Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Sticky Deposits & Storm Clouds: What’s Ahead for Credit Unions?
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Trekel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03I'm excited today to be here with Thomas Griswald, the managing director of a
- 0:08LM First Financial Advisors Services.
- 0:11Thomas, how you doing today?
- 0:12Yeah, doing well, mark.
- 0:13How are you?
- 0:14I'm doing great.
- 0:15I'm excited to have this opportunity to chat with you.
- 0:17We've been in sub.
- 0:19Joint calls in the industry before this.
- 0:21And I've always appreciated what a LM first can do for credit unions.
- 0:25And there's interesting things that have happened in credit
- 0:28unions in all of the things.
- 0:30I think probably that a LM first touches here over the last I.
- 0:34A few years.
- 0:35But if there's a listener who may not be, there's not a lot of credit unions
- 0:39that aren't, haven't heard the name a LM first, but if you wanna maybe do
- 0:42a little primer on what a LM first is before we jump into some questions about
- 0:47the trends in the industry, et cetera.
- 0:49Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 0:50So again, a LM first we've been around for, this is our 30 year
- 0:54anniversary, so officially.
- 0:56Been an institution for 30 years, predominantly in the credit union space.
- 1:00I'd say 95% plus of the work we do is within the credit union industry,
- 1:06and it's something we, we really hold onto and we really love.
- 1:08As far as what we do we've grown a lot in those 30 years.
- 1:13So started out as, a LM reporting, interest rate, risk management
- 1:17and investment management and grown significantly since then.
- 1:20And we have a number of subsidiaries, but if I could maybe simplify.
- 1:26Our approach, it's we want to help institutions manage capital and generate
- 1:31returns in a risk adjusted framework with the a LM piece being center.
- 1:36So we always like to understand, what is your asset mix?
- 1:40What is your liability mix?
- 1:41How can we ensure that, we're keeping a balanced balance sheet.
- 1:45But outside of that capital allocation piece, which again includes the investment
- 1:49portfolio, we have a loan transaction network that helps put buyers and sellers
- 1:54together in the loan participation world.
- 1:57We advise on securitizations.
- 1:59We help 'em derivative hedging and mortgage pipeline hedging.
- 2:02But we also have m and a advisory as well as the DDJ Meyers team that
- 2:08focuses on, talent management and talent acquisition is a part of our
- 2:12team and has been for a couple of years.
- 2:14Yeah, I'd say.
- 2:16It's a mouthful.
- 2:17We do so much and part of our focus is really how do we help
- 2:21credit unions just navigate these very turbulent waters for sure.
- 2:24Got it.
- 2:25And, as you described that in, in the capital allocation and
- 2:28managing capital, as the hub, I'm picturing a bike wheel, right?
- 2:31That's in the middle and all those other things relate back to that.
- 2:35And the other thing that pops into my head is cash is king, capital's king, right?
- 2:39Because if you've got great capital you can survive a lot of things.
- 2:42You can survive a lot of trends.
- 2:44And it is king, right?
- 2:45So I guess that might be why it's at the hub of the way you've just described it.
- 2:49But it's been, it has been interesting times we had in my mind when I.
- 2:55Having been an examiner, having been at NCUA, I always relied on the experts on
- 3:00the A LM because there, there's nuances there, there's assumptions there.
- 3:04NCUA, getting the capital market specialists and building that out is a, it
- 3:08is a great resource and a great topic, but it was always one that was nebulous to me.
- 3:12And it's I've described that and liquidity in different things as.
- 3:16A, as like oxygen that, it's you don't, you have to breathe,
- 3:21but you don't think about it.
- 3:22But then when you start, when it starts to put you in a corner and
- 3:25you can't breathe, you realize it.
- 3:27And when you have liquidity and a LM type things, you realize it.
- 3:30And then it's wow, this is super important.
- 3:32And you think about the pandemic, you think about.
- 3:36That, the journey we went through there with money coming in, and
- 3:39then what credit unions decided or not decided to do with that.
- 3:43And then the fed drops the huge rates rate increases on credit unions, which
- 3:48created an interesting environment in every area, but related to NEV, related
- 3:55to liquidity, et cetera, et cetera.
- 3:57So as.
- 3:58That's my 10,000 foot level of the recent history and where we're at.
- 4:02And there's a lot more to it.
- 4:03But in light of all that, what is it?
- 4:07Let's talk trends since then.
- 4:09Let's talk trends, if you wanna link back to the things I just said,
- 4:12but general thoughts on where the industry's at today, where it's been
- 4:16and where it's going trend-wise.
- 4:18Yeah, no, absolutely.
- 4:19And yeah, I think, we feels like we've probably fallen asleep
- 4:21a little bit prior to, 2022.
- 4:24We were in a zero rate environment for so long that, to your point,
- 4:27we forgot that all of this was important and it was intertwined.
- 4:31A LM liquidity credit.
- 4:33It's all linked.
- 4:34And we all know that we've seen such a significant rate increase,
- 4:38now we're, possibly going into a new rate regime with, some
- 4:41recent, fed cuts marks about, or.
- 4:45Are there cuts in the future?
- 4:46Are there not, not one to speculate on rates themselves, but it's
- 4:50definitely made fixed income.
- 4:51Interesting.
- 4:51Again, we've, again, we're in this period where, we were just sleepy
- 4:56because we didn't have to worry about interest rate risk, and in that extended
- 5:01quantitative easing, there was also no real credit risk to speak of.
- 5:04And I'd say, given that the recent trends that we've been observing that
- 5:10I think are going to impact a lot of institutions or one consumer loan
- 5:16growth has been fairly, I'm gonna say anemic the last few quarters.
- 5:23And that's something that again, directly hits all credit unions and.
- 5:29What that has led to, has led in my opinion, it's made balance sheets start
- 5:33to look and feel a little bit more liquid and that's something credit unions haven't
- 5:37seen or experienced in a couple years.
- 5:39When rates started increasing almost, there's a little bit of a lag, but
- 5:43very quickly credit unions started to see those geometry deposits
- 5:48that we had held onto and were such a big part of our funding base.
- 5:53We started seeing those outflows, and now a lot of it was just being moving into
- 5:57CD books, but that's not something we had really seen across the industry in a
- 6:02fairly long, a fairly good amount of time.
- 6:05And so we saw margins compress.
- 6:07We saw everyone just fighting for every deposit they can get, and it
- 6:12feels as though that's normalized.
- 6:14The rate shoppers have shopped but.
- 6:17The le liquidity piece to me is less about all this not, deposit growth
- 6:23coming back and more, it's about the loan growth being a little bit slower.
- 6:28And so we're starting to see a little bit of cash come back on balance sheets.
- 6:32And my big concern, if I look forward into the future and play this trend out,
- 6:37is when we see institutions that don't have the loan growth they typically want.
- 6:43They start trying to force demand that's not there.
- 6:46And the way we historically have done that is drop rates to
- 6:52just try and create that demand.
- 6:54And one thing we're talking about is, if the demand's not
- 6:57there, the demand's not there.
- 6:59We can't.
- 7:00We can't throw risk out the window and let you know, rates rule the day.
- 7:05We still have to make sure we're pricing our risks.
- 7:07So those are one of the big high level themes that we've been
- 7:10seeing the last few quarters.
- 7:11And again not that we have a crystal ball, something that we see as storm
- 7:15clouds on the horizon that we just wanna make sure we're preaching
- 7:18to still price risk appropriately.
- 7:21And pricing the risk.
- 7:22And then also, the other lever is the quality of the loan, right?
- 7:26It's like you, you can go into a meeting saying, Hey, our profits are tight
- 7:30because we're not getting the loans out.
- 7:31Let's look at let's go back, let's flip back through those last a
- 7:34hundred loans we denied and see if there's anything we should tweak.
- 7:39And you know what, maybe there is.
- 7:40I used to when I was an examiner and I went to a credit union that had
- 7:44commercial loans, which were more complex.
- 7:46I would always ask to see some loans that they denied just so I could get
- 7:50a flavor for what I could see what they thought was good, but I wanted
- 7:54to see if I could see what was bad.
- 7:55And sometimes that can be that can be helpful.
- 7:58You can learn from it, but it also can be turning up the risk in a way that doesn't.
- 8:04Keep the capital focused on the center of that wheel.
- 8:08Because if you put take too much risk short term you might be okay, but longer
- 8:12term, especially if the economy goes the wrong way, you could really kind
- 8:16yourself find yourselves in a tough spot.
- 8:18Any thoughts on that side of it?
- 8:19Yeah.
- 8:20You're spot on.
- 8:21If you're not pricing risk well, and on the risk side it's not just the
- 8:25duration or interest rate risk, but it's the credit piece, the liquidity piece.
- 8:29If you misprice that you don't see it tomorrow, it's not that, the
- 8:33next day you understand which of those loans were priced well or not.
- 8:36You see it six, 12 months, 18 months down the road.
- 8:40And that's the hard part is that the lag that you completely miss
- 8:44and when you're not expecting it is whenever you're getting hit
- 8:48usually from multiple sides, right?
- 8:50Yeah, exactly.
- 8:51And it goes straight to capital.
- 8:52And again, like you said, capital is the lifeblood.
- 8:55And if we're locating that or mismanaging it, that's what really leads to problems.
- 9:00And what's, what type of trends are you seeing then on the profitability side?
- 9:04Is it is the pressure super intense situational?
- 9:09Is everybody feeling it?
- 9:10What are you seeing in that arena in light of, these other trends?
- 9:14Y Yeah.
- 9:14Great.
- 9:15Great question.
- 9:16I do feel that it's maybe we're ca able to catch our breath a little bit.
- 9:20We've seen delinquencies, at least the rate of delinquencies start
- 9:24to plateau it feels and I think some of the ju just the lack of.
- 9:31Fighting for deposits has allowed margins to catch a little bit of breath
- 9:35because we haven't seen as many of the CD promos that are being usually
- 9:39being launched to try and capture funding wherever you can get it.
- 9:43So it seems as though the last quarter or two we've been able
- 9:46to catch our breath a little bit.
- 9:48It's more for me of let's not be complacent, let's catch our breath, make
- 9:52sure we can get our feet a little stable.
- 9:55But just be mindful of where we are in the future.
- 9:57But again, I think the shining light is, we haven't seen as many of those, the CD
- 10:03promos, the really short 6, 11, 12 month promotional rates nothing against them.
- 10:10At the end of the day, to me it's not about your funding costs.
- 10:14That's only one piece of it.
- 10:16It's about how you can line up funding costs and the rate
- 10:20you're getting on the asset side.
- 10:22I.
- 10:22Again, it's this dynamic.
- 10:23If we're not seeing consumer loan demand, we don't need
- 10:26that funding at that same rate.
- 10:28And so again, just we've seen a little bit of, a little bit more
- 10:31breathing room the last quarter or so as a result of that slowing down.
- 10:35One of the thing on the funding cost of the, when I, my head jumps to
- 10:40like the funding source side of it and it's money's fungible, right?
- 10:44I remember like back when I was at NCUA and I.
- 10:47If I was lucky enough to get an award where they gave me an extra
- 10:50couple thousand dollars for something that was really cool, that check
- 10:53would come in and it's you know what, I'm gonna buy a TV with that.
- 10:56And then it's you'd see, it's I'm gonna buy no wait, I already spent that money.
- 10:59But, the money's fungible.
- 11:00And one thing that always that always sticks a little bit with me when
- 11:04I'm thinking about the exam process and the regulatory process is.
- 11:10Every dollar is a borrowed fund, right?
- 11:12You your undivided earnings, you've borrowed from your members
- 11:15because you've decided to keep them and not disperse them.
- 11:18Your share certificates are from your members.
- 11:21Your share deposits are from your members.
- 11:24Money from the Federal Home Loan Bank is a borrowed product MO money
- 11:29from a purchased non-member cd.
- 11:31There, it's all one sort of borrowing and NCUA sometimes.
- 11:37In my mind over relies a little bit on the, it's not a core deposit
- 11:41and core deposits are stickier and I get all that stickier.
- 11:44But there's definitely a regulatory, I don't know, obviously a share
- 11:49that's been there for a hundred years is the best dollar.
- 11:52And the worst dollar is one of those other forms without naming one of 'em,
- 11:56any thoughts about that whole concept and how what's the best way for a credit
- 12:02union to look at those different options and different tools and different levers?
- 12:07'Cause obviously you need policies and procedures behind that, but every one of
- 12:10'em can play a really good role in, in making your credit union as its strongest.
- 12:16It can be.
- 12:17Absolutely.
- 12:18No, it's a, the funding side's a fun conversation 'cause you
- 12:21get, so many different opinions.
- 12:23But, on the, obviously, I think on the core deposit side.
- 12:27Would love for every institution to have an entire balance sheet full of savings
- 12:31accounts that cost five basis points.
- 12:33That would be phenomenal.
- 12:34And I'm sure every institution out there would love that as well.
- 12:38You, it's easier said than done, it's about meeting consumers where they're at.
- 12:43And I think on the, whether it's a nonmonetary deposit a cd, a borrowing,
- 12:48or a non-member CD or what have you, they're all just, like you said, sources
- 12:53of funding that all have different dynamic structures and rates and I think
- 12:59there's never a right or wrong answer.
- 13:01It's all about how it fits together as a part of the whole.
- 13:04I think there, there's definitely a case for borrowings from the FHLB and
- 13:09other areas like that because it could be a very good strategic lever to pull.
- 13:14And I think one thing I try and tell institutions is, yeah, CD promos,
- 13:19I called them out a little bit ago.
- 13:21Sure.
- 13:22They may be more expensive, maybe they're three 90 right now in a rate.
- 13:26There are a lot of participants in the financial industry that fund themselves
- 13:30at much higher rates than that.
- 13:33We're talking about our credit unions that are, maybe their cost
- 13:36of funds is 150, 200 basis points.
- 13:40We're still borrowing in a cheaper rate than the US government
- 13:43right now you know that's still something we have to keep in mind.
- 13:46And it's not.
- 13:47Good or bad in isolation, we have to think about everything as part of a whole.
- 13:52And it's about assets and liabilities.
- 13:54How do they mix together and what is the risk on the asset side compared
- 13:59to the risk on the liability side, and along those lines, and I'm, I I'm
- 14:04having a senior moment in my head, but the studies that credit unions need to
- 14:07do about the, their deposit stickiness i'm forgetting what that study is
- 14:11called, but NCA is asking for that.
- 14:14And during the last few years has asked for it because it they wanna make
- 14:18sure the assumptions are reasonable.
- 14:20They have their NEV test, which allows them to do a rough justice comparison.
- 14:25But I've seen some anecdotal situations where NCUA asked for that study to be
- 14:30redone and the deposits are even more stickier than the credit union thought.
- 14:35And it end up, it ends up almost, nCA thought that the study
- 14:40would say, yeah you're being too liberal in your assumptions.
- 14:43And the exact opposite was the fact.
- 14:45Have you seen that in any recent situations?
- 14:48A absolutely, we run a number of those deposit studies as you
- 14:51define, measuring how that decay and those outflows of deposit works.
- 14:55And in an a LM model, especially, it's designed to be highly conservative, so
- 15:01we've definitely seen that when we refresh the deposits, it's, they're very sticky.
- 15:07And that's still probably being fairly conservative, right?
- 15:11And in, in those types of studies, what we're often doing is we're building
- 15:14an assumption off of the individuals that are actually moving their money.
- 15:20So in an a LM model, it could be, again, a hundred percent of your
- 15:23pop of your population is going to have assumptions that are driven by.
- 15:295% of actual behavior.
- 15:31So the sample that we're using to explain or apply to the
- 15:34whole, it could be very small.
- 15:37And so that's, whenever you run these analyses, you actually see, hey
- 15:40there, we've had deposits here that have, they've been around right now.
- 15:44Does that mean they're gonna be there tomorrow?
- 15:46Maybe not.
- 15:47It's, the historical data's only as so good as as it is,
- 15:51credit unions being retail.
- 15:53Institutions, they have very sticky sources of funding.
- 15:57Sure.
- 15:57There's not as much concentration like you see in the, commercial banking space.
- 16:01It's like Silicon Valley Bank failing and the run that happened there
- 16:04and the the eye-opening experience of, their uninsured deposit was
- 16:11through the roof compared to banks.
- 16:12And banks on average were five or six times more than the average of the, or
- 16:17of the biggest outlier in credit unions.
- 16:19Which kind of speaks to that.
- 16:21Exactly.
- 16:22So it's just a, again, a different funding base and that's where.
- 16:26I'm the kind of person who says, there's no such thing as risk if you price it.
- 16:31The hard part though is pricing it.
- 16:32And I think we, we can't take anything as in isolation.
- 16:36We just have to think through, okay, what is the actual exposure and how
- 16:40do we all fit these pieces together?
- 16:43Is.
- 16:45Credit union, that banking industry, it's a very complex industry.
- 16:49Not only just from the regulatory side, but also just matching consumer
- 16:54behavior and all the risks that we're trying to evaluate simultaneously.
- 16:58It is a lot of work.
- 16:59It's tough and but we've just gotta think how it all fits together and
- 17:03along those lines, have there been changes in, in, so having gone through
- 17:11all the stimulus that kept rates low and kept kept us, made us lose a little bit
- 17:16of focus about this whole side of it.
- 17:18And now we've got through it and people have remembered or reremembered
- 17:20and brought it back to a key focus.
- 17:23Are you, were there any learning lessons from that or.
- 17:26Did that trigger any new tools or new ways that, that you at a LM first are looking
- 17:32at helping your clients and credit unions?
- 17:35Yeah, a absolutely.
- 17:36I think definitely some learning experiences and gentle or not
- 17:40so gentle reminders about more how quickly things can move.
- 17:45Especially with rate hikes, I think we could all say that.
- 17:48Yeah, maybe we expected rates to increase, but not to the extent that they did.
- 17:54And that kind of forgot that, markets, deposits can move quickly.
- 17:58I think that was one of the eye-opening things of deposits
- 18:02were changing at a rapid pace.
- 18:04Maybe not necessarily again in the credit union industry, but across,
- 18:08banking and credit unions funds.
- 18:11Were leaving the institution fairly quickly for.
- 18:14Again the Fidelity money market funds at Schwab, et cetera, treasury, direct.
- 18:19And the few things that we've built since then.
- 18:22We work to build more tools that our clients can use to assess their own risk.
- 18:28And so while we're an outsourced or insource provider, we'd like to say of
- 18:32a LM reporting we know that institutions want more at their fingertips.
- 18:38And we recently launched what we call our liquidity on demand.
- 18:41So that's been launched within the last nine months to, so institutions
- 18:45can be stress testing their liquidity, run, okay, how can we survive various
- 18:51versions of apocalyptic liquidity scenarios and, have the ability to build
- 18:57in, policy metrics and early warning indicators so we can see when do we get.
- 19:03Go from feeling nervous to heartburn, to nausea if you
- 19:08will and do that in real time.
- 19:10And then, similar to that, building out just more tools, like a more advanced
- 19:14interest rate, risk on demand tool just to give institutions more instantaneous
- 19:18access to the scenarios that need to run.
- 19:21Do you see are you yet tiptoeing into artificial intelligence side of
- 19:26that, or do you see that as something that's in the arc here moving forward?
- 19:31Any thoughts on that whole arena?
- 19:33Yeah, absolutely.
- 19:34Yeah.
- 19:34I'm not the, admittedly the best the AI and tech space.
- 19:37We definitely have our eyes on it.
- 19:39I, for me.
- 19:41Ai and it's really just been this evolution that, years ago we
- 19:44called it machine learning, right?
- 19:46And this is really just the next evolution and advancement of that.
- 19:49And I'm not tending to oversimplify the people that are live and breathe
- 19:53in the tech world would probably, throw something at me for make saying that.
- 19:58But do see that this is an opportunity for advancement.
- 20:01And where we're trying to evaluate it is, can we use it to create.
- 20:06Better capital allocation decisions.
- 20:09Can we use it to measure risk more in a real time basis and use that
- 20:14to advise institutions of, okay, we need to de-risk on the credit side
- 20:19or at some points, I think a number of institutions it might be the
- 20:22opposite of, we need to take more risk.
- 20:25We're getting paid a lot to take on.
- 20:28Risk in this particular sector, let's go do it.
- 20:31And so that, that's one thing we're evaluating and not something I'm gonna say
- 20:35we have ready to unveil to the world, just more on the investigation stage for sure.
- 20:41Yeah, no, that makes sense.
- 20:43The that the loan sale platform in a.
- 20:47Environment where consumer loads are drying up, there's probably some
- 20:51credit unions that have a unique field of membership or a unique situation
- 20:55in their city or state that might even have a little bit more demand.
- 20:59Are you seeing that spigot turn up or turn down recently?
- 21:05Yeah.
- 21:05Great.
- 21:05Great question.
- 21:07I'd say the market's definitely changed within the last 12 months.
- 21:10I'd say a year ago or so.
- 21:13There wasn't as much demand to purchase loans.
- 21:16I think people were still trying to get used to how much cash they had on hand.
- 21:21The outflow of deposits we were all experiencing.
- 21:25I, I think it left some scars naturally.
- 21:27But you, this year to start the year off, I'd say that has turned, there
- 21:31is more demand to purchase loans.
- 21:34And definitely seeing more appetite to fill loan buckets.
- 21:38And I don't, obviously nothing wrong with that.
- 21:39I think things are pretty well priced right now.
- 21:42But again, my concern is more for credit unions that feel,
- 21:46married to hitting a budget.
- 21:49At the end of the year, do we just add loans for the sake of adding loans?
- 21:55Regardless of what the rate is, that's where, we get a little nervous of maybe
- 22:00some discipline, falling by the wayside.
- 22:02Sure.
- 22:02But right now, that's more me just crying crying out into the wilderness,
- 22:07if you will, of let's be cautious.
- 22:09I don't think it's anything to be concerned about today.
- 22:12Just keep your eye on it.
- 22:13Exactly.
- 22:14Exactly.
- 22:14Yeah.
- 22:15Yeah.
- 22:15And then I.
- 22:17There's a, was there a pilot program that was recently approved by NCA?
- 22:22You want to talk through that a little bit and what it is and
- 22:25how you see that progressing?
- 22:27I.
- 22:27Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:27No, it's something we're really exciting excited about getting to
- 22:30advise on a loan fund for credit unions.
- 22:33So for federally chartered credit unions, they have, fund or funds, if
- 22:37you will, with a max of 30 investors.
- 22:40And the goal and the reason we're really excited about and work with the
- 22:43NCOA for a couple years prior to it being the pilot program being launched.
- 22:49Is that in this loan transaction world and in the participation
- 22:53world, there's some inefficiencies.
- 22:55And for, say a large credit union that wants to sell and generate liquidity,
- 23:01a lot of, some credit unions will go the securitization world where, we've
- 23:05advised on a number of those, or they'd go into the participation world and,
- 23:10maybe if they wanted to sell 300 million in auto loans, it would end up being.
- 23:1610 different credit unions that they'd have to piece it out to or even more.
- 23:21And that just doesn't create a lot of efficiencies.
- 23:24It creates costs in many different forms.
- 23:27And so one benefit we see is just economies of scale of, we could have
- 23:32the fund that just purchases that 300 million and then it's one buyer,
- 23:36and then the fund is responsible for parsing it out to the investor group.
- 23:41So really love it from that aspect where again, we can create
- 23:45more efficiency in the industry.
- 23:47And then again, because it can be a single large purchaser, really giving credit
- 23:53unions an opportunity to acquire assets or, sub-sectors of assets, that it'd
- 23:59be hard for them to get on their own.
- 24:02And so we think it really, again, is just a great thing.
- 24:05For the industry on a number of different levels and we're still building it out.
- 24:09We're.
- 24:10We want to take things in a very methodical pace and make sure that,
- 24:15we're not only dotting i's crossing t's and checking boxes, but that
- 24:19everything we do is gonna be really in line with safety and soundness.
- 24:24And so we're really going and, wanting to make sure that everything's, even
- 24:27the fund's even rated which isn't necessarily a requirement, but we
- 24:30think it's best for credit unions.
- 24:32Overall.
- 24:33Yeah, that makes sense.
- 24:34And if I'm remembering right, the derivative program started as a pilot
- 24:39program and I remember the reason I remember that is when I was at
- 24:44N-C-U-A-I, I remember at some juncture I thought, okay, pilot programs.
- 24:49Need to either end or they need to they either wind out as this didn't
- 24:53work or they convert to a real program.
- 24:55In that instance dipping the toe in the sandbox of the pilot program led
- 25:00to the agency saying, Hey, yeah, there, if it's structured right and if it is
- 25:04safe and sound, there's a, an arena where this can mitigate the risk for the
- 25:09credit union and then therefore mitigate risk to the insurance fund and NCUA.
- 25:13So I guess wise to.
- 25:15To put good guardrails around it because for it to convert from a pilot to a
- 25:21real authority NCA needs to get that their comfort around that as well.
- 25:27So I think that's a wise approach.
- 25:29Yeah.
- 25:30Yeah, absolutely.
- 25:30And it is been fun talking with institutions.
- 25:32We know there's a lot of excitement around the fund and, we're, again,
- 25:36very much looking forward to seeing how the pilot program plays out and, very.
- 25:41Excited to work with more credit unions and advancing it.
- 25:44Got it.
- 25:45You mentioned mergers and the like.
- 25:47So with these other pressures that we've seen what are you seeing in that arena?
- 25:51Is it, is there an uptick?
- 25:52Are you seeing more more, more large credit unions contemplating it?
- 25:57Are you seeing mergers of equals discussions more?
- 26:01Any thoughts on that topic?
- 26:03Yeah, absolutely.
- 26:04And definitely seeing more more mergers out there and more mergers of equals
- 26:08that are, at larger asset sizes.
- 26:11Number of hit the news wire as of late that you, I think just spurred
- 26:16the conversation regardless of asset size of, oh, do we need to merge?
- 26:21Do we need to grow?
- 26:23And, I'm not on, on the merger side of this, of the company.
- 26:27So I won't speak for them, I think it's all about to me, what is the institution's
- 26:32goal, what is the board's goal and how do you see that, that goal in perpetuity?
- 26:38I.
- 26:38So there's definitely different reasons to merge.
- 26:41Maybe it's just to, to get economies of scale.
- 26:43Maybe it's succession planning, but I also think there's, for those institutions
- 26:47that are kinda on the fence, not sure if it's the right move or not.
- 26:50I think there's a place for actual community institutions as well
- 26:54institutions that are really focused on.
- 26:57Serving the community, serving their members and being part of a
- 27:01growing, thriving again community.
- 27:03I think that can still, that's still viable.
- 27:06We just have to make sure we structure it correctly and that we're thinking
- 27:09of all all the possible pros and cons.
- 27:12Yeah.
- 27:12That makes good sense.
- 27:14Yeah.
- 27:15Is there any initiative or any hot topic that I should have
- 27:18asked you about here, Thomas?
- 27:20That, that I didn't.
- 27:21Great question.
- 27:22I think we really hit on the high points of what we're focused on.
- 27:26I'd say one other thing that we didn't touch on, which, I think is something
- 27:29that's important for credit unions is just the consistent focus on talent management.
- 27:35One of the challenges I think that sets credit unions apart from
- 27:38banking counterparts is the ability to lock in, your high level talent
- 27:43for a period of time, banks have, equity at their fingertips where
- 27:47there's some way of developing deferred compensation plans that are.
- 27:53A little bit easier to structure.
- 27:54Credit unions don't have that.
- 27:56And when looking at, how do we get overcome that type of challenge
- 28:01we've really focused on advancing and building out, employee benefit,
- 28:05pre-fund portfolio management as well as executive benefit teams because
- 28:10it's something that's not going away at least as we see the industry today.
- 28:14And I think it's important because, to keep.
- 28:17Quality employees in the credit union right now, effectively institutions
- 28:22have to pay, oversimplifying, it's cash compensation cash
- 28:26bonus and that's expensive.
- 28:28I.
- 28:29So that's another thing that, we've been working at for a number
- 28:32of years now and really excited to, to keep pushing that forward.
- 28:36Again, we think it's best for the industry.
- 28:38And we'll keep plugging away at it.
- 28:40Yeah.
- 28:40Yeah.
- 28:40Building those leaders is expensive and, keeping 'em might seem expensive,
- 28:45but if you don't keep 'em, replacing 'em is even more expensive and can have
- 28:48other collateral, collateral challenges.
- 28:50So no doubt.
- 28:51Gr I'm glad you brought that up.
- 28:53This has been a lot of fun.
- 28:54Talking through where you guys are at, where we think the industry's at.
- 28:57If one of my listeners or watchers want to touch base with you, Thomas,
- 29:01what's the best way for them to reach out to a LM first or to you directly?
- 29:05Yeah, absolutely.
- 29:06Feel free to, reach out.
- 29:07My email is.
- 29:08T griswold@almfirst.com.
- 29:11That's T-G-R-I-S-W-O-L-D at ALM first.
- 29:17And you can also reach out to our company directly.
- 29:20Go to our website, www.almfirst.com,
- 29:23or info at a LM first.
- 29:25All of those are perfectly accessible.
- 29:27We, we love helping institutions.
- 29:29However we can.
- 29:29Our mantra is really, we wanna help institutions solve problems.
- 29:34So love talking about whatever we can do to help.
- 29:39Very good.
- 29:39Appreciate your time today, Thomas.
- 29:41Absolutely.
- 29:42Thanks Mark.
- 29:42Really appreciate it.
- 29:43You got it.
- 29:43And listeners, watchers, I want to thank you for listening again,
- 29:46I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 29:48Mark TriCal, signing off with flying colors.