Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Raise When Your Job Description Is Outdated
Transcript
- Lucas: So there's this moment that happens in almost every job. You've been in the role for a year, maybe two, and you start to realize the work you're actually doing has drifted pretty far from the job description you were hired for. Luna: It's like the job description is a fossil and your real job is a living creature. Lucas: Exactly. And that gap can be a real problem when it's time to talk about money. Because HR is looking at a job title and a salary band that doesn't match what you're doing anymore. Luna: So what do you do? I feel like a lot of people think, well, I'll just ask for a raise and explain that I'm doing more. But that doesn't always land. Lucas: Right. A listener actually wrote in with this exact situation. They're a marketing coordinator, but over the last year they've started managing two junior people and they're leading the quarterly strategy for their product line. The job description still says, you know, 'assist with campaign execution.' Luna: That's a pretty big leap. And their manager keeps saying, 'you're doing great,' but there's no talk of a title change or a raise. Lucas: Yeah, and that's the trap. When your manager says you're doing great but nothing changes, it's often because the framework around you hasn't caught up. So this episode is about how to make that framework catch up. And the first step is to stop framing this as 'I do more work.' Luna: Because that sounds like you want a reward for effort. Which, sure, but that's not how compensation works. Lucas: Compensation is tied to the value of the role, not the effort you put in. So you need to show that your role has actually changed, and that the market value for that new role is higher than what you're being paid. Luna: So how do you document the shift without sounding like you're just listing chores? Lucas: You need to create a side-by-side comparison. On one side, you write down the core responsibilities from your official job description. On the other side, you write what you actually do now, with concrete examples and the percentage of your time that's spent on each. The key is to be specific, not emotional. Luna: Like, instead of 'I manage people,' you write 'I conduct weekly one-on-ones, I do performance reviews, I approve time off.' That kind of thing. Lucas: Exactly. And you want to quantify where you can. In this listener's case, they could say 'I now spend 40 percent of my time on strategy development, up from zero when I was hired.' Luna: That's powerful. But then what? You have this document, and you go to your manager, but what's the actual ask? Lucas: This is where a lot of people stumble. They say, 'I want a raise because I'm doing more.' But you want to say, 'My role has evolved into a different market position, and I'd like to be compensated for that role, not the one I was hired for.' Luna: So you're not asking for a raise, you're asking for a recognition of a role change. Lucas: Yes. And you can frame it as a question: 'Can we talk about how my compensation aligns with the role I'm actually in now?' That opens the conversation without being confrontational. Luna: And you need data. What does a marketing manager make compared to a coordinator? Lucas: In the US, the difference is substantial. A coordinator might be in the mid-fifties to low sixties, while a marketing manager is often in the seventy to ninety range. That's a significant jump, and you need to show you know that. Luna: So you're not just making numbers up, you're coming in with market data. Lucas: Right. You can use salary surveys, tools like Glassdoor or Payscale, and you can also look at job postings for roles similar to what you're doing now. Print those out, or screenshot them. Have that as part of your evidence. Luna: I like the idea of referencing actual job postings. Because it's not just about what you're doing, it's about what the market pays for that work. Lucas: And here's a subtle but important move. Before you meet with HR, you need to get your manager on board. Because if your manager doesn't champion the change, HR will just see a job description and a title, and they'll say no. Luna: So how do you get the manager on board? Because the manager might be the one who's been saying 'you're doing great' without acting. Lucas: You have to make it easy for them. You can say, 'I've put together a summary of how my role has evolved, and I'd love your feedback on it before I discuss it with HR. If you agree, could you support this in the comp review?' Luna: That gives them a chance to be your ally instead of your opponent. Lucas: Exactly. And if they push back, that's actually useful information. If they say 'well, you're still a coordinator,' then you know they don't see the value, and you can ask what would need to change for them to see it. Luna: That's a great way to turn a no into a roadmap. Lucas: And it's worth remembering that this isn't just about a raise today. If you can get the title changed, that has a compounding effect on your career. Future employers will see the title, and you'll have a stronger story to tell. Luna: So the goal is to get both the title and the money, but if you have to pick one, the title might be the smarter long-term move. Lucas: That's a really good point. And it's a decision we should each make based on our own situation. But in general, I'd say don't settle for just more money and a stale title, because you'll hit the same wall later. Luna: Before we go further, I want to mention something, because we've been talking about how to make a case, and it reminds me of how we make this show work. We're an independent podcast, and that means we answer these questions every day without a big corporate sponsor behind us. If you've found our career episodes helpful, and you're in a position to support us, you can do that at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small way to keep these conversations coming, and it's completely optional. Lucas: Yeah, that really does keep us going. And we're back to the listener's situation. So you've got your manager on board, you've got your document, and you're going to HR. What's the actual script for that meeting? Luna: I want to hear this, because HR can be intimidating. Lucas: You're not going in with a demand. You're going in with a proposal. You can say, 'My role has evolved significantly since I was hired, and I've documented that evolution. I'd like to discuss how my title and compensation can be adjusted to reflect the market value of this role.' Luna: And you hand them the document. Lucas: Yes. And then you let them ask questions. You don't need to fill the silence. You've made your case clear, and now you're giving them the space to respond. Luna: And if they say, 'we don't have a budget for that right now'? Lucas: Then you ask, 'When is the next compensation cycle, and what would I need to show by then to make this a priority?' That puts a timeline on it and gives you a clear target. Luna: So you're not taking no for an answer, but you're not being pushy either. Lucas: Exactly. It's a negotiation, and you're being professional about it. And remember, if they truly can't adjust your comp, you can still push for the title change, which as we said has long-term value. Luna: I think the biggest takeaway for me is that this isn't about complaining about your workload. It's about repositioning yourself in the market. Lucas: That's the core. Your job description is an artifact from the past. Your actual role is the living reality. And when you bring data, a solid argument, and a manager in your corner, you're giving the company a reason to say yes rather than a reason to say no. Luna: And if they still say no, then you have a clearer picture of where you stand, and maybe that's the push you need to look elsewhere. Lucas: Right. It's hard data for your own decision-making. Either way, you're not stuck in the dark. So if you're in this situation, start building that document today. It's the best first step you can take.