Latest / Ego and Other Things / I Borrowed Most of My Ideas. Here's What's Still Mine | Worldview Series
Transcript
- William: Dear Heavenly Father, I thank you for the opportunity to do this recording. Lord, I know that I can't make anything good out of this recording. But at the same time, I know that you can. I know that you live within me. I know that even if I feel nervous, even if I feel afraid to record, and you live within me, and you can do this recording. In a way that it was meant to be. You can do this recording in a way that is good. You can make good out of something, even when I'm afraid to do it. And so I surrender this recording into your hand. Holy Spirit, I ask you to do this recording through me, to make good out of it where I cannot. And again, Lord, I just thank you and I praise you for this opportunity to do this recording. I ask that you would make this useful to the people who would who would watch it. And also, Lord, I pray that you would teach me through doing this recording. And all this I pray in Jesus' mighty name. Amen. Alright, today's question is gonna be, what do I have, what do I believe I have to offer that is genuinely mine to give? With the sub-question of how would I feel about it changing someone's life? Now thinking about this question yesterday at work, I I came up with about three things that I think I could consider to be genuinely mine. And that question of what is genuinely mine to give is both interesting and complicated to me because I don't Really feel that that many of my ideas, for example, were were original to me. if I look at the Content of my idea, many of these ideas are in the modern culture. They preceded me in significant ways. Much of my philosophical ideas or system are kind of synthesis of ideas that have already been there, or that I've read somebody where somewhere else, or that I've heard someone else talk about. Many of the ideas that even if I came to them independently, I later learned that there are other schools. Of thought out there that had already come to those kinds of conclusions. I found this with many critiques I had of the state. I found this with when it came to phenomenology. and So it's hard to for me to say that many of my ideas are mine. or genuinely mine. And it's a similar thing when it comes to my faith, when it comes to my belief in God. Because I don't even feel as though I don't even think my faith is something which I got, which I took a leap into. As as I've talked about before, when it comes to my my faith journey, I often feel like the Holy Spirit kind of, you know, kicked me off the cliff cliff when it came to the leap of faith. And that God brought me to the place where I could finally accept who he was and trust in him enough to begin following him. I don't feel like I came to my faith on my own. I feel as though that was the entire work of God. And many of these things in in my life I feel like this this way. I don't though I have always been in this mode of trying to create a life around me that I wanted to live, and to search for ideas that I found were meaningful and useful and true, and try to improve myself and try to understand what was right and good. I Have almost always found that the significant progress in any of those kinds of things didn't really come from within me, from within my own mind, but rather came from outside of me. It came through relationships, it came through reading other authors, it came through what God was putting me through. It didn't really come from myself. I feel as though I have been filled up with the world around me. in a lot of ways. And if there is any element of me in that, it was not so much the ideas themselves, but as much as like the sorting. It wasn't the actions itself, but the the reactions that were my that were my not the events, but how I how I reacted to those events in the moment that were genuinely from me or genuinely an expression of who I am. But the other half of this question is the question what is genuinely mine to give? And I think the ending of that question to give changes the formula a little bit. It's not so much saying, one of you is 100% and uniquely you, but what do you have which you have enough experience, maybe authority? Or the power to give another person. like a a mat, I think about a math teacher, right? A math teacher in relationship to his students. Is math something that the math teacher has uniquely created himself? Well, no. Math has a long history to it, which the teacher himself at one point benefited from. But the math teacher in his study of mathematics, and then his learning about how to teach others about mathematics. has earned in one sense the right to give that knowledge of mathematics to his students. And while I don't think of myself as a teacher, and I don't want you to think that I'm implying in this that I am necessarily a teacher, I think the the idea of what is mine to give changes the context of the question for me enough to where I can I can find at least three broad elements that I think I can give with a kind of authority. And again, like I said, these are three. the first is the first is. my philosophy, the second is my failures, and the third is my faith. And you can see I tried to do a little phonetic equivalence there to just try to make it interesting. But these three things are the things which I think I have the authority to give. And sometimes that authority comes from my experiences and sometimes that that authority has been given to me by God in terms of the relationship of faith. But I'm gonna go through each of these one by one and describe what I'm talking about and why I think I have, in one sense, the right to give it. And then we can move on to the question of how I would feel if one of these things actually changed somebody's life, which in one sense is the goal. but we'll start off with philosophy. As I mentioned before, when I think when I reflect on my philosophy, it doesn't really strike me as something which is particularly unique or particularly striking. There are certainly some more controversial opinions in there, like peaceful parenting, anarchism, absolute authenticity. Which are not certainly conventionally held opinions in a lot of ways, but which have traditions, long storied traditions behind them, much of which I have pilfered for my own understanding of these different concepts and ideas and and philosophical physicians. And even to a certain degree, I'm not sure that the the the synthesis of my philosophy is particularly unique either. Meaning that many of the conclusions that I've come to sort of further down the chain, their natural consequence is the circum the the positions that I arrive at further up the chain. So in my ethics when I focus on autonomy, And on When I focus on autonomy and authenticity, those combined, there is a long tradition of autonomy and authenticity blossoming out into a a voluntarist, libertarian, anarchist position. In one sense, my politics is an outgrowth of my ethical beliefs, and there are some natural connections there that you can draw. And the tradition of drawing those connections is pretty long. So I don't really think of my philosophy as necessarily unique. It might be presented in a different lay in a way. There might be some unique, small unique ideas in there. There might be some unique syntheses that sit in there. But even the pr most profound syntheses that I've that I've found, the connection between childhood and the state, the idea of a force-based society, is itself it is itself been around for at least like eighty years, if not more. I mean, you could take that that idea and bring it all the way back to Janis Korchak, if not bring it back all the way to Rousseau. Never mind the the the places where I got it, like Alice Miller and Stefan Molyneux. And so even those ideas have this like unique long story tradition to them that I don't feel as though it is mine. But what I can offer to you is my philosophy. And basically w what I mean by this is is that I often think and I will often stress in these videos and sort of my metaphilosophical commentary, two large two big things. One, that a philosophy lives and dies with a philosopher. And two For truth to be known by you, it must be for truth to be known, it must be known by you, meaning you have to actually go out and do the work of discovering it. Meaning that the communication of philosophical ideas is something that happens in the conceptual and the abstract realm, but the actual validation, understanding, and experience of a philosophical idea comes through the individual who ultimately experiences and validates those things in a Epistemologically isolated way, meaning that they they come to understand and validate it through their own thoughts, emotions, feelings, and internal process of validation that cannot be cleanly communicated in the abstract and philosophical realm. And so I can call myself an anarchist, for example, but you could grab a hundred anarchists, put them into a room, ask them why they are an anarchist and get a hundred different kinds of answers. And if you could somehow get into the mind of each individual anarchist in that room, you would see a unique example of how they arrived at the at those beliefs, a unique life experience, a unique process of validation, a unique exposure to ideas that led them to that. And that is really half of the life of a philosophical idea, not the abstraction, but the actual person who experiences it, who validated who validates it, and who communicates it. My philosophical journey is one which has spanned almost. Almost fifteen years now. If you count the the the influence of mysticism that I began at around fifteen, then my philosophical journey is is almost fifteen years old. In terms of pursuing these ideas, thinking about them, writing about them, and more recently learning how to actually talk about and articulate them. I have a unique story which sits behind my philosophical ideas and brings it to life. I have my particular motivations, so to speak, when it comes to that philosophical system. And my philosophical system and perspective as a whole is unique as a whole, even if it isn't unique in its parts, and even if the vast majority of its parts and even its syntheses in some ways are borrowed from other thinkers. Regardless of whether they are I I discover them through other thinkers or whether other people preceded me in these ideas. These are ideas which I arrived arrived at through my own individual process of validation. And so have an individual kind of contour to them. I believe that if you laid out my if you could somehow lay out the entirety of my philosophical system in one go and laid it against the other other kinds of philosophers and thinkers, even within my own kind of tradition of phenomenology and voluntarism and Child ethics, that you would still see a unique philosophical system. And I believe that that, which is the work so far of 15 years and will continue to be a work that I progressively try to to refine and expand, is something which I have the authority to give. I know my own system because I'm the one who created it. I'm it is the product of my mind. It is the product of my mind and my life experiences and my passions. And it is something I believe that you can learn from, whether or not you agree with it or not, whether you agree with every particular element or not. In fact, I believe that if you studied my philosophical th system or got exposed to it and you came out with the same exact beliefs as me, that I believe that you wouldn't have been as critical or as engaged in the validation process as you needed to be. Meaning that while my philosophical some while my philosophical system is something that you can learn from, while it is a different perspective against which you can challenge your own beliefs about the world, your own worldview. And I can give it to you as I've developed it. I can't give you, as I've said before, the answers or the truth or the one system that is going to solve all the problems. I can give you this philosophical perspective as a place to start, as a place to develop your own worldview, as a place to test your ideas against, and as perhaps for some of you, an introduction to philosophical thinking as a whole. These are all things that I've been engrossed in. I have been I've engrossed myself in the philosophy for at least 10 years, if not 15 years, going all the way back to when I was interested in in mysticism. And so I can offer you my worldview, I can offer you my philosophy, I can offer you a system which has been at the very least Heavily thought out over the past decade or so. System to challenge you, a system to start in, a system from which you can learn what it means to do philosophy and to be a philosopher. The second thing which I think is genuinely mine to give is my failures. Now, when it comes to this, I feel a lot more confident in being able to offer this to you because as I talked about when I was talking with my stories, much of my life has been a bunch of failures. I've made a bunch of mistakes, I've done a bunch of wrong, I've gone down many paths in my life that you know, philosophical and otherwise, that led to disaster and despair and nihilism. I've been down Again, many of the the paths of ideas along the road, I sort certainly haven't just siphoned myself into one perspective, but d I oftentimes deliberately expose myself to the opposite and competing view when it came to my beliefs. So for instance, and I consider myself a a voluntarist anarchist, but I have dove in to Karl Marx and the the communitarian kinds of ethics and I've delved into the liberal philosophy of people like John Rawls. And the American founding fathers and the different kinds of traditions, philosophical and otherwise. I've exposed myself to analytic philosophy, even though I use phenomenology as a basis for my beliefs. I've delved into the analytic language philosophers, even though I really depend on in my philosophy a looseness of language rather than a clarity of language. I've delved into the opposing philosophical ideas in my life and tested them for better or for worse. And I've There was a there was a long time in my life where I was looking for the right philosophy, not just the not interested in developing my own. So I've even gone down the the failure paths of being a syphil sycophant for certain philosophical ideas. And in one sense or another, I've tried on every single philosophical hat that there is to try on in my pursuit over time, perhaps not every single one. For example, there's a whole school of of Japanese existentialism which I am hoping to become more familiar with and we'll see what they have to say. But that's sort of besides the point. The the point is to say that both in my philosophy in terms of my ideas, but in t also in terms of my life I tried a lot of different things. I've taken a lot of risks and I've failed a lot. And part of what will come out in these videos, part of what has already come out in my stories, part of what will come out as I talk about philosophy, part of what will come out as I continue to develop and grow as a thinker now in the public sphere, is failure. Is failure. In fact, part of the reason why I again I do these videos in this relatively unpolished and unproduced way. is to attempt to expose my failures as much as possible. It's interesting because I look at my my past videos so far and I already see so many mistakes. I already see that ways in which my thinking has become better over time, even in the past six or seven months since I've been posting videos. And so part of what I can offer to to you is the mistakes, both the mistakes of my past, but even the mistakes that I make when I'm making these videos, whether it's philosophical or otherwise. I can offer you those mistakes and While to a certain degree, I think we all have to fail, we can't necessarily avoid mistakes and failures in our life. It helps to learn about the failures and mistakes of the people so we can be better at avoiding those mistakes. When I look at, the mistakes of my my father, for example, if I hadn't picked up on the p mistakes that he he made, I could have gone on to repeat the kind of abuse and relational dynamics. And And arrogance to the extent that he displayed those things. Now, I certainly had a difficult time with relationships. I certainly struggled with my own arrogance. I certainly struggled with not treating people in the way that I should have, but it was to a much larger extent because in the back of my mind I always had, well, I know that I don't want to be like my dad because he failed in this, this, this, in this way. and I believe that genuinely I can give you my failures. I'm an authority in my own failure. And I can even be self-conscious or self. Negatively self-aware, I don't know if that's the right terminology in a sense where I tend to offer those things a lot of the times, regardless. And you can learn from my mistakes. You can learn from my the mistakes from my life, but you can also learn from my philosophical mistakes if you're interested in all that. And I really desire that you would do that. So that you know, for for all I know, I'm out here in some philosophical back alley with a dead end that I can't perceive. And but maybe. By listening to these videos and seeing me describe my philosophical ideas and my systems, you can see the back alley even before I do, because I'm I'm, in some sense in it, but you know where it's gonna go. That happened to me a lot with other thinkers and philosophers who, spent their whole life on their systems, spent their whole life on their worldview, spent their whole life on their philosophy. And at the end of that, I could see where the path was going. I could see the dead ends that were coming up. And that helped me to avoid a number of dead ends myself. And I can give you a realistic and honest picture of what it looks like to philosophize in real time rather than behind closed doors, rather than in the inauthentic presentation of you know books and and practiced presentations. I can give you the rawness philosophical discourse, not just its end products. And lastly, I think I can give you my faith. Now, I don't believe that this I can give you this based on my own authority. And what I mean by that is that I've only been a a Christian for about two years. And so it's very easy to s to to see and for me even for me even to see that I I've there's yet to be enough. You're there has yet to have been enough time to really test, you might say. the Christian faith. And I don't have any doubt that I'll I will r hold on to my faith until the very end. But the point is to say that I can understand that people would be hesitant to try to derive their faith or derive wisdom in their Christian their own Christian walk or or derive I guess resilience if you're the spiritually curious or you're an atheist. From somebody who has only been a Christian for about two years. And I think that intuition is correct. And I think, again, as I as I go through time, as I grow older, as I go through more and more struggles, as the Lord teaches me, I will be able to share more and more aspects of my faith. But when I say what I can share with you is my faith, what I feel authorized to share with you is, in one sense, my testimony, in one sense, How God has stepped into my life and changed it, how God has radically changed my perspective. For those of you who are atheists, for the vast majority of my life, right up until about two years ago, I was a strong philosophical atheist. I thought that, well, I knew that I could disproof God. I knew that God didn't exist. I knew that even if God did exist, that he must be evil or in some way a a sociopath or a narcissist or something like that. And I could have walked you through the arguments. And I could have proven proven it to you without a shadow of a doubt. I did this many times in my life. And yet God stepped into my life. And yet God gave me faith and yet God transformed me. And perhaps you're skeptical of that and I can totally understand that. But I can knew you the perspective of somebody who was a philosophically strong atheist and yet found God. For those of you who have been Christians Christian your whole life, I can give you a an outsider's perspective on what it's like for a person who really didn't grow up with Christianity or didn't grow up with religion, who considered God at at many points to be a at least a conceptual enemy of progress and civilization. I can give you an insight into what it's like to be such a strong atheist, the things that we that we struggle with, the the objections that we raise, the perspective that we have about Christianity, about God, about Jesus from the outside, and detached from the Holy Spirit. For the spiritually curious, I can show you what God means to me, what my relationship with Jesus means to me, how God has stepped into my life and transformed me. In that sense, I can share with you my faith, not in the sense of I can give you my faith because I can't give it to you, only God can give it to you, only Jesus can give it to you. But I can share with you my faith. And and not on my own authority, but because this is what God commands us to do. In the Bible, it says, Go out and make disciples of the whole earth, teaching them to obey the commands that I have given you, and surely I will be with you. Always. We are quite literally commanded by our Lord to go out and share our testimonies, to go out and share the gospel. And God knows that each of us have come to Him individu individually, that each of us have our own testimony, and that each of our lives speaks to a different group of people. I think my my testimony can speak to atheists. I think my testimony can speak to the philosophically minded. I think my testimony can speak to the spiritually curious, and I think my testimony can show what it is like to be an atheist in relationship to God to those who already consider themselves Christian from whatever denomination that you ascribe to. But my faith in that sense is unique. And while it was not earned by me but given to me by God, it is something that I have the authority to share with you. and is something that is uniquely shaped by who I am and what my story has been. And so those are essentially the three things that I I really believe that I have to offer. I have a philosophical perspective that can challenge you, that you can begin at gett that you can begin in, that you can examine, that you can Grow in an understanding of philosophy in, that you can get maybe a head start and some answers, really, that you can use your mind against in order to grow your own self-understanding of your own philosophy and your own worldview. While maybe teaching you a thing or two about philosophy and about what is the best way to go about philosophical thinking and developing your own worldview. I can offer you my failures and my stories, both in my past, but also as I go and and make these videos and learn how to articulate ideas and and learn more about philosophy and revise and expand my own philosophical worldview. I can offer you the failures. And the failures are things which you can learn to learn from and apply in your own life so that you don't have to experience the same mistakes that I've made, both in my personal life as well as in my philosophical and Christian journey. And lastly, I can offer you my story of faith, my testimony, what God means to me, why a philosophical atheist became a committed Christian and Perhaps enlighten you on my own personal experience of what it means to relate to Jesus and to God. And I think that can speak to atheists. I think that can speak to the spiritually curious. I think that can speak even to Christians who don't Christians who have grown up in the church who don't necessarily have a good understanding of what atheists think and believe about God and about Jesus. And so th those are the three major things that I feel I really have a right and the authority to give that are actually, in one sense, mine to give. They're not the only thing I think is mine to give. They're not the only thing I think I have the authority to give, but they are the three major things that that I think I can give. And they're three of the biggest elements that we're going to focus on in this channel as we move throughout these different kinds of questions. And flesh out the worldview as a whole, which includes all of these different kinds of elements. But to the sub-question, how would I feel about it changing someone's life? Which would essentially be how would I feel if my philosophy, my failures, and my faith changed somebody else's life? my instinct is to say I would feel fantastic about that. Except for a few caveats. When it comes to changing somebody's life. that is in some ways the goal of being Not just a thinker, but being somebody who wants to take their ideas and give them to the world, wants to take their perspective and their their arguments and their story and give it to the world. You want those things to impact people in a significant way. Otherwise, what's really the point? I mean, otherwise you're kind of just talking to a wall. And you so you want your perspective, your worldview, your your and your story to impact people in a significant way. But he wanted to impact them in a positive way, right? In a constructive and useful kind of way. And I don't want to happen to other people what happened to me in relationship to the thinkers that I ran into. Early on, when I ran into thinkers like Stefan Molly and Ayn Rand, well, in some ways they significantly and positively impacted my life, in other ways they left they let they led me down. Destructive paths and attitudes and methodologies for the truth and for trying to create a better world. And it took me years to unlearn those kinds of habits. Now, that wasn't only them. These are also habits I picked up from my own childhood experiences and abusive environment and whatnot. But the last thing that I want to do as a thinker, as somebody who is sharing these ideas and sharing my story with you, is for you to Engage in it uncritically, for you to engage in it unthinkingly, for you to engage in it as a passive consumer and not an active consumer, if you will. I don't know necessarily like the word consumer, but I want you to be an active participant in these videos, an active participant in the conversation. I want you to I would want a person who listens to my stuff and finds it to be impactful to take the time to be skeptical, to put the the ideas almost at a distance and observe them as objectively as they can, to not just get sucked into my worldview, not just get sucked into my philosophy or my perspective on faith, but to really understand and process those things for yourself. And if you do that and those ideas end up being a positive creating a positive impact on your life, then I'm all for it. I would love for somebody to to you know learn from my philosophy and learn from my story and learn from my testimony of faith, grow closer to God, get a better understanding of the good and the true, avoid many of the pitfalls that I had to suffer from. Of course I want those things for the people who watch these videos. but too often I think, especially in the modern culture, it's easy for us to get sucked into a perspective, to get pigeonholed, to, enter the echo chamber of somebody else's ideas or the community that they that they create around them. And you don't really get personal individual growth in those areas. You get a bunch of mirrors reflecting each other. And I don't want a bunch of mirrors reflecting me or my thoughts. Right. I want the active participants. I would much rather you do everything you can to critically tear down my my philosophy or criticize my life or criticize my faith than to simply accept those things passively or simply to consume these videos passively. So I don't mind if it changes a person's life, but only if it is something that they have actively engaged with, actively validated, actively criticized. In one sense, every time you hear anything that I say, especially if it seems convincing, you should ask yourself, what is the best argument against this? What is the best criticism of this, right? What is the most critical perspective in one sense that I could take I could take on this and how does it hold up to to something like that. And then to start to think about those things for yourself to develop your own worldview. So that would be the first thing. And the second thing would be as long as it's changing your your life, not just your ideas. I think that. the emphasis here is life, right? For me, philosophy is, what we call praxis. It is the application of ideas to life. It is the messy, in one sense, compromise of ideas applied to life, because ideas can sit in the ideal realm where they're not tested in your day-to-day interactions. But the truth of an idea becomes more clear, not always. case, but more clear in the actual living it out in life. And so these ideas or my story or my faith should be something that impacts your life, if it's going to impact you at all. not simply your ideas, not simply what you think about, but what you do. And if anything I talk about changes what you think, but doesn't change what you do, then I consider it to be a failure. And so I would love to to change a person's life positively. I would love to impact people with my philosophy and my story and my faith, but it must be done Critically. It can't be something that is simply accepted. I want to avoid the mistake that I made in relationship to thinkers where I kind of just followed them almost wherever they went because I trusted them on a few key issues. So yeah, I think that's all I think I have I that's all I have to say. If something comes up, maybe I'll talk about it in a different video. But I'm comfortable with impacting people as long as it is a an active impact, not a passive impact. But anyway, I think that's going be all for for today. So if you made it to the end of the video, thank you so much for watching. If you like this video, please subscribe to the channel for for more videos like this. And as always, thank you guys for listening. And I'll talk to you next time.