sports analogies there, I'm sure.
- 41:48Michael Hartmann: Um, so I want to like I'm gonna kind of take two two ends of sort of the the the whole process of AI adoption, and I would like to get your thoughts on sort of both because it feels like there's a linkage.
- 42:00Michael Hartmann: Um the first is for the people who are listening or watching this, right?
- 42:04Michael Hartmann: How should they be thinking about whether so if they're leaders, how should be they thinking about how to get AI initiatives started, right?
- 42:13Michael Hartmann: What should we be doing, maybe what should they not be doing?
- 42:16Michael Hartmann: What are some guiding principles there?
- 42:18Michael Hartmann: Um, should they be looking at doing things like building versus buying, especially if it's like we call it agenc stuff?
- 42:26Michael Hartmann: I hesitate to even use that term.
- 42:27Michael Hartmann: But then the one that keeps coming up regularly now is then how do they set things up so they know that they can measure the the the benefit from a I think really from a financial standpoint.
- 42:38Michael Hartmann: Maybe there's non-financial benefits too, but like what's your take on that?
- 42:42Michael Hartmann: That's big-ended, open-ended question for you there.
- 42:45Paul Shirer: Yeah.
- 42:45Paul Shirer: Yeah, that's good, good, good questions.
- 42:47Paul Shirer: Um, and I think that that's what we're that we're in that era now.
- 42:50Paul Shirer: Like we had the fun, there was sort of blink checks written.
- 42:54Paul Shirer: It's like we'll figure this out later.
- 42:56Paul Shirer: The competitions are doing it, and so we got to do it.
- 42:59Paul Shirer: If we don't do it, we may be left behind, fear factors, all that stuff.
- 43:02Paul Shirer: And now it's like, okay, wait a minute.
- 43:05Paul Shirer: Where's the real um where's the real ROI and uh how should we really be deliberate and have some sort of method to our madness and how we actually make decisions around this?
- 43:14Paul Shirer: Uh, which I love, it's which kind of the area I focus a lot on.
- 43:17Paul Shirer: And so um now having an expertise in that area actually makes a difference.
- 43:21Paul Shirer: I don't know.
- 43:22Paul Shirer: It's kind of interesting because um I I always like look at like how many people are actually um Googling or what's the trends around AI strategy or something like that, you know?
- 43:31Paul Shirer: And we see that uptick.
- 43:33Paul Shirer: I kind of follow that a lot being in the strategy space, and it's like I think they're starting to get the point that we might have to think about this and that kind of thing.
- 43:40Paul Shirer: But um so um, you know, when you're looking at um if we start with um, I guess a buy versus build, I'll kind of kind of give you a couple of anecdotes on this uh to kind of show you the difference and in might help guide the decision.
- 43:58Paul Shirer: Um it's really gonna come down to, and this has always been the case in buy versus build is not a new thing, right?
- 44:04Michael Hartmann: I think I know where this is going.
- 44:05Michael Hartmann: Okay, go.
- 44:07Paul Shirer: Yeah.
- 44:08Paul Shirer: You know, it's like um how bespoke, how how bespoke to your business does it need to be?
- 44:14Paul Shirer: And yeah, um, because there is going to be um a s a place, there's gonna be a time when it's it's just needs to be more bespoke.
- 44:22Paul Shirer: It's not like it's one size fit all will fit all.
- 44:25Paul Shirer: It's just we know that's not true.
- 44:27Paul Shirer: Um, even at the more precision like level and more nuanced and niched oriented solutions, it still can come up short.
- 44:34Paul Shirer: Um, I'll give you an example of a client I just met with yesterday, actually.
- 44:37Paul Shirer: Um and it was interesting.
- 44:39Paul Shirer: I was glad to hear it.
- 44:40Paul Shirer: Um, you know, it was like, look, I can go to compete intelligence tools right now.
- 44:45Paul Shirer: I know I can do that.
- 44:46Paul Shirer: I told you I was kind of working on a couple of compete uh solutions lately.
- 44:49Paul Shirer: But it doesn't help me because it's not best enough to me.
- 44:53Paul Shirer: It doesn't, I it doesn't know, it doesn't work with the data that I really wanted to work with.
- 44:59Paul Shirer: Um, it doesn't deliver it the way I need to deliver it.
- 45:03Paul Shirer: It doesn't have the lenses or the views or the outputs and the ways I need to see it.
- 45:07Paul Shirer: So there's just one thing after another.
- 45:09Paul Shirer: And so I think if you're going to uh do a buy versus build situation, that's the number one thing that they're looking at is um, and sometimes it's um there's nothing wrong with uh this is I remember getting this question a long time ago.
- 45:24Paul Shirer: It's like there there's really nothing wrong with buying right now and then building later.
- 45:29Paul Shirer: Right.
- 45:30Paul Shirer: You know, you can gap it, you know, you can get and you might learn from the buy.
- 45:34Paul Shirer: Experience to then maybe build later too.
- 45:37Paul Shirer: Um so sometimes a decision is just better than nothing at all.
- 45:40Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 45:41Michael Hartmann: Well, I think what uh this so what I expected you to be talking about is the trade-off, right?
- 45:45Michael Hartmann: For getting something more spoke bespoke is that now you're taking on sport and development maintenance.
- 45:51Paul Shirer: You know, that's a great point.
- 45:52Paul Shirer: I do want to when you're ready, I want to comment on that.
- 45:54Paul Shirer: Don't that's it, that's it.
- 45:55Paul Shirer: Okay, good.
- 45:56Paul Shirer: Yeah, uh, yeah.
- 45:57Paul Shirer: No, that's I love that point.
- 45:59Paul Shirer: And this is the crazy world we live in um with vibe coding, you know, and then with agentic level coding.
- 46:08Paul Shirer: And it's like it's like where you would have to buy in the past, you you may be able to spin something up that's reasonable.
- 46:14Paul Shirer: And then I mean like someone who knows what they're doing.
- 46:17Paul Shirer: I don't mean like straight go out to uh you know Lovable or Bolt and just like put up a prototype because there's a lot of vibe coding, it's just prototypes, they're not working.
- 46:25Paul Shirer: But you know, doing a lot of development uh with working with developers a lot, you know, with cursor and and now with cloud code and things like that, you can get things pretty bes well, bespoke for sure, but you can get it on point and in market with some level of MVP pretty quickly now.
- 46:42Paul Shirer: So your the build versus buy equation has changed because of that.
- 46:45Paul Shirer: I'm not saying that that's for everyone.
- 46:47Paul Shirer: I'm just noting that that is uh it's changed the equation.
- 46:50Michael Hartmann: Fair enough, true.
- 46:51Michael Hartmann: Yeah, yeah.
- 46:52Michael Hartmann: No, I think that's that's a good point.
- 46:53Michael Hartmann: But there's still like that is something you have to take on, right?
- 46:55Michael Hartmann: It's not a zero cost.
- 46:57Paul Shirer: It's technical debt.
- 46:57Paul Shirer: It's technical debt that you don't know where it's going.
- 47:01Paul Shirer: That's the the big unknown.
- 47:03Paul Shirer: You will never know where something you're building is going to go.
- 47:06Paul Shirer: And yeah, then you need good product managers.
- 47:08Paul Shirer: And I think that's always a way un misunderstood skill set in the world.
- 47:12Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 47:13Paul Shirer: Try managers know how to evaluate something for its for its business impact.
- 47:20Paul Shirer: They know how to t-shirt size things to know how big they are and how long they're gonna take and how much they're gonna cost.
- 47:25Paul Shirer: They're gonna know the technical debt, but most organizations don't have that um that muscle, so to speak.
- 47:30Paul Shirer: No, I think they think they they think they have it.
- 47:33Michael Hartmann: Yeah, no, I think so too.
- 47:34Michael Hartmann: Uh so so okay, so there's a buy versus bill.
- 47:38Michael Hartmann: Like, how do you how are you seeing companies that are successful in measuring the impact of AI initiatives?
- 47:47Paul Shirer: Yeah, another great one, right?
- 47:49Paul Shirer: And so you can build all the RRI calculators you want.
- 47:52Paul Shirer: There's a lot of them out there.
- 47:54Michael Hartmann: Um all models all models are inherently flawed, right?
- 47:58Paul Shirer: We can vibe code one right now.
- 48:00Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 48:02Paul Shirer: Right.
- 48:02Paul Shirer: No, no, but uh, but seriously, on this, you know, there are some things you can do before and after.
- 48:07Paul Shirer: I mean, there are clear things where like KP, like conversion rates on a sales funnel or something like that is a clear thing that can make a difference.
- 48:15Paul Shirer: Um, if you got uh outreach, um like you've got volume and quality equations with, say, outreach and sales, you can get a hold of did the quality versus the quality game work work?
- 48:26Paul Shirer: Did where was the personalization of this AI helping me in this matter?
- 48:30Paul Shirer: Um you can um you can do obviously time to time to be able to make decisions.
- 48:37Paul Shirer: Like decision time is huge when it comes to data and how you can ingest it and things like that.
- 48:41Paul Shirer: Those are things that I think you can get a hold of.
- 48:43Paul Shirer: But a lot of it's just gonna be pure qualitative.
- 48:45Paul Shirer: And I think a lot of people are scared of the qualitative, but I love it.
- 48:47Paul Shirer: I mean, I I I like the idea of go go ask your people.
- 48:51Paul Shirer: I mean, what's wrong with that?
- 48:52Paul Shirer: You know, yeah.
- 48:53Michael Hartmann: I I uh the analogy I I think you and I talked about was it's sort of like attribution reporting, which is the marketing.
- 48:59Michael Hartmann: Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 49:00Michael Hartmann: And and and I think it's right.
- 49:02Michael Hartmann: It's like it's it's rife with all kinds of data issues and challenges with measuring and you can't capture everything.
- 49:08Michael Hartmann: Uh, but I'm with you, right?
- 49:09Michael Hartmann: I'm a big believer that the the a lot of marketers, uh, and part of why I think they have their their percept the perception of them sometimes in organizations is not great.
- 49:19Michael Hartmann: It's because they forget to use the skill they should be really good at, which is storytelling within their organizations.
- 49:23Paul Shirer: Storytelling, there you go.
- 49:24Paul Shirer: That's awesome.
- 49:25Paul Shirer: I love that point a lot.
- 49:26Paul Shirer: I'm I'm gonna bank that one for sure.
- 49:28Paul Shirer: Go ahead because I mean that's the truth.
- 49:31Paul Shirer: And you know, have all these uh what I'm dealing with a lot is uh CEOs or leaders in orgs that have to get a board ready thing.
- 49:37Paul Shirer: You know, they have to it's like it's gonna be storytelling no matter what you do here, because there is no way to say anything any right now that would make everyone happy.
- 49:47Paul Shirer: I mean, there are investments being made, there are lots of proof of concepts, there are a lot of things that we're trying to do and understand, but you have to make the investments to get to the next step, otherwise you're gonna be left behind.
- 49:58Paul Shirer: And so it's not the thing that a board member wants to hear, or like someone who's paying and making the investment, um, because it's not what it's it's not how they want to work and anybody does want results, right?
- 50:11Paul Shirer: But the reality is this is I I've actually said it the other day, it's like I was like, wow, yeah, it's right.
- 50:16Paul Shirer: Like this is kind of a cool concept.
- 50:17Paul Shirer: We're the whole world is in in an RD phase right now.
- 50:21Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 50:21Paul Shirer: We're we're making investments and things that we just need to figure them out.
- 50:25Paul Shirer: And we have to kind of we're all collectively doing it together.
- 50:28Michael Hartmann: Well, and I know of at least one person on LinkedIn who's been uh posting regularly in the last two months, probably.
- 50:35Michael Hartmann: Here we are mid mid-June 2026, about like how these organizations are, yeah, the CFOs are all of a sudden seeing large chunks of money going out the door, you know.
- 50:46Michael Hartmann: So say they're using uh pick the clay is the easy target here, right?
- 50:51Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 50:51Michael Hartmann: People are like, oh, look at all this great stuff.
- 50:53Michael Hartmann: We can replace something like Zoom info and do this waterfall like um enrichment process, and then the bill comes in for what it costs to do that.
- 51:03Michael Hartmann: And it's this hidden cost that I think are going to drive the there's gonna be the forcing function that's gonna push people to go like we've got to figure out some way of measuring the impact.
- 51:13Michael Hartmann: Um, because otherwise there's just too much, too much money leaking out of the organization.
- 51:19Paul Shirer: Yeah, totally.
- 51:20Paul Shirer: And or and and not only that, modify behavior because of it, you know, because token costs is really are becoming huge.
- 51:28Paul Shirer: Um, more than the token war or like the uh the model war, they they I felt like they all figured it out.
- 51:34Paul Shirer: We'll just keep charging people and keep promoting fear that they don't get the latest model.
- 51:38Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 51:39Michael Hartmann: Um yeah.
- 51:42Michael Hartmann: Anyway, well, it's been great.
- 51:44Michael Hartmann: This we could like maybe let's let's wrap up here.
- 51:47Michael Hartmann: And and it's too bad Mike Rizzo couldn't join us because I think he would like us to ask he would want me to ask this question if if he or he would if I if he was here, which is I think he you and he, I think the two of you talked before, uh kind of he said that you had have a similar view as him and some others that like feature CMOs are gonna come out of an ops space, uh, or at least have a background in ops.
- 52:10Michael Hartmann: Um so curious, like is that true for you?
- 52:14Michael Hartmann: And then if so, the sense I get is you think that that like AI, like a lot of this AI activity is gonna be something that might accelerate that process.
- 52:24Paul Shirer: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 52:25Paul Shirer: Completely agree with Mike on that.
- 52:27Paul Shirer: Um and I think it's um it's a macro thing across leadership, and but it it's particularly in this area.
- 52:36Paul Shirer: Um you know, leaders of the past, and I actually did some research on this because I was wondering about what's the shift in terms of technology driven or oriented leaders versus you know like the classical, like maybe financially oriented or some sales-oriented leaders, like you look at C shows and things like that.
- 52:57Paul Shirer: Um, and it is shifting considerably, and you see in a lot of key companies, um, you know, like the Nvidia's and the uh even Microsoft when it shifted to more of a uh tech oriented, they they got their stuff together.
- 53:09Paul Shirer: Microsoft was becoming a joke, right?
- 53:11Paul Shirer: And then seven, eight years ago they shifted and now they're they're getting track.
- 53:15Paul Shirer: And I see we see this everywhere.
- 53:16Paul Shirer: And I think it's the same within marketing ops and marketing.
- 53:20Paul Shirer: Um, I mean, how can you possibly lead an organization, right?
- 53:24Paul Shirer: But not having some felt or understanding, like you gotta feel things.
- 53:28Paul Shirer: I was like the the I don't know if you've seen white man can't jump, it's like a movie.
- 53:33Michael Hartmann: It's been a long time, but yes, I know you're talking about, yeah.
- 53:35Paul Shirer: Yeah, it's like you you can feel you can't you hear Jimmy, but you can't feel Jimmy when he was talking about Jimi Hendrix, right?
- 53:41Michael Hartmann: So yeah, yeah.
- 53:43Michael Hartmann: I don't remember the scene, but that's uh it's a true statement, I think.
- 53:46Paul Shirer: Yeah, you know, that's the thing, that's the difference.
- 53:48Paul Shirer: Like you can't go into like just hearing it and somehow you gotta feel it.
- 53:52Paul Shirer: You you have to have been there.
- 53:54Paul Shirer: And I it's always hard for me to kind of talk to people, like explain to them why you can intuitively understand how something's built.
- 54:00Paul Shirer: Well, if you built something a hundred times, you just know you just can see it and you know where it's going.
- 54:05Paul Shirer: Kind of you're not always right, but you you got a real good sense of it.
- 54:08Michael Hartmann: Yeah.
- 54:09Paul Shirer: And I think if you don't have that, you're really in trouble.
- 54:12Paul Shirer: And it just I can't see how it plays out.
- 54:14Paul Shirer: Um, there's one other piece of that puzzle.
- 54:18Paul Shirer: I do still think you need leadership skills.
- 54:20Paul Shirer: You know, like leadership skills are a thing.
- 54:22Paul Shirer: Absolutely.
- 54:22Paul Shirer: You've got to know how orgs work, you gotta know how to um sell something internally.
- 54:27Paul Shirer: Um, you gotta know how to work with people and lay the groundwork.
- 54:31Paul Shirer: Um, uh all those things are, you know, everyone we know about leadership skills, but that a powerful combination of having that marketing ops background and knowing how this thing functionally works and feeling it.
- 54:42Paul Shirer: Um, plus the leadership skills, I think is the combination.
- 54:46Michael Hartmann: Love it.
- 54:46Michael Hartmann: Okay.
- 54:46Michael Hartmann: Well, I'm glad we got to get get into that question a little bit.
- 54:50Michael Hartmann: So hopefully people will stick around and listen to that.
- 54:52Michael Hartmann: That's an important piece.
- 54:53Michael Hartmann: Hey, so Paul, again, thanks for joining us.
- 54:56Michael Hartmann: Um, if folks want to continue, like they're interested in continuing and going deeper on some of these topics with you, what's the best way for them to do that?
- 55:03Paul Shirer: Yeah, uh, go out to LinkedIn, uh Paul Shire, P-A-U-L-S-H-I-R-E-R.
- 55:08Paul Shirer: I'm the only Paul Shire, I think, out there.
- 55:10Paul Shirer: Well, there was one other.
- 55:10Paul Shirer: He's got a he's got a financial planning uh company, and uh we talked.
- 55:14Paul Shirer: And so he's helping very well.
- 55:15Paul Shirer: It's a good guy.
- 55:16Paul Shirer: Um, but no, Paul Shire, I'm the other, you know, literally Paul Shire.
- 55:19Paul Shirer: And then uh Infinite Ideas AI is the uh business I've uh launched and um would love to even hear even feedback on that if you all get a chance to take a look at it.
- 55:30Michael Hartmann: Fantastic.
- 55:30Michael Hartmann: Again, Paul, thank you.
- 55:31Michael Hartmann: Thanks to our audience out there for continuing to support us.
- 55:34Michael Hartmann: We are always grateful for your input and and support.
- 55:37Michael Hartmann: And if you have ideas for topics or guests or want to be a guest, you can reach out to Naomi Mike or me, and we'd be happy to get the ball rolling.
- 55:44Michael Hartmann: Until next time, bye everybody.