Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Failing to Provide Necessities, Service of an Injunction and War Crimes Prosecutions
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for our regular segment Legally Speaking, joined by Michael Mulligan, Barrister and Solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: Morning Michael, how we doing Good morning.
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Interesting topics on the agenda.
- 0:11Adam Stirling: Today I'm reading a Crown Sentence Appeal for failing to provide.
- 0:15Adam Stirling: What does this mean?
- 0:16Adam Stirling: The necessities of life.
- 0:19Michael Mulligan: That's an excellent question, and I should say it's a very interesting section of the criminal code, because the criminal code with very few exceptions, this being one of them doesn't impose positive obligations on people to do anything.
- 0:35Michael Mulligan: So, for example, if you see a crime being committed, you're not generally under any obligation to do anything about it.
- 0:43Michael Mulligan: You don't have to rush over and save the person.
- 0:45Michael Mulligan: If you just stand passively and watch, you haven't committed any kind of a crime.
- 0:51Michael Mulligan: Which is just an interesting intellectual thing to think about is that the criminal code is generally concerned with prohibiting somebody from doing something that's going to harm someone else.
- 1:02Michael Mulligan: That would be the general theme of it, but this particular section of failing to provide the necessities of life is an exception to that, and this section imposes a positive duty and lists various people that it's imposed on.
- 1:18Michael Mulligan: They include a parent, foster parent, guardian, head of a family that's an interesting term these days to provide care for, or other people, including a spouse or common law partner or this language, a person under his charge.
- 1:37Michael Mulligan: That's gender specific, but it applies equally to men and women.
- 1:41Michael Mulligan: And then it also lists who this obligation might apply to and tries to define it, and so, for example, with that broad term of a person under his charge.
- 1:55Michael Mulligan: That would include someone who is unable by reason of age, mental disorder, detention or other causes, to withdraw himself or herself from that charge.
- 2:11Michael Mulligan: And so, for example I'll give you an example that might apply to so one of the pieces, one of the items there would be by reason of detention.
- 2:20Michael Mulligan: So, for example, if jail guards fail to feed an inmate and they starve to death, the jail guards can be prosecuted for failing to provide the necessities of life.
- 2:31Michael Mulligan: But it's broader than that, of course, because this includes all these different categories children, spouse and so forth.
- 2:42Michael Mulligan: And this particular case, where there was this appeal and a decision that was just released, involved a 55-year-old woman who had Down syndrome, who had been cared for for more than 18 years by the accused.
- 2:57Michael Mulligan: And the other thing which was very unique about the case is that there was no indication that the accused had any animosity towards the deceased.
- 3:08Michael Mulligan: In fact, they had a good caring relationship and extending over a very long period of time.
- 3:14Michael Mulligan: But what transpired is that the 55-year-old woman who had Down syndrome, who was being cared for, stopped eating.
- 3:24Michael Mulligan: She just wasn't eating as much as she previously did over a number of months, and the caregiver, for her part, listened to advice from the woman with Down syndrome's mother, who told her that this was just a common occurrence for people with Down syndrome of that age and that you can have, early on sent dementia and the lack of eating.
- 3:49Michael Mulligan: And this is just what happens, don't worry about it.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: And the caregiver accepted that advice and accepted it to the point where this woman became thinner and thinner over time, and she said she was still making some efforts to feed her, but the woman was like spitting out boosts and this kind of thing, but she never got her medical care.
- 4:11Michael Mulligan: That was really the crux of it.
- 4:14Michael Mulligan: And the caregiver said well, if she doesn't want to eat, this is the decision she's made.
- 4:18Michael Mulligan: I don't want to see her going into palliative care.
- 4:21Michael Mulligan: That would be bad for her.
- 4:22Michael Mulligan: I want to care for her at home.
- 4:23Michael Mulligan: Right, she was lived in a live in caregiver and eventually, sadly, the woman just expired and the cause of death was slow starvation.
- 4:32Michael Mulligan: And so the woman was prosecuted for both criminal negligence causing death.
- 4:38Michael Mulligan: She was found not guilty of that, but she was also prosecuted with the offense that we just talked about sailing to provide the necessities of life, and in this case that would be, I suppose, medical care, right, obtaining that for something in the necessity of life, or getting somehow food in her.
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: And so she was convicted and the sentencing judge, of course, and this is sort of that, one of those categories of cases which is the hard one, right.
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: It's not difficult to come to fashion a punitive sentence if you're dealing with somebody who was malicious or acted out of hatred or greed or some other reason.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: But this woman, the caregiver, appeared to have just been completely misguided and didn't take reasonable steps when she saw the woman she was caring for slowly expiring over a long period of time.
- 5:27Michael Mulligan: She accepted this bad advice from her mother that this was just a natural state of affairs, and so the trial judge sentenced the woman to what's referred to as a conditional jail sentence, and the conditional jail sentence sometimes people would refer to it as house arrest and the way that works is that if somebody is being sentenced to less than two years in prison and if there's no mandatory minimum sentence, one of the sentences available to a judge would be to put the person on a conditional sentence, usually house arrest, except for you know time, to go out and buy groceries, that kind of thing, rather than sending the person to prison.
- 6:03Michael Mulligan: So that's what the sentencing judge did.
- 6:07Michael Mulligan: The crown, for its part, thought that that sentence was inadequate and wanted an actual jail sentence for the woman, and so they appealed, and that's the decision that just came down from the BC court of appeal, and the court of appeal agreed with the crown, and the court of appeal said that an appropriate sentence here would have been a 15 month jail sentence, followed by a period of probation, which the judge had already imposed.
- 6:32Michael Mulligan: So the first thought as you're reading that decision, they go like oh, this caregiver is going to prison now for 15 months, but the court of appeal didn't do that.
- 6:43Michael Mulligan: What they said was the woman has already served the entire 12 month house arrest sentence, and so they gave her some additional credits.
- 6:54Michael Mulligan: In fact, she should already served it, she said.
- 6:56Michael Mulligan: Well, the crown court said the crown could have applied to stop the conditional sentence running, but they didn't.
- 7:01Michael Mulligan: And so the court of appeal has said there should have been a jail sentence.
- 7:07Michael Mulligan: Here we are imposing a 15 month jail sentence, but she need not serve it because she's already effectively served it by the house arrest.
- 7:14Michael Mulligan: So I must say it's an interesting thing, of course.
- 7:17Michael Mulligan: Right, because when you talk about some of these principles and often the court of appeal and certainly the Supreme Court of Canada are living in the land of principles right and broad principles in terms of range of sentences and so on, often run up to when that for a trial judge the reality of the individual person before them.
- 7:37Michael Mulligan: Right, and this is an example of that right.
- 7:39Michael Mulligan: You've got this caregiver with no record, who had a loving relationship, a caring relationship with this woman not loving, caring relationship with this woman for years, and wasn't intending to do harm, was doing what she thought was the right thing to do on the terrible advice of her mother.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: And so with that background, you have to be a you know it takes something to say well, now you're going off to prison to deter you or to deter others or to denounce this right.
- 8:05Michael Mulligan: So what we have now is that court of appeal decision saying sentence should have been longer, but they didn't quite have the, whatever it might be, to actually send the caregiver off to prison.
- 8:15Michael Mulligan: They found a legal way to avoid that, and so that's the outcome of a very unusual case and a very unusual fact pattern and one of the very few sections of the criminal code that actually compels you to go and do something, as opposed to just not do things that would harm other people.
- 8:33Adam Stirling: All right, let's take our first break.
- 8:34Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, we'll continue right after this.
- 8:36Adam Stirling: If it's happening, it's here.
- 8:42Adam Stirling: This is Adam Sterling on CFAQs 1070.
- 8:46Adam Stirling: Alright, we're back on the air here at CFAQs 1070.
- 8:48Adam Stirling: Legally speaking continues with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 8:51Adam Stirling: Michael, the next story on the agenda is one that seems to occupy the better part of my program, one where the other, it seems.
- 8:57Adam Stirling: From time to time it says here notice of a junction by leaving it under a tripod of a rainforest flying squad member.
- 9:05Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 9:08Michael Mulligan: So, as we talked about before and you've covered well, there were all sorts of people being prosecuted for criminal contempt for continuing to block the road following the injunction to stop doing that, and a good present of the cases wound up being stayed or discontinued after there was a decision that a sort of a summary of the injunction that the RCMP were reading to people blocking the road was not sufficient, right, not all the required information was in there, but this particular case I thought was a great fact pattern, and the fact pattern was a man sitting up above on a tripod, some 14 feet roughly off the ground blocking the road, and a staff surgeon showed up and was all on videotape and read to him the abbreviated version of the injunction, but then thought to take a copy of it and drop it under the tripod, pointing it out to the man, and then left and then came back an hour and a half later the man was still up at the tripod, the piece of paper is still sitting on the ground, and so the man was arrested and charged with criminal contempt.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: And so the issue in this case was whether this particular man had proper notice of the injunction, because of course there had been this decision, saying the brief summary of it wasn't sufficient.
- 10:35Michael Mulligan: And here the judge found that indeed dropping the copy of the injunction at the bottom of the tripod was completely sufficient.
- 10:46Michael Mulligan: The judge pointed out that the Supreme Court's civil rules provide that you can affect personal service on somebody.
- 10:56Michael Mulligan: You don't need to physically hand an injunction or order to somebody.
- 11:01Michael Mulligan: If you sort of put it there and draw the person's attention to it, you've succeeded right.
- 11:05Michael Mulligan: You can't avoid being served by, you know, dropping the item or holding your hands behind your back and running away.
- 11:12Adam Stirling: Putting your hands in your pockets?
- 11:13Michael Mulligan: Yeah, yeah, that doesn't do it.
- 11:16Michael Mulligan: And so the other interesting thing is the judge said look, the man had an hour and a half, and if you wanted to, he could have just climbed down from his tripod and read the injunction, but he didn't, perhaps out of concern he wouldn't be allowed to climb back up this tripod, but that was his problem.
- 11:31Michael Mulligan: And so, on the facts of this case, the judge found that indeed the staff surgeon did effective service by leaving the order by underneath the tripod.
- 11:42Michael Mulligan: The fact that the man didn't want to come down deep was his problem, and so the man was found guilty of criminal contempt.
- 11:48Michael Mulligan: So there was just a really interesting fact pattern.
- 11:51Michael Mulligan: The other interesting element the man also claimed that he should have had the order read to him in French After speaking English.
- 12:00Michael Mulligan: He then said again in French, please, sir.
- 12:02Michael Mulligan: The officer didn't speak any French, and so that didn't happen.
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: But again, the judge concluded that made absolutely no differences.
- 12:10Michael Mulligan: It was very clear the man could speak English, he was on video doing it, and so you can't avoid an obligation to comply with an injunction by demanding that it be read to you in another official language.
- 12:24Michael Mulligan: That doesn't work either, and so this man has been convicted, and while a number of these prosecutions can't proceed because of that decision on the summary version of the order not being sufficient, this one did succeed because of the force state to leave the piece of paper below the tripod and I should say it looks like some of this may be commencing again.
- 12:47Michael Mulligan: I have absolutely no doubt that the police will be bringing some lozenges with them and maybe a glass of water so they can read the entire injunction to whoever might be up on the tripod if that starts again this season.
- 13:03Michael Mulligan: So service the tripod and by the, that's completely satisfactory.
- 13:07Adam Stirling: This is a neat one I have next year.
- 13:09Adam Stirling: It's one of the most significant tributes that power has ever paid to reason, is it not?
- 13:15Michael Mulligan: Yeah, that's the opening of what I think is probably one of the very best opening statements in a case that I've ever seen, and I was reminded of a recent recently had an opportunity to attend the Palace of Justice in Nuremberg, germany, where some of the war crimes prosecutions occurred following the end of World War II, and what you just read was a part of the opening statement from Robert Jackson, who was the lead US prosecutor for those war crimes trials, and the point that he was making there was that in many instances, and in fact in this instance, the Soviets wanted to simply line up all the Nazis that were captured and shoot them, and a remarkable process it was.
- 14:16Michael Mulligan: The Soviets were persuaded to agree to hold a trial rather than simply shooting everyone, and so there was a trial.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: There were trials conducted in Nuremberg, at the courthouse there, and the trials operated by having four judges one appointed by the United States, one from the UK, one French and one Soviet judge and the accused were there and they were also afforded defense counsel if they wished it.
- 14:48Michael Mulligan: And one of the other points made by Jackson the Bath of a Prosecution was that it was important that the trials had these full appearance of fairness, and he used the language of how ineffective it would be if they were seen to have been handed poison, chalices, basically and the idea was that he wanted the world to be able to see the evidence about what these men had done they're all men and to see a fair and open process with reasons, rather than simply assuming they were guilty and killing them.
- 15:25Michael Mulligan: And so the trial was conducted.
- 15:28Michael Mulligan: It went on for many months.
- 15:31Michael Mulligan: Interestingly, there were various arguments made about the fairness of the process, appreciating that the process was yards better than what the Soviets would have done, and the complaints from defense counsel were wide range.
- 15:47Michael Mulligan: They started with an argument that the things they were charged with were not crimes, and they said well, they weren't written down.
- 15:56Michael Mulligan: Things like the indictment included, things like engaging in a war of aggression, right or genocide, things like that.
- 16:05Michael Mulligan: That did not succeed.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: The various other arguments they made were also interesting ones in terms of fairness, because they are issues which remain as modern day criminal law issues.
- 16:18Michael Mulligan: One of the issues that they raised which would have modern resonance is that they raised an argument that the prosecution was not required to show or provide the defense with evidence that would tend to show the accused person was not guilty.
- 16:35Michael Mulligan: They were only required to show them evidence they were gonna rely upon to prove their guilt, which is very interesting.
- 16:43Michael Mulligan: That's, of course, not the state of affairs any longer in Canada, but that state of affairs was found to be acceptable.
- 16:50Michael Mulligan: In this context, other challenges arose, including by virtue of the fact that the defense council of the case, all of whom were German lawyers, which is interesting.
- 17:02Michael Mulligan: None of them had any experience conducting a cross-examination, because that simply wasn't part of the German criminal justice system.
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: They've never done it before Interesting.
- 17:14Michael Mulligan: And so the trial proceeded on sort of a mixture of like affidavit evidence.
- 17:21Michael Mulligan: Some of the evidence that judges were considering didn't involve live witnesses, but there was provision made so that defense council could ask permission to cross-examine witnesses, and so many witnesses were in fact cross-examined and they just had no experience doing it.
- 17:39Michael Mulligan: The defense was also denied an adjournment to allow time for preparation or resources to gather evidence in the way that the prosecution had so clearly arguments to be made about all of those things, but the principal takeaway is just how impressive it is with that that a trial process was followed rather than something else.
- 18:05Michael Mulligan: Ultimately, the not all of the men who were charged were convicted, most were twelve of them were sentenced to death by hanging.
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: A number of them were sentenced to long prison terms, but three of them were found not guilty altogether, which is a very interesting outcome.
- 18:24Michael Mulligan: All of those decisions out of interest were split decisions and the way the rules worked is that you needed to have at least three judges agreed to convict and the Soviet judge would have convicted on, I think, virtually everything and, on orders of Stalin, voted for the death penalty for everyone.
- 18:47Michael Mulligan: I guess that being consistent with the Soviet position, that everyone should have been lined up against the wall and shot Indeed.
- 18:53Michael Mulligan: But that isn't the outcome.
- 18:56Michael Mulligan: And the other interesting thing is that there was well, generally speaking, the defense that was often raised was one of either Hitler's orders, sort of that we were ordered to do this, it's not my fault.
- 19:09Michael Mulligan: That didn't get anywhere, nor did, generally speaking, an argument that was made that the allies had conducted some things which were the same.
- 19:19Michael Mulligan: So, for example, the argument was made well, you've charged me with killing civilians.
- 19:25Michael Mulligan: So they would say well, here's an example of where some allied bombing did the same thing, for example.
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: That didn't succeed.
- 19:32Michael Mulligan: But one of the areas where that did succeed was a charge brought based on Nazi U-boats sinking Allied civilian supply ships without warning and then doing nothing to save the crew.
- 19:49Michael Mulligan: That wound up in the Atlantic.
- 19:50Michael Mulligan: And the arguments made there included the fact that many of the ships had arms on them or were supplying arms, and further that the allies had conducted similar operations.
- 20:04Michael Mulligan: And so that argument did succeed because not because of the hey, you're doing it too right, that didn't fly right, nor does that fly currently right.
- 20:14Michael Mulligan: If you're charged with speeding, it's no defense to say, but look at all the other cars, right, that's not going to help you any.
- 20:20Michael Mulligan: But it succeeded because many of these things, of course, were sort of amorphous principles.
- 20:28Michael Mulligan: There wasn't a law you could point to right, and so you were looking at things like you know, some reference to sort of the common law concepts of what is criminal and wrong, and so they would look at things like you know treaties and agreements in terms of how wars are to be conducted.
- 20:48Michael Mulligan: And on that particular example of the submarine sinking armed civilian ships, it just wasn't clear that that was contrary to the rules of war, and so the charges with respect to that resulted in acquittals, and so the entire process with all of its flaws of awards.
- 21:08Michael Mulligan: I think is exactly what you referred to at the outset, which is one of the greatest, one of the greatest examples of a tribute that powers paid to reason the idea that we're going to have a reason to trial, provide reasons for judge, reasons for the decision, and rather than simply acting out of an ability to do so as the victor.
- 21:32Michael Mulligan: So I think that was just a very interesting thing from the reminders of some of those principles that developed out of the war crimes prosecutions following the end of World War Two, some of the issues we're still dealing with today, Fascinating discussion.
- 21:50Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you so much as always.
- 21:53Michael Mulligan: Thank you so much.
- 21:53Michael Mulligan: Have a great day.
- 21:55Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday, you're on CFAQ's 1070.