Latest / Bloomberg Law / Special Counsel Testifies & Judge Dismisses 3 Trump Counts
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law, with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:10Speaker 2: We did not, however, identify evidence that rose to the
- 0:12Speaker 2: level of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Because the evidence
- 0:16Speaker 2: fell short of that standard, I declined to recommend criminal
- 0:20Speaker 2: charges against mister Biden.
- 0:21Speaker 3: Special Counsel Robert Hurr testified for more than four hours
- 0:25Speaker 3: before the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday, standing steadfastly by
- 0:30Speaker 3: the assessments of his year long investigation in his three
- 0:34Speaker 3: hundred and forty five page report that recommended no criminal
- 0:38Speaker 3: charges be brought against President Joe Biden for his handling
- 0:41Speaker 3: of classified documents, and Her insisted repeatedly that his description
- 0:46Speaker 3: of the eighty one year old president as a quote sympathetic,
- 0:50Speaker 3: well meaning, elderly man with a poor memory, a description
- 0:53Speaker 3: that set off a political firestorm, was necessary.
- 0:57Speaker 2: To include my assessment in the about the relevance of
- 1:01Speaker 2: the president's memory was necessary and accurate and fair. Most importantly,
- 1:07Speaker 2: what I wrote is what I believe the evidence shows,
- 1:10Speaker 2: and what I expect jurors would perceive and believe.
- 1:13Speaker 3: But Her faced aggressive questions, often in the form of
- 1:16Speaker 3: accusations from the members of both parties, with Republicans like
- 1:21Speaker 3: California Congressman Tom McClintock saying that the evidence for prosecution
- 1:25Speaker 3: was there and her gave Biden a pass.
- 1:29Speaker 2: All I have to do when I'm caught taking home
- 1:31Speaker 2: classified materials to say, I'm sorry, mister Herbert, but I'm
- 1:35Speaker 2: getting old.
- 1:36Speaker 4: My memory is not so great.
- 1:37Speaker 5: Yeah, Congressman, this is the doctrine that you've established in
- 1:41Speaker 5: our laws now, and it's frightening.
- 1:43Speaker 3: And Democrats like California Congressman Adam Schiff saying the language
- 1:48Speaker 3: characterizing Biden as an old man with a poor memory
- 1:51Speaker 3: was not only unnecessary, but against Department of Justice policy
- 1:56Speaker 3: that is.
- 1:56Speaker 2: Nowhere in the rules. I was to prepare a confidential
- 1:59Speaker 2: report was comprehensive and thorough of anything.
- 2:02Speaker 5: What is in the rules, mister Herr. What is in
- 2:04Speaker 5: the rules is you don't gratuitously do things to prejudice
- 2:09Speaker 5: this subject of an investigation where you're declining to prosecute.
- 2:13Speaker 5: You don't gratuitously add language that you'll know will be
- 2:16Speaker 5: useful in a political campaign. You were not born yesterday.
- 2:20Speaker 5: You understood exactly what you were doing. It was a choice.
- 2:25Speaker 5: You certainly didn't have to include that language.
- 2:28Speaker 3: Joining me is former federal prosecutor Michael Zelden, who also
- 2:31Speaker 3: served as a deputy independent counsel. I want to start
- 2:35Speaker 3: with HER's report itself. The conclusion of his report was
- 2:39Speaker 3: that no criminal charges were warranted against Biden. What's your
- 2:43Speaker 3: take on how he got to that decision and how
- 2:47Speaker 3: he reported on it.
- 2:50Speaker 4: It was very curious to me. The first sentence of
- 2:53Speaker 4: report says that yes, he did nothing that warranted indictment,
- 2:59Speaker 4: but he engaged in wilful conduct in retention and wilful
- 3:04Speaker 4: conduct in distribution, which would be you know, blocking and tackling.
- 3:10Speaker 4: Basics for a charge. But he walks away from charging
- 3:14Speaker 4: him because he says he would present himself to a jury,
- 3:19Speaker 4: probably as a sympathetic, well meaning elderly man with a
- 3:23Speaker 4: poor memory. So I found that incredibly confusing. One is,
- 3:28Speaker 4: if he willfully possessed and willfully distributed, then that's the
- 3:33Speaker 4: basis for a charge. If the evidence was soft and
- 3:38Speaker 4: it wasn't as clearly wilful, then he should have said
- 3:42Speaker 4: you could argue wilfulness, But in this case, totality of
- 3:45Speaker 4: the evidence would undermine a finding of wilfulness by a jury.
- 3:50Speaker 4: But this notion that he would likely present himself to
- 3:53Speaker 4: a jury in this way struck me as very difficult
- 3:57Speaker 4: to understand, because one, he has no idea how Biden
- 4:01Speaker 4: would present himself to a jewelry. Too, he doesn't even
- 4:03Speaker 4: know whether Biden would ever take the witness stand to
- 4:06Speaker 4: present himself to a jury. So it seemed to me
- 4:08Speaker 4: that he really should have limited his bindings to the
- 4:12Speaker 4: evidence presented, and if he felt that he willfully obstructed,
- 4:19Speaker 4: or wilfully retained or willfully distributed, then he should have
- 4:23Speaker 4: charged him. If he felt that the evidence was not
- 4:26Speaker 4: sufficiently wilful, then he should say there are extenuating circumstances
- 4:31Speaker 4: to undermine the notion of wilfulness, and therefore I didn't charge.
- 4:34Speaker 4: So I didn't like anything about the way he constructed
- 4:38Speaker 4: his evidence and the reporting of it, And.
- 4:43Speaker 3: After four hours of testimony, it wasn't any clear or
- 4:46Speaker 3: what he meant or what he intended. Fite prodding from
- 4:50Speaker 3: both sides, and Democrats were up in arms about his
- 4:55Speaker 3: description of Biden, as you mentioned, as a sympathetic, well
- 4:58Speaker 3: meaning elderly man with a poor memory. He said he
- 5:02Speaker 3: needed to say that it was necessary, accurate, and fair.
- 5:06Speaker 3: He had to explain why Biden's memory would make it
- 5:09Speaker 3: hard to prove to a jury that the president broke
- 5:12Speaker 3: the law. Did you buy his explanation or were those
- 5:15Speaker 3: just partisan words thrown in there?
- 5:18Speaker 4: Well, I don't know if I would call them partisan,
- 5:20Speaker 4: but they were certainly naives in failing to realize what
- 5:25Speaker 4: implications words like that would have. And I think Adam
- 5:28Speaker 4: Schiff sort of had it right when he said to
- 5:31Speaker 4: her during his five minutes, you could have said as
- 5:36Speaker 4: to this document, I found the evidence to be less
- 5:40Speaker 4: than convincing. As to that document, there was a little
- 5:43Speaker 4: bit more convincing, but they were extenuating circumstances because we
- 5:47Speaker 4: sort of quarreled about what the meaning of classified men.
- 5:50Speaker 4: Did it mean private? Did it mean classified in a
- 5:54Speaker 4: national security sense? Was it a diary entry like Reagan
- 5:58Speaker 4: or a national secure marked document like Trump possessed. He
- 6:03Speaker 4: could have explained all that stuff in very granular detail
- 6:07Speaker 4: without the need to say in this overarching sort of
- 6:11Speaker 4: prediction of how Biden would likely present himselves. So I
- 6:15Speaker 4: think Schiff had it right in that exchange, and that
- 6:17Speaker 4: her was I don't want to attribute to her partisanship,
- 6:21Speaker 4: but I will say that he did have a tear
- 6:25Speaker 4: for the implications of this, and I think that the
- 6:27Speaker 4: White House Counsel's Office recognize that in their efforts to
- 6:31Speaker 4: have them rethink this language. But of course they didn't prevail,
- 6:35Speaker 4: and Merrick Garland didn't dare change any of HER's language
- 6:39Speaker 4: for fear of cover up, and so it is as
- 6:42Speaker 4: it is.
- 6:43Speaker 1: And something else.
- 6:44Speaker 3: Adam Schiff said that you don't do things to prejudice
- 6:48Speaker 3: the subject of an investigation when you're declining to prosecute.
- 6:52Speaker 1: He said, that's that's the rule.
- 6:55Speaker 4: That is the rule. And you see this occur in
- 6:58Speaker 4: various contexts. So for example, but if you are going
- 7:01Speaker 4: to have somebody as an unindicted co conspirator, you list
- 7:05Speaker 4: them as unindicted co conspirator number one, because if you
- 7:10Speaker 4: say they are uninvited co conspirature by name, then that
- 7:15Speaker 4: person is named as a co conspirator with no forum
- 7:20Speaker 4: to clear their name to say I'm not a co
- 7:22Speaker 4: conspirator because they've not been charged and so there's no
- 7:25Speaker 4: way that they can come forward. Similarly, in this case,
- 7:29Speaker 4: he has essentially tarnished the president without giving him an
- 7:34Speaker 4: opportunity in a court of law to clear his names.
- 7:38Speaker 4: In some sense, in terms of clearing one's name. Biden
- 7:41Speaker 4: might have been advantage to be charged, and I mean seriously,
- 7:45Speaker 4: but because he then at least would have been able
- 7:47Speaker 4: to say, I am not an old man with a
- 7:49Speaker 4: bad memory. I am a vital eighty one year old
- 7:53Speaker 4: who is fully capable of responding to accusations against the
- 7:57Speaker 4: end of course running the country. So I thought it
- 7:59Speaker 4: was banned.
- 8:00Speaker 3: Now her tried to follow what I'll call Robert Muller's
- 8:03Speaker 3: style when he testified in twenty nineteen about the Trump
- 8:06Speaker 3: Russia findings, sticking to his report. You know, people would
- 8:10Speaker 3: question and me going, yes, that's what that page said,
- 8:13Speaker 3: not that's what I wrote, but that's what that page said.
- 8:16Speaker 1: Was that successful for him?
- 8:18Speaker 4: Well, it was successful in the sense that he didn't
- 8:22Speaker 4: get himself involved in lengthy what if types of conversations.
- 8:27Speaker 4: But I think he could have been more elaborate in
- 8:30Speaker 4: his answer. I think he could have said, look, I
- 8:33Speaker 4: wrote this this way because we were thinking along these lines.
- 8:39Speaker 4: So I think an explanation of the black letters on
- 8:43Speaker 4: his report would have advantaged him and would have allowed
- 8:48Speaker 4: the listening public as the members of Congress, to understand
- 8:52Speaker 4: better what his thinking was. I think it was smart
- 8:55Speaker 4: of him to not get trapped into hypotheticals. What if
- 9:00Speaker 4: this was a sixty year old man instead of an
- 9:02Speaker 4: eighty one year old man, what if it was tuesdays
- 9:05Speaker 4: that it wasn't. I don't think that would have behooved
- 9:07Speaker 4: him in any way, but I think he could have
- 9:08Speaker 4: been a little bit more forthcoming in letting us understand
- 9:13Speaker 4: the thought process that went into his written report.
- 9:18Speaker 3: So obviously there were different aims of the questioning, with
- 9:21Speaker 3: the Republicans trying to show that there was enough evidence
- 9:25Speaker 3: to prosecute Biden and he got a pass, the Democrats
- 9:29Speaker 3: trying to show that Biden was exonerated and his memory
- 9:32Speaker 3: was good. I mean, start with the Republicans. Did they
- 9:35Speaker 3: make a pretty good case that there was enough evidence
- 9:37Speaker 3: here to charge Biden?
- 9:39Speaker 4: Well, this was the problem that I had that we've
- 9:42Speaker 4: just been talking about. Her apparently believed that there wasn't
- 9:47Speaker 4: enough evidence to overcome a defense that Biden might put on,
- 9:52Speaker 4: and so the evidence of wilfulness had to have been
- 9:56Speaker 4: much weaker than the Republicans thought was, because if you
- 10:01Speaker 4: had very strong evidence of retention and wilfulness in terms
- 10:04Speaker 4: of sharing, then the idea that a prospective defendant might
- 10:08Speaker 4: present himself to the jury as sympathetic. It would be
- 10:11Speaker 4: of no moment. There's no prosecutor that I know of
- 10:14Speaker 4: who says, well, this is a likable old man, but
- 10:17Speaker 4: I've got overwhelming evidence, and therefore I'm not going to charge.
- 10:21Speaker 4: I think the evidence was weaker than the Republicans wanted
- 10:24Speaker 4: it to be. But because Her didn't explain the weaknesses
- 10:28Speaker 4: in his evidence of willfulness, it allowed, yes, the great
- 10:33Speaker 4: sound bites for them to say, let me see if
- 10:35Speaker 4: I understand just the elements of the crime he possessed,
- 10:38Speaker 4: he knew he possessed, he shared, he knew when he
- 10:41Speaker 4: shared it was classified. What am I missing here? Was
- 10:45Speaker 4: the question the Republicans asked, and Her said, because he
- 10:48Speaker 4: was a likable old man. And that's when Congressman like
- 10:52Speaker 4: Gates and others said, I'm sorry, are you creating a
- 10:56Speaker 4: forgetful old man defense of the Van Drew who are
- 11:00Speaker 4: creating a new precedent of that? If you're likable, forgetful
- 11:03Speaker 4: old man, Hell with the evidence, we're not going to
- 11:06Speaker 4: charge you. And Her was susceptible to that argument, and
- 11:09Speaker 4: I think the Republicans were, you know, sort of clever
- 11:12Speaker 4: to present it. I think also Jim Jordan, who I
- 11:15Speaker 4: thought did a very nice job all in all in
- 11:18Speaker 4: running this hearing, made a good point politically when he
- 11:22Speaker 4: talked about Biden's motive, the eight million reasons, the eight
- 11:27Speaker 4: million dollars he got paid for the book, and the
- 11:31Speaker 4: need for Biden to show his legacy, his historical significance
- 11:37Speaker 4: by saying he opposed the Afghanistan surge. So Jordan says, look,
- 11:42Speaker 4: you've got willful retentions, you've got willful sharing, and you've
- 11:46Speaker 4: got motive eight million dollars for a book legacy desires,
- 11:52Speaker 4: what more are you needing? Her? And I think that
- 11:55Speaker 4: you know, it's a depelling case unless Her says, look,
- 11:58Speaker 4: the evidence wasn't that good. It wasn't strong enough. When
- 12:01Speaker 4: Biden said to the biographer, this is a classified document
- 12:05Speaker 4: and then later goes to say, well, it's not really classified,
- 12:08Speaker 4: it's more sort of private. Her should have said that
- 12:12Speaker 4: undermines the notion of willful distribution, because he's tried to
- 12:15Speaker 4: explain how he defined classified. But Her didn't engage that way,
- 12:22Speaker 4: and therefore I think Republicans made wood point him coming up.
- 12:25Speaker 3: The Democrats take on her and a Georgia judge dismisses
- 12:29Speaker 3: three charges against Trump. I'm June Grosso. When you're listening
- 12:32Speaker 3: to Bloomberg is Bloomberg.
- 12:34Speaker 1: Law with June Grusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 12:39Speaker 3: Through four hours of aggressive questioning from both Democratic and
- 12:42Speaker 3: Republican members of the House Judiciary Committee, Special Counsel Robert
- 12:46Speaker 3: Hurr tried to defend the conclusions of his year long
- 12:49Speaker 3: investigation and his three hundred and forty five page report
- 12:53Speaker 3: that recommended no criminal charges be brought against President Joe
- 12:57Speaker 3: Biden for his handling of classified documents. He tried to
- 13:01Speaker 3: confine his precisely worded answers to the exact words of
- 13:04Speaker 3: the report, despite questions and hypotheticals trying to get him
- 13:08Speaker 3: to say either that Biden was guilty or that he
- 13:11Speaker 3: had been exonerated. Ironically, it was the questioning from Democratic
- 13:16Speaker 3: representative from Milijaia Paul that brought out her his most
- 13:20Speaker 3: damaging statement about Biden.
- 13:22Speaker 2: Congressman, that is one statute that we analyzed. I need
- 13:25Speaker 2: to go back and make sure that I take take
- 13:27Speaker 2: note of a word that you used, exoneration.
- 13:30Speaker 1: That is I'm going to continue with my question. I'm
- 13:34Speaker 1: going to continue with my questions.
- 13:35Speaker 2: The term I ultimately reached. I know that evidence existed
- 13:39Speaker 2: such that the likely outcome.
- 13:41Speaker 6: You exonerate a conviction.
- 13:43Speaker 1: I know that as options. Mister hurts my time.
- 13:48Speaker 3: I've been talking to former federal prosecutor Michael Zelden. So, Michael,
- 13:51Speaker 3: you talked about how the Republicans did with their questioning
- 13:54Speaker 3: of her.
- 13:54Speaker 1: How did the Democrats do?
- 13:56Speaker 4: Some of them, like thoughing Offward, I think was terrific
- 13:59Speaker 4: when she said, let me understand something about this Afghanistan memo.
- 14:04Speaker 4: Was that not a handwritten memo that Biden wrote, Yes,
- 14:08Speaker 4: it was. Let's now talk about Reagan and his diaries.
- 14:12Speaker 4: Were they not handwritten memoranda? Yeah, they were diary entries.
- 14:17Speaker 4: Did the Justice woman not say that those types of
- 14:21Speaker 4: diary entries are not covered? Yes? They did, so ergo
- 14:25Speaker 4: the Biden memo was a diary? Could it not be said?
- 14:29Speaker 7: So?
- 14:29Speaker 4: I think that was a very good exchange. I think
- 14:32Speaker 4: Shift did a good job and trying to bet out
- 14:35Speaker 4: the ten ear that her had. But most of the
- 14:39Speaker 4: others were just making political speeches, and I thought that
- 14:44Speaker 4: that was unfortunate. You know, they did make some points
- 14:48Speaker 4: with respect to Trump and the obstruction part of the
- 14:52Speaker 4: indictment being nothing like the Biden part of the avitce,
- 14:56Speaker 4: and so I think it was important for them to
- 14:58Speaker 4: articulate that they're really is the difference. Even if there
- 15:01Speaker 4: is some similarity on willful retention and distribution, there is
- 15:05Speaker 4: a whole world of difference with respect to obstruction.
- 15:09Speaker 3: Her played no part in the investigation into Trump's handling
- 15:13Speaker 3: of classified documents? Did he make a mistake by discussing
- 15:17Speaker 3: the material distinctions between the Biden and Trump cases and
- 15:21Speaker 3: his reports?
- 15:22Speaker 1: Should he have just left Trump out?
- 15:24Speaker 4: I think he had no choice but to say, I
- 15:27Speaker 4: know this other indictment exists, and the facts of that
- 15:30Speaker 4: case are materially different from the facts of this case.
- 15:35Speaker 4: Because think of what this hearing would have been like.
- 15:38Speaker 4: If he didn't recognize the distinction, then you have Republicans
- 15:44Speaker 4: screaming apples to apples. Why did one get indicted? One
- 15:48Speaker 4: not get indicted with no opportunity for her to respond
- 15:53Speaker 4: to the differences between them. If he's going to stick
- 15:56Speaker 4: to his report, I think that had to be in
- 15:58Speaker 4: his report, because otherwise I think he's put in a
- 16:01Speaker 4: terrible position of not being able to answer the question
- 16:03Speaker 4: of why one got it and one didn't get it.
- 16:06Speaker 3: So the Justice Department released the transcript of HER's interview
- 16:12Speaker 3: with Biden before the hearing, which I'd say was not
- 16:16Speaker 3: coincidental timing, and the Democrats used that was HER's testimony
- 16:22Speaker 3: undercut by the excerpts from the transcript, which seemed to
- 16:27Speaker 3: show that Joe Biden was not as forgetful, his memory
- 16:33Speaker 3: was not as bad as her made it out to be, that's.
- 16:37Speaker 4: Right, and that the evidence of wilfulness was more equivocal
- 16:41Speaker 4: than the report seemed to make it. I think the
- 16:45Speaker 4: Justice Department should have released this long before this hearing.
- 16:48Speaker 4: I think it was a mistake for the Justice Department
- 16:51Speaker 4: to release this report so close to the hearing. I
- 16:54Speaker 4: think it would have been better if the committee had
- 16:57Speaker 4: this transcript earlier so that it could be fully evaluated
- 17:01Speaker 4: and that it could be factored more intelligently or more
- 17:05Speaker 4: meaningfully in the questioning. So yeah, I think it was
- 17:09Speaker 4: not coincidental, but I think it was unfortunate that we
- 17:12Speaker 4: didn't really get the benefit of that transcript fully in
- 17:16Speaker 4: the exploration with her about the nature of his evidence.
- 17:21Speaker 3: There was this almost comical back and forth between her
- 17:26Speaker 3: and Democrat Promila Jayapaul about whether her had exonerated by it,
- 17:31Speaker 3: and it was like you did, I didn't, you did,
- 17:33Speaker 3: and they talked over each other. What's the difference to
- 17:37Speaker 3: a prosecutor between exonerating someone and not charging someone.
- 17:42Speaker 4: Well, not charging someone is possibly I'm not going to
- 17:47Speaker 4: charge them even though I think they did something criminal
- 17:50Speaker 4: because I don't think I can prove this case beyond
- 17:52Speaker 4: a reasonable doubt because key pieces of evidence are missing
- 17:56Speaker 4: or key witnesses is not cooperating, and therefore, while I
- 18:02Speaker 4: believe the person is guilty of this, I can't prove
- 18:06Speaker 4: my case beyond reasonal doubt, and therefore I'm not going
- 18:08Speaker 4: to bring it. That's very different than saying the person
- 18:11Speaker 4: is innocent did nothing wrong. So it might seem like
- 18:15Speaker 4: a fine line, but not being able to prove a
- 18:18Speaker 4: case and saying the person is innocent are two different things.
- 18:22Speaker 4: And I thought when the congresswoman engaged in the conversation
- 18:27Speaker 4: with him about was this exoneration or was this not exoneration?
- 18:31Speaker 4: She didn't help the Democrat cause because the headlines I
- 18:34Speaker 4: saw effort hearing was her refuses to exonerate Biden. How
- 18:38Speaker 4: is that a helpful exchange? So I think that like
- 18:42Speaker 4: in the Muller Report, where Muller wrote, if we had
- 18:45Speaker 4: confidence that the president did not commit a crime, we
- 18:50Speaker 4: would have said So that for me was a terrible line.
- 18:53Speaker 4: That was very problematic because essentially it says he may
- 18:57Speaker 4: be a criminal, but we can't yet.
- 19:00Speaker 2: Oh.
- 19:00Speaker 4: I just don't think you do things like that. I
- 19:02Speaker 4: don't think that's what declination or non memos should be
- 19:06Speaker 4: all about.
- 19:08Speaker 3: Do you think the differences between the Biden case and
- 19:12Speaker 3: the Trump case were made clear during that four hours
- 19:16Speaker 3: or was it muddled?
- 19:18Speaker 4: Well, it was definitely made clear. With respect to obstruction,
- 19:22Speaker 4: It's quite clear that her was unequivocal, that Biden cooperated,
- 19:27Speaker 4: and that there was nothing that was obstructive by Biden.
- 19:32Speaker 4: It may be a little bit obstructive behavior by the
- 19:35Speaker 4: ghostwriter in the leting of an audio conversation, but with
- 19:39Speaker 4: respect to Biden, Biden cooperated.
- 19:42Speaker 7: Trump did not.
- 19:43Speaker 4: And I thought that was really brought home over and
- 19:47Speaker 4: over by everybody on the Democrat and even in HER's case.
- 19:52Speaker 4: But these they are two maturely different cases.
- 19:54Speaker 3: So, Michael, what do you think the average person should
- 19:57Speaker 3: get out of this testimony?
- 20:00Speaker 4: The average person should say this five minutes per person
- 20:04Speaker 4: round of questioning process is horrible. It doesn't lend itself
- 20:08Speaker 4: to coherence. And couldn't they just have one or two
- 20:12Speaker 4: people duct these conversations with these witnesses in a way
- 20:16Speaker 4: that we could get to the bottom of things. And
- 20:18Speaker 4: two congressmen, even if they were four federal proscuts or
- 20:22Speaker 4: film or state proscins, don't seem to know how to
- 20:25Speaker 4: ask a question. This was so scripted. Nobody listened to
- 20:30Speaker 4: the testimony. They asked their pre written questions, even though
- 20:33Speaker 4: the exact question was asked just before them, and the
- 20:37Speaker 4: exact answer was elicited that they elicited. I mean, it
- 20:40Speaker 4: was a horrible, horrible process. But in the bottom line,
- 20:44Speaker 4: I think people are going to not have their opinion
- 20:47Speaker 4: changed by this. I think that the notion that Biden
- 20:50Speaker 4: is an old man is baked in among Republicans and
- 20:54Speaker 4: some Democrats and independents. I think that the notion that
- 20:58Speaker 4: Trump is being treated differently worse is baked in within
- 21:02Speaker 4: the MAGA crowd, and that special prosecutors have a lot
- 21:05Speaker 4: of work to do in bringing clarity to their analysis.
- 21:09Speaker 4: When you look at the Mulla report, look at the
- 21:11Speaker 4: Durham report, you look at her report, all these reports
- 21:15Speaker 4: did was make things more confusing. They brought no clarity
- 21:19Speaker 4: whatsoever to the circumstances that they were designed to investigate
- 21:23Speaker 4: and report on. So I think people are going to
- 21:26Speaker 4: come away from this disappointed in building. You hear what
- 21:29Speaker 4: you want to hear, and disregard their way. As Paul
- 21:31Speaker 4: Simon saying in The Boxer, I.
- 21:33Speaker 1: Love that song.
- 21:34Speaker 3: So does this show that Attorney General Merrick Garland is
- 21:39Speaker 3: using special counsels too much? He's using special councils in
- 21:43Speaker 3: so many instances.
- 21:45Speaker 4: Yeah, I don't know what Merrick Garland should do. It's
- 21:50Speaker 4: such a acrimonious time with this notion of the weaponized Justice Department,
- 21:56Speaker 4: that on the heels of the bar debacle with the
- 21:59Speaker 4: Mullor report, where Muller admits the report to bar Or,
- 22:03Speaker 4: sits on it for a while, then gives his own
- 22:07Speaker 4: summary of it, which Muller objects to, and it turns
- 22:09Speaker 4: out to be decidedly misleading. All Merrik Grong can really
- 22:14Speaker 4: say is I don't want to put the Justice woman
- 22:17Speaker 4: in that position, and the best way for me to
- 22:20Speaker 4: insulate the Justice woman from criticism is to use special counsel.
- 22:25Speaker 4: But I don't think it's working.
- 22:27Speaker 3: Very well, well, one of the Trump cases that has
- 22:29Speaker 3: nothing to do with the Justice Department is the Georgia
- 22:32Speaker 3: twenty twenty election interference case. Today, Judge Scott McAfee, the
- 22:37Speaker 3: trial judge, throughout three of the charges against former President
- 22:40Speaker 3: Donald Trump that have to do with soliciting public officers
- 22:44Speaker 3: to violate their oaths? What did the judge dismiss those counts?
- 22:48Speaker 4: So what I can gather from the eight page order
- 22:52Speaker 4: is that he said that while this conduct is probably criminal,
- 22:57Speaker 4: it wasn't pled meaning the diamond self, with enough specificity
- 23:03Speaker 4: so that the defendants could understand specifically what conduct they're
- 23:08Speaker 4: accused of having engaged in that would give rise to
- 23:14Speaker 4: unanimous jury. Very in cleaning your case, as a prosecutor,
- 23:18Speaker 4: in your indictment, you have to set forth clearly what
- 23:22Speaker 4: is the evidence and what is the statutes that evidence violates.
- 23:28Speaker 4: And the judge felt here that the way the case
- 23:30Speaker 4: was written, the way the case was pled, there was
- 23:33Speaker 4: a possibility of confusion by the defendants about what they
- 23:38Speaker 4: had to defend themselves against. And so he said, look,
- 23:41Speaker 4: unless you cure this, which I think they have the
- 23:44Speaker 4: authority to do, they can go back to a grand
- 23:46Speaker 4: jury and supersede this indictment to make these counts more
- 23:50Speaker 4: clear consistent with what the judge orders. Until then, the
- 23:54Speaker 4: judge says, look, it's disease defendants, they just don't know
- 23:57Speaker 4: how to defend this case because the way you wrote
- 23:59Speaker 4: it in less than Until you do that, I'm not
- 24:02Speaker 4: going to let you bring these charges before me, which
- 24:05Speaker 4: I think is a fine ruling in that I think
- 24:08Speaker 4: defendants are entitled to know specifically what crime they're accused
- 24:12Speaker 4: of and what conduct they engaged in that the prosecutors
- 24:15Speaker 4: believe gave rise to the indictment. So I've got no
- 24:18Speaker 4: problem with decision. And whether or not the prosecutors tweak
- 24:22Speaker 4: their language to satisfy him is up to them. But
- 24:26Speaker 4: I'm all for clarity in charging documents so that people's
- 24:30Speaker 4: constitutional rights to defend themselves can be fully achieved.
- 24:35Speaker 3: What's ironic about this is that one of the charges
- 24:39Speaker 3: relates to something that's been clear for how many years,
- 24:43Speaker 3: which is Donald Trump's call to the Georgia Secretary of
- 24:47Speaker 3: State asking him to find eleven thousand some odd votes.
- 24:52Speaker 4: Well, so there's a call between Trump and para State
- 24:56Speaker 4: Rastenberger where he says, all I need is eleven thousand
- 24:59Speaker 4: and seven Navy votes, one more than we have. But
- 25:05Speaker 4: that was a charge that said, you are asking the
- 25:08Speaker 4: Secretary of State to violate his oath to make sure
- 25:11Speaker 4: that there is election integrity, and what the court set
- 25:15Speaker 4: is explain to me a little bit more clearly how
- 25:18Speaker 4: that phone call specifically violated that statute. He said something like,
- 25:24Speaker 4: there's an abundance of evidence here, but the way it
- 25:27Speaker 4: was pled, you know, the specific way it was written
- 25:31Speaker 4: was just not clear enough. And so he's not saying
- 25:35Speaker 4: that's not necessarily innocent behavior. He's just saying, articulate it
- 25:41Speaker 4: more clearly so that Trump and company know exactly what
- 25:45Speaker 4: it is about that conversation that you think caused Rathenberger
- 25:51Speaker 4: to have to violate his oath of office where he
- 25:54Speaker 4: to have followed him. So it's just seeking clarity, I
- 25:59Speaker 4: mean as a problem for a long long time. I
- 26:01Speaker 4: started out as a defense attorney, and I always thought
- 26:03Speaker 4: that the tables are so stacked in favor of prosecutors
- 26:08Speaker 4: that when a court can sort of level the field
- 26:10Speaker 4: to make sure that defensial and defendants particularly have a
- 26:14Speaker 4: fair shot at understanding what they're being charged with and
- 26:17Speaker 4: how they can possibly defend themselves.
- 26:19Speaker 3: I'm all for it, Thanks so much, Michael. That's former
- 26:22Speaker 3: federal prosecutor Michael Zelden coming up a fight over a
- 26:26Speaker 3: national wildlife refuge in Georgia. This is Bloomberg. The Okefinoke
- 26:32Speaker 3: National Wildlife Refuge is a pristine six hundred and eighty
- 26:36Speaker 3: square mile wilderness in Georgia, an ecological wonder that's a
- 26:40Speaker 3: haven for threatened and endangered species and is world renowned
- 26:44Speaker 3: for its amphibian populations. It's one of the world's largest
- 26:48Speaker 3: intact freshwater ecosystems and was designated a Wetland of International
- 26:53Speaker 3: Importance by the United Nations in nineteen seventy one. And
- 26:57Speaker 3: now the federal government is making an unpressed sedented water
- 27:01Speaker 3: rights claim to try to prevent a mining company from
- 27:04Speaker 3: pumping so much groundwater for a proposed mind that it
- 27:08Speaker 3: could cut off part of the swamp's water source, imperiling
- 27:12Speaker 3: its biodiversity and its original purpose as a refuge from
- 27:15Speaker 3: migratory birds. Joining me is a water rights expert, Ryan Roeberry,
- 27:20Speaker 3: a professor at the Georgia State University Law School. Ryan
- 27:24Speaker 3: tell us about the facts, describe what's happening.
- 27:27Speaker 6: Here, sure, I mean the facts I mean, it's quite simple.
- 27:31Speaker 6: There is the ok Pinocchi Swamp, part of which is
- 27:35Speaker 6: a National Wildlife Refuge, obviously a very large swamp in
- 27:39Speaker 6: southern Georgia. About three miles away from that, in the
- 27:42Speaker 6: southeast section of the Okeo Swamp, mining company wants some
- 27:48Speaker 6: permits to some groundwater pumping permits because there's a water
- 27:54Speaker 6: mining is a water intensive process. They've applied for some
- 27:57Speaker 6: permits to mine titanium dioxide and that that process of
- 28:04Speaker 6: sort of using the groundwater and pumping the groundwater would
- 28:08Speaker 6: affect the water flow going through the Ok Phenochi National
- 28:12Speaker 6: Wildlife Refuge. So that is the challenge right now. It's
- 28:15Speaker 6: the water quantity issue that may happen because of these permits,
- 28:20Speaker 6: and would.
- 28:20Speaker 3: That lack of water be a hazard to the species
- 28:23Speaker 3: there that have been protected.
- 28:26Speaker 6: Absolutely so, I mean they I'm not a hydrologist, but
- 28:30Speaker 6: some hydrologists have studied this and they say that about
- 28:33Speaker 6: sixteen percent it could cause a diminution of water, about
- 28:36Speaker 6: sixteen percent of the recharge of the aquifer that sort
- 28:40Speaker 6: of naturally feeds the Ok Phenochi National Wildlife Refuge. If
- 28:44Speaker 6: that happens, that has a very big negative impact on
- 28:47Speaker 6: some endangered species, the ability of the swamp, and it's
- 28:51Speaker 6: the creatures inside the swamp, some of the trees, grasses,
- 28:55Speaker 6: some of the animals. It would negatively impact them if
- 28:59Speaker 6: that is, If that the case is that there's a
- 29:01Speaker 6: sixteen percent diminution, and that is what's an issue here
- 29:04Speaker 6: is what kind of damage, if any, would be groundwater
- 29:08Speaker 6: permits posed to the National Wildlife Refuge. And that's when
- 29:13Speaker 6: you get into the hydrology of it.
- 29:15Speaker 3: And I just want to clarify one thing. The Georgia
- 29:18Speaker 3: Environmental Protection Division issued a draft permit correct to build
- 29:23Speaker 3: to build this mine, and there was a public.
- 29:25Speaker 6: Hearing, correct, there was a public hearing, and there was
- 29:30Speaker 6: some complaints Lodge. They so this has been going on
- 29:33Speaker 6: for a couple of years now. This has not just
- 29:35Speaker 6: come out of the blue, and now they are in
- 29:39Speaker 6: the midst of the draft permit is sort of thing.
- 29:41Speaker 6: This is the permit we want to give the mining company.
- 29:44Speaker 6: They're accepting public comment on it, I believe up until
- 29:47Speaker 6: the early part of April, at which time they will
- 29:51Speaker 6: make a decision on whether to grant the permit to
- 29:54Speaker 6: the mining company or not.
- 29:56Speaker 3: I mean, do you know if the public's in favor
- 29:58Speaker 3: of the mining company or keeping the National Refuge clean.
- 30:03Speaker 6: I mean, the most people that I saw who are
- 30:06Speaker 6: far more concerned about the National Wildlife Refuge. We don't
- 30:10Speaker 6: have many spots like this in the East, particularly the
- 30:12Speaker 6: Eastern United States. I'm sure there are people on the
- 30:16Speaker 6: other side that would say, you know, of course the
- 30:18Speaker 6: mine would provide jobs, the economy, those kinds of things,
- 30:21Speaker 6: and so there's there's always going to be a built
- 30:23Speaker 6: intention between sort of preservation or economic development.
- 30:28Speaker 3: So the government and when I say the government, are
- 30:31Speaker 3: we talking about the Fish and Wildlife Service?
- 30:33Speaker 6: When we see yes, we're talking about the US Fish
- 30:35Speaker 6: and Wildlife So.
- 30:37Speaker 3: The US Fish and Wildlife Service made a claim in
- 30:39Speaker 3: January asserting its federal reserved water rights at Okafinoke.
- 30:45Speaker 1: Is that unusual?
- 30:48Speaker 6: Absolutely, this is highly unusual. In fact, I think it's
- 30:51Speaker 6: the first time that federal or reserve water rights have
- 30:55Speaker 6: been asserted east of the Mississippi River. And and four
- 31:00Speaker 6: that is, in the United States, we generally speaking have
- 31:03Speaker 6: two different water systems, one for the West, one for
- 31:05Speaker 6: the East. In the West, where it's very arid and dry,
- 31:09Speaker 6: where I grew up in Idaho and Colorado, you have
- 31:11Speaker 6: prior appropriation first, in time first, and right, there's sort
- 31:15Speaker 6: of the pecking order of who gets the water. The
- 31:18Speaker 6: government has asserted it's better reserved water rights, which is
- 31:22Speaker 6: as simply this, It's simply a claim that when the
- 31:24Speaker 6: federal government reserves the land, that it also implicitly reserves
- 31:29Speaker 6: the water necessary for that land to function as a reservation.
- 31:34Speaker 6: That has been asserted in the West. In the East,
- 31:36Speaker 6: we have a regulated Riparian system. Riparian system is predicated
- 31:42Speaker 6: on the premise that there's enough water for everybody, you
- 31:45Speaker 6: just have to share it reasonably. And I think one
- 31:48Speaker 6: of the challenges is is that with climate change, with
- 31:51Speaker 6: increased industrial use, we are seeing that there's not probably
- 31:56Speaker 6: might not be enough water for everybody anymore in the
- 31:59Speaker 6: riparian state. And so in this case, the US Fish
- 32:02Speaker 6: and Wildlife Service has.
- 32:04Speaker 7: Asserted its ce reserve water rights, which.
- 32:06Speaker 6: Again in a Riperian state. I believe this is the
- 32:08Speaker 6: first time this has happened, So yes, it is a
- 32:11Speaker 6: big deal.
- 32:12Speaker 3: The mining company claims a that the mind won't harm
- 32:16Speaker 3: the reserve and that federal reserve water rights is a
- 32:20Speaker 3: doctorate exclusive to Western water law. Where do you stand
- 32:24Speaker 3: on this?
- 32:25Speaker 6: I don't think it's exclusive to Western water law at all.
- 32:28Speaker 6: I mean, there is some argument that says, well, it
- 32:31Speaker 6: has to be land that was reserved in the public domain,
- 32:34Speaker 6: of which Georgia was not part of that because it's
- 32:36Speaker 6: part of the original thirteen colonies. But to me, the
- 32:39Speaker 6: doctrine of federal reserve water rights, it doesn't depend on
- 32:42Speaker 6: the status of the land that the government reserved. It
- 32:45Speaker 6: simply depends upon the reason for which the federal government
- 32:49Speaker 6: reserved the land. In the case of the Oki Finocchi.
- 32:52Speaker 7: It reserved the land.
- 32:53Speaker 6: To protect the water, the wildlife, the tree, et cetera.
- 32:57Speaker 6: And therefore the intent would have been to preserve enough
- 33:00Speaker 6: water for the congressionally congressionally recognized intent to take place.
- 33:05Speaker 6: So I am not of the opinion it's just a
- 33:08Speaker 6: Western issue that I think that the facts on the
- 33:12Speaker 6: ground have changed and that there's not enough water in
- 33:14Speaker 6: the East for everybody anymore, and this is a right
- 33:18Speaker 6: that the federal government can assert. There's no problem for
- 33:21Speaker 6: my opinion.
- 33:22Speaker 3: So the acting Regional Director of Fish and Wildlife Service,
- 33:25Speaker 3: Mike Boker, said that federal reserve water rights include all
- 33:29Speaker 3: the water needed to maintain the purpose of the Okefinoki Refuge,
- 33:33Speaker 3: which President Franklin Roosevelt created to protect migratory birds in
- 33:37Speaker 3: nineteen thirty seven with an executive order under the Migratory
- 33:41Speaker 3: Bird Conservation Act. Shouldn't that be enough that it's a
- 33:44Speaker 3: federal reserve and it has to be protected.
- 33:47Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean the challenge here again is the groundwater.
- 33:51Speaker 6: The permits are not on the federal reserve right, they
- 33:54Speaker 6: are outside at the by about three miles. And so
- 33:57Speaker 6: the issue then is what kind of things can the
- 34:01Speaker 6: federal government regulate that don't actually take place on federal
- 34:06Speaker 6: lands but could impact federal lands. And so that's I
- 34:11Speaker 6: think the real nub of the issue here. And the
- 34:15Speaker 6: simple fact that federal reserve water rights has not been
- 34:17Speaker 6: asserted in the East has led some people to believe
- 34:20Speaker 6: that well, they aren't applicable in a ripe Aerian jurisdiction,
- 34:24Speaker 6: which again I think is wrong. It's just the fact
- 34:27Speaker 6: that probably we've had enough water in the past to
- 34:29Speaker 6: handle everything, and now that seems to be changing.
- 34:33Speaker 3: So tell us about this unanimous nineteen seventy six Supreme
- 34:37Speaker 3: Court opinion that the Fish and Wildlife Service is relying on.
- 34:43Speaker 6: Sure, that's the case of USB Caffert, and that was
- 34:49Speaker 6: an assertion of a federal reserve water right, I believe
- 34:53Speaker 6: for the Devil's hole to protect a certain a small
- 34:57Speaker 6: type of fish, So that would be in the Western
- 34:59Speaker 6: United States. Again, but this also expanded the notion of
- 35:03Speaker 6: federal reserve water rights not just to Native American reservations
- 35:07Speaker 6: or national parks, but to all federal reservations that includes
- 35:11Speaker 6: national wildlife refuges, et cetera. And that says simply simply
- 35:17Speaker 6: stated Cafrit says, the primary purpose of a federal reservation,
- 35:22Speaker 6: then that that primary purpose needs to.
- 35:24Speaker 7: Be served by the water that is allotted to it.
- 35:30Speaker 6: So it's really the protection of the primary purpose for
- 35:33Speaker 6: which a reservation was made. And in the case of
- 35:36Speaker 6: the Okpoki Swamp, clearly water is part of a swamp
- 35:41Speaker 6: and part of the national wildlife refuge and so fulfilling
- 35:44Speaker 6: that primary purpose, it's whatever that minimum amount is needed
- 35:48Speaker 6: to fulfill the primary purpose, and that minimum amount nobody knows.
- 35:52Speaker 6: Nobody knows what is the minimum amount needed, and so
- 35:55Speaker 6: that would require hydrologists to sort of get active and
- 35:59Speaker 6: get involved, and I'm sure there will be disputes over
- 36:01Speaker 6: what is the minimum amount necessary.
- 36:03Speaker 3: Do most water rights experts think that federal water rights
- 36:08Speaker 3: take precedence over state groundwater rights.
- 36:12Speaker 6: Absolutely, absolutely, the federal claim would take precedence.
- 36:15Speaker 7: That's that's pretty clear. If the federal reserve.
- 36:18Speaker 6: Water rights exist, it is, it is its supersedes state
- 36:22Speaker 6: water right.
- 36:23Speaker 1: So what what do experts disagree on?
- 36:26Speaker 6: Well, I think some experts disagree on whether federal reserve
- 36:29Speaker 6: water rights exist in Ritian states like Georgia and regulated
- 36:33Speaker 6: Riparian states. And then the question is is how do
- 36:37Speaker 6: you make it fit. You're essentially saying we should privilege
- 36:41Speaker 6: the water usage of the National Wildlife Refuge in the
- 36:46Speaker 6: Okefinoke over other competing claims from you know, mining companies
- 36:51Speaker 6: or municipal industrial use. How are you going to fit
- 36:54Speaker 6: that in to a system that for many times, for
- 36:57Speaker 6: many years has not really looked at who gets its
- 37:00Speaker 6: first who gets the second, but it's been based off
- 37:03Speaker 6: of are you using the water reasonably? And that's a
- 37:07Speaker 6: very different question than in.
- 37:08Speaker 7: The West, where you have a.
- 37:10Speaker 6: Pecking order that is clearly established on who gets the
- 37:13Speaker 6: first amount and how much they get, who gets the second.
- 37:16Speaker 6: We don't have those same systems set up in the East.
- 37:19Speaker 6: So how it fits in to a sort of a
- 37:21Speaker 6: reasonable use standard system, which is very sort of ambiguous
- 37:25Speaker 6: and opaque is still to be determined.
- 37:28Speaker 3: But this end with the Georgia Environmental Protection Division saying no,
- 37:33Speaker 3: we're not going to give you a permit.
- 37:36Speaker 6: It's possible, it's possible. I think what's going to happen
- 37:39Speaker 6: and what should happen, is that Georgia EPD and the
- 37:43Speaker 6: US Fish and Wildlife Service need to sit down and
- 37:46Speaker 6: talk about this at are reserved water right and more importantly,
- 37:49Speaker 6: how much water is necessary for the ok forn Ok
- 37:53Speaker 6: to actually fulfill its mandated purpose. I think that should
- 37:56Speaker 6: be the next step. I don't think it has to
- 38:00Speaker 6: be yes or no on the permit. I think it
- 38:02Speaker 6: should be We're going to have to wait until we
- 38:04Speaker 6: figure out these conversations with the US Fish and Wildlife Service.
- 38:08Speaker 1: There is no legal case.
- 38:09Speaker 6: Yet, no correct there is no but it's been going on.
- 38:13Speaker 1: For years and still no legal case.
- 38:16Speaker 6: Well, the question about whether they were going to get
- 38:19Speaker 6: a permit, how much water would would they be pumping
- 38:21Speaker 6: out of the ground, et cetera. If and then once
- 38:24Speaker 6: you find out all that information, well does that harm
- 38:28Speaker 6: or could it harm the Ok Pinok Swamp or not
- 38:32Speaker 6: all of those questions.
- 38:33Speaker 7: That's what's been.
- 38:33Speaker 6: Going on over the several years, has been a lot
- 38:35Speaker 6: of fact finding and a lot of documents being put
- 38:38Speaker 6: together so that Georgia EPD would be able to assess
- 38:43Speaker 6: whether or not a permit was should be granted. So
- 38:46Speaker 6: that's what's been going on. And it takes takes years
- 38:49Speaker 6: for mining permits to happen, So this is not abnormal.
- 38:53Speaker 6: This is this is part of the process of any
- 38:56Speaker 6: sort of large mining operation, whether in the Western US
- 38:59Speaker 6: or the East. So it takes a lot of groundwork
- 39:02Speaker 6: to get your permits in order so that you can
- 39:04Speaker 6: bring a mind online.
- 39:05Speaker 3: Well, we'll have to keep track of this. Thanks so much, Ryan.
- 39:08Speaker 3: That's Professor Ryan Roberry of the Georgia State University Law School.
- 39:12Speaker 3: And that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 39:15Speaker 3: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 39:18Speaker 3: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 39:22Speaker 3: and at Bloomberg dot com, Slash podcast, Slash Law. I'm
- 39:26Speaker 3: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg