Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #213 - Naomi Klein
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. Hi. I'm Naomi Klein, and as some of you know,
- 0:21I have a doppelganger, a person who does many extreme things that cause
- 0:27strangers to chastise me, or thank me, or express their pity for me.
- 0:34I used to be horrified by this, but then something happened that I
- 0:39didn't expect. I got interested interested in what it means to have a doppelganger.
- 0:47So I decided to follow my doppelganger to a place I've come to think
- 0:51of as the mirror world. Hey folks, my name is Mohameir and this
- 0:56is Man Color, British Columbia's bonafide culture and politics TV talk show. So
- 1:00tonight we take a trip into the mirror world with one of the most influential
- 1:04public intellectuals of our time. Her seminal work No Logo became the manifesto for
- 1:10the anti globalization movement, and her revelatory expose of free market capitalism, The
- 1:15Shock Doctrine, detailed how crises around the world are exploited in order to implement
- 1:21unpopular economic policies. But her new book, Doppelganger may be my personal favorite.
- 1:27It's a weird wild ride that starts with her experience of being confused with
- 1:33another high profile but profoundly opposite social critic to explore the rise of conspiracy theories.
- 1:40An award winning journalist and columnist for The Guardian, New York Times,
- 1:44best selling author, and a tenured professor at the University of British Columbia,
- 1:48among so many other hats that she wears, she is Naomi Klein. Naomi,
- 1:53what an honor. Thank you will that's lovely, thank you for that
- 1:57shouldaction. Oh? Absolutely. Now here's the thing. I am such a
- 2:00fan. Your work has been so influential in my life, through my undergraduate
- 2:06degree, through my graduate degree, you know, really shaped the way how
- 2:08I looked at the world. And then I see you paling around with Trump
- 2:14campaign advisor Steve Bannon, You're co hosting podcasts, You're hanging out with Tucker
- 2:17Carlson. What happened to you? Naomi? I'm sorry to disappoint you so
- 2:22much. Yes, many people have asked themselves that question, and it's not
- 2:28you to be clear in the question. Yeah, whatever happened to So,
- 2:34yes, you're referencing the fact that I have a doppelganger. You do the
- 2:37other, Naomi, So that was not me with Steve Bannon or Tucker Carlson.
- 2:43I never claimed that vaccinated people shed onto unvaccinating people and that affected their
- 2:50fertility. Not true, But yeah, a lot of people get me confused.
- 2:53I don't know. Naomi's who write books, sort of big idea books.
- 2:59She wrote The Beauty Miss, which is right when I was an undergraduate,
- 3:02was sort of a big deal in the Democratic Party. She advised al
- 3:06Gore, So it was pretty shocking to a lot of people when she changed
- 3:12it kind of became a doppelganger of herself during COVID. She wasn't the only
- 3:15one. I think we all know people who kind of fell down the rabbit
- 3:19hole, and there were all these kind of cross political signals of people who
- 3:23we used to think of as being progressive and suddenly they're voting for the People's
- 3:28Party. You know, like we all know those stories, right, I
- 3:31got that yoga instructor who's suddenly QAnon. I have a few of those,
- 3:36yeah, right. So in the book, I decided to use my own
- 3:39doppelganger as a case study for the way in which this kind of a master
- 3:47arrangement that happened during the pandemic and carries through certainly to today, and I
- 3:53do want to get into that, but before we do, let's talk about
- 3:54the other Naomi. Let's talk about Naomi Wolf. Obviously, you share a
- 3:59name. You had partners both named AVII. You still do with someone named
- 4:04Brian else I have that problem. But she was like the standard bearer for
- 4:09nineties feminism. She was very active in the Occupy Wall Street movement, and
- 4:14so there was I could understand some of the mistaken identity that occurred. Was
- 4:20this something that really dogged your professional career or was it only once she kind
- 4:26of turned to this anti vax you know, right wing reactionary person persona that
- 4:31she became. So I just want to say, first of all, this
- 4:33happens to a lot of us. It's not that it's not that unique that
- 4:36we get confused with other people who sort of look like us online. I
- 4:41think it happens to racialize people who even got confused for Naomi Campbell. So
- 4:45it happens to you a lot. There is something about the name Naomi where
- 4:47it's just like just rare enough that the first Naomi you hear about becomes like
- 4:55the universal Naomi. But it is true that I had in the experience,
- 4:58particularly in the UK, where I would have like TV presenters be like coming
- 5:02up next an interview with Naomi Campbell, and I'd I'd have to apologize.
- 5:05I'm like, I'm so sorry to disappoint you. It's just me, you
- 5:10know. But so you know, that is obviously not identity confusion. That's
- 5:15just like a little glitch in in in something about the name. Uh.
- 5:20But but with Wolf, it was really not confusion but conflation. Like they
- 5:25were like, people were really really mixing us up. And maybe it's because
- 5:29we're both Jewish and publish these these nonfiction books. I don't know what it
- 5:33is, but I decided that it was. So you know, you were
- 5:38asking, you want to know more about her, Well, let's just get
- 5:41into her being your white rabbit into the mirror world. How would you explain
- 5:46the mirror world to someone who hasn't read your book yet? Sure, and
- 5:47it did. It did happen more during COVID because I think for a variety
- 5:53of reasons. One, we were all spending way too much time online,
- 5:58but also, you know, you to be that I think people we had
- 6:00clear lanes. You know, she was writing about women and gender and I
- 6:08was writing about capitalism and crises and climate change, And during COVID, she
- 6:13was really making an argument that was kind of like a doppelganger of the argument
- 6:16I make in the Shock Doctrine, which is that during times of crisis,
- 6:21you know, they we often have corporations and politicians try to smuggle through policies
- 6:28that they wouldn't be able to get through, exploitings exploiting crises. Now,
- 6:31I don't make the argument that they create the crises in order to exploit them.
- 6:34But during COVID, I'm sure you heard people in what I call them
- 6:39you or a world talk about how there was this was all a plandemic,
- 6:43right, and that maybe it was all that Bill Gates wanted to depopulate the
- 6:47earth, and it was some plot with the World Economic Forum and the Chinese
- 6:50Communist Party, and so it was, like, you know, I write
- 6:54in the book, it was as if someone had taken my ideas and like
- 6:57put them in one of those like vitamin splendors and like a bunch of tropical
- 7:00fruit, and then fed the thought puree to Tucker Carlson, who nodded vehemently
- 7:05right. And even a lot of her ideas were nonsensical or at least inconsistent
- 7:10in logic. Right, So on one hand it was this planned thing by
- 7:14you know, nefarious actors, but then on the other hand, it wasn't
- 7:17actually that serious in terms of how sick you could get, right, Yeah,
- 7:20which is why I don't call her and the people she POWs around with
- 7:26conspiracy theorists. Okay, just because I'm a fan of theory. I think
- 7:30I think it's important to have a good theory. And this is I call
- 7:34them conspiracy influencers because they're moving around from sort of hot topic to hot topic.
- 7:40So at first it's the virus itself is a bioweapon, but then when
- 7:46it's all about mask mandates, it's like, it's just a cold, what
- 7:48are you worry about it? And it's like, well, I thought it
- 7:50was a bioweapon. I should try try to avoid it, you know.
- 7:56So there's a there are big contradictions, but the pattern is it's really whatever
- 8:00is in the news, like whatever is going to get you the clicks,
- 8:03it's cloud chasing, it's it's and and that's I think helpful to distinguish between
- 8:09somebody who actually has a theory of how the world works. Yeah. So
- 8:11then in trying to make sense of the mirror world and understanding it again,
- 8:16how do we define it? Like, is it this idea of someone who
- 8:18looks to be serious but actually isn't. Once you peel back the layers,
- 8:22how would you describe it? Well, you know, I use this term
- 8:24to describe the way a lot of people have sort of have have cut ties
- 8:31with what I would recognize as a shared reality and are now living in a
- 8:37sort of parallel infrastructure where like, if you get kicked off Twitter, then
- 8:41you just join Getter, and if you get kicked off YouTube, you just
- 8:43joined Parlor. So in many ways, it's a mirror world in that it
- 8:46has exact replica institutions and platforms, and they're very large, and they're getting
- 8:54larger. So you know, often like when she was kicked off Twitter,
- 8:58she's now back when she was kicked off Twitter, Like a lot of the
- 9:00people who I know were acting as if she'd been deleted from planet Earth.
- 9:03But because I followed her down that rabbit hole and I was sort of interested
- 9:07in what she was doing, it was clear to me that she was reaching
- 9:11more people than she had, you know, in decades. So it's there's
- 9:15a mere infrastructure, but there are also mirror arguments. So you know,
- 9:18any argument on this side of the glass, there is an exact replica mirror
- 9:24argument over there. Fascinating reality, yes, but we also, you know,
- 9:31on this side of the glass. One of the problems is that we
- 9:33become very reactive. So if an issue gets traction over there, then we
- 9:39will not talk about it over here. Right. So, for instance,
- 9:43they were focused on COVID origins and then that became kind of an unsayable subject
- 9:48of debate among you know, liberal polite society, and then it turns out,
- 9:52well, maybe that was worth investigating. Right. I don't actually know
- 9:56whether it came from a lab or it came from a wet market, And
- 9:58why is that such a partisan question to ask? Like, why don't we
- 10:01look into it? So there are all kinds of ways that we react to
- 10:05one another in this kind of mirror dance. So I got to ask you
- 10:09about conspiracy theories, in particular the COVID nineteen pandemic, because I feel like,
- 10:13as you alluded to, it broke a lot of people whose whole personality
- 10:20is just about COVID, either the freedom folks or the COVID zero folks.
- 10:24I've seen people even today, this is all they want to talk about.
- 10:28They're kind of obsessed with it. What was it about COVID nineteen that quote
- 10:33unquote broke us? Well, I think humans are social beings and we make
- 10:41ourselves in conversation with one another. I don't think we're really built for isolation.
- 10:46And we were confronting an airborne virus that we didn't understand, and we
- 10:52were terrified, and we weren't able to engage in sense making with one another,
- 10:58so we went online. Oh that was our first mistake. Well,
- 11:03you know, this is at first I just want to say, you know,
- 11:05I have I've spent time in a lot of different contacts under extreme stress
- 11:11because to write the Shock Doctrine, I visited, you know, places that
- 11:15had been struck by tsunamis and hurricanes and wars. And conspiracies always surge during
- 11:22times when people are trying to make sense of something that doesn't seem to make
- 11:26sense that they've never experienced before, especially if it's being exploited by predatory interests.
- 11:31Right, So then they try to make sense of it, like,
- 11:33well, is it possible that somebody caused this in order to take advantage is
- 11:37take my home and my land. What was different about COVID. It's not
- 11:41that there were conspiracies surging. It's that we live in an attention economy now,
- 11:46and the people who were putting out the wildest conspiracy claims got the traffic,
- 11:52got the clicks in that moment when we all went online to try to
- 11:54find some simulation of community friendships, but also to make sense of where we
- 12:01were. Science takes time, right, I mean, if you're confronting a
- 12:05novel virus, credible scientists are going to take their time before they are able
- 12:09to share their findings with you. And that's just not true of conspiracy influencers.
- 12:13They're just going to make stuff up and they're going to get the clicks
- 12:16and they're going to monetize it. So it's interesting what you say that you
- 12:18know, the people are still obsessed with it. I think I think there
- 12:22are some people who still are. I think that we're also in this weird
- 12:26stage where people who got that kind of lift off, that magic carpet ride
- 12:31from COVID are looking for where they're going to get the lift off next.
- 12:35Right, It's like, am I going to get it from transphobia? You
- 12:37know? Am I going to get it from climate change denial. Is that
- 12:41why we see the linkages of you know, when the people those folks have
- 12:43the banners hanging off the highway, it's like anti vax stuff and then anti
- 12:48trans stuff as well, right, the things that seem very unrelated. Yeah,
- 12:54I think that there's a lot of trying to figure out what the next?
- 12:58What that because people got a sense of community, they got a sense
- 13:01of mission. You know, if you think about the trucker convoy, right,
- 13:03and that's sort of like the bouncy castles, and that's you know,
- 13:07if you were in the in group, you were having the time of your
- 13:11life. If you were in the outgroup and wearing a mask walking by,
- 13:13you certainly were not, especially if you're you know, a non white person.
- 13:16And is this one of the things that differentiates the COVID nineteen pandemic from
- 13:20let's say nine to eleven? Because I remember when you were on tour for
- 13:24the Shock Doctrine. The Truther movement at that time two thousand and seven two
- 13:28thousand and eight was really popular, and I remember sitting in a book talk
- 13:31that you were doing, and there was a Truther that came up and said,
- 13:33what about nine to eleven and what really happened, And yet that movement
- 13:37didn't seem to really take off in the same way that the COVID nineteen truthers
- 13:41or the anti vaxxers have taken off. I think that is the big difference,
- 13:46is that it is that that was pre attention economy. You know,
- 13:50two thousand and seven, that was the year of the iPhone, pree Facebook,
- 13:54pre Twitter, so there wasn't that same ability. But you know,
- 14:00that's so interesting to me that, yeah, that you that you remember that,
- 14:01because I do remember. It was always like the first person up to
- 14:05the mic, you know, why won't you admit that nine elec then a
- 14:07collective grown from the rest of us. I remember that. Yeah, And
- 14:09you know what I would say was, you know, I've just given a
- 14:13talk about how we were led into a war based on lies that hundreds of
- 14:18thousands of Iraqis have died. Why isn't that enough for you? Like?
- 14:22Why are you trying? Why are you moving the horizon of outrage beyond what
- 14:28we actually can prove? Right? And I feel the same way, And
- 14:31I think it's really important to understand about conspiracy culture today, Like there's plenty
- 14:37of reasons to be mad at Bill Gates without making anything up, you know,
- 14:39like you don't need to you know, don't need to claim that he's
- 14:43trying to track us with vaccines. How about the fact that he was working
- 14:46with drug companies to keep the vaccines patented in ways that prevented vaccines from reaching
- 14:54the global South. You know, there's you don't need to make anything up
- 14:58about people exploiting COVID, you know, to enrichments. Is that part of
- 15:03the problem that a lot of people that otherwise perhaps would have been critical of
- 15:05things like big pharma, big tech, or billionaires inflating their net value or
- 15:11net worth, they seem to be kind of missing, and that void seemed
- 15:15to be taken by these reactionaries, this conspiracy culture, as you say,
- 15:20Is that was that really part of the issue? Well, I do think,
- 15:22and this is what I mean by the reactivity. Right, So,
- 15:26once people in the mirror world started talking about Bill Gates and being very very
- 15:33anti vacs, then the line on much of the left and certainly in liberals,
- 15:39you know, was roll up your sleeve and get your vaccine and just
- 15:41follow the mandates. And we didn't question, well, why are we putting
- 15:45everything onto these vaccines and vaccine verification apps. Why aren't we Why don't we
- 15:48have more ambitious demands, like lift the patents on the vaccines, hire more
- 15:52teachers and nurses, really invest in our social infrastructure, make sure that every
- 15:58classroom has good air and air filtration. Right, we were still so focus
- 16:02on the individual rather than these collective sus exactly. Yeah, and we were
- 16:06just very reactive. So it's like whatever there are against, were for and
- 16:08vice versa. So yeah, that's that's that's what I mean, Like it's
- 16:12not just about them, you know, doppelgangers in movies and films, Like
- 16:17you think you're going after your your, your, your, your other self,
- 16:21but it ends up being a mirror of something that you don't want to
- 16:22look at about yourself. Right. I found that about my travels. Is
- 16:27the danger with conspiracy culture that instead of focusing on systems, they really want
- 16:33to focus on specific people to blame. And you know, the biggest conspiracy
- 16:37of all of them is blaming Jewish people, and so that is the oldest
- 16:41and most persistent, right, Yeah, So is that ultimately the problem with
- 16:45conspiracy culture is instead of looking at systems and how things operate, they really
- 16:48just want to they want someone to blame. Yeah, And I mean I
- 16:52think that that's why. You know, I'm so troubled by this, by
- 16:56this urge to move the horizon so where where we can't prove it right.
- 17:00It's just just some idea that there's this nefarious plot, this room somewhere where
- 17:04everybody's plotting against you, as opposed to this is a system doing what it
- 17:08was designed to do. You know, we live in a system that rewards
- 17:11profit making. It's the ultimate good within the logic of capitalism. So if
- 17:17you can exploit a crisis to get rich, that's why people are doing it,
- 17:19not because you know, there're whatever people are claiming is going on,
- 17:23you know, with with you know, adrenochrome and kid. I mean,
- 17:27you know, like I don't want to, I don't I don't want to
- 17:30overplay it. In a conversation about reality and dissolving reality, I feel like
- 17:34the Internet and social media in particular is like augmented reality. You know,
- 17:40it's it's still somewhat in reality and we're communicating with each other through screens,
- 17:44but there is a bit of a performative aspect of how we view reality where
- 17:49I see the next step going is artificial intelligence, where we don't even know
- 17:55if operations or communications are actually happening with a real individual, they might be
- 18:00happening with a machine. So is this in terms of just in general,
- 18:04is AI and artificial intelligence an existential threat to humanity? Well, it's definitely
- 18:11a threat to our ability to know who and what we can trust. I
- 18:18think it's definitely a threat to a lot of people's jobs. And I don't
- 18:21love the way tech companies have framed this in this sort of terminator way where
- 18:25once again they're moving the horizon of outrage, often to some like are they
- 18:29is it going to is it going to kill us all? Are the machines
- 18:32going to turn on us? But that way it is the ultimate doppel ganger.
- 18:36But it's it's not it's not speculative. Like right now, we have
- 18:40a toxic information sphere where we do not know, you know, whether each
- 18:44other are real, We don't know what we can believe, we don't have
- 18:47any shared reality. We're having conversations not about shared in like differing interpretations of
- 18:52reality, but who is in a simulation and who is in reality? Right,
- 18:57that's a big deal. And in a content like that where we already
- 19:02have misinformation spreading virally to introduce AI and deep fakes. And you know the
- 19:08idea that I could I could go online and there could be somebody who looks
- 19:12and sounds very much like you, but it's not you. It is taking
- 19:17your voice and is taking your face. How do I know if this Drake
- 19:18song is actually Drake? I mean, that is just going to make what
- 19:22we've been talking about the spread of conspiracy culture so much worse than it already
- 19:27is. And when then, when you mix in you know, international conflict
- 19:32and war, uh and governments, you know, creat you know, having
- 19:34a vested interest in this, we've got a big old mess on our hands.
- 19:37But yeah, we're all going to have doppelgangers of ourselves out there soon,
- 19:41so we're not We're not going to end the show on a positive note.
- 19:44Can you give me something about AI or the impending technology to maybe fall
- 19:48asleep at night? Think you know it's not not all lost? Do think
- 19:51it is good that actors and screenwriters and different artists are out there saying,
- 19:56you know, this is theft. Actually, why should you be allowed to
- 20:00train these machines on our work, on our faces, on our voices?
- 20:06And this is a really important sphere of struggle. I know it can seem
- 20:08a little bit, you know, maybe it seems too soft. It's cultural,
- 20:14but I think a lot depends on whether or not we know whether we
- 20:17can trust one another. Are we in another situation similar to social media where
- 20:21government is playing catch up, Like I feel like only now government is starting
- 20:25to implement rules and regulations, and with AI, they should try to be
- 20:29as proactive as possible. I know they're always going to be behind, but
- 20:32it just feels like government is not taking the threat seriously. No. And
- 20:36I think part of the reason why they're they're not is because it's being framed
- 20:40as in geopolitical terms, like if you don't let us do this, then
- 20:45China will get ahead of us. And then then it's like, okay,
- 20:48well China and we're doing it, and then it's just a wonderful gift to
- 20:52the same five tech companies, right, Okay, we get to mine us
- 20:56Naomi, this is being an honor, a privilege, a pleasure. Well,
- 21:00thank you so much for your time tonight. Thank you, min Congratulations
- 21:02on a very successful book tour. By the way, thank you. I'm
- 21:03home, happy to be absolutely thank you folks. That's our show. Thank
- 21:08you, of course, to our very special guest tonight, Naomi Klein,
- 21:11for all of her time tonight. Be sure to pick up her book Doppelganger,
- 21:15A Trip into the Mirror World. Find it at your local bookstore.
- 21:18I promise you you will not be disappointed. For now though, this is
- 21:23Van Cullor and I'm oamir telling you that in the province where you can be
- 21:26anything, be colorful. Peaks